Guest guest Posted December 7, 2010 Report Posted December 7, 2010 Steve, Half decent comment and question but first I might suggest going to our main website and learning more about us. We are attempting to help small innovative practices as informed as possible and to share our joint experiences on all of these important matters. I would say that almost ALL members share your perspective at heart, but many are having a difficult time severing the ties that the system has impossed on all of us, in it's attemtps to keep docs in bondage and patients pleasantly stupid and uninformed, mislead as to what the real problem is... Mainly them. So as you spend more time here you will see that we share info on how to stay afloat or survive both inside and out... We all have major life and business altering choices to make as individuals as we attempt to survive the insanity and choking control of the present dysfunctional system.... Part of our group is not to force any one stylpe upon one another but to share as much as possible so fellow members can make the best informed choices for themselves, their practices and their patients.... No one answer fits all comers and with the present structure of the system it is not practical for all docs to leave the carrier based third party system... Be it the rural or urban poor, or the rust belt working class on extended unemployment in areas such as ours, not all patient populations can even support a totally insurance free doctor and practice as much as we wish the opposite was true... Hope this helps to start this conversation in a good direction for all of you out there like Steve who are not I would guess official members yet.... Happy Holidays one and all........... To: Sent: Tue, December 7, 2010 5:00:18 PMSubject: Please don't flame me but.... Please don't flame me but..... This group is called . What exactly does that mean? Is it a way for docs to discuss better patient care in their practice? If so this is wonderful!! Or is it a way to discuss how to deal with third parties? If so, all this does is perpetuate the main issue in improving practices and thus patient care by agreeing to third party intrusion of our offices. The more we go along with the third party rules, regulations and payment hassles, the more intertwined we become and we lose sight of our practice. There is no improvement if there is no vision. What is the mission statement of this group? Horvitz, D.O. stown, NJ www.drhorvitz.com Quote
Guest guest Posted December 7, 2010 Report Posted December 7, 2010 Dr. Horvitz, I have been a member of this list serve since 2004 and truly admire the spirit behind its innovators. These wonderful people gave me the courage to provide truly patient centered medical care. My first 3 years as an IMP, I struggled to meet the needs of all the entities involved in third party payment for my services and meet the needs of my patients. I came to personal crisis when I held a check to me from Aetna, who had just sent me a letter asking me to tell them all the pre-existing conditions of their subscribers. That was a sentinel moment for me when I decided I could no longer sit on the fence and work for both third party payers and my patients. I too left the world of third party payers in 2008 and have not regretted it. The actual transition was tough for me emotionally, as I was still partially brainwashed that staying inside the third party " nonsystem " was something I owed humanity. I have not attended a " practice management seminar " in over 2 years! The time that I had been spending reviewing/renegotiating/finagling the insurance companies, resubmitting bills, begging to be paid for the work I had already done, not to mention the time spent learning how to " play their game " is now spent on time with my family or on better meeting the needs of my patients. What I did not know at that time is there is a good portion of the populace who are totally disgusted that physicians work for someone other than them. They are a significant portion of my patient population now. They are intelligent consumers of health care, believe in science, but also want a physician who not only understands the science behind modern medicine, but also is a healer and has arranged their practice in order to be able to be a true healer. As I have said many times before, I admire the spirit behind this wonderful group of innovators, but someone has to ask these tough questions. Who are we working for and is supporting the status quo perpetuating the brokeness? Is this good? With great love and respect, I too ask us to look deep and find what answer best serves the needs of our patients as well as our own. Ewing , M.D. Durango, CO Please don't flame me but..... This group is called . What exactly does that mean? Is it a way for docs to discuss better patient care in their practice? If so this is wonderful!! Or is it a way to discuss how to deal with third parties? If so, all this does is perpetuate the main issue in improving practices and thus patient care by agreeing to third party intrusion of our offices. The more we go along with the third party rules, regulations and payment hassles, the more intertwined we become and we lose sight of our practice. There is no improvement if there is no vision. What is the mission statement of this group? Horvitz, D.O. stown, NJ www.drhorvitz.com Quote
Guest guest Posted December 7, 2010 Report Posted December 7, 2010 Excellent question SteveThis list started out after I was flooded with calls and emails following my FPM article on Going Solo. The intent was to create a community of common interest with few boundaries as long as we each perceived some value in the venue.From that origin we received a grant and ran the Ideal Medical Practices project. The crux of that project was to test simple ways we could measure and improve upon the quality of care we deliver in our practices. That went well and we published some more and developed a 501c3 non profit: Ideal Medical Practices. This non profit exist to support those in pursuit of ideal care (broadly) with a major emphasis on working with primary care practices to support sensible quality measurement and improvement. (Our web presence is muddled and we're going for a major re-do in a few months.)We are in the midst of working up a quality self-assessement tool (based on what we used in the IMP project) so that any practice (not just the big organizations) can measure themselves against national norms. We are using a measurement framework focused on the essential features of good primary care:Be the first point of contact (i.e. provide good access to your patients)Provide for good relationships over time (i.e. continuity of care)Provide comprehensive services (e.g. superb communication, self management support, shared decision making, etc)Coordinate careThis self-assessment process is matched with an online curriculum and monthly conference calls we offer to members.We're in the prototyping phase of the self-assessment recognition program and expect to move to more open beta testing with folks in a few weeks.Gordon Steve, Half decent comment and question but first I might suggest going to our main website and learning more about us. We are attempting to help small innovative practices as informed as possible and to share our joint experiences on all of these important matters. I would say that almost ALL members share your perspective at heart, but many are having a difficult time severing the ties that the system has impossed on all of us, in it's attemtps to keep docs in bondage and patients pleasantly stupid and uninformed, mislead as to what the real problem is... Mainly them. So as you spend more time here you will see that we share info on how to stay afloat or survive both inside and out... We all have major life and business altering choices to make as individuals as we attempt to survive the insanity and choking control of the present dysfunctional system.... Part of our group is not to force any one stylpe upon one another but to share as much as possible so fellow members can make the best informed choices for themselves, their practices and their patients.... No one answer fits all comers and with the present structure of the system it is not practical for all docs to leave the carrier based third party system... Be it the rural or urban poor, or the rust belt working class on extended unemployment in areas such as ours, not all patient populations can even support a totally insurance free doctor and practice as much as we wish the opposite was true... Hope this helps to start this conversation in a good direction for all of you out there like Steve who are not I would guess official members yet.... Happy Holidays one and all........... To: Sent: Tue, December 7, 2010 5:00:18 PMSubject: Please don't flame me but.... Please don't flame me but..... This group is called . What exactly does that mean? Is it a way for docs to discuss better patient care in their practice? If so this is wonderful!! Or is it a way to discuss how to deal with third parties? If so, all this does is perpetuate the main issue in improving practices and thus patient care by agreeing to third party intrusion of our offices. The more we go along with the third party rules, regulations and payment hassles, the more intertwined we become and we lose sight of our practice. There is no improvement if there is no vision. What is the mission statement of this group? Horvitz, D.O. stown, NJ www.drhorvitz.com Quote
Guest guest Posted December 8, 2010 Report Posted December 8, 2010 Tagging on to what Gordon said. There are those of us who have decided that by working within the current insurance structure (which everyone agrees is failing), we can begin to affect change in the system. I totally understand why you may regard this as idealistic and stupid, but I still believe there is value in trying—for my patients, myself, and hopefully future docs. So from my perspective, the information present in the practiceimprovement1 list serve on third party stuff is invaluable. Incidentally, the results of the IMP Cohort studies showed that by following what is preached on this list serve, even those of us working within the insurance system can provide excellent care to our patients. So although insurance insanities can make working for our patients more difficult, accepting third party contracts does not exclude us from the responsibility or decrease our ability to give high quality care. From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of drhorvitz@...Sent: Tuesday, December 07, 2010 5:00 PMTo: Subject: Please don't flame me but.... Please don't flame me but..... This group is called . What exactly does that mean? Is it a way for docs to discuss better patient care in their practice? If so this is wonderful!! Or is it a way to discuss how to deal with third parties? If so, all this does is perpetuate the main issue in improving practices and thus patient care by agreeing to third party intrusion of our offices. The more we go along with the third party rules, regulations and payment hassles, the more intertwined we become and we lose sight of our practice. There is no improvement if there is no vision. What is the mission statement of this group? Horvitz, D.O.stown, NJwww.drhorvitz.com Quote
Guest guest Posted December 8, 2010 Report Posted December 8, 2010 just one thing I'd like to add...Everyone had their reasons for staying in the system and while none of us think it's a good one, we've made that choice for the time being (or maybe longterm in some cases). However statements like " I work for my patients and not the insurance company " seems to suggest that only those that do not accept insurance are working for what is best for their patients. One can accept insurance for patient visits but still make all their decisions based on what is best for a patient, irrespective of what is covered, etc. I think there are some excellent docs both in and outside this group (i feel myself included) that do only what is best for patients and really dont ever take insurance into the discussion. For me insurance is simply something I use to get paid for my office visits and nothing more. Tagging on to what Gordon said. There are those of us who have decided that by working within the current insurance structure (which everyone agrees is failing), we can begin to affect change in the system. I totally understand why you may regard this as idealistic and stupid, but I still believe there is value in trying—for my patients, myself, and hopefully future docs. So from my perspective, the information present in the practiceimprovement1 list serve on third party stuff is invaluable. Incidentally, the results of the IMP Cohort studies showed that by following what is preached on this list serve, even those of us working within the insurance system can provide excellent care to our patients. So although insurance insanities can make working for our patients more difficult, accepting third party contracts does not exclude us from the responsibility or decrease our ability to give high quality care. From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of drhorvitz@... Sent: Tuesday, December 07, 2010 5:00 PMTo: Subject: Please don't flame me but.... Please don't flame me but..... This group is called . What exactly does that mean? Is it a way for docs to discuss better patient care in their practice? If so this is wonderful!! Or is it a way to discuss how to deal with third parties? If so, all this does is perpetuate the main issue in improving practices and thus patient care by agreeing to third party intrusion of our offices. The more we go along with the third party rules, regulations and payment hassles, the more intertwined we become and we lose sight of our practice. There is no improvement if there is no vision. What is the mission statement of this group? Horvitz, D.O.stown, NJ www.drhorvitz.com Quote
Guest guest Posted December 8, 2010 Report Posted December 8, 2010 Re working for my pts Think this may refer to docs who work for hospital owned practices... I also take insurance mostly, but work for me AND my pts... Matt in Western PA Re: Please don't flame me but.... just one thing I'd like to add... Everyone had their reasons for staying in the system and while none of us think it's a good one, we've made that choice for the time being (or maybe longterm in some cases). However statements like "I work for my patients and not the insurance company" seems to suggest that only those that do not accept insurance are working for what is best for their patients. One can accept insurance for patient visits but still make all their decisions based on what is best for a patient, irrespective of what is covered, etc. I think there are some excellent docs both in and outside this group (i feel myself included) that do only what is best for patients and really dont ever take insurance into the discussion. For me insurance is simply something I use to get paid for my office visits and nothing more. Tagging on to what Gordon said. There are those of us who have decided that by working within the current insurance structure (which everyone agrees is failing), we can begin to affect change in the system. I totally understand why you may regard this as idealistic and stupid, but I still believe there is value in trying—for my patients, myself, and hopefully future docs. So from my perspective, the information present in the practiceimprovement1 list serve on third party stuff is invaluable. Incidentally, the results of the IMP Cohort studies showed that by following what is preached on this list serve, even those of us working within the insurance system can provide excellent care to our patients. So although insurance insanities can make working for our patients more difficult, accepting third party contracts does not exclude us from the responsibility or decrease our ability to give high quality care. From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of drhorvitz@...Sent: Tuesday, December 07, 2010 5:00 PMTo: Subject: Please don't flame me but.... Please don't flame me but..... This group is called . What exactly does that mean? Is it a way for docs to discuss better patient care in their practice? If so this is wonderful!! Or is it a way to discuss how to deal with third parties? If so, all this does is perpetuate the main issue in improving practices and thus patient care by agreeing to third party intrusion of our offices. The more we go along with the third party rules, regulations and payment hassles, the more intertwined we become and we lose sight of our practice. There is no improvement if there is no vision. What is the mission statement of this group? Horvitz, D.O. stown, NJ www.drhorvitz.com Quote
Guest guest Posted December 8, 2010 Report Posted December 8, 2010 Practiceimprovemtn1 means support and community and problem solving and sharing, I think at it s simplestAnd as for third parties- they exist third parties will not go away I do not think it feasible that they do, either Third parties should certainly change . I do not know if they will in my lifetime It is politically correct to say cheers, and be respectful to, people who do differently than i.... many tell me what to do . 'It is possible ... you can... " but they do not live here. What i am after- - is something replicable To change the system- which needs to happen- I am after something bigger.And becasue some take jobs and some opt out and 50 states vary tremendously , I fail to see how we can get there. I have lots of vision. And i know alot about improvement and I have 5.5 yrs of really good data to prove it. We don't walk in each others shoes much nor in the shoes of patients it is very bad out hereIt is my belief that unless and until docs( and midlevels, etcetc ) and patients join up together, not a thing can happen We have been successfully divided and fractionated for decades. We never stop being separate and going at each other. Just imagine if specialists supported primary c are Just imagine if you knew the issues that drive cardiology crazy Imagine if patients trusted us again. I mean by joining up together Imean that we are unrelenting in our advocacy and use of our voices. andI don;t see it happening.So don;t flame me either But don;t tell me how to practiceLet;s fix it for everyone. Please don't flame me but..... This group is called . What exactly does that mean? Is it a way for docs to discuss better patient care in their practice? If so this is wonderful!! Or is it a way to discuss how to deal with third parties? If so, all this does is perpetuate the main issue in improving practices and thus patient care by agreeing to third party intrusion of our offices. The more we go along with the third party rules, regulations and payment hassles, the more intertwined we become and we lose sight of our practice. There is no improvement if there is no vision. What is the mission statement of this group? Horvitz, D.O. stown, NJ www.drhorvitz.com -- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!) Email is best used for appointment making and brief questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org Quote
Guest guest Posted December 8, 2010 Report Posted December 8, 2010 " I totally understand why you may regard this as idealistic and stupid, " " ...So don;t flame me either But don;t tell me how to practice Let;s fix it for everyone... " " ...I work for my patients and not the insurance company " seems to suggest that only those that do not accept insurance are working for what is best for their patients... " Come on guys. No one is telling anyone how to practice. No one but the poster used the words " idealistic and stupid. " No one said that only those not accepting insurance have a corner market on doing what is right for their patients. I am very sad that this issue hits on such a deep nerve that good people choose to be insulted instead of uplifted or at least open minded to new ideas. We are all on the same team, but we choose instead to argue and defend, and thus we are divided. Good luck to us all. Good night. I am truly honored to have had you in my world for such an important transitional time in my life. I am forever grateful. Practiceimprovemtn1 means support and community and problem solving and sharing, I think at it s simplestAnd as for third parties- they exist third parties will not go away I do not think it feasible that they do, either Third parties should certainly change . I do not know if they will in my lifetime It is politically correct to say cheers, and be respectful to, people who do differently than i.... many tell me what to do . 'It is possible ... you can... " but they do not live here. What i am after- - is something replicable To change the system- which needs to happen- I am after something bigger.And becasue some take jobs and some opt out and 50 states vary tremendously , I fail to see how we can get there. I have lots of vision. And i know alot about improvement and I have 5.5 yrs of really good data to prove it. We don't walk in each others shoes much nor in the shoes of patients it is very bad out hereIt is my belief that unless and until docs( and midlevels, etcetc ) and patients join up together, not a thing can happen We have been successfully divided and fractionated for decades. We never stop being separate and going at each other. Just imagine if specialists supported primary c are Just imagine if you knew the issues that drive cardiology crazy Imagine if patients trusted us again. I mean by joining up together Imean that we are unrelenting in our advocacy and use of our voices. andI don;t see it happening.So don;t flame me either But don;t tell me how to practiceLet;s fix it for everyone. Please don't flame me but..... This group is called . What exactly does that mean? Is it a way for docs to discuss better patient care in their practice? If so this is wonderful!! Or is it a way to discuss how to deal with third parties? If so, all this does is perpetuate the main issue in improving practices and thus patient care by agreeing to third party intrusion of our offices. The more we go along with the third party rules, regulations and payment hassles, the more intertwined we become and we lose sight of our practice. There is no improvement if there is no vision. What is the mission statement of this group? Horvitz, D.O. stown, NJ www.drhorvitz.com -- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!) Email is best used for appointment making and brief questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org Quote
Guest guest Posted December 8, 2010 Report Posted December 8, 2010 ,You are right. After sending, I re-read my post and worried that the word “stupid” was probably a bad choice. I did not feel that was personally attacking. I did not feel angry or upset. However, I do think that a lot of people (many of us included) feel that continuing to work with the insurance companies is indeed stupid (perhaps more accurately insane if you use Einstein’s definition of insanity). My main focus of the post was to try and contradict the sentences “The more we go along with the third party rules, regulations and payment hassles, the more intertwined we become and we lose sight of our practice. There is no improvement if there is no vision.” The essence of this list serve and movement disproves this statement. From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Sent: Tuesday, December 07, 2010 11:54 PMTo: Subject: Re: Please don't flame me but.... " I totally understand why you may regard this as idealistic and stupid, " " ...So don;t flame me either But don;t tell me how to practiceLet;s fix it for everyone... " " ...I work for my patients and not the insurance company " seems to suggest that only those that do not accept insurance are working for what is best for their patients... " Come on guys. No one is telling anyone how to practice. No one but the poster used the words " idealistic and stupid. " No one said that only those not accepting insurance have a corner market on doing what is right for their patients. I am very sad that this issue hits on such a deep nerve that good people choose to be insulted instead of uplifted or at least open minded to new ideas. We are all on the same team, but we choose instead to argue and defend, and thus we are divided.Good luck to us all. Good night. I am truly honored to have had you in my world for such an important transitional time in my life. I am forever grateful. Practiceimprovemtn1 means support and community and problem solving and sharing, I think at it s simplestAnd as for third parties- they exist third parties will not go away I do not think it feasible that they do, either Third parties should certainly change .I do not know if they will in my lifetime It is politically correct to say cheers, and be respectful to, people who do differently than i.... many tell me what to do . 'It is possible ... you can... " but they do not live here. What i am after- - is something replicable To change the system- which needs to happen- I am after something bigger.And becasue some take jobs and some opt out and 50 states vary tremendously , I fail to see how we can get there. I have lots of vision. And i know alot about improvement and I have 5.5 yrs of really good data to prove it. We don't walk in each others shoes much nor in the shoes of patientsit is very bad out hereIt is my belief that unless and until docs( and midlevels, etcetc ) and patients join up together, not a thing can happen We have been successfully divided and fractionated for decades. We never stop being separate and going at each other. Just imagine if specialists supported primary c are Just imagine if you knew the issues that drive cardiology crazy Imagine if patients trusted us again. I mean by joining up together Imean that we are unrelenting in our advocacy and use of our voices. andI don;t see it happening.So don;t flame me either But don;t tell me how to practiceLet;s fix it for everyone. Please don't flame me but..... This group is called . What exactly does that mean? Is it a way for docs to discuss better patient care in their practice? If so this is wonderful!! Or is it a way to discuss how to deal with third parties? If so, all this does is perpetuate the main issue in improving practices and thus patient care by agreeing to third party intrusion of our offices. The more we go along with the third party rules, regulations and payment hassles, the more intertwined we become and we lose sight of our practice. There is no improvement if there is no vision. What is the mission statement of this group? Horvitz, D.O.stown, NJwww.drhorvitz.com -- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!)Email is best used for appointment making and brief questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org Quote
Guest guest Posted December 8, 2010 Report Posted December 8, 2010 RE how demographics give us an option... Remember that not all places give you the same options. Remember that Medicare is BEST PAYOR in NY, Calif, NJ -- so this dictates the max prices even if you opt out. Not all places will have a population that will pay cash for services, depends on the number of providers. Remember to share... Matt in Western PA Re: Please don't flame me but.... "I totally understand why you may regard this as idealistic and stupid,""...So don;t flame me either But don;t tell me how to practiceLet;s fix it for everyone...""...I work for my patients and not the insurance company" seems to suggest that only those that do not accept insurance are working for what is best for their patients..."Come on guys. No one is telling anyone how to practice. No one but the poster used the words "idealistic and stupid." No one said that only those not accepting insurance have a corner market on doing what is right for their patients. I am very sad that this issue hits on such a deep nerve that good people choose to be insulted instead of uplifted or at least open minded to new ideas. We are all on the same team, but we choose instead to argue and defend, and thus we are divided.Good luck to us all. Good night. I am truly honored to have had you in my world for such an important transitional time in my life. I am forever grateful. Practiceimprovemtn1 means support and community and problem solving and sharing, I think at it s simplestAnd as for third parties- they exist third parties will not go away I do not think it feasible that they do, either Third parties should certainly change .I do not know if they will in my lifetime It is politically correct to say cheers, and be respectful to, people who do differently than i.... many tell me what to do . 'It is possible ... you can..."but they do not live here. What i am after- - is something replicable To change the system- which needs to happen- I am after something bigger.And becasue some take jobs and some opt out and 50 states vary tremendously , I fail to see how we can get there. I have lots of vision. And i know alot about improvement and I have 5.5 yrs of really good data to prove it. We don't walk in each others shoes much nor in the shoes of patientsit is very bad out hereIt is my belief that unless and until docs( and midlevels, etcetc ) and patients join up together, not a thing can happen We have been successfully divided and fractionated for decades. We never stop being separate and going at each other. Just imagine if specialists supported primary c are Just imagine if you knew the issues that drive cardiology crazy Imagine if patients trusted us again. I mean by joining up together Imean that we are unrelenting in our advocacy and use of our voices. andI don;t see it happening.So don;t flame me either But don;t tell me how to practiceLet;s fix it for everyone. Please don't flame me but..... This group is called . What exactly does that mean? Is it a way for docs to discuss better patient care in their practice? If so this is wonderful!! Or is it a way to discuss how to deal with third parties? If so, all this does is perpetuate the main issue in improving practices and thus patient care by agreeing to third party intrusion of our offices. The more we go along with the third party rules, regulations and payment hassles, the more intertwined we become and we lose sight of our practice. There is no improvement if there is no vision. What is the mission statement of this group? Horvitz, D.O. stown, NJ www.drhorvitz.com -- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!)Email is best used for appointment making and brief questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org Quote
Guest guest Posted December 8, 2010 Report Posted December 8, 2010 The issue hits a nerve becasue people need hope People are hurting The list serv community sometimes offers hope Sometimes not It will always hit an nerve becasue as I said we area horribly divided When we are so divided we cannot effectively get change made. Jean " I totally understand why you may regard this as idealistic and stupid, " " ...So don;t flame me either But don;t tell me how to practice Let;s fix it for everyone... " " ...I work for my patients and not the insurance company " seems to suggest that only those that do not accept insurance are working for what is best for their patients... " Come on guys. No one is telling anyone how to practice. No one but the poster used the words " idealistic and stupid. " No one said that only those not accepting insurance have a corner market on doing what is right for their patients. I am very sad that this issue hits on such a deep nerve that good people choose to be insulted instead of uplifted or at least open minded to new ideas. We are all on the same team, but we choose instead to argue and defend, and thus we are divided. Good luck to us all. Good night. I am truly honored to have had you in my world for such an important transitional time in my life. I am forever grateful. Practiceimprovemtn1 means support and community and problem solving and sharing, I think at it s simplestAnd as for third parties- they exist third parties will not go away I do not think it feasible that they do, either Third parties should certainly change . I do not know if they will in my lifetime It is politically correct to say cheers, and be respectful to, people who do differently than i.... many tell me what to do . 'It is possible ... you can... " but they do not live here. What i am after- - is something replicable To change the system- which needs to happen- I am after something bigger.And becasue some take jobs and some opt out and 50 states vary tremendously , I fail to see how we can get there. I have lots of vision. And i know alot about improvement and I have 5.5 yrs of really good data to prove it. We don't walk in each others shoes much nor in the shoes of patients it is very bad out hereIt is my belief that unless and until docs( and midlevels, etcetc ) and patients join up together, not a thing can happen We have been successfully divided and fractionated for decades. We never stop being separate and going at each other. Just imagine if specialists supported primary c are Just imagine if you knew the issues that drive cardiology crazy Imagine if patients trusted us again. I mean by joining up together Imean that we are unrelenting in our advocacy and use of our voices. andI don;t see it happening.So don;t flame me either But don;t tell me how to practiceLet;s fix it for everyone. Please don't flame me but..... This group is called . What exactly does that mean? Is it a way for docs to discuss better patient care in their practice? If so this is wonderful!! Or is it a way to discuss how to deal with third parties? If so, all this does is perpetuate the main issue in improving practices and thus patient care by agreeing to third party intrusion of our offices. The more we go along with the third party rules, regulations and payment hassles, the more intertwined we become and we lose sight of our practice. There is no improvement if there is no vision. What is the mission statement of this group? Horvitz, D.O. stown, NJ www.drhorvitz.com -- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!) Email is best used for appointment making and brief questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org -- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!) Email is best used for appointment making and brief questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org Quote
Guest guest Posted December 8, 2010 Report Posted December 8, 2010 I am really hard pressed to figure out some of this vitriol. I have patients who pay for their insurance, either directly or via payroll deductions, who expect to be able to use it. Our community has taken a real hit in this economic downturn, and to pressure people to not use their insurance seems rather draconian in our neck of the woods-as says. We never should have been in this mess to begin with. Insurance is suppose to protect you from the catastrophic, not the mundane. The problem with insurances, in my opinion, started with Medicare and payment for everything. Insurers have provided products for business, labor unions, and individuals, that the buyers wanted. Increasing benefits, first dollar coverage, preventative care, etc. etc. The result has been rapid increases in provision of " everything for everybody and somebody else better pay for it " attitude in our county. If we had left health insurance as the coverage for severe illness, or hospitalization, the cost of care would have grown more slowly, the grow was abnormally coopted by payment system instead of the usual supply and demand. A recent study has shown the same thing about collage education. The availability of grants and scholorships has fueled the cost of college education where you can't afford college without them. (As a recent faculty member, I can tell you that the FM faculty makes much more that the average IMPer without seem 1/3 of the patients-right DAnielle?) This has driven the entitlement and cost of care beyond anyone's ability to pay for it. Now we are paying the price. I chuckle that the AARP folks who fight for the right for every 99 year old to have a heart transplant, and every orthopedic surgeon, who is afraid their $1m salary might be in jeopardy. But the system has been created by all of us; consumers, the buyers of insurance (business, unions, individuals), providers-including us. Is a change necessary. Sure, but don't link anyone's acceptance of insurance as sinister or stupid, we all work in the systems we work in. For me, taking insurance was a business decision and it works for me and my patients. Jim ________________________________________ From: [ ] On Behalf Of Dr. Brady [drbrady@...] Sent: Wednesday, December 08, 2010 5:51 AM To: Subject: RE: Please don't flame me but.... , You are right. After sending, I re-read my post and worried that the word “stupid” was probably a bad choice. I did not feel that was personally attacking. I did not feel angry or upset. However, I do think that a lot of people (many of us included) feel that continuing to work with the insurance companies is indeed stupid (perhaps more accurately insane if you use Einstein’s definition of insanity). My main focus of the post was to try and contradict the sentences “The more we go along with the third party rules, regulations and payment hassles, the more intertwined we become and we lose sight of our practice. There is no improvement if there is no vision.” The essence of this list serve and movement disproves this statement. From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Sent: Tuesday, December 07, 2010 11:54 PM To: Subject: Re: Please don't flame me but.... " I totally understand why you may regard this as idealistic and stupid, " " ...So don;t flame me either But don;t tell me how to practice Let;s fix it for everyone... " " ...I work for my patients and not the insurance company " seems to suggest that only those that do not accept insurance are working for what is best for their patients... " Come on guys. No one is telling anyone how to practice. No one but the poster used the words " idealistic and stupid. " No one said that only those not accepting insurance have a corner market on doing what is right for their patients. I am very sad that this issue hits on such a deep nerve that good people choose to be insulted instead of uplifted or at least open minded to new ideas. We are all on the same team, but we choose instead to argue and defend, and thus we are divided. Good luck to us all. Good night. I am truly honored to have had you in my world for such an important transitional time in my life. I am forever grateful. On Tue, Dec 7, 2010 at 7:55 PM, > wrote: Practiceimprovemtn1 means support and community and problem solving and sharing, I think at it s simplest And as for third parties- they exist third parties will not go away I do not think it feasible that they do, either Third parties should certainly change . I do not know if they will in my lifetime It is politically correct to say cheers, and be respectful to, people who do differently than i ..... many tell me what to do . 'It is possible ... you can... " but they do not live here. What i am after- - is something replicable To change the system- which needs to happen- I am after something bigger.And becasue some take jobs and some opt out and 50 states vary tremendously , I fail to see how we can get there. I have lots of vision. And i know alot about improvement and I have 5.5 yrs of really good data to prove it. We don't walk in each others shoes much nor in the shoes of patients it is very bad out here It is my belief that unless and until docs( and midlevels, etcetc ) and patients join up together, not a thing can happen We have been successfully divided and fractionated for decades. We never stop being separate and going at each other. Just imagine if specialists supported primary c are Just imagine if you knew the issues that drive cardiology crazy Imagine if patients trusted us again. I mean by joining up together Imean that we are unrelenting in our advocacy and use of our voices. and I don;t see it happening. So don;t flame me either But don;t tell me how to practice Let;s fix it for everyone. On Tue, Dec 7, 2010 at 5:00 PM, > wrote: Please don't flame me but..... This group is called . What exactly does that mean? Is it a way for docs to discuss better patient care in their practice? If so this is wonderful!! Or is it a way to discuss how to deal with third parties? If so, all this does is perpetuate the main issue in improving practices and thus patient care by agreeing to third party intrusion of our offices. The more we go along with the third party rules, regulations and payment hassles, the more intertwined we become and we lose sight of our practice. There is no improvement if there is no vision. What is the mission statement of this group? Horvitz, D.O. stown, NJ www.drhorvitz.com<http://www.drhorvitz.com> -- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!) Email is best used for appointment making and brief questions Email replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org<http://impcenter.org> Quote
Guest guest Posted December 8, 2010 Report Posted December 8, 2010 I'm glad to see Dr Horvitz joining the list. I enjoyed followed his blog last year on his transition to cash practice. There seems to be a lot of emotion or politics surrounding cash practice here and elsewhere. The fact is that commercial and government third party payment has created most of the problems faced by us and our patients. Moving to cash (with a safety net for the poor) is better for both in the long run, even if the transition is painful. Quality primary care is cheaper than cell phone service or cable TV. It is affordable for most of our patients. If not, all of us are also surrounded by nonprofit, supposedly charitable hospital systems that get paid more than us by third party payers for those who can't or won't pay us directly. Pierce The issue hits a nerve becasue people need hope People are hurting The list serv community sometimes offers hope Sometimes not It will always hit an nerve becasue as I said we area horribly divided When we are so divided we cannot effectively get change made. Jean Quote
Guest guest Posted December 8, 2010 Report Posted December 8, 2010 Jean You are absolutely correct in that as physicians, we have allowed ourselves to be thoroughly divided. It is my belief that 99% of physicians are caring, honest and work their butts off for their patients. However, getting back to my initial post, the main difference I see in physician practices, is the system that physicians place themselves in. There is no one size fits all system that will work for everyone. Just as this group helps each practice by sharing both good and bad ideas and outcomes, from the lurking I have been doing on this list serve, one of the main topics is how to maximize revenues from third parties, as opposed to how to provide the best patient care. Now we can talk all day about statistics and reports showing how small practices can function effectively in the care of their patients. I think Gordon's initial mission is terrific in that regard. But the implementation of these goals, by allowing ourselves and our practices to have to prove to Uncle Sam, or Cousin Aetna that we are worthy gets away from the reason I went into solo family practice. The only person I feel that I must prove myself to is the patent sitting in my exam/consultation room. Everyday I go into my office I feel the need to continue proving myself to my patients. I do this without looking for statistical quotas on how many patients are on statins, and how many women have had dexa scans. I make my recommendations as I see that fits each individual without any pressure on myself other than comes from the patient and my own ethics. I joke around a lot about the reason I went into solo family practice in 1998, against the advice of most of my colleagues, was because I do not play well with others. The funny thing is that I do play well with others, especially when we have the same goals in mind. My goals are excellent individualized and personalized family medical care with the focus squarely on the individual. I have trouble thinking that way when bombarded with Hedis and formularies, preauths and pre certifications, and patient quotas from bean counters. So I may be idealistic in my views, but it is real in my practice. Long winded but my point is that we need to open up this discussion if we ever have a chance of taking back control of our profession. It is my sincere belief that if physicians rid themselves of third party intruders, we would be able to give better, more effective, efficient and less expensive care to not only our patients, but to the millions of uninsured as well. I think that would fit very well into Gordon's mission for healthcare, and I hope others as well. Enough for now. It is my day off and I need to go work on my practice wellness newsletter. Horvitz, D.O. stown, NJ Www.drhorvitz.com Sent from my iPad Quote
Guest guest Posted December 8, 2010 Report Posted December 8, 2010 Email/listserv exchanges run the risk of mis-interpretation of emotion. We may be reading more into the emails than is truly there, so when you find yourself having a strong reaction to a post, consider that it may not have the intent you perceive.I certainly sense frustration with a broken payment system and variability in approaches sometimes chosen and sometimes forced upon clinicians. The things that bind us in common interest outweigh the differences. Diversity in approach enriches our discussion and community. Unlike natural selection we need not wait for successive generations to spread good ideas, we can pick and choose ideas that may fit our individual circumstances and look to the power of the community to help us try new things.Gordon I'm glad to see Dr Horvitz joining the list. I enjoyed followed his blog last year on his transition to cash practice. There seems to be a lot of emotion or politics surrounding cash practice here and elsewhere. The fact is that commercial and government third party payment has created most of the problems faced by us and our patients. Moving to cash (with a safety net for the poor) is better for both in the long run, even if the transition is painful. Quality primary care is cheaper than cell phone service or cable TV. It is affordable for most of our patients. If not, all of us are also surrounded by nonprofit, supposedly charitable hospital systems that get paid more than us by third party payers for those who can't or won't pay us directly. Pierce The issue hits a nerve becasue people need hope People are hurting The list serv community sometimes offers hope Sometimes not It will always hit an nerve becasue as I said we area horribly divided When we are so divided we cannot effectively get change made. Jean Quote
Guest guest Posted December 8, 2010 Report Posted December 8, 2010 I am emerging from a situation where the physician leadership coppedout/ passed the buck/ enabled the hosp admin in a situation of physican autonomy vs filthy lucre. I feel the same things you do steve, when I go to the hospital when I look at my colleagues, but here I am the copperouter/ enabler etc etc Email/listserv exchanges run the risk of mis-interpretation of emotion. We may be reading more into the emails than is truly there, so when you find yourself having a strong reaction to a post, consider that it may not have the intent you perceive. I certainly sense frustration with a broken payment system and variability in approaches sometimes chosen and sometimes forced upon clinicians. The things that bind us in common interest outweigh the differences. Diversity in approach enriches our discussion and community. Unlike natural selection we need not wait for successive generations to spread good ideas, we can pick and choose ideas that may fit our individual circumstances and look to the power of the community to help us try new things. Gordon I'm glad to see Dr Horvitz joining the list. I enjoyed followed his blog last year on his transition to cash practice. There seems to be a lot of emotion or politics surrounding cash practice here and elsewhere. The fact is that commercial and government third party payment has created most of the problems faced by us and our patients. Moving to cash (with a safety net for the poor) is better for both in the long run, even if the transition is painful. Quality primary care is cheaper than cell phone service or cable TV. It is affordable for most of our patients. If not, all of us are also surrounded by nonprofit, supposedly charitable hospital systems that get paid more than us by third party payers for those who can't or won't pay us directly. Pierce The issue hits a nerve becasue people need hope People are hurting The list serv community sometimes offers hope Sometimes not It will always hit an nerve becasue as I said we area horribly divided When we are so divided we cannot effectively get change made. Jean -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D7830 mont Mesa Blvd #287San Diego, CA 92111www.mypcponline.com Quote
Guest guest Posted December 8, 2010 Report Posted December 8, 2010 I know that I don’t have any ill feelings regarding cash practices and must have totally missed the post where someone got upset. What I do get upset about is that sometimes those doctors that have gone to cash only feel that them it can work for everyone. And that is simply not True. There are only so many cash only practices that a market can support. MDVIP and I am sure SIMDP have studied this very carefully and that's why they are so successful. Also, not all of us have charitable hospital systems near us that can see our indigent much less our insured who don’t want to pay. But I did score one for our affordability. Saw a patient who had been sick for 2 weeks with fevers and URI symptoms. Went to a Minute Clinic as she didn’t have insurance. Waited 1-3/4 hours, was diagnosed with strep, URI and double ear infections without any testing. Prescribed ear drops and Zithromax and charged $115. She saw me 2 weeks later, no better and I saw her for $62.50 and she can call me back if she doesn’t get better. Now she knows that I am cheaper and hopefully better. Kathy Saradarian, MD Branchville, NJ www.qualityfamilypractice.com Solo 4/03, Practicing since 9/90 Practice Partner 5/03 Low staffing From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Pierce Sent: Wednesday, December 08, 2010 11:22 AM To: Subject: Re: Please don't flame me but.... see Dr Horvitz joining the list. I enjoyed followed his blog last year on his transition to cash practice. There seems to be a lot of emotion or politics surrounding cash practice here and elsewhere. The fact is that commercial and government third party payment has created most of the problems faced by us and our patients. Moving to cash (with a safety net for the poor) is better for both in the long run, even if the transition is painful. Quality primary care is cheaper than cell phone service or cable TV. It is affordable for most of our patients. If not, all of us are also surrounded by nonprofit, supposedly charitable hospital systems that get paid more than us by third party payers for those who can't or won't pay us directly. Pierce The issue hits a nerve becasue people need hope People are hurting The list serv community sometimes offers hope Sometimes not It will always hit an nerve becasue as I said we area horribly divided When we are so divided we cannot effectively get change made. Jean CyberDefender has scanned this email for potential threats. Version 2.0 / Build 4.03.29.01 Get free PC security at http://www.cyberdefender.com Quote
Guest guest Posted December 8, 2010 Report Posted December 8, 2010 I thoroughly agree with you. I play very well with my patients, I did not play well with bean counters in the Government when I worked for IHS, in the hospital when I worked for them, etc. I always try to look behind the post at the emotions. Certainly this is a very emotional subject for all of us. Many of us are holding on by our toenails, doing whatever we can to stay alive. There is a great deal of fear of not surviving, with or without the insurance companies depending on your geographic local, and practice set up. I think there is room on this list for everyone, and all view points, and I welcome you to the list serve. PS Joanne, I got my first dozen eggs in partial payment from someone yesterday, she has a high deductible plan. I thought of you. Re: Please don't flame me but.... JeanYou are absolutely correct in that as physicians, we have allowed ourselves to be thoroughly divided. It is my belief that 99% of physicians are caring, honest and work their butts off for their patients. However, getting back to my initial post, the main difference I see in physician practices, is the system that physicians place themselves in.There is no one size fits all system that will work for everyone. Just as this group helps each practice by sharing both good and bad ideas and outcomes, from the lurking I have been doing on this list serve, one of the main topics is how to maximize revenues from third parties, as opposed to how to provide the best patient care.Now we can talk all day about statistics and reports showing how small practices can function effectively in the care of their patients. I think Gordon's initial mission is terrific in that regard. But the implementation of these goals, by allowing ourselves and our practices to have to prove to Uncle Sam, or Cousin Aetna that we are worthy gets away from the reason I went into solo family practice.The only person I feel that I must prove myself to is the patent sitting in my exam/consultation room. Everyday I go into my office I feel the need to continue proving myself to my patients. I do this without looking for statistical quotas on how many patients are on statins, and how many women have had dexa scans. I make my recommendations as I see that fits each individual without any pressure on myself other than comes from the patient and my own ethics.I joke around a lot about the reason I went into solo family practice in 1998, against the advice of most of my colleagues, was because I do not play well with others. The funny thing is that I do play well with others, especially when we have the same goals in mind. My goals are excellent individualized and personalized family medical care with the focus squarely on the individual. I have trouble thinking that way when bombarded with Hedis and formularies, preauths and pre certifications, and patient quotas from bean counters.So I may be idealistic in my views, but it is real in my practice.Long winded but my point is that we need to open up this discussion if we ever have a chance of taking back control of our profession. It is my sincere belief that if physicians rid themselves of third party intruders, we would be able to give better, more effective, efficient and less expensive care to not only our patients, but to the millions of uninsured as well. I think that would fit very well into Gordon's mission for healthcare, and I hope others as well.Enough for now. It is my day off and I need to go work on my practice wellness newsletter. Horvitz, D.O.stown, NJWww.drhorvitz.comSent from my iPad Quote
Guest guest Posted December 8, 2010 Report Posted December 8, 2010 ,You should have held out for chickens. That way, you get the eggs, too. ;-) SetoSouth Pasadena, CA I thoroughly agree with you. I play very well with my patients, I did not play well with bean counters in the Government when I worked for IHS, in the hospital when I worked for them, etc. I always try to look behind the post at the emotions. Certainly this is a very emotional subject for all of us. Many of us are holding on by our toenails, doing whatever we can to stay alive. There is a great deal of fear of not surviving, with or without the insurance companies depending on your geographic local, and practice set up. I think there is room on this list for everyone, and all view points, and I welcome you to the list serve. PS Joanne, I got my first dozen eggs in partial payment from someone yesterday, she has a high deductible plan. I thought of you. Re: Please don't flame me but.... JeanYou are absolutely correct in that as physicians, we have allowed ourselves to be thoroughly divided. It is my belief that 99% of physicians are caring, honest and work their butts off for their patients. However, getting back to my initial post, the main difference I see in physician practices, is the system that physicians place themselves in.There is no one size fits all system that will work for everyone. Just as this group helps each practice by sharing both good and bad ideas and outcomes, from the lurking I have been doing on this list serve, one of the main topics is how to maximize revenues from third parties, as opposed to how to provide the best patient care.Now we can talk all day about statistics and reports showing how small practices can function effectively in the care of their patients. I think Gordon's initial mission is terrific in that regard. But the implementation of these goals, by allowing ourselves and our practices to have to prove to Uncle Sam, or Cousin Aetna that we are worthy gets away from the reason I went into solo family practice.The only person I feel that I must prove myself to is the patent sitting in my exam/consultation room. Everyday I go into my office I feel the need to continue proving myself to my patients. I do this without looking for statistical quotas on how many patients are on statins, and how many women have had dexa scans. I make my recommendations as I see that fits each individual without any pressure on myself other than comes from the patient and my own ethics.I joke around a lot about the reason I went into solo family practice in 1998, against the advice of most of my colleagues, was because I do not play well with others. The funny thing is that I do play well with others, especially when we have the same goals in mind. My goals are excellent individualized and personalized family medical care with the focus squarely on the individual. I have trouble thinking that way when bombarded with Hedis and formularies, preauths and pre certifications, and patient quotas from bean counters.So I may be idealistic in my views, but it is real in my practice.Long winded but my point is that we need to open up this discussion if we ever have a chance of taking back control of our profession. It is my sincere belief that if physicians rid themselves of third party intruders, we would be able to give better, more effective, efficient and less expensive care to not only our patients, but to the millions of uninsured as well. I think that would fit very well into Gordon's mission for healthcare, and I hope others as well.Enough for now. It is my day off and I need to go work on my practice wellness newsletter. Horvitz, D.O.stown, NJWww.drhorvitz.comSent from my iPad Quote
Guest guest Posted December 8, 2010 Report Posted December 8, 2010 Thanks , Laughed all over again. Re: Please don't flame me but.... JeanYou are absolutely correct in that as physicians, we have allowed ourselves to be thoroughly divided. It is my belief that 99% of physicians are caring, honest and work their butts off for their patients. However, getting back to my initial post, the main difference I see in physician practices, is the system that physicians place themselves in.There is no one size fits all system that will work for everyone. Just as this group helps each practice by sharing both good and bad ideas and outcomes, from the lurking I have been doing on this list serve, one of the main topics is how to maximize revenues from third parties, as opposed to how to provide the best patient care.Now we can talk all day about statistics and reports showing how small practices can function effectively in the care of their patients. I think Gordon's initial mission is terrific in that regard. But the implementation of these goals, by allowing ourselves and our practices to have to prove to Uncle Sam, or Cousin Aetna that we are worthy gets away from the reason I went into solo family practice.The only person I feel that I must prove myself to is the patent sitting in my exam/consultation room. Everyday I go into my office I feel the need to continue proving myself to my patients. I do this without looking for statistical quotas on how many patients are on statins, and how many women have had dexa scans. I make my recommendations as I see that fits each individual without any pressure on myself other than comes from the patient and my own ethics.I joke around a lot about the reason I went into solo family practice in 1998, against the advice of most of my colleagues, was because I do not play well with others. The funny thing is that I do play well with others, especially when we have the same goals in mind. My goals are excellent individualized and personalized family medical care with the focus squarely on the individual. I have trouble thinking that way when bombarded with Hedis and formularies, preauths and pre certifications, and patient quotas from bean counters.So I may be idealistic in my views, but it is real in my practice.Long winded but my point is that we need to open up this discussion if we ever have a chance of taking back control of our profession. It is my sincere belief that if physicians rid themselves of third party intruders, we would be able to give better, more effective, efficient and less expensive care to not only our patients, but to the millions of uninsured as well. I think that would fit very well into Gordon's mission for healthcare, and I hope others as well.Enough for now. It is my day off and I need to go work on my practice wellness newsletter. Horvitz, D.O.stown, NJWww.drhorvitz.comSent from my iPad Quote
Guest guest Posted December 8, 2010 Report Posted December 8, 2010 Hmmm... have and tripped upon a good metaphor for health insurance and their payments? " They pay us in eggs, but chickens would be better!! " ;-) --Tim Re: Please don't flame me but.... Jean You are absolutely correct in that as physicians, we have allowed ourselves to be thoroughly divided. It is my belief that 99% of physicians are caring, honest and work their butts off for their patients. However, getting back to my initial post, the main difference I see in physician practices, is the system that physicians place themselves in. There is no one size fits all system that will work for everyone. Just as this group helps each practice by sharing both good and bad ideas and outcomes, from the lurking I have been doing on this list serve, one of the main topics is how to maximize revenues from third parties, as opposed to how to provide the best patient care. Now we can talk all day about statistics and reports showing how small practices can function effectively in the care of their patients. I think Gordon's initial mission is terrific in that regard. But the implementation of these goals, by allowing ourselves and our practices to h ave to prove to Uncle Sam, or Cousin Aetna that we are worthy gets away from the reason I went into solo family practice. The only person I feel that I must prove myself to is the patent sitting in my exam/consultation room. Everyday I go into my office I feel the need to continue proving myself to my patients. I do this without looking for statistical quotas on how many patients are on statins, and how many women have had dexa scans. I make my recommendations as I see that fits each individual without any pressure on myself other than comes from the patient and my own ethics. I joke around a lot about the reason I went into solo family practice in 1998, against the advice of most of my colleagues, was because I do not play well with others. The funny thing is that I do play well with others, especially when we have the same goals in mind. My goals are excellent individualized and personalized family medical care with the focus squarely on the individual. I hav e trouble thinking that way when bombarded with Hedis and formularies, preauths and pre certifications, and patient quotas from bean counters. So I may be idealistic in my views, but it is real in my practice. Long winded but my point is that we need to open up this discussion if we ever have a chance of taking back control of our profession. It is my sincere belief that if physicians rid themselves of third party intruders, we would be able to give better, more effective, efficient and less expensive care to not only our patients, but to the millions of uninsured as well. I think that would fit very well into Gordon's mission for healthcare, and I hope others as well. Enough for now. It is my day off and I need to go work on my practice wellness newsletter. Horvitz, D.O. stown, NJ Www.drhorvitz.com Sent from my iPad Quote
Guest guest Posted December 8, 2010 Report Posted December 8, 2010 , Where did you work in the IHS? I was in Ft Defiance, Az 1979-1981. ________________________________________ From: [ ] On Behalf Of magnetdoctor@... [magnetdoctor@...] Sent: Wednesday, December 08, 2010 11:08 AM To: Subject: Re: Re: Please don't flame me but.... I thoroughly agree with you. I play very well with my patients, I did not play well with bean counters in the Government when I worked for IHS, in the hospital when I worked for them, etc. I always try to look behind the post at the emotions. Certainly this is a very emotional subject for all of us. Many of us are holding on by our toenails, doing whatever we can to stay alive. There is a great deal of fear of not surviving, with or without the insurance companies depending on your geographic local, and practice set up. I think there is room on this list for everyone, and all view points, and I welcome you to the list serve. PS Joanne, I got my first dozen eggs in partial payment from someone yesterday, she has a high deductible plan. I thought of you. Re: Please don't flame me but.... Jean You are absolutely correct in that as physicians, we have allowed ourselves to be thoroughly divided. It is my belief that 99% of physicians are caring, honest and work their butts off for their patients. However, getting back to my initial post, the main difference I see in physician practices, is the system that physicians place themselves in. There is no one size fits all system that will work for everyone. Just as this group helps each practice by sharing both good and bad ideas and outcomes, from the lurking I have been doing on this list serve, one of the main topics is how to maximize revenues from third parties, as opposed to how to provide the best patient care. Now we can talk all day about statistics and reports showing how small practices can function effectively in the care of their patients. I think Gordon's initial mission is terrific in that regard. But the implementation of these goals, by allowing ourselves and our practices to have to prove to Uncle Sam, or Cousin Aetna that we are worthy gets away from the reason I went into solo family practice. The only person I feel that I must prove myself to is the patent sitting in my exam/consultation room. Everyday I go into my office I feel the need to continue proving myself to my patients. I do this without looking for statistical quotas on how many patients are on statins, and how many women have had dexa scans. I make my recommendations as I see that fits each individual without any pressure on myself other than comes from the patient and my own ethics. I joke around a lot about the reason I went into solo family practice in 1998, against the advice of most of my colleagues, was because I do not play well with others. The funny thing is that I do play well with others, especially when we have the same goals in mind. My goals are excellent individualized and personalized family medical care with the focus squarely on the individual. I have trouble thinking that way when bombarded with Hedis and formularies, preauths and pre certifications, and patient quotas from bean counters. So I may be idealistic in my views, but it is real in my practice. Long winded but my point is that we need to open up this discussion if we ever have a chance of taking back control of our profession. It is my sincere belief that if physicians rid themselves of third party intruders, we would be able to give better, more effective, efficient and less expensive care to not only our patients, but to the millions of uninsured as well. I think that would fit very well into Gordon's mission for healthcare, and I hope others as well. Enough for now. It is my day off and I need to go work on my practice wellness newsletter. Horvitz, D.O. stown, NJ Www.drhorvitz.com Sent from my iPad Quote
Guest guest Posted December 8, 2010 Report Posted December 8, 2010 I was mostly in Puyallup Washington, but a short stint in N. California, at the Hupi tribe in the redwood mountains, just an hour from Eurecka. Re: Please don't flame me but....JeanYou are absolutely correct in that as physicians, we have allowed ourselves to be thoroughly divided. It is my belief that 99% of physicians are caring, honest and work their butts off for their patients. However, getting back to my initial post, the main difference I see in physician practices, is the system that physicians place themselves in.There is no one size fits all system that will work for everyone. Just as this group helps each practice by sharing both good and bad ideas and outcomes, from the lurking I have been doing on this list serve, one of the main topics is how to maximize revenues from third parties, as opposed to how to provide the best patient care.Now we can talk all day about statistics and reports showing how small practices can function effectively in the care of their patients. I think Gordon's initial mission is terrific in that regard. But the implementation of these goals, by allowing ourselves and our practices to have to prove to Uncle Sam, or Cousin Aetna that we are worthy gets away from the reason I went into solo family practice.The only person I feel that I must prove myself to is the patent sitting in my exam/consultation room. Everyday I go into my office I feel the need to continue proving myself to my patients. I do this without looking for statistical quotas on how many patients are on statins, and how many women have had dexa scans. I make my recommendations as I see that fits each individual without any pressure on myself other than comes from the patient and my own ethics.I joke around a lot about the reason I went into solo family practice in 1998, against the advice of most of my colleagues, was because I do not play well with others. The funny thing is that I do play well with others, especially when we have the same goals in mind. My goals are excellent individualized and personalized family medical care with the focus squarely on the individual. I have trouble thinking that way when bombarded with Hedis and formularies, preauths and pre certifications, and patient quotas from bean counters.So I may be idealistic in my views, but it is real in my practice.Long winded but my point is that we need to open up this discussion if we ever have a chance of taking back control of our profession. It is my sincere belief that if physicians rid themselves of third party intruders, we would be able to give better, more effective, efficient and less expensive care to not only our patients, but to the millions of uninsured as well. I think that would fit very well into Gordon's mission for healthcare, and I hope others as well.Enough for now. It is my day off and I need to go work on my practice wellness newsletter. Horvitz, D.O.stown, NJWww.drhorvitz.comSent from my iPad------------------------------------ Quote
Guest guest Posted December 9, 2010 Report Posted December 9, 2010 Steve, I will not debate your mostly solid and well thought out reasons for leaving the system behind ang thank goodness you are viable and doing decently it would seem. And I agree some amount of concerted effort to push our way thru on this would be a positive step in the best direction too... BUT here is the rub... If one can not pay the medical school debt, the office rent, the morgage, and the old fashioned business loans, utilities, Med Mal and all the other crap that we must carry and the debt most of us have to service in one form or another, than all those best intentions are meaningless. WE, the practice and the practioner MUST survive first or all our best intentions are just a meaningless and infective as you point out by staying too wed and tied to the system can. And so YES the present system SUCKS, I will scream it with you for any and all to see and hear, I really will, just ask anyone else here... But if I loose my home and our Jeeps, get evicted from our office space, the G & E gets turned off... What have I done and what have I gained for myself or our patients... And that is why so much god damn time is wasted discussing matters as to how to keep having the system pay off as best as possible... I was reading a local Journal put out by the local Counties Medical Societies here in the CNY region. And like you I was just blown away as to how much time and paper and ink was wasted inside this beautiful glossy paged self engrandizing journal on the System, payments, new changed coming down the pike from healthcare reform and the trend of Hospitals purchasing practices AGAIN!!!! It is a waste of time, energy and does distract us from what should be the real goals and where our attention, energies and resources should be focused, On the patients and on the Care and Medical Knowledge and Research... But if we have to shutter our doors and loose all and everything, our kids in the street our pets housed with the ASPCA on Death Row, and in default on all of our debts, what have we accomplised and what good have we done ourselves or those patients that no longer have my wife to take care of them and the issues that they entrust with her??? One must survive and keep themselves afloat and alive first, then and ONLY then can we focus on other more lofty goals... No matter how important they may be... Glad to engage you in all of this... To: " " < >Sent: Wed, December 8, 2010 11:27:38 AMSubject: Re: Please don't flame me but.... JeanYou are absolutely correct in that as physicians, we have allowed ourselves to be thoroughly divided. It is my belief that 99% of physicians are caring, honest and work their butts off for their patients. However, getting back to my initial post, the main difference I see in physician practices, is the system that physicians place themselves in.There is no one size fits all system that will work for everyone. Just as this group helps each practice by sharing both good and bad ideas and outcomes, from the lurking I have been doing on this list serve, one of the main topics is how to maximize revenues from third parties, as opposed to how to provide the best patient care.Now we can talk all day about statistics and reports showing how small practices can function effectively in the care of their patients. I think Gordon's initial mission is terrific in that regard. But the implementation of these goals, by allowing ourselves and our practices to have to prove to Uncle Sam, or Cousin Aetna that we are worthy gets away from the reason I went into solo family practice.The only person I feel that I must prove myself to is the patent sitting in my exam/consultation room. Everyday I go into my office I feel the need to continue proving myself to my patients. I do this without looking for statistical quotas on how many patients are on statins, and how many women have had dexa scans. I make my recommendations as I see that fits each individual without any pressure on myself other than comes from the patient and my own ethics.I joke around a lot about the reason I went into solo family practice in 1998, against the advice of most of my colleagues, was because I do not play well with others. The funny thing is that I do play well with others, especially when we have the same goals in mind. My goals are excellent individualized and personalized family medical care with the focus squarely on the individual. I have trouble thinking that way when bombarded with Hedis and formularies, preauths and pre certifications, and patient quotas from bean counters.So I may be idealistic in my views, but it is real in my practice.Long winded but my point is that we need to open up this discussion if we ever have a chance of taking back control of our profession. It is my sincere belief that if physicians rid themselves of third party intruders, we would be able to give better, more effective, efficient and less expensive care to not only our patients, but to the millions of uninsured as well. I think that would fit very well into Gordon's mission for healthcare, and I hope others as well.Enough for now. It is my day off and I need to go work on my practice wellness newsletter. Horvitz, D.O.stown, NJWww.drhorvitz.comSent from my iPad Quote
Guest guest Posted December 9, 2010 Report Posted December 9, 2010 Ditto. And I agree with the notion that insurance should be for catastrophes. Car insurance is for accidents, not tune ups. We should pay for our own preventive services and be covered for when we're seriously ill. And maybe pay more of insurance if we don't take care of preventive stuff, discounts if we do, the way we get discounts for having air bags and anti-theft locks. We have all grown used to a feeling of entitlement in medicine. And we are all to blame. > I am really hard pressed to figure out some of this vitriol. I have patients who pay for their insurance, either directly or via payroll deductions, who expect to be able to use it. Our community has taken a real hit in this economic downturn, and to pressure people to not use their insurance seems rather draconian in our neck of the woods-as says. > We never should have been in this mess to begin with. Insurance is suppose to protect you from the catastrophic, not the mundane. The problem with insurances, in my opinion, started with Medicare and payment for everything. Insurers have provided products for business, labor unions, and individuals, that the buyers wanted. Increasing benefits, first dollar coverage, preventative care, etc. etc. The result has been rapid increases in provision of " everything for everybody and somebody else better pay for it " attitude in our county. If we had left health insurance as the coverage for severe illness, or hospitalization, the cost of care would have grown more slowly, the grow was abnormally coopted by payment system instead of the usual supply and demand. A recent study has shown the same thing about collage education. The availability of grants and scholorships has fueled the cost of college education where you can't afford college without them. (As a recent faculty member, I can tell you that the FM faculty makes much more that the average IMPer without seem 1/3 of the patients-right DAnielle?) > This has driven the entitlement and cost of care beyond anyone's ability to pay for it. Now we are paying the price. I chuckle that the AARP folks who fight for the right for every 99 year old to have a heart transplant, and every orthopedic surgeon, who is afraid their $1m salary might be in jeopardy. But the system has been created by all of us; consumers, the buyers of insurance (business, unions, individuals), providers-including us. Is a change necessary. Sure, but don't link anyone's acceptance of insurance as sinister or stupid, we all work in the systems we work in. For me, taking insurance was a business decision and it works for me and my patients. > Jim > ________________________________________ > From: [ ] On Behalf Of Dr. Brady [drbrady@...] > Sent: Wednesday, December 08, 2010 5:51 AM > To: > Subject: RE: Please don't flame me but.... > > , > You are right. After sending, I re-read my post and worried that the word “stupid” was probably a bad choice. I did not feel that was personally attacking. I did not feel angry or upset. However, I do think that a lot of people (many of us included) feel that continuing to work with the insurance companies is indeed stupid (perhaps more accurately insane if you use Einstein’s definition of insanity). My main focus of the post was to try and contradict the sentences “The more we go along with the third party rules, regulations and payment hassles, the more intertwined we become and we lose sight of our practice. There is no improvement if there is no vision.” The essence of this list serve and movement disproves this statement. > > > From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of > Sent: Tuesday, December 07, 2010 11:54 PM > To: > Subject: Re: Please don't flame me but.... > > > > " I totally understand why you may regard this as idealistic and stupid, " > > " ...So don;t flame me either But don;t tell me how to practice > Let;s fix it for everyone... " > > " ...I work for my patients and not the insurance company " seems to suggest that only those that do not accept insurance are working for what is best for their patients... " > > Come on guys. > > No one is telling anyone how to practice. No one but the poster used the words " idealistic and stupid. " No one said that only those not accepting insurance have a corner market on doing what is right for their patients. > > I am very sad that this issue hits on such a deep nerve that good people choose to be insulted instead of uplifted or at least open minded to new ideas. We are all on the same team, but we choose instead to argue and defend, and thus we are divided. > > Good luck to us all. Good night. I am truly honored to have had you in my world for such an important transitional time in my life. I am forever grateful. > > > > > On Tue, Dec 7, 2010 at 7:55 PM, Jean Antonucci> wrote: > > > Practiceimprovemtn1 means support and community and problem solving and sharing, I think at it s simplest > > And as for third parties- they exist > third parties will not go away I do not think it feasible that they do, either > Third parties should certainly change . > I do not know if they will in my lifetime > It is politically correct to say cheers, and be respectful to, people who do differently than i > .... many tell me what to do . 'It is possible ... you can... " > but > they do not live here. > > What i am after- - is something replicable > > To change the system- > which needs to happen- > I am after something bigger.And becasue some take jobs and some opt out and 50 states vary tremendously , I fail to see how we can get there. > > I have lots of vision. And i know alot about improvement and I have 5.5 yrs of really good data to prove it. > > > We don't walk in each others shoes much nor in the shoes of patients > it is very bad out here > It is my belief that unless and until docs( and midlevels, etcetc ) and patients join up together, not a thing can happen We have been successfully divided and fractionated for decades. We never stop being separate and going at each other. Just imagine if specialists supported primary c are Just imagine if you knew the issues that drive cardiology crazy Imagine if patients trusted us again. I mean by joining up together Imean that we are unrelenting in our advocacy and use of our voices. > and > I don;t see it happening. > So don;t flame me either But don;t tell me how to practice > Let;s fix it for everyone. > > > > On Tue, Dec 7, 2010 at 5:00 PM,> wrote: > > Please don't flame me but..... > > This group is called . > > What exactly does that mean? > > Is it a way for docs to discuss better patient care in their practice? > > If so this is wonderful!! > > Or is it a way to discuss how to deal with third parties? > > If so, all this does is perpetuate the main issue in improving practices and thus patient care by agreeing to third party intrusion of our offices. The more we go along with the third party rules, regulations and payment hassles, the more intertwined we become and we lose sight of our practice. There is no improvement if there is no vision. > > What is the mission statement of this group? > > Horvitz, D.O. > stown, NJ > www.drhorvitz.com<http://www.drhorvitz.com> > > > > > -- > PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!) > Email is best used for appointment making and brief questions > Email replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . > > > MD > > > ph fax > impcenter.org<http://impcenter.org> > > > > > > ------------------------------------ > > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.