Guest guest Posted November 21, 2010 Report Posted November 21, 2010 Stew, In SPADES!! You certainly have the right to not accept someone as a patient, and anyone who would say he's " going to make it his goal in life to make my life hell" is NOT someone you want to see. Consider yourself lucky to have found out before you accepted him! Sad to say, it's the patients with personality disorders that create the most problems in a practice. Since about 25% of the population has one, you can't avoid them all, and have to learn to manage most of them, but there's no sense asking for trouble. I would simply say that "From our conversations, I don't think we would be able to establish a satisfactory working relationship. Just as you have the choice of selecting a doctor, I have the option of accepting a patient, or not. I hope you establish a better relationship with your future doctor. This decision is not subject to appeal." In writing if you have to. Be sure the front desk staff knows. You DON'T have to get specific, and doing so might even give him more ammunition. PL "There is nothing so exhilarating as to be shot at and missed." 1st Sea Lord, Winston Churchill Quote
Guest guest Posted November 21, 2010 Report Posted November 21, 2010 Certified Return Reciept.... Document this as your NOT accepting him into your practice. You are allowed to not accept a patient you feel uncomfortable with... And goodness knows this one gives us all the creeps... To: Sent: Sun, November 21, 2010 1:43:06 AMSubject: Re: NCBF / Insurance Questions Stew,In SPADES!! You certainly have the right to not accept someone as a patient, and anyone who would say he's " going to make it his goal in life to make my life hell" is NOT someone you want to see. Consider yourself lucky to have found out before you accepted him! Sad to say, it's the patients with personality disorders that create the most problems in a practice. Since about 25% of the population has one, you can't avoid them all, and have to learn to manage most of them, but there's no sense asking for trouble.I would simply say that "From our conversations, I don't think we would be able to establish a satisfactory working relationship. Just as you have the choice of selecting a doctor, I have the option of accepting a patient, or not. I hope you establish a better relationship with your future doctor. This decision is not subject to appeal." In writing if you have to. Be sure the front desk staff knows. You DON'T have to get specific, and doing so might even give him more ammunition.PL"There is nothing so exhilarating as to be shot at and missed." 1st Sea Lord, Winston Churchill Quote
Guest guest Posted November 21, 2010 Report Posted November 21, 2010 This has been a great thread for me as we consider a retainer fee. Here are a couple other links that I have found doing research on this. Note the 2004 Office of Inspector General case resulting in a $53,400 judgment. An improperly worded retainer agreement there. There was also a recent MEDPAC presentation that recommended the OIG reevaluate the retainer model based on the new health care law. I like the idea of retainer simply being for "access" vs. specific services that may or may not be covered by Medicare or private insurance companies. Unfortunately, I haven't been able to find any discussion for this type of retainer contract wording.OIG Alert:http://oig.hhs.gov/fraud/docs/alertsandbulletins/2004/FA033104AssignViolationI.pdf Retainer Fee discussion paper from AAFP:http://www.aafp.org/online/etc/medialib/aafp_org/documents/policy/private/healthplans/payment/retainerfee.Par.0001.File.tmp/Retainer%20Practices%20discussion%20paper.doc General Lawyer paper on retainer/concierge practice issueshttp://www.drlaw.com/getattachment/222343d5-7523-49a6-8e36-7fabd45df2fc/.aspx MEDPAC presentation on retainer practices (couple pages down)http://www.edpma.org/downloads/advocacy/Avalere_Health_Summary_of_September_MedPAC_Meetingl.pdf Quote
Guest guest Posted November 22, 2010 Report Posted November 22, 2010 Stew,I agree with all the recommendations listed already - don't take on this patient, continue your NCBF, etc.Just to be the devil's advocate...I can totally see how patients are going to get frustrated. Due to a combination of lower fees to doctors, higher insurance premiums, and docs adding on Non-Covered Benefits Fees, I would also be frustrated to have my doc charging me even more.Here I am...a healthy person who just needs a physical every 2 years - and my insurance covers these physicals for " free " - no copay or co-insurance, plus my monthly premiums have gone up 15% again this year - for now reason. Then the doc wants to charge me a monthly or annual fee for care that I likely won't use because I only go to the doctor every 2 years.I'd be irritated, too.On the other hand, if that is how the doctor is running his practice and it isn't a good fit for me -- I'd check on using a different doc. That's the other side that I can see. Not saying this patient is right to threaten blackmail - just seeing why he might be frustrated with the system.Hope the situation works out. Locke, MD Quote
Guest guest Posted November 23, 2010 Report Posted November 23, 2010 , I do understand that frustration too - but people have choices. Update: So far just a menacing email that he thinks I am discriminating against him. Checked with my malpractice carrier, BCBS contracts and all my policies and feel I'm in pretty good stead. I do understand the frustration for young healthy people but I also know I'm underselling a valuable service. I think this situation has convinced me NOT to raise my rates on the NCBF and to be careful to only persuade but not require patients to pay for the service. I do have a box for those who are not ready to pay for service to check " I have questions and am not ready to pay for the HealthyAccess(NCBF) " . I have 2 or 3 patients who have checked this indefinately (which doesn't seem fair either). Stew Re: Re: NCBF / Insurance Questions Stew, I agree with all the recommendations listed already - don't take on this patient, continue your NCBF, etc. Just to be the devil's advocate...I can totally see how patients are going to get frustrated. Due to a combination of lower fees to doctors, higher insurance premiums, and docs adding on Non-Covered Benefits Fees, I would also be frustrated to have my doc charging me even more. Here I am...a healthy person who just needs a physical every 2 years - and my insurance covers these physicals for " free " - no copay or co-insurance, plus my monthly premiums have gone up 15% again this year - for now reason. Then the doc wants to charge me a monthly or annual fee for care that I likely won't use because I only go to the doctor every 2 years. I'd be irritated, too. On the other hand, if that is how the doctor is running his practice and it isn't a good fit for me -- I'd check on using a different doc. That's the other side that I can see. Not saying this patient is right to threaten blackmail - just seeing why he might be frustrated with the system. Hope the situation works out. Locke, MD Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.