Guest guest Posted April 21, 2010 Report Posted April 21, 2010 OK- So then get SUBJECTIVE numbers. Gather ye data while ye may my friends. Whether you use them or not is entirely dependant upon whether you gathered them. I prefer the option to NOT GRAPH numbers that exist than to wish that I could. We are in an exact sciences practice. The numbers are inherent in the process. Taking the time to get a client to QUANTIFY his/her EXPERIENCE in session is hugely important to Petes examples 1,2,3 and 4. Getting the data from the client's brain is as simple as telling the software WHAT to gather. IMO, not taking the simple step of telling the software what numbers to automatically export is akin to putting on the sensors and paste, but not bothering to clean the site or take hair out of the way. It's too simple not to do. Now for the high-ground: With the field's NEED for greater validation. The fact that many professionals count on referrals and want to build relationships with healthcare pros, it's interesting from a RESEARCH as well as a CLINICAL P.O.V. to be able to build a data base and to report on changes. I use two simple number scale checklists in each session to gather and graph SUBJECTIVE changes over time. I use an Evolution Graph to get and to give perspective to myself when making protocol change decisions and to my clients in regards to their real and observed changes. Psycho (Subjective) Physiology (Objective) is the basis of our SCIENCE. Been a long time since I've written here. This is clearly a subject that gets my voice. Empower. Employ, and ENJOY! Machado Van Deusen From: karenduncan@...Date: Mon, 19 Apr 2010 22:54:18 +0000Subject: Re: assessing how clients are doing in a session Liz~If I get asked "what does that (graph, line, etc..) mean?" I ask them back, "tell me how you are feeling?" It's that simple, and it really doesn't matter what it means if they feel good. It's also helpful over time to help them notice how things are changing in their life. I had a woman come in thinking she was regressing and said "oh I had a rough weekend, more stressful than it has been in a while" I asked what she had done over the weekend and she said she threw her 8 yr old a b-day party and it really stressed her out. I asked her to tell me how she would she have dealt with the B-day party before we started sessions and she said "Oh! I NEVER would have attempted to throw a b-day party for my son, this was his first, it wasn't something i was capable of doing before". So, what was key here is she felt so much better she decided to throw her son a party, then she organized it, and had it and everyone had fun and she survived. That shows she is making big changes, and, a graph is not going to show her that more than the changes she is making in her life. Hope this helps a little.~ "I have learned from experience that the greater part of our happiness or misery depends on our dispositions, and not on our circumstances." - Martha Washington assessing how clients are doing in a session Listmates. I haven't even approached BioReview yet, but I'm wondering how you assess (for yourself and the client) how someone is doing throughout a training session and across sessions. I'm just getting seriously into training with BioExplorer, and it seems that I would love to be able to see (and show the client), "OK. during the first training sessionyou did [something] X number of times during the sessions, and then, during session 5, you did [it] X+4 number of times, isn't that great?" I know we're looking for clinical results, but this would be so helpful to me, and, I'm presuming, the client. Is BioReview the way to go here? Or learn to set up a counter?For a specific example, I've been doing some training with Pete's alpha-gamma coherence/synchrony design. You can look at trends to see how someone is doing in real time, but what I'd like is a way to count the number of times in a session the various tones are sounded (the tones correlate with hitting certain values in synchrony, coherence, etc.). Here's a description from the notes about what tones there are:"Coherence in alpha, phase angle in alpha, coherence in gamma and phase angle in gamma each have a tone in a chord that plays the background for the brain's synchrony music. When all four are in range, the full chord sounds and a soft high-pitched crystal sound plays. Two harmonic melody lines play as well (one for alpha amplitude summed between the two channels and a faster one for gamma amplitude summed between the two channels.) There are also binaural beats at 10 Hz." That's a LOT Of tones going on at the same time. I find when I train myself I just hear a lot of noise and cannot discriminate among them and can't figure out how I'm doing.I wonder what tones could be held more important and how to work out a way to have them counted during the sessions.Is there anything already on the alpha gamma synch.bxd design (or any other design) that does this, but I'm not seeing it? Or how could I set this up? Or is it already implicit in the BioReview aspect of the software? Would it be easier to start with a simpler design, that's just doing one thing, and learn to design a counter or other simple way to collect a little summary data on what's going on? (in Francois Dupont's designs for Thought Technology there seem to be counters sometimes)Thank you.Llz Margoshes Hotmail: Trusted email with powerful SPAM protection. Sign up now. Quote
Guest guest Posted April 21, 2010 Report Posted April 21, 2010 OK- So then get SUBJECTIVE numbers. Gather ye data while ye may my friends. Whether you use them or not is entirely dependant upon whether you gathered them. I prefer the option to NOT GRAPH numbers that exist than to wish that I could. We are in an exact sciences practice. The numbers are inherent in the process. Taking the time to get a client to QUANTIFY his/her EXPERIENCE in session is hugely important to Petes examples 1,2,3 and 4. Getting the data from the client's brain is as simple as telling the software WHAT to gather. IMO, not taking the simple step of telling the software what numbers to automatically export is akin to putting on the sensors and paste, but not bothering to clean the site or take hair out of the way. It's too simple not to do. Now for the high-ground: With the field's NEED for greater validation. The fact that many professionals count on referrals and want to build relationships with healthcare pros, it's interesting from a RESEARCH as well as a CLINICAL P.O.V. to be able to build a data base and to report on changes. I use two simple number scale checklists in each session to gather and graph SUBJECTIVE changes over time. I use an Evolution Graph to get and to give perspective to myself when making protocol change decisions and to my clients in regards to their real and observed changes. Psycho (Subjective) Physiology (Objective) is the basis of our SCIENCE. Been a long time since I've written here. This is clearly a subject that gets my voice. Empower. Employ, and ENJOY! Machado Van Deusen From: karenduncan@...Date: Mon, 19 Apr 2010 22:54:18 +0000Subject: Re: assessing how clients are doing in a session Liz~If I get asked "what does that (graph, line, etc..) mean?" I ask them back, "tell me how you are feeling?" It's that simple, and it really doesn't matter what it means if they feel good. It's also helpful over time to help them notice how things are changing in their life. I had a woman come in thinking she was regressing and said "oh I had a rough weekend, more stressful than it has been in a while" I asked what she had done over the weekend and she said she threw her 8 yr old a b-day party and it really stressed her out. I asked her to tell me how she would she have dealt with the B-day party before we started sessions and she said "Oh! I NEVER would have attempted to throw a b-day party for my son, this was his first, it wasn't something i was capable of doing before". So, what was key here is she felt so much better she decided to throw her son a party, then she organized it, and had it and everyone had fun and she survived. That shows she is making big changes, and, a graph is not going to show her that more than the changes she is making in her life. Hope this helps a little.~ "I have learned from experience that the greater part of our happiness or misery depends on our dispositions, and not on our circumstances." - Martha Washington assessing how clients are doing in a session Listmates. I haven't even approached BioReview yet, but I'm wondering how you assess (for yourself and the client) how someone is doing throughout a training session and across sessions. I'm just getting seriously into training with BioExplorer, and it seems that I would love to be able to see (and show the client), "OK. during the first training sessionyou did [something] X number of times during the sessions, and then, during session 5, you did [it] X+4 number of times, isn't that great?" I know we're looking for clinical results, but this would be so helpful to me, and, I'm presuming, the client. Is BioReview the way to go here? Or learn to set up a counter?For a specific example, I've been doing some training with Pete's alpha-gamma coherence/synchrony design. You can look at trends to see how someone is doing in real time, but what I'd like is a way to count the number of times in a session the various tones are sounded (the tones correlate with hitting certain values in synchrony, coherence, etc.). Here's a description from the notes about what tones there are:"Coherence in alpha, phase angle in alpha, coherence in gamma and phase angle in gamma each have a tone in a chord that plays the background for the brain's synchrony music. When all four are in range, the full chord sounds and a soft high-pitched crystal sound plays. Two harmonic melody lines play as well (one for alpha amplitude summed between the two channels and a faster one for gamma amplitude summed between the two channels.) There are also binaural beats at 10 Hz." That's a LOT Of tones going on at the same time. I find when I train myself I just hear a lot of noise and cannot discriminate among them and can't figure out how I'm doing.I wonder what tones could be held more important and how to work out a way to have them counted during the sessions.Is there anything already on the alpha gamma synch.bxd design (or any other design) that does this, but I'm not seeing it? Or how could I set this up? Or is it already implicit in the BioReview aspect of the software? Would it be easier to start with a simpler design, that's just doing one thing, and learn to design a counter or other simple way to collect a little summary data on what's going on? (in Francois Dupont's designs for Thought Technology there seem to be counters sometimes)Thank you.Llz Margoshes Hotmail: Trusted email with powerful SPAM protection. Sign up now. Quote
Guest guest Posted April 21, 2010 Report Posted April 21, 2010 ,Thank you, and I will use that approach too. But specifically re: meditation for a moment: neurofeedback is being used to " confirm or deny " that certain EEG states are being attained. I would like to have the " objective " brain correlative, as a number of practitioners are doing these days. I think this is interesting and probably not at all difficult to do. I just lack the technological know-how at this moment, and would like to attain it. LizOn Mon, Apr 19, 2010 at 6:54 PM, Duncan <karenduncan@...> wrote: Liz~If I get asked " what does that (graph, line, etc..) mean? " I ask them back, " tell me how you are feeling? " It's that simple, and it really doesn't matter what it means if they feel good. It's also helpful over time to help them notice how things are changing in their life. I had a woman come in thinking she was regressing and said " oh I had a rough weekend, more stressful than it has been in a while " I asked what she had done over the weekend and she said she threw her 8 yr old a b-day party and it really stressed her out. I asked her to tell me how she would she have dealt with the B-day party before we started sessions and she said " Oh! I NEVER would have attempted to throw a b-day party for my son, this was his first, it wasn't something i was capable of doing before " . So, what was key here is she felt so much better she decided to throw her son a party, then she organized it, and had it and everyone had fun and she survived. That shows she is making big changes, and, a graph is not going to show her that more than the changes she is making in her life. Hope this helps a little. ~ " I have learned from experience that the greater part of our happiness or misery depends on our dispositions, and not on our circumstances. " - Martha Washington assessing how clients are doing in a session Listmates. I haven't even approached BioReview yet, but I'm wondering how you assess (for yourself and the client) how someone is doing throughout a training session and across sessions. I'm just getting seriously into training with BioExplorer, and it seems that I would love to be able to see (and show the client), " OK. during the first training session you did [something] X number of times during the sessions, and then, during session 5, you did [it] X+4 number of times, isn't that great? " I know we're looking for clinical results, but this would be so helpful to me, and, I'm presuming, the client. Is BioReview the way to go here? Or learn to set up a counter? For a specific example, I've been doing some training with Pete's alpha-gamma coherence/synchrony design. You can look at trends to see how someone is doing in real time, but what I'd like is a way to count the number of times in a session the various tones are sounded (the tones correlate with hitting certain values in synchrony, coherence, etc.). Here's a description from the notes about what tones there are: " Coherence in alpha, phase angle in alpha, coherence in gamma and phase angle in gamma each have a tone in a chord that plays the background for the brain's synchrony music. When all four are in range, the full chord sounds and a soft high-pitched crystal sound plays. Two harmonic melody lines play as well (one for alpha amplitude summed between the two channels and a faster one for gamma amplitude summed between the two channels.) There are also binaural beats at 10 Hz. " That's a LOT Of tones going on at the same time. I find when I train myself I just hear a lot of noise and cannot discriminate among them and can't figure out how I'm doing. I wonder what tones could be held more important and how to work out a way to have them counted during the sessions. Is there anything already on the alpha gamma synch.bxd design (or any other design) that does this, but I'm not seeing it? Or how could I set this up? Or is it already implicit in the BioReview aspect of the software? Would it be easier to start with a simpler design, that's just doing one thing, and learn to design a counter or other simple way to collect a little summary data on what's going on? (in Francois Dupont's designs for Thought Technology there seem to be counters sometimes) Thank you. Llz Margoshes Quote
Guest guest Posted April 21, 2010 Report Posted April 21, 2010 Liz, To set yourself up to collect data, 1) list what you want to track/gather data on. 2) Make sure you have objects in the signal diagram to do that. 3) Use Export Settings to name the signals to export. This shows how: Then it will be there when you (husband) are ready. Make your own graph: Rah From: drmargoshes@...Date: Wed, 21 Apr 2010 06:54:57 -0400Subject: Re: assessing how clients are doing in a session ,Thank you, and I will use that approach too. But specifically re: meditation for a moment: neurofeedback is being used to "confirm or deny" that certain EEG states are being attained. I would like to have the "objective" brain correlative, as a number of practitioners are doing these days. I think this is interesting and probably not at all difficult to do. I just lack the technological know-how at this moment, and would like to attain it. Liz The New Busy is not the too busy. Combine all your e-mail accounts with Hotmail. Get busy. Quote
Guest guest Posted April 21, 2010 Report Posted April 21, 2010 Thank you. Much to try. I also realized that I have 's tutorial and have not explored the part on BioReview yet (because I thought it was just tracking one session at a time (which I guess it is) but he's saying he also tells us in there how to graph data to compare sessions to each other. Plus there is Steve Reich (is that his name, or am I thinking of the composer?)'s bar graph, per Sharrie Hanley's post. MUCH to tackle now!Thanks again.LizOn Wed, Apr 21, 2010 at 7:07 AM, Rah Wheelihan <wheelihan82@...> wrote: Liz, To set yourself up to collect data, 1) list what you want to track/gather data on. 2) Make sure you have objects in the signal diagram to do that. 3) Use Export Settings to name the signals to export. This shows how: Then it will be there when you (husband) are ready. Make your own graph: Rah From: drmargoshes@...Date: Wed, 21 Apr 2010 06:54:57 -0400 Subject: Re: assessing how clients are doing in a session ,Thank you, and I will use that approach too. But specifically re: meditation for a moment: neurofeedback is being used to " confirm or deny " that certain EEG states are being attained. I would like to have the " objective " brain correlative, as a number of practitioners are doing these days. I think this is interesting and probably not at all difficult to do. I just lack the technological know-how at this moment, and would like to attain it. Liz The New Busy is not the too busy. Combine all your e-mail accounts with Hotmail. Get busy. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.