Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 Hi Liz, BioReview is for looking at one recorded session at a time. To use it, take your design and save as "All files" and don't use the .bxd extension, use .rpt. Then open it up in BioReview and edit as you like. You will see nothing in BioReview until you add a view. Add it, then add the signal you want. When you run on session the data will be graphed. To get a comparison count for some criteria, you will do better to use Excel. What you need to do is, yes, locate the thing you want to count and add a counter. Find what is feeding the sound and feed it also into the counter. There may sometimes already be a counter in the signal diagram. Then in Export Settings add the signal you want and name it. Use tab delimited. When you save your recording, BE will save a .txt file for this and all sessions' epochs and summary plus another file that collects all summaries together. That cumulative summary file will be the one to look at number of counts across sessions. Then you just need to open the txt file and make a chart. For feedback, remember you can open the Volumes tool and uncheck any sounds. Sometimes it helps to use some key sounds and then add more when you get the hang of it. BUT for this or other training, sometimes you are better off not "understanding" the feedback but just letting it be. Rah From: drmargoshes@...Date: Mon, 19 Apr 2010 08:01:13 -0400Subject: assessing how clients are doing in a session Listmates.I haven't even approached BioReview yet, but I'm wondering how you assess (for yourself and the client) how someone is doing throughout a training session and across sessions. I'm just getting seriously into training with BioExplorer, and it seems that I would love to be able to see (and show the client), "OK. during the first training sessionyou did [something] X number of times during the sessions, and then, during session 5, you did [it] X+4 number of times, isn't that great?" I know we're looking for clinical results, but this would be so helpful to me, and, I'm presuming, the client. Is BioReview the way to go here? Or learn to set up a counter?For a specific example, I've been doing some training with Pete's alpha-gamma coherence/synchrony design. You can look at trends to see how someone is doing in real time, but what I'd like is a way to count the number of times in a session the various tones are sounded (the tones correlate with hitting certain values in synchrony, coherence, etc.). Here's a description from the notes about what tones there are:"Coherence in alpha, phase angle in alpha, coherence in gamma and phase angle in gamma each have a tone in a chord that plays the background for the brain's synchrony music. When all four are in range, the full chord sounds and a soft high-pitched crystal sound plays. Two harmonic melody lines play as well (one for alpha amplitude summed between the two channels and a faster one for gamma amplitude summed between the two channels.) There are also binaural beats at 10 Hz." That's a LOT Of tones going on at the same time. I find when I train myself I just hear a lot of noise and cannot discriminate among them and can't figure out how I'm doing.I wonder what tones could be held more important and how to work out a way to have them counted during the sessions.Is there anything already on the alpha gamma synch.bxd design (or any other design) that does this, but I'm not seeing it? Or how could I set this up? Or is it already implicit in the BioReview aspect of the software? Would it be easier to start with a simpler design, that's just doing one thing, and learn to design a counter or other simple way to collect a little summary data on what's going on? (in Francois Dupont's designs for Thought Technology there seem to be counters sometimes)Thank you.Llz Margoshes The New Busy think 9 to 5 is a cute idea. Combine multiple calendars with Hotmail. Get busy. Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 Hi Liz, BioReview is for looking at one recorded session at a time. To use it, take your design and save as "All files" and don't use the .bxd extension, use .rpt. Then open it up in BioReview and edit as you like. You will see nothing in BioReview until you add a view. Add it, then add the signal you want. When you run on session the data will be graphed. To get a comparison count for some criteria, you will do better to use Excel. What you need to do is, yes, locate the thing you want to count and add a counter. Find what is feeding the sound and feed it also into the counter. There may sometimes already be a counter in the signal diagram. Then in Export Settings add the signal you want and name it. Use tab delimited. When you save your recording, BE will save a .txt file for this and all sessions' epochs and summary plus another file that collects all summaries together. That cumulative summary file will be the one to look at number of counts across sessions. Then you just need to open the txt file and make a chart. For feedback, remember you can open the Volumes tool and uncheck any sounds. Sometimes it helps to use some key sounds and then add more when you get the hang of it. BUT for this or other training, sometimes you are better off not "understanding" the feedback but just letting it be. Rah From: drmargoshes@...Date: Mon, 19 Apr 2010 08:01:13 -0400Subject: assessing how clients are doing in a session Listmates.I haven't even approached BioReview yet, but I'm wondering how you assess (for yourself and the client) how someone is doing throughout a training session and across sessions. I'm just getting seriously into training with BioExplorer, and it seems that I would love to be able to see (and show the client), "OK. during the first training sessionyou did [something] X number of times during the sessions, and then, during session 5, you did [it] X+4 number of times, isn't that great?" I know we're looking for clinical results, but this would be so helpful to me, and, I'm presuming, the client. Is BioReview the way to go here? Or learn to set up a counter?For a specific example, I've been doing some training with Pete's alpha-gamma coherence/synchrony design. You can look at trends to see how someone is doing in real time, but what I'd like is a way to count the number of times in a session the various tones are sounded (the tones correlate with hitting certain values in synchrony, coherence, etc.). Here's a description from the notes about what tones there are:"Coherence in alpha, phase angle in alpha, coherence in gamma and phase angle in gamma each have a tone in a chord that plays the background for the brain's synchrony music. When all four are in range, the full chord sounds and a soft high-pitched crystal sound plays. Two harmonic melody lines play as well (one for alpha amplitude summed between the two channels and a faster one for gamma amplitude summed between the two channels.) There are also binaural beats at 10 Hz." That's a LOT Of tones going on at the same time. I find when I train myself I just hear a lot of noise and cannot discriminate among them and can't figure out how I'm doing.I wonder what tones could be held more important and how to work out a way to have them counted during the sessions.Is there anything already on the alpha gamma synch.bxd design (or any other design) that does this, but I'm not seeing it? Or how could I set this up? Or is it already implicit in the BioReview aspect of the software? Would it be easier to start with a simpler design, that's just doing one thing, and learn to design a counter or other simple way to collect a little summary data on what's going on? (in Francois Dupont's designs for Thought Technology there seem to be counters sometimes)Thank you.Llz Margoshes The New Busy think 9 to 5 is a cute idea. Combine multiple calendars with Hotmail. Get busy. Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 Liz, In the beginning, I do Bioreview and look at the data for most sessions just to see if the protocol I am using is working for the client. Sometimes I go back to one of the first graphs and a later graph to see changes. Maybe after 6 sessions or so. I also sometimes do pieces of the TLC again to compare. This is very interesting as many times, what I am trying to remedy is gone after about 20 sessions. I like this the best to be honest. If you are working C3 for example and you do the piece of the TLC for C’s it only takes about 10 minutes to do it and artifact in and compare to the C’s in the initial assessment. If you don’t do the entire assessment, you can’t look at many of the pieces, but you can see the histogram and the theta/beta ratios and left to right reversals. Clinical results are key!!! Since many times they are gradual, you have to be very adamant about reminding the client where they were in the beginning. For instance, I have a boy I have been training for reading issues, attention and executive function issues. Well, his reading has improved significantly and so has his attention but we are still working on the executive function. I have to keep reminding the mom where we started as she tends to forget. Like, “remember when it took him 4 hours to do 20 minutes of homework and now he can do it in 30 minutes?” Hope this helps. Connie From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Margoshes Sent: Monday, April 19, 2010 8:01 AM Subject: assessing how clients are doing in a session Listmates. I haven't even approached BioReview yet, but I'm wondering how you assess (for yourself and the client) how someone is doing throughout a training session and across sessions. I'm just getting seriously into training with BioExplorer, and it seems that I would love to be able to see (and show the client), " OK. during the first training session you did [something] X number of times during the sessions, and then, during session 5, you did [it] X+4 number of times, isn't that great? " I know we're looking for clinical results, but this would be so helpful to me, and, I'm presuming, the client. Is BioReview the way to go here? Or learn to set up a counter? For a specific example, I've been doing some training with Pete's alpha-gamma coherence/synchrony design. You can look at trends to see how someone is doing in real time, but what I'd like is a way to count the number of times in a session the various tones are sounded (the tones correlate with hitting certain values in synchrony, coherence, etc.). Here's a description from the notes about what tones there are: " Coherence in alpha, phase angle in alpha, coherence in gamma and phase angle in gamma each have a tone in a chord that plays the background for the brain's synchrony music. When all four are in range, the full chord sounds and a soft high-pitched crystal sound plays. Two harmonic melody lines play as well (one for alpha amplitude summed between the two channels and a faster one for gamma amplitude summed between the two channels.) There are also binaural beats at 10 Hz. " That's a LOT Of tones going on at the same time. I find when I train myself I just hear a lot of noise and cannot discriminate among them and can't figure out how I'm doing. I wonder what tones could be held more important and how to work out a way to have them counted during the sessions. Is there anything already on the alpha gamma synch.bxd design (or any other design) that does this, but I'm not seeing it? Or how could I set this up? Or is it already implicit in the BioReview aspect of the software? Would it be easier to start with a simpler design, that's just doing one thing, and learn to design a counter or other simple way to collect a little summary data on what's going on? (in Francois Dupont's designs for Thought Technology there seem to be counters sometimes) Thank you. Llz Margoshes Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 Liz, In the beginning, I do Bioreview and look at the data for most sessions just to see if the protocol I am using is working for the client. Sometimes I go back to one of the first graphs and a later graph to see changes. Maybe after 6 sessions or so. I also sometimes do pieces of the TLC again to compare. This is very interesting as many times, what I am trying to remedy is gone after about 20 sessions. I like this the best to be honest. If you are working C3 for example and you do the piece of the TLC for C’s it only takes about 10 minutes to do it and artifact in and compare to the C’s in the initial assessment. If you don’t do the entire assessment, you can’t look at many of the pieces, but you can see the histogram and the theta/beta ratios and left to right reversals. Clinical results are key!!! Since many times they are gradual, you have to be very adamant about reminding the client where they were in the beginning. For instance, I have a boy I have been training for reading issues, attention and executive function issues. Well, his reading has improved significantly and so has his attention but we are still working on the executive function. I have to keep reminding the mom where we started as she tends to forget. Like, “remember when it took him 4 hours to do 20 minutes of homework and now he can do it in 30 minutes?” Hope this helps. Connie From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Margoshes Sent: Monday, April 19, 2010 8:01 AM Subject: assessing how clients are doing in a session Listmates. I haven't even approached BioReview yet, but I'm wondering how you assess (for yourself and the client) how someone is doing throughout a training session and across sessions. I'm just getting seriously into training with BioExplorer, and it seems that I would love to be able to see (and show the client), " OK. during the first training session you did [something] X number of times during the sessions, and then, during session 5, you did [it] X+4 number of times, isn't that great? " I know we're looking for clinical results, but this would be so helpful to me, and, I'm presuming, the client. Is BioReview the way to go here? Or learn to set up a counter? For a specific example, I've been doing some training with Pete's alpha-gamma coherence/synchrony design. You can look at trends to see how someone is doing in real time, but what I'd like is a way to count the number of times in a session the various tones are sounded (the tones correlate with hitting certain values in synchrony, coherence, etc.). Here's a description from the notes about what tones there are: " Coherence in alpha, phase angle in alpha, coherence in gamma and phase angle in gamma each have a tone in a chord that plays the background for the brain's synchrony music. When all four are in range, the full chord sounds and a soft high-pitched crystal sound plays. Two harmonic melody lines play as well (one for alpha amplitude summed between the two channels and a faster one for gamma amplitude summed between the two channels.) There are also binaural beats at 10 Hz. " That's a LOT Of tones going on at the same time. I find when I train myself I just hear a lot of noise and cannot discriminate among them and can't figure out how I'm doing. I wonder what tones could be held more important and how to work out a way to have them counted during the sessions. Is there anything already on the alpha gamma synch.bxd design (or any other design) that does this, but I'm not seeing it? Or how could I set this up? Or is it already implicit in the BioReview aspect of the software? Would it be easier to start with a simpler design, that's just doing one thing, and learn to design a counter or other simple way to collect a little summary data on what's going on? (in Francois Dupont's designs for Thought Technology there seem to be counters sometimes) Thank you. Llz Margoshes Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 Rah,I think a counter and Excel are what I want but I didn't really understand your instructions since I'm not an Excel person. My husband is and I'm going to get him in on this. Thank you.Liz On Mon, Apr 19, 2010 at 9:52 AM, Rah Wheelihan <wheelihan82@...> wrote: Hi Liz, BioReview is for looking at one recorded session at a time. To use it, take your design and save as " All files " and don't use the .bxd extension, use .rpt. Then open it up in BioReview and edit as you like. You will see nothing in BioReview until you add a view. Add it, then add the signal you want. When you run on session the data will be graphed. To get a comparison count for some criteria, you will do better to use Excel. What you need to do is, yes, locate the thing you want to count and add a counter. Find what is feeding the sound and feed it also into the counter. There may sometimes already be a counter in the signal diagram. Then in Export Settings add the signal you want and name it. Use tab delimited. When you save your recording, BE will save a .txt file for this and all sessions' epochs and summary plus another file that collects all summaries together. That cumulative summary file will be the one to look at number of counts across sessions. Then you just need to open the txt file and make a chart. For feedback, remember you can open the Volumes tool and uncheck any sounds. Sometimes it helps to use some key sounds and then add more when you get the hang of it. BUT for this or other training, sometimes you are better off not " understanding " the feedback but just letting it be. Rah From: drmargoshes@...Date: Mon, 19 Apr 2010 08:01:13 -0400 Subject: assessing how clients are doing in a session Listmates.I haven't even approached BioReview yet, but I'm wondering how you assess (for yourself and the client) how someone is doing throughout a training session and across sessions. I'm just getting seriously into training with BioExplorer, and it seems that I would love to be able to see (and show the client), " OK. during the first training session you did [something] X number of times during the sessions, and then, during session 5, you did [it] X+4 number of times, isn't that great? " I know we're looking for clinical results, but this would be so helpful to me, and, I'm presuming, the client. Is BioReview the way to go here? Or learn to set up a counter? For a specific example, I've been doing some training with Pete's alpha-gamma coherence/synchrony design. You can look at trends to see how someone is doing in real time, but what I'd like is a way to count the number of times in a session the various tones are sounded (the tones correlate with hitting certain values in synchrony, coherence, etc.). Here's a description from the notes about what tones there are: " Coherence in alpha, phase angle in alpha, coherence in gamma and phase angle in gamma each have a tone in a chord that plays the background for the brain's synchrony music. When all four are in range, the full chord sounds and a soft high-pitched crystal sound plays. Two harmonic melody lines play as well (one for alpha amplitude summed between the two channels and a faster one for gamma amplitude summed between the two channels.) There are also binaural beats at 10 Hz. " That's a LOT Of tones going on at the same time. I find when I train myself I just hear a lot of noise and cannot discriminate among them and can't figure out how I'm doing.I wonder what tones could be held more important and how to work out a way to have them counted during the sessions. Is there anything already on the alpha gamma synch.bxd design (or any other design) that does this, but I'm not seeing it? Or how could I set this up? Or is it already implicit in the BioReview aspect of the software? Would it be easier to start with a simpler design, that's just doing one thing, and learn to design a counter or other simple way to collect a little summary data on what's going on? (in Francois Dupont's designs for Thought Technology there seem to be counters sometimes)Thank you.Llz Margoshes The New Busy think 9 to 5 is a cute idea. Combine multiple calendars with Hotmail. Get busy. Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 Rah,I think a counter and Excel are what I want but I didn't really understand your instructions since I'm not an Excel person. My husband is and I'm going to get him in on this. Thank you.Liz On Mon, Apr 19, 2010 at 9:52 AM, Rah Wheelihan <wheelihan82@...> wrote: Hi Liz, BioReview is for looking at one recorded session at a time. To use it, take your design and save as " All files " and don't use the .bxd extension, use .rpt. Then open it up in BioReview and edit as you like. You will see nothing in BioReview until you add a view. Add it, then add the signal you want. When you run on session the data will be graphed. To get a comparison count for some criteria, you will do better to use Excel. What you need to do is, yes, locate the thing you want to count and add a counter. Find what is feeding the sound and feed it also into the counter. There may sometimes already be a counter in the signal diagram. Then in Export Settings add the signal you want and name it. Use tab delimited. When you save your recording, BE will save a .txt file for this and all sessions' epochs and summary plus another file that collects all summaries together. That cumulative summary file will be the one to look at number of counts across sessions. Then you just need to open the txt file and make a chart. For feedback, remember you can open the Volumes tool and uncheck any sounds. Sometimes it helps to use some key sounds and then add more when you get the hang of it. BUT for this or other training, sometimes you are better off not " understanding " the feedback but just letting it be. Rah From: drmargoshes@...Date: Mon, 19 Apr 2010 08:01:13 -0400 Subject: assessing how clients are doing in a session Listmates.I haven't even approached BioReview yet, but I'm wondering how you assess (for yourself and the client) how someone is doing throughout a training session and across sessions. I'm just getting seriously into training with BioExplorer, and it seems that I would love to be able to see (and show the client), " OK. during the first training session you did [something] X number of times during the sessions, and then, during session 5, you did [it] X+4 number of times, isn't that great? " I know we're looking for clinical results, but this would be so helpful to me, and, I'm presuming, the client. Is BioReview the way to go here? Or learn to set up a counter? For a specific example, I've been doing some training with Pete's alpha-gamma coherence/synchrony design. You can look at trends to see how someone is doing in real time, but what I'd like is a way to count the number of times in a session the various tones are sounded (the tones correlate with hitting certain values in synchrony, coherence, etc.). Here's a description from the notes about what tones there are: " Coherence in alpha, phase angle in alpha, coherence in gamma and phase angle in gamma each have a tone in a chord that plays the background for the brain's synchrony music. When all four are in range, the full chord sounds and a soft high-pitched crystal sound plays. Two harmonic melody lines play as well (one for alpha amplitude summed between the two channels and a faster one for gamma amplitude summed between the two channels.) There are also binaural beats at 10 Hz. " That's a LOT Of tones going on at the same time. I find when I train myself I just hear a lot of noise and cannot discriminate among them and can't figure out how I'm doing.I wonder what tones could be held more important and how to work out a way to have them counted during the sessions. Is there anything already on the alpha gamma synch.bxd design (or any other design) that does this, but I'm not seeing it? Or how could I set this up? Or is it already implicit in the BioReview aspect of the software? Would it be easier to start with a simpler design, that's just doing one thing, and learn to design a counter or other simple way to collect a little summary data on what's going on? (in Francois Dupont's designs for Thought Technology there seem to be counters sometimes)Thank you.Llz Margoshes The New Busy think 9 to 5 is a cute idea. Combine multiple calendars with Hotmail. Get busy. Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 Connie, Thank you for these suggestions. They're helpful. But it's important to me, at least as I begin training clients, to see if the treatment itself is getting " in. " Also, I don't know if I'm being too compulsive, but I'd like to see if the clinical improvements are due to the NF itself since there are so many extra-treatmentlike factors involved (e.g. having to sit still for a certain amount of time during the sessions; spendimg time with a caring professional; seeing that your mother takes your complaints seriously and is trying to help you rather than be judgmental; etc.) Mostly I would like to be able to *show* people that training, not just improvements in task performance (e.g. homework), is actually occurring. At the moment I'm particularly interested in the alpha-gamma because I have a number of available meditators (via someone I know who has a yoga studio) and I am fascinated (for myself as well) with the idea of EEG-assisted meditation (a la Soutar). I would love to be able to demonstrate that you really ARE changing your mindstate -- " See? you made those bells ring more after X sessions of NF! " I think it would be a much more powerful demonstration if I could show that changes in brain function had actually occurred -- not just how you " feel " . I'm very interested in this area which I think could be very helpful for people who are not in " clinical " distress and are not going to come to me for assessments, long treatments, etc. Maybe I don't need to show that " the bell rang 20 times this session. " Maybe there's another way (that has to do with graphs, comparing BioReview data across sessions, etc?) I really don't know anything about this. The thing about compiling statistics is I'm afraid of artifact (like muscle) contaminating the numbers? do you have to artifact the data in order for BioReview to do its job? However I also want to show " data " to parents, etc., when I get to that stage. thank you,LizOn Mon, Apr 19, 2010 at 10:33 AM, Connie Welsh <conniewelsh@...> wrote: Liz, In the beginning, I do Bioreview and look at the data for most sessions just to see if the protocol I am using is working for the client. Sometimes I go back to one of the first graphs and a later graph to see changes. Maybe after 6 sessions or so. I also sometimes do pieces of the TLC again to compare. This is very interesting as many times, what I am trying to remedy is gone after about 20 sessions. I like this the best to be honest. If you are working C3 for example and you do the piece of the TLC for C’s it only takes about 10 minutes to do it and artifact in and compare to the C’s in the initial assessment. If you don’t do the entire assessment, you can’t look at many of the pieces, but you can see the histogram and the theta/beta ratios and left to right reversals. Clinical results are key!!! Since many times they are gradual, you have to be very adamant about reminding the client where they were in the beginning. For instance, I have a boy I have been training for reading issues, attention and executive function issues. Well, his reading has improved significantly and so has his attention but we are still working on the executive function. I have to keep reminding the mom where we started as she tends to forget. Like, “remember when it took him 4 hours to do 20 minutes of homework and now he can do it in 30 minutes?” Hope this helps. Connie From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Margoshes Sent: Monday, April 19, 2010 8:01 AM Subject: assessing how clients are doing in a session Listmates. I haven't even approached BioReview yet, but I'm wondering how you assess (for yourself and the client) how someone is doing throughout a training session and across sessions. I'm just getting seriously into training with BioExplorer, and it seems that I would love to be able to see (and show the client), " OK. during the first training session you did [something] X number of times during the sessions, and then, during session 5, you did [it] X+4 number of times, isn't that great? " I know we're looking for clinical results, but this would be so helpful to me, and, I'm presuming, the client. Is BioReview the way to go here? Or learn to set up a counter? For a specific example, I've been doing some training with Pete's alpha-gamma coherence/synchrony design. You can look at trends to see how someone is doing in real time, but what I'd like is a way to count the number of times in a session the various tones are sounded (the tones correlate with hitting certain values in synchrony, coherence, etc.). Here's a description from the notes about what tones there are: " Coherence in alpha, phase angle in alpha, coherence in gamma and phase angle in gamma each have a tone in a chord that plays the background for the brain's synchrony music. When all four are in range, the full chord sounds and a soft high-pitched crystal sound plays. Two harmonic melody lines play as well (one for alpha amplitude summed between the two channels and a faster one for gamma amplitude summed between the two channels.) There are also binaural beats at 10 Hz. " That's a LOT Of tones going on at the same time. I find when I train myself I just hear a lot of noise and cannot discriminate among them and can't figure out how I'm doing. I wonder what tones could be held more important and how to work out a way to have them counted during the sessions. Is there anything already on the alpha gamma synch.bxd design (or any other design) that does this, but I'm not seeing it? Or how could I set this up? Or is it already implicit in the BioReview aspect of the software? Would it be easier to start with a simpler design, that's just doing one thing, and learn to design a counter or other simple way to collect a little summary data on what's going on? (in Francois Dupont's designs for Thought Technology there seem to be counters sometimes) Thank you. Llz Margoshes Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 Connie, Thank you for these suggestions. They're helpful. But it's important to me, at least as I begin training clients, to see if the treatment itself is getting " in. " Also, I don't know if I'm being too compulsive, but I'd like to see if the clinical improvements are due to the NF itself since there are so many extra-treatmentlike factors involved (e.g. having to sit still for a certain amount of time during the sessions; spendimg time with a caring professional; seeing that your mother takes your complaints seriously and is trying to help you rather than be judgmental; etc.) Mostly I would like to be able to *show* people that training, not just improvements in task performance (e.g. homework), is actually occurring. At the moment I'm particularly interested in the alpha-gamma because I have a number of available meditators (via someone I know who has a yoga studio) and I am fascinated (for myself as well) with the idea of EEG-assisted meditation (a la Soutar). I would love to be able to demonstrate that you really ARE changing your mindstate -- " See? you made those bells ring more after X sessions of NF! " I think it would be a much more powerful demonstration if I could show that changes in brain function had actually occurred -- not just how you " feel " . I'm very interested in this area which I think could be very helpful for people who are not in " clinical " distress and are not going to come to me for assessments, long treatments, etc. Maybe I don't need to show that " the bell rang 20 times this session. " Maybe there's another way (that has to do with graphs, comparing BioReview data across sessions, etc?) I really don't know anything about this. The thing about compiling statistics is I'm afraid of artifact (like muscle) contaminating the numbers? do you have to artifact the data in order for BioReview to do its job? However I also want to show " data " to parents, etc., when I get to that stage. thank you,LizOn Mon, Apr 19, 2010 at 10:33 AM, Connie Welsh <conniewelsh@...> wrote: Liz, In the beginning, I do Bioreview and look at the data for most sessions just to see if the protocol I am using is working for the client. Sometimes I go back to one of the first graphs and a later graph to see changes. Maybe after 6 sessions or so. I also sometimes do pieces of the TLC again to compare. This is very interesting as many times, what I am trying to remedy is gone after about 20 sessions. I like this the best to be honest. If you are working C3 for example and you do the piece of the TLC for C’s it only takes about 10 minutes to do it and artifact in and compare to the C’s in the initial assessment. If you don’t do the entire assessment, you can’t look at many of the pieces, but you can see the histogram and the theta/beta ratios and left to right reversals. Clinical results are key!!! Since many times they are gradual, you have to be very adamant about reminding the client where they were in the beginning. For instance, I have a boy I have been training for reading issues, attention and executive function issues. Well, his reading has improved significantly and so has his attention but we are still working on the executive function. I have to keep reminding the mom where we started as she tends to forget. Like, “remember when it took him 4 hours to do 20 minutes of homework and now he can do it in 30 minutes?” Hope this helps. Connie From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Margoshes Sent: Monday, April 19, 2010 8:01 AM Subject: assessing how clients are doing in a session Listmates. I haven't even approached BioReview yet, but I'm wondering how you assess (for yourself and the client) how someone is doing throughout a training session and across sessions. I'm just getting seriously into training with BioExplorer, and it seems that I would love to be able to see (and show the client), " OK. during the first training session you did [something] X number of times during the sessions, and then, during session 5, you did [it] X+4 number of times, isn't that great? " I know we're looking for clinical results, but this would be so helpful to me, and, I'm presuming, the client. Is BioReview the way to go here? Or learn to set up a counter? For a specific example, I've been doing some training with Pete's alpha-gamma coherence/synchrony design. You can look at trends to see how someone is doing in real time, but what I'd like is a way to count the number of times in a session the various tones are sounded (the tones correlate with hitting certain values in synchrony, coherence, etc.). Here's a description from the notes about what tones there are: " Coherence in alpha, phase angle in alpha, coherence in gamma and phase angle in gamma each have a tone in a chord that plays the background for the brain's synchrony music. When all four are in range, the full chord sounds and a soft high-pitched crystal sound plays. Two harmonic melody lines play as well (one for alpha amplitude summed between the two channels and a faster one for gamma amplitude summed between the two channels.) There are also binaural beats at 10 Hz. " That's a LOT Of tones going on at the same time. I find when I train myself I just hear a lot of noise and cannot discriminate among them and can't figure out how I'm doing. I wonder what tones could be held more important and how to work out a way to have them counted during the sessions. Is there anything already on the alpha gamma synch.bxd design (or any other design) that does this, but I'm not seeing it? Or how could I set this up? Or is it already implicit in the BioReview aspect of the software? Would it be easier to start with a simpler design, that's just doing one thing, and learn to design a counter or other simple way to collect a little summary data on what's going on? (in Francois Dupont's designs for Thought Technology there seem to be counters sometimes) Thank you. Llz Margoshes Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 Connie, Thank you for these suggestions. They're helpful. But it's important to me, at least as I begin training clients, to see if the treatment itself is getting " in. " Also, I don't know if I'm being too compulsive, but I'd like to see if the clinical improvements are due to the NF itself since there are so many extra-treatmentlike factors involved (e.g. having to sit still for a certain amount of time during the sessions; spendimg time with a caring professional; seeing that your mother takes your complaints seriously and is trying to help you rather than be judgmental; etc.) Mostly I would like to be able to *show* people that training, not just improvements in task performance (e.g. homework), is actually occurring. At the moment I'm particularly interested in the alpha-gamma because I have a number of available meditators (via someone I know who has a yoga studio) and I am fascinated (for myself as well) with the idea of EEG-assisted meditation (a la Soutar). I would love to be able to demonstrate that you really ARE changing your mindstate -- " See? you made those bells ring more after X sessions of NF! " I think it would be a much more powerful demonstration if I could show that changes in brain function had actually occurred -- not just how you " feel " . I'm very interested in this area which I think could be very helpful for people who are not in " clinical " distress and are not going to come to me for assessments, long treatments, etc. Maybe I don't need to show that " the bell rang 20 times this session. " Maybe there's another way (that has to do with graphs, comparing BioReview data across sessions, etc?) I really don't know anything about this. The thing about compiling statistics is I'm afraid of artifact (like muscle) contaminating the numbers? do you have to artifact the data in order for BioReview to do its job? However I also want to show " data " to parents, etc., when I get to that stage. thank you,LizOn Mon, Apr 19, 2010 at 10:33 AM, Connie Welsh <conniewelsh@...> wrote: Liz, In the beginning, I do Bioreview and look at the data for most sessions just to see if the protocol I am using is working for the client. Sometimes I go back to one of the first graphs and a later graph to see changes. Maybe after 6 sessions or so. I also sometimes do pieces of the TLC again to compare. This is very interesting as many times, what I am trying to remedy is gone after about 20 sessions. I like this the best to be honest. If you are working C3 for example and you do the piece of the TLC for C’s it only takes about 10 minutes to do it and artifact in and compare to the C’s in the initial assessment. If you don’t do the entire assessment, you can’t look at many of the pieces, but you can see the histogram and the theta/beta ratios and left to right reversals. Clinical results are key!!! Since many times they are gradual, you have to be very adamant about reminding the client where they were in the beginning. For instance, I have a boy I have been training for reading issues, attention and executive function issues. Well, his reading has improved significantly and so has his attention but we are still working on the executive function. I have to keep reminding the mom where we started as she tends to forget. Like, “remember when it took him 4 hours to do 20 minutes of homework and now he can do it in 30 minutes?” Hope this helps. Connie From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Margoshes Sent: Monday, April 19, 2010 8:01 AM Subject: assessing how clients are doing in a session Listmates. I haven't even approached BioReview yet, but I'm wondering how you assess (for yourself and the client) how someone is doing throughout a training session and across sessions. I'm just getting seriously into training with BioExplorer, and it seems that I would love to be able to see (and show the client), " OK. during the first training session you did [something] X number of times during the sessions, and then, during session 5, you did [it] X+4 number of times, isn't that great? " I know we're looking for clinical results, but this would be so helpful to me, and, I'm presuming, the client. Is BioReview the way to go here? Or learn to set up a counter? For a specific example, I've been doing some training with Pete's alpha-gamma coherence/synchrony design. You can look at trends to see how someone is doing in real time, but what I'd like is a way to count the number of times in a session the various tones are sounded (the tones correlate with hitting certain values in synchrony, coherence, etc.). Here's a description from the notes about what tones there are: " Coherence in alpha, phase angle in alpha, coherence in gamma and phase angle in gamma each have a tone in a chord that plays the background for the brain's synchrony music. When all four are in range, the full chord sounds and a soft high-pitched crystal sound plays. Two harmonic melody lines play as well (one for alpha amplitude summed between the two channels and a faster one for gamma amplitude summed between the two channels.) There are also binaural beats at 10 Hz. " That's a LOT Of tones going on at the same time. I find when I train myself I just hear a lot of noise and cannot discriminate among them and can't figure out how I'm doing. I wonder what tones could be held more important and how to work out a way to have them counted during the sessions. Is there anything already on the alpha gamma synch.bxd design (or any other design) that does this, but I'm not seeing it? Or how could I set this up? Or is it already implicit in the BioReview aspect of the software? Would it be easier to start with a simpler design, that's just doing one thing, and learn to design a counter or other simple way to collect a little summary data on what's going on? (in Francois Dupont's designs for Thought Technology there seem to be counters sometimes) Thank you. Llz Margoshes Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 Liz, you can use BioReview to look at trends which is what it appears you are looking for. Artifact is in the data but most times you can see the trend. So, for instance, you would define a variable like theta amplitude. You can then see the trend over the session. Is it getting smaller or bigger? Now, you have to look at trends at a high level. The graph could go down for awhile, back up and then back down and I would see that as positive. Especially if it ends less than it started. Get out the BioReview and look at some of Pete’s designs if he has some. If not, I can send one to you. Run a report and see what it does. Connie From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Margoshes Sent: Monday, April 19, 2010 10:53 AM Subject: Re: assessing how clients are doing in a session Connie, Thank you for these suggestions. They're helpful. But it's important to me, at least as I begin training clients, to see if the treatment itself is getting " in. " Also, I don't know if I'm being too compulsive, but I'd like to see if the clinical improvements are due to the NF itself since there are so many extra-treatmentlike factors involved (e.g. having to sit still for a certain amount of time during the sessions; spendimg time with a caring professional; seeing that your mother takes your complaints seriously and is trying to help you rather than be judgmental; etc.) Mostly I would like to be able to *show* people that training, not just improvements in task performance (e.g. homework), is actually occurring. At the moment I'm particularly interested in the alpha-gamma because I have a number of available meditators (via someone I know who has a yoga studio) and I am fascinated (for myself as well) with the idea of EEG-assisted meditation (a la Soutar). I would love to be able to demonstrate that you really ARE changing your mindstate -- " See? you made those bells ring more after X sessions of NF! " I think it would be a much more powerful demonstration if I could show that changes in brain function had actually occurred -- not just how you " feel " . I'm very interested in this area which I think could be very helpful for people who are not in " clinical " distress and are not going to come to me for assessments, long treatments, etc. Maybe I don't need to show that " the bell rang 20 times this session. " Maybe there's another way (that has to do with graphs, comparing BioReview data across sessions, etc?) I really don't know anything about this. The thing about compiling statistics is I'm afraid of artifact (like muscle) contaminating the numbers? do you have to artifact the data in order for BioReview to do its job? However I also want to show " data " to parents, etc., when I get to that stage. thank you, Liz On Mon, Apr 19, 2010 at 10:33 AM, Connie Welsh <conniewelsh@...> wrote: Liz, In the beginning, I do Bioreview and look at the data for most sessions just to see if the protocol I am using is working for the client. Sometimes I go back to one of the first graphs and a later graph to see changes. Maybe after 6 sessions or so. I also sometimes do pieces of the TLC again to compare. This is very interesting as many times, what I am trying to remedy is gone after about 20 sessions. I like this the best to be honest. If you are working C3 for example and you do the piece of the TLC for C’s it only takes about 10 minutes to do it and artifact in and compare to the C’s in the initial assessment. If you don’t do the entire assessment, you can’t look at many of the pieces, but you can see the histogram and the theta/beta ratios and left to right reversals. Clinical results are key!!! Since many times they are gradual, you have to be very adamant about reminding the client where they were in the beginning. For instance, I have a boy I have been training for reading issues, attention and executive function issues. Well, his reading has improved significantly and so has his attention but we are still working on the executive function. I have to keep reminding the mom where we started as she tends to forget. Like, “remember when it took him 4 hours to do 20 minutes of homework and now he can do it in 30 minutes?” Hope this helps. Connie From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Margoshes Sent: Monday, April 19, 2010 8:01 AM Subject: assessing how clients are doing in a session Listmates. I haven't even approached BioReview yet, but I'm wondering how you assess (for yourself and the client) how someone is doing throughout a training session and across sessions. I'm just getting seriously into training with BioExplorer, and it seems that I would love to be able to see (and show the client), " OK. during the first training session you did [something] X number of times during the sessions, and then, during session 5, you did [it] X+4 number of times, isn't that great? " I know we're looking for clinical results, but this would be so helpful to me, and, I'm presuming, the client. Is BioReview the way to go here? Or learn to set up a counter? For a specific example, I've been doing some training with Pete's alpha-gamma coherence/synchrony design. You can look at trends to see how someone is doing in real time, but what I'd like is a way to count the number of times in a session the various tones are sounded (the tones correlate with hitting certain values in synchrony, coherence, etc.). Here's a description from the notes about what tones there are: " Coherence in alpha, phase angle in alpha, coherence in gamma and phase angle in gamma each have a tone in a chord that plays the background for the brain's synchrony music. When all four are in range, the full chord sounds and a soft high-pitched crystal sound plays. Two harmonic melody lines play as well (one for alpha amplitude summed between the two channels and a faster one for gamma amplitude summed between the two channels.) There are also binaural beats at 10 Hz. " That's a LOT Of tones going on at the same time. I find when I train myself I just hear a lot of noise and cannot discriminate among them and can't figure out how I'm doing. I wonder what tones could be held more important and how to work out a way to have them counted during the sessions. Is there anything already on the alpha gamma synch.bxd design (or any other design) that does this, but I'm not seeing it? Or how could I set this up? Or is it already implicit in the BioReview aspect of the software? Would it be easier to start with a simpler design, that's just doing one thing, and learn to design a counter or other simple way to collect a little summary data on what's going on? (in Francois Dupont's designs for Thought Technology there seem to be counters sometimes) Thank you. Llz Margoshes Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 Liz, you can use BioReview to look at trends which is what it appears you are looking for. Artifact is in the data but most times you can see the trend. So, for instance, you would define a variable like theta amplitude. You can then see the trend over the session. Is it getting smaller or bigger? Now, you have to look at trends at a high level. The graph could go down for awhile, back up and then back down and I would see that as positive. Especially if it ends less than it started. Get out the BioReview and look at some of Pete’s designs if he has some. If not, I can send one to you. Run a report and see what it does. Connie From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Margoshes Sent: Monday, April 19, 2010 10:53 AM Subject: Re: assessing how clients are doing in a session Connie, Thank you for these suggestions. They're helpful. But it's important to me, at least as I begin training clients, to see if the treatment itself is getting " in. " Also, I don't know if I'm being too compulsive, but I'd like to see if the clinical improvements are due to the NF itself since there are so many extra-treatmentlike factors involved (e.g. having to sit still for a certain amount of time during the sessions; spendimg time with a caring professional; seeing that your mother takes your complaints seriously and is trying to help you rather than be judgmental; etc.) Mostly I would like to be able to *show* people that training, not just improvements in task performance (e.g. homework), is actually occurring. At the moment I'm particularly interested in the alpha-gamma because I have a number of available meditators (via someone I know who has a yoga studio) and I am fascinated (for myself as well) with the idea of EEG-assisted meditation (a la Soutar). I would love to be able to demonstrate that you really ARE changing your mindstate -- " See? you made those bells ring more after X sessions of NF! " I think it would be a much more powerful demonstration if I could show that changes in brain function had actually occurred -- not just how you " feel " . I'm very interested in this area which I think could be very helpful for people who are not in " clinical " distress and are not going to come to me for assessments, long treatments, etc. Maybe I don't need to show that " the bell rang 20 times this session. " Maybe there's another way (that has to do with graphs, comparing BioReview data across sessions, etc?) I really don't know anything about this. The thing about compiling statistics is I'm afraid of artifact (like muscle) contaminating the numbers? do you have to artifact the data in order for BioReview to do its job? However I also want to show " data " to parents, etc., when I get to that stage. thank you, Liz On Mon, Apr 19, 2010 at 10:33 AM, Connie Welsh <conniewelsh@...> wrote: Liz, In the beginning, I do Bioreview and look at the data for most sessions just to see if the protocol I am using is working for the client. Sometimes I go back to one of the first graphs and a later graph to see changes. Maybe after 6 sessions or so. I also sometimes do pieces of the TLC again to compare. This is very interesting as many times, what I am trying to remedy is gone after about 20 sessions. I like this the best to be honest. If you are working C3 for example and you do the piece of the TLC for C’s it only takes about 10 minutes to do it and artifact in and compare to the C’s in the initial assessment. If you don’t do the entire assessment, you can’t look at many of the pieces, but you can see the histogram and the theta/beta ratios and left to right reversals. Clinical results are key!!! Since many times they are gradual, you have to be very adamant about reminding the client where they were in the beginning. For instance, I have a boy I have been training for reading issues, attention and executive function issues. Well, his reading has improved significantly and so has his attention but we are still working on the executive function. I have to keep reminding the mom where we started as she tends to forget. Like, “remember when it took him 4 hours to do 20 minutes of homework and now he can do it in 30 minutes?” Hope this helps. Connie From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Margoshes Sent: Monday, April 19, 2010 8:01 AM Subject: assessing how clients are doing in a session Listmates. I haven't even approached BioReview yet, but I'm wondering how you assess (for yourself and the client) how someone is doing throughout a training session and across sessions. I'm just getting seriously into training with BioExplorer, and it seems that I would love to be able to see (and show the client), " OK. during the first training session you did [something] X number of times during the sessions, and then, during session 5, you did [it] X+4 number of times, isn't that great? " I know we're looking for clinical results, but this would be so helpful to me, and, I'm presuming, the client. Is BioReview the way to go here? Or learn to set up a counter? For a specific example, I've been doing some training with Pete's alpha-gamma coherence/synchrony design. You can look at trends to see how someone is doing in real time, but what I'd like is a way to count the number of times in a session the various tones are sounded (the tones correlate with hitting certain values in synchrony, coherence, etc.). Here's a description from the notes about what tones there are: " Coherence in alpha, phase angle in alpha, coherence in gamma and phase angle in gamma each have a tone in a chord that plays the background for the brain's synchrony music. When all four are in range, the full chord sounds and a soft high-pitched crystal sound plays. Two harmonic melody lines play as well (one for alpha amplitude summed between the two channels and a faster one for gamma amplitude summed between the two channels.) There are also binaural beats at 10 Hz. " That's a LOT Of tones going on at the same time. I find when I train myself I just hear a lot of noise and cannot discriminate among them and can't figure out how I'm doing. I wonder what tones could be held more important and how to work out a way to have them counted during the sessions. Is there anything already on the alpha gamma synch.bxd design (or any other design) that does this, but I'm not seeing it? Or how could I set this up? Or is it already implicit in the BioReview aspect of the software? Would it be easier to start with a simpler design, that's just doing one thing, and learn to design a counter or other simple way to collect a little summary data on what's going on? (in Francois Dupont's designs for Thought Technology there seem to be counters sometimes) Thank you. Llz Margoshes Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 Liz,If you will just start getting the alpha going, all this busywork will just melt away.If you don't know it's working, it's not working. If you believe that, after everything else you and the client have tried, suddenly the placebo effect is kicking it and THAT is what's causing the improvement, embrace the placebo effect. You can't PROVE it. And once you experience it, you don't NEED to prove it.Just train.Pete-- Van Deusenpvdtlc@...http://www.brain-trainer.com USA 305 433 3160BR 47 3346 6235The Learning Curve, Inc. On Mon, Apr 19, 2010 at 12:13 PM, Connie Welsh <conniewelsh@...> wrote: Liz, you can use BioReview to look at trends which is what it appears you are looking for. Artifact is in the data but most times you can see the trend. So, for instance, you would define a variable like theta amplitude. You can then see the trend over the session. Is it getting smaller or bigger? Now, you have to look at trends at a high level. The graph could go down for awhile, back up and then back down and I would see that as positive. Especially if it ends less than it started. Get out the BioReview and look at some of Pete’s designs if he has some. If not, I can send one to you. Run a report and see what it does. Connie From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Margoshes Sent: Monday, April 19, 2010 10:53 AM Subject: Re: assessing how clients are doing in a session Connie, Thank you for these suggestions. They're helpful. But it's important to me, at least as I begin training clients, to see if the treatment itself is getting " in. " Also, I don't know if I'm being too compulsive, but I'd like to see if the clinical improvements are due to the NF itself since there are so many extra-treatmentlike factors involved (e.g. having to sit still for a certain amount of time during the sessions; spendimg time with a caring professional; seeing that your mother takes your complaints seriously and is trying to help you rather than be judgmental; etc.) Mostly I would like to be able to *show* people that training, not just improvements in task performance (e.g. homework), is actually occurring. At the moment I'm particularly interested in the alpha-gamma because I have a number of available meditators (via someone I know who has a yoga studio) and I am fascinated (for myself as well) with the idea of EEG-assisted meditation (a la Soutar). I would love to be able to demonstrate that you really ARE changing your mindstate -- " See? you made those bells ring more after X sessions of NF! " I think it would be a much more powerful demonstration if I could show that changes in brain function had actually occurred -- not just how you " feel " . I'm very interested in this area which I think could be very helpful for people who are not in " clinical " distress and are not going to come to me for assessments, long treatments, etc. Maybe I don't need to show that " the bell rang 20 times this session. " Maybe there's another way (that has to do with graphs, comparing BioReview data across sessions, etc?) I really don't know anything about this. The thing about compiling statistics is I'm afraid of artifact (like muscle) contaminating the numbers? do you have to artifact the data in order for BioReview to do its job? However I also want to show " data " to parents, etc., when I get to that stage. thank you, Liz On Mon, Apr 19, 2010 at 10:33 AM, Connie Welsh <conniewelsh@...> wrote: Liz, In the beginning, I do Bioreview and look at the data for most sessions just to see if the protocol I am using is working for the client. Sometimes I go back to one of the first graphs and a later graph to see changes. Maybe after 6 sessions or so. I also sometimes do pieces of the TLC again to compare. This is very interesting as many times, what I am trying to remedy is gone after about 20 sessions. I like this the best to be honest. If you are working C3 for example and you do the piece of the TLC for C’s it only takes about 10 minutes to do it and artifact in and compare to the C’s in the initial assessment. If you don’t do the entire assessment, you can’t look at many of the pieces, but you can see the histogram and the theta/beta ratios and left to right reversals. Clinical results are key!!! Since many times they are gradual, you have to be very adamant about reminding the client where they were in the beginning. For instance, I have a boy I have been training for reading issues, attention and executive function issues. Well, his reading has improved significantly and so has his attention but we are still working on the executive function. I have to keep reminding the mom where we started as she tends to forget. Like, “remember when it took him 4 hours to do 20 minutes of homework and now he can do it in 30 minutes?” Hope this helps. Connie From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Margoshes Sent: Monday, April 19, 2010 8:01 AM Subject: assessing how clients are doing in a session Listmates. I haven't even approached BioReview yet, but I'm wondering how you assess (for yourself and the client) how someone is doing throughout a training session and across sessions. I'm just getting seriously into training with BioExplorer, and it seems that I would love to be able to see (and show the client), " OK. during the first training session you did [something] X number of times during the sessions, and then, during session 5, you did [it] X+4 number of times, isn't that great? " I know we're looking for clinical results, but this would be so helpful to me, and, I'm presuming, the client. Is BioReview the way to go here? Or learn to set up a counter? For a specific example, I've been doing some training with Pete's alpha-gamma coherence/synchrony design. You can look at trends to see how someone is doing in real time, but what I'd like is a way to count the number of times in a session the various tones are sounded (the tones correlate with hitting certain values in synchrony, coherence, etc.). Here's a description from the notes about what tones there are: " Coherence in alpha, phase angle in alpha, coherence in gamma and phase angle in gamma each have a tone in a chord that plays the background for the brain's synchrony music. When all four are in range, the full chord sounds and a soft high-pitched crystal sound plays. Two harmonic melody lines play as well (one for alpha amplitude summed between the two channels and a faster one for gamma amplitude summed between the two channels.) There are also binaural beats at 10 Hz. " That's a LOT Of tones going on at the same time. I find when I train myself I just hear a lot of noise and cannot discriminate among them and can't figure out how I'm doing. I wonder what tones could be held more important and how to work out a way to have them counted during the sessions. Is there anything already on the alpha gamma synch.bxd design (or any other design) that does this, but I'm not seeing it? Or how could I set this up? Or is it already implicit in the BioReview aspect of the software? Would it be easier to start with a simpler design, that's just doing one thing, and learn to design a counter or other simple way to collect a little summary data on what's going on? (in Francois Dupont's designs for Thought Technology there seem to be counters sometimes) Thank you. Llz Margoshes Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 Liz,If you will just start getting the alpha going, all this busywork will just melt away.If you don't know it's working, it's not working. If you believe that, after everything else you and the client have tried, suddenly the placebo effect is kicking it and THAT is what's causing the improvement, embrace the placebo effect. You can't PROVE it. And once you experience it, you don't NEED to prove it.Just train.Pete-- Van Deusenpvdtlc@...http://www.brain-trainer.com USA 305 433 3160BR 47 3346 6235The Learning Curve, Inc. On Mon, Apr 19, 2010 at 12:13 PM, Connie Welsh <conniewelsh@...> wrote: Liz, you can use BioReview to look at trends which is what it appears you are looking for. Artifact is in the data but most times you can see the trend. So, for instance, you would define a variable like theta amplitude. You can then see the trend over the session. Is it getting smaller or bigger? Now, you have to look at trends at a high level. The graph could go down for awhile, back up and then back down and I would see that as positive. Especially if it ends less than it started. Get out the BioReview and look at some of Pete’s designs if he has some. If not, I can send one to you. Run a report and see what it does. Connie From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Margoshes Sent: Monday, April 19, 2010 10:53 AM Subject: Re: assessing how clients are doing in a session Connie, Thank you for these suggestions. They're helpful. But it's important to me, at least as I begin training clients, to see if the treatment itself is getting " in. " Also, I don't know if I'm being too compulsive, but I'd like to see if the clinical improvements are due to the NF itself since there are so many extra-treatmentlike factors involved (e.g. having to sit still for a certain amount of time during the sessions; spendimg time with a caring professional; seeing that your mother takes your complaints seriously and is trying to help you rather than be judgmental; etc.) Mostly I would like to be able to *show* people that training, not just improvements in task performance (e.g. homework), is actually occurring. At the moment I'm particularly interested in the alpha-gamma because I have a number of available meditators (via someone I know who has a yoga studio) and I am fascinated (for myself as well) with the idea of EEG-assisted meditation (a la Soutar). I would love to be able to demonstrate that you really ARE changing your mindstate -- " See? you made those bells ring more after X sessions of NF! " I think it would be a much more powerful demonstration if I could show that changes in brain function had actually occurred -- not just how you " feel " . I'm very interested in this area which I think could be very helpful for people who are not in " clinical " distress and are not going to come to me for assessments, long treatments, etc. Maybe I don't need to show that " the bell rang 20 times this session. " Maybe there's another way (that has to do with graphs, comparing BioReview data across sessions, etc?) I really don't know anything about this. The thing about compiling statistics is I'm afraid of artifact (like muscle) contaminating the numbers? do you have to artifact the data in order for BioReview to do its job? However I also want to show " data " to parents, etc., when I get to that stage. thank you, Liz On Mon, Apr 19, 2010 at 10:33 AM, Connie Welsh <conniewelsh@...> wrote: Liz, In the beginning, I do Bioreview and look at the data for most sessions just to see if the protocol I am using is working for the client. Sometimes I go back to one of the first graphs and a later graph to see changes. Maybe after 6 sessions or so. I also sometimes do pieces of the TLC again to compare. This is very interesting as many times, what I am trying to remedy is gone after about 20 sessions. I like this the best to be honest. If you are working C3 for example and you do the piece of the TLC for C’s it only takes about 10 minutes to do it and artifact in and compare to the C’s in the initial assessment. If you don’t do the entire assessment, you can’t look at many of the pieces, but you can see the histogram and the theta/beta ratios and left to right reversals. Clinical results are key!!! Since many times they are gradual, you have to be very adamant about reminding the client where they were in the beginning. For instance, I have a boy I have been training for reading issues, attention and executive function issues. Well, his reading has improved significantly and so has his attention but we are still working on the executive function. I have to keep reminding the mom where we started as she tends to forget. Like, “remember when it took him 4 hours to do 20 minutes of homework and now he can do it in 30 minutes?” Hope this helps. Connie From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Margoshes Sent: Monday, April 19, 2010 8:01 AM Subject: assessing how clients are doing in a session Listmates. I haven't even approached BioReview yet, but I'm wondering how you assess (for yourself and the client) how someone is doing throughout a training session and across sessions. I'm just getting seriously into training with BioExplorer, and it seems that I would love to be able to see (and show the client), " OK. during the first training session you did [something] X number of times during the sessions, and then, during session 5, you did [it] X+4 number of times, isn't that great? " I know we're looking for clinical results, but this would be so helpful to me, and, I'm presuming, the client. Is BioReview the way to go here? Or learn to set up a counter? For a specific example, I've been doing some training with Pete's alpha-gamma coherence/synchrony design. You can look at trends to see how someone is doing in real time, but what I'd like is a way to count the number of times in a session the various tones are sounded (the tones correlate with hitting certain values in synchrony, coherence, etc.). Here's a description from the notes about what tones there are: " Coherence in alpha, phase angle in alpha, coherence in gamma and phase angle in gamma each have a tone in a chord that plays the background for the brain's synchrony music. When all four are in range, the full chord sounds and a soft high-pitched crystal sound plays. Two harmonic melody lines play as well (one for alpha amplitude summed between the two channels and a faster one for gamma amplitude summed between the two channels.) There are also binaural beats at 10 Hz. " That's a LOT Of tones going on at the same time. I find when I train myself I just hear a lot of noise and cannot discriminate among them and can't figure out how I'm doing. I wonder what tones could be held more important and how to work out a way to have them counted during the sessions. Is there anything already on the alpha gamma synch.bxd design (or any other design) that does this, but I'm not seeing it? Or how could I set this up? Or is it already implicit in the BioReview aspect of the software? Would it be easier to start with a simpler design, that's just doing one thing, and learn to design a counter or other simple way to collect a little summary data on what's going on? (in Francois Dupont's designs for Thought Technology there seem to be counters sometimes) Thank you. Llz Margoshes Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 Pete, love the placebo effect comment. I say that to my clients all the time. It may be placebo but just go with it, you didn’t have it beforeJ From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Van Deusen Sent: Monday, April 19, 2010 11:17 AM Subject: Re: assessing how clients are doing in a session Liz, If you will just start getting the alpha going, all this busywork will just melt away. If you don't know it's working, it's not working. If you believe that, after everything else you and the client have tried, suddenly the placebo effect is kicking it and THAT is what's causing the improvement, embrace the placebo effect. You can't PROVE it. And once you experience it, you don't NEED to prove it. Just train. Pete -- Van Deusen pvdtlc@... http://www.brain-trainer.com USA 305 433 3160 BR 47 3346 6235 The Learning Curve, Inc. On Mon, Apr 19, 2010 at 12:13 PM, Connie Welsh <conniewelsh@...> wrote: Liz, you can use BioReview to look at trends which is what it appears you are looking for. Artifact is in the data but most times you can see the trend. So, for instance, you would define a variable like theta amplitude. You can then see the trend over the session. Is it getting smaller or bigger? Now, you have to look at trends at a high level. The graph could go down for awhile, back up and then back down and I would see that as positive. Especially if it ends less than it started. Get out the BioReview and look at some of Pete’s designs if he has some. If not, I can send one to you. Run a report and see what it does. Connie From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Margoshes Sent: Monday, April 19, 2010 10:53 AM Subject: Re: assessing how clients are doing in a session Connie, Thank you for these suggestions. They're helpful. But it's important to me, at least as I begin training clients, to see if the treatment itself is getting " in. " Also, I don't know if I'm being too compulsive, but I'd like to see if the clinical improvements are due to the NF itself since there are so many extra-treatmentlike factors involved (e.g. having to sit still for a certain amount of time during the sessions; spendimg time with a caring professional; seeing that your mother takes your complaints seriously and is trying to help you rather than be judgmental; etc.) Mostly I would like to be able to *show* people that training, not just improvements in task performance (e.g. homework), is actually occurring. At the moment I'm particularly interested in the alpha-gamma because I have a number of available meditators (via someone I know who has a yoga studio) and I am fascinated (for myself as well) with the idea of EEG-assisted meditation (a la Soutar). I would love to be able to demonstrate that you really ARE changing your mindstate -- " See? you made those bells ring more after X sessions of NF! " I think it would be a much more powerful demonstration if I could show that changes in brain function had actually occurred -- not just how you " feel " . I'm very interested in this area which I think could be very helpful for people who are not in " clinical " distress and are not going to come to me for assessments, long treatments, etc. Maybe I don't need to show that " the bell rang 20 times this session. " Maybe there's another way (that has to do with graphs, comparing BioReview data across sessions, etc?) I really don't know anything about this. The thing about compiling statistics is I'm afraid of artifact (like muscle) contaminating the numbers? do you have to artifact the data in order for BioReview to do its job? However I also want to show " data " to parents, etc., when I get to that stage. thank you, Liz On Mon, Apr 19, 2010 at 10:33 AM, Connie Welsh <conniewelsh@...> wrote: Liz, In the beginning, I do Bioreview and look at the data for most sessions just to see if the protocol I am using is working for the client. Sometimes I go back to one of the first graphs and a later graph to see changes. Maybe after 6 sessions or so. I also sometimes do pieces of the TLC again to compare. This is very interesting as many times, what I am trying to remedy is gone after about 20 sessions. I like this the best to be honest. If you are working C3 for example and you do the piece of the TLC for C’s it only takes about 10 minutes to do it and artifact in and compare to the C’s in the initial assessment. If you don’t do the entire assessment, you can’t look at many of the pieces, but you can see the histogram and the theta/beta ratios and left to right reversals. Clinical results are key!!! Since many times they are gradual, you have to be very adamant about reminding the client where they were in the beginning. For instance, I have a boy I have been training for reading issues, attention and executive function issues. Well, his reading has improved significantly and so has his attention but we are still working on the executive function. I have to keep reminding the mom where we started as she tends to forget. Like, “remember when it took him 4 hours to do 20 minutes of homework and now he can do it in 30 minutes?” Hope this helps. Connie From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Margoshes Sent: Monday, April 19, 2010 8:01 AM Subject: assessing how clients are doing in a session Listmates. I haven't even approached BioReview yet, but I'm wondering how you assess (for yourself and the client) how someone is doing throughout a training session and across sessions. I'm just getting seriously into training with BioExplorer, and it seems that I would love to be able to see (and show the client), " OK. during the first training session you did [something] X number of times during the sessions, and then, during session 5, you did [it] X+4 number of times, isn't that great? " I know we're looking for clinical results, but this would be so helpful to me, and, I'm presuming, the client. Is BioReview the way to go here? Or learn to set up a counter? For a specific example, I've been doing some training with Pete's alpha-gamma coherence/synchrony design. You can look at trends to see how someone is doing in real time, but what I'd like is a way to count the number of times in a session the various tones are sounded (the tones correlate with hitting certain values in synchrony, coherence, etc.). Here's a description from the notes about what tones there are: " Coherence in alpha, phase angle in alpha, coherence in gamma and phase angle in gamma each have a tone in a chord that plays the background for the brain's synchrony music. When all four are in range, the full chord sounds and a soft high-pitched crystal sound plays. Two harmonic melody lines play as well (one for alpha amplitude summed between the two channels and a faster one for gamma amplitude summed between the two channels.) There are also binaural beats at 10 Hz. " That's a LOT Of tones going on at the same time. I find when I train myself I just hear a lot of noise and cannot discriminate among them and can't figure out how I'm doing. I wonder what tones could be held more important and how to work out a way to have them counted during the sessions. Is there anything already on the alpha gamma synch.bxd design (or any other design) that does this, but I'm not seeing it? Or how could I set this up? Or is it already implicit in the BioReview aspect of the software? Would it be easier to start with a simpler design, that's just doing one thing, and learn to design a counter or other simple way to collect a little summary data on what's going on? (in Francois Dupont's designs for Thought Technology there seem to be counters sometimes) Thank you. Llz Margoshes Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 Pete, love the placebo effect comment. I say that to my clients all the time. It may be placebo but just go with it, you didn’t have it beforeJ From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Van Deusen Sent: Monday, April 19, 2010 11:17 AM Subject: Re: assessing how clients are doing in a session Liz, If you will just start getting the alpha going, all this busywork will just melt away. If you don't know it's working, it's not working. If you believe that, after everything else you and the client have tried, suddenly the placebo effect is kicking it and THAT is what's causing the improvement, embrace the placebo effect. You can't PROVE it. And once you experience it, you don't NEED to prove it. Just train. Pete -- Van Deusen pvdtlc@... http://www.brain-trainer.com USA 305 433 3160 BR 47 3346 6235 The Learning Curve, Inc. On Mon, Apr 19, 2010 at 12:13 PM, Connie Welsh <conniewelsh@...> wrote: Liz, you can use BioReview to look at trends which is what it appears you are looking for. Artifact is in the data but most times you can see the trend. So, for instance, you would define a variable like theta amplitude. You can then see the trend over the session. Is it getting smaller or bigger? Now, you have to look at trends at a high level. The graph could go down for awhile, back up and then back down and I would see that as positive. Especially if it ends less than it started. Get out the BioReview and look at some of Pete’s designs if he has some. If not, I can send one to you. Run a report and see what it does. Connie From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Margoshes Sent: Monday, April 19, 2010 10:53 AM Subject: Re: assessing how clients are doing in a session Connie, Thank you for these suggestions. They're helpful. But it's important to me, at least as I begin training clients, to see if the treatment itself is getting " in. " Also, I don't know if I'm being too compulsive, but I'd like to see if the clinical improvements are due to the NF itself since there are so many extra-treatmentlike factors involved (e.g. having to sit still for a certain amount of time during the sessions; spendimg time with a caring professional; seeing that your mother takes your complaints seriously and is trying to help you rather than be judgmental; etc.) Mostly I would like to be able to *show* people that training, not just improvements in task performance (e.g. homework), is actually occurring. At the moment I'm particularly interested in the alpha-gamma because I have a number of available meditators (via someone I know who has a yoga studio) and I am fascinated (for myself as well) with the idea of EEG-assisted meditation (a la Soutar). I would love to be able to demonstrate that you really ARE changing your mindstate -- " See? you made those bells ring more after X sessions of NF! " I think it would be a much more powerful demonstration if I could show that changes in brain function had actually occurred -- not just how you " feel " . I'm very interested in this area which I think could be very helpful for people who are not in " clinical " distress and are not going to come to me for assessments, long treatments, etc. Maybe I don't need to show that " the bell rang 20 times this session. " Maybe there's another way (that has to do with graphs, comparing BioReview data across sessions, etc?) I really don't know anything about this. The thing about compiling statistics is I'm afraid of artifact (like muscle) contaminating the numbers? do you have to artifact the data in order for BioReview to do its job? However I also want to show " data " to parents, etc., when I get to that stage. thank you, Liz On Mon, Apr 19, 2010 at 10:33 AM, Connie Welsh <conniewelsh@...> wrote: Liz, In the beginning, I do Bioreview and look at the data for most sessions just to see if the protocol I am using is working for the client. Sometimes I go back to one of the first graphs and a later graph to see changes. Maybe after 6 sessions or so. I also sometimes do pieces of the TLC again to compare. This is very interesting as many times, what I am trying to remedy is gone after about 20 sessions. I like this the best to be honest. If you are working C3 for example and you do the piece of the TLC for C’s it only takes about 10 minutes to do it and artifact in and compare to the C’s in the initial assessment. If you don’t do the entire assessment, you can’t look at many of the pieces, but you can see the histogram and the theta/beta ratios and left to right reversals. Clinical results are key!!! Since many times they are gradual, you have to be very adamant about reminding the client where they were in the beginning. For instance, I have a boy I have been training for reading issues, attention and executive function issues. Well, his reading has improved significantly and so has his attention but we are still working on the executive function. I have to keep reminding the mom where we started as she tends to forget. Like, “remember when it took him 4 hours to do 20 minutes of homework and now he can do it in 30 minutes?” Hope this helps. Connie From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Margoshes Sent: Monday, April 19, 2010 8:01 AM Subject: assessing how clients are doing in a session Listmates. I haven't even approached BioReview yet, but I'm wondering how you assess (for yourself and the client) how someone is doing throughout a training session and across sessions. I'm just getting seriously into training with BioExplorer, and it seems that I would love to be able to see (and show the client), " OK. during the first training session you did [something] X number of times during the sessions, and then, during session 5, you did [it] X+4 number of times, isn't that great? " I know we're looking for clinical results, but this would be so helpful to me, and, I'm presuming, the client. Is BioReview the way to go here? Or learn to set up a counter? For a specific example, I've been doing some training with Pete's alpha-gamma coherence/synchrony design. You can look at trends to see how someone is doing in real time, but what I'd like is a way to count the number of times in a session the various tones are sounded (the tones correlate with hitting certain values in synchrony, coherence, etc.). Here's a description from the notes about what tones there are: " Coherence in alpha, phase angle in alpha, coherence in gamma and phase angle in gamma each have a tone in a chord that plays the background for the brain's synchrony music. When all four are in range, the full chord sounds and a soft high-pitched crystal sound plays. Two harmonic melody lines play as well (one for alpha amplitude summed between the two channels and a faster one for gamma amplitude summed between the two channels.) There are also binaural beats at 10 Hz. " That's a LOT Of tones going on at the same time. I find when I train myself I just hear a lot of noise and cannot discriminate among them and can't figure out how I'm doing. I wonder what tones could be held more important and how to work out a way to have them counted during the sessions. Is there anything already on the alpha gamma synch.bxd design (or any other design) that does this, but I'm not seeing it? Or how could I set this up? Or is it already implicit in the BioReview aspect of the software? Would it be easier to start with a simpler design, that's just doing one thing, and learn to design a counter or other simple way to collect a little summary data on what's going on? (in Francois Dupont's designs for Thought Technology there seem to be counters sometimes) Thank you. Llz Margoshes Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 Pete,Please excuse the " Duh " factor, but are you talking about training my own alpha? can you be more specific? (I know, I know).LizOn Mon, Apr 19, 2010 at 11:17 AM, Van Deusen <pvdtlc@...> wrote: Liz,If you will just start getting the alpha going, all this busywork will just melt away.If you don't know it's working, it's not working. If you believe that, after everything else you and the client have tried, suddenly the placebo effect is kicking it and THAT is what's causing the improvement, embrace the placebo effect. You can't PROVE it. And once you experience it, you don't NEED to prove it.Just train.Pete-- Van Deusenpvdtlc@... http://www.brain-trainer.com USA 305 433 3160BR 47 3346 6235The Learning Curve, Inc. On Mon, Apr 19, 2010 at 12:13 PM, Connie Welsh <conniewelsh@...> wrote: Liz, you can use BioReview to look at trends which is what it appears you are looking for. Artifact is in the data but most times you can see the trend. So, for instance, you would define a variable like theta amplitude. You can then see the trend over the session. Is it getting smaller or bigger? Now, you have to look at trends at a high level. The graph could go down for awhile, back up and then back down and I would see that as positive. Especially if it ends less than it started. Get out the BioReview and look at some of Pete’s designs if he has some. If not, I can send one to you. Run a report and see what it does. Connie From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Margoshes Sent: Monday, April 19, 2010 10:53 AM Subject: Re: assessing how clients are doing in a session Connie, Thank you for these suggestions. They're helpful. But it's important to me, at least as I begin training clients, to see if the treatment itself is getting " in. " Also, I don't know if I'm being too compulsive, but I'd like to see if the clinical improvements are due to the NF itself since there are so many extra-treatmentlike factors involved (e.g. having to sit still for a certain amount of time during the sessions; spendimg time with a caring professional; seeing that your mother takes your complaints seriously and is trying to help you rather than be judgmental; etc.) Mostly I would like to be able to *show* people that training, not just improvements in task performance (e.g. homework), is actually occurring. At the moment I'm particularly interested in the alpha-gamma because I have a number of available meditators (via someone I know who has a yoga studio) and I am fascinated (for myself as well) with the idea of EEG-assisted meditation (a la Soutar). I would love to be able to demonstrate that you really ARE changing your mindstate -- " See? you made those bells ring more after X sessions of NF! " I think it would be a much more powerful demonstration if I could show that changes in brain function had actually occurred -- not just how you " feel " . I'm very interested in this area which I think could be very helpful for people who are not in " clinical " distress and are not going to come to me for assessments, long treatments, etc. Maybe I don't need to show that " the bell rang 20 times this session. " Maybe there's another way (that has to do with graphs, comparing BioReview data across sessions, etc?) I really don't know anything about this. The thing about compiling statistics is I'm afraid of artifact (like muscle) contaminating the numbers? do you have to artifact the data in order for BioReview to do its job? However I also want to show " data " to parents, etc., when I get to that stage. thank you, Liz On Mon, Apr 19, 2010 at 10:33 AM, Connie Welsh <conniewelsh@...> wrote: Liz, In the beginning, I do Bioreview and look at the data for most sessions just to see if the protocol I am using is working for the client. Sometimes I go back to one of the first graphs and a later graph to see changes. Maybe after 6 sessions or so. I also sometimes do pieces of the TLC again to compare. This is very interesting as many times, what I am trying to remedy is gone after about 20 sessions. I like this the best to be honest. If you are working C3 for example and you do the piece of the TLC for C’s it only takes about 10 minutes to do it and artifact in and compare to the C’s in the initial assessment. If you don’t do the entire assessment, you can’t look at many of the pieces, but you can see the histogram and the theta/beta ratios and left to right reversals. Clinical results are key!!! Since many times they are gradual, you have to be very adamant about reminding the client where they were in the beginning. For instance, I have a boy I have been training for reading issues, attention and executive function issues. Well, his reading has improved significantly and so has his attention but we are still working on the executive function. I have to keep reminding the mom where we started as she tends to forget. Like, “remember when it took him 4 hours to do 20 minutes of homework and now he can do it in 30 minutes?” Hope this helps. Connie From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Margoshes Sent: Monday, April 19, 2010 8:01 AM Subject: assessing how clients are doing in a session Listmates. I haven't even approached BioReview yet, but I'm wondering how you assess (for yourself and the client) how someone is doing throughout a training session and across sessions. I'm just getting seriously into training with BioExplorer, and it seems that I would love to be able to see (and show the client), " OK. during the first training session you did [something] X number of times during the sessions, and then, during session 5, you did [it] X+4 number of times, isn't that great? " I know we're looking for clinical results, but this would be so helpful to me, and, I'm presuming, the client. Is BioReview the way to go here? Or learn to set up a counter? For a specific example, I've been doing some training with Pete's alpha-gamma coherence/synchrony design. You can look at trends to see how someone is doing in real time, but what I'd like is a way to count the number of times in a session the various tones are sounded (the tones correlate with hitting certain values in synchrony, coherence, etc.). Here's a description from the notes about what tones there are: " Coherence in alpha, phase angle in alpha, coherence in gamma and phase angle in gamma each have a tone in a chord that plays the background for the brain's synchrony music. When all four are in range, the full chord sounds and a soft high-pitched crystal sound plays. Two harmonic melody lines play as well (one for alpha amplitude summed between the two channels and a faster one for gamma amplitude summed between the two channels.) There are also binaural beats at 10 Hz. " That's a LOT Of tones going on at the same time. I find when I train myself I just hear a lot of noise and cannot discriminate among them and can't figure out how I'm doing. I wonder what tones could be held more important and how to work out a way to have them counted during the sessions. Is there anything already on the alpha gamma synch.bxd design (or any other design) that does this, but I'm not seeing it? Or how could I set this up? Or is it already implicit in the BioReview aspect of the software? Would it be easier to start with a simpler design, that's just doing one thing, and learn to design a counter or other simple way to collect a little summary data on what's going on? (in Francois Dupont's designs for Thought Technology there seem to be counters sometimes) Thank you. Llz Margoshes Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 I would like to know how to translate this into working with meditators to see if something is " really " happening. I can't remember who was talking about this -- a NF practitioner -- who was saying people say " Ooh, I'm meditating " but then when they're hooked up they see what it really feels like to get into that gamma state. That's the thing I'm going for. Maybe I don't need " stats " but a real-time observation of the trend graphs would be enough, rather than session-to-session " progress " reports? I still want to learn how to do this, as Connie, Sharrie, etc. have agreed it can be useful to show parents the graphs.LizOn Mon, Apr 19, 2010 at 12:29 PM, Connie Welsh <conniewelsh@...> wrote: Pete, love the placebo effect comment. I say that to my clients all the time. It may be placebo but just go with it, you didn’t have it beforeJ From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Van Deusen Sent: Monday, April 19, 2010 11:17 AM Subject: Re: assessing how clients are doing in a session Liz, If you will just start getting the alpha going, all this busywork will just melt away. If you don't know it's working, it's not working. If you believe that, after everything else you and the client have tried, suddenly the placebo effect is kicking it and THAT is what's causing the improvement, embrace the placebo effect. You can't PROVE it. And once you experience it, you don't NEED to prove it. Just train. Pete -- Van Deusen pvdtlc@... http://www.brain-trainer.com USA 305 433 3160 BR 47 3346 6235 The Learning Curve, Inc. On Mon, Apr 19, 2010 at 12:13 PM, Connie Welsh <conniewelsh@...> wrote: Liz, you can use BioReview to look at trends which is what it appears you are looking for. Artifact is in the data but most times you can see the trend. So, for instance, you would define a variable like theta amplitude. You can then see the trend over the session. Is it getting smaller or bigger? Now, you have to look at trends at a high level. The graph could go down for awhile, back up and then back down and I would see that as positive. Especially if it ends less than it started. Get out the BioReview and look at some of Pete’s designs if he has some. If not, I can send one to you. Run a report and see what it does. Connie From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Margoshes Sent: Monday, April 19, 2010 10:53 AM Subject: Re: assessing how clients are doing in a session Connie, Thank you for these suggestions. They're helpful. But it's important to me, at least as I begin training clients, to see if the treatment itself is getting " in. " Also, I don't know if I'm being too compulsive, but I'd like to see if the clinical improvements are due to the NF itself since there are so many extra-treatmentlike factors involved (e.g. having to sit still for a certain amount of time during the sessions; spendimg time with a caring professional; seeing that your mother takes your complaints seriously and is trying to help you rather than be judgmental; etc.) Mostly I would like to be able to *show* people that training, not just improvements in task performance (e.g. homework), is actually occurring. At the moment I'm particularly interested in the alpha-gamma because I have a number of available meditators (via someone I know who has a yoga studio) and I am fascinated (for myself as well) with the idea of EEG-assisted meditation (a la Soutar). I would love to be able to demonstrate that you really ARE changing your mindstate -- " See? you made those bells ring more after X sessions of NF! " I think it would be a much more powerful demonstration if I could show that changes in brain function had actually occurred -- not just how you " feel " . I'm very interested in this area which I think could be very helpful for people who are not in " clinical " distress and are not going to come to me for assessments, long treatments, etc. Maybe I don't need to show that " the bell rang 20 times this session. " Maybe there's another way (that has to do with graphs, comparing BioReview data across sessions, etc?) I really don't know anything about this. The thing about compiling statistics is I'm afraid of artifact (like muscle) contaminating the numbers? do you have to artifact the data in order for BioReview to do its job? However I also want to show " data " to parents, etc., when I get to that stage. thank you, Liz On Mon, Apr 19, 2010 at 10:33 AM, Connie Welsh <conniewelsh@...> wrote: Liz, In the beginning, I do Bioreview and look at the data for most sessions just to see if the protocol I am using is working for the client. Sometimes I go back to one of the first graphs and a later graph to see changes. Maybe after 6 sessions or so. I also sometimes do pieces of the TLC again to compare. This is very interesting as many times, what I am trying to remedy is gone after about 20 sessions. I like this the best to be honest. If you are working C3 for example and you do the piece of the TLC for C’s it only takes about 10 minutes to do it and artifact in and compare to the C’s in the initial assessment. If you don’t do the entire assessment, you can’t look at many of the pieces, but you can see the histogram and the theta/beta ratios and left to right reversals. Clinical results are key!!! Since many times they are gradual, you have to be very adamant about reminding the client where they were in the beginning. For instance, I have a boy I have been training for reading issues, attention and executive function issues. Well, his reading has improved significantly and so has his attention but we are still working on the executive function. I have to keep reminding the mom where we started as she tends to forget. Like, “remember when it took him 4 hours to do 20 minutes of homework and now he can do it in 30 minutes?” Hope this helps. Connie From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Margoshes Sent: Monday, April 19, 2010 8:01 AM Subject: assessing how clients are doing in a session Listmates. I haven't even approached BioReview yet, but I'm wondering how you assess (for yourself and the client) how someone is doing throughout a training session and across sessions. I'm just getting seriously into training with BioExplorer, and it seems that I would love to be able to see (and show the client), " OK. during the first training session you did [something] X number of times during the sessions, and then, during session 5, you did [it] X+4 number of times, isn't that great? " I know we're looking for clinical results, but this would be so helpful to me, and, I'm presuming, the client. Is BioReview the way to go here? Or learn to set up a counter? For a specific example, I've been doing some training with Pete's alpha-gamma coherence/synchrony design. You can look at trends to see how someone is doing in real time, but what I'd like is a way to count the number of times in a session the various tones are sounded (the tones correlate with hitting certain values in synchrony, coherence, etc.). Here's a description from the notes about what tones there are: " Coherence in alpha, phase angle in alpha, coherence in gamma and phase angle in gamma each have a tone in a chord that plays the background for the brain's synchrony music. When all four are in range, the full chord sounds and a soft high-pitched crystal sound plays. Two harmonic melody lines play as well (one for alpha amplitude summed between the two channels and a faster one for gamma amplitude summed between the two channels.) There are also binaural beats at 10 Hz. " That's a LOT Of tones going on at the same time. I find when I train myself I just hear a lot of noise and cannot discriminate among them and can't figure out how I'm doing. I wonder what tones could be held more important and how to work out a way to have them counted during the sessions. Is there anything already on the alpha gamma synch.bxd design (or any other design) that does this, but I'm not seeing it? Or how could I set this up? Or is it already implicit in the BioReview aspect of the software? Would it be easier to start with a simpler design, that's just doing one thing, and learn to design a counter or other simple way to collect a little summary data on what's going on? (in Francois Dupont's designs for Thought Technology there seem to be counters sometimes) Thank you. Llz Margoshes Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 I would like to know how to translate this into working with meditators to see if something is " really " happening. I can't remember who was talking about this -- a NF practitioner -- who was saying people say " Ooh, I'm meditating " but then when they're hooked up they see what it really feels like to get into that gamma state. That's the thing I'm going for. Maybe I don't need " stats " but a real-time observation of the trend graphs would be enough, rather than session-to-session " progress " reports? I still want to learn how to do this, as Connie, Sharrie, etc. have agreed it can be useful to show parents the graphs.LizOn Mon, Apr 19, 2010 at 12:29 PM, Connie Welsh <conniewelsh@...> wrote: Pete, love the placebo effect comment. I say that to my clients all the time. It may be placebo but just go with it, you didn’t have it beforeJ From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Van Deusen Sent: Monday, April 19, 2010 11:17 AM Subject: Re: assessing how clients are doing in a session Liz, If you will just start getting the alpha going, all this busywork will just melt away. If you don't know it's working, it's not working. If you believe that, after everything else you and the client have tried, suddenly the placebo effect is kicking it and THAT is what's causing the improvement, embrace the placebo effect. You can't PROVE it. And once you experience it, you don't NEED to prove it. Just train. Pete -- Van Deusen pvdtlc@... http://www.brain-trainer.com USA 305 433 3160 BR 47 3346 6235 The Learning Curve, Inc. On Mon, Apr 19, 2010 at 12:13 PM, Connie Welsh <conniewelsh@...> wrote: Liz, you can use BioReview to look at trends which is what it appears you are looking for. Artifact is in the data but most times you can see the trend. So, for instance, you would define a variable like theta amplitude. You can then see the trend over the session. Is it getting smaller or bigger? Now, you have to look at trends at a high level. The graph could go down for awhile, back up and then back down and I would see that as positive. Especially if it ends less than it started. Get out the BioReview and look at some of Pete’s designs if he has some. If not, I can send one to you. Run a report and see what it does. Connie From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Margoshes Sent: Monday, April 19, 2010 10:53 AM Subject: Re: assessing how clients are doing in a session Connie, Thank you for these suggestions. They're helpful. But it's important to me, at least as I begin training clients, to see if the treatment itself is getting " in. " Also, I don't know if I'm being too compulsive, but I'd like to see if the clinical improvements are due to the NF itself since there are so many extra-treatmentlike factors involved (e.g. having to sit still for a certain amount of time during the sessions; spendimg time with a caring professional; seeing that your mother takes your complaints seriously and is trying to help you rather than be judgmental; etc.) Mostly I would like to be able to *show* people that training, not just improvements in task performance (e.g. homework), is actually occurring. At the moment I'm particularly interested in the alpha-gamma because I have a number of available meditators (via someone I know who has a yoga studio) and I am fascinated (for myself as well) with the idea of EEG-assisted meditation (a la Soutar). I would love to be able to demonstrate that you really ARE changing your mindstate -- " See? you made those bells ring more after X sessions of NF! " I think it would be a much more powerful demonstration if I could show that changes in brain function had actually occurred -- not just how you " feel " . I'm very interested in this area which I think could be very helpful for people who are not in " clinical " distress and are not going to come to me for assessments, long treatments, etc. Maybe I don't need to show that " the bell rang 20 times this session. " Maybe there's another way (that has to do with graphs, comparing BioReview data across sessions, etc?) I really don't know anything about this. The thing about compiling statistics is I'm afraid of artifact (like muscle) contaminating the numbers? do you have to artifact the data in order for BioReview to do its job? However I also want to show " data " to parents, etc., when I get to that stage. thank you, Liz On Mon, Apr 19, 2010 at 10:33 AM, Connie Welsh <conniewelsh@...> wrote: Liz, In the beginning, I do Bioreview and look at the data for most sessions just to see if the protocol I am using is working for the client. Sometimes I go back to one of the first graphs and a later graph to see changes. Maybe after 6 sessions or so. I also sometimes do pieces of the TLC again to compare. This is very interesting as many times, what I am trying to remedy is gone after about 20 sessions. I like this the best to be honest. If you are working C3 for example and you do the piece of the TLC for C’s it only takes about 10 minutes to do it and artifact in and compare to the C’s in the initial assessment. If you don’t do the entire assessment, you can’t look at many of the pieces, but you can see the histogram and the theta/beta ratios and left to right reversals. Clinical results are key!!! Since many times they are gradual, you have to be very adamant about reminding the client where they were in the beginning. For instance, I have a boy I have been training for reading issues, attention and executive function issues. Well, his reading has improved significantly and so has his attention but we are still working on the executive function. I have to keep reminding the mom where we started as she tends to forget. Like, “remember when it took him 4 hours to do 20 minutes of homework and now he can do it in 30 minutes?” Hope this helps. Connie From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Margoshes Sent: Monday, April 19, 2010 8:01 AM Subject: assessing how clients are doing in a session Listmates. I haven't even approached BioReview yet, but I'm wondering how you assess (for yourself and the client) how someone is doing throughout a training session and across sessions. I'm just getting seriously into training with BioExplorer, and it seems that I would love to be able to see (and show the client), " OK. during the first training session you did [something] X number of times during the sessions, and then, during session 5, you did [it] X+4 number of times, isn't that great? " I know we're looking for clinical results, but this would be so helpful to me, and, I'm presuming, the client. Is BioReview the way to go here? Or learn to set up a counter? For a specific example, I've been doing some training with Pete's alpha-gamma coherence/synchrony design. You can look at trends to see how someone is doing in real time, but what I'd like is a way to count the number of times in a session the various tones are sounded (the tones correlate with hitting certain values in synchrony, coherence, etc.). Here's a description from the notes about what tones there are: " Coherence in alpha, phase angle in alpha, coherence in gamma and phase angle in gamma each have a tone in a chord that plays the background for the brain's synchrony music. When all four are in range, the full chord sounds and a soft high-pitched crystal sound plays. Two harmonic melody lines play as well (one for alpha amplitude summed between the two channels and a faster one for gamma amplitude summed between the two channels.) There are also binaural beats at 10 Hz. " That's a LOT Of tones going on at the same time. I find when I train myself I just hear a lot of noise and cannot discriminate among them and can't figure out how I'm doing. I wonder what tones could be held more important and how to work out a way to have them counted during the sessions. Is there anything already on the alpha gamma synch.bxd design (or any other design) that does this, but I'm not seeing it? Or how could I set this up? Or is it already implicit in the BioReview aspect of the software? Would it be easier to start with a simpler design, that's just doing one thing, and learn to design a counter or other simple way to collect a little summary data on what's going on? (in Francois Dupont's designs for Thought Technology there seem to be counters sometimes) Thank you. Llz Margoshes Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 The client is getting better and the graphs show " improvement " in the EEG.The client is not changing and the graph shows " improvement " , so you can " show " that the client is getting better... ( The client is not changing and the graph shows no " improvement " The client is getting better, but the graph shows no " improvement " If the graphs show what everyone already knows (options 1 and 3) what's the benefit? If the graph shows the client is improving but it doesn't show up in the real world--are your clients going to be satisfied?Worst of all, if the client is doing better, and the graph says no, the accountant/engineer mom or dad (the only one who really cares about seeing the graphs) will doubt that his/her experience of improvement is correct (numbers don't lie!). Pete-- Van Deusenpvdtlc@...http://www.brain-trainer.comUSA 305 433 3160BR 47 3346 6235 The Learning Curve, Inc. On Mon, Apr 19, 2010 at 2:29 PM, Margoshes <drmargoshes@...> wrote: I would like to know how to translate this into working with meditators to see if something is " really " happening. I can't remember who was talking about this -- a NF practitioner -- who was saying people say " Ooh, I'm meditating " but then when they're hooked up they see what it really feels like to get into that gamma state. That's the thing I'm going for. Maybe I don't need " stats " but a real-time observation of the trend graphs would be enough, rather than session-to-session " progress " reports? I still want to learn how to do this, as Connie, Sharrie, etc. have agreed it can be useful to show parents the graphs.LizOn Mon, Apr 19, 2010 at 12:29 PM, Connie Welsh <conniewelsh@...> wrote: Pete, love the placebo effect comment. I say that to my clients all the time. It may be placebo but just go with it, you didn’t have it beforeJ From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Van Deusen Sent: Monday, April 19, 2010 11:17 AM Subject: Re: assessing how clients are doing in a session Liz, If you will just start getting the alpha going, all this busywork will just melt away. If you don't know it's working, it's not working. If you believe that, after everything else you and the client have tried, suddenly the placebo effect is kicking it and THAT is what's causing the improvement, embrace the placebo effect. You can't PROVE it. And once you experience it, you don't NEED to prove it. Just train. Pete -- Van Deusen pvdtlc@... http://www.brain-trainer.com USA 305 433 3160 BR 47 3346 6235 The Learning Curve, Inc. On Mon, Apr 19, 2010 at 12:13 PM, Connie Welsh <conniewelsh@...> wrote: Liz, you can use BioReview to look at trends which is what it appears you are looking for. Artifact is in the data but most times you can see the trend. So, for instance, you would define a variable like theta amplitude. You can then see the trend over the session. Is it getting smaller or bigger? Now, you have to look at trends at a high level. The graph could go down for awhile, back up and then back down and I would see that as positive. Especially if it ends less than it started. Get out the BioReview and look at some of Pete’s designs if he has some. If not, I can send one to you. Run a report and see what it does. Connie From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Margoshes Sent: Monday, April 19, 2010 10:53 AM Subject: Re: assessing how clients are doing in a session Connie, Thank you for these suggestions. They're helpful. But it's important to me, at least as I begin training clients, to see if the treatment itself is getting " in. " Also, I don't know if I'm being too compulsive, but I'd like to see if the clinical improvements are due to the NF itself since there are so many extra-treatmentlike factors involved (e.g. having to sit still for a certain amount of time during the sessions; spendimg time with a caring professional; seeing that your mother takes your complaints seriously and is trying to help you rather than be judgmental; etc.) Mostly I would like to be able to *show* people that training, not just improvements in task performance (e.g. homework), is actually occurring. At the moment I'm particularly interested in the alpha-gamma because I have a number of available meditators (via someone I know who has a yoga studio) and I am fascinated (for myself as well) with the idea of EEG-assisted meditation (a la Soutar). I would love to be able to demonstrate that you really ARE changing your mindstate -- " See? you made those bells ring more after X sessions of NF! " I think it would be a much more powerful demonstration if I could show that changes in brain function had actually occurred -- not just how you " feel " . I'm very interested in this area which I think could be very helpful for people who are not in " clinical " distress and are not going to come to me for assessments, long treatments, etc. Maybe I don't need to show that " the bell rang 20 times this session. " Maybe there's another way (that has to do with graphs, comparing BioReview data across sessions, etc?) I really don't know anything about this. The thing about compiling statistics is I'm afraid of artifact (like muscle) contaminating the numbers? do you have to artifact the data in order for BioReview to do its job? However I also want to show " data " to parents, etc., when I get to that stage. thank you, Liz On Mon, Apr 19, 2010 at 10:33 AM, Connie Welsh <conniewelsh@...> wrote: Liz, In the beginning, I do Bioreview and look at the data for most sessions just to see if the protocol I am using is working for the client. Sometimes I go back to one of the first graphs and a later graph to see changes. Maybe after 6 sessions or so. I also sometimes do pieces of the TLC again to compare. This is very interesting as many times, what I am trying to remedy is gone after about 20 sessions. I like this the best to be honest. If you are working C3 for example and you do the piece of the TLC for C’s it only takes about 10 minutes to do it and artifact in and compare to the C’s in the initial assessment. If you don’t do the entire assessment, you can’t look at many of the pieces, but you can see the histogram and the theta/beta ratios and left to right reversals. Clinical results are key!!! Since many times they are gradual, you have to be very adamant about reminding the client where they were in the beginning. For instance, I have a boy I have been training for reading issues, attention and executive function issues. Well, his reading has improved significantly and so has his attention but we are still working on the executive function. I have to keep reminding the mom where we started as she tends to forget. Like, “remember when it took him 4 hours to do 20 minutes of homework and now he can do it in 30 minutes?” Hope this helps. Connie From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Margoshes Sent: Monday, April 19, 2010 8:01 AM Subject: assessing how clients are doing in a session Listmates. I haven't even approached BioReview yet, but I'm wondering how you assess (for yourself and the client) how someone is doing throughout a training session and across sessions. I'm just getting seriously into training with BioExplorer, and it seems that I would love to be able to see (and show the client), " OK. during the first training session you did [something] X number of times during the sessions, and then, during session 5, you did [it] X+4 number of times, isn't that great? " I know we're looking for clinical results, but this would be so helpful to me, and, I'm presuming, the client. Is BioReview the way to go here? Or learn to set up a counter? For a specific example, I've been doing some training with Pete's alpha-gamma coherence/synchrony design. You can look at trends to see how someone is doing in real time, but what I'd like is a way to count the number of times in a session the various tones are sounded (the tones correlate with hitting certain values in synchrony, coherence, etc.). Here's a description from the notes about what tones there are: " Coherence in alpha, phase angle in alpha, coherence in gamma and phase angle in gamma each have a tone in a chord that plays the background for the brain's synchrony music. When all four are in range, the full chord sounds and a soft high-pitched crystal sound plays. Two harmonic melody lines play as well (one for alpha amplitude summed between the two channels and a faster one for gamma amplitude summed between the two channels.) There are also binaural beats at 10 Hz. " That's a LOT Of tones going on at the same time. I find when I train myself I just hear a lot of noise and cannot discriminate among them and can't figure out how I'm doing. I wonder what tones could be held more important and how to work out a way to have them counted during the sessions. Is there anything already on the alpha gamma synch.bxd design (or any other design) that does this, but I'm not seeing it? Or how could I set this up? Or is it already implicit in the BioReview aspect of the software? Would it be easier to start with a simpler design, that's just doing one thing, and learn to design a counter or other simple way to collect a little summary data on what's going on? (in Francois Dupont's designs for Thought Technology there seem to be counters sometimes) Thank you. Llz Margoshes Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 The client is getting better and the graphs show " improvement " in the EEG.The client is not changing and the graph shows " improvement " , so you can " show " that the client is getting better... ( The client is not changing and the graph shows no " improvement " The client is getting better, but the graph shows no " improvement " If the graphs show what everyone already knows (options 1 and 3) what's the benefit? If the graph shows the client is improving but it doesn't show up in the real world--are your clients going to be satisfied?Worst of all, if the client is doing better, and the graph says no, the accountant/engineer mom or dad (the only one who really cares about seeing the graphs) will doubt that his/her experience of improvement is correct (numbers don't lie!). Pete-- Van Deusenpvdtlc@...http://www.brain-trainer.comUSA 305 433 3160BR 47 3346 6235 The Learning Curve, Inc. On Mon, Apr 19, 2010 at 2:29 PM, Margoshes <drmargoshes@...> wrote: I would like to know how to translate this into working with meditators to see if something is " really " happening. I can't remember who was talking about this -- a NF practitioner -- who was saying people say " Ooh, I'm meditating " but then when they're hooked up they see what it really feels like to get into that gamma state. That's the thing I'm going for. Maybe I don't need " stats " but a real-time observation of the trend graphs would be enough, rather than session-to-session " progress " reports? I still want to learn how to do this, as Connie, Sharrie, etc. have agreed it can be useful to show parents the graphs.LizOn Mon, Apr 19, 2010 at 12:29 PM, Connie Welsh <conniewelsh@...> wrote: Pete, love the placebo effect comment. I say that to my clients all the time. It may be placebo but just go with it, you didn’t have it beforeJ From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Van Deusen Sent: Monday, April 19, 2010 11:17 AM Subject: Re: assessing how clients are doing in a session Liz, If you will just start getting the alpha going, all this busywork will just melt away. If you don't know it's working, it's not working. If you believe that, after everything else you and the client have tried, suddenly the placebo effect is kicking it and THAT is what's causing the improvement, embrace the placebo effect. You can't PROVE it. And once you experience it, you don't NEED to prove it. Just train. Pete -- Van Deusen pvdtlc@... http://www.brain-trainer.com USA 305 433 3160 BR 47 3346 6235 The Learning Curve, Inc. On Mon, Apr 19, 2010 at 12:13 PM, Connie Welsh <conniewelsh@...> wrote: Liz, you can use BioReview to look at trends which is what it appears you are looking for. Artifact is in the data but most times you can see the trend. So, for instance, you would define a variable like theta amplitude. You can then see the trend over the session. Is it getting smaller or bigger? Now, you have to look at trends at a high level. The graph could go down for awhile, back up and then back down and I would see that as positive. Especially if it ends less than it started. Get out the BioReview and look at some of Pete’s designs if he has some. If not, I can send one to you. Run a report and see what it does. Connie From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Margoshes Sent: Monday, April 19, 2010 10:53 AM Subject: Re: assessing how clients are doing in a session Connie, Thank you for these suggestions. They're helpful. But it's important to me, at least as I begin training clients, to see if the treatment itself is getting " in. " Also, I don't know if I'm being too compulsive, but I'd like to see if the clinical improvements are due to the NF itself since there are so many extra-treatmentlike factors involved (e.g. having to sit still for a certain amount of time during the sessions; spendimg time with a caring professional; seeing that your mother takes your complaints seriously and is trying to help you rather than be judgmental; etc.) Mostly I would like to be able to *show* people that training, not just improvements in task performance (e.g. homework), is actually occurring. At the moment I'm particularly interested in the alpha-gamma because I have a number of available meditators (via someone I know who has a yoga studio) and I am fascinated (for myself as well) with the idea of EEG-assisted meditation (a la Soutar). I would love to be able to demonstrate that you really ARE changing your mindstate -- " See? you made those bells ring more after X sessions of NF! " I think it would be a much more powerful demonstration if I could show that changes in brain function had actually occurred -- not just how you " feel " . I'm very interested in this area which I think could be very helpful for people who are not in " clinical " distress and are not going to come to me for assessments, long treatments, etc. Maybe I don't need to show that " the bell rang 20 times this session. " Maybe there's another way (that has to do with graphs, comparing BioReview data across sessions, etc?) I really don't know anything about this. The thing about compiling statistics is I'm afraid of artifact (like muscle) contaminating the numbers? do you have to artifact the data in order for BioReview to do its job? However I also want to show " data " to parents, etc., when I get to that stage. thank you, Liz On Mon, Apr 19, 2010 at 10:33 AM, Connie Welsh <conniewelsh@...> wrote: Liz, In the beginning, I do Bioreview and look at the data for most sessions just to see if the protocol I am using is working for the client. Sometimes I go back to one of the first graphs and a later graph to see changes. Maybe after 6 sessions or so. I also sometimes do pieces of the TLC again to compare. This is very interesting as many times, what I am trying to remedy is gone after about 20 sessions. I like this the best to be honest. If you are working C3 for example and you do the piece of the TLC for C’s it only takes about 10 minutes to do it and artifact in and compare to the C’s in the initial assessment. If you don’t do the entire assessment, you can’t look at many of the pieces, but you can see the histogram and the theta/beta ratios and left to right reversals. Clinical results are key!!! Since many times they are gradual, you have to be very adamant about reminding the client where they were in the beginning. For instance, I have a boy I have been training for reading issues, attention and executive function issues. Well, his reading has improved significantly and so has his attention but we are still working on the executive function. I have to keep reminding the mom where we started as she tends to forget. Like, “remember when it took him 4 hours to do 20 minutes of homework and now he can do it in 30 minutes?” Hope this helps. Connie From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Margoshes Sent: Monday, April 19, 2010 8:01 AM Subject: assessing how clients are doing in a session Listmates. I haven't even approached BioReview yet, but I'm wondering how you assess (for yourself and the client) how someone is doing throughout a training session and across sessions. I'm just getting seriously into training with BioExplorer, and it seems that I would love to be able to see (and show the client), " OK. during the first training session you did [something] X number of times during the sessions, and then, during session 5, you did [it] X+4 number of times, isn't that great? " I know we're looking for clinical results, but this would be so helpful to me, and, I'm presuming, the client. Is BioReview the way to go here? Or learn to set up a counter? For a specific example, I've been doing some training with Pete's alpha-gamma coherence/synchrony design. You can look at trends to see how someone is doing in real time, but what I'd like is a way to count the number of times in a session the various tones are sounded (the tones correlate with hitting certain values in synchrony, coherence, etc.). Here's a description from the notes about what tones there are: " Coherence in alpha, phase angle in alpha, coherence in gamma and phase angle in gamma each have a tone in a chord that plays the background for the brain's synchrony music. When all four are in range, the full chord sounds and a soft high-pitched crystal sound plays. Two harmonic melody lines play as well (one for alpha amplitude summed between the two channels and a faster one for gamma amplitude summed between the two channels.) There are also binaural beats at 10 Hz. " That's a LOT Of tones going on at the same time. I find when I train myself I just hear a lot of noise and cannot discriminate among them and can't figure out how I'm doing. I wonder what tones could be held more important and how to work out a way to have them counted during the sessions. Is there anything already on the alpha gamma synch.bxd design (or any other design) that does this, but I'm not seeing it? Or how could I set this up? Or is it already implicit in the BioReview aspect of the software? Would it be easier to start with a simpler design, that's just doing one thing, and learn to design a counter or other simple way to collect a little summary data on what's going on? (in Francois Dupont's designs for Thought Technology there seem to be counters sometimes) Thank you. Llz Margoshes Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 Theoreticaly in terms of cogntive behavioral principles, yes. Empericaly in terms of what I have observed with a few clients, yes, Early in training with a few folks, having them see the eeg changes that are associated with them being able to experience the things they want, even before they did had them encouraged until till they did. I believe it's what shaping, successive approximations and good coaching is all about. It's worked for me when I taught tennis, it's worked for me as a psychotherapist and its working for me as a biofeedback trainer. Bruce >If the graph shows the client is improving but it doesn't show up in the real world--are your clients going to be satisfied?< Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 Hi Liz, A client of mine who has been having early morning awakenings and couldn't get back to sleep was just started on alpha/theta protocol at O1. His swingle assessment showed a he had a ratio of .60 T/B there with eyes closed where the expected range would be over 1.4 according to his research. I told the client I wanted to work on him being able to raise that ratio by doing some alpha/theta work with him. The graphs of the various ratios showed a beta preponderence unti around 18 minutes into the session at which point theta rose above both alpha and beta many times durring the remaining 10 minutes until he completed the session. He asked how he did and I asked what he noticed. He said he felt deeply relaxed and almost asleep. I showed him the session graphs and explained that he not only accomplished what I was hoping for in terms of experiencing deep relaxation but also in terms of stiring a bit at times and returning to the deep state. He agreed and was very curious about the graphs. When I explained them more he seemed even more encouraged. Basicaly what I further explained is that the ability to lower that ratio back there and to re lower it when it rises as he did durring the session could very well transfer into him doing this when he goes to sleep and when he stirs a bit from sleep. In other words that flexability and resilency in producing those self soothing brain rythms back there make sleep innitiation and maitenence more likely. I'm missing alot in this translation and this may only be loosely connected to what you have been asking but it's what came to mind. Bruce > >>> > >>> > >>> > >>> Liz, > >>> > >>> > >>> > >>> In the beginning, I do Bioreview and look at the data for most sessions > >>> just to see if the protocol I am using is working for the client. > >>> > >>> > >>> > >>> Sometimes I go back to one of the first graphs and a later graph to see > >>> changes. Maybe after 6 sessions or so. > >>> > >>> > >>> > >>> I also sometimes do pieces of the TLC again to compare. This is very > >>> interesting as many times, what I am trying to remedy is gone after about > >>> 20 sessions. I like this the best to be honest. If you are working C3 for > >>> example and you do the piece of the TLC for C's it only takes about 10 > >>> minutes to do it and artifact in and compare to the C's in the initial > >>> assessment. If you don't do the entire assessment, you can't look at many > >>> of the pieces, but you can see the histogram and the theta/beta ratios and > >>> left to right reversals. > >>> > >>> > >>> > >>> Clinical results are key!!! Since many times they are gradual, you have > >>> to be very adamant about reminding the client where they were in the > >>> beginning. For instance, I have a boy I have been training for reading > >>> issues, attention and executive function issues. Well, his reading has > >>> improved significantly and so has his attention but we are still working on > >>> the executive function. I have to keep reminding the mom where we started > >>> as she tends to forget. Like, " remember when it took him 4 hours to do 20 > >>> minutes of homework and now he can do it in 30 minutes? " > >>> > >>> > >>> > >>> Hope this helps. Connie > >>> > >>> > >>> > >>> *From:* [mailto: > >>> ] *On Behalf Of * Margoshes > >>> *Sent:* Monday, April 19, 2010 8:01 AM > >>> *To:* > >>> > >>> > >>> *Subject:* assessing how clients are doing in a session > >>> > >>> > >>> > >>> > >>> > >>> Listmates. > >>> > >>> > >>> > >>> I haven't even approached BioReview yet, but I'm wondering how you assess > >>> (for yourself and the client) how someone is doing throughout a training > >>> session and across sessions. I'm just getting seriously into training with > >>> BioExplorer, and it seems that I would love to be able to see (and show the > >>> client), " OK. during the first training session > >>> you did [something] X number of times during the sessions, and then, > >>> during session 5, you did [it] X+4 number of times, isn't that great? " > >>> > >>> I know we're looking for clinical results, but this would be so helpful > >>> to me, and, I'm presuming, the client. Is BioReview the way to go here? Or > >>> learn to set up a counter? > >>> > >>> For a specific example, I've been doing some training with Pete's > >>> alpha-gamma coherence/synchrony design. You can look at trends to see how > >>> someone is doing in real time, but what I'd like is a way to count the > >>> number of times in a session the various tones are sounded (the tones > >>> correlate with hitting certain values in synchrony, coherence, etc.). Here's > >>> a description from the notes about what tones there are: > >>> > >>> " Coherence in alpha, phase angle in alpha, coherence in gamma and phase > >>> angle in gamma each have a tone in a chord that plays the background for the > >>> brain's synchrony music. When all four are in range, the full chord sounds > >>> and a soft high-pitched crystal sound plays. Two harmonic melody lines play > >>> as well (one for alpha amplitude summed between the two channels and a > >>> faster one for gamma amplitude summed between the two channels.) There are > >>> also binaural beats at 10 Hz. " > >>> > >>> That's a LOT Of tones going on at the same time. I find when I train > >>> myself I just hear a lot of noise and cannot discriminate among them and > >>> can't figure out how I'm doing. > >>> > >>> I wonder what tones could be held more important and how to work out a > >>> way to have them counted during the sessions. > >>> > >>> Is there anything already on the alpha gamma synch.bxd design (or any > >>> other design) that does this, but I'm not seeing it? Or how could I set this > >>> up? Or is it already implicit in the BioReview aspect of the software? Would > >>> it be easier to start with a simpler design, that's just doing one thing, > >>> and learn to design a counter or other simple way to collect a little > >>> summary data on what's going on? > >>> > >>> (in Francois Dupont's designs for Thought Technology there seem to be > >>> counters sometimes) > >>> > >>> Thank you. > >>> > >>> Llz Margoshes > >>> > >>> > >>> > >>> > >>> > >>> > >>> > >>> > >> > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 Oh, I forgot to mention that his T/B ratio rose many times to the ratio that swingle finds is associated with better sleep and self soothing. It got as high as 1.7 and when it dropped back down to as low as .35 some times he quickly re entered a state that raised it right back up. I showed him this with the graphs and related the importance of this for his daily functional concerns. Bruce > > >>> > > >>> > > >>> > > >>> Liz, > > >>> > > >>> > > >>> > > >>> In the beginning, I do Bioreview and look at the data for most sessions > > >>> just to see if the protocol I am using is working for the client. > > >>> > > >>> > > >>> > > >>> Sometimes I go back to one of the first graphs and a later graph to see > > >>> changes. Maybe after 6 sessions or so. > > >>> > > >>> > > >>> > > >>> I also sometimes do pieces of the TLC again to compare. This is very > > >>> interesting as many times, what I am trying to remedy is gone after about > > >>> 20 sessions. I like this the best to be honest. If you are working C3 for > > >>> example and you do the piece of the TLC for C's it only takes about 10 > > >>> minutes to do it and artifact in and compare to the C's in the initial > > >>> assessment. If you don't do the entire assessment, you can't look at many > > >>> of the pieces, but you can see the histogram and the theta/beta ratios and > > >>> left to right reversals. > > >>> > > >>> > > >>> > > >>> Clinical results are key!!! Since many times they are gradual, you have > > >>> to be very adamant about reminding the client where they were in the > > >>> beginning. For instance, I have a boy I have been training for reading > > >>> issues, attention and executive function issues. Well, his reading has > > >>> improved significantly and so has his attention but we are still working on > > >>> the executive function. I have to keep reminding the mom where we started > > >>> as she tends to forget. Like, " remember when it took him 4 hours to do 20 > > >>> minutes of homework and now he can do it in 30 minutes? " > > >>> > > >>> > > >>> > > >>> Hope this helps. Connie > > >>> > > >>> > > >>> > > >>> *From:* [mailto: > > >>> ] *On Behalf Of * Margoshes > > >>> *Sent:* Monday, April 19, 2010 8:01 AM > > >>> *To:* > > >>> > > >>> > > >>> *Subject:* assessing how clients are doing in a session > > >>> > > >>> > > >>> > > >>> > > >>> > > >>> Listmates. > > >>> > > >>> > > >>> > > >>> I haven't even approached BioReview yet, but I'm wondering how you assess > > >>> (for yourself and the client) how someone is doing throughout a training > > >>> session and across sessions. I'm just getting seriously into training with > > >>> BioExplorer, and it seems that I would love to be able to see (and show the > > >>> client), " OK. during the first training session > > >>> you did [something] X number of times during the sessions, and then, > > >>> during session 5, you did [it] X+4 number of times, isn't that great? " > > >>> > > >>> I know we're looking for clinical results, but this would be so helpful > > >>> to me, and, I'm presuming, the client. Is BioReview the way to go here? Or > > >>> learn to set up a counter? > > >>> > > >>> For a specific example, I've been doing some training with Pete's > > >>> alpha-gamma coherence/synchrony design. You can look at trends to see how > > >>> someone is doing in real time, but what I'd like is a way to count the > > >>> number of times in a session the various tones are sounded (the tones > > >>> correlate with hitting certain values in synchrony, coherence, etc.). Here's > > >>> a description from the notes about what tones there are: > > >>> > > >>> " Coherence in alpha, phase angle in alpha, coherence in gamma and phase > > >>> angle in gamma each have a tone in a chord that plays the background for the > > >>> brain's synchrony music. When all four are in range, the full chord sounds > > >>> and a soft high-pitched crystal sound plays. Two harmonic melody lines play > > >>> as well (one for alpha amplitude summed between the two channels and a > > >>> faster one for gamma amplitude summed between the two channels.) There are > > >>> also binaural beats at 10 Hz. " > > >>> > > >>> That's a LOT Of tones going on at the same time. I find when I train > > >>> myself I just hear a lot of noise and cannot discriminate among them and > > >>> can't figure out how I'm doing. > > >>> > > >>> I wonder what tones could be held more important and how to work out a > > >>> way to have them counted during the sessions. > > >>> > > >>> Is there anything already on the alpha gamma synch.bxd design (or any > > >>> other design) that does this, but I'm not seeing it? Or how could I set this > > >>> up? Or is it already implicit in the BioReview aspect of the software? Would > > >>> it be easier to start with a simpler design, that's just doing one thing, > > >>> and learn to design a counter or other simple way to collect a little > > >>> summary data on what's going on? > > >>> > > >>> (in Francois Dupont's designs for Thought Technology there seem to be > > >>> counters sometimes) > > >>> > > >>> Thank you. > > >>> > > >>> Llz Margoshes > > >>> > > >>> > > >>> > > >>> > > >>> > > >>> > > >>> > > >>> > > >> > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 Liz~If I get asked "what does that (graph, line, etc..) mean?" I ask them back, "tell me how you are feeling?" It's that simple, and it really doesn't matter what it means if they feel good. It's also helpful over time to help them notice how things are changing in their life. I had a woman come in thinking she was regressing and said "oh I had a rough weekend, more stressful than it has been in a while" I asked what she had done over the weekend and she said she threw her 8 yr old a b-day party and it really stressed her out. I asked her to tell me how she would she have dealt with the B-day party before we started sessions and she said "Oh! I NEVER would have attempted to throw a b-day party for my son, this was his first, it wasn't something i was capable of doing before". So, what was key here is she felt so much better she decided to throw her son a party, then she organized it, and had it and everyone had fun and she survived. That shows she is making big changes, and, a graph is not going to show her that more than the changes she is making in her life. Hope this helps a little.~"I have learned from experience that the greater part of our happiness or misery depends on our dispositions, and not on our circumstances." - Martha Washington assessing how clients are doing in a session Listmates. I haven't even approached BioReview yet, but I'm wondering how you assess (for yourself and the client) how someone is doing throughout a training session and across sessions. I'm just getting seriously into training with BioExplorer, and it seems that I would love to be able to see (and show the client), "OK. during the first training session you did [something] X number of times during the sessions, and then, during session 5, you did [it] X+4 number of times, isn't that great?" I know we're looking for clinical results, but this would be so helpful to me, and, I'm presuming, the client. Is BioReview the way to go here? Or learn to set up a counter? For a specific example, I've been doing some training with Pete's alpha-gamma coherence/synchrony design. You can look at trends to see how someone is doing in real time, but what I'd like is a way to count the number of times in a session the various tones are sounded (the tones correlate with hitting certain values in synchrony, coherence, etc.). Here's a description from the notes about what tones there are: "Coherence in alpha, phase angle in alpha, coherence in gamma and phase angle in gamma each have a tone in a chord that plays the background for the brain's synchrony music. When all four are in range, the full chord sounds and a soft high-pitched crystal sound plays. Two harmonic melody lines play as well (one for alpha amplitude summed between the two channels and a faster one for gamma amplitude summed between the two channels.) There are also binaural beats at 10 Hz." That's a LOT Of tones going on at the same time. I find when I train myself I just hear a lot of noise and cannot discriminate among them and can't figure out how I'm doing. I wonder what tones could be held more important and how to work out a way to have them counted during the sessions. Is there anything already on the alpha gamma synch.bxd design (or any other design) that does this, but I'm not seeing it? Or how could I set this up? Or is it already implicit in the BioReview aspect of the software? Would it be easier to start with a simpler design, that's just doing one thing, and learn to design a counter or other simple way to collect a little summary data on what's going on? (in Francois Dupont's designs for Thought Technology there seem to be counters sometimes) Thank you. Llz Margoshes Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 Liz~If I get asked "what does that (graph, line, etc..) mean?" I ask them back, "tell me how you are feeling?" It's that simple, and it really doesn't matter what it means if they feel good. It's also helpful over time to help them notice how things are changing in their life. I had a woman come in thinking she was regressing and said "oh I had a rough weekend, more stressful than it has been in a while" I asked what she had done over the weekend and she said she threw her 8 yr old a b-day party and it really stressed her out. I asked her to tell me how she would she have dealt with the B-day party before we started sessions and she said "Oh! I NEVER would have attempted to throw a b-day party for my son, this was his first, it wasn't something i was capable of doing before". So, what was key here is she felt so much better she decided to throw her son a party, then she organized it, and had it and everyone had fun and she survived. That shows she is making big changes, and, a graph is not going to show her that more than the changes she is making in her life. Hope this helps a little.~"I have learned from experience that the greater part of our happiness or misery depends on our dispositions, and not on our circumstances." - Martha Washington assessing how clients are doing in a session Listmates. I haven't even approached BioReview yet, but I'm wondering how you assess (for yourself and the client) how someone is doing throughout a training session and across sessions. I'm just getting seriously into training with BioExplorer, and it seems that I would love to be able to see (and show the client), "OK. during the first training session you did [something] X number of times during the sessions, and then, during session 5, you did [it] X+4 number of times, isn't that great?" I know we're looking for clinical results, but this would be so helpful to me, and, I'm presuming, the client. Is BioReview the way to go here? Or learn to set up a counter? For a specific example, I've been doing some training with Pete's alpha-gamma coherence/synchrony design. You can look at trends to see how someone is doing in real time, but what I'd like is a way to count the number of times in a session the various tones are sounded (the tones correlate with hitting certain values in synchrony, coherence, etc.). Here's a description from the notes about what tones there are: "Coherence in alpha, phase angle in alpha, coherence in gamma and phase angle in gamma each have a tone in a chord that plays the background for the brain's synchrony music. When all four are in range, the full chord sounds and a soft high-pitched crystal sound plays. Two harmonic melody lines play as well (one for alpha amplitude summed between the two channels and a faster one for gamma amplitude summed between the two channels.) There are also binaural beats at 10 Hz." That's a LOT Of tones going on at the same time. I find when I train myself I just hear a lot of noise and cannot discriminate among them and can't figure out how I'm doing. I wonder what tones could be held more important and how to work out a way to have them counted during the sessions. Is there anything already on the alpha gamma synch.bxd design (or any other design) that does this, but I'm not seeing it? Or how could I set this up? Or is it already implicit in the BioReview aspect of the software? Would it be easier to start with a simpler design, that's just doing one thing, and learn to design a counter or other simple way to collect a little summary data on what's going on? (in Francois Dupont's designs for Thought Technology there seem to be counters sometimes) Thank you. Llz Margoshes Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.