Guest guest Posted June 18, 2010 Report Posted June 18, 2010 What an interesting thread. Thanks to all for such valuable sharing. Resentment and nursing resentment are two different things entirely and I think this distinction can not ever be made enough. Because it's just so easy to blur these two--happens in the blink of an eye. It happens so quickly it humbles me again and again. And yes, naturally resentment can be storied up as same as taking poison and waiting for the other guy to die. IF...I haven't accepted the resentment as simply resentment. If...I have fused with the narrative that culture and religion and mainstream recovery groups or family or whomever who have insisted over history and time that such thoughts and feelings as anger and resentment are sinful, bad, toxic, corrosive and even deadly. As though they are real substantive things that I have no control over. That's simply not true. If I skip steps, and it's very easy to do-- if I don't accept and trust and say YES to ALL that is there in my body and history that rumbles through I will quickly get into trouble. When I (as self as context) relax and breathe into to whatever I'm experiencing, there is no toxicity there. There is just there there. In this moment, I am standing with integrity, with my Self. I have a choice each and every moment as to what I nurse and what I don't. As I gently and lovingly allow what is there to come up without adding or subtracting from it, rather than it being corrosive, harmful or detracting from my values, the irony is this thing we call " anger " or " resentment " can actually inform me and draw me closer to my values, what I care about. If.. I listen closely, patiently. The choice is mine. Each and every moment. Regards, Terry > > You can think of forgiveness the act and forgiveness the feeling. Can you do forgiveness the act - I would say yes. Can you do forgiveness the feeling - I do not know how to do that. Likewise love. Love the act, love the feeling. I have been married for more than 30 years. The feeling waxes and wanes. The last week on vacation in the motorhome with the kids, last night on the shore of a lake in the Nevada high desert, remembering all the times my wife and I spent in settings much like this. Laying in the sun, watching the white pelicans, swimming. And, thinking of all the times since with the kids--and them nearly grown now. I have felt so full of love (the feeling) that I have been brought to tears numerous times this trip. But I don't feel like that all the time. Heavens, sometimes I feel impatient and angry and unloved and put upon and spiteful and.... On my good days, I am capable of the act of love even when I do not have the feeling of love. It is not fake. It is not a show. It is engagement in a valued pattern of living. > > And, I do not intend to push either the act or the feeling. Forgive if you want. Feel what you feel. Mostly I speak of my own life where resentment and nursing resentment have had very corrosive consequences. > > And, I have some people in my life who I spend very very little time with or the kind of interactions I have are quite limited. Why? Well, there are some sorts of interactions that I care about that others do not. Sad, but true. I feel kindly towards some of them, indifferent towards others, and somewhat bitter towards a few. When I exercise the bitterness by talking about them, for example, in ways that are likely to enlist the bitterness of others, I can feel the toxins rise. What is my point in that really? To show the world that there are bad people? Like that is a surprise.... To show the world that others are bad and that I am not like them? Well, I am not like a lot of people and a lot like a lot of people. Depending on the year and the day, I am much more poorly behaved than most. On my better days and years, I am a pretty good Joe. > > I have had some experiences with others where I let go of all expectations with them and have had many different outcomes. Sometimes the outcome has been that nothing changes in their behavior at all and the relationships become limited - typically because I stop investing my time in them. But I have had a small number, just a few really, where letting go of expectations has had truly transformational outcomes. Be clear please. I did not do this in order to achieve the outcomes. I forgave because it was in my values to do so. > > What does forgiveness " the act " look like for me? Well, I stop trying to get other people to co-sign my resentment. I look for my part in my difficulty with others and clean that up where possible and where it is not dangerous or toxic for me or others. I look at what I am investing my life in, and think about that investment stretched out over time, and then put my feet on the path. > > And some days, the very very best I can do is to sit on my hands. Look here for a little piece called days spent sitting on my hands > > http://www.facebook.com/note.php?note_id=134839170789 > > For me. And I do not say this for anyone but me. Resentment is captured pretty well by the AA adage - resentment is like taking poison and waiting for the other guy to die. Maybe not for you. If not, that is fine. > > I am deep in some writing deadlines right now, but at sometime soon, I will write about one of these acts of forgiveness. > > And, Simone, I LOVE the piggy bank metaphor. > > I offer you my heart in gratitude this morning, in this moment, where the feeling and the act have met. > > namaste, > kelly > > G. > 205 Peabody Building > Psychology Department > University of Mississippi > Oxford, MS 38677 > > ph: > fax: > > academic homepage: > www.olemiss.edu/working/kwilson/kwilson.htm > > also check out > www.onelifellc.com > www.mindfulnessfortwo.com > www.facebook.com/kellygwilson > www.tastybehaviorism.com > www.abnormalwootwoot.com > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 19, 2010 Report Posted June 19, 2010 WOW. I now feel like more of a social " outcast " in this forum than ever. Helena : Actually do you know what? You are second-guessing me too. We're all second-guessing each other. That's what humans do. Second-guess each other right? So I don't know. On one hand, I take what you say as something true. On the other hand, I get the feeling you meant it as a telling off. If that is so, then I'll ask you this : Who do you think you are? The morality police? If VC is incensed, he can certainly speak up for himself. I don't know about him, but if I were him I'd certainly not appreciate some old lady trying to speak up for me here. As for , well, I think he is just being quiet because he refuses to acknowledge that his therapy isn't working in some cases. In my case anyway. Whilst I think his book helped, I am in no way on the way to becoming a fan. And I won't even be wasting my time on this forum any longer. For all I know, its probably something that the ACT practitioners set up in order to positively-promote their own product and anything else that goes against what they want to promote gets swept under the carpet. Or they leave it to people who aren't actual practitioners to do all the fighting for them on here. I hereby apologise for having trespassed into the CHURCH of ACT and possibly have upset all its followers (NOT!) Good riddance. > > I have been lurking for some time and really find the advice here useful. I first encountered the book " Get out of your mind... " after I had ended up in A & E twice in March this year due to full-blown panic attacks that could not resolve themselves. So I read the book and did the exercises faithfully and was astounded at how much it had helped me in overcoming my panic attacks and anxiety. I still have some social anxiety lurking around and it flares up sometimes although not all the time when I'm out and about. At the same time that I was reading that book, I was put on Citalopram but couldn't tolerate the side effects so I stopped it myself against the wishes of my GP and did not get any more panic attacks which I credit to the help the book gave me. > > But now that the panic attacks are manageable and almost never flare up, I have another problem. Hatred, and specifically hatred towards parents for what they've done to me in the past. > > My parents were very cruel and unkind to me when I was growing up. They were abusive, controlling, authoritarian and cold (never hugged me or kissed me, never shared any moments of laughter or happiness with me). I left home as soon as I could and have not seen them for over a decade now. We used to speak on the phone very occasionally or email once a year. This is because we still don't agree on lots of issues concerning the way I live my life. Basically I still don't live the way they *wanted* me to and our conversations inadvertently end on a sour note and leave me sad and bitter for days afterwards. > > I don't think of them that much now. I have a family of 3 children whom I spend most of my days looking after and love dearly. But whenever I get some form of contact from them again, I feel a very deep sense of dread. Its almost like I really don't want to keep contact with them anymore because I feel like every time they talk to me, it really affects me deeply and negatively. I think I still have very strong feelings of hatred for them, there is almost no way I can really think of them in any positive light. When I think of them, the feeling I get is just a really strong feeling of hatred. If I had to draw a picture describing how I feel, it would be like a deep black dark hole that sucks all happiness out of me. > > But I also sadness as I realise my parents and I will never get along. > Its sad for me too because I don't have such a relationship with my children and I often wonder why they could not even have treated me with half the decency I do to my children. > > Someone told me that hatred is not good for me (which I agree its true). It takes a lot of effort to hate somebody, and it drains a lot out of you. I agree with it wholeheartedly, but the feelings are so strong that even when I practice acceptance, it never gets rid of them completely. But why does it never leave me? I have already built a new life for myself in a land far away from my parents' more than a decade ago, married with children and live a busy life but I love my children dearly and they fill my life with sunshine. I have some problems with my spouse, but not to the point of divorce, just quibbling often about trivial things, and this is typical of our relationship from the start so nothing really worrying about it. > > Its just that I feel frustrated at times when I sense the feelings of hatred returning every time I get contact from my family. I really don't wish to revisit those horrible days living under my parents' wing again but every time the hatred flares up after speaking to them, I am reminded of all those terrible incidents in the past. I am so weary of thinking of them. I severed ties with my dad and mum last year, but now recently I found myself severing ties with my sister and brother as well because they keep echoing the same words that my parents would have (though to a lesser extent)... and everytime they talk to me in that way I start to hate them too because they remind me of my parents so much. > > I still don't know if I was right to sever ties with the entire family completely now. Certainly I find little acceptance and sympathy amongst people if I do choose to divulge to them what I've done. That makes me question whether it was the right thing to do. I'm often told by those who disagree with what I did, that you can never choose your parents in life, and no matter how much they've hurted you, at least they have raised you and you should appreciate them for that and that alone. Which makes me feel like such an ungrateful person and that I'm such a weakling for not being able to keep my feelings of hatred in control. > > But can ACT really help in this? And how can it help? I can certainly accept my feelings of hatred, I even express it quite frankly sometimes, but it seems so unacceptable to many people to hate and especially to hate one's parents. > > I'm really at a loss how to deal with my feelings of hatred. > Am I doing the right thing? > Anybody have any advice for me about this? > > > TIA > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 19, 2010 Report Posted June 19, 2010 Very cool and compassionate take, . Yep, I've seen spiritual people (or folks who fancy themselves spiritual) get really caught up in that " I need to forgive " thing and they're so into the get rid of this now that it sadly becomes something they aren't owning but doing out of a fear or a should-- to look or feel spiritual or whatever. I was in a group once where a very adept tennis player shared how she was so grossly cheated out of a championship game and it was clear she was upset (as she takes the game seriously and works hard at it). She went on to say because she is on a spiritual plane,she was not at all upset and that she even shook the cheater's hand afterward. Clapping ensued upon her recounting this tale. Maybe she was telling the truth, but I felt a chill go up my spine. What I saw and felt was heaviness and flat affect and nothing near a sense of opening up or lightness that true forgiveness and acceptance brings. It appeared to me a lot more like resignation and suppression and avoidance than acceptance/forgiveness. I could understand her not confronting the cheater if you're not into confronting folks who have done you wrong (it's often not worth it or wise or safe), but to then go on and shake her hand? To me that felt like abandoning her Self, a bit like condoning abuse. In psych circles as some here know, they sometimes call this response: " reaction formation " --kind of like smiling at someone who has just offended you or continuing to engage someone you know to be abusive. I've done this before if I skip steps and don't at least quietly acknowledge to myself " Wow, what a poor sport. She just cheated and I feel like I've just been punched in the gut " . Then if needed, I can go on to defuse and choose what action to take (if any) based on my values. But I didn't hear any of that in her--she was not the chooser, she was doing what she had been told to do in order to stay away from that demon called resentment. Might work for her, and maybe for her there is no middle road when it comes to anger, but that's not what I want. On the other hand, I've seen people (including myself) really get sucked into anger and resentment and it can quickly have them/me by the throat-- become corrosive as said. So it's a fine line there, and it's really about my larger intention, me thinks. For me, I think it's about staying honest and open and curious as to what is working and what isn't. Cause this is tricky stuff and it will take on a life of it's own if left un-checked. I need to ask myself questions like: What is my larger goal here? Is there anything to be gained from this other than feeling temporarily superior/right? Is it bringing me lightness of being or more heaviness? What would my life be like without this feeling/thought? Is there a fear I might disappear without this in my life? Might I be inadvertently using this anger/resentment as something to hide behind? Is this resentment/anger/envy (whatever) perhaps a smokescreen for something else that I'm not attending to? Can it help point me to another part of me, a need/want/value that is asking for some time and attention? Only we/I can know the answer. Honor that. Own that. Holding lightly all, Terry > > > > Hi. > > > > > > > > I have a rough time with personal relationships with-in my extended family. > > I was ridiculed and made fun of, shunned because of my birth circumstances > > and my very existence within the family was resented by many. I was raised > > by my grandparents as their own child, but I actually was a granddaughter. > > My mother Kay had me when she was sisteen, this was back in the mid 50's in > > a very conservative back waters town. I was thirteen when the truth was told > > to me and of the many feelings I had, being ashamed was overwhelming and > > shaped my life. Growing up as a teenager I rebelled constantly, eventually > > quite school, ran away, etc:. I am a highly sensitive person I have > > suffered from comments and or actions from family members that have left me > > empty ,sad, destroyed and forever feeling guilty, even if I am not to blame. > > I in turn have further damaged relationships with members by being > > inflexible and angry, acting out on my hurt and rejection. > > > > > > > > My grandmother loved me, I didn't realize how much she protected me from > > other family members until she was gone. Since her death, I am estranged > > from most of my siblings. My grandmother made space for me in the family , > > and would not tolerate out and out meanness directed at me from others in > > the family. And in turn would plead my case, some viewed this as I was > > spoiled. With her death that protection died. > > > > > > > > I believed that family would stand by you no matter what. I had this > > believe that you would always be forgiven because you are family. I had > > this believe that I would be accepted and liked and welcomed with open arms > > because I was family. I knew that my family was not perfect, but they were > > family who were after all always going to have a special place for me. Love > > me. No not true. Learning to accept the circumstance for what they are, > > was hard. It hurt tremendously, I was very confused as to how I fitted > > into all this, why I had so many conflicting emotions, why I acted so badly. > > > > > > > > > > > > I can, even after all these years - become very fussed with the thoughts and > > feelings I can have about how I think the family should be, how they should > > treat me (past experiences) and I them (judgments). I Believe my story as > > being the absolute truth and justified in being anger and hating. Feed my > > ego. All it has done is caused pain and bitterness for me and others. I > > cannot do anything to change what happened. I have offered apologies which > > are not accepted. This all hurts tremendously. I have learnt to accept the > > thoughts around " family " as just thoughts.(ACT therapy) I have learnt to > > accept the occasional interaction with a family member with a smile and a > > politeness that I would accord any person that I had met. When my buttons > > are being pushed wither by me or them, I have learnt to stay calm, allow and > > expand with the thoughts, and carry on in a way that reflects my value of > > being a kind person.(ACT ) When there is contact because of births, > > graduations, I send a card or an email wishing well. In the case of > > funerals I go and don't stay around after offering condolences. I can > > accept this situation, not liking it, allow the thought to wash over me in > > waves, eventually those thought become less intense and wain. In unexpected > > meetings with relatives I no longer try to avoid them, like at the grocery > > store. I carry on with my values as best I can. It was not easy in the > > beginning , it is not easy at times when I am overcome with sadness, guilt, > > betrayal. It is not easy when I visualize the way it should be, or could > > have been. If, buts' and maybes... wishing and worrying does not change > > the facts. It is what it is. We were born into our families without > > choice, we can choice our friends and we can choose the values that we want > > to reflect as a human being. > > > > > > > > I have found the exercise for the white room helpful - a thought comes in > > one door swings around the room and departs by the other door. I am only > > the observer. I also like to get physical active, as this forces me to > > concentrate on what I am doing, (mindfulness). I get charged with adrenaline > > and need to move(get physical) to displace this energy in a non-self > > destructive means. I will use different combination of > > acceptance/expansion/diffusion exercises. The Mindfulness Acceptance > > Workbook for Anxiety offers many exercises, or any good ACT therapy book > > will contain some exercises to help. This board Is also tremendously > > helpful as there are many people who understand applying ACT and are able to > > express themselves quite articulately with process. > > > > > > > > The Serenity Prayer- somehow seemed ACT appropriate today. > > > > All the best Bre > > > > > > > > > > > > " Lord grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change, the > > courage to change the things I can, and the wisdom to know the difference. " > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > From: ACT_for_the_Public > > [mailto:ACT_for_the_Public ] On Behalf Of Mrs Himani Samdhya > > Dumre > > Sent: Monday, June 14, 2010 10:46 PM > > To: ACT_for_the_Public > > Subject: Re: How do you resolve strong feelings of > > hatred towards your parents?? > > > > > > > > > > > > Hi , I lurk on this group also.. I am new to ACT and have a therapist > > who is doing ACT with me... we have only just started.. I can relate to your > > troubles with your birth family. I don't exactly feel hatred but more like > > rage and anger at my mother and father.. but more so my mother as she was > > the " well " one and did nothing to change the situation of domestic violence > > I grew up in. I really would rather not see her anymore... My father passed > > away 7 years ago. I don't have contact with my birth sister.. that is a long > > story... Last time I saw my mother we ended up in a horrible argument.. She > > wants a close relationship with my baby daughter but I would rather not have > > her in my life very much at all.. My husband and I were thinking of having > > another child but then my mental health took a turn for the worse after > > seeing my mother and we started questioning the sense of having another > > child.. I have bipolar. > > > > > > > > I am also trying to learn how to unhook and defuse from these awful thoughts > > that bother me in relation to seeing my mother.. I can understand what you > > said about others not understanding why one has made a break from birth > > family.. I got that also from people...which just made me feel guilty. > > > > > > > > I hope I am not going off topic to much I just related so much to what you > > wrote... would be interested to work out how to use ACT on such heavy and > > dark thoughts. > > > > > > > > Peace > > > > Georgia > > > > How do you resolve strong feelings of hatred > > towards your parents?? > > > > > > > > > > > > I have been lurking for some time and really find the advice here useful. I > > first encountered the book " Get out of your mind... " after I > > had ended up in A & E twice in March this year due to full-blown panic attacks > > that could not resolve themselves. So I read the book and did the exercises > > faithfully and was astounded at how much it had helped me in overcoming my > > panic attacks and anxiety. I still have some social anxiety lurking around > > and it flares up sometimes although not all the time when I'm out and about. > > At the same time that I was reading that book, I was put on Citalopram but > > couldn't tolerate the side effects so I stopped it myself against the wishes > > of my GP and did not get any more panic attacks which I credit to the help > > the book gave me. > > > > But now that the panic attacks are manageable and almost never flare up, I > > have another problem. Hatred, and specifically hatred towards parents for > > what they've done to me in the past. > > > > My parents were very cruel and unkind to me when I was growing up. They were > > abusive, controlling, authoritarian and cold (never hugged me or kissed me, > > never shared any moments of laughter or happiness with me). I left home as > > soon as I could and have not seen them for over a decade now. We used to > > speak on the phone very occasionally or email once a year. This is because > > we still don't agree on lots of issues concerning the way I live my life. > > Basically I still don't live the way they *wanted* me to and our > > conversations inadvertently end on a sour note and leave me sad and bitter > > for days afterwards. > > > > I don't think of them that much now. I have a family of 3 children whom I > > spend most of my days looking after and love dearly. But whenever I get some > > form of contact from them again, I feel a very deep sense of dread. Its > > almost like I really don't want to keep contact with them anymore because I > > feel like every time they talk to me, it really affects me deeply and > > negatively. I think I still have very strong feelings of hatred for them, > > there is almost no way I can really think of them in any positive light. > > When I think of them, the feeling I get is just a really strong feeling of > > hatred. If I had to draw a picture describing how I feel, it would be like a > > deep black dark hole that sucks all happiness out of me. > > > > But I also sadness as I realise my parents and I will never get along. > > Its sad for me too because I don't have such a relationship with my children > > and I often wonder why they could not even have treated me with half the > > decency I do to my children. > > > > Someone told me that hatred is not good for me (which I agree its true). It > > takes a lot of effort to hate somebody, and it drains a lot out of you. I > > agree with it wholeheartedly, but the feelings are so strong that even when > > I practice acceptance, it never gets rid of them completely. But why does it > > never leave me? I have already built a new life for myself in a land far > > away from my parents' more than a decade ago, married with children and live > > a busy life but I love my children dearly and they fill my life with > > sunshine. I have some problems with my spouse, but not to the point of > > divorce, just quibbling often about trivial things, and this is typical of > > our relationship from the start so nothing really worrying about it. > > > > Its just that I feel frustrated at times when I sense the feelings of hatred > > returning every time I get contact from my family. I really don't wish to > > revisit those horrible days living under my parents' wing again but every > > time the hatred flares up after speaking to them, I am reminded of all those > > terrible incidents in the past. I am so weary of thinking of them. I severed > > ties with my dad and mum last year, but now recently I found myself severing > > ties with my sister and brother as well because they keep echoing the same > > words that my parents would have (though to a lesser extent)... and > > everytime they talk to me in that way I start to hate them too because they > > remind me of my parents so much. > > > > I still don't know if I was right to sever ties with the entire family > > completely now. Certainly I find little acceptance and sympathy amongst > > people if I do choose to divulge to them what I've done. That makes me > > question whether it was the right thing to do. I'm often told by those who > > disagree with what I did, that you can never choose your parents in life, > > and no matter how much they've hurted you, at least they have raised you and > > you should appreciate them for that and that alone. Which makes me feel like > > such an ungrateful person and that I'm such a weakling for not being able to > > keep my feelings of hatred in control. > > > > But can ACT really help in this? And how can it help? I can certainly accept > > my feelings of hatred, I even express it quite frankly sometimes, but it > > seems so unacceptable to many people to hate and especially to hate one's > > parents. > > > > I'm really at a loss how to deal with my feelings of hatred. > > Am I doing the right thing? > > Anybody have any advice for me about this? > > > > TIA > > > > > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.