Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Re: Re:OT: Emergency Contraception

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted

This, Father Tom, is a very interesting argument of yours: namely, that the responsible arena for freedom in these difficult cases is not in the technical control of the post-coital, involuntary vegetative processes that follow (e.g., ovulation), but rather the only legitimate arena for responsible and free intervention is in the freedom to engage in or avoid the conjugal act, which is what to a degree Pam and have been saying also -- probably to their credit! I must give this some real thought because it does have a compelling aspect to it, and the question is a difficult one morally. Against this notion would be the idea that the Church has spoken clearly in favor of the rights of the child to be conceived only through an act of love, and a personal act of love at that. Therefore the technical act of contrived reproduction cannot meet that criterion. But also, an

act of hateful violation which poses as a surrogate for intercourse

might also be argued not to be able to meet that criterion.That still

doesn't prove, though, that it is okay to interfere with the

post-coital involuntary (vegetative) generative sequelae in such a

situation; it only proves definitively that rape is wrong.

However one might argue that therefore conception out of an act of violence is intrinsically unjust. And if unjust, then even though the organs and their normal function are not intrinsically unjust, nonetheless they could be inhibited because this would be an anomalous result violating the rights of child and mother (because motherhood ought to be a free and voluntary act).

So, we are clear that acts of conjugal love must be left open to new life. Must the same be said about violent acts of intercourse? Must they be left open to new life? It bears some real consideration. I want to give this some real thought.....

Sincerely yours,

Dominic M. Pedulla MD, FACC, CNFPMC, ABVM, ACPh

Interventional Cardiologist, Endovascular Diplomate, Varicose Vein Specialist, Noncontraceptive Family Planning Consultant, Family Planning Researcher

Medical Director, The Oklahoma Vein and Endovascular Center (www.noveinok.com, varicoseveins1@...)

Executive Director, The Edith Stein Foundation (www.theedithsteinfoundation.com)

(office)

(cell)

pedullad@...

"Lent is like a long 'retreat' during

which we can turn back into ourselves and listen to the voice of God,

in order to defeat the temptations of the Evil One. It is a period of

spiritual 'combat' which we must experience alongside Jesus, not with

pride and presumption, but using the arms of faith: prayer, listening

to the word of God and penance. In this way we will be able to

celebrate Easter in truth, ready to renew the promises of our Baptism" (Pope Benedict XVI Homily on Jesus' temptations in the desert, First Sunday of Lent, 2/21/10)

Re: Re:OT: Emergency Contraception

Rather than contribute to the fray I think if is helpful define the broader principles. One, the natural process of transmitting human life is good, expressive of God's law in nature. Two, all the essential components of human nature and life including human reproduction are good. Three, the wilful commission of rape, the act itself, is evil; but the reproductive organs of a man and woman are integrally good as of all creation. Admittedly, "all analogies limp", but the analogy of a killer and his gun is a good example of the principle. One who unjustly kills another commits an evil act. A policeman who justly kills another with a gun in the performance of his duty does not commit and evil act. In either case the gun is neither good or evil in a moral sense. Likewise, it does not reasonably follow that the sperm of a rapist is an unjust "thing". The rape is unjust, but the 'natural consequences' of insemination are not unjust. The circumstances of intercourse are matters separate from the natural process of conception and human birth. God's forebearance defines our gift of freedom without which we would not be human which partially, at least, explains God's tolerance of good and evil in the world. Similarly, our divinely infused powers of intelligence, for example, are intrinsically good whether our thoughts and desires are good or evil. Human sperm serves God's plan for procreation whether the act preceding insemination is good, evil or thoughtless--which some would define as an "unwanted" pregrancy to justify an abortion. All these are the consequences of free will for good or evil. I recommend that these principles be weighed carefully before intervention, after the fact, in the process of human procreation.

Sincerely,

Father Tom

On Sun, Feb 21, 2010 at 8:57 PM, alicia <ahuntleyinterserv> wrote:

OK folks, we are getting a little testy here.

Time to take a few deep breaths and let it rest for a day or so. Go back and re-read the whole thread.

We all care passionately.

has the experience of being on the front lines as a health care provider dealing with women, and only women. has the experience of being on a college campus and dealing with both realities and the theoretical underpinnings.

Everyone here has had varying experience that colors the way we look at the topics being discussed.

Let's take a 24 hour time out here.

alicia

co-moderator

Harry Truman once quipped, "I never give them hell. I just tell the truth and they think its hell."

ahuntleyinterserv

Posted

A few thoughts in response to the last three emails - two by Dominic and one (below) by Fr. Tom ...

1. I think that one can perhaps speak of something at least remotely analogous to "obedience" in God - even apart from the kenosis mentioned in Phil. 2. That is to say, God "obeys" himself - or, maybe better - avoiding the term "obey" - God wills and acts in a self-consistent manner. In particular, God creates things with such-and-such natures and activities, and he then treats them in accordance with those natures and activities. This is not in any way to deny the reality of miracles - but I think it's pretty safe to say that those are an extraordinary case - not the ordinary way of things. So, in particular, God creates human beings and their genitals and gametes to work in a certain way - and then (again, ordinarily) refrains from doing things that would be at odds with that way - like intervening to prevent fertilization from resulting from rape. - Another way of saying all this is that God is not "beyond reason" in the way suggested by some religious tendencies, those criticized by Benedict XVI in his Regensburg speech.

2. It is possible that we're "losing too much sleep" over the rape/"contraception" issue - if it is true that only something like the Eugene Diamond protocol provides the needed moral certainty that the intervention won't act via a post-fertilization (abortifacient) mechanism - and, again, I leave that to others to work out. However - I think that it's possible that this is worth thinking carefully about - even if, in one sense, it's of purely theoretical interest. Why? For the following reasons. Contraception is a grave evil. We need to persuade the culture to reject it. We can only do that if we "get it right" regarding the reasons it's evil. Bad arguments against it won't help - they'll even hurt (they'll be exposed as such and actually discredit our effort). And the question of whether - in principle or theoretically - it's morally licit to prevent fertilization after rape, turns, as we've seen here, on the question of why contraception is wrong.

3. That takes me to Fr. Tom's email, which somewhat echoes others to which I've responded previously. Very briefly here: (a) It is perfectly reasonable to say that it is unjust for a woman to experience the "natural consequences" of an unjust act. (B) The Church's teaching - in HV taken in itself, and interpreted with the help of Wojtyla/ II and also of the Catechism - makes it pretty clear that contraception is a sin against marital chastity - against the 6th Commandment. Again, I don't think (as some others have sometimes suggested) that contraception doesn't add to the sins of fornication/adultery. But I do think that considerations of the requirements of chastity (i.e. of authentic love for one's spouse) are pretty obviously irrelevant to the question of whether it's permissible to try to prevent fertilization after rape. © I think that the argument against contraception that relates it to the requirements of chastity (of marital love) is a good (even - objectively - compelling) argument against contraception - as well as being the one suggested by the Church's teaching. I don't think that most other arguments - in particular, those that would exclude the possibility of trying to prevent fertilization after rape - are philosophically/theologically sound arguments. Specifically, in light of my point (a) above, and in light of the fact that - as I've said earlier - the fact that God permits x doesn't entail that we need to permit x, I think that the argument that's been proposed in this discussion fails. (d) I think all that is further confirmed by the CDF's evident lack of problem with the USCCB ERDs' handling of post-rape care (remember that other parts of the 2001 ERDs do include some revisions based on CDF concerns) - which permits preventing fertilization, if possible (without causing an abortion).

Re: Re:OT: Emergency Contraception

Rather than contribute to the fray I think if is helpful define the broader principles. One, the natural process of transmitting human life is good, expressive of God's law in nature. Two, all the essential components of human nature and life including human reproduction are good. Three, the wilful commission of rape, the act itself, is evil; but the reproductive organs of a man and woman are integrally good as of all creation. Admittedly, "all analogies limp", but the analogy of a killer and his gun is a good example of the principle. One who unjustly kills another commits an evil act. A policeman who justly kills another with a gun in the performance of his duty does not commit and evil act. In either case the gun is neither good or evil in a moral sense. Likewise, it does not reasonably follow that the sperm of a rapist is an unjust "thing". The rape is unjust, but the 'natural consequences' of insemination are not unjust. The circumstances of intercourse are matters separate from the natural process of conception and human birth. God's forebearance defines our gift of freedom without which we would not be human which partially, at least, explains God's tolerance of good and evil in the world. Similarly, our divinely infused powers of intelligence, for example, are intrinsically good whether our thoughts and desires are good or evil. Human sperm serves God's plan for procreation whether the act preceding insemination is good, evil or thoughtless--which some would define as an "unwanted" pregrancy to justify an abortion. All these are the consequences of free will for good or evil. I recommend that these principles be weighed carefully before intervention, after the fact, in the process of human procreation.

Sincerely,

Father Tom

OK folks, we are getting a little testy here.Time to take a few deep breaths and let it rest for a day or so. Go back and re-read the whole thread.We all care passionately. has the experience of being on the front lines as a health care provider dealing with women, and only women. has the experience of being on a college campus and dealing with both realities and the theoretical underpinnings. Everyone here has had varying experience that colors the way we look at the topics being discussed.Let's take a 24 hour time out here.aliciaco-moderator Harry Truman once quipped, "I never give them hell. I just tell the truth and they think its hell."

ahuntley@...

Posted

Hi ,

I'm sorry if I seemed to be name-calling. I don't think that you as a person are arrogant. But some of what you said - most especially "rationalization" (which comes across as an accusation of something like intellectual dishonesty) - was at least frustrating. When I - and lots and lots of other faithful Catholic theologians - put care and effort into thinking through a question - then it is, as I said, frustrating to have our analysis treated in what seems like such a dismissive way.

Even below - there seems to be something of a disconnect between your statement that you rely on - among others - theologians to help guide you, and your flat-out rejection of the idea that the theological argument I'm conveying might be important here.

I understand your point about post-fertilization mechanisms - yes, if it is true that we can't be morally certain of excluding these, then the discussion of preventing fertilization is in some sense theoretical. But - on the other hand - not entirely so - for reasons I mentioned in my response to Dominic and Fr. Tom. And even in post-rape care - we as human beings want to do the right thing for the right reason - not for a wrong reason (e.g., that even preventing fertilization would be immoral ... and I don't want to rehash that argument right at this minute; indeed, I don't think I have anything to say that I haven't already said, though if it would be helpful, maybe later I could try restating some of it).

I appreciate your work in the world of health care. Please understand that even though I'm not in those particular trenches, I'm still dealing with moral issues in the real world - as I said before, I think contraception is evil, and a significant part of my work involves trying to convince others of that - in the classroom and so on - and to equip them to convince others in turn.

Re:OT: Emergency Contraception

Oh Geeze . (trying to keep it light here)Must we resort to name calling? Especially if you are directing an answer to a third party? I have small children who need my attention, so no, I am not good at trying to word things very persuasively when I am "on the run" so to speak. If it was wrong for me to say so, Mea Culpa. I recall that I "respectfully submitted" that there were flaws in your arguments. I said you made suppositions because you said "Suppose" which then = a supposition, after which you made some conclusions. The Second supposition is the one we keep trying to say does not exist... It is just very frustrating to see all this debate and theory, because, as I previously stated, there are currently no readily or easily methods of determining the time of ovulation in the case of a woman presenting for rape, even IF the assumption that was presented was correct (that it is "ok" to try and prevent fertilization in the case of rape). I don't believe that conception is a behavior to be prevented. I believe that conception is an act of the will of God, which ideally is aided in the mutual cooperation of a congugal act that is agreed upon by a loving couple. The "behavior" applies to the couple or the rapist. (In the case of IVF, people are directly manipulating the ova and sperm, so in this case, I believe that God allows free will to be put into play, and allows fertilization to take place).If you are pursuaded of your position, then so be it. There was no intention to insult. My questions were meant as very real questions, rhetorical or not. I hope they at least provoked some more thinking, though they may seem to be very simplistic from a certain point of view. In the Obstetrical /Gynecological world I live in, there are lots of fish to fry. Heck in the health care arena in general. It can be *really* bad. Perhaps you have no idea how much some of us would just like to pick up and run, but we struggle to keep on fighting. With God's Grace, we suck it in and march in another day. We rely on Doctors of the Church, theologians, priests, and the magesterium to help guide us when we have questions that trouble us. We need to "hear" a human voice sometimes. God does speak to us in small moments, for which I am eternally grateful- and we are allowed to be witness to Him and for Him. But no, we are not always perfect.A wise priest recently told me that sometimes we are called to just stand at the foot of the cross and weep. And so I do. Blessings always. Sandrock

Posted

,Since I have not read every thread in this discussion I apologize if i'm rehashing an already-made point...but as I understand it, the direct affect that results from post-rape contraceptives - after reasonable assurance has been made that ovulation has not occurred (presumably already discussed here) - is that of protection from an aggressor. God does not will rape (which says nothing about the sanctity of a life that may result from such a union just as in the discussion on IVF) and to compare such an act to a "conjugal act agreed upon by a loving couple" would seem to be inappropriate when determining the use of a means of protection. Though I appreciate the dilemma in determining ovulation status and the intrinsic evil innate to contraception, I have come to appreciate the difference between its use in a marital act and that following an aggressive sexual attack. Remember, the Church has also held that contraceptives can be used for medicinal purposes despite their intrinsic nature (though I recognize that in such a case their contraceptive property is not the desired affect). I realize this does not "clear up" the debate but thought I would share my 2 bits. Mike Artigues Sent from my Cellular South BlackBerry® SmartphoneDate: Tue, 23 Feb 2010 21:29:32 -0800 (PST)To: <nfpprofessionals >Subject: Re:OT: Emergency Contraception Oh Geeze . (trying to keep it light here)Must we resort to name calling? Especially if you are directing an answer to a third party? I have small children who need my attention, so no, I am not good attrying to word things very persuasively when I am "on the run" so tospeak. If it was wrong for me to say so, Mea Culpa. I recall that I "respectfully submitted" that there were flaws in your arguments. I said you made suppositions because you said "Suppose" which then = a supposition, after which you made some conclusions. The Second supposition is the one we keep trying to say does not exist... It is just very frustrating to see all this debate and theory, because, as I previously stated, there are currently no readily or easily methods of determining the time of ovulation in the case of a woman presenting for rape, even IF the assumption that was presented was correct (that it is "ok" to try and prevent fertilization in the case of rape). I don't believe that conception is a behavior to be prevented. I believe that conception is an act of the will of God, which ideally is aided in the mutual cooperation of a congugal act that is agreed upon by a loving couple. The "behavior" applies to the couple or therapist. (In the case of IVF, people are directly manipulating the ova and sperm, so in this case, I believe that God allows free will to be put into play, and allows fertilization to take place).If you are pursuaded of your position, then so be it. There was no intention to insult. My questions were meant as very real questions, rhetorical or not. I hope they at least provoked some more thinking, though they may seem to be very simplistic from a certain point of view. In the Obstetrical /Gynecological world I live in, there are lots of fish to fry. Heck in the health care arena in general. It can be *really* bad. Perhaps you have no idea how much some of us would just like to pick up and run, but we struggle to keep on fighting. With God's Grace, we suck it in and march in another day. We rely on Doctors of the Church, theologians, priests, and the magesterium to help guide us when we have questions that trouble us. Weneed to "hear" a human voice sometimes. God does speak to us in small moments, for which I am eternally grateful- and we are allowed to be witness to Him and for Him. But no, we are not always perfect.A wise priest recently told me that sometimes we are called to just stand at the foot of the cross and weep. And so I do. Blessings always. Sandrock

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...