Guest guest Posted August 12, 2010 Report Posted August 12, 2010 I think we all can agree that the general concepts of exercise density and GPP are a good foundation for general fitness and health. The problem comes when they use a one size fits all approach to everyone and every need. A biomechanically challenged grandma with serious limitations of the hips and a 22 year old UFC fighter can't do the same workout even if it's scaled down for the granny. Crossfit works great unless you have a biomechanics break down or weak link, than it can make the problem worse not better. I train college level athletes very similar to CF, but they also have been assessed and had serious mechanical impairments corrected and have the proper motor skills to do this work. From a motor learning stand point I love that CF gives people many motor skill problems to solve, which always help motor development Garrison Mesa, AZ On Aug 12, 2010, at 9:50 AM, brockleggins@... wrote: > Haha, I will admit that is a bit of a funny story, . " Yea, pay us the fee then help us out. " But I will say I agree with pretty much the entire post. I have no problem with the concepts of CrossFit, particularly for the general population simply looking to get in better shape. And the complexity of movements is certainly something I think a lot of people's training could benefit from, if progressed properly. However, as has been stated, proper care and caution is not always taken to make sure these progressions are followed (a problem not limited to CrossFit). > > Brock Leggins > Norwalk, IA > Ultimateathletedevelopment.com > Sent from my U.S. Cellular BlackBerry® smartphone > > Re: Re: 2 Crossfitters 1 Chalk Bucket > > Crossfit has popularized the ideas of training density and General Physical Preparation (GPP) among a large group of people who otherwise probably wouldn't have heard of either concept. > > And that is a great thing. Training density is an important variable and GPP is also important. > > So, from that perspective I think it is good. I have steered high school wrestlers to the site for some workout ideas. > > The bad thing is the concept of 'one size fits all', IMO. Increasing training density should be done in a systematic way and arbitrarily 'fixing' the intensity level isn't a good idea. Poor form and injuries result. Crossfit central also makes some ludicrous claims - such as being the best program for athletes. For example, while it is adequate for most high school wrestlers, varsity and senior wrestlers need something more strenuous and specific to their level of adaptation. > > However, doing heavy complex movements - focusing on power and olympic lifts - teaching body control and mechanics through gymnastics and manipulating density as a training variable are all good things. The problems are: > > 1. one size doesn't fit all - and as points out doesn't necessarily fit the training facility either > > 2. technique is very important for safety and isn't emphasized enough > > 3. personally, I have some issues with their process for developing affiliates and charging members. > > My own personal experience was going down to the local Crossfit because I love the idea of a garage type of gym, it is close to my home and it had platforms and training bumpers. I have years of training experience in multiple disciplines, including: > > 1. Sports specific experience - quite extensive in powerlifting, baseball, hockey, long-distance running and rugby > > 2. Coaching acreditization in gymnastics, olympic weightlifting, Wado-kai karate, baseball, fastball, rugby, hockey and ringette > > 3. Experience training wrestlers up to (and including) olympic level > > 4. Recent degree in kinesiology > > So I talk to the manager there, who was familiar with me having seen me train in several gyms and being a student at the same time I was. Since I still compete in olympic lifting and until recently in powerlifting when I train in many people notice. I was also fairly well-known as a student - I challenged teachers quite often based on my own reading and experience. Despite that I had to go through their quickstart (expensive) and could only train at certain times doing their workout of the day. I couldn't come into the gym on my own. What was really funny was after telling me all that the guy asked if I would help him with his technique on the olympic lifts (he competes in the Crossfit games). > > Needless to say - I didn't join. Quote
Guest guest Posted August 12, 2010 Report Posted August 12, 2010 I think Brock brings up an important point I glossed over - " a problem not limited to Crossfit " . The issue of technique, individualization, etc. is not limited to Crossfit, nor can all affiliates be painted with the same brush. Like every other 'type' of gym - including the 'physical culture' style I like, there are good and bad gyms. I'm sure there are excellent Crossfit gyms - I didn't mean to imply otherwise. Hobman Saskatoon, Canada On 2010-08-12, at 10:50 AM, brockleggins@... wrote: > Haha, I will admit that is a bit of a funny story, . " Yea, pay us the fee then help us out. " But I will say I agree with pretty much the entire post. I have no problem with the concepts of CrossFit, particularly for the general population simply looking to get in better shape. And the complexity of movements is certainly something I think a lot of people's training could benefit from, if progressed properly. However, as has been stated, proper care and caution is not always taken to make sure these progressions are followed (a problem not limited to CrossFit). > > Brock Leggins > Norwalk, IA > Ultimateathletedevelopment.com > Sent from my U.S. Cellular BlackBerry® smartphone > > Re: Re: 2 Crossfitters 1 Chalk Bucket > > Crossfit has popularized the ideas of training density and General Physical Preparation (GPP) among a large group of people who otherwise probably wouldn't have heard of either concept. > > And that is a great thing. Training density is an important variable and GPP is also important. > > So, from that perspective I think it is good. I have steered high school wrestlers to the site for some workout ideas. > > The bad thing is the concept of 'one size fits all', IMO. Increasing training density should be done in a systematic way and arbitrarily 'fixing' the intensity level isn't a good idea. Poor form and injuries result. Crossfit central also makes some ludicrous claims - such as being the best program for athletes. For example, while it is adequate for most high school wrestlers, varsity and senior wrestlers need something more strenuous and specific to their level of adaptation. > > However, doing heavy complex movements - focusing on power and olympic lifts - teaching body control and mechanics through gymnastics and manipulating density as a training variable are all good things. The problems are: > > 1. one size doesn't fit all - and as points out doesn't necessarily fit the training facility either > > 2. technique is very important for safety and isn't emphasized enough > > 3. personally, I have some issues with their process for developing affiliates and charging members. > > My own personal experience was going down to the local Crossfit because I love the idea of a garage type of gym, it is close to my home and it had platforms and training bumpers. I have years of training experience in multiple disciplines, including: > > 1. Sports specific experience - quite extensive in powerlifting, baseball, hockey, long-distance running and rugby > > 2. Coaching acreditization in gymnastics, olympic weightlifting, Wado-kai karate, baseball, fastball, rugby, hockey and ringette > > 3. Experience training wrestlers up to (and including) olympic level > > 4. Recent degree in kinesiology > > So I talk to the manager there, who was familiar with me having seen me train in several gyms and being a student at the same time I was. Since I still compete in olympic lifting and until recently in powerlifting when I train in many people notice. I was also fairly well-known as a student - I challenged teachers quite often based on my own reading and experience. Despite that I had to go through their quickstart (expensive) and could only train at certain times doing their workout of the day. I couldn't come into the gym on my own. What was really funny was after telling me all that the guy asked if I would help him with his technique on the olympic lifts (he competes in the Crossfit games). > > Needless to say - I didn't join. > > Hobman > Saskatoon, Canada > > > On 2010-08-11, at 12:46 PM, casey gallagher wrote: > >> I would beg to differ that her form wasn't all that bad. Her weight transfers forward onto her toes and her knees move too varus. But yes, a 15 rep bodyweight over head squat is rather impressive. However 15 reps while sacrificing safety and technique is playing with fire. >> >> Casey Gallagher CSCS >> Snohomish, WA USA >> >> Re: 2 Crossfitters 1 Chalk Bucket >> >> I know little about Crossfit and have heard it disparaged by Mike Boyle and Gray Cook. However, one day I was looking for a link to show someone what an overhead squat looked like. I found this link. >> >> qI-WY> >> >> Any " program " that can get someone to do what they did can't be all bad. Even the form, at least until the final rep or 2 in a few cases looks pretty decent, at least to my unskilled eyes. >> >> Bob Dannegger >> Raleigh, NC >> >> >>>> >>>> With all due respect, name the athletes at the national and international level using cross fit. >>>> >>>> >>>> What sports are they competing, and how do they place? >>>> >>>> >>>> More importantly, are they receiving any financial support or endorsements from those who sell cross fit? >>>> >>>> >>>> If you did research, you likely were tapped into the mother ship, and not what the rest of us are seeing generally out here in gyms and suffering with the practitioners. the you tube videos were right on, generally these characters are what is out there. >>>> >>>> >>>> With all due respect to the few cross fit enthusiasts who have good form, the majority remind me of the dumbed down antics of " body pump " (likely some sort of registered or trade mark) for the women...sigh. >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> Quote
Guest guest Posted August 13, 2010 Report Posted August 13, 2010 This is in response to the thread more so than to any one paticular person... " The mechanical view of the body contains also anatomical and functional ideals—a form of utopian view of the body. The utopian view gives rise to the expectation that, like machines or computers, the body has to work in perfect precision/synchrony. The question that arises is does it really matter if these PSB factors or minor control changes exist and would they cause some catastrophic failure in the musculoskeletal system? " Quote taken from; Lederman, E. The fall of the postural–structural–biomechanical model in manual and physical therapies: Exemplified by lower back pain. CPDO Online Journal (2010), March, p1-14. www.cpdo.net Not staking a position on either side of this " debate " just adding a different perspective. Sam Brethauer Overland Park Kansas, Lees Summit Missouri, USA > > > > > > With all due respect, name the athletes at the national and international level using cross fit. > > > > > > > > > What sports are they competing, and how do they place? > > > > > > > > > More importantly, are they receiving any financial support or endorsements from those who sell cross fit? > > > > > > > > > If you did research, you likely were tapped into the mother ship, and not what the rest of us are seeing generally out here in gyms and suffering with the practitioners. the you tube videos were right on, generally these characters are what is out there. > > > > > > > > > With all due respect to the few cross fit enthusiasts who have good form, the majority remind me of the dumbed down antics of " body pump " (likely some sort of registered or trade mark) for the women...sigh. > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.