Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Re: Re:OT: Emergency Contraception

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted

You might be interested in one of my articles on this topic; go

to:

http://www.ncbcenter.org/NetCommunity/Page.aspx?pid=249

and select

November

2007 -

Getting It Right "The Morning-After"

Pax,

Fr. Tad

One more question:

If contraception, according to the teaching of the Church,

is objectively immoral, how is it justified even in this case?

Again, why are we working so hard to justify the

administration of a contraceptive, regardless of the origin of the

possible conception?

Pam in El Paso

We are all given a single life-time by the Lord, and the time is given

so that we

might serve. For the work of God's Church is never done, so long as

time shall

last, and it is a privilege to offer the service of one's life to

her mission.

-Bishop E. , Diocese of Brownsville, TX

Posted

"Some have argued that it may be immoral for Catholics to provide any contraceptive measures at all to a woman who has been raped. Such a view is incorrect, however, because a woman who has been sexually assaulted is clearly entitled to protect herself from the attacker’s sperm. The Church teaches that rape is not a unitive act that requires openness to procreation. It is rather an act of violence against another person, and the woman is allowed to take steps to prevent the possible fertilization of her own egg(s)."

Fr. Tad,

Can you supply me with the Vatican reference to the church teaching providing for the "protection" of the woman from the attacker's sperm? The only reference to this that I have been able to find is in documents from the USCCB, which does not necessarily have the teaching authority of the Church, but, as far as I understand, is only an administrative and pastoral body. I also have questions about the LH surge being the test of choice, as this may give the information that ovulation is in progress, but will tell you nothing about the window of time between ovulation/conception and implantation when the HCG begins to be produced. This is the window of time that creates the ethical dilemma, and there is not really a cost-effective way to provide testing to deal with this. Are you aware of any hospitals which actually provide the in-depth tests (i.e. ultrasound, blood tests for different hormone levels, etc.) to truly determine at which point the woman is in her cycle? Also, as an ER nurse and a pregnancy resource center nurse manager, I find it *extremely* rare that a woman can identify her time of ovulation, and very often women cannot even remember when their last menstrual period was.

Pam in El Paso

RE: Re:OT: Emergency Contraception

You might be interested in one of my articles on this topic; go to:

http://www.ncbcenter.org/NetCommunity/Page.aspx?pid=249

and select

November 2007 - Getting It Right "The Morning-After"

Pax,

Fr. Tad

One more question:

If contraception, according to the teaching of the Church, is objectively immoral, how is it justified even in this case?

Again, why are we working so hard to justify the administration of a contraceptive, regardless of the origin of the possible conception?

Pam in El Paso

We are all given a single life-time by the Lord, and the time is given so that we

might serve. For the work of God’s Church is never done, so long as time shall

last, and it is a privilege to offer the service of one’s life to her mission.

-Bishop E. , Diocese of Brownsville, TX

Posted



Pam,

I doubt that you will find official Vatican documents that teach that a woman can use contraceptive behaviors and devices and drugs to protect herself from the sperm deposited by a rapist. Here you enter into the area of arguments that are considered "probable" in terms of the theological theory and practice of "probabilism." Specifically dealing with the matter of rape, Fr. J. Bayer, S.T.D. wrote a book titled "Rape within Marriage: A Moral Analysis Delayed" in which he argued that even in the case where the wife's husband was the rapist, she could legitimately use a contraceptive device to prevent impregnation. The book was published in 1985 with the Nihil Obstat of Rev. Lorenzo Albacete, S.T.D. and the Imprimatur of Rev. Msgr. F. Donoghue of the Archdiocese of Washington. It is currently available by going to info@... and searching for the main title. If it is an accepted probable opinion that a married woman can use a contraceptive device in the case of unavoidable rape by her husband, you can be assured that this is built upon the prior acceptance of the opinion that any woman can thus protect herself against the sperm of a rapist other than her husband. I have about eight pages on this in the book under my signature below.

That, however, does not say that every means of "birth control" is legitimate in this case. Fr. Bayer would be among the first to agree that it would be wrong to seek to avoid continued pregnancy by using an anti-implantation agent or any other abortion-causing agent. I agree with you about the great practical difficulty of administering a drug with an abortifacient potential at such a time that it would not have any possibility of causing an early abortion. I agree with you that such a theoretical possibility remains so theoretical as to be impossible, or at least almost impossible, to do with moral certainty of not causing an early abortion.

F KippleyNFP Internationalwww.NFPandmore.org"Sex and the Marriage Covenant: A Basis for Morality" (Ignatius)

RE: Re:OT: Emergency Contraception

You might be interested in one of my articles on this topic; go to:

http://www.ncbcenter.org/NetCommunity/Page.aspx?pid=249

and select

November 2007 - Getting It Right "The Morning-After"

Pax,

Fr. Tad

One more question:

If contraception, according to the teaching of the Church, is objectively immoral, how is it justified even in this case?

Again, why are we working so hard to justify the administration of a contraceptive, regardless of the origin of the possible conception?

Pam in El Paso

We are all given a single life-time by the Lord, and the time is given so that we

might serve. For the work of God’s Church is never done, so long as time shall

last, and it is a privilege to offer the service of one’s life to her mission.

-Bishop E. , Diocese of Brownsville, TX

Posted

An important point here is that in that case we are not talking about contraception, which morally speaking requires freely choosing an act of intercourse and then at some point rendering either it or its natural consequences infertile. It may still be right or wrong, but not precisely as an act of contraception. Presumably its morality then is based on the proper care of the body and the respect due it, among other considerations, but it could not be classically considered contraception morally.

Sincerely yours,

Dominic M. Pedulla MD, FACC, CNFPMC, ABVM, ACPh

Interventional Cardiologist, Endovascular Diplomate, Varicose Vein Specialist, Noncontraceptive Family Planning Consultant, Family Planning Researcher

Medical Director, The Oklahoma Vein and Endovascular Center (www.noveinok.com, varicoseveins1@...)

Executive Director, The Edith Stein Foundation (www.theedithsteinfoundation.com)

(office)

(cell)

pedullad@...

Returning then to the question of justice,

theme of his Message for Lent 2010, the Pope observed that "Christ's

Gospel responds positively to man's thirst for justice, but in an

unexpected and surprising way. Christ does not propose a social or

political revolution, but a revolution of love which he has already

achieved with His cross and His resurrection. It is upon these that the

Beatitudes rest, opening a new horizon of justice".

Re: Re:OT: Emergency Contraception



Pam,

I doubt that you will find official Vatican documents that teach that a woman can use contraceptive behaviors and devices and drugs to protect herself from the sperm deposited by a rapist. Here you enter into the area of arguments that are considered "probable" in terms of the theological theory and practice of "probabilism." Specifically dealing with the matter of rape, Fr. J. Bayer, S.T.D. wrote a book titled "Rape within Marriage: A Moral Analysis Delayed" in which he argued that even in the case where the wife's husband was the rapist, she could legitimately use a contraceptive device to prevent impregnation. The book was published in 1985 with the Nihil Obstat of Rev. Lorenzo Albacete, S.T.D. and the Imprimatur of Rev. Msgr. F. Donoghue of the Archdiocese of Washington. It is currently available by going to infowipfandstock and searching for the main title. If it is an accepted probable opinion that a married woman can use a contraceptive device in the case of unavoidable rape by her husband, you can be assured that this is built upon the prior acceptance of the opinion that any woman can thus protect herself against the sperm of a rapist other than her husband. I have about eight pages on this in the book under my signature below.

That, however, does not say that every means of "birth control" is legitimate in this case. Fr. Bayer would be among the first to agree that it would be wrong to seek to avoid continued pregnancy by using an anti-implantation agent or any other abortion-causing agent. I agree with you about the great practical difficulty of administering a drug with an abortifacient potential at such a time that it would not have any possibility of causing an early abortion. I agree with you that such a theoretical possibility remains so theoretical as to be impossible, or at least almost impossible, to do with moral certainty of not causing an early abortion.

F Kippley

NFP International

www.NFPandmore.org

"Sex and the Marriage Covenant: A Basis for Morality" (Ignatius)

RE: Re:OT: Emergency Contraception

You might be interested in one of my articles on this topic; go to:

http://www.ncbcenter.org/NetCommunity/Page.aspx?pid=249

and select

November 2007 - Getting It Right "The Morning-After"

Pax,

Fr. Tad

One more question:

If contraception, according to the teaching of the Church, is objectively immoral, how is it justified even in this case?

Again, why are we working so hard to justify the administration of a contraceptive, regardless of the origin of the possible conception?

Pam in El Paso

We are all given a single life-time by the Lord, and the time is given so that we

might serve. For the work of God’s Church is never done, so long as time shall

last, and it is a privilege to offer the service of one’s life to her mission.

-Bishop E. , Diocese of Brownsville, TX

Posted

In all instances of potentially conflicted moral decisions a Catholic's first recourse for resolution are

the official teachings of the Church.  Pam, I refer you to the teaching of the Pontifical Academy For Life, " Statement on the so-called " morning after pill " at http://www.vatican.va/.  Some argue, falsely, that human life begins at implantation of the human embryo. The Church clearly teachers, however, that human life begins at conception preceding the implantation of the human embryo in the endometrium.  The Academy's

statement is clear and resolves any doubt on the issue and asserts its prohibition of contraceptives.  Unfortunately, the suffering of the victim of rape can not be undone, neither can the innocense of a child

born of rape. 

Sincerely,

Father Tom

 

" Some have argued that it may be immoral for Catholics to provide any contraceptive measures at all to a woman who has been raped. Such a view is incorrect, however, because a woman who has been sexually assaulted is clearly entitled to protect herself from the attacker’s sperm. The Church teaches that rape is not a unitive act that requires openness to procreation. It is rather an act of violence against another person, and the woman is allowed to take steps to prevent the possible fertilization of her own egg(s). "

 

Fr. Tad,

Can you supply me with the Vatican reference to the church teaching providing for the " protection " of the woman from the attacker's sperm?  The only reference to this that I have been able to find is in documents from the USCCB, which does not necessarily have the teaching authority of the Church, but, as far as I understand, is only an administrative and pastoral body. 

I also have questions about the LH surge being the test of choice, as this may give the information that ovulation is in progress, but will tell you nothing about the window of time between ovulation/conception and implantation when the HCG begins to be produced.  This is the window of time that creates the ethical dilemma, and there is not really a cost-effective way to provide testing to deal with this.  Are you aware of any hospitals which actually provide the in-depth tests (i.e. ultrasound, blood tests for different hormone levels, etc.) to truly determine at which point the woman is in her cycle?  Also, as an ER nurse and a pregnancy resource center nurse manager, I find it *extremely* rare that a woman can identify her time of ovulation, and very often women cannot even remember when their last menstrual period was.

Pam in El Paso

RE: Re:OT: Emergency Contraception  

You might be interested in one of my articles on this topic; go to:

http://www.ncbcenter.org/NetCommunity/Page.aspx?pid=249

and select

November 2007 - Getting It Right " The Morning-After "

Pax,

Fr. Tad

One more question:

If contraception, according to the teaching of the Church, is objectively immoral, how is it justified even in this case?

Again, why are we working so hard to justify the administration of a contraceptive, regardless of the origin of the possible conception?

Pam in El Paso

We are all given a single life-time by the Lord, and the time is given so that we

might serve. For the work of God’s Church is never done, so long as time shall

last, and it is a privilege to offer the service of one’s life to her mission.

-Bishop E. , Diocese of Brownsville, TX

Posted

How true Father! WHat I said dealt only with those acts not directly bearing on the life of the embryo, i.e., strictly anticonceptive but not abortifacient maneuvers. Father it's good to hear from a true Humanae Vitae priest warrior!!!

Sincerely yours,

Dominic M. Pedulla MD, FACC, CNFPMC, ABVM, ACPh

Interventional Cardiologist, Endovascular Diplomate, Varicose Vein Specialist, Noncontraceptive Family Planning Consultant, Family Planning Researcher

Medical Director, The Oklahoma Vein and Endovascular Center (www.noveinok.com, varicoseveins1@...)

Executive Director, The Edith Stein Foundation (www.theedithsteinfoundation.com)

(office)

(cell)

pedullad@...

Returning then to the question of justice,

theme of his Message for Lent 2010, the Pope observed that "Christ's

Gospel responds positively to man's thirst for justice, but in an

unexpected and surprising way. Christ does not propose a social or

political revolution, but a revolution of love which he has already

achieved with His cross and His resurrection. It is upon these that the

Beatitudes rest, opening a new horizon of justice".

RE: Re:OT: Emergency Contraception

You might be interested in one of my articles on this topic; go to:

http://www.ncbcenter.org/NetCommunity/Page.aspx?pid=249

and select

November 2007 - Getting It Right "The Morning-After"

Pax,

Fr. Tad

One more question:

If contraception, according to the teaching of the Church, is objectively immoral, how is it justified even in this case?

Again, why are we working so hard to justify the administration of a contraceptive, regardless of the origin of the possible conception?

Pam in El Paso

We are all given a single life-time by the Lord, and the time is given so that we

might serve. For the work of God’s Church is never done, so long as time shall

last, and it is a privilege to offer the service of one’s life to her mission.

-Bishop E. , Diocese of Brownsville, TX

Posted



Dominic,

You are certainly correct that the term "contraception" as used in the documents of the Church has meant the effort by the spouses to prevent the sperm from meeting the egg. But to say that the use of a douche after an unanticipated rape or the use of a female condom or diaphragm in the case of possible anticipated rape is not contraception is to avoid the obvious, namely, that these are contraceptive behaviors and they are not condemned by orthodox moral theologians.

It seems to me that the Church's teaching against contraceptive behaviors is conditioned upon the totality of circumstances that make up the moral act, the chief one being that the agents are married to each other. The teaching that was reaffirmed by Humanae Vitae used the term quilibet matrimonii usus in the last sentence of n. 11. "Each and every marriage act." It did not use terminology such as "each and every act of human sexual copulation" that would have included even acts of rape.

Those arguing that contraceptive behaviors used by a married woman in view of possible rape by her own husband have argued that marital rape is not a true marriage act and that therefore such protective efforts by the wife are not condemned by Humanae Vitae. One of those theologians is thought to have been instrumental in the writing of Humanae Vitae, and his argument appeared in L'Osservatore Romano.

Disclosure. Since about 1970 I have argued that the real evil of marital contraception is that it violates the marriage covenant. That raised a corollary question: what if there is no marriage covenant to renew? When the act is already the grave matter of mortal sin by reason of being an act of adultery, fornication, incest, etc., does contraception add the grave matter of a second mortal sin? It's a highly speculative question because the use of a true contraceptive would involve other such sins such as the purchase of the device, the planning, etc. This speculation has passed the review of several nihil obstats, but that is of limited meaning.

Jamison has somewhat recently argued that my interpretation of the implications of this corollary is erroneous (HPR, May 2006). He argues that what makes marital contraception intrinsically evil is its deliberate separation of the unitive and procreative aspects of the marriage act and that this would apply to mutually voluntary non-marital acts. His article is at our website: http://www.nfpandmore.org/fa_jameson.shtml.

RE: Re:OT: Emergency Contraception

You might be interested in one of my articles on this topic; go to:

http://www.ncbcenter.org/NetCommunity/Page.aspx?pid=249

and select

November 2007 - Getting It Right "The Morning-After"

Pax,

Fr. Tad

One more question:

If contraception, according to the teaching of the Church, is objectively immoral, how is it justified even in this case?

Again, why are we working so hard to justify the administration of a contraceptive, regardless of the origin of the possible conception?

Pam in El PasoWe are all given a single life-time by the Lord, and the time is given so that we

might serve. For the work of God’s Church is never done, so long as time shall

last, and it is a privilege to offer the service of one’s life to her mission.

-Bishop E. , Diocese of Brownsville, TX

Posted

Yes - I agree that this is an important point - and so would like to underline it. The Church teaches that contraception is intrinsically evil - i.e. cannot be justified regardless of intention/circumstances. The Church's teaching however also includes a definition of contraception - as can be seen by reading (for example - and especially) Humanae Vitae carefully. "Contraception" is defined in a way that presupposes "the marital act." Now - I think some people (maybe on this list some years ago?) have argued that this means that the teaching only applies within marriage - not also to fornication (or adultery). I disagree with that view. These acts are (obviously) morally different from marital intercourse - but they are still (by definition) freely chosen by both parties - and although they are already objectively selfish (rather than loving), I would argue that they can be made even more so - more evil - by the use of barrier devices or drugs that prevent ovulation or surgical sterilization or whatever. There is some - if rather minimal - analogy between these acts, and marital intercourse.

But with rape, the analogy breaks down completely - the physical behavior (of the rapist) may be very similar to the physical behavior in marital intercourse - but humanly/morally, the act is different - very fundamentally so. The woman is not a co-actor - she is suffering violence. She is not being in any way selfish by trying to prevent fertilization from being a result of the rape.

While you will not (that I know of) find a document by a pope or the CDF or the like saying explicitly that preventing fertilization after rape is not contraception and is morally acceptable - I think that this does pretty clearly follow from the details of the Church's teaching about contraception - specifically the Church's definition of contraception (and related authoritative explanations of why it is wrong).

I would also add however - that although USCCB documents are generally pretty limited in their teaching authority - it is worth noting that the Ethical and Religious Directives for Catholic Health Care were vetted by (I believe) the CDF - and some changes were made as a result of Vatican feedback (especailly - again, as I recall - regarding issues having to do with cooperation with abortion by Catholic facilities). So when the ERDs say that it is okay to prevent fertilization after rape - this is something that the Vatican has seen and has not said needs change.

This does not, of course, mean that abortifacient drugs or procedures are okay after rape. Their use would entail a grave injustice (especially to the newly conceived human person) - that is not changed by the circumstances of the conception.

Nor - since this was one of the questions that got this conversation going on the list - does this mean that it would be okay to provide sterilization or the like to a woman who is severely mentally challenged. I'm skeptical that in cases of severe disability, the answer would be to teach her NFP - as I think someone suggested - since I'm skeptical that in such cases, the woman would be capable of the sort of knowledge and consent that are required for marriage and marital intercourse. However - (1) providing - in advance - ways of preventing fertilization - is not a substitute for taking appropriate care to prevent rape entirely - and in a case like the one described, the care that is appropriate - that is a pretty serious requirement of justice - is care that would basically prevent rape - at least that would make the woman's risk of being raped not significantly greater than that of the average woman in our society. And - (2) surgical sterilization would never be appropriate - even in cases in which there is no way to keep a woman from being at significantly high risk of being raped - it is a bodily mutilation that couldn't be proportionate to the alleged benefit.

As to the question of whether drugs like "Plan B" do or don't pose a morally significant risk of post-fertilization - i.e. abortifacient - effects - that is a scientific question (even when Vatican documents have weighed in on it, they have done so based on advice from scientists, and their authority isn't generally greater than that of the advice they've received) - not a theological one - so I will leave it to others to hash it out.

I hope that helps.

Dept. of Theology

Franciscan Univ. of Steubenville

RE: Re:OT: Emergency Contraception

You might be interested in one of my articles on this topic; go to:

http://www.ncbcenter.org/NetCommunity/Page.aspx?pid=249

and select

November 2007 - Getting It Right "The Morning-After"

Pax,

Fr. Tad

One more question:

If contraception, according to the teaching of the Church, is objectively immoral, how is it justified even in this case?

Again, why are we working so hard to justify the administration of a contraceptive, regardless of the origin of the possible conception?

Pam in El PasoWe are all given a single life-time by the Lord, and the time is given so that we

might serve. For the work of God’s Church is never done, so long as time shall

last, and it is a privilege to offer the service of one’s life to her mission.

-Bishop E. , Diocese of Brownsville, TX

Posted

No I'm saying the term traditionally means not just anti-conceptive intervention ("the effort by the spouses to prevent the sperm from meeting the egg"), but specifically in the context of a conjugal act which is freely chosen; that's the true object, morally speaking, of the contraceptive act, action taken to render freely chosen conjugal act(s) infertile.

You are certainly correct that the term "contraception" as used in the documents of the Church has meant the effort by the spouses to prevent the sperm from meeting the egg. But to say that the use of a douche after an unanticipated rape or the use of a female condom or diaphragm in the case of possible anticipated rape is not contraception is to avoid the obvious, namely, that these are contraceptive behaviors and they are not condemned by orthodox moral theologians.

Sincerely yours,

Dominic M. Pedulla MD, FACC, CNFPMC, ABVM, ACPh

Interventional Cardiologist, Endovascular Diplomate, Varicose Vein Specialist, Noncontraceptive Family Planning Consultant, Family Planning Researcher

Medical Director, The Oklahoma Vein and Endovascular Center (www.noveinok.com, varicoseveins1@...)

Executive Director, The Edith Stein Foundation (www.theedithsteinfoundation.com)

(office)

(cell)

pedullad@...

Returning then to the question of justice,

theme of his Message for Lent 2010, the Pope observed that "Christ's

Gospel responds positively to man's thirst for justice, but in an

unexpected and surprising way. Christ does not propose a social or

political revolution, but a revolution of love which he has already

achieved with His cross and His resurrection. It is upon these that the

Beatitudes rest, opening a new horizon of justice".

Re: Re:OT: Emergency Contraception



Dominic,

You are certainly correct that the term "contraception" as used in the documents of the Church has meant the effort by the spouses to prevent the sperm from meeting the egg. But to say that the use of a douche after an unanticipated rape or the use of a female condom or diaphragm in the case of possible anticipated rape is not contraception is to avoid the obvious, namely, that these are contraceptive behaviors and they are not condemned by orthodox moral theologians.

It seems to me that the Church's teaching against contraceptive behaviors is conditioned upon the totality of circumstances that make up the moral act, the chief one being that the agents are married to each other. The teaching that was reaffirmed by Humanae Vitae used the term quilibet matrimonii usus in the last sentence of n. 11. "Each and every marriage act." It did not use terminology such as "each and every act of human sexual copulation" that would have included even acts of rape.

Those arguing that contraceptive behaviors used by a married woman in view of possible rape by her own husband have argued that marital rape is not a true marriage act and that therefore such protective efforts by the wife are not condemned by Humanae Vitae. One of those theologians is thought to have been instrumental in the writing of Humanae Vitae, and his argument appeared in L'Osservatore Romano.

Disclosure. Since about 1970 I have argued that the real evil of marital contraception is that it violates the marriage covenant. That raised a corollary question: what if there is no marriage covenant to renew? When the act is already the grave matter of mortal sin by reason of being an act of adultery, fornication, incest, etc., does contraception add the grave matter of a second mortal sin? It's a highly speculative question because the use of a true contraceptive would involve other such sins such as the purchase of the device, the planning, etc. This speculation has passed the review of several nihil obstats, but that is of limited meaning.

Jamison has somewhat recently argued that my interpretation of the implications of this corollary is erroneous (HPR, May 2006). He argues that what makes marital contraception intrinsically evil is its deliberate separation of the unitive and procreative aspects of the marriage act and that this would apply to mutually voluntary non-marital acts. His article is at our website: http://www.nfpandmore.org/fa_jameson.shtml.

RE: Re:OT: Emergency Contraception

You might be interested in one of my articles on this topic; go to:

http://www.ncbcenter.org/NetCommunity/Page.aspx?pid=249

and select

November 2007 - Getting It Right "The Morning-After"

Pax,

Fr. Tad

One more question:

If contraception, according to the teaching of the Church, is objectively immoral, how is it justified even in this case?

Again, why are we working so hard to justify the administration of a contraceptive, regardless of the origin of the possible conception?

Pam in El Paso

We are all given a single life-time by the Lord, and the time is given so that we

might serve. For the work of God’s Church is never done, so long as time shall

last, and it is a privilege to offer the service of one’s life to her mission.

-Bishop E. , Diocese of Brownsville, TX

Posted

Another consideration regarding the practical aspects of this issue: because of the lack of clear guidance on this issue, many conscienciously practicing Catholics in healthcare are left hung out to dry by their fellow not-so-practicing Catholics when the protest is raised about just handing out the morning-after-pill to rape victims. The response is "Catholic hospitals can use this in case of rape, the church has said so", but there is never any real understanding of the moral issues involved, or the requirements to be met in order to satisfy those moral imperatives. The church, in failing to take a definitive stand, is failing her members. There is so much uncertainty about the mechanisms of action that are in play with the morning-after-pill, and with the ability to actually determine if conception has occurred, that there is an appropriate place for saying with that much uncertainty, the moral choice would be to avoid it's use.

I still have a very negative gut reaction when trying to understand the concept of the entitlement to defense against the "attack" of the assailant's sperm. Sperm do not attack. The assailant attacks. Conception is not an attack that needs to be defended against; it is the beginning of human life. The only reason there is to "defend" against the attack of the sperm is to contracept, to take a definitive action to prevent the conception of human life. This entire perception in terms of "defense against attack" seems rather odd. The attack occurred with teh action of teh rape. The natural consequence that may occur with conception is not an attack. You might say that contracting an STI from a rape is also a consequence, and should be treated. However, an infection is a disease, a conception is not.

Whatever happened to the concept of trust in God, the one who throughout Scripture is described as opening or closing the womb; isn't He ultimately the one in control of this? How many non-marital acts of sexual intercourse, described in the Scriptures, even violent or involving a victim of one kind or another, resulted in blessings through the children who were conceived through those acts, who were vitally important in God's plan of salvation? Why must we assume that a child conceived in rape is an additional assault on the woman, rather than a blessing which God can use to bring that person closer to Himself? Doesn't this just open the doors for another slippery slope in regards to the use of contraception - if we can find this exception to the objective immorality of contraception, can't we find more?

In regards to the wife who is raped by her husband, what is actually doing that woman good? Is it contracepting her so that she can remain in the abusive relationship and suffer further, believing that contraception (which is never 100% effective anyway) will somehow keep her "safe" from a pregnancy? (What is the source of the threat to her safety - the abuse by her husband, or a child?) Wouldn't the better answer be to assist the woman out of her abusive environment, to provide her a way to avoid continued and possibly escalating abuse and perhaps help with healing in the relationship through counseling and other forms of support? (This does correlate in some way to the discussion of sterilizing or contracepting the mentally handicapped woman to keep her from getting pregnant by an abuser, when the better answer is to protect her from abuse in the first place).

Re: Re:OT: Emergency Contraception

 Pam,

I doubt that you will find official Vatican documents that teach that a woman can use contraceptive behaviors and devices and drugs to protect herself from the sperm deposited by a rapist. Here you enter into the area of arguments that are considered "probable" in terms of the theological theory and practice of "probabilism." Specifically dealing with the matter of rape, Fr. J. Bayer, S.T.D. wrote a book titled "Rape within Marriage: A Moral Analysis Delayed" in which he argued that even in the case where the wife's husband was the rapist, she could legitimately use a contraceptive device to prevent impregnation. The book was published in 1985 with the Nihil Obstat of Rev. Lorenzo Albacete, S.T.D. and the Imprimatur of Rev. Msgr. F. Donoghue of the Archdiocese of Washington. It is currently available by going to infowipfandstock and searching for the main title. If it is an accepted probable opinion that a married woman can use a contraceptive device in the case of unavoidable rape by her husband, you can be assured that this is built upon the prior acceptance of the opinion that any woman can thus protect herself against the sperm of a rapist other than her husband. I have about eight pages on this in the book under my signature below.

That, however, does not say that every means of "birth control" is legitimate in this case. Fr. Bayer would be among the first to agree that it would be wrong to seek to avoid continued pregnancy by using an anti-implantation agent or any other abortion-causing agent. I agree with you about the great practical difficulty of administering a drug with an abortifacient potential at such a time that it would not have any possibility of causing an early abortion. I agree with you that such a theoretical possibility remains so theoretical as to be impossible, or at least almost impossible, to do with moral certainty of not causing an early abortion.

F KippleyNFP Internationalwww.NFPandmore.org"Sex and the Marriage Covenant: A Basis for Morality" (Ignatius)

RE: Re:OT: Emergency Contraception

You might be interested in one of my articles on this topic; go to:

http://www.ncbcenter.org/NetCommunity/Page.aspx?pid=249

and select

November 2007 - Getting It Right "The Morning-After"

Pax,

Fr. Tad

One more question:

If contraception, according to the teaching of the Church, is objectively immoral, how is it justified even in this case?

Again, why are we working so hard to justify the administration of a contraceptive, regardless of the origin of the possible conception?

Pam in El Paso

We are all given a single life-time by the Lord, and the time is given so that we

might serve. For the work of God’s Church is never done, so long as time shall

last, and it is a privilege to offer the service of one’s life to her mission.

-Bishop E. , Diocese of Brownsville, TX

Posted

Pam I agree with you, 100%. Sandrock, CNMSent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerryDate: Fri, 19 Feb 2010 23:59:22 -0500 (EST)To: <nfpprofessionals >Subject: Re: Re:OT: Emergency ContraceptionAnother consideration regarding the practical aspects of this issue: because of the lack of clear guidance on this issue, many conscienciously practicing Catholics in healthcare are left hung out to dry by their fellow not-so-practicing Catholics when the protest is raised about just handing out the morning-after-pill to rape victims. The response is "Catholic hospitals can use this in case of rape, the church has said so", but there is never any real understanding of the moral issues involved, or the requirements to be met in order to satisfy those moral imperatives. The church, in failing to take a definitive stand, is failing her members. There is so much uncertainty about the mechanisms of action that are in play with the morning-after-pill, and with the ability to actually determine if conception has occurred, that there is an appropriate place for saying with that much uncertainty, the moral choice would be to avoid it's use. I still have a very negative gut reaction when trying to understand the concept of the entitlement to defense against the "attack" of the assailant's sperm. Sperm do not attack. The assailant attacks. Conception is not an attack that needs to be defended against; it is the beginning of human life. The only reason there is to "defend" against the attack of the sperm is to contracept, to take a definitive action to prevent the conception of human life. This entire perception in terms of "defense against attack" seems rather odd. The attack occurred with teh action of teh rape. The natural consequence that may occur with conception is not an attack. You might say that contracting an STI from a rape is also a consequence, and should be treated. However, an infection is a disease, a conception is not. Whatever happened to the concept of trust in God, the one who throughout Scripture is described as opening or closing the womb; isn't He ultimately the one in control of this? How many non-marital acts of sexual intercourse, described in the Scriptures, even violent or involving a victim of one kind or another, resulted in blessings through the children who were conceived through those acts, who were vitally important in God's plan of salvation? Why must we assume that a child conceived in rape is an additional assault on the woman, rather than a blessing which God can use to bring that person closer to Himself? Doesn't this just open the doors for another slippery slope in regards to the use of contraception - if we can find this exception to the objective immorality of contraception, can't we find more? In regards to the wife who is raped by her husband, what is actually doing that woman good? Is it contracepting her so that she can remain in the abusive relationship and suffer further, believing that contraception (which is never 100% effective anyway) will somehow keep her "safe" from a pregnancy? (What is the source of the threat to her safety - the abuse by her husband, or a child?) Wouldn't the better answer be to assist the woman out of her abusive environment, to provide her a way to avoid continued and possibly escalating abuse and perhaps help with healing in the relationship through counseling and other forms of support? (This does correlate in some way to the discussion of sterilizing or contracepting the mentally handicapped woman to keep her from getting pregnant by an abuser, when the better answer is to protect her from abuse in the first place). Re: Re:OT: Emergency Contraception  Pam, I doubt that you will find official Vatican documents that teach that a woman can use contraceptive behaviors and devices and drugs to protect herself from the sperm deposited by a rapist. Here you enter into the area of arguments that are considered "probable" in terms of the theological theory and practice of "probabilism." Specifically dealing with the matter of rape, Fr. J. Bayer, S.T.D. wrote a book titled "Rape within Marriage: A Moral Analysis Delayed" in which he argued that even in the case where the wife's husband was the rapist, she could legitimately use a contraceptive device to prevent impregnation. The book was published in 1985 with the Nihil Obstat of Rev. Lorenzo Albacete, S.T.D. and the Imprimatur of Rev. Msgr. F. Donoghue of the Archdiocese of Washington. It is currently available by going to infowipfandstock and searching for the main title. If it is an accepted probable opinion that a married woman can use a contraceptive device in the case of unavoidable rape by her husband, you can be assured that this is built upon the prior acceptance of the opinion that any woman can thus protect herself against the sperm of a rapist other than her husband. I have about eight pages on this in the book under my signature below. That, however, does not say that every means of "birth control" is legitimate in this case. Fr. Bayer would be among the first to agree that it would be wrong to seek to avoid continued pregnancy by using an anti-implantation agent or any other abortion-causing agent. I agree with you about the great practical difficulty of administering a drug with an abortifacient potential at such a time that it would not have any possibility of causing an early abortion. I agree with you that such a theoretical possibility remains so theoretical as to be impossible, or at least almost impossible, to do with moral certainty of not causing an early abortion. F KippleyNFP Internationalwww.NFPandmore.org"Sex and the Marriage Covenant: A Basis for Morality" (Ignatius) RE: Re:OT: Emergency Contraception You might be interested in one of my articles on this topic; go to:http://www.ncbcenter.org/NetCommunity/Page.aspx?pid=249and selectNovember 2007 - Getting It Right "The Morning-After"Pax,Fr. TadOne more question:If contraception, according to the teaching of the Church, is objectively immoral, how is it justified even in this case?Again, why are we working so hard to justify the administration of a contraceptive, regardless of the origin of the possible conception?Pam in El Paso

We are all given a single life-time by the Lord, and the time is given so that we

might serve. For the work of God’s Church is never done, so long as time shall

last, and it is a privilege to offer the service of one’s life to her mission.

-Bishop E. , Diocese of Brownsville, TX

Posted

Pam,

There is " clear guidance. "   I cited the Vatican source in my previous reply.  Sometimes we can make matters more complex than they really are, particularly when they result in an undesired effect.  The effects of sin abound in the world.  Standing on moral principle often incurs pain and suffering.  The Church's opposition to contraception is absolute.  If the " morning after pill " is contraceptive--clearly it is marketed as such--then conscientious Catholics should oppose its use.  The various other issues you raise are not causally but antecdotally related. The doubts about the moral implications of one's decision must ordinarily be resolved before one acts in doubt and should not be the basis of one's action, i.e., " what if . . . " . 

Sincerely,

Father Tom

 

Another consideration regarding the practical aspects of this issue:  because of the lack of clear guidance on this issue, many conscienciously practicing Catholics in healthcare are left hung out to dry by their fellow not-so-practicing Catholics when the protest is raised about just handing out the morning-after-pill to rape victims. The response is " Catholic hospitals can use this in case of rape, the church has said so " , but there is never any real understanding of the moral issues involved, or the requirements to be met in order to satisfy those moral imperatives.  The church, in failing to take a definitive stand, is failing her members.  There is so much uncertainty about the mechanisms of action that are in play with the morning-after-pill, and with the ability to actually determine if conception has occurred, that there is an appropriate place for saying with that much uncertainty, the moral choice would be to avoid it's use.

 

I still have a very negative gut reaction when trying to understand the concept of the entitlement to defense against the " attack " of the assailant's sperm.  Sperm do not attack.  The assailant attacks.  Conception is not an attack that needs to be defended against; it is the beginning of human life.  The only reason there is to " defend " against the attack of the sperm is to contracept, to take a definitive action to prevent the conception of human life.  This entire perception in terms of  " defense against attack " seems rather odd.  The attack occurred with teh action of teh rape.  The natural consequence that may occur with conception is not an attack.  You might say that contracting an STI from a rape is also a consequence, and should be treated. However, an infection is a disease, a conception is not.

 

Whatever happened to the concept of trust in God, the one who throughout Scripture is described as opening or closing the womb; isn't He ultimately the one in control of this?  How many non-marital acts of sexual intercourse, described in the Scriptures, even violent or involving a victim of one kind or another, resulted in blessings through the children who were conceived through those acts, who were vitally important in God's plan of salvation?  Why must we assume that a child conceived in rape is an additional assault on the woman, rather than a blessing which God can use to bring that person closer to Himself?  Doesn't this just open the doors for another slippery slope in regards to the use of contraception - if we can find this exception to the objective immorality of contraception, can't we find more?

 

In regards to the wife who is raped by her husband, what is actually doing that woman good?  Is it contracepting her so that she can remain in the abusive relationship and suffer further, believing that contraception (which is never 100% effective anyway) will somehow keep her " safe " from a pregnancy?  (What is the source of the threat to her safety - the abuse by her husband, or a child?) Wouldn't the better answer be to assist the woman out of her abusive environment, to provide her a way to avoid continued and possibly escalating abuse and perhaps help with healing in the relationship through counseling and other forms of support?  (This does correlate in some way to the discussion of sterilizing or contracepting the mentally handicapped woman to keep her from getting pregnant by an abuser, when the better answer is to protect her from abuse in the first place).

 

Re: Re:OT: Emergency Contraception 

 Pam,

    I doubt that you will find official Vatican documents that teach that a woman can use contraceptive behaviors and devices and drugs to protect herself from the sperm deposited by a rapist.  Here you enter into the area of arguments that are considered " probable " in terms of the theological theory and practice of " probabilism. "   Specifically dealing with the matter of rape, Fr. J. Bayer, S.T.D. wrote a book titled " Rape within Marriage: A Moral Analysis Delayed " in which he argued that even in the case where the wife's husband was the rapist, she could legitimately use a contraceptive device to prevent impregnation.  The book was published in 1985 with the Nihil Obstat of Rev. Lorenzo Albacete, S.T.D. and the Imprimatur of Rev. Msgr. F. Donoghue of the Archdiocese of Washington.  It is currently available by going to info@... and searching for the main title.  If it is an accepted probable opinion that a married woman can use a contraceptive device in the case of unavoidable rape by her husband, you can be assured that this is built upon the prior acceptance of the opinion that any woman can thus protect herself against the sperm of a rapist other than her husband.  I have about eight pages on this in the book under my signature below.

 

    That, however, does not say that every means of " birth control " is legitimate in this case.  Fr. Bayer would be among the first to agree that it would be wrong to seek to avoid continued pregnancy by using an anti-implantation agent or any other abortion-causing agent.  I agree with you about the great practical difficulty of administering a drug with an abortifacient potential at such a time that it would not have any possibility of causing an early abortion.  I agree with you that such a theoretical possibility remains so theoretical as to be impossible, or at least almost impossible, to do with moral certainty of not causing an early abortion. 

 

F KippleyNFP Internationalwww.NFPandmore.org " Sex and the Marriage Covenant: A Basis for Morality " (Ignatius)

 

 

 

 

 

RE: Re:OT: Emergency Contraception  

You might be interested in one of my articles on this topic; go to:

http://www.ncbcenter.org/NetCommunity/Page.aspx?pid=249

and select

November 2007 - Getting It Right " The Morning-After "

Pax,

Fr. Tad

One more question:

If contraception, according to the teaching of the Church, is objectively immoral, how is it justified even in this case?

Again, why are we working so hard to justify the administration of a contraceptive, regardless of the origin of the possible conception?

Pam in El Paso

We are all given a single life-time by the Lord, and the time is given so that we

might serve. For the work of God’s Church is never done, so long as time shall

last, and it is a privilege to offer the service of one’s life to her mission.

-Bishop E. , Diocese of Brownsville, TX

Posted

Once again though, the sin of contraception involves freely chosen intercourse, not merely anti-conceptive intervention. God willed that conception happen through a freely chosen act of love, so if a woman facing the moral certainty of unavoidable rape had available to her a purely anti-conceptive intervention that was not at all abortifacient, it would seem there would be no sin. Now whether that exists practically is another matter. I don't see how one can have moral certainty though that the morning after pill belongs to that category; i.e., solely anti-conceptive in nature and not abortifacient.

Sincerely yours,

Dominic M. Pedulla MD, FACC, CNFPMC, ABVM, ACPh

Interventional Cardiologist, Endovascular Diplomate, Varicose Vein Specialist, Noncontraceptive Family Planning Consultant, Family Planning Researcher

Medical Director, The Oklahoma Vein and Endovascular Center (www.noveinok.com, varicoseveins1@...)

Executive Director, The Edith Stein Foundation (www.theedithsteinfoundation.com)

(office)

(cell)

pedullad@...

Returning then to the question of justice,

theme of his Message for Lent 2010, the Pope observed that "Christ's

Gospel responds positively to man's thirst for justice, but in an

unexpected and surprising way. Christ does not propose a social or

political revolution, but a revolution of love which he has already

achieved with His cross and His resurrection. It is upon these that the

Beatitudes rest, opening a new horizon of justice".

Re: Re:OT: Emergency Contraception

Pam,

I doubt that you will find official Vatican documents that teach that a woman can use contraceptive behaviors and devices and drugs to protect herself from the sperm deposited by a rapist. Here you enter into the area of arguments that are considered "probable" in terms of the theological theory and practice of "probabilism." Specifically dealing with the matter of rape, Fr. J. Bayer, S.T.D. wrote a book titled "Rape within Marriage: A Moral Analysis Delayed" in which he argued that even in the case where the wife's husband was the rapist, she could legitimately use a contraceptive device to prevent impregnation. The book was published in 1985 with the Nihil Obstat of Rev. Lorenzo Albacete, S.T.D. and the Imprimatur of Rev. Msgr. F. Donoghue of the Archdiocese of Washington. It is currently available by going to infowipfandstock and searching for the main title. If it is an accepted probable opinion that a married woman can use a contraceptive device in the case of unavoidable rape by her husband, you can be assured that this is built upon the prior acceptance of the opinion that any woman can thus protect herself against the sperm of a rapist other than her husband. I have about eight pages on this in the book under my signature below.

That, however, does not say that every means of "birth control" is legitimate in this case. Fr. Bayer would be among the first to agree that it would be wrong to seek to avoid continued pregnancy by using an anti-implantation agent or any other abortion-causing agent. I agree with you about the great practical difficulty of administering a drug with an abortifacient potential at such a time that it would not have any possibility of causing an early abortion. I agree with you that such a theoretical possibility remains so theoretical as to be impossible, or at least almost impossible, to do with moral certainty of not causing an early abortion.

F Kippley

NFP International

www.NFPandmore.org

"Sex and the Marriage Covenant: A Basis for Morality" (Ignatius)

RE: Re:OT: Emergency Contraception

You might be interested in one of my articles on this topic; go to:

http://www.ncbcenter.org/NetCommunity/Page.aspx?pid=249

and select

November 2007 - Getting It Right "The Morning-After"

Pax,

Fr. Tad

One more question:

If contraception, according to the teaching of the Church, is objectively immoral, how is it justified even in this case?

Again, why are we working so hard to justify the administration of a contraceptive, regardless of the origin of the possible conception?

Pam in El Paso

We are all given a single life-time by the Lord, and the time is given so that we

might serve. For the work of God’s Church is never done, so long as time shall

last, and it is a privilege to offer the service of one’s life to her mission.

-Bishop E. , Diocese of Brownsville, TX

Posted

The bottom line is that GOD is the author of life. All human life resulting from

any act of intercourse either by rape/force, or consent, is because God, in

His infinite wisdom desired and allowed that child to come into being. A child

He knew even before he/she was formed in the womb.

Are we going to say we are wiser than God?

Is a child any less valuable because of the circumstances surrounding

conception?

Are we not still trying to circumvent God's will and over-ride it with our own?

As mentioned by another poster, a child is not an illness or disease. Babies

are a product of God's love for us.

Sandrock, CNM

Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry

Posted

And I think that is a good argument against abortion - including abortifacients - in cases of rape.

I don't think it follows, though - and the Church's teaching doesn't say that it follows - that preventing fertilization in cases of rape is morally wrong.

I would also note - that similar arguments are made by "providentialists" who oppose even the use of NFP within marriage - that NFP (even for just reasons) is an attempt to override God's will.

God allows babies to come into existence in all kinds of circumstances. That doesn't mean that it is prudent for couples to have intercourse during the fertile time when having another child would have serious negative consequences. And it also doesn't mean that it's necessary to allow fertilization to occur in cases of rape when the woman asks for - and when there is available - a way to prevent fertilization (with moral certainty that it will not allow fertilization and then cause an early abortion).

Put differently - we ought to trust God's will. Part of doing that is trusting that he will take care of us if/when a baby is conceived - even if we didn't want that to happen - even if we used morally licit measures to try to keep that from happening. But another part of doing that is trusting that he will help us to discern what we ought to do to make it more or less likely that a baby will be conceived to begin with.

Re: Re:OT: Emergency Contraception

The bottom line is that GOD is the author of life. All human life resulting from any act of intercourse either by rape/force, or consent, is because God, in His infinite wisdom desired and allowed that child to come into being. A child He knew even before he/she was formed in the womb.Are we going to say we are wiser than God?Is a child any less valuable because of the circumstances surrounding conception? Are we not still trying to circumvent God's will and over-ride it with our own?As mentioned by another poster, a child is not an illness or disease. Babies are a product of God's love for us. Sandrock, CNMSent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry

Posted

There is no drug or device yet invented that will. with 100% assurance, only prevent fertilization, especially in cases of rape. There will always be the "God Factor".Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerryDate: Sat, 20 Feb 2010 16:36:58 +0000 (UTC)To: <nfpprofessionals >Subject: Re: Re:OT: Emergency ContraceptionAnd I think that is a good argument against abortion - including abortifacients - in cases of rape. I don't think it follows, though - and the Church's teaching doesn't say that it follows - that preventing fertilization in cases of rape is morally wrong. I would also note - that similar arguments are made by "providentialists" who oppose even the use of NFP within marriage - that NFP (even for just reasons) is an attempt to override God's will. God allows babies to come into existence in all kinds of circumstances. That doesn't mean that it is prudent for couples to have intercourse during the fertile time when having another child would have serious negative consequences. And it also doesn't mean that it's necessary to allow fertilization to occur in cases of rape when the woman asks for - and when there is available - a way to prevent fertilization (with moral certainty that it will not allow fertilization and then cause an early abortion). Put differently - we ought to trust God's will. Part of doing that is trusting that he will take care of us if/when a baby is conceived - even if we didn't want that to happen - even if we used morally licit measures to try to keep that from happening. But another part of doing that is trusting that he will help us to discern what we ought to do to make it more or less likely that a baby will be conceived to begin with. Re: Re:OT: Emergency Contraception The bottom line is that GOD is the author of life. All human life resulting from any act of intercourse either by rape/force, or consent, is because God, in His infinite wisdom desired and allowed that child to come into being. A child He knew even before he/she was formed in the womb.Are we going to say we are wiser than God?Is a child any less valuable because of the circumstances surrounding conception? Are we not still trying to circumvent God's will and over-ride it with our own?As mentioned by another poster, a child is not an illness or disease. Babies are a product of God's love for us. Sandrock, CNMSent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry

Posted

Right but here it seems the issue is that even the mere moral assurance we need as a moral necessity, something not 100 percent or absolute assurance, seems lacking.Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerryFrom: cnmnancy@...Date: Sat, 20 Feb 2010 17:11:13 +0000To: <nfpprofessionals >Subject: Re: Re:OT: Emergency Contraception There is no drug or device yet invented that will. with 100% assurance, only prevent fertilization, especially in cases of rape. There will always be the "God Factor".Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerryFrom: " E. " <k.e.millercomcast (DOT) net>Date: Sat, 20 Feb 2010 16:36:58 +0000 (UTC)To: <nfpprofessionals >Subject: Re: Re:OT: Emergency ContraceptionAnd I think that is a good argument against abortion - including abortifacients - in cases of rape. I don't think it follows, though - and the Church's teaching doesn't say that it follows - that preventing fertilization in cases of rape is morally wrong. I would also note - that similar arguments are made by "providentialists" who oppose even the use of NFP within marriage - that NFP (even for just reasons) is an attempt to override God's will. God allows babies to come into existence in all kinds of circumstances. That doesn't mean that it is prudent for couples to have intercourse during the fertile time when having another child would have serious negative consequences. And it also doesn't mean that it's necessary to allow fertilization to occur in cases of rape when the woman asks for - and when there is available - a way to prevent fertilization (with moral certainty that it will not allow fertilization and then cause an early abortion). Put differently - we ought to trust God's will. Part of doing that is trusting that he will take care of us if/when a baby is conceived - even if we didn't want that to happen - even if we used morally licit measures to try to keep that from happening. But another part of doing that is trusting that he will help us to discern what we ought to do to make it more or less likely that a baby will be conceived to begin with. Re: Re:OT: Emergency Contraception The bottom line is that GOD is the author of life. All human life resulting from any act of intercourse either by rape/force, or consent, is because God, in His infinite wisdom desired and allowed that child to come into being. A child He knew even before he/she was formed in the womb.Are we going to say we are wiser than God?Is a child any less valuable because of the circumstances surrounding conception? Are we not still trying to circumvent God's will and over-ride it with our own?As mentioned by another poster, a child is not an illness or disease. Babies are a product of God's love for us. Sandrock, CNMSent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry

Posted

Yes but in doing so He "obeys" the freely chosen acts of human parents, his privileged and responsible co-cooperators to whom he entrusts the gift of life. We wouldn't want to say that God wills conception in for example cases of rape, because the Church says the child deserves to be conceived as the direct result of an act of marital love between the spouses within marriage. So it may be especially out of regard for the dignity of the child that we consider it thus. It's the same with IVF children for example, who have no less dignity than other children but whose act of conception constitutes a kind of violation, in advance, of their rights and human dignity. It is precisely because the child is "no less valuable" that these moral considerations are all the more important.

This is the way the Catholic Church looks at it anyway. So for example if a rapist, or corrupt lab technician in an IVF lab, or any other wants to inseminate a woman against her will outside a freely chosen act of intercourse, she would have the right to an anti-conceptive intervention in advance as long as that intervention was morally certain not to be abortifacient.

Sincerely yours,

Dominic M. Pedulla MD, FACC, CNFPMC, ABVM, ACPh

Interventional Cardiologist, Endovascular Diplomate, Varicose Vein Specialist, Noncontraceptive Family Planning Consultant, Family Planning Researcher

Medical Director, The Oklahoma Vein and Endovascular Center (www.noveinok.com, varicoseveins1@...)

Executive Director, The Edith Stein Foundation (www.theedithsteinfoundation.com)

(office)

(cell)

pedullad@...

Returning then to the question of justice,

theme of his Message for Lent 2010, the Pope observed that "Christ's

Gospel responds positively to man's thirst for justice, but in an

unexpected and surprising way. Christ does not propose a social or

political revolution, but a revolution of love which he has already

achieved with His cross and His resurrection. It is upon these that the

Beatitudes rest, opening a new horizon of justice".

Re: Re:OT: Emergency Contraception

The bottom line is that GOD is the author of life. All human life resulting from any act of intercourse either by rape/force, or consent, is because God, in His infinite wisdom desired and allowed that child to come into being. A child He knew even before he/she was formed in the womb.

Are we going to say we are wiser than God?

Is a child any less valuable because of the circumstances surrounding conception?

Are we not still trying to circumvent God's will and over-ride it with our own?

As mentioned by another poster, a child is not an illness or disease. Babies are a product of God's love for us.

Sandrock, CNM

Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry

Posted

1) It logically follows from what you say that God does not will conception in any case outside of an act of marital love between parents. If God does not will it, then why/how is that gift of life given? Just because the child does not deserve to be conceived under these circumstances does not mean that God does not will that life to be.

2) There is no certainty that the emergency contraceptives are not abortifiacient (including no certain ability to confirm that the woman has not already conceived), therefore, there should be no question that they should not be used.

Re: Re:OT: Emergency Contraception

The bottom line is that GOD is the author of life. All human life resulting from any act of intercourse either by rape/force, or consent, is because God, in His infinite wisdom desired and allowed that child to come into being. A child He knew even before he/she was formed in the womb.Are we going to say we are wiser than God?Is a child any less valuable because of the circumstances surrounding conception? Are we not still trying to circumvent God's will and over-ride it with our own?As mentioned by another poster, a child is not an illness or disease. Babies are a product of God's love for us. Sandrock, CNMSent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry

We are all given a single life-time by the Lord, and the time is given so that we

might serve. For the work of God’s Church is never done, so long as time shall

last, and it is a privilege to offer the service of one’s life to her mission.

-Bishop E. , Diocese of Brownsville, TX

Posted

Pam,

Yes - God "wills" it - in the sense that he "allows" it. But it simply does not follow from that that we are not morally permitted to take steps to try to prevent it from happening (IF those steps don't involve doing some other kind of moral evil - like abortion).

Re: Re:OT: Emergency Contraception

The bottom line is that GOD is the author of life. All human life resulting from any act of intercourse either by rape/force, or consent, is because God, in His infinite wisdom desired and allowed that child to come into being. A child He knew even before he/she was formed in the womb.Are we going to say we are wiser than God?Is a child any less valuable because of the circumstances surrounding conception? Are we not still trying to circumvent God's will and over-ride it with our own?As mentioned by another poster, a child is not an illness or disease. Babies are a product of God's love for us. Sandrock, CNMSent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry

We are all given a single life-time by the Lord, and the time is given so that we

might serve. For the work of God’s Church is never done, so long as time shall

last, and it is a privilege to offer the service of one’s life to her mission.

-Bishop E. , Diocese of Brownsville, TX

Posted

No - it doesn't automatically follow from that that we are "obligated" to help the woman avoid fertilization. However, there are other reasons - which have also been given here - to think that we are at least permitted to do so - again, IF there are means by which this can be done that don't also pose a risk of causing an abortion. And the claim that you seem to have been making - and to which I'm responding - is the claim that we're not even permitted to do so. And furthermore, the specific argument to which I was just before responding was the argument that simply because God "wills" it, therefore we may not prevent it. I'm saying that this argument simply does not work - it is not a (theo-)logically sound argument. Again, to see, beyond this, why in this case we are in fact permitted to prevent it, you have to go back and note the points that I (and others) have made earlier in the discussion - about the real meaning of "contraception" and so on.

I would now also add this, though, since you've now brought up "obligation." Suppose (just for the sake of argument) that all of the following conditions are satisfied: (1) A woman is in principle permitted to try to prevent fertilizationa after rape (as I've been arguing - obviously I think this is true - indeed I am morally certain that it is true). (2) There are means by which this can be done that we are morally certain aren't abortifacient (I think that this is "iffy" - but I think that the medical/scientific professionals need to be the ones to say whether it's true). (3) These means are of a sort that can only be provided by health-care or medical professionals (this seems likely, since we're talking about drugs and so on). I think that a case could then be made for the following conclusions: (1) The providing of these means is part of legitimate health care or medicine for a woman who has been raped and who wants them. (2) Health care or medical professionals are obliged to provide them (just as they are, in general, obliged to provide that which is part of legitimate health care or medicine).

Re: Re:OT: Emergency Contraception

The bottom line is that GOD is the author of life. All human life resulting from any act of intercourse either by rape/force, or consent, is because God, in His infinite wisdom desired and allowed that child to come into being. A child He knew even before he/she was formed in the womb.Are we going to say we are wiser than God?Is a child any less valuable because of the circumstances surrounding conception? Are we not still trying to circumvent God's will and over-ride it with our own?As mentioned by another poster, a child is not an illness or disease. Babies are a product of God's love for us. Sandrock, CNMSent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry

We are all given a single life-time by the Lord, and the time is given so that we

might serve. For the work of God’s Church is never done, so long as time shall

last, and it is a privilege to offer the service of one’s life to her mission.

-Bishop E. , Diocese of Brownsville, TX

We are all given a single life-time by the Lord, and the time is given so that we

might serve. For the work of God’s Church is never done, so long as time shall

last, and it is a privilege to offer the service of one’s life to her mission.

-Bishop E. , Diocese of Brownsville, TX

Posted

I am alarmed and somewhat appalled that the word " obey " is being used FOR God.

It seems blasphemous. I don't think anyone argues against the fact that children

are " best " and " ideally " conceived within a loving marriage, as a result of

natural congugal acts.

Out of every horrible situation, perceived or actual/real, God WILL bring some

good. That is an absolute. Since we know and describe children as GIFTS from

God, why is it so hard to acknowledge that children conceived as a result of

rape are any less- and how dare we say that God did not " will " it. He has a plan

and a purpose for that child as well as all others. God certainly did not " will "

the violent act, but He absolutely did plan and " will " for that child conceived

as a result of the act.

If Emergency Contraception is wrong for married persons, it is equally wrong for

all other persons.

All of this other stuff is rationalization. Maybe thought of as theological or

lofty thinking, analyzing, etc.

National Right to Life has a wonderful pamphlet called " Conceived in Rape, but a

Child of God " . I obtained that pamphlet long ago to give to my adopted daughter,

who was conceived in rape.

As a nurse-midwife, I have been blessed and privileged to see God's work in

action for and with several women who gave birth to a child that was conceived

in rape. The pregnancy and birth is often a healing process, especially when

there are pro-life counselors, helpful priests, health care workers and other

people to help support the woman. Something good comes from the violence. She

had no control over the rape, but she does have the power to protect HER child,

and she is entitled to the love that child will bring her if she chooses to keep

the child.

Christian/Catholic Counseling is so important. I am sad that even folks on this

list seem to work so hard to justify something for this situation that they

wouldn't justify otherwise...and I am sad that I can't explain it better.

My 15y/o daughter is going to visit her biological mother this summer. They are

both SO excited. Her mother never regretted giving birth to her.

Are we looking at children as an intrinsic good? Or are we taking in some of our

culture that views pregnancy and children as burdens and bothers, or perhaps

even curses?

Sandrock

Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry

Posted

Forgive me. I put it ("obeyed") in quotes so it would be obvious that God doesn't literally obey man, but implies the kenosis (radical self-emptying humility) evident in the scriptures -- God makes Himself the servant of man as in Phil. chapter 2. The last thing I would want to do is cause distress for anyone on a theological or religious issue. For give me if I wasn't clear.

Sincerely yours,

Dominic M. Pedulla MD, FACC, CNFPMC, ABVM, ACPh

Interventional Cardiologist, Endovascular Diplomate, Varicose Vein Specialist, Noncontraceptive Family Planning Consultant, Family Planning Researcher

Medical Director, The Oklahoma Vein and Endovascular Center (www.noveinok.com, varicoseveins1@...)

Executive Director, The Edith Stein Foundation (www.theedithsteinfoundation.com)

(office)

(cell)

pedullad@...

Returning then to the question of justice,

theme of his Message for Lent 2010, the Pope observed that "Christ's

Gospel responds positively to man's thirst for justice, but in an

unexpected and surprising way. Christ does not propose a social or

political revolution, but a revolution of love which he has already

achieved with His cross and His resurrection. It is upon these that the

Beatitudes rest, opening a new horizon of justice".

Re: Re:OT: Emergency Contraception

I am alarmed and somewhat appalled that the word "obey" is being used FOR God. It seems blasphemous. I don't think anyone argues against the fact that children are "best" and " ideally" conceived within a loving marriage, as a result of natural congugal acts.

Out of every horrible situation, perceived or actual/real, God WILL bring some good. That is an absolute. Since we know and describe children as GIFTS from God, why is it so hard to acknowledge that children conceived as a result of rape are any less- and how dare we say that God did not "will" it. He has a plan and a purpose for that child as well as all others. God certainly did not "will" the violent act, but He absolutely did plan and "will" for that child conceived as a result of the act.

If Emergency Contraception is wrong for married persons, it is equally wrong for all other persons.

All of this other stuff is rationalization. Maybe thought of as theological or lofty thinking, analyzing, etc.

National Right to Life has a wonderful pamphlet called "Conceived in Rape, but a Child of God". I obtained that pamphlet long ago to give to my adopted daughter, who was conceived in rape.

As a nurse-midwife, I have been blessed and privileged to see God's work in action for and with several women who gave birth to a child that was conceived in rape. The pregnancy and birth is often a healing process, especially when there are pro-life counselors, helpful priests, health care workers and other people to help support the woman. Something good comes from the violence. She had no control over the rape, but she does have the power to protect HER child, and she is entitled to the love that child will bring her if she chooses to keep the child.

Christian/Catholic Counseling is so important. I am sad that even folks on this list seem to work so hard to justify something for this situation that they wouldn't justify otherwise...and I am sad that I can't explain it better.

My 15y/o daughter is going to visit her biological mother this summer. They are both SO excited. Her mother never regretted giving birth to her.

Are we looking at children as an intrinsic good? Or are we taking in some of our culture that views pregnancy and children as burdens and bothers, or perhaps even curses?

Sandrock

Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry

Posted

To be honest, could it be we're "losing too much sleep" over this issue. For all the consternation it comes up only once in awhile, and we can always object to providing any treatment that bothers our consciences. Now if we are in, say, a Catholic hospital that has a Eugene Diamond protocol that can rule out impending ovulation that can give extra security. The part about freely chosen intercourse is a moral issue more determining the personal sin or lack thereof, so to a certain extent that is between the person and God, and not our major concern. If a woman says she was violated, I think we should assume she was, and help her as long as we don't help her end new life. If she deceives us, the sin isn't ours.

Should we maybe take a break on this issue??

Sincerely yours,

Dominic M. Pedulla MD, FACC, CNFPMC, ABVM, ACPh

Interventional Cardiologist, Endovascular Diplomate, Varicose Vein Specialist, Noncontraceptive Family Planning Consultant, Family Planning Researcher

Medical Director, The Oklahoma Vein and Endovascular Center (www.noveinok.com, varicoseveins1@...)

Executive Director, The Edith Stein Foundation (www.theedithsteinfoundation.com)

(office)

(cell)

pedullad@...

Returning then to the question of justice,

theme of his Message for Lent 2010, the Pope observed that "Christ's

Gospel responds positively to man's thirst for justice, but in an

unexpected and surprising way. Christ does not propose a social or

political revolution, but a revolution of love which he has already

achieved with His cross and His resurrection. It is upon these that the

Beatitudes rest, opening a new horizon of justice".

Re: Re:OT: Emergency Contraception

Pam,

I doubt that you will find official Vatican documents that teach that a woman can use contraceptive behaviors and devices and drugs to protect herself from the sperm deposited by a rapist. Here you enter into the area of arguments that are considered "probable" in terms of the theological theory and practice of "probabilism." Specifically dealing with the matter of rape, Fr. J. Bayer, S.T.D. wrote a book titled "Rape within Marriage: A Moral Analysis Delayed" in which he argued that even in the case where the wife's husband was the rapist, she could legitimately use a contraceptive device to prevent impregnation. The book was published in 1985 with the Nihil Obstat of Rev. Lorenzo Albacete, S.T.D. and the Imprimatur of Rev. Msgr. F. Donoghue of the Archdiocese of Washington. It is currently available by going to infowipfandstock and searching for the main title. If it is an accepted probable opinion that a married woman can use a contraceptive device in the case of unavoidable rape by her husband, you can be assured that this is built upon the prior acceptance of the opinion that any woman can thus protect herself against the sperm of a rapist other than her husband. I have about eight pages on this in the book under my signature below.

That, however, does not say that every means of "birth control" is legitimate in this case. Fr. Bayer would be among the first to agree that it would be wrong to seek to avoid continued pregnancy by using an anti-implantation agent or any other abortion-causing agent. I agree with you about the great practical difficulty of administering a drug with an abortifacient potential at such a time that it would not have any possibility of causing an early abortion. I agree with you that such a theoretical possibility remains so theoretical as to be impossible, or at least almost impossible, to do with moral certainty of not causing an early abortion.

F Kippley

NFP International

www.NFPandmore.org

"Sex and the Marriage Covenant: A Basis for Morality" (Ignatius)

RE: Re:OT: Emergency Contraception

You might be interested in one of my articles on this topic; go to:

http://www.ncbcenter.org/NetCommunity/Page.aspx?pid=249

and select

November 2007 - Getting It Right "The Morning-After"

Pax,

Fr. Tad

One more question:

If contraception, according to the teaching of the Church, is objectively immoral, how is it justified even in this case?

Again, why are we working so hard to justify the administration of a contraceptive, regardless of the origin of the possible conception?

Pam in El Paso

We are all given a single life-time by the Lord, and the time is given so that we

might serve. For the work of God’s Church is never done, so long as time shall

last, and it is a privilege to offer the service of one’s life to her mission.

-Bishop E. , Diocese of Brownsville, TX

We are all given a single life-time by the Lord, and the time is given so that we

might serve. For the work of God’s Church is never done, so long as time shall

last, and it is a privilege to offer the service of one’s life to her mission.

-Bishop E. , Diocese of Brownsville, TX

Posted

Rather than contribute to the fray I think if is helpful define the broader principles.  One, the natural process of transmitting human life is good, expressive of God's law in nature. Two, all the essential components of human nature and life including human reproduction are good.  Three, the wilful commission of rape, the act itself, is evil; but the reproductive organs of a man and woman are integrally good as of all creation.  Admittedly, " all analogies limp " , but the analogy of a killer and his gun is a good example of the principle.  One who unjustly kills another commits an evil act.  A policeman who justly kills another with a gun in the performance of his duty does not commit and evil act. In either case the gun is neither good or evil in a moral sense. Likewise, it does not reasonably follow that the sperm of a rapist is an unjust " thing " .  The rape is unjust, but the 'natural consequences' of insemination are not unjust.  The circumstances of intercourse are matters separate from the natural process of conception and human birth.  God's forebearance defines our gift of freedom without which we would not be human which partially, at least, explains God's tolerance of good and evil in the world.  Similarly, our divinely infused powers of intelligence, for example, are intrinsically good whether our thoughts and desires are good or evil.  Human sperm serves God's plan for procreation whether the act preceding insemination is good, evil or thoughtless--which some would define as an " unwanted " pregrancy to justify an abortion. All these are the consequences of free will for good or evil.  I recommend that these principles be weighed carefully before intervention, after the fact, in the process of human procreation.

Sincerely,

Father Tom

 

 

OK folks, we are getting a little testy here.Time to take a few deep breaths and let it rest for a day or so. Go back and re-read the whole thread.We all care passionately. has the experience of being on the front lines as a health care provider dealing with women, and only women. has the experience of being on a college campus and dealing with both realities and the theoretical underpinnings.

Everyone here has had varying experience that colors the way we look at the topics being discussed.Let's take a 24 hour time out here.aliciaco-moderator Harry Truman once quipped, " I never give them hell. I just tell the truth and they think its hell. "

ahuntley@...

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...