Guest guest Posted February 19, 2010 Report Posted February 19, 2010 Just a pointer …. The book mentioned for anxiety disorders was actually written for therapists. I know folks on this list have read it too. That’s fine. The book you may want to look at is The Mindfulness & Acceptance Workbook for Anxiety. This one is based on ACT and was written for folks struggling with anxiety. We have two clinical trials underway – one just finished, the other in progress – testing whether this workbook is helpful. We are still mining the data, but so far here’s what we found. Sample of 500 people from 25 countries – all reporting significant anxiety (and depression) prior to using the workbook. People were randomized to get the workbook or be on a waitlist. Folks who got the workbook worked with it for 12 weeks, and then we followed them at 3 and 6 months. At the end of the 12 weeks, the controls got the workbook and we followed them for 3 months. Bottom line: compared to controls, folks who got the workbook showed large and meaningful improvements in acceptance, mindfulness, self-compassion, and quality of life from pre to post. And, they showed large and meaningful reductions in thought suppression, anxiety, worry, social anxiety, fear, and even depression (though we do not explicitly talk about any of these as being major goals of using the workbook). Heck, we don’t even focus on depression. And, these gains were maintained at 3 month follow up. We have yet to look closely at the 6 month follow up. The controls showed no improvements during the first 12 weeks while they waited for the workbook, and in some cases actually worsened. This doesn’t mean the workbook or ACT is right for you, but just wanted to share this. We will soon be writing up the results of this first study and will share it with everyone when it is ready. Peace -j P. Forsyth, Ph.D. Associate Professor of Psychology Director of Clinical Training Director, Anxiety Disorders Research Program University at Albany, SUNY Department of Psychology Social Sciences 399 1400 Washington Avenue Albany, NY 12222 Ph: Fax: email: forsyth@... Lab Web Page: Anxiety Disorders Research Program Blogs: Mindfulness & Acceptance for Anxiety Peace of Mind at Psychology Today Dr. Forsyth on Amazon.com Our Clinical Trials Evaluating ACT for Anxiety: Visit ACTforAnxiety.com From: ACT_for_the_Public [mailto:ACT_for_the_Public ] On Behalf Of Suddarth Sent: Thursday, February 18, 2010 9:54 PM To: act_for_the_public Subject: RE: exhausted mentally and physically Oh I'm so sorry for your suffering. I was very depressed and didn't think life was worth living for a while. I was fortunate to be able to find a good therapist and benefited from talk therapy, along with the ACT workbook. I was able to tell my therapist things I've never told anyone and something about that release of my most secret fears and self hate was very freeing for me. I didn't click with my original therapist and so I wasn't able to open up and was contemplating quitting altogether. Thankfully she encouraged me to try another clinician at their group and I quickly was able to trust her. After probably 6-8 weekly sessions I felt I was ready to move on with my workbook self study and didn't feel the need to continue the talk therapy. It worked that well for me once I was able to trust her and open up. Something rooted is causing your severe anxiety and ACT is designed to uncover it and help you accept it in a loving way so you can move on with your valued life. I had some serious issues from my first childhood memories and by talking about them and accepting them I was able to get on with my life. Yes it sucks what happened to me but why should I give it power over my life forever? So my advice is to find a good therapist (preferably one trained in ACT), clinician, licensed social worker, or whoever you can trust and if after a couple of sessions you don't feel you're able to trust that person, move on until you do. And stick with the ACT therapy. Are you doing the " Get Out of your mind " workbook? That's the one I did but I know they have a specific one for Anxiety Disorders. I was severely depressed and had the anxiety that goes along with that, but not really an anxiety disorder. I had taken Lexapro and then Cymbalta, along with Xanax and developed a pretty serious addiction to Xanax and was worse off for ever messing with any of these things. I did try St. s Wart though when I was really bad and didn't want to take prescriptions again. I don't know if it helped but it didn't hurt me. You have to take it for a while. I do believe though that Niacinamide (B3) was helpful for me but I didn't start taking that until my depression was mostly better. But the serious changes in defining my values and moving toward them started shortly after I started taking Niacinimide. The first day I took it though I noticed a calming effect and for days after and then I've just felt good since then. Check out these links about it, especially the comments on revolutionhealth.com about Niacinamide & Anxiety. Niacinamide (B3) Vitamin Revolutionhealth.com comments on Niacinamide . I'm blogging about how happy my life is now from practicing ACT and have this post My vitamins & how they support my healthy life! about what I take and I think it helps. The B vitamins and Omegas are supposed to be good for mental health. (disclaimer - of course check with your health care provider before taking anything). I am actuallty very thankful now for my depression because if I wouldn't have gotten that bad off I wouldn't have searched for a better way. I love my life now and know it wouldn't be possible without the talk therapy I did and the ACT workbook, and of course my will to not give up. I hope this at least gives you some hope which sounds to me like you need at this point. So take a deep breath and give it another shot. Good luck I believe you can do this. http://myhappiestlife.com/ To: ACT_for_the_Public From: scott73i3@... Date: Fri, 19 Feb 2010 02:04:49 +0000 Subject: exhausted mentally and physically although i really like ACT, im starting to think in my opinion that it is more for people with milder forms of anxiety/depression...(disclaimer..i am in no way trying to belittle anyone's suffering) i don't see how by accepting that i have severe anxiety, and trying to flow with it, how it's going to do the trick. i have been trying that, and all i find is that im trying my best to flow with the river, while my feet barely touch the bottom as im gasping for breath trying not to go under. it hasn't gotten any easier. i don't sleep well at all, and im having all sorts of physical problems now that i really think are from my body breaking down due to constant high levels of anxiety, and lack of sleep. now im getting caught in a cycle of anxiety probably causing health problems, and health problems exacerbating anxiety. i really feel like im in a tough spot. cause if its true that the research shows that antidepressants aren't any better then placebos, then what ho! pe do i have? im terrified of meds, but now im more terrified at my current mental and physical state, . but how can i take meds if all im going to do is get side effects, and no lessening of my suffering? is psychiatry really a sham? what are these professionals practicing? im really sorry for posting such a negative post, but im in bad shape. if anyone can offer anything, it would be very appreciated -scott Hotmail: Powerful Free email with security by Microsoft. Get it now. Quote
Guest guest Posted February 19, 2010 Report Posted February 19, 2010 Keep chuckling!To: ACT_for_the_Public From: knitlou@...Date: Fri, 19 Feb 2010 06:29:51 -0800Subject: RE: exhausted mentally and physically Hi Bill, My quarrel with some types of religion or the way some try to proselytise is probably very personal:-) I have no quarrel with what you write below:-) ACT as a way of life, a process, a philosophy etc.. all make sense to me! I do sometimes have a problem with some of the "parables" used by ACT but I think that is also a very personal problem I have related to my brain.They also remind me of religion. On the other hand when I get to understand them they can be helpful. I like chuckling too and often chuckle at myself! Louise Rollo May: "I would define mental health as the capacity to be aware of the gapbetween stimulus and response, together with the capacity to use this gapconstructively." (from The psychological bases of freedom, 1962) although i really like ACT, im starting to think in my opinion that it is more for people with milder forms of anxiety/depression. ..(disclaimer. .i am in no way trying to belittle anyone's suffering) i don't see how by accepting that i have severe anxiety, and trying to flow with it, how it's going to do the trick. i have been trying that, and all i find is that im trying my best to flow with the river, while my feet barely touch the bottom as im gasping for breath trying not to go under. it hasn't gotten any easier. i don't sleep well at all, and im having all sorts of physical problems now that i really think are from my body breaking down due to constant high levels of anxiety, and lack of sleep. now im getting caught in a cycle of anxiety probably causing health problems, and health problems exacerbating anxiety. i really feel like im in a tough spot. cause if its true that the research shows that antidepressants aren't any better then placebos, then what hope do i have? im terrified of meds, but now im more terrified at my current mental and physical state, . but how can i take meds if all im going to do is get side effects, and no lessening of my suffering? is psychiatry really a sham? what are these professionals practicing? im really sorry for posting such a negative post, but im in bad shape. if anyone can offer anything, it would be very appreciated-scott Quote
Guest guest Posted February 19, 2010 Report Posted February 19, 2010 Absolutely! I keep using the gap to opt for a chuckle:-) LouiseRollo May: "I would define mental health as the capacity to be aware of the gapbetween stimulus and response, together with the capacity to use this gapconstructively." (from The psychological bases of freedom, 1962) although i really like ACT, im starting to think in my opinion that it is more for people with milder forms of anxiety/depression. ..(disclaimer. .i am in no way trying to belittle anyone's suffering) i don't see how by accepting that i have severe anxiety, and trying to flow with it, how it's going to do the trick. i have been trying that, and all i find is that im trying my best to flow with the river, while my feet barely touch the bottom as im gasping for breath trying not to go under. it hasn't gotten any easier. i don't sleep well at all, and im having all sorts of physical problems now that i really think are from my body breaking down due to constant high levels of anxiety, and lack of sleep. now im getting caught in a cycle of anxiety probably causing health problems, and health problems exacerbating anxiety. i really feel like im in a tough spot. cause if its true that the research shows that antidepressants aren't any better then placebos, then what hope do i have? im terrified of meds, but now im more terrified at my current mental and physical state, . but how can i take meds if all im going to do is get side effects, and no lessening of my suffering? is psychiatry really a sham? what are these professionals practicing? im really sorry for posting such a negative post, but im in bad shape. if anyone can offer anything, it would be very appreciated-scott Quote
Guest guest Posted February 19, 2010 Report Posted February 19, 2010 One idea that helped me tremendously is : Therapists,different methods of therapy, doctors, professionals, books, vitamins/supplements, exercise and medications are resources that I can USE to help and support me-this may seem a silly sentence, but in the past I have always looked to the above to give me a definitive answer and that if I just found the correct modality then I would be "FIXED". Changing my perspective and EXPECTATIONS that I was going to have a permanent solution from one the above; to one of: this is something I need to explore to see if it supports and helps me, was a big paradigm shift for me. It has also changed my attitude when I do see my therapist, psychiatrist or any professional for that matter- I have gone from: "okay here is another person out there that MIGHT be able to fix me", to one of: "okay, here is someone on my support team, let me brain storm with this person and see what we can come up with, that I am willing to try, and might help ". It might seem simple but this is a big thing for me. I would suggest you find some people who can be on your 'support team'.Re:Taking medication and being terrified:I have had major trauma in my life, have health issues and suffer from depression and anxiety. I have tried all the above and more and never found one steadfast solution. I do read peer reviewed scientific abstracts to see what is being learned and understood about brain states and drugs being tried for pain, health issues, depression and anxiety. IT still boils down to YOU as an individual and how you react to certain medications. I happen to be a far outlier on the bell curve so when I have tried medications I always have severe side effects and that is SCARY, but that being said I kept trying and exploring because I want to find those things that give me support. Doing my own 'research' places more responsibility in my hands but that feels good. And that said I KNOW that if I try a medication and my body gives me the signal that this doesn't feel good, I stop taking it. And because my doctors are on my trusted 'support team' they understand that I don't react typically and they go back to brain storming with me.hope this helps-kTo: ACT_for_the_Public From: scott73i3@...Date: Fri, 19 Feb 2010 02:04:49 +0000Subject: exhausted mentally and physically although i really like ACT, im starting to think in my opinion that it is more for people with milder forms of anxiety/depression...(disclaimer..i am in no way trying to belittle anyone's suffering) i don't see how by accepting that i have severe anxiety, and trying to flow with it, how it's going to do the trick. i have been trying that, and all i find is that im trying my best to flow with the river, while my feet barely touch the bottom as im gasping for breath trying not to go under. it hasn't gotten any easier. i don't sleep well at all, and im having all sorts of physical problems now that i really think are from my body breaking down due to constant high levels of anxiety, and lack of sleep. now im getting caught in a cycle of anxiety probably causing health problems, and health problems exacerbating anxiety. i really feel like im in a tough spot. cause if its true that the research shows that antidepressants aren't any better then placebos, then what hope do i have? im terrified of meds, but now im more terrified at my current mental and physical state, . but how can i take meds if all im going to do is get side effects, and no lessening of my suffering? is psychiatry really a sham? what are these professionals practicing? im really sorry for posting such a negative post, but im in bad shape. if anyone can offer anything, it would be very appreciated -scott Hotmail: Trusted email with Microsoft’s powerful SPAM protection. Sign up now. Quote
Guest guest Posted February 19, 2010 Report Posted February 19, 2010 thank you sugarkoan, i think your right about not switching methods being a problem. as with many people suffering anxiety/depression, i am afraid of change. i really dont want to take meds, but i have tried cbt, and act, and i just dont know what to do now. the fact that therapy hasnt worked for me is very frightening. its either that my mental illness is too severe for these strategies, or that im not doing it right. i think the therapy helps me when my anxiety/depression is mild, but when its in full swing like it is now, nothing works...and it all goes out the window. thanks for responding -scottFrom: sugarkoan Subject: Re: exhausted mentally and physicallyTo: ACT_for_the_Public Date: Friday, February 19, 2010, 2:34 PM Antidepressants and psychiatry are not a sham. But they are not the black and white science many portray them to be. I have been struggling for decades and now realize that most of my problem came from giving up too much instead of switching methods when one wasn't working for me. It's sort of like dating. If you get two bad dates in a row, the temptation might be to give up on relationships. But if you look at what you are doing and are persistent, you will be successful. Part of the disease is to throw in the towel and curl into a ball, I know too well. Lately I've been getting better. I have bad weeks, but I don't let them get me down while they are occurring. I tell myself they are to be expected. ACT is a tool, not the cure. Have hope! Quote
Guest guest Posted February 19, 2010 Report Posted February 19, 2010 that does help ellen, thanks for your inputSubject: RE: exhausted mentally and physicallyTo: act_for_the_public Date: Friday, February 19, 2010, 5:27 PM One idea that helped me tremendously is : Therapists,differen t methods of therapy, doctors, professionals, books, vitamins/supplement s, exercise and medications are resources that I can USE to help and support me-this may seem a silly sentence, but in the past I have always looked to the above to give me a definitive answer and that if I just found the correct modality then I would be "FIXED". Changing my perspective and EXPECTATIONS that I was going to have a permanent solution from one the above; to one of: this is something I need to explore to see if it supports and helps me, was a big paradigm shift for me. It has also changed my attitude when I do see my therapist, psychiatrist or any professional for that matter- I have gone from: "okay here is another person out there that MIGHT be able to fix me", to one of: "okay, here is someone on my support team, let me brain storm with this person and see what we can come up with, that I am willing to try, and might help ". It might seem simple but this is a big thing for me. I would suggest you find some people who can be on your 'support team'.Re:Taking medication and being terrified:I have had major trauma in my life, have health issues and suffer from depression and anxiety. I have tried all the above and more and never found one steadfast solution. I do read peer reviewed scientific abstracts to see what is being learned and understood about brain states and drugs being tried for pain, health issues, depression and anxiety. IT still boils down to YOU as an individual and how you react to certain medications. I happen to be a far outlier on the bell curve so when I have tried medications I always have severe side effects and that is SCARY, but that being said I kept trying and exploring because I want to find those things that give me support. Doing my own 'research' places more responsibility in my hands but that feels good. And that said I KNOW that if I try a medication and my body gives me the signal that this doesn't feel good, I stop taking it. And because my doctors are on my trusted 'support team' they understand that I don't react typically and they go back to brain storming with me.hope this helps-kTo: ACT_for_the_ Public@yahoogrou ps.comFrom: scott73i3yahoo (DOT) comDate: Fri, 19 Feb 2010 02:04:49 +0000Subject: [ACT_for_the_ Public] exhausted mentally and physically although i really like ACT, im starting to think in my opinion that it is more for people with milder forms of anxiety/depression. ..(disclaimer. .i am in no way trying to belittle anyone's suffering) i don't see how by accepting that i have severe anxiety, and trying to flow with it, how it's going to do the trick. i have been trying that, and all i find is that im trying my best to flow with the river, while my feet barely touch the bottom as im gasping for breath trying not to go under. it hasn't gotten any easier. i don't sleep well at all, and im having all sorts of physical problems now that i really think are from my body breaking down due to constant high levels of anxiety, and lack of sleep. now im getting caught in a cycle of anxiety probably causing health problems, and health problems exacerbating anxiety. i really feel like im in a tough spot. cause if its true that the research shows that antidepressants aren't any better then placebos, then what hope do i have? im terrified of meds, but now im more terrified at my current mental and physical state, . but how can i take meds if all im going to do is get side effects, and no lessening of my suffering? is psychiatry really a sham? what are these professionals practicing? im really sorry for posting such a negative post, but im in bad shape. if anyone can offer anything, it would be very appreciated -scott Hotmail: Trusted email with Microsoft’s powerful SPAM protection. Sign up now. Quote
Guest guest Posted February 19, 2010 Report Posted February 19, 2010 thanks steven, you are right that i need to try different things. i need to find the courage, and really try to combat the thought that nothing is going to work, if it hasnt worked so far. i think i do need professional help at this point in time. i would prefer a psychologist, cause a psychiatrist is instantly going to mean meds, and i am most likely going to have a problem being a compliant patient. what would be optimal, is if i could find a doctor who does both, cause im going to need therapy just to take meds it seems. are there doctors who do both? i am going to the neurologist on monday to get to the bottom of my physical problems (constant twitching in both my feet and calves, which now is pain and tightness, legs feeling heavy and weaker then normal, my hands falling asleep at night, with slight pain in both forearms). my mind in thinking the worst, like multiple sclerosis, or some other neuorloigal, or autoimmune disorder. the prospect of this has got me in quite a state. i wonder is these symptoms could be psychogenic? could these symptoms be the result of chronic moderately severe anxiety? or could my body be becoming diseased as a reult of long exposure to mental illness, stress, lack of sleep? i wonder if im developing some sort of psychosomatic disorder? any input would be greatly appreciated. -scott although i really like ACT, im starting to think in my opinion that it is more for people with milder forms of anxiety/depression. ..(disclaimer. .i am in no way trying to belittle anyone's suffering) i don't see how by accepting that i have severe anxiety, and trying to flow with it, how it's going to do the trick. i have been trying that, and all i find is that im trying my best to flow with the river, while my feet barely touch the bottom as im gasping for breath trying not to go under. it hasn't gotten any easier. i don't sleep well at all, and im having all sorts of physical problems now that i really think are from my body breaking down due to constant high levels of anxiety, and lack of sleep. now im getting caught in a cycle of anxiety probably causing health problems, and health problems exacerbating anxiety. i really feel like im in a tough spot. cause if its true that the research shows that antidepressants aren't any better then placebos, then what hope do i have? im terrified of meds, but now im more terrified at my current mental and physical state, . but how can i take meds if all im going to do is get side effects, and no lessening of my suffering? is psychiatry really a sham? what are these professionals practicing? im really sorry for posting such a negative post, but im in bad shape. if anyone can offer anything, it would be very appreciated -scott Quote
Guest guest Posted February 19, 2010 Report Posted February 19, 2010 If you scan the net you will find lots of articles that say antidepressants are effective for severe depression. But Irving Kisrch, who did most of this research on this topic of placebos and antidepessant drugs, has his doubts. If you read his book, The Emperors New Drugs, Exploding the Antidepressant Myth, he says that his research shows that these drugs have no benefit over active placebos in severe depression, although people with moderate severe depresion might benifit. So what you have an antideprssnant drug that is not more effective than an active placebo (a drug that is not an antidepressant but has side effcts) for mild depression, moderate depression, severe depression, and very severe depression, which this leaves Irving Kisrch very doubtful whether that these drugs are efective for moderate severe depression as well, but he say's more research is needed. Psychiatrist Joanne Moncrief, author of The Myth of the Chemical Cure, believes that people with moderate severe depression experience an enhanced placebo effect because they still have some hope that someting can help them, unlike people with more severe forms of depression. Taking antidepressant drugs is frought with dangers, for example they stop working for 30% of people in the first year and even more after that, and no one knows what has happened to the brains of these people. Dr ph Glenmullen say's in his book, Prozac Backlash, that this tolerance to antidepressants seems to be permamnent which is worrying. He also shows photographs of monkeys brains who were put on a serotonin boosting drug for only three days. Their brain serotoniin system was completely destroyed in that time and never recovered even after 18 months -the Milky Way of brain cells was reduced to about one or two stars. The drug was not an antidepressant but a diet pill, but it is believed that the boosted serotonin stays too long in the brain and goes rancid destroying serotonin cells. The monkeys behaved quite normally afterwards. No drug company has ever bothered to do this simple research on their drugs to see if antidepressants do the same damage and so safeguard the public. (Although I can't say if that is still true today - the book came out in 2000) http://www.amazon.com/Prozac-Backlash-Overcoming-Antidepressants-Alternatives/dp/0684860015 Also, antidepressants are the chief cause of rapid cycling in manic depressive patients, a very distressing condition unheard of before the introduction of these drugs. http://ajp.psychiatryonline.org/cgi/content/full/165/3/300 Antidepressants might be helpful for people with anxiety, or OCD, and I have not read anything contrary to that. Like me, you probably need professional help from a good therapist, although I can't aford it. I sorry to frighten the living daylights out of you, but these issues need to be resolved before anyone can say whether these drugs are safe or not for most people For me, they were an absolute dissaster. Kavy >> although i really like ACT, im starting to think in my opinion that it is more for people with milder forms of anxiety/depression...(disclaimer..i am in no way trying to belittle anyone's suffering) i don't see how by accepting that i have severe anxiety, and trying to flow with it, how it's going to do the trick. i have been trying that, and all i find is that im trying my best to flow with the river, while my feet barely touch the bottom as im gasping for breath trying not to go under. it hasn't gotten any easier. i don't sleep well at all, and im having all sorts of physical problems now that i really think are from my body breaking down due to constant high levels of anxiety, and lack of sleep. now im getting caught in a cycle of anxiety probably causing health problems, and health problems exacerbating anxiety. > i really feel like im in a tough spot. cause if its true that the research shows that antidepressants aren't any better then placebos, then what hope do i have? im terrified of meds, but now im more terrified at my current mental and physical state, . but how can i take meds if all im going to do is get side effects, and no lessening of my suffering? is psychiatry really a sham? what are these professionals practicing? > im really sorry for posting such a negative post, but im in bad shape. if anyone can offer anything, it would be very appreciated> -scott> Quote
Guest guest Posted February 19, 2010 Report Posted February 19, 2010 Certainly you will find all kinds of hypothesis- Breggin, MD has been decrying antidepressants long before they came into vogueWe are certainly in our infancy of understanding what altering brain chemistry can do (but that is true of just about everything from pollution, xenoestrogens, stress, exposure to artificial light, genetically modified food, sleep deprivation, etc) I think that is what is such a huge challenge of living in our modern dayI think this is where each person has to be their own authority of what works for themI liked the ideas in this blog entryhttp://carlatpsychiatry.blogspot.com/2010/01/antidepressant-effectiveness-and-false.htmlTo: ACT_for_the_Public From: akaivey@...Date: Fri, 19 Feb 2010 19:45:47 +0000Subject: Re: exhausted mentally and physically If you scan the net you will find lots of articles that say antidepressants are effective for severe depression. But Irving Kisrch, who did most of this research on this topic of placebos and antidepessant drugs, has his doubts. If you read his book, The Emperors New Drugs, Exploding the Antidepressant Myth, he says that his research shows that these drugs have no benefit over active placebos in severe depression, although people with moderate severe depresion might benifit. So what you have an antideprssnant drug that is not more effective than an active placebo (a drug that is not an antidepressant but has side effcts) for mild depression, moderate depression, severe depression, and very severe depression, which this leaves Irving Kisrch very doubtful whether that these drugs are efective for moderate severe depression as well, but he say's more research is needed. Psychiatrist Joanne Moncrief, author of The Myth of the Chemical Cure, believes that people with moderate severe depression experience an enhanced placebo effect because they still have some hope that someting can help them, unlike people with more severe forms of depression. Taking antidepressant drugs is frought with dangers, for example they stop working for 30% of people in the first year and even more after that, and no one knows what has happened to the brains of these people. Dr ph Glenmullen say's in his book, Prozac Backlash, that this tolerance to antidepressants seems to be permamnent which is worrying. He also shows photographs of monkeys brains who were put on a serotonin boosting drug for only three days. Their brain serotoniin system was completely destroyed in that time and never recovered even after 18 months -the Milky Way of brain cells was reduced to about one or two stars. The drug was not an antidepressant but a diet pill, but it is believed that the boosted serotonin stays too long in the brain and goes rancid destroying serotonin cells. The monkeys behaved quite normally afterwards. No drug company has ever bothered to do this simple research on their drugs to see if antidepressants do the same damage and so safeguard the public. (Although I can't say if that is still true today - the book came out in 2000) http://www.amazon.com/Prozac-Backlash-Overcoming-Antidepressants-Alternatives/dp/0684860015 Also, antidepressants are the chief cause of rapid cycling in manic depressive patients, a very distressing condition unheard of before the introduction of these drugs. http://ajp.psychiatryonline.org/cgi/content/full/165/3/300 Antidepressants might be helpful for people with anxiety, or OCD, and I have not read anything contrary to that. Like me, you probably need professional help from a good therapist, although I can't aford it. I sorry to frighten the living daylights out of you, but these issues need to be resolved before anyone can say whether these drugs are safe or not for most people For me, they were an absolute dissaster. Kavy Your E-mail and More On-the-Go. Get Windows Live Hotmail Free. Sign up now. Quote
Guest guest Posted February 19, 2010 Report Posted February 19, 2010 I found the workbook very helpful. BillTo: ACT_for_the_Public From: Forsyth@...Date: Fri, 19 Feb 2010 06:57:21 -0500Subject: RE: exhausted mentally and physically Just a pointer …. The book mentioned for anxiety disorders was actually written for therapists. I know folks on this list have read it too. That’s fine. The book you may want to look at is The Mindfulness & Acceptance Workbook for Anxiety. This one is based on ACT and was written for folks struggling with anxiety. We have two clinical trials underway – one just finished, the other in progress – testing whether this workbook is helpful. We are still mining the data, but so far here’s what we found. Sample of 500 people from 25 countries – all reporting significant anxiety (and depression) prior to using the workbook. People were randomized to get the workbook or be on a waitlist. Folks who got the workbook worked with it for 12 weeks, and then we followed them at 3 and 6 months. At the end of the 12 weeks, the controls got the workbook and we followed them for 3 months. Bottom line: compared to controls, folks who got the workbook showed large and meaningful improvements in acceptance, mindfulness, self-compassion, and quality of life from pre to post. And, they showed large and meaningful reductions in thought suppression, anxiety, worry, social anxiety, fear, and even depression (though we do not explicitly talk about any of these as being major goals of using the workbook). Heck, we don’t even focus on depression. And, these gains were maintained at 3 month follow up. We have yet to look closely at the 6 month follow up. The controls showed no improvements during the first 12 weeks while they waited for the workbook, and in some cases actually worsened. This doesn’t mean the workbook or ACT is right for you, but just wanted to share this. We will soon be writing up the results of this first study and will share it with everyone when it is ready. Peace -j P. Forsyth, Ph.D. Associate Professor of Psychology Director of Clinical Training Director, Anxiety Disorders Research Program University at Albany, SUNY Department of Psychology Social Sciences 399 1400 Washington Avenue Albany, NY 12222 Ph: Fax: email: forsyth@... Lab Web Page: Anxiety Disorders Research Program Blogs: Mindfulness & Acceptance for Anxiety Peace of Mind at Psychology Today Dr. Forsyth on Amazon.com Our Clinical Trials Evaluating ACT for Anxiety: Visit ACTforAnxiety.com From: ACT_for_the_Public [mailto:ACT_for_the_Public ] On Behalf Of Suddarth Sent: Thursday, February 18, 2010 9:54 PM To: act_for_the_public Subject: RE: exhausted mentally and physically Oh I'm so sorry for your suffering. I was very depressed and didn't think life was worth living for a while. I was fortunate to be able to find a good therapist and benefited from talk therapy, along with the ACT workbook. I was able to tell my therapist things I've never told anyone and something about that release of my most secret fears and self hate was very freeing for me. I didn't click with my original therapist and so I wasn't able to open up and was contemplating quitting altogether. Thankfully she encouraged me to try another clinician at their group and I quickly was able to trust her. After probably 6-8 weekly sessions I felt I was ready to move on with my workbook self study and didn't feel the need to continue the talk therapy. It worked that well for me once I was able to trust her and open up. Something rooted is causing your severe anxiety and ACT is designed to uncover it and help you accept it in a loving way so you can move on with your valued life. I had some serious issues from my first childhood memories and by talking about them and accepting them I was able to get on with my life. Yes it sucks what happened to me but why should I give it power over my life forever? So my advice is to find a good therapist (preferably one trained in ACT), clinician, licensed social worker, or whoever you can trust and if after a couple of sessions you don't feel you're able to trust that person, move on until you do. And stick with the ACT therapy. Are you doing the "Get Out of your mind" workbook? That's the one I did but I know they have a specific one for Anxiety Disorders. I was severely depressed and had the anxiety that goes along with that, but not really an anxiety disorder. I had taken Lexapro and then Cymbalta, along with Xanax and developed a pretty serious addiction to Xanax and was worse off for ever messing with any of these things. I did try St. s Wart though when I was really bad and didn't want to take prescriptions again. I don't know if it helped but it didn't hurt me. You have to take it for a while. I do believe though that Niacinamide (B3) was helpful for me but I didn't start taking that until my depression was mostly better. But the serious changes in defining my values and moving toward them started shortly after I started taking Niacinimide. The first day I took it though I noticed a calming effect and for days after and then I've just felt good since then. Check out these links about it, especially the comments on revolutionhealth.com about Niacinamide & Anxiety. Niacinamide (B3) Vitamin Revolutionhealth.com comments on Niacinamide . I'm blogging about how happy my life is now from practicing ACT and have this post My vitamins & how they support my healthy life! about what I take and I think it helps. The B vitamins and Omegas are supposed to be good for mental health. (disclaimer - of course check with your health care provider before taking anything). I am actuallty very thankful now for my depression because if I wouldn't have gotten that bad off I wouldn't have searched for a better way. I love my life now and know it wouldn't be possible without the talk therapy I did and the ACT workbook, and of course my will to not give up. I hope this at least gives you some hope which sounds to me like you need at this point. So take a deep breath and give it another shot. Good luck I believe you can do this. http://myhappiestlife.com/ To: ACT_for_the_Public From: scott73i3@... Date: Fri, 19 Feb 2010 02:04:49 +0000 Subject: exhausted mentally and physically although i really like ACT, im starting to think in my opinion that it is more for people with milder forms of anxiety/depression...(disclaimer..i am in no way trying to belittle anyone's suffering) i don't see how by accepting that i have severe anxiety, and trying to flow with it, how it's going to do the trick. i have been trying that, and all i find is that im trying my best to flow with the river, while my feet barely touch the bottom as im gasping for breath trying not to go under. it hasn't gotten any easier. i don't sleep well at all, and im having all sorts of physical problems now that i really think are from my body breaking down due to constant high levels of anxiety, and lack of sleep. now im getting caught in a cycle of anxiety probably causing health problems, and health problems exacerbating anxiety. i really feel like im in a tough spot. cause if its true that the research shows that antidepressants aren't any better then placebos, then what ho! pe do i have? im terrified of meds, but now im more terrified at my current mental and physical state, . but how can i take meds if all im going to do is get side effects, and no lessening of my suffering? is psychiatry really a sham? what are these professionals practicing? im really sorry for posting such a negative post, but im in bad shape. if anyone can offer anything, it would be very appreciated -scott Hotmail: Powerful Free email with security by Microsoft. Get it now. Quote
Guest guest Posted February 20, 2010 Report Posted February 20, 2010 Been there ...we have all had our share of up and downs...sometimes it just hits you and you get caught up in the cycle of it, and it is hard to get out... The ACT that I would really recommend, is to really learn how to start observing your thoughts...that will help give you some space, and eventually you will understand that you aren't your thoughts...once you realize that you aren't part of the battle, there is no reason to fight them, you can just let them be... I highly recommend professional counseling...I remember when I first starting having anxiety, I thought going to a specialist meant I was crazy...far from the truth, and it was one of the best things I ever did...I still see a therapist here and there, just to talk, bounce thoughts and ideas, etc... Wishing you well...and know you can post on here without judgment vc > > although i really like ACT, im starting to think in my opinion that it is more for people with milder forms of anxiety/depression...(disclaimer..i am in no way trying to belittle anyone's suffering) i don't see how by accepting that i have severe anxiety, and trying to flow with it, how it's going to do the trick. i have been trying that, and all i find is that im trying my best to flow with the river, while my feet barely touch the bottom as im gasping for breath trying not to go under. it hasn't gotten any easier. i don't sleep well at all, and im having all sorts of physical problems now that i really think are from my body breaking down due to constant high levels of anxiety, and lack of sleep. now im getting caught in a cycle of anxiety probably causing health problems, and health problems exacerbating anxiety. > i really feel like im in a tough spot. cause if its true that the research shows that antidepressants aren't any better then placebos, then what hope do i have? im terrified of meds, but now im more terrified at my current mental and physical state, . but how can i take meds if all im going to do is get side effects, and no lessening of my suffering? is psychiatry really a sham? what are these professionals practicing? > im really sorry for posting such a negative post, but im in bad shape. if anyone can offer anything, it would be very appreciated > -scott > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 20, 2010 Report Posted February 20, 2010 Try to find an ACT therapist. It might save time and money. http://www.contextualpsychology.org/therapist_referralsBill Quote
Guest guest Posted February 20, 2010 Report Posted February 20, 2010 The Workbook for Anxiety was the first ACT book I bought and I couldn't believe what I was reading - a brand new therapy that seemed so exiting and I have never looked back since. Another superb ACT book. I went into meltdown one day last week and became very scared which was like a severe depression coming on - everything was just going really weird, upside down, and inside out. I stuck to my guns and just allowed the distressing thoughts to be and carried on with my work. At the end of the day I started making progress and realised I had considerable strength, I just needed to believe and not listen to the dreadful thoughts were going to wreck me and give me a severe telling off. I used all my ACT skills and pulled through. phew! Being on warp 9 was no easy ride but ACT worked. Kavy > > > I found the workbook very helpful. Bill > > To: ACT_for_the_Public > From: Forsyth@... > Date: Fri, 19 Feb 2010 06:57:21 -0500 > Subject: RE: exhausted mentally and physically > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Just a pointer …. The book mentioned for anxiety disorders > was actually written for therapists. I know folks on this list have read > it too. That's fine. > > > > The book you may want to look at is The Mindfulness & > Acceptance Workbook for Anxiety. This one is based on ACT and was written > for folks struggling with anxiety. > > > > We have two clinical trials underway – one just finished, > the other in progress – testing whether this workbook is helpful. > We are still mining the data, but so far here's what we found. > > > > Sample of 500 people from 25 countries – all reporting significant > anxiety (and depression) prior to using the workbook. > > > > People were randomized to get the workbook or be on a waitlist. > > > > Folks who got the workbook worked with it for 12 weeks, and then > we followed them at 3 and 6 months. At the end of the 12 weeks, the > controls got the workbook and we followed them for 3 months. > > > > Bottom line: compared to controls, folks who got the > workbook showed large and meaningful improvements in acceptance, mindfulness, > self-compassion, and quality of life from pre to post. And, they showed > large and meaningful reductions in thought suppression, anxiety, worry, social > anxiety, fear, and even depression (though we do not explicitly talk about any > of these as being major goals of using the workbook). Heck, we don't > even focus on depression. And, these gains were maintained at 3 month > follow up. We have yet to look closely at the 6 month follow up. > > > > The controls showed no improvements during the first 12 weeks > while they waited for the workbook, and in some cases actually worsened. > > > > This doesn't mean the workbook or ACT is right for you, > but just wanted to share this. We will soon be writing up the results of > this first study and will share it with everyone when it is ready. > > > > Peace -j > > > > > > P. > Forsyth, Ph.D. > > > > Associate > Professor of Psychology > > Director of > Clinical Training > > Director, > Anxiety Disorders Research Program > > University at > Albany, SUNY > > Department of > Psychology > > Social Sciences > 399 > > 1400 Washington > Avenue > > Albany, NY > 12222 > > Ph: > > > Fax: > > > email: > forsyth@... > > > > Lab Web Page: > > Anxiety Disorders Research Program > > > > Blogs: > > Mindfulness & Acceptance for Anxiety > > > > Peace of Mind at Psychology > Today > > > > Dr. Forsyth on Amazon.com > > > > Our Clinical Trials Evaluating ACT for Anxiety: > > Visit ACTforAnxiety.com > > > > > > > > > > From: > ACT_for_the_Public [mailto:ACT_for_the_Public ] On > Behalf Of Suddarth > > Sent: Thursday, February 18, 2010 9:54 PM > > To: act_for_the_public > > Subject: RE: exhausted mentally and physically > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Oh I'm so sorry for your suffering. > > > > I was very depressed and didn't think life was worth living for a while. > I was fortunate to be able to find a good therapist and benefited from talk > therapy, along with the ACT workbook. I was able to tell my > therapist things I've never told anyone and something about that release > of my most secret fears and self hate was very freeing for me. I > didn't click with my original therapist and so I wasn't able to open up and was > contemplating quitting altogether. Thankfully she encouraged me to > try another clinician at their group and I quickly was able to trust > her. After probably 6-8 weekly sessions I felt I was ready to move on > with my workbook self study and didn't feel the need to continue the talk > therapy. It worked that well for me once I was able to trust her and open > up. > > > > Something rooted is causing your severe anxiety and ACT is designed to uncover > it and help you accept it in a loving way so you can move on with > your valued life. I had some serious issues from my first childhood > memories and by talking about them and accepting them I was able to get on with > my life. Yes it sucks what happened to me but why should I give it power > over my life forever? > > > > So my advice is to find a good therapist (preferably one trained in > ACT), clinician, licensed social worker, or whoever you can trust > and if after a couple of sessions you don't feel you're able to trust > that person, move on until you do. And stick with the ACT > therapy. Are you doing the " Get Out of your mind " > workbook? That's the one I did but I know they have a specific one > for Anxiety > Disorders. I was severely depressed and had the anxiety that goes > along with that, but not really an anxiety disorder. I had taken Lexapro > and then Cymbalta, along with Xanax and developed a pretty serious addiction to > Xanax and was worse off for ever messing with any of these things. > > > > I did try St. s Wart though when I was really bad and didn't want to take > prescriptions again. I don't know if it helped but it didn't hurt > me. You have to take it for a while. I do believe though that > Niacinamide (B3) was helpful for me but I didn't start taking that until my > depression was mostly better. But the serious changes in defining my values and > moving toward them started shortly after I started taking > Niacinimide. The first day I took it though I noticed a calming > effect and for days after and then I've just felt good since then. Check > out these links about it, especially the comments on revolutionhealth.com about > Niacinamide & Anxiety. Niacinamide > (B3) Vitamin Revolutionhealth.com comments > on Niacinamide . > > > > I'm blogging about how happy my life is now from practicing ACT and have this > post My vitamins & how they support my healthy life! about > what I take and I think it helps. The B vitamins and Omegas are supposed > to be good for mental health. (disclaimer - of course check with your > health care provider before taking anything). > > > > I am actuallty very thankful now for my depression because if I wouldn't have > gotten that bad off I wouldn't have searched for a better way. I love my > life now and know it wouldn't be possible without the talk therapy I did and > the ACT workbook, and of course my will to not give up. > > > > I hope this at least gives you some hope which sounds to me like you need at > this point. So take a deep breath and give it another shot. > > > > Good luck I believe you can do this. > > > > > > > > http://myhappiestlife.com/ > > > > > > > > > > > > > To: ACT_for_the_Public > > From: scott73i3@... > > Date: Fri, 19 Feb 2010 02:04:49 +0000 > > Subject: exhausted mentally and physically > > > > > > > > > > > > although i really like ACT, im > starting to think in my opinion that it is more for people with milder forms of > anxiety/depression...(disclaimer..i am in no way trying to belittle anyone's > suffering) i don't see how by accepting that i have severe anxiety, and trying > to flow with it, how it's going to do the trick. i have been trying that, and > all i find is that im trying my best to flow with the river, while my feet > barely touch the bottom as im gasping for breath trying not to go under. it > hasn't gotten any easier. i don't sleep well at all, and im having all sorts of > physical problems now that i really think are from my body breaking down due to > constant high levels of anxiety, and lack of sleep. now im getting caught in a > cycle of anxiety probably causing health problems, and health problems > exacerbating anxiety. > > i really feel like im in a tough spot. cause if its true that the research > shows that antidepressants aren't any better then placebos, then what ho! pe do > i have? im terrified of meds, but now im more terrified at my current mental > and physical state, . but how can i take meds if all im going to do is get side > effects, and no lessening of my suffering? is psychiatry really a sham? what > are these professionals practicing? > > im really sorry for posting such a negative post, but im in bad shape. if > anyone can offer anything, it would be very appreciated > > -scott > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Hotmail: Powerful Free email with security by Microsoft. Get it > now. > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 20, 2010 Report Posted February 20, 2010 im really sorry kavy that you have been so effected by these drugs. after reading this post however, i am in quite a state. i have always held the thought in the back of my head that i would try to overcome my med phobia and take meds if things got to a point that i just could not handle my suffering anymore. i feel like i am at that point now, and from reading this stuff, im really feeling hopeless. now i feel like i have no net, and there is no place but down. i dont know what to doSubject: Re: exhausted mentally and physicallyTo: ACT_for_the_Public Date: Friday, February 19, 2010, 7:45 PM If you scan the net you will find lots of articles that say antidepressants are effective for severe depression. But Irving Kisrch, who did most of this research on this topic of placebos and antidepessant drugs, has his doubts. If you read his book, The Emperors New Drugs, Exploding the Antidepressant Myth, he says that his research shows that these drugs have no benefit over active placebos in severe depression, although people with moderate severe depresion might benifit. So what you have an antideprssnant drug that is not more effective than an active placebo (a drug that is not an antidepressant but has side effcts) for mild depression, moderate depression, severe depression, and very severe depression, which this leaves Irving Kisrch very doubtful whether that these drugs are efective for moderate severe depression as well, but he say's more research is needed. Psychiatrist Joanne Moncrief, author of The Myth of the Chemical Cure, believes that people with moderate severe depression experience an enhanced placebo effect because they still have some hope that someting can help them, unlike people with more severe forms of depression. Taking antidepressant drugs is frought with dangers, for example they stop working for 30% of people in the first year and even more after that, and no one knows what has happened to the brains of these people. Dr ph Glenmullen say's in his book, Prozac Backlash, that this tolerance to antidepressants seems to be permamnent which is worrying. He also shows photographs of monkeys brains who were put on a serotonin boosting drug for only three days. Their brain serotoniin system was completely destroyed in that time and never recovered even after 18 months -the Milky Way of brain cells was reduced to about one or two stars. The drug was not an antidepressant but a diet pill, but it is believed that the boosted serotonin stays too long in the brain and goes rancid destroying serotonin cells. The monkeys behaved quite normally afterwards. No drug company has ever bothered to do this simple research on their drugs to see if antidepressants do the same damage and so safeguard the public. (Although I can't say if that is still true today - the book came out in 2000) http://www.amazon. com/Prozac- Backlash- Overcoming- Antidepressants- Alternatives/ dp/0684860015 Also, antidepressants are the chief cause of rapid cycling in manic depressive patients, a very distressing condition unheard of before the introduction of these drugs. http://ajp.psychiat ryonline. org/cgi/content/ full/165/ 3/300 Antidepressants might be helpful for people with anxiety, or OCD, and I have not read anything contrary to that. Like me, you probably need professional help from a good therapist, although I can't aford it. I sorry to frighten the living daylights out of you, but these issues need to be resolved before anyone can say whether these drugs are safe or not for most people For me, they were an absolute dissaster. Kavy >> although i really like ACT, im starting to think in my opinion that it is more for people with milder forms of anxiety/depression. ..(disclaimer. .i am in no way trying to belittle anyone's suffering) i don't see how by accepting that i have severe anxiety, and trying to flow with it, how it's going to do the trick. i have been trying that, and all i find is that im trying my best to flow with the river, while my feet barely touch the bottom as im gasping for breath trying not to go under. it hasn't gotten any easier. i don't sleep well at all, and im having all sorts of physical problems now that i really think are from my body breaking down due to constant high levels of anxiety, and lack of sleep. now im getting caught in a cycle of anxiety probably causing health problems, and health problems exacerbating anxiety. > i really feel like im in a tough spot. cause if its true that the research shows that antidepressants aren't any better then placebos, then what hope do i have? im terrified of meds, but now im more terrified at my current mental and physical state, . but how can i take meds if all im going to do is get side effects, and no lessening of my suffering? is psychiatry really a sham? what are these professionals practicing? > im really sorry for posting such a negative post, but im in bad shape. if anyone can offer anything, it would be very appreciated> -scott> Quote
Guest guest Posted February 20, 2010 Report Posted February 20, 2010 Most people who take these drugs and experience no real harm. If they did, doctors would refuse to prescribe them. Despite what I say about meds I'm pretty certain they will help you if you find the right one. If a drug increases your anxiety, causes restlessness, and disturbs your sleep, and this doesn't abate after a few weeks then stop the drug and try another one. My girlfriend experiences no side effects whatsoever from her meds and so they obviously work for her and not agianst her. I experienced some occasional agitation, restlessness, and poor sleep when I tried Paxil (Seroxat) but I was desperate for it to work so I stayed on it - a big mistake. My doctor said so it was safe to do so as many people experience a liitle bit of this. So if you find a drug you are comfortable with you will probably be okay. Many people on my PSSD site have also suffered with extreme anxiety and OCD and so took meds but these conditions didn't return so bad when they came off the drugs. Life had changed for them over the months and the old stressors had gone. The chances are you will be okay as severe reactions are very uncommon. All the best. Kavy > > > > although i really like ACT, im starting to think in my opinion that it is more for people with milder forms of anxiety/depression. ..(disclaimer. .i am in no way trying to belittle anyone's suffering) i don't see how by accepting that i have severe anxiety, and trying to flow with it, how it's going to do the trick. i have been trying that, and all i find is that im trying my best to flow with the river, while my feet barely touch the bottom as im gasping for breath trying not to go under. it hasn't gotten any easier. i don't sleep well at all, and im having all sorts of physical problems now that i really think are from my body breaking down due to constant high levels of anxiety, and lack of sleep. now im getting caught in a cycle of anxiety probably causing health problems, and health problems exacerbating anxiety. > > i really feel like im in a tough spot. cause if its true that the research shows that antidepressants aren't any better then placebos, then what hope do i have? im terrified of meds, but now im more terrified at my current mental and physical state, . but how can i take meds if all im going to do is get side effects, and no lessening of my suffering? is psychiatry really a sham? what are these professionals practicing? > > im really sorry for posting such a negative post, but im in bad shape. if anyone can offer anything, it would be very appreciated > > -scott > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 20, 2010 Report Posted February 20, 2010 , Kaivey offers an opinion based on experience and independent reasoning. There are other experiences and all reasons may be publicly tested. Personally, I see medication as an adjunct, neither good nor bad, although their effect on an individual is subject to the individual's chemistry. You really won't know until you try, but if you look at medication as a tool like any other rather than a crutch, it may help you to make a decision. Why do you place so much weight on the opinions of others (even mine)? I have used antidepressants myself and they helped to give me a bit of space while I addressed my concerns. They're not a panacea by any stretch, but they are quite useful for some people. Having said all of that, when you say you worry about not being able to handle your suffering anymore, that sounds like the thing you're really afraid of, and in a respect the medication might serve as an evasive measure. I like the saying I read recently that nothing between your ears can kill you. The thoughts trigger memories, feelings, and tangible discomfort, but they can't do you harm: all they can do is make you uncomfortable. Anyway, this is just my opinion, and should be considered with just as loosely as anyone else's. Cheers, Neil -----Original Message-----From: ACT_for_the_Public [mailto:ACT_for_the_Public ] On Behalf Of WarnerSent: Saturday, February 20, 2010 3:46 PMTo: ACT_for_the_Public Subject: Re: Re: exhausted mentally and physically im really sorry kavy that you have been so effected by these drugs. after reading this post however, i am in quite a state. i have always held the thought in the back of my head that i would try to overcome my med phobia and take meds if things got to a point that i just could not handle my suffering anymore. i feel like i am at that point now, and from reading this stuff, im really feeling hopeless. now i feel like i have no net, and there is no place but down. i dont know what to do Quote
Guest guest Posted February 20, 2010 Report Posted February 20, 2010 That is prety true but my whole world was destroyed by these drugs and that feels like a total reality to me i.e, everything that I know, there is nothing else. I am now a member of my leper colony, the PSSD site, who are my friends now. That site gives me strength. Kavy > > , > > Kaivey offers an opinion based on experience and independent reasoning. > There are other experiences and all reasons may be publicly tested. > Personally, I see medication as an adjunct, neither good nor bad, > although their effect on an individual is subject to the individual's > chemistry. You really won't know until you try, but if you look at > medication as a tool like any other rather than a crutch, it may help > you to make a decision. Why do you place so much weight on the opinions > of others (even mine)? > > I have used antidepressants myself and they helped to give me a bit of > space while I addressed my concerns. They're not a panacea by any > stretch, but they are quite useful for some people. > > Having said all of that, when you say you worry about not being able to > handle your suffering anymore, that sounds like the thing you're really > afraid of, and in a respect the medication might serve as an evasive > measure. I like the saying I read recently that nothing between your > ears can kill you. The thoughts trigger memories, feelings, and > tangible discomfort, but they can't do you harm: all they can do is make > you uncomfortable. > > Anyway, this is just my opinion, and should be considered with just as > loosely as anyone else's. > > Cheers, > > Neil > > Re: Re: exhausted mentally and physically > > > > > > im really sorry kavy that you have been so effected by these drugs. > after reading this post however, i am in quite a state. i have always > held the thought in the back of my head that i would try to overcome my > med phobia and take meds if things got to a point that i just could not > handle my suffering anymore. i feel like i am at that point now, and > from reading this stuff, im really feeling hopeless. now i feel like i > have no net, and there is no place but down. i dont know what to do > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 20, 2010 Report Posted February 20, 2010 This is what happened to one unfortunate person who tooks antidepressant medication. It is from my PSSD site. A very rare reaction I do agree. Hi im a 21 year old male. I was prescribed zoloft for 4 months and began noticing the sexual dysfunction soon after starting it, a couple months later it went away and i felt completely normal while on the meds. My anxiety came back tho and the doc doubled my dosage of the zoloft and the dysfunction came back. After the 4 months i stopped taking it, its been 11 months now since my last dose and the dysfunction still remains.MY symptoms are-*Lack of sensitivity in my penis, it has gotten better over time, its about 40% of what it used to be now, the top of the shaft is where it is worst, different areas of the penis are more sensitive then others.*When I cum it has a lot less feeling and it just kinda dribbles out.*My emotional range has been cut down dramatically. It's like I almost have complete apathy, this varies from day to day however.*My rectum has also been numbed, even more so then my penis at this point. I find this very odd and very uncomfortable at times.*My nipples have also been numbed.*Any area of the body that used to be very ticklish has become numbed, including my sides, my arm pits, my lower stomach and upper thighs. This is most noticable when taking a shower and im washing myself, it feels like my skin is just rubber it has almost no sensation at all.I think that about covers it, I just thought I would share my own effects of PSSD as I know it effects everyone differently. Kavy Windows LiveTM Hotmail®: Chat. Store. Share. Do more with mail. Check it out. > >> > ,> > > > Kaivey offers an opinion based on experience and independent reasoning.> > There are other experiences and all reasons may be publicly tested.> > Personally, I see medication as an adjunct, neither good nor bad,> > although their effect on an individual is subject to the individual's> > chemistry. You really won't know until you try, but if you look at> > medication as a tool like any other rather than a crutch, it may help> > you to make a decision. Why do you place so much weight on the opinions> > of others (even mine)?> > > > I have used antidepressants myself and they helped to give me a bit of> > space while I addressed my concerns. They're not a panacea by any> > stretch, but they are quite useful for some people.> > > > Having said all of that, when you say you worry about not being able to> > handle your suffering anymore, that sounds like the thing you're really> > afraid of, and in a respect the medication might serve as an evasive> > measure. I like the saying I read recently that nothing between your> > ears can kill you. The thoughts trigger memories, feelings, and> > tangible discomfort, but they can't do you harm: all they can do is make> > you uncomfortable.> > > > Anyway, this is just my opinion, and should be considered with just as> > loosely as anyone else's.> > > > Cheers,> > > > Neil> > > > Re: Re: exhausted mentally and physically> > > > > > > > > > > > im really sorry kavy that you have been so effected by these drugs.> > after reading this post however, i am in quite a state. i have always> > held the thought in the back of my head that i would try to overcome my> > med phobia and take meds if things got to a point that i just could not> > handle my suffering anymore. i feel like i am at that point now, and> > from reading this stuff, im really feeling hopeless. now i feel like i> > have no net, and there is no place but down. i dont know what to do> >> Quote
Guest guest Posted February 21, 2010 Report Posted February 21, 2010 ,  Kaivey offers an opinion based on experience and independent reasoning. There are other experiences and all reasons may be publicly tested. Personally, I see medication as an adjunct, neither good nor bad, although their effect on an individual is subject to the individual's chemistry. You really won't know until you try, but if you look at medication as a tool like any other rather than a crutch, it may help you to make a decision. Why do you place so much weight on the opinions of others (even mine)?  I have used antidepressants myself and they helped to give me a bit of space while I addressed my concerns. They're not a panacea by any stretch, but they are quite useful for some people.  Having said all of that, when you say you worry about not being able to handle your suffering anymore, that sounds like the thing you're really afraid of, and in a respect the medication might serve as an evasive measure. I like the saying I read recently that nothing between your ears can kill you. The thoughts trigger memories, feelings, and tangible discomfort, but they can't do you harm: all they can do is make you uncomfortable.  Anyway, this is just my opinion, and should be considered with just as loosely as anyone else's. Hi Neil, I think that saying " nothing between your ears can kill you " is very clever but actually it's not true is it! Medication is tested on a limited number of people over a limited period of time so these trials are not the whole picture even if they are all published. The problem can be that you can get worse rather than better and that this can be attributed to your depression/anxiety etc rather than the medication. Suicidal thoughts can end up killing you and they occur between your ears. So can brain tumours. I don't have the answers to my own questions about medication so don't want to influence anyone in any way but public testing doesn't have the answers either. Would I have gone downhill even faster if my GP hadn't prescribed paroxetine on my first visit after breaking down at work 13 years ago. Was increasing medication till I was on twice today's recommended max dose the cause of my severe anxiety? Maybe I'll never know. I do know though that it has never been suggested that I report side-effects using the yellow card system that operates in the UK and I doubt whether doctors ever encourage its use in general. So once the initial research has been done it is more a matter of individuals having to trust their doctor. It's so hard for the individual to know how their medication is affecting them. I had ototoxic medication nearly 50 years ago. It saved my life so I am glad I took it. However, it's taken me several years to realise after lots of searching through my e-mails to check dates that my tinnitus started suddenly after starting fluvoxamine. It had never occurred to me that there could be a connection. Tinnitus isn't fatal of course though there are reports of some being driven to suicide by it. Luckily I have had therapy as well and it is so much easier to assess the effectiveness of that! I'm still not anti-medication but I am just very aware of my lack of certainty about whether it helps me or not on balance. Also don't want to influence anyone:-) Louise Re: [ACT_for_the_ Public] Re: exhausted mentally and physically  im really sorry kavy that you have been so effected by these drugs. after reading this post however, i am in quite a state. i have always held the thought in the back of my head that i would try to overcome my med phobia and take meds if things got to a point that i just could not handle my suffering anymore. i feel like i am at that point now, and from reading this stuff, im really feeling hopeless. now i feel like i have no net, and there is no place but down. i dont know what to do Quote
Guest guest Posted February 21, 2010 Report Posted February 21, 2010 I don’t agree that suicidal thoughts can kill you.  Thoughts are just flitting images and notions and ideas that you must notice, of course, but they don’t really have any power in and of themselves and cannot kill. The knife, or the gun, or the overdose – that’s what kills. Of course, the knife, gun, or overdose are all innocent as well; it is the action of the individual who uses these items to kill that is responsible for the death. That the thought precedes the suicidal action does not mean that the thoughts killed the person. At least, that is how I view it from an ACT point of view. As far as brain tumors go, I think the phrase “what’s between your ears can’t kill you†refers to thoughts and not physical tumors, which seems clear in the context of this discussion. Now if brain surgeons were using the phrase, it would mean something quite different and would not be true. Helena Suicidal thoughts can end up killing you and they occur between your ears. So can brain tumours. Quote
Guest guest Posted February 21, 2010 Report Posted February 21, 2010 I folks can stand a bit more of this but I think this is important. , Have you tried St s Wort (SJW)? Most of these products are useless mainly because they are low cost but also because they are standardised to 3% Hyperrcin. Scientists have now discovered that it is Hyperflorin that is the antidepressant part of SJW. Also, Hyperflorin degrades easily so there is hardly any left in most SJW products. This is why lots of people have not had success with SJW. HBC make the most powerful SJW I have tried (it's a shame it did my head in though) and the Hyperflorin has been naturally preserved. They make excellent products at reasonable prices and they also export their products very cheaply. I think they are brilliant and I told them so. http://www.hbcprotocols.com/ Dr Irving Kirsch, author of the The Emperor's New Drugs, is quite fascinated by SJW. If an antidepressant has no side efects it doesn't work any beter than a placebo he say's, and yet, for most people, SJW does work and yet has no side effects at all. So this substance can be seen as truly therapeutic. Rhodiola Rosea is a relative of Ginseng and has incredible antidepressant properties, at least in me. It's a shame it stopped working after 7 weeks though, andI have never been able to get it to work again. If you try Rhodiola cycle 2 weeks on and 1 week off to stop building up a tolerance. Some people do 3 days on and 4 days off or vice a versa. When you first take it it can be stimulating at first so start low, e.g, 1/2 a tab. This stimulation might be a bit unpleasant if you are anxious but it soon begins to sooth, so start low. Another company combines all of the above together and make a product which they say is more effective than the antidepressant your doctor prescribe. I wouldn't go down this route because you can't cycle the Rhodiola as you need to keep takingthe SJW. But millions of people swear by it, and we are all diferrent. Ifound this product was quite powerful as well. http://www.amoryn.com/?gclid=CODpwZWtg6ACFVOZ2AodgnLMhA Lastly, when I am going through the wringer I usually find I am talking myself into it. Like, ' Oh, no, this is the end', 'I'm finished now, I can't go on', 'There's something seriously wrong with me', maybe those doctor's are right, I really do have a brain problem, I inhereted this and so I am truly useless', 'I've always been defective, eveyone is better than me so I ought to give up now and call it a day and see my doctor', etc. Just let this stuff go through and carry on with your tasks. I usually find I can still do things quite well, if a bit slower, and even if conversation is next to useless, but I can still function. At the end of the day I start pulling through and I get an enormous feeling of strength and satisfaction. It amazing how much fear the body and mind can take if you don't buy into these thoughts. Its still very hard and there still seems to be no light at the end of the tunnel, but that's just another thought. The light I see is me moving towards my goals and dreams, than I know there is hope. Another example: You are hanging for dear life on a rope on a side of the mountain. Your mind tells you it is hopeless, and it keeps saying this and so your fingers begin to slip and you lose will because you really believe it is pointless. But what if you don't listen to your thoughts and then find that not only can you hold on to the rope, you can raise yourself up and start moving in a valued direction, i.e, towards safety. ACT has helped me overcome my learned hopelesness and get me back into life because I'm not listening to the all that negative stuff going on inside my head. And if I'm often not very good at ACT, that is just another thought to let go. Kavy > >> > although i really like ACT, im starting to think in my opinion that it is more for people with milder forms of anxiety/depression. ..(disclaimer. .i am in no way trying to belittle anyone's suffering) i don't see how by accepting that i have severe anxiety, and trying to flow with it, how it's going to do the trick. i have been trying that, and all i find is that im trying my best to flow with the river, while my feet barely touch the bottom as im gasping for breath trying not to go under. it hasn't gotten any easier. i don't sleep well at all, and im having all sorts of physical problems now that i really think are from my body breaking down due to constant high levels of anxiety, and lack of sleep. now im getting caught in a cycle of anxiety probably causing health problems, and health problems exacerbating anxiety. > > i really feel like im in a tough spot. cause if its true that the research shows that antidepressants aren't any better then placebos, then what hope do i have? im terrified of meds, but now im more terrified at my current mental and physical state, . but how can i take meds if all im going to do is get side effects, and no lessening of my suffering? is psychiatry really a sham? what are these professionals practicing? > > im really sorry for posting such a negative post, but im in bad shape. if anyone can offer anything, it would be very appreciated> > -scott> >> Quote
Guest guest Posted February 21, 2010 Report Posted February 21, 2010 Louise, It is clear that everyone has his or her own unique experience of medication, and ultimately one's experience has to trump whatever empirical results have been published. After all, the strength of science as a discipline is confirming what is not true rather than what is. In other words, it's generally easier to disconfirm a hypothesis than explain it. My point to was simply that he needs to decide for himself and that no one can do it for him. All of us on this listserv view things through our own unique prism, but our strength lies in our willingness to share our knowledge and experience and learn from that, which is what I meant by public testing. If I say "I think this is a great idea," and someone comes back with "Hey, not so fast," then I have some information I might not otherwise have had on my own. My own experience of ACT is quite recent, November of last year, beginning with Russ ' book. I was on an antidepressant all last year and have been on others at other times in my life, including Paxil, Zoloft and Buspar. Despite the dangers I'd read about withdrawal, I decided to stop taking them one day cold turkey, and I have never regretted my decision, although it was mine to make and it is not something I would recommend in general. I wouldn't say I suffered any serious side effects on any of the medication I took, but although it gave me some breathing room to address my problems, I did not have the necessary tools to help me with my problems. Traditional cognitive therapy came the closest, but ACT was a breath of fresh air because of its emphasis on acceptance, which echoes the work of addiction specialist Stanton Peele. Suicidal thoughts can end up killing you and they occur between your ears. So can brain tumours. You're right about brain tumors! This is an interesting statement that deserves a little reflection. I can't find the quote I referenced, but it seems to me it's in The Mindfulness and Acceptance Workbook for Depression. In chapter 7, authors Kirk Strosahl and write: "Unwanted private events aren't toxic. They feel as if they're toxic and you may think they're unbearable, but they aren't." I would argue that it isn't suicidal thoughts that compel a person to take his own life, but the way he has fused with his storyline. As someone who has been suicidal, I can attest to the power of this statement. I was suicidal when I was on medication, and I stopped being so when I changed my perspective. Now, having said that, I have read cases of people - aborigines, I believe? - who were told they would die on a certain date and did, all because they believed they would. So rather than restate an orthodoxy, I'll leave the notion open that in certain rare cases, maybe what you think can be so distressing that your body shuts down. I would regard my remarks as conjecture, though, unless someone can cite a study or two backing my memory up. In general, I would argue that our thoughts distress us because of the power of language (in our head) to evoke visceral responses, but the thoughts in and of themselves have no power. What does everyone else think, and what has been everyone's experience? Neil Quote
Guest guest Posted February 21, 2010 Report Posted February 21, 2010 I have put this out again because if a post is a bit long not many people will reach the end where this was in my last one, but it is very much in tune with what Neil is saying. Lastly, when I am going through the wringer I usually find I am talking myself into it. Like, ' Oh, no, this is the end', 'I'm finished now, I can't go on', 'There's something seriously wrong with me', maybe those doctor's are right, I really do have a brain problem, I inhereted this and so I am truly useless', 'I've always been defective, eveyone is better than me so I ought to give up now and call it a day and see my doctor', etc. Just let these thoughts go through and carry on with your tasks. I usually find I can still do things quite well, if a bit slower, and even if conversation is next to useless, but I can still function. At the end of the day I start pulling through and I get an enormous feeling of strength and satisfaction. It amazing how much fear the body and mind can take if you don't buy into these thoughts. Its still very hard and there still seems to be no light at the end of the tunnel, but that's just another thought. The light I see is me moving towards my goals and dreams, then I know there is hope. Another example: You are hanging for dear life on a rope on a side of the mountain. Your mind tells you it is hopeless, and it keeps saying this and so your fingers begin to slip and you lose will because you really believe it is pointless. But what if you don't listen to your thoughts and then you find that not only can you hold on to the rope, you can raise yourself up and start moving in a valued direction, i.e, towards safety. ACT has helped me overcome much of my learned hopelesness and get me back into life because I'm not listening to the all that negative stuff going on inside my head. And if I'm often not very good at ACT, then that is just another thought to let go of. Kavy >> ,> > Kaivey offers an opinion based on experience and independent reasoning.> There are other experiences and all reasons may be publicly tested.> Personally, I see medication as an adjunct, neither good nor bad,> although their effect on an individual is subject to the individual's> chemistry. You really won't know until you try, but if you look at> medication as a tool like any other rather than a crutch, it may help> you to make a decision. Why do you place so much weight on the opinions> of others (even mine)?> > I have used antidepressants myself and they helped to give me a bit of> space while I addressed my concerns. They're not a panacea by any> stretch, but they are quite useful for some people.> > Having said all of that, when you say you worry about not being able to> handle your suffering anymore, that sounds like the thing you're really> afraid of, and in a respect the medication might serve as an evasive> measure. I like the saying I read recently that nothing between your> ears can kill you. The thoughts trigger memories, feelings, and> tangible discomfort, but they can't do you harm: all they can do is make> you uncomfortable.> > Anyway, this is just my opinion, and should be considered with just as> loosely as anyone else's.> > Cheers,> > Neil> > Re: Re: exhausted mentally and physically> > > > > > im really sorry kavy that you have been so effected by these drugs.> after reading this post however, i am in quite a state. i have always> held the thought in the back of my head that i would try to overcome my> med phobia and take meds if things got to a point that i just could not> handle my suffering anymore. i feel like i am at that point now, and> from reading this stuff, im really feeling hopeless. now i feel like i> have no net, and there is no place but down. i dont know what to do> Quote
Guest guest Posted February 21, 2010 Report Posted February 21, 2010 Kavy, the conclusion of studies on the effectiveness of SJW are not consistent and research has also shown that St. 's Wort is not without its side effects, such as fatigue, restlessness, confusion, dizziness, and negative interactions with other medications. And components of St. 's Wort may raise blood pressure, possibly resulting in a stroke for vulnerable people. I don’t know what Dr Irving Kirsch bases his findings on, unless he is selecting only certain studies that agree with his point of view. IMO, the jury is still out on the effectiveness and safety of SJW. It is not recommended for the treatment of severe or manic depression, and components of St. 's Wort may raise blood pressure, possibly resulting in a stroke. Having said all that, it is perhaps worth a try, as long as the user is fully aware that SJW is not necessarily safe, either. It will probably not produce the severe side effects that pharmaceuticals can, but it should be considered with caution, just the same. I have tried it, along with several other “natural” treatments for depression, and have not found any of them to be effective for me, and some of them made me downright nervous and spacey. So … before trying St. 's Wort, or any other natural medicine for that matter, do the research because " natural " does not necessarily mean safe. It’s a shame that it is so tough to sort out all the pros and cons of everything that is available. Helena From: ACT_for_the_Public [mailto:ACT_for_the_Public ] On Behalf Of Kaivey Sent: Sunday, February 21, 2010 8:13 AM To: ACT_for_the_Public Subject: Re: exhausted mentally and physically I folks can stand a bit more of this but I think this is important. , Have you tried St s Wort (SJW)? Most of these products are useless mainly because they are low cost but also because they are standardised to 3% Hyperrcin. Scientists have now discovered that it is Hyperflorin that is the antidepressant part of SJW. Also, Hyperflorin degrades easily so there is hardly any left in most SJW products. This is why lots of people have not had success with SJW. HBC make the most powerful SJW I have tried (it's a shame it did my head in though) and the Hyperflorin has been naturally preserved. They make excellent products at reasonable prices and they also export their products very cheaply. I think they are brilliant and I told them so. http://www.hbcprotocols.com/ Dr Irving Kirsch, author of the The Emperor's New Drugs, is quite fascinated by SJW. If an antidepressant has no side efects it doesn't work any beter than a placebo he say's, and yet, for most people, SJW does work and yet has no side effects at all. So this substance can be seen as truly therapeutic. Rhodiola Rosea is a relative of Ginseng and has incredible antidepressant properties, at least in me. It's a shame it stopped working after 7 weeks though, andI have never been able to get it to work again. If you try Rhodiola cycle 2 weeks on and 1 week off to stop building up a tolerance. Some people do 3 days on and 4 days off or vice a versa. When you first take it it can be stimulating at first so start low, e.g, 1/2 a tab. This stimulation might be a bit unpleasant if you are anxious but it soon begins to sooth, so start low. Another company combines all of the above together and make a product which they say is more effective than the antidepressant your doctor prescribe. I wouldn't go down this route because you can't cycle the Rhodiola as you need to keep takingthe SJW. But millions of people swear by it, and we are all diferrent. Ifound this product was quite powerful as well. http://www.amoryn.com/?gclid=CODpwZWtg6ACFVOZ2AodgnLMhA Lastly, when I am going through the wringer I usually find I am talking myself into it. Like, ' Oh, no, this is the end', 'I'm finished now, I can't go on', 'There's something seriously wrong with me', maybe those doctor's are right, I really do have a brain problem, I inhereted this and so I am truly useless', 'I've always been defective, eveyone is better than me so I ought to give up now and call it a day and see my doctor', etc. Just let this stuff go through and carry on with your tasks. I usually find I can still do things quite well, if a bit slower, and even if conversation is next to useless, but I can still function. At the end of the day I start pulling through and I get an enormous feeling of strength and satisfaction. It amazing how much fear the body and mind can take if you don't buy into these thoughts. Its still very hard and there still seems to be no light at the end of the tunnel, but that's just another thought. The light I see is me moving towards my goals and dreams, than I know there is hope. Another example: You are hanging for dear life on a rope on a side of the mountain. Your mind tells you it is hopeless, and it keeps saying this and so your fingers begin to slip and you lose will because you really believe it is pointless. But what if you don't listen to your thoughts and then find that not only can you hold on to the rope, you can raise yourself up and start moving in a valued direction, i.e, towards safety. ACT has helped me overcome my learned hopelesness and get me back into life because I'm not listening to the all that negative stuff going on inside my head. And if I'm often not very good at ACT, that is just another thought to let go. Kavy > > > > although i really like ACT, im starting to think in my opinion that it is more for people with milder forms of anxiety/depression. ..(disclaimer. ..i am in no way trying to belittle anyone's suffering) i don't see how by accepting that i have severe anxiety, and trying to flow with it, how it's going to do the trick. i have been trying that, and all i find is that im trying my best to flow with the river, while my feet barely touch the bottom as im gasping for breath trying not to go under. it hasn't gotten any easier. i don't sleep well at all, and im having all sorts of physical problems now that i really think are from my body breaking down due to constant high levels of anxiety, and lack of sleep. now im getting caught in a cycle of anxiety probably causing health problems, and health problems exacerbating anxiety. > > i really feel like im in a tough spot. cause if its true that the research shows that antidepressants aren't any better then placebos, then what hope do i have? im terrified of meds, but now im more terrified at my current mental and physical state, . but how can i take meds if all im going to do is get side effects, and no lessening of my suffering? is psychiatry really a sham? what are these professionals practicing? > > im really sorry for posting such a negative post, but im in bad shape. if anyone can offer anything, it would be very appreciated > > -scott > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 21, 2010 Report Posted February 21, 2010 Subject: RE: Re: exhausted mentally and physically To: ACT_for_the_Public Date: Sunday, 21 February, 2010, 13:20  Louise,  It is clear that everyone has his or her own unique experience of medication, and ultimately one's experience has to trump whatever empirical results have been published. After all, the strength of science as a discipline is confirming what is not true rather than what is. In other words, it's generally easier to disconfirm a hypothesis than explain it. Hi Neil, I wish it were true to say that I can see my experience as trumping whatever epirical results have been published. My point is that I can NOT assess my experience with medication effectively because I am alone. I am not able to tell whether medication made me worse very rapidly or whether it was my depression/anxiety/OCD that started very suddenly and spiralled downwards while taking medication very fast. I had very severe symptoms, tests for all sorts of conditions that came on very suddenly after taking paroxetine. To say that each person is individual and therefore there is little point in discussing medication as something which can lead to thoughts of suicide in individuals could be the very thing that leads to more people taking medication and being told they are the exceptions....and believing it, or believing that their symptoms were going to arise anyway. If there is no communication between people after the time-limited trials, which won't pick up long-term side-effects or very rare side-effects, then more people can get ill.  >My point to was simply that he needs to decide for himself and that no one can do it for him. All of us on this listserv view things through our own unique prism, but our strength lies in our willingness to share our knowledge and experience and learn from that, which is what I meant by public testing. If I say " I think this is a great idea, " and someone comes back with " Hey, not so fast, " then I have some information I might not otherwise have had on my own.> I agree every person needs to decide for himself. What I am saying in offering my experience is NOT that I believe I am right or want to influence anyone. I am saying that I want others' experiences to be evaluated just because I don't want to have to rely on my own experience in isolation. I am happy to share my experience without being sure whether it is generalisable.  >My own experience of ACT is quite recent, November of last year, beginning with Russ ' book. I was on an antidepressant all last year and have been on others at other times in my life, including Paxil, Zoloft and Buspar. Despite the dangers I'd read about withdrawal, I decided to stop taking them one day cold turkey, and I have never regretted my decision, although it was mine to make and it is not something I would recommend in general. I wouldn't say I suffered any serious side effects on any of the medication I took, but although it gave me some breathing room to address my problems, I did not have the necessary tools to help me with my problems. Traditional cognitive therapy came the closest, but ACT was a breath of fresh air because of its emphasis on acceptance, which echoes the work of addiction specialist Stanton Peele.> If medication can give you breathing space to address problems that is great. My experience was that I suffered a whole range of symptoms including mutism ( agreat help in therapy!!!), hemiballismus, stammering, tics, tinnitus, somnolence and more and each symptom was viewed as a symptom of my illness and medication changed or increased to treat my symptoms.  Suicidal thoughts can end up killing you and they occur between your ears. So can brain tumours.  >You're right about brain tumors!  This is an interesting statement that deserves a little reflection. I can't find the quote I referenced, but it seems to me it's in The Mindfulness and Acceptance Workbook for Depression. In chapter 7, authors Kirk Strosahl and write: " Unwanted private events aren't toxic. They feel as if they're toxic and you may think they're unbearable, but they aren't. "  I would argue that it isn't suicidal thoughts that compel a person to take his own life, but the way he has fused with his storyline. As someone who has been suicidal, I can attest to the power of this statement. I was suicidal when I was on medication, and I stopped being so when I changed my perspective.> I am in total agreement about thoughts themselves not being unbearable, that it is your reaction to thoughts either depressive ones or intrusive ones as in OCD (ie avoidance or mental/physical compulsions) that is the problem. That is all standard CBT stuff I have practised in therapy. I accept that totally. Actually acceptance of intrusive thoughts is what I have been taught in CBT! There is no point in arguing with an obsession!!! I knew someone would tell me thoughts couldn't kill me but medication also " happens " between your ears and if you have sudden suicidal thoughts after taking medication after one minor breakdown at work,being told to go straight to the doctor for a medical certificate, being prescribed an SSRI " in case you go downhill rapidly " and later antipsychotics and other drugs as well then there simply isn't time to do CBT or read a book on ACT before those thoughts take effect. So it really boils down to the same thing. Thoughts can cause suicide if you don't have time to do therapy first!  >Now, having said that, I have read cases of people - aborigines, I believe? - who were told they would die on a certain date and did, all because they believed they would. So rather than restate an orthodoxy, I'll leave the notion open that in certain rare cases, maybe what you think can be so distressing that your body shuts down. I would regard my remarks as conjecture, though, unless someone can cite a study or two backing my memory up. In general, I would argue that our thoughts distress us because of the power of language (in our head) to evoke visceral responses, but the thoughts in and of themselves have no power.> I think the power of thought is immense and the power of therapy too. It has helped me enormously. My problem with the power of medication is that the studies aren't necessarily being done that show that the medications can have a dangerous effect on thinking *in some people*, so there is little to cite! If medication is supposed to be powerful enough to stop obsessive thinking it can obviously be powerful enough to cause it....in some cases. Who is going to do studies to show medication is harmful in some cases? Who would want to? Medication happens between your ears and your thinking can become extreme, even suicidal, as a result so saying the problem is that you have fused with your thoughts seems to be irrelevant at that point. I have no wish at all for anyone to generalise from my experience. I am still taking a low dose of fluvoxamine and am awaiting a medication review at the psychiatrist's on Tuesday which I requested after being discharged five years ago. I have to say I am anxious about that as I fear that if I mention my concerns that the medication I have had over the years has actually largely contributed to if not caused my problems I will meet with hostility and refusal to take me seriously. In 1999 when my anxiety and tics were exhausting me physically I suggested to one psychiatrist that the paroxetine was the cause and he more or less told me not to be so stupid. " Paroxetine is prescribed for anxiety " he said. The irony is that my main obsession that developed over the years has been that I am a fraud and have invented my illness. The OCD came out of the blue and just didn't seem to make sense! So if anyone has any advice on how to be assertive without burning my boats as far as psychiatrists are concerned I'd be pleased. After all I may just be wrong! The one good thing is that this time, as my GP pointed out, I am able to speak coherently whereas I used to have to write my concerns down and hand them to the psychiatrist as I had such difficulty speaking, only to be met with the words " If you don't start behaving like an adult (ie speak!) you won't get better. " A bit like saying If you refuse to give up your spots you won't recover from measles:-)  >What does everyone else think, and what has been everyone's experience?> Well, that's mine and as I say it is not a therapy versus medication one. Therapy has saved my life.  Louise   Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.