Guest guest Posted September 8, 2010 Report Posted September 8, 2010 Dear Karel, A personal reflection: As I was reading this I started to think of my own mother. This would pretty well describe her own situation and I am child number four of ten. What this couple may need is a nanny to help the mother so she isn't so exhausted. My mother had a "hired girl" come in for a few weeks, which was a common thing to do in their community. I remember Kay Ek telling us the story of how she and her husband abstained while she breastfed because that was all they knew at that time. And they have a long and strong marriage! It might be helpful for your couple to speak with other married couples who could mentor them. God doesn't give us more than we can handle, right? Blessings, Judith Leonard I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Dear NFP professionals,I desperately need your competent advice about this extremely difficult situation of a couple I know very well.First of all: I absolutely agree with the Catholic Church teaching about contraception as intrinsically evil act. I am a seminarian with PhD. in psychology (dissertation on psychology of NFP), certified instructor of the STM of NFP (German method), deeply interested in moral theology and theology of the body.Situation, I am absolutely unable to resolve is this:A young Catholic married couple, deeply commited to Church`s teaching on contraception. First pregnancy unplanned, very early after wedding, with no NFP experience. Second pregnancy unplanned and very difficult to accept, because the wife conceived on 50th day (sic!) after delivery of the first child during FULL (EXCLUSIVE) BREASTFEEDING. Third pregnacy unplanned, during the 13th cycle of STM NFP observation. It was a perfect-use pregnancy, as I personally checked. The woman had very soon return of fertility after childbirth despite of full, exclusive, intensive breastfeeding. So, she has 3 children during 4 years now, she is exhausted, with absolutely no confidence in NFP. They did everything they were able to do. Their relationship is now in crisis, because of fear of further pregnancy. Total sexual abstinence is for them unacceptable. They dont want to try NFP once more. Both of them seems to doubt the teaching on immorality of contraception now. They see it as "contra-intuitive". However, the wife told me she is dreading of God`s punishment if they eventually use a barrier contraception. They are totally perplexed.I never met such a situation. I see no moral solution for it. I am inclined to think that the only „solution" is to accept their use of barrier contraceptives with hope for God`s mercy. I it possible they will be able to slowly accept the NFP once more later, but surely not now.What do you think of it?Thank youKarel SkocovskyP.S.: I am little bit angry because we NFP-fans sometimes underestimate difficulties married couples have to face to. I NEVER read anythink about what to do as a priest in such a difficult situation. I am very well aware of almost everything doctrinally orthodox written in English... What about „law of graduality"? I asked E. May on it and he was unable to explain me what it really means in practice... In last month, I met about 2-3 other perplexed couples using contraception with no real hope for change... We frequently present NFP as powerful marriage building tool. But we very often do not speak about long periods of abstinence during non-typical return of fertility after childbirth... Quote
Guest guest Posted September 8, 2010 Report Posted September 8, 2010 Dear Fr. Skocovsky: Thank you for sharing this difficult case -- but one that is not all that unusual. We do know that a small but sizable percentage of women/couples who use NFP ( i.e., around 25%) find it a challenge and are not satisfied with its use. We also know that many of our " modern " methods of NFP can result in extensive amounts of abstinence. I would think that the fear of another pregnancy, the lack of trust of NFP, the exhaustion of raising young children ---and fear of God's punishment -- would lessen the moral wrong (or i.e., sin) and their relationship with God. The fear of God's punishment bothers me -- since, we seek to have his love, care, and understanding. I wonder if she (they) would be willing to use a simple method of NFP along with barriers - until she (they) is/are confident in again using NFP. What I suggest is the use of the ClearBlue Easy Fertility monitor (which is available in Europe) -- along with a simple algorithm -- similar to the European Double check method (they are welcome to chart online at our NFP site http://nfp.marquette.edu . I would also let them know that barriers are no more effective than the use of NFP -- in fact the European Double check is more effective. However, the German's did find that the use of barriers did not lessen the efficacy of the method. The fertility monitor would provide them with a very objective test of fertility -- and would not be as burdensome as taking daily temps. The hormonal markers provided by the monitor are also more accurate than the standard markers of human fertility used with NFP. I would be gentle with this couple and help them to gradually re-gain acceptance of NFP. Thanks you for your pastoral work. J. Fehring Professor Marquette University PS - maybe Professor could enlighten us on the theory of graduality? I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Dear NFP professionals, I desperately need your competent advice about this extremely difficult situation of a couple I know very well. First of all: I absolutely agree with the Catholic Church teaching about contraception as intrinsically evil act. I am a seminarian with PhD. in psychology (dissertation on psychology of NFP), certified instructor of the STM of NFP (German method), deeply interested in moral theology and theology of the body. Situation, I am absolutely unable to resolve is this: A young Catholic married couple, deeply commited to Church`s teaching on contraception. First pregnancy unplanned, very early after wedding, with no NFP experience. Second pregnancy unplanned and very difficult to accept, because the wife conceived on 50th day (sic!) after delivery of the first child during FULL (EXCLUSIVE) BREASTFEEDING. Third pregnacy unplanned, during the 13th cycle of STM NFP observation. It was a perfect-use pregnancy, as I personally checked. The woman had very soon return of fertility after childbirth despite of full, exclusive, intensive breastfeeding. So, she has 3 children during 4 years now, she is exhausted, with absolutely no confidence in NFP. They did everything they were able to do. Their relationship is now in crisis, because of fear of further pregnancy. Total sexual abstinence is for them unacceptable. They dont want to try NFP once more. Both of them seems to doubt the teaching on immorality of contraception now. They see it as " contra-intuitive " . However, the wife told me she is dreading of God`s punishment if they eventually use a barrier contraception. They are totally perplexed. I never met such a situation. I see no moral solution for it. I am inclined to think that the only " solution " is to accept their use of barrier contraceptives with hope for God`s mercy. I it possible they will be able to slowly accept the NFP once more later, but surely not now. What do you think of it? Thank you Karel Skocovsky P.S.: I am little bit angry because we NFP-fans sometimes underestimate difficulties married couples have to face to. I NEVER read anythink about what to do as a priest in such a difficult situation. I am very well aware of almost everything doctrinally orthodox written in English... What about " law of graduality " ? I asked E. May on it and he was unable to explain me what it really means in practice... In last month, I met about 2-3 other perplexed couples using contraception with no real hope for change... We frequently present NFP as powerful marriage building tool. But we very often do not speak about long periods of abstinence during non-typical return of fertility after childbirth... ------------------------------------ Quote
Guest guest Posted September 8, 2010 Report Posted September 8, 2010 The couple could use the Creighton Model. We do post peak progesterone levels to scientifically reveal to the couple that ovulation has already occurred so that they can build confidence in the system and use their non-fertile days. We have several couples come to the Pope VI Institute with this same situation and we have helped them to maintain their marriage. a Garnett MD Associate Physician at PPVI Institute To: nfpprofessionals Sent: Wed, September 8, 2010 4:06:57 PMSubject: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Dear NFP professionals,I desperately need your competent advice about this extremely difficult situation of a couple I know very well.First of all: I absolutely agree with the Catholic Church teaching about contraception as intrinsically evil act. I am a seminarian with PhD. in psychology (dissertation on psychology of NFP), certified instructor of the STM of NFP (German method), deeply interested in moral theology and theology of the body.Situation, I am absolutely unable to resolve is this:A young Catholic married couple, deeply commited to Church`s teaching on contraception. First pregnancy unplanned, very early after wedding, with no NFP experience. Second pregnancy unplanned and very difficult to accept, because the wife conceived on 50th day (sic!) after delivery of the first child during FULL (EXCLUSIVE) BREASTFEEDING. Third pregnacy unplanned, during the 13th cycle of STM NFP observation. It was a perfect-use pregnancy, as I personally checked. The woman had very soon return of fertility after childbirth despite of full, exclusive, intensive breastfeeding. So, she has 3 children during 4 years now, she is exhausted, with absolutely no confidence in NFP. They did everything they were able to do. Their relationship is now in crisis, because of fear of further pregnancy. Total sexual abstinence is for them unacceptable. They dont want to try NFP once more. Both of them seems to doubt the teaching on immorality of contraception now. They see it as "contra-intuitive". However, the wife told me she is dreading of God`s punishment if they eventually use a barrier contraception. They are totally perplexed.I never met such a situation. I see no moral solution for it. I am inclined to think that the only „solution" is to accept their use of barrier contraceptives with hope for God`s mercy. I it possible they will be able to slowly accept the NFP once more later, but surely not now.What do you think of it?Thank youKarel SkocovskyP.S.: I am little bit angry because we NFP-fans sometimes underestimate difficulties married couples have to face to. I NEVER read anythink about what to do as a priest in such a difficult situation. I am very well aware of almost everything doctrinally orthodox written in English... What about „law of graduality"? I asked E. May on it and he was unable to explain me what it really means in practice... In last month, I met about 2-3 other perplexed couples using contraception with no real hope for change... We frequently present NFP as powerful marriage building tool. But we very often do not speak about long periods of abstinence during non-typical return of fertility after childbirth... Quote
Guest guest Posted September 8, 2010 Report Posted September 8, 2010 It is very hard to watch suffering, but misplaced compassion to relieve it by resorting to unethical or immoral means. I think it would be shortchanging the couple to give them permission to contracept. They are entitled to good direction, even in these tough circumstances, and they are also entitled to make their own decision. As difficult as this time is, it will get easier as the children mature. My suggestion is to suggest to them learning a new method of NFP. There are many choices, and some fit some couples better than others, and I have seen couples be quite content with their method, until breastfeeding for instance, when they found it inadequate for them. This is NOT a criticism of any one method....it is a recognition in fact that we are not " selling " a specific technique, but a way of life, and whichever technique helps them navigate that, is the one I want them to use. I am just about to have that very conversation with a couple I am teaching, who is struggling with confidence coming back to NFP after being surprised by a pregnancy----in their case, in addition to offering my support and instruction, I will also offer them a referral to a different teacher of the method, or a different teacher of a different method, if that is what will help them. Even if there is only one method available locally, there are many teachers who will teach long distance---I actually personally do more long distance teaching than local teaching. That opens up the realm of possibilities for the couple, in terms of method choice. Choice is good---but among moral options. Sheila St. Executive Director California Association of Natural Family Planning www.canfp.org 1-877-33-CANFP I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Dear NFP professionals, I desperately need your competent advice about this extremely difficult situation of a couple I know very well. First of all: I absolutely agree with the Catholic Church teaching about contraception as intrinsically evil act. I am a seminarian with PhD. in psychology (dissertation on psychology of NFP), certified instructor of the STM of NFP (German method), deeply interested in moral theology and theology of the body. Situation, I am absolutely unable to resolve is this: A young Catholic married couple, deeply commited to Church`s teaching on contraception. First pregnancy unplanned, very early after wedding, with no NFP experience. Second pregnancy unplanned and very difficult to accept, because the wife conceived on 50th day (sic!) after delivery of the first child during FULL (EXCLUSIVE) BREASTFEEDING. Third pregnacy unplanned, during the 13th cycle of STM NFP observation. It was a perfect-use pregnancy, as I personally checked. The woman had very soon return of fertility after childbirth despite of full, exclusive, intensive breastfeeding. So, she has 3 children during 4 years now, she is exhausted, with absolutely no confidence in NFP. They did everything they were able to do. Their relationship is now in crisis, because of fear of further pregnancy. Total sexual abstinence is for them unacceptable. They dont want to try NFP once more. Both of them seems to doubt the teaching on immorality of contraception now. They see it as " contra-intuitive " . However, the wife told me she is dreading of God`s punishment if they eventually use a barrier contraception. They are totally perplexed. I never met such a situation. I see no moral solution for it. I am inclined to think that the only " solution " is to accept their use of barrier contraceptives with hope for God`s mercy. I it possible they will be able to slowly accept the NFP once more later, but surely not now. What do you think of it? Thank you Karel Skocovsky P.S.: I am little bit angry because we NFP-fans sometimes underestimate difficulties married couples have to face to. I NEVER read anythink about what to do as a priest in such a difficult situation. I am very well aware of almost everything doctrinally orthodox written in English... What about " law of graduality " ? I asked E. May on it and he was unable to explain me what it really means in practice... In last month, I met about 2-3 other perplexed couples using contraception with no real hope for change... We frequently present NFP as powerful marriage building tool. But we very often do not speak about long periods of abstinence during non-typical return of fertility after childbirth... ------------------------------------ Quote
Guest guest Posted September 8, 2010 Report Posted September 8, 2010 Karel,Forgive me for being blunt, but some thoughts have come quickly to mind, and I pray they may be helpful.My first impression is to offer a reminder. We only track fertility, GOD creates Life. HE decides when conception occurs, and clearly this couple has been allowed to be put to the test - and perhaps you are being tested as well.Orthodoxy (right thinking) is not a solution to the mysteries of God, only a lens to help our poor eyesight.From my view, marital abstinence is called for here - and not because of risk of pregnancy, but because Mama is TIRED. It may prove to be a heroic effort, it may prove to be an "unfair" trial, but the Cross is not without it's fruit, it is just harder to see through the fog of suffering. I'm not an expert at theology, or at psychology, but the confusion this couple is suffering is born in part by their own expectations. This culture leads us to think of marital relations as a right - as THE fulcrum of the sacrament. Sometimes the reality that comes to us in marriage requires a sacrifice we did not imagine.God will lead them, and you, out of this situation, but in His time, and with His wisdom. Practicing NFP does not guarantee conception, or block it, but sometimes we get the sense we are at a level of control we do not really have in these matters.God Bless, onNFPIntl. "Those who Trust in Him shall understand Truth. And the Faithful shall abide with Him in Love, because Grace and Mercy are with His Holy Ones, and His Care is with His Elect."Wisdom 3:9 Dear NFP professionals, I desperately need your competent advice about this extremely difficult situation of a couple I know very well. First of all: I absolutely agree with the Catholic Church teaching about contraception as intrinsically evil act. I am a seminarian with PhD. in psychology (dissertation on psychology of NFP), certified instructor of the STM of NFP (German method), deeply interested in moral theology and theology of the body. Situation, I am absolutely unable to resolve is this: A young Catholic married couple, deeply committed to Church`s teaching on contraception. First pregnancy unplanned, very early after wedding, with no NFP experience. Second pregnancy unplanned and very difficult to accept, because the wife conceived on 50th day (sic!) after delivery of the first child during FULL (EXCLUSIVE) BREASTFEEDING. Third pregnancy unplanned, during the 13th cycle of STM NFP observation. It was a perfect-use pregnancy, as I personally checked. The woman had very soon return of fertility after childbirth despite of full, exclusive, intensive breastfeeding. So, she has 3 children during 4 years now, she is exhausted, with absolutely no confidence in NFP. They did everything they were able to do. Their relationship is now in crisis, because of fear of further pregnancy. Total sexual abstinence is for them unacceptable. They dont want to try NFP once more. Both of them seems to doubt the teaching on immorality of contraception now. They see it as "contra-intuitive". However, the wife told me she is dreading of God`s punishment if they eventually use a barrier contraception. They are totally perplexed. I never met such a situation. I see no moral solution for it. I am inclined to think that the only „solution" is to accept their use of barrier contraceptives with hope for God`s mercy. I it possible they will be able to slowly accept the NFP once more later, but surely not now. What do you think of it? Thank you Karel Skocovsky P.S.: I am little bit angry because we NFP-fans sometimes underestimate difficulties married couples have to face to. I NEVER read anythink about what to do as a priest in such a difficult situation. I am very well aware of almost everything doctrinally orthodox written in English... What about „law of graduality"? I asked E. May on it and he was unable to explain me what it really means in practice... In last month, I met about 2-3 other perplexed couples using contraception with no real hope for change... We frequently present NFP as powerful marriage building tool. But we very often do not speak about long periods of abstinence during non-typical return of fertility after childbirth... Quote
Guest guest Posted September 8, 2010 Report Posted September 8, 2010 I was thinking of this, as had a couple I worked with do this, as she had very very serious medical reasons not to conceive, so each month they waited until the levels done on the blood they sent in to PPVI confirmed they were past ovulation, and limited themselves to those confirmed post peak days. It relieved her intense anxiety, and they did this long term. However, is that possible since they are in Germany, and I thought she was not in cycles... Sheila St. Executive Director California Association of Natural Family Planning www.canfp.org 1-877-33-CANFP From: nfpprofessionals [mailto:nfpprofessionals ] On Behalf Of a Garnett Sent: Wednesday, September 08, 2010 2:41 PM To: nfpprofessionals Subject: Re: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation The couple could use the Creighton Model. We do post peak progesterone levels to scientifically reveal to the couple that ovulation has already occurred so that they can build confidence in the system and use their non-fertile days. We have several couples come to the Pope VI Institute with this same situation and we have helped them to maintain their marriage. a Garnett MD Associate Physician at PPVI Institute From: Karel To: nfpprofessionals Sent: Wed, September 8, 2010 4:06:57 PM Subject: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Dear NFP professionals, I desperately need your competent advice about this extremely difficult situation of a couple I know very well. First of all: I absolutely agree with the Catholic Church teaching about contraception as intrinsically evil act. I am a seminarian with PhD. in psychology (dissertation on psychology of NFP), certified instructor of the STM of NFP (German method), deeply interested in moral theology and theology of the body. Situation, I am absolutely unable to resolve is this: A young Catholic married couple, deeply commited to Church`s teaching on contraception. First pregnancy unplanned, very early after wedding, with no NFP experience. Second pregnancy unplanned and very difficult to accept, because the wife conceived on 50th day (sic!) after delivery of the first child during FULL (EXCLUSIVE) BREASTFEEDING. Third pregnacy unplanned, during the 13th cycle of STM NFP observation. It was a perfect-use pregnancy, as I personally checked. The woman had very soon return of fertility after childbirth despite of full, exclusive, intensive breastfeeding. So, she has 3 children during 4 years now, she is exhausted, with absolutely no confidence in NFP. They did everything they were able to do. Their relationship is now in crisis, because of fear of further pregnancy. Total sexual abstinence is for them unacceptable. They dont want to try NFP once more. Both of them seems to doubt the teaching on immorality of contraception now. They see it as " contra-intuitive " . However, the wife told me she is dreading of God`s punishment if they eventually use a barrier contraception. They are totally perplexed. I never met such a situation. I see no moral solution for it. I am inclined to think that the only „solution " is to accept their use of barrier contraceptives with hope for God`s mercy. I it possible they will be able to slowly accept the NFP once more later, but surely not now. What do you think of it? Thank you Karel Skocovsky P.S.: I am little bit angry because we NFP-fans sometimes underestimate difficulties married couples have to face to. I NEVER read anythink about what to do as a priest in such a difficult situation. I am very well aware of almost everything doctrinally orthodox written in English... What about „law of graduality " ? I asked E. May on it and he was unable to explain me what it really means in practice... In last month, I met about 2-3 other perplexed couples using contraception with no real hope for change... We frequently present NFP as powerful marriage building tool. But we very often do not speak about long periods of abstinence during non-typical return of fertility after childbirth... Quote
Guest guest Posted September 8, 2010 Report Posted September 8, 2010 If I may ask, is she continuing to breastfeed through her pregnancies and tandem nursing her babies, and still experiencing early return of fertility?  I myself experienced the return of fertility with my first two babies at 6 and 5 weeks postpartum, respectively.  With the birth of my third, I had read Breastfeeding and Natural Child Spacing and learned that, at least with my second, it was probably due to early sleeping through the night.  The third baby was a voracious eater who did not sleep through the night, and fertility returned at 5 mo pp.  Subsequently, I have never weaned a child before the next was born and have experienced delayed fertility of well past a year each (three subsequent babies so far).  I certainly empathize with this couple's plight.  We needed to commit to abstain through the first half of my cycles when we truly needed to space babies.  With short luteal phases due to breastfeeding, that often would only leave a few open days.  It is a challenge, but the alternatives are not good either.  Barrier contraceptives can have almost a 40% failure rate!  What really helped us was switching to Creighton and having the in-depth focus on the mucus sign.  We did ours long distance by phone. From one tired mama to another, I will remember this family in my prayers as they struggle.  Thank you for being a faithful witness to this family!--Bekah<><http://our-family.family-way.net/ appletreewebdesigns.comLearn about Home Birth: morebabiespreferhomebirth.com Dear NFP professionals, I desperately need your competent advice about this extremely difficult situation of a couple I know very well. First of all: I absolutely agree with the Catholic Church teaching about contraception as intrinsically evil act. I am a seminarian with PhD. in psychology (dissertation on psychology of NFP), certified instructor of the STM of NFP (German method), deeply interested in moral theology and theology of the body. Situation, I am absolutely unable to resolve is this: A young Catholic married couple, deeply commited to Church`s teaching on contraception. First pregnancy unplanned, very early after wedding, with no NFP experience. Second pregnancy unplanned and very difficult to accept, because the wife conceived on 50th day (sic!) after delivery of the first child during FULL (EXCLUSIVE) BREASTFEEDING. Third pregnacy unplanned, during the 13th cycle of STM NFP observation. It was a perfect-use pregnancy, as I personally checked. The woman had very soon return of fertility after childbirth despite of full, exclusive, intensive breastfeeding. So, she has 3 children during 4 years now, she is exhausted, with absolutely no confidence in NFP. They did everything they were able to do. Their relationship is now in crisis, because of fear of further pregnancy. Total sexual abstinence is for them unacceptable. They dont want to try NFP once more. Both of them seems to doubt the teaching on immorality of contraception now. They see it as " contra-intuitive " . However, the wife told me she is dreading of God`s punishment if they eventually use a barrier contraception. They are totally perplexed. I never met such a situation. I see no moral solution for it. I am inclined to think that the only „solution " is to accept their use of barrier contraceptives with hope for God`s mercy. I it possible they will be able to slowly accept the NFP once more later, but surely not now. What do you think of it? Thank you Karel Skocovsky P.S.: I am little bit angry because we NFP-fans sometimes underestimate difficulties married couples have to face to. I NEVER read anythink about what to do as a priest in such a difficult situation. I am very well aware of almost everything doctrinally orthodox written in English... What about „law of graduality " ? I asked E. May on it and he was unable to explain me what it really means in practice... In last month, I met about 2-3 other perplexed couples using contraception with no real hope for change... We frequently present NFP as powerful marriage building tool. But we very often do not speak about long periods of abstinence during non-typical return of fertility after childbirth... ------------------------------------ Quote
Guest guest Posted September 9, 2010 Report Posted September 9, 2010 I feel like saying here "Give me a break!". If they are Catholics, the moral part is a question of faith. With faith, we can certainly discuss a multiplicity of pastoral options here. Without it, none will likely be successful or acceptable to them. Once faith is accepted, the NFP portions of the dilemma can -- even if with very great difficulty -- be resolved, though it is naive to think it will be very simple. But Karel you have it backward. You must first start with faith (and at best your statements here in this regard are contradictory), then work the other way, not the other way around. None of this is to minimize to any degree the difficulties, but give me a break. First start with accepting the 10 commandments, then all else becomes do-able, however difficult. Sincerely yours, Dominic M. Pedulla MD, FACC, CNFPMC, ABVM, ACPh Interventional Cardiologist, Endovascular Diplomate, Varicose Vein Specialist, Noncontraceptive Family Planning Consultant, Family Planning Researcher Medical Director, The Oklahoma Vein and Endovascular Center (www.noveinok.com, veininfo@...) Executive Director, The Edith Stein Foundation (www.theedithsteinfoundation.com) (office) (cell) (FAX) pedullad@... "And he departed from our sight that we might return to our heart, and there find Him. For He departed, and behold, He is here." - St. Augustine Re: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation If I may ask, is she continuing to breastfeed through contraceptive mentality PRO-LIFE ACHILLES HEEL: Dominic Pedulla, MD, of the Edith Stein Foundation comments: In nature's plan, the woman is "chosen" from all others to receive love from a man, and then the child conceived is the living incarnation, symbol, and visible reminder (not unlike the living Eucharistic "anamnesis" of Luke 22:19) that she was a uniquely treasured and esteemed gift. Just as we can only love because Jesus has first loved us (cf. 1 Jn. 4:19), similarly the woman can only properly love the child conceived if that child is the living symbol of a genuine love she first received from the child's father. Contraceptive "love" is a betrayal; a degradation, a form of sexual depersonalization of the woman, not consciously admitted however. The shame from this is so great that (quite literally according to the medical and psychological literature), she in many cases would take her own life rather than see that trauma exposed. Similarly, she will abort her child because, in the absence of any real path to repersonalization for herself, she will have recourse to the depersonalizing of her own child. That way, her own shame can be "eradicated"; i.e., in the unconscious mind of the abortion-inclined woman, the shame dies with the child. This tells us not only why abortion occurs, but also how little this all has to do with the purely abstract question of a child's right to life, at least at the moment a woman discovers she has a pregnancy she does not want. Moreover, it tells us why some "prolifers" assiduously avoid tackling contraception. Perhaps they want to save babies, but perhaps many only want to do so until the moment of steep personal cost comes, until the moment they begin to look foolish. Unfortunately, that moment is also the moment of truth in the minds of women, the core issue that will eventually win back the minds and hearts of women to our side. Until that moment comes, the baby will always be the cancer they fear more than any other. pregnancies and tandem nursing her babies, and still experiencing early return of fertility? I myself experienced the return of fertility with my first two babies at 6 and 5 weeks postpartum, respectively. With the birth of my third, I had read Breastfeeding and Natural Child Spacing and learned that, at least with my second, it was probably due to early sleeping through the night. The third baby was a voracious eater who did not sleep through the night, and fertility returned at 5 mo pp. Subsequently, I have never weaned a child before the next was born and have experienced delayed fertility of well past a year each (three subsequent babies so far). I certainly empathize with this couple's plight. We needed to commit to abstain through the first half of my cycles when we truly needed to space babies. With short luteal phases due to breastfeeding, that often would only leave a few open days. It is a challenge, but the alternatives are not good either. Barrier contraceptives can have almost a 40% failure rate! What really helped us was switching to Creighton and having the in-depth focus on the mucus sign. We did ours long distance by phone. From one tired mama to another, I will remember this family in my prayers as they struggle. Thank you for being a faithful witness to this family!-- Bekah<>< http://our-family.family-way.net/ appletreewebdesigns.com Learn about Home Birth: morebabiespreferhomebirth.com Dear NFP professionals, I desperately need your competent advice about this extremely difficult situation of a couple I know very well. First of all: I absolutely agree with the Catholic Church teaching about contraception as intrinsically evil act. I am a seminarian with PhD. in psychology (dissertation on psychology of NFP), certified instructor of the STM of NFP (German method), deeply interested in moral theology and theology of the body. Situation, I am absolutely unable to resolve is this: A young Catholic married couple, deeply commited to Church`s teaching on contraception. First pregnancy unplanned, very early after wedding, with no NFP experience. Second pregnancy unplanned and very difficult to accept, because the wife conceived on 50th day (sic!) after delivery of the first child during FULL (EXCLUSIVE) BREASTFEEDING. Third pregnacy unplanned, during the 13th cycle of STM NFP observation. It was a perfect-use pregnancy, as I personally checked. The woman had very soon return of fertility after childbirth despite of full, exclusive, intensive breastfeeding. So, she has 3 children during 4 years now, she is exhausted, with absolutely no confidence in NFP. They did everything they were able to do. Their relationship is now in crisis, because of fear of further pregnancy. Total sexual abstinence is for them unacceptable. They dont want to try NFP once more. Both of them seems to doubt the teaching on immorality of contraception now. They see it as "contra-intuitive". However, the wife told me she is dreading of God`s punishment if they eventually use a barrier contraception. They are totally perplexed. I never met such a situation. I see no moral solution for it. I am inclined to think that the only „solution" is to accept their use of barrier contraceptives with hope for God`s mercy. I it possible they will be able to slowly accept the NFP once more later, but surely not now. What do you think of it? Thank you Karel Skocovsky P.S.: I am little bit angry because we NFP-fans sometimes underestimate difficulties married couples have to face to. I NEVER read anythink about what to do as a priest in such a difficult situation. I am very well aware of almost everything doctrinally orthodox written in English... What about „law of graduality"? I asked E. May on it and he was unable to explain me what it really means in practice... In last month, I met about 2-3 other perplexed couples using contraception with no real hope for change... We frequently present NFP as powerful marriage building tool. But we very often do not speak about long periods of abstinence during non-typical return of fertility after childbirth... ------------------------------------ Quote
Guest guest Posted September 9, 2010 Report Posted September 9, 2010 If they don't want to try NFP, then do total abstinence. Everyone knows this is 100% effective. Singles, nuns and priests have to do it. In some cases, it could be very difficult for them. If they blow it, they'll be parents. Human life is still possible without sex. Incarcerated inmates, many in the military, monks, astronauts, all sorts of people can survive, even thrive without resort to sex. Total sexual abstinence is impossible for them? How about if a submariner told his captain they must make an unscheduled stop in hawaii because he can no longer control his sexual urges. A different stop for each sailor? Was this the island hopping campaign of world war II? Some astronauts (e.g. Russians) spent very long periods aloft in space. Could they call Moscow for urgent and immediate sexual relief? Send someone right up? No method of NFP works perfectly. No method of contraception works perfectly. No method of contraception works noticeably better than well- done NFP (TL failure rate 2% over ten year follow-up). If they dread pregnancy that much, contraception is too risky for them. Total abstinence would be a good method for them, will improve their relationship, is an oppurtunity for grace through self denial. And after all-abstinence makes the heart grow fonder. No method will better grow their love and relationship. The beginning of wisdom is obedience. There is something they will learn if they obey. Paddy Jim Baggot MD To: nfpprofessionals From: pedullad@...Date: Thu, 9 Sep 2010 09:48:49 -0400Subject: Re: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation I feel like saying here "Give me a break!". If they are Catholics, the moral part is a question of faith. With faith, we can certainly discuss a multiplicity of pastoral options here. Without it, none will likely be successful or acceptable to them. Once faith is accepted, the NFP portions of the dilemma can -- even if with very great difficulty -- be resolved, though it is naive to think it will be very simple. But Karel you have it backward. You must first start with faith (and at best your statements here in this regard are contradictory), then work the other way, not the other way around. None of this is to minimize to any degree the difficulties, but give me a break. First start with accepting the 10 commandments, then all else becomes do-able, however difficult. Sincerely yours, Dominic M. Pedulla MD, FACC, CNFPMC, ABVM, ACPhInterventional Cardiologist, Endovascular Diplomate, Varicose Vein Specialist, Noncontraceptive Family Planning Consultant, Family Planning ResearcherMedical Director, The Oklahoma Vein and Endovascular Center (www.noveinok.com, veininfo@...)Executive Director, The Edith Stein Foundation (www.theedithsteinfoundation.com) (office) (cell) (FAX)pedullad@... "And he departed from our sight that we might return to our heart, and there find Him. For He departed, and behold, He is here."- St. Augustine Re: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation If I may ask, is she continuing to breastfeed through contraceptive mentality PRO-LIFE ACHILLES HEEL: Dominic Pedulla, MD, of the Edith Stein Foundation comments: In nature's plan, the woman is "chosen" from all others to receive love from a man, and then the child conceived is the living incarnation, symbol, and visible reminder (not unlike the living Eucharistic "anamnesis" of Luke 22:19) that she was a uniquely treasured and esteemed gift. Just as we can only love because Jesus has first loved us (cf. 1 Jn. 4:19), similarly the woman can only properly love the child conceived if that child is the living symbol of a genuine love she first received from the child's father. Contraceptive "love" is a betrayal; a degradation, a form of sexual depersonalization of the woman, not consciously admitted however. The shame from this is so great that (quite literally according to the medical and psychological literature), she in many cases would take her own life rather than see that trauma exposed. Similarly, she will abort her child because, in the absence of any real path to repersonalization for herself, she will have recourse to the depersonalizing of her own child. That way, her own shame can be "eradicated"; i.e., in the unconscious mind of the abortion-inclined woman, the shame dies with the child.This tells us not only why abortion occurs, but also how little this all has to do with the purely abstract question of a child's right to life, at least at the moment a woman discovers she has a pregnancy she does not want. Moreover, it tells us why some "prolifers" assiduously avoid tackling contraception. Perhaps they want to save babies, but perhaps many only want to do so until the moment of steep personal cost comes, until the moment they begin to look foolish. Unfortunately, that moment is also the moment of truth in the minds of women, the core issue that will eventually win back the minds and hearts of women to our side. Until that moment comes, the baby will always be the cancer they fear more than any other. pregnancies and tandem nursing her babies, and still experiencing early return of fertility? I myself experienced the return of fertility with my first two babies at 6 and 5 weeks postpartum, respectively. With the birth of my third, I had read Breastfeeding and Natural Child Spacing and learned that, at least with my second, it was probably due to early sleeping through the night. The third baby was a voracious eater who did not sleep through the night, and fertility returned at 5 mo pp. Subsequently, I have never weaned a child before the next was born and have experienced delayed fertility of well past a year each (three subsequent babies so far). I certainly empathize with this couple's plight. We needed to commit to abstain through the first half of my cycles when we truly needed to space babies. With short luteal phases due to breastfeeding, that often would only leave a few open days. It is a challenge, but the alternatives are not good either. Barrier contraceptives can have almost a 40% failure rate! What really helped us was switching to Creighton and having the in-depth focus on the mucus sign. We did ours long distance by phone. From one tired mama to another, I will remember this family in my prayers as they struggle. Thank you for being a faithful witness to this family!--Bekah<><http://our-family.family-way.net/appletreewebdesigns.comLearn about Home Birth: morebabiespreferhomebirth.com Dear NFP professionals,I desperately need your competent advice about this extremely difficult situation of a couple I know very well.First of all: I absolutely agree with the Catholic Church teaching about contraception as intrinsically evil act. I am a seminarian with PhD. in psychology (dissertation on psychology of NFP), certified instructor of the STM of NFP (German method), deeply interested in moral theology and theology of the body.Situation, I am absolutely unable to resolve is this:A young Catholic married couple, deeply commited to Church`s teaching on contraception. First pregnancy unplanned, very early after wedding, with no NFP experience. Second pregnancy unplanned and very difficult to accept, because the wife conceived on 50th day (sic!) after delivery of the first child during FULL (EXCLUSIVE) BREASTFEEDING. Third pregnacy unplanned, during the 13th cycle of STM NFP observation. It was a perfect-use pregnancy, as I personally checked. The woman had very soon return of fertility after childbirth despite of full, exclusive, intensive breastfeeding.So, she has 3 children during 4 years now, she is exhausted, with absolutely no confidence in NFP. They did everything they were able to do. Their relationship is now in crisis, because of fear of further pregnancy. Total sexual abstinence is for them unacceptable. They dont want to try NFP once more. Both of them seems to doubt the teaching on immorality of contraception now. They see it as "contra-intuitive". However, the wife told me she is dreading of God`s punishment if they eventually use a barrier contraception. They are totally perplexed.I never met such a situation. I see no moral solution for it. I am inclined to think that the only „solution" is to accept their use of barrier contraceptives with hope for God`s mercy. I it possible they will be able to slowly accept the NFP once more later, but surely not now.What do you think of it?Thank youKarel SkocovskyP.S.: I am little bit angry because we NFP-fans sometimes underestimate difficulties married couples have to face to. I NEVER read anythink about what to do as a priest in such a difficult situation. I am very well aware of almost everything doctrinally orthodox written in English... What about „law of graduality"? I asked E. May on it and he was unable to explain me what it really means in practice... In last month, I met about 2-3 other perplexed couples using contraception with no real hope for change... We frequently present NFP as powerful marriage building tool. But we very often do not speak about long periods of abstinence during non-typical return of fertility after childbirth...------------------------------------ Quote
Guest guest Posted September 9, 2010 Report Posted September 9, 2010 Absolutely right! Sincerely yours, Dominic M. Pedulla MD, FACC, CNFPMC, ABVM, ACPh Interventional Cardiologist, Endovascular Diplomate, Varicose Vein Specialist, Noncontraceptive Family Planning Consultant, Family Planning Researcher Medical Director, The Oklahoma Vein and Endovascular Center (www.noveinok.com, veininfo@...) Executive Director, The Edith Stein Foundation (www.theedithsteinfoundation.com) (office) (cell) (FAX) pedullad@... "And he departed from our sight that we might return to our heart, and there find Him. For He departed, and behold, He is here." - St. Augustine Re: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation If I may ask, is she continuing to breastfeed through contraceptive mentality PRO-LIFE ACHILLES HEEL: Dominic Pedulla, MD, of the Edith Stein Foundation comments: In nature's plan, the woman is "chosen" from all others to receive love from a man, and then the child conceived is the living incarnation, symbol, and visible reminder (not unlike the living Eucharistic "anamnesis" of Luke 22:19) that she was a uniquely treasured and esteemed gift. Just as we can only love because Jesus has first loved us (cf. 1 Jn. 4:19), similarly the woman can only properly love the child conceived if that child is the living symbol of a genuine love she first received from the child's father. Contraceptive "love" is a betrayal; a degradation, a form of sexual depersonalization of the woman, not consciously admitted however. The shame from this is so great that (quite literally according to the medical and psychological literature), she in many cases would take her own life rather than see that trauma exposed. Similarly, she will abort her child because, in the absence of any real path to repersonalization for herself, she will have recourse to the depersonalizing of her own child. That way, her own shame can be "eradicated"; i.e., in the unconscious mind of the abortion-inclined woman, the shame dies with the child. This tells us not only why abortion occurs, but also how little this all has to do with the purely abstract question of a child's right to life, at least at the moment a woman discovers she has a pregnancy she does not want. Moreover, it tells us why some "prolifers" assiduously avoid tackling contraception. Perhaps they want to save babies, but perhaps many only want to do so until the moment of steep personal cost comes, until the moment they begin to look foolish. Unfortunately, that moment is also the moment of truth in the minds of women, the core issue that will eventually win back the minds and hearts of women to our side. Until that moment comes, the baby will always be the cancer they fear more than any other. pregnancies and tandem nursing her babies, and still experiencing early return of fertility? I myself experienced the return of fertility with my first two babies at 6 and 5 weeks postpartum, respectively. With the birth of my third, I had read Breastfeeding and Natural Child Spacing and learned that, at least with my second, it was probably due to early sleeping through the night. The third baby was a voracious eater who did not sleep through the night, and fertility returned at 5 mo pp. Subsequently, I have never weaned a child before the next was born and have experienced delayed fertility of well past a year each (three subsequent babies so far). I certainly empathize with this couple's plight. We needed to commit to abstain through the first half of my cycles when we truly needed to space babies. With short luteal phases due to breastfeeding, that often would only leave a few open days. It is a challenge, but the alternatives are not good either. Barrier contraceptives can have almost a 40% failure rate! What really helped us was switching to Creighton and having the in-depth focus on the mucus sign. We did ours long distance by phone. From one tired mama to another, I will remember this family in my prayers as they struggle. Thank you for being a faithful witness to this family!-- Bekah<>< http://our-family.family-way.net/ appletreewebdesigns.com Learn about Home Birth: morebabiespreferhomebirth.com Dear NFP professionals, I desperately need your competent advice about this extremely difficult situation of a couple I know very well. First of all: I absolutely agree with the Catholic Church teaching about contraception as intrinsically evil act. I am a seminarian with PhD. in psychology (dissertation on psychology of NFP), certified instructor of the STM of NFP (German method), deeply interested in moral theology and theology of the body. Situation, I am absolutely unable to resolve is this: A young Catholic married couple, deeply commited to Church`s teaching on contraception. First pregnancy unplanned, very early after wedding, with no NFP experience. Second pregnancy unplanned and very difficult to accept, because the wife conceived on 50th day (sic!) after delivery of the first child during FULL (EXCLUSIVE) BREASTFEEDING. Third pregnacy unplanned, during the 13th cycle of STM NFP observation. It was a perfect-use pregnancy, as I personally checked. The woman had very soon return of fertility after childbirth despite of full, exclusive, intensive breastfeeding. So, she has 3 children during 4 years now, she is exhausted, with absolutely no confidence in NFP. They did everything they were able to do. Their relationship is now in crisis, because of fear of further pregnancy. Total sexual abstinence is for them unacceptable. They dont want to try NFP once more. Both of them seems to doubt the teaching on immorality of contraception now. They see it as "contra-intuitive". However, the wife told me she is dreading of God`s punishment if they eventually use a barrier contraception. They are totally perplexed. I never met such a situation. I see no moral solution for it. I am inclined to think that the only „solution" is to accept their use of barrier contraceptives with hope for God`s mercy. I it possible they will be able to slowly accept the NFP once more later, but surely not now. What do you think of it? Thank you Karel Skocovsky P.S.: I am little bit angry because we NFP-fans sometimes underestimate difficulties married couples have to face to. I NEVER read anythink about what to do as a priest in such a difficult situation. I am very well aware of almost everything doctrinally orthodox written in English... What about „law of graduality"? I asked E. May on it and he was unable to explain me what it really means in practice... In last month, I met about 2-3 other perplexed couples using contraception with no real hope for change... We frequently present NFP as powerful marriage building tool. But we very often do not speak about long periods of abstinence during non-typical return of fertility after childbirth... ------------------------------------ Quote
Guest guest Posted September 9, 2010 Report Posted September 9, 2010 Fr Karel and Friends, As the Co-Founder and long-time Director of One More Soul I have supported all the approved methods of NFP, including Ecological Breastfeeding. The One More Soul on-line Directory of NFP Teachers invites teachers of all methods to send their contact/method information to @.... The listing is FREE, and provides a much appreciated service to women, couples, physicians and pastors! The advantage of the sympto-thermal methods, and other multi observable methods, is their cross-checking ability that may provide additional assurance that the woman is in a particular phase of her fertility cycle. That this cross-checking provides some slight additional advantage in effectiveness might be contested by mucus-only method advocates. The disadvantage of multi-observable methods, compared to a mucus-only method, is that the attention of the observer is divided and diluted, instead of being focused on mucus alone. A woman who has become accustomed to focusing on her post-ovulation temperature rise, to determine the infertile phase, will be handicapped during breast feeding until her fertile phases begin again. I recall the statement made by a young husband and recent father: “I wish she (his wife—the mother of their new son) would wean him so she would cycle again and we would know when the safe time is.” This statement deeply saddened me, indicating as it did a competition between father and son for the wife/mother’s comfort/nourishment. Such cannot be in God’s plan. It seems to me that multi-observable methods should teach a strategy that considers cervical mucus as the primary observable, with all other observables considered as secondary, or supplementary. As confidence in cervical mucus observation grows, and it’s simplicity and constant observationability is realized, the woman can wean herself of other observables. With full confidence in her mucus observations, she will be equipped to recognize mucus patterns that are indicative of infertility, whether the pattern is dry or wet. This knowledge and experience will serve her and her husband through all phases of her life. Blessings to all. Steve Koob Founder & Director One More Soul To: nfpprofessionals From: BekahS77@...Date: Wed, 8 Sep 2010 18:57:42 -0500Subject: Re: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation If I may ask, is she continuing to breastfeed through her pregnancies and tandem nursing her babies, and still experiencing early return of fertility? I myself experienced the return of fertility with my first two babies at 6 and 5 weeks postpartum, respectively. With the birth of my third, I had read Breastfeeding and Natural Child Spacing and learned that, at least with my second, it was probably due to early sleeping through the night. The third baby was a voracious eater who did not sleep through the night, and fertility returned at 5 mo pp. Subsequently, I have never weaned a child before the next was born and have experienced delayed fertility of well past a year each (three subsequent babies so far). I certainly empathize with this couple's plight. We needed to commit to abstain through the first half of my cycles when we truly needed to space babies. With short luteal phases due to breastfeeding, that often would only leave a few open days. It is a challenge, but the alternatives are not good either. Barrier contraceptives can have almost a 40% failure rate! What really helped us was switching to Creighton and having the in-depth focus on the mucus sign. We did ours long distance by phone. From one tired mama to another, I will remember this family in my prayers as they struggle. Thank you for being a faithful witness to this family!--Bekah<><http://our-family.family-way.net/ appletreewebdesigns.comLearn about Home Birth: morebabiespreferhomebirth.com Dear NFP professionals, I desperately need your competent advice about this extremely difficult situation of a couple I know very well. First of all: I absolutely agree with the Catholic Church teaching about contraception as intrinsically evil act. I am a seminarian with PhD. in psychology (dissertation on psychology of NFP), certified instructor of the STM of NFP (German method), deeply interested in moral theology and theology of the body. Situation, I am absolutely unable to resolve is this: A young Catholic married couple, deeply commited to Church`s teaching on contraception. First pregnancy unplanned, very early after wedding, with no NFP experience. Second pregnancy unplanned and very difficult to accept, because the wife conceived on 50th day (sic!) after delivery of the first child during FULL (EXCLUSIVE) BREASTFEEDING. Third pregnacy unplanned, during the 13th cycle of STM NFP observation. It was a perfect-use pregnancy, as I personally checked. The woman had very soon return of fertility after childbirth despite of full, exclusive, intensive breastfeeding. So, she has 3 children during 4 years now, she is exhausted, with absolutely no confidence in NFP. They did everything they were able to do. Their relationship is now in crisis, because of fear of further pregnancy. Total sexual abstinence is for them unacceptable. They dont want to try NFP once more. Both of them seems to doubt the teaching on immorality of contraception now. They see it as "contra-intuitive". However, the wife told me she is dreading of God`s punishment if they eventually use a barrier contraception. They are totally perplexed. I never met such a situation. I see no moral solution for it. I am inclined to think that the only „solution" is to accept their use of barrier contraceptives with hope for God`s mercy. I it possible they will be able to slowly accept the NFP once more later, but surely not now. What do you think of it? Thank you Karel Skocovsky P.S.: I am little bit angry because we NFP-fans sometimes underestimate difficulties married couples have to face to. I NEVER read anythink about what to do as a priest in such a difficult situation. I am very well aware of almost everything doctrinally orthodox written in English... What about „law of graduality"? I asked E. May on it and he was unable to explain me what it really means in practice... In last month, I met about 2-3 other perplexed couples using contraception with no real hope for change... We frequently present NFP as powerful marriage building tool. But we very often do not speak about long periods of abstinence during non-typical return of fertility after childbirth... ------------------------------------ Quote
Guest guest Posted September 9, 2010 Report Posted September 9, 2010 She might try using www.billingsmentor.org which is getting rave reviews from Dr. . The women add their observations and the software tells them which rules to apply and even identifies a Basic Infertile Pattern for them if there is one. Working with a teacher is ideal. We ask women to start charting at 3 weeks postpartum or as soon as the lochia clears, whichever comes first. That way they are tuning into what the hormones are doing and can apply the 4 Rules of the Billings Method according to the hormonal patterns. We have a teacher who identified Peak Day at 6 weeks postpartum with each baby and was fully breastfeeding. The Billings Method rules worked beautifully for her. Sue Ek Billings Ovulation Method Association - USAwww.boma-usa.org www.billingslife.org www.woomb.org I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Dear NFP professionals,I desperately need your competent advice about this extremely difficult situation of a couple I know very well.First of all: I absolutely agree with the Catholic Church teaching about contraception as intrinsically evil act. I am a seminarian with PhD. in psychology (dissertation on psychology of NFP), certified instructor of the STM of NFP (German method), deeply interested in moral theology and theology of the body.Situation, I am absolutely unable to resolve is this:A young Catholic married couple, deeply commited to Church`s teaching on contraception. First pregnancy unplanned, very early after wedding, with no NFP experience. Second pregnancy unplanned and very difficult to accept, because the wife conceived on 50th day (sic!) after delivery of the first child during FULL (EXCLUSIVE) BREASTFEEDING. Third pregnacy unplanned, during the 13th cycle of STM NFP observation. It was a perfect-use pregnancy, as I personally checked. The woman had very soon return of fertility after childbirth despite of full, exclusive, intensive breastfeeding. So, she has 3 children during 4 years now, she is exhausted, with absolutely no confidence in NFP. They did everything they were able to do. Their relationship is now in crisis, because of fear of further pregnancy. Total sexual abstinence is for them unacceptable. They dont want to try NFP once more. Both of them seems to doubt the teaching on immorality of contraception now. They see it as "contra-intuitive". However, the wife told me she is dreading of God`s punishment if they eventually use a barrier contraception. They are totally perplexed.I never met such a situation. I see no moral solution for it. I am inclined to think that the only "solution" is to accept their use of barrier contraceptives with hope for God`s mercy. I it possible they will be able to slowly accept the NFP once more later, but surely not now.What do you think of it?Thank youKarel SkocovskyP.S.: I am little bit angry because we NFP-fans sometimes underestimate difficulties married couples have to face to. I NEVER read anythink about what to do as a priest in such a difficult situation. I am very well aware of almost everything doctrinally orthodox written in English... What about "law of graduality"? I asked E. May on it and he was unable to explain me what it really means in practice... In last month, I met about 2-3 other perplexed couples using contraception with no real hope for change... We frequently present NFP as powerful marriage building tool. But we very often do not speak about long periods of abstinence during non-typical return of fertility after childbirth... Quote
Guest guest Posted September 9, 2010 Report Posted September 9, 2010 Yes Steve but as you well know all methods will fail at least for some people, and for each method, however good it is, there will be some who cannot succeed with it; and for some total abstinence will even be easier, in some ways, than trying yet another approach. This is just life, and in these cases one still can call on faith and grace, which makes obedience possible (Eph. 2:8, ff.). Sincerely yours, Dominic M. Pedulla MD, FACC, CNFPMC, ABVM, ACPh Interventional Cardiologist, Endovascular Diplomate, Varicose Vein Specialist, Noncontraceptive Family Planning Consultant, Family Planning Researcher Medical Director, The Oklahoma Vein and Endovascular Center (www.noveinok.com, veininfo@...) Executive Director, The Edith Stein Foundation (www.theedithsteinfoundation.com) (office) (cell) (FAX) pedullad@... "And he departed from our sight that we might return to our heart, and there find Him. For He departed, and behold, He is here." - St. Augustine Re: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation If I may ask, is she continuing to breastfeed through her pregnancies and tandem nursing her babies, and still experiencing early return of fertility? I myself experienced the return of fertility with my first two babies at 6 and 5 weeks postpartum, respectively. With the birth of my third, I had read Breastfeeding and Natural Child Spacing and learned that, at least with my second, it was probably due to early sleeping through the night. The third baby was a voracious eater who did not sleep through the night, and fertility returned at 5 mo pp. Subsequently, I have never weaned a child before the next was born and have experienced delayed fertility of well past a year each (three subsequent babies so far). I certainly empathize with this couple's plight. We needed to commit to abstain through the first half of my cycles when we truly needed to space babies. With short luteal phases due to breastfeeding, that often would only leave a few open days. It is a challenge, but the alternatives are not good either. Barrier contraceptives can have almost a 40% failure rate! What really helped us was switching to Creighton and having the in-depth focus on the mucus sign. We did ours long distance by phone. From one tired mama to another, I will remember this family in my prayers as they struggle. Thank you for being a faithful witness to this family!-- Bekah<>< http://our-family.family-way.net/ appletreewebdesigns.com Learn about Home Birth: morebabiespreferhomebirth.com Dear NFP professionals, I desperately need your competent advice about this extremely difficult situation of a couple I know very well. First of all: I absolutely agree with the Catholic Church teaching about contraception as intrinsically evil act. I am a seminarian with PhD. in psychology (dissertation on psychology of NFP), certified instructor of the STM of NFP (German method), deeply interested in moral theology and theology of the body. Situation, I am absolutely unable to resolve is this: A young Catholic married couple, deeply commited to Church`s teaching on contraception. First pregnancy unplanned, very early after wedding, with no NFP experience. Second pregnancy unplanned and very difficult to accept, because the wife conceived on 50th day (sic!) after delivery of the first child during FULL (EXCLUSIVE) BREASTFEEDING. Third pregnacy unplanned, during the 13th cycle of STM NFP observation. It was a perfect-use pregnancy, as I personally checked. The woman had very soon return of fertility after childbirth despite of full, exclusive, intensive breastfeeding. So, she has 3 children during 4 years now, she is exhausted, with absolutely no confidence in NFP. They did everything they were able to do. Their relationship is now in crisis, because of fear of further pregnancy. Total sexual abstinence is for them unacceptable. They dont want to try NFP once more. Both of them seems to doubt the teaching on immorality of contraception now. They see it as "contra-intuitive". However, the wife told me she is dreading of God`s punishment if they eventually use a barrier contraception. They are totally perplexed. I never met such a situation. I see no moral solution for it. I am inclined to think that the only „solution" is to accept their use of barrier contraceptives with hope for God`s mercy. I it possible they will be able to slowly accept the NFP once more later, but surely not now. What do you think of it? Thank you Karel Skocovsky P.S.: I am little bit angry because we NFP-fans sometimes underestimate difficulties married couples have to face to. I NEVER read anythink about what to do as a priest in such a difficult situation. I am very well aware of almost everything doctrinally orthodox written in English... What about „law of graduality"? I asked E. May on it and he was unable to explain me what it really means in practice... In last month, I met about 2-3 other perplexed couples using contraception with no real hope for change... We frequently present NFP as powerful marriage building tool. But we very often do not speak about long periods of abstinence during non-typical return of fertility after childbirth... ------------------------------------ Quote
Guest guest Posted September 9, 2010 Report Posted September 9, 2010 I am going to gently step out here as I am not catholic, but I am a professing Christian who is a Billings teacher. Yes, abstinence does have it's place in marriage, but I think we should be sensitive to the anxiety that prolonged abstinence may cause some couples. I know that if I were undergoing the same issue I would not want someone just to tell me to go be abstinent and "deal with it." The scriptures state in 1 Corinthians 7:5: "Stop depriving one another, except by agreement for a time, so that you may devote yourselves to prayer, and come together again so that Satan will not tempt you because of your lack of self-control. One suggestion that I would make is that this may be a time as a couple to be abstinent to devote to prayer so that: a) they find a method they are comfortable with accept that God is in control and is calling them to grow their family c) obtaining renewed strength (husband -waiting and wife- waiting and the busyness of mothering young children d) self control and protection from temptation. Any one of these or all of the above. Sometimes prayer and waiting is the only answer. I firmly believe in P-U-S-H - Pray until something happens! This couple needs encouragement that God knows us and can provide during times of distress. To: nfpprofessionals From: pedullad@...Date: Thu, 9 Sep 2010 14:26:58 -0400Subject: Re: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Yes Steve but as you well know all methods will fail at least for some people, and for each method, however good it is, there will be some who cannot succeed with it; and for some total abstinence will even be easier, in some ways, than trying yet another approach. This is just life, and in these cases one still can call on faith and grace, which makes obedience possible (Eph. 2:8, ff.). Sincerely yours, Dominic M. Pedulla MD, FACC, CNFPMC, ABVM, ACPhInterventional Cardiologist, Endovascular Diplomate, Varicose Vein Specialist, Noncontraceptive Family Planning Consultant, Family Planning ResearcherMedical Director, The Oklahoma Vein and Endovascular Center (www.noveinok.com, veininfo@...)Executive Director, The Edith Stein Foundation (www.theedithsteinfoundation.com) (office) (cell) (FAX)pedullad@... "And he departed from our sight that we might return to our heart, and there find Him. For He departed, and behold, He is here."- St. Augustine Re: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation If I may ask, is she continuing to breastfeed through her pregnancies and tandem nursing her babies, and still experiencing early return of fertility? I myself experienced the return of fertility with my first two babies at 6 and 5 weeks postpartum, respectively. With the birth of my third, I had read Breastfeeding and Natural Child Spacing and learned that, at least with my second, it was probably due to early sleeping through the night. The third baby was a voracious eater who did not sleep through the night, and fertility returned at 5 mo pp. Subsequently, I have never weaned a child before the next was born and have experienced delayed fertility of well past a year each (three subsequent babies so far). I certainly empathize with this couple's plight. We needed to commit to abstain through the first half of my cycles when we truly needed to space babies. With short luteal phases due to breastfeeding, that often would only leave a few open days. It is a challenge, but the alternatives are not good either. Barrier contraceptives can have almost a 40% failure rate! What really helped us was switching to Creighton and having the in-depth focus on the mucus sign. We did ours long distance by phone. From one tired mama to another, I will remember this family in my prayers as they struggle. Thank you for being a faithful witness to this family!--Bekah<><http://our-family.family-way.net/appletreewebdesigns.comLearn about Home Birth: morebabiespreferhomebirth.com Dear NFP professionals,I desperately need your competent advice about this extremely difficult situation of a couple I know very well.First of all: I absolutely agree with the Catholic Church teaching about contraception as intrinsically evil act. I am a seminarian with PhD. in psychology (dissertation on psychology of NFP), certified instructor of the STM of NFP (German method), deeply interested in moral theology and theology of the body.Situation, I am absolutely unable to resolve is this:A young Catholic married couple, deeply commited to Church`s teaching on contraception. First pregnancy unplanned, very early after wedding, with no NFP experience. Second pregnancy unplanned and very difficult to accept, because the wife conceived on 50th day (sic!) after delivery of the first child during FULL (EXCLUSIVE) BREASTFEEDING. Third pregnacy unplanned, during the 13th cycle of STM NFP observation. It was a perfect-use pregnancy, as I personally checked. The woman had very soon return of fertility after childbirth despite of full, exclusive, intensive breastfeeding.So, she has 3 children during 4 years now, she is exhausted, with absolutely no confidence in NFP. They did everything they were able to do. Their relationship is now in crisis, because of fear of further pregnancy. Total sexual abstinence is for them unacceptable. They dont want to try NFP once more. Both of them seems to doubt the teaching on immorality of contraception now. They see it as "contra-intuitive". However, the wife told me she is dreading of God`s punishment if they eventually use a barrier contraception. They are totally perplexed.I never met such a situation. I see no moral solution for it. I am inclined to think that the only „solution" is to accept their use of barrier contraceptives with hope for God`s mercy. I it possible they will be able to slowly accept the NFP once more later, but surely not now.What do you think of it?Thank youKarel SkocovskyP.S.: I am little bit angry because we NFP-fans sometimes underestimate difficulties married couples have to face to. I NEVER read anythink about what to do as a priest in such a difficult situation. I am very well aware of almost everything doctrinally orthodox written in English... What about „law of graduality"? I asked E. May on it and he was unable to explain me what it really means in practice... In last month, I met about 2-3 other perplexed couples using contraception with no real hope for change... We frequently present NFP as powerful marriage building tool. But we very often do not speak about long periods of abstinence during non-typical return of fertility after childbirth...------------------------------------ Quote
Guest guest Posted September 9, 2010 Report Posted September 9, 2010 Hi everyone, I'll attempt to respond to the question about "graduality" - and then try to offer some further (and characteristically long-winded) thoughts about the case. I gather this is a reference to something that's mentioned in a couple of Church documents. In Pope II's 1981 Apostolic Exhortation on the Role of the Christian Family in the Modern World (Familiaris Consortio), no. 34, we find this paragraph; see especially the sentence I've emphasized: Married people too are called upon to progress unceasingly in their moral life, with the support of a sincere and active desire to gain ever better knowledge of the values enshrined in and fostered by the law of God. They must also be supported by an upright and generous willingness to embody these values in their concrete decisions. They cannot however look on the law as merely an ideal to be achieved in the future: they must consider it as a command of Christ the Lord to overcome difficulties with constancy. "And so what is known as 'the law of gradualness' or step-by-step advance cannot be identified with 'gradualness of the law,' as if there were different degrees or forms of precept in God's law for different individuals and situations. In God's plan, all husbands and wives are called in marriage to holiness, and this lofty vocation is fulfilled to the extent that the human person is able to respond to God's command with serene confidence in God's grace and in his or her own will."(95) On the same lines, it is part of the Church's pedagogy that husbands and wives should first of all recognize clearly the teaching of Humanae vitae as indicating the norm for the exercise of their sexuality, and that they should endeavor to establish the conditions necessary for observing that norm. Here is quoting from a homily that he had given about a year earlier. In 1997, the Pontifical Council for the Family issued the "Vademecum for Confessors Concerning Some Aspects of the Morality of Conjugal Life." In section 3.9 we read: The pastoral "law of gradualness", not to be confused with the "gradualness of the law" which would tend to diminish the demands it places on us, consists of requiring a decisive break with sin together with a progressive path towards total union with the will of God and with his loving demands. There is a footnote to Familiaris Consortio. The point here seems - above all - to be a caution against the view that moral precepts like the one forbidding contraception don't fully apply to people/couples in certain circumstances - and/or that it cannot reasonably be expected that people will, by God's grace, be capable of living these norms that indicate what is minimally necessary for the avoidance of what is objectively sinful. There is of course also a recognition here that progress beyond this minimum will be "gradual." Now to speak more directly to the difficult case that Karel described ... It would of course be wrong to suggest to the couple that using contraceptives, even for a time, is morally acceptable. Their situation might well diminish their subjective culpability were they to use contraception - but objectively they would still be doing themselves, and their relationships with each other and with God, a deep disservice. And of course the person suggesting that they use contraceptives would probably not have reason to think that his own subjective culpability for cooperating in this objective evil is in any way diminished - since that person is not himself under the kinds of pressures that they are. Let me add that it didn't sound to me like Karel or or anyone else here is proposing to make such a suggestion - so I think that some of the further responses are a little bit over the top - we are all on the same side here. It also sounds like there is a significant chance that the couple will themselves insist on using contraception, at least for a time. I think that if they do so, then encouraging them to do simultaneous charting is an excellent approach - to help them (re)gain confidence. Again, the point isn't that they should be encouraged, tacitly or explicitly, to use contraception, even for a time. The point is that if they themselves insist on doing so, we shouldn't simply give up - and we should try to figure out what is most likely to bring them around. I'm not sure that simply telling them to have faith and obey God's law and either use a method of NFP - maybe a different one - or abstain entirely (more on that below), is likely to be terribly effective in bringing them around, whether immediately or later. By God's grace, they can have the kind of relationship with him that is lived out in holiness, including moral goodness, including marital chastity, including refraining from using contraception. But for that to happen, we need to act and speak toward them in such a way as to be conduits of - and not obstacles to - God's grace. We need to convey to them that God's law is part of his genuinely loving plan - not simply a set of arbitrary and harmful dictates. We should be forthright about God's law - and also prudent and sensitive about how we articulate it - which includes not simply telling them to obey and/or playing into the idea that the main reason for doing so is that otherwise God will punish them - and which also includes really recognizing their pain - and which also includes really helping them to find a morally good and otherwise workable way of spacing their children. Regarding the latter - i.e. helping them to find a way: I agree that some married couples will sometimes need to abstain totally from intercourse - for a longer period than only the fertile period of each cycle. This can of course be necessary for reasons not having directly to do with spacing children. A spouse might be sick or injured or something along those lines and thus not really able to take part in the marital act - either not at all, or not in a way that's consistent with the act's loving meaning/purpose. Furthermore, it's true that marital intercourse isn't the only expression of marital love. I think that some recent Catholic treatments of this topic have perhaps exaggerated the importance of marital intercourse. But I also think that marital intercourse is indeed important - it has more than a little to do with marriage as a relationship of love and union ("one flesh") - one finds this recognized in the thought of some of the Church Fathers (e.g. Chrysostom) and one probably finds it recognized even more in Catholic thought today (e.g. Wojtyla/ II - again, even if some commentators somewhat exaggerate this dimension of his thought and/or fail to recognize that he is developing something that was already there in the tradition). There is a reason that we speak of "the marital act" - and that reason is not only that the physical act in question is morally good only within marriage - it is also because it is generally appropriate for married couples to engage in this act. I'm kind of skeptical that - with the knowledge that we have developed about the signs of fertility - a couple today would typically be called to accept the need for total abstinence as the only adequate way of spacing children. I think that suggesting this to a couple is probably not the right thing to do - I doubt that it's likely to be necessary - I suspect also that suggesting it is more likely to push them away from acceptance of the truth that contraception is morally unacceptable. I also think that - both in general, and even more so in difficult cases like this one - we need to do our absolute best to make sure that our advice regarding specific NFP methods is good advice - based on good evidence regarding efficacy. That one teaches method X and even that one has had many satisfied couples, does not mean that method X is the best one for everyone or more specifically for couples in difficult cases. It may not be the method that will work best in difficult cases - even if it works in some such cases. It may be more complicated than necessary for efficacy. Etc. Likewise - and even more so - one might develop in one's mind a hypothesis that focusing mostly or entirely on one specific sign of fertility - or on another - or focusing equally on multiple signs - will be best. But such hypotheses ought not be the basis for advice to couples - let alone couples in difficult circumstances - until and unless they have been validated by good efficacy studies. I would insist that there is a serious moral issue here. We have a moral duty - see the 8th Commandment - to be honest with ourselves and with others. Convincing ourselves and/or others that something is true when there isn't really good evidence that it's true, is a violation of this Commandment. No matter how much we might want something to be true - no matter how helpful it would be if something were true - we need a real basis for thinking it's true and/or for telling others that it's true. Others here need to sort out which NFP methods work best in which circumstances (that's the job of medical and health-care professionals and scientists - not theologians like me) - but I think that suggestions regarding advice for couples like this one need to be based on that kind of sorting out - based on the best real data we have - and there ought to be efforts to get even better data in the future so that we can refine our advice over time - obviously there will be other couples in the future who need this kind of advice. The more we can show couples really good evidence that a suggested method will work - the more likely they are to trust that it - and not contraception - is in keeping with God's loving plan. And also - the better our methods really work "as advertised," the fewer couples will become disillusioned about NFP. And also - the more we are honest, the more we are simply doing the right thing. I hope that all helps. RE: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Dear Fr. Skocovsky:Thank you for sharing this difficult case -- but one that is not all that unusual.We do know that a small but sizable percentage of women/couples who use NFP ( i.e., around 25%) find it a challenge and are not satisfied with its use. We also know that many of our "modern" methods of NFP can result in extensive amounts of abstinence.I would think that the fear of another pregnancy, the lack of trust of NFP, the exhaustion of raising young children ---and fear of God's punishment -- would lessen the moral wrong (or i.e., sin) and their relationship with God. The fear of God's punishment bothers me -- since, we seek to have his love, care, and understanding. I wonder if she (they) would be willing to use a simple method of NFP along with barriers - until she (they) is/are confident in again using NFP. What I suggest is the use of the ClearBlue Easy Fertility monitor (which is available in Europe) -- along with a simple algorithm -- similar to the European Double check method (they are welcome to chart online at our NFP site http://nfp.marquette.edu . I would also let them know that barriers are no more effective than the use of NFP -- in fact the European Double check is more effective. However, the German's did find that the use of barriers did not lessen the efficacy of the method. The fertility monitor would provide them with a very objective test of fertility -- and would not be as burdensome as taking daily temps. The hormonal markers provided by the monitor are also more accurate than the standard markers of human fertility used with NFP.I would be gentle with this couple and help them to gradually re-gain acceptance of NFP.Thanks you for your pastoral work. J. FehringProfessorMarquette University PS - maybe Professor could enlighten us on the theory of graduality?-----Original Message-----From: nfpprofessionals [mailto:nfpprofessionals ] On Behalf Of KarelSent: Wednesday, September 08, 2010 4:07 PMTo: nfpprofessionals Subject: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situationDear NFP professionals,I desperately need your competent advice about this extremely difficult situation of a couple I know very well.First of all: I absolutely agree with the Catholic Church teaching about contraception as intrinsically evil act. I am a seminarian with PhD. in psychology (dissertation on psychology of NFP), certified instructor of the STM of NFP (German method), deeply interested in moral theology and theology of the body.Situation, I am absolutely unable to resolve is this:A young Catholic married couple, deeply commited to Church`s teaching on contraception. First pregnancy unplanned, very early after wedding, with no NFP experience. Second pregnancy unplanned and very difficult to accept, because the wife conceived on 50th day (sic!) after delivery of the first child during FULL (EXCLUSIVE) BREASTFEEDING. Third pregnacy unplanned, during the 13th cycle of STM NFP observation. It was a perfect-use pregnancy, as I personally checked. The woman had very soon return of fertility after childbirth despite of full, exclusive, intensive breastfeeding. So, she has 3 children during 4 years now, she is exhausted, with absolutely no confidence in NFP. They did everything they were able to do. Their relationship is now in crisis, because of fear of further pregnancy. Total sexual abstinence is for them unacceptable. They dont want to try NFP once more. Both of them seems to doubt the teaching on immorality of contraception now. They see it as "contra-intuitive". However, the wife told me she is dreading of God`s punishment if they eventually use a barrier contraception. They are totally perplexed.I never met such a situation. I see no moral solution for it. I am inclined to think that the only "solution" is to accept their use of barrier contraceptives with hope for God`s mercy. I it possible they will be able to slowly accept the NFP once more later, but surely not now.What do you think of it?Thank youKarel SkocovskyP.S.: I am little bit angry because we NFP-fans sometimes underestimate difficulties married couples have to face to. I NEVER read anythink about what to do as a priest in such a difficult situation. I am very well aware of almost everything doctrinally orthodox written in English... What about "law of graduality"? I asked E. May on it and he was unable to explain me what it really means in practice... In last month, I met about 2-3 other perplexed couples using contraception with no real hope for change... We frequently present NFP as powerful marriage building tool. But we very often do not speak about long periods of abstinence during non-typical return of fertility after childbirth... ------------------------------------ Quote
Guest guest Posted September 9, 2010 Report Posted September 9, 2010 Thanks for your light, , especially the later comments.God bless, Rosko RN, BSNHer Choice Birmingham Pregnancy Resource CenterBirmingham, AL 35255To: nfpprofessionals From: k.e.miller@...Date: Thu, 9 Sep 2010 16:07:37 -0400Subject: Re: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Hi everyone, I'll attempt to respond to the question about "graduality" - and then try to offer some further (and characteristically long-winded) thoughts about the case. I gather this is a reference to something that's mentioned in a couple of Church documents. In Pope II's 1981 Apostolic Exhortation on the Role of the Christian Family in the Modern World (Familiaris Consortio), no. 34, we find this paragraph; see especially the sentence I've emphasized: Married people too are called upon to progress unceasingly in their moral life, with the support of a sincere and active desire to gain ever better knowledge of the values enshrined in and fostered by the law of God. They must also be supported by an upright and generous willingness to embody these values in their concrete decisions. They cannot however look on the law as merely an ideal to be achieved in the future: they must consider it as a command of Christ the Lord to overcome difficulties with constancy. "And so what is known as 'the law of gradualness' or step-by-step advance cannot be identified with 'gradualness of the law,' as if there were different degrees or forms of precept in God's law for different individuals and situations. In God's plan, all husbands and wives are called in marriage to holiness, and this lofty vocation is fulfilled to the extent that the human person is able to respond to God's command with serene confidence in God's grace and in his or her own will."(95) On the same lines, it is part of the Church's pedagogy that husbands and wives should first of all recognize clearly the teaching of Humanae vitae as indicating the norm for the exercise of their sexuality, and that they should endeavor to establish the conditions necessary for observing that norm. Here is quoting from a homily that he had given about a year earlier. In 1997, the Pontifical Council for the Family issued the "Vademecum for Confessors Concerning Some Aspects of the Morality of Conjugal Life." In section 3.9 we read: The pastoral "law of gradualness", not to be confused with the "gradualness of the law" which would tend to diminish the demands it places on us, consists of requiring a decisive break with sin together with a progressive path towards total union with the will of God and with his loving demands. There is a footnote to Familiaris Consortio. The point here seems - above all - to be a caution against the view that moral precepts like the one forbidding contraception don't fully apply to people/couples in certain circumstances - and/or that it cannot reasonably be expected that people will, by God's grace, be capable of living these norms that indicate what is minimally necessary for the avoidance of what is objectively sinful. There is of course also a recognition here that progress beyond this minimum will be "gradual." Now to speak more directly to the difficult case that Karel described ... It would of course be wrong to suggest to the couple that using contraceptives, even for a time, is morally acceptable. Their situation might well diminish their subjective culpability were they to use contraception - but objectively they would still be doing themselves, and their relationships with each other and with God, a deep disservice. And of course the person suggesting that they use contraceptives would probably not have reason to think that his own subjective culpability for cooperating in this objective evil is in any way diminished - since that person is not himself under the kinds of pressures that they are. Let me add that it didn't sound to me like Karel or or anyone else here is proposing to make such a suggestion - so I think that some of the further responses are a little bit over the top - we are all on the same side here. It also sounds like there is a significant chance that the couple will themselves insist on using contraception, at least for a time. I think that if they do so, then encouraging them to do simultaneous charting is an excellent approach - to help them (re)gain confidence. Again, the point isn't that they should be encouraged, tacitly or explicitly, to use contraception, even for a time. The point is that if they themselves insist on doing so, we shouldn't simply give up - and we should try to figure out what is most likely to bring them around. I'm not sure that simply telling them to have faith and obey God's law and either use a method of NFP - maybe a different one - or abstain entirely (more on that below), is likely to be terribly effective in bringing them around, whether immediately or later. By God's grace, they can have the kind of relationship with him that is lived out in holiness, including moral goodness, including marital chastity, including refraining from using contraception. But for that to happen, we need to act and speak toward them in such a way as to be conduits of - and not obstacles to - God's grace. We need to convey to them that God's law is part of his genuinely loving plan - not simply a set of arbitrary and harmful dictates. We should be forthright about God's law - and also prudent and sensitive about how we articulate it - which includes not simply telling them to obey and/or playing into the idea that the main reason for doing so is that otherwise God will punish them - and which also includes really recognizing their pain - and which also includes really helping them to find a morally good and otherwise workable way of spacing their children. Regarding the latter - i.e. helping them to find a way: I agree that some married couples will sometimes need to abstain totally from intercourse - for a longer period than only the fertile period of each cycle. This can of course be necessary for reasons not having directly to do with spacing children. A spouse might be sick or injured or something along those lines and thus not really able to take part in the marital act - either not at all, or not in a way that's consistent with the act's loving meaning/purpose. Furthermore, it's true that marital intercourse isn't the only expression of marital love. I think that some recent Catholic treatments of this topic have perhaps exaggerated the importance of marital intercourse. But I also think that marital intercourse is indeed important - it has more than a little to do with marriage as a relationship of love and union ("one flesh") - one finds this recognized in the thought of some of the Church Fathers (e.g. Chrysostom) and one probably finds it recognized even more in Catholic thought today (e.g. Wojtyla/ II - again, even if some commentators somewhat exaggerate this dimension of his thought and/or fail to recognize that he is developing something that was already there in the tradition). There is a reason that we speak of "the marital act" - and that reason is not only that the physical act in question is morally good only within marriage - it is also because it is generally appropriate for married couples to engage in this act. I'm kind of skeptical that - with the knowledge that we have developed about the signs of fertility - a couple today would typically be called to accept the need for total abstinence as the only adequate way of spacing children. I think that suggesting this to a couple is probably not the right thing to do - I doubt that it's likely to be necessary - I suspect also that suggesting it is more likely to push them away from acceptance of the truth that contraception is morally unacceptable. I also think that - both in general, and even more so in difficult cases like this one - we need to do our absolute best to make sure that our advice regarding specific NFP methods is good advice - based on good evidence regarding efficacy. That one teaches method X and even that one has had many satisfied couples, does not mean that method X is the best one for everyone or more specifically for couples in difficult cases. It may not be the method that will work best in difficult cases - even if it works in some such cases. It may be more complicated than necessary for efficacy. Etc. Likewise - and even more so - one might develop in one's mind a hypothesis that focusing mostly or entirely on one specific sign of fertility - or on another - or focusing equally on multiple signs - will be best. But such hypotheses ought not be the basis for advice to couples - let alone couples in difficult circumstances - until and unless they have been validated by good efficacy studies. I would insist that there is a serious moral issue here. We have a moral duty - see the 8th Commandment - to be honest with ourselves and with others. Convincing ourselves and/or others that something is true when there isn't really good evidence that it's true, is a violation of this Commandment. No matter how much we might want something to be true - no matter how helpful it would be if something were true - we need a real basis for thinking it's true and/or for telling others that it's true. Others here need to sort out which NFP methods work best in which circumstances (that's the job of medical and health-care professionals and scientists - not theologians like me) - but I think that suggestions regarding advice for couples like this one need to be based on that kind of sorting out - based on the best real data we have - and there ought to be efforts to get even better data in the future so that we can refine our advice over time - obviously there will be other couples in the future who need this kind of advice. The more we can show couples really good evidence that a suggested method will work - the more likely they are to trust that it - and not contraception - is in keeping with God's loving plan. And also - the better our methods really work "as advertised," the fewer couples will become disillusioned about NFP. And also - the more we are honest, the more we are simply doing the right thing. I hope that all helps. RE: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Dear Fr. Skocovsky:Thank you for sharing this difficult case -- but one that is not all that unusual.We do know that a small but sizable percentage of women/couples who use NFP ( i.e., around 25%) find it a challenge and are not satisfied with its use. We also know that many of our "modern" methods of NFP can result in extensive amounts of abstinence.I would think that the fear of another pregnancy, the lack of trust of NFP, the exhaustion of raising young children ---and fear of God's punishment -- would lessen the moral wrong (or i.e., sin) and their relationship with God. The fear of God's punishment bothers me -- since, we seek to have his love, care, and understanding. I wonder if she (they) would be willing to use a simple method of NFP along with barriers - until she (they) is/are confident in again using NFP. What I suggest is the use of the ClearBlue Easy Fertility monitor (which is available in Europe) -- along with a simple algorithm -- similar to the European Double check method (they are welcome to chart online at our NFP site http://nfp.marquette.edu . I would also let them know that barriers are no more effective than the use of NFP -- in fact the European Double check is more effective. However, the German's did find that the use of barriers did not lessen the efficacy of the method. The fertility monitor would provide them with a very objective test of fertility -- and would not be as burdensome as taking daily temps. The hormonal markers provided by the monitor are also more accurate than the standard markers of human fertility used with NFP.I would be gentle with this couple and help them to gradually re-gain acceptance of NFP.Thanks you for your pastoral work. J. FehringProfessorMarquette University PS - maybe Professor could enlighten us on the theory of graduality?-----Original Message-----From: nfpprofessionals [mailto:nfpprofessionals ] On Behalf Of KarelSent: Wednesday, September 08, 2010 4:07 PMTo: nfpprofessionals Subject: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situationDear NFP professionals,I desperately need your competent advice about this extremely difficult situation of a couple I know very well.First of all: I absolutely agree with the Catholic Church teaching about contraception as intrinsically evil act. I am a seminarian with PhD. in psychology (dissertation on psychology of NFP), certified instructor of the STM of NFP (German method), deeply interested in moral theology and theology of the body.Situation, I am absolutely unable to resolve is this:A young Catholic married couple, deeply commited to Church`s teaching on contraception. First pregnancy unplanned, very early after wedding, with no NFP experience. Second pregnancy unplanned and very difficult to accept, because the wife conceived on 50th day (sic!) after delivery of the first child during FULL (EXCLUSIVE) BREASTFEEDING. Third pregnacy unplanned, during the 13th cycle of STM NFP observation. It was a perfect-use pregnancy, as I personally checked. The woman had very soon return of fertility after childbirth despite of full, exclusive, intensive breastfeeding. So, she has 3 children during 4 years now, she is exhausted, with absolutely no confidence in NFP. They did everything they were able to do. Their relationship is now in crisis, because of fear of further pregnancy. Total sexual abstinence is for them unacceptable. They dont want to try NFP once more. Both of them seems to doubt the teaching on immorality of contraception now. They see it as "contra-intuitive". However, the wife told me she is dreading of God`s punishment if they eventually use a barrier contraception. They are totally perplexed.I never met such a situation. I see no moral solution for it. I am inclined to think that the only "solution" is to accept their use of barrier contraceptives with hope for God`s mercy. I it possible they will be able to slowly accept the NFP once more later, but surely not now.What do you think of it?Thank youKarel SkocovskyP.S.: I am little bit angry because we NFP-fans sometimes underestimate difficulties married couples have to face to. I NEVER read anythink about what to do as a priest in such a difficult situation. I am very well aware of almost everything doctrinally orthodox written in English... What about "law of graduality"? I asked E. May on it and he was unable to explain me what it really means in practice... In last month, I met about 2-3 other perplexed couples using contraception with no real hope for change... We frequently present NFP as powerful marriage building tool. But we very often do not speak about long periods of abstinence during non-typical return of fertility after childbirth... ------------------------------------ Quote
Guest guest Posted September 9, 2010 Report Posted September 9, 2010 P-U-S-H ... That is such good advice! > > I am going to gently step out here as I am not catholic, but I am a > professing Christian who is a Billings teacher. Yes, abstinence does have > it's place in marriage, but I think we should be sensitive to the anxiety > that prolonged abstinence may cause some couples. I know that if I were > undergoing the same issue I would not want someone just to tell me to go be > abstinent and " deal with it. " > > The scriptures state in 1 Corinthians 7:5: " Stop depriving one another, > except by agreement for a time, so that you may devote yourselves to prayer, > and come together again so that Satan will not tempt you because of your > lack of self-control. One suggestion that I would make is that this may be a > time as a couple to be abstinent to devote to prayer so that: a) they find a > method they are comfortable with accept that God is in control and is > calling them to grow their family c) obtaining renewed strength (husband > -waiting and wife- waiting and the busyness of mothering young children d) > self control and protection from temptation. Any one of these or all of > the above. Sometimes prayer and waiting is the only answer. I firmly > believe in P-U-S-H - Pray until something happens! This couple needs > encouragement that God knows us and can provide during times of distress. > > > To: nfpprofessionals > From: pedullad@... > Date: Thu, 9 Sep 2010 14:26:58 -0400 > Subject: Re: I need your help: extremely difficult > pastoral situation > > > > > > > Yes Steve but as you well know all methods will fail at least for some > people, and for each method, however good it is, there will be some who > cannot succeed with it; and for some total abstinence will even be easier, > in some ways, than trying yet another approach. This is just life, and in > these cases one still can call on faith and grace, which makes obedience > possible (Eph. 2:8, ff.). > > > Sincerely yours, > > > Dominic M. Pedulla MD, FACC, CNFPMC, ABVM, ACPh > Interventional Cardiologist, Endovascular Diplomate, Varicose Vein > Specialist, Noncontraceptive Family Planning Consultant, Family Planning > Researcher > Medical Director, The Oklahoma Vein and Endovascular Center > (www.noveinok.com, veininfo@...) > Executive Director, The Edith Stein Foundation > (www.theedithsteinfoundation.com) > (office) > (cell) > (FAX) > pedullad@... > > > " And he departed from our sight that we might return to our heart, and there > find Him. For He departed, and behold, He is here. " - St. Augustine > > > > Re: I need your help: extremely difficult > pastoral situation > > > > > If I may ask, is she continuing to breastfeed through her pregnancies and > tandem nursing her babies, and still experiencing early return of fertility? > I myself experienced the return of fertility with my first two babies at 6 > and 5 weeks postpartum, respectively. With the birth of my third, I had > read Breastfeeding and Natural Child Spacing and learned that, at least with > my second, it was probably due to early sleeping through the night. The > third baby was a voracious eater who did not sleep through the night, and > fertility returned at 5 mo pp. Subsequently, I have never weaned a child > before the next was born and have experienced delayed fertility of well past > a year each (three subsequent babies so far). > > > > I certainly empathize with this couple's plight. We needed to commit to > abstain through the first half of my cycles when we truly needed to space > babies. With short luteal phases due to breastfeeding, that often would > only leave a few open days. It is a challenge, but the alternatives are not > good either. Barrier contraceptives can have almost a 40% failure rate! > What really helped us was switching to Creighton and having the in-depth > focus on the mucus sign. We did ours long distance by phone. > > > From one tired mama to another, I will remember this family in my prayers as > they struggle. Thank you for being a faithful witness to this family!-- > Bekah<>< > http://our-family.family-way.net/ > appletreewebdesigns.com > Learn about Home Birth: morebabiespreferhomebirth.com > > > > > > Dear NFP professionals, > I desperately need your competent advice about this extremely difficult > situation of a couple I know very well. > > First of all: I absolutely agree with the Catholic Church teaching about > contraception as intrinsically evil act. I am a seminarian with PhD. in > psychology (dissertation on psychology of NFP), certified instructor of the > STM of NFP (German method), deeply interested in moral theology and theology > of the body. > > Situation, I am absolutely unable to resolve is this: > A young Catholic married couple, deeply commited to Church`s teaching on > contraception. First pregnancy unplanned, very early after wedding, with no > NFP experience. Second pregnancy unplanned and very difficult to accept, > because the wife conceived on 50th day (sic!) after delivery of the first > child during FULL (EXCLUSIVE) BREASTFEEDING. Third pregnacy unplanned, > during the 13th cycle of STM NFP observation. It was a perfect-use > pregnancy, as I personally checked. The woman had very soon return of > fertility after childbirth despite of full, exclusive, intensive > breastfeeding. > > So, she has 3 children during 4 years now, she is exhausted, with absolutely > no confidence in NFP. They did everything they were able to do. Their > relationship is now in crisis, because of fear of further pregnancy. Total > sexual abstinence is for them unacceptable. They dont want to try NFP once > more. Both of them seems to doubt the teaching on immorality of > contraception now. They see it as " contra-intuitive " . However, the wife told > me she is dreading of God`s punishment if they eventually use a barrier > contraception. They are totally perplexed. > > I never met such a situation. I see no moral solution for it. I am inclined > to think that the only „solution " is to accept their use of barrier > contraceptives with hope for God`s mercy. I it possible they will be able to > slowly accept the NFP once more later, but surely not now. > > What do you think of it? > > Thank you > > Karel Skocovsky > > P.S.: I am little bit angry because we NFP-fans sometimes underestimate > difficulties married couples have to face to. I NEVER read anythink about > what to do as a priest in such a difficult situation. I am very well aware > of almost everything doctrinally orthodox written in English... What about > „law of graduality " ? I asked E. May on it and he was unable to > explain me what it really means in practice... In last month, I met about > 2-3 other perplexed couples using contraception with no real hope for > change... We frequently present NFP as powerful marriage building tool. But > we very often do not speak about long periods of abstinence during > non-typical return of fertility after childbirth... > > > > > ------------------------------------ > > Quote
Guest guest Posted September 9, 2010 Report Posted September 9, 2010 Karel: I have attached a list of doctors/fertility care practitioners who practice in Germany. Just in case this couple wants to learn the CREIGHTON MODEL Fertility Care System. It is very difficult to practice any method of natural family planning with a genitocentric mentality. Learning the CM and the SPICE component (Spiritual, physical, intellectual, creative and emotional interaction) helps the couple to find other ways to communicate in times they are avoiding genital contact for serious reasons. Personally we have use and teach NFP for 6 years. We know that avoiding genital contact is challenging but in God everything is possible. In our practice we have never recommended the use of contraception due to the moral issues, serious secondary health effects, and also the failure rate. We have learned that using condoms during the fertile phase will decrease the effectiveness of the NFP method. For instance if a couple is using condoms during the fertile phase and they do not achieve a pregnancy in 6 moths, we are dealing probably with a case of infertility. We will keep this particular couple in our prayers. Liliana Cote de Bejarano MD, MPH, FCPI Quote
Guest guest Posted September 9, 2010 Report Posted September 9, 2010 One possible thought would be to recommend that the couple abstain in the preovulatory time for a few months or indefinitely. Most pregnancies that occur with NFP occur from marital embrace in the preovulatory phase. Once ovulation has been documented with temps and fertility monitors and the evening of the third or fourth day is achieved, they become absolutely infertile and cannot conceive. If this is gently pointed out to them, there is some extended abstinence but for good reason and they are free to do as they will in the post ovulatory phase. Les Ruppersberger, D.O. RE: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Dear Fr. Skocovsky:Thank you for sharing this difficult case -- but one that is not all that unusual.We do know that a small but sizable percentage of women/couples who use NFP ( i.e., around 25%) find it a challenge and are not satisfied with its use. We also know that many of our "modern" methods of NFP can result in extensive amounts of abstinence.I would think that the fear of another pregnancy, the lack of trust of NFP, the exhaustion of raising young children ---and fear of God's punishment -- would lessen the moral wrong (or i.e., sin) and their relationship with God. The fear of God's punishment bothers me -- since, we seek to have his love, care, and understanding. I wonder if she (they) would be willing to use a simple method of NFP along with barriers - until she (they) is/are confident in again using NFP. What I suggest is the use of the ClearBlue Easy Fertility monitor (which is available in Europe) -- along with a simple algorithm -- similar to the European Double check method (they are welcome to chart online at our NFP site http://nfp.marquette.edu . I would also let them know that barriers are no more effective than the use of NFP -- in fact the European Double check is more effective. However, the German's did find that the use of barriers did not lessen the efficacy of the method. The fertility monitor would provide them with a very objective test of fertility -- and would not be as burdensome as taking daily temps. The hormonal markers provided by the monitor are also more accurate than the standard markers of human fertility used with NFP.I would be gentle with this couple and help them to gradually re-gain acceptance of NFP.Thanks you for your pastoral work. J. FehringProfessorMarquette University PS - maybe Professor could enlighten us on the theory of graduality?-----Original Message-----From: nfpprofessionals [mailto:nfpprofessionals ] On Behalf Of KarelSent: Wednesday, September 08, 2010 4:07 PMTo: nfpprofessionals Subject: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situationDear NFP professionals,I desperately need your competent advice about this extremely difficult situation of a couple I know very well.First of all: I absolutely agree with the Catholic Church teaching about contraception as intrinsically evil act. I am a seminarian with PhD. in psychology (dissertation on psychology of NFP), certified instructor of the STM of NFP (German method), deeply interested in moral theology and theology of the body.Situation, I am absolutely unable to resolve is this:A young Catholic married couple, deeply commited to Church`s teaching on contraception. First pregnancy unplanned, very early after wedding, with no NFP experience. Second pregnancy unplanned and very difficult to accept, because the wife conceived on 50th day (sic!) after delivery of the first child during FULL (EXCLUSIVE) BREASTFEEDING. Third pregnacy unplanned, during the 13th cycle of STM NFP observation. It was a perfect-use pregnancy, as I personally checked. The woman had very soon return of fertility after childbirth despite of full, exclusive, intensive breastfeeding. So, she has 3 children during 4 years now, she is exhausted, with absolutely no confidence in NFP. They did everything they were able to do. Their relationship is now in crisis, because of fear of further pregnancy. Total sexual abstinence is for them unacceptable. They dont want to try NFP once more. Both of them seems to doubt the teaching on immorality of contraception now. They see it as "contra-intuitive". However, the wife told me she is dreading of God`s punishment if they eventually use a barrier contraception. They are totally perplexed.I never met such a situation. I see no moral solution for it. I am inclined to think that the only "solution" is to accept their use of barrier contraceptives with hope for God`s mercy. I it possible they will be able to slowly accept the NFP once more later, but surely not now.What do you think of it?Thank youKarel SkocovskyP.S.: I am little bit angry because we NFP-fans sometimes underestimate difficulties married couples have to face to. I NEVER read anythink about what to do as a priest in such a difficult situation. I am very well aware of almost everything doctrinally orthodox written in English... What about "law of graduality"? I asked E. May on it and he was unable to explain me what it really means in practice... In last month, I met about 2-3 other perplexed couples using contraception with no real hope for change... We frequently present NFP as powerful marriage building tool. But we very often do not speak about long periods of abstinence during non-typical return of fertility after childbirth... ------------------------------------ Quote
Guest guest Posted September 10, 2010 Report Posted September 10, 2010 I would suggest that the couple pray for intercession of the Blessed Virgin and St. ph. They lived marriage in a way that none of us have done.... and would know the grace they need.Amy Hogan, MD PS The post peak progesterone (one blood test per month approximately) via Pope VI was mentioned and could be a scientific way to prove ovulation has passed was mentioned by another clinician earlier.... could help too. Jesus was poked and prodded on the cross.... it could be offered up if it was considered suffering to get a blood draw.... Pope VI has a very reasonable rate for the price of the lab. www.popepaulvi.com One possible thought would be to recommend that the couple abstain in the preovulatory time for a few months or indefinitely. Most pregnancies that occur with NFP occur from marital embrace in the preovulatory phase. Once ovulation has been documented with temps and fertility monitors and the evening of the third or fourth day is achieved, they become absolutely infertile and cannot conceive. If this is gently pointed out to them, there is some extended abstinence but for good reason and they are free to do as they will in the post ovulatory phase. Les Ruppersberger, D.O. RE: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Dear Fr. Skocovsky:Thank you for sharing this difficult case -- but one that is not all that unusual.We do know that a small but sizable percentage of women/couples who use NFP ( i.e., around 25%) find it a challenge and are not satisfied with its use. We also know that many of our " modern " methods of NFP can result in extensive amounts of abstinence. I would think that the fear of another pregnancy, the lack of trust of NFP, the exhaustion of raising young children ---and fear of God's punishment -- would lessen the moral wrong (or i.e., sin) and their relationship with God. The fear of God's punishment bothers me -- since, we seek to have his love, care, and understanding. I wonder if she (they) would be willing to use a simple method of NFP along with barriers - until she (they) is/are confident in again using NFP. What I suggest is the use of the ClearBlue Easy Fertility monitor (which is available in Europe) -- along with a simple algorithm -- similar to the European Double check method (they are welcome to chart online at our NFP site http://nfp.marquette.edu . I would also let them know that barriers are no more effective than the use of NFP -- in fact the European Double check is more effective. However, the German's did find that the use of barriers did not lessen the efficacy of the method. The fertility monitor would provide them with a very objective test of fertility -- and would not be as burdensome as taking daily temps. The hormonal markers provided by the monitor are also more accurate than the standard markers of human fertility used with NFP. I would be gentle with this couple and help them to gradually re-gain acceptance of NFP.Thanks you for your pastoral work. J. FehringProfessorMarquette University PS - maybe Professor could enlighten us on the theory of graduality? -----Original Message-----From: nfpprofessionals [mailto:nfpprofessionals ] On Behalf Of Karel Sent: Wednesday, September 08, 2010 4:07 PMTo: nfpprofessionals Subject: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Dear NFP professionals,I desperately need your competent advice about this extremely difficult situation of a couple I know very well.First of all: I absolutely agree with the Catholic Church teaching about contraception as intrinsically evil act. I am a seminarian with PhD. in psychology (dissertation on psychology of NFP), certified instructor of the STM of NFP (German method), deeply interested in moral theology and theology of the body. Situation, I am absolutely unable to resolve is this:A young Catholic married couple, deeply commited to Church`s teaching on contraception. First pregnancy unplanned, very early after wedding, with no NFP experience. Second pregnancy unplanned and very difficult to accept, because the wife conceived on 50th day (sic!) after delivery of the first child during FULL (EXCLUSIVE) BREASTFEEDING. Third pregnacy unplanned, during the 13th cycle of STM NFP observation. It was a perfect-use pregnancy, as I personally checked. The woman had very soon return of fertility after childbirth despite of full, exclusive, intensive breastfeeding. So, she has 3 children during 4 years now, she is exhausted, with absolutely no confidence in NFP. They did everything they were able to do. Their relationship is now in crisis, because of fear of further pregnancy. Total sexual abstinence is for them unacceptable. They dont want to try NFP once more. Both of them seems to doubt the teaching on immorality of contraception now. They see it as " contra-intuitive " . However, the wife told me she is dreading of God`s punishment if they eventually use a barrier contraception. They are totally perplexed. I never met such a situation. I see no moral solution for it. I am inclined to think that the only " solution " is to accept their use of barrier contraceptives with hope for God`s mercy. I it possible they will be able to slowly accept the NFP once more later, but surely not now. What do you think of it?Thank youKarel SkocovskyP.S.: I am little bit angry because we NFP-fans sometimes underestimate difficulties married couples have to face to. I NEVER read anythink about what to do as a priest in such a difficult situation. I am very well aware of almost everything doctrinally orthodox written in English... What about " law of graduality " ? I asked E. May on it and he was unable to explain me what it really means in practice... In last month, I met about 2-3 other perplexed couples using contraception with no real hope for change... We frequently present NFP as powerful marriage building tool. But we very often do not speak about long periods of abstinence during non-typical return of fertility after childbirth... ------------------------------------ Quote
Guest guest Posted September 10, 2010 Report Posted September 10, 2010 The idea of a monthly blood draw to determine post-peak progesterone strikes me as expensive and highly unnecessary except perhaps in a situation of real medical necessity. That speaks to me of the "medicalization of NFP" which I think would be most unfortunate. Why not teach the observation of the temperature sign? How else does one explain a well elevated temperature pattern that cross-checks the drying-up of cervical mucus? Even with the possibility of a luteinized follicle that did not release an ovum, the elevated temps still provide a prima facie indication of the presence of progesterone. I suggest that anyone who has not read Dr. Doering's report on his temperature-only study should certainly read it. It's available at the NFPI website. http://www.nfpandmore.org/Doering-1967-100315.pdf I realize that Dr. Billings and his associates have warned for decades about the danger of the temperature sign -- that it is so easy and so good that women will ignore the mucus sign. There is something to be said for that criticism. The answer is not to ignore the temperature sign but to educate couples that the mucus and cervix signs can provide them information in difficult pre-ovulation situations that is simply not available only from the post-ovulation rise in temps. Further, the time to learn all the signs is during the years of normal fertility. Why not let couples make their own choices based on full disclosure? And if a woman is deficient in progesterone, is there any evidence that natural progesterone applied transdermally or via vaginal suppositories does not also do the job? A few years ago Dr. Lee became a publishing sensation for his books publicizing the value of natural progesterone applied transdermally. He also warned about the abortifacient potential of a sudden withdrawal of this supplement. F KippleyNFP Internationalwww.NFPandmore.org RE: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Dear Fr. Skocovsky:Thank you for sharing this difficult case -- but one that is not all that unusual.We do know that a small but sizable percentage of women/couples who use NFP ( i.e., around 25%) find it a challenge and are not satisfied with its use. We also know that many of our "modern" methods of NFP can result in extensive amounts of abstinence.I would think that the fear of another pregnancy, the lack of trust of NFP, the exhaustion of raising young children ---and fear of God's punishment -- would lessen the moral wrong (or i.e., sin) and their relationship with God. The fear of God's punishment bothers me -- since, we seek to have his love, care, and understanding. I wonder if she (they) would be willing to use a simple method of NFP along with barriers - until she (they) is/are confident in again using NFP. What I suggest is the use of the ClearBlue Easy Fertility monitor (which is available in Europe) -- along with a simple algorithm -- similar to the European Double check method (they are welcome to chart online at our NFP site http://nfp.marquette.edu . I would also let them know that barriers are no more effective than the use of NFP -- in fact the European Double check is more effective. However, the German's did find that the use of barriers did not lessen the efficacy of the method. The fertility monitor would provide them with a very objective test of fertility -- and would not be as burdensome as taking daily temps. The hormonal markers provided by the monitor are also more accurate than the standard markers of human fertility used with NFP.I would be gentle with this couple and help them to gradually re-gain acceptance of NFP.Thanks you for your pastoral work. J. FehringProfessorMarquette University PS - maybe Professor could enlighten us on the theory of graduality?-----Original Message-----From: nfpprofessionals [mailto:nfpprofessionals ] On Behalf Of KarelSent: Wednesday, September 08, 2010 4:07 PMTo: nfpprofessionals Subject: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situationDear NFP professionals,I desperately need your competent advice about this extremely difficult situation of a couple I know very well.First of all: I absolutely agree with the Catholic Church teaching about contraception as intrinsically evil act. I am a seminarian with PhD. in psychology (dissertation on psychology of NFP), certified instructor of the STM of NFP (German method), deeply interested in moral theology and theology of the body.Situation, I am absolutely unable to resolve is this:A young Catholic married couple, deeply commited to Church`s teaching on contraception. First pregnancy unplanned, very early after wedding, with no NFP experience. Second pregnancy unplanned and very difficult to accept, because the wife conceived on 50th day (sic!) after delivery of the first child during FULL (EXCLUSIVE) BREASTFEEDING. Third pregnacy unplanned, during the 13th cycle of STM NFP observation. It was a perfect-use pregnancy, as I personally checked. The woman had very soon return of fertility after childbirth despite of full, exclusive, intensive breastfeeding. So, she has 3 children during 4 years now, she is exhausted, with absolutely no confidence in NFP. They did everything they were able to do. Their relationship is now in crisis, because of fear of further pregnancy. Total sexual abstinence is for them unacceptable. They dont want to try NFP once more. Both of them seems to doubt the teaching on immorality of contraception now. They see it as "contra-intuitive". However, the wife told me she is dreading of God`s punishment if they eventually use a barrier contraception. They are totally perplexed.I never met such a situation. I see no moral solution for it. I am inclined to think that the only "solution" is to accept their use of barrier contraceptives with hope for God`s mercy. I it possible they will be able to slowly accept the NFP once more later, but surely not now.What do you think of it?Thank youKarel SkocovskyP.S.: I am little bit angry because we NFP-fans sometimes underestimate difficulties married couples have to face to. I NEVER read anythink about what to do as a priest in such a difficult situation. I am very well aware of almost everything doctrinally orthodox written in English... What about "law of graduality"? I asked E. May on it and he was unable to explain me what it really means in practice... In last month, I met about 2-3 other perplexed couples using contraception with no real hope for change... We frequently present NFP as powerful marriage building tool. But we very often do not speak about long periods of abstinence during non-typical return of fertility after childbirth... ------------------------------------ Quote
Guest guest Posted September 11, 2010 Report Posted September 11, 2010 (and all),Post peak progesterone is a resort when it is absolutely necessary to avoid pregnancy. We certainly don't recommend it to everyone.I live in a medical world, , " medicalizing NFP " is what I do all day!!! We live in a world where people need to hear about and understand their bodies no matter which direction it is coming from- the pulpit or the doctor or their grandmother.... everyone needs to understand the goodness of the body. Medical is not evil. Medical means it has been studied and applied to the wellness of the body. People come to me because they need help with problem cycles. As my FertilityCARE instructor says- I get all the " problem children " . I am thankful that many women and their husbands can learn NFP and not need a doctor to intervene. But because of our terrible diet, culture, and sexual morality of this world, there are a lot of broken people. I am not opposed to temperatures. I have used them myself personally for a time when I was postpartum. I think whatever we can do, that is still in accord with our natures as divinely created beings, to help the body work better can be applied. Thanks for listening,Amy Hogan, MD The idea of a monthly blood draw to determine post-peak progesterone strikes me as expensive and highly unnecessary except perhaps in a situation of real medical necessity. That speaks to me of the " medicalization of NFP " which I think would be most unfortunate. Why not teach the observation of the temperature sign? How else does one explain a well elevated temperature pattern that cross-checks the drying-up of cervical mucus? Even with the possibility of a luteinized follicle that did not release an ovum, the elevated temps still provide a prima facie indication of the presence of progesterone. I suggest that anyone who has not read Dr. Doering's report on his temperature-only study should certainly read it. It's available at the NFPI website. http://www.nfpandmore.org/Doering-1967-100315.pdf I realize that Dr. Billings and his associates have warned for decades about the danger of the temperature sign -- that it is so easy and so good that women will ignore the mucus sign. There is something to be said for that criticism. The answer is not to ignore the temperature sign but to educate couples that the mucus and cervix signs can provide them information in difficult pre-ovulation situations that is simply not available only from the post-ovulation rise in temps. Further, the time to learn all the signs is during the years of normal fertility. Why not let couples make their own choices based on full disclosure? And if a woman is deficient in progesterone, is there any evidence that natural progesterone applied transdermally or via vaginal suppositories does not also do the job? A few years ago Dr. Lee became a publishing sensation for his books publicizing the value of natural progesterone applied transdermally. He also warned about the abortifacient potential of a sudden withdrawal of this supplement. F KippleyNFP Internationalwww.NFPandmore.org RE: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Dear Fr. Skocovsky:Thank you for sharing this difficult case -- but one that is not all that unusual.We do know that a small but sizable percentage of women/couples who use NFP ( i.e., around 25%) find it a challenge and are not satisfied with its use. We also know that many of our " modern " methods of NFP can result in extensive amounts of abstinence.I would think that the fear of another pregnancy, the lack of trust of NFP, the exhaustion of raising young children ---and fear of God's punishment -- would lessen the moral wrong (or i.e., sin) and their relationship with God. The fear of God's punishment bothers me -- since, we seek to have his love, care, and understanding. I wonder if she (they) would be willing to use a simple method of NFP along with barriers - until she (they) is/are confident in again using NFP. What I suggest is the use of the ClearBlue Easy Fertility monitor (which is available in Europe) -- along with a simple algorithm -- similar to the European Double check method (they are welcome to chart online at our NFP site http://nfp.marquette.edu . I would also let them know that barriers are no more effective than the use of NFP -- in fact the European Double check is more effective. However, the German's did find that the use of barriers did not lessen the efficacy of the method. The fertility monitor would provide them with a very objective test of fertility -- and would not be as burdensome as taking daily temps. The hormonal markers provided by the monitor are also more accurate than the standard markers of human fertility used with NFP.I would be gentle with this couple and help them to gradually re-gain acceptance of NFP.Thanks you for your pastoral work. J. FehringProfessorMarquette University PS - maybe Professor could enlighten us on the theory of graduality?-----Original Message-----From: nfpprofessionals [mailto:nfpprofessionals ] On Behalf Of KarelSent: Wednesday, September 08, 2010 4:07 PMTo: nfpprofessionals Subject: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situationDear NFP professionals,I desperately need your competent advice about this extremely difficult situation of a couple I know very well.First of all: I absolutely agree with the Catholic Church teaching about contraception as intrinsically evil act. I am a seminarian with PhD. in psychology (dissertation on psychology of NFP), certified instructor of the STM of NFP (German method), deeply interested in moral theology and theology of the body.Situation, I am absolutely unable to resolve is this:A young Catholic married couple, deeply commited to Church`s teaching on contraception. First pregnancy unplanned, very early after wedding, with no NFP experience. Second pregnancy unplanned and very difficult to accept, because the wife conceived on 50th day (sic!) after delivery of the first child during FULL (EXCLUSIVE) BREASTFEEDING. Third pregnacy unplanned, during the 13th cycle of STM NFP observation. It was a perfect-use pregnancy, as I personally checked. The woman had very soon return of fertility after childbirth despite of full, exclusive, intensive breastfeeding. So, she has 3 children during 4 years now, she is exhausted, with absolutely no confidence in NFP. They did everything they were able to do. Their relationship is now in crisis, because of fear of further pregnancy. Total sexual abstinence is for them unacceptable. They dont want to try NFP once more. Both of them seems to doubt the teaching on immorality of contraception now. They see it as " contra-intuitive " . However, the wife told me she is dreading of God`s punishment if they eventually use a barrier contraception. They are totally perplexed.I never met such a situation. I see no moral solution for it. I am inclined to think that the only " solution " is to accept their use of barrier contraceptives with hope for God`s mercy. I it possible they will be able to slowly accept the NFP once more later, but surely not now.What do you think of it?Thank youKarel SkocovskyP.S.: I am little bit angry because we NFP-fans sometimes underestimate difficulties married couples have to face to. I NEVER read anythink about what to do as a priest in such a difficult situation. I am very well aware of almost everything doctrinally orthodox written in English... What about " law of graduality " ? I asked E. May on it and he was unable to explain me what it really means in practice... In last month, I met about 2-3 other perplexed couples using contraception with no real hope for change... We frequently present NFP as powerful marriage building tool. But we very often do not speak about long periods of abstinence during non-typical return of fertility after childbirth... ------------------------------------ Quote
Guest guest Posted September 13, 2010 Report Posted September 13, 2010 Roetzer had mothers chart mucus and temperature at 3 months postpartum for his study. With exclusive breastfeeding he found any occurrence of mucus, even egg-white, and any bleeding or periods could be ignored for the first 12 weeks postpartum. He had certain rules for exclusive breastfeeding and had more than 2000 postpartum charts observed for this conclusion. (Natural Conception Regulation by f Reotzer, 2002) Since the Bellagio Consensus, LAM has been studied many times at different sites throughout the world and the 56 day rule has also been studied. Thus the Bellagio Consensus was tested or studied and proven to be accurate. Of interest, in 1966 and I had no knowledge of the temperature sign, the mucus sign and the cervix sign. There is something to be said for keeping a rule simple. At that time our Catholic Ob/Gyn taught the temperature sign, but he knew I wanted to breastfeed. His rule: Do nothing but exclusive breastfeeding (no water, no juice, nothing except your milk) and call me when your first period returns. Our pediatrician would not tell me when to start solids even though I asked. He knew the advice I was given. Our baby began to show teeth at 8 months so I took that as a sign to start solids. Menstruation returned a year after childbirth. We moved to Canada at that time and I regret I did not call and thank the Ob/Gyn doctor for his advice. It did take several months while nursing to achieve pregnancy. Sheila K. KippleyNFP Internationalwww.NFPandmore.orgThe Seven Standards of Ecological BreastfeedingBreastfeeding and Catholic Motherhood I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Dear NFP professionals,I desperately need your competent advice about this extremely difficult situation of a couple I know very well.First of all: I absolutely agree with the Catholic Church teaching about contraception as intrinsically evil act. I am a seminarian with PhD. in psychology (dissertation on psychology of NFP), certified instructor of the STM of NFP (German method), deeply interested in moral theology and theology of the body.Situation, I am absolutely unable to resolve is this:A young Catholic married couple, deeply commited to Church`s teaching on contraception. First pregnancy unplanned, very early after wedding, with no NFP experience. Second pregnancy unplanned and very difficult to accept, because the wife conceived on 50th day (sic!) after delivery of the first child during FULL (EXCLUSIVE) BREASTFEEDING. Third pregnacy unplanned, during the 13th cycle of STM NFP observation. It was a perfect-use pregnancy, as I personally checked. The woman had very soon return of fertility after childbirth despite of full, exclusive, intensive breastfeeding. So, she has 3 children during 4 years now, she is exhausted, with absolutely no confidence in NFP. They did everything they were able to do. Their relationship is now in crisis, because of fear of further pregnancy. Total sexual abstinence is for them unacceptable. They dont want to try NFP once more. Both of them seems to doubt the teaching on immorality of contraception now. They see it as "contra-intuitive". However, the wife told me she is dreading of God`s punishment if they eventually use a barrier contraception. They are totally perplexed.I never met such a situation. I see no moral solution for it. I am inclined to think that the only "solution" is to accept their use of barrier contraceptives with hope for God`s mercy. I it possible they will be able to slowly accept the NFP once more later, but surely not now.What do you think of it?Thank youKarel SkocovskyP.S.: I am little bit angry because we NFP-fans sometimes underestimate difficulties married couples have to face to. I NEVER read anythink about what to do as a priest in such a difficult situation. I am very well aware of almost everything doctrinally orthodox written in English... What about "law of graduality"? I asked E. May on it and he was unable to explain me what it really means in practice... In last month, I met about 2-3 other perplexed couples using contraception with no real hope for change... We frequently present NFP as powerful marriage building tool. But we very often do not speak about long periods of abstinence during non-typical return of fertility after childbirth... Quote
Guest guest Posted September 15, 2010 Report Posted September 15, 2010 Thank you for your thorough response. It is much appreciated. a Van UdenBillings Ovulation Method Instructorwww.billingsnaturalfamilyplanning.orgwww.nfpcharting.comBillings Lethbridge Facebook GroupTo: nfpprofessionals From: audrey.smith@...Date: Wed, 15 Sep 2010 15:20:52 +1000Subject: Re: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Dear List Members In response to a’s comments on billingsMentor. (www.billingsMentor.org) a Van Uden wrote: I do think billingsmentor can be a very helpful tool, but I do not think it is an adequate substitute for the personalized support of a teacher - especially for clients feeling distressed about NFP. No software or program would be, it cannot communicate with the client about their misunderstandings or concerns. Any sort of tool like this used in conjunction with the personalized support of a teacher can be very useful! Used apart from personalized support, I have concerns. Reply: There are approximately 1.5 billion fertile women in the world. How many NFP teachers are there? a Van Uden wrote: "If the woman observes and records properly then the system performs the other NFP tasks of charting." This is precisely what concerns me. What if she's confused about what she's observing or what to record? Reply: billingsMentor is a learning tool. It always leads the woman to guidance, for both observing and recording. In teaching situations the woman can remain confused for days or weeks before she makes contact with a teacher. If the woman enters a daily record into billingsMentor it is examined in context and feed back is given immediately. a Van Uden wrote: What if she creates phony observations to try to make the software perform a charting task? Perhaps she is ignoring her actual observations and putting in what she thinks she should be observing at a particular time? Reply: That sort of behaviour is treated on its merits in billingsMentor and can be the basis for learning. If a woman wants to experiment with different charting situations that are not her own, she is able to do this to her benefit. This is the classic tutorial method used in most learning environments. a Van Uden wrote: Clients do this on their paper charts all the time when they are unsure. This is the sort of thing instructors watch for and discuss during follow-ups, whether they are face to face or by phone or by email. Reply: billingsMentor is an interactive system and gives the user feedback in real time. a Van Uden wrote: If the observation itself isn't done accurately, using the right stamp or applying the right rule will be irrelevant. I've instructed many long distance clients by email (not ideal, but do-able). It's been my experience that most clients simply want to be able to check in with a real person when they have questions or when they are anxious - even if that contact is by phone or email. Reply: The first aim of billingsMentor is to ensure that observation and recording are done well. Clients do not contact a teacher every time an uncertainty arises, that is typical human behaviour. billingsMentor detects when the descriptions of the symptoms are not yielding an interpretable pattern and advises the user to contact our teaching staff. a Van Uden wrote: I don't think the developers of billingsmentor should ignore that need, but find ways to work with it. This is what the developer of nfpcharting.com has done. The nfpcharting.com client charts are very accessible to instructors. We simply log in to our account, click on the client's chart in our Student List, and there it is! We can be on the phone together, the client makes the corrections as we discuss them, I hit "refresh" - and there is the updated chart on my screen. No transferring of attachments back and forth. It's instant and it's simple. Reply: The developer of billingsMentor pioneered that type of facility in the 1990’s. It has been available on www.woomb.org for the last eight years and more than a thousand women have been taught successfully that way. However the vast majority of people who visit the service do not proceed. Reasons are fears about privacy, payment for service (people are looking for free information on the internet) and the accepted learning paradigm for the internet which is self education. a Van Uden wrote: The objective isn't to do the charting for them, but to empower them to do the charting for themselves with confidence. It's to empower them with the understanding of what their observations mean and why the different rules are applied at different times. Maybe we should be discussing how to provide more online instructors for those who don't have one locally? My concern is that a computer program, by itself, may not be the best solution. Reply: The problem of remote location of a teacher has been answered by the internet. Because a system can make a decision on behalf of the woman does not mean it does not provide a learning opportunity. As already stated the woman is free to experiment with all sorts of patterns as a learning method. One of the main impacts of billingsMentor will be for post adolescent teenagers who can now learn fertility awareness in the privacy of their own PC or laptop or in the future on a portable device. Audrey Re: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Dear List Members, I am very familiar with billingsMentor. If a woman or couple have convenient access to good instruction, this is the advisable way for them to obtain assistance. billingsMentor is helping women who do not have this opportunity or choose, for a variety of reasons, not to use the face to face way of learning. billingsMentor represents a major step forward in e-learning for NFP (in this case the Billings Method). Of course the various methods of NFP have their different instructions for observations and have their own rules. We should be very clear about this. billingsMentor aims to teach a beginner how to observe and record her fertility symptoms. So it is not surprising that an experienced teacher would find data entry time consuming. There are novice and advanced levels which allow more streamlined data entry. If the woman observes and records properly then the system performs the other NFP tasks of charting (including stamp selection, Peak and BIP recognition) and rule interpretation for her. billingsMentor can be used as a learning system or for decision support by a person who is uncertain about the rules. billingsMentor can be used for teaching when both teacher and client have the software installed. The documents are transferred by email attachment. We believe that billingsMentor will prove very helpful for post adolescent teenagers who can now learn fertility awareness just by following the guidance in the privacy of their own PC or laptop. In future it is intended to release versions for the new portable devices. In response to a’s comment “The program actually messed up my computer quite badly“, I have spoken to the developer of billingsMentor who tells me billingsMentor is implemented using industry standard tools for Microsoft Windows. It is extremely unlikely that billingsMentor could cause a problem with a computer. billingsMentor can be downloaded at www.billingsmentor.org There is a free trial period of 35 days without obligation. A licence costs $20 one-off payment per computer. Audrey Quote
Guest guest Posted September 15, 2010 Report Posted September 15, 2010 ....or maybe we should be looking into excellent technologies that have the capability of eliminating the need for charting in the first place!! That's why after all Dr. JOHN BROWN (may he rest in peace) went out of his way in the 1980s seminal paper he authored, to mention that given the choice women place more confidence in monitor technology than charting. Like it or not, that's what he wrote. (But of course charting is wholly necessary in the absence of anything better, as I'm quite sure we all agree.) The objective isn't to do the charting for them, but to empower them to do the charting for themselves with confidence. It's to empower them with the understanding of what their observations mean and why the different rules are applied at different times. Maybe we should be discussing how to provide more online instructors for those who don't have one locally? Sincerely yours, Dominic M. Pedulla MD, FACC, CNFPMC, ABVM, ACPh Interventional Cardiologist, Endovascular Diplomate, Varicose Vein Specialist, Noncontraceptive Family Planning Consultant, Family Planning Researcher Medical Director, The Oklahoma Vein and Endovascular Center (www.noveinok.com, veininfo@...) Executive Director, The Edith Stein Foundation (www.theedithsteinfoundation.com) (office) (cell) (FAX) pedullad@... "And he departed from our sight that we might return to our heart, and there find Him. For He departed, and behold, He is here." - St. Augustine Re: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Dear List Members In response to a’s comments on billingsMentor. (www.billingsMentor.org) a Van Uden wrote: I do think billingsmentor can be a very helpful tool, but I do not think it is an adequate substitute for the personalized support of a teacher - especially for clients feeling distressed about NFP. No software or program would be, it cannot communicate with the client about their misunderstandings or concerns. Any sort of tool like this used in conjunction with the personalized support of a teacher can be very useful! Used apart from personalized support, I have concerns. Reply: There are approximately 1.5 billion fertile women in the world. How many NFP teachers are there? a Van Uden wrote: "If the woman observes and records properly then the system performs the other NFP tasks of charting." This is precisely what concerns me. What if she's confused about what she's observing or what to record? Reply: billingsMentor is a learning tool. It always leads the woman to guidance, for both observing and recording. In teaching situations the woman can remain confused for days or weeks before she makes contact with a teacher. If the woman enters a daily record into billingsMentor it is examined in context and feed back is given immediately. a Van Uden wrote: What if she creates phony observations to try to make the software perform a charting task? Perhaps she is ignoring her actual observations and putting in what she thinks she should be observing at a particular time? Reply: That sort of behaviour is treated on its merits in billingsMentor and can be the basis for learning. If a woman wants to experiment with different charting situations that are not her own, she is able to do this to her benefit. This is the classic tutorial method used in most learning environments. a Van Uden wrote: Clients do this on their paper charts all the time when they are unsure. This is the sort of thing instructors watch for and discuss during follow-ups, whether they are face to face or by phone or by email. Reply: billingsMentor is an interactive system and gives the user feedback in real time. a Van Uden wrote: If the observation itself isn't done accurately, using the right stamp or applying the right rule will be irrelevant. I've instructed many long distance clients by email (not ideal, but do-able). It's been my experience that most clients simply want to be able to check in with a real person when they have questions or when they are anxious - even if that contact is by phone or email. Reply: The first aim of billingsMentor is to ensure that observation and recording are done well. Clients do not contact a teacher every time an uncertainty arises, that is typical human behaviour. billingsMentor detects when the descriptions of the symptoms are not yielding an interpretable pattern and advises the user to contact our teaching staff. a Van Uden wrote: I don't think the developers of billingsmentor should ignore that need, but find ways to work with it. This is what the developer of nfpcharting.com has done. The nfpcharting.com client charts are very accessible to instructors. We simply log in to our account, click on the client's chart in our Student List, and there it is! We can be on the phone together, the client makes the corrections as we discuss them, I hit "refresh" - and there is the updated chart on my screen. No transferring of attachments back and forth. It's instant and it's simple. Reply: The developer of billingsMentor pioneered that type of facility in the 1990’s. It has been available on www.woomb.org for the last eight years and more than a thousand women have been taught successfully that way. However the vast majority of people who visit the service do not proceed. Reasons are fears about privacy, payment for service (people are looking for free information on the internet) and the accepted learning paradigm for the internet which is self education. a Van Uden wrote: The objective isn't to do the charting for them, but to empower them to do the charting for themselves with confidence. It's to empower them with the understanding of what their observations mean and why the different rules are applied at different times. Maybe we should be discussing how to provide more online instructors for those who don't have one locally? My concern is that a computer program, by itself, may not be the best solution. Reply: The problem of remote location of a teacher has been answered by the internet. Because a system can make a decision on behalf of the woman does not mean it does not provide a learning opportunity. As already stated the woman is free to experiment with all sorts of patterns as a learning method. One of the main impacts of billingsMentor will be for post adolescent teenagers who can now learn fertility awareness in the privacy of their own PC or laptop or in the future on a portable device. Audrey Re: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Dear List Members, I am very familiar with billingsMentor. If a woman or couple have convenient access to good instruction, this is the advisable way for them to obtain assistance. billingsMentor is helping women who do not have this opportunity or choose, for a variety of reasons, not to use the face to face way of learning. billingsMentor represents a major step forward in e-learning for NFP (in this case the Billings Method). Of course the various methods of NFP have their different instructions for observations and have their own rules. We should be very clear about this. billingsMentor aims to teach a beginner how to observe and record her fertility symptoms. So it is not surprising that an experienced teacher would find data entry time consuming. There are novice and advanced levels which allow more streamlined data entry. If the woman observes and records properly then the system performs the other NFP tasks of charting (including stamp selection, Peak and BIP recognition) and rule interpretation for her. billingsMentor can be used as a learning system or for decision support by a person who is uncertain about the rules. billingsMentor can be used for teaching when both teacher and client have the software installed. The documents are transferred by email attachment. We believe that billingsMentor will prove very helpful for post adolescent teenagers who can now learn fertility awareness just by following the guidance in the privacy of their own PC or laptop. In future it is intended to release versions for the new portable devices. In response to a’s comment “The program actually messed up my computer quite badly“, I have spoken to the developer of billingsMentor who tells me billingsMentor is implemented using industry standard tools for Microsoft Windows. It is extremely unlikely that billingsMentor could cause a problem with a computer. billingsMentor can be downloaded at www.billingsmentor.org There is a free trial period of 35 days without obligation. A licence costs $20 one-off payment per computer. Audrey Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.