Guest guest Posted August 16, 2010 Report Posted August 16, 2010 There are actually four ways in which having a name for "what's wrong with me" had helped. One is that simply knowing I have a neurological condition and it's not my fault has made it easier to accept my particular pattern of assets and deficits (and it finally "makes sense".) Not as an excuse, but as this is how I am, where do we go from here?Finding other people with AS has been very helpful. Sometimes, I will admit, our conversation deteriorates into "Why NT's just don't get it," but I think after decades of being the one who didn't fit in or measure up, a limited amount of this is healing. But more often relationships with other aspies have been a source of support and help. Selecting interventions and self-help books has also become much more targeted once I know what I am dealing with, including prioritizing what is necessary to change and what is better accommodated - as with child-rearing, choosing your battles is crucial.And finally, recognizing AS in myself and others has made me more accepting of people as individuals. I now know that when I fall apart because there is too much noise, I am not being self-indulgent or "difficult" - that's just the way my nervous system is. In the same way, maybe the kid who throws a fit because a disliked food is on her plate is not spoiled or bratty, but actually has a very sensitive sense of smell and is acutely uncomfortable. Even adults may be doing the best they can with what they have and are!So altogether, although having AS per se is a mixed bag, knowing that's what I have is a definite plus.To: aspires-relationships From: alwaysbe3@...Date: Mon, 16 Aug 2010 14:17:50 +0000Subject: How has knowing helped For those of you with AS, how has knowing helped you? I realize everyone's situation is different, but I'm realy curious. How has it mattered at home and work? Was it a good effect or bad one? Thanks - Quote
Guest guest Posted August 16, 2010 Report Posted August 16, 2010 On the positive side knowing I have AS has helped me make sense of why so much of life seems difficult when at first glance there's no reason why it should be for me. Sometimes it has made relationships easier or at least understandable. The big negative for me though is that it has become a lable which gets thrown around during arguments with my NT partner. One that never fails to rile me as it's used pejoratively. Tony > > For those of you with AS, how has knowing helped you? > > I realize everyone's situation is different, but I'm realy curious. How has it mattered at home and work? Was it a good effect or bad one? > > Thanks - > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 16, 2010 Report Posted August 16, 2010 Oh, it's helped me tremendously! I was diagnosed quite unexpectedly last year at the age of 67, and since then, now that I know what I am, I'm proud to be different and happy to find there are other Aspies who think like me and to discover we can communicate so much more easily and naturally than with NTs. I used to think I ought to put more effort into conforming and changing myself to be like others, but now I don't care. Trying to do that won't work and in any case I now know that it's much better to simply be myself. Besides blowing away all the pressure I used to put on myself to try and conform to societal norms, it explains so much about the way I've reacted to life in the past. Logic and reason take precedence over whimsical desires, I'm shy amongst groups of strangers, I'm unforgiving and hold long term grudges against people who have knowingly wronged me in the past. I now know that these and and a few other quirks I see in myself are all common Aspie traits, so there's no point in worrying about them any more. So all things considered, my diagnosis has been great news! ---- How has knowing helped For those of you with AS, how has knowing helped you? I realize everyone's situation is different, but I'm realy curious. How has it mattered at home and work? Was it a good effect or bad one? Thanks - Quote
Guest guest Posted August 16, 2010 Report Posted August 16, 2010 How has knowing helped For those of you with AS, how has knowing helped you?I realize everyone's situation is different, but I'm realy curious. How has it mattered at home and work? Was it a good effect or bad one?Thanks - , It has helped in understanding and explaining many of my life's difficulties. Why I have always been on the outside looking in, even when I managed to fake it well enough that other people accepted me, I still knew I didn't really belong there. It has helped in that I have been able to study and learn what is NT behavior/reactions and thus gain some measure of understanding as to why people are doing what they are doing. That has given me some peace because I no longer feel like everyone knows what is going on but me. It has helped give me peace in that I know that I am not crazy, I am not stupid, I am just different. I have been able to see that I have skills other people do NOT have, even while I have to work at skills other people think should be 'duh' things. It has helped me work on things like my body language which has enabled me to go to the grocery store without people treating me like I am invisible. I no longer get run into or cut off, which is nice. Also because I learned about AS I learned about facial expression/body language and am now able to see more of what people are saying and can more easily detect things like lying, which is very useful. On the negative side in general I don't recommend telling others about having AS. Most people have a negative response. Even if on the surface they have a positive reaction they generally end up somewhat touchy and pull back from relationship, even if they liked me fine up to that point. Some of them get over it after awhile and things are fine but frankly it's just a lot of work and not really worth it most of the time, I feel like I am on trial. Also for me a negative is that even when I do tell people they often do not believe me and seem to think that I am just looking for an excuse rather than just 'sucking it up' and being normal. That's the price of being borderline and more able to assimilate. The harder you work and the more normal you appear the more people expect and demand regardless if they know you are AS or not. In general people are not accepting of differences. It's also a negative to know there are certain parts of me that really aren't fixable. I can over ride them, work around them, hide them but they aren't going away. Jennie AS Quote
Guest guest Posted August 16, 2010 Report Posted August 16, 2010 lisamc8898 wrote: > For those of you with AS, how has knowing helped you? > > I realize everyone's situation is different, but I'm realy curious. > How has it mattered at home and work? Was it a good effect or bad > one? > > Thanks - Please, not " with " AS. Rather: *recognized as being* AS. That's the reality, however else the majority NT population chooses to view it. Rather than repeat what others have said already, I'll " second " , and Jennie whose stories seem most like my own. *Knowing* ( formal; five years ago) there are others like me has been nothing but a Positive experience. It saved my 40-year marriage - literally - as well as helping confirm to us both that my 68-yo wife is on the spectrum as well. And my mother, one son, daughter?, grandson and probably a great-grandson. - Bill, AS, 78; ...since evaluation NO downside. -- WD " Bill " Loughman - Berkeley, California USA http://home.earthlink.net/~wdloughman/wdl.htm Quote
Guest guest Posted August 16, 2010 Report Posted August 16, 2010 Being an NT in a home with an AS spouse & teen – I can see that our “knowing” has made an enormous difference. It gives us language & patience for the chasms we cross to reach each other. Hadassah From: aspires-relationships [mailto:aspires-relationships ] On Behalf Of WD Loughman Sent: Monday, August 16, 2010 11:57 AM To: aspires-relationships Subject: Re: How has knowing helped lisamc8898 wrote: > For those of you with AS, how has knowing helped you? > > I realize everyone's situation is different, but I'm realy curious. > How has it mattered at home and work? Was it a good effect or bad > one? > > Thanks - Please, not " with " AS. Rather: *recognized as being* AS. That's the reality, however else the majority NT population chooses to view it. Rather than repeat what others have said already, I'll " second " , and Jennie whose stories seem most like my own. *Knowing* ( formal; five years ago) there are others like me has been nothing but a Positive experience. It saved my 40-year marriage - literally - as well as helping confirm to us both that my 68-yo wife is on the spectrum as well. And my mother, one son, daughter?, grandson and probably a great-grandson. - Bill, AS, 78; ...since evaluation NO downside. -- WD " Bill " Loughman - Berkeley, California USA http://home.earthlink.net/~wdloughman/wdl.htm Quote
Guest guest Posted August 16, 2010 Report Posted August 16, 2010 > On the negative side in general I don't recommend telling others > about having AS. Most people have a negative response. Hmmm... that's the opposite to what I've experienced. For the first three or four months after I was diagnosed last year, I was quite afraid of what reaction I would get if I told my few friends and acquaintances. I'm isolated enough as it is, and didn't want to risk losing any of them. So I kept it very quiet at first, but then as my confidence grew, I risked trying it out on one of them. I was surprised how positive a reaction I got. They simply pointed out how everyone is very different anyway, and how the world is far from perfect, so many people have issues of one sort or another. They argued that I wasn't any more eccentric than most; the only difference really being that my eccentricity now has a name to it! They were very happy to talk about the whole thing with me and after a few days came up with a newspaper cutting they'd just discovered about AS, following our talk. That gave me confidence to try telling others, and each time, I got positive reactions from them. > Even if on the surface they have a positive reaction > they generally end up somewhat touchy and pull back > from relationship, even if they liked me fine up to that > point. No, that hasn't been my experience at all. Either you and I must have different kinds of friends and acquaintances, or perhaps it could be something to do with the way I explained it to them. I did, I admit, deliberately explain it in a positive light, saying how much better I felt for knowing what I am, and how proud I am to be in the same category as Mozart and Einstein! They could almost feel jealousy that I had it and they didn't !! > Some of them get over it after awhile and > things are fine but frankly it's just a lot of work and not really > worth it most of the time, I feel like I am on trial. From my point of view it, telling others about what I have lifts a big burden off my shoulders because I no longer have to try to pretend to be something different to what I really am with them. I can simply be myself. When I say or do something odd in front of them I can now easily laugh it off and put it down to being an Aspie trait. > Also for me a negative is that even when I do tell people they > often do not believe me and seem to think that I am just > looking for an excuse rather than just 'sucking it up' > and being normal. Maybe the difference between you and me here is that I have discarded all attempts to appear normal. I don't even wish to be " normal " . The more eccentric I appear, the more I'm being myself, and that's all that matters, > That's the price of being borderline and more able to > assimilate. The harder you work, and the more normal you appear > the more people expect and demand regardless if they know you > are AS or not. I'd say you sound as if you're succumbing to peer pressure there. My attitude is " why would I want to be normal? " Normal mostly means following the rest as if I was just another sheep in the flock, and that's the last thing I want to be. Much better to start off by admitting to everyone that I'm not normal, and don't even want to be normal. That gives me license to do and be anything I want. > In general people are not accepting of differences. They accept people with obvious abnormalities like no legs or blind or deaf, or a gaga-looking face. I think the more we admit openly to our abnormalities, the more understanding others will be. The biggest problem comes when we try to hide our abnormalities and the others start to think we might be in the same rat race that they're stuck in. Quote
Guest guest Posted August 17, 2010 Report Posted August 17, 2010 , I'm glad your experience with people has been better than mine. I think that part of my problem is that just being 'me' isn't eccentric enough to explain AS to folk. What I mean is I am naturally just over the line from normal. You see, just odd enough to be the weirdo but not odd enough for them to really believe I have AS. I don't know if that's because I have coped over the years before I learned about AS but at this point it's who I am. I don't have some of the typical visible AS traits like stimming, for example. All of that seems to be naturally internalized so people do not see my anxiety attacks or repetitive stuff, it all goes on like a movie in my head. Rather I have things like high intelligence and lacking social grace & tact so people think, "how rude". I still, even with as much as I have learned, tend to assume that the things that are obvious and clear to me are there for all to see, I have yet to figured out on an instictive level that just because it's as clear as black and white to me does not mean anyone else noticed it at all so it's best to keep ones mouth shut because you can't prove what a sunset looks like to a person born blind and if they have no faith that you can see it then..... But reality is, part of my problem is the people I am around. The person who accused me of using AS as an excuse was my mother. Hard to get away from ones own mother. Ironically my mother is likely AS herself, just has her head deeply embedded in sand. She really has spent her life worrying about what people think and come to think of it in the past I did too. I *think* I have moved beyond that at this point but you may be right, I may still have some of that. I'll have to think on it for a while. :-) My issues are also not just AS I am also stuck between worlds because I grew up in a cult- like religion and have a really hard time fitting in to regular society for that reason as well as the AS and sometimes struggle to be able to tell the difference. I have a hard time knowing what is an AS issue and what is stemming from the cultish backgroun. So I have more than one thing going on at the same time. Also many of those people from my childhood are still in my life so many of the negative experiences I have had are from those people. Jennie AS Re: How has knowing helped > On the negative side in general I don't recommend telling others> about having AS. Most people have a negative response.Hmmm... that's the opposite to what I've experienced. For the first three or four months after I was diagnosed last year, I was quite afraid of what reaction I would get if I told my few friends and acquaintances. I'm isolated enough as it is, and didn't want to risk losing any of them. So I kept it very quiet at first, but then as my confidence grew, I risked trying it out on one of them. I was surprised how positive a reaction I got. They simply pointed out how everyone is very different anyway, and how the world is far from perfect, so many people have issues of one sort or another. They argued that I wasn't any more eccentric than most; the only difference really being that my eccentricity now has a name to it! They were very happy to talk about the whole thing with me and after a few days came up with a newspaper cutting they'd just discovered about AS, following our talk. That gave me confidence to try telling others, and each time, I got positive reactions from them.> Even if on the surface they have a positive reaction> they generally end up somewhat touchy and pull back> from relationship, even if they liked me fine up to that> point.No, that hasn't been my experience at all. Either you and I must have different kinds of friends and acquaintances, or perhaps it could be something to do with the way I explained it to them. I did, I admit, deliberately explain it in a positive light, saying how much better I felt for knowing what I am, and how proud I am to be in the same category as Mozart and Einstein! They could almost feel jealousy that I had it and they didn't !!> Some of them get over it after awhile and> things are fine but frankly it's just a lot of work and not really> worth it most of the time, I feel like I am on trial.From my point of view it, telling others about what I have lifts a big burden off my shoulders because I no longer have to try to pretend to be something different to what I really am with them. I can simply be myself. When I say or do something odd in front of them I can now easily laugh it off and put it down to being an Aspie trait.> Also for me a negative is that even when I do tell people they> often do not believe me and seem to think that I am just> looking for an excuse rather than just 'sucking it up'> and being normal.Maybe the difference between you and me here is that I have discarded all attempts to appear normal. I don't even wish to be "normal". The more eccentric I appear, the more I'm being myself, and that's all that matters,> That's the price of being borderline and more able to> assimilate. The harder you work, and the more normal you appear> the more people expect and demand regardless if they know you> are AS or not.I'd say you sound as if you're succumbing to peer pressure there. My attitude is "why would I want to be normal?" Normal mostly means following the rest as if I was just another sheep in the flock, and that's the last thing I want to be. Much better to start off by admitting to everyone that I'm not normal, and don't even want to be normal. That gives me license to do and be anything I want.> In general people are not accepting of differences.They accept people with obvious abnormalities like no legs or blind or deaf, or a gaga-looking face. I think the more we admit openly to our abnormalities, the more understanding others will be. The biggest problem comes when we try to hide our abnormalities and the others start to think we might be in the same rat race that they're stuck in. Quote
Guest guest Posted August 17, 2010 Report Posted August 17, 2010 Newland wrote: > / Please, not " with " AS. Rather: *recognized as being* AS. That's the > reality, however else the majority NT population chooses to view it. > > Rather than repeat what others have said already, I'll " second " , > and Jennie whose stories seem most like my own. *Knowing* ( > formal; five years ago) there are others like me has been nothing but a > Positive experience.It saved my 40-year marriage - literally - as well > as helping confirm to us both that my 68-yo wife is on the spectrum > as well. And my mother, one son, daughter?, grandson and probably > a great-grandson. > > - Bill, AS, 78; ...since evaluation NO downside. / > Bill: would you not agree that the dynamics of a NS/AS marriage are > different with different challenges? I applaud your success. Thank you. I think the dynamics of ANY marriage change with time, and " challenges " of any kind change the dynamics even faster than if there were none. Whether AS *in and of itself* speeds that change more than might occur in marriages without it, I'm no longer prepared to say. I am prepared to say the more partners know, really *know* about each other and their relationship, the easier it is to find solutions to problems. Trite enough, but true: Knowledge is power. In that regard I'm beginning to believe that the anecdotal " evidence " we read in books and online forums about AS/NT/NS marriages isn't good enough to make a very firm case " against " AS. That is, other than there being " out there " a lot of unhappy people in a lot of unhappy marriages. Would you agree that's a supportable statement? With or without AS? - Bill, AS -- WD " Bill " Loughman - Berkeley, California USA http://home.earthlink.net/~wdloughman/wdl.htm Quote
Guest guest Posted August 17, 2010 Report Posted August 17, 2010 Up past your bedtime again, heh? <wicked grin> Newland wrote: > / In that regard I'm beginning to believe that the anecdotal " evidence " > we read in books and online forums about AS/NT/NS marriages isn't good > enough to make a very firm case " against " AS. That is, other than there > being " out there " a lot of unhappy people in a lot of unhappy marriages. > > Would you agree that's a supportable statement? With or without AS? > > - Bill, AS / > / / > I would and I wouldn't. I think it depends on " how " AS is expressed in > the individual. There is only one research study on AS/NT relationships > out of Australia where the results are soon to be released and it will > be interesting to see what they are. There are too many factors to > consider to say yeah or nay. Would you not agree? Agree of course -- provisionally. > The best thing I learned from growing up in a family with AS and > marrying it was to differentiate myself and not get caught up, enmeshed > or inducted into " their " drama. Not that NS people don't do this as > Personality Disorders are considered the drama queens of the DSM. I did > this as a safety technique and who knew it would be a survival technique > for being a good counselor? The minute a family member differentiates, > the family dynamics shift like a mobile hanging over a babies cribs. The > power struggle shifts when one member gets more healthy and strong. I'd agree with that. And add: Which direction and *to what effect* it shifts seems to me the critical issue. IF it shifts only to the benefit/advantage of *one* person growing " more healthy and strong " , THEN that surely can hurt a relationship. But... IF, in the process of " growing more healthy... " , that person grows *more able to help* the other(s),... and IF that one player *does it*, THEN the relationship as a whole might improve. The shifting dynamic becomes a benefit for all. ...An advantage, not a detriment. This is the meaning behind what I've so often said: It Takes *Two* to Tango. In any relationship, not just AS/NS/NT/... Always two, unless one of a couple is both incredibly savvy and inhumanly empathetic, compassionate and selfless. Even then, sometimes the best answer is splitsville. IMO. - Bill, AS -- WD " Bill " Loughman - Berkeley, California USA http://home.earthlink.net/~wdloughman/wdl.htm Quote
Guest guest Posted August 17, 2010 Report Posted August 17, 2010 WD Loughman wrote... ....an incomplete phrase -- complete one's below. > This is the meaning behind what I've so often said: It Takes *Two* to > Tango. In any relationship, not just AS/NS/NT/... > Always two, unless one of a couple is both incredibly savvy and > inhumanly empathetic, compassionate and selfless. Even then, sometimes > the best answer is splitsville. IMO. ....sometimes the best answer _for both_ is splitsville. - Bill, AS -- WD " Bill " Loughman - Berkeley, California USA http://home.earthlink.net/~wdloughman/wdl.htm Quote
Guest guest Posted August 17, 2010 Report Posted August 17, 2010 Subject: Re: How has knowing helped > said: The best thing I learned from growing up in a family with AS and> marrying it was to differentiate myself and not get caught up, enmeshed> or inducted into "their" drama. Not that NS people don't do this as> Personality Disorders are considered the drama queens of the DSM. I did> this as a safety technique and who knew it would be a survival technique> for being a good counselor? The minute a family member differentiates,> the family dynamics shift like a mobile hanging over a babies cribs. The> power struggle shifts when one member gets more healthy and strong.Bill said: I'd agree with that. And add: Which direction and *to what effect* it shifts seems to me the critical issue.IF it shifts only to the benefit/advantage of *one* person growing "more healthy and strong", THEN that surely can hurt a relationship.But...IF, in the process of "growing more healthy...", that person grows *more able to help* the other(s),...and IF that one player *does it*, THEN the relationship as a whole might improve. The shifting dynamic becomes a benefit for all. ...An advantage, not a detriment. Jennie: Sometimes in the process of growing more healthy things shift to where it becomes MORE crushing on the healthy person. The person becomes more healthy but the unhealthy person objects to this and increases their bad behaviors in an effort to make the person getting healthy to return to their previous state of codependant unhealthy behavior. Jennie AS Quote
Guest guest Posted August 17, 2010 Report Posted August 17, 2010 In addition to, or perhaps just rewording 's question below, I am wondering if the average person does not have the ability to remain healthy AND help someone so deeply emeshed in their lack of health? Jennie AS How has knowing helped IF, in the process of "growing more healthy...", that person grows *more able to help* the other(s),... and IF that one player *does it*, THEN the relationship as a whole might improve. The shifting dynamic becomes a benefit for all. ...An advantage, not a detriment. Bill: "WHY" should that person be placed in a "care giving" mode?" That is a lot of responsibility and is it healthy for the care giver? Many professionals will say no, as it can suck the life out of the one providing support when they are a family member. Some times support is better provided out side the family. That way each party has the opportunity to work on their own stuff and they become unmeshed. Just me. Quote
Guest guest Posted August 17, 2010 Report Posted August 17, 2010 Newland wrote: > / IF, in the process of " growing more healthy... " , that person grows > *more able to help* the other(s),... and IF that one player *does it*, > THEN the relationship as a whole might improve. The shifting dynamic > becomes a benefit for all. ...An advantage, not a detriment. / > / / > Bill: " WHY " should that person be placed in a " care giving " mode? " That > is a lot of responsibility and is it healthy for the care giver? Many Please re-read: " and IF that one player *does it*, THEN the relationship as a whole might improve. " Nothing dictates " one player " MUST " do it " . Nothing " requires " the relationship to improve. My premise is/was that at least one person, one player, *wants* joint improvement - not merely personal improvement. > professionals will say no, as it can suck the life out of the one > providing support when they are a family member. Some times support is > better provided out side the family. That way each party has the > opportunity to work on */their/* own stuff and they become unmeshed. I don't have a quarrel with any of that. Still, there are many more ways to become " unmeshed " than working alone. And " unmeshed " sometimes isn't what's wanted. - Bill, AS -- WD " Bill " Loughman - Berkeley, California USA http://home.earthlink.net/~wdloughman/wdl.htm Quote
Guest guest Posted August 18, 2010 Report Posted August 18, 2010 Jennie Unknown wrote: > *Subject:* Re: How has knowing helped > > said: The best thing I learned from growing up in a family > > with AS and marrying it was to differentiate myself and not get > > caught up, enmeshed or inducted into " their " drama. [ snip ] > Bill said: I'd agree with that. And add: Which direction and *to > what effect* it shifts seems to me the critical issue. > IF it shifts only to the benefit/advantage of *one* person growing > " more healthy and strong " , THEN that surely can hurt a relationship. > But... > IF, in the process of " growing more healthy... " , that person grows > *more able to help* the other(s),... > and IF that one player *does it*, THEN the relationship as a whole > might improve. The shifting dynamic becomes a benefit for all. ...An > advantage, not a detriment. > > Jennie: Sometimes in the process of growing more healthy things > shift to where it becomes MORE crushing on the healthy person. The > person becomes more healthy but the unhealthy person objects to this > and increases their bad behaviors in an effort to make the person > getting healthy to return to their previous state of codependant > unhealthy behavior. > > Jennie AS Agreed; it happens. Not so easy to see it coming, either. And it results in a return to the old " unhealthy " relationship. [Or maybe, sometimes, its dissolution.] Isn't that the everyday fare, the meat-and-potatoes, of ASPIRES? Unhealthy relationships looking for " healthy " solutions? NB: The focus here is unhealthy relationships involving at least one AS. But the *relationship* is composed of *TWO* (or more) people, and it cannot be called healthy unless *BOTH* people are " healthy " . For a " healthy " relationship to survive, BOTH people - TWO people - must be healthy at the same time. That isn't a sufficient condition for relationship survival; it *is necessary*. - Bill, AS -- WD " Bill " Loughman - Berkeley, California USA http://home.earthlink.net/~wdloughman/wdl.htm Quote
Guest guest Posted August 18, 2010 Report Posted August 18, 2010 Jennie Unknown wrote: > In addition to, or perhaps just rewording 's question below, I am > wondering if the average person does not have the ability to remain > healthy AND help someone so deeply emeshed in their lack of health? > Jennie AS Dunno. I believe many people under duress may find reserves of strength *they* never knew they had. I believe that most people (average?) are smarter and more capable than *we* credit them. So *I've* lost confidence in my own ability to judge what " average person " means to most people. ...And in my ability to judge the capacities of the average person. - Bill, AS > > * How has knowing helped > > / IF, in the process of " growing more healthy... " , that person grows > *more able to help* the other(s),... and IF that one player *does > it*, THEN the relationship as a whole might improve. The shifting > dynamic becomes a benefit for all. ...An advantage, not a detriment. / > / / > Bill: " WHY " should that person be placed in a " care giving " mode? " > That is a lot of responsibility and is it healthy for the care > giver? Many professionals will say no, as it can suck the life out > of the one providing support when they are a family member. Some > times support is better provided out side the family. That way each > party has the opportunity to work on */their/* own stuff and they > become unmeshed. > Just me. > -- WD " Bill " Loughman - Berkeley, California USA http://home.earthlink.net/~wdloughman/wdl.htm Quote
Guest guest Posted August 18, 2010 Report Posted August 18, 2010 Good point. History does show this over and over. In times of great stress, whether it be war, famine, or what have you people rise above and beyond to do what people uninvolved consider heroic and amazing. Those people consistently will say they aren't anyone special they just did what needed to be done. This must also be possible on a relational level. Jennie AS Re: How has knowing helped Jennie Unknown wrote:> In addition to, or perhaps just rewording 's question below, I am> wondering if the average person does not have the ability to remain> healthy AND help someone so deeply emeshed in their lack of health?> Jennie ASDunno.I believe many people under duress may find reserves of strength *they* never knew they had. I believe that most people (average?) are smarter and more capable than *we* credit them.So *I've* lost confidence in my own ability to judge what "average person" means to most people. ...And in my ability to judge the capacities of the average person.- Bill, AS Quote
Guest guest Posted August 18, 2010 Report Posted August 18, 2010 > For those of you with AS, how has knowing helped you? > > I realize everyone's situation is different, but I'm realy curious. How has it mattered at home and work? Was it a good effect or bad one? > > Thanks - I'm traveling with my family, and haven't had time to answer until now. I realized I'm Aspie when I was trying to figure out what was up with my then 3 year old daughter. (She's almost 15 now.) She didn't have AS, but I saw myself in the symptom lists. Honestly, it was a relief to find out. There were others with brains like mine! AS filled in the missing pieces about why I thought and responded the way I did, and helped my put my childhood troubles in perspective. I was able to label and categorize my weak points, and even better, explain them to others. I haven't worked outside the home since I found the label, but I think my method of rearing my children has been vastly changed by my awareness. I've made sure they weren't caught by the same traps I was, and have the tools I wish I had when I was growing up. And it has made a difference -- my daughter, who isn't Aspie but has some Spectrum thing we're calling PDD-NOS, has a deep understanding of herself and is able to see and compensate for her own weak areas. I'm hoping my husband, who was just diagnosed a few months ago, has as many positives as I've had. --Liz ------------ The Aspie Parent blog: http://aspergersparent.wordpress.com/ SF, science, and Gifted Ed butons, mugs, and other items at http://www.zazzle.com/CartesianBear* Higher Quality Adult & kid shirts at http://www.printfection.com/cartesianbear Quote
Guest guest Posted August 20, 2010 Report Posted August 20, 2010 Hi Bill, and Jennie, I'm coming in on the end of this discussion so I may be missing some vital things here, though I will say that this particular sub-discussion certainly pushed buttons for me. I'm guessing that what's being addressed here is a case of one person who is dysfunctional, and is dependent upon another person who is functional. I'll leave AS out of the equation here entirely, as I've come to conclusion that often times, when we are talking purely about dysfunction, AS is extraneous to the issue. I think folks have choices, and if they choose not to " get it " then it doesn't matter what the label is, does it? And I, as a spectrum person, use the word " choose " accurately. Yeah, some spectrum folks claim they can't " get it " and their non spectrum spouses cling to that excuse too. But it's more likely that the person, spectrum or non spectrum who is not " getting it " is protecting something that they don't want to give up, and their last line of defense is to (drum roll please) not " get it. " That avoids all kinds of unpleasantness ... for the short term. I will say from my own experience, that while yeah, a " one man band " (or one woman band) can carry the show for a long time, eventually something is going to give. I've said it over the years on this list, that " something " is intimacy, and that's pretty well an irrevocable loss when it's gone. While you can fake all kinds of things till you make it, intimacy ain't one of them. Also, while I didn't hear the word " compromise " being brought up in relation to this discussion, that is what the healthy person is often being asked to do. In my experience compromise DOES NOT WORK. The person who is the most capable of giving ground is generally the one who gives 100% and the other person gives nothing, and merrily goes on doing/not doing exactly as they did before. You either go 100% of the way for each other, or go home. THAT is love. Folks can argue semantics all they want, but without this basic willingness on both sides, while on the surface of it it may appear the couple is rock solid and things will go on indefinitely as they are, trust me, they won't. Maybe when Bill was talking about folks under duress finding reserves that they didn't know they had, maybe he simply means that they find the strength to do what they have to do, and sometimes that means that finally, finally, one partner walks. - Helen > > In addition to, or perhaps just rewording 's question below, I am > > wondering if the average person does not have the ability to remain > > healthy AND help someone so deeply emeshed in their lack of health? > > Jennie AS > > Dunno. > I believe many people under duress may find reserves of strength > *they* never knew they had. I believe that most people (average?) are > smarter and more capable than *we* credit them. > So *I've* lost confidence in my own ability to judge what " average > person " means to most people. ...And in my ability to judge the > capacities of the average person. > > - Bill, AS > > > > > * How has knowing helped > > > > / IF, in the process of " growing more healthy... " , that person grows > > *more able to help* the other(s),... and IF that one player *does > > it*, THEN the relationship as a whole might improve. The shifting > > dynamic becomes a benefit for all. ...An advantage, not a detriment. / > > / / > > Bill: " WHY " should that person be placed in a " care giving " mode? " > > That is a lot of responsibility and is it healthy for the care > > giver? Many professionals will say no, as it can suck the life out > > of the one providing support when they are a family member. Some > > times support is better provided out side the family. That way each > > party has the opportunity to work on */their/* own stuff and they > > become unmeshed. > > Just me. > > > > -- > WD " Bill " Loughman - Berkeley, California USA > http://home.earthlink.net/~wdloughman/wdl.htm > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 20, 2010 Report Posted August 20, 2010 Most excellent post, Helen. Definitely an insight that is usually born of experience (and perhaps a 12 step group or two). Not to mention the ability to step back and recognize that these problems are not unique to AS folks by any means. One question for you.... hfoisyca wrote: << I think folks have choices, and if they choose not to " get it " then it doesn't matter what the label is, does it? And I, as a spectrum person, use the word " choose " accurately. Yeah, some spectrum folks claim they can't " get it " and their non spectrum spouses cling to that excuse too. But it's more likely that the person, spectrum or non spectrum who is not " getting it " is protecting something that they don't want to give up, and their last line of defense is to (drum roll please) not " get it. " That avoids all kinds of unpleasantness ... for the short term. >> How does fear/unreadiness (on the part of the dysfunctional person) for change temper the above statements for you? IOW, the dysfunctional person may not be far enough along in their recovery/self-awareness/whatever to make a constructive choice at the point in time when their partner needs it most. The couple's pace for healing and moving forward together is out-of-step at that particular time in their journey. When my husband was alive, we struggled with a mismatched pace (not to mention expectations) on a good many occasions and on both sides. Was one (or both) of us choosing to not " get it " ? Was one (or both) of us making excuses? Or were we both muddling through life as best we could manage at the time, albeit with a less than optimal effort on one (or both) of our parts? I'm curious as to how you factor mismatched expectations with respect to pace and timing into your equation. Please be honest. You won't hurt my feelings. Really. Best, ~CJ Quote
Guest guest Posted August 20, 2010 Report Posted August 20, 2010 Hi Helen, As usual, you say exactly what I need to hear when I need to hear it. My own band is at that ‘something is going to give’ point, and I am struggling with the difficulty and grief of letting go. Any more light you can shed on your thoughts here is so welcome. Thank you! Cheryl From: aspires-relationships [mailto:aspires-relationships ] On Behalf Of hfoisyca Sent: Thursday, August 19, 2010 10:11 PM To: aspires-relationships Subject: Re: How has knowing helped Hi Bill, and Jennie, I'm coming in on the end of this discussion so I may be missing some vital things here, though I will say that this particular sub-discussion certainly pushed buttons for me. I'm guessing that what's being addressed here is a case of one person who is dysfunctional, and is dependent upon another person who is functional. I'll leave AS out of the equation here entirely, as I've come to conclusion that often times, when we are talking purely about dysfunction, AS is extraneous to the issue. I think folks have choices, and if they choose not to " get it " then it doesn't matter what the label is, does it? And I, as a spectrum person, use the word " choose " accurately. Yeah, some spectrum folks claim they can't " get it " and their non spectrum spouses cling to that excuse too. But it's more likely that the person, spectrum or non spectrum who is not " getting it " is protecting something that they don't want to give up, and their last line of defense is to (drum roll please) not " get it. " That avoids all kinds of unpleasantness ... for the short term. I will say from my own experience, that while yeah, a " one man band " (or one woman band) can carry the show for a long time, eventually something is going to give. I've said it over the years on this list, that " something " is intimacy, and that's pretty well an irrevocable loss when it's gone. While you can fake all kinds of things till you make it, intimacy ain't one of them. Also, while I didn't hear the word " compromise " being brought up in relation to this discussion, that is what the healthy person is often being asked to do. In my experience compromise DOES NOT WORK. The person who is the most capable of giving ground is generally the one who gives 100% and the other person gives nothing, and merrily goes on doing/not doing exactly as they did before. You either go 100% of the way for each other, or go home. THAT is love. Folks can argue semantics all they want, but without this basic willingness on both sides, while on the surface of it it may appear the couple is rock solid and things will go on indefinitely as they are, trust me, they won't. Maybe when Bill was talking about folks under duress finding reserves that they didn't know they had, maybe he simply means that they find the strength to do what they have to do, and sometimes that means that finally, finally, one partner walks. - Helen > > In addition to, or perhaps just rewording 's question below, I am > > wondering if the average person does not have the ability to remain > > healthy AND help someone so deeply emeshed in their lack of health? > > Jennie AS > > Dunno. > I believe many people under duress may find reserves of strength > *they* never knew they had. I believe that most people (average?) are > smarter and more capable than *we* credit them. > So *I've* lost confidence in my own ability to judge what " average > person " means to most people. ...And in my ability to judge the > capacities of the average person. > > - Bill, AS > > > > > * How has knowing helped > > > > / IF, in the process of " growing more healthy... " , that person grows > > *more able to help* the other(s),... and IF that one player *does > > it*, THEN the relationship as a whole might improve. The shifting > > dynamic becomes a benefit for all. ...An advantage, not a detriment. / > > / / > > Bill: " WHY " should that person be placed in a " care giving " mode? " > > That is a lot of responsibility and is it healthy for the care > > giver? Many professionals will say no, as it can suck the life out > > of the one providing support when they are a family member. Some > > times support is better provided out side the family. That way each > > party has the opportunity to work on */their/* own stuff and they > > become unmeshed. > > Just me. > > > > -- > WD " Bill " Loughman - Berkeley, California USA > http://home.earthlink.net/~wdloughman/wdl.htm > No virus found in this incoming message. Checked by AVG - www.avg.com Version: 9.0.851 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/3082 - Release Date: 08/19/10 12:35:00 Quote
Guest guest Posted August 20, 2010 Report Posted August 20, 2010 Hi CJ, I wrote a reply to a post three weeks ago that I haven't shared here yet, and that may partially answer your question, though not completely. I'm going to post it now. I want to re-read your questions and give them more thought, as in your case, obviously the unwellness of one partner (your spouse) led to a tragic outcome. However, I've said this before to you and I will say it again right now: I still think you are owning that when you shouldn't. cyber hugs, Helen > > << I think folks have choices, and if they choose not to " get it " then > it doesn't matter what the label is, does it? And I, as a spectrum > person, use the word " choose " accurately. Yeah, some spectrum folks > claim they can't " get it " and their non spectrum spouses cling to that > excuse too. But it's more likely that the person, spectrum or non > spectrum who is not " getting it " is protecting something that they don't > want to give up, and their last line of defense is to (drum roll please) > not " get it. " That avoids all kinds of unpleasantness ... for the short > term. >> > > How does fear/unreadiness (on the part of the dysfunctional person) for > change temper the above statements for you? > > IOW, the dysfunctional person may not be far enough along in their > recovery/self-awareness/whatever to make a constructive choice at the > point in time when their partner needs it most. The couple's pace for > healing and moving forward together is out-of-step at that particular > time in their journey. > > When my husband was alive, we struggled with a mismatched pace (not to > mention expectations) on a good many occasions and on both sides. > > Was one (or both) of us choosing to not " get it " ? > Was one (or both) of us making excuses? > Or were we both muddling through life as best we could manage at the > time, albeit with a less than optimal effort on one (or both) of our parts? > > I'm curious as to how you factor mismatched expectations with respect to > pace and timing into your equation. > > Please be honest. You won't hurt my feelings. Really. > > Best, > ~CJ > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 20, 2010 Report Posted August 20, 2010 hfoisyca wrote: << I wrote a reply to a post three weeks ago that I haven't shared here yet, and that may partially answer your question, though not completely. I'm going to post it now. >> Great! I look forward to reading it. << I want to re-read your questions and give them more thought, as in your case, obviously the unwellness of one partner (your spouse) led to a tragic outcome. However, I've said this before to you and I will say it again right now: I still think you are owning that when you shouldn't. >> Try not to think of me when you reply to the questions, as that could color your response. Best, ~CJ Quote
Guest guest Posted August 20, 2010 Report Posted August 20, 2010 Hi Cheryl, I think the " letting go " point occurs when you are ready for it to? That is highly individual and I would reckon there is no " right " or " wrong " time for this, unless of course, there is abuse. Again, I'm going to leave AS out of the discussion as in all the situations I know of in " real time " it's not a factor. What does seem to be a factor is the lost of trust, care and respect that is vital to keep the relationship alive. AS or no AS, if someone can't make the effort, there's a whole lot of other stuff happening/not happening, and the prognosis for long term relationship survival is poor. You will stay in it for as long as you need to stay for your own survival, and then you will finally leave for your own survival. And then ask yourself why the hell it took you so long. And then answer it in the same breath: self esteem. When your self esteem gets better, you'll find the strength. Unfortunately, as we age and health becomes an issue, it may appear that choices are more and more limited. However, I know personally of a situation where a woman in poor health ended her marriage, and though she still has health challenges, her health has improved considerably over the past decade since she made that choice. I'm not saying that walking is always the answer, but just saying there are still choices although it may not look like it at the time. The other partner can also make choices, and I would say that continued non-action on their part is a pretty clear choice, and an indication of how things are gonna be, so the ball is back in your court. I think we all make excuses for our own behavior and others, eg. (one I heard recently) " He's like that because his father was an alcoholic. " Okay, but this is, like, 2010, people don't live in caves anymore, there is help for that. This is what I mean by choices. - Helen > > Hi Helen, > As usual, you say exactly what I need to hear when I need to hear it. My > own band is at that 'something is going to give' point, and I am struggling > with the difficulty and grief of letting go. > Any more light you can shed on your thoughts here is so welcome. > Thank you! > Cheryl Quote
Guest guest Posted August 20, 2010 Report Posted August 20, 2010 This question strikes a chord with me. Sometimes it feels like " I was or I am not ready to work on that " and " I wasn't able to do that " is just one more thing a partner is supposed to make allowances for. I left an unhappy marriage. It caused me a lot of hurt and regret and still does. I loved my partner and still do, but I will not tolerate being lied to. I was totally prepared to make allowances, but instead of saying " I am not able to do something " or " Or I don't want to do something " he'd assure me that whatever it was was already done, or would happen tomorrow. That's fine if it's not something important, but it's harder to deal with if it's the house payment, or something vital for the kids. We saw counselors, because I insisted. We tried many things, because I made them happen, but in the end I decided that the only way to know what was really happening was to have control of my own life. Own my own home, raise the kids the way I wanted them raised - because I could not rely on anything my husband said. I guess my feeling is that if only you are affected by the way you behave then you can take as much time as you like. My husband knew how I felt but wasn't ready to work on it then. So I left. We both made choices. The divorce was final last year and now, oddly enough, now he's decided he is ready to work on it. I'm not sure whether I am. Quoting CJ : > > Most excellent post, Helen. Definitely an insight that is usually born > of experience (and perhaps a 12 step group or two). > > Not to mention the ability to step back and recognize that these > problems are not unique to AS folks by any means. > > One question for you.... > > > hfoisyca wrote: > > << I think folks have choices, and if they choose not to " get it " then > it doesn't matter what the label is, does it? And I, as a spectrum > person, use the word " choose " accurately. Yeah, some spectrum folks > claim they can't " get it " and their non spectrum spouses cling to that > excuse too. But it's more likely that the person, spectrum or non > spectrum who is not " getting it " is protecting something that they don't > want to give up, and their last line of defense is to (drum roll please) > not " get it. " That avoids all kinds of unpleasantness ... for the short > term. >> > > How does fear/unreadiness (on the part of the dysfunctional person) for > change temper the above statements for you? > > IOW, the dysfunctional person may not be far enough along in their > recovery/self-awareness/whatever to make a constructive choice at the > point in time when their partner needs it most. The couple's pace for > healing and moving forward together is out-of-step at that particular > time in their journey. > > When my husband was alive, we struggled with a mismatched pace (not to > mention expectations) on a good many occasions and on both sides. > > Was one (or both) of us choosing to not " get it " ? > Was one (or both) of us making excuses? > Or were we both muddling through life as best we could manage at the > time, albeit with a less than optimal effort on one (or both) of our parts? > > I'm curious as to how you factor mismatched expectations with respect to > pace and timing into your equation. > > Please be honest. You won't hurt my feelings. Really. > > Best, > ~CJ > > > > > > > ---------------------------------------------------------------- This message was sent using IMP, the Internet Messaging Program. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.