Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Re: ? regarding cost of keep of goats

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted

We raise Nubian and Lamancha goats. We mix all of our own food and never use GMO

corn, soy or beet pulp. We feed only one pound of grain per day per goat. We try

to raise low cost, self sustaining goats. They get good pastures and mixed

grass hay that we cut - never any alfalfa. Our girls get milked once a day and

give us 3 quarts a day until we rebreed. We milked one Nubian for 3 years

without rebreeding and she was still giving us 2 quarts a day. We have found as

we cut the grain mix that the health of the herd improved and the extra

attention that they needed went down. All of the girls are in good health, have

their own outside shelters and never go to the barn unless sick or delivering.

We also give them free choice kelp and baking soda. We mix apple cider vinegar

in the grain mix and have NO mastitis and the boys never get UC. We have found

simple is better.

Mike

Kentucky

>

>

> We milk goats and they give about the average of 3/4 gallon a day over their

lactation. Some a little more, some a little less. If we start with our own

breeding we generally milk a good ten months. they get about 3 lbs per day of

a homemade mix of about 14% protein with lots of goodies like flax, sunflower

seed and beet pulp along with a bit of wheat , lots of barley NO corn or soy.

Also alfalfa. We found that feeding a top qualtiy forage is what puts milk in

the pail. Try second or third cutitng deep dark green flakey, leafy hay of any

sort and you will get milk!

> Genetics also play a part in how much milk you get. Try lamancha's. They

are sweet, have rich milk and lots of it.

>

> Rhonda in NY

>

Posted

We raise Nubian and Lamancha goats. We mix all of our own food and never use GMO

corn, soy or beet pulp. We feed only one pound of grain per day per goat. We try

to raise low cost, self sustaining goats. They get good pastures and mixed

grass hay that we cut - never any alfalfa. Our girls get milked once a day and

give us 3 quarts a day until we rebreed. We milked one Nubian for 3 years

without rebreeding and she was still giving us 2 quarts a day. We have found as

we cut the grain mix that the health of the herd improved and the extra

attention that they needed went down. All of the girls are in good health, have

their own outside shelters and never go to the barn unless sick or delivering.

We also give them free choice kelp and baking soda. We mix apple cider vinegar

in the grain mix and have NO mastitis and the boys never get UC. We have found

simple is better.

Mike

Kentucky

>

>

> We milk goats and they give about the average of 3/4 gallon a day over their

lactation. Some a little more, some a little less. If we start with our own

breeding we generally milk a good ten months. they get about 3 lbs per day of

a homemade mix of about 14% protein with lots of goodies like flax, sunflower

seed and beet pulp along with a bit of wheat , lots of barley NO corn or soy.

Also alfalfa. We found that feeding a top qualtiy forage is what puts milk in

the pail. Try second or third cutitng deep dark green flakey, leafy hay of any

sort and you will get milk!

> Genetics also play a part in how much milk you get. Try lamancha's. They

are sweet, have rich milk and lots of it.

>

> Rhonda in NY

>

Posted

Everyone feeds differently. And of course location will change your costs a lot.

Goats require better hay and a shed, where cows do not. Between cows and goats, The initial cost on getting ready for goats is the highest. Four strands of barb wire keep in any cow. Goats fencing is a bit more specialized. Goats need a clean shed, our cows prefer the woods and didn't use the shed when we had one. They haven't had a shed in years. Goats require more worming, higher mineral needs, and hoof trimmings. Cows seem to have less worm and mineral needs, and should never need hooves trimmed. Goats need young well-dried hay free of mold. Cows can handle more mature hay and a bit of mold doesn't faze them.

But my goats are certainly cheaper to *feed* than my cows.

I feed just plain whole dry oats with black oil sunflower seeds on the milk stand. Each doe eats about 1-2 lbs per milking. They get quality 2nd, 3rd or 4th cutting alfalfa when I can get it, and alfalfa pellets if I cannot. They also have free-choice grass hay. Free-choice mineral that is high in copper(I have used a quality beef-cattle mineral for many years now).

But my cows are less work. I enjoy my goats more. DixonOzark JewelsNubians and Lamanchaswww.ozarkjewels.netMorningland Dairy Raw Milk Cheeseswww.morninglanddairy.com

Subject: ? regarding cost of keep of goatsTo: RawDairy Date: Thursday, August 19, 2010, 8:06 AM

We recently sold our milk cow and switched to dairy goats (Nubians). We love them and their milk. We thought one of the benefits would be that they ate less and therefore would cost less than a milk cow. We had a full-sized Jersey. But our 3 dairy goats eat a lot of grain in comparison to what our one Jersey ate, and that gets rather costly. I used to feed them Purina Goat Chow, but have switched to Nutrena Top Goat and a sweet feed of COB with molasses, 1/2 and 1/2. That has cut the cost of the grain almost in half, but not quite. Still very expensive compared to our cow's consumption of grain. Of course the milk production doesn't compare either. We were getting about 3 gallons a day from our Jersey and we get about 2 to 2.5 gal/day from our 3 goats.Reasons for switching to goats:A2 genetics (it was my understanding that all goats are A2)Health reasonsEase of keep - dc more comfortable with a smaller animal, cleaner, easier to

clean up after (all of which are true in our case)We thought they would be less expensive to keep.What is your experience in keeping goats? What do you feed them in the way of grain? How much? Is the grain necessary? (If they don't eat their ration, their milk production does drop.) Some folks don't feed their milk cow any grain at all.Any advice, experience, thoughts would be appreciated.Thanks so much!Dona

Posted

Everyone feeds differently. And of course location will change your costs a lot.

Goats require better hay and a shed, where cows do not. Between cows and goats, The initial cost on getting ready for goats is the highest. Four strands of barb wire keep in any cow. Goats fencing is a bit more specialized. Goats need a clean shed, our cows prefer the woods and didn't use the shed when we had one. They haven't had a shed in years. Goats require more worming, higher mineral needs, and hoof trimmings. Cows seem to have less worm and mineral needs, and should never need hooves trimmed. Goats need young well-dried hay free of mold. Cows can handle more mature hay and a bit of mold doesn't faze them.

But my goats are certainly cheaper to *feed* than my cows.

I feed just plain whole dry oats with black oil sunflower seeds on the milk stand. Each doe eats about 1-2 lbs per milking. They get quality 2nd, 3rd or 4th cutting alfalfa when I can get it, and alfalfa pellets if I cannot. They also have free-choice grass hay. Free-choice mineral that is high in copper(I have used a quality beef-cattle mineral for many years now).

But my cows are less work. I enjoy my goats more. DixonOzark JewelsNubians and Lamanchaswww.ozarkjewels.netMorningland Dairy Raw Milk Cheeseswww.morninglanddairy.com

Subject: ? regarding cost of keep of goatsTo: RawDairy Date: Thursday, August 19, 2010, 8:06 AM

We recently sold our milk cow and switched to dairy goats (Nubians). We love them and their milk. We thought one of the benefits would be that they ate less and therefore would cost less than a milk cow. We had a full-sized Jersey. But our 3 dairy goats eat a lot of grain in comparison to what our one Jersey ate, and that gets rather costly. I used to feed them Purina Goat Chow, but have switched to Nutrena Top Goat and a sweet feed of COB with molasses, 1/2 and 1/2. That has cut the cost of the grain almost in half, but not quite. Still very expensive compared to our cow's consumption of grain. Of course the milk production doesn't compare either. We were getting about 3 gallons a day from our Jersey and we get about 2 to 2.5 gal/day from our 3 goats.Reasons for switching to goats:A2 genetics (it was my understanding that all goats are A2)Health reasonsEase of keep - dc more comfortable with a smaller animal, cleaner, easier to

clean up after (all of which are true in our case)We thought they would be less expensive to keep.What is your experience in keeping goats? What do you feed them in the way of grain? How much? Is the grain necessary? (If they don't eat their ration, their milk production does drop.) Some folks don't feed their milk cow any grain at all.Any advice, experience, thoughts would be appreciated.Thanks so much!Dona

Posted

Dona, where are you located? The herbal wormer works for goats in *some* areas. Fecals should be done at intervals to make sure it is working for you, especially if you are in a warmer state. I've seen too many does die from worms while being "herbally wormed", in my area. So please be sure it is working for you.

Also, I would highly reccomend fencing in your pasture as soon as possible. The goats will eat weeds that the cows will not. If given the choice and a variety, goats will rarely eat anything poisonous. In fact, I have many plants in my pastures that are on the poisonous plants list. My goats eat some, then move on. Milkweed is one of them.=) Getting them out to browse will lighten your bill and you will have healthier goats. DixonOzark JewelsNubians and Lamanchaswww.ozarkjewels.netMorningland Dairy Raw Milk Cheeseswww.morninglanddairy.com

Subject: Re: ? regarding cost of keep of goatsTo: RawDairy Date: Thursday, August 19, 2010, 10:33 AM

Jo,

Thanks for your response. So I'm adding up the costs... hoof trimming, definitely less expensive, but only saves me about $20 a year, assuming I only own 1 cow. AI costs for the cow were only about $30 a year. I paid $50 for our little buckling and have to feed him. I use Molly's herbal dewormer. The cow used 4 TBSP a week. We have 3 does and 1 buckling, each get 1 TBSP a week. We have 2.5 acres of pasture, not alfalfa, but a combination of orchard grass, fescue, white clover and brome. We don't let the goats out on it because it isn't properly fenced and there are some weeds on the edges that include milk weed, which is supposed to be poisonous to goats. We cut the pasture twice a year to get some grass hay for storage. We also keep a cow or two for beef and they eat mostly the grass hay and the leftovers from the does. The cows have a smaller grazing

area just for them. Vet bills I can't really compare because we have luckily been pretty healthy and haven't needed much from the vet for the cow or the goats. Hay consumption is where the big difference for us is. The cow consumed 1/3-1/2 of a small bale of hay each day. The does only consume 1-2 large flakes a day, the buckling about 1/2 of the flake. We do buy alfalfa for the goats. But the grain consumption is turned way upside down! One of my goats, a large nubian, 2 yo first freshener, consumes about the same amount of grain our cow did!

I'm hoping that next year the milk production goes up somewhat. These goats were bought this year, all out of good milking lines, a few months into their lactation. The move undoubtedly dropped their production somewhat. One is a 6-yo who just had a single kid this year; in previous years she had twins. The other from the same place is a yearling, kidded 1 this year. The other, from a different place it the 2 yo. She had twins this year and is our biggest producer at 3.5-4 pints a milking. The move was stressful on her. We had some behavioral issues with her in the beginning... wouldn't eat, wouldn't get on the stand, was afraid of the other goats even though she is much bigger than the other two. She has calmed down quite a bit and is actually a very easy goat now.

I agree with you about the breed and output. We chose Nubians because of the composition of the milk, higher butterfat content, creamier milk. I must say, however, that I have never tasted Saanen milk, so I can't really compare in real life, just on paper. I might take your suggestion and put a Saanen in the mix. What do you know about the taste and texture of Saanen milk? I know we have had Holstein milk and Jersey milk and by far like the Jersey milk better. But if the Saanen milk was nice and sweet and it was just in the mix of our goat milk, we might not notice the difference. Or we could use the Saanen to raise bottle calves. Do the Saanens need proportionally more grain for their output? That would offset the advantage.

I do use a milk pellet as a top dressing, 28% protein.

We do love our goats! I just want to make it work within our budget!

I really appreciate your input. Thank you again for taking the time to respond. If you have any other thoughts to share, I would welcome them!

Sincerely,

Dona

Posted

Dona, where are you located? The herbal wormer works for goats in *some* areas. Fecals should be done at intervals to make sure it is working for you, especially if you are in a warmer state. I've seen too many does die from worms while being "herbally wormed", in my area. So please be sure it is working for you.

Also, I would highly reccomend fencing in your pasture as soon as possible. The goats will eat weeds that the cows will not. If given the choice and a variety, goats will rarely eat anything poisonous. In fact, I have many plants in my pastures that are on the poisonous plants list. My goats eat some, then move on. Milkweed is one of them.=) Getting them out to browse will lighten your bill and you will have healthier goats. DixonOzark JewelsNubians and Lamanchaswww.ozarkjewels.netMorningland Dairy Raw Milk Cheeseswww.morninglanddairy.com

Subject: Re: ? regarding cost of keep of goatsTo: RawDairy Date: Thursday, August 19, 2010, 10:33 AM

Jo,

Thanks for your response. So I'm adding up the costs... hoof trimming, definitely less expensive, but only saves me about $20 a year, assuming I only own 1 cow. AI costs for the cow were only about $30 a year. I paid $50 for our little buckling and have to feed him. I use Molly's herbal dewormer. The cow used 4 TBSP a week. We have 3 does and 1 buckling, each get 1 TBSP a week. We have 2.5 acres of pasture, not alfalfa, but a combination of orchard grass, fescue, white clover and brome. We don't let the goats out on it because it isn't properly fenced and there are some weeds on the edges that include milk weed, which is supposed to be poisonous to goats. We cut the pasture twice a year to get some grass hay for storage. We also keep a cow or two for beef and they eat mostly the grass hay and the leftovers from the does. The cows have a smaller grazing

area just for them. Vet bills I can't really compare because we have luckily been pretty healthy and haven't needed much from the vet for the cow or the goats. Hay consumption is where the big difference for us is. The cow consumed 1/3-1/2 of a small bale of hay each day. The does only consume 1-2 large flakes a day, the buckling about 1/2 of the flake. We do buy alfalfa for the goats. But the grain consumption is turned way upside down! One of my goats, a large nubian, 2 yo first freshener, consumes about the same amount of grain our cow did!

I'm hoping that next year the milk production goes up somewhat. These goats were bought this year, all out of good milking lines, a few months into their lactation. The move undoubtedly dropped their production somewhat. One is a 6-yo who just had a single kid this year; in previous years she had twins. The other from the same place is a yearling, kidded 1 this year. The other, from a different place it the 2 yo. She had twins this year and is our biggest producer at 3.5-4 pints a milking. The move was stressful on her. We had some behavioral issues with her in the beginning... wouldn't eat, wouldn't get on the stand, was afraid of the other goats even though she is much bigger than the other two. She has calmed down quite a bit and is actually a very easy goat now.

I agree with you about the breed and output. We chose Nubians because of the composition of the milk, higher butterfat content, creamier milk. I must say, however, that I have never tasted Saanen milk, so I can't really compare in real life, just on paper. I might take your suggestion and put a Saanen in the mix. What do you know about the taste and texture of Saanen milk? I know we have had Holstein milk and Jersey milk and by far like the Jersey milk better. But if the Saanen milk was nice and sweet and it was just in the mix of our goat milk, we might not notice the difference. Or we could use the Saanen to raise bottle calves. Do the Saanens need proportionally more grain for their output? That would offset the advantage.

I do use a milk pellet as a top dressing, 28% protein.

We do love our goats! I just want to make it work within our budget!

I really appreciate your input. Thank you again for taking the time to respond. If you have any other thoughts to share, I would welcome them!

Sincerely,

Dona

Posted

Dona, where are you located? The herbal wormer works for goats in *some* areas. Fecals should be done at intervals to make sure it is working for you, especially if you are in a warmer state. I've seen too many does die from worms while being "herbally wormed", in my area. So please be sure it is working for you.

Also, I would highly reccomend fencing in your pasture as soon as possible. The goats will eat weeds that the cows will not. If given the choice and a variety, goats will rarely eat anything poisonous. In fact, I have many plants in my pastures that are on the poisonous plants list. My goats eat some, then move on. Milkweed is one of them.=) Getting them out to browse will lighten your bill and you will have healthier goats. DixonOzark JewelsNubians and Lamanchaswww.ozarkjewels.netMorningland Dairy Raw Milk Cheeseswww.morninglanddairy.com

Subject: Re: ? regarding cost of keep of goatsTo: RawDairy Date: Thursday, August 19, 2010, 10:33 AM

Jo,

Thanks for your response. So I'm adding up the costs... hoof trimming, definitely less expensive, but only saves me about $20 a year, assuming I only own 1 cow. AI costs for the cow were only about $30 a year. I paid $50 for our little buckling and have to feed him. I use Molly's herbal dewormer. The cow used 4 TBSP a week. We have 3 does and 1 buckling, each get 1 TBSP a week. We have 2.5 acres of pasture, not alfalfa, but a combination of orchard grass, fescue, white clover and brome. We don't let the goats out on it because it isn't properly fenced and there are some weeds on the edges that include milk weed, which is supposed to be poisonous to goats. We cut the pasture twice a year to get some grass hay for storage. We also keep a cow or two for beef and they eat mostly the grass hay and the leftovers from the does. The cows have a smaller grazing

area just for them. Vet bills I can't really compare because we have luckily been pretty healthy and haven't needed much from the vet for the cow or the goats. Hay consumption is where the big difference for us is. The cow consumed 1/3-1/2 of a small bale of hay each day. The does only consume 1-2 large flakes a day, the buckling about 1/2 of the flake. We do buy alfalfa for the goats. But the grain consumption is turned way upside down! One of my goats, a large nubian, 2 yo first freshener, consumes about the same amount of grain our cow did!

I'm hoping that next year the milk production goes up somewhat. These goats were bought this year, all out of good milking lines, a few months into their lactation. The move undoubtedly dropped their production somewhat. One is a 6-yo who just had a single kid this year; in previous years she had twins. The other from the same place is a yearling, kidded 1 this year. The other, from a different place it the 2 yo. She had twins this year and is our biggest producer at 3.5-4 pints a milking. The move was stressful on her. We had some behavioral issues with her in the beginning... wouldn't eat, wouldn't get on the stand, was afraid of the other goats even though she is much bigger than the other two. She has calmed down quite a bit and is actually a very easy goat now.

I agree with you about the breed and output. We chose Nubians because of the composition of the milk, higher butterfat content, creamier milk. I must say, however, that I have never tasted Saanen milk, so I can't really compare in real life, just on paper. I might take your suggestion and put a Saanen in the mix. What do you know about the taste and texture of Saanen milk? I know we have had Holstein milk and Jersey milk and by far like the Jersey milk better. But if the Saanen milk was nice and sweet and it was just in the mix of our goat milk, we might not notice the difference. Or we could use the Saanen to raise bottle calves. Do the Saanens need proportionally more grain for their output? That would offset the advantage.

I do use a milk pellet as a top dressing, 28% protein.

We do love our goats! I just want to make it work within our budget!

I really appreciate your input. Thank you again for taking the time to respond. If you have any other thoughts to share, I would welcome them!

Sincerely,

Dona

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...