Guest guest Posted June 14, 2010 Report Posted June 14, 2010 I don't know whether you should continue to sever ties with your parents and siblings or reconnect with them. I think you have to examine your own values and the answer to that will hopefully surface. Personally speaking one of my main values is forgiveness. I find forgiveness one of the hardest of my values to follow but I do try. It is not my place or anyone else's to tell you your values but speaking for myself I find forgiveness lives better than hatred. Whether you reconnect with your family or not perhaps forgiveness of them for their mistakes (however bad) would give you more peace of mind. > > I have been lurking for some time and really find the advice here useful. I first encountered the book " Get out of your mind... " after I had ended up in A & E twice in March this year due to full-blown panic attacks that could not resolve themselves. So I read the book and did the exercises faithfully and was astounded at how much it had helped me in overcoming my panic attacks and anxiety. I still have some social anxiety lurking around and it flares up sometimes although not all the time when I'm out and about. At the same time that I was reading that book, I was put on Citalopram but couldn't tolerate the side effects so I stopped it myself against the wishes of my GP and did not get any more panic attacks which I credit to the help the book gave me. > > But now that the panic attacks are manageable and almost never flare up, I have another problem. Hatred, and specifically hatred towards parents for what they've done to me in the past. > > My parents were very cruel and unkind to me when I was growing up. They were abusive, controlling, authoritarian and cold (never hugged me or kissed me, never shared any moments of laughter or happiness with me). I left home as soon as I could and have not seen them for over a decade now. We used to speak on the phone very occasionally or email once a year. This is because we still don't agree on lots of issues concerning the way I live my life. Basically I still don't live the way they *wanted* me to and our conversations inadvertently end on a sour note and leave me sad and bitter for days afterwards. > > I don't think of them that much now. I have a family of 3 children whom I spend most of my days looking after and love dearly. But whenever I get some form of contact from them again, I feel a very deep sense of dread. Its almost like I really don't want to keep contact with them anymore because I feel like every time they talk to me, it really affects me deeply and negatively. I think I still have very strong feelings of hatred for them, there is almost no way I can really think of them in any positive light. When I think of them, the feeling I get is just a really strong feeling of hatred. If I had to draw a picture describing how I feel, it would be like a deep black dark hole that sucks all happiness out of me. > > But I also sadness as I realise my parents and I will never get along. > Its sad for me too because I don't have such a relationship with my children and I often wonder why they could not even have treated me with half the decency I do to my children. > > Someone told me that hatred is not good for me (which I agree its true). It takes a lot of effort to hate somebody, and it drains a lot out of you. I agree with it wholeheartedly, but the feelings are so strong that even when I practice acceptance, it never gets rid of them completely. But why does it never leave me? I have already built a new life for myself in a land far away from my parents' more than a decade ago, married with children and live a busy life but I love my children dearly and they fill my life with sunshine. I have some problems with my spouse, but not to the point of divorce, just quibbling often about trivial things, and this is typical of our relationship from the start so nothing really worrying about it. > > Its just that I feel frustrated at times when I sense the feelings of hatred returning every time I get contact from my family. I really don't wish to revisit those horrible days living under my parents' wing again but every time the hatred flares up after speaking to them, I am reminded of all those terrible incidents in the past. I am so weary of thinking of them. I severed ties with my dad and mum last year, but now recently I found myself severing ties with my sister and brother as well because they keep echoing the same words that my parents would have (though to a lesser extent)... and everytime they talk to me in that way I start to hate them too because they remind me of my parents so much. > > I still don't know if I was right to sever ties with the entire family completely now. Certainly I find little acceptance and sympathy amongst people if I do choose to divulge to them what I've done. That makes me question whether it was the right thing to do. I'm often told by those who disagree with what I did, that you can never choose your parents in life, and no matter how much they've hurted you, at least they have raised you and you should appreciate them for that and that alone. Which makes me feel like such an ungrateful person and that I'm such a weakling for not being able to keep my feelings of hatred in control. > > But can ACT really help in this? And how can it help? I can certainly accept my feelings of hatred, I even express it quite frankly sometimes, but it seems so unacceptable to many people to hate and especially to hate one's parents. > > I'm really at a loss how to deal with my feelings of hatred. > Am I doing the right thing? > Anybody have any advice for me about this? > > > TIA > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 15, 2010 Report Posted June 15, 2010 > > I also think forgiveness is a very misunderstood concept and is sometimes put on the victim/survivor so then the focus is on them rather than on the person who caused the offence. > > Peace > Georgia Exactly. I can tell you this Georgia, that my parents have not changed one bit since I left the family home. Its so evident on the telephone when they speak to me. The tone of their voice, their disgust, their condemnation. What am I supposed to do? Say yes to everything and do what they say at the expense of my happiness? They say I should go back to their side and look after them in their old age. Like I will. I couldn't even stand to be with them for 5 minutes. They said they don't want me to serve them, just give them money. I'm already struggling with finances, how am I able to give them money?? Okay then this qualifies me as a bad daughter. Okay tough. I told you they have never changed. I have to admit I can't help but feel that people who tell me to " just forgive my parents " have no idea what its like to be me, and to have gone through all I've gone through. Its just not as simple as Doing forgiveness. I don't really think forgiveness is something you do. I think its something that happens naturally, sometimes perhaps not consciously but you only realise when one day you think about the people you used to hate so much but you are surprised (pleasantly surprised) to find that hatred does not appear anymore even when you think of their face. I just think there's so much misunderstanding in the world. People who don't understand because they've never been through this and also because they don't seem to get that we are all very individualistic in our ways. There is no replica of each of us anywhere on this Earth, we are all unique in our thoughts, feelings, tendencies and life experiences. It may be easier for someone else to forgive someone, but that's because for that particular person, its easy. It doesn't mean that he/she can then transfer their own experiences onto other people's and make some comment like " Hey, all you have to do is forgive. Just forgive and all will be well. " To me that just sounds like a lack of basic understanding of the uniqueness of each of us and really, quite flippant. Perhaps I'm unduly influenced by Dorothy Rowe in some way... She speaks of how its actually impossible for anyone to truly understand what someone else is going through, what someone else is feeling, or thinking, or why someone else thinks different. That is because in reality all of us are alone in the way we think and feel and experience life... That is just the way it is. None of us have exact DNAs do we? And I think the hardest part is dealing with the subtle rejection of friends and family when they don't approve of your feelings, especially if they are feelings that are so strong and influenced a huge part of your life. What is happiness? Is happiness also not inclusive of the sense of belonging one feels with the world around them? Or at least the sense of belonging one feels with one's friends and family - i.e. people who matter most in one's life? No man is an island, and human beings are unfortunately social creatures and it is very hard to go against what is expected of you. We need other people's acceptance to a certain degree, or we'll feel isolated, which itself can bring about depression. However, being true to oneself is also central to personal happiness. I think for myself at least, being true to oneself and being accepted by those who matter to me, share first priority as values that matter most to me. The problem arises when you want to be true to yourself, but that doesn't agree with those who matter to you, and then you are stuck. Which part of you should you abandon or repress? What if both parts, if they can be allowed to happen, is the formula that can make you happy and whole? I suspect that true happiness is very elusive. Quote
Guest guest Posted June 15, 2010 Report Posted June 15, 2010 Hi , I'm familiar with feeling great anger towards one's parents - I had a difficult relationship with my own father over many decades, and often blamed him when I was younger for having neglected me, etc. However every family is different, so I can't pretend to know what you have gone through, nor attempt to give you advice based on the choices I have made for myself. From what you say, it sounds like you are really suffering & that your life is being affected in lots of ways - by your struggle with these feelings; by having to defend your stance toward your parents to others; by having had to cut your siblings out of your life now as well; and by the sadness you feel. That seems like a lot of hurt. Let me offer a couple of ideas. First, I would not use the word " acceptance " to describe your attitude towards your feelings about your parents. You write that you don't like the feelings you get when you speak with them, because these feelings affect you " deeply and negatively. " You also say that such feelings have persisted in your life, despite your efforts to get rid of them by " practicing acceptance. " In ACT, acceptance means that we are able to feel our thoughts and feelings without believing that they control our behavior. We may not always like them, but we are willing to have them without either trying to get rid of or justify them. So as I say, right now, " acceptance " does not seem to be where you're at with with these difficult feelings you're having. It seems more like you struggle with them (wish they would go away) at some times and fuse with them (defend them as 100 percent reality) at others. Second, I think it might be useful to look at what is meant in ACT by " forgiving. " I'm not an expert in any way, but I will try and repeat what I have read & heard. In ACT, forgiving is not a feeling, nor does it mean that you are excusing harmful behaviors by others. Forgiving is more like a choice you make - choice meaning it is something you do freely, not something forced upon you. If you choose to forgive, you do it not for others, but for yourself, so you can get back your life and your freedom. Another way to think of forgiving is as a chosen behavior. You say that ACT has helped you with panic attacks, so maybe this analogy will be helpful: Say you want to go out to some public event but are afraid you will have a panic attack if you do. With ACT, you can have those fearful thoughts & feelings and still choose your behavior - that is, you can go to the public event even though these thoughts and feelings say you can't. Forgiveness may be like that. I hope this is a little helpful. Maybe other folks on the list will step in & describe more about forgiving from an ACT perspective. --Randy P.S. I just read the reply by Bre (bahurwood) in this thread. There is a lot there about forgiveness in action. Quote
Guest guest Posted June 15, 2010 Report Posted June 15, 2010 There are a lot of replies about focusing on ACT techniques and I'm already doing them. There is no doubt in my mind that ACT techniques can lessen the pain of hatred when it occurs, but it can't cure the hatred itself. Its kind of like taking an aspirin for a flu-induced fever, but it doesn't actually cure the flu. I was looking for answers how to actually " cure the flu " so to speak, i.e. make my hatred of my parents history, but trying to wish hatred away for good is perhaps an unrealistic wish. Like anxiety it will always have the potential to crop up again. But unlike anxiety, hatred feels ten times worse and although I can use the techniques to relieve it, I can feel that its not gone for good, at the back of my mind, it always threatens to return in future, no matter how many years since I last felt it. My mind is so ingrained with hating them on auto whenever I even just see their face (even if I just think of their face in my mind). I don't think there's been a lot of research done on hatred, yes? Hatred appears to be the opposite of love, and if you can't love you can't hate. If you can't feel emotional, you can't hate. But if I continue to be an emotional being, I will always have the propensity to hate. I think cutting ties with family is probably the most important step I've taken in eliminating as many unnecessary hate-inducing contact I can have with them. After all I'm already living thousands of miles away from them, so day-to-day contact doesn't exist unless they turn up on my doorstep one day after coming out of a long-haul plane - which is never gonna happen anyway because who's gonna spend so much money buying a long-haul flight to UK just to piss me off? I know they won't. I can take steps to try and cut out all their contact so that less of those hateful incidents can happen... But then everytime someone who doesn't know me well asks about my mum/dad its also a triggering event because then I'd be reminded of their faces and all the feelings of hatred get stirred up again. I can practise ACT yes... and then for a while look a bit like an idiot staring into space unable to speak for a while while I focus on noticing my feelings, which are so strong I can hardly do much else except whilst I'm doing all that mental gymnastics. Its a never-ending conundrum and an irony of life. > > Hi. > > > > I have a rough time with personal relationships with-in my extended family. > I was ridiculed and made fun of, shunned because of my birth circumstances > and my very existence within the family was resented by many. I was raised > by my grandparents as their own child, but I actually was a granddaughter. > My mother Kay had me when she was sisteen, this was back in the mid 50's in > a very conservative back waters town. I was thirteen when the truth was told > to me and of the many feelings I had, being ashamed was overwhelming and > shaped my life. Growing up as a teenager I rebelled constantly, eventually > quite school, ran away, etc:. I am a highly sensitive person I have > suffered from comments and or actions from family members that have left me > empty ,sad, destroyed and forever feeling guilty, even if I am not to blame. > I in turn have further damaged relationships with members by being > inflexible and angry, acting out on my hurt and rejection. > > > > My grandmother loved me, I didn't realize how much she protected me from > other family members until she was gone. Since her death, I am estranged > from most of my siblings. My grandmother made space for me in the family , > and would not tolerate out and out meanness directed at me from others in > the family. And in turn would plead my case, some viewed this as I was > spoiled. With her death that protection died. > > > > I believed that family would stand by you no matter what. I had this > believe that you would always be forgiven because you are family. I had > this believe that I would be accepted and liked and welcomed with open arms > because I was family. I knew that my family was not perfect, but they were > family who were after all always going to have a special place for me. Love > me. No not true. Learning to accept the circumstance for what they are, > was hard. It hurt tremendously, I was very confused as to how I fitted > into all this, why I had so many conflicting emotions, why I acted so badly. > > > > > > I can, even after all these years - become very fussed with the thoughts and > feelings I can have about how I think the family should be, how they should > treat me (past experiences) and I them (judgments). I Believe my story as > being the absolute truth and justified in being anger and hating. Feed my > ego. All it has done is caused pain and bitterness for me and others. I > cannot do anything to change what happened. I have offered apologies which > are not accepted. This all hurts tremendously. I have learnt to accept the > thoughts around " family " as just thoughts.(ACT therapy) I have learnt to > accept the occasional interaction with a family member with a smile and a > politeness that I would accord any person that I had met. When my buttons > are being pushed wither by me or them, I have learnt to stay calm, allow and > expand with the thoughts, and carry on in a way that reflects my value of > being a kind person.(ACT ) When there is contact because of births, > graduations, I send a card or an email wishing well. In the case of > funerals I go and don't stay around after offering condolences. I can > accept this situation, not liking it, allow the thought to wash over me in > waves, eventually those thought become less intense and wain. In unexpected > meetings with relatives I no longer try to avoid them, like at the grocery > store. I carry on with my values as best I can. It was not easy in the > beginning , it is not easy at times when I am overcome with sadness, guilt, > betrayal. It is not easy when I visualize the way it should be, or could > have been. If, buts' and maybes... wishing and worrying does not change > the facts. It is what it is. We were born into our families without > choice, we can choice our friends and we can choose the values that we want > to reflect as a human being. > > > > I have found the exercise for the white room helpful - a thought comes in > one door swings around the room and departs by the other door. I am only > the observer. I also like to get physical active, as this forces me to > concentrate on what I am doing, (mindfulness). I get charged with adrenaline > and need to move(get physical) to displace this energy in a non-self > destructive means. I will use different combination of > acceptance/expansion/diffusion exercises. The Mindfulness Acceptance > Workbook for Anxiety offers many exercises, or any good ACT therapy book > will contain some exercises to help. This board Is also tremendously > helpful as there are many people who understand applying ACT and are able to > express themselves quite articulately with process. > > > > The Serenity Prayer- somehow seemed ACT appropriate today. > > All the best Bre > > > > > > " Lord grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change, the > courage to change the things I can, and the wisdom to know the difference. " > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > From: ACT_for_the_Public > [mailto:ACT_for_the_Public ] On Behalf Of Mrs Himani Samdhya > Dumre > Sent: Monday, June 14, 2010 10:46 PM > To: ACT_for_the_Public > Subject: Re: How do you resolve strong feelings of > hatred towards your parents?? > > > > > > Hi , I lurk on this group also.. I am new to ACT and have a therapist > who is doing ACT with me... we have only just started.. I can relate to your > troubles with your birth family. I don't exactly feel hatred but more like > rage and anger at my mother and father.. but more so my mother as she was > the " well " one and did nothing to change the situation of domestic violence > I grew up in. I really would rather not see her anymore... My father passed > away 7 years ago. I don't have contact with my birth sister.. that is a long > story... Last time I saw my mother we ended up in a horrible argument.. She > wants a close relationship with my baby daughter but I would rather not have > her in my life very much at all.. My husband and I were thinking of having > another child but then my mental health took a turn for the worse after > seeing my mother and we started questioning the sense of having another > child.. I have bipolar. > > > > I am also trying to learn how to unhook and defuse from these awful thoughts > that bother me in relation to seeing my mother.. I can understand what you > said about others not understanding why one has made a break from birth > family.. I got that also from people...which just made me feel guilty. > > > > I hope I am not going off topic to much I just related so much to what you > wrote... would be interested to work out how to use ACT on such heavy and > dark thoughts. > > > > Peace > > Georgia > > How do you resolve strong feelings of hatred > towards your parents?? > > > > > > I have been lurking for some time and really find the advice here useful. I > first encountered the book " Get out of your mind... " after I > had ended up in A & E twice in March this year due to full-blown panic attacks > that could not resolve themselves. So I read the book and did the exercises > faithfully and was astounded at how much it had helped me in overcoming my > panic attacks and anxiety. I still have some social anxiety lurking around > and it flares up sometimes although not all the time when I'm out and about. > At the same time that I was reading that book, I was put on Citalopram but > couldn't tolerate the side effects so I stopped it myself against the wishes > of my GP and did not get any more panic attacks which I credit to the help > the book gave me. > > But now that the panic attacks are manageable and almost never flare up, I > have another problem. Hatred, and specifically hatred towards parents for > what they've done to me in the past. > > My parents were very cruel and unkind to me when I was growing up. They were > abusive, controlling, authoritarian and cold (never hugged me or kissed me, > never shared any moments of laughter or happiness with me). I left home as > soon as I could and have not seen them for over a decade now. We used to > speak on the phone very occasionally or email once a year. This is because > we still don't agree on lots of issues concerning the way I live my life. > Basically I still don't live the way they *wanted* me to and our > conversations inadvertently end on a sour note and leave me sad and bitter > for days afterwards. > > I don't think of them that much now. I have a family of 3 children whom I > spend most of my days looking after and love dearly. But whenever I get some > form of contact from them again, I feel a very deep sense of dread. Its > almost like I really don't want to keep contact with them anymore because I > feel like every time they talk to me, it really affects me deeply and > negatively. I think I still have very strong feelings of hatred for them, > there is almost no way I can really think of them in any positive light. > When I think of them, the feeling I get is just a really strong feeling of > hatred. If I had to draw a picture describing how I feel, it would be like a > deep black dark hole that sucks all happiness out of me. > > But I also sadness as I realise my parents and I will never get along. > Its sad for me too because I don't have such a relationship with my children > and I often wonder why they could not even have treated me with half the > decency I do to my children. > > Someone told me that hatred is not good for me (which I agree its true). It > takes a lot of effort to hate somebody, and it drains a lot out of you. I > agree with it wholeheartedly, but the feelings are so strong that even when > I practice acceptance, it never gets rid of them completely. But why does it > never leave me? I have already built a new life for myself in a land far > away from my parents' more than a decade ago, married with children and live > a busy life but I love my children dearly and they fill my life with > sunshine. I have some problems with my spouse, but not to the point of > divorce, just quibbling often about trivial things, and this is typical of > our relationship from the start so nothing really worrying about it. > > Its just that I feel frustrated at times when I sense the feelings of hatred > returning every time I get contact from my family. I really don't wish to > revisit those horrible days living under my parents' wing again but every > time the hatred flares up after speaking to them, I am reminded of all those > terrible incidents in the past. I am so weary of thinking of them. I severed > ties with my dad and mum last year, but now recently I found myself severing > ties with my sister and brother as well because they keep echoing the same > words that my parents would have (though to a lesser extent)... and > everytime they talk to me in that way I start to hate them too because they > remind me of my parents so much. > > I still don't know if I was right to sever ties with the entire family > completely now. Certainly I find little acceptance and sympathy amongst > people if I do choose to divulge to them what I've done. That makes me > question whether it was the right thing to do. I'm often told by those who > disagree with what I did, that you can never choose your parents in life, > and no matter how much they've hurted you, at least they have raised you and > you should appreciate them for that and that alone. Which makes me feel like > such an ungrateful person and that I'm such a weakling for not being able to > keep my feelings of hatred in control. > > But can ACT really help in this? And how can it help? I can certainly accept > my feelings of hatred, I even express it quite frankly sometimes, but it > seems so unacceptable to many people to hate and especially to hate one's > parents. > > I'm really at a loss how to deal with my feelings of hatred. > Am I doing the right thing? > Anybody have any advice for me about this? > > TIA > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 15, 2010 Report Posted June 15, 2010 > Bill, I appreciate your insight and the wise things you said > in your post, except for one thing. Why would it be helpful to > to forgive herself for carrying around her anger? It > sounds like " blaming the victim " in a way. Helena, If I can jump in for a moment (and I anticipate that Bill will also reply) - Sometimes (not always) persons who blame others (e.g. a parent) also blame themselves for all sorts of things in the relationship. And sometimes self-blame of this sort can get in the way of living, just as other forms of self-judgment can. When this happens it is not " others blaming the victim " but rather " the victim blaming themself. " One response would be to offer such a person some reassurance & support - i.e. to say, " Don't blame yourself, it was not your fault but the fault of so-and-so. " Another response, especially on the part of the person concerned, might be self-forgiveness. My own experience has been that this is more successful if the goal is to connect with life. For me at least, self-forgiveness and forgiveness of others go hand-in-hand and have little to do with keeping a record of wrongs and rights. But that has only been my experience. Others may find their experience is different, or that self-blame is not much of an issue for them. -Randy Quote
Guest guest Posted June 15, 2010 Report Posted June 15, 2010 Okay this is just to clarify something. Since the time I left my parents' home, I have not felt guilty about hating my parents anymore. But when I was still living with them, YES. Every day. Why? Because they own the roof over my head. That's why. Now if they had charged me rent for it, then I would have moved even sooner. The thing is, as long as I feel that I owe them something which I could have gotten myself on my own, then I will always feel guilty for hating them - because it feels like I am biting on the hand that feeds me. But no, for these past 10 or so years since leaving their home, I have always just felt pure hatred and anger at them whenever the hatred is aroused from them making contact with me. But guilt? No. So to clarify things, I don't blame myself anymore for the hatred I feel for them. As far as I'm concerned, there's no forgiveness needed for myself in regards to the hatred of them because I certainly don't feel sorry for how I feel about them anymore. I was only wishing the hatred would go away really. But then now I realise hatred is an emotion and hence it will never go away for good as long as I continue to be an emotional being. Perhaps if I sustain a head injury in the " right " place and stop being able to feel emotions, then yes I suspect the feelings of hatred might then go away for good! Not that I wish this to happen to me, mind... I actually quite like having my emotions. ACT is good for defusing and sort of making the pain of hatred less painful. I will continue to work at it. But I think the propensity for hatred within me, just like the propensity for anxiety, cannot really go away ever. I can only learn to deal with it as best as I can. > > Bill, I appreciate your insight and the wise things you said > > in your post, except for one thing. Why would it be helpful to > > to forgive herself for carrying around her anger? It > > sounds like " blaming the victim " in a way. > > Helena, > > If I can jump in for a moment (and I anticipate that Bill will also > reply) - > > Sometimes (not always) persons who blame others (e.g. a parent) > also blame themselves for all sorts of things in the relationship. > And sometimes self-blame of this sort can get in the way of living, > just as other forms of self-judgment can. > > When this happens it is not " others blaming the victim " but rather > " the victim blaming themself. " > > One response would be to offer such a person some reassurance & > support - i.e. to say, " Don't blame yourself, it was not your fault > but the fault of so-and-so. " > > Another response, especially on the part of the person concerned, > might be self-forgiveness. My own experience has been that this is > more successful if the goal is to connect with life. For me at least, > self-forgiveness and forgiveness of others go hand-in-hand and > have little to do with keeping a record of wrongs and rights. > > But that has only been my experience. Others may find their > experience is different, or that self-blame is not much of an issue > for them. > > -Randy > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 15, 2010 Report Posted June 15, 2010 I have actually never used a therapist before, I actually find it quite tricky to get hold of a therapist who is an ACT practitioner where I live. It seems that CBT is the most widely-used therapy in the UK... Psychotherapy is also another one. But I know I do overthink everything. Its in my nature. Its certainly very helpful in some things, like in work, studies, etc... but yes when it spills over to daily life, it can be quite problematic. I believe already mentioned this before in the book of his I read... So yes, I got to keep practising and practising... but I'll keep in mind not to overthink or overdo it, as you've mentioned. > > > > > > Hi. > > > > > > > > > > > > I have a rough time with personal relationships with-in my extended family. > > > I was ridiculed and made fun of, shunned because of my birth circumstances > > > and my very existence within the family was resented by many. I was raised > > > by my grandparents as their own child, but I actually was a granddaughter. > > > My mother Kay had me when she was sisteen, this was back in the mid 50's in > > > a very conservative back waters town. I was thirteen when the truth was told > > > to me and of the many feelings I had, being ashamed was overwhelming and > > > shaped my life. Growing up as a teenager I rebelled constantly, eventually > > > quite school, ran away, etc:. I am a highly sensitive person I have > > > suffered from comments and or actions from family members that have left me > > > empty ,sad, destroyed and forever feeling guilty, even if I am not to blame. > > > I in turn have further damaged relationships with members by being > > > inflexible and angry, acting out on my hurt and rejection. > > > > > > > > > > > > My grandmother loved me, I didn't realize how much she protected me from > > > other family members until she was gone. Since her death, I am estranged > > > from most of my siblings. My grandmother made space for me in the family , > > > and would not tolerate out and out meanness directed at me from others in > > > the family. And in turn would plead my case, some viewed this as I was > > > spoiled. With her death that protection died. > > > > > > > > > > > > I believed that family would stand by you no matter what. I had this > > > believe that you would always be forgiven because you are family. I had > > > this believe that I would be accepted and liked and welcomed with open arms > > > because I was family. I knew that my family was not perfect, but they were > > > family who were after all always going to have a special place for me. Love > > > me. No not true. Learning to accept the circumstance for what they are, > > > was hard. It hurt tremendously, I was very confused as to how I fitted > > > into all this, why I had so many conflicting emotions, why I acted so badly. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I can, even after all these years - become very fussed with the thoughts and > > > feelings I can have about how I think the family should be, how they should > > > treat me (past experiences) and I them (judgments). I Believe my story as > > > being the absolute truth and justified in being anger and hating. Feed my > > > ego. All it has done is caused pain and bitterness for me and others. I > > > cannot do anything to change what happened. I have offered apologies which > > > are not accepted. This all hurts tremendously. I have learnt to accept the > > > thoughts around " family " as just thoughts.(ACT therapy) I have learnt to > > > accept the occasional interaction with a family member with a smile and a > > > politeness that I would accord any person that I had met. When my buttons > > > are being pushed wither by me or them, I have learnt to stay calm, allow and > > > expand with the thoughts, and carry on in a way that reflects my value of > > > being a kind person.(ACT ) When there is contact because of births, > > > graduations, I send a card or an email wishing well. In the case of > > > funerals I go and don't stay around after offering condolences. I can > > > accept this situation, not liking it, allow the thought to wash over me in > > > waves, eventually those thought become less intense and wain. In unexpected > > > meetings with relatives I no longer try to avoid them, like at the grocery > > > store. I carry on with my values as best I can. It was not easy in the > > > beginning , it is not easy at times when I am overcome with sadness, guilt, > > > betrayal. It is not easy when I visualize the way it should be, or could > > > have been. If, buts' and maybes... wishing and worrying does not change > > > the facts. It is what it is. We were born into our families without > > > choice, we can choice our friends and we can choose the values that we want > > > to reflect as a human being. > > > > > > > > > > > > I have found the exercise for the white room helpful - a thought comes in > > > one door swings around the room and departs by the other door. I am only > > > the observer. I also like to get physical active, as this forces me to > > > concentrate on what I am doing, (mindfulness). I get charged with adrenaline > > > and need to move(get physical) to displace this energy in a non-self > > > destructive means. I will use different combination of > > > acceptance/expansion/diffusion exercises. The Mindfulness Acceptance > > > Workbook for Anxiety offers many exercises, or any good ACT therapy book > > > will contain some exercises to help. This board Is also tremendously > > > helpful as there are many people who understand applying ACT and are able to > > > express themselves quite articulately with process. > > > > > > > > > > > > The Serenity Prayer- somehow seemed ACT appropriate today. > > > > > > All the best Bre > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > " Lord grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change, the > > > courage to change the things I can, and the wisdom to know the difference. " > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > From: ACT_for_the_Public > > > [mailto:ACT_for_the_Public ] On Behalf Of Mrs Himani Samdhya > > > Dumre > > > Sent: Monday, June 14, 2010 10:46 PM > > > To: ACT_for_the_Public > > > Subject: Re: How do you resolve strong feelings of > > > hatred towards your parents?? > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Hi , I lurk on this group also.. I am new to ACT and have a therapist > > > who is doing ACT with me... we have only just started.. I can relate to your > > > troubles with your birth family. I don't exactly feel hatred but more like > > > rage and anger at my mother and father.. but more so my mother as she was > > > the " well " one and did nothing to change the situation of domestic violence > > > I grew up in. I really would rather not see her anymore... My father passed > > > away 7 years ago. I don't have contact with my birth sister.. that is a long > > > story... Last time I saw my mother we ended up in a horrible argument.. She > > > wants a close relationship with my baby daughter but I would rather not have > > > her in my life very much at all.. My husband and I were thinking of having > > > another child but then my mental health took a turn for the worse after > > > seeing my mother and we started questioning the sense of having another > > > child.. I have bipolar. > > > > > > > > > > > > I am also trying to learn how to unhook and defuse from these awful thoughts > > > that bother me in relation to seeing my mother.. I can understand what you > > > said about others not understanding why one has made a break from birth > > > family.. I got that also from people...which just made me feel guilty. > > > > > > > > > > > > I hope I am not going off topic to much I just related so much to what you > > > wrote... would be interested to work out how to use ACT on such heavy and > > > dark thoughts. > > > > > > > > > > > > Peace > > > > > > Georgia > > > > > > How do you resolve strong feelings of hatred > > > towards your parents?? > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I have been lurking for some time and really find the advice here useful. I > > > first encountered the book " Get out of your mind... " after I > > > had ended up in A & E twice in March this year due to full-blown panic attacks > > > that could not resolve themselves. So I read the book and did the exercises > > > faithfully and was astounded at how much it had helped me in overcoming my > > > panic attacks and anxiety. I still have some social anxiety lurking around > > > and it flares up sometimes although not all the time when I'm out and about. > > > At the same time that I was reading that book, I was put on Citalopram but > > > couldn't tolerate the side effects so I stopped it myself against the wishes > > > of my GP and did not get any more panic attacks which I credit to the help > > > the book gave me. > > > > > > But now that the panic attacks are manageable and almost never flare up, I > > > have another problem. Hatred, and specifically hatred towards parents for > > > what they've done to me in the past. > > > > > > My parents were very cruel and unkind to me when I was growing up. They were > > > abusive, controlling, authoritarian and cold (never hugged me or kissed me, > > > never shared any moments of laughter or happiness with me). I left home as > > > soon as I could and have not seen them for over a decade now. We used to > > > speak on the phone very occasionally or email once a year. This is because > > > we still don't agree on lots of issues concerning the way I live my life. > > > Basically I still don't live the way they *wanted* me to and our > > > conversations inadvertently end on a sour note and leave me sad and bitter > > > for days afterwards. > > > > > > I don't think of them that much now. I have a family of 3 children whom I > > > spend most of my days looking after and love dearly. But whenever I get some > > > form of contact from them again, I feel a very deep sense of dread. Its > > > almost like I really don't want to keep contact with them anymore because I > > > feel like every time they talk to me, it really affects me deeply and > > > negatively. I think I still have very strong feelings of hatred for them, > > > there is almost no way I can really think of them in any positive light. > > > When I think of them, the feeling I get is just a really strong feeling of > > > hatred. If I had to draw a picture describing how I feel, it would be like a > > > deep black dark hole that sucks all happiness out of me. > > > > > > But I also sadness as I realise my parents and I will never get along. > > > Its sad for me too because I don't have such a relationship with my children > > > and I often wonder why they could not even have treated me with half the > > > decency I do to my children. > > > > > > Someone told me that hatred is not good for me (which I agree its true). It > > > takes a lot of effort to hate somebody, and it drains a lot out of you. I > > > agree with it wholeheartedly, but the feelings are so strong that even when > > > I practice acceptance, it never gets rid of them completely. But why does it > > > never leave me? I have already built a new life for myself in a land far > > > away from my parents' more than a decade ago, married with children and live > > > a busy life but I love my children dearly and they fill my life with > > > sunshine. I have some problems with my spouse, but not to the point of > > > divorce, just quibbling often about trivial things, and this is typical of > > > our relationship from the start so nothing really worrying about it. > > > > > > Its just that I feel frustrated at times when I sense the feelings of hatred > > > returning every time I get contact from my family. I really don't wish to > > > revisit those horrible days living under my parents' wing again but every > > > time the hatred flares up after speaking to them, I am reminded of all those > > > terrible incidents in the past. I am so weary of thinking of them. I severed > > > ties with my dad and mum last year, but now recently I found myself severing > > > ties with my sister and brother as well because they keep echoing the same > > > words that my parents would have (though to a lesser extent)... and > > > everytime they talk to me in that way I start to hate them too because they > > > remind me of my parents so much. > > > > > > I still don't know if I was right to sever ties with the entire family > > > completely now. Certainly I find little acceptance and sympathy amongst > > > people if I do choose to divulge to them what I've done. That makes me > > > question whether it was the right thing to do. I'm often told by those who > > > disagree with what I did, that you can never choose your parents in life, > > > and no matter how much they've hurted you, at least they have raised you and > > > you should appreciate them for that and that alone. Which makes me feel like > > > such an ungrateful person and that I'm such a weakling for not being able to > > > keep my feelings of hatred in control. > > > > > > But can ACT really help in this? And how can it help? I can certainly accept > > > my feelings of hatred, I even express it quite frankly sometimes, but it > > > seems so unacceptable to many people to hate and especially to hate one's > > > parents. > > > > > > I'm really at a loss how to deal with my feelings of hatred. > > > Am I doing the right thing? > > > Anybody have any advice for me about this? > > > > > > TIA > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > ------------------------------------ > > > > For other ACT materials and list serves see www.contextualpsychology.org > > > > If you do not wish to belong to ACT_for_the_Public, you may > > unsubscribe by sending an email to > > ACT_for_the_Public-unsubscribe@...! Groups Links > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 15, 2010 Report Posted June 15, 2010 These posts have been very helpful to me and have come at the right time. I got really angry today but I didn't act on it, there was just this implosion instead, with lots of self critism, and a desire to lash out, which I knew would be a disaster and then I would feel even worse. Maybe I had made a mistake, or maybe I hadn't? I coudn't figure it out. I tried defusion but it didn't work that well as I was so upset. But I was reading these posts about accepting, allowing these feelings, and accepting and I gave it go. My inner critic was saying I was 'mental' or 'nutty' for getting so angry, and therefor I was a really bad and dreadful person. In the end I had no choice but to just be with it without judgement and just be aware. I was then able to focus on the guitar and it felt weird that I was not trying to resolve this and absolve myself. I felt scared to let go like of the battle fearing that it would never cease, and I would never get to feel good about myself. But in the end I calmed down and enjoyed playing the guitar. Although the pain is still inside somewhere, and could flare up again, it has lessoned right down in intensity and now I feel that I problably never would have been able to figure it out anyway. I'm quite happy now with my guitar and I can hear the seagulls outside because I am being mindful and it is beautiful. I feel a lot of peace right now and yet I haven't sorted anything out. And I don't think there is any need to. I'm not perfect but it is okay, well my body say's its okay right now, so Im not going to argue with it. I make mistakes but I don't think that is anything too bad at the moment. Time for some keyboards now I think, but a few more moments listening to those seagulls outside is going to be rather nice I think. Kaivey > > > > > > > > Hi. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I have a rough time with personal relationships with-in my extended family. > > > > I was ridiculed and made fun of, shunned because of my birth circumstances > > > > and my very existence within the family was resented by many. I was raised > > > > by my grandparents as their own child, but I actually was a granddaughter. > > > > My mother Kay had me when she was sisteen, this was back in the mid 50's in > > > > a very conservative back waters town. I was thirteen when the truth was told > > > > to me and of the many feelings I had, being ashamed was overwhelming and > > > > shaped my life. Growing up as a teenager I rebelled constantly, eventually > > > > quite school, ran away, etc:. I am a highly sensitive person I have > > > > suffered from comments and or actions from family members that have left me > > > > empty ,sad, destroyed and forever feeling guilty, even if I am not to blame. > > > > I in turn have further damaged relationships with members by being > > > > inflexible and angry, acting out on my hurt and rejection. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > My grandmother loved me, I didn't realize how much she protected me from > > > > other family members until she was gone. Since her death, I am estranged > > > > from most of my siblings. My grandmother made space for me in the family , > > > > and would not tolerate out and out meanness directed at me from others in > > > > the family. And in turn would plead my case, some viewed this as I was > > > > spoiled. With her death that protection died. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I believed that family would stand by you no matter what. I had this > > > > believe that you would always be forgiven because you are family. I had > > > > this believe that I would be accepted and liked and welcomed with open arms > > > > because I was family. I knew that my family was not perfect, but they were > > > > family who were after all always going to have a special place for me. Love > > > > me. No not true. Learning to accept the circumstance for what they are, > > > > was hard. It hurt tremendously, I was very confused as to how I fitted > > > > into all this, why I had so many conflicting emotions, why I acted so badly. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I can, even after all these years - become very fussed with the thoughts and > > > > feelings I can have about how I think the family should be, how they should > > > > treat me (past experiences) and I them (judgments). I Believe my story as > > > > being the absolute truth and justified in being anger and hating. Feed my > > > > ego. All it has done is caused pain and bitterness for me and others. I > > > > cannot do anything to change what happened. I have offered apologies which > > > > are not accepted. This all hurts tremendously. I have learnt to accept the > > > > thoughts around " family " as just thoughts.(ACT therapy) I have learnt to > > > > accept the occasional interaction with a family member with a smile and a > > > > politeness that I would accord any person that I had met. When my buttons > > > > are being pushed wither by me or them, I have learnt to stay calm, allow and > > > > expand with the thoughts, and carry on in a way that reflects my value of > > > > being a kind person.(ACT ) When there is contact because of births, > > > > graduations, I send a card or an email wishing well. In the case of > > > > funerals I go and don't stay around after offering condolences. I can > > > > accept this situation, not liking it, allow the thought to wash over me in > > > > waves, eventually those thought become less intense and wain. In unexpected > > > > meetings with relatives I no longer try to avoid them, like at the grocery > > > > store. I carry on with my values as best I can. It was not easy in the > > > > beginning , it is not easy at times when I am overcome with sadness, guilt, > > > > betrayal. It is not easy when I visualize the way it should be, or could > > > > have been. If, buts' and maybes... wishing and worrying does not change > > > > the facts. It is what it is. We were born into our families without > > > > choice, we can choice our friends and we can choose the values that we want > > > > to reflect as a human being. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I have found the exercise for the white room helpful - a thought comes in > > > > one door swings around the room and departs by the other door. I am only > > > > the observer. I also like to get physical active, as this forces me to > > > > concentrate on what I am doing, (mindfulness). I get charged with adrenaline > > > > and need to move(get physical) to displace this energy in a non-self > > > > destructive means. I will use different combination of > > > > acceptance/expansion/diffusion exercises. The Mindfulness Acceptance > > > > Workbook for Anxiety offers many exercises, or any good ACT therapy book > > > > will contain some exercises to help. This board Is also tremendously > > > > helpful as there are many people who understand applying ACT and are able to > > > > express themselves quite articulately with process. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > The Serenity Prayer- somehow seemed ACT appropriate today. > > > > > > > > All the best Bre > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > " Lord grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change, the > > > > courage to change the things I can, and the wisdom to know the difference. " > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > From: ACT_for_the_Public > > > > [mailto:ACT_for_the_Public ] On Behalf Of Mrs Himani Samdhya > > > > Dumre > > > > Sent: Monday, June 14, 2010 10:46 PM > > > > To: ACT_for_the_Public > > > > Subject: Re: How do you resolve strong feelings of > > > > hatred towards your parents?? > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Hi , I lurk on this group also.. I am new to ACT and have a therapist > > > > who is doing ACT with me... we have only just started.. I can relate to your > > > > troubles with your birth family. I don't exactly feel hatred but more like > > > > rage and anger at my mother and father.. but more so my mother as she was > > > > the " well " one and did nothing to change the situation of domestic violence > > > > I grew up in. I really would rather not see her anymore... My father passed > > > > away 7 years ago. I don't have contact with my birth sister.. that is a long > > > > story... Last time I saw my mother we ended up in a horrible argument.. She > > > > wants a close relationship with my baby daughter but I would rather not have > > > > her in my life very much at all.. My husband and I were thinking of having > > > > another child but then my mental health took a turn for the worse after > > > > seeing my mother and we started questioning the sense of having another > > > > child.. I have bipolar. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I am also trying to learn how to unhook and defuse from these awful thoughts > > > > that bother me in relation to seeing my mother.. I can understand what you > > > > said about others not understanding why one has made a break from birth > > > > family.. I got that also from people...which just made me feel guilty. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I hope I am not going off topic to much I just related so much to what you > > > > wrote... would be interested to work out how to use ACT on such heavy and > > > > dark thoughts. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Peace > > > > > > > > Georgia > > > > > > > > How do you resolve strong feelings of hatred > > > > towards your parents?? > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I have been lurking for some time and really find the advice here useful. I > > > > first encountered the book " Get out of your mind... " after I > > > > had ended up in A & E twice in March this year due to full-blown panic attacks > > > > that could not resolve themselves. So I read the book and did the exercises > > > > faithfully and was astounded at how much it had helped me in overcoming my > > > > panic attacks and anxiety. I still have some social anxiety lurking around > > > > and it flares up sometimes although not all the time when I'm out and about. > > > > At the same time that I was reading that book, I was put on Citalopram but > > > > couldn't tolerate the side effects so I stopped it myself against the wishes > > > > of my GP and did not get any more panic attacks which I credit to the help > > > > the book gave me. > > > > > > > > But now that the panic attacks are manageable and almost never flare up, I > > > > have another problem. Hatred, and specifically hatred towards parents for > > > > what they've done to me in the past. > > > > > > > > My parents were very cruel and unkind to me when I was growing up. They were > > > > abusive, controlling, authoritarian and cold (never hugged me or kissed me, > > > > never shared any moments of laughter or happiness with me). I left home as > > > > soon as I could and have not seen them for over a decade now. We used to > > > > speak on the phone very occasionally or email once a year. This is because > > > > we still don't agree on lots of issues concerning the way I live my life. > > > > Basically I still don't live the way they *wanted* me to and our > > > > conversations inadvertently end on a sour note and leave me sad and bitter > > > > for days afterwards. > > > > > > > > I don't think of them that much now. I have a family of 3 children whom I > > > > spend most of my days looking after and love dearly. But whenever I get some > > > > form of contact from them again, I feel a very deep sense of dread. Its > > > > almost like I really don't want to keep contact with them anymore because I > > > > feel like every time they talk to me, it really affects me deeply and > > > > negatively. I think I still have very strong feelings of hatred for them, > > > > there is almost no way I can really think of them in any positive light. > > > > When I think of them, the feeling I get is just a really strong feeling of > > > > hatred. If I had to draw a picture describing how I feel, it would be like a > > > > deep black dark hole that sucks all happiness out of me. > > > > > > > > But I also sadness as I realise my parents and I will never get along. > > > > Its sad for me too because I don't have such a relationship with my children > > > > and I often wonder why they could not even have treated me with half the > > > > decency I do to my children. > > > > > > > > Someone told me that hatred is not good for me (which I agree its true). It > > > > takes a lot of effort to hate somebody, and it drains a lot out of you. I > > > > agree with it wholeheartedly, but the feelings are so strong that even when > > > > I practice acceptance, it never gets rid of them completely. But why does it > > > > never leave me? I have already built a new life for myself in a land far > > > > away from my parents' more than a decade ago, married with children and live > > > > a busy life but I love my children dearly and they fill my life with > > > > sunshine. I have some problems with my spouse, but not to the point of > > > > divorce, just quibbling often about trivial things, and this is typical of > > > > our relationship from the start so nothing really worrying about it. > > > > > > > > Its just that I feel frustrated at times when I sense the feelings of hatred > > > > returning every time I get contact from my family. I really don't wish to > > > > revisit those horrible days living under my parents' wing again but every > > > > time the hatred flares up after speaking to them, I am reminded of all those > > > > terrible incidents in the past. I am so weary of thinking of them. I severed > > > > ties with my dad and mum last year, but now recently I found myself severing > > > > ties with my sister and brother as well because they keep echoing the same > > > > words that my parents would have (though to a lesser extent)... and > > > > everytime they talk to me in that way I start to hate them too because they > > > > remind me of my parents so much. > > > > > > > > I still don't know if I was right to sever ties with the entire family > > > > completely now. Certainly I find little acceptance and sympathy amongst > > > > people if I do choose to divulge to them what I've done. That makes me > > > > question whether it was the right thing to do. I'm often told by those who > > > > disagree with what I did, that you can never choose your parents in life, > > > > and no matter how much they've hurted you, at least they have raised you and > > > > you should appreciate them for that and that alone. Which makes me feel like > > > > such an ungrateful person and that I'm such a weakling for not being able to > > > > keep my feelings of hatred in control. > > > > > > > > But can ACT really help in this? And how can it help? I can certainly accept > > > > my feelings of hatred, I even express it quite frankly sometimes, but it > > > > seems so unacceptable to many people to hate and especially to hate one's > > > > parents. > > > > > > > > I'm really at a loss how to deal with my feelings of hatred. > > > > Am I doing the right thing? > > > > Anybody have any advice for me about this? > > > > > > > > TIA > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > ------------------------------------ > > > > > > For other ACT materials and list serves see www.contextualpsychology.org > > > > > > If you do not wish to belong to ACT_for_the_Public, you may > > > unsubscribe by sending an email to > > > ACT_for_the_Public-unsubscribe@! Groups Links > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 15, 2010 Report Posted June 15, 2010 My father was a very mean and nasty person. I was in grad school when he had divorce papers filed on my mom the day she came home from major surgery. She begged and begged him not to leave her (yeah, her self esteem is really that low). My father's idea of divorice was to give my mom all the bills (including the credit cards that he maxed out on his girlfriend) and he would get the house and car and all the stuff. They still lived together for a year after the filing, awaiting a court date. My mom did not have the money to move out. During that year his abuse turned from verbal to physical and sexual. In the end she moved into the local women's shelter. My father made her life a living hell - even after the divorce. He'd call and yell at her. She got 1/2 his Army retirement by federal law and he'd dump it in pennies at the door to her apartment. (It took her over a decade to pay off the lawyer bills since she'd have to fight for things like direct payment instead of pennies.) When I finished grad school and didn't yet have a job I lived with her. I was awaiting an interview call and picked up the phone. It was my father. He came over to my mom's apartment, busted down the door and started choaking me because I'd " sided with " my mom. By chance my brother stopped by - he never just stopped by like that - and pulled my father off me before he killed me. I was 24. So yeah - I can relate. I hated my father for many years. The only time I felt guilty for hating him was when well-meaning therapists, friends and aqaintances told me I needed to " forgive him. " When I got married I changed my name and my co-workers were very angry I did that. They shut up when I said, " I'd rather have the name of a man who loves me, than the name of the ()^*$$(* who tried to kill me! " Over the years my hate faded into pity and sorrow. My dad was the way he was because of the childhood he had. While I could understand the source of his disfunction/undiagnoised mental illness, I could never forgive him for trying to kill me or for the living hell he made of my mother's life. I never tried to contact my father. After 20 + years he called me out of the blue. To reconcile? No - he yelled at me and told me he was dying and that I should tell my mother she wasn't going to be able to live off his retirement anymore. As if she lived off $350 a month! My father died a few months later. I did not go to the funeral. I wasn't happy he died. I wasn't sad he died. I'm 47 now and I no longer tear up or make fists while talking or writing about my father. It's taken over 20 years to reach that point. Barbara > But no, for these past 10 or so years since leaving their home, I have always just felt pure hatred and anger at them whenever the hatred is aroused from them making contact with me. > But guilt? No. > I was only wishing the hatred would go away really. Quote
Guest guest Posted June 15, 2010 Report Posted June 15, 2010 earlier this year i read...Finding Life Beyond Trauma, using ACT to heal... ( Follete, Pistorello) http://books.google.ca/books?id=bSpcP2BXpZgC & printsec=frontcover & dq=+Fol\ lette & hl=en & ei=C8sXTLPCEY7INeeJwI0L & sa=X & oi=book_result & ct=result & resnum=2 & ved=0\ CDEQ6AEwAQ#v=onepage & q & f=false Besides a repeat of the ACT processes, it introduced me to two key concepts which i found very helpful: (1) time travelling, - when we experience trauma in life (and trauma doesn't have to be war fare or being attacked, it could be anything that stung you and which you still suffer from today), because the traumatic event is so powerful and compelling that we often re-live those traumatic times, as though they just happened yesterday even though it was 10,20,30 years ago. (2) rings of pain - how we often deal w trauma, ie: avoidance, social avoidance, addictions, feelings of anger and hatred? etc etc, often creates outer rings of pain which extends from our traumatic event to behaviours which we sublimely choose on a daily basis. ie: for me ... trauma > social anxiety/ social avoidance > less intimate deep relationships > inability to move forward in life because i was socially anxious > my depression deepens.. why can't i move fwd? , etc etc. Anyways, thought this might help. Tom > > > Bill, I appreciate your insight and the wise things you said > > > in your post, except for one thing. Why would it be helpful to > > > to forgive herself for carrying around her anger? It > > > sounds like " blaming the victim " in a way. > > > > Helena, > > > > If I can jump in for a moment (and I anticipate that Bill will also > > reply) - > > > > Sometimes (not always) persons who blame others (e.g. a parent) > > also blame themselves for all sorts of things in the relationship. > > And sometimes self-blame of this sort can get in the way of living, > > just as other forms of self-judgment can. > > > > When this happens it is not " others blaming the victim " but rather > > " the victim blaming themself. " > > > > One response would be to offer such a person some reassurance & > > support - i.e. to say, " Don't blame yourself, it was not your fault > > but the fault of so-and-so. " > > > > Another response, especially on the part of the person concerned, > > might be self-forgiveness. My own experience has been that this is > > more successful if the goal is to connect with life. For me at least, > > self-forgiveness and forgiveness of others go hand-in-hand and > > have little to do with keeping a record of wrongs and rights. > > > > But that has only been my experience. Others may find their > > experience is different, or that self-blame is not much of an issue > > for them. > > > > -Randy > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 15, 2010 Report Posted June 15, 2010 Hi Tom, actually you know what? Those two concepts you mentioned really struck a chord in me! I can totally get them. Point 2 is especially poignant. I think the anger and hatred that wells up in me when I am reminded of my parents definitely has an effect on my behaviour in daily life. It does lead to some social anxiety, because my confidence has been crushed so badly whilst growing up and being told every other day that I was never wanted, that I was ugly, I was stupid, etc... Well the confidence has been painfully rebuilt over the years after I left them (I say painfully because I've had to go through many painful life experiences in order to realise the fundamental truth that I am an equal with any other human being on Earth, not below them), but in some social situations I still find social anxiety creeping in because some of those old thought patterns somehow find their way back. Less intimacy in daily life? Oh yes, because my parents have used me and misled me during my childhood for their own benefit (they made me turn against certain family members because they had personal feuds with them) and then later they'd turned their backs on me by deciding to " team up " with said family members and showing me up as some kind of horrible child in front of others. They've also told many lies to me, important life-affecting lies which I later found out but not to the detriment of myself in some way. Basically that made me decide never to trust anyone that easily anymore. I've been very cautious with people ever since I was a teen, and do you know something? I think its served me well throughout the years because when I was living and travelling on my own during my younger days, this was perhaps the reason why I had never really gotten together with the wrong sort, and I have never gotten duped/conned out of any my possessions. But the catch is that it also prevents me from getting closer to some people who might otherwise have become a new friend. To me, I always think I can never have too many friends in life. Friends are like true family to me, because I make good friends, and their support can outdo any family support that I have ever gotten in life, ever. I suppose in many ways, if I really wanted to strive for not getting so fused with my thoughts of anger and hatred, would be to focus on how its affecting me on a social level. Well, easier said than done, but thanks Tom. You were on to something. > > > > Bill, I appreciate your insight and the wise things you said > > > > in your post, except for one thing. Why would it be helpful to > > > > to forgive herself for carrying around her anger? It > > > > sounds like " blaming the victim " in a way. > > > > > > Helena, > > > > > > If I can jump in for a moment (and I anticipate that Bill will also > > > reply) - > > > > > > Sometimes (not always) persons who blame others (e.g. a parent) > > > also blame themselves for all sorts of things in the relationship. > > > And sometimes self-blame of this sort can get in the way of living, > > > just as other forms of self-judgment can. > > > > > > When this happens it is not " others blaming the victim " but rather > > > " the victim blaming themself. " > > > > > > One response would be to offer such a person some reassurance & > > > support - i.e. to say, " Don't blame yourself, it was not your fault > > > but the fault of so-and-so. " > > > > > > Another response, especially on the part of the person concerned, > > > might be self-forgiveness. My own experience has been that this is > > > more successful if the goal is to connect with life. For me at least, > > > self-forgiveness and forgiveness of others go hand-in-hand and > > > have little to do with keeping a record of wrongs and rights. > > > > > > But that has only been my experience. Others may find their > > > experience is different, or that self-blame is not much of an issue > > > for them. > > > > > > -Randy > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 15, 2010 Report Posted June 15, 2010 hi I am glad you found this helpful. Lotsa of good stuff/resources on this forum. Good luck on your journey. Tom > > > > > Bill, I appreciate your insight and the wise things you said > > > > > in your post, except for one thing. Why would it be helpful to > > > > > to forgive herself for carrying around her anger? It > > > > > sounds like " blaming the victim " in a way. > > > > > > > > Helena, > > > > > > > > If I can jump in for a moment (and I anticipate that Bill will also > > > > reply) - > > > > > > > > Sometimes (not always) persons who blame others (e.g. a parent) > > > > also blame themselves for all sorts of things in the relationship. > > > > And sometimes self-blame of this sort can get in the way of living, > > > > just as other forms of self-judgment can. > > > > > > > > When this happens it is not " others blaming the victim " but rather > > > > " the victim blaming themself. " > > > > > > > > One response would be to offer such a person some reassurance & > > > > support - i.e. to say, " Don't blame yourself, it was not your fault > > > > but the fault of so-and-so. " > > > > > > > > Another response, especially on the part of the person concerned, > > > > might be self-forgiveness. My own experience has been that this is > > > > more successful if the goal is to connect with life. For me at least, > > > > self-forgiveness and forgiveness of others go hand-in-hand and > > > > have little to do with keeping a record of wrongs and rights. > > > > > > > > But that has only been my experience. Others may find their > > > > experience is different, or that self-blame is not much of an issue > > > > for them. > > > > > > > > -Randy > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 16, 2010 Report Posted June 16, 2010 Much useful stuff has already been said, but I think the one thing to be remembered is that your parents are no longer the problem, it is the stories you keep telling yourself about them that is the problem...I am sure you feel justified in holding this hatred for them, but unless you are physically in front of them, and they are acting cruel, your hatred is stemming from thought, memory, from a story that you are repeating in your mind... Hate is thought based...you truly cannot hate a person, only the story you tell of them... So when you are telling yourself, my parents are " cruel, unkind, abusive, controlling, authoritarian " , that may have been true while you were under there care, but is it true now, in this moment, or is it a story you are telling of the past that you are reacting to in the present? Unfortunately there are no " shouldn'ts " in this world, and no amount of mental resistance is going to change what happened to you as a child...it sounds callous, but it SHOULD have happened because IT DID happen (reality)...thats not to say you agree or condone it, or you would ever treat anyone that way yourself, but not accepting it's reality is obviously futile and is consuming you... As Buddha said: " Holding on to anger is like grasping a hot coal with the intent of throwing it at someone else; you are the one who gets burned " Best, VC > > I have been lurking for some time and really find the advice here useful. I first encountered the book " Get out of your mind... " after I had ended up in A & E twice in March this year due to full-blown panic attacks that could not resolve themselves. So I read the book and did the exercises faithfully and was astounded at how much it had helped me in overcoming my panic attacks and anxiety. I still have some social anxiety lurking around and it flares up sometimes although not all the time when I'm out and about. At the same time that I was reading that book, I was put on Citalopram but couldn't tolerate the side effects so I stopped it myself against the wishes of my GP and did not get any more panic attacks which I credit to the help the book gave me. > > But now that the panic attacks are manageable and almost never flare up, I have another problem. Hatred, and specifically hatred towards parents for what they've done to me in the past. > > My parents were very cruel and unkind to me when I was growing up. They were abusive, controlling, authoritarian and cold (never hugged me or kissed me, never shared any moments of laughter or happiness with me). I left home as soon as I could and have not seen them for over a decade now. We used to speak on the phone very occasionally or email once a year. This is because we still don't agree on lots of issues concerning the way I live my life. Basically I still don't live the way they *wanted* me to and our conversations inadvertently end on a sour note and leave me sad and bitter for days afterwards. > > I don't think of them that much now. I have a family of 3 children whom I spend most of my days looking after and love dearly. But whenever I get some form of contact from them again, I feel a very deep sense of dread. Its almost like I really don't want to keep contact with them anymore because I feel like every time they talk to me, it really affects me deeply and negatively. I think I still have very strong feelings of hatred for them, there is almost no way I can really think of them in any positive light. When I think of them, the feeling I get is just a really strong feeling of hatred. If I had to draw a picture describing how I feel, it would be like a deep black dark hole that sucks all happiness out of me. > > But I also sadness as I realise my parents and I will never get along. > Its sad for me too because I don't have such a relationship with my children and I often wonder why they could not even have treated me with half the decency I do to my children. > > Someone told me that hatred is not good for me (which I agree its true). It takes a lot of effort to hate somebody, and it drains a lot out of you. I agree with it wholeheartedly, but the feelings are so strong that even when I practice acceptance, it never gets rid of them completely. But why does it never leave me? I have already built a new life for myself in a land far away from my parents' more than a decade ago, married with children and live a busy life but I love my children dearly and they fill my life with sunshine. I have some problems with my spouse, but not to the point of divorce, just quibbling often about trivial things, and this is typical of our relationship from the start so nothing really worrying about it. > > Its just that I feel frustrated at times when I sense the feelings of hatred returning every time I get contact from my family. I really don't wish to revisit those horrible days living under my parents' wing again but every time the hatred flares up after speaking to them, I am reminded of all those terrible incidents in the past. I am so weary of thinking of them. I severed ties with my dad and mum last year, but now recently I found myself severing ties with my sister and brother as well because they keep echoing the same words that my parents would have (though to a lesser extent)... and everytime they talk to me in that way I start to hate them too because they remind me of my parents so much. > > I still don't know if I was right to sever ties with the entire family completely now. Certainly I find little acceptance and sympathy amongst people if I do choose to divulge to them what I've done. That makes me question whether it was the right thing to do. I'm often told by those who disagree with what I did, that you can never choose your parents in life, and no matter how much they've hurted you, at least they have raised you and you should appreciate them for that and that alone. Which makes me feel like such an ungrateful person and that I'm such a weakling for not being able to keep my feelings of hatred in control. > > But can ACT really help in this? And how can it help? I can certainly accept my feelings of hatred, I even express it quite frankly sometimes, but it seems so unacceptable to many people to hate and especially to hate one's parents. > > I'm really at a loss how to deal with my feelings of hatred. > Am I doing the right thing? > Anybody have any advice for me about this? > > > TIA > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 16, 2010 Report Posted June 16, 2010 Bill, Yes, thought labeling is a great one...it doesn't deny or resist the thought, but just labels it for what it truly (in reality) is...a thought... It helps to cut off the identification of the content of the thought Also, maybe it would be helpful to inquire as to what the payoff is for holding the hatred...in my experience, the payoff for hatred, is that for one, believing (erroneously) that it will hurt the other person (remember the Buddha quote), and second, unconsciously, the hatred prevents them from having to experience the story (self-judgment) of what the original situation says about them... > > > > > > I have been lurking for some time and really find the advice here useful. I first encountered the book " Get out of your mind... " after I had ended up in A & E twice in March this year due to full-blown panic attacks that could not resolve themselves. So I read the book and did the exercises faithfully and was astounded at how much it had helped me in overcoming my panic attacks and anxiety. I still have some social anxiety lurking around and it flares up sometimes although not all the time when I'm out and about. At the same time that I was reading that book, I was put on Citalopram but couldn't tolerate the side effects so I stopped it myself against the wishes of my GP and did not get any more panic attacks which I credit to the help the book gave me. > > > > > > But now that the panic attacks are manageable and almost never flare up, I have another problem. Hatred, and specifically hatred towards parents for what they've done to me in the past. > > > > > > My parents were very cruel and unkind to me when I was growing up. They were abusive, controlling, authoritarian and cold (never hugged me or kissed me, never shared any moments of laughter or happiness with me). I left home as soon as I could and have not seen them for over a decade now. We used to speak on the phone very occasionally or email once a year. This is because we still don't agree on lots of issues concerning the way I live my life. Basically I still don't live the way they *wanted* me to and our conversations inadvertently end on a sour note and leave me sad and bitter for days afterwards. > > > > > > I don't think of them that much now. I have a family of 3 children whom I spend most of my days looking after and love dearly. But whenever I get some form of contact from them again, I feel a very deep sense of dread. Its almost like I really don't want to keep contact with them anymore because I feel like every time they talk to me, it really affects me deeply and negatively. I think I still have very strong feelings of hatred for them, there is almost no way I can really think of them in any positive light. When I think of them, the feeling I get is just a really strong feeling of hatred. If I had to draw a picture describing how I feel, it would be like a deep black dark hole that sucks all happiness out of me. > > > > > > But I also sadness as I realise my parents and I will never get along. > > > Its sad for me too because I don't have such a relationship with my children and I often wonder why they could not even have treated me with half the decency I do to my children. > > > > > > Someone told me that hatred is not good for me (which I agree its true). It takes a lot of effort to hate somebody, and it drains a lot out of you. I agree with it wholeheartedly, but the feelings are so strong that even when I practice acceptance, it never gets rid of them completely. But why does it never leave me? I have already built a new life for myself in a land far away from my parents' more than a decade ago, married with children and live a busy life but I love my children dearly and they fill my life with sunshine. I have some problems with my spouse, but not to the point of divorce, just quibbling often about trivial things, and this is typical of our relationship from the start so nothing really worrying about it. > > > > > > Its just that I feel frustrated at times when I sense the feelings of hatred returning every time I get contact from my family. I really don't wish to revisit those horrible days living under my parents' wing again but every time the hatred flares up after speaking to them, I am reminded of all those terrible incidents in the past. I am so weary of thinking of them. I severed ties with my dad and mum last year, but now recently I found myself severing ties with my sister and brother as well because they keep echoing the same words that my parents would have (though to a lesser extent)... and everytime they talk to me in that way I start to hate them too because they remind me of my parents so much. > > > > > > I still don't know if I was right to sever ties with the entire family completely now. Certainly I find little acceptance and sympathy amongst people if I do choose to divulge to them what I've done. That makes me question whether it was the right thing to do. I'm often told by those who disagree with what I did, that you can never choose your parents in life, and no matter how much they've hurted you, at least they have raised you and you should appreciate them for that and that alone. Which makes me feel like such an ungrateful person and that I'm such a weakling for not being able to keep my feelings of hatred in control. > > > > > > But can ACT really help in this? And how can it help? I can certainly accept my feelings of hatred, I even express it quite frankly sometimes, but it seems so unacceptable to many people to hate and especially to hate one's parents. > > > > > > I'm really at a loss how to deal with my feelings of hatred. > > > Am I doing the right thing? > > > Anybody have any advice for me about this? > > > > > > > > > TIA > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > ------------------------------------ > > > > For other ACT materials and list serves see www.contextualpsychology.org > > > > If you do not wish to belong to ACT_for_the_Public, you may > > unsubscribe by sending an email to > > ACT_for_the_Public-unsubscribe@...! Groups Links > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 16, 2010 Report Posted June 16, 2010 As Buddha said: " Holding on to anger is like grasping a hot coal with the intent of throwing it at someone else; you are the one who gets burned " [unquote] Nice......... Thanks Raja Quote
Guest guest Posted June 16, 2010 Report Posted June 16, 2010 2 things... 1) Sounds crazy, but you could just accept your parents EXACTLY as you think them to be, warts and all...which btw, is the SAME unconditional acceptance that seems to be wanting from them (hmmm) 2) Speak up for yourself, or remove yourself from the situation entirely seems to want a relationship with her parents or she wouldn't keep taking it even though she hates the way they make her feel a certain way. (though in truth, no one outside of yourself has the power to " make " you feel a certain way...that is internal) > > > > So  ........ it is OK to have anger but not to hold onto it. Anger is a normal human emotion that may be appropriate at times. Holding on to it can only hurt you. I can see that clearly. > > > > In 's case (excuse me, , for talking about you in the third person!), I believe she stated that the abuse was ongoing -- not just in the past, but it continues in the present. So that really presents a different twist on the anger; it keeps getting refueled and activated by current events. I can see how that would be exceedingly more difficult to defuse than something that occurred only in the past.  > > > > I guess I would try to figure out, if it were me, what the hatred and anger were doing for me in the present. It may be serving a useful, but subtle and counterproductive purpose.  For me, I think it would be to mask the pain that is too horrible to face. It may be easier to hate one's parents than to face the fact that they do not care for you or even like you! So that would be the starting point, I think ... to lean into the underlying emotion ... the pain.  > > > > Rationally, one could come to accept and defuse the pain and subsequent hatred, since it has absolutely nothing to do with you and your worth as a human being. A child cannot know that her parents' abuse has nothing to do with her, so it is all too easy to carry the belief into adulthood that she is somehow " not good " because her parents didn't care for her or even like her (if your mama don't like you, ain't noboby gonna like you!). But adults can reason through that false belief and come to say:  " Tough shit, so I had lousy parents. I'm not going to waste my energy hating them or holding on to the anger. "  The ACT processes are right there for the practicing. Not easy, but doable. > > > > And, I reiterate from a previous post: You do not have to have a " talking, seeing " relationship with your abusers, blood relatives or not. That is up to you entirely; protecting your sanity is a priority. > > > > Helena > >  > > > > > Re: How do you resolve strong feelings of hatred towards your parents?? > >  > > > > > As Buddha said: > > " Holding on to anger is like grasping a hot coal with the intent of throwing it at someone else; you are the one who gets burned " [unquote] > > Nice......... > > Thanks > Raja > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 16, 2010 Report Posted June 16, 2010 I remember when I severed ties with my parents, my other family members were very unhappy with this. They said it was wrong. Coming from an East Asian heritage, it is almost unheard of to do something like this. To this day, I don't even dare to tell that many people about what I've done. I've tried telling it to one or two people whom I thought I could trust, and got shunned by them. It really made me feel like its some kind of deep dark secret I must hide if I want to be accepted. Its terrible. I'm expected to talk as if I am still on good terms with my parents. If I divulge from the topic, etc. they'd suss out that something's not right. In the West its much easier. I've not had any Western friends of mine query me about my parents at all. But when I encounter Asian friends, family relations inevitably are key topics of conversation and I can't help but be drawn into it and finding myself pretending that all's well. Don't think anybody I know who is Asian has actually done what I did, and I know quite a lot of people! > > > But no, for these past 10 > or so years since leaving their home, I have always just felt pure hatred and > anger at them whenever the hatred is aroused from them making contact with me. > > > But guilt? No. > > > I was only wishing the hatred would go > away really. > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 17, 2010 Report Posted June 17, 2010 a forgiveness quote: " I came to see that there was nothing to forgive, that I was the one who caused my own problems " " I " meaning, my thinking, and " problems " meaning suffering, which is mental The minute one lets go of the belief that it's others who are responsible for one's suffering, a huge weight gets taken off...you stop blaming, and take control of your own emotional states...it's very freeing vc > > > > > > > > I have been lurking for some time and really find the advice here useful. I first encountered the book " Get out of your mind... " after I had ended up in A & E twice in March this year due to full-blown panic attacks that could not resolve themselves. So I read the book and did the exercises faithfully and was astounded at how much it had helped me in overcoming my panic attacks and anxiety. I still have some social anxiety lurking around and it flares up sometimes although not all the time when I'm out and about. At the same time that I was > reading that book, I was put on Citalopram but couldn't tolerate the side effects so I stopped it myself against the wishes of my GP and did not get any more panic attacks which I credit to the help the book gave me. > > > > > > > > But now that the panic attacks are manageable and almost never flare up, I have another problem. Hatred, and specifically hatred towards parents for what they've done to me in the past. > > > > > > > > My parents were very cruel and unkind to me when I was growing up. They were abusive, controlling, authoritarian and cold (never hugged me or kissed me, never shared any moments of laughter or happiness with me). I left home as soon as I could and have not seen them for over a decade now. We used to speak on the phone very occasionally or email once a year. This is because we still don't agree on lots of issues concerning the way I live my life. Basically I still don't live the way > they *wanted* me to and our conversations inadvertently end on a sour note and leave me sad and bitter for days afterwards. > > > > > > > > I don't think of them that much now. I have a family of 3 children whom I spend most of my days looking after and love dearly. But whenever I get some form of contact from them again, I feel a very deep sense of dread. Its almost like I really don't want to keep contact with them anymore because I feel like every time they talk to me, it really affects me deeply and negatively. I think I still have very strong feelings of hatred for them, there is almost no way I can really think of them in any positive light. When I think of them, the feeling I get is just a really strong feeling of hatred. If I had to draw a picture describing how I feel, it would be like a deep black dark hole that sucks all happiness out of me. > > > > > > > > But I also sadness as I realise my parents > and I will never get along. > > > > Its sad for me too because I don't have such a relationship with my children and I often wonder why they could not even have treated me with half the decency I do to my children. > > > > > > > > Someone told me that hatred is not good for me (which I agree its true). It takes a lot of effort to hate somebody, and it drains a lot out of you. I agree with it wholeheartedly, but the feelings are so strong that even when I practice acceptance, it never gets rid of them completely. But why does it never leave me? I have already built a new life for myself in a land far away from my parents' more than a decade ago, married with children and live a busy life but I love my children dearly and they fill my life with sunshine. I have some problems with my spouse, but not to the point of divorce, just quibbling often about trivial things, and this is typical of our relationship from the start so > nothing really worrying about it. > > > > > > > > Its just that I feel frustrated at times when I sense the feelings of hatred returning every time I get contact from my family. I really don't wish to revisit those horrible days living under my parents' wing again but every time the hatred flares up after speaking to them, I am reminded of all those terrible incidents in the past. I am so weary of thinking of them. I severed ties with my dad and mum last year, but now recently I found myself severing ties with my sister and brother as well because they keep echoing the same words that my parents would have (though to a lesser extent)... and everytime they talk to me in that way I start to hate them too because they remind me of my parents so much. > > > > > > > > I still don't know if I was right to sever ties with the entire family completely now. Certainly I find little acceptance and sympathy amongst people > if I do choose to divulge to them what I've done. That makes me question whether it was the right thing to do. I'm often told by those who disagree with what I did, that you can never choose your parents in life, and no matter how much they've hurted you, at least they have raised you and you should appreciate them for that and that alone. Which makes me feel like such an ungrateful person and that I'm such a weakling for not being able to keep my feelings of hatred in control. > > > > > > > > But can ACT really help in this? And how can it help? I can certainly accept my feelings of hatred, I even express it quite frankly sometimes, but it seems so unacceptable to many people to hate and especially to hate one's parents. > > > > > > > > I'm really at a loss how to deal with my feelings of hatred. > > > > Am I doing the right thing? > > > > Anybody have any advice for me about this? > > > > > > > > > > > > > TIA > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 17, 2010 Report Posted June 17, 2010 Thank you , was waiting for you to chime in on this thread > > > > > > > > > > > > I have been lurking for some time and really find the advice here > > useful. I first encountered the book " Get out of your mind... " > > after I had ended up in A & E twice in March this year due to full-blown panic > > attacks that could not resolve themselves. So I read the book and did the > > exercises faithfully and was astounded at how much it had helped me in > > overcoming my panic attacks and anxiety. I still have some social anxiety > > lurking around and it flares up sometimes although not all the time when I'm > > out and about. At the same time that I was > > > reading that book, I was put on Citalopram but couldn't tolerate the side > > effects so I stopped it myself against the wishes of my GP and did not get > > any more panic attacks which I credit to the help the book gave me. > > > > > > > > > > > > But now that the panic attacks are manageable and almost never > > flare up, I have another problem. Hatred, and specifically hatred towards > > parents for what they've done to me in the past. > > > > > > > > > > > > My parents were very cruel and unkind to me when I was growing up. > > They were abusive, controlling, authoritarian and cold (never hugged me or > > kissed me, never shared any moments of laughter or happiness with me). I > > left home as soon as I could and have not seen them for over a decade now. > > We used to speak on the phone very occasionally or email once a year. This > > is because we still don't agree on lots of issues concerning the way I live > > my life. Basically I still don't live the way > > > they *wanted* me to and our conversations inadvertently end on a sour > > note and leave me sad and bitter for days afterwards. > > > > > > > > > > > > I don't think of them that much now. I have a family of 3 children > > whom I spend most of my days looking after and love dearly. But whenever I > > get some form of contact from them again, I feel a very deep sense of dread. > > Its almost like I really don't want to keep contact with them anymore > > because I feel like every time they talk to me, it really affects me deeply > > and negatively. I think I still have very strong feelings of hatred for > > them, there is almost no way I can really think of them in any positive > > light. When I think of them, the feeling I get is just a really strong > > feeling of hatred. If I had to draw a picture describing how I feel, it > > would be like a deep black dark hole that sucks all happiness out of me. > > > > > > > > > > > > But I also sadness as I realise my parents > > > and I will never get along. > > > > > > Its sad for me too because I don't have such a relationship with my > > children and I often wonder why they could not even have treated me with > > half the decency I do to my children. > > > > > > > > > > > > Someone told me that hatred is not good for me (which I agree its > > true). It takes a lot of effort to hate somebody, and it drains a lot out of > > you. I agree with it wholeheartedly, but the feelings are so strong that > > even when I practice acceptance, it never gets rid of them completely. But > > why does it never leave me? I have already built a new life for myself in a > > land far away from my parents' more than a decade ago, married with children > > and live a busy life but I love my children dearly and they fill my life > > with sunshine. I have some problems with my spouse, but not to the point of > > divorce, just quibbling often about trivial things, and this is typical of > > our relationship from the start so > > > nothing really worrying about it. > > > > > > > > > > > > Its just that I feel frustrated at times when I sense the feelings > > of hatred returning every time I get contact from my family. I really don't > > wish to revisit those horrible days living under my parents' wing again but > > every time the hatred flares up after speaking to them, I am reminded of all > > those terrible incidents in the past. I am so weary of thinking of them. I > > severed ties with my dad and mum last year, but now recently I found myself > > severing ties with my sister and brother as well because they keep echoing > > the same words that my parents would have (though to a lesser extent)... and > > everytime they talk to me in that way I start to hate them too because they > > remind me of my parents so much. > > > > > > > > > > > > I still don't know if I was right to sever ties with the entire > > family completely now. Certainly I find little acceptance and sympathy > > amongst people > > > if I do choose to divulge to them what I've done. That makes me question > > whether it was the right thing to do. I'm often told by those who disagree > > with what I did, that you can never choose your parents in life, and no > > matter how much they've hurted you, at least they have raised you and you > > should appreciate them for that and that alone. Which makes me feel like > > such an ungrateful person and that I'm such a weakling for not being able to > > keep my feelings of hatred in control. > > > > > > > > > > > > But can ACT really help in this? And how can it help? I can > > certainly accept my feelings of hatred, I even express it quite frankly > > sometimes, but it seems so unacceptable to many people to hate and > > especially to hate one's parents. > > > > > > > > > > > > I'm really at a loss how to deal with my feelings of hatred. > > > > > > Am I doing the right thing? > > > > > > Anybody have any advice for me about this? > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > TIA > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 18, 2010 Report Posted June 18, 2010 Yes . Actually me too. When I cut ties with them, I always thought that its not a definite permanent cut-off. Nothing in life is certain. Its possible one day I might feel ready to get back in touch with them. I might. But this is not a promise. Its hard to say if it would happen, if at all. It really depends on whether forgiveness comes about. But cutting ties off is really the first most important step. I agree with you it is dramatic, yes! But necessary. There is no right or wrong way to forgive. People must seek out the way that works for them. And go from there. Cutting ties off is not something that works for everyone. I know there's a few on this list, VC, Bill, , etc. who are supposedly experienced in ACT who push forgiveness as something you consciously do. The problem with that view is that if you find you can't actually " do " forgiveness, then how are you supposed to feel? Like a failure?? Or like you're to blame? I think the danger in that is that can make someone feel even worse for not being able to forgive (yet). But I'll be gentle with myself and not keep striving for forgiveness as something to " do " . And I'll continue to keep Dorothy Rowe's words in my mind. http://www.dorothyrowe.com.au/index.php?u=openmind_forgiveness.htm http://www.dorothyrowe.com.au/index.php?u=Observer:_Louise_Carpenter_(July_2007)\ ..htm > > My personal challenge with " forgiveness " is that there are so many other people who see things so differently.(As if that were not true on almost every topic) To me, when I say I forgive someone, using the present tense, I usually mean that I have willfully chosen to stop asking them to make it right. When I say " I forgave " then I mean what most people mean, which is that most or all of the emotional content is gone. I have yet to find any way of speeding up that process for myself. Obviously, when the other party seeks to make amends, that does seem to help. But I'm not really in control of that, am I? > I've started explaining it to people by telling them the following. If you steal my money, and I choose to forgive you. That doesn't mean the money suddenly reappears from nowhere. I'm still missing some money. If, for some reason, you would realize your error and pay me back, there is still emotional content. You can't pay that back. I forgive not because it makes me suddenly whole but because it sets me on the path to wholeness. > I forgive my dad for what he has done to me in the past. It still hurts, but I have let go of expecting him to do anything about it. I don't know that he even comprehends trying to make amends. I forgive him for who he is, even though it is still hurtful to me to cut off contact. I just looked at it one day and realized that he was promising to keep hurting me and my family. There is some pain in cutting ties, which I think those who would judge us forget. I choose to accept the pain of separation over the suffering of torture. (bit dramatic I suppose, but I'll stick with it. > And thanks for bringing this up, by the way. It has only been a couple years now, and it has been helpful for me to review where I am with this and where I am going to go. I think that at one point, I thought I would go back and try to see if he has changed his mind, but I'm just not there yet. > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 18, 2010 Report Posted June 18, 2010 Hi , thanks for that. I think I have been doing all that already! Its not like we're just sitting around in our bedroom everyday moping about the past!?!! > > i don't know if this is useful or not, but i tried... > > one way is to go for values yourself > > instead of forcing forgiving you can also use a backdoor to it... > > here's a modified version of THE WORK for this... > > take a resentment: for example, I resent my mother for not holding me enough...or my father for being too distant. > > go ahead and be pissed about it or sad or whatever...work the feeling up on purpose if need be, i like to do it on long walks if something feels ripe...just feel what you feel first...accept all your thinking for now, meaning give it space to flower, don't fix anything > > (but don't go around bashing people for real!!!) > > then later...write down 3 ways you can do for yourself what they failed to do...heal the family problem in you... > > for example, take the mom one above: how can i hold (or maybe nurture) myself more? > > 1. I can ask for it in some form...to spend time with a friend for example > 2. I can do things that soothe me, go to the mall, or watch my favorite movie (hopefully non-harmful things) > 3. I can also express this more to others, when I nurture others, it is often a kind of self-nurturing for me > > there you have your new value...self-nurturance and nurturing others...this is workable and begins the process of letting your parents off the hook. forgiveness will happen as you no longer need them to do what you can do for yourself. some people don't forgive, because they are still counting on something from someone. forgiveness feels like they have to run back to that person to try to get it still. but, if you can do it yourself, you don't have to go back to that person to it...and you can let go/forgive. > > much later, you can consider, how to be nurturing for mom...when it is time for that, or if it ever is. > > jason > > >  > > > > ________________________________ > > To: ACT_for_the_Public > Sent: Mon, June 14, 2010 8:51:54 PM > Subject: Re: Re: How do you resolve strong feelings of hatred towards your parents?? > >  > , I too wonder if one can will forgiveness. .. I find that lots of things in my life have been a result of how I was raised... I do think it is possible to work on forgiveness but I do not see that forcing or willing forgiveness is helpful... I also think forgiveness is a very misunderstood concept and is sometimes put on the victim/survivor so then the focus is on them rather than on the person who caused the offence. >  > Peace > Georgia Quote
Guest guest Posted June 18, 2010 Report Posted June 18, 2010 > > I know there's a few on this list who are supposedly > experienced in ACT who push forgiveness as something you > consciously do. The problem with that view is that if you find > you can't actually " do " forgiveness, then how are you supposed > to feel? Like a failure?? Or like you're to blame? Hi , 's words seem to have resonated for you. They resonate for me too, even though my situation is different than his and I have made different choices. Something comes across to me in his words that I can't easily express. Maybe it is compassion? I don't think anyone on this list means to push a particular view of forgiveness on you. If that were anyone's intent, it would not be very ACT-like. Mostly I think folks are offering to explain how forgiveness is viewed from within ACT, the way someone might explain the rules of a game. No agreement is required. As you have noticed, sometimes folks also post specific questions to each other. This seems fine as long as the questions are non-judgemental. And the best questions are also like playing a game - just as we can choose to play or not play, we can answer or not answer as we please. I want to close with something I posted yesterday but got too cute about. What I meant is this: sometimes we only hear a message when we are ready for it. Before then we are deaf to it. So often that has been the case with me! However that does not mean that any particular message is meant for us as opposed to someone else. Words are just words & I don't think anyone can claim more than that. No one can force someone else to hear or claim that the other person " should " have heard. And yet we still have to be ready to hear something. There is no solving this mystery. I do think that for me, the old Zen parable is true - my cup is sometimes too full. It has been hard (and continues to be hard) to apply ACT in my life, only because my head is already so full of things I think I know. And so now & then I seek to empty that cup. I speak only for myself. -Randy Quote
Guest guest Posted June 18, 2010 Report Posted June 18, 2010 Hi all, on one hand, I know you are responding because you truly think it would help me. On the other hand, because its a big issue (well, kind of) for me, and I can't seem to " do " forgiveness at all no matter how, I get very exasperated when I hear so many people say " you gotta just do it, you gotta just do it. " And I'm thinking " HOW??!!! " I just don't get it, for the life of me. Doing forgiveness, etc. is just words. But in practical terms, it really does not translate into something I know how to do! Like I said, in the past, if I forgave somebody, it always came about by its own and I only realise it when I think of that person one day and no longer feel hatred in my heart. So forgiveness for me, based on past experience, never came about after conscious efforts to do so. I think at the end of the day, this is just mine and my issue alone. And its me who has to find my way around this. Everything else seems peripheral. Thank you for all your replies anyway They say that every single moment of your life, whatever you say or think or do, changes you in some way. Every interaction with someone changes you in some way, even if it seems like a teeny tiny bit. Perhaps all these exchanges of information has changed me in a way, I don't know. > >  > >Oooooh! I LOVE it! I WANT it! My soul is scorched! > > > >Now I just have to figure out how to release the anger and not get burned. > > > >Barbara > > > >--- In ACT_for_the_ Public@yahoogrou ps.com, " vcferrara " <> > > > > " Holding on to anger is like grasping a hot coal with the intent of throwing it at someone else; you are the one who gets burned " > >> > >> Best, > >> VC > >> > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 18, 2010 Report Posted June 18, 2010 I tried imagining my mother as a child before. It couldn't work because I think she is such a monster that I couldn't imagine any child's face as her... They are too angelic for that. Also I've never seen any real photos of her when she was a child. Also, I know this might sound freaky to some of you, but prior to severing ties with her, I used to have nightmares of her trying to kill me almost every time after she had contacted me by long-distance phonecall or email. Its just old memories though, but they feel so fresh and I still feel so scared of her when I think of it, I start trembling and feeling cold. I'd just remember one of those times when she chased me around the flat with a cleaver threatening to cut me up and kill me, or when she was trying to strangle me to death (well, on hindsight I guess she could have just killed me if she wanted but she didn't go through with it so perhaps she wasn't going to.) On a few occasions I went blue in the face before she gave up, once I nearly passed out. Other times she'd lock me up in the bedroom for so many hours, I wasn't sure how long though because my earliest memory of that was about 5 years old. Looking back, I *think* I might have been a depressed child, I don't know. Nobody ever asked about me or showed any concern in what I felt, and I never knew how to express those feelings or even aware of what they really were! I've never seen a psychologist or counsellor. I feel really uncomfortable expressing my thoughts feelings and my past to someone in person. I think they judge me, and I think they will never understand or comprehend me. When I was between the ages of 14 to 17 I went through a self-mutilation phase where I'd cut my arms with pen-knifes and things just for fun, and also if I felt really emotional because I've had a row with my parents, I'd do that because it takes the pain away a little. Then I stopped because my mum saw the scars one day and said I was nuts and threatened to put me into an asylum if I didn't stop this madness. I was afraid of course, because I've been to an old folks' home once as a teen to volunteer, and I saw how bad the conditions were and how little care the people received, and even though it was an old folks' home, there were young people there in their 20s and 30s who are just thrown in there because they were a bit retarded and their family didn't want to look after them anymore. I did not dare to think what the asylums would be like. It was like a national joke - the asylum. People often made fun of the asylum and it really wasn't seen as a place where people would go in, and really get treated and come out fine. It seemed like a place where people would go in and have little hope of ever rejoining society again. So I made a conscious effort to repress all my feelings of fear, anger, sadness, etc... for all these years. I moved out of my home, moved far away, set up a new home for myself, a new family, etc. I read Dorothy Rowe's description of asylums in England and it seems just as much as a place of hopelessness where people hardly ever emerge from it cured. There is no way I am going to go up to a doctor today and say " here's my problem. etc. etc. " I don't want any psychiatric drugs, I am having none of it. The life I've built is too good for me to throw away (even if its not perfect). But revisiting the past with my mother is very, very hard and very very traumatic for me. You'd think that in this day, when she's grown old and frail and no longer a match for me in physical strength, that I should have nothing to be afraid of her. Indeed, when I see her in person, I am not afraid of her trying to kill me again. But her words cut into me like daggers and I don't know why I still feel so badly hurt by even just her words. When I try to do any sort of mental exercise to " accept " what she did to me, it just throws up a range of horrible reactions in me that I don't even know where it springs from - the tingling behind my neck, the trembling of my hands, the cold feelings... and the nightmares. Those are the worse. I wake up a wreck, tears in my eyes, heart racing in fear... I feel like I'm going through it all over again. I don't know how or if its ever possible to overcome it. Just typing it out now sends shivers down my spine and makes me well up... When I was in the shower just now, I tried what Helena suggested worked for her in producing forgiveness... but the moment I tried to picture my mum as a child and I went to hug her, I started experiencing panic-attack symptoms again... the trembling, the cold shivers, the heart racing... And then I just had to stop. I just had to. It was so strong. Then I felt like such a failure... and I cried. And now I'm starting to wonder if I'm depressed. Now. I shouldn't be. I was quite happy today all day, until then... (sigh) Quote
Guest guest Posted June 18, 2010 Report Posted June 18, 2010 VC, Yes I am fighting the reality of what happened. Yes it continues to haunt me. No I cannot accept them. Yes you are trivialising what happened to me, even if you insist you don't. > > > > > > > > I have been lurking for some time and really find the advice here useful. I first encountered the book " Get out of your mind... " after I had ended up in A & E twice in March this year due to full-blown panic attacks that could not resolve themselves. So I read the book and did the exercises faithfully and was astounded at how much it had helped me in overcoming my panic attacks and anxiety. I still have some social anxiety lurking around and it flares up sometimes although not all the time when I'm out and about. At the same time that I was reading that book, I was put on Citalopram but couldn't tolerate the side effects so I stopped it myself against the wishes of my GP and did not get any more panic attacks which I credit to the help the book gave me. > > > > > > > > But now that the panic attacks are manageable and almost never flare up, I have another problem. Hatred, and specifically hatred towards parents for what they've done to me in the past. > > > > > > > > My parents were very cruel and unkind to me when I was growing up. They were abusive, controlling, authoritarian and cold (never hugged me or kissed me, never shared any moments of laughter or happiness with me). I left home as soon as I could and have not seen them for over a decade now. We used to speak on the phone very occasionally or email once a year. This is because we still don't agree on lots of issues concerning the way I live my life. Basically I still don't live the way they *wanted* me to and our conversations inadvertently end on a sour note and leave me sad and bitter for days afterwards. > > > > > > > > I don't think of them that much now. I have a family of 3 children whom I spend most of my days looking after and love dearly. But whenever I get some form of contact from them again, I feel a very deep sense of dread. Its almost like I really don't want to keep contact with them anymore because I feel like every time they talk to me, it really affects me deeply and negatively. I think I still have very strong feelings of hatred for them, there is almost no way I can really think of them in any positive light. When I think of them, the feeling I get is just a really strong feeling of hatred. If I had to draw a picture describing how I feel, it would be like a deep black dark hole that sucks all happiness out of me. > > > > > > > > But I also sadness as I realise my parents and I will never get along. > > > > Its sad for me too because I don't have such a relationship with my children and I often wonder why they could not even have treated me with half the decency I do to my children. > > > > > > > > Someone told me that hatred is not good for me (which I agree its true). It takes a lot of effort to hate somebody, and it drains a lot out of you. I agree with it wholeheartedly, but the feelings are so strong that even when I practice acceptance, it never gets rid of them completely. But why does it never leave me? I have already built a new life for myself in a land far away from my parents' more than a decade ago, married with children and live a busy life but I love my children dearly and they fill my life with sunshine. I have some problems with my spouse, but not to the point of divorce, just quibbling often about trivial things, and this is typical of our relationship from the start so nothing really worrying about it. > > > > > > > > Its just that I feel frustrated at times when I sense the feelings of hatred returning every time I get contact from my family. I really don't wish to revisit those horrible days living under my parents' wing again but every time the hatred flares up after speaking to them, I am reminded of all those terrible incidents in the past. I am so weary of thinking of them. I severed ties with my dad and mum last year, but now recently I found myself severing ties with my sister and brother as well because they keep echoing the same words that my parents would have (though to a lesser extent)... and everytime they talk to me in that way I start to hate them too because they remind me of my parents so much. > > > > > > > > I still don't know if I was right to sever ties with the entire family completely now. Certainly I find little acceptance and sympathy amongst people if I do choose to divulge to them what I've done. That makes me question whether it was the right thing to do. I'm often told by those who disagree with what I did, that you can never choose your parents in life, and no matter how much they've hurted you, at least they have raised you and you should appreciate them for that and that alone. Which makes me feel like such an ungrateful person and that I'm such a weakling for not being able to keep my feelings of hatred in control. > > > > > > > > But can ACT really help in this? And how can it help? I can certainly accept my feelings of hatred, I even express it quite frankly sometimes, but it seems so unacceptable to many people to hate and especially to hate one's parents. > > > > > > > > I'm really at a loss how to deal with my feelings of hatred. > > > > Am I doing the right thing? > > > > Anybody have any advice for me about this? > > > > > > > > > > > > TIA > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.