Guest guest Posted July 28, 2010 Report Posted July 28, 2010 Pretty funny. Real life, alas.... Yeah, they kinda sound like the cartoons for one thing. For another? the local ones tend not to pick up their toys and safety does not appear to be constantly on their radar - I had to get a bodybuilder (yeah.....they failed to listen to ANYBODY else...?) to tell them to STOP running across our benches. People were trying to bench press, and these characters had it in their heads they could do interval " sprints " back and forth down a narrow aisle down the foot of all the benches! (there is an unused enclosed basketball court in the same building by the way, but it would require them to walk another 60 yards...oh, the horror!) They appeared to not realize there were 3 angry people after the first pass, and glaring and even a shout at one failed to get their attention....? Sooo there you are, with the bar over your chest, trying to focus in the circus that is an open gym full of this nonsense and you get some guy actually RUNNING past you....with no regard for anybody else. He nearly collided with my guy (who was loading plates for me on shrug) on top of it all! I keep hoping they will naturally migrate to lift with their own kind....elsewhere. Generally speaking, the crossfitters I've encountered so far have been oblivious and quite discourteous, I'm sure they all cannot be this way - but it's like the circus has come to town when they arrive, and they leave things far worse than they find them. I tend to not watch, the form is discouragingly bad and I'm convinced a couple of these folks are just future ambulance visits in the making...they talk about squats, cleans, etc...but so far the form is nowhere near what you see from PL, OL, and even BB.... I hope the fad either calms down sufficiently to start policing and correcting their own ranks a bit or they retreat to places suited to their style of workout, with sufficient coaching to help alleviate the safety issues I see on a continuing basis. The Phantom aka Schaefer, CMT/RMT, competing powerlifter Denver, Colorado, USA 2 Crossfitters 1 Chalk Bucket Colleagues, If you don't mind a bit of potty mouth - I couldn't resist sharing this: Apologies to all you crossfitters out there but it's just too funny. Regards, Plisk Excelsior Sports Shelton CT www.excelsiorsports.com Prepare To Be A Champion! Quote
Guest guest Posted July 28, 2010 Report Posted July 28, 2010 " Crossfitters " - Their Web Site has a House of Horrors Injury Discussion Forum - Enough Said! Landau Aventura, Florida _www.exercisefraud.com_ (http://www.exercisefraud.com) In a message dated 7/28/2010 2:56:40 P.M. Eastern Daylight Time, deadliftdiva@... writes: Pretty funny. Real life, alas.... Yeah, they kinda sound like the cartoons for one thing. For another? the local ones tend not to pick up their toys and safety does not appear to be constantly on their radar - I had to get a bodybuilder (yeah.....they failed to listen to ANYBODY else...?) to tell them to STOP running across our benches. People were trying to bench press, and these characters had it in their heads they could do interval " sprints " back and forth down a narrow aisle down the foot of all the benches! (there is an unused enclosed basketball court in the same building by the way, but it would require them to walk another 60 yards...oh, the horror!) They appeared to not realize there were 3 angry people after the first pass, and glaring and even a shout at one failed to get their attention....? Sooo there you are, with the bar over your chest, trying to focus in the circus that is an open gym full of this nonsense and you get some guy actually RUNNING past you....with no regard for anybody else. He nearly collided with my guy (who was loading plates for me on shrug) on top of it all! I keep hoping they will naturally migrate to lift with their own kind....elsewhere. Generally speaking, the crossfitters I've encountered so far have been oblivious and quite discourteous, I'm sure they all cannot be this way - but it's like the circus has come to town when they arrive, and they leave things far worse than they find them. I tend to not watch, the form is discouragingly bad and I'm convinced a couple of these folks are just future ambulance visits in the making...they talk about squats, cleans, etc...but so far the form is nowhere near what you see from PL, OL, and even BB.... I hope the fad either calms down sufficiently to start policing and correcting their own ranks a bit or they retreat to places suited to their style of workout, with sufficient coaching to help alleviate the safety issues I see on a continuing basis. ====================== Quote
Guest guest Posted July 29, 2010 Report Posted July 29, 2010 Schaefer wrote: I keep hoping they will naturally migrate to lift with their own kind....elsewhere. Generally speaking, the crossfitters I've encountered so far have been oblivious and quite discourteous, I'm sure they all cannot be this way - but it's like the circus has come to town when they arrive, and they leave things far worse than they find them.... ---------- Hi , I think you're right they can't all be like that. But despite the nonsense, there's a bad - really bad - attitude among many crossfitters that they are 'elite'. Unfortunately the fads that seem to have staying power are the ones where a few kernels of truth have been dumbed down into some sort of idiocy. Based on how fast this one has gained in popularity, I think we may be dealing with it for a while. Regards, Plisk Excelsior Sports Shelton CT www.excelsiorsports.com Prepare To Be A Champion! Quote
Guest guest Posted July 29, 2010 Report Posted July 29, 2010 Landau wrote: " Crossfitters " - Their Web Site has a House of Horrors Injury Discussion Forum - Enough Said! ---------- , Great point. Unfortunately the usual suspects will probably use this to support their case that the O-lifts or powerlifts are dangerous - ignoring the fact that doing them stupidly is the real problem. Regards, Plisk Excelsior Sports Shelton CT www.excelsiorsports.com Prepare To Be A Champion! Quote
Guest guest Posted July 29, 2010 Report Posted July 29, 2010 I recently heard there's an OL team coexisting in the same gym with cross fitters lol. From the information I have on this, there's no confusion as to who is with which group... when you consider the OL team features a 75 yo lady, that should say it all? Enough said. The Phantom aka Schaefer, CMT/RMT, competing powerlifter Denver, Colorado, USA Re: 2 Crossfitters 1 Chalk Bucket Schaefer wrote: I keep hoping they will naturally migrate to lift with their own kind....elsewhere. Generally speaking, the crossfitters I've encountered so far have been oblivious and quite discourteous, I'm sure they all cannot be this way - but it's like the circus has come to town when they arrive, and they leave things far worse than they find them.... ---------- Hi , I think you're right they can't all be like that. But despite the nonsense, there's a bad - really bad - attitude among many crossfitters that they are 'elite'. Unfortunately the fads that seem to have staying power are the ones where a few kernels of truth have been dumbed down into some sort of idiocy. Based on how fast this one has gained in popularity, I think we may be dealing with it for a while. Regards, Plisk Excelsior Sports Shelton CT www.excelsiorsports.com Prepare To Be A Champion! Quote
Guest guest Posted July 29, 2010 Report Posted July 29, 2010 This is from the Crossfit website on a page titled " Understanding Crossfit " by Greg Glassman: " The methodology that drives CrossFit is entirely empirical. We believe that meaningful statements about safety, efficacy, and efficiency, the three most important and interdependent facets of any fitness program, can be supported only by measurable, observable, repeatable facts; i.e., data. " I haven't found much mention of research or citation of research data on the Crossfit site or in the presentations posted on the web site and , your comment shows that safety is just not one of the most important facets of their program - I've even heard Glassman himself contradict that position. If I was lifting in a gym where people were sprinting back and forth around me I would have a hard time not accidentally sticking a leg out and tripping one of them. Luckily I have my own place now. Casey Gallagher CSCS Snohomish, WA USA 2 Crossfitters 1 Chalk Bucket Colleagues, If you don't mind a bit of potty mouth - I couldn't resist sharing this: 5NgF0> wnImk> Apologies to all you crossfitters out there but it's just too funny. Regards, Plisk Excelsior Sports Shelton CT www.excelsiorsports.com Prepare To Be A Champion! Quote
Guest guest Posted July 29, 2010 Report Posted July 29, 2010 This is from the Crossfit website on a page titled " Understanding Crossfit " by Greg Glassman: " The methodology that drives CrossFit is entirely empirical. We believe that meaningful statements about safety, efficacy, and efficiency, the three most important and interdependent facets of any fitness program, can be supported only by measurable, observable, repeatable facts; i.e., data. " I haven't found much mention of research or citation of research data on the Crossfit site or in the presentations posted on the web site and , your comment shows that safety is just not one of the most important facets of their program - I've even heard Glassman himself contradict that position. If I was lifting in a gym where people were sprinting back and forth around me I would have a hard time not accidentally sticking a leg out and tripping one of them. Luckily I have my own place now. Casey Gallagher CSCS Snohomish, WA USA 2 Crossfitters 1 Chalk Bucket Colleagues, If you don't mind a bit of potty mouth - I couldn't resist sharing this: 5NgF0> wnImk> Apologies to all you crossfitters out there but it's just too funny. Regards, Plisk Excelsior Sports Shelton CT www.excelsiorsports.com Prepare To Be A Champion! Quote
Guest guest Posted July 29, 2010 Report Posted July 29, 2010 I have 2 major problems with Crossfit. The first is the premise that it is a good way to train athletes. I think anyone here can poke holes all over that argument. A haphazardly thrown together program is no way to prepare an athlete. Sure, it works great for " getting in shape " (whatever that means) for the average Joe or Jane, but that's about it.The other is the certification of every and anyone willing to pay a few thousand dollars. In fact I know a couple people with no background in exercise science or otherwise who have a certification and have recently opened their own Crossfit gym. Sure, it's a great way to supplement their income, and I don't know if they promote it as anything other than a place to come get a workout in. But the fact is that they have no background or ability to diagnose weaknesses or to suggest alternate exercises. Not to mention the exercise technique being taught tends to be gawd-awful, again due to the fact that few of them really understand the reason they are even doing what they are. Just my $.02 anyway. Brock Leggins Norwalk, IA Quote
Guest guest Posted July 30, 2010 Report Posted July 30, 2010 Hmm. I'm in agreement with the first part, the notion you train athletes for competition with this program is unlikely. The focus on speed, rather than on form is part of the problem overall. But then I'm hard pressed to think of a competing athlete I'd recommend slight knee bends and reverse clumsy curls to rather than actual squats and cleans to.... As for people without formal training, well, there are self taught athletes and coaches who are pretty good at their chosen sports. I don't think we should evaluate folks based on the lack of a 4 year degree in something - but on their competence in coaching or whatever they choose to do. As for the easy achieving of certifications, this isn't the only organization willing to hand out certifications for a few dollars....(sigh). I think of these guys as franchise owners in fast food chains, but I think there's less supervision than in fast food? Getting in shape for the average person is mostly about losing some excess bodyfat and gaining some ability to hike or do what they like without feeling totally winded or hurt by the experience. Speed workouts with light weights generally helps such a desire, but the form has to be there or you get a setback requiring at worst, medical intervention.... this particular fad feeds a " herd mentality " where they can move in packs... Lastly, two sites I reviewed with regard to cross fit mentioned that " best results overall can be achieved using steroids " . <rolling eyes> Yes, and a common gym rat using steroids will also get gains....right? Part of the overall feeling I get from reading their sites is that anything goes, you are hell bent on doing the named workout with extreme speed and so it's all about " how much and how fast " . In the end, it seems to be the worst of several gymrat tendencies rolled into one - forums where you brag up your feats, " squats " that fail to get within the same zip code of depth, and power moves without anything resembling form or power.... all in a way to aggravate everybody else in a gym sufficiently to require their own " gyms " lol. Be thankful your local lot has their own club house and let every one of your local herd know it's there, that's my advice. Carry cards for their gym and hand them out, along with your favorite MT and other practitioners, who can use the business in this economy....<grin>. the Phantom aka Schaefer, RMT/CMT, competing powerlifter Denver, Colorado, USA RE: 2 Crossfitters 1 Chalk Bucket I have 2 major problems with Crossfit. The first is the premise that it is a good way to train athletes. I think anyone here can poke holes all over that argument. A haphazardly thrown together program is no way to prepare an athlete. Sure, it works great for " getting in shape " (whatever that means) for the average Joe or Jane, but that's about it.The other is the certification of every and anyone willing to pay a few thousand dollars. In fact I know a couple people with no background in exercise science or otherwise who have a certification and have recently opened their own Crossfit gym. Sure, it's a great way to supplement their income, and I don't know if they promote it as anything other than a place to come get a workout in. But the fact is that they have no background or ability to diagnose weaknesses or to suggest alternate exercises. Not to mention the exercise technique being taught tends to be gawd-awful, again due to the fact that few of them really understand the reason they are even doing what they are. Just my $.02 anyway. Brock Leggins Norwalk, IA Quote
Guest guest Posted July 30, 2010 Report Posted July 30, 2010 I'm certainly not advocating that we disregard someone based solely on whether or not they possess a degree, and if it appeared that way, I apologize. Certainly there are plenty of very good coaches who took the hours and hours necessary to learn the human body and other aspects of human performance. Unfortunately, there are also plenty who have not taken the time, yet still feel qualified to coach. But I'm getting a bit off topic here. I guess the real point I was trying to make was that it does not require one to have any background in training or S & C (as far as I know) in order to obtain a certification from them. One simply need only a stack of money (I believe it's something like $1,000?) and a desire in making more money (by using the CF brand), and maybe a passing interest in fitness or exercise. However, I will also agree with you that unfortunately they are far from the only organizaton that this complaint could be made about. Brock Leggins Norwalk, IA Supertraining From: deadliftdiva@... Date: Fri, 30 Jul 2010 14:57:10 +0000 Subject: Re: 2 Crossfitters 1 Chalk Bucket Hmm. I'm in agreement with the first part, the notion you train athletes for competition with this program is unlikely. The focus on speed, rather than on form is part of the problem overall. But then I'm hard pressed to think of a competing athlete I'd recommend slight knee bends and reverse clumsy curls to rather than actual squats and cleans to.... As for people without formal training, well, there are self taught athletes and coaches who are pretty good at their chosen sports. I don't think we should evaluate folks based on the lack of a 4 year degree in something - but on their competence in coaching or whatever they choose to do. As for the easy achieving of certifications, this isn't the only organization willing to hand out certifications for a few dollars....(sigh). I think of these guys as franchise owners in fast food chains, but I think there's less supervision than in fast food? Getting in shape for the average person is mostly about losing some excess bodyfat and gaining some ability to hike or do what they like without feeling totally winded or hurt by the experience. Speed workouts with light weights generally helps such a desire, but the form has to be there or you get a setback requiring at worst, medical intervention.... this particular fad feeds a " herd mentality " where they can move in packs... Lastly, two sites I reviewed with regard to cross fit mentioned that " best results overall can be achieved using steroids " . <rolling eyes> Yes, and a common gym rat using steroids will also get gains....right? Part of the overall feeling I get from reading their sites is that anything goes, you are hell bent on doing the named workout with extreme speed and so it's all about " how much and how fast " . In the end, it seems to be the worst of several gymrat tendencies rolled into one - forums where you brag up your feats, " squats " that fail to get within the same zip code of depth, and power moves without anything resembling form or power.... all in a way to aggravate everybody else in a gym sufficiently to require their own " gyms " lol. Be thankful your local lot has their own club house and let every one of your local herd know it's there, that's my advice. Carry cards for their gym and hand them out, along with your favorite MT and other practitioners, who can use the business in this economy....<grin>. ========================== Quote
Guest guest Posted August 3, 2010 Report Posted August 3, 2010 It surprises me that this opinion continues to persist. There are loads of highly skilled and powerful, and fit athletes that incorporate the CrossFit methodology including National and International level athletes. The " slight knee bend " squat and " reverse clumsy curl " clean comments are rather interesting because from my research into CrossFit they have extremely high standards for technique when high loads are used and a higher tolerance level for deviation from that standard as the loads become lower or more relative and repetitons increase. The stories portrayed here are not typical of CrossFit in general. Working with the military has lead me to do extensive research into the methodolgy and community of CrossFit and I see quite the opposite. Obviously not everyone thinks this way. If it was that bad would USAW be joining forces in a joint venture. http://weightlifting.teamusa.org/news/2010/07/08/inaugural-crossfit-usa-weig htlifting-open-comes-to-colorado-springs-oct-1-3/37121 Barry Stockbrugger Ottawa, Canada _____ From: Supertraining [mailto:Supertraining ] On Behalf Of deadliftdiva@... Sent: Friday, July 30, 2010 10:57 AM Supertraining Subject: Re: 2 Crossfitters 1 Chalk Bucket Hmm. I'm in agreement with the first part, the notion you train athletes for competition with this program is unlikely. The focus on speed, rather than on form is part of the problem overall. But then I'm hard pressed to think of a competing athlete I'd recommend slight knee bends and reverse clumsy curls to rather than actual squats and cleans to.... As for people without formal training, well, there are self taught athletes and coaches who are pretty good at their chosen sports. I don't think we should evaluate folks based on the lack of a 4 year degree in something - but on their competence in coaching or whatever they choose to do. As for the easy achieving of certifications, this isn't the only organization willing to hand out certifications for a few dollars....(sigh). I think of these guys as franchise owners in fast food chains, but I think there's less supervision than in fast food? Getting in shape for the average person is mostly about losing some excess bodyfat and gaining some ability to hike or do what they like without feeling totally winded or hurt by the experience. Speed workouts with light weights generally helps such a desire, but the form has to be there or you get a setback requiring at worst, medical intervention.... this particular fad feeds a " herd mentality " where they can move in packs... Lastly, two sites I reviewed with regard to cross fit mentioned that " best results overall can be achieved using steroids " . <rolling eyes> Yes, and a common gym rat using steroids will also get gains....right? Part of the overall feeling I get from reading their sites is that anything goes, you are hell bent on doing the named workout with extreme speed and so it's all about " how much and how fast " . In the end, it seems to be the worst of several gymrat tendencies rolled into one - forums where you brag up your feats, " squats " that fail to get within the same zip code of depth, and power moves without anything resembling form or power.... all in a way to aggravate everybody else in a gym sufficiently to require their own " gyms " lol. Be thankful your local lot has their own club house and let every one of your local herd know it's there, that's my advice. Carry cards for their gym and hand them out, along with your favorite MT and other practitioners, who can use the business in this economy....<grin>. the Phantom aka Schaefer, RMT/CMT, competing powerlifter Denver, Colorado, USA RE: 2 Crossfitters 1 Chalk Bucket I have 2 major problems with Crossfit. The first is the premise that it is a good way to train athletes. I think anyone here can poke holes all over that argument. A haphazardly thrown together program is no way to prepare an athlete. Sure, it works great for " getting in shape " (whatever that means) for the average Joe or Jane, but that's about it.The other is the certification of every and anyone willing to pay a few thousand dollars. In fact I know a couple people with no background in exercise science or otherwise who have a certification and have recently opened their own Crossfit gym. Sure, it's a great way to supplement their income, and I don't know if they promote it as anything other than a place to come get a workout in. But the fact is that they have no background or ability to diagnose weaknesses or to suggest alternate exercises. Not to mention the exercise technique being taught tends to be gawd-awful, again due to the fact that few of them really understand the reason they are even doing what they are. Just my $.02 anyway. Brock Leggins Norwalk, IA Quote
Guest guest Posted August 4, 2010 Report Posted August 4, 2010 With all due respect, name the athletes at the national and international level using cross fit. What sports are they competing, and how do they place? More importantly, are they receiving any financial support or endorsements from those who sell cross fit? If you did research, you likely were tapped into the mother ship, and not what the rest of us are seeing generally out here in gyms and suffering with the practitioners. the you tube videos were right on, generally these characters are what is out there. With all due respect to the few cross fit enthusiasts who have good form, the majority remind me of the dumbed down antics of " body pump " (likely some sort of registered or trade mark) for the women...sigh. Speed is not the only thing you should take into consideration when performing a workout. The military, when using programs, takes the trouble to engage experienced, observant instructors for the most part when training people. They take the care to inspect the health and overall fitness of trainees. I repeat, there is a gym with an OL team and cross fitters in it. You can tell who does what without asking, and there is a 75 yo woman who competes OL who has better form.... I've trained with that team by the way, and know a good OL lift from a bad one...I just lack time and facilities up here in Denver to try to add OL on at this time to my PL competitions. I also had some instruction from Mel.... Just because a few crossfitters choose to compete OL and yes, PL at times now lately, does not mean this is a preferred method of training for either platform. USAW is doing anything it can to try to get people to compete OL. They've never had a lot of competing OL, not in USA. Since the pie in the sky is the Olympic dream for OL'ers, and you only have about 10 people who ever get there, that's part of the lack of overall motivation to join OL vs other sports where you might have more chance of long term success. The more people USAW can talk into casually competing OL, the more chance they have of getting more financial donations and support for the Olympic team. It's no mystery USAW is trying anything they can, since funding isn't what it was and they need new sources of trainees. They have been actively scouting PL athletes too, on the chance they can talk somebody into switching. PL too embraces meets with OL competitions, it's a natural affiliation. Despite the television coverage of OL over the years, it has failed to make the sport truly popular in the average person and that is what they are still trying to achieve. Gymnastics has cute, perky lil girlies, and buff lads.... arguably shane and cheryl were far from being as marketable - as well as that honking big gal from europe - germany? last Olympiad...good grief! camera was on her for a microsecond during the opening ceremonies and FLED! Will crossfitters fit into the more regulated world of OL? who can say....we'll have to look at the results and see how many bomb out due to failure to meet the standard in the lifts, or overestimate what they can do on the platform. Will they buy USAW cards? yes, to do the meet. USAW therefore profits. How many though will make the US Olympic team? At least one former PL has - shane hamman was a PL too, lol. I stand by the entirety of my comments put forth before, and I fervently hope all the crossfitters hanging out in the public gyms head into cloisters of their own kind, perhaps their form and safety overall will improve! The Phantom aka Schaefer, CMT/RMT, competing powerlifter Denver, Colorado, USA RE: 2 Crossfitters 1 Chalk Bucket It surprises me that this opinion continues to persist. There are loads of highly skilled and powerful, and fit athletes that incorporate the CrossFit methodology including National and International level athletes. The " slight knee bend " squat and " reverse clumsy curl " clean comments are rather interesting because from my research into CrossFit they have extremely high standards for technique when high loads are used and a higher tolerance level for deviation from that standard as the loads become lower or more relative and repetitons increase. The stories portrayed here are not typical of CrossFit in general. Working with the military has lead me to do extensive research into the methodolgy and community of CrossFit and I see quite the opposite. Obviously not everyone thinks this way. If it was that bad would USAW be joining forces in a joint venture. http://weightlifting.teamusa.org/news/2010/07/08/inaugural-crossfit-usa-weig htlifting-open-comes-to-colorado-springs-oct-1-3/37121 ========================= Quote
Guest guest Posted August 5, 2010 Report Posted August 5, 2010 I'm not much of a fan of CrossFit, but I know a great deal about it and trained in a CrossFit gym for a few months a few years back. I think a lot of the criticism is unfair, but heaving criticism often is done in an unfair manner no matter the recipient. I'll just address one thing. The majority of people doing CrossFit in non-CrossFit gyms probably have had close to zero hands-on instruction. You shouldn't expect some gym rat who's not being coached to have great exercise form. Most people who have good form in the powerlifts and Olympic lifts have had at least some hands-on instruction. CrossFit tends to be much better at teaching proper exercise form than the NSCA or other major certification groups. If you go to CrossFit gyms and see horrible form, then you can start criticizing. I think the top CrossFit trainers are pretty good with respects to teaching exercise form, while there are many others who can at least teach decent exercise form. I could heave criticism at CrossFit for days on end, but I think all my criticism would be fair based on years of direct involvement in the CrossFit community. Washington, D.C. Lee On Wed, Aug 4, 2010 at 10:34 AM, <deadliftdiva@...> wrote: > > > With all due respect, name the athletes at the national and international > level using cross fit. > > What sports are they competing, and how do they place? > > More importantly, are they receiving any financial support or endorsements > from those who sell cross fit? > > If you did research, you likely were tapped into the mother ship, and not > what the rest of us are seeing generally out here in gyms and suffering with > the practitioners. the you tube videos were right on, generally these > characters are what is out there. > > With all due respect to the few cross fit enthusiasts who have good form, > the majority remind me of the dumbed down antics of " body pump " (likely some > sort of registered or trade mark) for the women...sigh. > > Speed is not the only thing you should take into consideration when > performing a workout. > > The military, when using programs, takes the trouble to engage experienced, > observant instructors for the most part when training people. They take the > care to inspect the health and overall fitness of trainees. > > I repeat, there is a gym with an OL team and cross fitters in it. You can > tell who does what without asking, and there is a 75 yo woman who competes > OL who has better form.... I've trained with that team by the way, and know > a good OL lift from a bad one...I just lack time and facilities up here in > Denver to try to add OL on at this time to my PL competitions. I also had > some instruction from Mel.... > > Just because a few crossfitters choose to compete OL and yes, PL at times > now lately, does not mean this is a preferred method of training for either > platform. > > USAW is doing anything it can to try to get people to compete OL. They've > never had a lot of competing OL, not in USA. Since the pie in the sky is the > Olympic dream for OL'ers, and you only have about 10 people who ever get > there, that's part of the lack of overall motivation to join OL vs other > sports where you might have more chance of long term success. The more > people USAW can talk into casually competing OL, the more chance they have > of getting more financial donations and support for the Olympic team. It's > no mystery USAW is trying anything they can, since funding isn't what it was > and they need new sources of trainees. They have been actively scouting PL > athletes too, on the chance they can talk somebody into switching. PL too > embraces meets with OL competitions, it's a natural affiliation. Despite the > television coverage of OL over the years, it has failed to make the sport > truly popular in the average person and that is what they are still trying > to achieve. Gymnastics has cute, perky lil girlies, and buff lads.... > arguably shane and cheryl were far from being as marketable - as well as > that honking big gal from europe - germany? last Olympiad...good grief! > camera was on her for a microsecond during the opening ceremonies and FLED! > > Will crossfitters fit into the more regulated world of OL? who can > say....we'll have to look at the results and see how many bomb out due to > failure to meet the standard in the lifts, or overestimate what they can do > on the platform. Will they buy USAW cards? yes, to do the meet. USAW > therefore profits. > > How many though will make the US Olympic team? > > At least one former PL has - shane hamman was a PL too, lol. > > I stand by the entirety of my comments put forth before, and I fervently > hope all the crossfitters hanging out in the public gyms head into cloisters > of their own kind, perhaps their form and safety overall will improve! > > The Phantom > aka Schaefer, CMT/RMT, competing powerlifter > Denver, Colorado, USA > RE: 2 Crossfitters 1 Chalk Bucket > > It surprises me that this opinion continues to persist. There are loads of > highly skilled and powerful, and fit athletes that incorporate the CrossFit > > methodology including National and International level athletes. The > " slight > knee bend " squat and " reverse clumsy curl " clean comments are rather > interesting because from my research into CrossFit they have extremely high > > standards for technique when high loads are used and a higher tolerance > level for deviation from that standard as the loads become lower or more > relative and repetitons increase. The stories portrayed here are not > typical > of CrossFit in general. Working with the military has lead me to do > extensive research into the methodolgy and community of CrossFit and I see > quite the opposite. > > Obviously not everyone thinks this way. If it was that bad would USAW be > joining forces in a joint venture. > > > http://weightlifting.teamusa.org/news/2010/07/08/inaugural-crossfit-usa-weig > htlifting-open-comes-to-colorado-springs-oct-1-3/37121 > > ========================= > > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 5, 2010 Report Posted August 5, 2010 I know that several members of the Canadian National Rowing Team are using some of the CrossFit Methodology including members who have successfully competed in multiple Olympics just for starters. Considering that there are over 2000 CrossFit gyms with between 50 and 300+ members, and not including those working out at standard fitness centres, but doing what might be considered CrossFit to those around them (although that could be debatable), I am sure there are plenty of people training with less than optimal technique with those types of numbers. That is like blaming the NSCA for people who read a journal and then try and squat without a quality coach. Not to mention the 1000's of athletes training all across North America using OL and PL and absolutely no affiliation to CrossFit or desire to " compete " in either OL or PL. Although I would prefer that the athletes using OL or PL spend the time to develop optimal technique and get good coaching, I would not expect that they have the time to devote to " competition level " technique. Then it is a matter of safety and return on the investment of time. Point being that OL and PL are probably used by more athletes than there are those competing in the two sports. You are used to training with competitive PL and/or OL where technique is far more refined and training age with these movements is far greater. Although I am sure there are exceptions. I would suspect that other athletes who use OL and/or PL can develop very solid technique given enough good training and coaching exposure. I see tons of evidence of that in many CrossFit gyms across North America. Considering that the main source of CrossFit's OL teaching come from Mike Burgener who is what many would consider one of the best in the US at coaching OL, it is not that they aren't being exposed to very best. Admittedly you will get those less than competent that decide to try their hand, but I am not sure I would set that on the shoulders of CrossFit in general. I might also venture to guess that they may have never been to an actual workshop/seminar/certification (what ever you want to call it). I too stand by my comments. I would agree that those who are CrossFitting should train at an appropriate training facility with the proper equipment and make sure that they are seeking out good coaches which there are lots of. I know that for myself, I needed to attend a CrossFit Seminar to fully apprecaite the high quality of the instructors and technique taught. Barry Stockbrugger Ottawa, Canada _____ From: Supertraining [mailto:Supertraining ] On Behalf Of deadliftdiva@... Sent: Wednesday, August 04, 2010 10:35 AM Supertraining Subject: Re: 2 Crossfitters 1 Chalk Bucket With all due respect, name the athletes at the national and international level using cross fit. What sports are they competing, and how do they place? More importantly, are they receiving any financial support or endorsements from those who sell cross fit? If you did research, you likely were tapped into the mother ship, and not what the rest of us are seeing generally out here in gyms and suffering with the practitioners. the you tube videos were right on, generally these characters are what is out there. With all due respect to the few cross fit enthusiasts who have good form, the majority remind me of the dumbed down antics of " body pump " (likely some sort of registered or trade mark) for the women...sigh. Speed is not the only thing you should take into consideration when performing a workout. The military, when using programs, takes the trouble to engage experienced, observant instructors for the most part when training people. They take the care to inspect the health and overall fitness of trainees. I repeat, there is a gym with an OL team and cross fitters in it. You can tell who does what without asking, and there is a 75 yo woman who competes OL who has better form.... I've trained with that team by the way, and know a good OL lift from a bad one...I just lack time and facilities up here in Denver to try to add OL on at this time to my PL competitions. I also had some instruction from Mel.... Just because a few crossfitters choose to compete OL and yes, PL at times now lately, does not mean this is a preferred method of training for either platform. USAW is doing anything it can to try to get people to compete OL. They've never had a lot of competing OL, not in USA. Since the pie in the sky is the Olympic dream for OL'ers, and you only have about 10 people who ever get there, that's part of the lack of overall motivation to join OL vs other sports where you might have more chance of long term success. The more people USAW can talk into casually competing OL, the more chance they have of getting more financial donations and support for the Olympic team. It's no mystery USAW is trying anything they can, since funding isn't what it was and they need new sources of trainees. They have been actively scouting PL athletes too, on the chance they can talk somebody into switching. PL too embraces meets with OL competitions, it's a natural affiliation. Despite the television coverage of OL over the years, it has failed to make the sport truly popular in the average person and that is what they are still trying to achieve. Gymnastics has cute, perky lil girlies, and buff lads.... arguably shane and cheryl were far from being as marketable - as well as that honking big gal from europe - germany? last Olympiad...good grief! camera was on her for a microsecond during the opening ceremonies and FLED! Will crossfitters fit into the more regulated world of OL? who can say....we'll have to look at the results and see how many bomb out due to failure to meet the standard in the lifts, or overestimate what they can do on the platform. Will they buy USAW cards? yes, to do the meet. USAW therefore profits. How many though will make the US Olympic team? At least one former PL has - shane hamman was a PL too, lol. I stand by the entirety of my comments put forth before, and I fervently hope all the crossfitters hanging out in the public gyms head into cloisters of their own kind, perhaps their form and safety overall will improve! The Phantom aka Schaefer, CMT/RMT, competing powerlifter Denver, Colorado, USA RE: 2 Crossfitters 1 Chalk Bucket It surprises me that this opinion continues to persist. There are loads of highly skilled and powerful, and fit athletes that incorporate the CrossFit methodology including National and International level athletes. The " slight knee bend " squat and " reverse clumsy curl " clean comments are rather interesting because from my research into CrossFit they have extremely high standards for technique when high loads are used and a higher tolerance level for deviation from that standard as the loads become lower or more relative and repetitons increase. The stories portrayed here are not typical of CrossFit in general. Working with the military has lead me to do extensive research into the methodolgy and community of CrossFit and I see quite the opposite. Obviously not everyone thinks this way. If it was that bad would USAW be joining forces in a joint venture. http://weightlifting.teamusa.org/news/2010/07/08/inaugural-crossfit-usa-weig htlifting-open-comes-to-colorado-springs-oct-1-3/37121 ========================= Quote
Guest guest Posted August 5, 2010 Report Posted August 5, 2010 , you're view is from your own window here. I'm not a cross fitter, but I do understand and relate to what I believe to be their general premise. Asking where they've competed in and won is anathema to what " cross fit " is. Of course they're not going to set new records in dead lifting. Their name isn't " deadlift fit " . The whole idea is to be good at many things. How many OLs can run a 40 min 10K? Think more along the lines of Decathlon, not along the lines of being just a pole vault champion. Now, as to whether they do well in a " decathlon " mode, I don't know. But I'd bet they're not too bad. Track and field, lifting, running, basketball, skiing, there is no good measure of " general " , but that doesn't make it less worthwhile or even less satisfying. I just don't buy the argument that because they're not producing greats by some exact specific measure then that means they're not training athletes. That's a poor reason to deprecate the program. Now, if they could only put in some general manors routines.. and not be butt heads in their training.. now _that_ might help create even _better_, more well rounded athletes. -ds > > With all due respect, name the athletes at the national and international level using cross fit. > > > What sports are they competing, and how do they place? > > > More importantly, are they receiving any financial support or endorsements from those who sell cross fit? > > > If you did research, you likely were tapped into the mother ship, and not what the rest of us are seeing generally out here in gyms and suffering with the practitioners. the you tube videos were right on, generally these characters are what is out there. > > > With all due respect to the few cross fit enthusiasts who have good form, the majority remind me of the dumbed down antics of " body pump " (likely some sort of registered or trade mark) for the women...sigh. Quote
Guest guest Posted August 6, 2010 Report Posted August 6, 2010 Sigh. Hence my recommendation that we encourage them to go to their own gyms and learn from their own kind.... If they use poor gym manners in their own gyms, full of crossfitters, at least they will only be impacting their own members and not the members of more general gyms. When the fad truly got rolling and we started to see more than 2 or 3 in our gyms here, the toys didn't get put away, and the attitude got started that they had the only workouts worth doing... as I said before, including highly dangerous " sprints " across the foots of the bench press, and other nonsense! I don't think all of them have come from some magical place lacking their own kind and instruction, although I'm sure some of the people have come from solely looking at web sites or from poor second source instruction (like another member with questionable form passing it on). Fads tend to get zealous buy-in and oversell and you get the attitude that aggravates people who are not faddists around them lol. I mean, kettlebells and other fads can be a bit irritating when people say we must all do it, or we aren't working out . I'm sure that there are properly performed lifts in some crossfit venues with some members. It is, however, yet another guru driven program like the informercial one cited originally in the same vein, and your mileage may truly vary. As others have pointed out, reading their mother ship sites is pretty entertaining, including WOD recommendations, etc. The notion that someone can do just cross fit and perform at a truly " elite " level in sports is not likely....and I don't think just doing cross fit will get you onto the OL team for the Olympics, nor make you a 1000 lb squatter or bencher - or deadlifter. So it sounds like despite the unhappiness at my tone, you are saying we should send them to their own gyms to learn better form...and I said that, encourage them to seek their own kind, apart from the rest of us - for the sake of all of us! The Phantom aka Schaefer, CMT/RMT, competing powerlifter Denver, Colorado, USA RE: 2 Crossfitters 1 Chalk Bucket > > It surprises me that this opinion continues to persist. There are loads of > highly skilled and powerful, and fit athletes that incorporate the CrossFit > > methodology including National and International level athletes. The > " slight > knee bend " squat and " reverse clumsy curl " clean comments are rather > interesting because from my research into CrossFit they have extremely high > > standards for technique when high loads are used and a higher tolerance > level for deviation from that standard as the loads become lower or more > relative and repetitons increase. The stories portrayed here are not > typical > of CrossFit in general. Working with the military has lead me to do > extensive research into the methodolgy and community of CrossFit and I see > quite the opposite. > > Obviously not everyone thinks this way. If it was that bad would USAW be > joining forces in a joint venture. > > > http://weightlifting.teamusa.org/news/2010/07/08/inaugural-crossfit-usa-weig > htlifting-open-comes-to-colorado-springs-oct-1-3/37121 > > ========================= > > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 6, 2010 Report Posted August 6, 2010 Ok, so you have some rowers, fine... That's a bit different from suggesting that elite athletes all around need to use cross fit - and that's been a lot of the stuff slung by cross fitters and their advocates. Didn't suggest they should all compete OL or PL - in fact, I said most are far from it. You brought up the OL competition and USAW - I didn't. I also pointed out a major fact, USAW is still trying to get more interest in OL overall - and will try nearly anything to get it. PL on the other hand has so many people doing it in so many different feds lately...heck, I dunno what we'd get as a head count overall any more. <shrug> Plus a lot of folks have retired to basements or garages trying to avoid the more mainstream gyms, I still am considering that myself given the latest trend in crossfit invasion... Enthusiasts in fads always do try to make it sound like it's a good idea to do it. 2000 gyms? goodness - there's a gym in Denver nearly every block lately it seems - and I only know of 2 cross fit gyms around here right now (that I've actually seen.). One is brand new in a small strip mall and I cannot see how much business they have. They are directly across from a major regular gym - again, maybe a good idea, maybe not? How many other gyms are there? My biggest point has been either change the attitude of the membership when they're out of their own little fishbowls or keep them the heck out of our way. I think you could poll the gyms I've lifted in recently and get that one solidly put back to you - they don't put things away overall, they tend to even " run over " people in their zeal - and it's annoying as hell overall. Better ambassadors of their chosen group would be highly advisable....sigh. The biggest irony is that some gyms think PL and OL and BB are annoying - when most of that lot tend to put weights away and try generally to be decent gym citizens! The Phantom aka Schaefer, CMT/RMT, competing powerlifter Denver, Colorado, USA RE: 2 Crossfitters 1 Chalk Bucket It surprises me that this opinion continues to persist. There are loads of highly skilled and powerful, and fit athletes that incorporate the CrossFit methodology including National and International level athletes. The " slight knee bend " squat and " reverse clumsy curl " clean comments are rather interesting because from my research into CrossFit they have extremely high standards for technique when high loads are used and a higher tolerance level for deviation from that standard as the loads become lower or more relative and repetitons increase. The stories portrayed here are not typical of CrossFit in general. Working with the military has lead me to do extensive research into the methodolgy and community of CrossFit and I see quite the opposite. Obviously not everyone thinks this way. If it was that bad would USAW be joining forces in a joint venture. http://weightlifting.teamusa.org/news/2010/07/08/inaugural-crossfit-usa-weig htlifting-open-comes-to-colorado-springs-oct-1-3/37121 ========================= Quote
Guest guest Posted August 7, 2010 Report Posted August 7, 2010 : " Thank God " you can do the play by play, as I train exclusively in my Private Quarters. Fad is the key word, but the Trend is frightening. It Reminds me of the Novel, " Return of the Primitive. " Landau Aventura, Florida _www.exercisefraud.com_ (http://www.exercisefraud.com) In a message dated 8/7/2010 3:02:08 P.M. Eastern Daylight Time, deadliftdiva@... writes: Sigh. Hence my recommendation that we encourage them to go to their own gyms and learn from their own kind.... If they use poor gym manners in their own gyms, full of crossfitters, at least they will only be impacting their own members and not the members of more general gyms. When the fad truly got rolling and we started to see more than 2 or 3 in our gyms here, the toys didn't get put away, and the attitude got started that they had the only workouts worth doing... as I said before, including highly dangerous " sprints " across the foots of the bench press, and other nonsense! I don't think all of them have come from some magical place lacking their own kind and instruction, although I'm sure some of the people have come from solely looking at web sites or from poor second source instruction (like another member with questionable form passing it on). Fads tend to get zealous buy-in and oversell and you get the attitude that aggravates people who are not faddists around them lol. I mean, kettlebells and other fads can be a bit irritating when people say we must all do it, or we aren't working out . I'm sure that there are properly performed lifts in some crossfit venues with some members. It is, however, yet another guru driven program like the informercial one cited originally in the same vein, and your mileage may truly vary. As others have pointed out, reading their mother ship sites is pretty entertaining, including WOD recommendations, etc. The notion that someone can do just cross fit and perform at a truly " elite " level in sports is not likely....and I don't think just doing cross fit will get you onto the OL team for the Olympics, nor make you a 1000 lb squatter or bencher - or deadlifter. So it sounds like despite the unhappiness at my tone, you are saying we should send them to their own gyms to learn better form...and I said that, encourage them to seek their own kind, apart from the rest of us - for the sake of all of us! ============================= Quote
Guest guest Posted August 8, 2010 Report Posted August 8, 2010 , The big problem many have with crossfit is their lack of willingness to measure crossfit by any metrics other than their own. Crossfit states that they have done of empirical data to back up that crossfit is the best program around. The only metric crossfit is willing to utilize is improved times in their own workouts, which is the equivalent of having untrained athletes perform rowing workouts on a ergometer, and then point to the supermacy of rowing when the athletes dramatically improve in rowing. Crossfitters claim to havee the best all around fitness and be able to smoke " specialists " . However to my knowledge I have not seene formalized competitions involving crossfitters going up against specialist in a broad range of universally agreed upon standardized tests. The only real " proof " of cf's superiority over other athletes i have seen is when athletes perfrom a " fran " or other workout against very experienced cf competitors. They feel this is " proof " that cf is superior, yet these same advocates would balk at the notion of having CF competitors suit up against D-I football players for skills drills on the field since they feel it's an unfair comparison. Crossfit claims it isn't for specialist, but a vast majority of sports are specialist sports. A football player who can also run a competitive 10K is pointless. A weightlifter who is good at rowing is a lifter in last place. Garrison Mesa, AZ Supertraining From: jetskers@... Date: Fri, 6 Aug 2010 03:44:55 +0000 Subject: Re: 2 Crossfitters 1 Chalk Bucket , you're view is from your own window here. I'm not a cross fitter, but I do understand and relate to what I believe to be their general premise. Asking where they've competed in and won is anathema to what " cross fit " is. Of course they're not going to set new records in dead lifting. Their name isn't " deadlift fit " . The whole idea is to be good at many things. How many OLs can run a 40 min 10K? Think more along the lines of Decathlon, not along the lines of being just a pole vault champion. Now, as to whether they do well in a " decathlon " mode, I don't know. But I'd bet they're not too bad. Track and field, lifting, running, basketball, skiing, there is no good measure of " general " , but that doesn't make it less worthwhile or even less satisfying. I just don't buy the argument that because they're not producing greats by some exact specific measure then that means they're not training athletes. That's a poor reason to deprecate the program. Now, if they could only put in some general manors routines.. and not be butt heads in their training.. now _that_ might help create even _better_, more well rounded athletes. ================================ Quote
Guest guest Posted August 9, 2010 Report Posted August 9, 2010 We have to remember that Crossfit is an affiliate system; it's not a franchise. Crossfit says that affiliates are free to design their own programs or follow Crossfit's. That would create a wide range of systems and programs within the Crossfit paradigm. My opinion is that Crossfit gyms have given people another outlet for exercise, which is a good thing. I do think that skill development is low on their list of priorities - I have watched a video presentation of Glassman stating just that - and I don't agree at all with the notion that one workout is great for everyone - as Mark put it, " Fit for purpose " . I have held the belief though that the ends justify the means. I have also yet to find the research they purport that supports their programming philosophy If a person is happy with their results or performance and they remain free from injury or injuring other people (or annoying or negatively impacting others' workouts) then the more power to them. Casey Gallagher CSCS Snohomish, WA USA Re: 2 Crossfitters 1 Chalk Bucket , you're view is from your own window here. I'm not a cross fitter, but I do understand and relate to what I believe to be their general premise. Asking where they've competed in and won is anathema to what " cross fit " is. Of course they're not going to set new records in dead lifting. Their name isn't " deadlift fit " . The whole idea is to be good at many things. How many OLs can run a 40 min 10K? Think more along the lines of Decathlon, not along the lines of being just a pole vault champion. Now, as to whether they do well in a " decathlon " mode, I don't know. But I'd bet they're not too bad. Track and field, lifting, running, basketball, skiing, there is no good measure of " general " , but that doesn't make it less worthwhile or even less satisfying. I just don't buy the argument that because they're not producing greats by some exact specific measure then that means they're not training athletes. That's a poor reason to deprecate the program. Now, if they could only put in some general manors routines.. and not be butt heads in their training.. now _that_ might help create even _better_, more well rounded athletes. -ds > > With all due respect, name the athletes at the national and international level using cross fit. > > > What sports are they competing, and how do they place? > > > More importantly, are they receiving any financial support or endorsements from those who sell cross fit? > > > If you did research, you likely were tapped into the mother ship, and not what the rest of us are seeing generally out here in gyms and suffering with the practitioners. the you tube videos were right on, generally these characters are what is out there. > > > With all due respect to the few cross fit enthusiasts who have good form, the majority remind me of the dumbed down antics of " body pump " (likely some sort of registered or trade mark) for the women...sigh. Quote
Guest guest Posted August 11, 2010 Report Posted August 11, 2010 I know little about Crossfit and have heard it disparaged by Mike Boyle and Gray Cook. However, one day I was looking for a link to show someone what an overhead squat looked like. I found this link. Any " program " that can get someone to do what they did can't be all bad. Even the form, at least until the final rep or 2 in a few cases looks pretty decent, at least to my unskilled eyes. Bob Dannegger Raleigh, NC > > > > With all due respect, name the athletes at the national and international level using cross fit. > > > > > > What sports are they competing, and how do they place? > > > > > > More importantly, are they receiving any financial support or endorsements from those who sell cross fit? > > > > > > If you did research, you likely were tapped into the mother ship, and not what the rest of us are seeing generally out here in gyms and suffering with the practitioners. the you tube videos were right on, generally these characters are what is out there. > > > > > > With all due respect to the few cross fit enthusiasts who have good form, the majority remind me of the dumbed down antics of " body pump " (likely some sort of registered or trade mark) for the women...sigh. > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 11, 2010 Report Posted August 11, 2010 I would beg to differ that her form wasn't all that bad. Her weight transfers forward onto her toes and her knees move too varus. But yes, a 15 rep bodyweight over head squat is rather impressive. However 15 reps while sacrificing safety and technique is playing with fire. Casey Gallagher CSCS Snohomish, WA USA Re: 2 Crossfitters 1 Chalk Bucket I know little about Crossfit and have heard it disparaged by Mike Boyle and Gray Cook. However, one day I was looking for a link to show someone what an overhead squat looked like. I found this link. qI-WY> Any " program " that can get someone to do what they did can't be all bad. Even the form, at least until the final rep or 2 in a few cases looks pretty decent, at least to my unskilled eyes. Bob Dannegger Raleigh, NC > > > > With all due respect, name the athletes at the national and international level using cross fit. > > > > > > What sports are they competing, and how do they place? > > > > > > More importantly, are they receiving any financial support or endorsements from those who sell cross fit? > > > > > > If you did research, you likely were tapped into the mother ship, and not what the rest of us are seeing generally out here in gyms and suffering with the practitioners. the you tube videos were right on, generally these characters are what is out there. > > > > > > With all due respect to the few cross fit enthusiasts who have good form, the majority remind me of the dumbed down antics of " body pump " (likely some sort of registered or trade mark) for the women...sigh. > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 12, 2010 Report Posted August 12, 2010 Crossfit has popularized the ideas of training density and General Physical Preparation (GPP) among a large group of people who otherwise probably wouldn't have heard of either concept. And that is a great thing. Training density is an important variable and GPP is also important. So, from that perspective I think it is good. I have steered high school wrestlers to the site for some workout ideas. The bad thing is the concept of 'one size fits all', IMO. Increasing training density should be done in a systematic way and arbitrarily 'fixing' the intensity level isn't a good idea. Poor form and injuries result. Crossfit central also makes some ludicrous claims - such as being the best program for athletes. For example, while it is adequate for most high school wrestlers, varsity and senior wrestlers need something more strenuous and specific to their level of adaptation. However, doing heavy complex movements - focusing on power and olympic lifts - teaching body control and mechanics through gymnastics and manipulating density as a training variable are all good things. The problems are: 1. one size doesn't fit all - and as points out doesn't necessarily fit the training facility either 2. technique is very important for safety and isn't emphasized enough 3. personally, I have some issues with their process for developing affiliates and charging members. My own personal experience was going down to the local Crossfit because I love the idea of a garage type of gym, it is close to my home and it had platforms and training bumpers. I have years of training experience in multiple disciplines, including: 1. Sports specific experience - quite extensive in powerlifting, baseball, hockey, long-distance running and rugby 2. Coaching acreditization in gymnastics, olympic weightlifting, Wado-kai karate, baseball, fastball, rugby, hockey and ringette 3. Experience training wrestlers up to (and including) olympic level 4. Recent degree in kinesiology So I talk to the manager there, who was familiar with me having seen me train in several gyms and being a student at the same time I was. Since I still compete in olympic lifting and until recently in powerlifting when I train in many people notice. I was also fairly well-known as a student - I challenged teachers quite often based on my own reading and experience. Despite that I had to go through their quickstart (expensive) and could only train at certain times doing their workout of the day. I couldn't come into the gym on my own. What was really funny was after telling me all that the guy asked if I would help him with his technique on the olympic lifts (he competes in the Crossfit games). Needless to say - I didn't join. Hobman Saskatoon, Canada On 2010-08-11, at 12:46 PM, casey gallagher wrote: > I would beg to differ that her form wasn't all that bad. Her weight transfers forward onto her toes and her knees move too varus. But yes, a 15 rep bodyweight over head squat is rather impressive. However 15 reps while sacrificing safety and technique is playing with fire. > > Casey Gallagher CSCS > Snohomish, WA USA > > Re: 2 Crossfitters 1 Chalk Bucket > > I know little about Crossfit and have heard it disparaged by Mike Boyle and Gray Cook. However, one day I was looking for a link to show someone what an overhead squat looked like. I found this link. > > qI-WY> > > Any " program " that can get someone to do what they did can't be all bad. Even the form, at least until the final rep or 2 in a few cases looks pretty decent, at least to my unskilled eyes. > > Bob Dannegger > Raleigh, NC > > > > > > > > With all due respect, name the athletes at the national and international level using cross fit. > > > > > > > > > What sports are they competing, and how do they place? > > > > > > > > > More importantly, are they receiving any financial support or endorsements from those who sell cross fit? > > > > > > > > > If you did research, you likely were tapped into the mother ship, and not what the rest of us are seeing generally out here in gyms and suffering with the practitioners. the you tube videos were right on, generally these characters are what is out there. > > > > > > > > > With all due respect to the few cross fit enthusiasts who have good form, the majority remind me of the dumbed down antics of " body pump " (likely some sort of registered or trade mark) for the women...sigh. > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 12, 2010 Report Posted August 12, 2010 , I think you've summed it up quite well. Garrison Mesa, AZ Supertraining From: keith.hobman@... Date: Thu, 12 Aug 2010 08:02:53 -0600 Subject: Re: Re: 2 Crossfitters 1 Chalk Bucket Crossfit has popularized the ideas of training density and General Physical Preparation (GPP) among a large group of people who otherwise probably wouldn't have heard of either concept. And that is a great thing. Training density is an important variable and GPP is also important. So, from that perspective I think it is good. I have steered high school wrestlers to the site for some workout ideas. The bad thing is the concept of 'one size fits all', IMO. Increasing training density should be done in a systematic way and arbitrarily 'fixing' the intensity level isn't a good idea. Poor form and injuries result. Crossfit central also makes some ludicrous claims - such as being the best program for athletes. For example, while it is adequate for most high school wrestlers, varsity and senior wrestlers need something more strenuous and specific to their level of adaptation. However, doing heavy complex movements - focusing on power and olympic lifts - teaching body control and mechanics through gymnastics and manipulating density as a training variable are all good things. The problems are: 1. one size doesn't fit all - and as points out doesn't necessarily fit the training facility either 2. technique is very important for safety and isn't emphasized enough 3. personally, I have some issues with their process for developing affiliates and charging members. My own personal experience was going down to the local Crossfit because I love the idea of a garage type of gym, it is close to my home and it had platforms and training bumpers. I have years of training experience in multiple disciplines, including: 1. Sports specific experience - quite extensive in powerlifting, baseball, hockey, long-distance running and rugby 2. Coaching acreditization in gymnastics, olympic weightlifting, Wado-kai karate, baseball, fastball, rugby, hockey and ringette 3. Experience training wrestlers up to (and including) olympic level 4. Recent degree in kinesiology So I talk to the manager there, who was familiar with me having seen me train in several gyms and being a student at the same time I was. Since I still compete in olympic lifting and until recently in powerlifting when I train in many people notice. I was also fairly well-known as a student - I challenged teachers quite often based on my own reading and experience. Despite that I had to go through their quickstart (expensive) and could only train at certain times doing their workout of the day. I couldn't come into the gym on my own. What was really funny was after telling me all that the guy asked if I would help him with his technique on the olympic lifts (he competes in the Crossfit games). Needless to say - I didn't join. ========================= Quote
Guest guest Posted August 12, 2010 Report Posted August 12, 2010 Haha, I will admit that is a bit of a funny story, . " Yea, pay us the fee then help us out. " But I will say I agree with pretty much the entire post. I have no problem with the concepts of CrossFit, particularly for the general population simply looking to get in better shape. And the complexity of movements is certainly something I think a lot of people's training could benefit from, if progressed properly. However, as has been stated, proper care and caution is not always taken to make sure these progressions are followed (a problem not limited to CrossFit). Brock Leggins Norwalk, IA Ultimateathletedevelopment.com Sent from my U.S. Cellular BlackBerry® smartphone Re: Re: 2 Crossfitters 1 Chalk Bucket Crossfit has popularized the ideas of training density and General Physical Preparation (GPP) among a large group of people who otherwise probably wouldn't have heard of either concept. And that is a great thing. Training density is an important variable and GPP is also important. So, from that perspective I think it is good. I have steered high school wrestlers to the site for some workout ideas. The bad thing is the concept of 'one size fits all', IMO. Increasing training density should be done in a systematic way and arbitrarily 'fixing' the intensity level isn't a good idea. Poor form and injuries result. Crossfit central also makes some ludicrous claims - such as being the best program for athletes. For example, while it is adequate for most high school wrestlers, varsity and senior wrestlers need something more strenuous and specific to their level of adaptation. However, doing heavy complex movements - focusing on power and olympic lifts - teaching body control and mechanics through gymnastics and manipulating density as a training variable are all good things. The problems are: 1. one size doesn't fit all - and as points out doesn't necessarily fit the training facility either 2. technique is very important for safety and isn't emphasized enough 3. personally, I have some issues with their process for developing affiliates and charging members. My own personal experience was going down to the local Crossfit because I love the idea of a garage type of gym, it is close to my home and it had platforms and training bumpers. I have years of training experience in multiple disciplines, including: 1. Sports specific experience - quite extensive in powerlifting, baseball, hockey, long-distance running and rugby 2. Coaching acreditization in gymnastics, olympic weightlifting, Wado-kai karate, baseball, fastball, rugby, hockey and ringette 3. Experience training wrestlers up to (and including) olympic level 4. Recent degree in kinesiology So I talk to the manager there, who was familiar with me having seen me train in several gyms and being a student at the same time I was. Since I still compete in olympic lifting and until recently in powerlifting when I train in many people notice. I was also fairly well-known as a student - I challenged teachers quite often based on my own reading and experience. Despite that I had to go through their quickstart (expensive) and could only train at certain times doing their workout of the day. I couldn't come into the gym on my own. What was really funny was after telling me all that the guy asked if I would help him with his technique on the olympic lifts (he competes in the Crossfit games). Needless to say - I didn't join. Hobman Saskatoon, Canada On 2010-08-11, at 12:46 PM, casey gallagher wrote: > I would beg to differ that her form wasn't all that bad. Her weight transfers forward onto her toes and her knees move too varus. But yes, a 15 rep bodyweight over head squat is rather impressive. However 15 reps while sacrificing safety and technique is playing with fire. > > Casey Gallagher CSCS > Snohomish, WA USA > > Re: 2 Crossfitters 1 Chalk Bucket > > I know little about Crossfit and have heard it disparaged by Mike Boyle and Gray Cook. However, one day I was looking for a link to show someone what an overhead squat looked like. I found this link. > > qI-WY> > > Any " program " that can get someone to do what they did can't be all bad. Even the form, at least until the final rep or 2 in a few cases looks pretty decent, at least to my unskilled eyes. > > Bob Dannegger > Raleigh, NC > > > > > > > > With all due respect, name the athletes at the national and international level using cross fit. > > > > > > > > > What sports are they competing, and how do they place? > > > > > > > > > More importantly, are they receiving any financial support or endorsements from those who sell cross fit? > > > > > > > > > If you did research, you likely were tapped into the mother ship, and not what the rest of us are seeing generally out here in gyms and suffering with the practitioners. the you tube videos were right on, generally these characters are what is out there. > > > > > > > > > With all due respect to the few cross fit enthusiasts who have good form, the majority remind me of the dumbed down antics of " body pump " (likely some sort of registered or trade mark) for the women...sigh. > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.