Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Re: Maybe nada isn't BPD?

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Guest guest
Posted

Hey, all--

This thread has been very enlightening to me. My nada is high functioning, and

is usually high on the " normal " scale.

When I was 11, my sister was dx with lupus. That sent her off the charts w/ the

BP, and she swung into full-blown witch/queen.

Things settled down when I was about 15. (Sheesh--was it that long????!!!!)

It was always there, in the background, but she was nearly normal for a while.

Then, my sister moved back from CA crazy as a loon!! (She's also BP, and was

full-blown BP when she came back, due to her experience in CA). This, in turn,

triggered nada's BP again. She again became full-blown BP witch/queen.

I went NC after that one. Couldn't deal anymore, and wasn't about to deal for

another 5 years until she somehow came back, as much as she ever does come back.

Its been helpful to see there was an " ebb and flow " to her madness. The clarity

helps me see it wasn't me imagining anything when I remember her more normal

behavior.

Thanks,

Karla

> >

> > I am so confused. Fada has never really been a part of my life, but his dad

(my grandpa) has always kept in touch. Fada has been living with my grandpa for

the past few years, but we never really talk. Grandpa died last week. I called

Fada to give him my condolences. I thought what the hell? I'm going to ask him

about nada and when they were together. maybe I will get some good insight. I

totally expected some serious validation in the sense that I thought he was

going to tell me how crazy nada was. But he didn't. And I am 99% sure he was not

lying. He was honest about some other things and I asked him to be honest about

nada- that I would not be upset. He said for the most part nada was really fun

and had a " bubbly " personality. WHAT????? Before she was got sick, nada could

really be the life of the party sometimes. But in general I have never known her

to be anything but unhappy. He told me a little about her alcoholic father, who

she never talks about. He admitted he handled everything wrong with ending their

relationship and not having one with me. But I am so confused. He did not

mention one single BPD behavior, even though I described the way she is today to

him. It's like we were talking about two different people. Could it be that nada

is NOT BPD? She never was officially diagnosed. My T, who I have been seeing for

years, has a lot of experience with BPDs and is convinced she has it. Fada and

nada were together for 7 years- I feel like he would pick up on it. How could he

not? I have had some limited contact with Fada in my life. I have known him to

be weak, not honor his promises and for a while he was a meth addict. But I have

never known him to lie, and I really think he was being honest about this.

> >

>

Guest guest
Posted

Yes, I see this too - the delicate dance of those who think they're telling me

something I don't know. Her friends, or new caretakers, start hemming and

hawing about her " condition " - and when I just come out and say, " you know she's

mentally ill, don't you? " - there's this audible " whoosh " of them expelling a

big breath. Then we can actually have a conversation about it.

> > > >

> > > > I am so confused. Fada has never really been a part of my life, but his

dad (my grandpa) has always kept in touch. Fada has been living with my grandpa

for the past few years, but we never really talk. Grandpa died last week. I

called Fada to give him my condolences. I thought what the hell? I'm going to

ask him about nada and when they were together. maybe I will get some good

insight. I totally expected some serious validation in the sense that I thought

he was going to tell me how crazy nada was. But he didn't. And I am 99% sure he

was not lying. He was honest about some other things and I asked him to be

honest about nada- that I would not be upset. He said for the most part nada was

really fun and had a " bubbly " personality. WHAT????? Before she was got sick,

nada could really be the life of the party sometimes. But in general I have

never known her to be anything but unhappy. He told me a little about her

alcoholic father, who she never talks about. He admitted he handled everything

wrong with ending their relationship and not having one with me. But I am so

confused. He did not mention one single BPD behavior, even though I described

the way she is today to him. It's like we were talking about two different

people. Could it be that nada is NOT BPD? She never was officially diagnosed. My

T, who I have been seeing for years, has a lot of experience with BPDs and is

convinced she has it. Fada and nada were together for 7 years- I feel like he

would pick up on it. How could he not? I have had some limited contact with Fada

in my life. I have known him to be weak, not honor his promises and for a while

he was a meth addict. But I have never known him to lie, and I really think he

was being honest about this.

> > > >

> > >

> >

>

Guest guest
Posted

yes, diane i cling to Christ too, as my hp who has helped me out of many of a

hole i have fallen into.  the peace and love i find in prayer settles my heart

and troubled mind many times. 

i seem to have little ability to set goals for myself (and i wonder if others do

too) but i can pray for just a 'little help' and guidance when i feel the need

and that will often answer an unspoken question or problem and i will feel my

prayer has been heard.  nada and fada couldn't hear but i believe God does and

i am grateful.  also for the folks in this group!  thanks for being there for

all of us and for caring.  blessings, ann

Subject: Re: Maybe nada isn't BPD?

To: WTOAdultChildren1

Date: Monday, March 29, 2010, 12:06 PM

 

Fellow KO's and Mozz,

The good Lord must have brought me right to this topic for a reason,

because the past few days have been especially difficult. Reality has

been tough, now that I'm working so much on myself and admitting that

I was, all three of us kids were abused. I'm alone in this though

because I'm the only girl, the oldest, and my brothers are treated

differently. So I've gone NC with the family for a spell. I wish the

experiences would go NC with me haha.

What is truth? Often truth is what we want it to be. My truth is not

the same as my brothers' truths. They say each kid grows up in a

different family because of chronology, parent experience, and so on.

I believe my truth is my truth. Not because I want it...because I

don't.

It just is. What happened to me under nada really happened, no matter

how much she wants to villanize me. Lately my SO has been reading up on

bpd and such, and he has come to me several times saying he is sorry we

moved back so close to nada's house, and he's sorry for what I went

through as a kid, and so on. He gets some of it. He validates me. In

fact we all validate one another on here and it is soooooooo

helpful!!!!

During those 'lucid' times when your nada/fada was so charming, happy

and seemed normal - we don't really know why. Could be they were

getting their false needs met through an affair, hiding their drinking,

or some other acting out behind the scenes. As we know, the bpd

turns one way then another to get those false needs met. So don't

worry about being 'judgemental' on your nada/fada because they

seemed to have 'normal' periods. Even we KO's don't know everything

about them.

I cling to Christ to help me get through stuff. He's my big brother.

He looks out for me. I hope others of you understand that too...

Because if I know anything about being a KO, it's that very early in

life I looked for someone, something, that was greater, more powerful,

and had more authority than my nada...and could help me out now and

then.!!!

with Love

Diane

>

> I am so confused. Fada has never really been a part of my life, but

his dad (my grandpa) has always kept in touch. Fada has been living with

my grandpa for the past few years, but we never really talk. Grandpa

died last week. I called Fada to give him my condolences. I thought what

the hell?

Guest guest
Posted

Like so many of the posts I've read on this group, I can really relate! My nada

is also very high functioning, and I've had times in my life when I've gotten

" the good mom " . People were shocked when I told them why we went NC with her,

saying " I can't believe it! She seems SO NICE! " My brother has also been

mostly the " golden child " so he still tells me that he is not convinced that

nada has BPD. His wife is convinced though (she has been the victim of nada's

rage). So, we are working on getting him gently to understand. He would rather

stick his head in the sand though and not deal with anything too emotional -

easier for him that way. He learned that so well from my dad.

Don't know if this is helpful, but I watched this video on Youtube today, where

a mental health professional is describing BPD to clinicians learning about it.

It helped me understand the Borderline's perspective a bit more, and I thought

it was interesting that they teach clinicians dealing with BPD patients to " take

care of yourself, get plenty of rest " and " surround yourself with people who

understand BPD for support " . I guess that doesn't just apply to KOs!

-

> >

> > I am so confused. Fada has never really been a part of my life, but

> his dad (my grandpa) has always kept in touch. Fada has been living with

> my grandpa for the past few years, but we never really talk. Grandpa

> died last week. I called Fada to give him my condolences. I thought what

> the hell?

>

Guest guest
Posted

Scary when it's put that way and so, so true. : (

In a message dated 3/30/2010 7:05:37 P.M. Eastern Daylight Time,

anuria-67854@... writes:

I agree. I find it highly ironic that trained professional adult therapists

find bpd patients so difficult to deal with that some refuse to even treat

them, and yet the little children of bpd parents are expected to just suck

up their own pain, damage and misery and endure abuse from a mentally ill

parent 24/7 with NO training and NO support system.

Its unconscionable.

-Annie

> > >

> > > I am so confused. Fada has never really been a part of my life, but

> > his dad (my grandpa) has always kept in touch. Fada has been living

with

> > my grandpa for the past few years, but we never really talk. Grandpa

> > died last week. I called Fada to give him my condolences. I thought

what

> > the hell?

> >

>

Guest guest
Posted

I agree. I find it highly ironic that trained professional adult therapists find

bpd patients so difficult to deal with that some refuse to even treat them, and

yet the little children of bpd parents are expected to just suck up their own

pain, damage and misery and endure abuse from a mentally ill parent 24/7 with NO

training and NO support system.

Its unconscionable.

-Annie

> > >

> > > I am so confused. Fada has never really been a part of my life, but

> > his dad (my grandpa) has always kept in touch. Fada has been living with

> > my grandpa for the past few years, but we never really talk. Grandpa

> > died last week. I called Fada to give him my condolences. I thought what

> > the hell?

> >

>

Guest guest
Posted

WOW SO TRUE!!!

> > > >

> > > > I am so confused. Fada has never really been a part of my life, but

> > > his dad (my grandpa) has always kept in touch. Fada has been living with

> > > my grandpa for the past few years, but we never really talk. Grandpa

> > > died last week. I called Fada to give him my condolences. I thought what

> > > the hell?

> > >

> >

>

Guest guest
Posted

yes!  doesn't it just make you want to scream?  arrrrauuughh!people are

allowed to have children with no one to coach or help them, no matter how much

loony tunes they are, by 'instinct' or something, whereas to cut someone's hair

you need to go to school and get a license.. 

how i wish i had had just one person who could have listened to my story after

my nada physically as well as emotionally abused me, just to have been heard..

it would have meant sooo much and made such a difference in my life i think.

every child needs advocates and when the parents aren't 'it' who will step in? 

no wonder they taught me not to trust.. 'strangers' they called them, people who

might hurt me.. what a sick joke!  all i seemed to be able to do at the time

was curl up into ball and hide. and i still do sometimes to this day.  it is

just too sad.

Subject: Re: Maybe nada isn't BPD?

To: WTOAdultChildren1

Date: Tuesday, March 30, 2010, 6:05 PM

 

I agree. I find it highly ironic that trained professional adult

therapists find bpd patients so difficult to deal with that some refuse to even

treat them, and yet the little children of bpd parents are expected to just suck

up their own pain, damage and misery and endure abuse from a mentally ill parent

24/7 with NO training and NO support system.

Its unconscionable.

-Annie

> > >

> > > I am so confused. Fada has never really been a part of my life, but

> > his dad (my grandpa) has always kept in touch. Fada has been living with

> > my grandpa for the past few years, but we never really talk. Grandpa

> > died last week. I called Fada to give him my condolences. I thought what

> > the hell?

> >

>

Guest guest
Posted

I totally agree, good point !!

Jackie

I agree. I find it highly ironic that trained professional adult therapists

find bpd patients so difficult to deal with that some refuse to even treat

them, and yet the little children of bpd parents are expected to just suck

up their own pain, damage and misery and endure abuse from a mentally ill

parent 24/7 with NO training and NO support system.

Its unconscionable.

-Annie

Guest guest
Posted

Good point indeed Annie.

Perhaps what is needed is some communication between the mental health

community and the CPS community. I know T s who say they hate to treat

BPs, some actually limit the number of BP pts they will have on their

case loads at any given time.

And they hate it to be treating one and not realize it until after

months of wasted effort dealing with all the extraneous nada stuff.

But these same functional but insane ( fair description of how the

system treats them, they are nuts and drive even T to distraction, yet

no one will mandate meds or treatment, no social worker calls to do a

reality check as with a Schizophrenic) are OK to care for a defenseless

child. ( Read that as " All of us " )

The court system is fooled by them as well, defaulting to a child is

better of with its mother. They don t understand, and in fairness it is

a complex problem. How old were some of us before we read SWOE and the

light came on and we said SHIT! So THATS it! ( Pardon me ladies, I m

sure none of YOU ever said SHIT in re to nada. :)

It s too late for us to be protected as children, but lots of them are

still out there. I have a friend going thru a horrible divorce from a BP

right now, she is filing Protective orders, trying to ban him from even

seeing his kids, and is a CLASSIC Queen/Witch BP. I can look from

across the room at her girls and tell you right away which is golden and

which is scapegoat, and I ll predict right now that the golden 16 yo is

or will be promiscuous and probably pregnant before she gets out of

school. I know they must be screwed up. Some of his friends have

convinced him to fight for full custody, but it s an uphill battle.

One we all should fight where and as we can.

Doug

> > > >

> > > > I am so confused. Fada has never really been a part of my life,

but

> > > his dad (my grandpa) has always kept in touch. Fada has been

living with

> > > my grandpa for the past few years, but we never really talk.

Grandpa

> > > died last week. I called Fada to give him my condolences. I

thought what

> > > the hell?

> > >

> >

>

Guest guest
Posted

I wish that we could start educating children, very young children, about what

constitutes " mentally healthy behaviors " and what doesn't. I'd call the class

" Emotional Hygiene " and make it a regular part of the school curriculum. It

would address things like what is good physical hygiene, what are good things to

eat, what is bullying and how to deal with it, what children's rights are in

relation to their parents (according to the United Nations) and the class would

give examples in the form of films demonstrating mentally healthy ways to deal

with an issue as opposed to mentally disordered ways.

Children have absolutely no means of comprehending that the behaviors they are

experiencing in their own home from their own parent(s) are not healthy or

normal.

If mommy is locking them in their house for days at a time while she goes to Las

Vegas with her boyfriend, or if stepdad is touching her all over at night, or if

big brother is beating up his younger sibs, or if mommy never takes you to have

dental checkups and cleanings, never gives you shoes that fit, makes you stay

home from school to take care of mommy or younger sibs, prevents you from

having friends, etc., etc., etc. (the abuses are unfortunately endless) then the

child needs to understand that that is not normal and its not OK.

I think that Knowledge is Power, and children might start reporting abusive home

environments if they understand that they actually are being abused.

Also, there should also be a child advocate in each school; possibly the school

counselor could also be a child advocate/lawyer with the power to take on a

child as a client and investigate a child's claims of abuse from a different

angle than CPS: as a lawyer protecting his client's rights.

Children need access to legal aid as much as if not more so than adults do.

-Annie

>

>

> Good point indeed Annie.

>

> Perhaps what is needed is some communication between the mental health

> community and the CPS community. I know T s who say they hate to treat

> BPs, some actually limit the number of BP pts they will have on their

> case loads at any given time.

>

> And they hate it to be treating one and not realize it until after

> months of wasted effort dealing with all the extraneous nada stuff.

>

> But these same functional but insane ( fair description of how the

> system treats them, they are nuts and drive even T to distraction, yet

> no one will mandate meds or treatment, no social worker calls to do a

> reality check as with a Schizophrenic) are OK to care for a defenseless

> child. ( Read that as " All of us " )

>

> The court system is fooled by them as well, defaulting to a child is

> better of with its mother. They don t understand, and in fairness it is

> a complex problem. How old were some of us before we read SWOE and the

> light came on and we said SHIT! So THATS it! ( Pardon me ladies, I m

> sure none of YOU ever said SHIT in re to nada. :)

>

> It s too late for us to be protected as children, but lots of them are

> still out there. I have a friend going thru a horrible divorce from a BP

> right now, she is filing Protective orders, trying to ban him from even

> seeing his kids, and is a CLASSIC Queen/Witch BP. I can look from

> across the room at her girls and tell you right away which is golden and

> which is scapegoat, and I ll predict right now that the golden 16 yo is

> or will be promiscuous and probably pregnant before she gets out of

> school. I know they must be screwed up. Some of his friends have

> convinced him to fight for full custody, but it s an uphill battle.

>

>

>

> One we all should fight where and as we can.

>

>

>

> Doug

Guest guest
Posted

Sure Mozz

" Wasn't I Real before? " asked the little Rabbit.

" You were Real to the Boy, " the Fairy said, " because he loved you. Now

you shall be Real to every one. "

The summary. The rabbit became real to the boy, because he loved it.

The rabbit had yearned, first to learn what Real was, then to become

real.

How like us.

For those who loved the story and want to read it again, here it is in

entirety.

http://digital.library.upenn.edu/women/williams/rabbit/rabbit.html

<http://digital.library.upenn.edu/women/williams/rabbit/rabbit.html>

Doug

> > > >Isn't it crazy that KO's doubt their own experiences so much? I

> > > >do all the time. It's just insane that I have a hard time

> > > >believing MYSELF.

> > >

> > > --

> > > Katrina

> > >

> >

>

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...