Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Re: Is she trying to get my brother to kill himself?

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Guest guest
Posted

Its not you. She really is that vicious. BPD is murderous to the extreme, but

it is a disease that slowly murders the heart and souls of all those close to

it.

You are not insane. You are not wrong. You are not confused. You have

everything spot-on right. She really IS that bad. There is nothing about your

perspective that is paranoid or off. You are the only one in this situation

with clarity. The darkness in her could very easily be encouraging suicide.

And she obviously doesn't even know it.

I have two sons. And the thought of looking at them and actually speaking the

curse/filth of: " you would be better off dead " makes me want to vomit. That is

horrible and evil.

If it helps: I am a very strong Christian, and I have been NC for over a year

now. Unfortunately, there is no wiggle room in BP. I had to choose either:

disconnecting from nada and claiming God as God in my life, or continuing to

stay connected with nada and have her own me (at least a great deal of me)

through abuse and crazy-making. There were no other options than those two, and

trust me I looked for them.

Nada actually became an idol to me--one I could not break away from, one I

unintentionally " worshipped " with attention, and one I sacrificed offerings to.

(Those offerings were pieces of me, of course). I couldn't stay connected to

her and still claim God as the highest authority in my life.

Your pastor sounds great. But please bear in mind he does not know BPD. And it

is not your job to make him know. Many people who are well-versed in

dysfunction tend to think BPD is just another place on the spectrum of

dysfunction. He is failing to appreciate BPD is a mental illness, even as he

keeps reminding you of that. He could never understand it, sadly. Just be

careful of holding him as an authority in this when you know so much more than

he does.

Anyway, hope you feel more safe soon. I'm so sorry--this is a tragic story in

the extreme. Nothing is more torturous than watching someone you love die

slowly. And that seems like what you are having to do with your brother. It

makes me very sad with you.

Blessings,

Karla

>

> I haven't been on this forum for a couple of weeks, but it's good to be back.

I'm back because I need validation so badly. I've been driven lately to see

things more clearly than I had before. But as I grapple with that I find I'm

struggling with confusion and fog.

>

> My pastor heard that my nada was visiting this weekend and called to see how

it went. I told him how the confrontation I was afraid of had happened but that

I was really proud of myself because I had stayed calm with her. (As I had

expected and others on this forum had predicted, my mom confronted me because I

kept avoiding leaving my son alone with her. I tried to be tactful, but she

wanted to know if that was what I was doing. I told her " I just feel more

comfortable when we are together as a group. " We then did a few hours of baby

fun activities, but then she cornered me when I was alone and wanted to know

why, " so I don't have to wonder. " I won't give the play by play, but the short

version is that I said " there were things that happened when I was a kid and I

just feel more comfortable when we are together as a group. " She started with

the whole invalidating story about how she " wasn't equipped " and the version

that includes some minor

> conflict when I was a teenager but does not involve physical abuse throughout

childhood or what I consider much worse, systematic emotional abuse. I told her

that we had different memories, that being alone with my son was non-negotiable

and that I was going to take a break. I walked out and made my husband stay at

my side the rest of the visit. First she sulked in her room then she started

playing " super nice grandma " but being cold to me. Before she played that super

nice routine though, she did something that just made me sure I was right, my

son, who has of course fallen in love with her which actually hurts me somehow,

was crawling over and trying to get her to play with him. She ignored him

totally because she was mad at me. My grandnada did that to me, and it is

unacceptable.)

>

> Anyway, I told my pastor that story and we talked a little bit about how much

BPs are responsible for themselves and how much is " mental illness. " He's big

on boundaries but he always reminds me she's mentally ill, and this time I

challenged him on it. He's got more counseling background than most pastors,

but he's not a psychologist with a specialty in BPD or anything. On the other

hand, he helps with some of the issues that come up that touch on what's right

as a christian and all. Sometimes it's hard for me to trust what a therapist

tells me because I wonder if that's okay as a christian. Can any of you relate?

>

> Anyway, I told him I was questioning the mental illness thing a bit since my

nada can totally control herself when she wants to and since so much of what she

does is " mean " as I put it to him, not just emotional regulation issues or

whatever. He said he finds it really hard to figure that stuff out, but he

thinks NC is probably not an option for a christian. He also told me that if I

told him I was going NC he wouldn't say anything to me or give me a hard time

and he would support me at the time, but he might talk with me more about it

later. At first I felt ok about this, but after I got off the phone I started

to get really panicky.

>

> My husband asked if I had shared what she's doing to my family members. So I

emailed him about how I found out the reason my Dad was suicidal last year was

because she was telling him he was better off dead on a regular basis. (They

lost their savings in the financial crisis and I think he told me she was

telling him he was worthless and everyone would be better off with the insurance

money). I also told him she's attacking my dangerously depressed younger

brother who is stuck living at home and unemployed right now and who can't get

on his feet because every time he makes a positive move she comes and tears him

down. I told him that she was telling my brother he's better off dead.

>

> But I'm hedging because suddenly I'm not sure. I know my Dad told me she was

telling him he was better off dead. I know she is regularly attacking my

brother (who was a all-bad child). But I'm having major fog and mom-headache.

I can't think straight. I said to my husband, " here I go making it all up

again " and couldn't believe I blurted that out. Did someone tell me she was

telling my brother he's better off dead or did I make that up? I know I don't

make it up, but my contact with her and her denial of the abuse has me

struggling to retain my identity and sense of trusting my own sense of reality.

I'm spiraling. I feel like I'm fighting for my survival again.

>

> Anyway, my pastor responded to that email saying that based on this info he

feels much stronger boundaries are in order. So we're supposed to talk again

next week, but I want to make sure I'm giving accurate information. Becuase

otherwise I'll doubt the validity of whatever plan we come up with.

>

> Does it matter if she is actually coming out and saying my brother is better

off dead? The logical conclusion of her messages to us was always that anyway.

>

> I know some of you all have mothers who are sometimes the good mom, but I

don't think my good mom is very nice. She has a really scary malicious " witch "

in her. But I think she might be always the witch just a little bit. What I

mean is she really shows no interest in me as me. The only interest she has inme

is what I can give her, and sometimes that means " mirroring " . her message is

always and always has been that who I am as a person is unacceptable and

disgusting to me. I tried to kill my soul as a child to please her and she

tried to destroy my personality and replace it with her own or some kind of

servant who praised her constantly. She is one of the " merger-hungry "

personalities from UBM.

>

> My mother's message to me is that I as who I am evil and disgusting and when I

used to believe her I always felt I didn't have a right to be alive. She did a

lot of things very systematically to destroy who I was and I feel like all of

her faces (witch, nice, withdrawn, etc etc) are part of the same message and

project to get me to be her mirror/vessel/servant.

>

> Can she really be like this? Am I making it up? Am I being unfair to her?

Is it my own weakness that contact with her is SO BAD for me? Can she really be

so mean?

>

> I just want to get away from her. I want to be at a place where I feel free,

where whatever love I give I give freely, not just because I can't get away

because she's " mentally ill. " Are you really telling me she can't help it?

Does being an emotional adolescent make you scary mean? Most teenagers are not

murderous....

>

> Any thoughts? I want out of the fog.

>

>

>

>

>

>

Guest guest
Posted

" he thinks NC is not an option for a Christian "

What??? Where does he get off on that?

You get to set your own boundaries on what you will allow in your life for you

and your family. Being a good Christian does not mean you must set you or your

family up for pain. In fact, bravely setting boundaries would be far more noble

than allowing that crap in your life. You can not let the light in when the

darkness is in the way. Please know we are here for you in your time of

confusion and fog.

>

> I haven't been on this forum for a couple of weeks, but it's good to be back.

I'm back because I need validation so badly. I've been driven lately to see

things more clearly than I had before. But as I grapple with that I find I'm

struggling with confusion and fog.

>

> My pastor heard that my nada was visiting this weekend and called to see how

it went. I told him how the confrontation I was afraid of had happened but that

I was really proud of myself because I had stayed calm with her. (As I had

expected and others on this forum had predicted, my mom confronted me because I

kept avoiding leaving my son alone with her. I tried to be tactful, but she

wanted to know if that was what I was doing. I told her " I just feel more

comfortable when we are together as a group. " We then did a few hours of baby

fun activities, but then she cornered me when I was alone and wanted to know

why, " so I don't have to wonder. " I won't give the play by play, but the short

version is that I said " there were things that happened when I was a kid and I

just feel more comfortable when we are together as a group. " She started with

the whole invalidating story about how she " wasn't equipped " and the version

that includes some minor

> conflict when I was a teenager but does not involve physical abuse throughout

childhood or what I consider much worse, systematic emotional abuse. I told her

that we had different memories, that being alone with my son was non-negotiable

and that I was going to take a break. I walked out and made my husband stay at

my side the rest of the visit. First she sulked in her room then she started

playing " super nice grandma " but being cold to me. Before she played that super

nice routine though, she did something that just made me sure I was right, my

son, who has of course fallen in love with her which actually hurts me somehow,

was crawling over and trying to get her to play with him. She ignored him

totally because she was mad at me. My grandnada did that to me, and it is

unacceptable.)

>

> Anyway, I told my pastor that story and we talked a little bit about how much

BPs are responsible for themselves and how much is " mental illness. " He's big

on boundaries but he always reminds me she's mentally ill, and this time I

challenged him on it. He's got more counseling background than most pastors,

but he's not a psychologist with a specialty in BPD or anything. On the other

hand, he helps with some of the issues that come up that touch on what's right

as a christian and all. Sometimes it's hard for me to trust what a therapist

tells me because I wonder if that's okay as a christian. Can any of you relate?

>

> Anyway, I told him I was questioning the mental illness thing a bit since my

nada can totally control herself when she wants to and since so much of what she

does is " mean " as I put it to him, not just emotional regulation issues or

whatever. He said he finds it really hard to figure that stuff out, but he

thinks NC is probably not an option for a christian. He also told me that if I

told him I was going NC he wouldn't say anything to me or give me a hard time

and he would support me at the time, but he might talk with me more about it

later. At first I felt ok about this, but after I got off the phone I started

to get really panicky.

>

> My husband asked if I had shared what she's doing to my family members. So I

emailed him about how I found out the reason my Dad was suicidal last year was

because she was telling him he was better off dead on a regular basis. (They

lost their savings in the financial crisis and I think he told me she was

telling him he was worthless and everyone would be better off with the insurance

money). I also told him she's attacking my dangerously depressed younger

brother who is stuck living at home and unemployed right now and who can't get

on his feet because every time he makes a positive move she comes and tears him

down. I told him that she was telling my brother he's better off dead.

>

> But I'm hedging because suddenly I'm not sure. I know my Dad told me she was

telling him he was better off dead. I know she is regularly attacking my

brother (who was a all-bad child). But I'm having major fog and mom-headache.

I can't think straight. I said to my husband, " here I go making it all up

again " and couldn't believe I blurted that out. Did someone tell me she was

telling my brother he's better off dead or did I make that up? I know I don't

make it up, but my contact with her and her denial of the abuse has me

struggling to retain my identity and sense of trusting my own sense of reality.

I'm spiraling. I feel like I'm fighting for my survival again.

>

> Anyway, my pastor responded to that email saying that based on this info he

feels much stronger boundaries are in order. So we're supposed to talk again

next week, but I want to make sure I'm giving accurate information. Becuase

otherwise I'll doubt the validity of whatever plan we come up with.

>

> Does it matter if she is actually coming out and saying my brother is better

off dead? The logical conclusion of her messages to us was always that anyway.

>

> I know some of you all have mothers who are sometimes the good mom, but I

don't think my good mom is very nice. She has a really scary malicious " witch "

in her. But I think she might be always the witch just a little bit. What I

mean is she really shows no interest in me as me. The only interest she has inme

is what I can give her, and sometimes that means " mirroring " . her message is

always and always has been that who I am as a person is unacceptable and

disgusting to me. I tried to kill my soul as a child to please her and she

tried to destroy my personality and replace it with her own or some kind of

servant who praised her constantly. She is one of the " merger-hungry "

personalities from UBM.

>

> My mother's message to me is that I as who I am evil and disgusting and when I

used to believe her I always felt I didn't have a right to be alive. She did a

lot of things very systematically to destroy who I was and I feel like all of

her faces (witch, nice, withdrawn, etc etc) are part of the same message and

project to get me to be her mirror/vessel/servant.

>

> Can she really be like this? Am I making it up? Am I being unfair to her?

Is it my own weakness that contact with her is SO BAD for me? Can she really be

so mean?

>

> I just want to get away from her. I want to be at a place where I feel free,

where whatever love I give I give freely, not just because I can't get away

because she's " mentally ill. " Are you really telling me she can't help it?

Does being an emotional adolescent make you scary mean? Most teenagers are not

murderous....

>

> Any thoughts? I want out of the fog.

>

>

>

>

>

>

Guest guest
Posted

" he thinks NC is not an option for a Christian "

What??? Where does he get off on that?

You get to set your own boundaries on what you will allow in your life for you

and your family. Being a good Christian does not mean you must set you or your

family up for pain. In fact, bravely setting boundaries would be far more noble

than allowing that crap in your life. You can not let the light in when the

darkness is in the way. Please know we are here for you in your time of

confusion and fog.

>

> I haven't been on this forum for a couple of weeks, but it's good to be back.

I'm back because I need validation so badly. I've been driven lately to see

things more clearly than I had before. But as I grapple with that I find I'm

struggling with confusion and fog.

>

> My pastor heard that my nada was visiting this weekend and called to see how

it went. I told him how the confrontation I was afraid of had happened but that

I was really proud of myself because I had stayed calm with her. (As I had

expected and others on this forum had predicted, my mom confronted me because I

kept avoiding leaving my son alone with her. I tried to be tactful, but she

wanted to know if that was what I was doing. I told her " I just feel more

comfortable when we are together as a group. " We then did a few hours of baby

fun activities, but then she cornered me when I was alone and wanted to know

why, " so I don't have to wonder. " I won't give the play by play, but the short

version is that I said " there were things that happened when I was a kid and I

just feel more comfortable when we are together as a group. " She started with

the whole invalidating story about how she " wasn't equipped " and the version

that includes some minor

> conflict when I was a teenager but does not involve physical abuse throughout

childhood or what I consider much worse, systematic emotional abuse. I told her

that we had different memories, that being alone with my son was non-negotiable

and that I was going to take a break. I walked out and made my husband stay at

my side the rest of the visit. First she sulked in her room then she started

playing " super nice grandma " but being cold to me. Before she played that super

nice routine though, she did something that just made me sure I was right, my

son, who has of course fallen in love with her which actually hurts me somehow,

was crawling over and trying to get her to play with him. She ignored him

totally because she was mad at me. My grandnada did that to me, and it is

unacceptable.)

>

> Anyway, I told my pastor that story and we talked a little bit about how much

BPs are responsible for themselves and how much is " mental illness. " He's big

on boundaries but he always reminds me she's mentally ill, and this time I

challenged him on it. He's got more counseling background than most pastors,

but he's not a psychologist with a specialty in BPD or anything. On the other

hand, he helps with some of the issues that come up that touch on what's right

as a christian and all. Sometimes it's hard for me to trust what a therapist

tells me because I wonder if that's okay as a christian. Can any of you relate?

>

> Anyway, I told him I was questioning the mental illness thing a bit since my

nada can totally control herself when she wants to and since so much of what she

does is " mean " as I put it to him, not just emotional regulation issues or

whatever. He said he finds it really hard to figure that stuff out, but he

thinks NC is probably not an option for a christian. He also told me that if I

told him I was going NC he wouldn't say anything to me or give me a hard time

and he would support me at the time, but he might talk with me more about it

later. At first I felt ok about this, but after I got off the phone I started

to get really panicky.

>

> My husband asked if I had shared what she's doing to my family members. So I

emailed him about how I found out the reason my Dad was suicidal last year was

because she was telling him he was better off dead on a regular basis. (They

lost their savings in the financial crisis and I think he told me she was

telling him he was worthless and everyone would be better off with the insurance

money). I also told him she's attacking my dangerously depressed younger

brother who is stuck living at home and unemployed right now and who can't get

on his feet because every time he makes a positive move she comes and tears him

down. I told him that she was telling my brother he's better off dead.

>

> But I'm hedging because suddenly I'm not sure. I know my Dad told me she was

telling him he was better off dead. I know she is regularly attacking my

brother (who was a all-bad child). But I'm having major fog and mom-headache.

I can't think straight. I said to my husband, " here I go making it all up

again " and couldn't believe I blurted that out. Did someone tell me she was

telling my brother he's better off dead or did I make that up? I know I don't

make it up, but my contact with her and her denial of the abuse has me

struggling to retain my identity and sense of trusting my own sense of reality.

I'm spiraling. I feel like I'm fighting for my survival again.

>

> Anyway, my pastor responded to that email saying that based on this info he

feels much stronger boundaries are in order. So we're supposed to talk again

next week, but I want to make sure I'm giving accurate information. Becuase

otherwise I'll doubt the validity of whatever plan we come up with.

>

> Does it matter if she is actually coming out and saying my brother is better

off dead? The logical conclusion of her messages to us was always that anyway.

>

> I know some of you all have mothers who are sometimes the good mom, but I

don't think my good mom is very nice. She has a really scary malicious " witch "

in her. But I think she might be always the witch just a little bit. What I

mean is she really shows no interest in me as me. The only interest she has inme

is what I can give her, and sometimes that means " mirroring " . her message is

always and always has been that who I am as a person is unacceptable and

disgusting to me. I tried to kill my soul as a child to please her and she

tried to destroy my personality and replace it with her own or some kind of

servant who praised her constantly. She is one of the " merger-hungry "

personalities from UBM.

>

> My mother's message to me is that I as who I am evil and disgusting and when I

used to believe her I always felt I didn't have a right to be alive. She did a

lot of things very systematically to destroy who I was and I feel like all of

her faces (witch, nice, withdrawn, etc etc) are part of the same message and

project to get me to be her mirror/vessel/servant.

>

> Can she really be like this? Am I making it up? Am I being unfair to her?

Is it my own weakness that contact with her is SO BAD for me? Can she really be

so mean?

>

> I just want to get away from her. I want to be at a place where I feel free,

where whatever love I give I give freely, not just because I can't get away

because she's " mentally ill. " Are you really telling me she can't help it?

Does being an emotional adolescent make you scary mean? Most teenagers are not

murderous....

>

> Any thoughts? I want out of the fog.

>

>

>

>

>

>

Guest guest
Posted

Karla, just had to say you are going to be an *awesome* minister. Your

congregations will be lucky people.

MP, echoing what Karla said that you are living it, you are there, you know your

reality. And perhaps the urge to doubt oneself has extra power when what you

perceive is so painful.

> >

> > I haven't been on this forum for a couple of weeks, but it's good to be

back. I'm back because I need validation so badly. I've been driven lately to

see things more clearly than I had before. But as I grapple with that I find

I'm struggling with confusion and fog.

> >

> > My pastor heard that my nada was visiting this weekend and called to see how

it went. I told him how the confrontation I was afraid of had happened but that

I was really proud of myself because I had stayed calm with her. (As I had

expected and others on this forum had predicted, my mom confronted me because I

kept avoiding leaving my son alone with her. I tried to be tactful, but she

wanted to know if that was what I was doing. I told her " I just feel more

comfortable when we are together as a group. " We then did a few hours of baby

fun activities, but then she cornered me when I was alone and wanted to know

why, " so I don't have to wonder. " I won't give the play by play, but the short

version is that I said " there were things that happened when I was a kid and I

just feel more comfortable when we are together as a group. " She started with

the whole invalidating story about how she " wasn't equipped " and the version

that includes some minor

> > conflict when I was a teenager but does not involve physical abuse

throughout childhood or what I consider much worse, systematic emotional abuse.

I told her that we had different memories, that being alone with my son was

non-negotiable and that I was going to take a break. I walked out and made my

husband stay at my side the rest of the visit. First she sulked in her room

then she started playing " super nice grandma " but being cold to me. Before she

played that super nice routine though, she did something that just made me sure

I was right, my son, who has of course fallen in love with her which actually

hurts me somehow, was crawling over and trying to get her to play with him. She

ignored him totally because she was mad at me. My grandnada did that to me, and

it is unacceptable.)

> >

> > Anyway, I told my pastor that story and we talked a little bit about how

much BPs are responsible for themselves and how much is " mental illness. " He's

big on boundaries but he always reminds me she's mentally ill, and this time I

challenged him on it. He's got more counseling background than most pastors,

but he's not a psychologist with a specialty in BPD or anything. On the other

hand, he helps with some of the issues that come up that touch on what's right

as a christian and all. Sometimes it's hard for me to trust what a therapist

tells me because I wonder if that's okay as a christian. Can any of you relate?

> >

> > Anyway, I told him I was questioning the mental illness thing a bit since my

nada can totally control herself when she wants to and since so much of what she

does is " mean " as I put it to him, not just emotional regulation issues or

whatever. He said he finds it really hard to figure that stuff out, but he

thinks NC is probably not an option for a christian. He also told me that if I

told him I was going NC he wouldn't say anything to me or give me a hard time

and he would support me at the time, but he might talk with me more about it

later. At first I felt ok about this, but after I got off the phone I started

to get really panicky.

> >

> > My husband asked if I had shared what she's doing to my family members. So

I emailed him about how I found out the reason my Dad was suicidal last year was

because she was telling him he was better off dead on a regular basis. (They

lost their savings in the financial crisis and I think he told me she was

telling him he was worthless and everyone would be better off with the insurance

money). I also told him she's attacking my dangerously depressed younger

brother who is stuck living at home and unemployed right now and who can't get

on his feet because every time he makes a positive move she comes and tears him

down. I told him that she was telling my brother he's better off dead.

> >

> > But I'm hedging because suddenly I'm not sure. I know my Dad told me she

was telling him he was better off dead. I know she is regularly attacking my

brother (who was a all-bad child). But I'm having major fog and mom-headache.

I can't think straight. I said to my husband, " here I go making it all up

again " and couldn't believe I blurted that out. Did someone tell me she was

telling my brother he's better off dead or did I make that up? I know I don't

make it up, but my contact with her and her denial of the abuse has me

struggling to retain my identity and sense of trusting my own sense of reality.

I'm spiraling. I feel like I'm fighting for my survival again.

> >

> > Anyway, my pastor responded to that email saying that based on this info he

feels much stronger boundaries are in order. So we're supposed to talk again

next week, but I want to make sure I'm giving accurate information. Becuase

otherwise I'll doubt the validity of whatever plan we come up with.

> >

> > Does it matter if she is actually coming out and saying my brother is better

off dead? The logical conclusion of her messages to us was always that anyway.

> >

> > I know some of you all have mothers who are sometimes the good mom, but I

don't think my good mom is very nice. She has a really scary malicious " witch "

in her. But I think she might be always the witch just a little bit. What I

mean is she really shows no interest in me as me. The only interest she has inme

is what I can give her, and sometimes that means " mirroring " . her message is

always and always has been that who I am as a person is unacceptable and

disgusting to me. I tried to kill my soul as a child to please her and she

tried to destroy my personality and replace it with her own or some kind of

servant who praised her constantly. She is one of the " merger-hungry "

personalities from UBM.

> >

> > My mother's message to me is that I as who I am evil and disgusting and when

I used to believe her I always felt I didn't have a right to be alive. She did

a lot of things very systematically to destroy who I was and I feel like all of

her faces (witch, nice, withdrawn, etc etc) are part of the same message and

project to get me to be her mirror/vessel/servant.

> >

> > Can she really be like this? Am I making it up? Am I being unfair to her?

Is it my own weakness that contact with her is SO BAD for me? Can she really be

so mean?

> >

> > I just want to get away from her. I want to be at a place where I feel

free, where whatever love I give I give freely, not just because I can't get

away because she's " mentally ill. " Are you really telling me she can't help it?

Does being an emotional adolescent make you scary mean? Most teenagers are not

murderous....

> >

> > Any thoughts? I want out of the fog.

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

Guest guest
Posted

Your pastor doesn't think a Christian should go NC?

Really?

I think that there are circumstances in which going NC *is* the Christian thing

to do. Then again, I'm Catholic and there are a lot of Christians who think

Catholics don't count as Christians to begin with. Whatever.

I have no idea if this will help you or not, and I realize my theology may be

different from yours. But, as a person who takes her faith very very seriously

I can share with you my own thoughts on being NC and how being faithful works

with that. You can agree or disagree as you wish. :-)

When we allow others to mistreat us, we harm ourselves AND WE HARM THEM. By

accepting abuse we teach the other person that this is okay to do. This, for

the faithful, is NOT part of being a " good Christian " . While we are told to

honor our mother and father, the flip side of that is that our parents are

supposed to lead us to Christ...and we honor Christ by honoring that guidance.

However, we are also commanded to follow God FIRST and we are told in Scripture

that following Christ can set us against our parents. In other words, if our

parents aren't being good parents we don't honor them or God by allowing them to

continue being bad parents. Obviously when we are children we hold little power

to do anything. As adults, we have more choices.

" Turning the other cheek " does NOT mean " allow someone to continue abusing you. "

Let's put that one into proper context, shall we? Way back when...in Jesus's

time...the right hand was your " clean " hand and your left hand was your " dirty "

hand. Literally. You used your left hand for dirty things, like wiping

yourself, etc. Your right hand was used for cleaner activities like eating,

touching others, etc. There are remnants of this tradition in modern times (A

friend of mine recently traveled to Dubai where she accidentally started eating

her bread from her left hand and got horrified stares in the restaurant!). If

you were to hit someone, the way you hit them indicated your stations to each

other. To hit someone who was your subordinate (a servant, a lower class, etc)

you backhanded them with your right hand...thus striking them on the right

cheek. If they were equal to you in station, you punched them with a closed

fist, thus striking them on

the left cheek. If that person then " turned the other cheek " to you for you to

hit them again, they were then forcing you to hit them THE OTHER WAY. Jesus

specifically said " If someone strikes you on the right cheek " ...so He was

referring to a superior hitting an inferior. Meaning, if I backhanded you and

you turned the other cheek...in order for me to hit you again I'd have to punch

you and admit you were my equal. Turning the other cheek isn't about inviting

more abuse, it's about nonviolently taking back control of the situation and

denying the other person the ability to humiliate you.

Going NC pretty much does just that, in my opinion. And, as such, NC done in

the right spirit can actually BE the Christian thing to do.

Ninera

>

> Subject: Is she trying to get my brother to kill himself?

> To: WTOAdultChildren1

> Date: Sunday, April 4, 2010, 2:33 AM

> I haven't been on this forum for a

> couple of weeks, but it's good to be back.  I'm back

> because I need validation so badly.  I've been driven

> lately to see things more clearly than I had before. 

> But as I grapple with that I find I'm struggling with

> confusion and fog.

>

> My pastor heard that my nada was visiting this weekend and

> called to see how it went.  I told him how the

> confrontation I was afraid of had happened but that I was

> really proud of myself because I had stayed calm with

> her.  (As I had expected and others on this forum had

> predicted, my mom confronted me because I kept avoiding

> leaving my son alone with her.  I tried to be tactful,

> but she wanted to know if that was what I was doing.  I

> told her " I just feel more comfortable when we are together

> as a group. "   We then did a few hours of baby fun

> activities, but then she cornered me when I was alone and

> wanted to know why, " so I don't have to wonder. "   I

> won't give the play by play, but the short version is that I

> said " there were things that happened when I was a kid and I

> just feel more comfortable when we are together as a

> group. "   She started with the whole invalidating story

> about how she " wasn't equipped " and the version that

> includes some minor

> conflict when I was a teenager but does not involve

> physical abuse throughout childhood or what I consider much

> worse, systematic emotional abuse.  I told her that we

> had different memories, that being alone with my son was

> non-negotiable and that I was going to take a break.  I

> walked out and made my husband stay at my side the rest of

> the visit.  First she sulked in her room then she

> started playing " super nice grandma " but being cold to

> me.  Before she played that super nice routine though,

> she did something that just made me sure I was right, my

> son, who has of course fallen in love with her which

> actually hurts me somehow, was crawling over and trying to

> get her to play with him.  She ignored him totally

> because she was mad at me.  My grandnada did that to

> me, and it is unacceptable.) 

>

> Anyway, I told my pastor that story and we talked a little

> bit about how much BPs are responsible for themselves and

> how much is " mental illness. "   He's big on boundaries

> but he always reminds me she's mentally ill, and this time I

> challenged him on it.  He's got more counseling

> background than most pastors, but he's not a psychologist

> with a specialty in BPD or anything.  On the other

> hand, he helps with some of the issues that come up that

> touch on what's right as a christian and all. 

> Sometimes it's hard for me to trust what a therapist tells

> me because I wonder if that's okay as a christian.  Can

> any of you relate? 

>

> Anyway, I told him I was questioning the mental illness

> thing a bit since my nada can totally control herself when

> she wants to and since so much of what she does is " mean " as

> I put it to him, not just emotional regulation issues or

> whatever.  He said he finds it really hard to figure

> that stuff out, but he thinks NC is probably not an option

> for a christian. He also told me that if I told him I was

> going NC he wouldn't say anything to me or give me a hard

> time and he would support me at the time, but he might talk

> with me more about it later.  At first I felt ok about

> this, but after I got off the phone I started to get really

> panicky.

>

> My husband asked if I had shared what she's doing to my

> family members.  So I emailed him about how I found out

> the reason my Dad was suicidal last year was because she was

> telling him he was better off dead on a regular basis. 

> (They lost their savings in the financial crisis and I think

> he told me she was telling him he was worthless and everyone

> would be better off with the insurance money).  I also

> told him she's attacking my dangerously depressed younger

> brother who is stuck living at home and unemployed right now

> and who can't get on his feet because every time he makes a

> positive move she comes and tears him down. I told him that

> she was telling my brother he's better off dead.

>

> But I'm hedging because suddenly I'm not sure.  I know

> my Dad told me she was telling him he was better off

> dead.  I know she is regularly attacking my brother

> (who was a all-bad child).  But I'm having major fog

> and mom-headache.  I can't think straight.  I said

> to my husband, " here I go making it all up again " and

> couldn't believe I blurted that out.  Did someone tell

> me she was telling my brother he's better off dead or did I

> make that up?  I know I don't make it up, but my

> contact with her and her denial of the abuse has me

> struggling to retain my identity and sense of trusting my

> own sense of reality.  I'm spiraling.  I feel like

> I'm fighting for my survival again.

>

> Anyway, my pastor responded to that email saying that based

> on this info he feels much stronger boundaries are in

> order.  So we're supposed to talk again next week, but

> I want to make sure I'm giving accurate information. Becuase

> otherwise I'll doubt the validity of whatever plan we come

> up with.

>

> Does it matter if she is actually coming out and saying my

> brother is better off dead?  The logical conclusion of

> her messages to us was always that anyway. 

>

> I know some of you all have mothers who are sometimes the

> good mom, but I don't think my good mom is very nice. 

> She has a really scary malicious " witch " in her.  But I

> think she might be always the witch just a little bit. What

> I mean is she really shows no interest in me as me. The only

> interest she has inme is what I can give her, and sometimes

> that means " mirroring " .  her message is always and

> always has been that who I am as a person is unacceptable

> and disgusting to me.  I tried to kill my soul as a

> child to please her and she tried to destroy my personality

> and replace it with her own or some kind of servant who

> praised her constantly.  She is one of the

> " merger-hungry " personalities from UBM. 

>

> My mother's message to me is that I as who I am evil and

> disgusting and when I used to believe her I always felt I

> didn't have a right to be alive.  She did a lot of

> things very systematically to destroy who I was and I feel

> like all of her faces (witch, nice, withdrawn, etc etc) are

> part of the same message and project to get me to be her

> mirror/vessel/servant.

>

> Can she really be like this?  Am I making it up? 

> Am I being unfair to her?  Is it my own weakness that

> contact with her is SO BAD for me?  Can she really be

> so mean? 

>

> I just want to get away from her.  I want to be at a

> place where I feel free, where whatever love I give I give

> freely, not just because I can't get away because she's

> " mentally ill. "   Are you really telling me she can't

> help it?  Does being an emotional adolescent make you

> scary mean?  Most teenagers are not murderous....

>

> Any thoughts?  I want out of the fog. 

>

>

>

>      

>

>

Guest guest
Posted

Hi MP,

I can't give feedback from a Christian perspective but as the daughter of

a Witch nada---yours sounds very similar to mine in many ways--I can really

relate to your feelings of fogginess and confusion.I've thought about this alot

the past year or so,this trying to wrap my head around my nada's intentions of

evil versus was it REAL as purposeful intention or some unconscious weird thing

she did.And I've come to the conclusion that I wouldn't have these fears about

her intentions or these thoughts about her being evil without an actual basis

for them.

Which is to say,if you even have to ask the question " Is she trying to

get my brother to kill himself? " ,there is a reason for it.A valid one.I think

it's impossible for us as nons to fully *apprehend* what drives them,truly--we

are simply not LIKE THEM.And it can seem too nasty or evil to fully take in or

take on.Who would want to believe this of another person,let alone their own

mother? I know that I have a hard time believing sometimes that my nada was as

vicious as she really was and I have to consciously remind myself that yes,she

really did say the things she said to me,such as encouraging me to kill myself

when I was a kid and still my psyche balks at the very thought of it.The

mentality of a nada like this,someone so mean and so murderous,is beyond the

realm of what is human as most of us know it.

It can seem so surreal you almost *want* to doubt it or to question

your own perceptions/memory...but that sickening sinking feeling in the pit of

your stomach is still there and deep down you do still know it.

I think it's really hard to hold on to what you don't even want to

quite accept (because it's inhuman,it is) while you're needing or asking for

support and backup from others.I'm not sure how that works exactly or why but I

have felt that,the knowing what I know and remembering what I remember (like

with what your nada said to your father about him being better off

dead---btw,that sounds very real and likely to me; something my nada would have

done too) and then...feeling it sort of slip...feeling it as surreal again...it

is just hard to hold on to,but that doesn't mean it isn't true or valid.It's

just too much,I think.Too much to try to contain,simply too much to wrap the

head around.

You're not making it up,but I understand how a witch-like nada can take

possession of your soul and totally mess with your will and clarity of mind.Just

remember that what you are giving to your pastor is emotionally accurate

information.You have reason to be seriously concerned--your nada is very

sick.Very sick reads dangerous,all the details condensed in that one word:

Dangerous.Emotionally lethal.That is what she is,to you and to others like your

brother.You would not feel that way about her for no reason.You just would not.

You're not being unfair to her.My nada stole my soul,too,and for the

longest time I made excuses for her in an attempt to salvage her humanity,one

she didn't quite have.People who have not had their soul taken or who weren't

forced to offer up their souls to a witch mother can't *feel* what that *is* but

dangerous malicious ill intent is what it is and if it's important to you that

your pastor supports you in the fact that your nada is dangerous,IMO you are

justified in sticking to what you remember about her telling your father he was

better off dead,even if internally you are doubting to some extent that it

really was that bad,if that helps him to understand that fraction of your

experience with her.Does that make sense?

I'm sorry you're going through this.I've been there.I know it's mind

blowingly difficult to process on your own and how much you need supporters and

advocates and how confused it makes you feel.

(((HUGS)))

>

> I haven't been on this forum for a couple of weeks, but it's good to be back.

I'm back because I need validation so badly. I've been driven lately to see

things more clearly than I had before. But as I grapple with that I find I'm

struggling with confusion and fog.

>

> My pastor heard that my nada was visiting this weekend and called to see how

it went. I told him how the confrontation I was afraid of had happened but that

I was really proud of myself because I had stayed calm with her. (As I had

expected and others on this forum had predicted, my mom confronted me because I

kept avoiding leaving my son alone with her. I tried to be tactful, but she

wanted to know if that was what I was doing. I told her " I just feel more

comfortable when we are together as a group. " We then did a few hours of baby

fun activities, but then she cornered me when I was alone and wanted to know

why, " so I don't have to wonder. " I won't give the play by play, but the short

version is that I said " there were things that happened when I was a kid and I

just feel more comfortable when we are together as a group. " She started with

the whole invalidating story about how she " wasn't equipped " and the version

that includes some minor

> conflict when I was a teenager but does not involve physical abuse throughout

childhood or what I consider much worse, systematic emotional abuse. I told her

that we had different memories, that being alone with my son was non-negotiable

and that I was going to take a break. I walked out and made my husband stay at

my side the rest of the visit. First she sulked in her room then she started

playing " super nice grandma " but being cold to me. Before she played that super

nice routine though, she did something that just made me sure I was right, my

son, who has of course fallen in love with her which actually hurts me somehow,

was crawling over and trying to get her to play with him. She ignored him

totally because she was mad at me. My grandnada did that to me, and it is

unacceptable.)

>

> Anyway, I told my pastor that story and we talked a little bit about how much

BPs are responsible for themselves and how much is " mental illness. " He's big

on boundaries but he always reminds me she's mentally ill, and this time I

challenged him on it. He's got more counseling background than most pastors,

but he's not a psychologist with a specialty in BPD or anything. On the other

hand, he helps with some of the issues that come up that touch on what's right

as a christian and all. Sometimes it's hard for me to trust what a therapist

tells me because I wonder if that's okay as a christian. Can any of you relate?

>

> Anyway, I told him I was questioning the mental illness thing a bit since my

nada can totally control herself when she wants to and since so much of what she

does is " mean " as I put it to him, not just emotional regulation issues or

whatever. He said he finds it really hard to figure that stuff out, but he

thinks NC is probably not an option for a christian. He also told me that if I

told him I was going NC he wouldn't say anything to me or give me a hard time

and he would support me at the time, but he might talk with me more about it

later. At first I felt ok about this, but after I got off the phone I started

to get really panicky.

>

> My husband asked if I had shared what she's doing to my family members. So I

emailed him about how I found out the reason my Dad was suicidal last year was

because she was telling him he was better off dead on a regular basis. (They

lost their savings in the financial crisis and I think he told me she was

telling him he was worthless and everyone would be better off with the insurance

money). I also told him she's attacking my dangerously depressed younger

brother who is stuck living at home and unemployed right now and who can't get

on his feet because every time he makes a positive move she comes and tears him

down. I told him that she was telling my brother he's better off dead.

>

> But I'm hedging because suddenly I'm not sure. I know my Dad told me she was

telling him he was better off dead. I know she is regularly attacking my

brother (who was a all-bad child). But I'm having major fog and mom-headache.

I can't think straight. I said to my husband, " here I go making it all up

again " and couldn't believe I blurted that out. Did someone tell me she was

telling my brother he's better off dead or did I make that up? I know I don't

make it up, but my contact with her and her denial of the abuse has me

struggling to retain my identity and sense of trusting my own sense of reality.

I'm spiraling. I feel like I'm fighting for my survival again.

>

> Anyway, my pastor responded to that email saying that based on this info he

feels much stronger boundaries are in order. So we're supposed to talk again

next week, but I want to make sure I'm giving accurate information. Becuase

otherwise I'll doubt the validity of whatever plan we come up with.

>

> Does it matter if she is actually coming out and saying my brother is better

off dead? The logical conclusion of her messages to us was always that anyway.

>

> I know some of you all have mothers who are sometimes the good mom, but I

don't think my good mom is very nice. She has a really scary malicious " witch "

in her. But I think she might be always the witch just a little bit. What I

mean is she really shows no interest in me as me. The only interest she has inme

is what I can give her, and sometimes that means " mirroring " . her message is

always and always has been that who I am as a person is unacceptable and

disgusting to me. I tried to kill my soul as a child to please her and she

tried to destroy my personality and replace it with her own or some kind of

servant who praised her constantly. She is one of the " merger-hungry "

personalities from UBM.

>

> My mother's message to me is that I as who I am evil and disgusting and when I

used to believe her I always felt I didn't have a right to be alive. She did a

lot of things very systematically to destroy who I was and I feel like all of

her faces (witch, nice, withdrawn, etc etc) are part of the same message and

project to get me to be her mirror/vessel/servant.

>

> Can she really be like this? Am I making it up? Am I being unfair to her?

Is it my own weakness that contact with her is SO BAD for me? Can she really be

so mean?

>

> I just want to get away from her. I want to be at a place where I feel free,

where whatever love I give I give freely, not just because I can't get away

because she's " mentally ill. " Are you really telling me she can't help it?

Does being an emotional adolescent make you scary mean? Most teenagers are not

murderous....

>

> Any thoughts? I want out of the fog.

>

>

>

>

>

>

Guest guest
Posted

B R A V O !!!!!!! Well written, this is a keeper and going in my toolbox.

May we all heal

>

> Your pastor doesn't think a Christian should go NC?

>

> Really?

>

> I think that there are circumstances in which going NC *is* the Christian

thing to do. Then again, I'm Catholic and there are a lot of Christians who

think Catholics don't count as Christians to begin with. Whatever.

>

> I have no idea if this will help you or not, and I realize my theology may be

different from yours. But, as a person who takes her faith very very seriously

I can share with you my own thoughts on being NC and how being faithful works

with that. You can agree or disagree as you wish. :-)

>

> When we allow others to mistreat us, we harm ourselves AND WE HARM THEM. By

accepting abuse we teach the other person that this is okay to do. This, for

the faithful, is NOT part of being a " good Christian " . While we are told to

honor our mother and father, the flip side of that is that our parents are

supposed to lead us to Christ...and we honor Christ by honoring that guidance.

However, we are also commanded to follow God FIRST and we are told in Scripture

that following Christ can set us against our parents. In other words, if our

parents aren't being good parents we don't honor them or God by allowing them to

continue being bad parents. Obviously when we are children we hold little power

to do anything. As adults, we have more choices.

>

> " Turning the other cheek " does NOT mean " allow someone to continue abusing

you. " Let's put that one into proper context, shall we? Way back when...in

Jesus's time...the right hand was your " clean " hand and your left hand was your

" dirty " hand. Literally. You used your left hand for dirty things, like wiping

yourself, etc. Your right hand was used for cleaner activities like eating,

touching others, etc. There are remnants of this tradition in modern times (A

friend of mine recently traveled to Dubai where she accidentally started eating

her bread from her left hand and got horrified stares in the restaurant!). If

you were to hit someone, the way you hit them indicated your stations to each

other. To hit someone who was your subordinate (a servant, a lower class, etc)

you backhanded them with your right hand...thus striking them on the right

cheek. If they were equal to you in station, you punched them with a closed

fist, thus striking them on

> the left cheek. If that person then " turned the other cheek " to you for you

to hit them again, they were then forcing you to hit them THE OTHER WAY. Jesus

specifically said " If someone strikes you on the right cheek " ...so He was

referring to a superior hitting an inferior. Meaning, if I backhanded you and

you turned the other cheek...in order for me to hit you again I'd have to punch

you and admit you were my equal. Turning the other cheek isn't about inviting

more abuse, it's about nonviolently taking back control of the situation and

denying the other person the ability to humiliate you.

>

> Going NC pretty much does just that, in my opinion. And, as such, NC done in

the right spirit can actually BE the Christian thing to do.

>

> Ninera

>

>

Guest guest
Posted

You guys give such helpful perspectives. First, of course catholics are

christians! Second, I appreciate all perspectives! I think some of you get

though how faith can be saving (it gave me a perspective that first made me

start doubting my nada when I was an adult--when I realized that what she was

saying didn't match what we were supposed to believe), and how it can be

confusing because forgiveness and grace are so central--so I always struggle to

figure out how to navigate it all.

Since I had a son I suddenly feel like I've woken up to another level of

clarity. I feel like it might be more important to protect myself now that I

have him to take care of. I'm also realizing this whole thing that nada is

never actually nice. I feel like the witch is always peeking out at me from her

eyes. I've started to see our " good " interactions as like one of those teen

thrillers where the villain seems all nice but reveals their true intentions by

a cunning look or a masked insult. You keep wanted to yell at the naive

protagonist " look out! she's evil! " I feel now like my " wise mind " is yelling

that at me all the time.

, this quote really helps. This is exactly what happens. I remember

reading about this in UBM, but it also helps that you share this experience.

" I'm not sure how that works exactly or why but I have felt that,the

knowing what I know and remembering what I remember (like with what your nada

said to your father about him being better off dead---btw,that

sounds very real and likely to me; something my nada would have done

too) and then...feeling it sort of slip...feeling it as surreal

again...it is just hard to hold on to,but that doesn't mean it isn't

true or valid. "

It is very disappointed to wake up and find my hope that there was actually a

good mother in there dashed. I've worked so hard on boundaries and giving her a

chance and all over the years, in order to maximize time with the good mother

and allow that part of the relationship to flourish. I think for some nadas,

what the books say may be misleading. I think they led me to believe there

really was a good mother. But I'm coming to believe that for my nada there

isn't, ever. Just a different mask over the predator. I feel like a very

emotionally exhausted Charlie Brown. Lucy is always going to pull the football

away and make me fall on my back. And Lucy won't let me spend any time with her

without setting it up as the kicking the football scenario. I'm so tired.

I'm tired of the drama. Over the past month I've suddenly seen what I've put my

husband through all these years, and how patient and supportive he's been. He

can't stand nada. He is a very gentle guy, but he really can't stand her. He

hates watching the way she hurts me, and he's gotten tired of the months

surrounding each visit that leave me withdrawn and struggling to recover.

I want to go LC. I've decided not to invite nada to my baby's 1 year birthday.

I've also decided to go ahead and invite the well behaved relatives (why should

they be excluded becuase it will make nada mad?) I know she's putting out a

distortion campaign on me with my relatives, but I'm tired. I'm just too tired.

Nada ruined every major event in my life, or at least left a scarring memory I

try to shut out when I remember those times: my graduations, my birthdays, my

wedding, my immediate post partum period. I want my little nuclear family to

enjoy my son's first birthday. And we will if nada isn't around. She'll

probably go NC if I don't invite her to the party. I'm just going to tell her

that her behavior at this visit was very unpleasant for us and created a lot of

tension and that it's not fair to my son to have that at his party.

KOs: I'm so sick of feeling responsible for nada. As long as that feeling

lasts she'll always own a piece of me. it gives my personal " devil a foothold. "

And yes, my pastor is wonderful, and he tries hard to understand. It's not his

fault that I want a father figure to help me feel permission to walk away from

nada. In most cases, I agree with him that cutting off relationship with

difficult people is not what christians do. But he also says that if it's a

dangerous abusive relationship that it's appropriate. I know he doesn't really

understand BPD. And I know that as a compassionate person he can't really

comprehend how evil nada-witch can be. I have a hard time comprehending it. I

guess I'm looking to see where he goes with things when I give him full data. I

think I've been too afraid to share some of the real darkness with him prior to

this point. Again, becuase I've hit my limit.

Last night, after writing my first email I had an 'aha' moment. I realized that

even though she's not physically attacking me anymore, even though toward me

personally she's not coming out with direct insults anymore, it's still an

" abusive relationship " . I guess I felt that if she didn't do those direct

things it's not really abusive, just manipulative. So I ask now, what's the

difference? When she is invalidating and cold toward me, that's enough to

trigger my reactions. It's enough for me to start falling into fog and fear and

my physical symptoms start up again (irritable bowel--bad pain there, mom

headache, muscle spasms, fatigue, and hives). Even though no one but the people

on this forum and my husband believe me, I think my nada's good behavior may

still constitute an abusive relationship for me. I guess the word abuse helps

me because it implies a right and probably a duty to protect oneself. We

forgive sin, we defend ourselves from

abuse...

One of the take-away messages I read int he books, like UBM...well what I mean

is they are all about how to work within relationship with your nada. I've

always felt they implied that if you have to go NC it's your personal weakness.

Does anyone have a perspective on that?

Also, does anyone have a perspective on KO roles? I find one of the things that

is very confusing to me is that I don't quite fit the profile. My brother was

the all-bad child. My youngest brother was the all-good child. And I was

all-good and all-bad in equal measure. I was also the child my mom was trying

most to merge with--I was the intended vessel because I am a girl. I find that

sometimes this leads me to be even more confused about my nada and myself.

Happy Easter for those who celebrate.

________________________________

To: WTOAdultChildren1

Sent: Sun, April 4, 2010 1:47:29 AM

Subject: Re: Is she trying to get my brother to kill

himself?

Hi MP,

I can't give feedback from a Christian perspective but as the daughter of a

Witch nada---yours sounds very similar to mine in many ways--I can really relate

to your feelings of fogginess and confusion.I' ve thought about this alot the

past year or so,this trying to wrap my head around my nada's intentions of evil

versus was it REAL as purposeful intention or some unconscious weird thing she

did.And I've come to the conclusion that I wouldn't have these fears about her

intentions or these thoughts about her being evil without an actual basis for

them.

Which is to say,if you even have to ask the question " Is she trying to get my

brother to kill himself? " ,there is a reason for it.A valid one.I think it's

impossible for us as nons to fully *apprehend* what drives them,truly-- we are

simply not LIKE THEM.And it can seem too nasty or evil to fully take in or take

on.Who would want to believe this of another person,let alone their own mother?

I know that I have a hard time believing sometimes that my nada was as vicious

as she really was and I have to consciously remind myself that yes,she really

did say the things she said to me,such as encouraging me to kill myself when I

was a kid and still my psyche balks at the very thought of it.The mentality of a

nada like this,someone so mean and so murderous,is beyond the realm of what is

human as most of us know it.

It can seem so surreal you almost *want* to doubt it or to question your own

perceptions/ memory... but that sickening sinking feeling in the pit of your

stomach is still there and deep down you do still know it.

I think it's really hard to hold on to what you don't even want to quite accept

(because it's inhuman,it is) while you're needing or asking for support and

backup from others.I'm not sure how that works exactly or why but I have felt

that,the knowing what I know and remembering what I remember (like with what

your nada said to your father about him being better off dead---btw,that sounds

very real and likely to me; something my nada would have done too) and

then...feeling it sort of slip...feeling it as surreal again...it is just hard

to hold on to,but that doesn't mean it isn't true or valid.It's just too much,I

think.Too much to try to contain,simply too much to wrap the head around.

You're not making it up,but I understand how a witch-like nada can take

possession of your soul and totally mess with your will and clarity of mind.Just

remember that what you are giving to your pastor is emotionally accurate

information. You have reason to be seriously concerned--your nada is very

sick.Very sick reads dangerous,all the details condensed in that one word:

Dangerous.Emotional ly lethal.That is what she is,to you and to others like your

brother.You would not feel that way about her for no reason.You just would not.

You're not being unfair to her.My nada stole my soul,too,and for the longest

time I made excuses for her in an attempt to salvage her humanity,one she didn't

quite have.People who have not had their soul taken or who weren't forced to

offer up their souls to a witch mother can't *feel* what that *is* but dangerous

malicious ill intent is what it is and if it's important to you that your pastor

supports you in the fact that your nada is dangerous,IMO you are justified in

sticking to what you remember about her telling your father he was better off

dead,even if internally you are doubting to some extent that it really was that

bad,if that helps him to understand that fraction of your experience with

her.Does that make sense?

I'm sorry you're going through this.I've been there.I know it's mind blowingly

difficult to process on your own and how much you need supporters and advocates

and how confused it makes you feel.

(((HUGS)))

>

> I haven't been on this forum for a couple of weeks, but it's good to be back.

I'm back because I need validation so badly. I've been driven lately to see

things more clearly than I had before. But as I grapple with that I find I'm

struggling with confusion and fog.

>

> My pastor heard that my nada was visiting this weekend and called to see how

it went. I told him how the confrontation I was afraid of had happened but that

I was really proud of myself because I had stayed calm with her. (As I had

expected and others on this forum had predicted, my mom confronted me because I

kept avoiding leaving my son alone with her. I tried to be tactful, but she

wanted to know if that was what I was doing. I told her " I just feel more

comfortable when we are together as a group. " We then did a few hours of baby

fun activities, but then she cornered me when I was alone and wanted to know

why, " so I don't have to wonder. " I won't give the play by play, but the short

version is that I said " there were things that happened when I was a kid and I

just feel more comfortable when we are together as a group. " She started with

the whole invalidating story about how she " wasn't equipped " and the version

that includes some minor

> conflict when I was a teenager but does not involve physical abuse throughout

childhood or what I consider much worse, systematic emotional abuse. I told her

that we had different memories, that being alone with my son was non-negotiable

and that I was going to take a break. I walked out and made my husband stay at

my side the rest of the visit. First she sulked in her room then she started

playing " super nice grandma " but being cold to me. Before she played that super

nice routine though, she did something that just made me sure I was right, my

son, who has of course fallen in love with her which actually hurts me somehow,

was crawling over and trying to get her to play with him. She ignored him

totally because she was mad at me. My grandnada did that to me, and it is

unacceptable. )

>

> Anyway, I told my pastor that story and we talked a little bit about how much

BPs are responsible for themselves and how much is " mental illness. " He's big

on boundaries but he always reminds me she's mentally ill, and this time I

challenged him on it. He's got more counseling background than most pastors,

but he's not a psychologist with a specialty in BPD or anything. On the other

hand, he helps with some of the issues that come up that touch on what's right

as a christian and all. Sometimes it's hard for me to trust what a therapist

tells me because I wonder if that's okay as a christian. Can any of you relate?

>

> Anyway, I told him I was questioning the mental illness thing a bit since my

nada can totally control herself when she wants to and since so much of what she

does is " mean " as I put it to him, not just emotional regulation issues or

whatever. He said he finds it really hard to figure that stuff out, but he

thinks NC is probably not an option for a christian. He also told me that if I

told him I was going NC he wouldn't say anything to me or give me a hard time

and he would support me at the time, but he might talk with me more about it

later. At first I felt ok about this, but after I got off the phone I started

to get really panicky.

>

> My husband asked if I had shared what she's doing to my family members. So I

emailed him about how I found out the reason my Dad was suicidal last year was

because she was telling him he was better off dead on a regular basis. (They

lost their savings in the financial crisis and I think he told me she was

telling him he was worthless and everyone would be better off with the insurance

money). I also told him she's attacking my dangerously depressed younger

brother who is stuck living at home and unemployed right now and who can't get

on his feet because every time he makes a positive move she comes and tears him

down. I told him that she was telling my brother he's better off dead.

>

> But I'm hedging because suddenly I'm not sure. I know my Dad told me she was

telling him he was better off dead. I know she is regularly attacking my

brother (who was a all-bad child). But I'm having major fog and mom-headache.

I can't think straight. I said to my husband, " here I go making it all up

again " and couldn't believe I blurted that out. Did someone tell me she was

telling my brother he's better off dead or did I make that up? I know I don't

make it up, but my contact with her and her denial of the abuse has me

struggling to retain my identity and sense of trusting my own sense of reality.

I'm spiraling. I feel like I'm fighting for my survival again.

>

> Anyway, my pastor responded to that email saying that based on this info he

feels much stronger boundaries are in order. So we're supposed to talk again

next week, but I want to make sure I'm giving accurate information. Becuase

otherwise I'll doubt the validity of whatever plan we come up with.

>

> Does it matter if she is actually coming out and saying my brother is better

off dead? The logical conclusion of her messages to us was always that anyway.

>

> I know some of you all have mothers who are sometimes the good mom, but I

don't think my good mom is very nice. She has a really scary malicious " witch "

in her. But I think she might be always the witch just a little bit. What I

mean is she really shows no interest in me as me. The only interest she has inme

is what I can give her, and sometimes that means " mirroring " . her message is

always and always has been that who I am as a person is unacceptable and

disgusting to me. I tried to kill my soul as a child to please her and she

tried to destroy my personality and replace it with her own or some kind of

servant who praised her constantly. She is one of the " merger-hungry "

personalities from UBM.

>

> My mother's message to me is that I as who I am evil and disgusting and when I

used to believe her I always felt I didn't have a right to be alive. She did a

lot of things very systematically to destroy who I was and I feel like all of

her faces (witch, nice, withdrawn, etc etc) are part of the same message and

project to get me to be her mirror/vessel/ servant.

>

> Can she really be like this? Am I making it up? Am I being unfair to her?

Is it my own weakness that contact with her is SO BAD for me? Can she really be

so mean?

>

> I just want to get away from her. I want to be at a place where I feel free,

where whatever love I give I give freely, not just because I can't get away

because she's " mentally ill. " Are you really telling me she can't help it?

Does being an emotional adolescent make you scary mean? Most teenagers are not

murderous... .

>

> Any thoughts? I want out of the fog.

>

>

>

>

>

>

Guest guest
Posted

It is NOT due to your own weakness that contact with her is so

bad for you. No amount of strength on your part will change the

fact that she's mentally ill. The things you've described really

are abusive and mean. The fact that she denies them is pretty

much to be expected. Nadas live in their own reality. They

almost always deny having done the abusive and nasty things

they've done. Often, they believe their own lies either because

their view of the world is so distorted that the things they've

done don't have the same meaning to them or because they've

rewritten history in their heads. (My nada does both of those

things.)

I don't think you should look at it as her possibly not being

mentally ill because she is able to control herself when she

wants to. In my experience, what's wrong with our nadas isn't an

issue of not being able to control themselves. Their problem is

that the parts of them that decide what kind of control is

needed are broken. It is like having a blind person driving a

car. The steering wheel, accelerator and brakes all work just

fine but the blind person can't tell when and how to use them

appropriately. Our nadas aren't able to tell how they should

control their own behavior.

If the message she's giving your brother is that he'd be better

off dead, it doesn't matter what words she uses to convey the

message. Making him think that is abusive and potentially

dangerous to him.

I don't believe in a God who'd expect anyone to continue to be

abused. I don't believe that being Christian requires you to

continue to have contact with someone who continues to abuse you

and who will almost certainly end up abusing your child if

allowed to. If your pastor doesn't have training in the mental

health field and specifically about BPD, he probably doesn't

really understand what dealing with it is like. Being Christian

may require you to try to have a better relationship with her

and to be kind to her, but if you try your best and it doesn't

work through no fault of your own, I don't think you're required

to torture yourself and put your son at risk continuing to have

contact with her.

At 10:33 PM 04/03/2010 More Private wrote:

>I haven't been on this forum for a couple of weeks, but it's

>good to be back. I'm back because I need validation so

>badly. I've been driven lately to see things more clearly than

>I had before. But as I grapple with that I find I'm struggling

>with confusion and fog.

>

>My pastor heard that my nada was visiting this weekend and

>called to see how it went. I told him how the confrontation I

>was afraid of had happened but that I was really proud of

>myself because I had stayed calm with her. (As I had expected

>and others on this forum had predicted, my mom confronted me

>because I kept avoiding leaving my son alone with her. I tried

>to be tactful, but she wanted to know if that was what I was

>doing. I told her " I just feel more comfortable when we are

>together as a group. " We then did a few hours of baby fun

>activities, but then she cornered me when I was alone and

>wanted to know why, " so I don't have to wonder. " I won't give

>the play by play, but the short version is that I said " there

>were things that happened when I was a kid and I just feel more

>comfortable when we are together as a group. " She started with

>the whole invalidating story about how she " wasn't equipped "

>and the version that includes some minor

> conflict when I was a teenager but does not involve physical

> abuse throughout childhood or what I consider much worse,

> systematic emotional abuse. I told her that we had different

> memories, that being alone with my son was non-negotiable and

> that I was going to take a break. I walked out and made my

> husband stay at my side the rest of the visit. First she

> sulked in her room then she started playing " super nice

> grandma " but being cold to me. Before she played that super

> nice routine though, she did something that just made me sure

> I was right, my son, who has of course fallen in love with her

> which actually hurts me somehow, was crawling over and trying

> to get her to play with him. She ignored him totally because

> she was mad at me. My grandnada did that to me, and it is

> unacceptable.)

>

>Anyway, I told my pastor that story and we talked a little bit

>about how much BPs are responsible for themselves and how much

>is " mental illness. " He's big on boundaries but he always

>reminds me she's mentally ill, and this time I challenged him

>on it. He's got more counseling background than most pastors,

>but he's not a psychologist with a specialty in BPD or

>anything. On the other hand, he helps with some of the issues

>that come up that touch on what's right as a christian and

>all. Sometimes it's hard for me to trust what a therapist

>tells me because I wonder if that's okay as a christian. Can

>any of you relate?

>

>Anyway, I told him I was questioning the mental illness thing a

>bit since my nada can totally control herself when she wants to

>and since so much of what she does is " mean " as I put it to

>him, not just emotional regulation issues or whatever. He said

>he finds it really hard to figure that stuff out, but he thinks

>NC is probably not an option for a christian. He also told me

>that if I told him I was going NC he wouldn't say anything to

>me or give me a hard time and he would support me at the time,

>but he might talk with me more about it later. At first I felt

>ok about this, but after I got off the phone I started to get

>really panicky.

>

>My husband asked if I had shared what she's doing to my family

>members. So I emailed him about how I found out the reason my

>Dad was suicidal last year was because she was telling him he

>was better off dead on a regular basis. (They lost their

>savings in the financial crisis and I think he told me she was

>telling him he was worthless and everyone would be better off

>with the insurance money). I also told him she's attacking my

>dangerously depressed younger brother who is stuck living at

>home and unemployed right now and who can't get on his feet

>because every time he makes a positive move she comes and tears

>him down. I told him that she was telling my brother he's

>better off dead.

>

>But I'm hedging because suddenly I'm not sure. I know my Dad

>told me she was telling him he was better off dead. I know she

>is regularly attacking my brother (who was a all-bad

>child). But I'm having major fog and mom-headache. I can't

>think straight. I said to my husband, " here I go making it all

>up again " and couldn't believe I blurted that out. Did someone

>tell me she was telling my brother he's better off dead or did

>I make that up? I know I don't make it up, but my contact with

>her and her denial of the abuse has me struggling to retain my

>identity and sense of trusting my own sense of reality. I'm

>spiraling. I feel like I'm fighting for my survival again.

>

>Anyway, my pastor responded to that email saying that based on

>this info he feels much stronger boundaries are in order. So

>we're supposed to talk again next week, but I want to make sure

>I'm giving accurate information. Becuase otherwise I'll doubt

>the validity of whatever plan we come up with.

>

>Does it matter if she is actually coming out and saying my

>brother is better off dead? The logical conclusion of her

>messages to us was always that anyway.

>

>I know some of you all have mothers who are sometimes the good

>mom, but I don't think my good mom is very nice. She has a

>really scary malicious " witch " in her. But I think she might

>be always the witch just a little bit. What I mean is she

>really shows no interest in me as me. The only interest she has

>inme is what I can give her, and sometimes that means

> " mirroring " . her message is always and always has been that

>who I am as a person is unacceptable and disgusting to me. I

>tried to kill my soul as a child to please her and she tried to

>destroy my personality and replace it with her own or some kind

>of servant who praised her constantly. She is one of the

> " merger-hungry " personalities from UBM.

>

>My mother's message to me is that I as who I am evil and

>disgusting and when I used to believe her I always felt I

>didn't have a right to be alive. She did a lot of things very

>systematically to destroy who I was and I feel like all of her

>faces (witch, nice, withdrawn, etc etc) are part of the same

>message and project to get me to be her mirror/vessel/servant.

>

>Can she really be like this? Am I making it up? Am I being

>unfair to her? Is it my own weakness that contact with her is

>SO BAD for me? Can she really be so mean?

>

>I just want to get away from her. I want to be at a place

>where I feel free, where whatever love I give I give freely,

>not just because I can't get away because she's " mentally

>ill. " Are you really telling me she can't help it? Does being

>an emotional adolescent make you scary mean? Most teenagers

>are not murderous....

>

>Any thoughts? I want out of the fog.

--

Katrina

Guest guest
Posted

I don't think going NC is a sign of personal weakness. In fact,

I think it can require more strength to do than staying in

contact does. Staying in contact may just mean continuing to put

up with the status quo, accepting the continuing abuse, which

isn't exactly a sign of strength. Unless you can do it by moving

away and ensuring that no one tells your nada how to reach you,

going NC requires being strong and refusing to give in to her

efforts to contact and abuse you. My sister did it by joining

the army and never telling nada how to reach her after she got

out of basic training. (Being in basic training severely limits

contact with everyone whether you want to be in contact or not.)

Most of us don't have an opportunity like that that is

tailor-made for going NC.

As for KO roles, I think everyone suffers through their own

variation of the standard roles that get talked about. While

there are lots of similarities between them, each nada is a

little different in how she acts out.

At 10:48 AM 04/04/2010 More Private wrote:

>You guys give such helpful perspectives. First, of course

>catholics are christians! Second, I appreciate all

>perspectives! I think some of you get though how faith can be

>saving (it gave me a perspective that first made me start

>doubting my nada when I was an adult--when I realized that what

>she was saying didn't match what we were supposed to believe),

>and how it can be confusing because forgiveness and grace are

>so central--so I always struggle to figure out how to navigate

>it all.

>

>Since I had a son I suddenly feel like I've woken up to another

>level of clarity. I feel like it might be more important to

>protect myself now that I have him to take care of. I'm also

>realizing this whole thing that nada is never actually nice. I

>feel like the witch is always peeking out at me from her

>eyes. I've started to see our " good " interactions as like one

>of those teen thrillers where the villain seems all nice but

>reveals their true intentions by a cunning look or a masked

>insult. You keep wanted to yell at the naive protagonist " look

>out! she's evil! " I feel now like my " wise mind " is yelling

>that at me all the time.

>

>, this quote really helps. This is exactly what

>happens. I remember reading about this in UBM, but it also

>helps that you share this experience. " I'm not sure how that

>works exactly or why but I have felt that,the

>knowing what I know and remembering what I remember (like with

>what your nada said to your father about him being better off

>dead---btw,that

>sounds very real and likely to me; something my nada would have

>done

>too) and then...feeling it sort of slip...feeling it as surreal

>

>again...it is just hard to hold on to,but that doesn't mean it

>isn't

>true or valid. "

>

>It is very disappointed to wake up and find my hope that there

>was actually a good mother in there dashed. I've worked so hard

>on boundaries and giving her a chance and all over the years,

>in order to maximize time with the good mother and allow that

>part of the relationship to flourish. I think for some nadas,

>what the books say may be misleading. I think they led me to

>believe there really was a good mother. But I'm coming to

>believe that for my nada there isn't, ever. Just a different

>mask over the predator. I feel like a very emotionally

>exhausted Charlie Brown. Lucy is always going to pull the

>football away and make me fall on my back. And Lucy won't let

>me spend any time with her without setting it up as the kicking

>the football scenario. I'm so tired.

>

>I'm tired of the drama. Over the past month I've suddenly seen

>what I've put my husband through all these years, and how

>patient and supportive he's been. He can't stand nada. He is

>a very gentle guy, but he really can't stand her. He hates

>watching the way she hurts me, and he's gotten tired of the

>months surrounding each visit that leave me withdrawn and

>struggling to recover.

>

>I want to go LC. I've decided not to invite nada to my baby's

>1 year birthday. I've also decided to go ahead and invite the

>well behaved relatives (why should they be excluded becuase it

>will make nada mad?) I know she's putting out a distortion

>campaign on me with my relatives, but I'm tired. I'm just too

>tired. Nada ruined every major event in my life, or at least

>left a scarring memory I try to shut out when I remember those

>times: my graduations, my birthdays, my wedding, my immediate

>post partum period. I want my little nuclear family to enjoy

>my son's first birthday. And we will if nada isn't

>around. She'll probably go NC if I don't invite her to the

>party. I'm just going to tell her that her behavior at this

>visit was very unpleasant for us and created a lot of tension

>and that it's not fair to my son to have that at his party.

>

>KOs: I'm so sick of feeling responsible for nada. As long as

>that feeling lasts she'll always own a piece of me. it gives

>my personal " devil a foothold. " And yes, my pastor is

>wonderful, and he tries hard to understand. It's not his fault

>that I want a father figure to help me feel permission to walk

>away from nada. In most cases, I agree with him that cutting

>off relationship with difficult people is not what christians

>do. But he also says that if it's a dangerous abusive

>relationship that it's appropriate. I know he doesn't really

>understand BPD. And I know that as a compassionate person he

>can't really comprehend how evil nada-witch can be. I have a

>hard time comprehending it. I guess I'm looking to see where

>he goes with things when I give him full data. I think I've

>been too afraid to share some of the real darkness with him

>prior to this point. Again, becuase I've hit my limit.

>

>Last night, after writing my first email I had an 'aha'

>moment. I realized that even though she's not physically

>attacking me anymore, even though toward me personally she's

>not coming out with direct insults anymore, it's still an

> " abusive relationship " . I guess I felt that if she didn't do

>those direct things it's not really abusive, just manipulative.

>So I ask now, what's the difference? When she is invalidating

>and cold toward me, that's enough to trigger my

>reactions. It's enough for me to start falling into fog and

>fear and my physical symptoms start up again (irritable

>bowel--bad pain there, mom headache, muscle spasms, fatigue,

>and hives). Even though no one but the people on this forum

>and my husband believe me, I think my nada's good behavior may

>still constitute an abusive relationship for me. I guess the

>word abuse helps me because it implies a right and probably a

>duty to protect oneself. We forgive sin, we defend ourselves

>from

> abuse...

>

>One of the take-away messages I read int he books, like

>UBM...well what I mean is they are all about how to work within

>relationship with your nada. I've always felt they implied

>that if you have to go NC it's your personal weakness. Does

>anyone have a perspective on that?

>

>Also, does anyone have a perspective on KO roles? I find one

>of the things that is very confusing to me is that I don't

>quite fit the profile. My brother was the all-bad child. My

>youngest brother was the all-good child. And I was all-good

>and all-bad in equal measure. I was also the child my mom was

>trying most to merge with--I was the intended vessel because I

>am a girl. I find that sometimes this leads me to be even more

>confused about my nada and myself.

>

>Happy Easter for those who celebrate.

--

Katrina

Guest guest
Posted

I totally agree with this !! very well put !

Jackie

Your pastor doesn't think a Christian should go NC?

Really?

I think that there are circumstances in which going NC *is* the Christian

thing to do. Then again, I'm Catholic and there are a lot of Christians who

think Catholics don't count as Christians to begin with. Whatever.

I have no idea if this will help you or not, and I realize my theology may

be different from yours. But, as a person who takes her faith very very

seriously I can share with you my own thoughts on being NC and how being

faithful works with that. You can agree or disagree as you wish. :-)

When we allow others to mistreat us, we harm ourselves AND WE HARM THEM. By

accepting abuse we teach the other person that this is okay to do. This,

for the faithful, is NOT part of being a " good Christian " . While we are

told to honor our mother and father, the flip side of that is that our

parents are supposed to lead us to Christ...and we honor Christ by honoring

that guidance. However, we are also commanded to follow God FIRST and we

are told in Scripture that following Christ can set us against our parents.

In other words, if our parents aren't being good parents we don't honor them

or God by allowing them to continue being bad parents. Obviously when we

are children we hold little power to do anything. As adults, we have more

choices.

" Turning the other cheek " does NOT mean " allow someone to continue abusing

you. " Let's put that one into proper context, shall we? Way back when...in

Jesus's time...the right hand was your " clean " hand and your left hand was

your " dirty " hand. Literally. You used your left hand for dirty things,

like wiping yourself, etc. Your right hand was used for cleaner activities

like eating, touching others, etc. There are remnants of this tradition in

modern times (A friend of mine recently traveled to Dubai where she

accidentally started eating her bread from her left hand and got horrified

stares in the restaurant!). If you were to hit someone, the way you hit

them indicated your stations to each other. To hit someone who was your

subordinate (a servant, a lower class, etc) you backhanded them with your

right hand...thus striking them on the right cheek. If they were equal to

you in station, you punched them with a closed fist, thus striking them on

the left cheek. If that person then " turned the other cheek " to you for

you to hit them again, they were then forcing you to hit them THE OTHER WAY.

Jesus specifically said " If someone strikes you on the right cheek " ...so He

was referring to a superior hitting an inferior. Meaning, if I backhanded

you and you turned the other cheek...in order for me to hit you again I'd

have to punch you and admit you were my equal. Turning the other cheek

isn't about inviting more abuse, it's about nonviolently taking back control

of the situation and denying the other person the ability to humiliate you.

Going NC pretty much does just that, in my opinion. And, as such, NC done

in the right spirit can actually BE the Christian thing to do.

Ninera

Guest guest
Posted

Hi,

I can soooo feel for what you are going through. I remember those days so well:

When I didn't expect an issue with her, something terrible would happen and I

would be going, " OMG, I can't stand this...what are we going to do with her when

she gets older...I want to be free of this messed up person! " And then I'd go

into the next interaction, visit, whatever, shaking in my number eight shoes,

and she'd be...fine!

And then I'd feel guilty. " I must have been making it all up. "

" Can she really be like this? Am I making it up? "

Um, no. You are not making anything up. That's the thing with these people.

Whatever state they're in, they believe it. They really believe it! So

strongly that you end up asking, " Am I making it up? "

I did some detective work with other members of the family and the more I

learned, the more I realized how very serious her problems are and the less I

was inclined to think it was all just me.

" Am I being unfair to her? Is it my own weakness that contact with her is SO BAD

for me? Can she really be so mean? "

As far as her being so mean: You have to understand that these people are in a

tidal wave of pain *all the time.* They lash out, they will do or say

*anything* to make themselves feel better in the moment. So even when what they

are doing is just totally incomprehensible to us, yeah, they can really be that

mean. My stepfather had a BP of 300 for like, we don't know how long. (I

suspect it came from living 20+ years with her.) He wouldn't go to the doctor

and kept having these spells where she thought he'd been drinking. Turns out it

was mini strokes. Finally he had one big one and ended up in the hospital in

very bad condition. She stood over him and bitched about how it was his own

fault while the poor man was crying over what had happened. It really broke my

heart when I heard about it. Yeah, they can really be this mean. No lie.

That contact with this kind of illness is really bad for you is NO weakness on

your part, believe me. Keep in mind that therapists, the best ones in the

country, train for YEARS to treat these people and they still find this illness

very, very challenging. And they only have to see these people a couple of

hours a week! When this is the person who raised you and you have all these

leftover issues about being this person's little girl, and you have a family

relationship with them...it's much, much harder. Much, much harder.

I have several BPD books written for therapists. Even in Marsha Linehan's

seminal book about DBT, it is stressed many, many times how hard the therapist

has it in dealing with these folks, and they have conferences to support each

other in this. You have no such thing, and you aren't trained in these

techniques. So imagine how much harder it is for you.

You can't ask the impossible of yourself.

Are you being unfair? I don't think the question is one of fairness or

unfairness. It's more like, is the person capable of stepping up and dealing

with their illness in a responsible, um, somewhat-capable manner?

Wanna-be-capable manner? If my nada could/would do that, I could take a whole

lot more crap. If she actually recognized that she had a problem and was

committed to working in therapy to get well, it would be a whole lot different.

These folks have the hugest, HUGEST uphill battle to get better.

It's when they don't/can't have the insight that THEY have some responsibility

for the problems they're in and that THEY and their behavior are actually

hurting other people, that you have to step back. In my situation, I found out

the biggest family secret of all...and I knew after that that my nada was never

going to step up. That was when I said, " I have to limit this damage to myself.

I have my own problems, and all she wants me to do is things that are

destructive to me and destructive TO HER. "

Because it's true. When you do what the BP wants, you just keep the problems

the same, and growing and growing and growing and growing. There's no point in

continuing to act in ways that just result in the same damage to everyone over

and over again. If the BP wants X and you give them X, even though it's hurting

you to do so, then what have they been allowed to discover?

" I just want to get away from her. I want to be at a place where I feel free,

where whatever love I give I give freely, not just because I can't get away

because she's " mentally ill. " Are you really telling me she can't help it? "

This is a question I have often wondered about myself. There were times when my

nada became crystal clear about how she has acted and how destructive it was to

us kids. Stanton Samenow, Ph.D., has documented the same phenomenon working

with criminals. At some point the criminal will hit a low point and come to an

understanding of his behavior that makes him...momentarily at least...want to

change. What Samenow says is that this is where the prison system/the

therapist/society has to learn to strike when the iron is hot. At this choice

point you can sometimes get a criminal to step up. But not at other

times...they aren't motivated.

I think BP's are the same way. I think if the right intervention could have

been made at those times, maybe my nada might have stepped up. But if you never

observe those kinds of feelings at all in yours, it doesn't sound like there's a

whole lot of hope.

I don't think that, say, to use an analogy someone else used on here recently,

if a dog were rabid or something and biting people, Jesus would be happy to see

someone ignoring it and letting it be in pain. However, if there were

absolutely no way to help the dog, would he ask you to just keep sticking your

hand in its cage and letting it bite you? I wonder what your minister would say

to this. He sounds like a good guy, but how much does he know about personality

disorders?

Good luck to you and Happy Easter.

--.

Guest guest
Posted

MP,I remember reading in the Witch chapter of UBM that the child of a witch must

choose her own protection and safety first-this is imperative when dealing with

a witch.At the time,I had just begun NC with nada and was feeling like a jerk

about it,so reading that was so helpful.I can't see how it's any different for

you,except that unlike me,you also have a baby to consider.To me,that gives you

even more of a reason to stick to your boundaries as I know you're doing.I

totally think you're doing the right thing and I hope you have a really lovely

nada free day on your little son's first birthday.Nada drama free and just

nice,as it should be.By RIGHTS.Simply as it should be.

I know what you mean about the masks that cover the true face of the

predator.I find that shit scary,myself.The knowing of that.Knowing that,seeing

that but not wanting to,is SO deflating to the spirit.It is spiritually

exhausting.Some mothers are indeed not good ones and all our efforts at being

" understanding " just lead to more hurting,for us.I think that it just isn't

REAL,to offer understanding to a predatory mother--it truly is not our

responsibility to do that and truly it isn't going to help or change

anything.There is nothing weak about just being real about it.Actually that is

strength.I know that my own nada's " goodness " was never from the heart,only

intended for effect--and to me,to lie about being good or loving is abusive

manipulation of the evilest sort.There is a chilling coldness to that that is

unholy,that is disturbingly malevolent,even demonic.It's like spiritual

exploitation.

As to fitting the profile,what you mentioned sounds like a KO thing to

me: being split both bad and good.I was split bad (considered to be pure

evil,all of her evil projected onto me) but here on the group I have read of

other KOs being alternatively split good and bad,esp. group members who were

only children.You being the only girl would be akin to being an only.Really

damaging merging issues also seem to be a feature of being an only.That being

forced to merge instead of healthily encouraged to individuate causes serious

confusion because it is just contrary to the nature of child development,it is

totally abnormal and un-natural from both a social and biological standpoint.So

what you're planning to do with excluding your nada from your son's birthday

party is actually healthy individuation since having her there would only be her

putting more of that merging pathology on to you--this is an excellent and wise

Mom decision you're making here.A very healthy one.

Best wishes to you,

>

> You guys give such helpful perspectives. First, of course catholics are

christians! Second, I appreciate all perspectives! I think some of you get

though how faith can be saving (it gave me a perspective that first made me

start doubting my nada when I was an adult--when I realized that what she was

saying didn't match what we were supposed to believe), and how it can be

confusing because forgiveness and grace are so central--so I always struggle to

figure out how to navigate it all.

>

> Since I had a son I suddenly feel like I've woken up to another level of

clarity. I feel like it might be more important to protect myself now that I

have him to take care of. I'm also realizing this whole thing that nada is

never actually nice. I feel like the witch is always peeking out at me from her

eyes. I've started to see our " good " interactions as like one of those teen

thrillers where the villain seems all nice but reveals their true intentions by

a cunning look or a masked insult. You keep wanted to yell at the naive

protagonist " look out! she's evil! " I feel now like my " wise mind " is yelling

that at me all the time.

>

> , this quote really helps. This is exactly what happens. I remember

reading about this in UBM, but it also helps that you share this experience.

" I'm not sure how that works exactly or why but I have felt that,the

> knowing what I know and remembering what I remember (like with what your nada

said to your father about him being better off dead---btw,that

> sounds very real and likely to me; something my nada would have done

> too) and then...feeling it sort of slip...feeling it as surreal

> again...it is just hard to hold on to,but that doesn't mean it isn't

> true or valid. "

>

> It is very disappointed to wake up and find my hope that there was actually a

good mother in there dashed. I've worked so hard on boundaries and giving her a

chance and all over the years, in order to maximize time with the good mother

and allow that part of the relationship to flourish. I think for some nadas,

what the books say may be misleading. I think they led me to believe there

really was a good mother. But I'm coming to believe that for my nada there

isn't, ever. Just a different mask over the predator. I feel like a very

emotionally exhausted Charlie Brown. Lucy is always going to pull the football

away and make me fall on my back. And Lucy won't let me spend any time with her

without setting it up as the kicking the football scenario. I'm so tired.

>

> I'm tired of the drama. Over the past month I've suddenly seen what I've put

my husband through all these years, and how patient and supportive he's been.

He can't stand nada. He is a very gentle guy, but he really can't stand her.

He hates watching the way she hurts me, and he's gotten tired of the months

surrounding each visit that leave me withdrawn and struggling to recover.

>

> I want to go LC. I've decided not to invite nada to my baby's 1 year

birthday. I've also decided to go ahead and invite the well behaved relatives

(why should they be excluded becuase it will make nada mad?) I know she's

putting out a distortion campaign on me with my relatives, but I'm tired. I'm

just too tired. Nada ruined every major event in my life, or at least left a

scarring memory I try to shut out when I remember those times: my graduations,

my birthdays, my wedding, my immediate post partum period. I want my little

nuclear family to enjoy my son's first birthday. And we will if nada isn't

around. She'll probably go NC if I don't invite her to the party. I'm just

going to tell her that her behavior at this visit was very unpleasant for us and

created a lot of tension and that it's not fair to my son to have that at his

party.

>

> KOs: I'm so sick of feeling responsible for nada. As long as that feeling

lasts she'll always own a piece of me. it gives my personal " devil a foothold. "

And yes, my pastor is wonderful, and he tries hard to understand. It's not his

fault that I want a father figure to help me feel permission to walk away from

nada. In most cases, I agree with him that cutting off relationship with

difficult people is not what christians do. But he also says that if it's a

dangerous abusive relationship that it's appropriate. I know he doesn't really

understand BPD. And I know that as a compassionate person he can't really

comprehend how evil nada-witch can be. I have a hard time comprehending it. I

guess I'm looking to see where he goes with things when I give him full data. I

think I've been too afraid to share some of the real darkness with him prior to

this point. Again, becuase I've hit my limit.

>

> Last night, after writing my first email I had an 'aha' moment. I realized

that even though she's not physically attacking me anymore, even though toward

me personally she's not coming out with direct insults anymore, it's still an

" abusive relationship " . I guess I felt that if she didn't do those direct

things it's not really abusive, just manipulative. So I ask now, what's the

difference? When she is invalidating and cold toward me, that's enough to

trigger my reactions. It's enough for me to start falling into fog and fear and

my physical symptoms start up again (irritable bowel--bad pain there, mom

headache, muscle spasms, fatigue, and hives). Even though no one but the people

on this forum and my husband believe me, I think my nada's good behavior may

still constitute an abusive relationship for me. I guess the word abuse helps

me because it implies a right and probably a duty to protect oneself. We

forgive sin, we defend ourselves from

> abuse...

>

> One of the take-away messages I read int he books, like UBM...well what I mean

is they are all about how to work within relationship with your nada. I've

always felt they implied that if you have to go NC it's your personal weakness.

Does anyone have a perspective on that?

>

> Also, does anyone have a perspective on KO roles? I find one of the things

that is very confusing to me is that I don't quite fit the profile. My brother

was the all-bad child. My youngest brother was the all-good child. And I was

all-good and all-bad in equal measure. I was also the child my mom was trying

most to merge with--I was the intended vessel because I am a girl. I find that

sometimes this leads me to be even more confused about my nada and myself.

>

> Happy Easter for those who celebrate.

>

Guest guest
Posted

Happy Easter!

I am both the all good child and the all bad child. I get the " honor " of being

the family toilet and scapegoat. And, whenever they needed somtehing they

always came to me to fix them and help them and be their capable " arm. " And,

they hated me for " taking charge " as they resolutely demanded I be in charge.

Quite a trap.

So yes, I get it. I think some of us are both.

Blessings,

Karla

> >

> > I haven't been on this forum for a couple of weeks, but it's good to be

back. I'm back because I need validation so badly. I've been driven lately to

see things more clearly than I had before. But as I grapple with that I find

I'm struggling with confusion and fog.

> >

> > My pastor heard that my nada was visiting this weekend and called to see how

it went. I told him how the confrontation I was afraid of had happened but that

I was really proud of myself because I had stayed calm with her. (As I had

expected and others on this forum had predicted, my mom confronted me because I

kept avoiding leaving my son alone with her. I tried to be tactful, but she

wanted to know if that was what I was doing. I told her " I just feel more

comfortable when we are together as a group. " We then did a few hours of baby

fun activities, but then she cornered me when I was alone and wanted to know

why, " so I don't have to wonder. " I won't give the play by play, but the short

version is that I said " there were things that happened when I was a kid and I

just feel more comfortable when we are together as a group. " She started with

the whole invalidating story about how she " wasn't equipped " and the version

that includes some minor

> > conflict when I was a teenager but does not involve physical abuse

throughout childhood or what I consider much worse, systematic emotional abuse.

I told her that we had different memories, that being alone with my son was

non-negotiable and that I was going to take a break. I walked out and made my

husband stay at my side the rest of the visit. First she sulked in her room

then she started playing " super nice grandma " but being cold to me. Before she

played that super nice routine though, she did something that just made me sure

I was right, my son, who has of course fallen in love with her which actually

hurts me somehow, was crawling over and trying to get her to play with him. She

ignored him totally because she was mad at me. My grandnada did that to me, and

it is unacceptable. )

> >

> > Anyway, I told my pastor that story and we talked a little bit about how

much BPs are responsible for themselves and how much is " mental illness. " He's

big on boundaries but he always reminds me she's mentally ill, and this time I

challenged him on it. He's got more counseling background than most pastors,

but he's not a psychologist with a specialty in BPD or anything. On the other

hand, he helps with some of the issues that come up that touch on what's right

as a christian and all. Sometimes it's hard for me to trust what a therapist

tells me because I wonder if that's okay as a christian. Can any of you relate?

> >

> > Anyway, I told him I was questioning the mental illness thing a bit since my

nada can totally control herself when she wants to and since so much of what she

does is " mean " as I put it to him, not just emotional regulation issues or

whatever. He said he finds it really hard to figure that stuff out, but he

thinks NC is probably not an option for a christian. He also told me that if I

told him I was going NC he wouldn't say anything to me or give me a hard time

and he would support me at the time, but he might talk with me more about it

later. At first I felt ok about this, but after I got off the phone I started

to get really panicky.

> >

> > My husband asked if I had shared what she's doing to my family members. So

I emailed him about how I found out the reason my Dad was suicidal last year was

because she was telling him he was better off dead on a regular basis. (They

lost their savings in the financial crisis and I think he told me she was

telling him he was worthless and everyone would be better off with the insurance

money). I also told him she's attacking my dangerously depressed younger

brother who is stuck living at home and unemployed right now and who can't get

on his feet because every time he makes a positive move she comes and tears him

down. I told him that she was telling my brother he's better off dead.

> >

> > But I'm hedging because suddenly I'm not sure. I know my Dad told me she

was telling him he was better off dead. I know she is regularly attacking my

brother (who was a all-bad child). But I'm having major fog and mom-headache.

I can't think straight. I said to my husband, " here I go making it all up

again " and couldn't believe I blurted that out. Did someone tell me she was

telling my brother he's better off dead or did I make that up? I know I don't

make it up, but my contact with her and her denial of the abuse has me

struggling to retain my identity and sense of trusting my own sense of reality.

I'm spiraling. I feel like I'm fighting for my survival again.

> >

> > Anyway, my pastor responded to that email saying that based on this info he

feels much stronger boundaries are in order. So we're supposed to talk again

next week, but I want to make sure I'm giving accurate information. Becuase

otherwise I'll doubt the validity of whatever plan we come up with.

> >

> > Does it matter if she is actually coming out and saying my brother is better

off dead? The logical conclusion of her messages to us was always that anyway.

> >

> > I know some of you all have mothers who are sometimes the good mom, but I

don't think my good mom is very nice. She has a really scary malicious " witch "

in her. But I think she might be always the witch just a little bit. What I

mean is she really shows no interest in me as me. The only interest she has inme

is what I can give her, and sometimes that means " mirroring " . her message is

always and always has been that who I am as a person is unacceptable and

disgusting to me. I tried to kill my soul as a child to please her and she

tried to destroy my personality and replace it with her own or some kind of

servant who praised her constantly. She is one of the " merger-hungry "

personalities from UBM.

> >

> > My mother's message to me is that I as who I am evil and disgusting and when

I used to believe her I always felt I didn't have a right to be alive. She did

a lot of things very systematically to destroy who I was and I feel like all of

her faces (witch, nice, withdrawn, etc etc) are part of the same message and

project to get me to be her mirror/vessel/ servant.

> >

> > Can she really be like this? Am I making it up? Am I being unfair to her?

Is it my own weakness that contact with her is SO BAD for me? Can she really be

so mean?

> >

> > I just want to get away from her. I want to be at a place where I feel

free, where whatever love I give I give freely, not just because I can't get

away because she's " mentally ill. " Are you really telling me she can't help it?

Does being an emotional adolescent make you scary mean? Most teenagers are not

murderous... .

> >

> > Any thoughts? I want out of the fog.

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

Guest guest
Posted

Ninera--

This breakdown of the " right cheek left cheek " thing was extraordinary. Thank

you for having the courage to share that not knowing how it would be received.

It was so helpful to me, and added a lot of life-sought clarity.

You're the best! Thanks again for that clarity-

Blessings,

Karla

>

> >

> > Subject: Is she trying to get my brother to kill

himself?

> > To: WTOAdultChildren1

> > Date: Sunday, April 4, 2010, 2:33 AM

> > I haven't been on this forum for a

> > couple of weeks, but it's good to be back.  I'm back

> > because I need validation so badly.  I've been driven

> > lately to see things more clearly than I had before. 

> > But as I grapple with that I find I'm struggling with

> > confusion and fog.

> >

> > My pastor heard that my nada was visiting this weekend and

> > called to see how it went.  I told him how the

> > confrontation I was afraid of had happened but that I was

> > really proud of myself because I had stayed calm with

> > her.  (As I had expected and others on this forum had

> > predicted, my mom confronted me because I kept avoiding

> > leaving my son alone with her.  I tried to be tactful,

> > but she wanted to know if that was what I was doing.  I

> > told her " I just feel more comfortable when we are together

> > as a group. "   We then did a few hours of baby fun

> > activities, but then she cornered me when I was alone and

> > wanted to know why, " so I don't have to wonder. "   I

> > won't give the play by play, but the short version is that I

> > said " there were things that happened when I was a kid and I

> > just feel more comfortable when we are together as a

> > group. "   She started with the whole invalidating story

> > about how she " wasn't equipped " and the version that

> > includes some minor

> > conflict when I was a teenager but does not involve

> > physical abuse throughout childhood or what I consider much

> > worse, systematic emotional abuse.  I told her that we

> > had different memories, that being alone with my son was

> > non-negotiable and that I was going to take a break.  I

> > walked out and made my husband stay at my side the rest of

> > the visit.  First she sulked in her room then she

> > started playing " super nice grandma " but being cold to

> > me.  Before she played that super nice routine though,

> > she did something that just made me sure I was right, my

> > son, who has of course fallen in love with her which

> > actually hurts me somehow, was crawling over and trying to

> > get her to play with him.  She ignored him totally

> > because she was mad at me.  My grandnada did that to

> > me, and it is unacceptable.) 

> >

> > Anyway, I told my pastor that story and we talked a little

> > bit about how much BPs are responsible for themselves and

> > how much is " mental illness. "   He's big on boundaries

> > but he always reminds me she's mentally ill, and this time I

> > challenged him on it.  He's got more counseling

> > background than most pastors, but he's not a psychologist

> > with a specialty in BPD or anything.  On the other

> > hand, he helps with some of the issues that come up that

> > touch on what's right as a christian and all. 

> > Sometimes it's hard for me to trust what a therapist tells

> > me because I wonder if that's okay as a christian.  Can

> > any of you relate? 

> >

> > Anyway, I told him I was questioning the mental illness

> > thing a bit since my nada can totally control herself when

> > she wants to and since so much of what she does is " mean " as

> > I put it to him, not just emotional regulation issues or

> > whatever.  He said he finds it really hard to figure

> > that stuff out, but he thinks NC is probably not an option

> > for a christian. He also told me that if I told him I was

> > going NC he wouldn't say anything to me or give me a hard

> > time and he would support me at the time, but he might talk

> > with me more about it later.  At first I felt ok about

> > this, but after I got off the phone I started to get really

> > panicky.

> >

> > My husband asked if I had shared what she's doing to my

> > family members.  So I emailed him about how I found out

> > the reason my Dad was suicidal last year was because she was

> > telling him he was better off dead on a regular basis. 

> > (They lost their savings in the financial crisis and I think

> > he told me she was telling him he was worthless and everyone

> > would be better off with the insurance money).  I also

> > told him she's attacking my dangerously depressed younger

> > brother who is stuck living at home and unemployed right now

> > and who can't get on his feet because every time he makes a

> > positive move she comes and tears him down. I told him that

> > she was telling my brother he's better off dead.

> >

> > But I'm hedging because suddenly I'm not sure.  I know

> > my Dad told me she was telling him he was better off

> > dead.  I know she is regularly attacking my brother

> > (who was a all-bad child).  But I'm having major fog

> > and mom-headache.  I can't think straight.  I said

> > to my husband, " here I go making it all up again " and

> > couldn't believe I blurted that out.  Did someone tell

> > me she was telling my brother he's better off dead or did I

> > make that up?  I know I don't make it up, but my

> > contact with her and her denial of the abuse has me

> > struggling to retain my identity and sense of trusting my

> > own sense of reality.  I'm spiraling.  I feel like

> > I'm fighting for my survival again.

> >

> > Anyway, my pastor responded to that email saying that based

> > on this info he feels much stronger boundaries are in

> > order.  So we're supposed to talk again next week, but

> > I want to make sure I'm giving accurate information. Becuase

> > otherwise I'll doubt the validity of whatever plan we come

> > up with.

> >

> > Does it matter if she is actually coming out and saying my

> > brother is better off dead?  The logical conclusion of

> > her messages to us was always that anyway. 

> >

> > I know some of you all have mothers who are sometimes the

> > good mom, but I don't think my good mom is very nice. 

> > She has a really scary malicious " witch " in her.  But I

> > think she might be always the witch just a little bit. What

> > I mean is she really shows no interest in me as me. The only

> > interest she has inme is what I can give her, and sometimes

> > that means " mirroring " .  her message is always and

> > always has been that who I am as a person is unacceptable

> > and disgusting to me.  I tried to kill my soul as a

> > child to please her and she tried to destroy my personality

> > and replace it with her own or some kind of servant who

> > praised her constantly.  She is one of the

> > " merger-hungry " personalities from UBM. 

> >

> > My mother's message to me is that I as who I am evil and

> > disgusting and when I used to believe her I always felt I

> > didn't have a right to be alive.  She did a lot of

> > things very systematically to destroy who I was and I feel

> > like all of her faces (witch, nice, withdrawn, etc etc) are

> > part of the same message and project to get me to be her

> > mirror/vessel/servant.

> >

> > Can she really be like this?  Am I making it up? 

> > Am I being unfair to her?  Is it my own weakness that

> > contact with her is SO BAD for me?  Can she really be

> > so mean? 

> >

> > I just want to get away from her.  I want to be at a

> > place where I feel free, where whatever love I give I give

> > freely, not just because I can't get away because she's

> > " mentally ill. "   Are you really telling me she can't

> > help it?  Does being an emotional adolescent make you

> > scary mean?  Most teenagers are not murderous....

> >

> > Any thoughts?  I want out of the fog. 

> >

> >

> >

> >      

> >

> >

Guest guest
Posted

I hope today finds you in a better place with all the support you can find here.

I relate to you very well and I've just gone NC after LC for a year. Like you

it all got too hared and I needed a break completely. Then there are no games

no analysing and your head and heart can have a rest. The book that has given

me that strength is called BOUNDRIES by Dr Henry Cloud and Dr Townsend. It

is written about the expectations of Christians and the guilt that is placed

upon you when it comes to all this stuff.

I am not a Christian so to speak but I do believe in God. The book was amazing

for me. The use of the bible quotes may help you too. It is exactly about the

subject you are talking about and confusion you are feeling.

I hope you find peace just as I am about to hopefully find by going NC. We have

a right to be happy and live our life. GOD does want that for us.

Kazam x

Guest guest
Posted

Karla,

you hit it! All of my adult life, even after I became a christian, I

worshipped/served/feared/idolized my mother. Nothing I could do was enough; More

was always better for her. I gave her the resources/time/talent that now I

realize should have gone to bettering myself, connecting with others, making

friendships, improving my marriage, etc.

But when she would see me doing these things, she would make clear I didn't

really love her, etc. Actually, both she and my father would do that. He was

pretty awful, too.

God, I just want my life and to make decisions without her shadow on me.

> >

> > I haven't been on this forum for a couple of weeks, but it's good to be

back. I'm back because I need validation so badly. I've been driven lately to

see things more clearly than I had before. But as I grapple with that I find

I'm struggling with confusion and fog.

> >

> > My pastor heard that my nada was visiting this weekend and called to see how

it went. I told him how the confrontation I was afraid of had happened but that

I was really proud of myself because I had stayed calm with her. (As I had

expected and others on this forum had predicted, my mom confronted me because I

kept avoiding leaving my son alone with her. I tried to be tactful, but she

wanted to know if that was what I was doing. I told her " I just feel more

comfortable when we are together as a group. " We then did a few hours of baby

fun activities, but then she cornered me when I was alone and wanted to know

why, " so I don't have to wonder. " I won't give the play by play, but the short

version is that I said " there were things that happened when I was a kid and I

just feel more comfortable when we are together as a group. " She started with

the whole invalidating story about how she " wasn't equipped " and the version

that includes some minor

> > conflict when I was a teenager but does not involve physical abuse

throughout childhood or what I consider much worse, systematic emotional abuse.

I told her that we had different memories, that being alone with my son was

non-negotiable and that I was going to take a break. I walked out and made my

husband stay at my side the rest of the visit. First she sulked in her room

then she started playing " super nice grandma " but being cold to me. Before she

played that super nice routine though, she did something that just made me sure

I was right, my son, who has of course fallen in love with her which actually

hurts me somehow, was crawling over and trying to get her to play with him. She

ignored him totally because she was mad at me. My grandnada did that to me, and

it is unacceptable.)

> >

> > Anyway, I told my pastor that story and we talked a little bit about how

much BPs are responsible for themselves and how much is " mental illness. " He's

big on boundaries but he always reminds me she's mentally ill, and this time I

challenged him on it. He's got more counseling background than most pastors,

but he's not a psychologist with a specialty in BPD or anything. On the other

hand, he helps with some of the issues that come up that touch on what's right

as a christian and all. Sometimes it's hard for me to trust what a therapist

tells me because I wonder if that's okay as a christian. Can any of you relate?

> >

> > Anyway, I told him I was questioning the mental illness thing a bit since my

nada can totally control herself when she wants to and since so much of what she

does is " mean " as I put it to him, not just emotional regulation issues or

whatever. He said he finds it really hard to figure that stuff out, but he

thinks NC is probably not an option for a christian. He also told me that if I

told him I was going NC he wouldn't say anything to me or give me a hard time

and he would support me at the time, but he might talk with me more about it

later. At first I felt ok about this, but after I got off the phone I started

to get really panicky.

> >

> > My husband asked if I had shared what she's doing to my family members. So

I emailed him about how I found out the reason my Dad was suicidal last year was

because she was telling him he was better off dead on a regular basis. (They

lost their savings in the financial crisis and I think he told me she was

telling him he was worthless and everyone would be better off with the insurance

money). I also told him she's attacking my dangerously depressed younger

brother who is stuck living at home and unemployed right now and who can't get

on his feet because every time he makes a positive move she comes and tears him

down. I told him that she was telling my brother he's better off dead.

> >

> > But I'm hedging because suddenly I'm not sure. I know my Dad told me she

was telling him he was better off dead. I know she is regularly attacking my

brother (who was a all-bad child). But I'm having major fog and mom-headache.

I can't think straight. I said to my husband, " here I go making it all up

again " and couldn't believe I blurted that out. Did someone tell me she was

telling my brother he's better off dead or did I make that up? I know I don't

make it up, but my contact with her and her denial of the abuse has me

struggling to retain my identity and sense of trusting my own sense of reality.

I'm spiraling. I feel like I'm fighting for my survival again.

> >

> > Anyway, my pastor responded to that email saying that based on this info he

feels much stronger boundaries are in order. So we're supposed to talk again

next week, but I want to make sure I'm giving accurate information. Becuase

otherwise I'll doubt the validity of whatever plan we come up with.

> >

> > Does it matter if she is actually coming out and saying my brother is better

off dead? The logical conclusion of her messages to us was always that anyway.

> >

> > I know some of you all have mothers who are sometimes the good mom, but I

don't think my good mom is very nice. She has a really scary malicious " witch "

in her. But I think she might be always the witch just a little bit. What I

mean is she really shows no interest in me as me. The only interest she has inme

is what I can give her, and sometimes that means " mirroring " . her message is

always and always has been that who I am as a person is unacceptable and

disgusting to me. I tried to kill my soul as a child to please her and she

tried to destroy my personality and replace it with her own or some kind of

servant who praised her constantly. She is one of the " merger-hungry "

personalities from UBM.

> >

> > My mother's message to me is that I as who I am evil and disgusting and when

I used to believe her I always felt I didn't have a right to be alive. She did

a lot of things very systematically to destroy who I was and I feel like all of

her faces (witch, nice, withdrawn, etc etc) are part of the same message and

project to get me to be her mirror/vessel/servant.

> >

> > Can she really be like this? Am I making it up? Am I being unfair to her?

Is it my own weakness that contact with her is SO BAD for me? Can she really be

so mean?

> >

> > I just want to get away from her. I want to be at a place where I feel

free, where whatever love I give I give freely, not just because I can't get

away because she's " mentally ill. " Are you really telling me she can't help it?

Does being an emotional adolescent make you scary mean? Most teenagers are not

murderous....

> >

> > Any thoughts? I want out of the fog.

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

Guest guest
Posted

Well said Karla, that's a great summary of my role. In addition to being the

crisis manager they resent, I'm also supposed to be the " hero " from the alcholic

family roles literature: achiever who is successful so everyone can point to be

and be proud, but then nada tears me down for it and attacks me for being proud.

What fun.

________________________________

To: WTOAdultChildren1

Sent: Sun, April 4, 2010 3:39:00 PM

Subject: Re: Is she trying to get my brother to kill

himself?

Happy Easter!

I am both the all good child and the all bad child. I get the " honor " of being

the family toilet and scapegoat. And, whenever they needed somtehing they

always came to me to fix them and help them and be their capable " arm. " And,

they hated me for " taking charge " as they resolutely demanded I be in charge.

Quite a trap.

So yes, I get it. I think some of us are both.

Blessings,

Karla

> >

> > I haven't been on this forum for a couple of weeks, but it's good to be

back. I'm back because I need validation so badly. I've been driven lately to

see things more clearly than I had before. But as I grapple with that I find

I'm struggling with confusion and fog.

> >

> > My pastor heard that my nada was visiting this weekend and called to see how

it went. I told him how the confrontation I was afraid of had happened but that

I was really proud of myself because I had stayed calm with her. (As I had

expected and others on this forum had predicted, my mom confronted me because I

kept avoiding leaving my son alone with her. I tried to be tactful, but she

wanted to know if that was what I was doing. I told her " I just feel more

comfortable when we are together as a group. " We then did a few hours of baby

fun activities, but then she cornered me when I was alone and wanted to know

why, " so I don't have to wonder. " I won't give the play by play, but the short

version is that I said " there were things that happened when I was a kid and I

just feel more comfortable when we are together as a group. " She started with

the whole invalidating story about how she " wasn't equipped " and the version

that includes some minor

> > conflict when I was a teenager but does not involve physical abuse

throughout childhood or what I consider much worse, systematic emotional abuse.

I told her that we had different memories, that being alone with my son was

non-negotiable and that I was going to take a break. I walked out and made my

husband stay at my side the rest of the visit. First she sulked in her room

then she started playing " super nice grandma " but being cold to me. Before she

played that super nice routine though, she did something that just made me sure

I was right, my son, who has of course fallen in love with her which actually

hurts me somehow, was crawling over and trying to get her to play with him. She

ignored him totally because she was mad at me. My grandnada did that to me, and

it is unacceptable. )

> >

> > Anyway, I told my pastor that story and we talked a little bit about how

much BPs are responsible for themselves and how much is " mental illness. " He's

big on boundaries but he always reminds me she's mentally ill, and this time I

challenged him on it. He's got more counseling background than most pastors,

but he's not a psychologist with a specialty in BPD or anything. On the other

hand, he helps with some of the issues that come up that touch on what's right

as a christian and all. Sometimes it's hard for me to trust what a therapist

tells me because I wonder if that's okay as a christian. Can any of you relate?

> >

> > Anyway, I told him I was questioning the mental illness thing a bit since my

nada can totally control herself when she wants to and since so much of what she

does is " mean " as I put it to him, not just emotional regulation issues or

whatever. He said he finds it really hard to figure that stuff out, but he

thinks NC is probably not an option for a christian. He also told me that if I

told him I was going NC he wouldn't say anything to me or give me a hard time

and he would support me at the time, but he might talk with me more about it

later. At first I felt ok about this, but after I got off the phone I started

to get really panicky.

> >

> > My husband asked if I had shared what she's doing to my family members. So

I emailed him about how I found out the reason my Dad was suicidal last year was

because she was telling him he was better off dead on a regular basis. (They

lost their savings in the financial crisis and I think he told me she was

telling him he was worthless and everyone would be better off with the insurance

money). I also told him she's attacking my dangerously depressed younger

brother who is stuck living at home and unemployed right now and who can't get

on his feet because every time he makes a positive move she comes and tears him

down. I told him that she was telling my brother he's better off dead.

> >

> > But I'm hedging because suddenly I'm not sure. I know my Dad told me she

was telling him he was better off dead. I know she is regularly attacking my

brother (who was a all-bad child). But I'm having major fog and mom-headache.

I can't think straight. I said to my husband, " here I go making it all up

again " and couldn't believe I blurted that out. Did someone tell me she was

telling my brother he's better off dead or did I make that up? I know I don't

make it up, but my contact with her and her denial of the abuse has me

struggling to retain my identity and sense of trusting my own sense of reality.

I'm spiraling. I feel like I'm fighting for my survival again.

> >

> > Anyway, my pastor responded to that email saying that based on this info he

feels much stronger boundaries are in order. So we're supposed to talk again

next week, but I want to make sure I'm giving accurate information. Becuase

otherwise I'll doubt the validity of whatever plan we come up with.

> >

> > Does it matter if she is actually coming out and saying my brother is better

off dead? The logical conclusion of her messages to us was always that anyway.

> >

> > I know some of you all have mothers who are sometimes the good mom, but I

don't think my good mom is very nice. She has a really scary malicious " witch "

in her. But I think she might be always the witch just a little bit. What I

mean is she really shows no interest in me as me. The only interest she has inme

is what I can give her, and sometimes that means " mirroring " . her message is

always and always has been that who I am as a person is unacceptable and

disgusting to me. I tried to kill my soul as a child to please her and she

tried to destroy my personality and replace it with her own or some kind of

servant who praised her constantly. She is one of the " merger-hungry "

personalities from UBM.

> >

> > My mother's message to me is that I as who I am evil and disgusting and when

I used to believe her I always felt I didn't have a right to be alive. She did

a lot of things very systematically to destroy who I was and I feel like all of

her faces (witch, nice, withdrawn, etc etc) are part of the same message and

project to get me to be her mirror/vessel/ servant.

> >

> > Can she really be like this? Am I making it up? Am I being unfair to her?

Is it my own weakness that contact with her is SO BAD for me? Can she really be

so mean?

> >

> > I just want to get away from her. I want to be at a place where I feel

free, where whatever love I give I give freely, not just because I can't get

away because she's " mentally ill. " Are you really telling me she can't help it?

Does being an emotional adolescent make you scary mean? Most teenagers are not

murderous... .

> >

> > Any thoughts? I want out of the fog.

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

Guest guest
Posted

Ninera,

I agree with Karla thanks for sharing it was very insightful. I love this

group because we all feel safe and respect each other's spiritual and religious

beliefs. We are all trying to heal and whatever we need to get there and

whatever works for the individual needs to be respected and also offers insight

to others here.

Kazam x

> >

> > > From: More Private <moreprivate20@>

> > > Subject: Is she trying to get my brother to kill

himself?

> > > To: WTOAdultChildren1

> > > Date: Sunday, April 4, 2010, 2:33 AM

> > > I haven't been on this forum for a

> > > couple of weeks, but it's good to be back.  I'm back

> > > because I need validation so badly.  I've been driven

> > > lately to see things more clearly than I had before. 

> > > But as I grapple with that I find I'm struggling with

> > > confusion and fog.

> > >

> > > My pastor heard that my nada was visiting this weekend and

> > > called to see how it went.  I told him how the

> > > confrontation I was afraid of had happened but that I was

> > > really proud of myself because I had stayed calm with

> > > her.  (As I had expected and others on this forum had

> > > predicted, my mom confronted me because I kept avoiding

> > > leaving my son alone with her.  I tried to be tactful,

> > > but she wanted to know if that was what I was doing.  I

> > > told her " I just feel more comfortable when we are together

> > > as a group. "   We then did a few hours of baby fun

> > > activities, but then she cornered me when I was alone and

> > > wanted to know why, " so I don't have to wonder. "   I

> > > won't give the play by play, but the short version is that I

> > > said " there were things that happened when I was a kid and I

> > > just feel more comfortable when we are together as a

> > > group. "   She started with the whole invalidating story

> > > about how she " wasn't equipped " and the version that

> > > includes some minor

> > > conflict when I was a teenager but does not involve

> > > physical abuse throughout childhood or what I consider much

> > > worse, systematic emotional abuse.  I told her that we

> > > had different memories, that being alone with my son was

> > > non-negotiable and that I was going to take a break.  I

> > > walked out and made my husband stay at my side the rest of

> > > the visit.  First she sulked in her room then she

> > > started playing " super nice grandma " but being cold to

> > > me.  Before she played that super nice routine though,

> > > she did something that just made me sure I was right, my

> > > son, who has of course fallen in love with her which

> > > actually hurts me somehow, was crawling over and trying to

> > > get her to play with him.  She ignored him totally

> > > because she was mad at me.  My grandnada did that to

> > > me, and it is unacceptable.) 

> > >

> > > Anyway, I told my pastor that story and we talked a little

> > > bit about how much BPs are responsible for themselves and

> > > how much is " mental illness. "   He's big on boundaries

> > > but he always reminds me she's mentally ill, and this time I

> > > challenged him on it.  He's got more counseling

> > > background than most pastors, but he's not a psychologist

> > > with a specialty in BPD or anything.  On the other

> > > hand, he helps with some of the issues that come up that

> > > touch on what's right as a christian and all. 

> > > Sometimes it's hard for me to trust what a therapist tells

> > > me because I wonder if that's okay as a christian.  Can

> > > any of you relate? 

> > >

> > > Anyway, I told him I was questioning the mental illness

> > > thing a bit since my nada can totally control herself when

> > > she wants to and since so much of what she does is " mean " as

> > > I put it to him, not just emotional regulation issues or

> > > whatever.  He said he finds it really hard to figure

> > > that stuff out, but he thinks NC is probably not an option

> > > for a christian. He also told me that if I told him I was

> > > going NC he wouldn't say anything to me or give me a hard

> > > time and he would support me at the time, but he might talk

> > > with me more about it later.  At first I felt ok about

> > > this, but after I got off the phone I started to get really

> > > panicky.

> > >

> > > My husband asked if I had shared what she's doing to my

> > > family members.  So I emailed him about how I found out

> > > the reason my Dad was suicidal last year was because she was

> > > telling him he was better off dead on a regular basis. 

> > > (They lost their savings in the financial crisis and I think

> > > he told me she was telling him he was worthless and everyone

> > > would be better off with the insurance money).  I also

> > > told him she's attacking my dangerously depressed younger

> > > brother who is stuck living at home and unemployed right now

> > > and who can't get on his feet because every time he makes a

> > > positive move she comes and tears him down. I told him that

> > > she was telling my brother he's better off dead.

> > >

> > > But I'm hedging because suddenly I'm not sure.  I know

> > > my Dad told me she was telling him he was better off

> > > dead.  I know she is regularly attacking my brother

> > > (who was a all-bad child).  But I'm having major fog

> > > and mom-headache.  I can't think straight.  I said

> > > to my husband, " here I go making it all up again " and

> > > couldn't believe I blurted that out.  Did someone tell

> > > me she was telling my brother he's better off dead or did I

> > > make that up?  I know I don't make it up, but my

> > > contact with her and her denial of the abuse has me

> > > struggling to retain my identity and sense of trusting my

> > > own sense of reality.  I'm spiraling.  I feel like

> > > I'm fighting for my survival again.

> > >

> > > Anyway, my pastor responded to that email saying that based

> > > on this info he feels much stronger boundaries are in

> > > order.  So we're supposed to talk again next week, but

> > > I want to make sure I'm giving accurate information. Becuase

> > > otherwise I'll doubt the validity of whatever plan we come

> > > up with.

> > >

> > > Does it matter if she is actually coming out and saying my

> > > brother is better off dead?  The logical conclusion of

> > > her messages to us was always that anyway. 

> > >

> > > I know some of you all have mothers who are sometimes the

> > > good mom, but I don't think my good mom is very nice. 

> > > She has a really scary malicious " witch " in her.  But I

> > > think she might be always the witch just a little bit. What

> > > I mean is she really shows no interest in me as me. The only

> > > interest she has inme is what I can give her, and sometimes

> > > that means " mirroring " .  her message is always and

> > > always has been that who I am as a person is unacceptable

> > > and disgusting to me.  I tried to kill my soul as a

> > > child to please her and she tried to destroy my personality

> > > and replace it with her own or some kind of servant who

> > > praised her constantly.  She is one of the

> > > " merger-hungry " personalities from UBM. 

> > >

> > > My mother's message to me is that I as who I am evil and

> > > disgusting and when I used to believe her I always felt I

> > > didn't have a right to be alive.  She did a lot of

> > > things very systematically to destroy who I was and I feel

> > > like all of her faces (witch, nice, withdrawn, etc etc) are

> > > part of the same message and project to get me to be her

> > > mirror/vessel/servant.

> > >

> > > Can she really be like this?  Am I making it up? 

> > > Am I being unfair to her?  Is it my own weakness that

> > > contact with her is SO BAD for me?  Can she really be

> > > so mean? 

> > >

> > > I just want to get away from her.  I want to be at a

> > > place where I feel free, where whatever love I give I give

> > > freely, not just because I can't get away because she's

> > > " mentally ill. "   Are you really telling me she can't

> > > help it?  Does being an emotional adolescent make you

> > > scary mean?  Most teenagers are not murderous....

> > >

> > > Any thoughts?  I want out of the fog. 

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > >      

> > >

> > >

Guest guest
Posted

Awwww...thanks. I'm glad it was of help for a few. When I learned that about

the right cheek/left cheek thing it was a HUGE thing for me and I love to share

it.

And it comes in REALLY HANDY when well intentioned but poorly informed people

try to tell me to be " forgiving " and to " turn the other cheek " to nada. :-)

Ninera

>

> Subject: Re: Is she trying to get my brother to kill

himself?

> To: WTOAdultChildren1

> Date: Monday, April 5, 2010, 9:22 PM

> Ninera,

> I agree with Karla thanks for sharing it was very

> insightful.  I love this group because we all feel safe

> and respect each other's spiritual and religious

> beliefs.  We are all trying to heal and whatever we

> need to get there and whatever works for the individual

> needs to be respected and also offers insight to others

> here.

> Kazam x

>

>

> > >

> > > > From: More Private <moreprivate20@>

> > > > Subject: Is she trying

> to get my brother to kill himself?

> > > > To: WTOAdultChildren1

> > > > Date: Sunday, April 4, 2010, 2:33 AM

> > > > I haven't been on this forum for a

> > > > couple of weeks, but it's good to be

> back.  I'm back

> > > > because I need validation so badly.  I've

> been driven

> > > > lately to see things more clearly than I had

> before. 

> > > > But as I grapple with that I find I'm

> struggling with

> > > > confusion and fog.

> > > >

> > > > My pastor heard that my nada was visiting

> this weekend and

> > > > called to see how it went.  I told him

> how the

> > > > confrontation I was afraid of had happened

> but that I was

> > > > really proud of myself because I had stayed

> calm with

> > > > her.  (As I had expected and others on

> this forum had

> > > > predicted, my mom confronted me because I

> kept avoiding

> > > > leaving my son alone with her.  I tried

> to be tactful,

> > > > but she wanted to know if that was what I

> was doing.  I

> > > > told her " I just feel more comfortable when

> we are together

> > > > as a group. "   We then did a few hours of

> baby fun

> > > > activities, but then she cornered me when I

> was alone and

> > > > wanted to know why, " so I don't have to

> wonder. "   I

> > > > won't give the play by play, but the short

> version is that I

> > > > said " there were things that happened when I

> was a kid and I

> > > > just feel more comfortable when we are

> together as a

> > > > group. "   She started with the whole

> invalidating story

> > > > about how she " wasn't equipped " and the

> version that

> > > > includes some minor

> > > >  conflict when I was a teenager but

> does not involve

> > > > physical abuse throughout childhood or what

> I consider much

> > > > worse, systematic emotional abuse.  I

> told her that we

> > > > had different memories, that being alone

> with my son was

> > > > non-negotiable and that I was going to take

> a break.  I

> > > > walked out and made my husband stay at my

> side the rest of

> > > > the visit.  First she sulked in her room

> then she

> > > > started playing " super nice grandma " but

> being cold to

> > > > me.  Before she played that super nice

> routine though,

> > > > she did something that just made me sure I

> was right, my

> > > > son, who has of course fallen in love with

> her which

> > > > actually hurts me somehow, was crawling over

> and trying to

> > > > get her to play with him.  She ignored

> him totally

> > > > because she was mad at me.  My grandnada

> did that to

> > > > me, and it is unacceptable.) 

> > > >

> > > > Anyway, I told my pastor that story and we

> talked a little

> > > > bit about how much BPs are responsible for

> themselves and

> > > > how much is " mental illness. "   He's big

> on boundaries

> > > > but he always reminds me she's mentally ill,

> and this time I

> > > > challenged him on it.  He's got more

> counseling

> > > > background than most pastors, but he's not a

> psychologist

> > > > with a specialty in BPD or anything.  On

> the other

> > > > hand, he helps with some of the issues that

> come up that

> > > > touch on what's right as a christian and

> all. 

> > > > Sometimes it's hard for me to trust what a

> therapist tells

> > > > me because I wonder if that's okay as a

> christian.  Can

> > > > any of you relate? 

> > > >

> > > > Anyway, I told him I was questioning the

> mental illness

> > > > thing a bit since my nada can totally

> control herself when

> > > > she wants to and since so much of what she

> does is " mean " as

> > > > I put it to him, not just emotional

> regulation issues or

> > > > whatever.  He said he finds it really

> hard to figure

> > > > that stuff out, but he thinks NC is probably

> not an option

> > > > for a christian. He also told me that if I

> told him I was

> > > > going NC he wouldn't say anything to me or

> give me a hard

> > > > time and he would support me at the time,

> but he might talk

> > > > with me more about it later.  At first I

> felt ok about

> > > > this, but after I got off the phone I

> started to get really

> > > > panicky.

> > > >

> > > > My husband asked if I had shared what she's

> doing to my

> > > > family members.  So I emailed him about

> how I found out

> > > > the reason my Dad was suicidal last year was

> because she was

> > > > telling him he was better off dead on a

> regular basis. 

> > > > (They lost their savings in the financial

> crisis and I think

> > > > he told me she was telling him he was

> worthless and everyone

> > > > would be better off with the insurance

> money).  I also

> > > > told him she's attacking my dangerously

> depressed younger

> > > > brother who is stuck living at home and

> unemployed right now

> > > > and who can't get on his feet because every

> time he makes a

> > > > positive move she comes and tears him down.

> I told him that

> > > > she was telling my brother he's better off

> dead.

> > > >

> > > > But I'm hedging because suddenly I'm not

> sure.  I know

> > > > my Dad told me she was telling him he was

> better off

> > > > dead.  I know she is regularly attacking

> my brother

> > > > (who was a all-bad child).  But I'm

> having major fog

> > > > and mom-headache.  I can't think

> straight.  I said

> > > > to my husband, " here I go making it all up

> again " and

> > > > couldn't believe I blurted that out.  Did

> someone tell

> > > > me she was telling my brother he's better

> off dead or did I

> > > > make that up?  I know I don't make it up,

> but my

> > > > contact with her and her denial of the abuse

> has me

> > > > struggling to retain my identity and sense

> of trusting my

> > > > own sense of reality.  I'm spiraling. 

> I feel like

> > > > I'm fighting for my survival again.

> > > >

> > > > Anyway, my pastor responded to that email

> saying that based

> > > > on this info he feels much stronger

> boundaries are in

> > > > order.  So we're supposed to talk again

> next week, but

> > > > I want to make sure I'm giving accurate

> information. Becuase

> > > > otherwise I'll doubt the validity of

> whatever plan we come

> > > > up with.

> > > >

> > > > Does it matter if she is actually coming out

> and saying my

> > > > brother is better off dead?  The logical

> conclusion of

> > > > her messages to us was always that

> anyway. 

> > > >

> > > > I know some of you all have mothers who are

> sometimes the

> > > > good mom, but I don't think my good mom is

> very nice. 

> > > > She has a really scary malicious " witch " in

> her.  But I

> > > > think she might be always the witch just a

> little bit. What

> > > > I mean is she really shows no interest in me

> as me. The only

> > > > interest she has inme is what I can give

> her, and sometimes

> > > > that means " mirroring " .  her message is

> always and

> > > > always has been that who I am as a person is

> unacceptable

> > > > and disgusting to me.  I tried to kill my

> soul as a

> > > > child to please her and she tried to destroy

> my personality

> > > > and replace it with her own or some kind of

> servant who

> > > > praised her constantly.  She is one of

> the

> > > > " merger-hungry " personalities from UBM. 

>

> > > >

> > > > My mother's message to me is that I as who I

> am evil and

> > > > disgusting and when I used to believe her I

> always felt I

> > > > didn't have a right to be alive.  She did

> a lot of

> > > > things very systematically to destroy who I

> was and I feel

> > > > like all of her faces (witch, nice,

> withdrawn, etc etc) are

> > > > part of the same message and project to get

> me to be her

> > > > mirror/vessel/servant.

> > > >

> > > > Can she really be like this?  Am I making

> it up? 

> > > > Am I being unfair to her?  Is it my own

> weakness that

> > > > contact with her is SO BAD for me?  Can

> she really be

> > > > so mean? 

> > > >

> > > > I just want to get away from her.  I want

> to be at a

> > > > place where I feel free, where whatever love

> I give I give

> > > > freely, not just because I can't get away

> because she's

> > > > " mentally ill. "   Are you really telling

> me she can't

> > > > help it?  Does being an emotional

> adolescent make you

> > > > scary mean?  Most teenagers are not

> murderous....

> > > >

> > > > Any thoughts?  I want out of the fog. 

>

> > > >

> > > >

> > > >

> > > >      

> > > >

> > > > [Non-text portions of this message have been

> removed]

> > > >

> > > >

> > > >

> > > > ------------------------------------

> > > >

> > > > Problems? Ask our friendly List Manager

> for help at @

> > > > SEND HER ANY POSTS THAT CONCERN YOU; DO NOT

> Respond ON THE

> > > > GROUP.

> > > >

> > > > To order the KO bible " Stop Walking on

> Eggshells, " call

> > > > 888-35-SHELL () for your copy.

> We also refer to

> > > > “Understanding the Borderline

> Mother� (Lawson) and

> > > > “Surviving the Borderline

> Parent,� (Roth) which you can

> > > > find at any bookstore. Welcome to the WTO

> community!

> > > >

> > > > From Randi Kreger, Owner BPDCentral, WTO

> Online Community

> > > > and author SWOE and the SWOE Workbook.Yahoo!

> Groups Links

> > > >

> > > >

> > > >     WTOAdultChildren1-fullfeatured

> > > >

> > > >

> > > >

> > >

> >

>

>

>

>

> ------------------------------------

>

> Problems? Ask our friendly List Manager for help at @....

> SEND HER ANY POSTS THAT CONCERN YOU; DO NOT Respond ON THE

> GROUP.

>

> To order the KO bible " Stop Walking on Eggshells, " call

> 888-35-SHELL () for your copy. We also refer to

> “Understanding the Borderline Mother†(Lawson) and

> “Surviving the Borderline Parent,†(Roth) which you can

> find at any bookstore. Welcome to the WTO community!

>

> From Randi Kreger, Owner BPDCentral, WTO Online Community

> and author SWOE and the SWOE Workbook.

Guest guest
Posted

Reading Boundaries since yesterday. So helpful! I thought I knew all about

boundaries, but apparently I needed more!

________________________________

To: WTOAdultChildren1

Sent: Mon, April 5, 2010 4:22:30 PM

Subject: Re: Is she trying to get my brother to kill

himself?

Ninera,

I agree with Karla thanks for sharing it was very insightful. I love this group

because we all feel safe and respect each other's spiritual and religious

beliefs. We are all trying to heal and whatever we need to get there and

whatever works for the individual needs to be respected and also offers insight

to others here.

Kazam x

> >

> > > From: More Private <moreprivate20@ >

> > > Subject: Is she trying to get my brother to kill

himself?

> > > To: WTOAdultChildren1@ yahoogroups. com

> > > Date: Sunday, April 4, 2010, 2:33 AM

> > > I haven't been on this forum for a

> > > couple of weeks, but it's good to be back. I'm back

> > > because I need validation so badly. I've been driven

> > > lately to see things more clearly than I had before.Â

> > > But as I grapple with that I find I'm struggling with

> > > confusion and fog.

> > >

> > > My pastor heard that my nada was visiting this weekend and

> > > called to see how it went. I told him how the

> > > confrontation I was afraid of had happened but that I was

> > > really proud of myself because I had stayed calm with

> > > her. (As I had expected and others on this forum had

> > > predicted, my mom confronted me because I kept avoiding

> > > leaving my son alone with her. I tried to be tactful,

> > > but she wanted to know if that was what I was doing. I

> > > told her " I just feel more comfortable when we are together

> > > as a group. " Â We then did a few hours of baby fun

> > > activities, but then she cornered me when I was alone and

> > > wanted to know why, " so I don't have to wonder. " Â I

> > > won't give the play by play, but the short version is that I

> > > said " there were things that happened when I was a kid and I

> > > just feel more comfortable when we are together as a

> > > group. " Â She started with the whole invalidating story

> > > about how she " wasn't equipped " and the version that

> > > includes some minor

> > > conflict when I was a teenager but does not involve

> > > physical abuse throughout childhood or what I consider much

> > > worse, systematic emotional abuse. I told her that we

> > > had different memories, that being alone with my son was

> > > non-negotiable and that I was going to take a break. I

> > > walked out and made my husband stay at my side the rest of

> > > the visit. First she sulked in her room then she

> > > started playing " super nice grandma " but being cold to

> > > me. Before she played that super nice routine though,

> > > she did something that just made me sure I was right, my

> > > son, who has of course fallen in love with her which

> > > actually hurts me somehow, was crawling over and trying to

> > > get her to play with him. She ignored him totally

> > > because she was mad at me. My grandnada did that to

> > > me, and it is unacceptable. )Â

> > >

> > > Anyway, I told my pastor that story and we talked a little

> > > bit about how much BPs are responsible for themselves and

> > > how much is " mental illness. " Â He's big on boundaries

> > > but he always reminds me she's mentally ill, and this time I

> > > challenged him on it. He's got more counseling

> > > background than most pastors, but he's not a psychologist

> > > with a specialty in BPD or anything. On the other

> > > hand, he helps with some of the issues that come up that

> > > touch on what's right as a christian and all.Â

> > > Sometimes it's hard for me to trust what a therapist tells

> > > me because I wonder if that's okay as a christian. Can

> > > any of you relate?Â

> > >

> > > Anyway, I told him I was questioning the mental illness

> > > thing a bit since my nada can totally control herself when

> > > she wants to and since so much of what she does is " mean " as

> > > I put it to him, not just emotional regulation issues or

> > > whatever. He said he finds it really hard to figure

> > > that stuff out, but he thinks NC is probably not an option

> > > for a christian. He also told me that if I told him I was

> > > going NC he wouldn't say anything to me or give me a hard

> > > time and he would support me at the time, but he might talk

> > > with me more about it later. At first I felt ok about

> > > this, but after I got off the phone I started to get really

> > > panicky.

> > >

> > > My husband asked if I had shared what she's doing to my

> > > family members. So I emailed him about how I found out

> > > the reason my Dad was suicidal last year was because she was

> > > telling him he was better off dead on a regular basis.Â

> > > (They lost their savings in the financial crisis and I think

> > > he told me she was telling him he was worthless and everyone

> > > would be better off with the insurance money). I also

> > > told him she's attacking my dangerously depressed younger

> > > brother who is stuck living at home and unemployed right now

> > > and who can't get on his feet because every time he makes a

> > > positive move she comes and tears him down. I told him that

> > > she was telling my brother he's better off dead.

> > >

> > > But I'm hedging because suddenly I'm not sure. I know

> > > my Dad told me she was telling him he was better off

> > > dead. I know she is regularly attacking my brother

> > > (who was a all-bad child). But I'm having major fog

> > > and mom-headache. I can't think straight. I said

> > > to my husband, " here I go making it all up again " and

> > > couldn't believe I blurted that out. Did someone tell

> > > me she was telling my brother he's better off dead or did I

> > > make that up? I know I don't make it up, but my

> > > contact with her and her denial of the abuse has me

> > > struggling to retain my identity and sense of trusting my

> > > own sense of reality. I'm spiraling. I feel like

> > > I'm fighting for my survival again.

> > >

> > > Anyway, my pastor responded to that email saying that based

> > > on this info he feels much stronger boundaries are in

> > > order. So we're supposed to talk again next week, but

> > > I want to make sure I'm giving accurate information. Becuase

> > > otherwise I'll doubt the validity of whatever plan we come

> > > up with.

> > >

> > > Does it matter if she is actually coming out and saying my

> > > brother is better off dead? The logical conclusion of

> > > her messages to us was always that anyway.Â

> > >

> > > I know some of you all have mothers who are sometimes the

> > > good mom, but I don't think my good mom is very nice.Â

> > > She has a really scary malicious " witch " in her. But I

> > > think she might be always the witch just a little bit. What

> > > I mean is she really shows no interest in me as me. The only

> > > interest she has inme is what I can give her, and sometimes

> > > that means " mirroring " . her message is always and

> > > always has been that who I am as a person is unacceptable

> > > and disgusting to me. I tried to kill my soul as a

> > > child to please her and she tried to destroy my personality

> > > and replace it with her own or some kind of servant who

> > > praised her constantly. She is one of the

> > > " merger-hungry " personalities from UBM.Â

> > >

> > > My mother's message to me is that I as who I am evil and

> > > disgusting and when I used to believe her I always felt I

> > > didn't have a right to be alive. She did a lot of

> > > things very systematically to destroy who I was and I feel

> > > like all of her faces (witch, nice, withdrawn, etc etc) are

> > > part of the same message and project to get me to be her

> > > mirror/vessel/ servant.

> > >

> > > Can she really be like this? Am I making it up?Â

> > > Am I being unfair to her? Is it my own weakness that

> > > contact with her is SO BAD for me? Can she really be

> > > so mean?Â

> > >

> > > I just want to get away from her. I want to be at a

> > > place where I feel free, where whatever love I give I give

> > > freely, not just because I can't get away because she's

> > > " mentally ill. " Â Are you really telling me she can't

> > > help it? Does being an emotional adolescent make you

> > > scary mean? Most teenagers are not murderous... .

> > >

> > > Any thoughts? I want out of the fog.Â

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > > Â Â Â

> > >

> > >

Guest guest
Posted

MP, that's great news hope it helps. The Authors have other great books that

are worth a read too.

Kazam x

> > >

> > > > From: More Private <moreprivate20@ >

> > > > Subject: Is she trying to get my brother to kill

himself?

> > > > To: WTOAdultChildren1@ yahoogroups. com

> > > > Date: Sunday, April 4, 2010, 2:33 AM

> > > > I haven't been on this forum for a

> > > > couple of weeks, but it's good to be back. I'm back

> > > > because I need validation so badly. I've been driven

> > > > lately to see things more clearly than I had before.Â

> > > > But as I grapple with that I find I'm struggling with

> > > > confusion and fog.

> > > >

> > > > My pastor heard that my nada was visiting this weekend and

> > > > called to see how it went. I told him how the

> > > > confrontation I was afraid of had happened but that I was

> > > > really proud of myself because I had stayed calm with

> > > > her. (As I had expected and others on this forum had

> > > > predicted, my mom confronted me because I kept avoiding

> > > > leaving my son alone with her. I tried to be tactful,

> > > > but she wanted to know if that was what I was doing. I

> > > > told her " I just feel more comfortable when we are together

> > > > as a group. " Â We then did a few hours of baby fun

> > > > activities, but then she cornered me when I was alone and

> > > > wanted to know why, " so I don't have to wonder. " Â I

> > > > won't give the play by play, but the short version is that I

> > > > said " there were things that happened when I was a kid and I

> > > > just feel more comfortable when we are together as a

> > > > group. " Â She started with the whole invalidating story

> > > > about how she " wasn't equipped " and the version that

> > > > includes some minor

> > > > conflict when I was a teenager but does not involve

> > > > physical abuse throughout childhood or what I consider much

> > > > worse, systematic emotional abuse. I told her that we

> > > > had different memories, that being alone with my son was

> > > > non-negotiable and that I was going to take a break. I

> > > > walked out and made my husband stay at my side the rest of

> > > > the visit. First she sulked in her room then she

> > > > started playing " super nice grandma " but being cold to

> > > > me. Before she played that super nice routine though,

> > > > she did something that just made me sure I was right, my

> > > > son, who has of course fallen in love with her which

> > > > actually hurts me somehow, was crawling over and trying to

> > > > get her to play with him. She ignored him totally

> > > > because she was mad at me. My grandnada did that to

> > > > me, and it is unacceptable. )Â

> > > >

> > > > Anyway, I told my pastor that story and we talked a little

> > > > bit about how much BPs are responsible for themselves and

> > > > how much is " mental illness. " Â He's big on boundaries

> > > > but he always reminds me she's mentally ill, and this time I

> > > > challenged him on it. He's got more counseling

> > > > background than most pastors, but he's not a psychologist

> > > > with a specialty in BPD or anything. On the other

> > > > hand, he helps with some of the issues that come up that

> > > > touch on what's right as a christian and all.Â

> > > > Sometimes it's hard for me to trust what a therapist tells

> > > > me because I wonder if that's okay as a christian. Can

> > > > any of you relate?Â

> > > >

> > > > Anyway, I told him I was questioning the mental illness

> > > > thing a bit since my nada can totally control herself when

> > > > she wants to and since so much of what she does is " mean " as

> > > > I put it to him, not just emotional regulation issues or

> > > > whatever. He said he finds it really hard to figure

> > > > that stuff out, but he thinks NC is probably not an option

> > > > for a christian. He also told me that if I told him I was

> > > > going NC he wouldn't say anything to me or give me a hard

> > > > time and he would support me at the time, but he might talk

> > > > with me more about it later. At first I felt ok about

> > > > this, but after I got off the phone I started to get really

> > > > panicky.

> > > >

> > > > My husband asked if I had shared what she's doing to my

> > > > family members. So I emailed him about how I found out

> > > > the reason my Dad was suicidal last year was because she was

> > > > telling him he was better off dead on a regular basis.Â

> > > > (They lost their savings in the financial crisis and I think

> > > > he told me she was telling him he was worthless and everyone

> > > > would be better off with the insurance money). I also

> > > > told him she's attacking my dangerously depressed younger

> > > > brother who is stuck living at home and unemployed right now

> > > > and who can't get on his feet because every time he makes a

> > > > positive move she comes and tears him down. I told him that

> > > > she was telling my brother he's better off dead.

> > > >

> > > > But I'm hedging because suddenly I'm not sure. I know

> > > > my Dad told me she was telling him he was better off

> > > > dead. I know she is regularly attacking my brother

> > > > (who was a all-bad child). But I'm having major fog

> > > > and mom-headache. I can't think straight. I said

> > > > to my husband, " here I go making it all up again " and

> > > > couldn't believe I blurted that out. Did someone tell

> > > > me she was telling my brother he's better off dead or did I

> > > > make that up? I know I don't make it up, but my

> > > > contact with her and her denial of the abuse has me

> > > > struggling to retain my identity and sense of trusting my

> > > > own sense of reality. I'm spiraling. I feel like

> > > > I'm fighting for my survival again.

> > > >

> > > > Anyway, my pastor responded to that email saying that based

> > > > on this info he feels much stronger boundaries are in

> > > > order. So we're supposed to talk again next week, but

> > > > I want to make sure I'm giving accurate information. Becuase

> > > > otherwise I'll doubt the validity of whatever plan we come

> > > > up with.

> > > >

> > > > Does it matter if she is actually coming out and saying my

> > > > brother is better off dead? The logical conclusion of

> > > > her messages to us was always that anyway.Â

> > > >

> > > > I know some of you all have mothers who are sometimes the

> > > > good mom, but I don't think my good mom is very nice.Â

> > > > She has a really scary malicious " witch " in her. But I

> > > > think she might be always the witch just a little bit. What

> > > > I mean is she really shows no interest in me as me. The only

> > > > interest she has inme is what I can give her, and sometimes

> > > > that means " mirroring " . her message is always and

> > > > always has been that who I am as a person is unacceptable

> > > > and disgusting to me. I tried to kill my soul as a

> > > > child to please her and she tried to destroy my personality

> > > > and replace it with her own or some kind of servant who

> > > > praised her constantly. She is one of the

> > > > " merger-hungry " personalities from UBM.Â

> > > >

> > > > My mother's message to me is that I as who I am evil and

> > > > disgusting and when I used to believe her I always felt I

> > > > didn't have a right to be alive. She did a lot of

> > > > things very systematically to destroy who I was and I feel

> > > > like all of her faces (witch, nice, withdrawn, etc etc) are

> > > > part of the same message and project to get me to be her

> > > > mirror/vessel/ servant.

> > > >

> > > > Can she really be like this? Am I making it up?Â

> > > > Am I being unfair to her? Is it my own weakness that

> > > > contact with her is SO BAD for me? Can she really be

> > > > so mean?Â

> > > >

> > > > I just want to get away from her. I want to be at a

> > > > place where I feel free, where whatever love I give I give

> > > > freely, not just because I can't get away because she's

> > > > " mentally ill. " Â Are you really telling me she can't

> > > > help it? Does being an emotional adolescent make you

> > > > scary mean? Most teenagers are not murderous... .

> > > >

> > > > Any thoughts? I want out of the fog.Â

> > > >

> > > >

> > > >

> > > > Â Â Â

> > > >

> > > >

Guest guest
Posted

MP--

I just had a thought that helped me, and I wanted to share. I got a little more

clarity on what it means to be NC.

My going NC was really nadas decision, if that makes sense. I told her (for

over a year) that her behavior was extremely hurtful, and if she didn't stop I

would have to disconnect from her.

Obviously, she didn't stop.

So, I went NC based on HER behavior. I think its important for all of us to

remember we aren't disconnecting out of anger or vengence or cruelty. I had to

go NC out of sheer need for survival. I literally wasn't going to make it

through the horrible time of life I was in with the weight and pain of her

constant abuse.

Going NC was literally a matter of life and death for me.

And, this thread also helped me see something important. If she ever learns how

to connect with me and not abuse me, of course she would be welcome in my life.

Yes, it would be extremely limited, and no, she wouldn't be a real mom all of

the sudden, and yes, everything would be different.

But the door will always be open if she can be more safe. Its up to her, not

me. And the decision was hers much more than mine, because she was warned for

over a year that I was gearing up to disconnecting from her.

I think its tricky for folks like your pastor. When they hear NC, they think

cruelty, anger, unforgiveness and purposeful irresponsibility on our part.

Unfortunately, they can't understand that 1) it is never our choice. we would

all rather have a mom than a nada. 2) we are put in a corner of having to

choose our own sanity or talking to nada. 3) that choice is one of the most

tormenting, painful choices out there. who wants to have to choose to become an

" orphan " just to keep surviving? when their mother is still alive and " wanting "

to be involved in your life? when we so desperately need a mother instead of a

nada? Its like double and triple sadness.

People outside of this group could never understand the torment that goes with

this choice. They just naturally assume we make it lightly, with a limited

understanding of God.

But remember: your NC only has to go as long as she learns to behave or you can

get strong enough to absorb more abuse. I think that is the model of Christian

compassion and forgiveness, if you ask me. But you are really only respecting

what she chooses to do. Its on her, my dear.

I mean, imagine putting your son in a place where he has to choose his own

mental health OR disconnect from you!?!? Doesn't that put a whole new light on

how sick she is?

Hope this makes sense!

Blessings,

>

> I haven't been on this forum for a couple of weeks, but it's good to be back.

I'm back because I need validation so badly. I've been driven lately to see

things more clearly than I had before. But as I grapple with that I find I'm

struggling with confusion and fog.

>

> My pastor heard that my nada was visiting this weekend and called to see how

it went. I told him how the confrontation I was afraid of had happened but that

I was really proud of myself because I had stayed calm with her. (As I had

expected and others on this forum had predicted, my mom confronted me because I

kept avoiding leaving my son alone with her. I tried to be tactful, but she

wanted to know if that was what I was doing. I told her " I just feel more

comfortable when we are together as a group. " We then did a few hours of baby

fun activities, but then she cornered me when I was alone and wanted to know

why, " so I don't have to wonder. " I won't give the play by play, but the short

version is that I said " there were things that happened when I was a kid and I

just feel more comfortable when we are together as a group. " She started with

the whole invalidating story about how she " wasn't equipped " and the version

that includes some minor

> conflict when I was a teenager but does not involve physical abuse throughout

childhood or what I consider much worse, systematic emotional abuse. I told her

that we had different memories, that being alone with my son was non-negotiable

and that I was going to take a break. I walked out and made my husband stay at

my side the rest of the visit. First she sulked in her room then she started

playing " super nice grandma " but being cold to me. Before she played that super

nice routine though, she did something that just made me sure I was right, my

son, who has of course fallen in love with her which actually hurts me somehow,

was crawling over and trying to get her to play with him. She ignored him

totally because she was mad at me. My grandnada did that to me, and it is

unacceptable.)

>

> Anyway, I told my pastor that story and we talked a little bit about how much

BPs are responsible for themselves and how much is " mental illness. " He's big

on boundaries but he always reminds me she's mentally ill, and this time I

challenged him on it. He's got more counseling background than most pastors,

but he's not a psychologist with a specialty in BPD or anything. On the other

hand, he helps with some of the issues that come up that touch on what's right

as a christian and all. Sometimes it's hard for me to trust what a therapist

tells me because I wonder if that's okay as a christian. Can any of you relate?

>

> Anyway, I told him I was questioning the mental illness thing a bit since my

nada can totally control herself when she wants to and since so much of what she

does is " mean " as I put it to him, not just emotional regulation issues or

whatever. He said he finds it really hard to figure that stuff out, but he

thinks NC is probably not an option for a christian. He also told me that if I

told him I was going NC he wouldn't say anything to me or give me a hard time

and he would support me at the time, but he might talk with me more about it

later. At first I felt ok about this, but after I got off the phone I started

to get really panicky.

>

> My husband asked if I had shared what she's doing to my family members. So I

emailed him about how I found out the reason my Dad was suicidal last year was

because she was telling him he was better off dead on a regular basis. (They

lost their savings in the financial crisis and I think he told me she was

telling him he was worthless and everyone would be better off with the insurance

money). I also told him she's attacking my dangerously depressed younger

brother who is stuck living at home and unemployed right now and who can't get

on his feet because every time he makes a positive move she comes and tears him

down. I told him that she was telling my brother he's better off dead.

>

> But I'm hedging because suddenly I'm not sure. I know my Dad told me she was

telling him he was better off dead. I know she is regularly attacking my

brother (who was a all-bad child). But I'm having major fog and mom-headache.

I can't think straight. I said to my husband, " here I go making it all up

again " and couldn't believe I blurted that out. Did someone tell me she was

telling my brother he's better off dead or did I make that up? I know I don't

make it up, but my contact with her and her denial of the abuse has me

struggling to retain my identity and sense of trusting my own sense of reality.

I'm spiraling. I feel like I'm fighting for my survival again.

>

> Anyway, my pastor responded to that email saying that based on this info he

feels much stronger boundaries are in order. So we're supposed to talk again

next week, but I want to make sure I'm giving accurate information. Becuase

otherwise I'll doubt the validity of whatever plan we come up with.

>

> Does it matter if she is actually coming out and saying my brother is better

off dead? The logical conclusion of her messages to us was always that anyway.

>

> I know some of you all have mothers who are sometimes the good mom, but I

don't think my good mom is very nice. She has a really scary malicious " witch "

in her. But I think she might be always the witch just a little bit. What I

mean is she really shows no interest in me as me. The only interest she has inme

is what I can give her, and sometimes that means " mirroring " . her message is

always and always has been that who I am as a person is unacceptable and

disgusting to me. I tried to kill my soul as a child to please her and she

tried to destroy my personality and replace it with her own or some kind of

servant who praised her constantly. She is one of the " merger-hungry "

personalities from UBM.

>

> My mother's message to me is that I as who I am evil and disgusting and when I

used to believe her I always felt I didn't have a right to be alive. She did a

lot of things very systematically to destroy who I was and I feel like all of

her faces (witch, nice, withdrawn, etc etc) are part of the same message and

project to get me to be her mirror/vessel/servant.

>

> Can she really be like this? Am I making it up? Am I being unfair to her?

Is it my own weakness that contact with her is SO BAD for me? Can she really be

so mean?

>

> I just want to get away from her. I want to be at a place where I feel free,

where whatever love I give I give freely, not just because I can't get away

because she's " mentally ill. " Are you really telling me she can't help it?

Does being an emotional adolescent make you scary mean? Most teenagers are not

murderous....

>

> Any thoughts? I want out of the fog.

>

>

>

>

>

>

Guest guest
Posted

Thank-you Thank-you Thank-you 40 days. That was just what I needed to hear and

is sooooo true. I have just gone NC after LC for a year. Yes I told her what I

needed and expected and yes it hasn't happened. I can't do it to myself anymore

either.

Your post helped me and confirmed it all. Thank-you again.

Kazam x

> >

> > I haven't been on this forum for a couple of weeks, but it's good to be

back. I'm back because I need validation so badly. I've been driven lately to

see things more clearly than I had before. But as I grapple with that I find

I'm struggling with confusion and fog.

> >

> > My pastor heard that my nada was visiting this weekend and called to see how

it went. I told him how the confrontation I was afraid of had happened but that

I was really proud of myself because I had stayed calm with her. (As I had

expected and others on this forum had predicted, my mom confronted me because I

kept avoiding leaving my son alone with her. I tried to be tactful, but she

wanted to know if that was what I was doing. I told her " I just feel more

comfortable when we are together as a group. " We then did a few hours of baby

fun activities, but then she cornered me when I was alone and wanted to know

why, " so I don't have to wonder. " I won't give the play by play, but the short

version is that I said " there were things that happened when I was a kid and I

just feel more comfortable when we are together as a group. " She started with

the whole invalidating story about how she " wasn't equipped " and the version

that includes some minor

> > conflict when I was a teenager but does not involve physical abuse

throughout childhood or what I consider much worse, systematic emotional abuse.

I told her that we had different memories, that being alone with my son was

non-negotiable and that I was going to take a break. I walked out and made my

husband stay at my side the rest of the visit. First she sulked in her room

then she started playing " super nice grandma " but being cold to me. Before she

played that super nice routine though, she did something that just made me sure

I was right, my son, who has of course fallen in love with her which actually

hurts me somehow, was crawling over and trying to get her to play with him. She

ignored him totally because she was mad at me. My grandnada did that to me, and

it is unacceptable.)

> >

> > Anyway, I told my pastor that story and we talked a little bit about how

much BPs are responsible for themselves and how much is " mental illness. " He's

big on boundaries but he always reminds me she's mentally ill, and this time I

challenged him on it. He's got more counseling background than most pastors,

but he's not a psychologist with a specialty in BPD or anything. On the other

hand, he helps with some of the issues that come up that touch on what's right

as a christian and all. Sometimes it's hard for me to trust what a therapist

tells me because I wonder if that's okay as a christian. Can any of you relate?

> >

> > Anyway, I told him I was questioning the mental illness thing a bit since my

nada can totally control herself when she wants to and since so much of what she

does is " mean " as I put it to him, not just emotional regulation issues or

whatever. He said he finds it really hard to figure that stuff out, but he

thinks NC is probably not an option for a christian. He also told me that if I

told him I was going NC he wouldn't say anything to me or give me a hard time

and he would support me at the time, but he might talk with me more about it

later. At first I felt ok about this, but after I got off the phone I started

to get really panicky.

> >

> > My husband asked if I had shared what she's doing to my family members. So

I emailed him about how I found out the reason my Dad was suicidal last year was

because she was telling him he was better off dead on a regular basis. (They

lost their savings in the financial crisis and I think he told me she was

telling him he was worthless and everyone would be better off with the insurance

money). I also told him she's attacking my dangerously depressed younger

brother who is stuck living at home and unemployed right now and who can't get

on his feet because every time he makes a positive move she comes and tears him

down. I told him that she was telling my brother he's better off dead.

> >

> > But I'm hedging because suddenly I'm not sure. I know my Dad told me she

was telling him he was better off dead. I know she is regularly attacking my

brother (who was a all-bad child). But I'm having major fog and mom-headache.

I can't think straight. I said to my husband, " here I go making it all up

again " and couldn't believe I blurted that out. Did someone tell me she was

telling my brother he's better off dead or did I make that up? I know I don't

make it up, but my contact with her and her denial of the abuse has me

struggling to retain my identity and sense of trusting my own sense of reality.

I'm spiraling. I feel like I'm fighting for my survival again.

> >

> > Anyway, my pastor responded to that email saying that based on this info he

feels much stronger boundaries are in order. So we're supposed to talk again

next week, but I want to make sure I'm giving accurate information. Becuase

otherwise I'll doubt the validity of whatever plan we come up with.

> >

> > Does it matter if she is actually coming out and saying my brother is better

off dead? The logical conclusion of her messages to us was always that anyway.

> >

> > I know some of you all have mothers who are sometimes the good mom, but I

don't think my good mom is very nice. She has a really scary malicious " witch "

in her. But I think she might be always the witch just a little bit. What I

mean is she really shows no interest in me as me. The only interest she has inme

is what I can give her, and sometimes that means " mirroring " . her message is

always and always has been that who I am as a person is unacceptable and

disgusting to me. I tried to kill my soul as a child to please her and she

tried to destroy my personality and replace it with her own or some kind of

servant who praised her constantly. She is one of the " merger-hungry "

personalities from UBM.

> >

> > My mother's message to me is that I as who I am evil and disgusting and when

I used to believe her I always felt I didn't have a right to be alive. She did

a lot of things very systematically to destroy who I was and I feel like all of

her faces (witch, nice, withdrawn, etc etc) are part of the same message and

project to get me to be her mirror/vessel/servant.

> >

> > Can she really be like this? Am I making it up? Am I being unfair to her?

Is it my own weakness that contact with her is SO BAD for me? Can she really be

so mean?

> >

> > I just want to get away from her. I want to be at a place where I feel

free, where whatever love I give I give freely, not just because I can't get

away because she's " mentally ill. " Are you really telling me she can't help it?

Does being an emotional adolescent make you scary mean? Most teenagers are not

murderous....

> >

> > Any thoughts? I want out of the fog.

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

Guest guest
Posted

Hi 40days,

Just a couple of questions for you. How long has NC been for you?

Did it help you going NC to have more peace or does it just bring up another set

of issues?

At the moment for me it feels like I have finally stood my ground and have said

no more. There is sadness but also I feel very empowered and strong. I feel

brave and that I have finally spoken up for myself. LC was just too hard for

me. So just wondering how the transition went for you?

Kazam x

> >

> > I haven't been on this forum for a couple of weeks, but it's good to be

back. I'm back because I need validation so badly. I've been driven lately to

see things more clearly than I had before. But as I grapple with that I find

I'm struggling with confusion and fog.

> >

> > My pastor heard that my nada was visiting this weekend and called to see how

it went. I told him how the confrontation I was afraid of had happened but that

I was really proud of myself because I had stayed calm with her. (As I had

expected and others on this forum had predicted, my mom confronted me because I

kept avoiding leaving my son alone with her. I tried to be tactful, but she

wanted to know if that was what I was doing. I told her " I just feel more

comfortable when we are together as a group. " We then did a few hours of baby

fun activities, but then she cornered me when I was alone and wanted to know

why, " so I don't have to wonder. " I won't give the play by play, but the short

version is that I said " there were things that happened when I was a kid and I

just feel more comfortable when we are together as a group. " She started with

the whole invalidating story about how she " wasn't equipped " and the version

that includes some minor

> > conflict when I was a teenager but does not involve physical abuse

throughout childhood or what I consider much worse, systematic emotional abuse.

I told her that we had different memories, that being alone with my son was

non-negotiable and that I was going to take a break. I walked out and made my

husband stay at my side the rest of the visit. First she sulked in her room

then she started playing " super nice grandma " but being cold to me. Before she

played that super nice routine though, she did something that just made me sure

I was right, my son, who has of course fallen in love with her which actually

hurts me somehow, was crawling over and trying to get her to play with him. She

ignored him totally because she was mad at me. My grandnada did that to me, and

it is unacceptable.)

> >

> > Anyway, I told my pastor that story and we talked a little bit about how

much BPs are responsible for themselves and how much is " mental illness. " He's

big on boundaries but he always reminds me she's mentally ill, and this time I

challenged him on it. He's got more counseling background than most pastors,

but he's not a psychologist with a specialty in BPD or anything. On the other

hand, he helps with some of the issues that come up that touch on what's right

as a christian and all. Sometimes it's hard for me to trust what a therapist

tells me because I wonder if that's okay as a christian. Can any of you relate?

> >

> > Anyway, I told him I was questioning the mental illness thing a bit since my

nada can totally control herself when she wants to and since so much of what she

does is " mean " as I put it to him, not just emotional regulation issues or

whatever. He said he finds it really hard to figure that stuff out, but he

thinks NC is probably not an option for a christian. He also told me that if I

told him I was going NC he wouldn't say anything to me or give me a hard time

and he would support me at the time, but he might talk with me more about it

later. At first I felt ok about this, but after I got off the phone I started

to get really panicky.

> >

> > My husband asked if I had shared what she's doing to my family members. So

I emailed him about how I found out the reason my Dad was suicidal last year was

because she was telling him he was better off dead on a regular basis. (They

lost their savings in the financial crisis and I think he told me she was

telling him he was worthless and everyone would be better off with the insurance

money). I also told him she's attacking my dangerously depressed younger

brother who is stuck living at home and unemployed right now and who can't get

on his feet because every time he makes a positive move she comes and tears him

down. I told him that she was telling my brother he's better off dead.

> >

> > But I'm hedging because suddenly I'm not sure. I know my Dad told me she

was telling him he was better off dead. I know she is regularly attacking my

brother (who was a all-bad child). But I'm having major fog and mom-headache.

I can't think straight. I said to my husband, " here I go making it all up

again " and couldn't believe I blurted that out. Did someone tell me she was

telling my brother he's better off dead or did I make that up? I know I don't

make it up, but my contact with her and her denial of the abuse has me

struggling to retain my identity and sense of trusting my own sense of reality.

I'm spiraling. I feel like I'm fighting for my survival again.

> >

> > Anyway, my pastor responded to that email saying that based on this info he

feels much stronger boundaries are in order. So we're supposed to talk again

next week, but I want to make sure I'm giving accurate information. Becuase

otherwise I'll doubt the validity of whatever plan we come up with.

> >

> > Does it matter if she is actually coming out and saying my brother is better

off dead? The logical conclusion of her messages to us was always that anyway.

> >

> > I know some of you all have mothers who are sometimes the good mom, but I

don't think my good mom is very nice. She has a really scary malicious " witch "

in her. But I think she might be always the witch just a little bit. What I

mean is she really shows no interest in me as me. The only interest she has inme

is what I can give her, and sometimes that means " mirroring " . her message is

always and always has been that who I am as a person is unacceptable and

disgusting to me. I tried to kill my soul as a child to please her and she

tried to destroy my personality and replace it with her own or some kind of

servant who praised her constantly. She is one of the " merger-hungry "

personalities from UBM.

> >

> > My mother's message to me is that I as who I am evil and disgusting and when

I used to believe her I always felt I didn't have a right to be alive. She did

a lot of things very systematically to destroy who I was and I feel like all of

her faces (witch, nice, withdrawn, etc etc) are part of the same message and

project to get me to be her mirror/vessel/servant.

> >

> > Can she really be like this? Am I making it up? Am I being unfair to her?

Is it my own weakness that contact with her is SO BAD for me? Can she really be

so mean?

> >

> > I just want to get away from her. I want to be at a place where I feel

free, where whatever love I give I give freely, not just because I can't get

away because she's " mentally ill. " Are you really telling me she can't help it?

Does being an emotional adolescent make you scary mean? Most teenagers are not

murderous....

> >

> > Any thoughts? I want out of the fog.

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...