Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

I feel really dumb right now

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted

Not only is it hard to believe that they can't get stuff that should be obvious

it gets really tiring trying to explain to them why you are upset. Especially

when they turn it around on you and do the " Geeeee whiz, you're sooooooo

sensitive " BS. Its like you don't even want to express how you are feeling and

" get it out " because you know that you're just going to walk away feeling even

worse than when you started trying to express yourself in the first place!!!!!

You know...on this. I am really starting to appreciate the people in my life

with whom I can have open dialog with. I mean...any relationship is going to

result in feelings being hurt or boundaries being crossed at times but if you

can talk about it you can work through it. My mentor, for example. He can be an

ass sometimes. He can be needy and fear of abandonment like and invalidating.

Lots of people don't like him. Sometimes I don't like him. But what I appreciate

about him is I can say " Dude...you are being an ass right now " or " That is not

true and here is why its not true " or " I think we have a failure to communicate

here...lets start over " and he'll actually think about it for a moment and then

apologize or at least recognize that a boundary has been crossed. I can usually

come out of a disagreement with him feeling like something has been

accomplished.

> >

> > In 4 days I'll have my PhD

> > In 4 days I will have given my final seminar and I'll be finished

> > All I have to do at this point is rehearse my presentation...a presentation

I've given many times over.

> > I'm not nervous

> > I'm not scared

> > I'm not joyful

> > In fact...until a few minutes ago I wasn't feeling anything much at all

about it.

> > But then I thought about my nada and all I can feel is sad.

> >

> > A couple of months ago when I told her I'd scheduled my defense she said " OH

god...what have you done. " She thought I meant for a crime I'd committed.

Gee...she knows me so well. I'd shrug it off as...well most people don't know

what getting a PhD involves...but she's my MOTHER...I've told her time and again

what is involved.

> >

> > A few years ago she asked me what she should tell people when they ask her

what I do for a living. I told her she should tell them I'm a doctoral student

doing research in the biomedical sciences. She said " Can't I just tell them

you're a career student? " What a B*#%^@!!!!! I mean...seriously...what a

B*#$@!!!!!! I PUT MYSELF THROUGH SCHOOL!!! OF COURSE ITS TAKEN AWHILE!!!!!

> >

> > My friends will come. And we'll have a party afterwards. Its not like this

day is going to pass unnoticed or uncelebrated.

> >

> > But for some reason I want to share this accomplishment with my mother. To

have her want to come see me give my seminar. To have her bring a cake and a

bottle of champagne. To get the genuine " Im so proud of you " blah blah blah

thing.

> >

> > And the reason I feel really dumb right now is because I know better than to

expect that kind of thing to ever happen.

> >

> > Thanks for listening.

> >

>

Posted

Hello All,

I find this part of this tread very interesting. I read hear NOT as a KO, but

as a father of two teen girls with a BPD mom to learn how to help them deal

from their perspective of having a mother with BPD. But yet I know what you are

saying if only somewhat, by hearing the way my wife talks to them.

As I was trying to wrap my head around how 'possessive' it must feel at times

the way they refer to a person as THIER 'property' I was trying to think what

the 'opposite' of that would be - the 'right way' if you will. What I realized

is that when I talk about my kids, and what they have done on the good side of

things, I often have a feeling of...........I dont know quite how to describe

it.....but almost like I am amazed for what THEY have done, in spite of what

they have been through by my lack of the part of parenting skills that should

have kicked my BPD's ass out a long time before I did so they could have had a

'normal' environment. I often feel guilt that whatever shortcomings from being

raised by a BPD mom may await them down the road could have been avoided if I

would have had the balls to do what was right a long time ago. Sort of like

because of my lack of action, they were harmed, but yet THEY still survived and

did GREAT.

Almost as if I am at a level sometimes of being a 'notch below' them, where

they have overcome in spite of all. Like I would say " this is my daughter

'Suzy', who has done all she has even though *I* failed her, she has risen

above, and I am SO proud of her "

Not sure if that makes sense to all of you, but to me it seems like the

'opposite'. Like instead of feeling like I 'own' her, I am privileged to be

associated with her, because she/they have just taken the family gene pool up a

level or two.

I am sorry that so many of you have had to go through life with a NON parent

that would not stand up for you or what is right. I am doing my best to not do

that, and thank you all for the knowledge of how to do that.

DKC

DKC

________________________________

To: WTOAdultChildren1

Sent: Sat, January 16, 2010 12:25:15 PM

Subject: Re: I feel really dumb right now

I want to try to respond to all who posted but first I need to address this

one...cause oh do I get it.

So...the whole MY DAUGHTER did/is doing this really cool thing is something my

BPD/NPD fada would do. And like Annie...if it were good it was his

accomplishment and if it were bad then I was a bad shameful person. What really

drives me batty about this is the stealing of your identity in that one phrase.

You cease to become you who accomplished this and become him/her who

accomplished this thing...as though they accomplished it by proxy simply because

they provided one of the gametes necessary to spawn you. I remember at a

Christmas Party a few years back...when my fada and I were still speaking (we

are NC now) he was going around telling everyone " MY DAUGHTER is working on her

doctorate " and I would always reply " Yes I (add emphasis) am. " He would get this

weird look on his face every time I did that. He never got it...that it was I

(add emphasis) doing this really cool stuff. He just didn't see the difference

between saying something like " MY

DAUGHTER... " vs. " This is my Daughter Jen...she is working on... "

My nada on the other hand...when it comes to my career choice " just cant believe

my little girl does that kind of thing " and I quote " I just don't even want to

think about it. " Like its gross or something.

Another thing relating to this. My mentor was trying to prepare me for how I

might feel day of...that many people get really emotional and that I shouldn't

be surprised if I do. I'm normally pretty " together " under pressure but he said

It just might hit you whats going on moments before you get up there...cause its

a really big deal what you're doing Tuesday! And...he keeps comparing this to a

Wedding. He's like this day is as big and important a day as a Wedding. I feel

pretty confident that if it WERE a wedding she'd put the date on her calendar

and show up to play the mother of the bride part. Which got me to thinking...do

I even actually really want her there? What would it actually be like if she

were there? And when I think about THAT the answer is actually probably not.

What I want there is the mother I, and we all, should have had. In the absence

of that I guess its good that I can go ahead and celebrate the way I want to

without dealing wish her

passive aggressive subtly invalidating oh don't mind me but make sure you

notice how much I've suffered to be here BS.

>

> > As far as major accomplishments, when I got into a very competetive medical

school I was understandably excited. When I went to her with this, her response

was " Are you saying that MY DAUGHTER got into medical school? " She repeated the

" MY DAUGHTER " bit over and over. And then she wanted to go to a restaurant of

her choosing to celebrate. By the end of the day I felt like I had my good news

stolen from me.

> >

>

Posted

Jennesis, just wanted to congratulate you on your incredible, wonderful, and

*real* accomplishment. I know that empty space too when you want to share it

with your nada and know how it would go, but give yourself credit to for not

being like Charlie Brown with Lucy and the football. You are taking good care

of you and ensuring a great future for yourself.

> > > >

> > > > In 4 days I'll have my PhD

> > > > In 4 days I will have given my final seminar and I'll be finished

> > > > All I have to do at this point is rehearse my presentation...a

presentation I've given many times over.

> > > > I'm not nervous

> > > > I'm not scared

> > > > I'm not joyful

> > > > In fact...until a few minutes ago I wasn't feeling anything much at all

about it.

> > > > But then I thought about my nada and all I can feel is sad.

> > > >

> > > > A couple of months ago when I told her I'd scheduled my defense she said

" OH god...what have you done. " She thought I meant for a crime I'd committed.

Gee...she knows me so well. I'd shrug it off as...well most people don't know

what getting a PhD involves...but she's my MOTHER...I've told her time and again

what is involved.

> > > >

> > > > A few years ago she asked me what she should tell people when they ask

her what I do for a living. I told her she should tell them I'm a doctoral

student doing research in the biomedical sciences. She said " Can't I just tell

them you're a career student? " What a B*#%^@!!!!! I mean...seriously...what a

B*#$@!!!!!! I PUT MYSELF THROUGH SCHOOL!!! OF COURSE ITS TAKEN AWHILE!!!!!

> > > >

> > > > My friends will come. And we'll have a party afterwards. Its not like

this day is going to pass unnoticed or uncelebrated.

> > > >

> > > > But for some reason I want to share this accomplishment with my mother.

To have her want to come see me give my seminar. To have her bring a cake and a

bottle of champagne. To get the genuine " Im so proud of you " blah blah blah

thing.

> > > >

> > > > And the reason I feel really dumb right now is because I know better

than to expect that kind of thing to ever happen.

> > > >

> > > > Thanks for listening.

> > > >

> > >

> >

>

Posted

Charlie Brown and Lucy...with the football. Thats AWESOME. Man...that little

scenario was so frustrating for me when I was a kid. Still is. I want to scream

at the TV " Don't fall for it Charlie!!!! " while simultaneously pulling the rug

out from underneath Lucy's feet. What an unlikeable character that Lucy is.

Thanks for the message. Hope all is well with you :)

> > > > >

> > > > > In 4 days I'll have my PhD

> > > > > In 4 days I will have given my final seminar and I'll be finished

> > > > > All I have to do at this point is rehearse my presentation...a

presentation I've given many times over.

> > > > > I'm not nervous

> > > > > I'm not scared

> > > > > I'm not joyful

> > > > > In fact...until a few minutes ago I wasn't feeling anything much at

all about it.

> > > > > But then I thought about my nada and all I can feel is sad.

> > > > >

> > > > > A couple of months ago when I told her I'd scheduled my defense she

said " OH god...what have you done. " She thought I meant for a crime I'd

committed. Gee...she knows me so well. I'd shrug it off as...well most people

don't know what getting a PhD involves...but she's my MOTHER...I've told her

time and again what is involved.

> > > > >

> > > > > A few years ago she asked me what she should tell people when they ask

her what I do for a living. I told her she should tell them I'm a doctoral

student doing research in the biomedical sciences. She said " Can't I just tell

them you're a career student? " What a B*#%^@!!!!! I mean...seriously...what a

B*#$@!!!!!! I PUT MYSELF THROUGH SCHOOL!!! OF COURSE ITS TAKEN AWHILE!!!!!

> > > > >

> > > > > My friends will come. And we'll have a party afterwards. Its not like

this day is going to pass unnoticed or uncelebrated.

> > > > >

> > > > > But for some reason I want to share this accomplishment with my

mother. To have her want to come see me give my seminar. To have her bring a

cake and a bottle of champagne. To get the genuine " Im so proud of you " blah

blah blah thing.

> > > > >

> > > > > And the reason I feel really dumb right now is because I know better

than to expect that kind of thing to ever happen.

> > > > >

> > > > > Thanks for listening.

> > > > >

> > > >

> > >

> >

>

Posted

My " mother " says all kinds of invalidating dumb stuff. Thanks for your empathy

:)

Re: Nursing school- You can do it woman!!!! One step/day at a time :)

> > >

> > > In 4 days I'll have my PhD

> > > In 4 days I will have given my final seminar and I'll be finished

> > > All I have to do at this point is rehearse my presentation. All I have

> to do at this point is rehearse

> > > I'm not nervous

> > > I'm not scared

> > > I'm not joyful

> > > In fact...until a few minutes ago I wasn't feeling anything much at

> all about it.

> > > But then I thought about my nada and all I can feel is sad.

> > >

> > > A couple of months ago when I told her I'd scheduled my defense she

> said " OH god...what have you done. " She thought I meant for a crime I'd

> committed. Gee...she knows me so well. I'd shrug it off as...well most people

> don't know what getting a PhD involves...but she's my MOTHER...I've told her

> time and again what is involved.

> > >

> > > A few years ago she asked me what she should tell people when they ask

> her what I do for a living. I told her she should tell them I'm a doctoral

> student doing research in the biomedical sciences. She said " Can't I just

> tell them you're a career student? " What a B*#%^@!!!!! I mean...seriously.

> A few years ago she asked me what she should tell people when they ask her

> what I

> > >

> > > My friends will come. And we'll have a party afterwards. Its not like

> this day is going to pass unnoticed or uncelebrated.

> > >

> > > But for some reason I want to share this accomplishment with my

> mother. To have her want to come see me give my seminar. To have her bring a

cake

> and a bottle of champagne. To get the genuine " Im so proud of you " blah

> blah blah thing.

> > >

> > > And the reason I feel really dumb right now is because I know better

> than to expect that kind of thing to ever happen.

> > >

> > > Thanks for listening.

> > >

> >

>

>

>

>

>

>

Posted

Hi ,

Thank you for this post. I can imagine how you must feel reading here with the

feeling that you could have saved your daughters sooner than you did. But please

try to realize that you are saving your daughters NOW. They are still very young

(relatively speaking) and to have an enlightened witness that can help to

validate their experience will do wonders to counteract any damage done by your

BPD ex spouse. I know that I look back on some of the people that validated my

experience over the years and I know that this is part of the reason that I

didn't fall into utter madness and was able to retain my identity mostly intact.

Even if you are unwilling at this point to cut yourself some slack I'd certainly

like to give you a bit of rope. What you are doing is HUGE so please give

yourself some credit.

There may come a day that they express anger with you for not doing something

sooner...or there may not. If that day comes you can apologize then. Just

remember that we are all capable of making mistakes and many people stay in

toxic relationships for what seem like good reasons at the time...and later

just...well...just DON'T. Been there...done that.

Regarding your statement " this is my daughter 'Suzy', who has done all she has

even though *I* failed her, she has risen above, and I am SO proud of her "

I'd like to amend it to read " this is my daughter 'Suzy', who has done all she

has and I am SO proud of her " .

See, there is nothing wrong with the original statement if made to a friend

outside your daughters presence. That would be a time and place for you to be

seen and for your issues being married to a person with BPD to be worked

through. Though...in her presence, and if she has any issues about " being seen "

it could be unconsciously heard as Dad drawing attention to himself and his

perceive failures...which is something that people do at times even in the

absence of a personality disorder. I've made these fumbles of speech myself so I

know that is not what it is about...and it is not how you mean it however...and

I'm not sure how to word this but it's almost a Pavlovian dog response to

something that should be about her being made about someone else. Does that make

any kind of sense? I mean...I guess what I'm trying to say is you can tell her

that you feel privileged to know her without pointing out that you feel you have

failed her. That is, at least, my initial gut reaction upon reading that

statement...bearing in mind that I still have issues that I'm working through.

Best to you and your daughters :)

> >

> > > As far as major accomplishments, when I got into a very competetive

medical school I was understandably excited. When I went to her with this, her

response was " Are you saying that MY DAUGHTER got into medical school? " She

repeated the " MY DAUGHTER " bit over and over. And then she wanted to go to a

restaurant of her choosing to celebrate. By the end of the day I felt like I

had my good news stolen from me.

> > >

> >

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

Posted

" Almost as if I am at a level sometimes of being a 'notch below' them, where

they have overcome in spite of all. Like I would say " this is my daughter

'Suzy', who has done all she has even though *I* failed her, she has risen

above, and I am SO proud of her "

Did you ever think that maybe your daughters found the courage to keep on going

and " rise above " the way they have because they had a dad who actually had the

capacity to notice what they were going through, and care enough about it to

think it through and end up doing the right thing for them?

Nobody gets what's really going on in a BPD family overnight. By the time you

realize how wrong something is, you're mired neck deep in it. You don't want to

break the family up unless you really, really have to. There's a lot to sort

out: " What about the finances? " " Are the kids really going to be better off

away from their mom? " " Do I want to start all over again alone? " " How awful is

the divorce going to be and do I really want to put everyone through it? Will

it really be worth it? "

With all of that to mull through, it's understandable that most people might

take a while to really make the decision and extricate themselves from the

situation. BUT, even if it takes some time, you are still sensitive to what the

kids are going through, and you are seeing it and evaluating it, and you care

about them, and kids notice that. And it makes a difference.

My father died suddenly when I was 12. I can't say he was a whole lot of help

dealing with my BPD nada. But, once upon a time, on one of those rare occasions

I had to go somewhere with him in the car alone (he was usually escaping from

BPD nada at work), I told him about some upsetting thing she had done. I can't

remember what it was now...I was maybe six. She had this way of dragging out of

me every single little bitty tiny bit of detail about my day at school and then

critiquing the way I had handled whatever happened. I was supposed to look at

it exactly as she would have looked at it, felt exactly the way she wanted me to

feel about it, and do whatever she told me to do. And I really hated this, and

I told my dad about it.

And, although he wasn't much help beyond this one conversation, he did give me

support about it. And he said, " Sometimes it's best not to tell Mom anything. "

I took that advice to heart, and it saved me *some* crap over the years. (There

was plenty other crap, but oh, well.)

When he died when I was 12, I did have the knowledge that my dad cared about me.

I just found out through an elderly relative that he really was considering

leaving my mom, and although he didn't live to do that, the fact that he gave a

shit, and wasn't just completely checked out, did make some difference to me as

I grew up. I shudder to think that I might still be mired in BPD

dysfunctionality with her without some degree of independent confirmation that

something was really wrong there, and that there were other ways than hers of

looking at life.

Imagine, then, the ten-thousand-fold more positive impact of having a dad who

actually did get the kids out, even if it took some time to see it and do it?

THAT'S why your daughters have done so well.

Dude...ya gotta give yourself some credit here. ;)

I didn't mean to derail the thread. Jennesis, I have been wanting to write for

several days, and life has been too crazy and I haven't had the time to actually

write anything.

Congratulations on your Ph.D. I can't imagine the years and years of struggle

and hard work. It's natural to have that moment of sadness without the support

of a parent who cares enough to " get " anything about you or your life's work.

It's a shame and I'm sorry.

I don't know, maybe it would help to think of it as, " I don't need that in my

life anymore and now I'm free to have better. " You had friends who threw you a

party, so it seems you certainly do. Be assured you deserve it! You've honored

your right to craft a full life in spite of her, and you have people who love

you more than she ever did. Those are things some KO's are never able to do.

Best,

--LL.

Posted

Jennesis,

Thanks for the response.

The way I feel at times in NOT something that I say outloud other than to my T

and my best friend that I confide in. I try not to express it at all around my

kids, although I am sure they can tell how I feel on occasion. My oldest has

told me " Dad, you did the best you could at the time " and she really seems to

get the meaning of that, as in 'with the knowledge, skill, resources, etc...

that were available at the time.

I think I probably come across more negative in my writing than I actually am.

It is more those 'back of the mind thoughts' that are always looking for

answers, although there may never be 'an answer', just a vauge maybe this or

that.

I DO realize that I am helping them now, even though I hadn't before as much as

I would have liked to if I could get a 'do over'. Of course we dont usually get

'do overs' in real life, so we must keep on doing the best we can today and

tomorrow, while learning from yesterday.

DKC

________________________________

To: WTOAdultChildren1

Sent: Sat, January 16, 2010 7:14:56 PM

Subject: Re: I feel really dumb right now

Hi ,

Thank you for this post. I can imagine how you must feel reading here with the

feeling that you could have saved your daughters sooner than you did. But please

try to realize that you are saving your daughters NOW. They are still very young

(relatively speaking) and to have an enlightened witness that can help to

validate their experience will do wonders to counteract any damage done by your

BPD ex spouse. I know that I look back on some of the people that validated my

experience over the years and I know that this is part of the reason that I

didn't fall into utter madness and was able to retain my identity mostly intact.

Even if you are unwilling at this point to cut yourself some slack I'd certainly

like to give you a bit of rope. What you are doing is HUGE so please give

yourself some credit.

There may come a day that they express anger with you for not doing something

sooner...or there may not. If that day comes you can apologize then. Just

remember that we are all capable of making mistakes and many people stay in

toxic relationships for what seem like good reasons at the time...and later

just...well. ..just DON'T. Been there...done that.

Regarding your statement " this is my daughter 'Suzy', who has done all she has

even though *I* failed her, she has risen above, and I am SO proud of her "

I'd like to amend it to read " this is my daughter 'Suzy', who has done all she

has and I am SO proud of her " .

See, there is nothing wrong with the original statement if made to a friend

outside your daughters presence. That would be a time and place for you to be

seen and for your issues being married to a person with BPD to be worked

through. Though...in her presence, and if she has any issues about " being seen "

it could be unconsciously heard as Dad drawing attention to himself and his

perceive failures...which is something that people do at times even in the

absence of a personality disorder. I've made these fumbles of speech myself so I

know that is not what it is about...and it is not how you mean it however...and

I'm not sure how to word this but it's almost a Pavlovian dog response to

something that should be about her being made about someone else. Does that make

any kind of sense? I mean...I guess what I'm trying to say is you can tell her

that you feel privileged to know her without pointing out that you feel you have

failed her. That is, at least, my

initial gut reaction upon reading that statement... bearing in mind that I

still have issues that I'm working through.

Best to you and your daughters :)

> >

> > > As far as major accomplishments, when I got into a very competetive

medical school I was understandably excited. When I went to her with this, her

response was " Are you saying that MY DAUGHTER got into medical school? " She

repeated the " MY DAUGHTER " bit over and over. And then she wanted to go to a

restaurant of her choosing to celebrate. By the end of the day I felt like I

had my good news stolen from me.

> > >

> >

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

Posted

Roganda,

Thanks for the reply. See my other response too to this tread please. I dont

show my doubt too much in myself. So I DO know that I am making a difference in

thier lives. It the nagging little guy in the back of my head that wonders if I

" could have done better " , but I have to let him go sometimes ;).

I do know I have made a huge difference to them. People (who dont know the bad

side of BPD mom) are often telling me 'what a great dad you are', sometimes to

the point friends who are dads give me crap becasue I am used as a 'model dad'

in their conflicts at home as in " DKC does x,y,and z with his kids, why dont

you " type of thing. I guess part of it is that I have always truely loved being

a dad.....both teaching by example, and just spending time with them.

Luckily thier mom was a great mom from ages of 0 to about 11-12, when they

started getting thier own opinions....didnt go real well then. So it had only

been the last few years that have gotten really bad. I still remember when my

youngest was 12 and we were driving after her an mom had a fight. She asked with

tears streaming down her face " why does mom hate *me* Sooooo much, am I that

bad?? " like she actually thought maybe she was that bad. That was the day I knew

I needed to start seeing a T to get my shit together and start standing up for

what is right. Since then, I have always stood up for them when they are in the

rights. Of course I would take the 'parent' side too when they were in the

wrong.....cnat just let them think mom is always wrong when she is not at times.

A phrase Ie use often now is " sometimes the kid has to be the bigger person when

the parent doesnt know how to act. I sucks, but its a fact of life " They seem to

get it. They are learing to let things go and just walk away too, which is much

better than arguing with a BPD.

Thanks, DKC

________________________________

To: WTOAdultChildren1

Sent: Sun, January 17, 2010 10:19:56 AM

Subject: Re: I feel really dumb right now

" Almost as if I am at a level sometimes of being a 'notch below' them, where

they have overcome in spite of all. Like I would say " this is my daughter

'Suzy', who has done all she has even though *I* failed her, she has risen

above, and I am SO proud of her "

Did you ever think that maybe your daughters found the courage to keep on going

and " rise above " the way they have because they had a dad who actually had the

capacity to notice what they were going through, and care enough about it to

think it through and end up doing the right thing for them?

Nobody gets what's really going on in a BPD family overnight. By the time you

realize how wrong something is, you're mired neck deep in it. You don't want to

break the family up unless you really, really have to. There's a lot to sort

out: " What about the finances? " " Are the kids really going to be better off

away from their mom? " " Do I want to start all over again alone? " " How awful is

the divorce going to be and do I really want to put everyone through it? Will

it really be worth it? "

With all of that to mull through, it's understandable that most people might

take a while to really make the decision and extricate themselves from the

situation. BUT, even if it takes some time, you are still sensitive to what the

kids are going through, and you are seeing it and evaluating it, and you care

about them, and kids notice that. And it makes a difference.

My father died suddenly when I was 12. I can't say he was a whole lot of help

dealing with my BPD nada. But, once upon a time, on one of those rare occasions

I had to go somewhere with him in the car alone (he was usually escaping from

BPD nada at work), I told him about some upsetting thing she had done. I can't

remember what it was now...I was maybe six. She had this way of dragging out of

me every single little bitty tiny bit of detail about my day at school and then

critiquing the way I had handled whatever happened. I was supposed to look at

it exactly as she would have looked at it, felt exactly the way she wanted me to

feel about it, and do whatever she told me to do. And I really hated this, and

I told my dad about it.

And, although he wasn't much help beyond this one conversation, he did give me

support about it. And he said, " Sometimes it's best not to tell Mom anything. "

I took that advice to heart, and it saved me *some* crap over the years. (There

was plenty other crap, but oh, well.)

When he died when I was 12, I did have the knowledge that my dad cared about me.

I just found out through an elderly relative that he really was considering

leaving my mom, and although he didn't live to do that, the fact that he gave a

shit, and wasn't just completely checked out, did make some difference to me as

I grew up. I shudder to think that I might still be mired in BPD

dysfunctionality with her without some degree of independent confirmation that

something was really wrong there, and that there were other ways than hers of

looking at life.

Imagine, then, the ten-thousand- fold more positive impact of having a dad who

actually did get the kids out, even if it took some time to see it and do it?

THAT'S why your daughters have done so well.

Dude...ya gotta give yourself some credit here. ;)

I didn't mean to derail the thread. Jennesis, I have been wanting to write for

several days, and life has been too crazy and I haven't had the time to actually

write anything.

Congratulations on your Ph.D. I can't imagine the years and years of struggle

and hard work. It's natural to have that moment of sadness without the support

of a parent who cares enough to " get " anything about you or your life's work.

It's a shame and I'm sorry.

I don't know, maybe it would help to think of it as, " I don't need that in my

life anymore and now I'm free to have better. " You had friends who threw you a

party, so it seems you certainly do. Be assured you deserve it! You've honored

your right to craft a full life in spite of her, and you have people who love

you more than she ever did. Those are things some KO's are never able to do.

Best,

--LL.

Posted

Good luck -- I'm sure you will do well!!!!! We can't count on them to support

us. I was the first person in my family to get a graduate degree. My mother

wouldn't drive an hour and a half to see me graduate from law school. Congrats

on your PH.D!!!!!!

________________________________

To: WTOAdultChildren1

Sent: Sat, January 16, 2010 4:20:31 AM

Subject: Re: I feel really dumb right now

Dear DOCTOR:

((((HUGS)))) )

I wish I had words. But I'm crying for you, too. Its so odd how we run through

our lives doing well, and all of the sudden we just hit a spot where all we can

do is stare at an abyss of where our real mothers should be. It just leave you

feeling dumbfounded when it still turns up as a surprise. I think we all have

that happen.

One thing you can take to the bank: My sons are 7 and 11. If they become have

the grownups you are--to pursue a goal through so many years of hard work and

stress and sacrifice--I would be the happiest woman alive. Whether they become

PhDs or factory workers, I would be proud of them for showing such character.

Not only does this PhD speak of a huge accomplishment, it speaks to your

incredible fortitude.

I, for one, am VERY proud of you!! Good work--have a glass of wine for me to

celebrate!!

>

> In 4 days I'll have my PhD

> In 4 days I will have given my final seminar and I'll be finished

> All I have to do at this point is rehearse my presentation. ..a presentation

I've given many times over.

> I'm not nervous

> I'm not scared

> I'm not joyful

> In fact...until a few minutes ago I wasn't feeling anything much at all about

it.

> But then I thought about my nada and all I can feel is sad.

>

> A couple of months ago when I told her I'd scheduled my defense she said " OH

god...what have you done. " She thought I meant for a crime I'd committed.

Gee...she knows me so well. I'd shrug it off as...well most people don't know

what getting a PhD involves...but she's my MOTHER...I've told her time and again

what is involved.

>

> A few years ago she asked me what she should tell people when they ask her

what I do for a living. I told her she should tell them I'm a doctoral student

doing research in the biomedical sciences. She said " Can't I just tell them

you're a career student? " What a B*#%^@!!!!! I mean...seriously. ..what a

B*#$@!!!!!! I PUT MYSELF THROUGH SCHOOL!!! OF COURSE ITS TAKEN AWHILE!!!!!

>

> My friends will come. And we'll have a party afterwards. Its not like this day

is going to pass unnoticed or uncelebrated.

>

> But for some reason I want to share this accomplishment with my mother. To

have her want to come see me give my seminar. To have her bring a cake and a

bottle of champagne. To get the genuine " Im so proud of you " blah blah blah

thing.

>

> And the reason I feel really dumb right now is because I know better than to

expect that kind of thing to ever happen.

>

> Thanks for listening.

>

Posted

Dear Jennesis,

(First off, what a wonderful name!)

I just joined this group, moments ago and yours was the first thread I've read;

clearly, I am home. :) Tons of wonderful, loving responses in this thread, but I

wanted to share just one more. Hopefully, this is on-target for this forum, as

I haven't read through any other threads yet.

Your subject header struck me: I wrote a similar comment in my journal last

week feeling " hopeful to the point of idiocy " about wanting a different kind of

reaction from my mom. I've been giving this some thought over the week,

and....I don't think either one of us should feel dumb. I think wanting,

*hoping* for a loving, supportive mom--even while knowing it's not

possible--isn't dumb. It's the innate knowledge of what *should* be, of what we

deserve from a mom. And maybe it's important for us to *always* recognize and

feel the dissonance of what is and what should be--so that we know the

difference and don't start to internalize the " normalness " of a hurtful mom. So

I prefer to think of it as a good kind of optimism and internal barometer--and

maybe it never goes completely away. (hasn't for me yet...44 years and

counting.) That's my story and I'm sticking to it, cuz I know I'll have more

unrealistic, unmet hopes again in the future. :)

Happily, there seems to be many folks who recognize and laud your exceptional

accomplishment--including me. :) Congratulations!! May the love and support of

your many friends provide many moms'-worth of love and support.

-

>

> In 4 days I'll have my PhD

> In 4 days I will have given my final seminar and I'll be finished

> All I have to do at this point is rehearse my presentation...a presentation

I've given many times over.

> I'm not nervous

> I'm not scared

> I'm not joyful

> In fact...until a few minutes ago I wasn't feeling anything much at all about

it.

> But then I thought about my nada and all I can feel is sad.

>

> A couple of months ago when I told her I'd scheduled my defense she said " OH

god...what have you done. " She thought I meant for a crime I'd committed.

Gee...she knows me so well. I'd shrug it off as...well most people don't know

what getting a PhD involves...but she's my MOTHER...I've told her time and again

what is involved.

>

> A few years ago she asked me what she should tell people when they ask her

what I do for a living. I told her she should tell them I'm a doctoral student

doing research in the biomedical sciences. She said " Can't I just tell them

you're a career student? " What a B*#%^@!!!!! I mean...seriously...what a

B*#$@!!!!!! I PUT MYSELF THROUGH SCHOOL!!! OF COURSE ITS TAKEN AWHILE!!!!!

>

> My friends will come. And we'll have a party afterwards. Its not like this day

is going to pass unnoticed or uncelebrated.

>

> But for some reason I want to share this accomplishment with my mother. To

have her want to come see me give my seminar. To have her bring a cake and a

bottle of champagne. To get the genuine " Im so proud of you " blah blah blah

thing.

>

> And the reason I feel really dumb right now is because I know better than to

expect that kind of thing to ever happen.

>

> Thanks for listening.

>

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...