Guest guest Posted January 15, 2010 Report Posted January 15, 2010 In 4 days I'll have my PhD In 4 days I will have given my final seminar and I'll be finished All I have to do at this point is rehearse my presentation...a presentation I've given many times over. I'm not nervous I'm not scared I'm not joyful In fact...until a few minutes ago I wasn't feeling anything much at all about it. But then I thought about my nada and all I can feel is sad. A couple of months ago when I told her I'd scheduled my defense she said " OH god...what have you done. " She thought I meant for a crime I'd committed. Gee...she knows me so well. I'd shrug it off as...well most people don't know what getting a PhD involves...but she's my MOTHER...I've told her time and again what is involved. A few years ago she asked me what she should tell people when they ask her what I do for a living. I told her she should tell them I'm a doctoral student doing research in the biomedical sciences. She said " Can't I just tell them you're a career student? " What a B*#%^@!!!!! I mean...seriously...what a B*#$@!!!!!! I PUT MYSELF THROUGH SCHOOL!!! OF COURSE ITS TAKEN AWHILE!!!!! My friends will come. And we'll have a party afterwards. Its not like this day is going to pass unnoticed or uncelebrated. But for some reason I want to share this accomplishment with my mother. To have her want to come see me give my seminar. To have her bring a cake and a bottle of champagne. To get the genuine " Im so proud of you " blah blah blah thing. And the reason I feel really dumb right now is because I know better than to expect that kind of thing to ever happen. Thanks for listening. Quote
Guest guest Posted January 15, 2010 Report Posted January 15, 2010 This brings tears to my eyes. I can say that there is a little girl in you who wants her mother's encouragement and will never get it. She can get that love and encouragement from you. I know it's not the same, but it's something. Congratulations on receiving your PhD. That is such a great accomplishment. I am proud of you. Deanna > > In 4 days I'll have my PhD > In 4 days I will have given my final seminar and I'll be finished > All I have to do at this point is rehearse my presentation...a presentation I've given many times over. > I'm not nervous > I'm not scared > I'm not joyful > In fact...until a few minutes ago I wasn't feeling anything much at all about it. > But then I thought about my nada and all I can feel is sad. > > A couple of months ago when I told her I'd scheduled my defense she said " OH god...what have you done. " She thought I meant for a crime I'd committed. Gee...she knows me so well. I'd shrug it off as...well most people don't know what getting a PhD involves...but she's my MOTHER...I've told her time and again what is involved. > > A few years ago she asked me what she should tell people when they ask her what I do for a living. I told her she should tell them I'm a doctoral student doing research in the biomedical sciences. She said " Can't I just tell them you're a career student? " What a B*#%^@!!!!! I mean...seriously...what a B*#$@!!!!!! I PUT MYSELF THROUGH SCHOOL!!! OF COURSE ITS TAKEN AWHILE!!!!! > > My friends will come. And we'll have a party afterwards. Its not like this day is going to pass unnoticed or uncelebrated. > > But for some reason I want to share this accomplishment with my mother. To have her want to come see me give my seminar. To have her bring a cake and a bottle of champagne. To get the genuine " Im so proud of you " blah blah blah thing. > > And the reason I feel really dumb right now is because I know better than to expect that kind of thing to ever happen. > > Thanks for listening. > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 15, 2010 Report Posted January 15, 2010 My daughter is still in undergrad, but planning on going for a Phd. Just when I heard her even have that as a career ambition before she started college almost made me weep proudly with joy. She is the kind, like you, that can take the long hard road to get to where you really want. You both have foresight, determination, all that good stuff. I myself have done well in life but never went to college. Biggest regret of my life. I admire those who do, especialy for the long haul. So even if she cant be properly proud of you, I/we are!!! Sometimes we have to remember that BPD is a serious mental illness no matter how good they can fake normal to the outside world. They CANT get it. We wish they could. So take this as a 'high five' from someone who thinks in terms of how a 'normal' parent would, since she cant. We are proud. DKC ________________________________ To: WTOAdultChildren1 Sent: Fri, January 15, 2010 5:41:40 PM Subject: I feel really dumb right now In 4 days I'll have my PhD In 4 days I will have given my final seminar and I'll be finished All I have to do at this point is rehearse my presentation. ..a presentation I've given many times over. I'm not nervous I'm not scared I'm not joyful In fact...until a few minutes ago I wasn't feeling anything much at all about it. But then I thought about my nada and all I can feel is sad. A couple of months ago when I told her I'd scheduled my defense she said " OH god...what have you done. " She thought I meant for a crime I'd committed. Gee...she knows me so well. I'd shrug it off as...well most people don't know what getting a PhD involves...but she's my MOTHER...I've told her time and again what is involved. A few years ago she asked me what she should tell people when they ask her what I do for a living. I told her she should tell them I'm a doctoral student doing research in the biomedical sciences. She said " Can't I just tell them you're a career student? " What a B*#%^@!!!!! I mean...seriously. ..what a B*#$@!!!!!! I PUT MYSELF THROUGH SCHOOL!!! OF COURSE ITS TAKEN AWHILE!!!!! My friends will come. And we'll have a party afterwards. Its not like this day is going to pass unnoticed or uncelebrated. But for some reason I want to share this accomplishment with my mother. To have her want to come see me give my seminar. To have her bring a cake and a bottle of champagne. To get the genuine " Im so proud of you " blah blah blah thing. And the reason I feel really dumb right now is because I know better than to expect that kind of thing to ever happen. Thanks for listening. Quote
Guest guest Posted January 15, 2010 Report Posted January 15, 2010 I, too, have tears in my eyes right now for you Jennesis. It is not only the weak, bad moments that we need a mother, but the triumphant ones as well. I'm so sorry you don't have the mother you deserved, cheering for you, proud of you. This is a huge accomplishment for you and you should feel so incredibly proud, but I understand how you cannot and how there is pain in your heart. It's almost like deep down thinking " NOW do you think I am good enough/smart enough? NOW that I have a phD, will you love me? " But the answer is always, always the same. They are not capable of support, negative or POSITIVE, or real unconditional love. I'm glad you are having a celebration with friends who are proud of you. You deserve that. You deserve a big cheering section. Congratulations to you. WE are proud of you, too. Way to go! > > > > In 4 days I'll have my PhD > > In 4 days I will have given my final seminar and I'll be finished > > All I have to do at this point is rehearse my presentation...a presentation I've given many times over. > > I'm not nervous > > I'm not scared > > I'm not joyful > > In fact...until a few minutes ago I wasn't feeling anything much at all about it. > > But then I thought about my nada and all I can feel is sad. > > > > A couple of months ago when I told her I'd scheduled my defense she said " OH god...what have you done. " She thought I meant for a crime I'd committed. Gee...she knows me so well. I'd shrug it off as...well most people don't know what getting a PhD involves...but she's my MOTHER...I've told her time and again what is involved. > > > > A few years ago she asked me what she should tell people when they ask her what I do for a living. I told her she should tell them I'm a doctoral student doing research in the biomedical sciences. She said " Can't I just tell them you're a career student? " What a B*#%^@!!!!! I mean...seriously...what a B*#$@!!!!!! I PUT MYSELF THROUGH SCHOOL!!! OF COURSE ITS TAKEN AWHILE!!!!! > > > > My friends will come. And we'll have a party afterwards. Its not like this day is going to pass unnoticed or uncelebrated. > > > > But for some reason I want to share this accomplishment with my mother. To have her want to come see me give my seminar. To have her bring a cake and a bottle of champagne. To get the genuine " Im so proud of you " blah blah blah thing. > > > > And the reason I feel really dumb right now is because I know better than to expect that kind of thing to ever happen. > > > > Thanks for listening. > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 15, 2010 Report Posted January 15, 2010 Thanks guys I'm sorry I made you cry though. Deanna- I hadn't really thought of it as the " inner child " wanting her mommy, but I think you are right Deanna! Maybe I'll let her play some guitar hero and eat ice cream for dinner tonight And real-mom: I know...honestly for me...lots of times its the triumphant moments where it really hits me that I had a couple of really crappy ass parents. Its like...I know that she didn't put this on her calendar, that she wont call me to wish me luck, and that she won't call me to congratulate me. Next time I talk to her she'll ask me what's new and I'll have to remind her that I've graduated and then I'll get the pouty insincere " well Im sooooooory " followed by an uncomfortable chuckle and an " I didn't know it was so important to you...of course Congratulations sweetie " BS thing. Just thought of something...maybe part of what's upsetting me right now is knowing that I'll be going through that little conversation in a month or two. Like knowing I'm going to have to hear that puts a cloud over the whole thing. Again thanks both of you for your words > > > > > > In 4 days I'll have my PhD > > > In 4 days I will have given my final seminar and I'll be finished > > > All I have to do at this point is rehearse my presentation...a presentation I've given many times over. > > > I'm not nervous > > > I'm not scared > > > I'm not joyful > > > In fact...until a few minutes ago I wasn't feeling anything much at all about it. > > > But then I thought about my nada and all I can feel is sad. > > > > > > A couple of months ago when I told her I'd scheduled my defense she said " OH god...what have you done. " She thought I meant for a crime I'd committed. Gee...she knows me so well. I'd shrug it off as...well most people don't know what getting a PhD involves...but she's my MOTHER...I've told her time and again what is involved. > > > > > > A few years ago she asked me what she should tell people when they ask her what I do for a living. I told her she should tell them I'm a doctoral student doing research in the biomedical sciences. She said " Can't I just tell them you're a career student? " What a B*#%^@!!!!! I mean...seriously...what a B*#$@!!!!!! I PUT MYSELF THROUGH SCHOOL!!! OF COURSE ITS TAKEN AWHILE!!!!! > > > > > > My friends will come. And we'll have a party afterwards. Its not like this day is going to pass unnoticed or uncelebrated. > > > > > > But for some reason I want to share this accomplishment with my mother. To have her want to come see me give my seminar. To have her bring a cake and a bottle of champagne. To get the genuine " Im so proud of you " blah blah blah thing. > > > > > > And the reason I feel really dumb right now is because I know better than to expect that kind of thing to ever happen. > > > > > > Thanks for listening. > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 15, 2010 Report Posted January 15, 2010 Thanks , Wow...your daughter is a lucky girl to have that kind of support! I mean...seriously. Since this is one of those pursuits where the downs almost outweigh the ups as you go through it it will be helpful to her to know she has your support when the going gets tough! I'm thinking...this weekend is going to be a bit up and down for me emotional roller coaster wise so its nice to know that I have the support of the group > > My daughter is still in undergrad, but planning on going for a Phd. Just when I heard her even have that as a career ambition before she started college almost made me weep proudly with joy. She is the kind, like you, that can take the long hard road to get to where you really want. You both have foresight, determination, all that good stuff. I myself have done well in life but never went to college. Biggest regret of my life. I admire those who do, especialy for the long haul. > > So even if she cant be properly proud of you, I/we are!!! Sometimes we have to remember that BPD is a serious mental illness no matter how good they can fake normal to the outside world. They CANT get it. We wish they could. > > So take this as a 'high five' from someone who thinks in terms of how a 'normal' parent would, since she cant. We are proud. > > DKC > > > > > ________________________________ > > To: WTOAdultChildren1 > Sent: Fri, January 15, 2010 5:41:40 PM > Subject: I feel really dumb right now > > > In 4 days I'll have my PhD > In 4 days I will have given my final seminar and I'll be finished > All I have to do at this point is rehearse my presentation. ..a presentation I've given many times over. > I'm not nervous > I'm not scared > I'm not joyful > In fact...until a few minutes ago I wasn't feeling anything much at all about it. > But then I thought about my nada and all I can feel is sad. > > A couple of months ago when I told her I'd scheduled my defense she said " OH god...what have you done. " She thought I meant for a crime I'd committed. Gee...she knows me so well. I'd shrug it off as...well most people don't know what getting a PhD involves...but she's my MOTHER...I've told her time and again what is involved. > > A few years ago she asked me what she should tell people when they ask her what I do for a living. I told her she should tell them I'm a doctoral student doing research in the biomedical sciences. She said " Can't I just tell them you're a career student? " What a B*#%^@!!!!! I mean...seriously. ..what a B*#$@!!!!!! I PUT MYSELF THROUGH SCHOOL!!! OF COURSE ITS TAKEN AWHILE!!!!! > > My friends will come. And we'll have a party afterwards. Its not like this day is going to pass unnoticed or uncelebrated. > > But for some reason I want to share this accomplishment with my mother. To have her want to come see me give my seminar. To have her bring a cake and a bottle of champagne. To get the genuine " Im so proud of you " blah blah blah thing. > > And the reason I feel really dumb right now is because I know better than to expect that kind of thing to ever happen. > > Thanks for listening. > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 15, 2010 Report Posted January 15, 2010 ((((((Jennesis))))))) If your mother were mentally healthy, she would share your happiness with you and she'd be so proud of you for what you've accomplished. Putting yourself through a doctoral program is a remarkable achievement! But she's too dysfunctional to relate to you in a normal way, and that is sad. Truly sad. It is hard to let go of the hope and expectation that she might be able to show you the affection and approval you deserve, but maybe it will help to think of her as a 2 year old. You wouldn't expect a 2 year old to understand and be happy for you. Nadas are sort of emotionally feeble-minded; they lack the capacity for empathy and are totally self-absorbed, and it truly is sad. Its like, when we come across an adult who is severely intellectually impaired, we immediately comprehend that we can't expect this person to relate to us in a normal way. We effortlessly drop our expectations that its even possible to have a normal adult relationship with a severely intellectually impaired adult. But we have no context to pattern a similar response to an individual who looks like an adult, and who speaks to us with an adult's level of intelligence... and yet has the emotional development level of a small child. We don't " get " that, and we have to force ourselves to comprehend it. Yet that's the reality. I'm so happy for you that you have friends who will be there to celebrate with you, though. I'm sure all of us here at this Group will be toasting you and celebrating with you in spirit! Congratulations, and well done! -Annie > > In 4 days I'll have my PhD > In 4 days I will have given my final seminar and I'll be finished > All I have to do at this point is rehearse my presentation...a presentation I've given many times over. > I'm not nervous > I'm not scared > I'm not joyful > In fact...until a few minutes ago I wasn't feeling anything much at all about it. > But then I thought about my nada and all I can feel is sad. > > A couple of months ago when I told her I'd scheduled my defense she said " OH god...what have you done. " She thought I meant for a crime I'd committed. Gee...she knows me so well. I'd shrug it off as...well most people don't know what getting a PhD involves...but she's my MOTHER...I've told her time and again what is involved. > > A few years ago she asked me what she should tell people when they ask her what I do for a living. I told her she should tell them I'm a doctoral student doing research in the biomedical sciences. She said " Can't I just tell them you're a career student? " What a B*#%^@!!!!! I mean...seriously...what a B*#$@!!!!!! I PUT MYSELF THROUGH SCHOOL!!! OF COURSE ITS TAKEN AWHILE!!!!! > > My friends will come. And we'll have a party afterwards. Its not like this day is going to pass unnoticed or uncelebrated. > > But for some reason I want to share this accomplishment with my mother. To have her want to come see me give my seminar. To have her bring a cake and a bottle of champagne. To get the genuine " Im so proud of you " blah blah blah thing. > > And the reason I feel really dumb right now is because I know better than to expect that kind of thing to ever happen. > > Thanks for listening. > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 15, 2010 Report Posted January 15, 2010 Thank you Annie You know...you're right. If my nada were learning disabled or...as you say...actually 2 years old then It wouldn't even occur to me to expect her to act like an adult or to give a rats booty about me. Though...I have to say, I've known some pretty caring and empathetic learning disabled people. Her loss right? > > > > In 4 days I'll have my PhD > > In 4 days I will have given my final seminar and I'll be finished > > All I have to do at this point is rehearse my presentation...a presentation I've given many times over. > > I'm not nervous > > I'm not scared > > I'm not joyful > > In fact...until a few minutes ago I wasn't feeling anything much at all about it. > > But then I thought about my nada and all I can feel is sad. > > > > A couple of months ago when I told her I'd scheduled my defense she said " OH god...what have you done. " She thought I meant for a crime I'd committed. Gee...she knows me so well. I'd shrug it off as...well most people don't know what getting a PhD involves...but she's my MOTHER...I've told her time and again what is involved. > > > > A few years ago she asked me what she should tell people when they ask her what I do for a living. I told her she should tell them I'm a doctoral student doing research in the biomedical sciences. She said " Can't I just tell them you're a career student? " What a B*#%^@!!!!! I mean...seriously...what a B*#$@!!!!!! I PUT MYSELF THROUGH SCHOOL!!! OF COURSE ITS TAKEN AWHILE!!!!! > > > > My friends will come. And we'll have a party afterwards. Its not like this day is going to pass unnoticed or uncelebrated. > > > > But for some reason I want to share this accomplishment with my mother. To have her want to come see me give my seminar. To have her bring a cake and a bottle of champagne. To get the genuine " Im so proud of you " blah blah blah thing. > > > > And the reason I feel really dumb right now is because I know better than to expect that kind of thing to ever happen. > > > > Thanks for listening. > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 15, 2010 Report Posted January 15, 2010 This reminds me of Tatum O'Neal's book, A Paper Life, in which she recalls telling her father that she had been nominated for an , at age 10. She was nominated for the movie she did with him, but he was not nominated. His response was to punch her in the face. Obviously out of jealousy. Men are usually more direct than women. Deanna > > > > In 4 days I'll have my PhD > > In 4 days I will have given my final seminar and I'll be finished > > All I have to do at this point is rehearse my presentation...a presentation I've given many times over. > > I'm not nervous > > I'm not scared > > I'm not joyful > > In fact...until a few minutes ago I wasn't feeling anything much at all about it. > > But then I thought about my nada and all I can feel is sad. > > > > A couple of months ago when I told her I'd scheduled my defense she said " OH god...what have you done. " She thought I meant for a crime I'd committed. Gee...she knows me so well. I'd shrug it off as...well most people don't know what getting a PhD involves...but she's my MOTHER...I've told her time and again what is involved. > > > > A few years ago she asked me what she should tell people when they ask her what I do for a living. I told her she should tell them I'm a doctoral student doing research in the biomedical sciences. She said " Can't I just tell them you're a career student? " What a B*#%^@!!!!! I mean...seriously...what a B*#$@!!!!!! I PUT MYSELF THROUGH SCHOOL!!! OF COURSE ITS TAKEN AWHILE!!!!! > > > > My friends will come. And we'll have a party afterwards. Its not like this day is going to pass unnoticed or uncelebrated. > > > > But for some reason I want to share this accomplishment with my mother. To have her want to come see me give my seminar. To have her bring a cake and a bottle of champagne. To get the genuine " Im so proud of you " blah blah blah thing. > > > > And the reason I feel really dumb right now is because I know better than to expect that kind of thing to ever happen. > > > > Thanks for listening. > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 15, 2010 Report Posted January 15, 2010 I support you in doing this. > > Deanna- I hadn't really thought of it as the " inner child " wanting her mommy, but I think you are right Deanna! Maybe I'll let her play some guitar hero and eat ice cream for dinner tonight Quote
Guest guest Posted January 15, 2010 Report Posted January 15, 2010 You are so NOT dumb! I totally understand what you are saying though. I don't think my nada ever understood what my brother and I did (we both have technical MS degrees). We would have to explain it to her like we were talking to a 2nd grader, then she'd completely lose interest. My dad is intellectually brilliant, so he always understood but did not ever try to explain it to her. If it didn't involve her, there was no point. I completely understand your sadness. It seems every time I've had a major accomplishment in my life, my nada always puts a damper on it somehow. I've never fully been able to enjoy my accomplishments. Sometimes she will say " I'm so proud of you " but then later she will turn around and do something completely destructive to me. I've seen a pattern that whenever I've had something really positive in my life, it seems to set my nada off on some kind of rampage against me. I think the more I learn about BPD and understand that nada's behavior is an illness, the easier it is to observe it when it happens and try just a tiny bit not to take it personally and put things into perspective. I'm working on accepting compliments and support from the people around me who really do care - my friends and chosen family. You have done something AMAZING! Not many people can say they put themselves through school and earned a PhD in such a cutting-edge field. I'm extremely impressed with your accomplishments!! Be proud of yourself and celebrate with your friends - you deserve it! ((((((HUGS)))))) - > > In 4 days I'll have my PhD > In 4 days I will have given my final seminar and I'll be finished > All I have to do at this point is rehearse my presentation...a presentation I've given many times over. > I'm not nervous > I'm not scared > I'm not joyful > In fact...until a few minutes ago I wasn't feeling anything much at all about it. > But then I thought about my nada and all I can feel is sad. > > A couple of months ago when I told her I'd scheduled my defense she said " OH god...what have you done. " She thought I meant for a crime I'd committed. Gee...she knows me so well. I'd shrug it off as...well most people don't know what getting a PhD involves...but she's my MOTHER...I've told her time and again what is involved. > > A few years ago she asked me what she should tell people when they ask her what I do for a living. I told her she should tell them I'm a doctoral student doing research in the biomedical sciences. She said " Can't I just tell them you're a career student? " What a B*#%^@!!!!! I mean...seriously...what a B*#$@!!!!!! I PUT MYSELF THROUGH SCHOOL!!! OF COURSE ITS TAKEN AWHILE!!!!! > > My friends will come. And we'll have a party afterwards. Its not like this day is going to pass unnoticed or uncelebrated. > > But for some reason I want to share this accomplishment with my mother. To have her want to come see me give my seminar. To have her bring a cake and a bottle of champagne. To get the genuine " Im so proud of you " blah blah blah thing. > > And the reason I feel really dumb right now is because I know better than to expect that kind of thing to ever happen. > > Thanks for listening. > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 15, 2010 Report Posted January 15, 2010 Congratulations Jennesis!! You said what I was thinking as I read the other responses ( " her loss " ), that it may help to think of it as her being the one who is really losing out on the experience. I know when my kids do even little things, I am so happy for them. It is sad that she can't feel that. It is more of a threat and competition than motherly pride. Really, no one wins that game. I find your subject heading interesting. It is really how your reaching such achievements probably makes your nada feel and I would guess she can't move beyond that. I found this to be stronger between my nada then with my two brothers. She seemed proud of them but it always seemed that no matter what I achieved, it never even drew a bit of notice. Anyway, you get it in your head but there is that hole in your heart. I join the others here in saying how proud I am of your accomplishments. I wish you joy, pride, nervous excitement and all the other great feelings that go with completing such a wonderful thing. Yeah for you!!! patinage > > > > > > In 4 days I'll have my PhD > > > In 4 days I will have given my final seminar and I'll be finished > > > All I have to do at this point is rehearse my presentation...a presentation I've given many times over. > > > I'm not nervous > > > I'm not scared > > > I'm not joyful > > > In fact...until a few minutes ago I wasn't feeling anything much at all about it. > > > But then I thought about my nada and all I can feel is sad. > > > > > > A couple of months ago when I told her I'd scheduled my defense she said " OH god...what have you done. " She thought I meant for a crime I'd committed. Gee...she knows me so well. I'd shrug it off as...well most people don't know what getting a PhD involves...but she's my MOTHER...I've told her time and again what is involved. > > > > > > A few years ago she asked me what she should tell people when they ask her what I do for a living. I told her she should tell them I'm a doctoral student doing research in the biomedical sciences. She said " Can't I just tell them you're a career student? " What a B*#%^@!!!!! I mean...seriously...what a B*#$@!!!!!! I PUT MYSELF THROUGH SCHOOL!!! OF COURSE ITS TAKEN AWHILE!!!!! > > > > > > My friends will come. And we'll have a party afterwards. Its not like this day is going to pass unnoticed or uncelebrated. > > > > > > But for some reason I want to share this accomplishment with my mother. To have her want to come see me give my seminar. To have her bring a cake and a bottle of champagne. To get the genuine " Im so proud of you " blah blah blah thing. > > > > > > And the reason I feel really dumb right now is because I know better than to expect that kind of thing to ever happen. > > > > > > Thanks for listening. > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 16, 2010 Report Posted January 16, 2010 Dear DOCTOR: ((((HUGS))))) I wish I had words. But I'm crying for you, too. Its so odd how we run through our lives doing well, and all of the sudden we just hit a spot where all we can do is stare at an abyss of where our real mothers should be. It just leave you feeling dumbfounded when it still turns up as a surprise. I think we all have that happen. One thing you can take to the bank: My sons are 7 and 11. If they become have the grownups you are--to pursue a goal through so many years of hard work and stress and sacrifice--I would be the happiest woman alive. Whether they become PhDs or factory workers, I would be proud of them for showing such character. Not only does this PhD speak of a huge accomplishment, it speaks to your incredible fortitude. I, for one, am VERY proud of you!! Good work--have a glass of wine for me to celebrate!! > > In 4 days I'll have my PhD > In 4 days I will have given my final seminar and I'll be finished > All I have to do at this point is rehearse my presentation...a presentation I've given many times over. > I'm not nervous > I'm not scared > I'm not joyful > In fact...until a few minutes ago I wasn't feeling anything much at all about it. > But then I thought about my nada and all I can feel is sad. > > A couple of months ago when I told her I'd scheduled my defense she said " OH god...what have you done. " She thought I meant for a crime I'd committed. Gee...she knows me so well. I'd shrug it off as...well most people don't know what getting a PhD involves...but she's my MOTHER...I've told her time and again what is involved. > > A few years ago she asked me what she should tell people when they ask her what I do for a living. I told her she should tell them I'm a doctoral student doing research in the biomedical sciences. She said " Can't I just tell them you're a career student? " What a B*#%^@!!!!! I mean...seriously...what a B*#$@!!!!!! I PUT MYSELF THROUGH SCHOOL!!! OF COURSE ITS TAKEN AWHILE!!!!! > > My friends will come. And we'll have a party afterwards. Its not like this day is going to pass unnoticed or uncelebrated. > > But for some reason I want to share this accomplishment with my mother. To have her want to come see me give my seminar. To have her bring a cake and a bottle of champagne. To get the genuine " Im so proud of you " blah blah blah thing. > > And the reason I feel really dumb right now is because I know better than to expect that kind of thing to ever happen. > > Thanks for listening. > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 16, 2010 Report Posted January 16, 2010 " You are so NOT dumb! I totally understand what you are saying though. I don't think my nada ever understood what my brother and I did (we both have technical MS degrees). We would have to explain it to her like we were talking to a 2nd grader, then she'd completely lose interest. My dad is intellectually brilliant, so he always understood but did not ever try to explain it to her. If it didn't involve her, there was no point. I completely understand your sadness. It seems every time I've had a major accomplishment in my life, my nada always puts a damper on it somehow. I've never fully been able to enjoy my accomplishments. Sometimes she will say " I'm so proud of you " but then later she will turn around and do something completely destructive to me. I've seen a pattern that whenever I've had something really positive in my life, it seems to set my nada off on some kind of rampage against me. " This describes my nada to a T. She completely did not understand my college/medical school/residency experience even though I tried to explain it to her on numerous occasions. I'd tell her something, and then she'd ask a question that made it evident that she hadn't been listening to a word I'd said. Then she'd get mad that I never tell her anything. As far as major accomplishments, when I got into a very competetive medical school I was understandably excited. When I went to her with this, her response was " Are you saying that MY DAUGHTER got into medical school? " She repeated the " MY DAUGHTER " bit over and over. And then she wanted to go to a restaurant of her choosing to celebrate. By the end of the day I felt like I had my good news stolen from me. Quote
Guest guest Posted January 16, 2010 Report Posted January 16, 2010 The behavior you describe made me feel highly conflicted about trying to accomplish things. If I did achieve something, like win a competition, then my nada would make it her own achievement. Like you said, as though she stole it from me. I wound up being so conflicted that I mostly became ossified, just frozen in place. I never wanted to try to do anything because it was going to either be taken from me if it was good, or reviled and shamed and all my fault if it was bad. -Annie > As far as major accomplishments, when I got into a very competetive medical school I was understandably excited. When I went to her with this, her response was " Are you saying that MY DAUGHTER got into medical school? " She repeated the " MY DAUGHTER " bit over and over. And then she wanted to go to a restaurant of her choosing to celebrate. By the end of the day I felt like I had my good news stolen from me. > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 16, 2010 Report Posted January 16, 2010 That is exactly what those conversations feel like - a punch in the face!! I think it'd be better if emotional abuse left a bruise, that way other people could see the hurt without asking. Congratulations on your degree! You've done a great job raising and nurturing yourself. > This reminds me of Tatum O'Neal's book, A Paper Life, in which she recalls telling her father that she had been nominated for an , at age 10. She was nominated for the movie she did with him, but he was not nominated. His response was to punch her in the face. Obviously out of jealousy. Men are usually more direct than women. > > Deanna Quote
Guest guest Posted January 16, 2010 Report Posted January 16, 2010 I'm sorry your mother said that. Congratulations!!! All the hard work pays off. You are now my inspiration to finish nursing school!! In a message dated 1/16/2010 1:54:42 P.M. Eastern Standard Time, jennesis11 @yahoo.com writes: " the abyss of where our real mothers should be " WELL SAID!!!!!! Thank you > > > > In 4 days I'll have my PhD > > In 4 days I will have given my final seminar and I'll be finished > > All I have to do at this point is rehearse my presentation. All I have to do at this point is rehearse > > I'm not nervous > > I'm not scared > > I'm not joyful > > In fact...until a few minutes ago I wasn't feeling anything much at all about it. > > But then I thought about my nada and all I can feel is sad. > > > > A couple of months ago when I told her I'd scheduled my defense she said " OH god...what have you done. " She thought I meant for a crime I'd committed. Gee...she knows me so well. I'd shrug it off as...well most people don't know what getting a PhD involves...but she's my MOTHER...I've told her time and again what is involved. > > > > A few years ago she asked me what she should tell people when they ask her what I do for a living. I told her she should tell them I'm a doctoral student doing research in the biomedical sciences. She said " Can't I just tell them you're a career student? " What a B*#%^@!!!!! I mean...seriously. A few years ago she asked me what she should tell people when they ask her what I > > > > My friends will come. And we'll have a party afterwards. Its not like this day is going to pass unnoticed or uncelebrated. > > > > But for some reason I want to share this accomplishment with my mother. To have her want to come see me give my seminar. To have her bring a cake and a bottle of champagne. To get the genuine " Im so proud of you " blah blah blah thing. > > > > And the reason I feel really dumb right now is because I know better than to expect that kind of thing to ever happen. > > > > Thanks for listening. > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 16, 2010 Report Posted January 16, 2010 I am so sorry...after all your hard work, of course you'd want a pat on the back from your nada and a " great job, I'm so proud of you " but you will never get it....we have to accept our accomplishments for ourselves only, and not expect to share them with nadas....it's not fair!! but...CONGRATULATIONS !!!!!! I know that took a LOT of time and hard work on your part to get where you are :-) Jackie In 4 days I'll have my PhD In 4 days I will have given my final seminar and I'll be finished All I have to do at this point is rehearse my presentation...a presentation I've given many times over. I'm not nervous I'm not scared I'm not joyful In fact...until a few minutes ago I wasn't feeling anything much at all about it. But then I thought about my nada and all I can feel is sad. A couple of months ago when I told her I'd scheduled my defense she said " OH god...what have you done. " She thought I meant for a crime I'd committed. Gee...she knows me so well. I'd shrug it off as...well most people don't know what getting a PhD involves...but she's my MOTHER...I've told her time and again what is involved. A few years ago she asked me what she should tell people when they ask her what I do for a living. I told her she should tell them I'm a doctoral student doing research in the biomedical sciences. She said " Can't I just tell them you're a career student? " What a B*#%^@!!!!! I mean...seriously...what a B*#$@!!!!!! I PUT MYSELF THROUGH SCHOOL!!! OF COURSE ITS TAKEN AWHILE!!!!! My friends will come. And we'll have a party afterwards. Its not like this day is going to pass unnoticed or uncelebrated. But for some reason I want to share this accomplishment with my mother. To have her want to come see me give my seminar. To have her bring a cake and a bottle of champagne. To get the genuine " Im so proud of you " blah blah blah thing. And the reason I feel really dumb right now is because I know better than to expect that kind of thing to ever happen. Thanks for listening. Quote
Guest guest Posted January 16, 2010 Report Posted January 16, 2010 OK this paragraph makes me feel woozy. My mother has referred to me too often as " MY OWN DAUGHTER " , like she frickin owns me. Only a fellow KO would understand how creepy that is and how not normal it is. I'm sure healthy parents use that term but they use it...differently somehow. > As far as major accomplishments, when I got into a very competetive medical school I was understandably excited. When I went to her with this, her response was " Are you saying that MY DAUGHTER got into medical school? " She repeated the " MY DAUGHTER " bit over and over. And then she wanted to go to a restaurant of her choosing to celebrate. By the end of the day I felt like I had my good news stolen from me. > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 16, 2010 Report Posted January 16, 2010 Congratulations Dr. Jennesis!!!! Getting a PhD in microbiology is no mean feat.I'm very proud of you! It's so natural to want your mother to share in your triumphs with you.It's so hard to understand and accept that the emotional cognition of a BPD is as primitive and basic as it is...and negative...and petty...It's just hard to believe sometimes how they can fail to get stuff that has been explained to them or stuff that *should* be obvious--and impossible at times not to feel upset when it's your own mother. I'm sorry your nada isn't able to share in this moment with you and be proud of your serious accomplishment.It truly is her loss. All my best wishes for a fruitful,fulfilling,brilliant career > > In 4 days I'll have my PhD > In 4 days I will have given my final seminar and I'll be finished > All I have to do at this point is rehearse my presentation...a presentation I've given many times over. > I'm not nervous > I'm not scared > I'm not joyful > In fact...until a few minutes ago I wasn't feeling anything much at all about it. > But then I thought about my nada and all I can feel is sad. > > A couple of months ago when I told her I'd scheduled my defense she said " OH god...what have you done. " She thought I meant for a crime I'd committed. Gee...she knows me so well. I'd shrug it off as...well most people don't know what getting a PhD involves...but she's my MOTHER...I've told her time and again what is involved. > > A few years ago she asked me what she should tell people when they ask her what I do for a living. I told her she should tell them I'm a doctoral student doing research in the biomedical sciences. She said " Can't I just tell them you're a career student? " What a B*#%^@!!!!! I mean...seriously...what a B*#$@!!!!!! I PUT MYSELF THROUGH SCHOOL!!! OF COURSE ITS TAKEN AWHILE!!!!! > > My friends will come. And we'll have a party afterwards. Its not like this day is going to pass unnoticed or uncelebrated. > > But for some reason I want to share this accomplishment with my mother. To have her want to come see me give my seminar. To have her bring a cake and a bottle of champagne. To get the genuine " Im so proud of you " blah blah blah thing. > > And the reason I feel really dumb right now is because I know better than to expect that kind of thing to ever happen. > > Thanks for listening. > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 16, 2010 Report Posted January 16, 2010 I want to try to respond to all who posted but first I need to address this one...cause oh do I get it. So...the whole MY DAUGHTER did/is doing this really cool thing is something my BPD/NPD fada would do. And like Annie...if it were good it was his accomplishment and if it were bad then I was a bad shameful person. What really drives me batty about this is the stealing of your identity in that one phrase. You cease to become you who accomplished this and become him/her who accomplished this thing...as though they accomplished it by proxy simply because they provided one of the gametes necessary to spawn you. I remember at a Christmas Party a few years back...when my fada and I were still speaking (we are NC now) he was going around telling everyone " MY DAUGHTER is working on her doctorate " and I would always reply " Yes I (add emphasis) am. " He would get this weird look on his face every time I did that. He never got it...that it was I (add emphasis) doing this really cool stuff. He just didn't see the difference between saying something like " MY DAUGHTER... " vs. " This is my Daughter Jen...she is working on... " My nada on the other hand...when it comes to my career choice " just cant believe my little girl does that kind of thing " and I quote " I just don't even want to think about it. " Like its gross or something. Another thing relating to this. My mentor was trying to prepare me for how I might feel day of...that many people get really emotional and that I shouldn't be surprised if I do. I'm normally pretty " together " under pressure but he said It just might hit you whats going on moments before you get up there...cause its a really big deal what you're doing Tuesday! And...he keeps comparing this to a Wedding. He's like this day is as big and important a day as a Wedding. I feel pretty confident that if it WERE a wedding she'd put the date on her calendar and show up to play the mother of the bride part. Which got me to thinking...do I even actually really want her there? What would it actually be like if she were there? And when I think about THAT the answer is actually probably not. What I want there is the mother I, and we all, should have had. In the absence of that I guess its good that I can go ahead and celebrate the way I want to without dealing wish her passive aggressive subtly invalidating oh don't mind me but make sure you notice how much I've suffered to be here BS. > > > As far as major accomplishments, when I got into a very competetive medical school I was understandably excited. When I went to her with this, her response was " Are you saying that MY DAUGHTER got into medical school? " She repeated the " MY DAUGHTER " bit over and over. And then she wanted to go to a restaurant of her choosing to celebrate. By the end of the day I felt like I had my good news stolen from me. > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 16, 2010 Report Posted January 16, 2010 That really is the rub in all of this isn't it. Getting it in your head but having your heart understand as well. When I first began therapy I told my therapist that what I really wanted was " for my head and my heart to start having some productive conversations with each other cause what my head understands my heart really doesn't get. " I'm still working on it, and most days I'm pretty successful at remembering that its not about something being wrong with me but that its about having parents that really had no business entering into parenthood. Every now and then the reality of how sucky this is just hits me like a Mack truck and my heart takes over the lead in the conversation. I'm really thankful for this board in those moments > > > > > > > > In 4 days I'll have my PhD > > > > In 4 days I will have given my final seminar and I'll be finished > > > > All I have to do at this point is rehearse my presentation...a presentation I've given many times over. > > > > I'm not nervous > > > > I'm not scared > > > > I'm not joyful > > > > In fact...until a few minutes ago I wasn't feeling anything much at all about it. > > > > But then I thought about my nada and all I can feel is sad. > > > > > > > > A couple of months ago when I told her I'd scheduled my defense she said " OH god...what have you done. " She thought I meant for a crime I'd committed. Gee...she knows me so well. I'd shrug it off as...well most people don't know what getting a PhD involves...but she's my MOTHER...I've told her time and again what is involved. > > > > > > > > A few years ago she asked me what she should tell people when they ask her what I do for a living. I told her she should tell them I'm a doctoral student doing research in the biomedical sciences. She said " Can't I just tell them you're a career student? " What a B*#%^@!!!!! I mean...seriously...what a B*#$@!!!!!! I PUT MYSELF THROUGH SCHOOL!!! OF COURSE ITS TAKEN AWHILE!!!!! > > > > > > > > My friends will come. And we'll have a party afterwards. Its not like this day is going to pass unnoticed or uncelebrated. > > > > > > > > But for some reason I want to share this accomplishment with my mother. To have her want to come see me give my seminar. To have her bring a cake and a bottle of champagne. To get the genuine " Im so proud of you " blah blah blah thing. > > > > > > > > And the reason I feel really dumb right now is because I know better than to expect that kind of thing to ever happen. > > > > > > > > Thanks for listening. > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 16, 2010 Report Posted January 16, 2010 OH totally!!!!! You know...my fada is the " punch in the face " kinda guy. While that is definitely not cool I actually appreciate that more than the passive aggressive BS. My fada has been so much easier to " get over " because he is so over the top obviously disturbed that its hard not to. I mean...when you're fada can throw a full blown jumping up and down banging his hands on his knees temper tantrum at the end of the driveway in the middle of the afternoon on a Saturday because he didnt get his way...you sorta know that something isn't right with the man. But when its subversive and manipulative to the point that you almost feel crazy trying to explain to an outsider why you feel the way you do about your nada (because only those that are really paying attention, have gone through it themselves, or otherwise know the meaning of boundaries and appropriate behavior can understand) its a little harder to get past because you end up second guessing yourself...like " am I being too sensitive? " , " am I the one with the problem? " Fada throwing childish tantrum in broad daylight= easy for anyone to understand. Nada being invalidating and shaming= not so easy. > > > > > > In 4 days I'll have my PhD > > > In 4 days I will have given my final seminar and I'll be finished > > > All I have to do at this point is rehearse my presentation...a presentation I've given many times over. > > > I'm not nervous > > > I'm not scared > > > I'm not joyful > > > In fact...until a few minutes ago I wasn't feeling anything much at all about it. > > > But then I thought about my nada and all I can feel is sad. > > > > > > A couple of months ago when I told her I'd scheduled my defense she said " OH god...what have you done. " She thought I meant for a crime I'd committed. Gee...she knows me so well. I'd shrug it off as...well most people don't know what getting a PhD involves...but she's my MOTHER...I've told her time and again what is involved. > > > > > > A few years ago she asked me what she should tell people when they ask her what I do for a living. I told her she should tell them I'm a doctoral student doing research in the biomedical sciences. She said " Can't I just tell them you're a career student? " What a B*#%^@!!!!! I mean...seriously...what a B*#$@!!!!!! I PUT MYSELF THROUGH SCHOOL!!! OF COURSE ITS TAKEN AWHILE!!!!! > > > > > > My friends will come. And we'll have a party afterwards. Its not like this day is going to pass unnoticed or uncelebrated. > > > > > > But for some reason I want to share this accomplishment with my mother. To have her want to come see me give my seminar. To have her bring a cake and a bottle of champagne. To get the genuine " Im so proud of you " blah blah blah thing. > > > > > > And the reason I feel really dumb right now is because I know better than to expect that kind of thing to ever happen. > > > > > > Thanks for listening. > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 16, 2010 Report Posted January 16, 2010 " the abyss of where our real mothers should be " WELL SAID!!!!!! Thank you > > > > In 4 days I'll have my PhD > > In 4 days I will have given my final seminar and I'll be finished > > All I have to do at this point is rehearse my presentation...a presentation I've given many times over. > > I'm not nervous > > I'm not scared > > I'm not joyful > > In fact...until a few minutes ago I wasn't feeling anything much at all about it. > > But then I thought about my nada and all I can feel is sad. > > > > A couple of months ago when I told her I'd scheduled my defense she said " OH god...what have you done. " She thought I meant for a crime I'd committed. Gee...she knows me so well. I'd shrug it off as...well most people don't know what getting a PhD involves...but she's my MOTHER...I've told her time and again what is involved. > > > > A few years ago she asked me what she should tell people when they ask her what I do for a living. I told her she should tell them I'm a doctoral student doing research in the biomedical sciences. She said " Can't I just tell them you're a career student? " What a B*#%^@!!!!! I mean...seriously...what a B*#$@!!!!!! I PUT MYSELF THROUGH SCHOOL!!! OF COURSE ITS TAKEN AWHILE!!!!! > > > > My friends will come. And we'll have a party afterwards. Its not like this day is going to pass unnoticed or uncelebrated. > > > > But for some reason I want to share this accomplishment with my mother. To have her want to come see me give my seminar. To have her bring a cake and a bottle of champagne. To get the genuine " Im so proud of you " blah blah blah thing. > > > > And the reason I feel really dumb right now is because I know better than to expect that kind of thing to ever happen. > > > > Thanks for listening. > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 16, 2010 Report Posted January 16, 2010 It isn't fair. For any of us! > > I am so sorry...after all your hard work, of course you'd want a pat on the > back from your nada and a " great job, I'm so proud of you " but you will > never get it....we have to accept our accomplishments for ourselves only, > and not expect to share them with nadas....it's not fair!! > but...CONGRATULATIONS !!!!!! I know that took a LOT of time and hard work > on your part to get where you are :-) > > Jackie > > > > In 4 days I'll have my PhD > In 4 days I will have given my final seminar and I'll be finished > All I have to do at this point is rehearse my presentation...a presentation > I've given many times over. > I'm not nervous > I'm not scared > I'm not joyful > In fact...until a few minutes ago I wasn't feeling anything much at all > about it. > But then I thought about my nada and all I can feel is sad. > > A couple of months ago when I told her I'd scheduled my defense she said " OH > god...what have you done. " She thought I meant for a crime I'd committed. > Gee...she knows me so well. I'd shrug it off as...well most people don't > know what getting a PhD involves...but she's my MOTHER...I've told her time > and again what is involved. > > A few years ago she asked me what she should tell people when they ask her > what I do for a living. I told her she should tell them I'm a doctoral > student doing research in the biomedical sciences. She said " Can't I just > tell them you're a career student? " What a B*#%^@!!!!! I > mean...seriously...what a B*#$@!!!!!! I PUT MYSELF THROUGH SCHOOL!!! OF > COURSE ITS TAKEN AWHILE!!!!! > > My friends will come. And we'll have a party afterwards. Its not like this > day is going to pass unnoticed or uncelebrated. > > But for some reason I want to share this accomplishment with my mother. To > have her want to come see me give my seminar. To have her bring a cake and a > bottle of champagne. To get the genuine " Im so proud of you " blah blah blah > thing. > > And the reason I feel really dumb right now is because I know better than to > expect that kind of thing to ever happen. > > Thanks for listening. > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.