Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Re: ? regarding cost of keep of goats

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted

I am interested in this topic as well.  I will be watching.  Thanks!

 

We recently sold our milk cow and switched to dairy goats (Nubians). We love them and their milk. We thought one of the benefits would be that they ate less and therefore would cost less than a milk cow. We had a full-sized Jersey. But our 3 dairy goats eat a lot of grain in comparison to what our one Jersey ate, and that gets rather costly. I used to feed them Purina Goat Chow, but have switched to Nutrena Top Goat and a sweet feed of COB with molasses, 1/2 and 1/2. That has cut the cost of the grain almost in half, but not quite. Still very expensive compared to our cow's consumption of grain. Of course the milk production doesn't compare either. We were getting about 3 gallons a day from our Jersey and we get about 2 to 2.5 gal/day from our 3 goats.

Reasons for switching to goats:

A2 genetics (it was my understanding that all goats are A2)

Health reasons

Ease of keep - dc more comfortable with a smaller animal, cleaner, easier to clean up after (all of which are true in our case)

We thought they would be less expensive to keep.

What is your experience in keeping goats? What do you feed them in the way of grain? How much? Is the grain necessary? (If they don't eat their ration, their milk production does drop.) Some folks don't feed their milk cow any grain at all.

Any advice, experience, thoughts would be appreciated.

Thanks so much!

Dona

-- Ann sThe Udder Side FarmElk Park, NCwww.janesjewel.com

Posted

I was always “told” or under the impression pound for pound goats were more efficient. And yielded the same amounts of milk. So although its a 1200lb cow giving 3 gal aday you have 3 125lb goats giving that lb for lb equivalent. they take up less room. Less acreage necessary. Less upkeep. Vet bills. Care (ie. Trimming hooves, worming amounts) and so on. I think you should factor all these into costs. I think it would be cheaper when those things are added up. Cows are grazing animals and are more efficient from that. Goats aren’t and need that added grain ration. Browse alone just doesn’t cut it like it can with cows grazing. Also Nubians aren’t the biggest producers, if you want large yields then a saanen is where you would likely get more for less goat. But I love my nubians. I might add a saanen in the mix one day. Also, you have to take into consideration lactation level of goat. Age. And milk lines. It’s possible you just don’t have the heavy milking nubians. I know I have two lines here. And its obvious the differences. 3 heavy milking saanens would possibly change the scenario of costs comparisons. Friends who have them say they can output 2 gal a day when they are mature.

To increase yield you have to experiment in your area for your goats. Supplementing certain minerals to achieve greatest output. In general I’ve used things like beet pulp and black oil sunflower seeds to increase yields. Calf manna helped as a top dress feed. And certain mineral mixes added. As well feeding a higher percentage hay. I too just switched from purina. Too expensive and not worth it. And now that I’m in a penny pinching mode I’ve found a walpole feed that is half the cost of purina that I’m now using. And allows me to add other things while being cheaper then before. My girls are down across the board and I think its the excessively hot summer. You just have to experiment and this takes time. Now that I’ve switched I’m going to add back some things and see if it helps the yield. Of course, I’m also in my 6month of lactation so I’ll never really know the best course etc. till I have a few years of consistent observations.

jo

--

www.goodnessgraciousacres.com

Become a fan on FB

Delilah’s Dairy Goat Milk Soap

http://tinyurl.com/yzbq5j8

Reply-To: " RawDairy " <RawDairy >

Date: Thu, 19 Aug 2010 13:06:54 -0000

To: " RawDairy " <RawDairy >

Subject: ? regarding cost of keep of goats

What is your experience in keeping goats? What do you feed them in the way of grain? How much? Is the grain necessary? (If they don't eat their ration, their milk production does drop.) Some folks don't feed their milk cow any grain at all.

Any advice, experience, thoughts would be appreciated.

Thanks so much!

Posted

I feed sprouted whole barley on the stand myself. They do have pasture and

alfalfa hay. My cow - who lives at my sisters house is feeding out some calves

instead of being milked but she would definitely put out milk easier on just

grass then goats - though you can do it you wont get the yield per animals that

you do if you supplement. Pound for pound though - 5 goats to a cow at 6 pounds

a day for the goats on quality pasture alone it all come out about even - if you

have heavier milking breeds you will get more volume but less solids -

generally. So it depends on if you are looking for lots of volume or nutrient

density. I just plain like goats milk better then cows milk - I milk nubians

and mini nubians though. I dont generally like other breeds milk in terms of

how long they taste good to me so I have nubs.

aliza

>

> I was always ³told² or under the impression pound for pound goats were more

> efficient. And yielded the same amounts of milk. So although its a 1200lb

> cow giving 3 gal aday you have 3 125lb goats giving that lb for lb

> equivalent. they take up less room. Less acreage necessary. Less upkeep.

Posted

Jo,

Thanks for your response. So I'm adding up the costs... hoof trimming, definitely less expensive, but only saves me about $20 a year, assuming I only own 1 cow. AI costs for the cow were only about $30 a year. I paid $50 for our little buckling and have to feed him. I use Molly's herbal dewormer. The cow used 4 TBSP a week. We have 3 does and 1 buckling, each get 1 TBSP a week. We have 2.5 acres of pasture, not alfalfa, but a combination of orchard grass, fescue, white clover and brome. We don't let the goats out on it because it isn't properly fenced and there are some weeds on the edges that include milk weed, which is supposed to be poisonous to goats. We cut the pasture twice a year to get some grass hay for storage. We also keep a cow or two for beef and they eat mostly the grass hay and the leftovers from the does. The cows have a smaller grazing area just for them. Vet bills I can't really compare because we have luckily been pretty healthy and haven't needed much from the vet for the cow or the goats. Hay consumption is where the big difference for us is. The cow consumed 1/3-1/2 of a small bale of hay each day. The does only consume 1-2 large flakes a day, the buckling about 1/2 of the flake. We do buy alfalfa for the goats. But the grain consumption is turned way upside down! One of my goats, a large nubian, 2 yo first freshener, consumes about the same amount of grain our cow did!

I'm hoping that next year the milk production goes up somewhat. These goats were bought this year, all out of good milking lines, a few months into their lactation. The move undoubtedly dropped their production somewhat. One is a 6-yo who just had a single kid this year; in previous years she had twins. The other from the same place is a yearling, kidded 1 this year. The other, from a different place it the 2 yo. She had twins this year and is our biggest producer at 3.5-4 pints a milking. The move was stressful on her. We had some behavioral issues with her in the beginning... wouldn't eat, wouldn't get on the stand, was afraid of the other goats even though she is much bigger than the other two. She has calmed down quite a bit and is actually a very easy goat now.

I agree with you about the breed and output. We chose Nubians because of the composition of the milk, higher butterfat content, creamier milk. I must say, however, that I have never tasted Saanen milk, so I can't really compare in real life, just on paper. I might take your suggestion and put a Saanen in the mix. What do you know about the taste and texture of Saanen milk? I know we have had Holstein milk and Jersey milk and by far like the Jersey milk better. But if the Saanen milk was nice and sweet and it was just in the mix of our goat milk, we might not notice the difference. Or we could use the Saanen to raise bottle calves. Do the Saanens need proportionally more grain for their output? That would offset the advantage.

I do use a milk pellet as a top dressing, 28% protein.

We do love our goats! I just want to make it work within our budget!

I really appreciate your input. Thank you again for taking the time to respond. If you have any other thoughts to share, I would welcome them!

Sincerely,

Dona

Posted

A lot of questions here.

First I will state that I figure the current cost of keeping a full size breed

milking dairy goat is $400-500 per year. That would cover, hay, grain, minerals,

dewormer, etc but not any unexpected vet costs. I did not get any objection (and

plenty of agreement) when I posted those numbers on another active forum I

participate in.

I think the most critical factor is a good supply of quality hay at a reasonable

price. My hay averages about $8-9 per bale. If you are buying your alafla hay at

a " horse " store and paying 14 or 15 per bale your costs will be higher.

For a milking doe you probably do need to supplement with some grain if you want

to get the most possible production - but not much if you are feeding a good

quality aflalfa. I have personally found that switching from a grass hay to

alfalfa increased production by 25% or more.

Remember that goats are ruminants and need long stem fiber. Pouring the grain to

them will result in health problems and is not advisable. I truly believe (as

told to me by several long time successful goat breeders) that quality hay and

feeding it free choice is where you should spend your money and is the best

investment. If you cant get quality hay at a good price alfalfa pellets are an

alternative.

If you want good milk production at a reasonable cost be sure to invest in

quality stock to start with. It costs just as much to feed a poor producer as a

superb one.

Ziggy

www.sunrisefarmnc.com

>

> We recently sold our milk cow and switched to dairy goats (Nubians). We love

them and their milk. We thought one of the benefits would be that they ate less

and therefore would cost less than a milk cow. We had a full-sized Jersey. But

our 3 dairy goats eat a lot of grain in comparison to what our one Jersey ate,

and that gets rather costly. I used to feed them Purina Goat Chow, but have

switched to Nutrena Top Goat and a sweet feed of COB with molasses, 1/2 and 1/2.

That has cut the cost of the grain almost in half, but not quite. Still very

expensive compared to our cow's consumption of grain. Of course the milk

production doesn't compare either. We were getting about 3 gallons a day from

our Jersey and we get about 2 to 2.5 gal/day from our 3 goats.

>

> Reasons for switching to goats:

> A2 genetics (it was my understanding that all goats are A2)

> Health reasons

> Ease of keep - dc more comfortable with a smaller animal, cleaner, easier to

clean up after (all of which are true in our case)

> We thought they would be less expensive to keep.

>

> What is your experience in keeping goats? What do you feed them in the way of

grain? How much? Is the grain necessary? (If they don't eat their ration,

their milk production does drop.) Some folks don't feed their milk cow any

grain at all.

>

> Any advice, experience, thoughts would be appreciated.

>

> Thanks so much!

> Dona

>

Posted

Dona,

As a former goat owner and long time cow owner I prefer cows. I have to say that I am a licensed raw milk dairy. I could not make what I make now on cows with goats. So if I am going to have a viable business I am going to do cows. This is fluid milk only not cheese. I milk three cows and get 125 gallons of milk a week. I would have to milk a lot of goats for that amount of milk and could not sell it all even if I did get it. I started as a family milker and so one animal for our family was fine. A small breed cow managed properly I feel is a bigger advantage than two or thee goats. I have found that all of my cows will eat brush just like a goat. So if you don't have improved pasture that is ok. I feed very little grain and all grass hay, so the cost per lb of milk I feel is good. It may not be as cheap as a lb of goat milk. I also feel you can do more with cows milk because you can get a lot of the cream with out using cream separator. I also find that fencing in a cow is much easier than goats. Cows also seem to be less demanding in their up keep. I trim hooves once a year as to monthly with goats. I only worm once a year. A good cow can milk up to 16 years, not many goats will go that long. A calf is of greater value in a cow as well. So I guess I will stay with my cows.

ChrisReasons for switching to goats:A2 genetics (it was my understanding that all goats are A2)Health reasonsEase of keep - dc more comfortable with a smaller animal, cleaner, easier to clean up after (all of which are true in our case)We thought they would be less expensive to keep.What is your experience in keeping goats? What do you feed them in the way of grain? How much? Is the grain necessary? (If they don't eat their ration, their milk production does drop.) Some folks don't feed their milk cow any grain at all.

Posted

Hi

What kind of cows do you have? We might go back to cows at some point. But I would like to have a slightly different set-up for them where we aren't cleaning out the shelter 2 times a day which is attached to the parlor. I'd like them to have a shelter out in the cow area we have. We could let them graze in the pasture, but then it wouldn't be good for harvesting and we aren't set up for rotation. Ahhhh, I wish some of you folks lived close around here where we could have these conversations in person!!

Thanks for your reponse!

Dona

Posted

I have 10 acres of woods and pasture. It is unimproved which I hope to change this year. I am milking Brown Swiss. They are all of my breeding so I am really happy with them. They are about 1300 lbs so not to big. I just sent a 6 yr old cow to the sale because I could not get her to settle and she was 1800 lbs, big cow. I average about 5 to 6 gallons of milk daily with a 30% butter fat. I feed 12 lbs of a grain mix that I have custom made for me. It is soy and corn free and is mostly forage products. I do add 3 lbs of alfalfa pellets daily. I feed only grass hay which here is expensive. All hay here is expensive and a chore to get. I buy 6 months worth at a time. Wish I could put up a years worth. My cows will eat anything. I move no manure at all. Bad back and I farm on my own with the help of my son. All cows are out all day and night long. I have run in shelters and a covered feeding station for hay. There are rubber mats so I use a flat shovel to clean them as needed. I do rotate my cows over the land. This last lactation I averaged 375 gallons a month from three cows. I am going to slow down a little and just do two this lactation. I have a lot of farm work to do this year. I raise a bull every year for breeding and then we eat him. So breeding is free and so is our meat, I sell half. I had over thirty goats and milked an average of 10 a day when I was raising calves. I really like my two little cows allot. Up keep is much easier too. I just retired a cow after 12 great lactations and only one lost calf, my fault. Most goats don't do as well and I get a full 10 month lactation out of my cows at a good production rate.

Chris

Hi

What kind of cows do you have? We might go back to cows at some point. But I would like to have a slightly different set-up for them where we aren't cleaning out the shelter 2 times a day which is attached to the parlor. I'd like them to have a shelter out in the cow area we have. We could let them graze in the pasture, but then it wouldn't be good for harvesting and we aren't set up for rotation. Ahhhh, I wish some of you folks lived close around here where we could have these conversations in person!!

Thanks for your reponse!

Dona

Posted

Dona - Best response I read was from Ziggy. I've been milking goats for over 18yrs. and a member of RMAC...there is a "saying you will never get rich off milking goats!" True, I'm afraid, those of us that milk goats do it for the Love of it.

If you are getting 2 to 2.5 gals a day from 3 goats think that is average production. A goat that gives a gallon of milk in two milkings, would be a great producer. Your reasons for switching to goats are valid. I agree 100% with Ziggy about GRAIN. My goats, get 1.5pounds of grain each between 2 milkings. As Ziggy mentioned, good quality alfalfa, and I also feed nice grass hay. Maybe your cost would cut if you did not feed free choice. I feed 2X daily, rule of thumb one flake per animal, or some say what they will mostly eat up within 30-40 minutes. I buy hay farmer direct (not from feed store) save 30-50% per bale.

Read some responses dealing with Nubians vs. other breeds for milk flavor...think that discussion was aired once before. Milk flavor is related to feed and good rumin conversion, not necessarily breed, though Nubian milk tends to be richer. I milk Nubians and Saanens, find the milk to be rich, creamy, sweet ... my experience good quality feed in great quality milk out.

Best of Luck sharron

Subject: ? regarding cost of keep of goatsTo: RawDairy Date: Thursday, August 19, 2010, 7:06 AM

We recently sold our milk cow and switched to dairy goats (Nubians). We love them and their milk. We thought one of the benefits would be that they ate less and therefore would cost less than a milk cow. We had a full-sized Jersey. But our 3 dairy goats eat a lot of grain in comparison to what our one Jersey ate, and that gets rather costly. I used to feed them Purina Goat Chow, but have switched to Nutrena Top Goat and a sweet feed of COB with molasses, 1/2 and 1/2. That has cut the cost of the grain almost in half, but not quite. Still very expensive compared to our cow's consumption of grain. Of course the milk production doesn't compare either. We were getting about 3 gallons a day from our Jersey and we get about 2 to 2.5 gal/day from our 3 goats.Reasons for switching to goats:A2 genetics (it was my understanding that all goats are A2)Health reasonsEase of keep - dc more comfortable with a smaller animal, cleaner, easier to

clean up after (all of which are true in our case)We thought they would be less expensive to keep.What is your experience in keeping goats? What do you feed them in the way of grain? How much? Is the grain necessary? (If they don't eat their ration, their milk production does drop.) Some folks don't feed their milk cow any grain at all.Any advice, experience, thoughts would be appreciated.Thanks so much!Dona

Posted

>

>

> I have 10 acres of woods and pasture. It is unimproved which I hope to

change this year. I am milking Brown Swiss. They are all of my breeding so I

am really happy with them. They are about 1300 lbs so not to big. I just sent

a 6 yr old cow to the sale because I could not get her to settle and she was

1800 lbs, big cow. I average about 5 to 6 gallons of milk daily with a 30%

butter fat. I feed 12 lbs of a grain mix that I have custom made for me. It is

soy and corn free and is mostly forage products. I do add 3 lbs of alfalfa

pellets daily. I feed only grass hay which here is expensive. All hay here is

expensive and a chore to get. I buy 6 months worth at a time. Wish I could put

up a years worth. My cows will eat anything. I move no manure at all. Bad

back and I farm on my own with the help of my son. All cows are out all day and

night long. I have run in shelters and a covered feeding station for hay.

There are rubber mats so I use a flat shovel to clean them as needed. I do

rotate my cows over the land. This last lactation I averaged 375 gallons a

month from three cows. I am going to slow down a little and just do two this

lactation. I have a lot of farm work to do this year. I raise a bull every

year for breeding and then we eat him. So breeding is free and so is our meat,

I sell half. I had over thirty goats and milked an average of 10 a day when I

was raising calves. I really like my two little cows allot. Up keep is much

easier too. I just retired a cow after 12 great lactations and only one lost

calf, my fault. Most goats don't do as well and I get a full 10 month lactation

out of my cows at a good production rate.

> Chris

>

>

>

>

> Hi

>

> What kind of cows do you have? We might go back to cows at some point. But

I would like to have a slightly different set-up for them where we aren't

cleaning out the shelter 2 times a day which is attached to the parlor. I'd

like them to have a shelter out in the cow area we have. We could let them

graze in the pasture, but then it wouldn't be good for harvesting and we aren't

set up for rotation. Ahhhh, I wish some of you folks lived close around here

where we could have these conversations in person!!

>

> Thanks for your reponse!

> Dona

>

chris, you said in your post that you feed a custom mix of mostly forage

products. I was wondering if you would mind sharing the ingredients as we make

our own feed due to the lack of intrest of our feed mills in this area to

support the little guy as well as cost of ingredients in bulk quantities. It

looks like you have a good mixture worked out and I might want to try it myself

in the near future.

Posted

>

>

> I have 10 acres of woods and pasture. It is unimproved which I hope to

change this year. I am milking Brown Swiss. They are all of my breeding so I

am really happy with them. They are about 1300 lbs so not to big. I just sent

a 6 yr old cow to the sale because I could not get her to settle and she was

1800 lbs, big cow. I average about 5 to 6 gallons of milk daily with a 30%

butter fat. I feed 12 lbs of a grain mix that I have custom made for me. It is

soy and corn free and is mostly forage products. I do add 3 lbs of alfalfa

pellets daily. I feed only grass hay which here is expensive. All hay here is

expensive and a chore to get. I buy 6 months worth at a time. Wish I could put

up a years worth. My cows will eat anything. I move no manure at all. Bad

back and I farm on my own with the help of my son. All cows are out all day and

night long. I have run in shelters and a covered feeding station for hay.

There are rubber mats so I use a flat shovel to clean them as needed. I do

rotate my cows over the land. This last lactation I averaged 375 gallons a

month from three cows. I am going to slow down a little and just do two this

lactation. I have a lot of farm work to do this year. I raise a bull every

year for breeding and then we eat him. So breeding is free and so is our meat,

I sell half. I had over thirty goats and milked an average of 10 a day when I

was raising calves. I really like my two little cows allot. Up keep is much

easier too. I just retired a cow after 12 great lactations and only one lost

calf, my fault. Most goats don't do as well and I get a full 10 month lactation

out of my cows at a good production rate.

> Chris

>

>

>

>

> Hi

>

> What kind of cows do you have? We might go back to cows at some point. But

I would like to have a slightly different set-up for them where we aren't

cleaning out the shelter 2 times a day which is attached to the parlor. I'd

like them to have a shelter out in the cow area we have. We could let them

graze in the pasture, but then it wouldn't be good for harvesting and we aren't

set up for rotation. Ahhhh, I wish some of you folks lived close around here

where we could have these conversations in person!!

>

> Thanks for your reponse!

> Dona

>

chris, you said in your post that you feed a custom mix of mostly forage

products. I was wondering if you would mind sharing the ingredients as we make

our own feed due to the lack of intrest of our feed mills in this area to

support the little guy as well as cost of ingredients in bulk quantities. It

looks like you have a good mixture worked out and I might want to try it myself

in the near future.

Posted

I second the post about adding in things like sunflower seeds and make sure your

minerals are really good - we love Redmond. Of course, we're in Utah so they're

just down the road. I also second making sure your milk lines are strong.

Also, goats aren't grazers like cows, they're foragers - they love brush, tree

brances, sunflowers (any safe flowers are like candy), vines. They'll eat grass

if they have to but they don't prefer it which makes it easier on those of us

keeping them in our backyard. They're perfectly happy to have me cut and drag

stuff to them - I don't need acre upon acre of land for them to graze. You

might have acres and so a cow may end up being easier in the long run. We've

really developed a taste for goats milk (so pretty and white) and love using it

for our cheese so we can't imagine going back to cows milk. But to each his

own, of course!

We've added to the goat's ration some really nice scratch grain we got for the

chickens this seasson and they've loved it. You have to watch out giving them

wheat, though, as it can contain a bacteria (I think it's bacteria) that the

goat's have a hard time with - just make sure you trust the source. Right now

our girls get a goat pellet (put out by our feed store so we save a few bucks

over Purina), a COB mix without molasses, beet mash, sunflower seeds, minerals,

yeast, Probios, lots of branches, alfalfa and the occassional wildflower mix.

There are calculators out there to make sure that you're giving your girls

enough protein and minerals in their feed but don't be hestitant to experiment a

bit.

We love our goats and it's so much nicer having smaller animals. Don't get me

wrong, there's nothing finer than a really great cow, but they're SO BIG!

Good luck,

tessa

>

> We recently sold our milk cow and switched to dairy goats (Nubians). We love

them and their milk. We thought one of the benefits would be that they ate less

and therefore would cost less than a milk cow. We had a full-sized Jersey. But

our 3 dairy goats eat a lot of grain in comparison to what our one Jersey ate,

and that gets rather costly. I used to feed them Purina Goat Chow, but have

switched to Nutrena Top Goat and a sweet feed of COB with molasses, 1/2 and 1/2.

That has cut the cost of the grain almost in half, but not quite. Still very

expensive compared to our cow's consumption of grain. Of course the milk

production doesn't compare either. We were getting about 3 gallons a day from

our Jersey and we get about 2 to 2.5 gal/day from our 3 goats.

>

> Reasons for switching to goats:

> A2 genetics (it was my understanding that all goats are A2)

> Health reasons

> Ease of keep - dc more comfortable with a smaller animal, cleaner, easier to

clean up after (all of which are true in our case)

> We thought they would be less expensive to keep.

>

> What is your experience in keeping goats? What do you feed them in the way of

grain? How much? Is the grain necessary? (If they don't eat their ration,

their milk production does drop.) Some folks don't feed their milk cow any

grain at all.

>

> Any advice, experience, thoughts would be appreciated.

>

> Thanks so much!

> Dona

>

Posted

I second the post about adding in things like sunflower seeds and make sure your

minerals are really good - we love Redmond. Of course, we're in Utah so they're

just down the road. I also second making sure your milk lines are strong.

Also, goats aren't grazers like cows, they're foragers - they love brush, tree

brances, sunflowers (any safe flowers are like candy), vines. They'll eat grass

if they have to but they don't prefer it which makes it easier on those of us

keeping them in our backyard. They're perfectly happy to have me cut and drag

stuff to them - I don't need acre upon acre of land for them to graze. You

might have acres and so a cow may end up being easier in the long run. We've

really developed a taste for goats milk (so pretty and white) and love using it

for our cheese so we can't imagine going back to cows milk. But to each his

own, of course!

We've added to the goat's ration some really nice scratch grain we got for the

chickens this seasson and they've loved it. You have to watch out giving them

wheat, though, as it can contain a bacteria (I think it's bacteria) that the

goat's have a hard time with - just make sure you trust the source. Right now

our girls get a goat pellet (put out by our feed store so we save a few bucks

over Purina), a COB mix without molasses, beet mash, sunflower seeds, minerals,

yeast, Probios, lots of branches, alfalfa and the occassional wildflower mix.

There are calculators out there to make sure that you're giving your girls

enough protein and minerals in their feed but don't be hestitant to experiment a

bit.

We love our goats and it's so much nicer having smaller animals. Don't get me

wrong, there's nothing finer than a really great cow, but they're SO BIG!

Good luck,

tessa

>

> We recently sold our milk cow and switched to dairy goats (Nubians). We love

them and their milk. We thought one of the benefits would be that they ate less

and therefore would cost less than a milk cow. We had a full-sized Jersey. But

our 3 dairy goats eat a lot of grain in comparison to what our one Jersey ate,

and that gets rather costly. I used to feed them Purina Goat Chow, but have

switched to Nutrena Top Goat and a sweet feed of COB with molasses, 1/2 and 1/2.

That has cut the cost of the grain almost in half, but not quite. Still very

expensive compared to our cow's consumption of grain. Of course the milk

production doesn't compare either. We were getting about 3 gallons a day from

our Jersey and we get about 2 to 2.5 gal/day from our 3 goats.

>

> Reasons for switching to goats:

> A2 genetics (it was my understanding that all goats are A2)

> Health reasons

> Ease of keep - dc more comfortable with a smaller animal, cleaner, easier to

clean up after (all of which are true in our case)

> We thought they would be less expensive to keep.

>

> What is your experience in keeping goats? What do you feed them in the way of

grain? How much? Is the grain necessary? (If they don't eat their ration,

their milk production does drop.) Some folks don't feed their milk cow any

grain at all.

>

> Any advice, experience, thoughts would be appreciated.

>

> Thanks so much!

> Dona

>

Posted

I second the post about adding in things like sunflower seeds and make sure your

minerals are really good - we love Redmond. Of course, we're in Utah so they're

just down the road. I also second making sure your milk lines are strong.

Also, goats aren't grazers like cows, they're foragers - they love brush, tree

brances, sunflowers (any safe flowers are like candy), vines. They'll eat grass

if they have to but they don't prefer it which makes it easier on those of us

keeping them in our backyard. They're perfectly happy to have me cut and drag

stuff to them - I don't need acre upon acre of land for them to graze. You

might have acres and so a cow may end up being easier in the long run. We've

really developed a taste for goats milk (so pretty and white) and love using it

for our cheese so we can't imagine going back to cows milk. But to each his

own, of course!

We've added to the goat's ration some really nice scratch grain we got for the

chickens this seasson and they've loved it. You have to watch out giving them

wheat, though, as it can contain a bacteria (I think it's bacteria) that the

goat's have a hard time with - just make sure you trust the source. Right now

our girls get a goat pellet (put out by our feed store so we save a few bucks

over Purina), a COB mix without molasses, beet mash, sunflower seeds, minerals,

yeast, Probios, lots of branches, alfalfa and the occassional wildflower mix.

There are calculators out there to make sure that you're giving your girls

enough protein and minerals in their feed but don't be hestitant to experiment a

bit.

We love our goats and it's so much nicer having smaller animals. Don't get me

wrong, there's nothing finer than a really great cow, but they're SO BIG!

Good luck,

tessa

>

> We recently sold our milk cow and switched to dairy goats (Nubians). We love

them and their milk. We thought one of the benefits would be that they ate less

and therefore would cost less than a milk cow. We had a full-sized Jersey. But

our 3 dairy goats eat a lot of grain in comparison to what our one Jersey ate,

and that gets rather costly. I used to feed them Purina Goat Chow, but have

switched to Nutrena Top Goat and a sweet feed of COB with molasses, 1/2 and 1/2.

That has cut the cost of the grain almost in half, but not quite. Still very

expensive compared to our cow's consumption of grain. Of course the milk

production doesn't compare either. We were getting about 3 gallons a day from

our Jersey and we get about 2 to 2.5 gal/day from our 3 goats.

>

> Reasons for switching to goats:

> A2 genetics (it was my understanding that all goats are A2)

> Health reasons

> Ease of keep - dc more comfortable with a smaller animal, cleaner, easier to

clean up after (all of which are true in our case)

> We thought they would be less expensive to keep.

>

> What is your experience in keeping goats? What do you feed them in the way of

grain? How much? Is the grain necessary? (If they don't eat their ration,

their milk production does drop.) Some folks don't feed their milk cow any

grain at all.

>

> Any advice, experience, thoughts would be appreciated.

>

> Thanks so much!

> Dona

>

Posted

I forgot to mention, although this is probably as dumb as telling you to buckle

your seat belt, only feed the goats when you milk - or twice a day, since some

people only milk once a day. A normal size milk doe should really only have 3-4

cups at time of grain ration. You risk bloat and feed waste (eventually what

they eat stops turning into milk and starts turning into fat!) if you let them

eat as much as they want. Minerals and soda can be fed free choice, as well as

hay and browse.

So, duh, you probably already know that, but there you go...

tessa

> >

> > We recently sold our milk cow and switched to dairy goats (Nubians). We

love them and their milk. We thought one of the benefits would be that they ate

less and therefore would cost less than a milk cow. We had a full-sized Jersey.

But our 3 dairy goats eat a lot of grain in comparison to what our one Jersey

ate, and that gets rather costly. I used to feed them Purina Goat Chow, but

have switched to Nutrena Top Goat and a sweet feed of COB with molasses, 1/2 and

1/2. That has cut the cost of the grain almost in half, but not quite. Still

very expensive compared to our cow's consumption of grain. Of course the milk

production doesn't compare either. We were getting about 3 gallons a day from

our Jersey and we get about 2 to 2.5 gal/day from our 3 goats.

> >

> > Reasons for switching to goats:

> > A2 genetics (it was my understanding that all goats are A2)

> > Health reasons

> > Ease of keep - dc more comfortable with a smaller animal, cleaner, easier to

clean up after (all of which are true in our case)

> > We thought they would be less expensive to keep.

> >

> > What is your experience in keeping goats? What do you feed them in the way

of grain? How much? Is the grain necessary? (If they don't eat their ration,

their milk production does drop.) Some folks don't feed their milk cow any

grain at all.

> >

> > Any advice, experience, thoughts would be appreciated.

> >

> > Thanks so much!

> > Dona

> >

>

Posted

I forgot to mention, although this is probably as dumb as telling you to buckle

your seat belt, only feed the goats when you milk - or twice a day, since some

people only milk once a day. A normal size milk doe should really only have 3-4

cups at time of grain ration. You risk bloat and feed waste (eventually what

they eat stops turning into milk and starts turning into fat!) if you let them

eat as much as they want. Minerals and soda can be fed free choice, as well as

hay and browse.

So, duh, you probably already know that, but there you go...

tessa

> >

> > We recently sold our milk cow and switched to dairy goats (Nubians). We

love them and their milk. We thought one of the benefits would be that they ate

less and therefore would cost less than a milk cow. We had a full-sized Jersey.

But our 3 dairy goats eat a lot of grain in comparison to what our one Jersey

ate, and that gets rather costly. I used to feed them Purina Goat Chow, but

have switched to Nutrena Top Goat and a sweet feed of COB with molasses, 1/2 and

1/2. That has cut the cost of the grain almost in half, but not quite. Still

very expensive compared to our cow's consumption of grain. Of course the milk

production doesn't compare either. We were getting about 3 gallons a day from

our Jersey and we get about 2 to 2.5 gal/day from our 3 goats.

> >

> > Reasons for switching to goats:

> > A2 genetics (it was my understanding that all goats are A2)

> > Health reasons

> > Ease of keep - dc more comfortable with a smaller animal, cleaner, easier to

clean up after (all of which are true in our case)

> > We thought they would be less expensive to keep.

> >

> > What is your experience in keeping goats? What do you feed them in the way

of grain? How much? Is the grain necessary? (If they don't eat their ration,

their milk production does drop.) Some folks don't feed their milk cow any

grain at all.

> >

> > Any advice, experience, thoughts would be appreciated.

> >

> > Thanks so much!

> > Dona

> >

>

Posted

We've had both milk goats and milk cows, and the goats have turned out to be cheaper plus them being a small animal and easier to care for. Most does here get 1 pound of grain, 2x a day (so 2 lbs/day), bigger producers get 3 pounds a day. We use a horse feed. Every morning they get fed alfalfa hay, and then our does go out to pasture for about 8 hours everyday.During the winter months (we milk about 1/2 the does through) we feed alfalfa/orchard grass hay and the same amount of grain to the milkers. All our does produce very well and are in good weight.It costs us about $1 per gallon of milk, give or take a little. That is extremely cheap, but even if it was not cheaper - we would still do the goats. Some of my family cannot tolerate *anything* that has cow milk in it, plus all of us like goat milk so much better!To each their own, that's just our experience ;).Suriyah ________Good Goats ~ Mini Nubian Dairy & Meat Goats in NE Oklahoma,http://www.goodgoats.netBlog - http://goodgoats.blogspot.com Donna - If I could get hay at that price I suspect my cost would go down to $300 per year or maybe less. Even the "worst" straight fescue is $4/bale around here from the farm. I have Alpines, Nubians and one Lamancha and one Saanen (the singles are kids purchased this year to satisfy personal preferences of children so they can show them). We only feed grain to milkers on the milk stand and probably only about 3 pounds per day (or 1.5 per milking) - I know feed manufacturers may recommend more but they are all in good body condition at this rate. (I calculated this by how many pounds of feed I go through a month - average 50 pounds per day divided by 16 milkers) On average our goats give us just over a gallon a day per goat - first fresheners are allowed a little less but if they aren't putting that out by 2nd year then they are sent down the road. I have several that are closer to 2 gallons a day - one of my Nubians milked 14.4 lbs on a one day milk test on one of the hottest days of the summer and a few of my Alpines do about the same. Ziggy www.sunrisefarmnc.com

Posted

We've had both milk goats and milk cows, and the goats have turned out to be cheaper plus them being a small animal and easier to care for. Most does here get 1 pound of grain, 2x a day (so 2 lbs/day), bigger producers get 3 pounds a day. We use a horse feed. Every morning they get fed alfalfa hay, and then our does go out to pasture for about 8 hours everyday.During the winter months (we milk about 1/2 the does through) we feed alfalfa/orchard grass hay and the same amount of grain to the milkers. All our does produce very well and are in good weight.It costs us about $1 per gallon of milk, give or take a little. That is extremely cheap, but even if it was not cheaper - we would still do the goats. Some of my family cannot tolerate *anything* that has cow milk in it, plus all of us like goat milk so much better!To each their own, that's just our experience ;).Suriyah ________Good Goats ~ Mini Nubian Dairy & Meat Goats in NE Oklahoma,http://www.goodgoats.netBlog - http://goodgoats.blogspot.com Donna - If I could get hay at that price I suspect my cost would go down to $300 per year or maybe less. Even the "worst" straight fescue is $4/bale around here from the farm. I have Alpines, Nubians and one Lamancha and one Saanen (the singles are kids purchased this year to satisfy personal preferences of children so they can show them). We only feed grain to milkers on the milk stand and probably only about 3 pounds per day (or 1.5 per milking) - I know feed manufacturers may recommend more but they are all in good body condition at this rate. (I calculated this by how many pounds of feed I go through a month - average 50 pounds per day divided by 16 milkers) On average our goats give us just over a gallon a day per goat - first fresheners are allowed a little less but if they aren't putting that out by 2nd year then they are sent down the road. I have several that are closer to 2 gallons a day - one of my Nubians milked 14.4 lbs on a one day milk test on one of the hottest days of the summer and a few of my Alpines do about the same. Ziggy www.sunrisefarmnc.com

Posted

We've had both milk goats and milk cows, and the goats have turned out to be cheaper plus them being a small animal and easier to care for. Most does here get 1 pound of grain, 2x a day (so 2 lbs/day), bigger producers get 3 pounds a day. We use a horse feed. Every morning they get fed alfalfa hay, and then our does go out to pasture for about 8 hours everyday.During the winter months (we milk about 1/2 the does through) we feed alfalfa/orchard grass hay and the same amount of grain to the milkers. All our does produce very well and are in good weight.It costs us about $1 per gallon of milk, give or take a little. That is extremely cheap, but even if it was not cheaper - we would still do the goats. Some of my family cannot tolerate *anything* that has cow milk in it, plus all of us like goat milk so much better!To each their own, that's just our experience ;).Suriyah ________Good Goats ~ Mini Nubian Dairy & Meat Goats in NE Oklahoma,http://www.goodgoats.netBlog - http://goodgoats.blogspot.com Donna - If I could get hay at that price I suspect my cost would go down to $300 per year or maybe less. Even the "worst" straight fescue is $4/bale around here from the farm. I have Alpines, Nubians and one Lamancha and one Saanen (the singles are kids purchased this year to satisfy personal preferences of children so they can show them). We only feed grain to milkers on the milk stand and probably only about 3 pounds per day (or 1.5 per milking) - I know feed manufacturers may recommend more but they are all in good body condition at this rate. (I calculated this by how many pounds of feed I go through a month - average 50 pounds per day divided by 16 milkers) On average our goats give us just over a gallon a day per goat - first fresheners are allowed a little less but if they aren't putting that out by 2nd year then they are sent down the road. I have several that are closer to 2 gallons a day - one of my Nubians milked 14.4 lbs on a one day milk test on one of the hottest days of the summer and a few of my Alpines do about the same. Ziggy www.sunrisefarmnc.com

Posted

We milk goats and they give about the average of 3/4 gallon a day over their lactation. Some a little more, some a little less. If we start with our own breeding we generally milk a good ten months. they get about 3 lbs per day of a homemade mix of about 14% protein with lots of goodies like flax, sunflower seed and beet pulp along with a bit of wheat , lots of barley NO corn or soy. Also alfalfa. We found that feeding a top qualtiy forage is what puts milk in the pail. Try second or third cutitng deep dark green flakey, leafy hay of any sort and you will get milk!

Genetics also play a part in how much milk you get. Try lamancha's. They are sweet, have rich milk and lots of it.

Rhonda in NY

Posted

We milk goats and they give about the average of 3/4 gallon a day over their lactation. Some a little more, some a little less. If we start with our own breeding we generally milk a good ten months. they get about 3 lbs per day of a homemade mix of about 14% protein with lots of goodies like flax, sunflower seed and beet pulp along with a bit of wheat , lots of barley NO corn or soy. Also alfalfa. We found that feeding a top qualtiy forage is what puts milk in the pail. Try second or third cutitng deep dark green flakey, leafy hay of any sort and you will get milk!

Genetics also play a part in how much milk you get. Try lamancha's. They are sweet, have rich milk and lots of it.

Rhonda in NY

Posted

We milk goats and they give about the average of 3/4 gallon a day over their lactation. Some a little more, some a little less. If we start with our own breeding we generally milk a good ten months. they get about 3 lbs per day of a homemade mix of about 14% protein with lots of goodies like flax, sunflower seed and beet pulp along with a bit of wheat , lots of barley NO corn or soy. Also alfalfa. We found that feeding a top qualtiy forage is what puts milk in the pail. Try second or third cutitng deep dark green flakey, leafy hay of any sort and you will get milk!

Genetics also play a part in how much milk you get. Try lamancha's. They are sweet, have rich milk and lots of it.

Rhonda in NY

Posted

It also depends on the breeds; my neighbor with Saanens and

Alpines gets between 2-4 gallons a day from her does. My mini-Togg give us up

to 2 quarts a day, milking once a day. We have also found that some beautiful

perfectly conformed goats may do well in the show ring, but are terrible

milkers. Buy the goat based on what you want it to do.

Becky Leach

Rocky Ridge Ranch

Posted

We keep a herd of 50 nubians on 32 scrub covered acres. We spend $10 / month per

goat in sunny south Texas, not including fences and barns.

> >

> > We recently sold our milk cow and switched to dairy goats (Nubians). We

love them and their milk. We thought one of the benefits would be that they ate

less and therefore would cost less than a milk cow. We had a full-sized Jersey.

But our 3 dairy goats eat a lot of grain in comparison to what our one Jersey

ate, and that gets rather costly. I used to feed them Purina Goat Chow, but

have switched to Nutrena Top Goat and a sweet feed of COB with molasses, 1/2 and

1/2. That has cut the cost of the grain almost in half, but not quite. Still

very expensive compared to our cow's consumption of grain. Of course the milk

production doesn't compare either. We were getting about 3 gallons a day from

our Jersey and we get about 2 to 2.5 gal/day from our 3 goats.

> >

> > Reasons for switching to goats:

> > A2 genetics (it was my understanding that all goats are A2)

> > Health reasons

> > Ease of keep - dc more comfortable with a smaller animal, cleaner, easier to

clean up after (all of which are true in our case)

> > We thought they would be less expensive to keep.

> >

> > What is your experience in keeping goats? What do you feed them in the way

of grain? How much? Is the grain necessary? (If they don't eat their ration,

their milk production does drop.) Some folks don't feed their milk cow any

grain at all.

> >

> > Any advice, experience, thoughts would be appreciated.

> >

> > Thanks so much!

> > Dona

> >

>

Posted

We raise Nubian and Lamancha goats. We mix all of our own food and never use GMO

corn, soy or beet pulp. We feed only one pound of grain per day per goat. We try

to raise low cost, self sustaining goats. They get good pastures and mixed

grass hay that we cut - never any alfalfa. Our girls get milked once a day and

give us 3 quarts a day until we rebreed. We milked one Nubian for 3 years

without rebreeding and she was still giving us 2 quarts a day. We have found as

we cut the grain mix that the health of the herd improved and the extra

attention that they needed went down. All of the girls are in good health, have

their own outside shelters and never go to the barn unless sick or delivering.

We also give them free choice kelp and baking soda. We mix apple cider vinegar

in the grain mix and have NO mastitis and the boys never get UC. We have found

simple is better.

Mike

Kentucky

>

>

> We milk goats and they give about the average of 3/4 gallon a day over their

lactation. Some a little more, some a little less. If we start with our own

breeding we generally milk a good ten months. they get about 3 lbs per day of

a homemade mix of about 14% protein with lots of goodies like flax, sunflower

seed and beet pulp along with a bit of wheat , lots of barley NO corn or soy.

Also alfalfa. We found that feeding a top qualtiy forage is what puts milk in

the pail. Try second or third cutitng deep dark green flakey, leafy hay of any

sort and you will get milk!

> Genetics also play a part in how much milk you get. Try lamancha's. They

are sweet, have rich milk and lots of it.

>

> Rhonda in NY

>

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...