Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Re: Is she trying to get my brother to kill himself?

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Guest guest
Posted

I think the way you put all of this really puts words to what I am trying to get

clear.  It's hard because on the one hand I'm getting to a place where I can't

take it and want less abuse, but on the other there's emotional blackmail

because if I go LC she'll likely go NC (cut me off). She did it before when I

wouldnt' give her a key to my house.  I was devastated, but then started to

feel a bit better after a while.  Yet somehow this time it feels like it would

be terrible if she cut me off again. 

I expected her to go NC after I told her she couldnt' be alone with my son, but

I should have known better....  An adoring cute infant who really likes her

would of course be like heroin to her.  He's a perfect " mirror " which I have

stopped being.  So now I have to make more purposeful decisions.

I'm reading that book " Boundaries " which has been recommended a lot on this

forum and really connect with his description of how if I don't set a boundary,

I just take on myself the consequences of her actions.  I've never heard it put

quite that way and I've been working on boundary setting for a long time.  It

just makes it seem so much less aggressive and rejecting.  She was unpleasant

and rude to my husband at this visit and ruined our weekend.  The consequence

of that behavior is that she will not be invited to my son's birthday party. 

She may choose to cut off contact based on that, but that is her choice.  If I

cancel my son's party so she won't come, or let her come, I'll be taking the

consequences on myself and I'm too tired to keep doing that, and she will learn

nothing. 

Also, I keep remembering something Doug said on another thread weeks ago, " The

only way to win with a borderline is not to play. "

________________________________

To: WTOAdultChildren1

Sent: Tue, April 6, 2010 10:14:40 AM

Subject: Re: Is she trying to get my brother to kill

himself?

 

MP--

I just had a thought that helped me, and I wanted to share. I got a little more

clarity on what it means to be NC.

My going NC was really nadas decision, if that makes sense. I told her (for over

a year) that her behavior was extremely hurtful, and if she didn't stop I would

have to disconnect from her.

Obviously, she didn't stop.

So, I went NC based on HER behavior. I think its important for all of us to

remember we aren't disconnecting out of anger or vengence or cruelty. I had to

go NC out of sheer need for survival. I literally wasn't going to make it

through the horrible time of life I was in with the weight and pain of her

constant abuse.

Going NC was literally a matter of life and death for me.

And, this thread also helped me see something important. If she ever learns how

to connect with me and not abuse me, of course she would be welcome in my life.

Yes, it would be extremely limited, and no, she wouldn't be a real mom all of

the sudden, and yes, everything would be different.

But the door will always be open if she can be more safe. Its up to her, not me.

And the decision was hers much more than mine, because she was warned for over a

year that I was gearing up to disconnecting from her.

I think its tricky for folks like your pastor. When they hear NC, they think

cruelty, anger, unforgiveness and purposeful irresponsibility on our part.

Unfortunately, they can't understand that 1) it is never our choice. we would

all rather have a mom than a nada. 2) we are put in a corner of having to choose

our own sanity or talking to nada. 3) that choice is one of the most tormenting,

painful choices out there. who wants to have to choose to become an " orphan "

just to keep surviving? when their mother is still alive and " wanting " to be

involved in your life? when we so desperately need a mother instead of a nada?

Its like double and triple sadness.

People outside of this group could never understand the torment that goes with

this choice. They just naturally assume we make it lightly, with a limited

understanding of God.

But remember: your NC only has to go as long as she learns to behave or you can

get strong enough to absorb more abuse. I think that is the model of Christian

compassion and forgiveness, if you ask me. But you are really only respecting

what she chooses to do. Its on her, my dear.

I mean, imagine putting your son in a place where he has to choose his own

mental health OR disconnect from you!?!? Doesn't that put a whole new light on

how sick she is?

Hope this makes sense!

Blessings,

>

> I haven't been on this forum for a couple of weeks, but it's good to be back.

I'm back because I need validation so badly. I've been driven lately to see

things more clearly than I had before. But as I grapple with that I find I'm

struggling with confusion and fog.

>

> My pastor heard that my nada was visiting this weekend and called to see how

it went. I told him how the confrontation I was afraid of had happened but that

I was really proud of myself because I had stayed calm with her. (As I had

expected and others on this forum had predicted, my mom confronted me because I

kept avoiding leaving my son alone with her. I tried to be tactful, but she

wanted to know if that was what I was doing. I told her " I just feel more

comfortable when we are together as a group. " We then did a few hours of baby

fun activities, but then she cornered me when I was alone and wanted to know

why, " so I don't have to wonder. " I won't give the play by play, but the short

version is that I said " there were things that happened when I was a kid and I

just feel more comfortable when we are together as a group. " She started with

the whole invalidating story about how she " wasn't equipped " and the version

that includes some minor

> conflict when I was a teenager but does not involve physical abuse throughout

childhood or what I consider much worse, systematic emotional abuse. I told her

that we had different memories, that being alone with my son was non-negotiable

and that I was going to take a break. I walked out and made my husband stay at

my side the rest of the visit. First she sulked in her room then she started

playing " super nice grandma " but being cold to me. Before she played that super

nice routine though, she did something that just made me sure I was right, my

son, who has of course fallen in love with her which actually hurts me somehow,

was crawling over and trying to get her to play with him. She ignored him

totally because she was mad at me. My grandnada did that to me, and it is

unacceptable. )

>

> Anyway, I told my pastor that story and we talked a little bit about how much

BPs are responsible for themselves and how much is " mental illness. " He's big on

boundaries but he always reminds me she's mentally ill, and this time I

challenged him on it. He's got more counseling background than most pastors, but

he's not a psychologist with a specialty in BPD or anything. On the other hand,

he helps with some of the issues that come up that touch on what's right as a

christian and all. Sometimes it's hard for me to trust what a therapist tells me

because I wonder if that's okay as a christian. Can any of you relate?

>

> Anyway, I told him I was questioning the mental illness thing a bit since my

nada can totally control herself when she wants to and since so much of what she

does is " mean " as I put it to him, not just emotional regulation issues or

whatever. He said he finds it really hard to figure that stuff out, but he

thinks NC is probably not an option for a christian. He also told me that if I

told him I was going NC he wouldn't say anything to me or give me a hard time

and he would support me at the time, but he might talk with me more about it

later. At first I felt ok about this, but after I got off the phone I started to

get really panicky.

>

> My husband asked if I had shared what she's doing to my family members. So I

emailed him about how I found out the reason my Dad was suicidal last year was

because she was telling him he was better off dead on a regular basis. (They

lost their savings in the financial crisis and I think he told me she was

telling him he was worthless and everyone would be better off with the insurance

money). I also told him she's attacking my dangerously depressed younger brother

who is stuck living at home and unemployed right now and who can't get on his

feet because every time he makes a positive move she comes and tears him down. I

told him that she was telling my brother he's better off dead.

>

> But I'm hedging because suddenly I'm not sure. I know my Dad told me she was

telling him he was better off dead. I know she is regularly attacking my brother

(who was a all-bad child). But I'm having major fog and mom-headache. I can't

think straight. I said to my husband, " here I go making it all up again " and

couldn't believe I blurted that out. Did someone tell me she was telling my

brother he's better off dead or did I make that up? I know I don't make it up,

but my contact with her and her denial of the abuse has me struggling to retain

my identity and sense of trusting my own sense of reality. I'm spiraling. I feel

like I'm fighting for my survival again.

>

> Anyway, my pastor responded to that email saying that based on this info he

feels much stronger boundaries are in order. So we're supposed to talk again

next week, but I want to make sure I'm giving accurate information. Becuase

otherwise I'll doubt the validity of whatever plan we come up with.

>

> Does it matter if she is actually coming out and saying my brother is better

off dead? The logical conclusion of her messages to us was always that anyway.

>

> I know some of you all have mothers who are sometimes the good mom, but I

don't think my good mom is very nice. She has a really scary malicious " witch "

in her. But I think she might be always the witch just a little bit. What I mean

is she really shows no interest in me as me. The only interest she has inme is

what I can give her, and sometimes that means " mirroring " . her message is always

and always has been that who I am as a person is unacceptable and disgusting to

me. I tried to kill my soul as a child to please her and she tried to destroy my

personality and replace it with her own or some kind of servant who praised her

constantly. She is one of the " merger-hungry " personalities from UBM.

>

> My mother's message to me is that I as who I am evil and disgusting and when I

used to believe her I always felt I didn't have a right to be alive. She did a

lot of things very systematically to destroy who I was and I feel like all of

her faces (witch, nice, withdrawn, etc etc) are part of the same message and

project to get me to be her mirror/vessel/ servant.

>

> Can she really be like this? Am I making it up? Am I being unfair to her? Is

it my own weakness that contact with her is SO BAD for me? Can she really be so

mean?

>

> I just want to get away from her. I want to be at a place where I feel free,

where whatever love I give I give freely, not just because I can't get away

because she's " mentally ill. " Are you really telling me she can't help it? Does

being an emotional adolescent make you scary mean? Most teenagers are not

murderous... .

>

> Any thoughts? I want out of the fog.

>

>

>

>

>

>

Guest guest
Posted

For me? It was the most tragic and painful decision I've ever made.

And the very very best as well. Like I said--I didn't really feel like I had a

choice.

I could start talking about how much better life is, but that would take all

day!! :)

Seriously, I can't even tell you the strength, clarity and energy I have now for

ME and my calling now that she's gone. It is a freedom I didn't know life could

have. I am ASTONISHED at how much I've come into my own for the very first

time.

She still tries to get in contact with me on occassion (inviting me for lunch

like we are just fine) and let's not forget inviting my crazy/stalker/abuser

ex-husband to her house for family functions . . .

it hasn't been easy, and cutting ties was pretty hard since she worked REALLY

hard to get me reeled back in. (Expect massive hoovering if you decide to go

NC).

But I haven't regretted it for a second. And I wish I had done it sooner,

really.

I have to end this, though, with the encouragement for you to do what is right

for you. These things are so complex and there just isn't one good or right

answer. At the end of the day, you only have to make peace with you. Make sure

you are doing what is right for you. I would never encourage someone to go NC

because of my experience, and I had to work up to it over the course of a few

years. With TONS of therapy!!

Hope this helps. I know you'll make the right decision, no matter what that is.

I have fully confidence in you! You are on the right path--

Blessings,

Karla

> > >

> > > I haven't been on this forum for a couple of weeks, but it's good to be

back. I'm back because I need validation so badly. I've been driven lately to

see things more clearly than I had before. But as I grapple with that I find

I'm struggling with confusion and fog.

> > >

> > > My pastor heard that my nada was visiting this weekend and called to see

how it went. I told him how the confrontation I was afraid of had happened but

that I was really proud of myself because I had stayed calm with her. (As I had

expected and others on this forum had predicted, my mom confronted me because I

kept avoiding leaving my son alone with her. I tried to be tactful, but she

wanted to know if that was what I was doing. I told her " I just feel more

comfortable when we are together as a group. " We then did a few hours of baby

fun activities, but then she cornered me when I was alone and wanted to know

why, " so I don't have to wonder. " I won't give the play by play, but the short

version is that I said " there were things that happened when I was a kid and I

just feel more comfortable when we are together as a group. " She started with

the whole invalidating story about how she " wasn't equipped " and the version

that includes some minor

> > > conflict when I was a teenager but does not involve physical abuse

throughout childhood or what I consider much worse, systematic emotional abuse.

I told her that we had different memories, that being alone with my son was

non-negotiable and that I was going to take a break. I walked out and made my

husband stay at my side the rest of the visit. First she sulked in her room

then she started playing " super nice grandma " but being cold to me. Before she

played that super nice routine though, she did something that just made me sure

I was right, my son, who has of course fallen in love with her which actually

hurts me somehow, was crawling over and trying to get her to play with him. She

ignored him totally because she was mad at me. My grandnada did that to me, and

it is unacceptable.)

> > >

> > > Anyway, I told my pastor that story and we talked a little bit about how

much BPs are responsible for themselves and how much is " mental illness. " He's

big on boundaries but he always reminds me she's mentally ill, and this time I

challenged him on it. He's got more counseling background than most pastors,

but he's not a psychologist with a specialty in BPD or anything. On the other

hand, he helps with some of the issues that come up that touch on what's right

as a christian and all. Sometimes it's hard for me to trust what a therapist

tells me because I wonder if that's okay as a christian. Can any of you relate?

> > >

> > > Anyway, I told him I was questioning the mental illness thing a bit since

my nada can totally control herself when she wants to and since so much of what

she does is " mean " as I put it to him, not just emotional regulation issues or

whatever. He said he finds it really hard to figure that stuff out, but he

thinks NC is probably not an option for a christian. He also told me that if I

told him I was going NC he wouldn't say anything to me or give me a hard time

and he would support me at the time, but he might talk with me more about it

later. At first I felt ok about this, but after I got off the phone I started

to get really panicky.

> > >

> > > My husband asked if I had shared what she's doing to my family members.

So I emailed him about how I found out the reason my Dad was suicidal last year

was because she was telling him he was better off dead on a regular basis.

(They lost their savings in the financial crisis and I think he told me she was

telling him he was worthless and everyone would be better off with the insurance

money). I also told him she's attacking my dangerously depressed younger

brother who is stuck living at home and unemployed right now and who can't get

on his feet because every time he makes a positive move she comes and tears him

down. I told him that she was telling my brother he's better off dead.

> > >

> > > But I'm hedging because suddenly I'm not sure. I know my Dad told me she

was telling him he was better off dead. I know she is regularly attacking my

brother (who was a all-bad child). But I'm having major fog and mom-headache.

I can't think straight. I said to my husband, " here I go making it all up

again " and couldn't believe I blurted that out. Did someone tell me she was

telling my brother he's better off dead or did I make that up? I know I don't

make it up, but my contact with her and her denial of the abuse has me

struggling to retain my identity and sense of trusting my own sense of reality.

I'm spiraling. I feel like I'm fighting for my survival again.

> > >

> > > Anyway, my pastor responded to that email saying that based on this info

he feels much stronger boundaries are in order. So we're supposed to talk again

next week, but I want to make sure I'm giving accurate information. Becuase

otherwise I'll doubt the validity of whatever plan we come up with.

> > >

> > > Does it matter if she is actually coming out and saying my brother is

better off dead? The logical conclusion of her messages to us was always that

anyway.

> > >

> > > I know some of you all have mothers who are sometimes the good mom, but I

don't think my good mom is very nice. She has a really scary malicious " witch "

in her. But I think she might be always the witch just a little bit. What I

mean is she really shows no interest in me as me. The only interest she has inme

is what I can give her, and sometimes that means " mirroring " . her message is

always and always has been that who I am as a person is unacceptable and

disgusting to me. I tried to kill my soul as a child to please her and she

tried to destroy my personality and replace it with her own or some kind of

servant who praised her constantly. She is one of the " merger-hungry "

personalities from UBM.

> > >

> > > My mother's message to me is that I as who I am evil and disgusting and

when I used to believe her I always felt I didn't have a right to be alive. She

did a lot of things very systematically to destroy who I was and I feel like all

of her faces (witch, nice, withdrawn, etc etc) are part of the same message and

project to get me to be her mirror/vessel/servant.

> > >

> > > Can she really be like this? Am I making it up? Am I being unfair to

her? Is it my own weakness that contact with her is SO BAD for me? Can she

really be so mean?

> > >

> > > I just want to get away from her. I want to be at a place where I feel

free, where whatever love I give I give freely, not just because I can't get

away because she's " mentally ill. " Are you really telling me she can't help it?

Does being an emotional adolescent make you scary mean? Most teenagers are not

murderous....

> > >

> > > Any thoughts? I want out of the fog.

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > >

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...