Guest guest Posted January 15, 2007 Report Posted January 15, 2007 I guess I now know the official term for the unfortunate and rapid demise of my L2-3 disc after the initial surgery ;o) Something I was told by the surgeon I first saw about my flatback is that severe and early disc degeneration in the disc immediately below a fusion is considerably more common in people who had earlier anterior procedures. I'm not sure if there are any studies out there to back this up, or whether it was more of an anecdote based on what he'd seen over the years, but either way he seemed to think that the anterior had a lot to do with my disc collapse. Specifically, the reason for this was that you can see clearly on my xray a whole load of little staples that were used to clamp off blood vessels in the region. He said that clamping off the wrong ones, or too many, deprives the disc of it's necessary supply and makes degeneration both more likely and more rapid as the disc is poorly hydrated among other problems. Certainly it is true that I never recovered any significant " stand time " after the initial surgery, and by the time I was discharged from care a little less than 2 years later, the disc had already halved in height so was significantly degenerated in just that short period of time. My L3-S1 discs did not degenerate in the same way, and L4-S1 which remain unfused still looked great on my last MRI which was about 3.5 years after (posterior only) revision surgery. I should do some research as I am curious whether this has been subject to proper study, and whether there is noted difference in risk of disc degeneration/transition syndrome in people who have had anterior surgery compared to posterior only. titch-- The wages of sin are death, but by the time taxes are taken out, it's just sort of a tired feeling - a Poundstone Quote
Guest guest Posted January 15, 2007 Report Posted January 15, 2007 Cam, The problem with this 40% statistic seems to be that they only studied patients who were about 7 years post op. So many of us had no problems at that stage. Our problems did not begin until way after the 7 year mark. IMO, They need to study patients up to at least 25 years post op Harrington Rod surgery to get anything approaching a realistic statistic. Bonnie [ ] Re: Statistics While looking through my search returns using "scoliosis" + "syndrome" this article popped up: http://www.ocpamn.com/skeleton/spine/spine2.cfm The Orthopaedic Consultant,PA website history says they are the group founded by Dr Moe, one of the "go to" scoli doctors in his day. I must say that I think it is one of the most suscinct articles detailing scoliosis, and all the associated thinking, risks, problems (including flat back), bracing, adult treatment...the gamut. Anyway...here is their summary (from the full article) of the incidence of flatback following HR surgery that Peggy was asking about (40%). If that number is correct, and the number of primary HR surgeries could be determined, then you could find a base number of folks affected by flatback deformity. Judging by the numbers that join the various support groups on line, we are just the tip of the iceberg: Instrumentation Harrington Procedure. Until ten years ago, the standard instruments used in fusion procedures were those of the Harrington procedure, first developed in the 1960s: To support the fusion of the vertebrae, the surgeon uses a steel rod, extending from the bottom to the top of the curve. (More than one rod may be used depending on the type of curve and whether kyphosis is present.) The rod is attached by hooks that are suspended from pegs inserted into the bone. Similar to changing a tire, the steel rod is jacked up and then locked into place to support the spine securely. The surgeon is then ready to fuse the vertebrae together. After this operation, patients are required to wear a full body cast and lie in bed for three to six months until fusion is complete enough to stabilize the spine. The Harrington procedure is very difficult to undergo, particularly for young people, and although the operation can achieve a correction of the curve of over 50%, studies have reported a loss in this correction of between 10% to 25% over time. The procedure does not correct the rotation of the spine and, therefore, does not improve an existing rib hump that was caused by the rotation. The operation does not interfere with normal pregnancies and deliveries later in life. Certain complications may occur from this procedure: About 40% of Harrington patients have a condition called the flat back syndrome, because the procedure eliminates normal lordosis (the inward curving of the lower back). Flat back syndrome from the Harrington procedure does not cause any immediate pain, but in later years the discs may collapse below the fusion and cause difficulty in standing erect. Studies have reported that five to seven years after their surgery between 20% and a third of patients who had the Harrington procedure experienced low back pain. (In one study only 3% had experienced back pain before surgery.) In such cases, however, the pain was not severe enough to interfere with normal activities and did not require additional surgery. In some cases corrective surgery called closing wedge osteotomy may be needed, in which wedges of bone from the fused mass are removed and spaces are closed to restore a curve. In children under eleven whose skeleton is immatur With this procedure, parallel rods are cross-linked for better stability in holding the fused vertebrae. Improvement in correction averaged 66% in one study, with a later correction loss reported to be 5%. (Other studies have reported loss of curvature correction at less than 2%.) Over 95% of patients reported the results to be good or very good (only 86% of patients who had the Harrington procedure experienced the same levels of satisfaction). Patients often go home in five days and may be back in school in three weeks. Complication rates are similar to the Harrington procedure, but there are some differences: Operation time and blood loss are greater than with Harrington procedure. Cotrel-Dubousset and other procedures that are designed to reverse the rotation of the spine have less risk for flat back syndrome but they have a higher risk for spinal imbalance than the Harrington procedure. Cotrel-Dubousset instrumentation does not eliminate the risk for disc deterioration later on, which in one follow-up study occurred in nearly a quarter of the patients. Experts hope that the advances in current scoliosis procedures will help reduce the long-term adverse effects. Other Instrumentations. Other instrumentation procedures have refined the hardware used in the Harrington and Cotrel-Dubousset operations. The Texas ish-Rite instrumentation (TSRH) is similar to the Cotrel-Dubousset procedure in that it uses parallel rods and other devices that reverse rotation as well as improve curvature. The instruments, however, use smooth rods and hooks that are designed to make removal or adjustment easier later on if complications arise. Complications are similar to the Cotrel-Dubousset procedure. Another technique to prevent rotation is the Wisconsin segmental spine instrumentation (WSSI). Luque instrumentation was developed to help maintain normal lordosis and experts hoped that bracing would not be needed afterward with this device. A number of studies showed, however, that without braces, correction was lost after this operation, and there also may be a higher risk for spinal cord injury than with standard procedures. Luque instrumentation is used primarily in people whose scoliosis is due to problems of nerves and muscles. The use of a device called a pedicle screw to stabili And there you have it. Cam Quote
Guest guest Posted January 15, 2007 Report Posted January 15, 2007 Hi Bonnie... I’m not sure that’s correct. While the author mentions a study that showed some HR patients were in pain 5 to 7 years postop, he doesn’t state where the 40% figure comes from, and I don’t think it’s from the same study. -- On 1/15/07 1:06 PM, " Bonnie " <bonnie@...> wrote: Cam, The problem with this 40% statistic seems to be that they only studied patients who were about 7 years post op. So many of us had no problems at that stage. Our problems did not begin until way after the 7 year mark. IMO, They need to study patients up to at least 25 years post op Harrington Rod surgery to get anything approaching a realistic statistic. Bonnie [ ] Re: Statistics While looking through my search returns using " scoliosis " + " syndrome " this article popped up: http://www.ocpamn.com/skeleton/spine/spine2.cfm The Orthopaedic Consultant,PA website history says they are the group founded by Dr Moe, one of the " go to " scoli doctors in his day. I must say that I think it is one of the most suscinct articles detailing scoliosis, and all the associated thinking, risks, problems (including flat back), bracing, adult treatment...the gamut. Anyway...here is their summary (from the full article) of the incidence of flatback following HR surgery that Peggy was asking about (40%). If that number is correct, and the number of primary HR surgeries could be determined, then you could find a base number of folks affected by flatback deformity. Judging by the numbers that join the various support groups on line, we are just the tip of the iceberg: Instrumentation Harrington Procedure. Until ten years ago, the standard instruments used in fusion procedures were those of the Harrington procedure, first developed in the 1960s: To support the fusion of the vertebrae, the surgeon uses a steel rod, extending from the bottom to the top of the curve. (More than one rod may be used depending on the type of curve and whether kyphosis is present.) The rod is attached by hooks that are suspended from pegs inserted into the bone. Similar to changing a tire, the steel rod is jacked up and then locked into place to support the spine securely. The surgeon is then ready to fuse the vertebrae together. After this operation, patients are required to wear a full body cast and lie in bed for three to six months until fusion is complete enough to stabilize the spine. The Harrington procedure is very difficult to undergo, particularly for young people, and although the operation can achieve a correction of the curve of over 50%, studies have reported a loss in this correction of between 10% to 25% over time. The procedure does not correct the rotation of the spine and, therefore, does not improve an existing rib hump that was caused by the rotation. The operation does not interfere with normal pregnancies and deliveries later in life. Certain complications may occur from this procedure: About 40% of Harrington patients have a condition called the flat back syndrome, because the procedure eliminates normal lordosis (the inward curving of the lower back). Flat back syndrome from the Harrington procedure does not cause any immediate pain, but in later years the discs may collapse below the fusion and cause difficulty in standing erect. Studies have reported that five to seven years after their surgery between 20% and a third of patients who had the Harrington procedure experienced low back pain. (In one study only 3% had experienced back pain before surgery.) In such cases, however, the pain was not severe enough to interfere with normal activities and did not require additional surgery. In some cases corrective surgery called closing wedge osteotomy may be needed, in which wedges of bone from the fused mass are removed and spaces are closed to restore a curve. In children under eleven whose skeleton is immatur With this procedure, parallel rods are cross-linked for better stability in holding the fused vertebrae. Improvement in correction averaged 66% in one study, with a later correction loss reported to be 5%. (Other studies have reported loss of curvature correction at less than 2%.) Over 95% of patients reported the results to be good or very good (only 86% of patients who had the Harrington procedure experienced the same levels of satisfaction). Patients often go home in five days and may be back in school in three weeks. Complication rates are similar to the Harrington procedure, but there are some differences: Operation time and blood loss are greater than with Harrington procedure. Cotrel-Dubousset and other procedures that are designed to reverse the rotation of the spine have less risk for flat back syndrome but they have a higher risk for spinal imbalance than the Harrington procedure. Cotrel-Dubousset instrumentation does not eliminate the risk for disc deterioration later on, which in one follow-up study occurred in nearly a quarter of the patients. Experts hope that the advances in current scoliosis procedures will help reduce the long-term adverse effects. Other Instrumentations. Other instrumentation procedures have refined the hardware used in the Harrington and Cotrel-Dubousset operations. The Texas ish-Rite instrumentation (TSRH) is similar to the Cotrel-Dubousset procedure in that it uses parallel rods and other devices that reverse rotation as well as improve curvature. The instruments, however, use smooth rods and hooks that are designed to make removal or adjustment easier later on if complications arise. Complications are similar to the Cotrel-Dubousset procedure. Another technique to prevent rotation is the Wisconsin segmental spine instrumentation (WSSI). Luque instrumentation was developed to help maintain normal lordosis and experts hoped that bracing would not be needed afterward with this device. A number of studies showed, however, that without braces, correction was lost after this operation, and there also may be a higher risk for spinal cord injury than with standard procedures. Luque instrumentation is used primarily in people whose scoliosis is due to problems of nerves and muscles. The use of a device called a pedicle screw to stabili And there you have it. Cam Quote
Guest guest Posted March 27, 2008 Report Posted March 27, 2008 Here are some good stats on recurrance http://medicina.kmu.lt/0409/0409- 05e.pdf > > does anyone know where i might find statistic on incidence of > cholesteatomas preferably broken down by age groups and possibly > recurrence rates and how they might relate to age at onset? also > curious about the odds of my children having them too. i've been > dealing with cholesteatomas for 30yrs. but i always spent my time > learning about what they were going to do to me never what it was and > why its there. didn't even know it was a disease for the first 15 > yrs. just thought i had bad luck when it came to ears. anything that > might lead me in the right direction whould be great. cindy > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 27, 2008 Report Posted March 27, 2008 does anyone know where i might find statistic on incidence of cholesteatomas preferably broken down by age groups and possibly recurrence rates and how they might relate to age at onset? also curious about the odds of my children having them too. i've been dealing with cholesteatomas for 30yrs. but i always spent my time learning about what they were going to do to me never what it was and why its there. didn't even know it was a disease for the first 15 yrs. just thought i had bad luck when it came to ears. anything that might lead me in the right direction whould be great. cindy Hi It's a long time since I tried looking but I never found anything but very rough guesses about the incidence of ctoma. a couple countries had done surveys but even there the figures were very general. The figure that came up most often was that ctoma occurs in abut one 20,000 of the general population. I have no idea if that is remotely accurate though it woud suggest that there is plenty of ctoma around but not enough that you would necessarily meet anyone else with the disease, unless you go looking for them on the Web. The recurrence rate of ctoma has been covered more often but even there the figures given tend to vary greatly. Recurrence is also always looked at with regard to the type of surgery that has been done. Therefore closed procedures (canal wall up) can mean a recurrence rate of 30%, 40% or more whereas radical procedures (canal wall down) reduce the rate to about 5% to 10%. Chronic ear disease is the prelude to most occurences of ctoma. So if ear disease runs in your family then your children are more likely to get it to, although it usually starts up fairly early in life. Even with chronic ear disease, most people don't go on to develop ctoma. There is nothing inevitable about it, in a way you do have to be a bit unlucky. If you happen to find any reliable statisticss for the incidence of ctoma, please let us know. Phil Quote
Guest guest Posted August 12, 2009 Report Posted August 12, 2009 Very interesting, indeed. I am not refuting any of this, since I haven't seen the original work. I would just say all statistics are not created equal... some are definitely more valid than others. Ellen Ellen Garber Bronfeld egskb@... statistics " Out of every 160 children diagnosed with ASD, 60 of them (37.5%) will somehow go on to lose that diagnosis " I just don't see how that is possible Very interesting.--- PUBLIC HEALTH Autism Rate Now at One Percent of All US Children? By Kirby, huffingtonpost.com bit.ly/108qhZ A pair of federally funded studies on autism rates is about to make news – big news – and it isn't good: It would appear that somewhere around one percent of all US children currently have an autism spectrum disorder. The rate is even higher among six to 11 year olds and among boys, according to data from at least one of the new studies. If you are an expectant parent, or planning to have a child soon, you might want to sit down before absorbing these staggering statistics, recently released by the National Survey of Children's Health (NSCH), which is supported by the Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA) of the US Department of Health and Human Services. According to data from the 2007 telephone survey of parents of nearly 82,000 US children, the odds of a child receiving an ASD diagnosis are one in 63. If it is a boy, the chances climb to a science fiction-like level of one in 38, or 2.6% of all male children in America. But there was also some surprisingly good news. Enormous numbers of children originally diagnosed with ASD went on to shed their diagnosis as they got older, parents reported. Among all children aged two to 17, according to respondents, one in 100 (100-per-10,000) currently have an ASD diagnosis, which is considerably higher than the previously (CDC) estimated rate of 1-in-150, (or 66-per-10,000). But researchers were also told by parents that 60-per-10,000 children " had autism, Asperger's Disorder etc. at some point, but not currently. " This suggests two rather remarkable things: 1. At some point in their lives, 1-in-63 US children (160-per-10,000) will have an ASD diagnosis and; 2. Out of every 160 children diagnosed with ASD, 60 of them (37.5%) will somehow go on to lose that diagnosis. Among boys, for every 260-per-10,000 male children originally diagnosed with ASD, 90 of them (34.6%) reportedly do not have the diagnosis now. This still leaves a monumentally high rate of one in 58 boys with ASD today, or 1.7 percent (170-per-10,000). The percentage of girls who apparently lost their original diagnosis was 44.5%. There was a big difference among age groups as well. Among those children who still have the diagnosis, the rate of ASD was 40% higher in 6-11 year olds (140-per-10,000, or 1-in-71) than the current rate of 12-17 year olds (100-per-10,000, or 1-in-100). + Read more: bit.ly/108qhZ Get free photo software from Windows Live Click here. _________________________________________________________________ Windows Live™: Keep your life in sync. http://windowslive.com/explore?ocid=PID23384::T:WLMTAGL:ON:WL:en-US:NF_BR_sync:0\ 82009 Quote
Guest guest Posted August 12, 2009 Report Posted August 12, 2009 Very interesting, indeed. I am not refuting any of this, since I haven't seen the original work. I would just say all statistics are not created equal... some are definitely more valid than others. Ellen Ellen Garber Bronfeld egskb@... statistics " Out of every 160 children diagnosed with ASD, 60 of them (37.5%) will somehow go on to lose that diagnosis " I just don't see how that is possible Very interesting.--- PUBLIC HEALTH Autism Rate Now at One Percent of All US Children? By Kirby, huffingtonpost.com bit.ly/108qhZ A pair of federally funded studies on autism rates is about to make news – big news – and it isn't good: It would appear that somewhere around one percent of all US children currently have an autism spectrum disorder. The rate is even higher among six to 11 year olds and among boys, according to data from at least one of the new studies. If you are an expectant parent, or planning to have a child soon, you might want to sit down before absorbing these staggering statistics, recently released by the National Survey of Children's Health (NSCH), which is supported by the Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA) of the US Department of Health and Human Services. According to data from the 2007 telephone survey of parents of nearly 82,000 US children, the odds of a child receiving an ASD diagnosis are one in 63. If it is a boy, the chances climb to a science fiction-like level of one in 38, or 2.6% of all male children in America. But there was also some surprisingly good news. Enormous numbers of children originally diagnosed with ASD went on to shed their diagnosis as they got older, parents reported. Among all children aged two to 17, according to respondents, one in 100 (100-per-10,000) currently have an ASD diagnosis, which is considerably higher than the previously (CDC) estimated rate of 1-in-150, (or 66-per-10,000). But researchers were also told by parents that 60-per-10,000 children " had autism, Asperger's Disorder etc. at some point, but not currently. " This suggests two rather remarkable things: 1. At some point in their lives, 1-in-63 US children (160-per-10,000) will have an ASD diagnosis and; 2. Out of every 160 children diagnosed with ASD, 60 of them (37.5%) will somehow go on to lose that diagnosis. Among boys, for every 260-per-10,000 male children originally diagnosed with ASD, 90 of them (34.6%) reportedly do not have the diagnosis now. This still leaves a monumentally high rate of one in 58 boys with ASD today, or 1.7 percent (170-per-10,000). The percentage of girls who apparently lost their original diagnosis was 44.5%. There was a big difference among age groups as well. Among those children who still have the diagnosis, the rate of ASD was 40% higher in 6-11 year olds (140-per-10,000, or 1-in-71) than the current rate of 12-17 year olds (100-per-10,000, or 1-in-100). + Read more: bit.ly/108qhZ Get free photo software from Windows Live Click here. _________________________________________________________________ Windows Live™: Keep your life in sync. http://windowslive.com/explore?ocid=PID23384::T:WLMTAGL:ON:WL:en-US:NF_BR_sync:0\ 82009 Quote
Guest guest Posted August 13, 2009 Report Posted August 13, 2009 What's interesting is the source of info--a very large survey of parents, not MDs. I wonder if this is a case of parents saying, " Yeah, when my son was little, he was a late talker and kind of hyper, and the pediatrician said he might be ASD. " Do you think that 1% of 82,000 parents even could give a good working definition of ASD? For all I know, they might've thought the survey people meant ADD. OTOH, many of those kids might've been DX'ed with ASD, but as they grew, they did all right in school, and the parents discounted some social skill difficulties, because there were others in the family who were " like that " . It'd be even more interesting to see the actual questions from the survey. -Gail From: <teresadpaul@...> Subject: statistics ipaddunite Date: Wednesday, August 12, 2009, 10:42 PM  " Out of every 160 children diagnosed with ASD, 60 of them (37.5%) will somehow go on to lose that diagnosis " I just don't see how that is possible Very interesting.--- PUBLIC HEALTH Autism Rate Now at One Percent of All US Children?    By Kirby, huffingtonpost.com bit.ly/108qhZ    A pair of federally funded studies on autism rates is about to make news – big news – and it isn't good: It would appear that somewhere around one percent of all US children currently have an autism spectrum disorder. The rate is even higher among six to 11 year olds and among boys, according to data from at least one of the new studies..    If you are an expectant parent, or planning to have a child soon, you might want to sit down before absorbing these staggering statistics, recently released by the National Survey of Children's Health (NSCH), which is supported by the Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA) of the US Department of Health and Human Services.    According to data from the 2007 telephone survey of parents of nearly 82,000 US children, the odds of a child receiving an ASD diagnosis are one in 63. If it is a boy, the chances climb to a science fiction-like level of one in 38, or 2.6% of all male children in America.    But there was also some surprisingly good news. Enormous numbers of children originally diagnosed with ASD went on to shed their diagnosis as they got older, parents reported.    Among all children aged two to 17, according to respondents, one in 100 (100-per-10,000) currently have an ASD diagnosis, which is considerably higher than the previously (CDC) estimated rate of 1-in-150, (or 66-per-10,000).    But researchers were also told by parents that 60-per-10,000 children " had autism, Asperger's Disorder etc. at some point, but not currently. "    This suggests two rather remarkable things: 1. At some point in their lives, 1-in-63 US children (160-per-10,000) will have an ASD diagnosis and; 2. Out of every 160 children diagnosed with ASD, 60 of them (37.5%) will somehow go on to lose that diagnosis.    Among boys, for every 260-per-10,000 male children originally diagnosed with ASD, 90 of them (34.6%) reportedly do not have the diagnosis now. This still leaves a monumentally high rate of one in 58 boys with ASD today, or 1.7 percent (170-per-10,000).    The percentage of girls who apparently lost their original diagnosis was 44.5%.    There was a big difference among age groups as well. Among those children who still have the diagnosis, the rate of ASD was 40% higher in 6-11 year olds (140-per-10,000, or 1-in-71) than the current rate of 12-17 year olds (100-per-10,000, or 1-in-100). + Read more: bit.ly/108qhZ Get free photo software from Windows Live Click here. _________________________________________________________________ Windows Live™: Keep your life in sync. http://windowslive.com/explore?ocid=PID23384::T:WLMTAGL:ON:WL:en-US:NF_BR_sync:0\ 82009 Quote
Guest guest Posted August 13, 2009 Report Posted August 13, 2009 What's interesting is the source of info--a very large survey of parents, not MDs. I wonder if this is a case of parents saying, " Yeah, when my son was little, he was a late talker and kind of hyper, and the pediatrician said he might be ASD. " Do you think that 1% of 82,000 parents even could give a good working definition of ASD? For all I know, they might've thought the survey people meant ADD. OTOH, many of those kids might've been DX'ed with ASD, but as they grew, they did all right in school, and the parents discounted some social skill difficulties, because there were others in the family who were " like that " . It'd be even more interesting to see the actual questions from the survey. -Gail From: <teresadpaul@...> Subject: statistics ipaddunite Date: Wednesday, August 12, 2009, 10:42 PM  " Out of every 160 children diagnosed with ASD, 60 of them (37.5%) will somehow go on to lose that diagnosis " I just don't see how that is possible Very interesting.--- PUBLIC HEALTH Autism Rate Now at One Percent of All US Children?    By Kirby, huffingtonpost.com bit.ly/108qhZ    A pair of federally funded studies on autism rates is about to make news – big news – and it isn't good: It would appear that somewhere around one percent of all US children currently have an autism spectrum disorder. The rate is even higher among six to 11 year olds and among boys, according to data from at least one of the new studies..    If you are an expectant parent, or planning to have a child soon, you might want to sit down before absorbing these staggering statistics, recently released by the National Survey of Children's Health (NSCH), which is supported by the Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA) of the US Department of Health and Human Services.    According to data from the 2007 telephone survey of parents of nearly 82,000 US children, the odds of a child receiving an ASD diagnosis are one in 63. If it is a boy, the chances climb to a science fiction-like level of one in 38, or 2.6% of all male children in America.    But there was also some surprisingly good news. Enormous numbers of children originally diagnosed with ASD went on to shed their diagnosis as they got older, parents reported.    Among all children aged two to 17, according to respondents, one in 100 (100-per-10,000) currently have an ASD diagnosis, which is considerably higher than the previously (CDC) estimated rate of 1-in-150, (or 66-per-10,000).    But researchers were also told by parents that 60-per-10,000 children " had autism, Asperger's Disorder etc. at some point, but not currently. "    This suggests two rather remarkable things: 1. At some point in their lives, 1-in-63 US children (160-per-10,000) will have an ASD diagnosis and; 2. Out of every 160 children diagnosed with ASD, 60 of them (37.5%) will somehow go on to lose that diagnosis.    Among boys, for every 260-per-10,000 male children originally diagnosed with ASD, 90 of them (34.6%) reportedly do not have the diagnosis now. This still leaves a monumentally high rate of one in 58 boys with ASD today, or 1.7 percent (170-per-10,000).    The percentage of girls who apparently lost their original diagnosis was 44.5%.    There was a big difference among age groups as well. Among those children who still have the diagnosis, the rate of ASD was 40% higher in 6-11 year olds (140-per-10,000, or 1-in-71) than the current rate of 12-17 year olds (100-per-10,000, or 1-in-100). + Read more: bit.ly/108qhZ Get free photo software from Windows Live Click here. _________________________________________________________________ Windows Live™: Keep your life in sync. http://windowslive.com/explore?ocid=PID23384::T:WLMTAGL:ON:WL:en-US:NF_BR_sync:0\ 82009 Quote
Guest guest Posted April 2, 2010 Report Posted April 2, 2010 Re the quote from Dr. H. at the bottom...............I read somewhere quite a while ago a study that showed that people who ignore their diagnoses and think they're just fine do better and live longer than folks who dwell upon it. My own uncle died of prostate cancer last Aug. at the age of a month shy of 87. He had been dxed. with prostate cancer 20 years before that and chose to ignore the dx., never followed up, never had tx., and told us that the doctors weren't sure anyway. He died at home alone after a day of real suffering. He was a widower. The only symptoms he had that were bothersome in the year before his death were urinary frequency. He lived life to the fullest, was always cheerful, and was a deep believer in God. The last day or so of his life his kidneys were probably poisoned because of the cancer, he couldn't urinate at all. Also, I knew a man who died at 91 who had been dxed. with colon cancer about 15 years previously, and did go through all the chemo, etc.. I saw him shortly after his tx., and he was skin and bones and I was sure he wasn't going to make it. He lived an additional 15 yrs., and I took him to a dr.'s appt. a year or 2 before he died where he said the doc drained "water" out of his abdomen. I'm sure now that it was ascites. He thought he was cured, and was going to live forever, though I'm sure the doc who drained him told him it was the cancer back. Nevertheless, he trucked onward, thinking he was good to go. He only died when his heart quit. Perhaps the body has ways of making the end not so bad. Perhaps it's best not to know. Ellen R. Ellen Diamond wrote: Dr. H—Like all of us who know your work, I'm deeply appreciative of everything you've done for CLL. And your blog about your experience with colon cancer has been very moving and informative. I'm sure Chris's intentions in posting those stats were the same generous ones in all his posts—to contribute to the knowledge base on this list. Causing fear would be the last thing on his mind. However, posting life-expectancy stats did do just what you refer to below—take away our choice about knowing. Once that elephant was in the room I really wanted to provide some cushioning. "Patient truths" may not contribute directly to CLL research but I think more doctors should give them a thought. Not a lot of members are commenting on all this. Hopefully that means they didn't react as strongly to the stats—a good thing.- Ellen D. "I'm afraid that most of us have difficulty handling the truth, me included, when it comes to our own illnesses. Would we be better not knowing? That is a personal decision. No one can make it for you." Quote
Guest guest Posted April 2, 2010 Report Posted April 2, 2010 I'm not too worried about those statistics, which I managed to delete, because I was trying to clear my inbox of a lot of e-mails. The government figures for determining my life expectancy according to the paying out of my IRA to me says that I'll live until I'm 97, as I'm 72 and they have it saying I've got 25.6 years to go, so I get less each year than I'd really like, for I don't think I'll live that long, with CLL/SLL, a pacemaker and heart disease risks handed down to me from both parents. But, I'm not going to worry about statistics, for I know that God already knows how long I have to be here. I'm taking care of personal and financial matters, seeing my doctors and leaving the rest to Him. Norma Oxley Quote
Guest guest Posted April 2, 2010 Report Posted April 2, 2010 I don't know how the "silent majority" on the CLL/SLL list feels about this issue, but I can tell you what my own thoughts are. As all of us, I highly appreciate Dr. Hamblin's contributions as well as Chris's and wouldn't want either of them - or anyone else for that matter - to feel constrained when posting information about our disease. I think most of our group is mature enough to evaluate information and realize, for instance, that statistics apply to groups of people and not a particular individual. I'm certainly not opposed to hoping, but I also want to have a realistic idea of what to expect in my future. Such knowledge helps me to use my time remaining as wisely as possible and to put my affairs in order while I'm able to do so. In one word, thank you Dr. Hamblin for the data about our CLL survival statistics and please keep it in mind that we appreciate it as much as any other knowledge you choose to share with us. Andy G. No virus found in this outgoing message. Checked by AVG - www.avg.com Version: 8.5.437 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/2785 - Release Date: 04/02/10 06:32:00 Quote
Guest guest Posted August 11, 2010 Report Posted August 11, 2010 There is no research of ldn and breast cancer. Ldn is good but i will try to look at iodine. Breast Cancer and Iodine : How to Prevent and How to Survive Breast Cancer And also the right antifungus (candida) diet.the site knowthecause is good. The Fungus Link: An Introduction to Fungal Disease Including the Initial Phase Diet The Fungus Link _________________ I am using the Free version of SPAMfighter.SPAMfighter has removed 490 of my spam emails to date.Do you have a slow PC? Try free scan! Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.