Guest guest Posted November 3, 2010 Report Posted November 3, 2010 I just received a call from United asking for some clarification on my NCBF. Apparently a couple patients submitted my invoice to United asking for reimbursement. The message from United wasn't immediately alarming as the lady just stated she wanted to clarify so she would know whether they should reimburse the patient. This is the first time, I've had to talk to the insurance company about the fee. I know to be clear that this is specifically for services they do not cover and not any sort of retainer or membership fee. Does anyone that has charged NCBF having any experience with questions from insurances or good " buzz words " or phrases to use. thanksdave gordon Quote
Guest guest Posted November 4, 2010 Report Posted November 4, 2010 I've had the conversation with Healthnet/Tricare but didn't get anywhere when they decided it wasn't allowed under their contract. So maybe someone more successful that me will respond. For conversations like yours, it would be nice if there were a CPT code for them to run through their system and automatically generate a denial. Since there isn't, the way they handle it seems to vary based on the personality of the person whose desk it lands on. The goal is to get them just to hand it back to the patient as non-covered. (Perhaps let them know how much easier their life will be if they don't have to traverse the bureaucracy of their own company?) Maybe worth giving them a couple of CPT codes that you're NOT going to bill because they are covered under the NCBF. Maybe they'll run those through the system and feel that they're on firmer ground in making the decision not to pursue it further. Haresch > > I just received a call from United asking for some clarification on my NCBF. > Apparently a couple patients submitted my invoice to United asking for > reimbursement. The message from United wasn't immediately alarming as the > lady just stated she wanted to clarify so she would know whether they should > reimburse the patient. > > This is the first time, I've had to talk to the insurance company about the > fee. I know to be clear that this is specifically for services they do not > cover and not any sort of retainer or membership fee. Does anyone that has > charged NCBF having any experience with questions from insurances or good > " buzz words " or phrases to use. > > thanks > > dave gordon > Quote
Guest guest Posted November 5, 2010 Report Posted November 5, 2010 But could you risk themn saying the the code is not covered and the allowed amount you can charge is $0? Ellen brought that up before. What about the this- a level 4 code gives you 25 min with pt, if you spend more time can you add those codes and they would be denied I've had the conversation with Healthnet/Tricare but didn't get anywhere when they decided it wasn't allowed under their contract. So maybe someone more successful that me will respond.For conversations like yours, it would be nice if there were a CPT code for them to run through their system and automatically generate a denial. Since there isn't, the way they handle it seems to vary based on the personality of the person whose desk it lands on. The goal is to get them just to hand it back to the patient as non-covered. (Perhaps let them know how much easier their life will be if they don't have to traverse the bureaucracy of their own company?) Maybe worth giving them a couple of CPT codes that you're NOT going to bill because they are covered under the NCBF. Maybe they'll run those through the system and feel that they're on firmer ground in making the decision not to pursue it further. Haresch >> I just received a call from United asking for some clarification on my NCBF. > Apparently a couple patients submitted my invoice to United asking for> reimbursement. The message from United wasn't immediately alarming as the> lady just stated she wanted to clarify so she would know whether they should > reimburse the patient.> > This is the first time, I've had to talk to the insurance company about the> fee. I know to be clear that this is specifically for services they do not> cover and not any sort of retainer or membership fee. Does anyone that has > charged NCBF having any experience with questions from insurances or good> " buzz words " or phrases to use.> > thanks> > dave gordon> -- M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined. This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error. Quote
Guest guest Posted November 5, 2010 Report Posted November 5, 2010 There is not actually going to be any billing of any codes, because the NCBF covers multiple services -- some with CPT codes, some not. I was just saying have a code would make things more black-and-white, but it's not going to happen anyway. There are several non-covered codes that I could submit rather than use an NCBF, but I didn't feel that the hassle and ill-will of that approach was worth it. Haresch > > > > > > I just received a call from United asking for some clarification on my > > NCBF. > > > Apparently a couple patients submitted my invoice to United asking for > > > reimbursement. The message from United wasn't immediately alarming as the > > > lady just stated she wanted to clarify so she would know whether they > > should > > > reimburse the patient. > > > > > > This is the first time, I've had to talk to the insurance company about > > the > > > fee. I know to be clear that this is specifically for services they do > > not > > > cover and not any sort of retainer or membership fee. Does anyone that > > has > > > charged NCBF having any experience with questions from insurances or good > > > " buzz words " or phrases to use. > > > > > > thanks > > > > > > dave gordon > > > > > > > > > > > > > -- > M.D. > www.elainemd.com > Office: begin_of_the_skype_highlighting end_of_the_skype_\ highlighting > Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined. > This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly > confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal > information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual > or entity named above. > > > > If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, > publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the > intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, > please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the > information that email in error. > Quote
Guest guest Posted November 6, 2010 Report Posted November 6, 2010 FWIW, i called yesterday and the lady who called me was out of the office. I then send an email simply saying " my patients should not be reimbursed because my charge is specifically for services not covered by insurance. " I didn't hear anything today...fingers are crossed. There is not actually going to be any billing of any codes, because the NCBF covers multiple services -- some with CPT codes, some not. I was just saying have a code would make things more black-and-white, but it's not going to happen anyway. There are several non-covered codes that I could submit rather than use an NCBF, but I didn't feel that the hassle and ill-will of that approach was worth it. Haresch > > > > > > I just received a call from United asking for some clarification on my > > NCBF. > > > Apparently a couple patients submitted my invoice to United asking for > > > reimbursement. The message from United wasn't immediately alarming as the > > > lady just stated she wanted to clarify so she would know whether they > > should > > > reimburse the patient. > > > > > > This is the first time, I've had to talk to the insurance company about > > the > > > fee. I know to be clear that this is specifically for services they do > > not > > > cover and not any sort of retainer or membership fee. Does anyone that > > has > > > charged NCBF having any experience with questions from insurances or good > > > " buzz words " or phrases to use. > > > > > > thanks > > > > > > dave gordon > > > > > > > > > > > > > -- > M.D. > www.elainemd.com > Office: begin_of_the_skype_highlighting end_of_the_skype_highlighting > Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined. > This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly > confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal > information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual > or entity named above. > > > > If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, > publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the > intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, > please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the > information that email in error. > Quote
Guest guest Posted November 19, 2010 Report Posted November 19, 2010 NEED ADVICE!! From those of you navigating the NCBF. Dave and ? Patient today asks for an appointment and when my assistant tells him my NCBF $10/month " HealthyAccess Fee " applies to ALL patients because I do not have 2 tiers of service and all patients have access to me 24 x 7 for email and phone, he replied that he was going to call Regence/Blue Cross BlueShield because he is certain that it is unethical to charge ALL patient an extra fee. He states that I am " forcing patients to pay just to walk in the door " and that all he wants is a physical every 2 years that his insurance allows without a copay or coinsurance. I decided to call him and answer his questions over the phone so he didn't have to call REgence and make my life hell. He tells me he met me 2 or 3 times, at my previous practice, he liked me, thinks I'm different (in a good way) from other docs and wants to see me but he doesn't want a relationship with his doctor, he doesn't want to talk to his doctor on the phone or email, he just wants his physical, he wants ME to do his physical and if I don't do the physical and waive the NCBF (because he says he should have a choice)he says he going to make it his goal in life to make my life hell. (he is an unemployed medical imaging " consultant " ) He is going to call RegenceBC/BS AND write articles about how doctors doing what I'm doing are taking advantage of patients and bilking the system to just make as much money as they can. He says he is not " blackmailing " me, he just wants his physical and doesn't want to pay. I told him (after way too much time on the phone) that I would see him for his physical and that I would re-evaluate the issue of choice in my healthy access fee. Perhaps I would offer to charge per phone call/email (do I need an ABN? for that) rather than a global fee. I feel threatened and blackmailed - but I don't actually dislike the guy. He is the kind of guy who you want as your friend, but never ever want as your enemy. If I were his friendly doctor, though, when he gives himself a heart attack, I most certainly will be blamed by him. So my tentative gameplan is to add to my policy, a provision to opt-out of the global NCBF and a choice to sign an ABN for telephone/email exchanges (I hate that idea because it discourages patients from contacting their doctor) and then I think I might call BCBS first (because this guy definately will) and spill the beans and see if I can get anyone half witted to understand what I'm saying, and then call this guy back and say. " I now offer patients a choice at my practice - pay a low monthly fee for the NCBF or pay per occurrence of each specific non covered phone or email exchange, BUT I am not willing to take you on as a patient because I feel uncomfortable (threatened and intimidated) due to the tone of our last conversation - I do not think we are a good match. " This guy has put me in a pickle. Stew Mones Maitree Family Medicine > > > > > > > > > > I just received a call from United asking for some clarification on > > my > > > > NCBF. > > > > > Apparently a couple patients submitted my invoice to United asking > > for > > > > > reimbursement. The message from United wasn't immediately alarming as > > the > > > > > lady just stated she wanted to clarify so she would know whether they > > > > should > > > > > reimburse the patient. > > > > > > > > > > This is the first time, I've had to talk to the insurance company > > about > > > > the > > > > > fee. I know to be clear that this is specifically for services they > > do > > > > not > > > > > cover and not any sort of retainer or membership fee. Does anyone > > that > > > > has > > > > > charged NCBF having any experience with questions from insurances or > > good > > > > > " buzz words " or phrases to use. > > > > > > > > > > thanks > > > > > > > > > > dave gordon > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > -- > > > M.D. > > > www.elainemd.com > > > Office: > > begin_of_the_skype_highlighting end_of_the_skype_highlighting > > > > > Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined. > > > This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly > > > confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal > > > information. The information is intended only for the use of the > > individual > > > or entity named above. > > > > > > > > > > > > If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, > > > publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not > > the > > > intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, > > > please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the > > > information that email in error. > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted November 19, 2010 Report Posted November 19, 2010 Do not enter into a doctor patient relationship with this guy. You are under no obligation to change your practice arrangements to satisfy him. Drop him a note saying that you enjoyed speaking with him but you suggest he look elsewhere for the practice that will exactly fit his needs.Joann NEED ADVICE!! From those of you navigating the NCBF. Dave and ? Patient today asks for an appointment and when my assistant tells him my NCBF $10/month "HealthyAccess Fee" applies to ALL patients because I do not have 2 tiers of service and all patients have access to me 24 x 7 for email and phone, he replied that he was going to call Regence/Blue Cross BlueShield because he is certain that it is unethical to charge ALL patient an extra fee. He states that I am "forcing patients to pay just to walk in the door" and that all he wants is a physical every 2 years that his insurance allows without a copay or coinsurance. I decided to call him and answer his questions over the phone so he didn't have to call REgence and make my life hell. He tells me he met me 2 or 3 times, at my previous practice, he liked me, thinks I'm different (in a good way) from other docs and wants to see me but he doesn't want a relationship with his doctor, he doesn't want to talk to his doctor on the phone or email, he just wants his physical, he wants ME to do his physical and if I don't do the physical and waive the NCBF (because he says he should have a choice)he says he going to make it his goal in life to make my life hell. (he is an unemployed medical imaging "consultant") He is going to call RegenceBC/BS AND write articles about how doctors doing what I'm doing are taking advantage of patients and bilking the system to just make as much money as they can. He says he is not "blackmailing" me, he just wants his physical and doesn't want to pay. I told him (after way too much time on the phone) that I would see him for his physical and that I would re-evaluate the issue of choice in my healthy access fee. Perhaps I would offer to charge per phone call/email (do I need an ABN? for that) rather than a global fee. I feel threatened and blackmailed - but I don't actually dislike the guy. He is the kind of guy who you want as your friend, but never ever want as your enemy. If I were his friendly doctor, though, when he gives himself a heart attack, I most certainly will be blamed by him. So my tentative gameplan is to add to my policy, a provision to opt-out of the global NCBF and a choice to sign an ABN for telephone/email exchanges (I hate that idea because it discourages patients from contacting their doctor) and then I think I might call BCBS first (because this guy definately will) and spill the beans and see if I can get anyone half witted to understand what I'm saying, and then call this guy back and say. "I now offer patients a choice at my practice - pay a low monthly fee for the NCBF or pay per occurrence of each specific non covered phone or email exchange, BUT I am not willing to take you on as a patient because I feel uncomfortable (threatened and intimidated) due to the tone of our last conversation - I do not think we are a good match." This guy has put me in a pickle. Stew Mones Maitree Family Medicine > > > > > > > > > > I just received a call from United asking for some clarification on > > my > > > > NCBF. > > > > > Apparently a couple patients submitted my invoice to United asking > > for > > > > > reimbursement. The message from United wasn't immediately alarming as > > the > > > > > lady just stated she wanted to clarify so she would know whether they > > > > should > > > > > reimburse the patient. > > > > > > > > > > This is the first time, I've had to talk to the insurance company > > about > > > > the > > > > > fee. I know to be clear that this is specifically for services they > > do > > > > not > > > > > cover and not any sort of retainer or membership fee. Does anyone > > that > > > > has > > > > > charged NCBF having any experience with questions from insurances or > > good > > > > > "buzz words" or phrases to use. > > > > > > > > > > thanks > > > > > > > > > > dave gordon > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > -- > > > M.D. > > > www.elainemd.com > > > Office: > > begin_of_the_skype_highlighting end_of_the_skype_highlighting > > > > > Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined. > > > This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly > > > confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal > > > information. The information is intended only for the use of the > > individual > > > or entity named above. > > > > > > > > > > > > If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, > > > publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not > > the > > > intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, > > > please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the > > > information that email in error. > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted November 19, 2010 Report Posted November 19, 2010 But, stew is worried about calls to regence and is asking for language to stave that headache off..now how/ Do not enter into a doctor patient relationship with this guy. You are under no obligation to change your practice arrangements to satisfy him. Drop him a note saying that you enjoyed speaking with him but you suggest he look elsewhere for the practice that will exactly fit his needs. Joann NEED ADVICE!! From those of you navigating the NCBF. Dave and ? Patient today asks for an appointment and when my assistant tells him my NCBF $10/month " HealthyAccess Fee " applies to ALL patients because I do not have 2 tiers of service and all patients have access to me 24 x 7 for email and phone, he replied that he was going to call Regence/Blue Cross BlueShield because he is certain that it is unethical to charge ALL patient an extra fee. He states that I am " forcing patients to pay just to walk in the door " and that all he wants is a physical every 2 years that his insurance allows without a copay or coinsurance. I decided to call him and answer his questions over the phone so he didn't have to call REgence and make my life hell. He tells me he met me 2 or 3 times, at my previous practice, he liked me, thinks I'm different (in a good way) from other docs and wants to see me but he doesn't want a relationship with his doctor, he doesn't want to talk to his doctor on the phone or email, he just wants his physical, he wants ME to do his physical and if I don't do the physical and waive the NCBF (because he says he should have a choice)he says he going to make it his goal in life to make my life hell. (he is an unemployed medical imaging " consultant " ) He is going to call RegenceBC/BS AND write articles about how doctors doing what I'm doing are taking advantage of patients and bilking the system to just make as much money as they can. He says he is not " blackmailing " me, he just wants his physical and doesn't want to pay. I told him (after way too much time on the phone) that I would see him for his physical and that I would re-evaluate the issue of choice in my healthy access fee. Perhaps I would offer to charge per phone call/email (do I need an ABN? for that) rather than a global fee. I feel threatened and blackmailed - but I don't actually dislike the guy. He is the kind of guy who you want as your friend, but never ever want as your enemy. If I were his friendly doctor, though, when he gives himself a heart attack, I most certainly will be blamed by him. So my tentative gameplan is to add to my policy, a provision to opt-out of the global NCBF and a choice to sign an ABN for telephone/email exchanges (I hate that idea because it discourages patients from contacting their doctor) and then I think I might call BCBS first (because this guy definately will) and spill the beans and see if I can get anyone half witted to understand what I'm saying, and then call this guy back and say. " I now offer patients a choice at my practice - pay a low monthly fee for the NCBF or pay per occurrence of each specific non covered phone or email exchange, BUT I am not willing to take you on as a patient because I feel uncomfortable (threatened and intimidated) due to the tone of our last conversation - I do not think we are a good match. " This guy has put me in a pickle. Stew Mones Maitree Family Medicine > > > > > > > > > > I just received a call from United asking for some clarification on > > my > > > > NCBF. > > > > > Apparently a couple patients submitted my invoice to United asking > > for > > > > > reimbursement. The message from United wasn't immediately alarming as > > the > > > > > lady just stated she wanted to clarify so she would know whether they > > > > should > > > > > reimburse the patient. > > > > > > > > > > This is the first time, I've had to talk to the insurance company > > about > > > > the > > > > > fee. I know to be clear that this is specifically for services they > > do > > > > not > > > > > cover and not any sort of retainer or membership fee. Does anyone > > that > > > > has > > > > > charged NCBF having any experience with questions from insurances or > > good > > > > > " buzz words " or phrases to use. > > > > > > > > > > thanks > > > > > > > > > > dave gordon > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > -- > > > M.D. > > > www.elainemd.com > > > Office: > > begin_of_the_skype_highlighting end_of_the_skype_highlighting > > > > > Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined. > > > This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly > > > confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal > > > information. The information is intended only for the use of the > > individual > > > or entity named above. > > > > > > > > > > > > If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, > > > publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not > > the > > > intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, > > > please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the > > > information that email in error. > > > > > > > > > > -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D7830 mont Mesa Blvd #287San Diego, CA 92111www.mypcponline.com Quote
Guest guest Posted November 19, 2010 Report Posted November 19, 2010 Now that I've had a little breather I wish I had told him " you have a choice - choose a different doctor to harass " and not caved in to his threats, but he hit my achilles heel. I will not establish a P-p relationship with him. I just have to get prepared for a call from BCBS and see how it goes. But I may need to get discrete CPT codes. Telephone codes maybe? Stew Re: Re: NCBF / Insurance Questions But, stew is worried about calls to regence and is asking for language to stave that headache off.. now how/ > > > Do not enter into a doctor patient relationship with this guy. You are > under no obligation to change your practice arrangements to satisfy him. > Drop him a note saying that you enjoyed speaking with him but you suggest he > look elsewhere for the practice that will exactly fit his needs. > Joann > > > > > > > NEED ADVICE!! From those of you navigating the NCBF. Dave and ? > > Patient today asks for an appointment and when my assistant tells him my > NCBF $10/month " HealthyAccess Fee " applies to ALL patients because I do not > have 2 tiers of service and all patients have access to me 24 x 7 for email > and phone, he replied that he was going to call Regence/Blue Cross > BlueShield because he is certain that it is unethical to charge ALL patient > an extra fee. He states that I am " forcing patients to pay just to walk in > the door " and that all he wants is a physical every 2 years that his > insurance allows without a copay or coinsurance. > > I decided to call him and answer his questions over the phone so he didn't > have to call REgence and make my life hell. He tells me he met me 2 or 3 > times, at my previous practice, he liked me, thinks I'm different (in a good > way) from other docs and wants to see me but he doesn't want a relationship > with his doctor, he doesn't want to talk to his doctor on the phone or > email, he just wants his physical, he wants ME to do his physical and if I > don't do the physical and waive the NCBF (because he says he should have a > choice)he says he going to make it his goal in life to make my life hell. > (he is an unemployed medical imaging " consultant " ) > > He is going to call RegenceBC/BS AND write articles about how doctors doing > what I'm doing are taking advantage of patients and bilking the system to > just make as much money as they can. > > He says he is not " blackmailing " me, he just wants his physical and doesn't > want to pay. I told him (after way too much time on the phone) that I would > see him for his physical and that I would re-evaluate the issue of choice in > my healthy access fee. Perhaps I would offer to charge per phone call/email > (do I need an ABN? for that) rather than a global fee. > > I feel threatened and blackmailed - but I don't actually dislike the guy. > He is the kind of guy who you want as your friend, but never ever want as > your enemy. If I were his friendly doctor, though, when he gives himself a > heart attack, I most certainly will be blamed by him. > > So my tentative gameplan is to add to my policy, a provision to opt-out of > the global NCBF and a choice to sign an ABN for telephone/email exchanges (I > hate that idea because it discourages patients from contacting their doctor) > and then I think I might call BCBS first (because this guy definately will) > and spill the beans and see if I can get anyone half witted to understand > what I'm saying, and then call this guy back and say. " I now offer patients > a choice at my practice - pay a low monthly fee for the NCBF or pay per > occurrence of each specific non covered phone or email exchange, BUT I am > not willing to take you on as a patient because I feel uncomfortable > (threatened and intimidated) due to the tone of our last conversation - I do > not think we are a good match. " > > This guy has put me in a pickle. > > Stew Mones > Maitree Family Medicine > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I just received a call from United asking for some clarification > on > > > my > > > > > NCBF. > > > > > > Apparently a couple patients submitted my invoice to United > asking > > > for > > > > > > reimbursement. The message from United wasn't immediately > alarming as > > > the > > > > > > lady just stated she wanted to clarify so she would know whether > they > > > > > should > > > > > > reimburse the patient. > > > > > > > > > > > > This is the first time, I've had to talk to the insurance company > > > about > > > > > the > > > > > > fee. I know to be clear that this is specifically for services > they > > > do > > > > > not > > > > > > cover and not any sort of retainer or membership fee. Does anyone > > > that > > > > > has > > > > > > charged NCBF having any experience with questions from insurances > or > > > good > > > > > > " buzz words " or phrases to use. > > > > > > > > > > > > thanks > > > > > > > > > > > > dave gordon > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > -- > > > > M.D. > > > > <http://www.elainemd.com>www.elainemd.com > > > > Office: > > > begin_of_the_skype_highlighting > end_of_the_skype_highlighting > > > > > > > Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've > imagined. > > > > This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly > > > > confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or > legal > > > > information. The information is intended only for the use of the > > > individual > > > > or entity named above. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not > use, > > > > publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are > not > > > the > > > > intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in > error, > > > > please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the > > > > information that email in error. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D 7830 mont Mesa Blvd #287 San Diego, CA 92111 www.mypcponline.com Quote
Guest guest Posted November 19, 2010 Report Posted November 19, 2010 All I can saw is wow. I think there was a book about this, catch-22 i believe. To be completely honest, I'm not sure what I would do. I agree with Joann 100% that this is a patient that you don't want in your practice. However, I know my NCBF is the lifeblood of my practice and I frankly couldn't survive without it. Thus anything that potentially could jeopordize that is a big deal. For what it's worth, I've had 2 episodes regarding insurance contacting me regarding the fee in the past month (since I sent out my letter raising the fee to $300).The first as mentioned in the top of this thread was a simple voicemail asking more about the fee wondering if they should reimburse a patient that submitted my bill. I wrote an email (after calling and being told the person wasn't in the office) that simply said " no you should not reimburse the patient because the fee is specifically for services that insurance doesnt cover. " I never heard back. That was united. A week later I got call from my credentialing person. It was from the BCBS Denver contact manager saying patients had called complaining about my fee and that I shouldnt be allowed to charge it. My credentialing person played dumb and said she'd have to find out more info. The BCBS told her that patients were telling them I was charging for administrative fees like billing and collections, etc. I then called the BCBS agent and left 1 voicemail generic. I called the next day and got voicemail again. I simply said " that I'd be happy to answer any questions and that it sounded like they were given misinformation from my patients. My fee was specifically for medical services that insurance doesn't cover and in no way related to administrative costs, billing, collections or anything of that sort. " I have yet to hear anything back and that was now a week ago (or more). I dont like the idea of changing all your office policies globally and bringing this out into the open for question by all patients. Even if you choose to do some ABN issue with him, it can be on an isolated basis. further, if you choose to see him, i might even spur the whole abn thing and just see him, be brief, and respond briefly for future issues without further confrontation. as I write this, I still cant say which route is best. if bcbs isn't one of your big payers (i.e. could you survive without them) I'd probably error towards the polite note saying you cannot provide care, knowing he'll call them and raise a stink and start preparing your speech. you can stress that his not wanting to pay the fee has nothing to do with your decision not to see him but rather him threatening you. if you don't feel comfortable with the insurance fight, or you are not prepared to drop bcbs than I might just bite the bullet. the one thing I probably wouldnt do is give him a pay the fee or leave option simply b/c its more threatening. if you dont want to cave to him i'd do what was mentionedmore than anything, I'm depressed in the fact that we as physicians even have to deal with these dilemma and justify how we run our business. one more reason obviously to ditch the insurance world but as discussed multiple times and places that isn't realistic for certain areas and people good luck with this one. i can at least feel a little better about the challenges and stressors I've been having regarding my NCBF over the last monthkeep us posted But, stew is worried about calls to regence and is asking for language to stave that headache off..now how/ Do not enter into a doctor patient relationship with this guy. You are under no obligation to change your practice arrangements to satisfy him. Drop him a note saying that you enjoyed speaking with him but you suggest he look elsewhere for the practice that will exactly fit his needs. Joann NEED ADVICE!! From those of you navigating the NCBF. Dave and ? Patient today asks for an appointment and when my assistant tells him my NCBF $10/month " HealthyAccess Fee " applies to ALL patients because I do not have 2 tiers of service and all patients have access to me 24 x 7 for email and phone, he replied that he was going to call Regence/Blue Cross BlueShield because he is certain that it is unethical to charge ALL patient an extra fee. He states that I am " forcing patients to pay just to walk in the door " and that all he wants is a physical every 2 years that his insurance allows without a copay or coinsurance. I decided to call him and answer his questions over the phone so he didn't have to call REgence and make my life hell. He tells me he met me 2 or 3 times, at my previous practice, he liked me, thinks I'm different (in a good way) from other docs and wants to see me but he doesn't want a relationship with his doctor, he doesn't want to talk to his doctor on the phone or email, he just wants his physical, he wants ME to do his physical and if I don't do the physical and waive the NCBF (because he says he should have a choice)he says he going to make it his goal in life to make my life hell. (he is an unemployed medical imaging " consultant " ) He is going to call RegenceBC/BS AND write articles about how doctors doing what I'm doing are taking advantage of patients and bilking the system to just make as much money as they can. He says he is not " blackmailing " me, he just wants his physical and doesn't want to pay. I told him (after way too much time on the phone) that I would see him for his physical and that I would re-evaluate the issue of choice in my healthy access fee. Perhaps I would offer to charge per phone call/email (do I need an ABN? for that) rather than a global fee. I feel threatened and blackmailed - but I don't actually dislike the guy. He is the kind of guy who you want as your friend, but never ever want as your enemy. If I were his friendly doctor, though, when he gives himself a heart attack, I most certainly will be blamed by him. So my tentative gameplan is to add to my policy, a provision to opt-out of the global NCBF and a choice to sign an ABN for telephone/email exchanges (I hate that idea because it discourages patients from contacting their doctor) and then I think I might call BCBS first (because this guy definately will) and spill the beans and see if I can get anyone half witted to understand what I'm saying, and then call this guy back and say. " I now offer patients a choice at my practice - pay a low monthly fee for the NCBF or pay per occurrence of each specific non covered phone or email exchange, BUT I am not willing to take you on as a patient because I feel uncomfortable (threatened and intimidated) due to the tone of our last conversation - I do not think we are a good match. " This guy has put me in a pickle. Stew Mones Maitree Family Medicine > > > > > > > > > > I just received a call from United asking for some clarification on > > my > > > > NCBF. > > > > > Apparently a couple patients submitted my invoice to United asking > > for > > > > > reimbursement. The message from United wasn't immediately alarming as > > the > > > > > lady just stated she wanted to clarify so she would know whether they > > > > should > > > > > reimburse the patient. > > > > > > > > > > This is the first time, I've had to talk to the insurance company > > about > > > > the > > > > > fee. I know to be clear that this is specifically for services they > > do > > > > not > > > > > cover and not any sort of retainer or membership fee. Does anyone > > that > > > > has > > > > > charged NCBF having any experience with questions from insurances or > > good > > > > > " buzz words " or phrases to use. > > > > > > > > > > thanks > > > > > > > > > > dave gordon > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > -- > > > M.D. > > > www.elainemd.com > > > Office: > > begin_of_the_skype_highlighting end_of_the_skype_highlighting > > > > > Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined. > > > This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly > > > confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal > > > information. The information is intended only for the use of the > > individual > > > or entity named above. > > > > > > > > > > > > If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, > > > publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not > > the > > > intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, > > > please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the > > > information that email in error. > > > > > > > > > > -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D7830 mont Mesa Blvd #287San Diego, CA 92111www.mypcponline.com Quote
Guest guest Posted November 19, 2010 Report Posted November 19, 2010 Stew, Good luck with this. Make sure that BCBS doesn’t cover email and/or phone CPT codes; you should be able to look them up on their website. If they don’t, you can state that as part of the NCBF, you offer “free” email and phone consultation, that you offer 24/7 access directly to you – not an answering machine (assuming that this is true?) – and that the NCBF applies to all of your patients (since you do not have different tiers of service depending on how frequent or infrequently a patient may choose to use these services), regardless of type of insurance the patient may have. Stick to your guns. You had reasons for charging the fee in the first place, cite those reasons to BCBS if they should happen to call. A guy like that is definitely not worth having around in your practice… Pratt Office Manager Oak Tree Internal Medicine P.C www.prattmd.info From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Mones MD Sent: Thursday, November 18, 2010 8:43 PM To: Subject: RE: Re: NCBF / Insurance Questions Now that I've had a little breather I wish I had told him " you have a choice - choose a different doctor to harass " and not caved in to his threats, but he hit my achilles heel. I will not establish a P-p relationship with him. I just have to get prepared for a call from BCBS and see how it goes. But I may need to get discrete CPT codes. Telephone codes maybe? Stew Re: Re: NCBF / Insurance Questions But, stew is worried about calls to regence and is asking for language to stave that headache off.. now how/ > > > Do not enter into a doctor patient relationship with this guy. You are > under no obligation to change your practice arrangements to satisfy him. > Drop him a note saying that you enjoyed speaking with him but you suggest he > look elsewhere for the practice that will exactly fit his needs. > Joann > > > > > > > NEED ADVICE!! From those of you navigating the NCBF. Dave and ? > > Patient today asks for an appointment and when my assistant tells him my > NCBF $10/month " HealthyAccess Fee " applies to ALL patients because I do not > have 2 tiers of service and all patients have access to me 24 x 7 for email > and phone, he replied that he was going to call Regence/Blue Cross > BlueShield because he is certain that it is unethical to charge ALL patient > an extra fee. He states that I am " forcing patients to pay just to walk in > the door " and that all he wants is a physical every 2 years that his > insurance allows without a copay or coinsurance. > > I decided to call him and answer his questions over the phone so he didn't > have to call REgence and make my life hell. He tells me he met me 2 or 3 > times, at my previous practice, he liked me, thinks I'm different (in a good > way) from other docs and wants to see me but he doesn't want a relationship > with his doctor, he doesn't want to talk to his doctor on the phone or > email, he just wants his physical, he wants ME to do his physical and if I > don't do the physical and waive the NCBF (because he says he should have a > choice)he says he going to make it his goal in life to make my life hell. > (he is an unemployed medical imaging " consultant " ) > > He is going to call RegenceBC/BS AND write articles about how doctors doing > what I'm doing are taking advantage of patients and bilking the system to > just make as much money as they can. > > He says he is not " blackmailing " me, he just wants his physical and doesn't > want to pay. I told him (after way too much time on the phone) that I would > see him for his physical and that I would re-evaluate the issue of choice in > my healthy access fee. Perhaps I would offer to charge per phone call/email > (do I need an ABN? for that) rather than a global fee. > > I feel threatened and blackmailed - but I don't actually dislike the guy. > He is the kind of guy who you want as your friend, but never ever want as > your enemy. If I were his friendly doctor, though, when he gives himself a > heart attack, I most certainly will be blamed by him. > > So my tentative gameplan is to add to my policy, a provision to opt-out of > the global NCBF and a choice to sign an ABN for telephone/email exchanges (I > hate that idea because it discourages patients from contacting their doctor) > and then I think I might call BCBS first (because this guy definately will) > and spill the beans and see if I can get anyone half witted to understand > what I'm saying, and then call this guy back and say. " I now offer patients > a choice at my practice - pay a low monthly fee for the NCBF or pay per > occurrence of each specific non covered phone or email exchange, BUT I am > not willing to take you on as a patient because I feel uncomfortable > (threatened and intimidated) due to the tone of our last conversation - I do > not think we are a good match. " > > This guy has put me in a pickle. > > Stew Mones > Maitree Family Medicine > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I just received a call from United asking for some clarification > on > > > my > > > > > NCBF. > > > > > > Apparently a couple patients submitted my invoice to United > asking > > > for > > > > > > reimbursement. The message from United wasn't immediately > alarming as > > > the > > > > > > lady just stated she wanted to clarify so she would know whether > they > > > > > should > > > > > > reimburse the patient. > > > > > > > > > > > > This is the first time, I've had to talk to the insurance company > > > about > > > > > the > > > > > > fee. I know to be clear that this is specifically for services > they > > > do > > > > > not > > > > > > cover and not any sort of retainer or membership fee. Does anyone > > > that > > > > > has > > > > > > charged NCBF having any experience with questions from insurances > or > > > good > > > > > > " buzz words " or phrases to use. > > > > > > > > > > > > thanks > > > > > > > > > > > > dave gordon > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > -- > > > > M.D. > > > > <http://www.elainemd.com>www.elainemd.com > > > > Office: > > > begin_of_the_skype_highlighting > end_of_the_skype_highlighting > > > > > > > Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've > imagined. > > > > This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly > > > > confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or > legal > > > > information. The information is intended only for the use of the > > > individual > > > > or entity named above. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not > use, > > > > publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are > not > > > the > > > > intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in > error, > > > > please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the > > > > information that email in error. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D 7830 mont Mesa Blvd #287 San Diego, CA 92111 www.mypcponline.com Quote
Guest guest Posted November 19, 2010 Report Posted November 19, 2010 agree with karen about being careful about listing codes - they can come back with the ever so keen " we cover that code, our reimbursement is just zero. " i would try to be as nebulous as you can if they come calling. let them lead the conversation and just rebutt their points. i was going to use arguments more to the fact that i provided services that others in the community dont. even though that is somewhat different than not covered, it's easier to explain. for example, your insurance contract states you must ensure there is 24 hour coverage for patients - thus the covered service is " anyone " being available 24/7 but the non-covered service is " you " being available 24/7. Same thing communication. Avoid specifically saying email or phone consults are the services but rather, the insurance contract states " you as an office, including subordinates " must answer questions related to past visits, medications, etc. but the non-covered service is the direct access to you. You can highlight your difference between other practices and say that service obviously isnt a covered benefit because you cant get it at any other practice. Likewise, patients being able to schedule their own appointments after hours - it doesn't say anywhere in your insurance contract that you have to provide that thus by default i consider it a non-covered service. You can ask whomever you talk with, " can you get your specific physician on his/her cell any time day or night, any day of the year, schedule your own appointments anytime of the day or night, get appointments with your specific physician within 24 hours, etc. etc. (as I write, I get a call on my cell from a patient who nows feels comfortable because she talked to her doc that knows her well, but i digress) - since obviously that answer will be no, you can then argue that your patients can get all those things because you provide these services that are not covered - again using the argument that since no one else provides the services, they are not covered - it's technically not accurate potentially but i think the argument works better Stew, Good luck with this. Make sure that BCBS doesn’t cover email and/or phone CPT codes; you should be able to look them up on their website. If they don’t, you can state that as part of the NCBF, you offer “free” email and phone consultation, that you offer 24/7 access directly to you – not an answering machine (assuming that this is true?) – and that the NCBF applies to all of your patients (since you do not have different tiers of service depending on how frequent or infrequently a patient may choose to use these services), regardless of type of insurance the patient may have. Stick to your guns. You had reasons for charging the fee in the first place, cite those reasons to BCBS if they should happen to call. A guy like that is definitely not worth having around in your practice… Pratt Office Manager Oak Tree Internal Medicine P.C www.prattmd.info From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Mones MD Sent: Thursday, November 18, 2010 8:43 PM To: Subject: RE: Re: NCBF / Insurance Questions Now that I've had a little breather I wish I had told him " you have a choice - choose a different doctor to harass " and not caved in to his threats, but he hit my achilles heel. I will not establish a P-p relationship with him. I just have to get prepared for a call from BCBS and see how it goes. But I may need to get discrete CPT codes. Telephone codes maybe? Stew Re: Re: NCBF / Insurance Questions But, stew is worried about calls to regence and is asking for language to stave that headache off.. now how/ > > > Do not enter into a doctor patient relationship with this guy. You are > under no obligation to change your practice arrangements to satisfy him. > Drop him a note saying that you enjoyed speaking with him but you suggest he > look elsewhere for the practice that will exactly fit his needs. > Joann > > > > > > > NEED ADVICE!! From those of you navigating the NCBF. Dave and ? > > Patient today asks for an appointment and when my assistant tells him my > NCBF $10/month " HealthyAccess Fee " applies to ALL patients because I do not > have 2 tiers of service and all patients have access to me 24 x 7 for email > and phone, he replied that he was going to call Regence/Blue Cross > BlueShield because he is certain that it is unethical to charge ALL patient > an extra fee. He states that I am " forcing patients to pay just to walk in > the door " and that all he wants is a physical every 2 years that his > insurance allows without a copay or coinsurance. > > I decided to call him and answer his questions over the phone so he didn't > have to call REgence and make my life hell. He tells me he met me 2 or 3 > times, at my previous practice, he liked me, thinks I'm different (in a good > way) from other docs and wants to see me but he doesn't want a relationship > with his doctor, he doesn't want to talk to his doctor on the phone or > email, he just wants his physical, he wants ME to do his physical and if I > don't do the physical and waive the NCBF (because he says he should have a > choice)he says he going to make it his goal in life to make my life hell. > (he is an unemployed medical imaging " consultant " ) > > He is going to call RegenceBC/BS AND write articles about how doctors doing > what I'm doing are taking advantage of patients and bilking the system to > just make as much money as they can. > > He says he is not " blackmailing " me, he just wants his physical and doesn't > want to pay. I told him (after way too much time on the phone) that I would > see him for his physical and that I would re-evaluate the issue of choice in > my healthy access fee. Perhaps I would offer to charge per phone call/email > (do I need an ABN? for that) rather than a global fee. > > I feel threatened and blackmailed - but I don't actually dislike the guy. > He is the kind of guy who you want as your friend, but never ever want as > your enemy. If I were his friendly doctor, though, when he gives himself a > heart attack, I most certainly will be blamed by him. > > So my tentative gameplan is to add to my policy, a provision to opt-out of > the global NCBF and a choice to sign an ABN for telephone/email exchanges (I > hate that idea because it discourages patients from contacting their doctor) > and then I think I might call BCBS first (because this guy definately will) > and spill the beans and see if I can get anyone half witted to understand > what I'm saying, and then call this guy back and say. " I now offer patients > a choice at my practice - pay a low monthly fee for the NCBF or pay per > occurrence of each specific non covered phone or email exchange, BUT I am > not willing to take you on as a patient because I feel uncomfortable > (threatened and intimidated) due to the tone of our last conversation - I do > not think we are a good match. " > > This guy has put me in a pickle. > > Stew Mones > Maitree Family Medicine > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I just received a call from United asking for some clarification > on > > > my > > > > > NCBF. > > > > > > Apparently a couple patients submitted my invoice to United > asking > > > for > > > > > > reimbursement. The message from United wasn't immediately > alarming as > > > the > > > > > > lady just stated she wanted to clarify so she would know whether > they > > > > > should > > > > > > reimburse the patient. > > > > > > > > > > > > This is the first time, I've had to talk to the insurance company > > > about > > > > > the > > > > > > fee. I know to be clear that this is specifically for services > they > > > do > > > > > not > > > > > > cover and not any sort of retainer or membership fee. Does anyone > > > that > > > > > has > > > > > > charged NCBF having any experience with questions from insurances > or > > > good > > > > > > " buzz words " or phrases to use. > > > > > > > > > > > > thanks > > > > > > > > > > > > dave gordon > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > -- > > > > M.D. > > > > <http://www.elainemd.com>www.elainemd.com > > > > Office: > > > begin_of_the_skype_highlighting > end_of_the_skype_highlighting > > > > > > > Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've > imagined. > > > > This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly > > > > confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or > legal > > > > information. The information is intended only for the use of the > > > individual > > > > or entity named above. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not > use, > > > > publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are > not > > > the > > > > intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in > error, > > > > please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the > > > > information that email in error. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D 7830 mont Mesa Blvd #287 San Diego, CA 92111 www.mypcponline.com Quote
Guest guest Posted November 19, 2010 Report Posted November 19, 2010 Dave (and ), Thanks for your thoughts - I'm going to be able to sleep a bit now that I've got some defensive strategy. I think your right - I should not ask for permission and say too much, certainly not ask for forgiveness, just be prepared to concisely address the questions and misperceptions. This guy really rattled my cage, but I'm feeling a bit more confident now. Stew Re: Re: NCBF / Insurance Questions > > But, stew is worried about calls to regence and is asking for language to > stave that headache off.. > > now how/ > > On Thu, Nov 18, 2010 at 7:07 PM, Joann M <JMMD@...<JMMD%40aol.com>> > wrote: > > > > > > > Do not enter into a doctor patient relationship with this guy. You are > > under no obligation to change your practice arrangements to satisfy him Quote
Guest guest Posted November 19, 2010 Report Posted November 19, 2010 Dave (and ), Thanks for your thoughts - I'm going to be able to sleep a bit now that I've got some defensive strategy. I think your right - I should not ask for permission and say too much, certainly not ask for forgiveness, just be prepared to concisely address the questions and misperceptions. This guy really rattled my cage, but I'm feeling a bit more confident now. Stew Re: Re: NCBF / Insurance Questions > > But, stew is worried about calls to regence and is asking for language to > stave that headache off.. > > now how/ > > On Thu, Nov 18, 2010 at 7:07 PM, Joann M <JMMD@...<JMMD%40aol.com>> > wrote: > > > > > > > Do not enter into a doctor patient relationship with this guy. You are > > under no obligation to change your practice arrangements to satisfy him Quote
Guest guest Posted November 19, 2010 Report Posted November 19, 2010 If you have the stomach for it, tell him do right ahead and then you will be forced to do what you were attempting to have to do, Drop his BC plan and perhaps others down the line if he makes such a big stink. There are lots of facts that support you but this man had no right to be your patient if he is just coming in the door after being somewhere else if I am not mistaken. New solo practice from a larger shop... He letter equals no more doctor patient relationship. If he likes you being different then he must put his money where is mouth is, help pay me my fee because as recent studies PROVE the average PCP who gets his fees cut and underpaid by the likes of his BC, Lose another 40% of what they are able to collect (2 weeks to NEVER...) to playing the game, the system for our patients... I would be less defensive and more upset as you know exactly why you are forced to do this because the present system would put you right back on the Hamster Wheel without your reasonable fee... We have dropped a number of carries in the past year or two and we no longer make an appologies for it... And I have a long list of reasons why like the 40% lose, the uncompensated work, the denied payments and loped off codes and charges for the likes of women's well care... Selfish contracts, one sided gov't anti-trust waivers (and say just like Major League Baseball does from the feds) so the carriers can collude against docs and patients but we small practices can't join forces and leverage back in like kind. I also stand firm by the concept that no other private contractor at this personal one on one level service providers has to have a huge, one side contract just to have access to their own customers of their own end services... Not the HVAC man for your hot water heater or furnace, not your auto mechanic, not your VET!!!!, and not your lawyer... But some how these SOB's weazled their way into our relationship where they DON'T belong and they certainly charge much more to cover our office visits than it costs to pay for them... We don't need them... They don't cover primary care to take a loss on it... They do it to make lots of MONEY on your hard earned dollars by stealing from you and underpaying ME... It's tough but we really do need to stop being so appologetic about what we do and how we do it... We would impliment a very similar structure at our place but in NYS the state is prosecuting doctors for "Insurance Fraud" because they are claiming that any and all such fees are "selling insurance". I really want to make a big test case of a class of NYS docs all charging very similar fees, and literally claim that they are "Retainers" plain and simple... You pay my retainer in exchange for our promise that we will not over load our practice with too many patients and treat you like a number, treat the problem that is in front of us only, and return to the old days of 20-45 minute visits... Our visit slots are half an hour a piece, with AQ for do it yourself on-line appointments same day access and even walk-ins now... Ya can't get much better service than that.... And it works most of the days we barely have 3 or 4 people on that morning, but by the end of the day we have seen our IMP 8-12 patients... But to the retainers I want a court to rule that for some reason Docs are not allowed to charge much cheaper versions of the same thing that most lawyers do... It pays for NOTHING other than a double promise to keep a slot open for you and eventually deny a slot to someone else because you have paid for the access to a slot in a low volumm, higher quality, more personal practice... Tell him you welcome his challenge in the local papers and will go editorial to editorial with him about your business loans, your student loans, your 10 year old car, your lack of personal savings or retirement of any sort, and your highest level of education of any professional in the country that makes his Lawyers training look like a return to special ed high school basket weaving... And while he is at, please go get the care you want, the kind of modern 21st century the insurance industry controls everything... Have him swear in writing to not every use a small or solo office again, and to make sure he goes to the largest hamster wheel meat market in town because that is what he is supporting and not getting... Like the congressman who wants he gov't sponsored healthcare and without a waiting period... I have these conversations all the time... If he really values you then he will put up and understand that you too are a small player stuck with almost no control over your own profession that you spent years to learn and too much to pay for too... And that this is your solution to being able to still process his insurance for him... and if not the PLEASE belly up and sign into the Meat Market down the road... I am proud and comfortable with my choices... Can the 10 million dollar CEO of your BC carrier really say the same???? Can you if you follow thru??? Break a leg... To: Sent: Thu, November 18, 2010 9:17:49 PMSubject: Re: NCBF / Insurance Questions NEED ADVICE!! From those of you navigating the NCBF. Dave and ?Patient today asks for an appointment and when my assistant tells him my NCBF $10/month "HealthyAccess Fee" applies to ALL patients because I do not have 2 tiers of service and all patients have access to me 24 x 7 for email and phone, he replied that he was going to call Regence/Blue Cross BlueShield because he is certain that it is unethical to charge ALL patient an extra fee. He states that I am "forcing patients to pay just to walk in the door" and that all he wants is a physical every 2 years that his insurance allows without a copay or coinsurance. I decided to call him and answer his questions over the phone so he didn't have to call REgence and make my life hell. He tells me he met me 2 or 3 times, at my previous practice, he liked me, thinks I'm different (in a good way) from other docs and wants to see me but he doesn't want a relationship with his doctor, he doesn't want to talk to his doctor on the phone or email, he just wants his physical, he wants ME to do his physical and if I don't do the physical and waive the NCBF (because he says he should have a choice)he says he going to make it his goal in life to make my life hell. (he is an unemployed medical imaging "consultant") He is going to call RegenceBC/BS AND write articles about how doctors doing what I'm doing are taking advantage of patients and bilking the system to just make as much money as they can. He says he is not "blackmailing" me, he just wants his physical and doesn't want to pay. I told him (after way too much time on the phone) that I would see him for his physical and that I would re-evaluate the issue of choice in my healthy access fee. Perhaps I would offer to charge per phone call/email (do I need an ABN? for that) rather than a global fee. I feel threatened and blackmailed - but I don't actually dislike the guy. He is the kind of guy who you want as your friend, but never ever want as your enemy. If I were his friendly doctor, though, when he gives himself a heart attack, I most certainly will be blamed by him. So my tentative gameplan is to add to my policy, a provision to opt-out of the global NCBF and a choice to sign an ABN for telephone/email exchanges (I hate that idea because it discourages patients from contacting their doctor) and then I think I might call BCBS first (because this guy definately will) and spill the beans and see if I can get anyone half witted to understand what I'm saying, and then call this guy back and say. "I now offer patients a choice at my practice - pay a low monthly fee for the NCBF or pay per occurrence of each specific non covered phone or email exchange, BUT I am not willing to take you on as a patient because I feel uncomfortable (threatened and intimidated) due to the tone of our last conversation - I do not think we are a good match."This guy has put me in a pickle.Stew MonesMaitree Family Medicine> > > > >> > > > > I just received a call from United asking for some clarification on> > my> > > > NCBF.> > > > > Apparently a couple patients submitted my invoice to United asking> > for> > > > > reimbursement. The message from United wasn't immediately alarming as> > the> > > > > lady just stated she wanted to clarify so she would know whether they> > > > should> > > > > reimburse the patient.> > > > >> > > > > This is the first time, I've had to talk to the insurance company> > about> > > > the> > > > > fee. I know to be clear that this is specifically for services they> > do> > > > not> > > > > cover and not any sort of retainer or membership fee. Does anyone> > that> > > > has> > > > > charged NCBF having any experience with questions from insurances or> > good> > > > > "buzz words" or phrases to use.> > > > >> > > > > thanks> > > > >> > > > > dave gordon> > > > >> > > >> > > >> > > >> > >> > >> > >> > > --> > > M.D.> > > www.elainemd.com> > > Office: > > begin_of_the_skype_highlighting end_of_the_skype_highlighting> >> > > Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.> > > This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly> > > confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal> > > information. The information is intended only for the use of the> > individual> > > or entity named above.> > >> > >> > >> > > If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use,> > > publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not> > the> > > intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error,> > > please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the> > > information that email in error.> > >> >> > > >> Quote
Guest guest Posted November 19, 2010 Report Posted November 19, 2010 Stew I have no idea about NCBF but if a patient says he will make it his goal in life to make your life hell, I uh would be outta there " Hey thanks for bring this to my attention I will have a talk with Regence and double check agian .But I am not sure this is the right practice for you " really. I would offensively calmly interactively sweetly say I was gonna call Regence who cares if i do or not .This guy could be legitimately unhappy about being charged a fee- I get that It may be his way of expressing loss/lack of control - the entire world screws us over all the time and he just wants what he thinks is simple--fair enough--(I am in patietn shoes here) and some guy-you,Stew,- has to take that away and after all he likes you and you have taken YOU away from him but his anger is a uh tad much I as the patient would pitch a fit and say but this is horrible why do docs have to do this/ I just want/ i cannot afford /etcbut make your life hell ???? uhuh Outta that relationship( which he does not want hahah) Dave (and ), Thanks for your thoughts - I'm going to be able to sleep a bit now that I've got some defensive strategy. I think your right - I should not ask for permission and say too much, certainly not ask for forgiveness, just be prepared to concisely address the questions and misperceptions. This guy really rattled my cage, but I'm feeling a bit more confident now. Stew Re: Re: NCBF / Insurance Questions > > But, stew is worried about calls to regence and is asking for language to > stave that headache off.. > > now how/ > > On Thu, Nov 18, 2010 at 7:07 PM, Joann M <JMMD@...<JMMD%40aol.com>> > wrote: > > > > > > > Do not enter into a doctor patient relationship with this guy. You are > > under no obligation to change your practice arrangements to satisfy him -- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!) Email is best used for appointment making and brief questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org Quote
Guest guest Posted November 19, 2010 Report Posted November 19, 2010 He really does sound like a liability problem just waiting for a reason to pick your nose over something in the future. I have parents like this on my son's hockey team that just don't know how to say nothing at all, no less God Forbid something nice and positive for us guys out on the ice busting our butts with their kids... Just waiting for a reason to swoop in and make a stink and spread bad things about you.... Ditch 'em. No amount of money is worth the hell this kind of patient will impose upon you in the future when given half a reason. There is a reason they are looking for a new practice now isn't there... Some have legit reasons including our favorites of wanting something different, but most of those folks are approachable and understand our between a rock and hard place situation even if they can't or won't pay us up front or a Fee, Retainer like payment or in full out of pocket... Even most of those "get it"... The fact that this man is so one sided and can not bring himself to even try to see your side of the issue, shows just how much of a problem in the making he really is... Don't establish, give him the phone number of the local medical society to help him find another qualified provider and wash your hands of this explosive mixture just waiting for an ignition source... To: Sent: Fri, November 19, 2010 8:04:57 AMSubject: Re: Re: NCBF / Insurance Questions Stew I have no idea about NCBF but if a patient says he will make it his goal in life to make your life hell, I uh would be outta there"Hey thanks for bring this to my attention I will have a talk with Regence and double check agian .But I am not sure this is the right practice for you" really. I would offensively calmly interactively sweetly say I was gonna call Regence who cares if i do or not .This guy could be legitimately unhappy about being charged a fee- I get that It may be his way of expressing loss/lack of control - the entire world screws us over all the time and he just wants what he thinks is simple--fair enough--(I am in patietn shoes here) and some guy-you,Stew,- has to take that away and after all he likes you and you have taken YOU away from him but his anger is a uh tad much I as the patient would pitch a fit and say but this is horrible why do docs have to do this/ I just want/ i cannot afford /etcbut make your life hell ???? uhuh Outta that relationship( which he does not want hahah) Dave (and ), Thanks for your thoughts - I'm going to be able to sleep a bit now that I've got some defensive strategy. I think your right - I should not ask for permission and say too much, certainly not ask for forgiveness, just be prepared to concisely address the questions and misperceptions. This guy really rattled my cage, but I'm feeling a bit more confident now.Stew Re: Re: NCBF / Insurance Questions>> But, stew is worried about calls to regence and is asking for language to> stave that headache off..>> now how/>> On Thu, Nov 18, 2010 at 7:07 PM, Joann M <JMMD@...<JMMD%40aol.com>> > wrote:>> >> >> > Do not enter into a doctor patient relationship with this guy. You are> > under no obligation to change your practice arrangements to satisfy him -- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!)Email is best used for appointment making and brief questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org Quote
Guest guest Posted November 19, 2010 Report Posted November 19, 2010 You can't be an affective doctor to a pt who threatens you. So for that reason, I would drop him from my practice. You don't need the stress. When I introduced my NCBF, I offered pt and alternative practice that they could go to...the practice where I chief once a week and they have a nice sliding scale. Anyway if insurance companies call me, I would also say there are many practices in my neighborhood that charge a lot more than me...10 times more. Most of my pts think they are getting a good deal. Today I am going to send out letters to the insurance carriers requesting then to pay me the Medicare rate. Wish me luck NEED ADVICE!! From those of you navigating the NCBF. Dave and ?Patient today asks for an appointment and when my assistant tells him my NCBF $10/month " HealthyAccess Fee " applies to ALL patients because I do not have 2 tiers of service and all patients have access to me 24 x 7 for email and phone, he replied that he was going to call Regence/Blue Cross BlueShield because he is certain that it is unethical to charge ALL patient an extra fee. He states that I am " forcing patients to pay just to walk in the door " and that all he wants is a physical every 2 years that his insurance allows without a copay or coinsurance. I decided to call him and answer his questions over the phone so he didn't have to call REgence and make my life hell. He tells me he met me 2 or 3 times, at my previous practice, he liked me, thinks I'm different (in a good way) from other docs and wants to see me but he doesn't want a relationship with his doctor, he doesn't want to talk to his doctor on the phone or email, he just wants his physical, he wants ME to do his physical and if I don't do the physical and waive the NCBF (because he says he should have a choice)he says he going to make it his goal in life to make my life hell. (he is an unemployed medical imaging " consultant " ) He is going to call RegenceBC/BS AND write articles about how doctors doing what I'm doing are taking advantage of patients and bilking the system to just make as much money as they can. He says he is not " blackmailing " me, he just wants his physical and doesn't want to pay. I told him (after way too much time on the phone) that I would see him for his physical and that I would re-evaluate the issue of choice in my healthy access fee. Perhaps I would offer to charge per phone call/email (do I need an ABN? for that) rather than a global fee. I feel threatened and blackmailed - but I don't actually dislike the guy. He is the kind of guy who you want as your friend, but never ever want as your enemy. If I were his friendly doctor, though, when he gives himself a heart attack, I most certainly will be blamed by him. So my tentative gameplan is to add to my policy, a provision to opt-out of the global NCBF and a choice to sign an ABN for telephone/email exchanges (I hate that idea because it discourages patients from contacting their doctor) and then I think I might call BCBS first (because this guy definately will) and spill the beans and see if I can get anyone half witted to understand what I'm saying, and then call this guy back and say. " I now offer patients a choice at my practice - pay a low monthly fee for the NCBF or pay per occurrence of each specific non covered phone or email exchange, BUT I am not willing to take you on as a patient because I feel uncomfortable (threatened and intimidated) due to the tone of our last conversation - I do not think we are a good match. " This guy has put me in a pickle.Stew MonesMaitree Family Medicine > > > > > > > > > > I just received a call from United asking for some clarification on> > my> > > > NCBF.> > > > > Apparently a couple patients submitted my invoice to United asking > > for> > > > > reimbursement. The message from United wasn't immediately alarming as> > the> > > > > lady just stated she wanted to clarify so she would know whether they > > > > should> > > > > reimburse the patient.> > > > >> > > > > This is the first time, I've had to talk to the insurance company> > about > > > > the> > > > > fee. I know to be clear that this is specifically for services they> > do> > > > not> > > > > cover and not any sort of retainer or membership fee. Does anyone > > that> > > > has> > > > > charged NCBF having any experience with questions from insurances or> > good> > > > > " buzz words " or phrases to use. > > > > >> > > > > thanks> > > > >> > > > > dave gordon> > > > >> > > >> > > >> > > > > > >> > >> > >> > > --> > > M.D.> > > www.elainemd.com> > > Office: > > begin_of_the_skype_highlighting end_of_the_skype_highlighting> >> > > Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.> > > This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly > > > confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal> > > information. The information is intended only for the use of the> > individual> > > or entity named above. > > >> > >> > >> > > If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use,> > > publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not > > the> > > intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error,> > > please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the> > > information that email in error. > > >> >> > > >> -- M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined. This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error. Quote
Guest guest Posted November 19, 2010 Report Posted November 19, 2010 Stew, I've been stressing about my NCBF (only $75/yr), too. I agree that this person is not a good fit for your practice. When a few patients have brought up the " I just want a physical " thing, I have agreed with them that, if that is all they need, then my practice is probably not the best for them. I am specifically set up to optimize longitudinal care, and someone just needing episodic care may fit better somewhere else. I do have some of those people who come here because I'm much more convenient or they like having access in case something else does come up. So I see that they are paying to maintain a high level of access. At least where I live, that is worth something. I'm stressing because of a recent OIG publication that lists an example of a Medicare-accepting doc paying them $100K because SOME unspecified services covered under the NCBF were considered covered by Medicare. I hate it, but I'm considering changing to using the phone and e-visit codes and making people come in for unnecessary things because of the legal uncertainty of the NCBF. The thought of that change distubs me because I feel that my stress of caring for people has gone down and care has improved with implementing the NCBF. I don't worry about people accessing me, and they don't worry about it as much, either. I don't want to go to nickel-and-diming people at every turn. Haresch, MD > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I just received a call from United asking for some clarification > > on > > > > my > > > > > > NCBF. > > > > > > > Apparently a couple patients submitted my invoice to United > > asking > > > > for > > > > > > > reimbursement. The message from United wasn't immediately > > alarming as > > > > the > > > > > > > lady just stated she wanted to clarify so she would know whether > > they > > > > > > should > > > > > > > reimburse the patient. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > This is the first time, I've had to talk to the insurance company > > > > about > > > > > > the > > > > > > > fee. I know to be clear that this is specifically for services > > they > > > > do > > > > > > not > > > > > > > cover and not any sort of retainer or membership fee. Does anyone > > > > that > > > > > > has > > > > > > > charged NCBF having any experience with questions from insurances > > or > > > > good > > > > > > > " buzz words " or phrases to use. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > thanks > > > > > > > > > > > > > > dave gordon > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > -- > > > > > M.D. > > > > > <http://www.elainemd.com>www.elainemd.com > > > > > Office: > > > > begin_of_the_skype_highlighting > > end_of_the_skype_highlighting > > > > > > > > > Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've > > imagined. > > > > > This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly > > > > > confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or > > legal > > > > > information. The information is intended only for the use of the > > > > individual > > > > > or entity named above. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not > > use, > > > > > publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are > > not > > > > the > > > > > intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in > > error, > > > > > please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the > > > > > information that email in error. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > -- > Sangeetha Murthy M.D > 7830 mont Mesa Blvd #287 > San Diego, CA 92111 > www.mypcponline.com > Quote
Guest guest Posted November 19, 2010 Report Posted November 19, 2010 Stew,Others have commented already and I agree that this guy is not someone you want to do business with. 1. While I would not recommend antagonizing him any further, he IS attempting to blackmail you. black·mail (blkml)n. 1.a. Extortion of money or something else of value from a person by the threat of exposing a criminal act or discreditable information. b. Something of value extorted in this manner.2. The NCBF is not for the timid. Anyone choosing to charge a NCBF (Noncovered Benefits Fee) needs to understand that there is risk involved and be willing to accept that risk. It is a gray area that has not been fully established as legal in many states. I believe in some states it is definitely legal, while in most states, the question of legality is unanswered. If there was no question of its legality, there would be no power in his blackmail threat. If you don't think your NCBF will hold up once BCBS find out about it, you either shouldn't charge a NCBF or participate in BCBS. 3. I am not a lawyer, but I believe a NCBF is legal as long as you define it properly. It cannot be used to pay for administrative costs. I think calling it a "HealthyAccess Fee" implies it is to pay for "access", which is of questionable legality. When I started charging my NCBF, I called up Blue Cross, Blue Shield and Cigna and spoke with their representatives. I told them I wanted to charge a fee to pay for the noncovered benefits of 24/7 availability to me by cellphone or e-mail, being able to schedule a same day or next day appointment, online scheduling, and extended visit times. Each of them told me that as long as I told patients that these services were not covered, that insurance wouldn't pay/reimburse for them and that there was a signed written agreement from the patient agreeing to pay for these services, then they considered that acceptable. I offered to send them my NCBF agreement but they weren't interested in seeing it. So if a patient of mine ever threatens to call up an insurance company, I will tell them that I already did and that the insurance company already said I could charge my fee. Feel free to use me as an example of someone who charges a similar fee and has gotten permission from their insurer to do so. Keep in mind also that this is not a legal opinion on the legality of the NCBF.4. If your BCBS PPO contract is like mine, you are under no obligation to accept any or all patients. I think some HMO contracts require you to accept every patient with that plan as long as you are accepting new patients, but I wouldn't know for sure since I haven't participated in HMO plans since going solo. You don't have to discharge him since you've never seen him and there is no patient-physician relationship yet.5. Per 's comment about Medicare penalizing a doctor whose NCBF was felt to overlap some Medicare-covered services, that is one reason why I opted out of Medicare when I started my NCBF. Good luck! SetoSouth Pasadena, CA NEED ADVICE!! From those of you navigating the NCBF. Dave and ? Patient today asks for an appointment and when my assistant tells him my NCBF $10/month "HealthyAccess Fee" applies to ALL patients because I do not have 2 tiers of service and all patients have access to me 24 x 7 for email and phone, he replied that he was going to call Regence/Blue Cross BlueShield because he is certain that it is unethical to charge ALL patient an extra fee. He states that I am "forcing patients to pay just to walk in the door" and that all he wants is a physical every 2 years that his insurance allows without a copay or coinsurance. I decided to call him and answer his questions over the phone so he didn't have to call REgence and make my life hell. He tells me he met me 2 or 3 times, at my previous practice, he liked me, thinks I'm different (in a good way) from other docs and wants to see me but he doesn't want a relationship with his doctor, he doesn't want to talk to his doctor on the phone or email, he just wants his physical, he wants ME to do his physical and if I don't do the physical and waive the NCBF (because he says he should have a choice)he says he going to make it his goal in life to make my life hell. (he is an unemployed medical imaging "consultant") He is going to call RegenceBC/BS AND write articles about how doctors doing what I'm doing are taking advantage of patients and bilking the system to just make as much money as they can. He says he is not "blackmailing" me, he just wants his physical and doesn't want to pay. I told him (after way too much time on the phone) that I would see him for his physical and that I would re-evaluate the issue of choice in my healthy access fee. Perhaps I would offer to charge per phone call/email (do I need an ABN? for that) rather than a global fee. I feel threatened and blackmailed - but I don't actually dislike the guy. He is the kind of guy who you want as your friend, but never ever want as your enemy. If I were his friendly doctor, though, when he gives himself a heart attack, I most certainly will be blamed by him. So my tentative gameplan is to add to my policy, a provision to opt-out of the global NCBF and a choice to sign an ABN for telephone/email exchanges (I hate that idea because it discourages patients from contacting their doctor) and then I think I might call BCBS first (because this guy definately will) and spill the beans and see if I can get anyone half witted to understand what I'm saying, and then call this guy back and say. "I now offer patients a choice at my practice - pay a low monthly fee for the NCBF or pay per occurrence of each specific non covered phone or email exchange, BUT I am not willing to take you on as a patient because I feel uncomfortable (threatened and intimidated) due to the tone of our last conversation - I do not think we are a good match." This guy has put me in a pickle. Stew Mones Maitree Family Medicine > > > > > > > > > > I just received a call from United asking for some clarification on > > my > > > > NCBF. > > > > > Apparently a couple patients submitted my invoice to United asking > > for > > > > > reimbursement. The message from United wasn't immediately alarming as > > the > > > > > lady just stated she wanted to clarify so she would know whether they > > > > should > > > > > reimburse the patient. > > > > > > > > > > This is the first time, I've had to talk to the insurance company > > about > > > > the > > > > > fee. I know to be clear that this is specifically for services they > > do > > > > not > > > > > cover and not any sort of retainer or membership fee. Does anyone > > that > > > > has > > > > > charged NCBF having any experience with questions from insurances or > > good > > > > > "buzz words" or phrases to use. > > > > > > > > > > thanks > > > > > > > > > > dave gordon > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > -- > > > M.D. > > > www.elainemd.com > > > Office: > > begin_of_the_skype_highlighting end_of_the_skype_highlighting > > > > > Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined. > > > This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly > > > confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal > > > information. The information is intended only for the use of the > > individual > > > or entity named above. > > > > > > > > > > > > If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, > > > publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not > > the > > > intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, > > > please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the > > > information that email in error. > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted November 19, 2010 Report Posted November 19, 2010 That is really weird. Definitely would not want to be married to him. Wait, is he my ex? Pamela > > > > > > > > > > > > I just received a call from United asking for some clarification on > > > my > > > > > NCBF. > > > > > > Apparently a couple patients submitted my invoice to United asking > > > for > > > > > > reimbursement. The message from United wasn't immediately alarming as > > > the > > > > > > lady just stated she wanted to clarify so she would know whether they > > > > > should > > > > > > reimburse the patient. > > > > > > > > > > > > This is the first time, I've had to talk to the insurance company > > > about > > > > > the > > > > > > fee. I know to be clear that this is specifically for services they > > > do > > > > > not > > > > > > cover and not any sort of retainer or membership fee. Does anyone > > > that > > > > > has > > > > > > charged NCBF having any experience with questions from insurances or > > > good > > > > > > " buzz words " or phrases to use. > > > > > > > > > > > > thanks > > > > > > > > > > > > dave gordon > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > -- > > > > M.D. > > > > www.elainemd.com > > > > Office: > > > begin_of_the_skype_highlighting end_of_the_skype_highlighting > > > > > > > Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined. > > > > This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly > > > > confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal > > > > information. The information is intended only for the use of the > > > individual > > > > or entity named above. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, > > > > publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not > > > the > > > > intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, > > > > please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the > > > > information that email in error. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted November 19, 2010 Report Posted November 19, 2010 don't say you " enjoyed " speaking with him unless you did. Just the facts. I hope I didn't refer this guy to you. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I just received a call from United asking for some clarification on > > > > my > > > > > > NCBF. > > > > > > > Apparently a couple patients submitted my invoice to United asking > > > > for > > > > > > > reimbursement. The message from United wasn't immediately alarming as > > > > the > > > > > > > lady just stated she wanted to clarify so she would know whether they > > > > > > should > > > > > > > reimburse the patient. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > This is the first time, I've had to talk to the insurance company > > > > about > > > > > > the > > > > > > > fee. I know to be clear that this is specifically for services they > > > > do > > > > > > not > > > > > > > cover and not any sort of retainer or membership fee. Does anyone > > > > that > > > > > > has > > > > > > > charged NCBF having any experience with questions from insurances or > > > > good > > > > > > > " buzz words " or phrases to use. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > thanks > > > > > > > > > > > > > > dave gordon > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > -- > > > > > M.D. > > > > > www.elainemd.com > > > > > Office: > > > > begin_of_the_skype_highlighting end_of_the_skype_highlighting > > > > > > > > > Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined. > > > > > This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly > > > > > confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal > > > > > information. The information is intended only for the use of the > > > > individual > > > > > or entity named above. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, > > > > > publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not > > > > the > > > > > intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, > > > > > please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the > > > > > information that email in error. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted November 19, 2010 Report Posted November 19, 2010 Thanks Everyone, , I appreciate your points - and your offer to be able to mention that this approach has been checked out by a physician with some insurance plans - but not all. Certainly I know that there is a risk, I believe the fee is legal and fair, but I don't want a time-consuming battle - that's where he got me flustered - a few phone calls would be fine - and hopefully that is how it will go. I left a message on his cell phone informing him that I would not become his doctor and I have a letter set to go because it turns out I saw him, but only once, about 2.5 years ago. Since he has seen no one else at the previous practice I thought I should put in writing that I am not his physician so there could be no accusation of abandonment. I'll include my letter at the below although I feel pretty good about it. I didn't realize that you, , opted out of medicare in part because of a potential conflict with medicare/OIG regulations. It would be really unfortunate to not be able to serve medicare patients . . . But I would rather let the insurer's walk, then change the way I practice. uhhhgg! LETTER: I find it necessary to inform you that I will decline to become your doctor. Your only medical need that you have reported is a desire for a 2 year physical exam. From our phone conversation I have concluded that your medical needs are not consistent with the primary focus of my practice - longitudinal, comprehensive care management and care coordination which relies primarily on the ongoing patient-physician relationship. As an independent medical professional, I do have the liberty to decline to become your physician. You already have an established relationship with the provider group at Santa Clara Medical Clinic, have providers there ready to serve your needs at any time, and you have many choices of other doctors to choose from on your insurance plan who will gladly see you for a one time physical exam. As you may need medical attention in the future, I recommend that you access care where you have an established chart and provider group ready to serve your needs. Presently you have direct access to any of the providers at Santa Clara Medical Clinic because you have your established medical chart at their office. I have not seen you at my new location, have not established a medical chart or medical relationship with you at my office, and am not your doctor. Bear in mind, if you need urgent or emergent care or prescribing, you are able to make an appointment at Santa Clara Medical Clinic. I recommend that you do establish a relationship with a specific provider where ever you choose to go so that you always have a provider to call in case of emergencies or urgencies. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I just received a call from United asking for some clarification on > > > > my > > > > > > NCBF. > > > > > > > Apparently a couple patients submitted my invoice to United asking > > > > for > > > > > > > reimbursement. The message from United wasn't immediately alarming as > > > > the > > > > > > > lady just stated she wanted to clarify so she would know whether they > > > > > > should > > > > > > > reimburse the patient. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > This is the first time, I've had to talk to the insurance company > > > > about > > > > > > the > > > > > > > fee. I know to be clear that this is specifically for services they > > > > do > > > > > > not > > > > > > > cover and not any sort of retainer or membership fee. Does anyone > > > > that > > > > > > has > > > > > > > charged NCBF having any experience with questions from insurances or > > > > good > > > > > > > " buzz words " or phrases to use. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > thanks > > > > > > > > > > > > > > dave gordon > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > -- > > > > > M.D. > > > > > www.elainemd.com > > > > > Office: > > > > begin_of_the_skype_highlighting end_of_the_skype_highlighting > > > > > > > > > Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined. > > > > > This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly > > > > > confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal > > > > > information. The information is intended only for the use of the > > > > individual > > > > > or entity named above. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, > > > > > publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not > > > > the > > > > > intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, > > > > > please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the > > > > > information that email in error. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted November 19, 2010 Report Posted November 19, 2010 Stew, I am in total agreement with everyone...do not take this patinet on!!!! IN fact your mal-practice carrier would tell you that you cannot. He has already displayed hostility toward you and the practice...that makes him a high risk patient. Beside what other manipulative crap could he try. As far as the fee goes.....check out my website www.MyStudioMD.com and my TANCS fee or on FACEBOOK. I had some long, heart to heart talks with a lawyer here in CA before I set up my practice. He was very clear with me that in his opinion the all these fees are illegal because in the state of CA the laws says that you cannot charge for " coordination of medical care". He feels that "coordination of medical care" is an extremely braod definition. He strongly advised me not to do a fee....and then added that he has about 25 clients in CA that DO charge fees. So.....I am extremely vague about what my fee is for...technology, amenities...whatever and there is NO contract. Patients talk to us on the phone or they come in for a meet and greet or many of them come by referral and they GET IT...they know what is is that I am doing and providing. If they are not sure they don't sign up or they pay a monthly fee. By and large most of them pay the annual and are just concerned that they might not get a spot in my 800 patient panel. I am not trying to justify what I charge with "free phone consultaions" or email etc. This is all about a STYLE of medical practice not a here's what you get for each dollar. I really think that most patinets understand this and can be on board. Hopefully this means that if BCBS ever calls me for an explanation I will tell them that the fee is to sit on my pretty couch in my lovely waiting room....I bet thats NOT coverd by insurance. For what its worth on a Friday afternoon..... Dannielle To: Sent: Thu, November 18, 2010 9:09:23 PMSubject: RE: Re: NCBF / Insurance Questions Stew, Good luck with this. Make sure that BCBS doesn’t cover email and/or phone CPT codes; you should be able to look them up on their website. If they don’t, you can state that as part of the NCBF, you offer “free†email and phone consultation, that you offer 24/7 access directly to you – not an answering machine (assuming that this is true?) – and that the NCBF applies to all of your patients (since you do not have different tiers of service depending on how frequent or infrequently a patient may choose to use these services), regardless of type of insurance the patient may have. Stick to your guns. You had reasons for charging the fee in the first place, cite those reasons to BCBS if they should happen to call. A guy like that is definitely not worth having around in your practice… Pratt Office Manager Oak Tree Internal Medicine P.C www.prattmd.info From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Mones MDSent: Thursday, November 18, 2010 8:43 PMTo: Subject: RE: Re: NCBF / Insurance Questions Now that I've had a little breather I wish I had told him "you have a choice - choose a different doctor to harass"and not caved in to his threats, but he hit my achilles heel. I will not establish a P-p relationship with him. I just have to get prepared for a call from BCBS and see how it goes. But I may need to get discrete CPT codes. Telephone codes maybe?Stew Re: Re: NCBF / Insurance QuestionsBut, stew is worried about calls to regence and is asking for language tostave that headache off..now how/>>> Do not enter into a doctor patient relationship with this guy. You are> under no obligation to change your practice arrangements to satisfy him.> Drop him a note saying that you enjoyed speaking with him but you suggest he> look elsewhere for the practice that will exactly fit his needs.> Joann >>> >>>> NEED ADVICE!! From those of you navigating the NCBF. Dave and ?>> Patient today asks for an appointment and when my assistant tells him my> NCBF $10/month "HealthyAccess Fee" applies to ALL patients because I do not> have 2 tiers of service and all patients have access to me 24 x 7 for email> and phone, he replied that he was going to call Regence/Blue Cross> BlueShield because he is certain that it is unethical to charge ALL patient> an extra fee. He states that I am "forcing patients to pay just to walk in> the door" and that all he wants is a physical every 2 years that his> insurance allows without a copay or coinsurance.>> I decided to call him and answer his questions over the phone so he didn't> have to call REgence and make my life hell. He tells me he met me 2 or 3> times, at my previous practice, he liked me, thinks I'm different (in a good> way) from other docs and wants to see me but he doesn't want a relationship> with his doctor, he doesn't want to talk to his doctor on the phone or> email, he just wants his physical, he wants ME to do his physical and if I> don't do the physical and waive the NCBF (because he says he should have a> choice)he says he going to make it his goal in life to make my life hell.> (he is an unemployed medical imaging "consultant")>> He is going to call RegenceBC/BS AND write articles about how doctors doing> what I'm doing are taking advantage of patients and bilking the system to> just make as much money as they can.>> He says he is not "blackmailing" me, he just wants his physical and doesn't> want to pay. I told him (after way too much time on the phone) that I would> see him for his physical and that I would re-evaluate the issue of choice in> my healthy access fee. Perhaps I would offer to charge per phone call/email> (do I need an ABN? for that) rather than a global fee.>> I feel threatened and blackmailed - but I don't actually dislike the guy.> He is the kind of guy who you want as your friend, but never ever want as> your enemy. If I were his friendly doctor, though, when he gives himself a> heart attack, I most certainly will be blamed by him.>> So my tentative gameplan is to add to my policy, a provision to opt-out of> the global NCBF and a choice to sign an ABN for telephone/email exchanges (I> hate that idea because it discourages patients from contacting their doctor)> and then I think I might call BCBS first (because this guy definately will)> and spill the beans and see if I can get anyone half witted to understand> what I'm saying, and then call this guy back and say. "I now offer patients> a choice at my practice - pay a low monthly fee for the NCBF or pay per> occurrence of each specific non covered phone or email exchange, BUT I am> not willing to take you on as a patient because I feel uncomfortable> (threatened and intimidated) due to the tone of our last conversation - I do> not think we are a good match.">> This guy has put me in a pickle.>> Stew Mones> Maitree Family Medicine>> > > > > > >> > > > > > I just received a call from United asking for some clarification> on> > > my> > > > > NCBF.> > > > > > Apparently a couple patients submitted my invoice to United> asking> > > for> > > > > > reimbursement. The message from United wasn't immediately> alarming as> > > the> > > > > > lady just stated she wanted to clarify so she would know whether> they> > > > > should> > > > > > reimburse the patient.> > > > > >> > > > > > This is the first time, I've had to talk to the insurance company> > > about> > > > > the> > > > > > fee. I know to be clear that this is specifically for services> they> > > do> > > > > not> > > > > > cover and not any sort of retainer or membership fee. Does anyone> > > that> > > > > has> > > > > > charged NCBF having any experience with questions from insurances> or> > > good> > > > > > "buzz words" or phrases to use.> > > > > >> > > > > > thanks> > > > > >> > > > > > dave gordon> > > > > >> > > > >> > > > >> > > > >> > > >> > > >> > > >> > > > --> > > > M.D.> > > > <http://www.elainemd.com>www.elainemd.com> > > > Office: > > > begin_of_the_skype_highlighting > end_of_the_skype_highlighting> > >> > > > Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've> imagined.> > > > This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly> > > > confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or> legal> > > > information. The information is intended only for the use of the> > > individual> > > > or entity named above.> > > >> > > >> > > >> > > > If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not> use,> > > > publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are> not> > > the> > > > intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in> error,> > > > please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the> > > > information that email in error.> > > >> > >> > >> > >> >>> >-- Sangeetha Murthy M.D7830 mont Mesa Blvd #287San Diego , CA 92111www.mypcponline.com Quote
Guest guest Posted November 19, 2010 Report Posted November 19, 2010 I think medicare says you can't charge for a nice office... I believe the insurance co have sent snitches into my office. They get such excellent care. Never heard back nor ever heard back from these pts either Sent from my iPhone On Nov 19, 2010, at 2:27 PM, Dannielle Harwood wrote: > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.