Guest guest Posted August 20, 2010 Report Posted August 20, 2010 hfoisyca wrote: > Hi Bill, and Jennie, I'm coming in on the end of this > discussion so I may be missing some vital things here, though I will > say that this particular sub-discussion certainly pushed buttons for me. [ snip ] Not how it started, but a good enough guess for your comments to be both germane and welcome. [ snip ] > You either go 100% of the way for each other, or go home. You either *BOTH* go 100% of the way for each other (in ANY relationship), or go home (quit the relationship). That's the basic, real meaning of " It takes two to tango " . [ snip ] > Maybe when Bill was talking about folks under duress finding reserves > that they didn't know they had, maybe he simply means that they find > the strength to do what they have to do, ....*whatever* that may be... > and sometimes that means > that finally, finally, one partner walks. - Helen Ah Helen, ...ever perceptive. YES. I said other things too, over 5-6 posts, all to the effect that walking away does not imply they who do the walking are solely the " healthy ones " . Nor that those left behind are solely " unhealthy " . Remember (backdrop to it all, for those new to this list): Steadily over the last five+ years, I've claimed that if/when **both** relationship partners buy into it, really REALLY buy in, AS/NT/NS marital demons *can* be brought to bay. Sadly, but probably it's true, we don't all have the prerequisites for buying in. Which may be part of what Jennie was writing about (below). > >>> In addition to, or perhaps just rewording 's question below, >>> I am wondering if the average person does not have the ability to >>> remain healthy AND help someone so deeply emeshed in their lack >>> of health? Jennie AS >> >> Dunno. I believe many people under duress may find reserves of >> strength *they* never knew they had. I believe that most people >> (average?) are smarter and more capable than *we* credit them. So >> *I've* lost confidence in my own ability to judge what " average >> person " means to most people. ...And in my ability to judge the >> capacities of the average person. >> >> - Bill, AS [ snip ] - Bill, AS; ...twice married, ...great-grand-kids -- WD " Bill " Loughman - Berkeley, California USA http://home.earthlink.net/~wdloughman/wdl.htm Quote
Guest guest Posted August 20, 2010 Report Posted August 20, 2010 Bill Remember (backdrop to it all, for those new to this list): Steadily over the last five+ years, I've claimed that if/when **both** relationship partners buy into it, really REALLY buy in, AS/NT/NS marital demons *can* be brought to bay. The key word here in your words is "both" and that rarely happens in AS or NT relationships as folks develope on different timelines or can grow apart. Sometimes it does and they are the lucky ones. Just me. Quote
Guest guest Posted August 20, 2010 Report Posted August 20, 2010 Newland wrote: << The key word here in your words is " both " and that rarely happens in AS or NT relationships as folks develope on different timelines or can grow apart. >> Yep. That's how my marriage was. Different diagnoses and timing of diagnoses. Different levels of awareness and interpretations of (our own and the other's) behavior. Different expectations of pace and progress of recovery. Different baggage brought to the party that colored all of the above. All fed into judgments, anger, and resentment that eventually tore us apart. Best, ~CJ Quote
Guest guest Posted August 20, 2010 Report Posted August 20, 2010 > How does fear/unreadiness (on the part of the dysfunctional person) for > change temper the above statements for you? Me: You asked me not to think of your situation, so it would not colour my response; fair enough. I thought of other people I have known (and/or still know) who have reduced capacity due to mental illness. > IOW, the dysfunctional person may not be far enough along in their > recovery/self-awareness/whatever to make a constructive choice at the > point in time when their partner needs it most. The couple's pace for > healing and moving forward together is out-of-step at that particular > time in their journey. Me: Thinking about these other folk (not your husband) I realized that each of them still had resources at hand to help them find the way forward. Maybe it was still out of sync with what their partners at the time needed, but over a long period of time (two decades or more) they forged a workable relationship with a partner (usually different from when I knew them when I was young) and also they had learned how to manage their illness responsibly (eg. complying with medication, etc.) That's the case for the majority that I know of. For a small minority, I don't know where they are at anymore because they could not take personal responsibility. With folks like that, I did what I could before I saw that all they were going to LET me do was continue to enable them, and simply engaging them became an act of enabling, so I ended contact. One could also argue that this approach isn't helpful, but I disagree. You have a responsibility to yourself first and foremost, as after all, who else will be responsible for you, if you aren't? Every interaction you have with others takes time for both of you, and if you are simply pouring good money after bad with one individual, why not re-direct that energy where it can do the the most good. > When my husband was alive, we struggled with a mismatched pace (not to > mention expectations) on a good many occasions and on both sides. M: Honestly, CJ, this happens with a LOT of couples who are having problems, and probably some who aren't having problems. Different personalities, different temperaments, different needs - and different baggage. I think there's a certain rare, rare point of maturity where both couples could recognize that, and make it work. (Personally I've not experienced that rare point of maturity myself yet.) It would take a lot of care, respect, trust, selflessness - and love. Without the last condition, I doubt there could be sufficient motivation for the rest. > Was one (or both) of us choosing to not " get it " ? > Was one (or both) of us making excuses? Me: Only you will know the answers to those questions. No one else can possibly know for sure. But I don't think your husband, as ill has he was, had the capacity, but I think he was also still protecting something, as was the case of another ill person that I knew. She died a very early death and there is no doubt that her mental illness played a huge factor. But she couldn't be helped. She clung to certain beliefs and she took no responsibility for anything. She wanted to be rescued and she was continually testing everyone around her, like a great sucking wound. > Or were we both muddling through life as best we could manage at the > time, albeit with a less than optimal effort on one (or both) of our parts? Me: I would presume this is the most likely case! > I'm curious as to how you factor mismatched expectations with respect to > pace and timing into your equation. Me: As above, it happens all the time. You say it so succinctly, I'm going to remember that, because this descriptor is the very essense of failure, reduced to its lowest common denominator: mismatched expectations. Now if both parties want it to work, both parties have a responsibility to do *everything* they can to make it work. Maybe the effort won't seem " equal " but certainly each one must have certain capabilities they should exercise fully! Now, a thought about trying to re-think this all for, what must be, at least, the 500th time for you..... A long, long time ago, when I was going through the agony of loosing with a partner who I had hoped would be a life partner, one of my wise friends was listening to me patiently. Finally she said that my attempts to analyze the whole thing were an attempt at trying to control, at least in my own mind, an essentially uncontrollable situation. When she said that, I was thunderstruck. I stopped analyzing and started making choices. Not every choice was right, but it was better than making a passive decision (eg. doing nothing until a decision is made for you.) cyber hugs, Helen Quote
Guest guest Posted August 20, 2010 Report Posted August 20, 2010 > I said other things too, over 5-6 posts, all to the effect that walking > away does not imply they who do the walking are solely the " healthy > ones " . Nor that those left behind are solely " unhealthy " . Hi Bill, I guess that's another way of saying there is not necessarily a " wrong " and " right " party but simply that each party has very different needs that can no longer be met in the marriage. Thought I'd clarify that here for others though as it might put some (who are really hurting at this time) on the defensive... - Helen Quote
Guest guest Posted August 21, 2010 Report Posted August 21, 2010 hfoisyca wrote: > > >> I said other things too, over 5-6 posts, all to the effect that >> walking away does not imply they who do the walking are solely the >> " healthy ones " . Nor that those left behind are solely >> " unhealthy " . > > Hi Bill, I guess that's another way of saying there is not > necessarily a " wrong " and " right " party but simply that each party > has very different needs that can no longer be met in the marriage. Certainly that's another interpretation, but it's not exactly what I meant. Think of Burton and ( and Martha) in the movie " Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf " - where their " needs " *are* met. ...In bizarre and unfortunate ways. It is our " Takes Two to Tango " with a twist. A *big* twist, the possibility of which we forget at our peril. > Thought I'd clarify that here for others though as it might put some > (who are really hurting at this time) on the defensive... - Helen Had to think on that a bit. Yet again. As I've said also, many times during my time here, I have *huge* sympathy for people who hurt. In real life I'm the first one, almost, to offer help. And I've offered very direct help - advice - on this List. Always the trick is to identify who it is, really, who's doing the hurting -- and why, really. Not so easy when we always hear *one* side of two-sided stories - inevitably more complex than we ever learn. We forget *that* at our peril too. From my experiences in Real Life I'm persuaded that the best advice always includes the truth. Glossing things..., at root is a lie. People will handle the truth far better than ever they will handle lies. - Bill, AS -- WD " Bill " Loughman - Berkeley, California USA http://home.earthlink.net/~wdloughman/wdl.htm Quote
Guest guest Posted August 21, 2010 Report Posted August 21, 2010 > Not so easy when we always hear *one* side of two-sided stories - > inevitably more complex than we ever learn. We forget *that* at our > peril too. Well yeah, but you know what, " the other side of the story " isn't a member of this list, and presumably won't asking for our help. So I tend to want to be supportive, loyal, and meet the needs of the one who *is* here. > From my experiences in Real Life I'm persuaded that the best advice > always includes the truth. Glossing things..., at root is a lie. > People will handle the truth far better than ever they will handle lies. Well another AS does, yes, LOL. But most other folks aren't looking so much for " answers " (they probably have some idea what the answer is already) so much as they are looking for validation. Now as a younger spectrum person, it took me like forever to " get " that, but now I do. It's another kind of communication, just as valid as ours, Bill. NO, they aren't asking for *the* truth, or let's put it this way, if they wanted *the* truth, they'd ask for it specifically. What they really need to hear at this juncture is something to the effect of " you're not crazy, you're all right. " Now if they really *aren't* all right, as in they are about to go straight of the deep end, then I suppose it would be a terrible dis-service to keep supporting them in wrong thinking, but most of the time that isn't the case. I'd cut them some slack first, and then cut to the chase scene later. - Helen Quote
Guest guest Posted August 21, 2010 Report Posted August 21, 2010 I know I started this thread and haven't jumped in the mix. So much of it has helped though not all; but that's ok too. I'm just so overwhelmed to respond to all this, but I thank you all emensely. I really do! You all gave me A LOT to think over. Thanks again! Quote
Guest guest Posted August 21, 2010 Report Posted August 21, 2010 Helen,I'm with you on this! Sometimes we may want reality slapped in our face, like a dead fish, but mostly we are looking for support and validation here. We can get the dead fish anywhere, and mostly we do...which is why we need somewhere to come for warm fuzzies! Even if we need to be served the dead fish once in awhile, we don't come here to get smacked in the face with it; we come here to have it served nicely! ~ "Nobody realizes that some people expend tremendous energy merely to be normal."--Albert Camus Sent from my VZW BlackBerrySender: aspires-relationships Date: Sat, 21 Aug 2010 04:00:00 +0000To: <aspires-relationships >ReplyTo: aspires-relationships Subject: Re: How has knowing helped > Not so easy when we always hear *one* side of two-sided stories - > inevitably more complex than we ever learn. We forget *that* at our > peril too.Well yeah, but you know what, " the other side of the story " isn't a member of this list, and presumably won't asking for our help. So I tend to want to be supportive, loyal, and meet the needs of the one who *is* here. > From my experiences in Real Life I'm persuaded that the best advice > always includes the truth. Glossing things..., at root is a lie. > People will handle the truth far better than ever they will handle lies.Well another AS does, yes, LOL. But most other folks aren't looking so much for " answers " (they probably have some idea what the answer is already) so much as they are looking for validation. Now as a younger spectrum person, it took me like forever to " get " that, but now I do. It's another kind of communication, just as valid as ours, Bill. NO, they aren't asking for *the* truth, or let's put it this way, if they wanted *the* truth, they'd ask for it specifically.What they really need to hear at this juncture is something to the effect of " you're not crazy, you're all right. " Now if they really *aren't* all right, as in they are about to go straight of the deep end, then I suppose it would be a terrible dis-service to keep supporting them in wrong thinking, but most of the time that isn't the case. I'd cut them some slack first, and then cut to the chase scene later.- Helen Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.