Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Re: exhausted mentally and physically

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted

Louise,

I read your post a few times to ensure that I understood what you were

saying. I'm not sure if I do, so if I have gotten anything wrong,

please let me know.

<< I wish it were true to say that I can see my experience as trumping

whatever empirical results have been published. My point is that I can

NOT assess my experience with medication effectively because I am alone.

I am not able to tell whether medication made me worse very rapidly or

whether it was my depression/anxiety/OCD that started very suddenly and

spiralled downwards while taking medication very fast. I had very severe

symptoms, tests for all sorts of conditions that came on very suddenly

after taking paroxetine. To say that each person is individual and

therefore there is little point in discussing medication as something

which can lead to thoughts of suicide in individuals could be the very

thing that leads to more people taking medication and being told they

are the exceptions....and believing it, or believing that their symptoms

were going to arise anyway. If there is no communication between people

after the time-limited trials, which won't pick

up long-term side-effects or very rare side-effects, then more people

can get ill. >>

I think what you're saying here is that without a discussion of the

possible side effects of antidepressants, and having people try the

medications for themselves to gauge their effects, they may find

themselves at the mercy of serious adverse consequences. Is that

correct? If so, I think that's a reasonable concern, and I still think

has to decide for himself.

Schwartz works with OCD patients and has a four step approach he

uses based on Buddhism's Fourfold Path. It may be worth investigating

for you. His self-help book is Brain Lock and he has another book that

goes into the development and theory behind it called The Mind and the

Brain.

<< Thoughts can cause suicide if you don't have time to do therapy

first! >>

I think that what you're saying here is that without an awareness that

thoughts cannot hurt you, a susceptible person may act on those

thoughts? Am I correct here? If so, then I agree again, in principle.

That said, suicide, like any other action, is a deliberate choice.

Arguably, most suicidal behavior is an extreme cry for help.

<< Medication happens between your ears and your thinking can become

extreme, even suicidal, as a result so saying the problem is that you

have fused with your thoughts seems to be irrelevant at that point. >>

I think I see your point here.

<< The irony is that my main obsession that developed over the years has

been that I am a fraud and have invented my illness. The OCD came out of

the blue and just didn't seem to make sense!

So if anyone has any advice on how to be assertive without burning my

boats as far as psychiatrists are concerned I'd be pleased. After all I

may just be wrong! The one good thing is that this time, as my GP

pointed out, I am able to speak coherently whereas I used to have to

write my concerns down and hand them to the psychiatrist as I had such

difficulty speaking, only to be met with the words " If you don't start

behaving like an adult (ie speak!) you won't get better. " A bit like

saying If you refuse to give up your spots you won't recover from

measles:-) >>

Everyone on this listserv strikes me as sincere and intelligent, and I

fail to understand the power of the psychiatric community. I will,

perhaps rather boldly, assert that it is often not really there (with

all due respect to Clint Eastwood's recent film, Changeling, and events

similar to what that film was based on). In a Time magazine article on

ACT, Beck, a man I admire, dismissed the rising star of ACT

compared to cognitive therapy because the data wasn't conclusive

enough. His response struck me as petulant and ironic given his own

early struggle to establish cognitive therapy, he being a psychiatrist

and rooted in an analytic tradition. But his emphasis on empiricism has

served the psychological community well, and unlike psychoanalysis,

which has little empirical support (this may be another bold statement,

and I am open to any refutations if there are any), and general

psychiatry, which emphasizes a disease model for psychological

difficulties, and is heavily influenced by the pharmaceutical industry,

cognitive therapy and the emerging third wave therapies are firmly

rooted in case studies.

Whether you express yourself well to your psychiatrist or not should be

irrelevant to me, because a professional ought to appreciate the

difficulties any one of us might encounter trying to articulate our

concerns. Do you feel comfortable firing the person? That is always an

option. As the consumer, you have every right to seek out the care you

feel you deserve.

Years ago I went through five different general physicians before I

found out that I had reactive hypoglycemia. One doctor suggested that

my condition was psychiatric. I ignored him, saw the primary physician

in the office, and he advised me to take a glucose tolerance test.

One of the things I like about the ACT community, including its

originators and practitioners, is their sense of integrity and humanity,

their willingness to discuss their weaknesses while pursuing their

values. In that respect, they model the material they teach.

Good luck in getting the care you need. It doesn't really matter what

your psychiatrist says or thinks, even if it stings, because you're

paying him/her for a service.

Cheers,

Neil

Posted

In a Time magazine article on ACT, Beck, a man I admire, dismissed the rising star of ACT compared to cognitive therapy because the data wasn't conclusive enough.

I think that is why I think I enjoyed 'A CBT Practioners Guide to ACT' so much. It is wriiten for a very skeptical audience i.e. already established CBT therapists. But it has to go that extra mile to convince these people of the merits of ACT as they already have a very useful working therapy which they naturally think is the best thing ever. It is also a beginners book because it assumes these people know hardly anything about ACT, which is why I probably found it so useful.

You don't need to buy it though if you already have a good ACT book, as it won't tell you anything more. But it was the most simplistic and easy to understand ACT book I have read yet.

Kavy

>> Louise,> > I read your post a few times to ensure that I understood what you were> saying. I'm not sure if I do, so if I have gotten anything wrong,> please let me know.> > << I wish it were true to say that I can see my experience as trumping> whatever empirical results have been published. My point is that I can> NOT assess my experience with medication effectively because I am alone.> I am not able to tell whether medication made me worse very rapidly or> whether it was my depression/anxiety/OCD that started very suddenly and> spiralled downwards while taking medication very fast. I had very severe> symptoms, tests for all sorts of conditions that came on very suddenly> after taking paroxetine. To say that each person is individual and> therefore there is little point in discussing medication as something> which can lead to thoughts of suicide in individuals could be the very> thing that leads to more people taking medication and being told they> are the exceptions....and believing it, or believing that their symptoms> were going to arise anyway. If there is no communication between people> after the time-limited trials, which won't pick> up long-term side-effects or very rare side-effects, then more people> can get ill. >>> > I think what you're saying here is that without a discussion of the> possible side effects of antidepressants, and having people try the> medications for themselves to gauge their effects, they may find> themselves at the mercy of serious adverse consequences. Is that> correct? If so, I think that's a reasonable concern, and I still think> has to decide for himself.> > Schwartz works with OCD patients and has a four step approach he> uses based on Buddhism's Fourfold Path. It may be worth investigating> for you. His self-help book is Brain Lock and he has another book that> goes into the development and theory behind it called The Mind and the> Brain.> > << Thoughts can cause suicide if you don't have time to do therapy> first! >>> > I think that what you're saying here is that without an awareness that> thoughts cannot hurt you, a susceptible person may act on those> thoughts? Am I correct here? If so, then I agree again, in principle.> That said, suicide, like any other action, is a deliberate choice.> Arguably, most suicidal behavior is an extreme cry for help.> > << Medication happens between your ears and your thinking can become> extreme, even suicidal, as a result so saying the problem is that you> have fused with your thoughts seems to be irrelevant at that point. >>> > I think I see your point here.> > << The irony is that my main obsession that developed over the years has> been that I am a fraud and have invented my illness. The OCD came out of> the blue and just didn't seem to make sense!> > So if anyone has any advice on how to be assertive without burning my> boats as far as psychiatrists are concerned I'd be pleased. After all I> may just be wrong! The one good thing is that this time, as my GP> pointed out, I am able to speak coherently whereas I used to have to> write my concerns down and hand them to the psychiatrist as I had such> difficulty speaking, only to be met with the words "If you don't start> behaving like an adult (ie speak!) you won't get better." A bit like> saying If you refuse to give up your spots you won't recover from> measles:-) >>> > Everyone on this listserv strikes me as sincere and intelligent, and I> fail to understand the power of the psychiatric community. I will,> perhaps rather boldly, assert that it is often not really there (with> all due respect to Clint Eastwood's recent film, Changeling, and events> similar to what that film was based on). In a Time magazine article on> ACT, Beck, a man I admire, dismissed the rising star of ACT> compared to cognitive therapy because the data wasn't conclusive> enough. His response struck me as petulant and ironic given his own> early struggle to establish cognitive therapy, he being a psychiatrist> and rooted in an analytic tradition. But his emphasis on empiricism has> served the psychological community well, and unlike psychoanalysis,> which has little empirical support (this may be another bold statement,> and I am open to any refutations if there are any), and general> psychiatry, which emphasizes a disease model for psychological> difficulties, and is heavily influenced by the pharmaceutical industry,> cognitive therapy and the emerging third wave therapies are firmly> rooted in case studies.> > Whether you express yourself well to your psychiatrist or not should be> irrelevant to me, because a professional ought to appreciate the> difficulties any one of us might encounter trying to articulate our> concerns. Do you feel comfortable firing the person? That is always an> option. As the consumer, you have every right to seek out the care you> feel you deserve.> > Years ago I went through five different general physicians before I> found out that I had reactive hypoglycemia. One doctor suggested that> my condition was psychiatric. I ignored him, saw the primary physician> in the office, and he advised me to take a glucose tolerance test. > > One of the things I like about the ACT community, including its> originators and practitioners, is their sense of integrity and humanity,> their willingness to discuss their weaknesses while pursuing their> values. In that respect, they model the material they teach.> > Good luck in getting the care you need. It doesn't really matter what> your psychiatrist says or thinks, even if it stings, because you're> paying him/her for a service.> > Cheers,> > Neil>

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...