Depression

[Guest guest]

Some people have good results with St. 's Wort. (for depression).

------------------------------------------------------------------------

[Guest guest]

Dear Esther,

Thank for replying. I forgot to specify that I've been on St. 's

Wort--300 mg. 3X a day--for months. At first I thought it was helping, but

now I'm not so sure.

Joan

------------------------------------------------------------------------

[Guest guest]

Esther:

Some St. Wort work better than others. I've found an oral spray that is

obsorbed faster that a pill. The co. is called " Young Living " . It is a new

product but you can check out their web site if you are interested .

------------------------------------------------------------------------

[Guest guest]

Joe, my depression was not causesd by interferon; I never took

interferon and cannot and will not for fear of bringing on the

depression again. Also, from what I hear and read, the interferon can

cause medical problems that are worse than the hepatitis. For me,

simply not worth the risk if I did have a choice. Arlene

[Guest guest]

Dear Joe:

Am so very sorry to here that you have had such a difficult and dangerous

time with the interferon. I am one of the fortunate ones that have garnered

positive results from it. Am in my sixth week of it. However my Dr is

monitoring what is going on with me very closely. Blood at week 2, 4, 8,

12. So far it is all positive. But it did have it's depressing effects to

begin with but my Dr. told me it would and he really stressed that. I am

single, living alone, so for a while on shot night friends came and stayed

with me and that was very comforting......Now the depression hits about 3/4

hours after the shot and i call someone and cry if i need to or what ever.

Am glad for you and your children that you were able to hold on. The other

thing I did was start a vitamin detox regimen at the same time I started the

interferon and really believe that has helped a great deal.

But it is a chemical and we all are not able to tolerate it. If you are no

longer taking the interferon what kind of treatments are you using. HCV

left untreated can be a worse nightmare than the treatments.

And meditation has been my real ally in all of this. If for no reason that

to give me focus on all that is good in my life and to keep that first and

formost.......

Hope you are okay and if i can be of help do not hesitate to write.

Rowena

Mrs Jane Sindoni wrote:

> From: Mrs Jane Sindoni <JSINDONI@...>

>

> Arlene

> Just wanted to share with you when you descibed how painful it was while

> on interferon, that was excatlly the way I felt. If it wasn't for

> having children that looked up to me, I really don't think I would be

> here today. wanted to let other people who are currently on interferon,

> to consider stopping (or insisting to see their doctor) interferon if

> they have these side effects. Waking up out of a sound sleep with fast

> shooting pains from one side of chest to the other, this is the pain

> that i had about 3 months into the interferon, about 6 days after

> stopping interferon arms and legs went numb with buring pain across

> chest. This has left me with permenant nerve damage in both sides,

> which I have to take med to control the pain. Just felt that I had a

> duty to inform people of this. Also had eye pain, lost 30 pounds and my

> body was depleted of many needed vitamins. Very depressed, also felt

> much aniexity. I know that interferon is helping many people out there

> but it also can have serious and permenant side effects. Goodbye for

> now and God Bless Joe

>

> ------------------------------------------------------------------------

> With more than 17 million e-mails exchanged daily...

>

> ...ONElist is THE place where the world talks!

[Guest guest]

Barbara,

Thank you for the reply, I guess I'll just have to trust the doctors huh?

(AIH)

[Guest guest]

I started with 60 mg of prednisone and within 4 weeks had a full blown

depression. For me, prednisone was like pouring gasoline on a fire. I

have a family history of mental illness and had been on depressants in

the past, but I was not on anti-depressants at the time I started the

prednisone. Unfortunately, I was not expecting a depression and it took

me some time to recognize what was happening.

Prednisone doesn't act as a depressant for everyone, so you may be

lucky. Already being on anti-depressants might help. Also, since your

doctor has been delaying starting the prednisone, he probably won't

start with the maximum dosage as my doctor did. The big problem I had

with the prednisone was not sleeping which tends to trigger depression

for me. With 150 mg of trazadone (maximum dosage again), I slept fine.

Two years later, I am still working with my psychiatrist to get the

proper level of anti-depressant. Fortunately, he has been my

psychiatrist for several years and we have a good relationship. I sleep

a lot and am still trying to determine if this is a result of the liver

disease or the anti-depressant. Right now I think it is the liver

problem in spite of having good lab test results.

La7de@... wrote:

>

> From: La7de@...

>

> Hi all,

>

> I'm seeing a new psyciatrist (another one, say your prayers) on Monday

> morning. My GI wanted me to see him before I start on prednisone, since I am

> already on anti-depressants (zoloft & trazodone). The GI wants to make sure

> I am stable (LOL) since the prednisone can also cause depression. My

> question is this: How badly did the prednisone hit you all who were already

> being treated for depression? I need to know what to expect, and if there is

> anything that can help. Please e-mail me directly if the answer shouldn't be

> posted for newcomers. Thanks alot...

>

> (AIH)

> La7de@...

>

> ---------------------------

[Guest guest]

I noticed no difference when I started taking prednisone. I already had

problems

with depression. I had no ill affects from the prednisone. Lynn

La7de@... wrote:

> From: La7de@...

>

> Hi all,

>

> I'm seeing a new psyciatrist (another one, say your prayers) on Monday

> morning. My GI wanted me to see him before I start on prednisone, since I am

> already on anti-depressants (zoloft & trazodone). The GI wants to make sure

> I am stable (LOL) since the prednisone can also cause depression. My

> question is this: How badly did the prednisone hit you all who were already

> being treated for depression? I need to know what to expect, and if there is

> anything that can help. Please e-mail me directly if the answer shouldn't be

> posted for newcomers. Thanks alot...

>

> (AIH)

> La7de@...

>

> ---------------------------

[Guest guest]

Hi

I was on prozac and trazadone at the time I first started taking prednisone

(1991). I don't think I notice increased depression. But a few years later

the prozac wasn't working any more. So I have been on Zoloft and trazadone

for several years now. My shrink also added Remeron several months ago cuz

the zoloft wasn't doing much either (I'm on 150 mg. of zoloft/day and 30 mg

of Remeron/day, plus 50 of trazadone.) I certainly can't rule out the

prednisone having an effect but I think it's more to do with perhaps my

body's tolerance to the psych meds.

Take Care,

Dianne A.

[Guest guest]

Lynn,

Thanks for that bit of hope!

(AIH)

[Guest guest]

,

I'm so glad to here of yet another person on anti-depressants who didn't seem

too bother by prednisone initially. My Zoloft hasn't done too well the last

year either, so maybe I'll ask my psyc about Remeron too. Thanks a million.

(AIH)

[Guest guest]

Hi diane,

I am not yet on prednisone and have been treated for clinical depression

with prozac and paxil. The prozac worked better for me than the paxil, but

then not as well, doc increased prozac from 20 to 30 and now 40 mg a day.

Wondering why antidepressants do that.

J

>From: Dpa1228@...

>Reply- onelist

> onelist

>Subject: Re: [ ] Depression

>Date: Sun, 12 Sep 1999 07:20:45 EDT

>MIME-Version: 1.0

>From errors-165537-6437-shireen42 Sun Sep 12 04:20:57 1999

>Received: from [209.207.164.205] by hotmail.com (2.1) with ESMTP id

>MHotMailB9A4D79900F4D82197C2D1CFA4CD18DB0; Sun Sep 12 04:20:57 1999

>Received: (qmail 815 invoked by alias); 12 Sep 1999 11:20:42 -0000

>Received: (qmail 748 invoked from network); 12 Sep 1999 11:20:37 -0000

>Received: from unknown (HELO imo-d10.mx) (205.188.157.42) by

>pop.onelist.com with SMTP; 12 Sep 1999 11:20:37 -0000

>Received: from Dpa1228@... by imo-d10.mx.aol.com (mail_out_v22.4.) id

>hHTBR7bbL_ (4590) for < onelist>; Sun, 12 Sep 1999

>07:20:45 -0400 (EDT)

>Message-ID: <2e366cc6.250ce68d@...>

>X-Mailer: AOL 4.0 for Windows 95 sub 21

>Mailing-List: list onelist; contact

> -owneronelist

>Delivered-mailing list onelist

>Precedence: bulk

>List-Unsubscribe: <mailto: -unsubscribeONElist>

>

>From: Dpa1228@...

>

>Hi

>

>I was on prozac and trazadone at the time I first started taking prednisone

>(1991). I don't think I notice increased depression. But a few years

>later

>the prozac wasn't working any more. So I have been on Zoloft and trazadone

>for several years now. My shrink also added Remeron several months ago cuz

>the zoloft wasn't doing much either (I'm on 150 mg. of zoloft/day and 30 mg

>of Remeron/day, plus 50 of trazadone.) I certainly can't rule out the

>prednisone having an effect but I think it's more to do with perhaps my

>body's tolerance to the psych meds.

>

>Take Care,

> Dianne A.

>

>---------------------------

[Guest guest]

Is Remoran similar to prozac or paxil, or has differnt way of working?

J

>From: La7de@...

>Reply- onelist

> onelist

>Subject: Re: [ ] Depression

>Date: Sun, 12 Sep 1999 09:55:29 EDT

>MIME-Version: 1.0

>From errors-165537-6449-shireen42 Sun Sep 12 06:55:59 1999

>Received: from [209.207.164.205] by hotmail.com (2.1) with ESMTP id

>MHotMailB9A4FBEF0112D820F3B7D1CFA4CD1BF70; Sun Sep 12 06:55:59 1999

>Received: (qmail 31896 invoked by alias); 12 Sep 1999 13:55:39 -0000

>Received: (qmail 31823 invoked from network); 12 Sep 1999 13:55:37 -0000

>Received: from unknown (HELO imo14.mx.aol.com) (198.81.17.4) by

>pop.onelist.com with SMTP; 12 Sep 1999 13:55:37 -0000

>Received: from La7de@... by imo14.mx.aol.com (mail_out_v22.4.) id

>hPOAa24004 (4322) for < onelist>; Sun, 12 Sep 1999

>09:55:30 -0400 (EDT)

>Message-ID: <660cecf5.250d0ad1@...>

>X-Mailer: AOL 4.0 for Windows 95 sub 22

>Mailing-List: list onelist; contact

> -owneronelist

>Delivered-mailing list onelist

>Precedence: bulk

>List-Unsubscribe: <mailto: -unsubscribeONElist>

>

>From: La7de@...

>

>,

>

>I'm so glad to here of yet another person on anti-depressants who didn't

>seem

>too bother by prednisone initially. My Zoloft hasn't done too well the

>last

>year either, so maybe I'll ask my psyc about Remeron too. Thanks a

>million.

>

> (AIH)

>

>---------------------------

[Guest guest]

I was on predisone for 18 months before I crashed and realized how hard I had

been fighting depression. No one had warned me that it could be a result of

either the meds or the disease or both. I was only on 10mgs of the steroids

at the time and had been at that level for a long time.

Any time the doctor has changed my steroids too rapidly even if only a few

mgs. I would have another crash.

Right now I am on 50 mgs of Zoloft and 150 mgs of Wellbutrin.

For a while I was on 100mgs of just the Zoloft. I also tend to twice a cycle

have a bit of a dip so have just added 50 mgs of Zoloft just for that day or

two and it helps balance things out.

So all of that to say, for me the predisone affects me.

Warmly,

S.

[Guest guest]

,

Were you on the anti-depressants prior to going on prednisone?

[Guest guest]

Hi ,

Yes, depression is documented to be a possible side effect of the

prednisone. Actually, manic depression runs in our family, so when they

started me on it, they were particularly interested to see if I was

developing any depression, and they've monitored that each visit. I've found

that on my " bad " days, I've been depressed for the entire day, and there's

no way out of it. It's different than I've ever felt before (and not fun)!

As the pred has decreased, so have the bad days. Usually I'm due for one a

couple of days after I change the dose. Also good new, now that I'm down to

15mg, it no longer lasts a whole day! This is my personal experience so

far. I hope it helps!

>From: Dpa1228@...

>Reply- onelist

> onelist

>Subject: Re: [ ] Depression

>Date: Sun, 12 Sep 1999 07:20:45 EDT

>

>From: Dpa1228@...

>

>Hi

>

>I was on prozac and trazadone at the time I first started taking prednisone

>(1991). I don't think I notice increased depression. But a few years

>later

>the prozac wasn't working any more. So I have been on Zoloft and trazadone

>for several years now. My shrink also added Remeron several months ago cuz

>the zoloft wasn't doing much either (I'm on 150 mg. of zoloft/day and 30 mg

>of Remeron/day, plus 50 of trazadone.) I certainly can't rule out the

>prednisone having an effect but I think it's more to do with perhaps my

>body's tolerance to the psych meds.

>

>Take Care,

> Dianne A.

>

>---------------------------

[Guest guest]

My daughter was on Zoloft. They took her off when it wasn't helping any more.

The Dr. said that Zoloft can do that. It hits a certain point and then will

quit

being effective. Lynn aih Apparently that is for some people, not all.

La7de@... wrote:

> From: La7de@...

>

> ,

>

> I'm so glad to here of yet another person on anti-depressants who didn't seem

> too bother by prednisone initially. My Zoloft hasn't done too well the last

> year either, so maybe I'll ask my psyc about Remeron too. Thanks a million.

>

> (AIH)

>

> ---------------------------

[Guest guest]

no !!

diana

[Guest guest]

I saw the doc tonight that orders my prozac. She said it does not cause

liver damage,but not recommended for those who have cirrhosis.

susan j

>From: La7de@...

>Reply- onelist

> onelist

>Subject: Re: [ ] Joint pain

>Date: Sun, 3 Oct 1999 12:41:52 EDT

>MIME-Version: 1.0

>From errors-165537-7172-shireen42=hotmail.comonelist Sun Oct 3

>09:42:03 1999

>Received: (qmail 1227 invoked by alias); 3 Oct 1999 16:42:00 -0000

>Received: (qmail 1221 invoked from network); 3 Oct 1999 16:41:57 -0000

>Received: from unknown (209.207.164.239) by pop4.onelist.com with QMQP; 3

>Oct 1999 16:41:57 -0000

>Received: from unknown (HELO imo14.mx.aol.com) (198.81.17.4) by

>mta1.onelist.com with SMTP; 3 Oct 1999 16:41:58 -0000

>Received: from La7de@... by imo14.mx.aol.com (mail_out_v22.4.) id

>hLFOa12678 (4235) for < onelist>; Sun, 3 Oct 1999

>12:41:52 -0400 (EDT)

>Message-ID: <20ff474f.2528e150@...>

>X-Mailer: AOL 4.0 for Windows 95 sub 27

>Mailing-List: list onelist; contact

> -owneronelist

>Delivered-mailing list onelist

>Precedence: bulk

>List-Unsubscribe: <mailto: -unsubscribeONElist>

>

>Geri,

>

>I don't think you would be able to see joint swelling, I think that would

>be

>internal. Of course that is only my guess. I can certainly relate to the

>pain you are having in your legs and wrists, even though mine is not nearly

>as bad as yours. The wrist weakness/pain kind of comes and goes, but the

>legs are constant.

>

>I'm so happy for you that your family is coming and will help you with the

>house... Mine is looking pretty neglected, but I just can't seem to find

>the

>heart to care. I go from fatigue to depression to feeling pretty good, and

>at that point I just want to get out of the house and do things, and see my

>family. I too wonder just what the future holds, but that is mostly on my

> " down " days. I have alot of " stuff " going on in my head, and am looking

>forward to seeing my new psyciatrist on Tuesday. I need to get some of

>this

>out...

>

>My appointment with the U of M is not until Nov. 5th. I also made an appt.

>with a rheumatologist for later this month, but today is a " down " day and

>I'm

>wondering why bother. You know it's funny, cause on good days I feel like

>I

>can lick the world.

>

>Tomorrow will surely be a better day, and that is what I hold onto.

>

>Love you,

> (AIH)

>P.S. Thanks for being there....

>

>------------------------------------------------------------------------

>Please support the American Liver Foundation!

>

>1.) To subscribe send e-mail to -subscribeonelist

>2.) To UNsubscribe send to -unsubscribeonelist

>3.) Digest e-mail format send to -digestonelist

>4.) Normal e-mail format send to -normalonelist

><< text3.html >>

[Guest guest]

Dear a,

I suffer from severe recurrent depression amongst

other problems from past trauma. My parent's ND never

mentioned anything about this stuff to me. Does it

really work?

Also, I'm wondering if you are anyone on this list

knows what 's Syndrome is, because my mom was

just recently diagnosed with it.

Mona

P.S. Does anyone know of anything that can help me to

be able to fall asleep at night? Right now I can't

seem to sleep, I've been trying for the last 1 1/2

hours to try to sleep, but nothing.

--- a Perza <chestnutt@...> wrote:

> Hi guys,

> I wanted to comment on the depression that alot of

> you are mentioning. I

> too have experienced this and man was it horrible.

> Anxiety and panick

> attacks as well as severe depression and inability

> to function. Rather

> than the doctors meds such as Xanax or Paxil, my

> homeopath who is my

> godsend recommended BACH flowers. For all you you

> that have been on this

> list for a while you have no doubt heard me mention

> this before. There

> are 38 differnt homeopathic flower remedies that

> work wonders without

> the other side effects of doctor perscribed meds

> that can reak havok

> with our internal organs. If you do a search under

> BACH flowers you will

> find some information on the remedies and perhaps

> identify some that

> would work for you. They are all natural and within

> 2 doses I was back

> to my old self again. I use them now only when I am

> stressed out, have

> to drive at night, am in situations that might be

> nerve racking for me.

> They really do work!

>

> If anyone wants more info or has trouble finding a

> good informative

> site, feel free to contact me personally and I will

> locate a good site

> for you.

> BE WELL,

> a

>

__________________________________________________

[Guest guest]

I have never heard of 's syndrome so on that topic I am useless.

As far as the BACH flowers go... yes.. they work. They are amazing.

They also have a concoction of flowers in combination that is called

RESCUE REMEDY. This is a very common homeopathic remedy. Ask your

homeopath. They also have tinctures at the heath food store for sleep.

The last time I was there I saw a woman purchase one called SLEEPEZE.

It too was a homeopathic remedy. Can be taken directly under tounge or

dropped into water. This one I have not used but I swear by the BACH

flowers.

The point of the whole thing is that if we change our thinking, our

phycology, we will be better able to heal our body. This is too true.

Can you imagine when telling the doctors that you feel unwell they all

stated that since I look so great I was mentally ill rather than unwell.

When 5 so called professionals can't figure it out, and you have to tell

them, it feels like a losing battle and the head space goes.

(consequently with candida I had a mono type of virus) I had to INSIST

on blood work.

The only person who offered me any confort, help or support during the

worst days of my life was the ND that I went to.

ANYHOW>. if you need anymore info, dont hesitate to find me.

BE WELL.

a

Ramona Bates wrote:

>

> From: Ramona Bates <monique_el@...>

>

> Dear a,

>

> I suffer from severe recurrent depression amongst

> other problems from past trauma. My parent's ND never

> mentioned anything about this stuff to me. Does it

> really work?

>

> Also, I'm wondering if you are anyone on this list

> knows what 's Syndrome is, because my mom was

> just recently diagnosed with it.

>

> Mona

>

> P.S. Does anyone know of anything that can help me to

> be able to fall asleep at night? Right now I can't

> seem to sleep, I've been trying for the last 1 1/2

> hours to try to sleep, but nothing.

>

> --- a Perza <chestnutt@...> wrote:

> > Hi guys,

> > I wanted to comment on the depression that alot of

> > you are mentioning. I

> > too have experienced this and man was it horrible.

> > Anxiety and panick

> > attacks as well as severe depression and inability

> > to function. Rather

> > than the doctors meds such as Xanax or Paxil, my

> > homeopath who is my

> > godsend recommended BACH flowers. For all you you

> > that have been on this

> > list for a while you have no doubt heard me mention

> > this before. There

> > are 38 differnt homeopathic flower remedies that

> > work wonders without

> > the other side effects of doctor perscribed meds

> > that can reak havok

> > with our internal organs. If you do a search under

> > BACH flowers you will

> > find some information on the remedies and perhaps

> > identify some that

> > would work for you. They are all natural and within

> > 2 doses I was back

> > to my old self again. I use them now only when I am

> > stressed out, have

> > to drive at night, am in situations that might be

> > nerve racking for me.

> > They really do work!

> >

> > If anyone wants more info or has trouble finding a

> > good informative

> > site, feel free to contact me personally and I will

> > locate a good site

> > for you.

> > BE WELL,

> > a

> >

>

> __________________________________________________

>

[Guest guest]

Hi ,

You all will probably be getting sick of me today..LOL But with a minor in

Psychology and many many research papers on people with limitations, I will

tell you that depression isn't like a light switch it isn't here and then

gone. It run in cycles, we all have good days physically and that reflects

in our mood, and then on those rainy days when we hurt a little more, we get

a little grumpy. Facts are facts, I do motivational speaking and even *I*

have those bad days when I snap at my husband and just want to lay in bed

with the heating pad <yesterday was one of them for me> What I do <and may

help some of you> is on those days I put on a positive sounding song <my

kids sing " High Hopes " to me> and I LOOK for something ANYTHING that I can

accomplish that day, sometimes it is something as simple as pulling up a

chair and cleaning out a junk drawer or sitting on the bed and directing my

daughter as she cleans out the bottom of her closet. Just something to

focus on instead of the depression.

As far as seeing a professional, in general they just sit there and let you

talk, ask you why you think you feel the way you feel etc.. Any good friend

can do that for you and to an extent this group can do that, the problem

with JUST using this group is that via internet you can write anything and

since we don't really know you we don't know if you are being completely

honest so our replies are limited to our perceptions from what you have told

us. Does that make scense?

Hugs,

Deb

The Schuh Family

Dan, Debbie, Dottie, Kody and Wyatt

From: brandy_erin@...

i can see from your replies, that some of you think i suffer from

depression. i had suffered from depression about a year a go, went

through meds and have been depression free since. i have just been

letting things go because i know that you people understand what i

say and hopefully what i feel. i have never had the oppurtunity to

speak like this before so i think its fairly natural to say it all,

good and bad. i didn't intend to worry anyone, i am not depressed.

i actually am quite a happy person, but who could be happy about jra?

do you see what i mean? there is a difference. and i am talking to

you guys, that is a help. i am also glad to know that the others

like myself that have already grown uo with jra fear the same things,

rational or not. the fear of what could happen is almost worse than

the actual happening. please don't worry, i like myself and my life,

i think my worries are pretty normal for the circumstances. even so,

i have at times thought os seeing a professional. what could they

say though? i don't think i am irrational, so what could they help

with except for being someone to talk to that knows nothing about jra

and gets paid big bucks to listen? i am not trying to be difficult,

i just don't see a problem to take to a counselor. do you see or

read something i am missing? i'd like to know, really. is my

attitude bad or something? i really do put a lot of effort into

being a good person. please reply, brandy

[Guest guest]

Depression is very normal to the disease and the therapy. It would be

abnormal if you never were feeling down. With having a chronic, and

potentially lethal disease, the costs-physical and mental, of daily

meds, putting most of your life on hold while you try to beat this

dragon, are issues that have been well documented for any long term

therapy.

Some of my patients have had increased depression during the latter

parts of therapy. So long as your labs are measured, there is no reason

you can not take any of the SSRI antidepression/anxiety medications. The

SSRI class includes Prozac, Wellbutrin, Zoloft, Celexa, etc. Reasonable

doses should not interfere with your therapy.

There are also a few other options you can try. My wife found that

taking the shot first thing in the morning, towards the last few months,

and going to work, was a better time, then in the evening. It makes some

sense, because if you have gotten a good night's rest, and you can

function at your job, taking the medication early, allows less time to

focus on the virus and may help to reduce the psychological affects of

the medications. You are busy, and have less time to focus on what is

coming from the drugs. Some other patients have tried it, and it has

worked well for some, and not as well for others.

It is not a great idea to go off the medications for a week, just

because of the type of depression you are having. If it turns to

thoughts of suicide, or serious other psychiatric problems, then it can

be a possibility.

Taking off one week will probably not hurt you, but, there is no way to

tell what is in the future. Besides, just to be pessimistic for a

moment, if you just take off a week, and after finishing therapy your

viral load goes back up, you will probably be more depressed, and drive

yourself " nuts " , playing the " what if " game, ie: what if I did not stop

that wee?; what if I took another antidepressant?, etc.

If you can refocus on something positive, it may help the depression,

although probably not stop it altogether. I do not think I have ever

seen or heard first hand, a person placed on combo therapy who does not

experience varying degrees of depression/anxiety/panic. It is VERY

normal.

If the SSRIs are helping stay with them and your medications. If the

depression becomes worse, you may benefit stopping for a week. But, this

is usually done for blood results that are really out of whack, and to

give the body a short rest. If your providers have really stated you can

not take the combo therapy and any of the SSRIs at the same time, this

is their opinion, and not based on the research.

But, you have to play the " politics " of the treatment, and, if your

providers really would drop you, then this may be one of the times, if

it were me, that I would not tell them. I went through the same things

with two groups in my area for my wife. When she refused the biopsy, one

GI said he would not treat without this, although he could not explain

why. The other, after finding out she was started on the combo therapy

without the biopsy, and his prescribing the medications, refused to see

her back.

To me, if these providers are so rigid, and will only follow the " cook

book " approach, they probably are not specialists keeping up with HCV,

or, are so strict, they will only do exactly what the protocols state.

They forget that people are different, and need to be treated as a

person, and not just a disease.

I will also mention that, they may be concerned about malpractice,

because if the treatment does not hold, and you took another medication,

you might be able to find some scum attorney who would sue for

malpractice for treating you for something besides the virus itself. The

fact that the depression might make your therapy less effective, would

not be the argument. It stinks, but it is all too true. It is also

possible they have been previously burnt when they combined medications,

and they refuse to take another chance.

But, who knows exactly why, so, see if you can stick it out, and

continue on the medications as long as everything else is within

acceptable levels. Although I never suggest hiding something from your

provider, it sounds like, you may be in a situation that is worse then

keeping this information from them. The final decision must be yours,

under any circumstance.

Hope this helps. Marty

[Guest guest]

Excellent advice, Marty.

byteme wrote:

>

> Depression is very normal to the disease and the therapy. It would be

> abnormal if you never were feeling down. With having a chronic, and

> potentially lethal disease, the costs-physical and mental, of daily

> meds, putting most of your life on hold while you try to beat this

> dragon, are issues that have been well documented for any long term

> therapy.

>

> Some of my patients have had increased depression during the latter

> parts of therapy. So long as your labs are measured, there is no reason

> you can not take any of the SSRI antidepression/anxiety medications. The

> SSRI class includes Prozac, Wellbutrin, Zoloft, Celexa, etc. Reasonable

> doses should not interfere with your therapy.

>

> There are also a few other options you can try. My wife found that

> taking the shot first thing in the morning, towards the last few months,

> and going to work, was a better time, then in the evening. It makes some

> sense, because if you have gotten a good night's rest, and you can

> function at your job, taking the medication early, allows less time to

> focus on the virus and may help to reduce the psychological affects of

> the medications. You are busy, and have less time to focus on what is

> coming from the drugs. Some other patients have tried it, and it has

> worked well for some, and not as well for others.

>

> It is not a great idea to go off the medications for a week, just

> because of the type of depression you are having. If it turns to

> thoughts of suicide, or serious other psychiatric problems, then it can

> be a possibility.

>

> Taking off one week will probably not hurt you, but, there is no way to

> tell what is in the future. Besides, just to be pessimistic for a

> moment, if you just take off a week, and after finishing therapy your

> viral load goes back up, you will probably be more depressed, and drive

> yourself " nuts " , playing the " what if " game, ie: what if I did not stop

> that wee?; what if I took another antidepressant?, etc.

>

> If you can refocus on something positive, it may help the depression,

> although probably not stop it altogether. I do not think I have ever

> seen or heard first hand, a person placed on combo therapy who does not

> experience varying degrees of depression/anxiety/panic. It is VERY

> normal.

>

> If the SSRIs are helping stay with them and your medications. If the

> depression becomes worse, you may benefit stopping for a week. But, this

> is usually done for blood results that are really out of whack, and to

> give the body a short rest. If your providers have really stated you can

> not take the combo therapy and any of the SSRIs at the same time, this

> is their opinion, and not based on the research.

>

> But, you have to play the " politics " of the treatment, and, if your

> providers really would drop you, then this may be one of the times, if

> it were me, that I would not tell them. I went through the same things

> with two groups in my area for my wife. When she refused the biopsy, one

> GI said he would not treat without this, although he could not explain

> why. The other, after finding out she was started on the combo therapy

> without the biopsy, and his prescribing the medications, refused to see

> her back.

>

> To me, if these providers are so rigid, and will only follow the " cook

> book " approach, they probably are not specialists keeping up with HCV,

> or, are so strict, they will only do exactly what the protocols state.

> They forget that people are different, and need to be treated as a

> person, and not just a disease.

>

> I will also mention that, they may be concerned about malpractice,

> because if the treatment does not hold, and you took another medication,

> you might be able to find some scum attorney who would sue for

> malpractice for treating you for something besides the virus itself. The

> fact that the depression might make your therapy less effective, would

> not be the argument. It stinks, but it is all too true. It is also

> possible they have been previously burnt when they combined medications,

> and they refuse to take another chance.

>

> But, who knows exactly why, so, see if you can stick it out, and

> continue on the medications as long as everything else is within

> acceptable levels. Although I never suggest hiding something from your

> provider, it sounds like, you may be in a situation that is worse then

> keeping this information from them. The final decision must be yours,

> under any circumstance.

>

> Hope this helps. Marty

>

> ------------------------------------------------------------------------

> You can win $1000!

> Time-limited offer. Enter today at:

> 1/2864/0/_/619765/_/955863269/

> ------------------------------------------------------------------------

>

>

[Guest guest]

In a message dated 5/9/00 4:52:18 PM Eastern Daylight Time,

n.scott@... writes:

<< (altho sweet potato chips may be beneficial, eating an entire bag in

one evening can't be good). >>

Hi ,

That would be my guess as well. Where can I get sweet potato chips? :}

Many things cause depression. Ceasing the eating of 'comfort' foods leaves

hidden depression in the open. Exercise, plenty of water, good doses of

sunshine help me. Also kelp, greens, bladderwrack are helpful if your low

temps show a low thyroid function which gives a feeling of slowness, sadness,

and fatique.

Don't panic. Dont fight or fear the depression. Treat yourself well,

instead. If you stay depressed you should get help. But it's not surprising

to feel let down, with the changes you are making.

You can do it.

Bye,

Ann Moss in Florida

©