Guest guest Posted December 3, 2002 Report Posted December 3, 2002 Percentages should be the same in Canada as anywhere else. Here's what I've seen: Achondroplasia: between one in 26,000 and one in 40,000 births SED: one in 90,000 births Diastrophic dysplasia: one in 110,000 births All types of dwarfism: maybe one in 10,000 births Dan Kennedy Editor, LPA Online Little People of America, Inc. <http://www.lpaonline.org> >Hi, Does Anybody have any reliable statistics on the overall >percentage of people in the country of Canada that have some form of >dwarfism? If you have any or know anywhere I could find these please >post them. I would greatly appreciate it. Thanks, > Quote
Guest guest Posted May 22, 2005 Report Posted May 22, 2005 Jess, I just wanted to point out a few things here... I'm not sure if I followed the "tone" of your post, but it seemed like you thought that some of these things were significant in some way. You said "i still found it interesting that re-opperation is so common & usuallyfor LES related procedures." Please note that they specified that *ESOPHAGEAL* reoperations are LES related (GERD or achalasia). Think about that for a minute..... since most *esophageal* surgeries are LES related, it would make sense that most of the "repeat" operations would be LES related. TCC is also renowned for these types of surgeries (both initial operations and repeats) -- they have patients that come from across the country JUST to be treated there, so it's not surprising that such a large number of their thoracic surgeries are for achalasia. Dr. Rice has become legendary for his expertise in achalasia surgery, and members of the group who are his patients come here and sing his praises after their surgeries. I know that when the time comes for me to have surgery, I'll be going to Dr. Rice, even if he's not at TCC anymore. (Now, as a side note to anyone who has met the man.... does he remind anyone else of Emerson Winchester III from the tv show M*A*S*H ??? Not personality-wise, he's much more personable! But looks-wise I saw quite a similarity, which I find funny b/c ' character was a thoracic surgeon! LOL) Debbi in Michigan From: Jess achalasia Sent: Sunday, May 22, 2005 3:49 AM Subject: Statistics I was perusing Clevland Clinic's website, I bounced via a link lookingfor a surgeon in California, but I digress.Here are some interesting Achalasia related statistics for Clevland Clinic27% of their Thoracic surgeries are for Achalasia.Reoperative surgery is becoming an increasing proportion of theiresophegeal practice. Currently at 15%. The majority of esophegealreoperations are for failed GERD or Achalsia treatments.In 2004 70% of their myotomies were Laproscopic & 30% open.Obviously the #'s would not be identical for all facilities, but istill found it interesting that re-opperation is so common & usuallyfor LES related procedures. Oh yes, and apparently they consider theEsophagectomy to be the most technically challenging thoracicproceedure. Good to know. -Jess Quote
Guest guest Posted May 25, 2005 Report Posted May 25, 2005 Well, I definitely found the statistics interesting because I haven't seen anything so well put together for any facilities in my area. Your statement on majority re-operated & majority LES operations is true. LES operations accounted for about 64% of operations. They didn't give an exact % for re-ops, but I had gotten the impression it was a larger majority. One should take into account however that 29% of the operations are resections for cancer which one would think is a more difficult operation. Just goes to show what a technical procedure we're all asking for. And I hadn't thought of it before but as you, and another member, pointed out (duh) of course people would come to a better hospital to fix a botched procedure. This makes perfect sense. I only wish I had the ability to research the surgeons available at my hospital. Unfortunately I'm stumped because the supposed thoracic surgeons that my GI mentioned are all listed as General and now I can't locate the `specialists'. I'm utterly lost and basically I've given up until I at least talk to the surgeon I'm already scheduled with. Anyway, I just found the numbers interesting, but then again I get dazzled easily by graphs & statistics -Jess > Jess, I just wanted to point out a few things here... I'm not sure if I followed the " tone " of your post, but it seemed like you thought that some of these things were significant in some way. > > You said " i still found it interesting that re-opperation is so common & usually > for LES related procedures. " Please note that they specified that *ESOPHAGEAL* reoperations are LES related (GERD or achalasia). Think about that for a minute..... since most *esophageal* surgeries are LES related, it would make sense that most of the " repeat " operations would be LES related. > > TCC is also renowned for these types of surgeries (both initial operations and repeats) -- they have patients that come from across the country JUST to be treated there, so it's not surprising that such a large number of their thoracic surgeries are for achalasia. Dr. Rice has become legendary for his expertise in achalasia surgery, and members of the group who are his patients come here and sing his praises after their surgeries. > > I know that when the time comes for me to have surgery, I'll be going to Dr. Rice, even if he's not at TCC anymore. (Now, as a side note to anyone who has met the man.... does he remind anyone else of Emerson Winchester III from the tv show M*A*S*H ??? Not personality-wise, he's much more personable! But looks-wise I saw quite a similarity, which I find funny b/c ' character was a thoracic surgeon! LOL) > > Debbi in Michigan Quote
Guest guest Posted May 25, 2005 Report Posted May 25, 2005 Jess wrote: Anyway, I just found the numbers interesting, but then again I get dazzled easily by graphs & statistics Well folks, now we know -- if we want to impress Jess, just whip together a bar graph! LOLDebbi, feeling like a smarty pants today Quote
Guest guest Posted October 30, 2005 Report Posted October 30, 2005 , I find that hard to believe, too. I'm understanding speech more and more all the time, especially when I practice " in the dark " with my husband. I'm also surprising myself by picking up phrases in a prayer or phone conversation that I'm not really even listening for. I still have a long way to go. I'm a person that has been a lip reader all of my life (48 years). Laurie in TN Born with Severe/Profound hearing loss Implanted with Freedom 08/30/05 Activated 09/20/2005 Quote
Guest guest Posted October 30, 2005 Report Posted October 30, 2005 hi , Was this " friend " of yours prelingual? Is the friend wearing a cochlear implant? Larry statistics >A friend of mine, said that only 3% of CI patients can hear and > distinguish speech sounds. I find that hard to believe, thinking it > should be much higher than that. > Does anyone have actual statistics? > Thanks, > > Freedom 9/21/05 HOOKED!! > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 30, 2005 Report Posted October 30, 2005 Hello , I think if you just kept track of the person on this list you will find that the percentage is much higher than what your friend described. I have had my CI for three years plus now and I am on several forums and the percentage is much higher. statistics > A friend of mine, said that only 3% of CI patients can hear and > distinguish speech sounds. I find that hard to believe, thinking it > should be much higher than that. > Does anyone have actual statistics? > Thanks, > > Freedom 9/21/05 HOOKED!! > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 30, 2005 Report Posted October 30, 2005 This " friend " is a non CI user, she has been deaf since infancy. However she does have excellent speech and language skills for never having worn hearing aids, and holds two masters degrees. I wanted to direct her to a reliable documentation that would be more representative of the statistics. I KNOW 3% is incorrect. Freedom 9/21/05 HOOKED!! > > hi , > Was this " friend " of yours prelingual? Is the friend wearing a cochlear > implant? Larry > statistics > > > >A friend of mine, said that only 3% of CI patients can hear and > > distinguish speech sounds. I find that hard to believe, thinking it > > should be much higher than that. > > Does anyone have actual statistics? > > Thanks, > > > > Freedom 9/21/05 HOOKED!! > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 30, 2005 Report Posted October 30, 2005 , It sounds as if your friend is not updated. Many years ago, the statistics were not nearly as good as they are today. You might ask her to join this list and ask questions and to go to the website at http://www..com where she can read the CI Stories. Of particular interest to her might be this link http://clerccenter2.gallaudet.edu/kidsworlddeafnet/e-docs/CI/index.html which is in the resources section of the site. Alice http://www..com Quote
Guest guest Posted October 30, 2005 Report Posted October 30, 2005 , There is a lot of misinformation in the deaf community when it comes to implants. While some do want to badmouth implants because they fear a loss of their culture, others just receive the information and accept it. It's good that your friend is asking the right questions so she can be educated about the implant. In a message dated 10/30/2005 4:14:15 PM Eastern Standard Time, lwilson005@... writes: Hi , May I suggest this " deaf " friend is trying, to the best of her ability, to bad mouth people with Ci's. If the success ratio were only 3%: How could they stay in business? Would there be three companies making ci's? Why has Quote
Guest guest Posted October 30, 2005 Report Posted October 30, 2005 Hi , May I suggest this " deaf " friend is trying, to the best of her ability, to bad mouth people with Ci's. If the success ratio were only 3%: How could they stay in business? Would there be three companies making ci's? Why has the fda approved these implants if the ratio is only 3%? Did you ask her where she got this data? Master degrees? Maybe she should go for her PhD. (piled high and dry) Larry statistics >> >> >> >A friend of mine, said that only 3% of CI patients can hear and >> > distinguish speech sounds. I find that hard to believe, thinking it >> > should be much higher than that. >> > Does anyone have actual statistics? >> > Thanks, >> > >> > Freedom 9/21/05 HOOKED!! >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 30, 2005 Report Posted October 30, 2005 I agree with that assessment about being alot of misinformation out there. In another forum that I keep up with, I saw a comment that a person didn't know that water is not a problem with a CI as the wearer simply takes it off! (i.e., taking a shower, swimming, scuba diving [restricted depth of course] and etc.). I would not believe the 3% success rate remark either. I am one of those successful ones and I have run into another person in my church who has bilaterals and is doing very well with them as well. Then there is all the people I heard from my audi and those on this forum and even the other forum I keep up with of folks are can do pretty well with their CIs. Somebody's math just doesn't add up. I would be more inclined to believe that there is a 3% failure rate for people with CIs (not due to technical reasons but the inability to use it for one reason or another). Dale --- Ci92000@... wrote: > , > There is a lot of misinformation in the deaf > community when it comes to > implants. While some do want to badmouth implants > because they fear a loss of > their culture, others just receive the information > and accept it. It's good > that your friend is asking the right questions so > she can be educated about the > implant. > > > In a message dated 10/30/2005 4:14:15 PM Eastern > Standard Time, > lwilson005@... writes: > Hi , > May I suggest this " deaf " friend is trying, to > the best of her ability, > to bad mouth people with Ci's. If the success ratio > were only 3%: How could > they stay in business? Would there be three > companies making ci's? Why has > > > [Non-text portions of this message have been > removed] > > __________________________________ - PC Magazine Editors' Choice 2005 http://mail. Quote
Guest guest Posted October 30, 2005 Report Posted October 30, 2005 I agree Dale...a lot of misreprensentation. That means we as successful CI users need to educate the community in our areas. I was once told by my family doctor that unless I spoke out to the community, no one was going to understand deafness. I'll bet he'd say the same thing about the success of CI's. Freedom 9/21/05 HOOKED!! > > > , > > There is a lot of misinformation in the deaf > > community when it comes to > > implants. While some do want to badmouth implants > > because they fear a loss of > > their culture, others just receive the information > > and accept it. It's good > > that your friend is asking the right questions so > > she can be educated about the > > implant. > > > > > > In a message dated 10/30/2005 4:14:15 PM Eastern > > Standard Time, > > lwilson005@c... writes: > > Hi , > > May I suggest this " deaf " friend is trying, to > > the best of her ability, > > to bad mouth people with Ci's. If the success ratio > > were only 3%: How could > > they stay in business? Would there be three > > companies making ci's? Why has > > > > > > [Non-text portions of this message have been > > removed] > > > > > > > > > > __________________________________ > - PC Magazine Editors' Choice 2005 > http://mail. > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 12, 2006 Report Posted October 12, 2006 Virg, LOL! When I talked to my professor at the beginning of the semester, I told him I thought the class would be interesting (just to see what kind of a reaction I would get). You know what? He actually believed me -- probably because I was the first student ever to tell him that. LOL! Left ear - Nucleus 24 Contour Advance with 3G Implanted: 12/22/04 Activated: 1/18/05 Right ear - Nucleus Freedom Implanted: 2/1/06 Activated: 3/1/06 Quote
Guest guest Posted October 13, 2006 Report Posted October 13, 2006 Oh, ! What a way to get on your prof's good side! LOL Good luck on mid-terms! (smiles) Jackie Quote
Guest guest Posted October 14, 2006 Report Posted October 14, 2006 Jackie, LOL! I never thought about it that way, but you're right. <grin> If I earn an " A " on my exam, I will most definitely be on his good side! (Hoping and praying...) Left ear - Nucleus 24 Contour Advance with 3G Implanted: 12/22/04 Activated: 1/18/05 Right ear - Nucleus Freedom Implanted: 2/1/06 Activated: 3/1/06 Quote
Guest guest Posted January 14, 2007 Report Posted January 14, 2007 Francine, I don't know if anyone has a handle on the numbers you are seeking. On the various scoli boards I read people have speculated and some have tried to get solid numbers out of the Scoliosis Research Society, but without much success. I think the best you can do is know that if you have a true HR (not the segmental type that followed the long straight original rod), and if you are fused to L4 or L5 from somewhere in the thoracic spine....the patient is more likely than not to develop problems, if not outright flatback. may have some other data to point you to. I know when I was curious about this kind of stuff I spent a lot of time on www.pubmed.com looking at the research....you might get some satisfaction there. If nothing else...you will learn some things, I promise. For instance yesterday when I was looking for info for Alpine I learned another name for the condition many of us have that is related to our scoli surgery but not quite flatback. They have a nice euphamism for it....it is called " Transition Syndrome " . Right....transitioning from an active and full life to that of a pain ridden couch potato....aaarrrggghhhh. Take Care, Cam > > Does anyone know of reliable statistics on the frequency of > flatback? I'd be interested to know how many people either worldwide > or in the U.S. have had Harrington rods implanted. Of those, how many > develop flatback. Of those, how many get revision surgery. Of those, > how long is the average fusion length to sacrum. etc. What I'm really > wondering is how rare is our condition of having this really long > solid bone of a spine? To me, it's got to be very rare, but it's the > actual statistics that I'd love to find out. > Francine > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 14, 2007 Report Posted January 14, 2007 Hey, Cam - what is " transition syndome " ? Do you have a link where I can read more? Thanks! Deb > > > > Does anyone know of reliable statistics on the frequency of > > flatback? I'd be interested to know how many people either worldwide > > or in the U.S. have had Harrington rods implanted. Of those, how > many > > develop flatback. Of those, how many get revision surgery. Of > those, > > how long is the average fusion length to sacrum. etc. What I'm > really > > wondering is how rare is our condition of having this really long > > solid bone of a spine? To me, it's got to be very rare, but it's the > > actual statistics that I'd love to find out. > > Francine > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 14, 2007 Report Posted January 14, 2007 I wonder if that "transitional syndrome" is the same as "junctional syndrome", where the joints immediately below or above a long fusion get worn out. That's what Dr. LaGrone called it in his letter to me. That would be the transition between fused and unfused spinal segments --- although I do like your interpretation, Cam. Sharon [ ] Re: Statistics Francine,I don't know if anyone has a handle on the numbers you are seeking. On the various scoli boards I read people have speculated and some have tried to get solid numbers out of the Scoliosis Research Society, but without much success.I think the best you can do is know that if you have a true HR (not the segmental type that followed the long straight original rod), and if you are fused to L4 or L5 from somewhere in the thoracic spine....the patient is more likely than not to develop problems, if not outright flatback. may have some other data to point you to. I know when I was curious about this kind of stuff I spent a lot of time on www.pubmed.com looking at the research....you might get some satisfaction there. If nothing else...you will learn some things, I promise. For instance yesterday when I was looking for info for Alpine I learned another name for the condition many of us have that is related to our scoli surgery but not quite flatback. They have a nice euphamism for it....it is called "Transition Syndrome".Right....transitioning from an active and full life to that of a pain ridden couch potato....aaarrrggghhhh.Take Care, Cam>> Does anyone know of reliable statistics on the frequency of > flatback? I'd be interested to know how many people either worldwide > or in the U.S. have had Harrington rods implanted. Of those, how many > develop flatback. Of those, how many get revision surgery. Of those, > how long is the average fusion length to sacrum. etc. What I'm really > wondering is how rare is our condition of having this really long > solid bone of a spine? To me, it's got to be very rare, but it's the > actual statistics that I'd love to find out.> Francine> Quote
Guest guest Posted January 14, 2007 Report Posted January 14, 2007 ....Or NO implants at all. <cammaltby@...> wrote:...flatback is possible with other implants.Take Care, Cam Quote
Guest guest Posted January 15, 2007 Report Posted January 15, 2007 While looking through my search returns using "scoliosis" + "syndrome" this article popped up: http://www.ocpamn.com/skeleton/spine/spine2.cfm The Orthopaedic Consultant,PA website history says they are the group founded by Dr Moe, one of the "go to" scoli doctors in his day. I must say that I think it is one of the most suscinct articles detailing scoliosis, and all the associated thinking, risks, problems (including flat back), bracing, adult treatment...the gamut. Anyway...here is their summary (from the full article) of the incidence of flatback following HR surgery that Peggy was asking about (40%). If that number is correct, and the number of primary HR surgeries could be determined, then you could find a base number of folks affected by flatback deformity. Judging by the numbers that join the various support groups on line, we are just the tip of the iceberg: Instrumentation Harrington Procedure. Until ten years ago, the standard instruments used in fusion procedures were those of the Harrington procedure, first developed in the 1960s: To support the fusion of the vertebrae, the surgeon uses a steel rod, extending from the bottom to the top of the curve. (More than one rod may be used depending on the type of curve and whether kyphosis is present.) The rod is attached by hooks that are suspended from pegs inserted into the bone. Similar to changing a tire, the steel rod is jacked up and then locked into place to support the spine securely. The surgeon is then ready to fuse the vertebrae together. After this operation, patients are required to wear a full body cast and lie in bed for three to six months until fusion is complete enough to stabilize the spine. The Harrington procedure is very difficult to undergo, particularly for young people, and although the operation can achieve a correction of the curve of over 50%, studies have reported a loss in this correction of between 10% to 25% over time. The procedure does not correct the rotation of the spine and, therefore, does not improve an existing rib hump that was caused by the rotation. The operation does not interfere with normal pregnancies and deliveries later in life. Certain complications may occur from this procedure: About 40% of Harrington patients have a condition called the flat back syndrome, because the procedure eliminates normal lordosis (the inward curving of the lower back). Flat back syndrome from the Harrington procedure does not cause any immediate pain, but in later years the discs may collapse below the fusion and cause difficulty in standing erect. Studies have reported that five to seven years after their surgery between 20% and a third of patients who had the Harrington procedure experienced low back pain. (In one study only 3% had experienced back pain before surgery.) In such cases, however, the pain was not severe enough to interfere with normal activities and did not require additional surgery. In some cases corrective surgery called closing wedge osteotomy may be needed, in which wedges of bone from the fused mass are removed and spaces are closed to restore a curve. In children under eleven whose skeleton is immature and who have the Harrington procedure, there is a fairly high risk for a specific curve progression called the crankshaft phenomenon. This condition occurs after the procedure when the front of the fused spine continues to grow. The spine cannot grow longer, so it twists and develops a curvature. In one study that followed patients for between five and 16 years, crankshaft curve progression was moderate, however, with the Cobb angle averaging 9 degrees and rotation averaging 7 degrees. Cotrel-Dubousset Procedure. The Cotrel-Dubousset procedure not only corrects the curve but may also help to correct rotation, and it does not cause flat back syndrome: With this procedure, parallel rods are cross-linked for better stability in holding the fused vertebrae. Improvement in correction averaged 66% in one study, with a later correction loss reported to be 5%. (Other studies have reported loss of curvature correction at less than 2%.) Over 95% of patients reported the results to be good or very good (only 86% of patients who had the Harrington procedure experienced the same levels of satisfaction). Patients often go home in five days and may be back in school in three weeks. Complication rates are similar to the Harrington procedure, but there are some differences: Operation time and blood loss are greater than with Harrington procedure. Cotrel-Dubousset and other procedures that are designed to reverse the rotation of the spine have less risk for flat back syndrome but they have a higher risk for spinal imbalance than the Harrington procedure. Cotrel-Dubousset instrumentation does not eliminate the risk for disc deterioration later on, which in one follow-up study occurred in nearly a quarter of the patients. Experts hope that the advances in current scoliosis procedures will help reduce the long-term adverse effects. Other Instrumentations. Other instrumentation procedures have refined the hardware used in the Harrington and Cotrel-Dubousset operations. The Texas ish-Rite instrumentation (TSRH) is similar to the Cotrel-Dubousset procedure in that it uses parallel rods and other devices that reverse rotation as well as improve curvature. The instruments, however, use smooth rods and hooks that are designed to make removal or adjustment easier later on if complications arise. Complications are similar to the Cotrel-Dubousset procedure. Another technique to prevent rotation is the Wisconsin segmental spine instrumentation (WSSI). Luque instrumentation was developed to help maintain normal lordosis and experts hoped that bracing would not be needed afterward with this device. A number of studies showed, however, that without braces, correction was lost after this operation, and there also may be a higher risk for spinal cord injury than with standard procedures. Luque instrumentation is used primarily in people whose scoliosis is due to problems of nerves and muscles. The use of a device called a pedicle screw to stabilize the fused spine is now being used and, after early high complication rates, is now proving to be reliable and effective. European studies are reporting that complication rates are now acceptable and there is a very low risk for neurologic injury. And there you have it. Cam Quote
Guest guest Posted January 15, 2007 Report Posted January 15, 2007 Dear Cam, Wow, this is what I read awhile back. Someone awhile back asked what percentage of people with Harrington Rods would develope Flatback, and I remembered reading somewhere that around 40 percent. Good to know I wasn't loosing my mind! I think in that conversation someones doc said that all Harrington Rod patients would develope it. I think 40 percent is probably on the low side, and 100 percent on the high side. I have met women that are my age, still have their rods and are doing well, and lets hope they always do! [ ] Re: Statistics While looking through my search returns using "scoliosis" + "syndrome" this article popped up: http://www.ocpamn.com/skeleton/spine/spine2.cfm The Orthopaedic Consultant,PA website history says they are the group founded by Dr Moe, one of the "go to" scoli doctors in his day. I must say that I think it is one of the most suscinct articles detailing scoliosis, and all the associated thinking, risks, problems (including flat back), bracing, adult treatment...the gamut. Anyway...here is their summary (from the full article) of the incidence of flatback following HR surgery that Peggy was asking about (40%). If that number is correct, and the number of primary HR surgeries could be determined, then you could find a base number of folks affected by flatback deformity. Judging by the numbers that join the various support groups on line, we are just the tip of the iceberg: Instrumentation Harrington Procedure. Until ten years ago, the standard instruments used in fusion procedures were those of the Harrington procedure, first developed in the 1960s: To support the fusion of the vertebrae, the surgeon uses a steel rod, extending from the bottom to the top of the curve. (More than one rod may be used depending on the type of curve and whether kyphosis is present.) The rod is attached by hooks that are suspended from pegs inserted into the bone. Similar to changing a tire, the steel rod is jacked up and then locked into place to support the spine securely. The surgeon is then ready to fuse the vertebrae together. After this operation, patients are required to wear a full body cast and lie in bed for three to six months until fusion is complete enough to stabilize the spine. The Harrington procedure is very difficult to undergo, particularly for young people, and although the operation can achieve a correction of the curve of over 50%, studies have reported a loss in this correction of between 10% to 25% over time. The procedure does not correct the rotation of the spine and, therefore, does not improve an existing rib hump that was caused by the rotation. The operation does not interfere with normal pregnancies and deliveries later in life. Certain complications may occur from this procedure: About 40% of Harrington patients have a condition called the flat back syndrome, because the procedure eliminates normal lordosis (the inward curving of the lower back). Flat back syndrome from the Harrington procedure does not cause any immediate pain, but in later years the discs may collapse below the fusion and cause difficulty in standing erect. Studies have reported that five to seven years after their surgery between 20% and a third of patients who had the Harrington procedure experienced low back pain. (In one study only 3% had experienced back pain before surgery.) In such cases, however, the pain was not severe enough to interfere with normal activities and did not require additional surgery. In some cases corrective surgery called closing wedge osteotomy may be needed, in which wedges of bone from the fused mass are removed and spaces are closed to restore a curve. In children under eleven whose skeleton is immature and who have the Harrington procedure, there is a fairly high risk for a specific curve progression called the crankshaft phenomenon. This condition occurs after the procedure when the front of the fused spine continues to grow. The spine cannot grow longer, so it twists and develops a curvature. In one study that followed patients for between five and 16 years, crankshaft curve progression was moderate, however, with the Cobb angle averaging 9 degrees and rotation averaging 7 degrees. Cotrel-Dubousset Procedure. The Cotrel-Dubousset procedure not only corrects the curve but may also help to correct rotation, and it does not cause flat back syndrome: With this procedure, parallel rods are cross-linked for better stability in holding the fused vertebrae. Improvement in correction averaged 66% in one study, with a later correction loss reported to be 5%. (Other studies have reported loss of curvature correction at less than 2%.) Over 95% of patients reported the results to be good or very good (only 86% of patients who had the Harrington procedure experienced the same levels of satisfaction). Patients often go home in five days and may be back in school in three weeks. Complication rates are similar to the Harrington procedure, but there are some differences: Operation time and blood loss are greater than with Harrington procedure. Cotrel-Dubousset and other procedures that are designed to reverse the rotation of the spine have less risk for flat back syndrome but they have a higher risk for spinal imbalance than the Harrington procedure. Cotrel-Dubousset instrumentation does not eliminate the risk for disc deterioration later on, which in one follow-up study occurred in nearly a quarter of the patients. Experts hope that the advances in current scoliosis procedures will help reduce the long-term adverse effects. Other Instrumentations. Other instrumentation procedures have refined the hardware used in the Harrington and Cotrel-Dubousset operations. The Texas ish-Rite instrumentation (TSRH) is similar to the Cotrel-Dubousset procedure in that it uses parallel rods and other devices that reverse rotation as well as improve curvature. The instruments, however, use smooth rods and hooks that are designed to make removal or adjustment easier later on if complications arise. Complications are similar to the Cotrel-Dubousset procedure. Another technique to prevent rotation is the Wisconsin segmental spine instrumentation (WSSI). Luque instrumentation was developed to help maintain normal lordosis and experts hoped that bracing would not be needed afterward with this device. A number of studies showed, however, that without braces, correction was lost after this operation, and there also may be a higher risk for spinal cord injury than with standard procedures. Luque instrumentation is used primarily in people whose scoliosis is due to problems of nerves and muscles. The use of a device called a pedicle screw to stabilize the fused spine is now being used and, after early high complication rates, is now proving to be reliable and effective. European studies are reporting that complication rates are now acceptable and there is a very low risk for neurologic injury. And there you have it. Cam Quote
Guest guest Posted January 15, 2007 Report Posted January 15, 2007 Cam... I talked to Dr. Marc Asher about this subject two years ago. He runs the Harrington Archives in Kansas City. He said there would be absolutely no way to know the number of Harrington rod patients. He couldn’t even estimate whether it would be thousands, tends of thousands, or hundreds of thousands. Regards, On 1/15/07 8:15 AM, " cammaltby " <cammaltby@...> wrote: While looking through my search returns using " scoliosis " + " syndrome " this article popped up: http://www.ocpamn.com/skeleton/spine/spine2.cfm The Orthopaedic Consultant,PA website history says they are the group founded by Dr Moe, one of the " go to " scoli doctors in his day. I must say that I think it is one of the most suscinct articles detailing scoliosis, and all the associated thinking, risks, problems (including flat back), bracing, adult treatment...the gamut. Anyway...here is their summary (from the full article) of the incidence of flatback following HR surgery that Peggy was asking about (40%). If that number is correct, and the number of primary HR surgeries could be determined, then you could find a base number of folks affected by flatback deformity. Judging by the numbers that join the various support groups on line, we are just the tip of the iceberg: Instrumentation Harrington Procedure. Until ten years ago, the standard instruments used in fusion procedures were those of the Harrington procedure, first developed in the 1960s: To support the fusion of the vertebrae, the surgeon uses a steel rod, extending from the bottom to the top of the curve. (More than one rod may be used depending on the type of curve and whether kyphosis is present.) The rod is attached by hooks that are suspended from pegs inserted into the bone. Similar to changing a tire, the steel rod is jacked up and then locked into place to support the spine securely. The surgeon is then ready to fuse the vertebrae together. After this operation, patients are required to wear a full body cast and lie in bed for three to six months until fusion is complete enough to stabilize the spine. The Harrington procedure is very difficult to undergo, particularly for young people, and although the operation can achieve a correction of the curve of over 50%, studies have reported a loss in this correction of between 10% to 25% over time. The procedure does not correct the rotation of the spine and, therefore, does not improve an existing rib hump that was caused by the rotation. The operation does not interfere with normal pregnancies and deliveries later in life. Certain complications may occur from this procedure: About 40% of Harrington patients have a condition called the flat back syndrome, because the procedure eliminates normal lordosis (the inward curving of the lower back). Flat back syndrome from the Harrington procedure does not cause any immediate pain, but in later years the discs may collapse below the fusion and cause difficulty in standing erect. Studies have reported that five to seven years after their surgery between 20% and a third of patients who had the Harrington procedure experienced low back pain. (In one study only 3% had experienced back pain before surgery.) In such cases, however, the pain was not severe enough to interfere with normal activities and did not require additional surgery. In some cases corrective surgery called closing wedge osteotomy may be needed, in which wedges of bone from the fused mass are removed and spaces are closed to restore a curve. In children under eleven whose skeleton is immature and who have the Harrington procedure, there is a fairly high risk for a specific curve progression called the crankshaft phenomenon. This condition occurs after the procedure when the front of the fused spine continues to grow. The spine cannot grow longer, so it twists and develops a curvature. In one study that followed patients for between five and 16 years, crankshaft curve progression was moderate, however, with the Cobb angle averaging 9 degrees and rotation averaging 7 degrees. Cotrel-Dubousset Procedure. The Cotrel-Dubousset procedure not only corrects the curve but may also help to correct rotation, and it does not cause flat back syndrome: With this procedure, parallel rods are cross-linked for better stability in holding the fused vertebrae. Improvement in correction averaged 66% in one study, with a later correction loss reported to be 5%. (Other studies have reported loss of curvature correction at less than 2%.) Over 95% of patients reported the results to be good or very good (only 86% of patients who had the Harrington procedure experienced the same levels of satisfaction). Patients often go home in five days and may be back in school in three weeks. Complication rates are similar to the Harrington procedure, but there are some differences: Operation time and blood loss are greater than with Harrington procedure. Cotrel-Dubousset and other procedures that are designed to reverse the rotation of the spine have less risk for flat back syndrome but they have a higher risk for spinal imbalance than the Harrington procedure. Cotrel-Dubousset instrumentation does not eliminate the risk for disc deterioration later on, which in one follow-up study occurred in nearly a quarter of the patients. Experts hope that the advances in current scoliosis procedures will help reduce the long-term adverse effects. Other Instrumentations. Other instrumentation procedures have refined the hardware used in the Harrington and Cotrel-Dubousset operations. The Texas ish-Rite instrumentation (TSRH) is similar to the Cotrel-Dubousset procedure in that it uses parallel rods and other devices that reverse rotation as well as improve curvature. The instruments, however, use smooth rods and hooks that are designed to make removal or adjustment easier later on if complications arise. Complications are similar to the Cotrel-Dubousset procedure. Another technique to prevent rotation is the Wisconsin segmental spine instrumentation (WSSI). Luque instrumentation was developed to help maintain normal lordosis and experts hoped that bracing would not be needed afterward with this device. A number of studies showed, however, that without braces, correction was lost after this operation, and there also may be a higher risk for spinal cord injury than with standard procedures. Luque instrumentation is used primarily in people whose scoliosis is due to problems of nerves and muscles. The use of a device called a pedicle screw to stabilize the fused spine is now being used and, after early high complication rates, is now proving to be reliable and effective. European studies are reporting that complication rates are now acceptable and there is a very low risk for neurologic injury. And there you have it. Cam Quote
Guest guest Posted January 15, 2007 Report Posted January 15, 2007 Hi ... Many HR patients had only short fusions done in their thoracic spines, and thus, probably have a lot fewer problems than those with longer fusions into the lumbar spine, so 40% seems about right to me. Regards, On 1/15/07 8:42 AM, " Kirkaldie " <.Kirkaldie@...> wrote: Dear Cam, Wow, this is what I read awhile back. Someone awhile back asked what percentage of people with Harrington Rods would develope Flatback, and I remembered reading somewhere that around 40 percent. Good to know I wasn't loosing my mind! I think in that conversation someones doc said that all Harrington Rod patients would develope it. I think 40 percent is probably on the low side, and 100 percent on the high side. I have met women that are my age, still have their rods and are doing well, and lets hope they always do! Quote
Guest guest Posted January 15, 2007 Report Posted January 15, 2007 , Well...there wasn't really a date on that piece, except that it says that Harrington Rods had stopped being used 10 years previously...so that statement alone probably means it is late '90's...almost 10 years old. We HR patients are now 10 years older and the incidence probably has risen above 40%...and there my be some research supporting that idea. My new guess is at least 40% will develop flatback and the rest will develop " Transition syndrome " if they are fused below L2!!! Take Care, Cam Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.