Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Re: Re: Retainer fees and Medicare

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted

Yes, but I’m not pointing that out to

Medicare, and somehow there must be a loophole or the insurance company wouldn’t

do that. And I only have 1 contract that pays me less, and it’s only on a few

codes. I’ll let you guess who it is (and no, it’s not UHC).

Pratt

Office Manager

Oak Tree Internal Medicine P.C

www.prattmd.info

From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of

Sent: Wednesday, August 25, 2010

10:25 PM

To:

Subject: Re:

Re: Retainer fees and Medicare

But that

happens in CA when private ins pay us less then MC, doesn't?

On Wed, Aug 25, 2010 at 2:46 PM, Pratt

wrote:

Ellen,

The stipulation is that you can’t charge

other patients LESS than what you charge Medicare patients. Medicare

doesn’t want to pay more than what you are willing to accept from others.

Pratt

Office Manager

Oak Tree Internal Medicine P.C

www.prattmd.info

From:

[mailto: ]

On Behalf Of Ellen son

Sent: Tuesday, August 24, 2010

8:52 PM

To:

Subject: Re:

Re: Retainer fees and Medicare

In Portland,

private insurance pays 70-80+% charges vs 40% Medicare. I

may try to get to camp this yr--would be nice to see

what others are

doing and share info,

meet the faces behind the names. I have been in my own IMP for 8 yrs now

and doing well. But there are always ways to improve and grow. No end to

things to do.

I thought there was some stipulation if you take Medicare that you can't

charge other pts more(that doesn't mean you don't get paid more but you

have to charge everyone the same).

So that's why I'm curious about having a retainer and also taking

Medicare. I have not read the fine print so I can't say, it's only what

I've gleaned here and elsewhere.

Ellen

Gordon wrote:

>

> I think it's really all a matter of what point of view you are looking

> at it from. if you are following the absolute strict line of the the

> wording in the medicare law, I suspect it says everything and anything

> we do regarding a patient is covered by their office visit charges.

> However, I choose to look at things compared to what is standard of

> care in my community and thus the services I'm providing is

> drastically different than most if not all other practitioners seeing

> medicare patients. Thus I consider these services to be non-covered

> since I could not do them and still get the same amount of money from

> medicare.

>

> I made the change last year from regular practice to IMP with NCBF. I

> simply stated that the services I was providing required the

> non-covered benefits charge. On my website in the philosophy

> frequently asked questions section there is some wording I have used

> (www.intmedcc.com

<http://www.intmedcc.com>).

I agree it's a little

> harsh to develop repoire with patients and then hit them with " if you

> want to continue with me it's now going to cost you extra, " and I do

> get twinges of guilt at times (especially now as I'm about to increase

> the fee). However, I go back to the fact that I'm providing service

> that simply they wont get at a traditional practice and even at $300

> per year it's well worth it in my opinion. They have the option to

> leave. Finally, I would never turn anyone away for a true financial

> hardship. 2 of my 500 patients really wanted to stay but contacted me

> and said they really couldnt do the $100 fee this year and I was fine

> with that. I certainly didn't publicize that I would do it.

>

> I'll be talking more at IMP Camp about transitioning and the NCBF as

> will others so I'd highly recommend camp if you anyone hasn't already

> signed up.

>

> Of note, in Denver,

private insurers are generally 20-40% higher than

> medicare in terms of reimbursement.

>

> On Tue, Aug 24, 2010 at 11:42 AM, Ellen son

> <nellegreen@...

>

wrote:

>

> Pt Centered Med Home, just one example, says that SDA are part of

> what

> we should be offering to out pts, without a retainer fee. I use a

> cell

> phone for after hours calls.

> So how do I/you justify charging extra for cell communication? Just

> trying to understand the boundaries of it all. As someone here

> mentioned, some Medicare pts have lots of money,

> I certainly have some who do, and I'm annoyed when they want to

> discuss

> their abnormal labs over the tel. How would you start charging for

> services to pts you have worked with for a number of years and NOT

> charged them extra for these things?

>

> Ellen

>

>

>

> Gordon wrote:

> >

> > I charge a non-covered benefits fee for everyone including

> medicare. i

> > would say the medicare patients utilize the non-covered services

> like

> > email/cell communication, some day access, etc. more than most. i

> > agree with brian that what we offer is worth far more than we

> charge

> > (currently i'm 100/yr but next year will be 250-300). in my area,

> > there are concierge docs charging 3-5K per year and from what I

> hear I

> > offer far more than they do - i have waived the fee for those

> under 25

> > though I just picked that at random. it's only about 5-10 of my 500

> > patients. probably will continue that next year as well but not

> sure.

> > i know it's a little sketchy charging the extra fee for medicare

> > patients from the legality side of things but this is one area i

> just

> > choose to play naive. my backup plan was that if medicare came

> after

> > me, I would start a nation media campaign about how i was being

> > punished for providing excellent care (hopefully that will not be

> > necessary)

> >

> > On Tue, Aug 24, 2010 at 9:36 AM, Pierce

> > <bpierce@...

> <mailto:bpierce%40midcoastmedicine.com>

> <mailto:bpierce@...

> <mailto:bpierce%40midcoastmedicine.com>>>

> > wrote:

> >

> > Most of my wealthier patients are over 65.

> >

> > However, most of the fees I see discussed here are less than the

> > price of the cable TV or cell phone plans that nearly all of my

> > patients seem to find affordable.

> >

> > We need to stop undervaluing ourselves.

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >>

> >> I don't think there is anything wrong about giving people 65 and

> >> over a break. many businesses do...movie theatres, Ross dept

> >> stores, etc

> >>

> >> On Mon, Aug 23, 2010 at 7:53 PM, Ellen son

> >> <nellegreen@...

<mailto:nellegreen%40earthlink.net>

> <mailto:nellegreen@...

> <mailto:nellegreen%40earthlink.net>>>

wrote:

> >>

> >> I wasn't thinking of charging Medicare pts a retainer. I was

> >> wondering

> >> about having Medicare pts in your practice and also having

> >> pts who pay a

> >> retainer fee. Is that reasonable?

> >> Allowable? Medicare pts are on fixed incomes. Some do have

> >> money but

> >> many don't. Medicare does pay for an H & P within the first

> >> 12 mos. You

> >> can also do a PAP and E & M code at the same visit.

> >> As of Jan 2011, all new insurance policies will have to pay for

> >> preventive services--though what those are will probably

> >> differ unless

> >> the govern't creates a definition.

> >>

> >>

> >>

> >> Craig Ross wrote:

> >> >

> >> > Charging Medicare patients a retainer fee has been

> >> challenged in court

> >> > several time and the has retainer fee won every time ... so

> >> far.

> >> > However, it must be for services not covered by Medicare.

Many

> >> > practices charging a high retainer fee (e.g.

" Concierge "

> >> practices)

> >> > are using the fact that Medicare doesn't currently cover

> >> Health

> >> > Maintenance Exams (HMEs) as the main reason for the charge.

> >> For

> >> > example, they say they charge $500 annual retainer fee.

> >> $300 is for

> >> > the annual exam and $200 is for chronic care management,

> >> 24/7 access,

> >> > telephone and email access, etc.

> >> >

> >> > All this will change once HCR mandates Medicare pay for an

> >> annual

> >> > health assessment. Concierge practices will need to find a

> >> different

> >> > break down for their annual fee for non-covered services as

> >> charging

> >> > $300 for an annual exam will no longer be legal.

> >> >

> >> > You can still charge a retainer fee for telephone, 24/7

> >> access to you,

> >> > email etc as long as Medicare doesn't pay for them.

> >> However, you need

> >> > to make sure you have the patient sign the form ahead of

> >> time that

> >> > says that Medicare won't pay for these services.

> >> >

> >> > Craig

> >> >

> >> >

> >> > > > >

> >> > > > > I think changing the language will work.

> >> > > > >

> >> > > > > If you say: " In Medicare we trust,

everyone else pays

> >> cash " and

> >> > " Kids

> >> > > > > get care free " .... it should work fine.

> >> > > > > ie language would be that We dont accept any

> >> insurance other than

> >> > > > > Medicare but we offer our discounted cash

rates to

> >> those who have

> >> > > > > other insurances......

> >> > > > >

> >> > > > > In this wording you are not saying you are

charging

> >> those between

> >> > > > > 26-65 but you are saying that you are giving

discount

> >> to those

> >> > <26 and

> >> > > > > >65. It means the same but technical

language is

> >> different.

> >> > > > >

> >> > > > > ------------------

> >> > > > > When I say " In Medicare we trust,

everyone else pays

> >> cash " , most

> >> > docs

> >> > > > > from most parts of country will laugh but

quite

> >> ironically,

> >> > Medicare

> >> > > > > is the best payer in CA and many parts in

east coast.

> >> > > > >

> >> > > > > Still doctors want to move to CA!

> >> > > > >

> >> > > > > -----------------------

> >> > > > > To avoid getting in trouble with Medicare's

" most

> >> favored "

> >> > clause, I

> >> > > > > would keep per visit charge same for all new

visit

> >> and one same

> >> > charge

> >> > > > > for all f/ups and then give 40-60% discount

for PATOS

> >> ...... so,

> >> > > > > 99201-99205 are all charged $500 and there is

80%

> >> PATOS discount

> >> > > > > ........... 99211-99215 are all $400 and with

80% PATOS

> >> > discount, pt

> >> > > > > pays $80

> >> > > > >

> >> > > > > One key thing in retainer model is to not

allow

> >> unlimited number of

> >> > > > > visits ....... once you cover unlimited

number of

> >> visits, you are

> >> > > > > assuming an unknown risk and it makes you

insurance

> >> and Ins Co

> >> > could

> >> > > > > complaint agaisnt you to the insurance board

etc

> >> .......... it

> >> > will be

> >> > > > > fine if you say that yearly retainer charge

covers

> >> 500 (yes, five

> >> > > > > hundreds) visits a year ...... but there has

to be a

> >> finite number

> >> > > > >

> >> > > > > see doctorsh blog for one such model

> >> > > > >

> >> > > > >

> >> > > >

> >> > >

> >> >

> >> >

> >>

> >>

> >>

> >>

> >> --

> >> M.D.

> >> www.elainemd.com

<http://www.elainemd.com>

> <http://www.elainemd.com>

>

> >> Office:

> >> Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've

> >> imagined.

> >> This email transmission may contain protected and privileged,

> >> highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information

> >> (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only

> >> for the use of the individual or entity named above.

> >>

> >>

> >>

> >> If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may

> >> not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute

> >> it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have

> >> received this transmission in error, please notify the sender

> >> immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email

> >> in error.

> >

> >

> >

>

>

>

--

M.D.

www.elainemd.com

Office:

Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.

This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly

confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal

information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or

entity named above.

If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use,

publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the

intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please

notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that

email in error.

Posted

What is NCBF?

From:

[mailto: ] On Behalf Of Gordon

Sent: Tuesday, August 24, 2010 9:18 PM

To:

Subject: Re: Re: Retainer fees and Medicare

I think it's really all a matter of what point

of view you are looking at it from. if you are following the absolute

strict line of the the wording in the medicare law, I suspect it says

everything and anything we do regarding a patient is covered by their office visit

charges. However, I choose to look at things compared to what is standard

of care in my community and thus the services I'm providing is drastically

different than most if not all other practitioners seeing medicare

patients. Thus I consider these services to be non-covered since I could

not do them and still get the same amount of money from medicare.

I made the change last year from regular practice to IMP with NCBF. I

simply stated that the services I was providing required the non-covered benefits

charge. On my website in the philosophy frequently asked questions

section there is some wording I have used (www.intmedcc.com).

I agree it's a little harsh to develop repoire with patients and then hit them

with " if you want to continue with me it's now going to cost you

extra, " and I do get twinges of guilt at times (especially now as I'm

about to increase the fee). However, I go back to the fact that I'm

providing service that simply they wont get at a traditional practice and even

at $300 per year it's well worth it in my opinion. They have the option

to leave. Finally, I would never turn anyone away for a true financial

hardship. 2 of my 500 patients really wanted to stay but contacted me and

said they really couldnt do the $100 fee this year and I was fine with

that. I certainly didn't publicize that I would do it.

I'll be talking more at IMP Camp about transitioning and the NCBF as will

others so I'd highly recommend camp if you anyone hasn't already signed up.

Of note, in Denver, private insurers are generally 20-40% higher than medicare

in terms of reimbursement.

Pt Centered Med Home, just one example, says that

SDA are part of what

we should be offering to out pts, without a retainer fee. I use a cell

phone for after hours calls.

So how do I/you justify charging extra for cell communication? Just

trying to understand the boundaries of it all. As someone here

mentioned, some Medicare pts have lots of money,

I certainly have some who do, and I'm annoyed when they want to discuss

their abnormal labs over the tel. How would you start charging for

services to pts you have worked with for a number of years and NOT

charged them extra for these things?

Ellen

Gordon wrote:

>

> I charge a non-covered benefits fee for everyone including medicare. i

> would say the medicare patients utilize the non-covered services like

> email/cell communication, some day access, etc. more than most. i

> agree with brian that what we offer is worth far more than we charge

> (currently i'm 100/yr but next year will be 250-300). in my area,

> there are concierge docs charging 3-5K per year and from what I hear I

> offer far more than they do - i have waived the fee for those under 25

> though I just picked that at random. it's only about 5-10 of my 500

> patients. probably will continue that next year as well but not sure.

> i know it's a little sketchy charging the extra fee for medicare

> patients from the legality side of things but this is one area i just

> choose to play naive. my backup plan was that if medicare came after

> me, I would start a nation media campaign about how i was being

> punished for providing excellent care (hopefully that will not be

> necessary)

>

> On Tue, Aug 24, 2010 at 9:36 AM, Pierce

> <bpierce@...

>

> wrote:

>

> Most of my wealthier patients are over 65.

>

> However, most of the fees I see discussed here are less than the

> price of the cable TV or cell phone plans that nearly all of my

> patients seem to find affordable.

>

> We need to stop undervaluing ourselves.

>

>

>

>

>

>

>>

>> I don't think there is anything wrong about giving people 65 and

>> over a break. many businesses do...movie theatres, Ross dept

>> stores, etc

>>

>> On Mon, Aug 23, 2010 at 7:53 PM, Ellen son

>> <nellegreen@...

>

wrote:

>>

>> I wasn't thinking of charging Medicare pts a retainer. I was

>> wondering

>> about having Medicare pts in your practice and also having

>> pts who pay a

>> retainer fee. Is that reasonable?

>> Allowable? Medicare pts are on fixed incomes. Some do have

>> money but

>> many don't. Medicare does pay for an H & P within the first

>> 12 mos. You

>> can also do a PAP and E & M code at the same visit.

>> As of Jan 2011, all new insurance policies will have to pay for

>> preventive services--though what those are will probably

>> differ unless

>> the govern't creates a definition.

>>

>>

>>

>> Craig Ross wrote:

>> >

>> > Charging Medicare patients a retainer fee has been

>> challenged in court

>> > several time and the has retainer fee won every time ... so

>> far.

>> > However, it must be for services not covered by Medicare. Many

>> > practices charging a high retainer fee (e.g.

" Concierge "

>> practices)

>> > are using the fact that Medicare doesn't currently cover

>> Health

>> > Maintenance Exams (HMEs) as the main reason for the charge.

>> For

>> > example, they say they charge $500 annual retainer fee.

>> $300 is for

>> > the annual exam and $200 is for chronic care management,

>> 24/7 access,

>> > telephone and email access, etc.

>> >

>> > All this will change once HCR mandates Medicare pay for an

>> annual

>> > health assessment. Concierge practices will need to find a

>> different

>> > break down for their annual fee for non-covered services as

>> charging

>> > $300 for an annual exam will no longer be legal.

>> >

>> > You can still charge a retainer fee for telephone, 24/7

>> access to you,

>> > email etc as long as Medicare doesn't pay for them.

>> However, you need

>> > to make sure you have the patient sign the form ahead of

>> time that

>> > says that Medicare won't pay for these services.

>> >

>> > Craig

>> >

>> >

>> > > > >

>> > > > > I think changing the language will work.

>> > > > >

>> > > > > If you say: " In Medicare we trust, everyone

else pays

>> cash " and

>> > " Kids

>> > > > > get care free " .... it should work fine.

>> > > > > ie language would be that We dont accept any

>> insurance other than

>> > > > > Medicare but we offer our discounted cash rates to

>> those who have

>> > > > > other insurances......

>> > > > >

>> > > > > In this wording you are not saying you are

charging

>> those between

>> > > > > 26-65 but you are saying that you are giving

discount

>> to those

>> > <26 and

>> > > > > >65. It means the same but technical language

is

>> different.

>> > > > >

>> > > > > ------------------

>> > > > > When I say " In Medicare we trust, everyone

else pays

>> cash " , most

>> > docs

>> > > > > from most parts of country will laugh but quite

>> ironically,

>> > Medicare

>> > > > > is the best payer in CA and many parts in east

coast.

>> > > > >

>> > > > > Still doctors want to move to CA!

>> > > > >

>> > > > > -----------------------

>> > > > > To avoid getting in trouble with Medicare's

" most

>> favored "

>> > clause, I

>> > > > > would keep per visit charge same for all new visit

>> and one same

>> > charge

>> > > > > for all f/ups and then give 40-60% discount for

PATOS

>> ...... so,

>> > > > > 99201-99205 are all charged $500 and there is 80%

>> PATOS discount

>> > > > > ........... 99211-99215 are all $400 and with 80%

PATOS

>> > discount, pt

>> > > > > pays $80

>> > > > >

>> > > > > One key thing in retainer model is to not allow

>> unlimited number of

>> > > > > visits ....... once you cover unlimited number of

>> visits, you are

>> > > > > assuming an unknown risk and it makes you

insurance

>> and Ins Co

>> > could

>> > > > > complaint agaisnt you to the insurance board etc

>> .......... it

>> > will be

>> > > > > fine if you say that yearly retainer charge covers

>> 500 (yes, five

>> > > > > hundreds) visits a year ...... but there has to be

a

>> finite number

>> > > > >

>> > > > > see doctorsh blog for one such model

>> > > > >

>> > > > >

>> > > >

>> > >

>> >

>> >

>>

>>

>>

>>

>> --

>> M.D.

>> www.elainemd.com <http://www.elainemd.com>

>> Office:

>> Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've

>> imagined.

>> This email transmission may contain protected and privileged,

>> highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information

>> (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only

>> for the use of the individual or entity named above.

>>

>>

>>

>> If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may

>> not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute

>> it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have

>> received this transmission in error, please notify the sender

>> immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email

>> in error.

>

>

>

Posted

Non covered benefits fee...sorry

> What is NCBF?> > > > From:

> [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Gordon> Sent: Tuesday, August 24, 2010 9:18 PM> To:

> Subject: Re: Re: Retainer fees and Medicare> > > > > > I think it's really all a matter of what point of view you are looking at it> from. if you are following the absolute strict line of the the wording in

> the medicare law, I suspect it says everything and anything we do regarding> a patient is covered by their office visit charges. However, I choose to> look at things compared to what is standard of care in my community and thus

> the services I'm providing is drastically different than most if not all> other practitioners seeing medicare patients. Thus I consider these> services to be non-covered since I could not do them and still get the same

> amount of money from medicare.> > I made the change last year from regular practice to IMP with NCBF. I> simply stated that the services I was providing required the non-covered> benefits charge. On my website in the philosophy frequently asked questions

> section there is some wording I have used (www.intmedcc.com). I agree it's> a little harsh to develop repoire with patients and then hit them with " if> you want to continue with me it's now going to cost you extra, " and I do get

> twinges of guilt at times (especially now as I'm about to increase the fee).> However, I go back to the fact that I'm providing service that simply they> wont get at a traditional practice and even at $300 per year it's well worth

> it in my opinion. They have the option to leave. Finally, I would never> turn anyone away for a true financial hardship. 2 of my 500 patients really> wanted to stay but contacted me and said they really couldnt do the $100 fee

> this year and I was fine with that. I certainly didn't publicize that I> would do it.> > I'll be talking more at IMP Camp about transitioning and the NCBF as will> others so I'd highly recommend camp if you anyone hasn't already signed up.

> > Of note, in Denver, private insurers are generally 20-40% higher than> medicare in terms of reimbursement.> >

> > > > Pt Centered Med Home, just one example, says that SDA are part of what > we should be offering to out pts, without a retainer fee. I use a cell > phone for after hours calls.

> So how do I/you justify charging extra for cell communication? Just > trying to understand the boundaries of it all. As someone here > mentioned, some Medicare pts have lots of money,> I certainly have some who do, and I'm annoyed when they want to discuss

> their abnormal labs over the tel. How would you start charging for > services to pts you have worked with for a number of years and NOT > charged them extra for these things?> > Ellen>

> > > Gordon wrote:>>>> I charge a non-covered benefits fee for everyone including medicare. i >> would say the medicare patients utilize the non-covered services like

>> email/cell communication, some day access, etc. more than most. i >> agree with brian that what we offer is worth far more than we charge >> (currently i'm 100/yr but next year will be 250-300). in my area,

>> there are concierge docs charging 3-5K per year and from what I hear I >> offer far more than they do - i have waived the fee for those under 25 >> though I just picked that at random. it's only about 5-10 of my 500

>> patients. probably will continue that next year as well but not sure. >> i know it's a little sketchy charging the extra fee for medicare >> patients from the legality side of things but this is one area i just

>> choose to play naive. my backup plan was that if medicare came after >> me, I would start a nation media campaign about how i was being >> punished for providing excellent care (hopefully that will not be

>> necessary)>>>> On Tue, Aug 24, 2010 at 9:36 AM, Pierce > >> <bpierce@... <mailto:bpierce%40midcoastmedicine.com>

> <mailto:bpierce@... <mailto:bpierce%40midcoastmedicine.com>>>> >

>> wrote:>>>> Most of my wealthier patients are over 65.>>>> However, most of the fees I see discussed here are less than the>> price of the cable TV or cell phone plans that nearly all of my

>> patients seem to find affordable.>>>> We need to stop undervaluing ourselves.>>>> >>>>>>>>

>>>>>> I don't think there is anything wrong about giving people 65 and>>> over a break. many businesses do...movie theatres, Ross dept>>> stores, etc>>>

>>> On Mon, Aug 23, 2010 at 7:53 PM, Ellen son> >>> <nellegreen@... <mailto:nellegreen%40earthlink.net>

> <mailto:nellegreen@... <mailto:nellegreen%40earthlink.net> >>> wrote:>>>

>>> I wasn't thinking of charging Medicare pts a retainer. I was>>> wondering>>> about having Medicare pts in your practice and also having>>> pts who pay a>>> retainer fee. Is that reasonable?

>>> Allowable? Medicare pts are on fixed incomes. Some do have>>> money but>>> many don't. Medicare does pay for an H & P within the first>>> 12 mos. You>>> can also do a PAP and E & M code at the same visit.

>>> As of Jan 2011, all new insurance policies will have to pay for>>> preventive services--though what those are will probably>>> differ unless>>> the govern't creates a definition.

>>>>>>>>>>>> Craig Ross wrote:>>> >>>> > Charging Medicare patients a retainer fee has been>>> challenged in court>>> > several time and the has retainer fee won every time ... so

>>> far.>>> > However, it must be for services not covered by Medicare. Many>>> > practices charging a high retainer fee (e.g. " Concierge " >>> practices)>>> > are using the fact that Medicare doesn't currently cover

>>> Health>>> > Maintenance Exams (HMEs) as the main reason for the charge.>>> For>>> > example, they say they charge $500 annual retainer fee.>>> $300 is for

>>> > the annual exam and $200 is for chronic care management,>>> 24/7 access,>>> > telephone and email access, etc.>>> >>>> > All this will change once HCR mandates Medicare pay for an

>>> annual>>> > health assessment. Concierge practices will need to find a>>> different>>> > break down for their annual fee for non-covered services as>>> charging

>>> > $300 for an annual exam will no longer be legal.>>> >>>> > You can still charge a retainer fee for telephone, 24/7>>> access to you,>>> > email etc as long as Medicare doesn't pay for them.

>>> However, you need>>> > to make sure you have the patient sign the form ahead of>>> time that>>> > says that Medicare won't pay for these services.>>> >

>>> > Craig>>> >>>> >

>>> > > > >>>> > > > > I think changing the language will work.>>> > > > >>>> > > > > If you say: " In Medicare we trust, everyone else pays

>>> cash " and>>> > " Kids>>> > > > > get care free " .... it should work fine.>>> > > > > ie language would be that We dont accept any

>>> insurance other than>>> > > > > Medicare but we offer our discounted cash rates to>>> those who have>>> > > > > other insurances......>>> > > > >

>>> > > > > In this wording you are not saying you are charging>>> those between>>> > > > > 26-65 but you are saying that you are giving discount>>> to those

>>> > <26 and>>> > > > > >65. It means the same but technical language is>>> different.>>> > > > >>>> > > > > ------------------

>>> > > > > When I say " In Medicare we trust, everyone else pays>>> cash " , most>>> > docs>>> > > > > from most parts of country will laugh but quite

>>> ironically,>>> > Medicare>>> > > > > is the best payer in CA and many parts in east coast.>>> > > > >>>> > > > > Still doctors want to move to CA!

>>> > > > >>>> > > > > ----------------------->>> > > > > To avoid getting in trouble with Medicare's " most>>> favored "

>>> > clause, I>>> > > > > would keep per visit charge same for all new visit>>> and one same>>> > charge>>> > > > > for all f/ups and then give 40-60% discount for PATOS

>>> ...... so,>>> > > > > 99201-99205 are all charged $500 and there is 80%>>> PATOS discount>>> > > > > ........... 99211-99215 are all $400 and with 80% PATOS

>>> > discount, pt>>> > > > > pays $80>>> > > > >>>> > > > > One key thing in retainer model is to not allow>>> unlimited number of

>>> > > > > visits ....... once you cover unlimited number of>>> visits, you are>>> > > > > assuming an unknown risk and it makes you insurance>>> and Ins Co

>>> > could>>> > > > > complaint agaisnt you to the insurance board etc>>> .......... it>>> > will be>>> > > > > fine if you say that yearly retainer charge covers

>>> 500 (yes, five>>> > > > > hundreds) visits a year ...... but there has to be a>>> finite number>>> > > > >>>> > > > > see doctorsh blog for one such model

>>> > > > >>>> > > > >>>> > > >>>> > >>>> >>>> >>>>>>>>>>>>>

>>> -- >>> M.D.> >>> www.elainemd.com <http://www.elainemd.com>> > >>> Office:

>>> Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've>>> imagined.>>> This email transmission may contain protected and privileged,>>> highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information

>>> (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only>>> for the use of the individual or entity named above.>>>>>>>>>>>> If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may

>>> not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute>>> it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have>>> received this transmission in error, please notify the sender

>>> immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email>>> in error.>>>>>> > > > > >

Posted

I am really looking forward to more

discussion on the NCBF idea at IMP camp later this month.

I have no such fee, but have begun to feel

taken advantage by my patients who are increasingly demanding and now expect

many services for free, simply because they are loyal patients! In the

last 2 months, I have had numerous patients balk at the $15.00 forms and

letters fee that I have always charged (even back in my traditional practice

before starting IMP).

Patients have come to expect long e-mail

replies, frequent e-mail reminders on overdue items, 20 minute plus phone

discussions, multiple copies of prescriptions for mail in, prior authorization

work, extended appointment times, and excellent access as included in the fees

they pay at the time of their visit. ALL of these services are clearly

not available at “the other guys” in town, yet I offer for NO

additional fee. The only thing I do charge for is the letters/forms

fee. I have yet to charge for no shows, though I reserve the right to do

so.

I am starting to feel a bit

under-valued. Today, I was thinking that perhaps my patients would find

charges for some (of the free) services more palatable than my forms/letters

fee.

Along those lines, may I ask those

interested to state what they charge for (if anything at all):

Forms/letters

No

show/late cancellation

Reminder

e-mail or phone calls for overdue items

RX

refills without a visit

E-mail

communication

Mail

in RX paperwork

Prior

Auth paperwork

Telephone

consults

PS: My bottom line is such this year

that I will need to make a change in order to stay open. Just not sure

what that change will be. A low annual fee is starting to rise to top of

my list of possibilities.

Sorry so long winded.

Ramona

Ramona G. Seidel, MD

www.baycrossingfamilymedicine.com

Your Bridge to Health

269 Peninsula Farm Road

Suite F

Arnold, MD 21012

410 518-9808

From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Zambrano

Sent: Monday, August 30, 2010

10:53 AM

To:

Subject: Re:

Re: Retainer fees and Medicare

Just curious,

What is the monthly payment for services that take first call. I would guess at

least 180 a month. IMO this really feels like we are selling ourselves short

for 24x7 360 coverage the majority which is non-reimbursable.

My two cents.

I think it is very

affordable US

180/year for 24x7 acess!! If I will start to charge will be around US25-30 a

month!

I need to buy a EKG machine ( just opened the clinic!)...which will be your

recommendation?

Thank you!

lia Leite- MD,MPH

Palm Beach

Hello Health

On Sun, Aug 29, 2010 at 11:24 PM, Mones MD

wrote:

,

I charge $120/year " HealthyAccess " NCBF for 24x7 access to me the doc

- frequently providing phone medicine without charge. I'm under selling myself

and have thought about raising the fee to $180? What is your rationale for the

jump to $250-$300?

Stew Mones

Eugene, OR

Re: Re: Retainer fees and Medicare

>

>

>

>

>

> I think it's really all a matter of what point of view you are looking at

it

> from. if you are following the absolute strict line of the the wording in

> the medicare law, I suspect it says everything and anything we do

regarding

> a patient is covered by their office visit charges. However, I choose to

> look at things compared to what is standard of care in my community and

thus

> the services I'm providing is drastically different than most if not all

> other practitioners seeing medicare patients. Thus I consider these

> services to be non-covered since I could not do them and still get the

same

> amount of money from medicare.

>

> I made the change last year from regular practice to IMP with NCBF. I

> simply stated that the services I was providing required the non-covered

> benefits charge. On my website in the philosophy frequently asked

questions

> section there is some wording I have used (www.intmedcc.com). I agree

it's

> a little harsh to develop repoire with patients and then hit them with

" if

> you want to continue with me it's now going to cost you extra, " and I

do

get

> twinges of guilt at times (especially now as I'm about to increase the

fee).

> However, I go back to the fact that I'm providing service that simply they

> wont get at a traditional practice and even at $300 per year it's well

worth

> it in my opinion. They have the option to leave. Finally, I would never

> turn anyone away for a true financial hardship. 2 of my 500 patients

really

> wanted to stay but contacted me and said they really couldnt do the $100

fee

> this year and I was fine with that. I certainly didn't publicize that I

> would do it.

>

> I'll be talking more at IMP Camp about transitioning and the NCBF as will

> others so I'd highly recommend camp if you anyone hasn't already signed

up.

>

> Of note, in Denver,

private insurers are generally 20-40% higher than

> medicare in terms of reimbursement.

>

> On Tue, Aug 24, 2010 at 11:42 AM, Ellen son

>

wrote:

>

>

>

> Pt Centered Med Home, just one example, says that SDA are part of what

> we should be offering to out pts, without a retainer fee. I use a cell

> phone for after hours calls.

> So how do I/you justify charging extra for cell communication? Just

> trying to understand the boundaries of it all. As someone here

> mentioned, some Medicare pts have lots of money,

> I certainly have some who do, and I'm annoyed when they want to discuss

> their abnormal labs over the tel. How would you start charging for

> services to pts you have worked with for a number of years and NOT

> charged them extra for these things?

>

> Ellen

>

>

>

> Gordon wrote:

>>

>> I charge a non-covered benefits fee for everyone including medicare. i

>> would say the medicare patients utilize the non-covered services like

>> email/cell communication, some day access, etc. more than most. i

>> agree with brian that what we offer is worth far more than we charge

>> (currently i'm 100/yr but next year will be 250-300). in my area,

>> there are concierge docs charging 3-5K per year and from what I hear I

>> offer far more than they do - i have waived the fee for those under 25

>> though I just picked that at random. it's only about 5-10 of my 500

>> patients. probably will continue that next year as well but not sure.

>> i know it's a little sketchy charging the extra fee for medicare

>> patients from the legality side of things but this is one area i just

>> choose to play naive. my backup plan was that if medicare came after

>> me, I would start a nation media campaign about how i was being

>> punished for providing excellent care (hopefully that will not be

>> necessary)

>>

>> On Tue, Aug 24, 2010 at 9:36 AM, Pierce

>

>> <bpierce@...

<mailto:bpierce%40midcoastmedicine.com<bpierce%2540midcoastmedicine.com>

>

> <mailto:bpierce@...

<mailto:

bpierce%40midcoastmedicine.com

<bpierce%2540midcoastmedicine.com>>

>>>

>

>> wrote:

>>

>> Most of my wealthier patients are over 65.

>>

>> However, most of the fees I see discussed here are less than the

>> price of the cable TV or cell phone plans that nearly all of my

>> patients seem to find affordable.

>>

>> We need to stop undervaluing ourselves.

>>

>>

>>

>>

>>

>>

>>>

>>> I don't think there is anything wrong about giving people 65 and

>>> over a break. many businesses do...movie theatres, Ross dept

>>> stores, etc

>>>

>>> On Mon, Aug 23, 2010 at 7:53 PM, Ellen son

>

>>> <nellegreen@...

<mailto:nellegreen%40earthlink.net<nellegreen%2540earthlink.net>

>

> <mailto:nellegreen@...

<mailto:nellegreen%40earthlink.net<nellegreen%2540earthlink.net>>

>>

> wrote:

>>>

>>> I wasn't thinking of charging Medicare pts a retainer. I was

>>> wondering

>>> about having Medicare pts in your practice and also having

>>> pts who pay a

>>> retainer fee. Is that reasonable?

>>> Allowable? Medicare pts are on fixed incomes. Some do have

>>> money but

>>> many don't. Medicare does pay for an H & P within the first

>>> 12 mos. You

>>> can also do a PAP and E & M code at the same visit.

>>> As of Jan 2011, all new insurance policies will have to pay for

>>> preventive services--though what those are will probably

>>> differ unless

>>> the govern't creates a definition.

>>>

>>>

>>>

>>> Craig Ross wrote:

>>> >

>>> > Charging Medicare patients a retainer fee has been

>>> challenged in court

>>> > several time and the has retainer fee won every time ... so

>>> far.

>>> > However, it must be for services not covered by Medicare.

Many

>>> > practices charging a high retainer fee (e.g.

" Concierge "

>>> practices)

>>> > are using the fact that Medicare doesn't currently cover

>>> Health

>>> > Maintenance Exams (HMEs) as the main reason for the charge.

>>> For

>>> > example, they say they charge $500 annual retainer fee.

>>> $300 is for

>>> > the annual exam and $200 is for chronic care management,

>>> 24/7 access,

>>> > telephone and email access, etc.

>>> >

>>> > All this will change once HCR mandates Medicare pay for an

>>> annual

>>> > health assessment. Concierge practices will need to find a

>>> different

>>> > break down for their annual fee for non-covered services as

>>> charging

>>> > $300 for an annual exam will no longer be legal.

>>> >

>>> > You can still charge a retainer fee for telephone, 24/7

>>> access to you,

>>> > email etc as long as Medicare doesn't pay for them.

>>> However, you need

>>> > to make sure you have the patient sign the form ahead of

>>> time that

>>> > says that Medicare won't pay for these services.

>>> >

>>> > Craig

>>> >

>>> >

>>> > > > >

>>> > > > > I think changing the language will work.

>>> > > > >

>>> > > > > If you say: " In Medicare we trust,

everyone else pays

>>> cash " and

>>> > " Kids

>>> > > > > get care free " .... it should work fine.

>>> > > > > ie language would be that We dont accept any

>>> insurance other than

>>> > > > > Medicare but we offer our discounted cash

rates to

>>> those who have

>>> > > > > other insurances......

>>> > > > >

>>> > > > > In this wording you are not saying you are

charging

>>> those between

>>> > > > > 26-65 but you are saying that you are giving

discount

>>> to those

>>> > <26 and

>>> > > > > >65. It means the same but technical

language is

>>> different.

>>> > > > >

>>> > > > > ------------------

>>> > > > > When I say " In Medicare we trust,

everyone else pays

>>> cash " , most

>>> > docs

>>> > > > > from most parts of country will laugh but

quite

>>> ironically,

>>> > Medicare

>>> > > > > is the best payer in CA and many parts in east

coast.

>>> > > > >

>>> > > > > Still doctors want to move to CA!

>>> > > > >

>>> > > > > -----------------------

>>> > > > > To avoid getting in trouble with Medicare's

" most

>>> favored "

>>> > clause, I

>>> > > > > would keep per visit charge same for all new

visit

>>> and one same

>>> > charge

>>> > > > > for all f/ups and then give 40-60% discount

for PATOS

>>> ...... so,

>>> > > > > 99201-99205 are all charged $500 and there is

80%

>>> PATOS discount

>>> > > > > ........... 99211-99215 are all $400 and with

80% PATOS

>>> > discount, pt

>>> > > > > pays $80

>>> > > > >

>>> > > > > One key thing in retainer model is to not

allow

>>> unlimited number of

>>> > > > > visits ....... once you cover unlimited number

of

>>> visits, you are

>>> > > > > assuming an unknown risk and it makes you

insurance

>>> and Ins Co

>>> > could

>>> > > > > complaint agaisnt you to the insurance board

etc

>>> .......... it

>>> > will be

>>> > > > > fine if you say that yearly retainer charge

covers

>>> 500 (yes, five

>>> > > > > hundreds) visits a year ...... but there has

to be a

>>> finite number

>>> > > > >

>>> > > > > see doctorsh blog for one such model

>>> > > > >

>>> > > > >

>>> > > >

>>> > >

>>> >

>>> >

>>>

>>>

>>>

>>>

>>> --

>>> M.D.

>

>>> www.elainemd.com

<http://www.elainemd.com>

>

>

>>> Office:

>>> Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've

>>> imagined.

>>> This email transmission may contain protected and privileged,

>>> highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information

>>> (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only

>>> for the use of the individual or entity named above.

>>>

>>>

>>>

>>> If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may

>>> not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute

>>> it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have

>>> received this transmission in error, please notify the sender

>>> immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email

>>> in error.

>>

>>

>>

>

>

>

>

>

--

lia Leite- MD

Palm Beach

Hello Health

Posted

Thanks ,

I really appreciate you sharing the details. My situation is pretty similar to

yours but I am still bringing in about $6000-$8000/month from my hospice

involvment. Without that I would really be scraping by. My practice is small

(150) and often just a morning or afternoon and it makes sense to grow it with

patients who appreciate the service (and are willing to spend more for it.) If

I'm going to raise the fee for 2011 - I will need to announce it soon, so I will

crunch some numbers.

There was a time when primary care were considered essential (remember the

'gatekeepers'), now their is more marginalization( an urgent care has the same

copay as the PCP visit?!!?). I think we have to value our services, charge the

'correct' amount (which is likely more than we charge for access and

availability) and then convince patients why they want " a doctor who knows them

well " rather than provider-du-jour or the urgent care doc.

Certainly no one else in the system seems to recognize or be promoting the

access and availabilty of your one and only doctor who knows you well - it's off

the radar b/c it is thought to not exist anymore. So it's up to us to collect

and share the data - and convince patients who will be convinced, that it is

worth it.

Stew

Re: Re: Retainer fees and Medicare

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > I think it's really all a matter of what point of view you are looking at

> it

> > from. if you are following the absolute strict line of the the wording in

> > the medicare law, I suspect it says everything and anything we do

> regarding

> > a patient is covered by their office visit charges. However, I choose to

> > look at things compared to what is standard of care in my community and

> thus

> > the services I'm providing is drastically different than most if not all

> > other practitioners seeing medicare patients. Thus I consider these

> > services to be non-covered since I could not do them and still get the

> same

> > amount of money from medicare.

> >

> > I made the change last year from regular practice to IMP with NCBF. I

> > simply stated that the services I was providing required the non-covered

> > benefits charge. On my website in the philosophy frequently asked

> questions

> > section there is some wording I have used (www.intmedcc.com). I agree

> it's

> > a little harsh to develop repoire with patients and then hit them with

> " if

> > you want to continue with me it's now going to cost you extra, " and I do

> get

> > twinges of guilt at times (especially now as I'm about to increase the

> fee).

> > However, I go back to the fact that I'm providing service that simply

> they

> > wont get at a traditional practice and even at $300 per year it's well

> worth

> > it in my opinion. They have the option to leave. Finally, I would never

> > turn anyone away for a true financial hardship. 2 of my 500 patients

> really

> > wanted to stay but contacted me and said they really couldnt do the $100

> fee

> > this year and I was fine with that. I certainly didn't publicize that I

> > would do it.

> >

> > I'll be talking more at IMP Camp about transitioning and the NCBF as will

> > others so I'd highly recommend camp if you anyone hasn't already signed

> up.

> >

> > Of note, in Denver, private insurers are generally 20-40% higher than

> > medicare in terms of reimbursement.

> >

> > On Tue, Aug 24, 2010 at 11:42 AM, Ellen son

> > <nellegreen@... <nellegreen%40earthlink.net>> wrote:

> >

> >

> >

> > Pt Centered Med Home, just one example, says that SDA are part of what

> > we should be offering to out pts, without a retainer fee. I use a cell

> > phone for after hours calls.

> > So how do I/you justify charging extra for cell communication? Just

> > trying to understand the boundaries of it all. As someone here

> > mentioned, some Medicare pts have lots of money,

> > I certainly have some who do, and I'm annoyed when they want to discuss

> > their abnormal labs over the tel. How would you start charging for

> > services to pts you have worked with for a number of years and NOT

> > charged them extra for these things?

> >

> > Ellen

> >

> >

> >

> > Gordon wrote:

> >>

> >> I charge a non-covered benefits fee for everyone including medicare. i

> >> would say the medicare patients utilize the non-covered services like

> >> email/cell communication, some day access, etc. more than most. i

> >> agree with brian that what we offer is worth far more than we charge

> >> (currently i'm 100/yr but next year will be 250-300). in my area,

> >> there are concierge docs charging 3-5K per year and from what I hear I

> >> offer far more than they do - i have waived the fee for those under 25

> >> though I just picked that at random. it's only about 5-10 of my 500

> >> patients. probably will continue that next year as well but not sure.

> >> i know it's a little sketchy charging the extra fee for medicare

> >> patients from the legality side of things but this is one area i just

> >> choose to play naive. my backup plan was that if medicare came after

> >> me, I would start a nation media campaign about how i was being

> >> punished for providing excellent care (hopefully that will not be

> >> necessary)

> >>

> >> On Tue, Aug 24, 2010 at 9:36 AM, Pierce

> >

> >> <bpierce@... <bpierce%40midcoastmedicine.com> <mailto:

> bpierce%40midcoastmedicine.com <bpierce%2540midcoastmedicine.com><bpierce%

> 2540midcoastmedicine.com>

>

> >

> > <mailto:bpierce@...

<bpierce%40midcoastmedicine.com><mailto:

> bpierce%40midcoastmedicine.com <bpierce%2540midcoastmedicine.com>>

>

> >>>

> >

> >> wrote:

> >>

> >> Most of my wealthier patients are over 65.

> >>

> >> However, most of the fees I see discussed here are less than the

> >> price of the cable TV or cell phone plans that nearly all of my

> >> patients seem to find affordable.

> >>

> >> We need to stop undervaluing ourselves.

> >>

> >>

> >>

> >>

> >>

> >>

> >>>

> >>> I don't think there is anything wrong about giving people 65 and

> >>> over a break. many businesses do...movie theatres, Ross dept

> >>> stores, etc

> >>>

> >>> On Mon, Aug 23, 2010 at 7:53 PM, Ellen son

> >

> >>> <nellegreen@... <nellegreen%40earthlink.net> <mailto:

> nellegreen%40earthlink.net <nellegreen%2540earthlink.net><nellegreen%

> 2540earthlink.net>

> >

> > <mailto:nellegreen@... <nellegreen%40earthlink.net> <mailto:

> nellegreen%40earthlink.net <nellegreen%2540earthlink.net><nellegreen%

> 2540earthlink.net>>

>

> >>

> > wrote:

> >>>

> >>> I wasn't thinking of charging Medicare pts a retainer. I was

> >>> wondering

> >>> about having Medicare pts in your practice and also having

> >>> pts who pay a

> >>> retainer fee. Is that reasonable?

> >>> Allowable? Medicare pts are on fixed incomes. Some do have

> >>> money but

> >>> many don't. Medicare does pay for an H & P within the first

> >>> 12 mos. You

> >>> can also do a PAP and E & M code at the same visit.

> >>> As of Jan 2011, all new insurance policies will have to pay for

> >>> preventive services--though what those are will probably

> >>> differ unless

> >>> the govern't creates a definition.

> >>>

> >>>

> >>>

> >>> Craig Ross wrote:

> >>> >

> >>> > Charging Medicare patients a retainer fee has been

> >>> challenged in court

> >>> > several time and the has retainer fee won every time ... so

> >>> far.

> >>> > However, it must be for services not covered by Medicare. Many

> >>> > practices charging a high retainer fee (e.g. " Concierge "

> >>> practices)

> >>> > are using the fact that Medicare doesn't currently cover

> >>> Health

> >>> > Maintenance Exams (HMEs) as the main reason for the charge.

> >>> For

> >>> > example, they say they charge $500 annual retainer fee.

> >>> $300 is for

> >>> > the annual exam and $200 is for chronic care management,

> >>> 24/7 access,

> >>> > telephone and email access, etc.

> >>> >

> >>> > All this will change once HCR mandates Medicare pay for an

> >>> annual

> >>> > health assessment. Concierge practices will need to find a

> >>> different

> >>> > break down for their annual fee for non-covered services as

> >>> charging

> >>> > $300 for an annual exam will no longer be legal.

> >>> >

> >>> > You can still charge a retainer fee for telephone, 24/7

> >>> access to you,

> >>> > email etc as long as Medicare doesn't pay for them.

> >>> However, you need

> >>> > to make sure you have the patient sign the form ahead of

> >>> time that

> >>> > says that Medicare won't pay for these services.

> >>> >

> >>> > Craig

> >>> >

> >>> >

> >>> > > > >

> >>> > > > > I think changing the language will work.

> >>> > > > >

> >>> > > > > If you say: " In Medicare we trust, everyone else pays

> >>> cash " and

> >>> > " Kids

> >>> > > > > get care free " .... it should work fine.

> >>> > > > > ie language would be that We dont accept any

> >>> insurance other than

> >>> > > > > Medicare but we offer our discounted cash rates to

> >>> those who have

> >>> > > > > other insurances......

> >>> > > > >

> >>> > > > > In this wording you are not saying you are charging

> >>> those between

> >>> > > > > 26-65 but you are saying that you are giving discount

> >>> to those

> >>> > <26 and

> >>> > > > > >65. It means the same but technical language is

> >>> different.

> >>> > > > >

> >>> > > > > ------------------

> >>> > > > > When I say " In Medicare we trust, everyone else pays

> >>> cash " , most

> >>> > docs

> >>> > > > > from most parts of country will laugh but quite

> >>> ironically,

> >>> > Medicare

> >>> > > > > is the best payer in CA and many parts in east coast.

> >>> > > > >

> >>> > > > > Still doctors want to move to CA!

> >>> > > > >

> >>> > > > > -----------------------

> >>> > > > > To avoid getting in trouble with Medicare's " most

> >>> favored "

> >>> > clause, I

> >>> > > > > would keep per visit charge same for all new visit

> >>> and one same

> >>> > charge

> >>> > > > > for all f/ups and then give 40-60% discount for PATOS

> >>> ...... so,

> >>> > > > > 99201-99205 are all charged $500 and there is 80%

> >>> PATOS discount

> >>> > > > > ........... 99211-99215 are all $400 and with 80% PATOS

> >>> > discount, pt

> >>> > > > > pays $80

> >>> > > > >

> >>> > > > > One key thing in retainer model is to not allow

> >>> unlimited number of

> >>> > > > > visits ....... once you cover unlimited number of

> >>> visits, you are

> >>> > > > > assuming an unknown risk and it makes you insurance

> >>> and Ins Co

> >>> > could

> >>> > > > > complaint agaisnt you to the insurance board etc

> >>> .......... it

> >>> > will be

> >>> > > > > fine if you say that yearly retainer charge covers

> >>> 500 (yes, five

> >>> > > > > hundreds) visits a year ...... but there has to be a

> >>> finite number

> >>> > > > >

> >>> > > > > see doctorsh blog for one such model

> >>> > > > >

> >>> > > > >

> >>> > > >

> >>> > >

> >>> >

> >>> >

> >>>

> >>>

> >>>

> >>>

> >>> --

> >>> M.D.

> >

> >>> www.elainemd.com <http://www.elainemd.com>

> >

> >

> >>> Office:

> >>> Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've

> >>> imagined.

> >>> This email transmission may contain protected and privileged,

> >>> highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information

> >>> (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only

> >>> for the use of the individual or entity named above.

> >>>

> >>>

> >>>

> >>> If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may

> >>> not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute

> >>> it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have

> >>> received this transmission in error, please notify the sender

> >>> immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email

> >>> in error.

> >>

> >>

> >>

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

>

>

>

Posted

Ramona, my very thoughts the last few days... every one of them

Sangeetha Murthy

> I am really looking forward to more discussion on the NCBF idea at IMP camp

> later this month.> > > > I have no such fee, but have begun to feel taken advantage by my patients> who are increasingly demanding and now expect many services for free, simply

> because they are loyal patients! In the last 2 months, I have had numerous> patients balk at the $15.00 forms and letters fee that I have always charged> (even back in my traditional practice before starting IMP).

> > > > Patients have come to expect long e-mail replies, frequent e-mail reminders> on overdue items, 20 minute plus phone discussions, multiple copies of> prescriptions for mail in, prior authorization work, extended appointment

> times, and excellent access as included in the fees they pay at the time of> their visit. ALL of these services are clearly not available at " the other> guys " in town, yet I offer for NO additional fee. The only thing I do

> charge for is the letters/forms fee. I have yet to charge for no shows,> though I reserve the right to do so.> > > > I am starting to feel a bit under-valued. Today, I was thinking that

> perhaps my patients would find charges for some (of the free) services more> palatable than my forms/letters fee.> > > > Along those lines, may I ask those interested to state what they charge for

> (if anything at all):> > * Forms/letters> * No show/late cancellation> * Reminder e-mail or phone calls for overdue items> * RX refills without a visit> * E-mail communication

> * Mail in RX paperwork> * Prior Auth paperwork> * Telephone consults> > > > PS: My bottom line is such this year that I will need to make a change in> order to stay open. Just not sure what that change will be. A low annual

> fee is starting to rise to top of my list of possibilities.> > > Sorry so long winded.> > Ramona> > > > Ramona G. Seidel, MD> > www.baycrossingfamilymedicine.com

> > Your Bridge to Health> > > > 269 Peninsula Farm Road> Suite F> > Arnold, MD 21012> > > > 410 518-9808> > >

> > > _____ > > From: > [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Zambrano

> Sent: Monday, August 30, 2010 10:53 AM> To: > Subject: Re: Re: Retainer fees and Medicare

> > > > > > Just curious,> > What is the monthly payment for services that take first call. I would guess> at least 180 a month. IMO this really feels like we are selling ourselves

> short for 24x7 360 coverage the majority which is non-reimbursable. > My two cents.> > > On Mon, Aug 30, 2010 at 9:31 AM, lia Leite-

> wrote:> > I think it is very affordable US 180/year for 24x7 acess!! If I will start> to charge will be around US25-30 a month!> I need to buy a EKG machine ( just opened the clinic!)...which will be your

> recommendation?> Thank you!> > lia Leite- MD,MPH> Palm Beach Hello Health> > On Sun, Aug 29, 2010 at 11:24 PM, Mones MD

> wrote:> > , > I charge $120/year " HealthyAccess " NCBF for 24x7 access to me the doc -> frequently providing phone medicine without charge. I'm under selling myself> and have thought about raising the fee to $180? What is your rationale for

> the jump to $250-$300?> Stew Mones> Eugene, OR > > Re: Re: Retainer fees and Medicare>>>>

>>>>>>>> I think it's really all a matter of what point of view you are looking at> it>> from. if you are following the absolute strict line of the the wording in

>> the medicare law, I suspect it says everything and anything we do> regarding>> a patient is covered by their office visit charges. However, I choose to>> look at things compared to what is standard of care in my community and

> thus>> the services I'm providing is drastically different than most if not all>> other practitioners seeing medicare patients. Thus I consider these>> services to be non-covered since I could not do them and still get the

> same>> amount of money from medicare.>>>> I made the change last year from regular practice to IMP with NCBF. I>> simply stated that the services I was providing required the non-covered

>> benefits charge. On my website in the philosophy frequently asked> questions>> section there is some wording I have used (www.intmedcc.com). I agree it's

>> a little harsh to develop repoire with patients and then hit them with " if>> you want to continue with me it's now going to cost you extra, " and I do> get>> twinges of guilt at times (especially now as I'm about to increase the

> fee).>> However, I go back to the fact that I'm providing service that simply they>> wont get at a traditional practice and even at $300 per year it's well> worth>> it in my opinion. They have the option to leave. Finally, I would never

>> turn anyone away for a true financial hardship. 2 of my 500 patients> really>> wanted to stay but contacted me and said they really couldnt do the $100> fee>> this year and I was fine with that. I certainly didn't publicize that I

>> would do it.>>>> I'll be talking more at IMP Camp about transitioning and the NCBF as will>> others so I'd highly recommend camp if you anyone hasn't already signed> up.

>>>> Of note, in Denver, private insurers are generally 20-40% higher than>> medicare in terms of reimbursement.>>>> On Tue, Aug 24, 2010 at 11:42 AM, Ellen son>> <nellegreen@... <mailto:nellegreen%40earthlink.net> > wrote:

>>>>>>>> Pt Centered Med Home, just one example, says that SDA are part of what>> we should be offering to out pts, without a retainer fee. I use a cell>> phone for after hours calls.

>> So how do I/you justify charging extra for cell communication? Just>> trying to understand the boundaries of it all. As someone here>> mentioned, some Medicare pts have lots of money,>> I certainly have some who do, and I'm annoyed when they want to discuss

>> their abnormal labs over the tel. How would you start charging for>> services to pts you have worked with for a number of years and NOT>> charged them extra for these things?>>>> Ellen

>>>>>>>> Gordon wrote:>>>>>> I charge a non-covered benefits fee for everyone including medicare. i>>> would say the medicare patients utilize the non-covered services like

>>> email/cell communication, some day access, etc. more than most. i>>> agree with brian that what we offer is worth far more than we charge>>> (currently i'm 100/yr but next year will be 250-300). in my area,

>>> there are concierge docs charging 3-5K per year and from what I hear I>>> offer far more than they do - i have waived the fee for those under 25>>> though I just picked that at random. it's only about 5-10 of my 500

>>> patients. probably will continue that next year as well but not sure.>>> i know it's a little sketchy charging the extra fee for medicare>>> patients from the legality side of things but this is one area i just

>>> choose to play naive. my backup plan was that if medicare came after>>> me, I would start a nation media campaign about how i was being>>> punished for providing excellent care (hopefully that will not be

>>> necessary)>>>>>> On Tue, Aug 24, 2010 at 9:36 AM, Pierce>>>>> <bpierce@... <mailto:bpierce%40midcoastmedicine.com>

> <mailto:bpierce%40midcoastmedicine.com> <mailto:bpierce%2540midcoastmedicine.com> <bpierce%2540midcoastmedicine.com>

>>>> <mailto:bpierce%40midcoastmedicine.com> <mailto:

> bpierce%40midcoastmedicine.com <bpierce%2540midcoastmedicine.com>>>>>>>>>>> wrote:

>>>>>> Most of my wealthier patients are over 65.>>>>>> However, most of the fees I see discussed here are less than the>>> price of the cable TV or cell phone plans that nearly all of my

>>> patients seem to find affordable.>>>>>> We need to stop undervaluing ourselves.>>>>>> >>>>>>>>>>>>

>>>>>>>> I don't think there is anything wrong about giving people 65 and>>>> over a break. many businesses do...movie theatres, Ross dept>>>> stores, etc

>>>>>>>> On Mon, Aug 23, 2010 at 7:53 PM, Ellen son>>>>>> <nellegreen@... <mailto:nellegreen%40earthlink.net>

> <mailto:nellegreen%40earthlink.net <mailto:nellegreen%2540earthlink.net>> <nellegreen%2540earthlink.net>

>>>> <mailto:nellegreen@... <mailto:nellegreen%40earthlink.net>> <mailto:nellegreen%40earthlink.net <mailto:nellegreen%2540earthlink.net>

> <nellegreen%2540earthlink.net>>>>>>> wrote:>>>>>>>> I wasn't thinking of charging Medicare pts a retainer. I was

>>>> wondering>>>> about having Medicare pts in your practice and also having>>>> pts who pay a>>>> retainer fee. Is that reasonable?>>>> Allowable? Medicare pts are on fixed incomes. Some do have

>>>> money but>>>> many don't. Medicare does pay for an H & P within the first>>>> 12 mos. You>>>> can also do a PAP and E & M code at the same visit.

>>>> As of Jan 2011, all new insurance policies will have to pay for>>>> preventive services--though what those are will probably>>>> differ unless>>>> the govern't creates a definition.

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Craig Ross wrote:>>>> >>>>> > Charging Medicare patients a retainer fee has been>>>> challenged in court

>>>> > several time and the has retainer fee won every time ... so>>>> far.>>>> > However, it must be for services not covered by Medicare. Many>>>> > practices charging a high retainer fee (e.g. " Concierge "

>>>> practices)>>>> > are using the fact that Medicare doesn't currently cover>>>> Health>>>> > Maintenance Exams (HMEs) as the main reason for the charge.

>>>> For>>>> > example, they say they charge $500 annual retainer fee.>>>> $300 is for>>>> > the annual exam and $200 is for chronic care management,>>>> 24/7 access,

>>>> > telephone and email access, etc.>>>> >>>>> > All this will change once HCR mandates Medicare pay for an>>>> annual>>>> > health assessment. Concierge practices will need to find a

>>>> different>>>> > break down for their annual fee for non-covered services as>>>> charging>>>> > $300 for an annual exam will no longer be legal.>>>> >

>>>> > You can still charge a retainer fee for telephone, 24/7>>>> access to you,>>>> > email etc as long as Medicare doesn't pay for them.>>>> However, you need

>>>> > to make sure you have the patient sign the form ahead of>>>> time that>>>> > says that Medicare won't pay for these services.>>>> >>>>> > Craig

>>>> >>>>> > >>>> > > > >>>>> > > > > I think changing the language will work.>>>> > > > >>>>> > > > > If you say: " In Medicare we trust, everyone else pays

>>>> cash " and>>>> > " Kids>>>> > > > > get care free " .... it should work fine.>>>> > > > > ie language would be that We dont accept any

>>>> insurance other than>>>> > > > > Medicare but we offer our discounted cash rates to>>>> those who have>>>> > > > > other insurances......

>>>> > > > >>>>> > > > > In this wording you are not saying you are charging>>>> those between>>>> > > > > 26-65 but you are saying that you are giving discount

>>>> to those>>>> > <26 and>>>> > > > > >65. It means the same but technical language is>>>> different.>>>> > > > >

>>>> > > > > ------------------>>>> > > > > When I say " In Medicare we trust, everyone else pays>>>> cash " , most>>>> > docs

>>>> > > > > from most parts of country will laugh but quite>>>> ironically,>>>> > Medicare>>>> > > > > is the best payer in CA and many parts in east coast.

>>>> > > > >>>>> > > > > Still doctors want to move to CA!>>>> > > > >>>>> > > > > ----------------------->>>> > > > > To avoid getting in trouble with Medicare's " most

>>>> favored " >>>> > clause, I>>>> > > > > would keep per visit charge same for all new visit>>>> and one same>>>> > charge

>>>> > > > > for all f/ups and then give 40-60% discount for PATOS>>>> ...... so,>>>> > > > > 99201-99205 are all charged $500 and there is 80%>>>> PATOS discount

>>>> > > > > ........... 99211-99215 are all $400 and with 80% PATOS>>>> > discount, pt>>>> > > > > pays $80>>>> > > > >

>>>> > > > > One key thing in retainer model is to not allow>>>> unlimited number of>>>> > > > > visits ....... once you cover unlimited number of>>>> visits, you are

>>>> > > > > assuming an unknown risk and it makes you insurance>>>> and Ins Co>>>> > could>>>> > > > > complaint agaisnt you to the insurance board etc

>>>> .......... it>>>> > will be>>>> > > > > fine if you say that yearly retainer charge covers>>>> 500 (yes, five>>>> > > > > hundreds) visits a year ...... but there has to be a

>>>> finite number>>>> > > > >>>>> > > > > see doctorsh blog for one such model>>>> > > > >>>>> > > > >

>>>> > > >>>>> > >>>>> >>>>> >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> -->>>> M.D.

>>>>>> www.elainemd.com <http://www.elainemd.com>>>>>>>>> Office:

>>>> Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've>>>> imagined.>>>> This email transmission may contain protected and privileged,>>>> highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information

>>>> (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only>>>> for the use of the individual or entity named above.>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may

>>>> not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute>>>> it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have>>>> received this transmission in error, please notify the sender

>>>> immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email>>>> in error.>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

> > > > > -- > lia Leite- MD> Palm Beach Hello Health> > > > >

Posted

Forms/letters- forms $20 letters/ $25 only if done outside of an office visit. Havent had much push back except for one patient

No show/late cancellation $35- in the last 6 months 2 patients have paid, the rest are playign passive aggressive, saying they mailed it 2 days prior etc etc

Reminder e-mail or phone calls for overdue items NO

RX refills without a visit started $15- everybody opted to WAIT for the visit.

E-mail communication- NONE

Mail in RX paperwork- NONE if during office visit

Prior Auth paperwork- are we allowed to charge for that?

Telephone consults - $35 to $50

 

I am really looking forward to more

discussion on the NCBF idea at IMP camp later this month.

 

I have no such fee, but have begun to feel

taken advantage by my patients who are increasingly demanding and now expect

many services for free, simply because they are loyal patients!  In the

last 2 months, I have had numerous patients balk at the $15.00 forms and

letters fee that I have always charged (even back in my traditional practice

before starting IMP).  

 

Patients have come to expect long e-mail

replies, frequent e-mail reminders on overdue items, 20 minute plus phone

discussions, multiple copies of prescriptions for mail in, prior authorization

work, extended appointment times, and excellent access as included in the fees

they pay at the time of their visit.  ALL of these services are clearly

not available at “the other guys” in town, yet I offer for NO

additional fee.   The only thing I do charge for is the letters/forms

fee.  I have yet to charge for no shows, though I reserve the right to do

so.

 

I am starting to feel a bit

under-valued.  Today, I was thinking that perhaps my patients would find

charges for some (of the free) services more palatable than my forms/letters

fee.

 

Along those lines, may I ask those

interested to state what they charge for (if anything at all):

Forms/letters

No

show/late cancellation

Reminder

e-mail or phone calls for overdue items

RX

refills without a visit

E-mail

communication

Mail

in RX paperwork

Prior

Auth paperwork

Telephone

consults

 

PS:  My bottom line is such this year

that I will need to make a change in order to stay open.  Just not sure

what that change will be.  A low annual fee is starting to rise to top of

my list of possibilities.

Sorry so long winded.

Ramona

 

Ramona G. Seidel, MD

www.baycrossingfamilymedicine.com

Your Bridge to Health

 

269 Peninsula Farm Road

Suite F

Arnold, MD  21012

 

410 518-9808

 

 

From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Zambrano

Sent: Monday, August 30, 2010

10:53 AM

To:

Subject: Re:

Re: Retainer fees and Medicare

 

 

Just curious,

What is the monthly payment for services that take first call. I would guess at

least 180 a month. IMO this really feels like we are selling ourselves short

for 24x7 360 coverage the majority which is non-reimbursable.

My two cents.

I think it is very

affordable US

180/year for 24x7 acess!! If I will start to charge will be around US25-30 a

month!

I need to buy a EKG machine ( just opened the clinic!)...which will be your

recommendation?

Thank you!

lia Leite- MD,MPH

Palm Beach

Hello Health

On Sun, Aug 29, 2010 at 11:24 PM, Mones MD

wrote:

,

I charge $120/year " HealthyAccess " NCBF for 24x7 access to me the doc

- frequently providing phone medicine without charge. I'm under selling myself

and have thought about raising the fee to $180? What is your rationale for the

jump to $250-$300?

Stew Mones

Eugene, OR

Re: Re: Retainer fees and Medicare

>

>

>

>

>

> I think it's really all a matter of what point of view you are looking at

it

> from. if you are following the absolute strict line of the the wording in

> the medicare law, I suspect it says everything and anything we do

regarding

> a patient is covered by their office visit charges. However, I choose to

> look at things compared to what is standard of care in my community and

thus

> the services I'm providing is drastically different than most if not all

> other practitioners seeing medicare patients. Thus I consider these

> services to be non-covered since I could not do them and still get the

same

> amount of money from medicare.

>

> I made the change last year from regular practice to IMP with NCBF. I

> simply stated that the services I was providing required the non-covered

> benefits charge. On my website in the philosophy frequently asked

questions

> section there is some wording I have used (www.intmedcc.com). I agree

it's

> a little harsh to develop repoire with patients and then hit them with

" if

> you want to continue with me it's now going to cost you extra, " and I

do

get

> twinges of guilt at times (especially now as I'm about to increase the

fee).

> However, I go back to the fact that I'm providing service that simply they

> wont get at a traditional practice and even at $300 per year it's well

worth

> it in my opinion. They have the option to leave. Finally, I would never

> turn anyone away for a true financial hardship. 2 of my 500 patients

really

> wanted to stay but contacted me and said they really couldnt do the $100

fee

> this year and I was fine with that. I certainly didn't publicize that I

> would do it.

>

> I'll be talking more at IMP Camp about transitioning and the NCBF as will

> others so I'd highly recommend camp if you anyone hasn't already signed

up.

>

> Of note, in Denver,

private insurers are generally 20-40% higher than

> medicare in terms of reimbursement.

>

> On Tue, Aug 24, 2010 at 11:42 AM, Ellen son

>

wrote:

>

>

>

> Pt Centered Med Home, just one example, says that SDA are part of what

> we should be offering to out pts, without a retainer fee. I use a cell

> phone for after hours calls.

> So how do I/you justify charging extra for cell communication? Just

> trying to understand the boundaries of it all. As someone here

> mentioned, some Medicare pts have lots of money,

> I certainly have some who do, and I'm annoyed when they want to discuss

> their abnormal labs over the tel. How would you start charging for

> services to pts you have worked with for a number of years and NOT

> charged them extra for these things?

>

> Ellen

>

>

>

> Gordon wrote:

>>

>> I charge a non-covered benefits fee for everyone including medicare. i

>> would say the medicare patients utilize the non-covered services like

>> email/cell communication, some day access, etc. more than most. i

>> agree with brian that what we offer is worth far more than we charge

>> (currently i'm 100/yr but next year will be 250-300). in my area,

>> there are concierge docs charging 3-5K per year and from what I hear I

>> offer far more than they do - i have waived the fee for those under 25

>> though I just picked that at random. it's only about 5-10 of my 500

>> patients. probably will continue that next year as well but not sure.

>> i know it's a little sketchy charging the extra fee for medicare

>> patients from the legality side of things but this is one area i just

>> choose to play naive. my backup plan was that if medicare came after

>> me, I would start a nation media campaign about how i was being

>> punished for providing excellent care (hopefully that will not be

>> necessary)

>>

>> On Tue, Aug 24, 2010 at 9:36 AM, Pierce

>

>> <bpierce@...

<mailto:bpierce%40midcoastmedicine.com<bpierce%2540midcoastmedicine.com>

>

> <mailto:bpierce@...

<mailto:

bpierce%40midcoastmedicine.com

<bpierce%2540midcoastmedicine.com>>

>>>

>

>> wrote:

>>

>> Most of my wealthier patients are over 65.

>>

>> However, most of the fees I see discussed here are less than the

>> price of the cable TV or cell phone plans that nearly all of my

>> patients seem to find affordable.

>>

>> We need to stop undervaluing ourselves.

>>

>>

>>

>>

>>

>>

>>>

>>> I don't think there is anything wrong about giving people 65 and

>>> over a break. many businesses do...movie theatres, Ross dept

>>> stores, etc

>>>

>>> On Mon, Aug 23, 2010 at 7:53 PM, Ellen son

>

>>> <nellegreen@...

<mailto:nellegreen%40earthlink.net<nellegreen%2540earthlink.net>

>

> <mailto:nellegreen@...

<mailto:nellegreen%40earthlink.net<nellegreen%2540earthlink.net>>

>>

> wrote:

>>>

>>> I wasn't thinking of charging Medicare pts a retainer. I was

>>> wondering

>>> about having Medicare pts in your practice and also having

>>> pts who pay a

>>> retainer fee. Is that reasonable?

>>> Allowable? Medicare pts are on fixed incomes. Some do have

>>> money but

>>> many don't. Medicare does pay for an H & P within the first

>>> 12 mos. You

>>> can also do a PAP and E & M code at the same visit.

>>> As of Jan 2011, all new insurance policies will have to pay for

>>> preventive services--though what those are will probably

>>> differ unless

>>> the govern't creates a definition.

>>>

>>>

>>>

>>> Craig Ross wrote:

>>> >

>>> > Charging Medicare patients a retainer fee has been

>>> challenged in court

>>> > several time and the has retainer fee won every time ... so

>>> far.

>>> > However, it must be for services not covered by Medicare.

Many

>>> > practices charging a high retainer fee (e.g.

" Concierge "

>>> practices)

>>> > are using the fact that Medicare doesn't currently cover

>>> Health

>>> > Maintenance Exams (HMEs) as the main reason for the charge.

>>> For

>>> > example, they say they charge $500 annual retainer fee.

>>> $300 is for

>>> > the annual exam and $200 is for chronic care management,

>>> 24/7 access,

>>> > telephone and email access, etc.

>>> >

>>> > All this will change once HCR mandates Medicare pay for an

>>> annual

>>> > health assessment. Concierge practices will need to find a

>>> different

>>> > break down for their annual fee for non-covered services as

>>> charging

>>> > $300 for an annual exam will no longer be legal.

>>> >

>>> > You can still charge a retainer fee for telephone, 24/7

>>> access to you,

>>> > email etc as long as Medicare doesn't pay for them.

>>> However, you need

>>> > to make sure you have the patient sign the form ahead of

>>> time that

>>> > says that Medicare won't pay for these services.

>>> >

>>> > Craig

>>> >

>>> >

>>> > > > >

>>> > > > > I think changing the language will work.

>>> > > > >

>>> > > > > If you say: " In Medicare we trust,

everyone else pays

>>> cash " and

>>> > " Kids

>>> > > > > get care free " .... it should work fine.

>>> > > > > ie language would be that We dont accept any

>>> insurance other than

>>> > > > > Medicare but we offer our discounted cash

rates to

>>> those who have

>>> > > > > other insurances......

>>> > > > >

>>> > > > > In this wording you are not saying you are

charging

>>> those between

>>> > > > > 26-65 but you are saying that you are giving

discount

>>> to those

>>> > <26 and

>>> > > > > >65. It means the same but technical

language is

>>> different.

>>> > > > >

>>> > > > > ------------------

>>> > > > > When I say " In Medicare we trust,

everyone else pays

>>> cash " , most

>>> > docs

>>> > > > > from most parts of country will laugh but

quite

>>> ironically,

>>> > Medicare

>>> > > > > is the best payer in CA and many parts in east

coast.

>>> > > > >

>>> > > > > Still doctors want to move to CA!

>>> > > > >

>>> > > > > -----------------------

>>> > > > > To avoid getting in trouble with Medicare's

" most

>>> favored "

>>> > clause, I

>>> > > > > would keep per visit charge same for all new

visit

>>> and one same

>>> > charge

>>> > > > > for all f/ups and then give 40-60% discount

for PATOS

>>> ...... so,

>>> > > > > 99201-99205 are all charged $500 and there is

80%

>>> PATOS discount

>>> > > > > ........... 99211-99215 are all $400 and with

80% PATOS

>>> > discount, pt

>>> > > > > pays $80

>>> > > > >

>>> > > > > One key thing in retainer model is to not

allow

>>> unlimited number of

>>> > > > > visits ....... once you cover unlimited number

of

>>> visits, you are

>>> > > > > assuming an unknown risk and it makes you

insurance

>>> and Ins Co

>>> > could

>>> > > > > complaint agaisnt you to the insurance board

etc

>>> .......... it

>>> > will be

>>> > > > > fine if you say that yearly retainer charge

covers

>>> 500 (yes, five

>>> > > > > hundreds) visits a year ...... but there has

to be a

>>> finite number

>>> > > > >

>>> > > > > see doctorsh blog for one such model

>>> > > > >

>>> > > > >

>>> > > >

>>> > >

>>> >

>>> >

>>>

>>>

>>>

>>>

>>> --

>>> M.D.

>

>>> www.elainemd.com

<http://www.elainemd.com>

>

>

>>> Office:

>>> Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've

>>> imagined.

>>> This email transmission may contain protected and privileged,

>>> highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information

>>> (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only

>>> for the use of the individual or entity named above.

>>>

>>>

>>>

>>> If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may

>>> not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute

>>> it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have

>>> received this transmission in error, please notify the sender

>>> immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email

>>> in error.

>>

>>

>>

>

>

>

>

>

--

lia Leite- MD

Palm Beach

Hello Health

 

-- Sangeetha Murthy M.D

Posted

Ramona,

I’m sorry that your patients are

taking advantage of you. If you explain to them clearly why you must

charge the fee, most are understanding. In our office, we explain that

any forms or letters (such as return to work, disability, etc) that the doctor

can complete at an office visit are no charge. If the patient asks us to

fill out the form without a visit (and Steve doesn’t feel a visit is

warranted), we charge $20 and explain to the patient that it takes us time to

accurately complete the form/write the letter and that this is a service that

is not billable to their insurance company and therefore must be paid by them.

We charge $40 no show fee. Less than

24 hours notice is considered a no show in our office. Obviously, there

are times when we waive this fee. And we always let it go twice.

The third time that they call to cancel with late notice (or no show), they are

charged the fee. We do advise the patient on the 2nd no-show/late

cancellation that in the future if they have to cancel, we will charge them the

$40 fee. If the patient has left a message, we put it in the note that

pops up if the patient were to try to schedule again so that the person taking

the appointment can remind the patient that they have had 2 missed

appointments/late cancellations and if they are not able to keep this

appointment and cancel with less than 24 hours notice, we will charge

them. I have only once had a patient be belligerent about not paying the

fee, and that patient found another physician shortly thereafter.

We do not charge for reminders for overdue

items. Honestly, right now, we are not very good about following up on tracking

things, except with our HMO patients and the HMO sends letters at no charge to

us. Periodically I run reports and have Steve tell us who he needs to

see. But since these patients are coming in for an office visit, we don’t

charge for the reminder email/phone call, as it’s a source of future

revenue.

Patients can email us only through

RelayHealth. This is a little less patient-friendly than simply giving

them an email address. But it also eliminates unnecessary emails from

patients. Steve has a “3 email rule” whereby if the patient

replies more than twice (other thank to say “thanks”), he simply

emails back that it would be best if the patient comes in for a visit, as the

issue is not being adequately resolved via email. RelayHealth also has

the option for WebVisits, which we rarely do (maybe 2 per year), and those are

(I think) $30.

I’m not sure about what you mean by

Mail in RX paperwork. We don’t fill out any mail in RX forms.

If the patients want the forms filled out, the patient fills them out. We

only provide a printed RX, although most of the mail-orders will take a direct

FAX RX from our office if the patient is already established with the mail

order pharmacy. If the patient is not already established, we give them a

paper rx and let them fill out and mail the forms themselves.

Prior auths are charged the same as a

form. This is a little trickier. We do not charge for a PA if Steve

is recommending the specific medication for a chronic condition. But more

than likely, the patient was on that med before they came to see us and refuses

to change to the med in formulary. In that case (and the case of elective

meds, such as Viagra), the patient must pay the form completion fee. We explain

that it is due to the many questions that their pharmacy asks on the PA

form. The patient’s choice is to come in for a visit (and many of

our patients do not want to spend the time or money for that, as $20 is the

same or less than their copay)

Phone consults are billed by time. I

can’t recall our fees, but they are posted in our Financial Policy on our

website: https://prattmd.info/uploads/Financial_and_Office_Policies_03_10.pdf

If you scroll to page 4, you will see all of these fees listed.

There is another office in town that lists

all of their fees (similar to ours), or you can opt to pay an annual fee (can’t

remember what it is right now – something like $75 per person). We

toyed with that idea, but decided it would be too much of a headache to know

who had paid the annual fee and who was paying a la carte.

We also got to the point where we had to

do something to stay afloat, which is when Steve started doing E.H.R. It

has helped tremendously, to the point that if money were the only issue, he

would probably do that full time (and make about 3 times what we made last

year!). But money isn’t the only thing in life, and he really

enjoys seeing patients. So we continue to have him work 20 hours E.H.R.

and 30 hours in the office.

Good luck with whatever you decide to do,

Pratt

Office Manager

Oak Tree Internal Medicine P.C

www.prattmd.info

From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of RGMS

Sent: Monday, August 30, 2010 7:35

PM

To:

Subject: RE:

Re: Retainer fees and Medicare

Along

those lines, may I ask those interested to state what they charge for (if

anything at all):

Forms/letters

No show/late cancellation

Reminder e-mail or phone calls

for overdue items

RX refills without a visit

E-mail communication

Mail in RX paperwork

Prior Auth paperwork

Telephone consults

_,_._,___

Posted

i looked at that option as well and just didnt want the hassle (especially without staff) of charging for every little thing - thus I went with the flat feei think the biggest downside is that is definitely self selects a more needy population and since people are paying for the services, they're more likely to use them (especially email).  however, i still think it's a big plus overall as i know so much more what's happening with my patients and since they are getting answers from me directly, they are less likely to ask the same question more than once i've found

 

Ramona,

I’m sorry that your patients are

taking advantage of you.  If you explain to them clearly why you must

charge the fee, most are understanding.  In our office, we explain that

any forms or letters (such as return to work, disability, etc) that the doctor

can complete at an office visit are no charge.  If the patient asks us to

fill out the form without a visit (and Steve doesn’t feel a visit is

warranted), we charge $20 and explain to the patient that it takes us time to

accurately complete the form/write the letter and that this is a service that

is not billable to their insurance company and therefore must be paid by them.

 

We charge $40 no show fee.  Less than

24 hours notice is considered a no show in our office.  Obviously, there

are times when we waive this fee.  And we always let it go twice. 

The third time that they call to cancel with late notice (or no show), they are

charged the fee.  We do advise the patient on the 2nd no-show/late

cancellation that in the future if they have to cancel, we will charge them the

$40 fee.  If the patient has left a message, we put it in the note that

pops up if the patient were to try to schedule again so that the person taking

the appointment can remind the patient that they have had 2 missed

appointments/late cancellations and if they are not able to keep this

appointment and cancel with less than 24 hours notice, we will charge

them.  I have only once had a patient be belligerent about not paying the

fee, and that patient found another physician shortly thereafter.

 

We do not charge for reminders for overdue

items. Honestly, right now, we are not very good about following up on tracking

things, except with our HMO patients and the HMO sends letters at no charge to

us.  Periodically I run reports and have Steve tell us who he needs to

see.  But since these patients are coming in for an office visit, we don’t

charge for the reminder email/phone call, as it’s a source of future

revenue.

 

Patients can email us only through

RelayHealth.  This is a little less patient-friendly than simply giving

them an email address.  But it also eliminates unnecessary emails from

patients.  Steve has a “3 email rule” whereby if the patient

replies more than twice (other thank to say “thanks”), he simply

emails back that it would be best if the patient comes in for a visit, as the

issue is not being adequately resolved via email.  RelayHealth also has

the option for WebVisits, which we rarely do (maybe 2 per year), and those are

(I think) $30.

 

I’m not sure about what you mean by

Mail in RX paperwork.  We don’t fill out any mail in RX forms. 

If the patients want the forms filled out, the patient fills them out.  We

only provide a printed RX, although most of the mail-orders will take a direct

FAX RX from our office if the patient is already established with the mail

order pharmacy.  If the patient is not already established, we give them a

paper rx and let them fill out and mail the forms themselves.

 

Prior auths are charged the same as a

form.  This is a little trickier.  We do not charge for a PA if Steve

is recommending the specific medication for a chronic condition.  But more

than likely, the patient was on that med before they came to see us and refuses

to change to the med in formulary.  In that case (and the case of elective

meds, such as Viagra), the patient must pay the form completion fee.  We explain

that it is due to the many questions that their pharmacy asks on the PA

form.  The patient’s choice is to come in for a visit (and many of

our patients do not want to spend the time or money for that, as $20 is the

same or less than their copay)

 

Phone consults are billed by time.  I

can’t recall our fees, but they are posted in our Financial Policy on our

website: https://prattmd.info/uploads/Financial_and_Office_Policies_03_10.pdf

 If you scroll to page 4, you will see all of these fees listed.

 

There is another office in town that lists

all of their fees (similar to ours), or you can opt to pay an annual fee (can’t

remember what it is right now – something like $75 per person).  We

toyed with that idea, but decided it would be too much of a headache to know

who had paid the annual fee and who was paying a la carte.

 

We also got to the point where we had to

do something to stay afloat, which is when Steve started doing E.H.R.  It

has helped tremendously, to the point that if money were the only issue, he

would probably do that full time (and make about 3 times what we made last

year!).  But money isn’t the only thing in life, and he really

enjoys seeing patients.  So we continue to have him work 20 hours E.H.R.

and 30 hours in the office.

 

Good luck with whatever you decide to do,

Pratt

Office Manager

Oak Tree Internal Medicine P.C

www.prattmd.info

From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of RGMS

Sent: Monday, August 30, 2010 7:35

PM

To:

Subject: RE:

Re: Retainer fees and Medicare

 

  Along

those lines, may I ask those interested to state what they charge for (if

anything at all):

Forms/letters

No show/late cancellation

Reminder e-mail or phone calls

for overdue items

RX refills without a visit

E-mail communication

Mail in RX paperwork

Prior Auth paperwork

Telephone consults

_,_._,___

Posted

Thanks ,

I really appreciate you sharing the details. My situation is pretty similar to

yours but I am still bringing in about $6000-$8000/month from my hospice

involvment. Without that I would really be scraping by. My practice is small

(150) and often just a morning or afternoon and it makes sense to grow it with

patients who appreciate the service (and are willing to spend more for it.) If

I'm going to raise the fee for 2011 - I will need to announce it soon, so I will

crunch some numbers.

There was a time when primary care were considered essential (remember the

'gatekeepers'), now their is more marginalization( an urgent care has the same

copay as the PCP visit?!!?). I think we have to value our services, charge the

'correct' amount (which is likely more than we charge for access and

availability) and then convince patients why they want " a doctor who knows them

well " rather than provider-du-jour or the urgent care doc.

Certainly no one else in the system seems to recognize or be promoting the

access and availabilty of your one and only doctor who knows you well - it's off

the radar b/c it is thought to not exist anymore. So it's up to us to collect

and share the data - and convince patients who will be convinced, that it is

worth it.

Stew

Re: Re: Retainer fees and Medicare

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > I think it's really all a matter of what point of view you are looking at

> it

> > from. if you are following the absolute strict line of the the wording in

> > the medicare law, I suspect it says everything and anything we do

> regarding

> > a patient is covered by their office visit charges. However, I choose to

> > look at things compared to what is standard of care in my community and

> thus

> > the services I'm providing is drastically different than most if not all

> > other practitioners seeing medicare patients. Thus I consider these

> > services to be non-covered since I could not do them and still get the

> same

> > amount of money from medicare.

> >

> > I made the change last year from regular practice to IMP with NCBF. I

> > simply stated that the services I was providing required the non-covered

> > benefits charge. On my website in the philosophy frequently asked

> questions

> > section there is some wording I have used (www.intmedcc.com). I agree

> it's

> > a little harsh to develop repoire with patients and then hit them with

> " if

> > you want to continue with me it's now going to cost you extra, " and I do

> get

> > twinges of guilt at times (especially now as I'm about to increase the

> fee).

> > However, I go back to the fact that I'm providing service that simply

> they

> > wont get at a traditional practice and even at $300 per year it's well

> worth

> > it in my opinion. They have the option to leave. Finally, I would never

> > turn anyone away for a true financial hardship. 2 of my 500 patients

> really

> > wanted to stay but contacted me and said they really couldnt do the $100

> fee

> > this year and I was fine with that. I certainly didn't publicize that I

> > would do it.

> >

> > I'll be talking more at IMP Camp about transitioning and the NCBF as will

> > others so I'd highly recommend camp if you anyone hasn't already signed

> up.

> >

> > Of note, in Denver, private insurers are generally 20-40% higher than

> > medicare in terms of reimbursement.

> >

> > On Tue, Aug 24, 2010 at 11:42 AM, Ellen son

> > <nellegreen@... <nellegreen%40earthlink.net>> wrote:

> >

> >

> >

> > Pt Centered Med Home, just one example, says that SDA are part of what

> > we should be offering to out pts, without a retainer fee. I use a cell

> > phone for after hours calls.

> > So how do I/you justify charging extra for cell communication? Just

> > trying to understand the boundaries of it all. As someone here

> > mentioned, some Medicare pts have lots of money,

> > I certainly have some who do, and I'm annoyed when they want to discuss

> > their abnormal labs over the tel. How would you start charging for

> > services to pts you have worked with for a number of years and NOT

> > charged them extra for these things?

> >

> > Ellen

> >

> >

> >

> > Gordon wrote:

> >>

> >> I charge a non-covered benefits fee for everyone including medicare. i

> >> would say the medicare patients utilize the non-covered services like

> >> email/cell communication, some day access, etc. more than most. i

> >> agree with brian that what we offer is worth far more than we charge

> >> (currently i'm 100/yr but next year will be 250-300). in my area,

> >> there are concierge docs charging 3-5K per year and from what I hear I

> >> offer far more than they do - i have waived the fee for those under 25

> >> though I just picked that at random. it's only about 5-10 of my 500

> >> patients. probably will continue that next year as well but not sure.

> >> i know it's a little sketchy charging the extra fee for medicare

> >> patients from the legality side of things but this is one area i just

> >> choose to play naive. my backup plan was that if medicare came after

> >> me, I would start a nation media campaign about how i was being

> >> punished for providing excellent care (hopefully that will not be

> >> necessary)

> >>

> >> On Tue, Aug 24, 2010 at 9:36 AM, Pierce

> >

> >> <bpierce@... <bpierce%40midcoastmedicine.com> <mailto:

> bpierce%40midcoastmedicine.com <bpierce%2540midcoastmedicine.com><bpierce%

> 2540midcoastmedicine.com>

>

> >

> > <mailto:bpierce@...

<bpierce%40midcoastmedicine.com><mailto:

> bpierce%40midcoastmedicine.com <bpierce%2540midcoastmedicine.com>>

>

> >>>

> >

> >> wrote:

> >>

> >> Most of my wealthier patients are over 65.

> >>

> >> However, most of the fees I see discussed here are less than the

> >> price of the cable TV or cell phone plans that nearly all of my

> >> patients seem to find affordable.

> >>

> >> We need to stop undervaluing ourselves.

> >>

> >>

> >>

> >>

> >>

> >>

> >>>

> >>> I don't think there is anything wrong about giving people 65 and

> >>> over a break. many businesses do...movie theatres, Ross dept

> >>> stores, etc

> >>>

> >>> On Mon, Aug 23, 2010 at 7:53 PM, Ellen son

> >

> >>> <nellegreen@... <nellegreen%40earthlink.net> <mailto:

> nellegreen%40earthlink.net <nellegreen%2540earthlink.net><nellegreen%

> 2540earthlink.net>

> >

> > <mailto:nellegreen@... <nellegreen%40earthlink.net> <mailto:

> nellegreen%40earthlink.net <nellegreen%2540earthlink.net><nellegreen%

> 2540earthlink.net>>

>

> >>

> > wrote:

> >>>

> >>> I wasn't thinking of charging Medicare pts a retainer. I was

> >>> wondering

> >>> about having Medicare pts in your practice and also having

> >>> pts who pay a

> >>> retainer fee. Is that reasonable?

> >>> Allowable? Medicare pts are on fixed incomes. Some do have

> >>> money but

> >>> many don't. Medicare does pay for an H & P within the first

> >>> 12 mos. You

> >>> can also do a PAP and E & M code at the same visit.

> >>> As of Jan 2011, all new insurance policies will have to pay for

> >>> preventive services--though what those are will probably

> >>> differ unless

> >>> the govern't creates a definition.

> >>>

> >>>

> >>>

> >>> Craig Ross wrote:

> >>> >

> >>> > Charging Medicare patients a retainer fee has been

> >>> challenged in court

> >>> > several time and the has retainer fee won every time ... so

> >>> far.

> >>> > However, it must be for services not covered by Medicare. Many

> >>> > practices charging a high retainer fee (e.g. " Concierge "

> >>> practices)

> >>> > are using the fact that Medicare doesn't currently cover

> >>> Health

> >>> > Maintenance Exams (HMEs) as the main reason for the charge.

> >>> For

> >>> > example, they say they charge $500 annual retainer fee.

> >>> $300 is for

> >>> > the annual exam and $200 is for chronic care management,

> >>> 24/7 access,

> >>> > telephone and email access, etc.

> >>> >

> >>> > All this will change once HCR mandates Medicare pay for an

> >>> annual

> >>> > health assessment. Concierge practices will need to find a

> >>> different

> >>> > break down for their annual fee for non-covered services as

> >>> charging

> >>> > $300 for an annual exam will no longer be legal.

> >>> >

> >>> > You can still charge a retainer fee for telephone, 24/7

> >>> access to you,

> >>> > email etc as long as Medicare doesn't pay for them.

> >>> However, you need

> >>> > to make sure you have the patient sign the form ahead of

> >>> time that

> >>> > says that Medicare won't pay for these services.

> >>> >

> >>> > Craig

> >>> >

> >>> >

> >>> > > > >

> >>> > > > > I think changing the language will work.

> >>> > > > >

> >>> > > > > If you say: " In Medicare we trust, everyone else pays

> >>> cash " and

> >>> > " Kids

> >>> > > > > get care free " .... it should work fine.

> >>> > > > > ie language would be that We dont accept any

> >>> insurance other than

> >>> > > > > Medicare but we offer our discounted cash rates to

> >>> those who have

> >>> > > > > other insurances......

> >>> > > > >

> >>> > > > > In this wording you are not saying you are charging

> >>> those between

> >>> > > > > 26-65 but you are saying that you are giving discount

> >>> to those

> >>> > <26 and

> >>> > > > > >65. It means the same but technical language is

> >>> different.

> >>> > > > >

> >>> > > > > ------------------

> >>> > > > > When I say " In Medicare we trust, everyone else pays

> >>> cash " , most

> >>> > docs

> >>> > > > > from most parts of country will laugh but quite

> >>> ironically,

> >>> > Medicare

> >>> > > > > is the best payer in CA and many parts in east coast.

> >>> > > > >

> >>> > > > > Still doctors want to move to CA!

> >>> > > > >

> >>> > > > > -----------------------

> >>> > > > > To avoid getting in trouble with Medicare's " most

> >>> favored "

> >>> > clause, I

> >>> > > > > would keep per visit charge same for all new visit

> >>> and one same

> >>> > charge

> >>> > > > > for all f/ups and then give 40-60% discount for PATOS

> >>> ...... so,

> >>> > > > > 99201-99205 are all charged $500 and there is 80%

> >>> PATOS discount

> >>> > > > > ........... 99211-99215 are all $400 and with 80% PATOS

> >>> > discount, pt

> >>> > > > > pays $80

> >>> > > > >

> >>> > > > > One key thing in retainer model is to not allow

> >>> unlimited number of

> >>> > > > > visits ....... once you cover unlimited number of

> >>> visits, you are

> >>> > > > > assuming an unknown risk and it makes you insurance

> >>> and Ins Co

> >>> > could

> >>> > > > > complaint agaisnt you to the insurance board etc

> >>> .......... it

> >>> > will be

> >>> > > > > fine if you say that yearly retainer charge covers

> >>> 500 (yes, five

> >>> > > > > hundreds) visits a year ...... but there has to be a

> >>> finite number

> >>> > > > >

> >>> > > > > see doctorsh blog for one such model

> >>> > > > >

> >>> > > > >

> >>> > > >

> >>> > >

> >>> >

> >>> >

> >>>

> >>>

> >>>

> >>>

> >>> --

> >>> M.D.

> >

> >>> www.elainemd.com <http://www.elainemd.com>

> >

> >

> >>> Office:

> >>> Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've

> >>> imagined.

> >>> This email transmission may contain protected and privileged,

> >>> highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information

> >>> (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only

> >>> for the use of the individual or entity named above.

> >>>

> >>>

> >>>

> >>> If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may

> >>> not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute

> >>> it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have

> >>> received this transmission in error, please notify the sender

> >>> immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email

> >>> in error.

> >>

> >>

> >>

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

>

>

>

Posted

Hi Ramona,

Sorry to hear

your patients are taking advantage of you. Sounds like it might be time

to retrain them ;)

I used to have

separate fees for all of these (except PARs, except once when I had to go

through an hour of jumping through all of the hoops and finally talk with the

medical director – I charged that long time pt $20 and she left my

practice), but it was too time consuming and annoying to me (and my patients I

suspect) to have to create all those charges. So I changed to a flat ‘Annual

Access Fee’ of $360 that covers all of this, except the telephone visits and

gets them discounted appointment charges. Those are 15 minutes,

pre-scheduled appointments that I charge $85 for. I do have a ‘no-show’

fee and letters I send out, but it’s been years since that has happened.

Happy to

discuss this with others at Camp.

Eads, MD

Pinnacle Family Medicine

www.PinnacleFamilyMedicine.com

From:

[mailto: ] On Behalf Of RGMS

Sent: Monday, August 30, 2010 8:35 PM

To:

Subject: RE: Re: Retainer fees and Medicare

I am

really looking forward to more discussion on the NCBF idea at IMP camp later

this month.

I have no

such fee, but have begun to feel taken advantage by my patients who are

increasingly demanding and now expect many services for free, simply because

they are loyal patients! In the last 2 months, I have had numerous

patients balk at the $15.00 forms and letters fee that I have always charged

(even back in my traditional practice before starting IMP).

Patients

have come to expect long e-mail replies, frequent e-mail reminders on overdue

items, 20 minute plus phone discussions, multiple copies of prescriptions for

mail in, prior authorization work, extended appointment times, and excellent

access as included in the fees they pay at the time of their visit. ALL

of these services are clearly not available at “the other guys” in

town, yet I offer for NO additional fee. The only thing I do charge

for is the letters/forms fee. I have yet to charge for no shows, though I

reserve the right to do so.

I am

starting to feel a bit under-valued. Today, I was thinking that perhaps

my patients would find charges for some (of the free) services more palatable

than my forms/letters fee.

Along

those lines, may I ask those interested to state what they charge for (if

anything at all):

Forms/letters

No show/late cancellation

Reminder e-mail or phone calls for overdue items

RX refills without a visit

E-mail communication

Mail in RX paperwork

Prior Auth paperwork

Telephone consults

PS:

My bottom line is such this year that I will need to make a change in order to

stay open. Just not sure what that change will be. A low annual fee

is starting to rise to top of my list of possibilities.

Sorry so long winded.

Ramona

Ramona G.

Seidel, MD

www.baycrossingfamilymedicine.com

Posted

Feeling 'taken advantage of' is due to our knowledge that the work we do for patients goes well beyond the office visit. We know that patients need communication on issues large and small that do not require a face-to-face meeting, but payment policy fails to value that work. From the patient perspective the communication attempts are logical and appropriate. They ask questions via any portal because that's how people communicate in the modern world. We are punished for communicated in the modern world because we're held to fee for office visit payment and monstrous unfunded work dealing with insurance company administrative trivia.If the insurance industry would recognize the full scope of effective primary care and make it possible for me to communicate with my patients via all modern portals I would not feel abused. If we could shed the immense burden and costs of dealing with arcane insurance industry policies we could get off the hamster wheel and focus more on meeting the needs of our patients.We need to shift the payment paradigm to support the full scope of our work. With some minor exceptions the insurance industry pays only lip service to this shift and we're left asking the public to pick up the tab in a country where we're already spending more than twice per person for health care than every other developed country in the world. People are not thrilled at having to fork over more $$, but at this point I don't see any other move that gets us to a place where we can even approximate the level of care our patients deserve.I understand the patient's attempts to work around broken policies. I understand their reluctance to put even more money into a system that sucks in such a huge percent of our GDP. Effective primary care is the foundation of high performing health systems and the value of our work is immense. It is going to take time and effort getting people to understand.Help people understand that your time is your 'product.' We didn't make this stupid system and we should not continue to support the policies that hurt us and our patients.Gordon

Hi Ramona, Sorry to hear

your patients are taking advantage of you. Sounds like it might be time

to retrain them ;) I used to have

separate fees for all of these (except PARs, except once when I had to go

through an hour of jumping through all of the hoops and finally talk with the

medical director – I charged that long time pt $20 and she left my

practice), but it was too time consuming and annoying to me (and my patients I

suspect) to have to create all those charges. So I changed to a flat ‘Annual

Access Fee’ of $360 that covers all of this, except the telephone visits and

gets them discounted appointment charges. Those are 15 minutes,

pre-scheduled appointments that I charge $85 for. I do have a ‘no-show’

fee and letters I send out, but it’s been years since that has happened. Happy to

discuss this with others at Camp. Eads, MDPinnacle Family Medicinewww.PinnacleFamilyMedicine.com

From:

[mailto: ] On Behalf Of RGMS

Sent: Monday, August 30, 2010 8:35 PM

To:

Subject: RE: Re: Retainer fees and Medicare

I am

really looking forward to more discussion on the NCBF idea at IMP camp later

this month. I have no

such fee, but have begun to feel taken advantage by my patients who are

increasingly demanding and now expect many services for free, simply because

they are loyal patients! In the last 2 months, I have had numerous

patients balk at the $15.00 forms and letters fee that I have always charged

(even back in my traditional practice before starting IMP). Patients

have come to expect long e-mail replies, frequent e-mail reminders on overdue

items, 20 minute plus phone discussions, multiple copies of prescriptions for

mail in, prior authorization work, extended appointment times, and excellent

access as included in the fees they pay at the time of their visit. ALL

of these services are clearly not available at “the other guys” in

town, yet I offer for NO additional fee. The only thing I do charge

for is the letters/forms fee. I have yet to charge for no shows, though I

reserve the right to do so. I am

starting to feel a bit under-valued. Today, I was thinking that perhaps

my patients would find charges for some (of the free) services more palatable

than my forms/letters fee. Along

those lines, may I ask those interested to state what they charge for (if

anything at all):

Forms/letters

No show/late cancellation

Reminder e-mail or phone calls for overdue items

RX refills without a visit

E-mail communication

Mail in RX paperwork

Prior Auth paperwork

Telephone consults

PS:

My bottom line is such this year that I will need to make a change in order to

stay open. Just not sure what that change will be. A low annual fee

is starting to rise to top of my list of possibilities.

Sorry so long winded.Ramona

Ramona G.

Seidel, MDwww.baycrossingfamilymedicine.com

Posted

But when they( my particular pool of patients) balk at paying noshow fees, form fees etc I doubt a reasonable chunk of them would stay if I instituted  a  ncbf/access fee.The fees are  really more to dissuade people from expecting you to be their mother ( my kids don't expect me to be their mother!!!- NOT that kind of mother anyways)

I am still very interested in  Freemium Model - in other words- insurance patients  and the other would be the insurance plus fee patients  where I can deliver care without regard to insurance mandated inefficiencies. 

 All episodes of contact ( sounds awful-  doesn'tit?- but its our time  and we have to get it paid for) with the premium set would have to be distinctly and  automatically identifiable as premium events and reflexively without much thought/ tearing hair( now is this patient plus or no, let me look it up yadda yadda)  slotted into the premium responses. Its when we have to make the decision with every call- now that becomes distressing

Now how do we design a process that works like that?

 

i looked at that option as well and just didnt want the hassle (especially without staff) of charging for every little thing - thus I went with the flat feei think the biggest downside is that is definitely self selects a more needy population and since people are paying for the services, they're more likely to use them (especially email).  however, i still think it's a big plus overall as i know so much more what's happening with my patients and since they are getting answers from me directly, they are less likely to ask the same question more than once i've found

 

Ramona,

I’m sorry that your patients are

taking advantage of you.  If you explain to them clearly why you must

charge the fee, most are understanding.  In our office, we explain that

any forms or letters (such as return to work, disability, etc) that the doctor

can complete at an office visit are no charge.  If the patient asks us to

fill out the form without a visit (and Steve doesn’t feel a visit is

warranted), we charge $20 and explain to the patient that it takes us time to

accurately complete the form/write the letter and that this is a service that

is not billable to their insurance company and therefore must be paid by them.

 

We charge $40 no show fee.  Less than

24 hours notice is considered a no show in our office.  Obviously, there

are times when we waive this fee.  And we always let it go twice. 

The third time that they call to cancel with late notice (or no show), they are

charged the fee.  We do advise the patient on the 2nd no-show/late

cancellation that in the future if they have to cancel, we will charge them the

$40 fee.  If the patient has left a message, we put it in the note that

pops up if the patient were to try to schedule again so that the person taking

the appointment can remind the patient that they have had 2 missed

appointments/late cancellations and if they are not able to keep this

appointment and cancel with less than 24 hours notice, we will charge

them.  I have only once had a patient be belligerent about not paying the

fee, and that patient found another physician shortly thereafter.

 

We do not charge for reminders for overdue

items. Honestly, right now, we are not very good about following up on tracking

things, except with our HMO patients and the HMO sends letters at no charge to

us.  Periodically I run reports and have Steve tell us who he needs to

see.  But since these patients are coming in for an office visit, we don’t

charge for the reminder email/phone call, as it’s a source of future

revenue.

 

Patients can email us only through

RelayHealth.  This is a little less patient-friendly than simply giving

them an email address.  But it also eliminates unnecessary emails from

patients.  Steve has a “3 email rule” whereby if the patient

replies more than twice (other thank to say “thanks”), he simply

emails back that it would be best if the patient comes in for a visit, as the

issue is not being adequately resolved via email.  RelayHealth also has

the option for WebVisits, which we rarely do (maybe 2 per year), and those are

(I think) $30.

 

I’m not sure about what you mean by

Mail in RX paperwork.  We don’t fill out any mail in RX forms. 

If the patients want the forms filled out, the patient fills them out.  We

only provide a printed RX, although most of the mail-orders will take a direct

FAX RX from our office if the patient is already established with the mail

order pharmacy.  If the patient is not already established, we give them a

paper rx and let them fill out and mail the forms themselves.

 

Prior auths are charged the same as a

form.  This is a little trickier.  We do not charge for a PA if Steve

is recommending the specific medication for a chronic condition.  But more

than likely, the patient was on that med before they came to see us and refuses

to change to the med in formulary.  In that case (and the case of elective

meds, such as Viagra), the patient must pay the form completion fee.  We explain

that it is due to the many questions that their pharmacy asks on the PA

form.  The patient’s choice is to come in for a visit (and many of

our patients do not want to spend the time or money for that, as $20 is the

same or less than their copay)

 

Phone consults are billed by time.  I

can’t recall our fees, but they are posted in our Financial Policy on our

website: https://prattmd.info/uploads/Financial_and_Office_Policies_03_10.pdf

 If you scroll to page 4, you will see all of these fees listed.

 

There is another office in town that lists

all of their fees (similar to ours), or you can opt to pay an annual fee (can’t

remember what it is right now – something like $75 per person).  We

toyed with that idea, but decided it would be too much of a headache to know

who had paid the annual fee and who was paying a la carte.

 

We also got to the point where we had to

do something to stay afloat, which is when Steve started doing E.H.R.  It

has helped tremendously, to the point that if money were the only issue, he

would probably do that full time (and make about 3 times what we made last

year!).  But money isn’t the only thing in life, and he really

enjoys seeing patients.  So we continue to have him work 20 hours E.H.R.

and 30 hours in the office.

 

Good luck with whatever you decide to do,

Pratt

Office Manager

Oak Tree Internal Medicine P.C

www.prattmd.info

From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of RGMS

Sent: Monday, August 30, 2010 7:35

PM

To:

Subject: RE:

Re: Retainer fees and Medicare

 

  Along

those lines, may I ask those interested to state what they charge for (if

anything at all):

Forms/letters

No show/late cancellation

Reminder e-mail or phone calls

for overdue items

RX refills without a visit

E-mail communication

Mail in RX paperwork

Prior Auth paperwork

Telephone consults

_,_._,___

-- Sangeetha Murthy M.D

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...