Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Re: Maybe nada isn't BPD?

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Guest guest
Posted

Mozz--

Believe what you believe and know what you know. You're experiences don't

change, and your knowledge is too deep for it to not be real.

I think spouses and former spouses of BP are the very worst judges of their

abnormal behavior. He may truly not remember or see it--just like my father

would never see my nada's behavior as anything but normal. And he would say the

same thing (for that matter, my entire FOO would) about nada: that she is a

joy, the life of the party, and fine.

I wonder, also, if he tried to " focus on the positive " to protect you? If I

didn't know BP, I think it would be distasteful to tell the ugly truth about

someone's dead mother. Since I know BP, though, I know the truth would have

been better. He may not know that.

You are not the crazy one. You are not the one in denial. You are not the one

with the distorted perspective. All of his sincere blindness does not make her

BP go away, unfortunately.

Sorry this happened to you. You must feel like the sand is shifting under your

feet. Just know you have support through all the confusion!

Blessings,

Karla

>

> I am so confused. Fada has never really been a part of my life, but his dad

(my grandpa) has always kept in touch. Fada has been living with my grandpa for

the past few years, but we never really talk. Grandpa died last week. I called

Fada to give him my condolences. I thought what the hell? I'm going to ask him

about nada and when they were together. maybe I will get some good insight. I

totally expected some serious validation in the sense that I thought he was

going to tell me how crazy nada was. But he didn't. And I am 99% sure he was not

lying. He was honest about some other things and I asked him to be honest about

nada- that I would not be upset. He said for the most part nada was really fun

and had a " bubbly " personality. WHAT????? Before she was got sick, nada could

really be the life of the party sometimes. But in general I have never known her

to be anything but unhappy. He told me a little about her alcoholic father, who

she never talks about. He admitted he handled everything wrong with ending their

relationship and not having one with me. But I am so confused. He did not

mention one single BPD behavior, even though I described the way she is today to

him. It's like we were talking about two different people. Could it be that nada

is NOT BPD? She never was officially diagnosed. My T, who I have been seeing for

years, has a lot of experience with BPDs and is convinced she has it. Fada and

nada were together for 7 years- I feel like he would pick up on it. How could he

not? I have had some limited contact with Fada in my life. I have known him to

be weak, not honor his promises and for a while he was a meth addict. But I have

never known him to lie, and I really think he was being honest about this.

>

Guest guest
Posted

Mozz

It is so amazing how life with a BP can alter our thinking and logic.

Fada lived with nada ( boy, sounds like a song) for a long time. Have

you ever heard the old saw about how to boil a frog? Put him in cold

water, and slowly bring it to a boil. He ll adjust to what eventually

kills him and sit right there. Toss him in hot water and he ll jump

right out.

The closer you are to it, the harder it is to see. And if you are

married to it, and stay with it, it is excruciating to admit you stayed

and put up with it.

As to nada being bubbly and the life of the party, yes, BP s can be very

charming when they are getting their way. They can also be very

manipulative. But everything is a mask to them. Trust your gut, and

your heart. You know what you lived with. Dont let a codependant

enabler convince you otherwise.

And gently, as a friend and fellow KO, may I point out a little

distorted thinking going on in your mind? You write

" I feel like he would pick up on it. How could he not? I have had some

limited contact with Fada in my life. I have known him to be weak, not

honor his promises and for a while he was a meth addict. But I have

never known him to lie, and I really think he was being honest about

this. "

Do you hear yourself, Mozz? You have known him to not honor his

promises, but never known him to lie. Not honoring his promises IS

lying.

And for a while he was a meth addict. Addiction is not like a cold. It

doesnt go away. If he is a sober addict, great, but don t be terribly

sure he is. And Addicts lie. Let me repeat that for emphasis. ADDICTS

LIE. As easily as they breathe they lie, to protect themselves, to shift

blame, but most importantly , to get to that next high. An addict who

is not sober and in good solid recovery will lie with every breathe.

You have known him to be weak? Of course. He and nada probably had a

nice enabling co addiction going on. His meth,her drama and all that

entails. He lied most of all to himself, and may have been so in denial

he can t remember or face the truth, or bought her gaslighting.

I remember an old story about a man caught in bed with a woman by his

wife. She railed and screamed, while he and the floozy calmly dressed

and she left. Then he made the bed and went into the living room and

started to read the paper. After a while, he said to her, Dear I don t

know what in the world you are talking about. Whats for dinner?

And the wife goes to make dinner, and thinks, well, there is no

evidence, maybe I just imagined it. I mean, after all, why would he lie.

She may not have been diagnosed, but many, maybe most, are not. She is

what she is. Listen to the stories on here. How many of us do you hear

talking about FOO s who can t understand why we are so mean and

neglectful of our wondeful moms.

Dont let him do this to you Mozz. Trust what you know, what you

experienced.

One of the favorite tricks of nada s is to convince people that everyone

around them is crazy , but not them. Sometimes they even convince

therapists of it.

Believe your heart. It was what it was. It was awful, but it is part of

your life experience. You are not crazy.

LOL..but , having a BP mom, you ARE a carrier.

sorry, little BPD humor there.

May we all heal.

Doug

>

> I am so confused. Fada has never really been a part of my life, but

his dad (my grandpa) has always kept in touch. Fada has been living with

my grandpa for the past few years, but we never really talk. Grandpa

died last week. I called Fada to give him my condolences. I thought what

the hell? I'm going to ask him about nada and when they were together.

maybe I will get some good insight. I totally expected some serious

validation in the sense that I thought he was going to tell me how crazy

nada was. But he didn't. And I am 99% sure he was not lying. He was

honest about some other things and I asked him to be honest about nada-

that I would not be upset. He said for the most part nada was really fun

and had a " bubbly " personality. WHAT????? Before she was got sick, nada

could really be the life of the party sometimes. But in general I have

never known her to be anything but unhappy. He told me a little about

her alcoholic father, who she never talks about. He admitted he handled

everything wrong with ending their relationship and not having one with

me. But I am so confused. He did not mention one single BPD behavior,

even though I described the way she is today to him. It's like we were

talking about two different people. Could it be that nada is NOT BPD?

She never was officially diagnosed. My T, who I have been seeing for

years, has a lot of experience with BPDs and is convinced she has it.

Fada and nada were together for 7 years- I feel like he would pick up on

it. How could he not? I have had some limited contact with Fada in my

life. I have known him to be weak, not honor his promises and for a

while he was a meth addict. But I have never known him to lie, and I

really think he was being honest about this.

>

Guest guest
Posted

Mozz, sometimes I question about my mother being BPD because she doesn't do some

of the actions on the spectacular end of things, raging only once every few

years, no suicide attempts, no cutting. But when I read the stories of others

here and realize I *feel* the way they do, and you guys understand the impact my

mother has on me that I share...well that means something. What an amazing

coincidence, eh? If your mother were not BPD at all would this group feel even

remotely right to you?

>

> I am so confused. Fada has never really been a part of my life, but his dad

(my grandpa) has always kept in touch. Fada has been living with my grandpa for

the past few years, but we never really talk. Grandpa died last week. I called

Fada to give him my condolences. I thought what the hell? I'm going to ask him

about nada and when they were together. maybe I will get some good insight. I

totally expected some serious validation in the sense that I thought he was

going to tell me how crazy nada was. But he didn't. And I am 99% sure he was not

lying. He was honest about some other things and I asked him to be honest about

nada- that I would not be upset. He said for the most part nada was really fun

and had a " bubbly " personality. WHAT????? Before she was got sick, nada could

really be the life of the party sometimes. But in general I have never known her

to be anything but unhappy. He told me a little about her alcoholic father, who

she never talks about. He admitted he handled everything wrong with ending their

relationship and not having one with me. But I am so confused. He did not

mention one single BPD behavior, even though I described the way she is today to

him. It's like we were talking about two different people. Could it be that nada

is NOT BPD? She never was officially diagnosed. My T, who I have been seeing for

years, has a lot of experience with BPDs and is convinced she has it. Fada and

nada were together for 7 years- I feel like he would pick up on it. How could he

not? I have had some limited contact with Fada in my life. I have known him to

be weak, not honor his promises and for a while he was a meth addict. But I have

never known him to lie, and I really think he was being honest about this.

>

Guest guest
Posted

It sounds like (from stories told) that my mother's developed in her late

teens. She lied to my father about already having a child, even told him she

had leukemia. Just weird stuff. From what he says, she was sick their

whole marriage and I wasn't born until my mother was 26.

In a message dated 3/28/2010 10:59:11 A.M. Eastern Daylight Time,

new_special_account@... writes:

Mozarella,

You also have to consider the fact that with BPD, as with many other

diseases, the age of onset varies. Most people do not have full-blown illness

until they are in their 30s. Just because someone did not have diabetes at

age 30, it does not mean that they don't have it now at age 50. Your father

lived with your mother for 7 years when she was much younger, and likely

before the onset of her disease. In fact, his handling " everything wrong " at

the end of their relationship could have contributed (like a trigger of

sorts) to her disease manifestation. She already had trauma from her alcoholic

father (it sounds like), add to that the stress of a broken relationship,

and her inherent susceptibility and you end up with the BPD coming out in

full force.

You father's experiences do not invalidate yours in any way whatsoever.

Arianna

>

> I am so confused. Fada has never really been a part of my life, but his

dad (my grandpa) has always kept in touch. Fada has been living with my

grandpa for the past few years, but we never really talk. Grandpa died last

week. I called Fada to give him my condolences. I thought what the hell? I'm

going to ask him about nada and when they were together. maybe I will get

some good insight. I totally expected some serious validation in the sense

that I thought he was going to tell me how crazy nada was. But he didn't.

And I am 99% sure he was not lying. He was honest about some other things and

I asked him to be honest about nada- that I would not be upset. He said

for the most part nada was really fun and had a " bubbly " personality.

WHAT????? Before she was got sick, nada could really be the life of the party

sometimes. But in general I have never known her to be anything but unhappy. He

told me a little about her alcoholic father, who she never talks about. He

admitted he handled everything wrong with ending their relationship and

not having one with me. But I am so confused. He did not mention one single

BPD behavior, even though I described the way she is today to him. It's like

we were talking about two different people. Could it be that nada is NOT

BPD? She never was officially diagnosed. My T, who I have been seeing for

years, has a lot of experience with BPDs and is convinced she has it. Fada

and nada were together for 7 years- I feel like he would pick up on it. How

could he not? I have had some limited contact with Fada in my life. I have

known him to be weak, not honor his promises and for a while he was a meth

addict. But I have never known him to lie, and I really think he was being

honest about this.

>

Guest guest
Posted

That is a very good point, . Thanks so much.

> >

> > I am so confused. Fada has never really been a part of my life, but his dad

(my grandpa) has always kept in touch. Fada has been living with my grandpa for

the past few years, but we never really talk. Grandpa died last week. I called

Fada to give him my condolences. I thought what the hell? I'm going to ask him

about nada and when they were together. maybe I will get some good insight. I

totally expected some serious validation in the sense that I thought he was

going to tell me how crazy nada was. But he didn't. And I am 99% sure he was not

lying. He was honest about some other things and I asked him to be honest about

nada- that I would not be upset. He said for the most part nada was really fun

and had a " bubbly " personality. WHAT????? Before she was got sick, nada could

really be the life of the party sometimes. But in general I have never known her

to be anything but unhappy. He told me a little about her alcoholic father, who

she never talks about. He admitted he handled everything wrong with ending their

relationship and not having one with me. But I am so confused. He did not

mention one single BPD behavior, even though I described the way she is today to

him. It's like we were talking about two different people. Could it be that nada

is NOT BPD? She never was officially diagnosed. My T, who I have been seeing for

years, has a lot of experience with BPDs and is convinced she has it. Fada and

nada were together for 7 years- I feel like he would pick up on it. How could he

not? I have had some limited contact with Fada in my life. I have known him to

be weak, not honor his promises and for a while he was a meth addict. But I have

never known him to lie, and I really think he was being honest about this.

> >

>

Guest guest
Posted

Hi Doug,

Thanks for gently pointing that out. Yes I realize that sounded crazy- the part

about never knowing him to lie in the same sentence as not honoring promises. I

realized that as I was typing it. I guess I was just trying to get the point

across that even though he was a horrible father I am pretty sure he wasn't

lying- just a feeling. I know he is sober b/c he had been living with my

grandpa. But you bring up a lot of good points. And to expand on those, last

night my husband also mentioned that he is remembering back 30 years ago, he

probably doesn't even remember clearly, esp. with the drug addiction years most

likely clouding things up. I mean if things were that great why would he leave?

> >

> > I am so confused. Fada has never really been a part of my life, but

> his dad (my grandpa) has always kept in touch. Fada has been living with

> my grandpa for the past few years, but we never really talk. Grandpa

> died last week. I called Fada to give him my condolences. I thought what

> the hell? I'm going to ask him about nada and when they were together.

> maybe I will get some good insight. I totally expected some serious

> validation in the sense that I thought he was going to tell me how crazy

> nada was. But he didn't. And I am 99% sure he was not lying. He was

> honest about some other things and I asked him to be honest about nada-

> that I would not be upset. He said for the most part nada was really fun

> and had a " bubbly " personality. WHAT????? Before she was got sick, nada

> could really be the life of the party sometimes. But in general I have

> never known her to be anything but unhappy. He told me a little about

> her alcoholic father, who she never talks about. He admitted he handled

> everything wrong with ending their relationship and not having one with

> me. But I am so confused. He did not mention one single BPD behavior,

> even though I described the way she is today to him. It's like we were

> talking about two different people. Could it be that nada is NOT BPD?

> She never was officially diagnosed. My T, who I have been seeing for

> years, has a lot of experience with BPDs and is convinced she has it.

> Fada and nada were together for 7 years- I feel like he would pick up on

> it. How could he not? I have had some limited contact with Fada in my

> life. I have known him to be weak, not honor his promises and for a

> while he was a meth addict. But I have never known him to lie, and I

> really think he was being honest about this.

> >

>

Guest guest
Posted

I DID feel like sand was shifting under my feet. Thank you for that validation,

Karla.

> >

> > I am so confused. Fada has never really been a part of my life, but his dad

(my grandpa) has always kept in touch. Fada has been living with my grandpa for

the past few years, but we never really talk. Grandpa died last week. I called

Fada to give him my condolences. I thought what the hell? I'm going to ask him

about nada and when they were together. maybe I will get some good insight. I

totally expected some serious validation in the sense that I thought he was

going to tell me how crazy nada was. But he didn't. And I am 99% sure he was not

lying. He was honest about some other things and I asked him to be honest about

nada- that I would not be upset. He said for the most part nada was really fun

and had a " bubbly " personality. WHAT????? Before she was got sick, nada could

really be the life of the party sometimes. But in general I have never known her

to be anything but unhappy. He told me a little about her alcoholic father, who

she never talks about. He admitted he handled everything wrong with ending their

relationship and not having one with me. But I am so confused. He did not

mention one single BPD behavior, even though I described the way she is today to

him. It's like we were talking about two different people. Could it be that nada

is NOT BPD? She never was officially diagnosed. My T, who I have been seeing for

years, has a lot of experience with BPDs and is convinced she has it. Fada and

nada were together for 7 years- I feel like he would pick up on it. How could he

not? I have had some limited contact with Fada in my life. I have known him to

be weak, not honor his promises and for a while he was a meth addict. But I have

never known him to lie, and I really think he was being honest about this.

> >

>

Guest guest
Posted

Mozarella,

You also have to consider the fact that with BPD, as with many other diseases,

the age of onset varies. Most people do not have full-blown illness until they

are in their 30s. Just because someone did not have diabetes at age 30, it does

not mean that they don't have it now at age 50. Your father lived with your

mother for 7 years when she was much younger, and likely before the onset of her

disease. In fact, his handling " everything wrong " at the end of their

relationship could have contributed (like a trigger of sorts) to her disease

manifestation. She already had trauma from her alcoholic father (it sounds

like), add to that the stress of a broken relationship, and her inherent

susceptibility and you end up with the BPD coming out in full force.

You father's experiences do not invalidate yours in any way whatsoever.

Arianna

>

> I am so confused. Fada has never really been a part of my life, but his dad

(my grandpa) has always kept in touch. Fada has been living with my grandpa for

the past few years, but we never really talk. Grandpa died last week. I called

Fada to give him my condolences. I thought what the hell? I'm going to ask him

about nada and when they were together. maybe I will get some good insight. I

totally expected some serious validation in the sense that I thought he was

going to tell me how crazy nada was. But he didn't. And I am 99% sure he was not

lying. He was honest about some other things and I asked him to be honest about

nada- that I would not be upset. He said for the most part nada was really fun

and had a " bubbly " personality. WHAT????? Before she was got sick, nada could

really be the life of the party sometimes. But in general I have never known her

to be anything but unhappy. He told me a little about her alcoholic father, who

she never talks about. He admitted he handled everything wrong with ending their

relationship and not having one with me. But I am so confused. He did not

mention one single BPD behavior, even though I described the way she is today to

him. It's like we were talking about two different people. Could it be that nada

is NOT BPD? She never was officially diagnosed. My T, who I have been seeing for

years, has a lot of experience with BPDs and is convinced she has it. Fada and

nada were together for 7 years- I feel like he would pick up on it. How could he

not? I have had some limited contact with Fada in my life. I have known him to

be weak, not honor his promises and for a while he was a meth addict. But I have

never known him to lie, and I really think he was being honest about this.

>

Guest guest
Posted

Mozz,

If she doesn't have BPD, how do you explain what she's done to

you? You're not doubting your own experiences, are you? If it

looks like a duck and quacks like a duck, then it probably is a

duck.

Someone doesn't have to be intentionally lying to say things

that aren't the truth. He may believe what he told you but that

doesn't make it true. How long has it been since your Fada left

your Nada? If he's never really been part of your life, it must

be quite a while. People are usually selective about what they

remember. He might not have wanted to remember the painful parts

of their relationship for a variety of reasons. Or, if he was

using drugs, he might have been pretty oblivious to a lot of

what was going on. Even if he wasn't using drugs, he may have

been making excuses to himself for her the whole time she was

together so that she didn't end up as being at fault in his

memory. Sometimes people are in love with their image of who

their partner should be and when that happens, they can be very

blind to the reality of who their partner really is. My father

certainly did his best to not accept that my nada was causing

problems, until the things she was doing got so extreme that he

couldn't explain her misbehavior away in his head. For years he

saw her as the person he wanted her to be. It is also possible

that your nada's behavior around him was better than it has been

around you. Her behavior probably got worse as the years went

by. If your fada is the weak dishrag type, he may have given in

to what she wanted without fighting back at all, giving her less

reason to show her bad qualities. Being fun, bubbly and the

life of the party is not necessarily at odds with having BPD.

All of those things could have been said about my nada when I

was young. Those were the things she showed to other people. Her

friends didn't see how she was tormenting her children at home

or making bad decisions about all sorts of things.

Stop doubting yourself. Your experiences are real, whether or

not your fada remembers having similar experiences.

At 01:25 AM 03/28/2010 mozzarella27 wrote:

>I am so confused. Fada has never really been a part of my life,

>but his dad (my grandpa) has always kept in touch. Fada has

>been living with my grandpa for the past few years, but we

>never really talk. Grandpa died last week. I called Fada to

>give him my condolences. I thought what the hell? I'm going to

>ask him about nada and when they were together. maybe I will

>get some good insight. I totally expected some serious

>validation in the sense that I thought he was going to tell me

>how crazy nada was. But he didn't. And I am 99% sure he was not

>lying. He was honest about some other things and I asked him to

>be honest about nada- that I would not be upset. He said for

>the most part nada was really fun and had a " bubbly "

>personality. WHAT????? Before she was got sick, nada could

>really be the life of the party sometimes. But in general I

>have never known her to be anything but unhappy. He told me a

>little about her alcoholic father, who she never talks about.

>He admitted he handled everything wrong with ending their

>relationship and not having one with me. But I am so confused.

>He did not mention one single BPD behavior, even though I

>described the way she is today to him. It's like we were

>talking about two different people. Could it be that nada is

>NOT BPD? She never was officially diagnosed. My T, who I have

>been seeing for years, has a lot of experience with BPDs and is

>convinced she has it. Fada and nada were together for 7 years-

>I feel like he would pick up on it. How could he not? I have

>had some limited contact with Fada in my life. I have known him

>to be weak, not honor his promises and for a while he was a

>meth addict. But I have never known him to lie, and I really

>think he was being honest about this.

--

Katrina

Guest guest
Posted

your fada is in denial !! if you asked my fada, or my oldest brother before

he died, they'd both tell you what a great person nada is ...just because

they're not together any more does mean he's not in denial

Jackie

I am so confused. Fada has never really been a part of my life, but his dad

(my grandpa) has always kept in touch. Fada has been living with my grandpa

for the past few years, but we never really talk. Grandpa died last week. I

called Fada to give him my condolences. I thought what the hell? I'm going

to ask him about nada and when they were together. maybe I will get some

good insight. I totally expected some serious validation in the sense that I

thought he was going to tell me how crazy nada was. But he didn't. And I am

99% sure he was not lying. He was honest about some other things and I asked

him to be honest about nada- that I would not be upset. He said for the most

part nada was really fun and had a " bubbly " personality. WHAT????? Before

she was got sick, nada could really be the life of the party sometimes. But

in general I have never known her to be anything but unhappy. He told me a

little about her alcoholic father, who she never talks about. He admitted he

handled everything wrong with ending their relationship and not having one

with me. But I am so confused. He did not mention one single BPD behavior,

even though I described the way she is today to him. It's like we were

talking about two different people. Could it be that nada is NOT BPD? She

never was officially diagnosed. My T, who I have been seeing for years, has

a lot of experience with BPDs and is convinced she has it. Fada and nada

were together for 7 years- I feel like he would pick up on it. How could he

not? I have had some limited contact with Fada in my life. I have known him

to be weak, not honor his promises and for a while he was a meth addict. But

I have never known him to lie, and I really think he was being honest about

this.

Guest guest
Posted

Arianna,

This is a really good point. My mother talks about my father being " normal "

before going into the coast guards during WWII. He was discharged for his

mental problems. He never saw combat. He was about 30 years old. This was the

big family secret. My mother didn't tell me until after his death. There sanity

must just hang by a thread until something happens to trigger them and they just

don't come back.

Mozz,

Trust your feelings. My BPfather has been dead for about 20 years and my mother

and sister just don't remember things like they were. I have to remind them of

things and they always make me feel like I should just shut up.

> >

> > I am so confused. Fada has never really been a part of my life, but his dad

(my grandpa) has always kept in touch. Fada has been living with my grandpa for

the past few years, but we never really talk. Grandpa died last week. I called

Fada to give him my condolences. I thought what the hell? I'm going to ask him

about nada and when they were together. maybe I will get some good insight. I

totally expected some serious validation in the sense that I thought he was

going to tell me how crazy nada was. But he didn't. And I am 99% sure he was not

lying. He was honest about some other things and I asked him to be honest about

nada- that I would not be upset. He said for the most part nada was really fun

and had a " bubbly " personality. WHAT????? Before she was got sick, nada could

really be the life of the party sometimes. But in general I have never known her

to be anything but unhappy. He told me a little about her alcoholic father, who

she never talks about. He admitted he handled everything wrong with ending their

relationship and not having one with me. But I am so confused. He did not

mention one single BPD behavior, even though I described the way she is today to

him. It's like we were talking about two different people. Could it be that nada

is NOT BPD? She never was officially diagnosed. My T, who I have been seeing for

years, has a lot of experience with BPDs and is convinced she has it. Fada and

nada were together for 7 years- I feel like he would pick up on it. How could he

not? I have had some limited contact with Fada in my life. I have known him to

be weak, not honor his promises and for a while he was a meth addict. But I have

never known him to lie, and I really think he was being honest about this.

> >

>

Guest guest
Posted

Mozz,

Your fada has never kept in touch with his own daughter.  At the very least,

this is unnatural behavior.  I think it makes a lot more sense to think that

fada has his own issues and his own reasons for only remembering the bubbly part

of your nada and not the crazy part than to think that you have just been making

everything up or that nada had a personality transplant along the way.  Denial

is a very powerful force.  I wouldn't underestimate it.

Best,

Ashana

Your Mail works best with the New Yahoo Optimized IE8. Get it NOW!

http://downloads.yahoo.com/in/internetexplorer/

Guest guest
Posted

Mozz, I have struggled with this same thought for a while now regarding my own

nada. She didn't quite fit the whole picture of BPD but she did had many of the

characteristics. I often felt guilty about being a member of this group

because, maybe, I thought that my nada wasn't like the really evil nadas that I

read about here. That being said my nada was irrational, explosive, emotionally

immature, a bully and never seemed to understand that her behaviour was

inappropriate.

I have come to believe that nada-ness may be fluid and there may be a continuum

of Nada-ness. Therefor there are nada's at the far ends of the continuum as

well as nadas somewhere in the middle. For instance there are nadas that are

" High Functioning " and they would be at the end of the scale that is nearer to

" normal " , then there are the really crazy, evil, " witch archetype " nadas at the

far end near the psychotic and psychopathic diagnosis.

My nada was usually near the " normal " end but occasionally approached the crazy

end.

Sheila

>

> I am so confused. Fada has never really been a part of my life, but his dad

(my grandpa) has always kept in touch. Fada has been living with my grandpa for

the past few years, but we never really talk. Grandpa died last week. I called

Fada to give him my condolences. I thought what the hell? I'm going to ask him

about nada and when they were together. maybe I will get some good insight. I

totally expected some serious validation in the sense that I thought he was

going to tell me how crazy nada was. But he didn't. And I am 99% sure he was not

lying. He was honest about some other things and I asked him to be honest about

nada- that I would not be upset. He said for the most part nada was really fun

and had a " bubbly " personality. WHAT????? Before she was got sick, nada could

really be the life of the party sometimes. But in general I have never known her

to be anything but unhappy. He told me a little about her alcoholic father, who

she never talks about. He admitted he handled everything wrong with ending their

relationship and not having one with me. But I am so confused. He did not

mention one single BPD behavior, even though I described the way she is today to

him. It's like we were talking about two different people. Could it be that nada

is NOT BPD? She never was officially diagnosed. My T, who I have been seeing for

years, has a lot of experience with BPDs and is convinced she has it. Fada and

nada were together for 7 years- I feel like he would pick up on it. How could he

not? I have had some limited contact with Fada in my life. I have known him to

be weak, not honor his promises and for a while he was a meth addict. But I have

never known him to lie, and I really think he was being honest about this.

>

Guest guest
Posted

Mozz Dear,

Words mean things. The labels are important only in that they help us

hang a tag on what happened to us, the water we swam in, the air we

breathed. Call it what you will, we spent years in a toxic soup. The

pains and trauma were real. They are real. BPD gives us a thing to grab

onto as we try to understand why wasnt Mom like other moms, why did I

always feel like a failed adult instead of a successful kid.

God, I have got to write that book bubbling in me. We really have to

learn to swim out of all that mess into clean waters.

Keep healing.

Doug

> > >

> > > I am so confused. Fada has never really been a part of my life,

but

> > his dad (my grandpa) has always kept in touch. Fada has been living

with

> > my grandpa for the past few years, but we never really talk. Grandpa

> > died last week. I called Fada to give him my condolences. I thought

what

> > the hell? I'm going to ask him about nada and when they were

together.

> > maybe I will get some good insight. I totally expected some serious

> > validation in the sense that I thought he was going to tell me how

crazy

> > nada was. But he didn't. And I am 99% sure he was not lying. He was

> > honest about some other things and I asked him to be honest about

nada-

> > that I would not be upset. He said for the most part nada was really

fun

> > and had a " bubbly " personality. WHAT????? Before she was got sick,

nada

> > could really be the life of the party sometimes. But in general I

have

> > never known her to be anything but unhappy. He told me a little

about

> > her alcoholic father, who she never talks about. He admitted he

handled

> > everything wrong with ending their relationship and not having one

with

> > me. But I am so confused. He did not mention one single BPD

behavior,

> > even though I described the way she is today to him. It's like we

were

> > talking about two different people. Could it be that nada is NOT

BPD?

> > She never was officially diagnosed. My T, who I have been seeing for

> > years, has a lot of experience with BPDs and is convinced she has

it.

> > Fada and nada were together for 7 years- I feel like he would pick

up on

> > it. How could he not? I have had some limited contact with Fada in

my

> > life. I have known him to be weak, not honor his promises and for a

> > while he was a meth addict. But I have never known him to lie, and I

> > really think he was being honest about this.

> > >

> >

>

Guest guest
Posted

I always ask myself- why is it so HARD? When we know they were wrong, messed up,

BPD, whatever. Why is it so hard to let it go swim into those clean waters? This

is sort of a gross example, but the only one that comes to mind- it's like I

want to molt and shed my skin, come out a new person.

> > > >

> > > > I am so confused. Fada has never really been a part of my life,

> but

> > > his dad (my grandpa) has always kept in touch. Fada has been living

> with

> > > my grandpa for the past few years, but we never really talk. Grandpa

> > > died last week. I called Fada to give him my condolences. I thought

> what

> > > the hell? I'm going to ask him about nada and when they were

> together.

> > > maybe I will get some good insight. I totally expected some serious

> > > validation in the sense that I thought he was going to tell me how

> crazy

> > > nada was. But he didn't. And I am 99% sure he was not lying. He was

> > > honest about some other things and I asked him to be honest about

> nada-

> > > that I would not be upset. He said for the most part nada was really

> fun

> > > and had a " bubbly " personality. WHAT????? Before she was got sick,

> nada

> > > could really be the life of the party sometimes. But in general I

> have

> > > never known her to be anything but unhappy. He told me a little

> about

> > > her alcoholic father, who she never talks about. He admitted he

> handled

> > > everything wrong with ending their relationship and not having one

> with

> > > me. But I am so confused. He did not mention one single BPD

> behavior,

> > > even though I described the way she is today to him. It's like we

> were

> > > talking about two different people. Could it be that nada is NOT

> BPD?

> > > She never was officially diagnosed. My T, who I have been seeing for

> > > years, has a lot of experience with BPDs and is convinced she has

> it.

> > > Fada and nada were together for 7 years- I feel like he would pick

> up on

> > > it. How could he not? I have had some limited contact with Fada in

> my

> > > life. I have known him to be weak, not honor his promises and for a

> > > while he was a meth addict. But I have never known him to lie, and I

> > > really think he was being honest about this.

> > > >

> > >

> >

>

Guest guest
Posted

I didn't know that about age of onset. I sort of figured they'd have some

characteristics all along. He left her when she was about 32 or 33 so that makes

sense. My T says nada is a high functioning (or was before she got cancer) BPD-

that she could hold up a pot but as soon as anyone pours any water into that pot

she drops it.

> >

> > I am so confused. Fada has never really been a part of my life, but his dad

(my grandpa) has always kept in touch. Fada has been living with my grandpa for

the past few years, but we never really talk. Grandpa died last week. I called

Fada to give him my condolences. I thought what the hell? I'm going to ask him

about nada and when they were together. maybe I will get some good insight. I

totally expected some serious validation in the sense that I thought he was

going to tell me how crazy nada was. But he didn't. And I am 99% sure he was not

lying. He was honest about some other things and I asked him to be honest about

nada- that I would not be upset. He said for the most part nada was really fun

and had a " bubbly " personality. WHAT????? Before she was got sick, nada could

really be the life of the party sometimes. But in general I have never known her

to be anything but unhappy. He told me a little about her alcoholic father, who

she never talks about. He admitted he handled everything wrong with ending their

relationship and not having one with me. But I am so confused. He did not

mention one single BPD behavior, even though I described the way she is today to

him. It's like we were talking about two different people. Could it be that nada

is NOT BPD? She never was officially diagnosed. My T, who I have been seeing for

years, has a lot of experience with BPDs and is convinced she has it. Fada and

nada were together for 7 years- I feel like he would pick up on it. How could he

not? I have had some limited contact with Fada in my life. I have known him to

be weak, not honor his promises and for a while he was a meth addict. But I have

never known him to lie, and I really think he was being honest about this.

> >

>

Guest guest
Posted

Isn't it crazy that KO's doubt their own experiences so much? I do all the time.

It's just insane that I have a hard time believing MYSELF.

> >I am so confused. Fada has never really been a part of my life,

> >but his dad (my grandpa) has always kept in touch. Fada has

> >been living with my grandpa for the past few years, but we

> >never really talk. Grandpa died last week. I called Fada to

> >give him my condolences. I thought what the hell? I'm going to

> >ask him about nada and when they were together. maybe I will

> >get some good insight. I totally expected some serious

> >validation in the sense that I thought he was going to tell me

> >how crazy nada was. But he didn't. And I am 99% sure he was not

> >lying. He was honest about some other things and I asked him to

> >be honest about nada- that I would not be upset. He said for

> >the most part nada was really fun and had a " bubbly "

> >personality. WHAT????? Before she was got sick, nada could

> >really be the life of the party sometimes. But in general I

> >have never known her to be anything but unhappy. He told me a

> >little about her alcoholic father, who she never talks about.

> >He admitted he handled everything wrong with ending their

> >relationship and not having one with me. But I am so confused.

> >He did not mention one single BPD behavior, even though I

> >described the way she is today to him. It's like we were

> >talking about two different people. Could it be that nada is

> >NOT BPD? She never was officially diagnosed. My T, who I have

> >been seeing for years, has a lot of experience with BPDs and is

> >convinced she has it. Fada and nada were together for 7 years-

> >I feel like he would pick up on it. How could he not? I have

> >had some limited contact with Fada in my life. I have known him

> >to be weak, not honor his promises and for a while he was a

> >meth addict. But I have never known him to lie, and I really

> >think he was being honest about this.

>

> --

> Katrina

>

Guest guest
Posted

Hi Sheila,

Yes my nada could be very " normal " too. But it's bizarre how her irrational fear

of abandonment and her total lack of reality with what are normal relationship

boundaries became a form of emotional abuse. And that's what makes it so hard to

explain to others. To others it sounds like I am complaining that nada loves me

too much or that I am ungrateful for all she has done for me. What they don't

understand is the price I have paid over and over for nada's affection. No one

but a fellow KO would ever understand that. It's so infuriating. If I said, Oh

my mom's a psychopath, then people would have sympathy. No one really knows

about BPD. It doesn't even seem to make sense when you read about it. Living it,

I think, is the only way to really get it. That's why I often feel alone and

wonder if I am the crazy one.

> >

> > I am so confused. Fada has never really been a part of my life, but his dad

(my grandpa) has always kept in touch. Fada has been living with my grandpa for

the past few years, but we never really talk. Grandpa died last week. I called

Fada to give him my condolences. I thought what the hell? I'm going to ask him

about nada and when they were together. maybe I will get some good insight. I

totally expected some serious validation in the sense that I thought he was

going to tell me how crazy nada was. But he didn't. And I am 99% sure he was not

lying. He was honest about some other things and I asked him to be honest about

nada- that I would not be upset. He said for the most part nada was really fun

and had a " bubbly " personality. WHAT????? Before she was got sick, nada could

really be the life of the party sometimes. But in general I have never known her

to be anything but unhappy. He told me a little about her alcoholic father, who

she never talks about. He admitted he handled everything wrong with ending their

relationship and not having one with me. But I am so confused. He did not

mention one single BPD behavior, even though I described the way she is today to

him. It's like we were talking about two different people. Could it be that nada

is NOT BPD? She never was officially diagnosed. My T, who I have been seeing for

years, has a lot of experience with BPDs and is convinced she has it. Fada and

nada were together for 7 years- I feel like he would pick up on it. How could he

not? I have had some limited contact with Fada in my life. I have known him to

be weak, not honor his promises and for a while he was a meth addict. But I have

never known him to lie, and I really think he was being honest about this.

> >

>

Guest guest
Posted

When you grow up being told that black is white because that's

how nada wants it to be, even though you can tell the

difference, you learn to doubt your senses and thoughts.

At 10:45 PM 03/28/2010 mozzarella27 wrote:

>Isn't it crazy that KO's doubt their own experiences so much? I

>do all the time. It's just insane that I have a hard time

>believing MYSELF.

--

Katrina

Guest guest
Posted

Katrina

Very perceptive. All our experience is invalidated. The one we look to

most for nurturing in our deveopling years reverses it and draws from us

before we have anything to give. The one we look to for comfort and

reassurance makes us an extension of her happiness, and since she cannot

find it, gives us the message that we are at fault.

And we see and hear, both directly, and indirectly, that she is never

ever to blame or at fault for anything, it is always someone else. Then

she turns to us for her nurture needs. And finds us wanting.

Yes. Small wonder we doubt our experience. At times we can doubt our

very existance.

We hear lots of talk about the suicide rate among BPs. Someone should

study the rate among their children. If we don t really exist, how can

we keep going?

Remember the Velveteen Rabbit? :)

Doug

> >Isn't it crazy that KO's doubt their own experiences so much? I

> >do all the time. It's just insane that I have a hard time

> >believing MYSELF.

>

> --

> Katrina

>

Guest guest
Posted

continuum ? definitely ... It helps me deal with the behaviors of BPD even if

it's never been diagnosed ... My mom has BPD (I say) because she has the

symptoms. As bad as the BP in someone else's life? no... or at least I don't

think so .. that other BP isn't in MY life ...

> >

> > I am so confused. Fada has never really been a part of my life, but his dad

(my grandpa) has always kept in touch. Fada has been living with my grandpa for

the past few years, but we never really talk. Grandpa died last week. I called

Fada to give him my condolences. I thought what the hell? I'm going to ask him

about nada and when they were together. maybe I will get some good insight. I

totally expected some serious validation in the sense that I thought he was

going to tell me how crazy nada was. But he didn't. And I am 99% sure he was not

lying. He was honest about some other things and I asked him to be honest about

nada- that I would not be upset. He said for the most part nada was really fun

and had a " bubbly " personality. WHAT????? Before she was got sick, nada could

really be the life of the party sometimes. But in general I have never known her

to be anything but unhappy. He told me a little about her alcoholic father, who

she never talks about. He admitted he handled everything wrong with ending their

relationship and not having one with me. But I am so confused. He did not

mention one single BPD behavior, even though I described the way she is today to

him. It's like we were talking about two different people. Could it be that nada

is NOT BPD? She never was officially diagnosed. My T, who I have been seeing for

years, has a lot of experience with BPDs and is convinced she has it. Fada and

nada were together for 7 years- I feel like he would pick up on it. How could he

not? I have had some limited contact with Fada in my life. I have known him to

be weak, not honor his promises and for a while he was a meth addict. But I have

never known him to lie, and I really think he was being honest about this.

> >

>

Guest guest
Posted

Lots of people have seen BPD symptoms in my nada and it confuses them. It

doesn't help them for me to talk about it in terms of BPD when they've

(understandably) never even heard about the condition before. ... I don't live

near my nada, but I visit from time to time. I can tell when someone realizes

that the symptoms are signs of a real problem: They don't know if I'm aware or

not, and they're guarded about talking about my nada with me. .. a few would

like to have a name for it ( " Is it strokes? " ), but they must want something that

they know a little about ...

> > >

> > > I am so confused. Fada has never really been a part of my life, but his

dad (my grandpa) has always kept in touch. Fada has been living with my grandpa

for the past few years, but we never really talk. Grandpa died last week. I

called Fada to give him my condolences. I thought what the hell? I'm going to

ask him about nada and when they were together. maybe I will get some good

insight. I totally expected some serious validation in the sense that I thought

he was going to tell me how crazy nada was. But he didn't. And I am 99% sure he

was not lying. He was honest about some other things and I asked him to be

honest about nada- that I would not be upset. He said for the most part nada was

really fun and had a " bubbly " personality. WHAT????? Before she was got sick,

nada could really be the life of the party sometimes. But in general I have

never known her to be anything but unhappy. He told me a little about her

alcoholic father, who she never talks about. He admitted he handled everything

wrong with ending their relationship and not having one with me. But I am so

confused. He did not mention one single BPD behavior, even though I described

the way she is today to him. It's like we were talking about two different

people. Could it be that nada is NOT BPD? She never was officially diagnosed. My

T, who I have been seeing for years, has a lot of experience with BPDs and is

convinced she has it. Fada and nada were together for 7 years- I feel like he

would pick up on it. How could he not? I have had some limited contact with Fada

in my life. I have known him to be weak, not honor his promises and for a while

he was a meth addict. But I have never known him to lie, and I really think he

was being honest about this.

> > >

> >

>

Guest guest
Posted

Doug,

Would you mind expanding on the Velveteen rabbit? It's been a long time since I

read that story. Thanks!

> > >Isn't it crazy that KO's doubt their own experiences so much? I

> > >do all the time. It's just insane that I have a hard time

> > >believing MYSELF.

> >

> > --

> > Katrina

> >

>

Guest guest
Posted

Fellow KO's and Mozz,

The good Lord must have brought me right to this topic for a reason,

because the past few days have been especially difficult. Reality has

been tough, now that I'm working so much on myself and admitting that

I was, all three of us kids were abused. I'm alone in this though

because I'm the only girl, the oldest, and my brothers are treated

differently. So I've gone NC with the family for a spell. I wish the

experiences would go NC with me haha.

What is truth? Often truth is what we want it to be. My truth is not

the same as my brothers' truths. They say each kid grows up in a

different family because of chronology, parent experience, and so on.

I believe my truth is my truth. Not because I want it...because I

don't.

It just is. What happened to me under nada really happened, no matter

how much she wants to villanize me. Lately my SO has been reading up on

bpd and such, and he has come to me several times saying he is sorry we

moved back so close to nada's house, and he's sorry for what I went

through as a kid, and so on. He gets some of it. He validates me. In

fact we all validate one another on here and it is soooooooo

helpful!!!!

During those 'lucid' times when your nada/fada was so charming, happy

and seemed normal - we don't really know why. Could be they were

getting their false needs met through an affair, hiding their drinking,

or some other acting out behind the scenes. As we know, the bpd

turns one way then another to get those false needs met. So don't

worry about being 'judgemental' on your nada/fada because they

seemed to have 'normal' periods. Even we KO's don't know everything

about them.

I cling to Christ to help me get through stuff. He's my big brother.

He looks out for me. I hope others of you understand that too...

Because if I know anything about being a KO, it's that very early in

life I looked for someone, something, that was greater, more powerful,

and had more authority than my nada...and could help me out now and

then.!!!

with Love

Diane

>

> I am so confused. Fada has never really been a part of my life, but

his dad (my grandpa) has always kept in touch. Fada has been living with

my grandpa for the past few years, but we never really talk. Grandpa

died last week. I called Fada to give him my condolences. I thought what

the hell?

Guest guest
Posted

That's my favorite childhood story, hands down.  :)

________________________________

To: WTOAdultChildren1

Sent: Mon, March 29, 2010 12:57:30 PM

Subject: Re: Maybe nada isn't BPD?

 

Doug,

Would you mind expanding on the Velveteen rabbit? It's been a long time since I

read that story. Thanks!

> > >Isn't it crazy that KO's doubt their own experiences so much? I

> > >do all the time. It's just insane that I have a hard time

> > >believing MYSELF.

> >

> > --

> > Katrina

> >

>

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...