Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Re: Re: Retainer fees and Medicare

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted

Elaine,

Are you doing a retainer fee that includes visits or are you charging separately for visits?Sharon

Posted

I have a small " non covered service " retainer fee. Visits and co pays are still billed to their insurance as before retainer fee. Set up like Seto's. So I can't say I give a discount to <26, >65 because they will not be charged a retainer

 

Elaine,

Are you doing a retainer fee that includes visits or are you charging separately for visits?Sharon

-- M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.

This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above.

 If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error.

Posted

Has anyone commented on taking Medicare but also taking retainer(and

what does it cover?) for others? I do take cash discounts for people

without insurance and/or with a high deductible.

There are some who I know can and would pay a retainer for the

opportunity to do more tel chats. A few have suggested I charge them but

I haven't as yet decided if I want to do this,

or how to do it. I have also been charging people who have lost their

insurance and job $50 for f/u's so they don't fall thru the cracks and

get lost. People have really appreciated it and a few now

have insurance again.

pk_endo wrote:

>

> I think changing the language will work.

>

> If you say: " In Medicare we trust, everyone else pays cash " and " Kids

> get care free " .... it should work fine.

> ie language would be that We dont accept any insurance other than

> Medicare but we offer our discounted cash rates to those who have

> other insurances......

>

> In this wording you are not saying you are charging those between

> 26-65 but you are saying that you are giving discount to those <26 and

> >65. It means the same but technical language is different.

>

> ------------------

> When I say " In Medicare we trust, everyone else pays cash " , most docs

> from most parts of country will laugh but quite ironically, Medicare

> is the best payer in CA and many parts in east coast.

>

> Still doctors want to move to CA!

>

> -----------------------

> To avoid getting in trouble with Medicare's " most favored " clause, I

> would keep per visit charge same for all new visit and one same charge

> for all f/ups and then give 40-60% discount for PATOS ...... so,

> 99201-99205 are all charged $500 and there is 80% PATOS discount

> ........... 99211-99215 are all $400 and with 80% PATOS discount, pt

> pays $80

>

> One key thing in retainer model is to not allow unlimited number of

> visits ....... once you cover unlimited number of visits, you are

> assuming an unknown risk and it makes you insurance and Ins Co could

> complaint agaisnt you to the insurance board etc .......... it will be

> fine if you say that yearly retainer charge covers 500 (yes, five

> hundreds) visits a year ...... but there has to be a finite number

>

> see doctorsh blog for one such model

>

>

Attachment: vcard [not shown]

Posted

I don't have that many medicare pts. don't want to Govt hassels and as Joanne from the Drain said, they are on fixed income and deserve a break. Also medicare is our highest payer in CA. This small retainer fee would make private payers on par w medicare

 

If it is small, why not charge everyone? For medicare, you could add a fine print " .. except where expressely prohibited by federal laws ... "

-- M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.

This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above.

 If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error.

Posted

I presume you get paid the same rate for Medicare in Cal as anywhere in

the US since it's a federal program. So that must mean your insurance

carriers are not paying you very well at all.

Medicare payments in Oregon are ~40% of charges while private insurers

pay 70-80% of charges. Many MDs are limiting or not taking new Medicare

pts because payments are comparatively so low.

wrote:

>

> I don't have that many medicare pts. don't want to Govt hassels and as

> Joanne from the Drain said, they are on fixed income and deserve a

> break. Also medicare is our highest payer in CA. This small retainer

> fee would make private payers on par w medicare

>

> On Sun, Aug 22, 2010 at 8:21 AM, pk_endo <drpawankumar@...

> > wrote:

>

> If it is small, why not charge everyone? For medicare, you could

> add a fine print " .. except where expressely prohibited by federal

> laws ... "

>

>

>

>

> --

> M.D.

> www.elainemd.com <http://www.elainemd.com>

> Office:

> Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.

> This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly

> confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or

> legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the

> individual or entity named above.

>

>

>

> If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not

> use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you

> are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this

> transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and

> confidentially destroy the information that email in error.

>

Attachment: vcard [not shown]

Posted

Elaine,

You should re-negotiate some of those

contracts. We’re getting more than Medicare from most (granted, not much more,

but every % helps!). I think we only have 2 right now that are less than MDC.

I’ll let you guess which two J

Pratt

Office Manager

Oak Tree Internal Medicine P.C

www.prattmd.info

From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of

Sent: Sunday, August 22, 2010 7:00

PM

To:

Subject: Re:

Re: Retainer fees and Medicare

I don't have that many medicare pts. don't want to

Govt hassels and as Joanne from the Drain said, they are on fixed income and

deserve a break. Also medicare is our highest payer in CA. This small retainer

fee would make private payers on par w medicare

If it is small, why not

charge everyone? For medicare, you could add a fine print " .. except where

expressely prohibited by federal laws ... "

--

M.D.

www.elainemd.com

Office:

Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.

This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly

confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal

information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or

entity named above.

If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use,

publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the

intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please

notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that

email in error.

Posted

I think medicare in CA is still less than the rest of the country

 

I presume you get paid the same rate for Medicare in Cal as anywhere in the US since it's a federal program. So that must mean your insurance carriers are not paying you very well at all.Medicare payments in Oregon are ~40% of charges while private insurers

pay 70-80% of charges. Many MDs are limiting or not taking new Medicare pts because payments are comparatively so low. wrote:>> I don't have that many medicare pts. don't want to Govt hassels and as > Joanne from the Drain said, they are on fixed income and deserve a > break. Also medicare is our highest payer in CA. This small retainer

> fee would make private payers on par w medicare>> On Sun, Aug 22, 2010 at 8:21 AM, pk_endo <drpawankumar@...

> > wrote:>> If it is small, why not charge everyone? For medicare, you could> add a fine print " .. except where expressely prohibited by federal

> laws ... " >>>>> -- > M.D.> www.elainemd.com <http://www.elainemd.com> > Office: > Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.> This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly > confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or

> legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the > individual or entity named above.>>>> If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not

> use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you > are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this > transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and

> confidentially destroy the information that email in error.>

-- M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.

This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above.

 If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error.

Posted

I would love to do that. Did you call or write a letter? If letter, can you email me a copy? Yes anything helps

 

Elaine,

You should re-negotiate some of those contracts.  We’re getting more than Medicare from most (granted, not much more, but every % helps!).  I think we only have 2 right now that are less than MDC.  I’ll let you guess which two J

 

Pratt

Office Manager

Oak Tree Internal Medicine P.C

www.prattmd.info

From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of

Sent: Sunday, August 22, 2010 7:00 PMTo:

Subject: Re: Re: Retainer fees and Medicare

 

 

I don't have that many medicare pts. don't want to Govt hassels and as Joanne from the Drain said, they are on fixed income and deserve a break. Also medicare is our highest payer in CA. This small retainer fee would make private payers on par w medicare

 

If it is small, why not charge everyone? For medicare, you could add a fine print " .. except where expressely prohibited by federal laws ... "

-- M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.

This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above.

 If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error.

-- M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.

This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above.

 If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error.

Posted

Actually, Medicare in parts of CA is

higher than other parts of the country. Medicare pays a fee schedule

based on locality, which is based on cost of living for an area. So, for

example, San Francisco is paid higher than Fresno. If you go

to the Medicare fee schedule look-up tool, you can see how much Medicare is

paying you as opposed to someone working in another part of the country: http://www.cms.gov/apps/ama/license.asp?file=/pfslookup/02_PFSsearch.asp

Click “Accept” at the bottom

of the license agreement, use Calendar Year 210B, and then you can look up a

single HCPC (CPT) code, a range, or multiples; on the next page, click the

button next to “specific locality”. For example, a 99213 in Oakland (my locality) is $75.91 (non-facility price); in

LA it is $74.40; in the first “Rest of CA” it is $67.85; in “Rest

of Maine” it is $64.26; in Kansas,

it’s $64.20…….etc, etc.

Pratt

Office Manager

Oak Tree Internal Medicine P.C

www.prattmd.info

From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of

Sent: Monday, August 23, 2010 6:03

AM

To:

Subject: Re:

Re: Retainer fees and Medicare

I think medicare in CA is still less than the rest of

the country

I presume you get paid the same rate for Medicare in Cal as anywhere in

the US

since it's a federal program. So that must mean your insurance

carriers are not paying you very well at all.

Medicare payments in Oregon

are ~40% of charges while private insurers

pay 70-80% of charges. Many MDs are limiting or not taking new Medicare

pts because payments are comparatively so low.

wrote:

>

> I don't have that many medicare pts. don't want to Govt hassels and as

> Joanne from the Drain said, they are on fixed income and deserve a

> break. Also medicare is our highest payer in CA. This small retainer

> fee would make private payers on par w medicare

>

> On Sun, Aug 22, 2010 at 8:21 AM, pk_endo <drpawankumar@...

> >

wrote:

>

> If it is small, why not charge everyone? For medicare, you could

> add a fine print " .. except where expressely prohibited by federal

> laws ... "

>

>

>

>

> --

> M.D.

> www.elainemd.com

<http://www.elainemd.com>

> Office:

> Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.

> This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly

> confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or

> legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the

> individual or entity named above.

>

>

>

> If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not

> use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you

> are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this

> transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and

> confidentially destroy the information that email in error.

>

--

M.D.

www.elainemd.com

Office:

Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.

This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly

confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal

information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or

entity named above.

If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use,

publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the

intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please

notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that

email in error.

Posted

You have to be willing to give up that

contract if you really want to effect change. The CMA has a “toolkit”

available that walks you through evaluating your contracts, looking for clauses

that are not physician-friendly, and has sample letters. Not sure if it is

available to non-members or not. Mine is at the office and I’m not going in

for a few days because of the start of school in 30 minutes ;-)

Pratt

Office Manager

Oak Tree Internal Medicine P.C

www.prattmd.info

From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of

Sent: Monday, August 23, 2010 6:05

AM

To:

Subject: Re:

Re: Retainer fees and Medicare

I would love to do that. Did you call or write a

letter? If letter, can you email me a copy? Yes anything helps

On Mon, Aug 23, 2010 at 12:01 AM, Pratt

wrote:

Elaine,

You should re-negotiate some of those

contracts. We’re getting more than Medicare from most (granted, not much

more, but every % helps!). I think we only have 2 right now that are less

than MDC. I’ll let you guess which two J

Pratt

Office Manager

Oak Tree Internal Medicine P.C

www.prattmd.info

From:

[mailto: ]

On Behalf Of

Sent: Sunday, August 22, 2010 7:00

PM

To:

Subject: Re:

Re: Retainer fees and Medicare

I don't have that many medicare pts. don't want to

Govt hassels and as Joanne from the Drain said, they are on fixed income and

deserve a break. Also medicare is our highest payer in CA. This small retainer

fee would make private payers on par w medicare

On Sun, Aug 22, 2010 at 8:21 AM, pk_endo

wrote:

If it is small, why not charge everyone? For medicare,

you could add a fine print " .. except where expressely prohibited by

federal laws ... "

--

M.D.

www.elainemd.com

Office:

Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.

This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly

confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal

information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or

entity named above.

If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use,

publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the

intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please

notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that

email in error.

--

M.D.

www.elainemd.com

Office:

Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.

This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly

confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal

information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or

entity named above.

If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use,

publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the

intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please

notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that

email in error.

Posted

Medicare does not pay the same across the country. That is the reason for the GPSI codes. They " take into consideration, " the cost of living, and other regional differences. Being bureaucrats, they

have more power if they can " give something " to someone at their behest.

From: [ ] On Behalf Of Ellen son [nellegreen@...]

Sent: Sunday, August 22, 2010 9:13 PM

To:

Subject: Re: Re: Retainer fees and Medicare

I presume you get paid the same rate for Medicare in Cal as anywhere in

the US since it's a federal program. So that must mean your insurance

carriers are not paying you very well at all.

Medicare payments in Oregon are ~40% of charges while private insurers

pay 70-80% of charges. Many MDs are limiting or not taking new Medicare

pts because payments are comparatively so low.

wrote:

>

> I don't have that many medicare pts. don't want to Govt hassels and as

> Joanne from the Drain said, they are on fixed income and deserve a

> break. Also medicare is our highest payer in CA. This small retainer

> fee would make private payers on par w medicare

>

> On Sun, Aug 22, 2010 at 8:21 AM, pk_endo <drpawankumar@...

> > wrote:

>

> If it is small, why not charge everyone? For medicare, you could

> add a fine print " .. except where expressely prohibited by federal

> laws ... "

>

>

>

>

> --

> M.D.

> www.elainemd.com <http://www.elainemd.com>

> Office:

> Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.

> This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly

> confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or

> legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the

> individual or entity named above.

>

>

>

> If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not

> use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you

> are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this

> transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and

> confidentially destroy the information that email in error.

>

Posted

I charge a non-covered benefits fee for everyone including medicare.  i would say the medicare patients utilize the non-covered services like email/cell communication, some day access, etc. more than most.  i agree with brian that what we offer is worth far more than we charge (currently i'm 100/yr but next year will be 250-300).  in my area, there are concierge docs charging 3-5K per year and from what I hear I offer far more than they do - i have waived the fee for those under 25 though I just picked that at random.  it's only about 5-10 of my 500 patients.  probably will continue that next year as well but not sure.  i know it's a little sketchy charging the extra fee for medicare patients from the legality side of things but this is one area i just choose to play naive.  my backup plan was that if medicare came after me, I would start a nation media campaign about how i was being punished for providing excellent care (hopefully that will not be necessary)

 

Most of my wealthier patients are over 65. 

However, most of the fees I see discussed here are less than the

price of the cable TV or cell phone plans that nearly all of my

patients seem to find affordable.  

We need to stop undervaluing ourselves.

 

I don't think there is anything wrong about giving people

65 and over a break. many businesses do...movie theatres,

Ross dept stores, etc

On Mon, Aug 23, 2010 at 7:53 PM,

Ellen son

wrote:

 

I wasn't thinking of charging Medicare pts a

retainer. I was wondering

about having Medicare pts in your practice and

also having pts who pay a

retainer fee. Is that reasonable?

Allowable? Medicare pts are on fixed incomes.

Some do have money but

many don't. Medicare does pay for an H & P

within the first 12 mos. You

can also do a PAP and E & M code at the

same visit.

As of Jan 2011, all new insurance policies

will have to pay for

preventive services--though what those are

will probably differ unless

the govern't creates a definition.

Craig Ross wrote:

>

> Charging Medicare patients a retainer fee

has been challenged in court

> several time and the has retainer fee won

every time ... so far.

> However, it must be for services not

covered by Medicare. Many

> practices charging a high retainer fee

(e.g. " Concierge " practices)

> are using the fact that Medicare doesn't

currently cover Health

> Maintenance Exams (HMEs) as the main

reason for the charge. For

> example, they say they charge $500 annual

retainer fee. $300 is for

> the annual exam and $200 is for chronic

care management, 24/7 access,

> telephone and email access, etc.

>

> All this will change once HCR mandates

Medicare pay for an annual

> health assessment. Concierge practices

will need to find a different

> break down for their annual fee for

non-covered services as charging

> $300 for an annual exam will no longer be

legal.

>

> You can still charge a retainer fee for

telephone, 24/7 access to you,

> email etc as long as Medicare doesn't pay

for them. However, you need

> to make sure you have the patient sign

the form ahead of time that

> says that Medicare won't pay for these

services.

>

> Craig

>

>

> > > >

> > > > I think changing the

language will work.

> > > >

> > > > If you say: " In Medicare

we trust, everyone else pays cash " and

> " Kids

> > > > get care free " .... it

should work fine.

> > > > ie language would be

that We dont accept any insurance other than

> > > > Medicare but we offer

our discounted cash rates to those who have

> > > > other insurances......

> > > >

> > > > In this wording you are

not saying you are charging those between

> > > > 26-65 but you are saying

that you are giving discount to those

> <26 and

> > > > >65. It means the

same but technical language is different.

> > > >

> > > > ------------------

> > > > When I say " In Medicare

we trust, everyone else pays cash " , most

> docs

> > > > from most parts of

country will laugh but quite ironically,

> Medicare

> > > > is the best payer in CA

and many parts in east coast.

> > > >

> > > > Still doctors want to

move to CA!

> > > >

> > > > -----------------------

> > > > To avoid getting in

trouble with Medicare's " most favored "

> clause, I

> > > > would keep per visit

charge same for all new visit and one same

> charge

> > > > for all f/ups and then

give 40-60% discount for PATOS ...... so,

> > > > 99201-99205 are all

charged $500 and there is 80% PATOS discount

> > > > ........... 99211-99215

are all $400 and with 80% PATOS

> discount, pt

> > > > pays $80

> > > >

> > > > One key thing in

retainer model is to not allow unlimited

number of

> > > > visits ....... once you

cover unlimited number of visits, you are

> > > > assuming an unknown risk

and it makes you insurance and Ins Co

> could

> > > > complaint agaisnt you to

the insurance board etc .......... it

> will be

> > > > fine if you say that

yearly retainer charge covers 500 (yes, five

> > > > hundreds) visits a year

....... but there has to be a finite number

> > > >

> > > > see doctorsh blog for

one such model

> > > >

> > > >

> > >

> >

>

>

--

M.D.

www.elainemd.com

Office:

Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've

imagined.

This email transmission may contain protected and

privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health

Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information

is intended only for the use of the individual or entity

named above.

 

If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you

may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise

distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if

you have received this transmission in error, please notify

the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the

information that email in error.

Posted

Pt Centered Med Home, just one example, says that SDA are part of what

we should be offering to out pts, without a retainer fee. I use a cell

phone for after hours calls.

So how do I/you justify charging extra for cell communication? Just

trying to understand the boundaries of it all. As someone here

mentioned, some Medicare pts have lots of money,

I certainly have some who do, and I'm annoyed when they want to discuss

their abnormal labs over the tel. How would you start charging for

services to pts you have worked with for a number of years and NOT

charged them extra for these things?

Ellen

Gordon wrote:

>

> I charge a non-covered benefits fee for everyone including medicare. i

> would say the medicare patients utilize the non-covered services like

> email/cell communication, some day access, etc. more than most. i

> agree with brian that what we offer is worth far more than we charge

> (currently i'm 100/yr but next year will be 250-300). in my area,

> there are concierge docs charging 3-5K per year and from what I hear I

> offer far more than they do - i have waived the fee for those under 25

> though I just picked that at random. it's only about 5-10 of my 500

> patients. probably will continue that next year as well but not sure.

> i know it's a little sketchy charging the extra fee for medicare

> patients from the legality side of things but this is one area i just

> choose to play naive. my backup plan was that if medicare came after

> me, I would start a nation media campaign about how i was being

> punished for providing excellent care (hopefully that will not be

> necessary)

>

> On Tue, Aug 24, 2010 at 9:36 AM, Pierce

> >

> wrote:

>

> Most of my wealthier patients are over 65.

>

> However, most of the fees I see discussed here are less than the

> price of the cable TV or cell phone plans that nearly all of my

> patients seem to find affordable.

>

> We need to stop undervaluing ourselves.

>

>

>

>

>

>

>>

>> I don't think there is anything wrong about giving people 65 and

>> over a break. many businesses do...movie theatres, Ross dept

>> stores, etc

>>

>> On Mon, Aug 23, 2010 at 7:53 PM, Ellen son

>> > wrote:

>>

>> I wasn't thinking of charging Medicare pts a retainer. I was

>> wondering

>> about having Medicare pts in your practice and also having

>> pts who pay a

>> retainer fee. Is that reasonable?

>> Allowable? Medicare pts are on fixed incomes. Some do have

>> money but

>> many don't. Medicare does pay for an H & P within the first

>> 12 mos. You

>> can also do a PAP and E & M code at the same visit.

>> As of Jan 2011, all new insurance policies will have to pay for

>> preventive services--though what those are will probably

>> differ unless

>> the govern't creates a definition.

>>

>>

>>

>> Craig Ross wrote:

>> >

>> > Charging Medicare patients a retainer fee has been

>> challenged in court

>> > several time and the has retainer fee won every time ... so

>> far.

>> > However, it must be for services not covered by Medicare. Many

>> > practices charging a high retainer fee (e.g. " Concierge "

>> practices)

>> > are using the fact that Medicare doesn't currently cover

>> Health

>> > Maintenance Exams (HMEs) as the main reason for the charge.

>> For

>> > example, they say they charge $500 annual retainer fee.

>> $300 is for

>> > the annual exam and $200 is for chronic care management,

>> 24/7 access,

>> > telephone and email access, etc.

>> >

>> > All this will change once HCR mandates Medicare pay for an

>> annual

>> > health assessment. Concierge practices will need to find a

>> different

>> > break down for their annual fee for non-covered services as

>> charging

>> > $300 for an annual exam will no longer be legal.

>> >

>> > You can still charge a retainer fee for telephone, 24/7

>> access to you,

>> > email etc as long as Medicare doesn't pay for them.

>> However, you need

>> > to make sure you have the patient sign the form ahead of

>> time that

>> > says that Medicare won't pay for these services.

>> >

>> > Craig

>> >

>> >

>> > > > >

>> > > > > I think changing the language will work.

>> > > > >

>> > > > > If you say: " In Medicare we trust, everyone else pays

>> cash " and

>> > " Kids

>> > > > > get care free " .... it should work fine.

>> > > > > ie language would be that We dont accept any

>> insurance other than

>> > > > > Medicare but we offer our discounted cash rates to

>> those who have

>> > > > > other insurances......

>> > > > >

>> > > > > In this wording you are not saying you are charging

>> those between

>> > > > > 26-65 but you are saying that you are giving discount

>> to those

>> > <26 and

>> > > > > >65. It means the same but technical language is

>> different.

>> > > > >

>> > > > > ------------------

>> > > > > When I say " In Medicare we trust, everyone else pays

>> cash " , most

>> > docs

>> > > > > from most parts of country will laugh but quite

>> ironically,

>> > Medicare

>> > > > > is the best payer in CA and many parts in east coast.

>> > > > >

>> > > > > Still doctors want to move to CA!

>> > > > >

>> > > > > -----------------------

>> > > > > To avoid getting in trouble with Medicare's " most

>> favored "

>> > clause, I

>> > > > > would keep per visit charge same for all new visit

>> and one same

>> > charge

>> > > > > for all f/ups and then give 40-60% discount for PATOS

>> ...... so,

>> > > > > 99201-99205 are all charged $500 and there is 80%

>> PATOS discount

>> > > > > ........... 99211-99215 are all $400 and with 80% PATOS

>> > discount, pt

>> > > > > pays $80

>> > > > >

>> > > > > One key thing in retainer model is to not allow

>> unlimited number of

>> > > > > visits ....... once you cover unlimited number of

>> visits, you are

>> > > > > assuming an unknown risk and it makes you insurance

>> and Ins Co

>> > could

>> > > > > complaint agaisnt you to the insurance board etc

>> .......... it

>> > will be

>> > > > > fine if you say that yearly retainer charge covers

>> 500 (yes, five

>> > > > > hundreds) visits a year ...... but there has to be a

>> finite number

>> > > > >

>> > > > > see doctorsh blog for one such model

>> > > > >

>> > > > >

>> > > >

>> > >

>> >

>> >

>>

>>

>>

>>

>> --

>> M.D.

>> www.elainemd.com <http://www.elainemd.com>

>> Office:

>> Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've

>> imagined.

>> This email transmission may contain protected and privileged,

>> highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information

>> (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only

>> for the use of the individual or entity named above.

>>

>>

>>

>> If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may

>> not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute

>> it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have

>> received this transmission in error, please notify the sender

>> immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email

>> in error.

>

>

>

Attachment: vcard [not shown]

Posted

NOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!

Medicare is DIFFERENT depending on where you live.

Also, in many states OTHER THAN Calif, NJ, NY, Medicare is WORST payor (privates pay 110% of Medicare).

Also, remember that charges mean NOTHING -- if I set my charges high enough, NOONE would pay more than say 40% of my "regular" rates.

Medicare does set a base, but some private insurers, I don't know how, get away with paying only a % OF Medicare.........

Sorry, guess this time I'm happy to live in Pa

Matt in Western PA

Re: Re: Retainer fees and Medicare

I presume you get paid the same rate for Medicare in Cal as anywhere in the US since it's a federal program. So that must mean your insurance carriers are not paying you very well at all.Medicare payments in Oregon are ~40% of charges while private insurers pay 70-80% of charges. Many MDs are limiting or not taking new Medicare pts because payments are comparatively so low. wrote:>> I don't have that many medicare pts. don't want to Govt hassels and as > Joanne from the Drain said, they are on fixed income and deserve a > break. Also medicare is our highest payer in CA. This small retainer > fee would make private payers on par w medicare>> On Sun, Aug 22, 2010 at 8:21 AM, pk_endo > wrote:>> If it is small, why not charge everyone? For medicare, you could> add a fine print ".. except where expressely prohibited by federal> laws ...">>>>> -- > M.D.> www.elainemd.com <http://www.elainemd.com>> Office: > Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.> This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly > confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or > legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the > individual or entity named above.>>>> If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not > use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you > are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this > transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and > confidentially destroy the information that email in error.>

Posted

, what state do you live in?

Matt in Western PA (where the privates DO pay over Medicare rates).........

RE: Re: Retainer fees and Medicare

Elaine,

You should re-negotiate some of those contracts. We’re getting more than Medicare from most (granted, not much more, but every % helps!). I think we only have 2 right now that are less than MDC. I’ll let you guess which two J

Pratt

Office Manager

Oak Tree Internal Medicine P.C

www.prattmd.info

From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Sent: Sunday, August 22, 2010 7:00 PMTo: Subject: Re: Re: Retainer fees and Medicare

I don't have that many medicare pts. don't want to Govt hassels and as Joanne from the Drain said, they are on fixed income and deserve a break. Also medicare is our highest payer in CA. This small retainer fee would make private payers on par w medicare

If it is small, why not charge everyone? For medicare, you could add a fine print ".. except where expressely prohibited by federal laws ..."

-- M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error.

Posted

-- what state are you in?

Matt in Western PA

Helps me to decide on when/if annual fee will come out in Western PA

Re: Re: Retainer fees and Medicare

I charge a non-covered benefits fee for everyone including medicare. i would say the medicare patients utilize the non-covered services like email/cell communication, some day access, etc. more than most. i agree with brian that what we offer is worth far more than we charge (currently i'm 100/yr but next year will be 250-300). in my area, there are concierge docs charging 3-5K per year and from what I hear I offer far more than they do - i have waived the fee for those under 25 though I just picked that at random. it's only about 5-10 of my 500 patients. probably will continue that next year as well but not sure. i know it's a little sketchy charging the extra fee for medicare patients from the legality side of things but this is one area i just choose to play naive. my backup plan was that if medicare came after me, I would start a nation media campaign about how i was being punished for providing excellent care (hopefully that will not be necessary)

Most of my wealthier patients are over 65. However, most of the fees I see discussed here are less than the price of the cable TV or cell phone plans that nearly all of my patients seem to find affordable. We need to stop undervaluing ourselves.

I don't think there is anything wrong about giving people 65 and over a break. many businesses do...movie theatres, Ross dept stores, etc

I wasn't thinking of charging Medicare pts a retainer. I was wondering about having Medicare pts in your practice and also having pts who pay a retainer fee. Is that reasonable?Allowable? Medicare pts are on fixed incomes. Some do have money but many don't. Medicare does pay for an H & P within the first 12 mos. You can also do a PAP and E & M code at the same visit.As of Jan 2011, all new insurance policies will have to pay for preventive services--though what those are will probably differ unless the govern't creates a definition.

Craig Ross wrote:>> Charging Medicare patients a retainer fee has been challenged in court > several time and the has retainer fee won every time ... so far. > However, it must be for services not covered by Medicare. Many > practices charging a high retainer fee (e.g. "Concierge" practices) > are using the fact that Medicare doesn't currently cover Health > Maintenance Exams (HMEs) as the main reason for the charge. For > example, they say they charge $500 annual retainer fee. $300 is for > the annual exam and $200 is for chronic care management, 24/7 access, > telephone and email access, etc.>> All this will change once HCR mandates Medicare pay for an annual > health assessment. Concierge practices will need to find a different > break down for their annual fee for non-covered services as charging > $300 for an annual exam will no longer be legal.>> You can still charge a retainer fee for telephone, 24/7 access to you, > email etc as long as Medicare doesn't pay for them. However, you need > to make sure you have the patient sign the form ahead of time that > says that Medicare won't pay for these services.>> Craig>> > > > >> > > > I think changing the language will work.> > > >> > > > If you say: "In Medicare we trust, everyone else pays cash" and > "Kids> > > > get care free" .... it should work fine.> > > > ie language would be that We dont accept any insurance other than> > > > Medicare but we offer our discounted cash rates to those who have> > > > other insurances......> > > >> > > > In this wording you are not saying you are charging those between> > > > 26-65 but you are saying that you are giving discount to those > <26 and> > > > >65. It means the same but technical language is different.> > > >> > > > ------------------> > > > When I say "In Medicare we trust, everyone else pays cash", most > docs> > > > from most parts of country will laugh but quite ironically, > Medicare> > > > is the best payer in CA and many parts in east coast.> > > >> > > > Still doctors want to move to CA!> > > >> > > > -----------------------> > > > To avoid getting in trouble with Medicare's "most favored" > clause, I> > > > would keep per visit charge same for all new visit and one same > charge> > > > for all f/ups and then give 40-60% discount for PATOS ...... so,> > > > 99201-99205 are all charged $500 and there is 80% PATOS discount> > > > ........... 99211-99215 are all $400 and with 80% PATOS > discount, pt> > > > pays $80> > > >> > > > One key thing in retainer model is to not allow unlimited number of> > > > visits ....... once you cover unlimited number of visits, you are> > > > assuming an unknown risk and it makes you insurance and Ins Co > could> > > > complaint agaisnt you to the insurance board etc .......... it > will be> > > > fine if you say that yearly retainer charge covers 500 (yes, five> > > > hundreds) visits a year ...... but there has to be a finite number> > > >> > > > see doctorsh blog for one such model> > > >> > > >> > >> >>> -- M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error.

Posted

Be consistent with all........do you bring EVERY pt back to discuss abnormal labs????

Re: Re: Retainer fees and Medicare

Pt Centered Med Home, just one example, says that SDA are part of what we should be offering to out pts, without a retainer fee. I use a cell phone for after hours calls.So how do I/you justify charging extra for cell communication? Just trying to understand the boundaries of it all. As someone here mentioned, some Medicare pts have lots of money,I certainly have some who do, and I'm annoyed when they want to discuss their abnormal labs over the tel. How would you start charging for services to pts you have worked with for a number of years and NOT charged them extra for these things?Ellen Gordon wrote:>> I charge a non-covered benefits fee for everyone including medicare. i > would say the medicare patients utilize the non-covered services like > email/cell communication, some day access, etc. more than most. i > agree with brian that what we offer is worth far more than we charge > (currently i'm 100/yr but next year will be 250-300). in my area, > there are concierge docs charging 3-5K per year and from what I hear I > offer far more than they do - i have waived the fee for those under 25 > though I just picked that at random. it's only about 5-10 of my 500 > patients. probably will continue that next year as well but not sure. > i know it's a little sketchy charging the extra fee for medicare > patients from the legality side of things but this is one area i just > choose to play naive. my backup plan was that if medicare came after > me, I would start a nation media campaign about how i was being > punished for providing excellent care (hopefully that will not be > necessary)>> On Tue, Aug 24, 2010 at 9:36 AM, Pierce > > > wrote:>> Most of my wealthier patients are over 65.>> However, most of the fees I see discussed here are less than the> price of the cable TV or cell phone plans that nearly all of my> patients seem to find affordable.>> We need to stop undervaluing ourselves.>> >>>> >>>> I don't think there is anything wrong about giving people 65 and>> over a break. many businesses do...movie theatres, Ross dept>> stores, etc>>>> On Mon, Aug 23, 2010 at 7:53 PM, Ellen son>> > wrote:>>>> I wasn't thinking of charging Medicare pts a retainer. I was>> wondering>> about having Medicare pts in your practice and also having>> pts who pay a>> retainer fee. Is that reasonable?>> Allowable? Medicare pts are on fixed incomes. Some do have>> money but>> many don't. Medicare does pay for an H & P within the first>> 12 mos. You>> can also do a PAP and E & M code at the same visit.>> As of Jan 2011, all new insurance policies will have to pay for>> preventive services--though what those are will probably>> differ unless>> the govern't creates a definition.>>>>>>>> Craig Ross wrote:>> >>> > Charging Medicare patients a retainer fee has been>> challenged in court>> > several time and the has retainer fee won every time ... so>> far.>> > However, it must be for services not covered by Medicare. Many>> > practices charging a high retainer fee (e.g. "Concierge">> practices)>> > are using the fact that Medicare doesn't currently cover>> Health>> > Maintenance Exams (HMEs) as the main reason for the charge.>> For>> > example, they say they charge $500 annual retainer fee.>> $300 is for>> > the annual exam and $200 is for chronic care management,>> 24/7 access,>> > telephone and email access, etc.>> >>> > All this will change once HCR mandates Medicare pay for an>> annual>> > health assessment. Concierge practices will need to find a>> different>> > break down for their annual fee for non-covered services as>> charging>> > $300 for an annual exam will no longer be legal.>> >>> > You can still charge a retainer fee for telephone, 24/7>> access to you,>> > email etc as long as Medicare doesn't pay for them.>> However, you need>> > to make sure you have the patient sign the form ahead of>> time that>> > says that Medicare won't pay for these services.>> >>> > Craig>> >>> > >> > > > >>> > > > > I think changing the language will work.>> > > > >>> > > > > If you say: "In Medicare we trust, everyone else pays>> cash" and>> > "Kids>> > > > > get care free" .... it should work fine.>> > > > > ie language would be that We dont accept any>> insurance other than>> > > > > Medicare but we offer our discounted cash rates to>> those who have>> > > > > other insurances......>> > > > >>> > > > > In this wording you are not saying you are charging>> those between>> > > > > 26-65 but you are saying that you are giving discount>> to those>> > <26 and>> > > > > >65. It means the same but technical language is>> different.>> > > > >>> > > > > ------------------>> > > > > When I say "In Medicare we trust, everyone else pays>> cash", most>> > docs>> > > > > from most parts of country will laugh but quite>> ironically,>> > Medicare>> > > > > is the best payer in CA and many parts in east coast.>> > > > >>> > > > > Still doctors want to move to CA!>> > > > >>> > > > > ----------------------->> > > > > To avoid getting in trouble with Medicare's "most>> favored">> > clause, I>> > > > > would keep per visit charge same for all new visit>> and one same>> > charge>> > > > > for all f/ups and then give 40-60% discount for PATOS>> ...... so,>> > > > > 99201-99205 are all charged $500 and there is 80%>> PATOS discount>> > > > > ........... 99211-99215 are all $400 and with 80% PATOS>> > discount, pt>> > > > > pays $80>> > > > >>> > > > > One key thing in retainer model is to not allow>> unlimited number of>> > > > > visits ....... once you cover unlimited number of>> visits, you are>> > > > > assuming an unknown risk and it makes you insurance>> and Ins Co>> > could>> > > > > complaint agaisnt you to the insurance board etc>> .......... it>> > will be>> > > > > fine if you say that yearly retainer charge covers>> 500 (yes, five>> > > > > hundreds) visits a year ...... but there has to be a>> finite number>> > > > >>> > > > > see doctorsh blog for one such model>> > > > >>> > > > >>> > > >>> > >>> >>> >>>>>>>>>>> -- >> M.D.>> www.elainemd.com <http://www.elainemd.com>>> Office: >> Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've>> imagined.>> This email transmission may contain protected and privileged,>> highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information>> (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only>> for the use of the individual or entity named above.>>>>>>>> If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may>> not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute>> it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have>> received this transmission in error, please notify the sender>> immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email>> in error.>>>

Posted

I think it's really all a matter of what point of view you are looking at it from.  if you are following the absolute strict line of the the wording in the medicare law, I suspect it says everything and anything we do regarding a patient is covered by their office visit charges.  However, I choose to look at things compared to what is standard of care in my community and thus the services I'm providing is drastically different than most if not all other practitioners seeing medicare patients.  Thus I consider these services to be non-covered since I could not do them and still get the same amount of money from medicare.

I made the change last year from regular practice to IMP with NCBF.  I simply stated that the services I was providing required the non-covered benefits charge.  On my website in the philosophy frequently asked questions section there is some wording I have used (www.intmedcc.com).  I agree it's a little harsh to develop repoire with patients and then hit them with " if you want to continue with me it's now going to cost you extra, " and I do get twinges of guilt at times (especially now as I'm about to increase the fee).  However, I go back to the fact that I'm providing service that simply they wont get at a traditional practice and even at $300 per year it's well worth it in my opinion.  They have the option to leave.  Finally, I would never turn anyone away for a true financial hardship.  2 of my 500 patients really wanted to stay but contacted me and said they really couldnt do the $100 fee this year and I was fine with that.  I certainly didn't publicize that I would do it.

I'll be talking more at IMP Camp about transitioning and the NCBF as will others so I'd highly recommend camp if you anyone hasn't already signed up.Of note, in Denver, private insurers are generally 20-40% higher than medicare in terms of reimbursement.

 

Pt Centered Med Home, just one example, says that SDA are part of what

we should be offering to out pts, without a retainer fee. I use a cell

phone for after hours calls.

So how do I/you justify charging extra for cell communication? Just

trying to understand the boundaries of it all. As someone here

mentioned, some Medicare pts have lots of money,

I certainly have some who do, and I'm annoyed when they want to discuss

their abnormal labs over the tel. How would you start charging for

services to pts you have worked with for a number of years and NOT

charged them extra for these things?

Ellen

Gordon wrote:

>

> I charge a non-covered benefits fee for everyone including medicare. i

> would say the medicare patients utilize the non-covered services like

> email/cell communication, some day access, etc. more than most. i

> agree with brian that what we offer is worth far more than we charge

> (currently i'm 100/yr but next year will be 250-300). in my area,

> there are concierge docs charging 3-5K per year and from what I hear I

> offer far more than they do - i have waived the fee for those under 25

> though I just picked that at random. it's only about 5-10 of my 500

> patients. probably will continue that next year as well but not sure.

> i know it's a little sketchy charging the extra fee for medicare

> patients from the legality side of things but this is one area i just

> choose to play naive. my backup plan was that if medicare came after

> me, I would start a nation media campaign about how i was being

> punished for providing excellent care (hopefully that will not be

> necessary)

>

> On Tue, Aug 24, 2010 at 9:36 AM, Pierce

> >

> wrote:

>

> Most of my wealthier patients are over 65.

>

> However, most of the fees I see discussed here are less than the

> price of the cable TV or cell phone plans that nearly all of my

> patients seem to find affordable.

>

> We need to stop undervaluing ourselves.

>

>

>

>

>

>

>>

>> I don't think there is anything wrong about giving people 65 and

>> over a break. many businesses do...movie theatres, Ross dept

>> stores, etc

>>

>> On Mon, Aug 23, 2010 at 7:53 PM, Ellen son

>> > wrote:

>>

>> I wasn't thinking of charging Medicare pts a retainer. I was

>> wondering

>> about having Medicare pts in your practice and also having

>> pts who pay a

>> retainer fee. Is that reasonable?

>> Allowable? Medicare pts are on fixed incomes. Some do have

>> money but

>> many don't. Medicare does pay for an H & P within the first

>> 12 mos. You

>> can also do a PAP and E & M code at the same visit.

>> As of Jan 2011, all new insurance policies will have to pay for

>> preventive services--though what those are will probably

>> differ unless

>> the govern't creates a definition.

>>

>>

>>

>> Craig Ross wrote:

>> >

>> > Charging Medicare patients a retainer fee has been

>> challenged in court

>> > several time and the has retainer fee won every time ... so

>> far.

>> > However, it must be for services not covered by Medicare. Many

>> > practices charging a high retainer fee (e.g. " Concierge "

>> practices)

>> > are using the fact that Medicare doesn't currently cover

>> Health

>> > Maintenance Exams (HMEs) as the main reason for the charge.

>> For

>> > example, they say they charge $500 annual retainer fee.

>> $300 is for

>> > the annual exam and $200 is for chronic care management,

>> 24/7 access,

>> > telephone and email access, etc.

>> >

>> > All this will change once HCR mandates Medicare pay for an

>> annual

>> > health assessment. Concierge practices will need to find a

>> different

>> > break down for their annual fee for non-covered services as

>> charging

>> > $300 for an annual exam will no longer be legal.

>> >

>> > You can still charge a retainer fee for telephone, 24/7

>> access to you,

>> > email etc as long as Medicare doesn't pay for them.

>> However, you need

>> > to make sure you have the patient sign the form ahead of

>> time that

>> > says that Medicare won't pay for these services.

>> >

>> > Craig

>> >

>> >

>> > > > >

>> > > > > I think changing the language will work.

>> > > > >

>> > > > > If you say: " In Medicare we trust, everyone else pays

>> cash " and

>> > " Kids

>> > > > > get care free " .... it should work fine.

>> > > > > ie language would be that We dont accept any

>> insurance other than

>> > > > > Medicare but we offer our discounted cash rates to

>> those who have

>> > > > > other insurances......

>> > > > >

>> > > > > In this wording you are not saying you are charging

>> those between

>> > > > > 26-65 but you are saying that you are giving discount

>> to those

>> > <26 and

>> > > > > >65. It means the same but technical language is

>> different.

>> > > > >

>> > > > > ------------------

>> > > > > When I say " In Medicare we trust, everyone else pays

>> cash " , most

>> > docs

>> > > > > from most parts of country will laugh but quite

>> ironically,

>> > Medicare

>> > > > > is the best payer in CA and many parts in east coast.

>> > > > >

>> > > > > Still doctors want to move to CA!

>> > > > >

>> > > > > -----------------------

>> > > > > To avoid getting in trouble with Medicare's " most

>> favored "

>> > clause, I

>> > > > > would keep per visit charge same for all new visit

>> and one same

>> > charge

>> > > > > for all f/ups and then give 40-60% discount for PATOS

>> ...... so,

>> > > > > 99201-99205 are all charged $500 and there is 80%

>> PATOS discount

>> > > > > ........... 99211-99215 are all $400 and with 80% PATOS

>> > discount, pt

>> > > > > pays $80

>> > > > >

>> > > > > One key thing in retainer model is to not allow

>> unlimited number of

>> > > > > visits ....... once you cover unlimited number of

>> visits, you are

>> > > > > assuming an unknown risk and it makes you insurance

>> and Ins Co

>> > could

>> > > > > complaint agaisnt you to the insurance board etc

>> .......... it

>> > will be

>> > > > > fine if you say that yearly retainer charge covers

>> 500 (yes, five

>> > > > > hundreds) visits a year ...... but there has to be a

>> finite number

>> > > > >

>> > > > > see doctorsh blog for one such model

>> > > > >

>> > > > >

>> > > >

>> > >

>> >

>> >

>>

>>

>>

>>

>> --

>> M.D.

>> www.elainemd.com <http://www.elainemd.com>

>> Office:

>> Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've

>> imagined.

>> This email transmission may contain protected and privileged,

>> highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information

>> (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only

>> for the use of the individual or entity named above.

>>

>>

>>

>> If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may

>> not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute

>> it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have

>> received this transmission in error, please notify the sender

>> immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email

>> in error.

>

>

>

Posted

CA

Pratt

Office Manager

Oak Tree Internal Medicine P.C

www.prattmd.info

From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Dr Levin

Sent: Tuesday, August 24, 2010

6:44 PM

To:

Subject: Re:

Re: Retainer fees and Medicare

, what state do you live in?

Matt in Western PA (where

the privates DO pay over Medicare rates).........

Re:

Re: Retainer fees and Medicare

I don't

have that many medicare pts. don't want to Govt hassels and as Joanne from the

Drain said, they are on fixed income and deserve a break. Also medicare is our

highest payer in CA. This small retainer fee would make private payers on par w

medicare

On Sun, Aug 22,

2010 at 8:21 AM, pk_endo

wrote:

If it is small, why not charge everyone? For medicare,

you could add a fine print " .. except where expressely prohibited by

federal laws ... "

--

M.D.

www.elainemd.com

Office:

Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.

This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly

confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information.

The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named

above.

If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use,

publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the

intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please

notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that

email in error.

Posted

From what I hear, I guess I get paid ok in Oregon. Certainly compared

to Maine.

Ellen

Dr Levin wrote:

>

> NOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!

> Medicare is DIFFERENT depending on where you live.

> Also, in many states OTHER THAN Calif, NJ, NY, Medicare is WORST payor

> (privates pay 110% of Medicare).

> Also, remember that charges mean NOTHING -- if I set my charges high

> enough, NOONE would pay more than say 40% of my " regular " rates.

> Medicare does set a base, but some private insurers, I don't know how,

> get away with paying only a % OF Medicare.........

> Sorry, guess this time I'm happy to live in Pa

> Matt in Western PA

>

> * Re: Re: Retainer fees and Medicare

>

> I presume you get paid the same rate for Medicare in Cal as

> anywhere in

> the US since it's a federal program. So that must mean your insurance

> carriers are not paying you very well at all.

> Medicare payments in Oregon are ~40% of charges while private

> insurers

> pay 70-80% of charges. Many MDs are limiting or not taking new

> Medicare

> pts because payments are comparatively so low.

>

> wrote:

> >

> > I don't have that many medicare pts. don't want to Govt hassels

> and as

> > Joanne from the Drain said, they are on fixed income and deserve a

> > break. Also medicare is our highest payer in CA. This small

> retainer

> > fee would make private payers on par w medicare

> >

> > On Sun, Aug 22, 2010 at 8:21 AM, pk_endo <drpawankumar@...

> <mailto:drpawankumar%40gmail.com>

> > <mailto:drpawankumar@...

> <mailto:drpawankumar%40gmail.com>>> wrote:

> >

> > If it is small, why not charge everyone? For medicare, you could

> > add a fine print " .. except where expressely prohibited by federal

> > laws ... "

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > --

> > M.D.

> > www.elainemd.com <http://www.elainemd.com>

> > Office:

> > Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've

> imagined.

> > This email transmission may contain protected and privileged,

> highly

> > confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or

> > legal information. The information is intended only for the use

> of the

> > individual or entity named above.

> >

> >

> >

> > If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not

> > use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it.

> If you

> > are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this

> > transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and

> > confidentially destroy the information that email in error.

> >

>

>

Attachment: vcard [not shown]

Posted

I generally do have pts come back to discuss abnormal labs. If all is

normal, I'll send them a copy in the mail.

I tell them that up front, and that I will ask them to come in to review

abn's. But some pts occasionally want

to talk over the tel. I try /not/ to do this. There can be so much

confusion on the tel and you never can be sure

if pts really hear you.

Dr Levin wrote:

>

> Be consistent with all........do you bring EVERY pt back to discuss

> abnormal labs????

>

> * Re: Re: Retainer fees and Medicare

>

> Pt Centered Med Home, just one example, says that SDA are part of

> what

> we should be offering to out pts, without a retainer fee. I use a

> cell

> phone for after hours calls.

> So how do I/you justify charging extra for cell communication? Just

> trying to understand the boundaries of it all. As someone here

> mentioned, some Medicare pts have lots of money,

> I certainly have some who do, and I'm annoyed when they want to

> discuss

> their abnormal labs over the tel. How would you start charging for

> services to pts you have worked with for a number of years and NOT

> charged them extra for these things?

>

> Ellen

>

> Gordon wrote:

> >

> > I charge a non-covered benefits fee for everyone including

> medicare. i

> > would say the medicare patients utilize the non-covered services

> like

> > email/cell communication, some day access, etc. more than most. i

> > agree with brian that what we offer is worth far more than we

> charge

> > (currently i'm 100/yr but next year will be 250-300). in my area,

> > there are concierge docs charging 3-5K per year and from what I

> hear I

> > offer far more than they do - i have waived the fee for those

> under 25

> > though I just picked that at random. it's only about 5-10 of my 500

> > patients. probably will continue that next year as well but not

> sure.

> > i know it's a little sketchy charging the extra fee for medicare

> > patients from the legality side of things but this is one area i

> just

> > choose to play naive. my backup plan was that if medicare came

> after

> > me, I would start a nation media campaign about how i was being

> > punished for providing excellent care (hopefully that will not be

> > necessary)

> >

> > On Tue, Aug 24, 2010 at 9:36 AM, Pierce

> > <bpierce@...

> <mailto:bpierce%40midcoastmedicine.com>

> <mailto:bpierce@...

> <mailto:bpierce%40midcoastmedicine.com>>>

> > wrote:

> >

> > Most of my wealthier patients are over 65.

> >

> > However, most of the fees I see discussed here are less than the

> > price of the cable TV or cell phone plans that nearly all of my

> > patients seem to find affordable.

> >

> > We need to stop undervaluing ourselves.

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >>

> >> I don't think there is anything wrong about giving people 65 and

> >> over a break. many businesses do...movie theatres, Ross dept

> >> stores, etc

> >>

> >> On Mon, Aug 23, 2010 at 7:53 PM, Ellen son

> >> <nellegreen@... <mailto:nellegreen%40earthlink.net>

> <mailto:nellegreen@...

> <mailto:nellegreen%40earthlink.net>>> wrote:

> >>

> >> I wasn't thinking of charging Medicare pts a retainer. I was

> >> wondering

> >> about having Medicare pts in your practice and also having

> >> pts who pay a

> >> retainer fee. Is that reasonable?

> >> Allowable? Medicare pts are on fixed incomes. Some do have

> >> money but

> >> many don't. Medicare does pay for an H & P within the first

> >> 12 mos. You

> >> can also do a PAP and E & M code at the same visit.

> >> As of Jan 2011, all new insurance policies will have to pay for

> >> preventive services--though what those are will probably

> >> differ unless

> >> the govern't creates a definition.

> >>

> >>

> >>

> >> Craig Ross wrote:

> >> >

> >> > Charging Medicare patients a retainer fee has been

> >> challenged in court

> >> > several time and the has retainer fee won every time ... so

> >> far.

> >> > However, it must be for services not covered by Medicare. Many

> >> > practices charging a high retainer fee (e.g. " Concierge "

> >> practices)

> >> > are using the fact that Medicare doesn't currently cover

> >> Health

> >> > Maintenance Exams (HMEs) as the main reason for the charge.

> >> For

> >> > example, they say they charge $500 annual retainer fee.

> >> $300 is for

> >> > the annual exam and $200 is for chronic care management,

> >> 24/7 access,

> >> > telephone and email access, etc.

> >> >

> >> > All this will change once HCR mandates Medicare pay for an

> >> annual

> >> > health assessment. Concierge practices will need to find a

> >> different

> >> > break down for their annual fee for non-covered services as

> >> charging

> >> > $300 for an annual exam will no longer be legal.

> >> >

> >> > You can still charge a retainer fee for telephone, 24/7

> >> access to you,

> >> > email etc as long as Medicare doesn't pay for them.

> >> However, you need

> >> > to make sure you have the patient sign the form ahead of

> >> time that

> >> > says that Medicare won't pay for these services.

> >> >

> >> > Craig

> >> >

> >> >

> >> > > > >

> >> > > > > I think changing the language will work.

> >> > > > >

> >> > > > > If you say: " In Medicare we trust, everyone else pays

> >> cash " and

> >> > " Kids

> >> > > > > get care free " .... it should work fine.

> >> > > > > ie language would be that We dont accept any

> >> insurance other than

> >> > > > > Medicare but we offer our discounted cash rates to

> >> those who have

> >> > > > > other insurances......

> >> > > > >

> >> > > > > In this wording you are not saying you are charging

> >> those between

> >> > > > > 26-65 but you are saying that you are giving discount

> >> to those

> >> > <26 and

> >> > > > > >65. It means the same but technical language is

> >> different.

> >> > > > >

> >> > > > > ------------------

> >> > > > > When I say " In Medicare we trust, everyone else pays

> >> cash " , most

> >> > docs

> >> > > > > from most parts of country will laugh but quite

> >> ironically,

> >> > Medicare

> >> > > > > is the best payer in CA and many parts in east coast.

> >> > > > >

> >> > > > > Still doctors want to move to CA!

> >> > > > >

> >> > > > > -----------------------

> >> > > > > To avoid getting in trouble with Medicare's " most

> >> favored "

> >> > clause, I

> >> > > > > would keep per visit charge same for all new visit

> >> and one same

> >> > charge

> >> > > > > for all f/ups and then give 40-60% discount for PATOS

> >> ...... so,

> >> > > > > 99201-99205 are all charged $500 and there is 80%

> >> PATOS discount

> >> > > > > ........... 99211-99215 are all $400 and with 80% PATOS

> >> > discount, pt

> >> > > > > pays $80

> >> > > > >

> >> > > > > One key thing in retainer model is to not allow

> >> unlimited number of

> >> > > > > visits ....... once you cover unlimited number of

> >> visits, you are

> >> > > > > assuming an unknown risk and it makes you insurance

> >> and Ins Co

> >> > could

> >> > > > > complaint agaisnt you to the insurance board etc

> >> .......... it

> >> > will be

> >> > > > > fine if you say that yearly retainer charge covers

> >> 500 (yes, five

> >> > > > > hundreds) visits a year ...... but there has to be a

> >> finite number

> >> > > > >

> >> > > > > see doctorsh blog for one such model

> >> > > > >

> >> > > > >

> >> > > >

> >> > >

> >> >

> >> >

> >>

> >>

> >>

> >>

> >> --

> >> M.D.

> >> www.elainemd.com <http://www.elainemd.com>

> >> Office:

> >> Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've

> >> imagined.

> >> This email transmission may contain protected and privileged,

> >> highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information

> >> (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only

> >> for the use of the individual or entity named above.

> >>

> >>

> >>

> >> If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may

> >> not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute

> >> it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have

> >> received this transmission in error, please notify the sender

> >> immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email

> >> in error.

> >

> >

> >

>

>

Attachment: vcard [not shown]

Posted

In Portland, private insurance pays 70-80+% charges vs 40% Medicare. I

may try to get to camp this yr--would be nice to see what others are

doing and share info,

meet the faces behind the names. I have been in my own IMP for 8 yrs now

and doing well. But there are always ways to improve and grow. No end to

things to do.

I thought there was some stipulation if you take Medicare that you can't

charge other pts more(that doesn't mean you don't get paid more but you

have to charge everyone the same).

So that's why I'm curious about having a retainer and also taking

Medicare. I have not read the fine print so I can't say, it's only what

I've gleaned here and elsewhere.

Ellen

Gordon wrote:

>

> I think it's really all a matter of what point of view you are looking

> at it from. if you are following the absolute strict line of the the

> wording in the medicare law, I suspect it says everything and anything

> we do regarding a patient is covered by their office visit charges.

> However, I choose to look at things compared to what is standard of

> care in my community and thus the services I'm providing is

> drastically different than most if not all other practitioners seeing

> medicare patients. Thus I consider these services to be non-covered

> since I could not do them and still get the same amount of money from

> medicare.

>

> I made the change last year from regular practice to IMP with NCBF. I

> simply stated that the services I was providing required the

> non-covered benefits charge. On my website in the philosophy

> frequently asked questions section there is some wording I have used

> (www.intmedcc.com <http://www.intmedcc.com>). I agree it's a little

> harsh to develop repoire with patients and then hit them with " if you

> want to continue with me it's now going to cost you extra, " and I do

> get twinges of guilt at times (especially now as I'm about to increase

> the fee). However, I go back to the fact that I'm providing service

> that simply they wont get at a traditional practice and even at $300

> per year it's well worth it in my opinion. They have the option to

> leave. Finally, I would never turn anyone away for a true financial

> hardship. 2 of my 500 patients really wanted to stay but contacted me

> and said they really couldnt do the $100 fee this year and I was fine

> with that. I certainly didn't publicize that I would do it.

>

> I'll be talking more at IMP Camp about transitioning and the NCBF as

> will others so I'd highly recommend camp if you anyone hasn't already

> signed up.

>

> Of note, in Denver, private insurers are generally 20-40% higher than

> medicare in terms of reimbursement.

>

> On Tue, Aug 24, 2010 at 11:42 AM, Ellen son

> > wrote:

>

> Pt Centered Med Home, just one example, says that SDA are part of

> what

> we should be offering to out pts, without a retainer fee. I use a

> cell

> phone for after hours calls.

> So how do I/you justify charging extra for cell communication? Just

> trying to understand the boundaries of it all. As someone here

> mentioned, some Medicare pts have lots of money,

> I certainly have some who do, and I'm annoyed when they want to

> discuss

> their abnormal labs over the tel. How would you start charging for

> services to pts you have worked with for a number of years and NOT

> charged them extra for these things?

>

> Ellen

>

>

>

> Gordon wrote:

> >

> > I charge a non-covered benefits fee for everyone including

> medicare. i

> > would say the medicare patients utilize the non-covered services

> like

> > email/cell communication, some day access, etc. more than most. i

> > agree with brian that what we offer is worth far more than we

> charge

> > (currently i'm 100/yr but next year will be 250-300). in my area,

> > there are concierge docs charging 3-5K per year and from what I

> hear I

> > offer far more than they do - i have waived the fee for those

> under 25

> > though I just picked that at random. it's only about 5-10 of my 500

> > patients. probably will continue that next year as well but not

> sure.

> > i know it's a little sketchy charging the extra fee for medicare

> > patients from the legality side of things but this is one area i

> just

> > choose to play naive. my backup plan was that if medicare came

> after

> > me, I would start a nation media campaign about how i was being

> > punished for providing excellent care (hopefully that will not be

> > necessary)

> >

> > On Tue, Aug 24, 2010 at 9:36 AM, Pierce

> > <bpierce@...

> <mailto:bpierce%40midcoastmedicine.com>

> <mailto:bpierce@...

> <mailto:bpierce%40midcoastmedicine.com>>>

> > wrote:

> >

> > Most of my wealthier patients are over 65.

> >

> > However, most of the fees I see discussed here are less than the

> > price of the cable TV or cell phone plans that nearly all of my

> > patients seem to find affordable.

> >

> > We need to stop undervaluing ourselves.

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >>

> >> I don't think there is anything wrong about giving people 65 and

> >> over a break. many businesses do...movie theatres, Ross dept

> >> stores, etc

> >>

> >> On Mon, Aug 23, 2010 at 7:53 PM, Ellen son

> >> <nellegreen@... <mailto:nellegreen%40earthlink.net>

> <mailto:nellegreen@...

> <mailto:nellegreen%40earthlink.net>>> wrote:

> >>

> >> I wasn't thinking of charging Medicare pts a retainer. I was

> >> wondering

> >> about having Medicare pts in your practice and also having

> >> pts who pay a

> >> retainer fee. Is that reasonable?

> >> Allowable? Medicare pts are on fixed incomes. Some do have

> >> money but

> >> many don't. Medicare does pay for an H & P within the first

> >> 12 mos. You

> >> can also do a PAP and E & M code at the same visit.

> >> As of Jan 2011, all new insurance policies will have to pay for

> >> preventive services--though what those are will probably

> >> differ unless

> >> the govern't creates a definition.

> >>

> >>

> >>

> >> Craig Ross wrote:

> >> >

> >> > Charging Medicare patients a retainer fee has been

> >> challenged in court

> >> > several time and the has retainer fee won every time ... so

> >> far.

> >> > However, it must be for services not covered by Medicare. Many

> >> > practices charging a high retainer fee (e.g. " Concierge "

> >> practices)

> >> > are using the fact that Medicare doesn't currently cover

> >> Health

> >> > Maintenance Exams (HMEs) as the main reason for the charge.

> >> For

> >> > example, they say they charge $500 annual retainer fee.

> >> $300 is for

> >> > the annual exam and $200 is for chronic care management,

> >> 24/7 access,

> >> > telephone and email access, etc.

> >> >

> >> > All this will change once HCR mandates Medicare pay for an

> >> annual

> >> > health assessment. Concierge practices will need to find a

> >> different

> >> > break down for their annual fee for non-covered services as

> >> charging

> >> > $300 for an annual exam will no longer be legal.

> >> >

> >> > You can still charge a retainer fee for telephone, 24/7

> >> access to you,

> >> > email etc as long as Medicare doesn't pay for them.

> >> However, you need

> >> > to make sure you have the patient sign the form ahead of

> >> time that

> >> > says that Medicare won't pay for these services.

> >> >

> >> > Craig

> >> >

> >> >

> >> > > > >

> >> > > > > I think changing the language will work.

> >> > > > >

> >> > > > > If you say: " In Medicare we trust, everyone else pays

> >> cash " and

> >> > " Kids

> >> > > > > get care free " .... it should work fine.

> >> > > > > ie language would be that We dont accept any

> >> insurance other than

> >> > > > > Medicare but we offer our discounted cash rates to

> >> those who have

> >> > > > > other insurances......

> >> > > > >

> >> > > > > In this wording you are not saying you are charging

> >> those between

> >> > > > > 26-65 but you are saying that you are giving discount

> >> to those

> >> > <26 and

> >> > > > > >65. It means the same but technical language is

> >> different.

> >> > > > >

> >> > > > > ------------------

> >> > > > > When I say " In Medicare we trust, everyone else pays

> >> cash " , most

> >> > docs

> >> > > > > from most parts of country will laugh but quite

> >> ironically,

> >> > Medicare

> >> > > > > is the best payer in CA and many parts in east coast.

> >> > > > >

> >> > > > > Still doctors want to move to CA!

> >> > > > >

> >> > > > > -----------------------

> >> > > > > To avoid getting in trouble with Medicare's " most

> >> favored "

> >> > clause, I

> >> > > > > would keep per visit charge same for all new visit

> >> and one same

> >> > charge

> >> > > > > for all f/ups and then give 40-60% discount for PATOS

> >> ...... so,

> >> > > > > 99201-99205 are all charged $500 and there is 80%

> >> PATOS discount

> >> > > > > ........... 99211-99215 are all $400 and with 80% PATOS

> >> > discount, pt

> >> > > > > pays $80

> >> > > > >

> >> > > > > One key thing in retainer model is to not allow

> >> unlimited number of

> >> > > > > visits ....... once you cover unlimited number of

> >> visits, you are

> >> > > > > assuming an unknown risk and it makes you insurance

> >> and Ins Co

> >> > could

> >> > > > > complaint agaisnt you to the insurance board etc

> >> .......... it

> >> > will be

> >> > > > > fine if you say that yearly retainer charge covers

> >> 500 (yes, five

> >> > > > > hundreds) visits a year ...... but there has to be a

> >> finite number

> >> > > > >

> >> > > > > see doctorsh blog for one such model

> >> > > > >

> >> > > > >

> >> > > >

> >> > >

> >> >

> >> >

> >>

> >>

> >>

> >>

> >> --

> >> M.D.

> >> www.elainemd.com <http://www.elainemd.com>

> <http://www.elainemd.com>

>

> >> Office:

> >> Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've

> >> imagined.

> >> This email transmission may contain protected and privileged,

> >> highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information

> >> (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only

> >> for the use of the individual or entity named above.

> >>

> >>

> >>

> >> If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may

> >> not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute

> >> it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have

> >> received this transmission in error, please notify the sender

> >> immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email

> >> in error.

> >

> >

> >

>

>

>

Attachment: vcard [not shown]

Posted

- I can't imagine any insurance co. would give me a break on my contract and pay me more. I am not ready to drop them. So it might not be worth my while to ask for equal reimbursement to Medicare. Wish doctors were more organized and had a lobbying that someone actually respected 

 

CA

 

Pratt

Office Manager

Oak Tree Internal Medicine P.C

www.prattmd.info

From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Dr Levin

Sent: Tuesday, August 24, 2010 6:44 PM

To: Subject: Re: Re: Retainer fees and Medicare

 

 

, what state do you live in?

 

Matt in Western PA (where the privates DO pay over Medicare rates).........

Re: Re: Retainer fees and Medicare

 

I don't have that many medicare pts. don't want to Govt hassels and as Joanne from the Drain said, they are on fixed income and deserve a break. Also medicare is our highest payer in CA. This small retainer fee would make private payers on par w medicare

 

If it is small, why not charge everyone? For medicare, you could add a fine print " .. except where expressely prohibited by federal laws ... "

-- M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice:

Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above.

 If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error.

-- M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.

This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above.

 If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error.

Posted

Ellen,

The stipulation is that you can’t charge

other patients LESS than what you charge Medicare patients. Medicare doesn’t

want to pay more than what you are willing to accept from others.

Pratt

Office Manager

Oak Tree Internal Medicine P.C

www.prattmd.info

From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Ellen son

Sent: Tuesday, August 24, 2010

8:52 PM

To:

Subject: Re:

Re: Retainer fees and Medicare

In Portland, private

insurance pays 70-80+% charges vs 40% Medicare. I

may try to get to camp this yr--would be nice to see what others are

doing and share info,

meet the faces behind the names. I have been in my own IMP for 8 yrs now

and doing well. But there are always ways to improve and grow. No end to

things to do.

I thought there was some stipulation if you take Medicare that you can't

charge other pts more(that doesn't mean you don't get paid more but you

have to charge everyone the same).

So that's why I'm curious about having a retainer and also taking

Medicare. I have not read the fine print so I can't say, it's only what

I've gleaned here and elsewhere.

Ellen

Gordon wrote:

>

> I think it's really all a matter of what point of view you are looking

> at it from. if you are following the absolute strict line of the the

> wording in the medicare law, I suspect it says everything and anything

> we do regarding a patient is covered by their office visit charges.

> However, I choose to look at things compared to what is standard of

> care in my community and thus the services I'm providing is

> drastically different than most if not all other practitioners seeing

> medicare patients. Thus I consider these services to be non-covered

> since I could not do them and still get the same amount of money from

> medicare.

>

> I made the change last year from regular practice to IMP with NCBF. I

> simply stated that the services I was providing required the

> non-covered benefits charge. On my website in the philosophy

> frequently asked questions section there is some wording I have used

> (www.intmedcc.com <http://www.intmedcc.com>).

I agree it's a little

> harsh to develop repoire with patients and then hit them with " if you

> want to continue with me it's now going to cost you extra, " and I do

> get twinges of guilt at times (especially now as I'm about to increase

> the fee). However, I go back to the fact that I'm providing service

> that simply they wont get at a traditional practice and even at $300

> per year it's well worth it in my opinion. They have the option to

> leave. Finally, I would never turn anyone away for a true financial

> hardship. 2 of my 500 patients really wanted to stay but contacted me

> and said they really couldnt do the $100 fee this year and I was fine

> with that. I certainly didn't publicize that I would do it.

>

> I'll be talking more at IMP Camp about transitioning and the NCBF as

> will others so I'd highly recommend camp if you anyone hasn't already

> signed up.

>

> Of note, in Denver,

private insurers are generally 20-40% higher than

> medicare in terms of reimbursement.

>

> On Tue, Aug 24, 2010 at 11:42 AM, Ellen son

> <nellegreen@...

>

wrote:

>

> Pt Centered Med Home, just one example, says that SDA are part of

> what

> we should be offering to out pts, without a retainer fee. I use a

> cell

> phone for after hours calls.

> So how do I/you justify charging extra for cell communication? Just

> trying to understand the boundaries of it all. As someone here

> mentioned, some Medicare pts have lots of money,

> I certainly have some who do, and I'm annoyed when they want to

> discuss

> their abnormal labs over the tel. How would you start charging for

> services to pts you have worked with for a number of years and NOT

> charged them extra for these things?

>

> Ellen

>

>

>

> Gordon wrote:

> >

> > I charge a non-covered benefits fee for everyone including

> medicare. i

> > would say the medicare patients utilize the non-covered services

> like

> > email/cell communication, some day access, etc. more than most. i

> > agree with brian that what we offer is worth far more than we

> charge

> > (currently i'm 100/yr but next year will be 250-300). in my area,

> > there are concierge docs charging 3-5K per year and from what I

> hear I

> > offer far more than they do - i have waived the fee for those

> under 25

> > though I just picked that at random. it's only about 5-10 of my 500

> > patients. probably will continue that next year as well but not

> sure.

> > i know it's a little sketchy charging the extra fee for medicare

> > patients from the legality side of things but this is one area i

> just

> > choose to play naive. my backup plan was that if medicare came

> after

> > me, I would start a nation media campaign about how i was being

> > punished for providing excellent care (hopefully that will not be

> > necessary)

> >

> > On Tue, Aug 24, 2010 at 9:36 AM, Pierce

> > <bpierce@...

> <mailto:bpierce%40midcoastmedicine.com>

> <mailto:bpierce@...

> <mailto:bpierce%40midcoastmedicine.com>>>

> > wrote:

> >

> > Most of my wealthier patients are over 65.

> >

> > However, most of the fees I see discussed here are less than the

> > price of the cable TV or cell phone plans that nearly all of my

> > patients seem to find affordable.

> >

> > We need to stop undervaluing ourselves.

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >>

> >> I don't think there is anything wrong about giving people 65 and

> >> over a break. many businesses do...movie theatres, Ross dept

> >> stores, etc

> >>

> >> On Mon, Aug 23, 2010 at 7:53 PM, Ellen son

> >> <nellegreen@...

<mailto:nellegreen%40earthlink.net>

> <mailto:nellegreen@...

> <mailto:nellegreen%40earthlink.net>>> wrote:

> >>

> >> I wasn't thinking of charging Medicare pts a retainer. I was

> >> wondering

> >> about having Medicare pts in your practice and also having

> >> pts who pay a

> >> retainer fee. Is that reasonable?

> >> Allowable? Medicare pts are on fixed incomes. Some do have

> >> money but

> >> many don't. Medicare does pay for an H & P within the first

> >> 12 mos. You

> >> can also do a PAP and E & M code at the same visit.

> >> As of Jan 2011, all new insurance policies will have to pay for

> >> preventive services--though what those are will probably

> >> differ unless

> >> the govern't creates a definition.

> >>

> >>

> >>

> >> Craig Ross wrote:

> >> >

> >> > Charging Medicare patients a retainer fee has been

> >> challenged in court

> >> > several time and the has retainer fee won every time ... so

> >> far.

> >> > However, it must be for services not covered by Medicare.

Many

> >> > practices charging a high retainer fee (e.g.

" Concierge "

> >> practices)

> >> > are using the fact that Medicare doesn't currently cover

> >> Health

> >> > Maintenance Exams (HMEs) as the main reason for the charge.

> >> For

> >> > example, they say they charge $500 annual retainer fee.

> >> $300 is for

> >> > the annual exam and $200 is for chronic care management,

> >> 24/7 access,

> >> > telephone and email access, etc.

> >> >

> >> > All this will change once HCR mandates Medicare pay for an

> >> annual

> >> > health assessment. Concierge practices will need to find a

> >> different

> >> > break down for their annual fee for non-covered services as

> >> charging

> >> > $300 for an annual exam will no longer be legal.

> >> >

> >> > You can still charge a retainer fee for telephone, 24/7

> >> access to you,

> >> > email etc as long as Medicare doesn't pay for them.

> >> However, you need

> >> > to make sure you have the patient sign the form ahead of

> >> time that

> >> > says that Medicare won't pay for these services.

> >> >

> >> > Craig

> >> >

> >> >

> >> > > > >

> >> > > > > I think changing the language will work.

> >> > > > >

> >> > > > > If you say: " In Medicare we trust,

everyone else pays

> >> cash " and

> >> > " Kids

> >> > > > > get care free " .... it should work fine.

> >> > > > > ie language would be that We dont accept any

> >> insurance other than

> >> > > > > Medicare but we offer our discounted cash

rates to

> >> those who have

> >> > > > > other insurances......

> >> > > > >

> >> > > > > In this wording you are not saying you are

charging

> >> those between

> >> > > > > 26-65 but you are saying that you are giving

discount

> >> to those

> >> > <26 and

> >> > > > > >65. It means the same but technical

language is

> >> different.

> >> > > > >

> >> > > > > ------------------

> >> > > > > When I say " In Medicare we trust,

everyone else pays

> >> cash " , most

> >> > docs

> >> > > > > from most parts of country will laugh but

quite

> >> ironically,

> >> > Medicare

> >> > > > > is the best payer in CA and many parts in

east coast.

> >> > > > >

> >> > > > > Still doctors want to move to CA!

> >> > > > >

> >> > > > > -----------------------

> >> > > > > To avoid getting in trouble with Medicare's

" most

> >> favored "

> >> > clause, I

> >> > > > > would keep per visit charge same for all new

visit

> >> and one same

> >> > charge

> >> > > > > for all f/ups and then give 40-60% discount

for PATOS

> >> ...... so,

> >> > > > > 99201-99205 are all charged $500 and there is

80%

> >> PATOS discount

> >> > > > > ........... 99211-99215 are all $400 and with

80% PATOS

> >> > discount, pt

> >> > > > > pays $80

> >> > > > >

> >> > > > > One key thing in retainer model is to not

allow

> >> unlimited number of

> >> > > > > visits ....... once you cover unlimited

number of

> >> visits, you are

> >> > > > > assuming an unknown risk and it makes you

insurance

> >> and Ins Co

> >> > could

> >> > > > > complaint agaisnt you to the insurance board

etc

> >> .......... it

> >> > will be

> >> > > > > fine if you say that yearly retainer charge

covers

> >> 500 (yes, five

> >> > > > > hundreds) visits a year ...... but there has

to be a

> >> finite number

> >> > > > >

> >> > > > > see doctorsh blog for one such model

> >> > > > >

> >> > > > >

> >> > > >

> >> > >

> >> >

> >> >

> >>

> >>

> >>

> >>

> >> --

> >> M.D.

> >> www.elainemd.com <http://www.elainemd.com>

> <http://www.elainemd.com>

>

> >> Office:

> >> Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've

> >> imagined.

> >> This email transmission may contain protected and privileged,

> >> highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information

> >> (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only

> >> for the use of the individual or entity named above.

> >>

> >>

> >>

> >> If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may

> >> not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute

> >> it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have

> >> received this transmission in error, please notify the sender

> >> immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email

> >> in error.

> >

> >

> >

>

>

>

Posted

But that happens in CA when private ins pay us less then MC, doesn't?

 

Ellen,

The stipulation is that you can’t charge other patients LESS than what you charge Medicare patients.  Medicare doesn’t want to pay more than what you are willing to accept from others.

 

Pratt

Office Manager

Oak Tree Internal Medicine P.C

www.prattmd.info

From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Ellen son

Sent: Tuesday, August 24, 2010 8:52 PM To: Subject: Re: Re: Retainer fees and Medicare

 

 

In Portland, private insurance pays 70-80+% charges vs 40% Medicare. I

may try to get to camp this yr--would be nice to see what others are doing and share info,meet the faces behind the names. I have been in my own IMP for 8 yrs now and doing well. But there are always ways to improve and grow. No end to

things to do.I thought there was some stipulation if you take Medicare that you can't charge other pts more(that doesn't mean you don't get paid more but you have to charge everyone the same).

So that's why I'm curious about having a retainer and also taking Medicare. I have not read the fine print so I can't say, it's only what I've gleaned here and elsewhere.Ellen Gordon wrote:

>> I think it's really all a matter of what point of view you are looking > at it from. if you are following the absolute strict line of the the > wording in the medicare law, I suspect it says everything and anything

> we do regarding a patient is covered by their office visit charges. > However, I choose to look at things compared to what is standard of > care in my community and thus the services I'm providing is

> drastically different than most if not all other practitioners seeing > medicare patients. Thus I consider these services to be non-covered > since I could not do them and still get the same amount of money from

> medicare.>> I made the change last year from regular practice to IMP with NCBF. I > simply stated that the services I was providing required the > non-covered benefits charge. On my website in the philosophy

> frequently asked questions section there is some wording I have used > (www.intmedcc.com <http://www.intmedcc.com>). I agree it's a little

> harsh to develop repoire with patients and then hit them with " if you > want to continue with me it's now going to cost you extra, " and I do > get twinges of guilt at times (especially now as I'm about to increase

> the fee). However, I go back to the fact that I'm providing service > that simply they wont get at a traditional practice and even at $300 > per year it's well worth it in my opinion. They have the option to

> leave. Finally, I would never turn anyone away for a true financial > hardship. 2 of my 500 patients really wanted to stay but contacted me > and said they really couldnt do the $100 fee this year and I was fine

> with that. I certainly didn't publicize that I would do it.>> I'll be talking more at IMP Camp about transitioning and the NCBF as > will others so I'd highly recommend camp if you anyone hasn't already

> signed up.>> Of note, in Denver, private insurers are generally 20-40% higher than > medicare in terms of reimbursement.>> On Tue, Aug 24, 2010 at 11:42 AM, Ellen son > > wrote:

>> Pt Centered Med Home, just one example, says that SDA are part of> what> we should be offering to out pts, without a retainer fee. I use a> cell> phone for after hours calls.> So how do I/you justify charging extra for cell communication? Just

> trying to understand the boundaries of it all. As someone here> mentioned, some Medicare pts have lots of money,> I certainly have some who do, and I'm annoyed when they want to> discuss> their abnormal labs over the tel. How would you start charging for

> services to pts you have worked with for a number of years and NOT> charged them extra for these things?>> Ellen>>>> Gordon wrote:> >> > I charge a non-covered benefits fee for everyone including

> medicare. i> > would say the medicare patients utilize the non-covered services> like> > email/cell communication, some day access, etc. more than most. i> > agree with brian that what we offer is worth far more than we

> charge> > (currently i'm 100/yr but next year will be 250-300). in my area,> > there are concierge docs charging 3-5K per year and from what I> hear I> > offer far more than they do - i have waived the fee for those

> under 25> > though I just picked that at random. it's only about 5-10 of my 500> > patients. probably will continue that next year as well but not> sure.> > i know it's a little sketchy charging the extra fee for medicare

> > patients from the legality side of things but this is one area i> just> > choose to play naive. my backup plan was that if medicare came> after> > me, I would start a nation media campaign about how i was being

> > punished for providing excellent care (hopefully that will not be> > necessary)> >> > On Tue, Aug 24, 2010 at 9:36 AM, Pierce> > <bpierce@...

> <mailto:bpierce%40midcoastmedicine.com>> <mailto:bpierce@...

> <mailto:bpierce%40midcoastmedicine.com>>>> > wrote:> >> > Most of my wealthier patients are over 65.

> >> > However, most of the fees I see discussed here are less than the> > price of the cable TV or cell phone plans that nearly all of my> > patients seem to find affordable.> >

> > We need to stop undervaluing ourselves.> >> > > >> >> >> > > >>> >> I don't think there is anything wrong about giving people 65 and

> >> over a break. many businesses do...movie theatres, Ross dept> >> stores, etc> >>> >> On Mon, Aug 23, 2010 at 7:53 PM, Ellen son> >> <nellegreen@... <mailto:nellegreen%40earthlink.net>

> <mailto:nellegreen%40earthlink.net>>> wrote:

> >>> >> I wasn't thinking of charging Medicare pts a retainer. I was> >> wondering> >> about having Medicare pts in your practice and also having> >> pts who pay a

> >> retainer fee. Is that reasonable?> >> Allowable? Medicare pts are on fixed incomes. Some do have> >> money but> >> many don't. Medicare does pay for an H & P within the first

> >> 12 mos. You> >> can also do a PAP and E & M code at the same visit.> >> As of Jan 2011, all new insurance policies will have to pay for> >> preventive services--though what those are will probably

> >> differ unless> >> the govern't creates a definition.> >>> >>> >>> >> Craig Ross wrote:> >> >> >> > Charging Medicare patients a retainer fee has been

> >> challenged in court> >> > several time and the has retainer fee won every time ... so> >> far.> >> > However, it must be for services not covered by Medicare. Many

> >> > practices charging a high retainer fee (e.g. " Concierge " > >> practices)> >> > are using the fact that Medicare doesn't currently cover> >> Health

> >> > Maintenance Exams (HMEs) as the main reason for the charge.> >> For> >> > example, they say they charge $500 annual retainer fee.> >> $300 is for> >> > the annual exam and $200 is for chronic care management,

> >> 24/7 access,> >> > telephone and email access, etc.> >> >> >> > All this will change once HCR mandates Medicare pay for an> >> annual> >> > health assessment. Concierge practices will need to find a

> >> different> >> > break down for their annual fee for non-covered services as> >> charging> >> > $300 for an annual exam will no longer be legal.> >> >

> >> > You can still charge a retainer fee for telephone, 24/7> >> access to you,> >> > email etc as long as Medicare doesn't pay for them.> >> However, you need

> >> > to make sure you have the patient sign the form ahead of> >> time that> >> > says that Medicare won't pay for these services.> >> >> >> > Craig

> >> >> >> >

> >> > > > >> >> > > > > I think changing the language will work.> >> > > > >> >> > > > > If you say: " In Medicare we trust, everyone else pays

> >> cash " and> >> > " Kids> >> > > > > get care free " .... it should work fine.> >> > > > > ie language would be that We dont accept any

> >> insurance other than> >> > > > > Medicare but we offer our discounted cash rates to> >> those who have> >> > > > > other insurances......> >> > > > >

> >> > > > > In this wording you are not saying you are charging> >> those between> >> > > > > 26-65 but you are saying that you are giving discount> >> to those

> >> > <26 and> >> > > > > >65. It means the same but technical language is> >> different.> >> > > > >> >> > > > > ------------------

> >> > > > > When I say " In Medicare we trust, everyone else pays> >> cash " , most> >> > docs> >> > > > > from most parts of country will laugh but quite

> >> ironically,> >> > Medicare> >> > > > > is the best payer in CA and many parts in east coast.> >> > > > >> >> > > > > Still doctors want to move to CA!

> >> > > > >> >> > > > > -----------------------> >> > > > > To avoid getting in trouble with Medicare's " most> >> favored "

> >> > clause, I> >> > > > > would keep per visit charge same for all new visit> >> and one same> >> > charge> >> > > > > for all f/ups and then give 40-60% discount for PATOS

> >> ...... so,> >> > > > > 99201-99205 are all charged $500 and there is 80%> >> PATOS discount> >> > > > > ........... 99211-99215 are all $400 and with 80% PATOS

> >> > discount, pt> >> > > > > pays $80> >> > > > >> >> > > > > One key thing in retainer model is to not allow> >> unlimited number of

> >> > > > > visits ....... once you cover unlimited number of> >> visits, you are> >> > > > > assuming an unknown risk and it makes you insurance> >> and Ins Co

> >> > could> >> > > > > complaint agaisnt you to the insurance board etc> >> .......... it> >> > will be> >> > > > > fine if you say that yearly retainer charge covers

> >> 500 (yes, five> >> > > > > hundreds) visits a year ...... but there has to be a> >> finite number> >> > > > >> >> > > > > see doctorsh blog for one such model

> >> > > > >> >> > > > >> >> > > >> >> > >> >> >> >> >> >>> >>> >>

> >>> >> --> >> M.D.> >> www.elainemd.com <http://www.elainemd.com>

> <http://www.elainemd.com>>> >> Office: > >> Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've

> >> imagined.> >> This email transmission may contain protected and privileged,> >> highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information> >> (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only

> >> for the use of the individual or entity named above.> >>> >>> >>> >> If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may> >> not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute

> >> it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have> >> received this transmission in error, please notify the sender> >> immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email

> >> in error.> >> >> >>>>

-- M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.

This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above.

 If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error.

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...