Guest guest Posted September 15, 2010 Report Posted September 15, 2010 When the monitor is developed that will eradicate charting, I'll host a chart burning party myself! :)a Van UdenBillings Ovulation Method Instructorwww.billingsnaturalfamilyplanning.orgwww.nfpcharting.comBillings Lethbridge Facebook GroupTo: nfpprofessionals From: pedullad@...Date: Wed, 15 Sep 2010 09:23:55 -0400Subject: Re: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation ....or maybe we should be looking into excellent technologies that have the capability of eliminating the need for charting in the first place!! That's why after all Dr. JOHN BROWN (may he rest in peace) went out of his way in the 1980s seminal paper he authored, to mention that given the choice women place more confidence in monitor technology than charting. Like it or not, that's what he wrote. (But of course charting is wholly necessary in the absence of anything better, as I'm quite sure we all agree.) The objective isn't to do the charting for them, but to empower them to do the charting for themselves with confidence. It's to empower them with the understanding of what their observations mean and why the different rules are applied at different times. Maybe we should be discussing how to provide more online instructors for those who don't have one locally? Sincerely yours, Dominic M. Pedulla MD, FACC, CNFPMC, ABVM, ACPh Interventional Cardiologist, Endovascular Diplomate, Varicose Vein Specialist, Noncontraceptive Family Planning Consultant, Family Planning Researcher Medical Director, The Oklahoma Vein and Endovascular Center (www.noveinok.com, veininfo@...) Executive Director, The Edith Stein Foundation (www.theedithsteinfoundation.com) (office) (cell) (FAX) pedullad@... "And he departed from our sight that we might return to our heart, and there find Him. For He departed, and behold, He is here." - St. Augustine Re: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Dear List Members In response to a’s comments on billingsMentor. (www.billingsMentor.org) a Van Uden wrote: I do think billingsmentor can be a very helpful tool, but I do not think it is an adequate substitute for the personalized support of a teacher - especially for clients feeling distressed about NFP. No software or program would be, it cannot communicate with the client about their misunderstandings or concerns. Any sort of tool like this used in conjunction with the personalized support of a teacher can be very useful! Used apart from personalized support, I have concerns. Reply: There are approximately 1.5 billion fertile women in the world. How many NFP teachers are there? a Van Uden wrote: "If the woman observes and records properly then the system performs the other NFP tasks of charting." This is precisely what concerns me. What if she's confused about what she's observing or what to record? Reply: billingsMentor is a learning tool. It always leads the woman to guidance, for both observing and recording. In teaching situations the woman can remain confused for days or weeks before she makes contact with a teacher. If the woman enters a daily record into billingsMentor it is examined in context and feed back is given immediately. a Van Uden wrote: What if she creates phony observations to try to make the software perform a charting task? Perhaps she is ignoring her actual observations and putting in what she thinks she should be observing at a particular time? Reply: That sort of behaviour is treated on its merits in billingsMentor and can be the basis for learning. If a woman wants to experiment with different charting situations that are not her own, she is able to do this to her benefit. This is the classic tutorial method used in most learning environments. a Van Uden wrote: Clients do this on their paper charts all the time when they are unsure. This is the sort of thing instructors watch for and discuss during follow-ups, whether they are face to face or by phone or by email. Reply: billingsMentor is an interactive system and gives the user feedback in real time. a Van Uden wrote: If the observation itself isn't done accurately, using the right stamp or applying the right rule will be irrelevant. I've instructed many long distance clients by email (not ideal, but do-able). It's been my experience that most clients simply want to be able to check in with a real person when they have questions or when they are anxious - even if that contact is by phone or email. Reply: The first aim of billingsMentor is to ensure that observation and recording are done well. Clients do not contact a teacher every time an uncertainty arises, that is typical human behaviour. billingsMentor detects when the descriptions of the symptoms are not yielding an interpretable pattern and advises the user to contact our teaching staff. a Van Uden wrote: I don't think the developers of billingsmentor should ignore that need, but find ways to work with it. This is what the developer of nfpcharting.com has done. The nfpcharting.com client charts are very accessible to instructors. We simply log in to our account, click on the client's chart in our Student List, and there it is! We can be on the phone together, the client makes the corrections as we discuss them, I hit "refresh" - and there is the updated chart on my screen. No transferring of attachments back and forth. It's instant and it's simple. Reply: The developer of billingsMentor pioneered that type of facility in the 1990’s. It has been available on www.woomb.org for the last eight years and more than a thousand women have been taught successfully that way. However the vast majority of people who visit the service do not proceed. Reasons are fears about privacy, payment for service (people are looking for free information on the internet) and the accepted learning paradigm for the internet which is self education. a Van Uden wrote: The objective isn't to do the charting for them, but to empower them to do the charting for themselves with confidence. It's to empower them with the understanding of what their observations mean and why the different rules are applied at different times. Maybe we should be discussing how to provide more online instructors for those who don't have one locally? My concern is that a computer program, by itself, may not be the best solution. Reply: The problem of remote location of a teacher has been answered by the internet. Because a system can make a decision on behalf of the woman does not mean it does not provide a learning opportunity. As already stated the woman is free to experiment with all sorts of patterns as a learning method. One of the main impacts of billingsMentor will be for post adolescent teenagers who can now learn fertility awareness in the privacy of their own PC or laptop or in the future on a portable device. Audrey Re: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Dear List Members, I am very familiar with billingsMentor. If a woman or couple have convenient access to good instruction, this is the advisable way for them to obtain assistance. billingsMentor is helping women who do not have this opportunity or choose, for a variety of reasons, not to use the face to face way of learning. billingsMentor represents a major step forward in e-learning for NFP (in this case the Billings Method). Of course the various methods of NFP have their different instructions for observations and have their own rules. We should be very clear about this. billingsMentor aims to teach a beginner how to observe and record her fertility symptoms. So it is not surprising that an experienced teacher would find data entry time consuming. There are novice and advanced levels which allow more streamlined data entry. If the woman observes and records properly then the system performs the other NFP tasks of charting (including stamp selection, Peak and BIP recognition) and rule interpretation for her. billingsMentor can be used as a learning system or for decision support by a person who is uncertain about the rules. billingsMentor can be used for teaching when both teacher and client have the software installed. The documents are transferred by email attachment. We believe that billingsMentor will prove very helpful for post adolescent teenagers who can now learn fertility awareness just by following the guidance in the privacy of their own PC or laptop. In future it is intended to release versions for the new portable devices. In response to a’s comment “The program actually messed up my computer quite badly“, I have spoken to the developer of billingsMentor who tells me billingsMentor is implemented using industry standard tools for Microsoft Windows. It is extremely unlikely that billingsMentor could cause a problem with a computer. billingsMentor can be downloaded at www.billingsmentor.org There is a free trial period of 35 days without obligation. A licence costs $20 one-off payment per computer. Audrey Quote
Guest guest Posted September 15, 2010 Report Posted September 15, 2010 Right. Correct. Sincerely yours, Dominic M. Pedulla MD, FACC, CNFPMC, ABVM, ACPh Interventional Cardiologist, Endovascular Diplomate, Varicose Vein Specialist, Noncontraceptive Family Planning Consultant, Family Planning Researcher Medical Director, The Oklahoma Vein and Endovascular Center (www.noveinok.com, veininfo@...) Executive Director, The Edith Stein Foundation (www.theedithsteinfoundation.com) (office) (cell) (FAX) pedullad@... "And he departed from our sight that we might return to our heart, and there find Him. For He departed, and behold, He is here." - St. Augustine Re: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Dear List Members In response to a’s comments on billingsMentor. (www.billingsMentor.org) a Van Uden wrote: I do think billingsmentor can be a very helpful tool, but I do not think it is an adequate substitute for the personalized support of a teacher - especially for clients feeling distressed about NFP. No software or program would be, it cannot communicate with the client about their misunderstandings or concerns. Any sort of tool like this used in conjunction with the personalized support of a teacher can be very useful! Used apart from personalized support, I have concerns. Reply: There are approximately 1.5 billion fertile women in the world. How many NFP teachers are there? a Van Uden wrote: "If the woman observes and records properly then the system performs the other NFP tasks of charting." This is precisely what concerns me. What if she's confused about what she's observing or what to record? Reply: billingsMentor is a learning tool. It always leads the woman to guidance, for both observing and recording. In teaching situations the woman can remain confused for days or weeks before she makes contact with a teacher. If the woman enters a daily record into billingsMentor it is examined in context and feed back is given immediately. a Van Uden wrote: What if she creates phony observations to try to make the software perform a charting task? Perhaps she is ignoring her actual observations and putting in what she thinks she should be observing at a particular time? Reply: That sort of behaviour is treated on its merits in billingsMentor and can be the basis for learning. If a woman wants to experiment with different charting situations that are not her own, she is able to do this to her benefit. This is the classic tutorial method used in most learning environments. a Van Uden wrote: Clients do this on their paper charts all the time when they are unsure. This is the sort of thing instructors watch for and discuss during follow-ups, whether they are face to face or by phone or by email. Reply: billingsMentor is an interactive system and gives the user feedback in real time. a Van Uden wrote: If the observation itself isn't done accurately, using the right stamp or applying the right rule will be irrelevant. I've instructed many long distance clients by email (not ideal, but do-able). It's been my experience that most clients simply want to be able to check in with a real person when they have questions or when they are anxious - even if that contact is by phone or email. Reply: The first aim of billingsMentor is to ensure that observation and recording are done well. Clients do not contact a teacher every time an uncertainty arises, that is typical human behaviour. billingsMentor detects when the descriptions of the symptoms are not yielding an interpretable pattern and advises the user to contact our teaching staff. a Van Uden wrote: I don't think the developers of billingsmentor should ignore that need, but find ways to work with it. This is what the developer of nfpcharting.com has done. The nfpcharting.com client charts are very accessible to instructors. We simply log in to our account, click on the client's chart in our Student List, and there it is! We can be on the phone together, the client makes the corrections as we discuss them, I hit "refresh" - and there is the updated chart on my screen. No transferring of attachments back and forth. It's instant and it's simple. Reply: The developer of billingsMentor pioneered that type of facility in the 1990’s. It has been available on www.woomb.org for the last eight years and more than a thousand women have been taught successfully that way. However the vast majority of people who visit the service do not proceed. Reasons are fears about privacy, payment for service (people are looking for free information on the internet) and the accepted learning paradigm for the internet which is self education. a Van Uden wrote: The objective isn't to do the charting for them, but to empower them to do the charting for themselves with confidence. It's to empower them with the understanding of what their observations mean and why the different rules are applied at different times. Maybe we should be discussing how to provide more online instructors for those who don't have one locally? My concern is that a computer program, by itself, may not be the best solution. Reply: The problem of remote location of a teacher has been answered by the internet. Because a system can make a decision on behalf of the woman does not mean it does not provide a learning opportunity. As already stated the woman is free to experiment with all sorts of patterns as a learning method. One of the main impacts of billingsMentor will be for post adolescent teenagers who can now learn fertility awareness in the privacy of their own PC or laptop or in the future on a portable device. Audrey Re: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Dear List Members, I am very familiar with billingsMentor. If a woman or couple have convenient access to good instruction, this is the advisable way for them to obtain assistance. billingsMentor is helping women who do not have this opportunity or choose, for a variety of reasons, not to use the face to face way of learning. billingsMentor represents a major step forward in e-learning for NFP (in this case the Billings Method). Of course the various methods of NFP have their different instructions for observations and have their own rules. We should be very clear about this. billingsMentor aims to teach a beginner how to observe and record her fertility symptoms. So it is not surprising that an experienced teacher would find data entry time consuming. There are novice and advanced levels which allow more streamlined data entry. If the woman observes and records properly then the system performs the other NFP tasks of charting (including stamp selection, Peak and BIP recognition) and rule interpretation for her. billingsMentor can be used as a learning system or for decision support by a person who is uncertain about the rules. billingsMentor can be used for teaching when both teacher and client have the software installed. The documents are transferred by email attachment. We believe that billingsMentor will prove very helpful for post adolescent teenagers who can now learn fertility awareness just by following the guidance in the privacy of their own PC or laptop. In future it is intended to release versions for the new portable devices. In response to a’s comment “The program actually messed up my computer quite badly“, I have spoken to the developer of billingsMentor who tells me billingsMentor is implemented using industry standard tools for Microsoft Windows. It is extremely unlikely that billingsMentor could cause a problem with a computer. billingsMentor can be downloaded at www.billingsmentor.org There is a free trial period of 35 days without obligation. A licence costs $20 one-off payment per computer. Audrey Quote
Guest guest Posted September 15, 2010 Report Posted September 15, 2010 Just a note about the Billings Mentor Program from a clinician's perspective. I have extensive experience with the Mentor program which has revolutionized the introduction of NFP into clinical practice. While I have always taught the Billings Method to patients who wish an alternative to contraceptives, truth is, most patients have difficulty finding time to call and arrange an appointment with a certified instructor. Patients must also pay out-of-pocket for the teaching and followup in most states. While the "already converted" took the trouble to chart and return for followup, most did not. Moreover, when I did the instruction myself, I spent the next visit correcting the charting, which is time-consuming. Just 2 days ago I spent an hour with one couple in the "teachable moment" while my other 41 patients waited. I have recommended the Mentor program to all of my gyn patients, postpartum and infertility patients over the past 18 months. While not all have followed through, many have. The charting is impeccable. The computer has no bias in detecting patterns. "Uninterpretable patterns" are just that: a reflection of the continuum of ovarian activity described by the late Prof. Brown in his soon-to-be published seminal work: The Continuum of Ovarian Activity. As pointed out in a previous response, there is a dearth of NFP instructors, and even fewer doctors and clinicians. The Mentor program is a way to introduce NFP to the masses of potential users and clinicians who don't have to worry about the accuracy of the chart and the application of 4 simple rules. While I can understand that NFP teachers may find this a little threatening, and we can debate until doomsday whether every user should be able to understand and apply the rules, the goal is to appeal to the masses who want the benefits of natural family planning and may not have access to a qualified instructor, nor the interest in learning the science. I am reminded of when computers became a part of my daily professional life. My fear was assuaged by the following analogy: you don't have to be a mechanic to drive a car. Likewise, I don't have to be a programmer to use my computer. If the Mentor program, which, BTW, is to be tested by an academic research protocol currently being designed, is as valuable as I believe it will be, some BOM teachers may become the clinical consultants of the future in chart interpretation. By far, the most useful aspect of the program is that it accurately reflects the relative production of estradiol and progesterone throughout the reproductive years. The diagnostic potential is immense. I am currently preparing a presentation for the Catholic Medical Association Conference on the diagnostic use of the Mentor program in differentiating between the 3 subtypes of Polycystic Ovarian Syndrome. The Billings Mentor Program is not yet approved by the Billings Ovulation Method. When I give the website, I give the disclaimer, but I can assure you that the application of the rules is conservative. There have been no surprise pregnancies. I find that taking the human interpretative element out of rule application eliminates the bias, which admittedly exists in all NFP methods. Rest assured, NFP teachers, your jobs are secure. But let's not bury our heads in the sand as even third world countries obtain and use smart phone and computer technologies. W. , M.D.,FACOG Billings Center For Fertility and Reproductive Medicine Re: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Dear List Members In response to a’s comments on billingsMentor. (www.billingsMentor.org) a Van Uden wrote: I do think billingsmentor can be a very helpful tool, but I do not think it is an adequate substitute for the personalized support of a teacher - especially for clients feeling distressed about NFP. No software or program would be, it cannot communicate with the client about their misunderstandings or concerns. Any sort of tool like this used in conjunction with the personalized support of a teacher can be very useful! Used apart from personalized support, I have concerns. Reply: There are approximately 1.5 billion fertile women in the world. How many NFP teachers are there? a Van Uden wrote: "If the woman observes and records properly then the system performs the other NFP tasks of charting." This is precisely what concerns me. What if she's confused about what she's observing or what to record? Reply: billingsMentor is a learning tool. It always leads the woman to guidance, for both observing and recording. In teaching situations the woman can remain confused for days or weeks before she makes contact with a teacher. If the woman enters a daily record into billingsMentor it is examined in context and feed back is given immediately. a Van Uden wrote: What if she creates phony observations to try to make the software perform a charting task? Perhaps she is ignoring her actual observations and putting in what she thinks she should be observing at a particular time? Reply: That sort of behaviour is treated on its merits in billingsMentor and can be the basis for learning. If a woman wants to experiment with different charting situations that are not her own, she is able to do this to her benefit. This is the classic tutorial method used in most learning environments. a Van Uden wrote: Clients do this on their paper charts all the time when they are unsure. This is the sort of thing instructors watch for and discuss during follow-ups, whether they are face to face or by phone or by email. Reply: billingsMentor is an interactive system and gives the user feedback in real time. a Van Uden wrote: If the observation itself isn't done accurately, using the right stamp or applying the right rule will be irrelevant. I've instructed many long distance clients by email (not ideal, but do-able). It's been my experience that most clients simply want to be able to check in with a real person when they have questions or when they are anxious - even if that contact is by phone or email. Reply: The first aim of billingsMentor is to ensure that observation and recording are done well. Clients do not contact a teacher every time an uncertainty arises, that is typical human behaviour. billingsMentor detects when the descriptions of the symptoms are not yielding an interpretable pattern and advises the user to contact our teaching staff. a Van Uden wrote: I don't think the developers of billingsmentor should ignore that need, but find ways to work with it. This is what the developer of nfpcharting.com has done. The nfpcharting.com client charts are very accessible to instructors. We simply log in to our account, click on the client's chart in our Student List, and there it is! We can be on the phone together, the client makes the corrections as we discuss them, I hit "refresh" - and there is the updated chart on my screen. No transferring of attachments back and forth. It's instant and it's simple. Reply: The developer of billingsMentor pioneered that type of facility in the 1990’s. It has been available on www.woomb.org for the last eight years and more than a thousand women have been taught successfully that way. However the vast majority of people who visit the service do not proceed. Reasons are fears about privacy, payment for service (people are looking for free information on the internet) and the accepted learning paradigm for the internet which is self education. a Van Uden wrote: The objective isn't to do the charting for them, but to empower them to do the charting for themselves with confidence. It's to empower them with the understanding of what their observations mean and why the different rules are applied at different times. Maybe we should be discussing how to provide more online instructors for those who don't have one locally? My concern is that a computer program, by itself, may not be the best solution. Reply: The problem of remote location of a teacher has been answered by the internet. Because a system can make a decision on behalf of the woman does not mean it does not provide a learning opportunity. As already stated the woman is free to experiment with all sorts of patterns as a learning method. One of the main impacts of billingsMentor will be for post adolescent teenagers who can now learn fertility awareness in the privacy of their own PC or laptop or in the future on a portable device. Audrey Re: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Dear List Members, I am very familiar with billingsMentor. If a woman or couple have convenient access to good instruction, this is the advisable way for them to obtain assistance. billingsMentor is helping women who do not have this opportunity or choose, for a variety of reasons, not to use the face to face way of learning. billingsMentor represents a major step forward in e-learning for NFP (in this case the Billings Method). Of course the various methods of NFP have their different instructions for observations and have their own rules. We should be very clear about this. billingsMentor aims to teach a beginner how to observe and record her fertility symptoms. So it is not surprising that an experienced teacher would find data entry time consuming. There are novice and advanced levels which allow more streamlined data entry. If the woman observes and records properly then the system performs the other NFP tasks of charting (including stamp selection, Peak and BIP recognition) and rule interpretation for her. billingsMentor can be used as a learning system or for decision support by a person who is uncertain about the rules. billingsMentor can be used for teaching when both teacher and client have the software installed. The documents are transferred by email attachment. We believe that billingsMentor will prove very helpful for post adolescent teenagers who can now learn fertility awareness just by following the guidance in the privacy of their own PC or laptop. In future it is intended to release versions for the new portable devices. In response to a’s comment “The program actually messed up my computer quite badly“, I have spoken to the developer of billingsMentor who tells me billingsMentor is implemented using industry standard tools for Microsoft Windows. It is extremely unlikely that billingsMentor could cause a problem with a computer. billingsMentor can be downloaded at www.billingsmentor.org There is a free trial period of 35 days without obligation. A licence costs $20 one-off payment per computer. Audrey Quote
Guest guest Posted September 15, 2010 Report Posted September 15, 2010  Dear Dominic, Re: NFP charts It is important that we be clear about what is necessary and sufficient for the practice of NFP. It is not necessary for the billingsMentor user to know how to chart or how to read a chart. The purpose of the chart is for those who wish to attain fertility awareness. The only thing a woman must do for the practice of NFP is to observe and report her fertility symptoms adequately. billingsMentor interprets the symptoms and gives advice for avoiding or achieving a pregnancy on a daily basis. The chart is a visualization of fertility that is used primarily for review. It may not be the best form of visualization. An auralization may be a better presentation for many users. All such presentations could be generated by billingsMentor to serve e-learning. billingsMentor generates a chart because it is an accepted part of the Billings Method today. It remains that it is sufficient for the user to observe and record adequately. Audrey Re: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Dear List Members, I am very familiar with billingsMentor. If a woman or couple have convenient access to good instruction, this is the advisable way for them to obtain assistance. billingsMentor is helping women who do not have this opportunity or choose, for a variety of reasons, not to use the face to face way of learning. billingsMentor represents a major step forward in e-learning for NFP (in this case the Billings Method). Of course the various methods of NFP have their different instructions for observations and have their own rules. We should be very clear about this. billingsMentor aims to teach a beginner how to observe and record her fertility symptoms. So it is not surprising that an experienced teacher would find data entry time consuming. There are novice and advanced levels which allow more streamlined data entry. If the woman observes and records properly then the system performs the other NFP tasks of charting (including stamp selection, Peak and BIP recognition) and rule interpretation for her. billingsMentor can be used as a learning system or for decision support by a person who is uncertain about the rules. billingsMentor can be used for teaching when both teacher and client have the software installed. The documents are transferred by email attachment. We believe that billingsMentor will prove very helpful for post adolescent teenagers who can now learn fertility awareness just by following the guidance in the privacy of their own PC or laptop. In future it is intended to release versions for the new portable devices. In response to a’s comment “The program actually messed up my computer quite badly“, I have spoken to the developer of billingsMentor who tells me billingsMentor is implemented using industry standard tools for Microsoft Windows. It is extremely unlikely that billingsMentor could cause a problem with a computer. billingsMentor can be downloaded at www.billingsmentor.org There is a free trial period of 35 days without obligation. A licence costs $20 one-off payment per computer. Audrey Quote
Guest guest Posted September 16, 2010 Report Posted September 16, 2010 Yes agreed but that has nothing to do with what I wrote, which is to call for the eventual technology that can supplant and replace charting completely; obviously the mentor is not that technology. Sincerely yours, Dominic M. Pedulla MD, FACC, CNFPMC, ABVM, ACPh Interventional Cardiologist, Endovascular Diplomate, Varicose Vein Specialist, Noncontraceptive Family Planning Consultant, Family Planning Researcher Medical Director, The Oklahoma Vein and Endovascular Center (www.noveinok.com, veininfo@...) Executive Director, The Edith Stein Foundation (www.theedithsteinfoundation.com) (office) (cell) (FAX) pedullad@... "And he departed from our sight that we might return to our heart, and there find Him. For He departed, and behold, He is here." - St. Augustine Re: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Dear Dominic, Re: NFP charts It is important that we be clear about what is necessary and sufficient for the practice of NFP. It is not necessary for the billingsMentor user to know how to chart or how to read a chart. The purpose of the chart is for those who wish to attain fertility awareness. The only thing a woman must do for the practice of NFP is to observe and report her fertility symptoms adequately. billingsMentor interprets the symptoms and gives advice for avoiding or achieving a pregnancy on a daily basis. The chart is a visualization of fertility that is used primarily for review. It may not be the best form of visualization. An auralization may be a better presentation for many users. All such presentations could be generated by billingsMentor to serve e-learning. billingsMentor generates a chart because it is an accepted part of the Billings Method today. It remains that it is sufficient for the user to observe and record adequately. Audrey Re: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Dear List Members, I am very familiar with billingsMentor. If a woman or couple have convenient access to good instruction, this is the advisable way for them to obtain assistance. billingsMentor is helping women who do not have this opportunity or choose, for a variety of reasons, not to use the face to face way of learning. billingsMentor represents a major step forward in e-learning for NFP (in this case the Billings Method). Of course the various methods of NFP have their different instructions for observations and have their own rules. We should be very clear about this. billingsMentor aims to teach a beginner how to observe and record her fertility symptoms. So it is not surprising that an experienced teacher would find data entry time consuming. There are novice and advanced levels which allow more streamlined data entry. If the woman observes and records properly then the system performs the other NFP tasks of charting (including stamp selection, Peak and BIP recognition) and rule interpretation for her. billingsMentor can be used as a learning system or for decision support by a person who is uncertain about the rules. billingsMentor can be used for teaching when both teacher and client have the software installed. The documents are transferred by email attachment. We believe that billingsMentor will prove very helpful for post adolescent teenagers who can now learn fertility awareness just by following the guidance in the privacy of their own PC or laptop. In future it is intended to release versions for the new portable devices. In response to a’s comment “The program actually messed up my computer quite badly“, I have spoken to the developer of billingsMentor who tells me billingsMentor is implemented using industry standard tools for Microsoft Windows. It is extremely unlikely that billingsMentor could cause a problem with a computer. billingsMentor can be downloaded at www.billingsmentor.org There is a free trial period of 35 days without obligation. A licence costs $20 one-off payment per computer. Audrey Quote
Guest guest Posted September 16, 2010 Report Posted September 16, 2010 Dominic: There already exists – high and low technology that can and do replace charting. There is the Persona hormonal monitor available in Europe – made by Swiss Precisions Diagnostics and other electronic devices. There are the CycleBeads – which are a form of low technology. I guess you could consider the beads a chart? I am not sure what you envision – when you say technology to replace charting. One of the concepts going around the contraceptive/family planning world is“forgettable contraception†– as an ideal, i.e., the IUD, sterilization, long term injection. I doubt if you mean something like that. From a health standpoint it is better and healthier for the woman to chart her cycles and fertility in some simple way. It is even recommended by the American Pediatric Association for teens. Marquette University From: nfpprofessionals [mailto:nfpprofessionals ]On Behalf Of DominicSent: Thursday, September 16, 2010 8:56 AMTo: nfpprofessionals Subject: Re: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Yes agreed but that has nothing to do with what I wrote, which is to call for the eventual technology that can supplant and replace charting completely; obviouslythe mentor is not that technology.Sincerely yours,Dominic M. Pedulla MD, FACC, CNFPMC, ABVM, ACPhInterventional Cardiologist, Endovascular Diplomate, Varicose Vein Specialist, Noncontraceptive Family Planning Consultant, Family Planning ResearcherMedical Director, The Oklahoma Vein and Endovascular Center (www.noveinok.com, veininfo@...)Executive Director, The Edith Stein Foundation (www.theedithsteinfoundation.com) (office) (cell) (FAX)pedullad@... " And he departed from our sight that we might return to our heart, and there find Him. For He departed, and behold, He is here. " - St. Augustine Re: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Dear Dominic, Re: NFP charts It is important that we be clear about what is necessary and sufficient for the practice of NFP.It is not necessary for the billingsMentor user to know how to chart or how to read a chart. The purpose of the chart is for those who wish to attain fertility awareness.The only thing a woman must do for the practice of NFP is to observe and report her fertility symptoms adequately.billingsMentor interprets the symptoms and gives advice for avoiding or achieving a pregnancy on a daily basis.The chart is a visualization of fertility that is used primarily for review. It may not be the best form of visualization. An auralization may be a better presentation for manyusers.All such presentations could be generated by billingsMentor to serve e-learning.billingsMentor generates a chart because it is an accepted part of the Billings Method today.It remains that it is sufficient for the user to observe and record adequately.Audrey Re: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Dear List Members,I am very familiar with billingsMentor.If a woman or couple have convenient access to good instruction, this is the advisable way for them to obtain assistance. billingsMentor is helping women whodo not have this opportunity or choose, for a variety of reasons, not to use the face to face way of learning.billingsMentor represents a major step forward in e-learning for NFP (in this case the Billings Method).Of course the various methods of NFP have their different instructions for observations and have their own rules. We should be very clear about this.billingsMentor aims to teach a beginner how to observe and record her fertility symptoms. So it is not surprising that an experienced teacher would find dataentry time consuming. There are novice and advanced levels which allow more streamlined data entry.If the woman observes and records properly then the system performs the other NFP tasks of charting (including stamp selection, Peak and BIP recognition) andrule interpretation for her.billingsMentor can be used as a learning system or for decision support by a person who is uncertain about the rules.billingsMentor can be used for teaching when both teacher and client have the software installed. The documents are transferred by email attachment.We believe that billingsMentor will prove very helpful for post adolescent teenagers who can now learn fertility awareness just by following the guidance inthe privacy of their own PC or laptop. In future it is intended to release versions for the new portable devices.In response to a’s comment “The program actually messed up my computer quite badly“, I have spoken to the developer of billingsMentor who tells me billingsMentoris implemented using industry standard tools for Microsoft Windows. It is extremely unlikely that billingsMentor could cause a problem with a computer.billingsMentor can be downloaded atwww.billingsmentor.orgThere is a free trial period of 35 days without obligation. A licence costs $20 one-off payment per computer.Audrey Quote
Guest guest Posted September 16, 2010 Report Posted September 16, 2010 No, I mean monitor technology that affords 99% method effectiveness, has no empiric rules other than tells you the days conception is possible, and relies on daily sampling but without charting. No, , contraception is something very different. Sincerely yours, Dominic M. Pedulla MD, FACC, CNFPMC, ABVM, ACPh Interventional Cardiologist, Endovascular Diplomate, Varicose Vein Specialist, Noncontraceptive Family Planning Consultant, Family Planning Researcher Medical Director, The Oklahoma Vein and Endovascular Center (www.noveinok.com, veininfo@...) Executive Director, The Edith Stein Foundation (www.theedithsteinfoundation.com) (office) (cell) (FAX) pedullad@... "And he departed from our sight that we might return to our heart, and there find Him. For He departed, and behold, He is here." - St. Augustine Re: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Dear Dominic, Re: NFP charts It is important that we be clear about what is necessary and sufficient for the practice of NFP. It is not necessary for the billingsMentor user to know how to chart or how to read a chart. The purpose of the chart is for those who wish to attain fertility awareness. The only thing a woman must do for the practice of NFP is to observe and report her fertility symptoms adequately. billingsMentor interprets the symptoms and gives advice for avoiding or achieving a pregnancy on a daily basis. The chart is a visualization of fertility that is used primarily for review. It may not be the best form of visualization. An auralization may be a better presentation for many users. All such presentations could be generated by billingsMentor to serve e-learning. billingsMentor generates a chart because it is an accepted part of the Billings Method today. It remains that it is sufficient for the user to observe and record adequately. Audrey Re: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Dear List Members, I am very familiar with billingsMentor. If a woman or couple have convenient access to good instruction, this is the advisable way for them to obtain assistance. billingsMentor is helping women who do not have this opportunity or choose, for a variety of reasons, not to use the face to face way of learning. billingsMentor represents a major step forward in e-learning for NFP (in this case the Billings Method). Of course the various methods of NFP have their different instructions for observations and have their own rules. We should be very clear about this. billingsMentor aims to teach a beginner how to observe and record her fertility symptoms. So it is not surprising that an experienced teacher would find data entry time consuming. There are novice and advanced levels which allow more streamlined data entry. If the woman observes and records properly then the system performs the other NFP tasks of charting (including stamp selection, Peak and BIP recognition) and rule interpretation for her. billingsMentor can be used as a learning system or for decision support by a person who is uncertain about the rules. billingsMentor can be used for teaching when both teacher and client have the software installed. The documents are transferred by email attachment. We believe that billingsMentor will prove very helpful for post adolescent teenagers who can now learn fertility awareness just by following the guidance in the privacy of their own PC or laptop. In future it is intended to release versions for the new portable devices. In response to a’s comment “The program actually messed up my computer quite badly“, I have spoken to the developer of billingsMentor who tells me billingsMentor is implemented using industry standard tools for Microsoft Windows. It is extremely unlikely that billingsMentor could cause a problem with a computer. billingsMentor can be downloaded at www.billingsmentor.org There is a free trial period of 35 days without obligation. A licence costs $20 one-off payment per computer. Audrey Quote
Guest guest Posted September 16, 2010 Report Posted September 16, 2010 :I agree with both you and Dominic.Technology for NFP/ovulation prediction-timing is available and should be aggressively pursued, but more needs to be done. We need more accurate and powerful technology to signal the potential period of fertility and the transition to the luteal phase. There is still skepticism of available NFP techniques by the majority of the medical profession and the public. Sadly, we do need a 'stand-alone' device that is as simple as an iPod App to signal 'green' and 'red'. Until then - the Persona, CycleBeads, OM, STM, Creighton, etc. Steve J. Usala, M.D., Ph.D., F.A.C.P.Private Practice, Endocrinology & Diabetes, Amarillo Medical SpecialistsClinical Associate Professor, Dept of Med, TTU HSC, Amarillo, TX Adjunct Associate Professor, Dept of Chemical Engineering, Lubbock, TXVice President, AMS Rheology & Reproductioncell: fax: ofc: email: stephenusala@...On Thu, Sep 16, 2010 at 10:12 AM, Fehring, wrote: Dominic: There already exists – high and low technology that can and do replace charting. There is the Persona hormonal monitor available in Europe – made by Swiss Precisions Diagnostics and other electronic devices. There are the CycleBeads – which are a form of low technology. I guess you could consider the beads a chart? I am not sure what you envision – when you say technology to replace charting. One of the concepts going around the contraceptive/family planning world is “forgettable contraception” – as an ideal, i.e., the IUD, sterilization, long term injection. I doubt if you mean something like that. From a health standpoint it is better and healthier for the woman to chart her cycles and fertility in some simple way. It is even recommended by the American Pediatric Association for teens. Marquette University From: nfpprofessionals [mailto:nfpprofessionals ] On Behalf Of Dominic Sent: Thursday, September 16, 2010 8:56 AM To: nfpprofessionals Subject: Re: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Yes agreed but that has nothing to do with what I wrote, which is to call for the eventual technology that can supplant and replace charting completely; obviously the mentor is not that technology. Sincerely yours, Dominic M. Pedulla MD, FACC, CNFPMC, ABVM, ACPh Interventional Cardiologist, Endovascular Diplomate, Varicose Vein Specialist, Noncontraceptive Family Planning Consultant, Family Planning Researcher Medical Director, The Oklahoma Vein and Endovascular Center (www.noveinok.com, veininfo@...) Executive Director, The Edith Stein Foundation (www.theedithsteinfoundation.com) (office) (cell) (FAX) pedullad@... " And he departed from our sight that we might return to our heart, and there find Him. For He departed, and behold, He is here. " - St. Augustine Re: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Dear Dominic, Re: NFP charts It is important that we be clear about what is necessary and sufficient for the practice of NFP. It is not necessary for the billingsMentor user to know how to chart or how to read a chart. The purpose of the chart is for those who wish to attain fertility awareness. The only thing a woman must do for the practice of NFP is to observe and report her fertility symptoms adequately. billingsMentor interprets the symptoms and gives advice for avoiding or achieving a pregnancy on a daily basis. The chart is a visualization of fertility that is used primarily for review. It may not be the best form of visualization. An auralization may be a better presentation for many users. All such presentations could be generated by billingsMentor to serve e-learning. billingsMentor generates a chart because it is an accepted part of the Billings Method today. It remains that it is sufficient for the user to observe and record adequately. Audrey Re: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Dear List Members, I am very familiar with billingsMentor. If a woman or couple have convenient access to good instruction, this is the advisable way for them to obtain assistance. billingsMentor is helping women who do not have this opportunity or choose, for a variety of reasons, not to use the face to face way of learning. billingsMentor represents a major step forward in e-learning for NFP (in this case the Billings Method). Of course the various methods of NFP have their different instructions for observations and have their own rules. We should be very clear about this. billingsMentor aims to teach a beginner how to observe and record her fertility symptoms. So it is not surprising that an experienced teacher would find data entry time consuming. There are novice and advanced levels which allow more streamlined data entry. If the woman observes and records properly then the system performs the other NFP tasks of charting (including stamp selection, Peak and BIP recognition) and rule interpretation for her. billingsMentor can be used as a learning system or for decision support by a person who is uncertain about the rules. billingsMentor can be used for teaching when both teacher and client have the software installed. The documents are transferred by email attachment. We believe that billingsMentor will prove very helpful for post adolescent teenagers who can now learn fertility awareness just by following the guidance in the privacy of their own PC or laptop. In future it is intended to release versions for the new portable devices. In response to a’s comment “The program actually messed up my computer quite badly“, I have spoken to the developer of billingsMentor who tells me billingsMentor is implemented using industry standard tools for Microsoft Windows. It is extremely unlikely that billingsMentor could cause a problem with a computer. billingsMentor can be downloaded at www.billingsmentor.org There is a free trial period of 35 days without obligation. A licence costs $20 one-off payment per computer. Audrey Quote
Guest guest Posted September 16, 2010 Report Posted September 16, 2010 I hesitate to join this fray, BUT I find all this talk of monitors and charts bewildering to my simple mind, AND I ask the question, "How are the poor and uneducated and Amazon jungle hut dwellers going to make use of this stuff?" God made sexual intercourse accessible to virtually everyone, independent of age, religion, marital status, ethnicity, economic condition, social state, color, intelligence, etc. I would think that He would like every woman to have access to knowledge about her body's fertility. It's a SOLIDARITY thing--sexual intercourse and fertility knowledge!Toward this highly desirable end, of every woman having access to knowledge about her fertility, I find the "Two-Day Method" quite attractive. [The title might suggest only two days of abstinence, but that is not the meaning, attractive though that may be.] The one "rule" is exceptionally simple: "At the end of the day, if the woman has been dry (no indication of cervical mucus) today and yesterday, she is infertile. If she has observed any cervical mucus (by sensation, touch or sight), either today or yesterday, she should consider herself fertile." This Two-Day Method (TDM) was developed by the people at the "Institute for Reproductive Health" at town U over ten years ago and studies of its efficacy, etc, are available at IRH's web site.The "Two-Day Method" is actually a clarification and quantification of the "Seven-Second Method" (SSM). The SSM was developed by Mercedes at the Family of the Americas Foundation. The "rule" is one sentence, with two commas, one semicolon and one period: "If you are dry, the sperm will die; if you are wet, a baby you may get." The rhyming facilitates the memorization. Charting is optional.Here's a coalesced (hybrid) version: "If you were dry yesterday and today, the sperm will die; if you were wet either yesterday or today, a baby you may get." It takes about another second: "Eight-Second Method" (ESM). Charting still optional.Thanks and blessings to all.Steve KoobTo: nfpprofessionals From: pedullad@...Date: Thu, 16 Sep 2010 11:26:25 -0400Subject: Re: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation No, I mean monitor technology that affords 99% method effectiveness, has no empiric rules other than tells you the days conception is possible, and relies on daily sampling but without charting. No, , contraception is something very different. Sincerely yours, Dominic M. Pedulla MD, FACC, CNFPMC, ABVM, ACPh Interventional Cardiologist, Endovascular Diplomate, Varicose Vein Specialist, Noncontraceptive Family Planning Consultant, Family Planning Researcher Medical Director, The Oklahoma Vein and Endovascular Center (www.noveinok.com, veininfo@...) Executive Director, The Edith Stein Foundation (www.theedithsteinfoundation.com) (office) (cell) (FAX) pedullad@... "And he departed from our sight that we might return to our heart, and there find Him. For He departed, and behold, He is here." - St. Augustine Re: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Dear Dominic, Re: NFP charts It is important that we be clear about what is necessary and sufficient for the practice of NFP. It is not necessary for the billingsMentor user to know how to chart or how to read a chart. The purpose of the chart is for those who wish to attain fertility awareness. The only thing a woman must do for the practice of NFP is to observe and report her fertility symptoms adequately. billingsMentor interprets the symptoms and gives advice for avoiding or achieving a pregnancy on a daily basis. The chart is a visualization of fertility that is used primarily for review. It may not be the best form of visualization. An auralization may be a better presentation for many users. All such presentations could be generated by billingsMentor to serve e-learning. billingsMentor generates a chart because it is an accepted part of the Billings Method today. It remains that it is sufficient for the user to observe and record adequately. Audrey Re: I need your help: extremely difficult pastoral situation Dear List Members, I am very familiar with billingsMentor. If a woman or couple have convenient access to good instruction, this is the advisable way for them to obtain assistance. billingsMentor is helping women who do not have this opportunity or choose, for a variety of reasons, not to use the face to face way of learning. billingsMentor represents a major step forward in e-learning for NFP (in this case the Billings Method). Of course the various methods of NFP have their different instructions for observations and have their own rules. We should be very clear about this. billingsMentor aims to teach a beginner how to observe and record her fertility symptoms. So it is not surprising that an experienced teacher would find data entry time consuming. There are novice and advanced levels which allow more streamlined data entry. If the woman observes and records properly then the system performs the other NFP tasks of charting (including stamp selection, Peak and BIP recognition) and rule interpretation for her. billingsMentor can be used as a learning system or for decision support by a person who is uncertain about the rules. billingsMentor can be used for teaching when both teacher and client have the software installed. The documents are transferred by email attachment. We believe that billingsMentor will prove very helpful for post adolescent teenagers who can now learn fertility awareness just by following the guidance in the privacy of their own PC or laptop. In future it is intended to release versions for the new portable devices. In response to a’s comment “The program actually messed up my computer quite badly“, I have spoken to the developer of billingsMentor who tells me billingsMentor is implemented using industry standard tools for Microsoft Windows. It is extremely unlikely that billingsMentor could cause a problem with a computer. billingsMentor can be downloaded at www.billingsmentor.org There is a free trial period of 35 days without obligation. A licence costs $20 one-off payment per computer. Audrey Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.