Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Re: Please don't flame me but....

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted

I’m not sure I buy this argument. There is a lot of waste/profiteering in medicine. We are incentivized through the current payment models to push productivity and procedures over quality. But, I’m not certain that health insurance should only be for catastrophes. The difference is that we are not cars. If you don’t change your oil and your car breaks down, you ride public transport or go buy another one. You can find a car for $300 or one for $100,000. If a body breaks down, there are no alternatives or trade ins. We know that the more people have to pay for their health care, the less likely they are to go to the doctor. The most likely place this will happen is in the primary care office (as we are the first line for most things). Therefore, by increasing the out of pocket costs, we are immediately eliminating potentially life-saving primary care appointments. Now, you can argue that we can incentivize people to come in, but then we are still working within the insurance industry (unless we do a wonderful marketing campaign and finally open the eyes of the millions of Americans that having a strong relationship with a primary care doc is one of the best values anyone can ask for). I wonder many times (particularly as I read this thread) if it is really the concept of insurance that we hate or just the way we get paid by the insurance companies. More specifically, if the insurance company paid me a dollar a day and I was allowed to charge $10/visit, would I be railing against the concept of insurance? I don’t think so—because deep down I believe that everyone should be able to receive high quality, patient centered care (i.e. I agree with the sense of entitlement). Incidentally, I also think it can be done without bankrupting the country. From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Ellen sonSent: Thursday, December 09, 2010 12:40 AMTo: Subject: Re: Please don't flame me but.... Ditto. And I agree with the notion that insurance should be for catastrophes. Car insurance is for accidents, not tune ups. We should pay for our own preventive servicesand be covered for when we're seriously ill. And maybe pay more of insurance if we don't take care of preventive stuff, discounts if we do, the way we get discounts for having air bags and anti-theft locks. We have all grown used to a feeling of entitlement in medicine. And we are all to blame.> I am really hard pressed to figure out some of this vitriol. I have patients who pay for their insurance, either directly or via payroll deductions, who expect to be able to use it. Our community has taken a real hit in this economic downturn, and to pressure people to not use their insurance seems rather draconian in our neck of the woods-as says.> We never should have been in this mess to begin with. Insurance is suppose to protect you from the catastrophic, not the mundane. The problem with insurances, in my opinion, started with Medicare and payment for everything. Insurers have provided products for business, labor unions, and individuals, that the buyers wanted. Increasing benefits, first dollar coverage, preventative care, etc. etc. The result has been rapid increases in provision of " everything for everybody and somebody else better pay for it " attitude in our county. If we had left health insurance as the coverage for severe illness, or hospitalization, the cost of care would have grown more slowly, the grow was abnormally coopted by payment system instead of the usual supply and demand. A recent study has shown the same thing about collage education. The availability of grants and scholorships has fueled the cost of college education where you can't afford college without them. (As a recent faculty member, I can tell you that the FM faculty makes much more that the average IMPer without seem 1/3 of the patients-right DAnielle?)> This has driven the entitlement and cost of care beyond anyone's ability to pay for it. Now we are paying the price. I chuckle that the AARP folks who fight for the right for every 99 year old to have a heart transplant, and every orthopedic surgeon, who is afraid their $1m salary might be in jeopardy. But the system has been created by all of us; consumers, the buyers of insurance (business, unions, individuals), providers-including us. Is a change necessary. Sure, but don't link anyone's acceptance of insurance as sinister or stupid, we all work in the systems we work in. For me, taking insurance was a business decision and it works for me and my patients.> Jim> ________________________________________> From: [ ] On Behalf Of Dr. Brady [drbrady@...]> Sent: Wednesday, December 08, 2010 5:51 AM> To: > Subject: RE: Please don't flame me but....>> ,> You are right. After sending, I re-read my post and worried that the word “stupid” was probably a bad choice. I did not feel that was personally attacking. I did not feel angry or upset. However, I do think that a lot of people (many of us included) feel that continuing to work with the insurance companies is indeed stupid (perhaps more accurately insane if you use Einstein’s definition of insanity). My main focus of the post was to try and contradict the sentences “The more we go along with the third party rules, regulations and payment hassles, the more intertwined we become and we lose sight of our practice. There is no improvement if there is no vision.” The essence of this list serve and movement disproves this statement.> >> From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of > Sent: Tuesday, December 07, 2010 11:54 PM> To: > Subject: Re: Please don't flame me but....>>>> " I totally understand why you may regard this as idealistic and stupid, " >> " ...So don;t flame me either But don;t tell me how to practice> Let;s fix it for everyone... " >> " ...I work for my patients and not the insurance company " seems to suggest that only those that do not accept insurance are working for what is best for their patients... " >> Come on guys.>> No one is telling anyone how to practice. No one but the poster used the words " idealistic and stupid. " No one said that only those not accepting insurance have a corner market on doing what is right for their patients.>> I am very sad that this issue hits on such a deep nerve that good people choose to be insulted instead of uplifted or at least open minded to new ideas. We are all on the same team, but we choose instead to argue and defend, and thus we are divided.>> Good luck to us all. Good night. I am truly honored to have had you in my world for such an important transitional time in my life. I am forever grateful.>> >>> On Tue, Dec 7, 2010 at 7:55 PM, > wrote:>>> Practiceimprovemtn1 means support and community and problem solving and sharing, I think at it s simplest>> And as for third parties- they exist> third parties will not go away I do not think it feasible that they do, either> Third parties should certainly change .> I do not know if they will in my lifetime> It is politically correct to say cheers, and be respectful to, people who do differently than i> .... many tell me what to do . 'It is possible ... you can... " > but> they do not live here.>> What i am after- - is something replicable>> To change the system-> which needs to happen-> I am after something bigger.And becasue some take jobs and some opt out and 50 states vary tremendously , I fail to see how we can get there.>> I have lots of vision. And i know alot about improvement and I have 5.5 yrs of really good data to prove it.>>> We don't walk in each others shoes much nor in the shoes of patients> it is very bad out here> It is my belief that unless and until docs( and midlevels, etcetc ) and patients join up together, not a thing can happen We have been successfully divided and fractionated for decades. We never stop being separate and going at each other. Just imagine if specialists supported primary c are Just imagine if you knew the issues that drive cardiology crazy Imagine if patients trusted us again. I mean by joining up together Imean that we are unrelenting in our advocacy and use of our voices.> and> I don;t see it happening.> So don;t flame me either But don;t tell me how to practice> Let;s fix it for everyone.>>>> On Tue, Dec 7, 2010 at 5:00 PM,> wrote:>> Please don't flame me but.....>> This group is called .>> What exactly does that mean?>> Is it a way for docs to discuss better patient care in their practice?>> If so this is wonderful!!>> Or is it a way to discuss how to deal with third parties?>> If so, all this does is perpetuate the main issue in improving practices and thus patient care by agreeing to third party intrusion of our offices. The more we go along with the third party rules, regulations and payment hassles, the more intertwined we become and we lose sight of our practice. There is no improvement if there is no vision.>> What is the mission statement of this group?>> Horvitz, D.O.> stown, NJ> www.drhorvitz.com<http://www.drhorvitz.com>>>>>> --> PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!)> Email is best used for appointment making and brief questions> Email replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent .>>> MD> > > ph fax > impcenter.org<http://impcenter.org>>>>>>> ------------------------------------>>

Posted

But the reason most people don't go to the doctor if it costs more is

because we--everyone--has encouraged it to be that way. Pts have told me

they don't want to do preventive things because if I find something,

then they'll have a pre-existing condition. It's circle that gets us no

where. People who really want to see an ND or an LAc pay out of pocket

to go. I have pts who fly to China every yr for Chinese New

Year's(they're immigrants) but I have to struggle to get them to pay for

their Vit D when they have osteoporosis. In China, health care is free,

so maybe that's a bad example. I'm not sure the car metaphor is totally

applicable either but we don't get 'free' care even if we have

insurance. People seem to forget that. The issue is what are we paying

for, what do we want to pay for, and how much responsibility do people

want to take for their health. Maybe people ought to have a

choice--insurance to cover preventive things or to cover more serious

things. People with chronic illness are in another category--much more

complicated and I don't have many ideas about them and they are really

the ones who cost so much to care for.

>

> I’m not sure I buy this argument. There is a lot of waste/profiteering

> in medicine. We are incentivized through the current payment models to

> push productivity and procedures over quality. But, I’m not certain

> that health insurance should only be for catastrophes. The difference

> is that we are not cars. If you don’t change your oil and your car

> breaks down, you ride public transport or go buy another one. You can

> find a car for $300 or one for $100,000. If a body breaks down, there

> are no alternatives or trade ins. We know that the more people have to

> pay for their health care, the less likely they are to go to the

> doctor. The most likely place this will happen is in the primary care

> office (as we are the first line for most things). Therefore, by

> increasing the out of pocket costs, we are immediately eliminating

> potentially life-saving primary care appointments. Now, you can argue

> that we can incentivize people to come in, but then we are still

> working within the insurance industry (unless we do a wonderful

> marketing campaign and finally open the eyes of the millions of

> Americans that having a strong relationship with a primary care doc is

> one of the best values anyone can ask for). I wonder many times

> (particularly as I read this thread) if it is really the concept of

> insurance that we hate or just the way we get paid by the insurance

> companies. More specifically, if the insurance company paid me a

> dollar a day and I was allowed to charge $10/visit, would I be railing

> against the concept of insurance? I don’t think so—because deep down I

> believe that everyone should be able to receive high quality, patient

> centered care (i.e. I agree with the sense of entitlement).

> Incidentally, I also think it can be done without bankrupting the country.

>

>

>

> *From:*

> [mailto: ] *On Behalf Of *Ellen

> son

> *Sent:* Thursday, December 09, 2010 12:40 AM

> *To:*

> *Subject:* Re: Please don't flame me but....

>

> Ditto. And I agree with the notion that insurance should be for

> catastrophes. Car insurance is for accidents, not tune ups. We should

> pay for our own preventive services

> and be covered for when we're seriously ill. And maybe pay more of

> insurance if we don't take care of preventive stuff, discounts if we do,

> the way we get discounts for having air bags and anti-theft locks. We

> have all grown used to a feeling of entitlement in medicine. And we are

> all to blame.

>

>

> > I am really hard pressed to figure out some of this vitriol. I have

> patients who pay for their insurance, either directly or via payroll

> deductions, who expect to be able to use it. Our community has taken a

> real hit in this economic downturn, and to pressure people to not use

> their insurance seems rather draconian in our neck of the woods-as

> says.

> > We never should have been in this mess to begin with. Insurance is

> suppose to protect you from the catastrophic, not the mundane. The

> problem with insurances, in my opinion, started with Medicare and

> payment for everything. Insurers have provided products for business,

> labor unions, and individuals, that the buyers wanted. Increasing

> benefits, first dollar coverage, preventative care, etc. etc. The

> result has been rapid increases in provision of " everything for

> everybody and somebody else better pay for it " attitude in our county.

> If we had left health insurance as the coverage for severe illness, or

> hospitalization, the cost of care would have grown more slowly, the

> grow was abnormally coopted by payment system instead of the usual

> supply and demand. A recent study has shown the same thing about

> collage education. The availability of grants and scholorships has

> fueled the cost of college education where you can't afford college

> without them. (As a recent faculty member, I can tell you that the FM

> faculty makes much more that the average IMPer without seem 1/3 of the

> patients-right DAnielle?)

> > This has driven the entitlement and cost of care beyond anyone's

> ability to pay for it. Now we are paying the price. I chuckle that the

> AARP folks who fight for the right for every 99 year old to have a

> heart transplant, and every orthopedic surgeon, who is afraid their

> $1m salary might be in jeopardy. But the system has been created by

> all of us; consumers, the buyers of insurance (business, unions,

> individuals), providers-including us. Is a change necessary. Sure, but

> don't link anyone's acceptance of insurance as sinister or stupid, we

> all work in the systems we work in. For me, taking insurance was a

> business decision and it works for me and my patients.

> > Jim

> > ________________________________________

> > From:

> <mailto:%40yahoogroups.com>

> [

> <mailto:%40yahoogroups.com>] On Behalf Of Dr.

> Brady [drbrady@...

> <mailto:drbrady%40thevillagedoctor.hrcoxmail.com>]

> > Sent: Wednesday, December 08, 2010 5:51 AM

> > To:

> <mailto:%40yahoogroups.com>

> > Subject: RE: Please don't flame me but....

> >

> > ,

> > You are right. After sending, I re-read my post and worried that the

> word “stupid” was probably a bad choice. I did not feel that

> was personally attacking. I did not feel angry or upset. However, I do

> think that a lot of people (many of us included) feel that continuing

> to work with the insurance companies is indeed stupid (perhaps more

> accurately insane if you use Einstein’s definition of insanity). My

> main focus of the post was to try and contradict the sentences “The

> more we go along with the third party rules, regulations and payment

> hassles, the more intertwined we become and we lose sight of our

> practice. There is no improvement if there is no vision.” The essence

> of this list serve and movement disproves this statement.

> >

> >

> > From:

> <mailto:%40yahoogroups.com>

> [mailto:

> <mailto:%40yahoogroups.com>] On Behalf Of

> > Sent: Tuesday, December 07, 2010 11:54 PM

> > To:

> <mailto:%40yahoogroups.com>

> > Subject: Re: Please don't flame me but....

> >

> >

> >

> > " I totally understand why you may regard this as idealistic and stupid, "

> >

> > " ...So don;t flame me either But don;t tell me how to practice

> > Let;s fix it for everyone... "

> >

> > " ...I work for my patients and not the insurance company " seems to

> suggest that only those that do not accept insurance are working for

> what is best for their patients... "

> >

> > Come on guys.

> >

> > No one is telling anyone how to practice. No one but the poster used

> the words " idealistic and stupid. " No one said that only those not

> accepting insurance have a corner market on doing what is right for

> their patients.

> >

> > I am very sad that this issue hits on such a deep nerve that good

> people choose to be insulted instead of uplifted or at least open

> minded to new ideas. We are all on the same team, but we choose

> instead to argue and defend, and thus we are divided.

> >

> > Good luck to us all. Good night. I am truly honored to have had you

> in my world for such an important transitional time in my life. I am

> forever grateful.

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > On Tue, Dec 7, 2010 at 7:55 PM, <jnantonucci@...

> <mailto:jnantonucci%40gmail.com><mailto:jnantonucci@...

> <mailto:jnantonucci%40gmail.com>>> wrote:

> >

> >

> > Practiceimprovemtn1 means support and community and problem solving

> and sharing, I think at it s simplest

> >

> > And as for third parties- they exist

> > third parties will not go away I do not think it feasible that they

> do, either

> > Third parties should certainly change .

> > I do not know if they will in my lifetime

> > It is politically correct to say cheers, and be respectful to,

> people who do differently than i

> > .... many tell me what to do . 'It is possible ... you can... "

> > but

> > they do not live here.

> >

> > What i am after- - is something replicable

> >

> > To change the system-

> > which needs to happen-

> > I am after something bigger.And becasue some take jobs and some opt

> out and 50 states vary tremendously , I fail to see how we can get there.

> >

> > I have lots of vision. And i know alot about improvement and I have

> 5.5 yrs of really good data to prove it.

> >

> >

> > We don't walk in each others shoes much nor in the shoes of patients

> > it is very bad out here

> > It is my belief that unless and until docs( and midlevels, etcetc )

> and patients join up together, not a thing can happen We have been

> successfully divided and fractionated for decades. We never stop being

> separate and going at each other. Just imagine if specialists

> supported primary c are Just imagine if you knew the issues that drive

> cardiology crazy Imagine if patients trusted us again. I mean by

> joining up together Imean that we are unrelenting in our advocacy and

> use of our voices.

> > and

> > I don;t see it happening.

> > So don;t flame me either But don;t tell me how to practice

> > Let;s fix it for everyone.

> >

> >

> >

> > On Tue, Dec 7, 2010 at 5:00 PM,<drhorvitz@...

> <mailto:drhorvitz%40drhorvitz.com><mailto:drhorvitz@...

> <mailto:drhorvitz%40drhorvitz.com>>> wrote:

> >

> > Please don't flame me but.....

> >

> > This group is called .

> >

> > What exactly does that mean?

> >

> > Is it a way for docs to discuss better patient care in their practice?

> >

> > If so this is wonderful!!

> >

> > Or is it a way to discuss how to deal with third parties?

> >

> > If so, all this does is perpetuate the main issue in improving

> practices and thus patient care by agreeing to third party intrusion

> of our offices. The more we go along with the third party rules,

> regulations and payment hassles, the more intertwined we become and we

> lose sight of our practice. There is no improvement if there is no vision.

> >

> > What is the mission statement of this group?

> >

> > Horvitz, D.O.

> > stown, NJ

> > www.drhorvitz.com<http://www.drhorvitz.com>

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > --

> > PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and

> that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart

> ( be careful what you say!)

> > Email is best used for appointment making and brief questions

> > Email replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the

> matter is more urgent .

> >

> >

> > MD

> >

> >

> > ph fax

> > impcenter.org<http://impcenter.org>

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > ------------------------------------

> >

> >

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...