Guest guest Posted March 3, 2010 Report Posted March 3, 2010 ambyb wrote: > I've noticed a number of articles recently that seem to case doubts > on the utility of many core strength exercises. I'm curious if anyone > has thoughts or other experiences with this subject. To be an > effective use of anyone's time, I would expect an exercise to either: > (A) improve performance; or ( improve health, ie, reduce injuries. > Does core strength training do either of these better than other > exercises might? For example, one of the cited articles implies that > traditional, high resistance strength training might be better for > core development than most popular core exercises. Sounds reasonable > to me. Your thoughts? Rippetoe writes on this point : http://startingstrength.com/articles/core_stability_rippetoe.pdf It is a matter of pride to me that I can go through an entire weekend seminar without once using the “C”-word. Out of a concern for my participants and my reputation I fastidiously avoid using the term “core” when referring to the trunk musculature or the stability thereof. I am so utterly goddamn tired of hearing about the “core” from members of the lay public, infomercialers, doctors, PTs, ATCs, personal trainers, and strength coaches that as a form of protest I refuse to use the term at all. That is why it will appear in this article only in scare quotes. “Core.” “Core,” dammit. The “core” is the collection of muscles that stabilize the spine. It is composed of all of the abs, the three layers of the side abdominal wall, the posterior spinal muscles, the pelvic floor muscles, the hip flexors, and actually the diaphragm and the intercostals, although that may be working a little too far north. These muscles work together to control spinal position, which normally means keeping the spine rigid during work that involves force generated by the hips and legs and transferred through the trunk to a resistance at the hands, or in the specific training situation created by the squat, on the back or shoulders. The “core” muscles maintain the intervertebral relationships that allow the spine to both transfer force and remain uninjured in the process. They are extremely important in all sports, especially the barbell sports, and that is why I have an interest in this topic. The problem with the concept of training specifically for “core” stabilization is that it doesn’t make any sense. Leaving aside the arguments for using it to prevent back pain in sedentary populations (everybody that doesn’t have a “stable core” has back pain?), it proceeds from several ridiculous assumptions, and it is completely inapplicable to an athlete who is training properly on a basic barbell program. While it is absolutely true that all movements in sports that involve a ground reaction – a movement involving the feet generating power against the ground while the body, usually through the hands, applies it to a resistance – utilize the pelvic and trunk musculature to stabilize the spine during the movement, there is nothing magical about this part of the muscular anatomy that causes it to function as anything but a normal link in the kinetic chain. The “motor” is the hips and legs and the “transmission” is the spine. Without a big motor, the transmission has nothing hard to do. The spine is important, and therefore its stability is important; when the whole system is loaded, the motor and the transmission adapt together at the same time. The entire kinetic chain is developed by barbell training because squats, deadlifts, presses, and the Olympic lifts utilize the entire kinetic chain – and therefore strengthen the entire kinetic chain in the same way you’re going to use it........ I am puzzled that anyone who has actually gone through the process of getting strong themselves actually thinks that this approach to training really causes an improvement in athletic performance. Unless a person is an unadapted rank novice (for whom anything acts as an adaptive stimulus) or a genetic freak (for whom ineffective silly shit like 5 lb. Alternate Dumbbell Presses while standing on a Bosu® thingee) will not adversely affect an already elite performance (as said athlete will confirm when asked by somebody other than his coach), “core stability” training is an absolute waste of time that could be much better spent getting stronger – and therefore more stable – in much more effective ways. Any person who has first-hand experience with both heavy barbell training and fooling around at the physical therapist’s office knows this to be true. And most importantly of all, this is actually the way the vast majority of the drivel that composes modern exercise “science” gets promulgated: people with no personal experience with the process of getting much stronger begin to hold forth on a method they like, one that seems like it ought to work. They try it on untrained populations, who – not terribly surprisingly – get better than they were before. They write about it in a peer-reviewed journal (whose reviewers are all publishing in the same journal) or on the internet. Time goes by, and a brand-new training system is born. Sound familiar? I hope so. Learn to evaluate before you end up wasting precious time..... Carl Brewer Melbourne, Australia Quote
Guest guest Posted March 4, 2010 Report Posted March 4, 2010 Amby Burfoot wrote: I've noticed a number of articles recently that seem to case doubts on the utility of many core strength exercises. I'm curious if anyone has thoughts or other experiences with this subject. To be an effective use of anyone's time, I would expect an exercise to either: (A) improve performance; or ( improve health, ie, reduce injuries. Does core strength training do either of these better than other exercises might? For example, one of the cited articles implies that traditional, high resistance strength training might be better for core development than most popular core exercises. Sounds reasonable to me. Your thoughts? ----- Amy, The evidence (empirical as well as a growing body of research) seems to indicate that the core is best trained in the same way as other body parts or muscle groups: by getting on our feet and moving. Popular 'core training' exercises are probably still useful in a supplemental role. However many folks use them in a primary role, diverting time and effort away from activities that are more effective/efficient. Core training has grown into a cottage industry that does seem to do a couple things very well: It provides the koolaid that many people want and enriches the people serving it. Regards, Plisk Excelsior Sports •Shelton CT www.excelsiorsports.com Prepare To Be A Champion! Quote
Guest guest Posted March 4, 2010 Report Posted March 4, 2010 Interesting post Carl.....another way to look at this topic....I thoroughly enjoyed the perspective Bill Hawkins Ohio > I've noticed a number of articles recently that seem to case doubts > on the utility of many core strength exercises. I'm curious if anyone > has thoughts or other experiences with this subject. To be an > effective use of anyone's time, I would expect an exercise to either: > (A) improve performance; or ( improve health, ie, reduce injuries. > Does core strength training do either of these better than other > exercises might? For example, one of the cited articles implies that > traditional, high resistance strength training might be better for > core development than most popular core exercises. Sounds reasonable > to me. Your thoughts? Rippetoe writes on this point : http://startingstre ngth.com/ articles/ core_stability_ rippetoe. pdf It is a matter of pride to me that I can go through an entire weekend seminar without once using the “Câ€-word. Out of a concern for my participants and my reputation I fastidiously avoid using the term “core†when referring to the trunk musculature or the stability thereof. I am so utterly goddamn tired of hearing about the “core†from members of the lay public, infomercialers, doctors, PTs, ATCs, personal trainers, and strength coaches that as a form of protest I refuse to use the term at all. That is why it will appear in this article only in scare quotes. “Core.†“Core,†dammit. The “core†is the collection of muscles that stabilize the spine. It is composed of all of the abs, the three layers of the side abdominal wall, the posterior spinal muscles, the pelvic floor muscles, the hip flexors, and actually the diaphragm and the intercostals, although that may be working a little too far north. These muscles work together to control spinal position, which normally means keeping the spine rigid during work that involves force generated by the hips and legs and transferred through the trunk to a resistance at the hands, or in the specific training situation created by the squat, on the back or shoulders. The “core†muscles maintain the intervertebral relationships that allow the spine to both transfer force and remain uninjured in the process. They are extremely important in all sports, especially the barbell sports, and that is why I have an interest in this topic. The problem with the concept of training specifically for “core†stabilization is that it doesn’t make any sense. Leaving aside the arguments for using it to prevent back pain in sedentary populations (everybody that doesn’t have a “stable core†has back pain?), it proceeds from several ridiculous assumptions, and it is completely inapplicable to an athlete who is training properly on a basic barbell program. While it is absolutely true that all movements in sports that involve a ground reaction – a movement involving the feet generating power against the ground while the body, usually through the hands, applies it to a resistance – utilize the pelvic and trunk musculature to stabilize the spine during the movement, there is nothing magical about this part of the muscular anatomy that causes it to function as anything but a normal link in the kinetic chain. The “motor†is the hips and legs and the “transmission†is the spine. Without a big motor, the transmission has nothing hard to do. The spine is important, and therefore its stability is important; when the whole system is loaded, the motor and the transmission adapt together at the same time. The entire kinetic chain is developed by barbell training because squats, deadlifts, presses, and the Olympic lifts utilize the entire kinetic chain – and therefore strengthen the entire kinetic chain in the same way you’re going to use it........ I am puzzled that anyone who has actually gone through the process of getting strong themselves actually thinks that this approach to training really causes an improvement in athletic performance. Unless a person is an unadapted rank novice (for whom anything acts as an adaptive stimulus) or a genetic freak (for whom ineffective silly shit like 5 lb. Alternate Dumbbell Presses while standing on a Bosu® thingee) will not adversely affect an already elite performance (as said athlete will confirm when asked by somebody other than his coach), “core stability†training is an absolute waste of time that could be much better spent getting stronger – and therefore more stable – in much more effective ways. Any person who has first-hand experience with both heavy barbell training and fooling around at the physical therapist’s office knows this to be true. And most importantly of all, this is actually the way the vast majority of the drivel that composes modern exercise “science†gets promulgated: people with no personal experience with the process of getting much stronger begin to hold forth on a method they like, one that seems like it ought to work. They try it on untrained populations, who – not terribly surprisingly – get better than they were before. They write about it in a peer-reviewed journal (whose reviewers are all publishing in the same journal) or on the internet. Time goes by, and a brand-new training system is born. Sound familiar? I hope so. Learn to evaluate before you end up wasting precious time..... Carl Brewer Melbourne, Australia Quote
Guest guest Posted March 4, 2010 Report Posted March 4, 2010 The whole article from Rippetoe is quite good and entertaining. I have been going round and round with a client as to why we don't do isolation abdominal specific exercises. I've given her many articles and reports on the matter and she still doesn't get it. Casey Gallagher CSCS Snohomish, WA USA Re: What does core strength training achieve? Interesting post Carl.....another way to look at this topic....I thoroughly enjoyed the perspective Bill Hawkins Ohio > I've noticed a number of articles recently that seem to case doubts > on the utility of many core strength exercises. I'm curious if anyone > has thoughts or other experiences with this subject. To be an > effective use of anyone's time, I would expect an exercise to either: > (A) improve performance; or ( improve health, ie, reduce injuries. > Does core strength training do either of these better than other > exercises might? For example, one of the cited articles implies that > traditional, high resistance strength training might be better for > core development than most popular core exercises. Sounds reasonable > to me. Your thoughts? Rippetoe writes on this point : http://startingstre<http://startingstre/> ngth.com/ articles/ core_stability_ rippetoe. pdf It is a matter of pride to me that I can go through an entire weekend seminar without once using the “Câ€-word. Out of a concern for my participants and my reputation I fastidiously avoid using the term “core†when referring to the trunk musculature or the stability thereof. I am so utterly goddamn tired of hearing about the “core†from members of the lay public, infomercialers, doctors, PTs, ATCs, personal trainers, and strength coaches that as a form of protest I refuse to use the term at all. That is why it will appear in this article only in scare quotes. “Core.†“Core,†dammit. The “core†is the collection of muscles that stabilize the spine. It is composed of all of the abs, the three layers of the side abdominal wall, the posterior spinal muscles, the pelvic floor muscles, the hip flexors, and actually the diaphragm and the intercostals, although that may be working a little too far north. These muscles work together to control spinal position, which normally means keeping the spine rigid during work that involves force generated by the hips and legs and transferred through the trunk to a resistance at the hands, or in the specific training situation created by the squat, on the back or shoulders. The “core†muscles maintain the intervertebral relationships that allow the spine to both transfer force and remain uninjured in the process. They are extremely important in all sports, especially the barbell sports, and that is why I have an interest in this topic. The problem with the concept of training specifically for “core†stabilization is that it doesn’t make any sense. Leaving aside the arguments for using it to prevent back pain in sedentary populations (everybody that doesn’t have a “stable core†has back pain?), it proceeds from several ridiculous assumptions, and it is completely inapplicable to an athlete who is training properly on a basic barbell program. While it is absolutely true that all movements in sports that involve a ground reaction – a movement involving the feet generating power against the ground while the body, usually through the hands, applies it to a resistance – utilize the pelvic and trunk musculature to stabilize the spine during the movement, there is nothing magical about this part of the muscular anatomy that causes it to function as anything but a normal link in the kinetic chain. The “motor†is the hips and legs and the “transmission†is the spine. Without a big motor, the transmission has nothing hard to do. The spine is important, and therefore its stability is important; when the whole system is loaded, the motor and the transmission adapt together at the same time. The entire kinetic chain is developed by barbell training because squats, deadlifts, presses, and the Olympic lifts utilize the entire kinetic chain – and therefore strengthen the entire kinetic chain in the same way you’re going to use it........ I am puzzled that anyone who has actually gone through the process of getting strong themselves actually thinks that this approach to training really causes an improvement in athletic performance. Unless a person is an unadapted rank novice (for whom anything acts as an adaptive stimulus) or a genetic freak (for whom ineffective silly shit like 5 lb. Alternate Dumbbell Presses while standing on a Bosu® thingee) will not adversely affect an already elite performance (as said athlete will confirm when asked by somebody other than his coach), “core stability†training is an absolute waste of time that could be much better spent getting stronger – and therefore more stable – in much more effective ways. Any person who has first-hand experience with both heavy barbell training and fooling around at the physical therapist’s office knows this to be true. And most importantly of all, this is actually the way the vast majority of the drivel that composes modern exercise “science†gets promulgated: people with no personal experience with the process of getting much stronger begin to hold forth on a method they like, one that seems like it ought to work. They try it on untrained populations, who – not terribly surprisingly – get better than they were before. They write about it in a peer-reviewed journal (whose reviewers are all publishing in the same journal) or on the internet. Time goes by, and a brand-new training system is born. Sound familiar? I hope so. Learn to evaluate before you end up wasting precious time..... Carl Brewer Melbourne, Australia Quote
Guest guest Posted March 4, 2010 Report Posted March 4, 2010 THAT was AWESOME! It's kinda weird in that it's almost " taboo " to challenge the " core " mindset in this way. It's the cult of core. Thanks! Bill Cahall Dayton, Ohio ________________________________ From: Carl Brewer <carl@...> Supertraining Sent: Wed, March 3, 2010 4:02:04 PM Subject: Re: What does core strength training achieve? ambyb wrote: > I've noticed a number of articles recently that seem to case doubts > on the utility of many core strength exercises. I'm curious if anyone > has thoughts or other experiences with this subject. To be an > effective use of anyone's time, I would expect an exercise to either: > (A) improve performance; or ( improve health, ie, reduce injuries. > Does core strength training do either of these better than other > exercises might? For example, one of the cited articles implies that > traditional, high resistance strength training might be better for > core development than most popular core exercises. Sounds reasonable > to me. Your thoughts? Rippetoe writes on this point : http://startingstre ngth.com/ articles/ core_stability_ rippetoe. pdf It is a matter of pride to me that I can go through an entire weekend seminar without once using the “Câ€-word. Out of a concern for my participants and my reputation I fastidiously avoid using the term “core†when referring to the trunk musculature or the stability thereof. I am so utterly goddamn tired of hearing about the “core†from members of the lay public, infomercialers, doctors, PTs, ATCs, personal trainers, and strength coaches that as a form of protest I refuse to use the term at all. That is why it will appear in this article only in scare quotes. “Core.†“Core,†dammit. The “core†is the collection of muscles that stabilize the spine. It is composed of all of the abs, the three layers of the side abdominal wall, the posterior spinal muscles, the pelvic floor muscles, the hip flexors, and actually the diaphragm and the intercostals, although that may be working a little too far north. These muscles work together to control spinal position, which normally means keeping the spine rigid during work that involves force generated by the hips and legs and transferred through the trunk to a resistance at the hands, or in the specific training situation created by the squat, on the back or shoulders. The “core†muscles maintain the intervertebral relationships that allow the spine to both transfer force and remain uninjured in the process. They are extremely important in all sports, especially the barbell sports, and that is why I have an interest in this topic. The problem with the concept of training specifically for “core†stabilization is that it doesn’t make any sense. Leaving aside the arguments for using it to prevent back pain in sedentary populations (everybody that doesn’t have a “stable core†has back pain?), it proceeds from several ridiculous assumptions, and it is completely inapplicable to an athlete who is training properly on a basic barbell program. While it is absolutely true that all movements in sports that involve a ground reaction – a movement involving the feet generating power against the ground while the body, usually through the hands, applies it to a resistance – utilize the pelvic and trunk musculature to stabilize the spine during the movement, there is nothing magical about this part of the muscular anatomy that causes it to function as anything but a normal link in the kinetic chain. The “motor†is the hips and legs and the “transmission†is the spine. Without a big motor, the transmission has nothing hard to do. The spine is important, and therefore its stability is important; when the whole system is loaded, the motor and the transmission adapt together at the same time. The entire kinetic chain is developed by barbell training because squats, deadlifts, presses, and the Olympic lifts utilize the entire kinetic chain – and therefore strengthen the entire kinetic chain in the same way you’re going to use it........ I am puzzled that anyone who has actually gone through the process of getting strong themselves actually thinks that this approach to training really causes an improvement in athletic performance. Unless a person is an unadapted rank novice (for whom anything acts as an adaptive stimulus) or a genetic freak (for whom ineffective silly shit like 5 lb. Alternate Dumbbell Presses while standing on a Bosu® thingee) will not adversely affect an already elite performance (as said athlete will confirm when asked by somebody other than his coach), “core stability†training is an absolute waste of time that could be much better spent getting stronger – and therefore more stable – in much more effective ways. Any person who has first-hand experience with both heavy barbell training and fooling around at the physical therapist’s office knows this to be true. And most importantly of all, this is actually the way the vast majority of the drivel that composes modern exercise “science†gets promulgated: people with no personal experience with the process of getting much stronger begin to hold forth on a method they like, one that seems like it ought to work. They try it on untrained populations, who – not terribly surprisingly – get better than they were before. They write about it in a peer-reviewed journal (whose reviewers are all publishing in the same journal) or on the internet. Time goes by, and a brand-new training system is born. Sound familiar? I hope so. Learn to evaluate before you end up wasting precious time..... Carl Brewer Melbourne, Australia Quote
Guest guest Posted March 5, 2010 Report Posted March 5, 2010 My 2 cents worth (without ever having done instability core exercises): In hindsight I realize I needed to learn how to activate my abs so I could use them effectively for my primary childhood competitive sport (swimming). Back in those days (70's & mid 80's) we did lots of situps. Once I learned how to activate the abs I used them much more for swimming and further strengthened them from swimming alone. About 5-6 years ago I got a Pilates DVD and learned how to activate more of the core muscles, and now I find that I use them even more for swimming and running thereby further strengthening them. Also engage them for the wimpy upper body strength training I do. (overhead press, upward row and bench press) Now when I take a break from swimming and start back up, the first part of me to get sore is the abs. So I think this is like a chicken and egg question. Another point -- from the kids I teach in swim lessons, some have the natural ability to drive their body motion from the " core " but most need to be taught through extra exercises. (try doing dolphin kick on your back for 100 yards in the pool and see how sore your abs get) Gloria Bach Willseyville NY > > > I've noticed a number of articles recently that seem to case doubts on the utility of many core strength exercises. I'm curious if anyone has thoughts or other experiences with this subject. To be an effective use of anyone's time, I would expect an exercise to either: (A) improve performance; or ( improve health, ie, reduce injuries. Does core strength training do either of these better than other exercises might? For example, one of the cited articles implies that traditional, high resistance strength training might be better for core development than most popular core exercises. Sounds reasonable to me. Your thoughts? > > Myth of core > http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20006294 > > Core maybe good for back, but max strength better otherwise > http://article.pubs.nrc-cnrc.gc.ca/RPAS/rpv?hm=HInit & calyLang=eng & journal=apnm & v\ olume=35 & afpf=h09-127.pdf > > Running beats curl up and back extension exercise for trunk muscle activation > http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20029508 > > Core doesn't contribute to strength/power of soccer players > http://faculty.css.edu/tboone2/asep/JEPonlineNesserApril2009.pdf > > Core does improve 5K runners speed, not lower leg stability > http://journals.lww.com/nsca-jscr/Abstract/2009/01000/Does_Core_Strength_Trainin\ g_Influence_Running.22.aspx > > Amby Burfoot, Runner's World > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 5, 2010 Report Posted March 5, 2010 I'm a big fan of Rippetoe and rank his book as my #1 for getting the foundation of form and programming. I'm unconvinced though that weight training is enough to completely strengthen the core, but perhaps it's adequate to keep getting strong and participating in the sports your training for at least through your 20's. Now I'm not a big fan of the " core " agenda and have no interest in balance boards or bosu ball jumping jacks. What I do question is since I do all my OH presses standing, do bb squats to parallel, and deadlifts with perfect form than as others have stated my core should be good to go. Now just 2 weeks ago I started back with Pilates and signed up for beginners level since I've been away. It is incredibly hard for me to pull of an hours worth of mostly beginners moves when in the past I've been able to do advanced classes when I was a regular with it. So with weight lifting and minimal ab work(knee raises, planks, etc) shouldn't I have been able to at least handle the basics with weightlifting keeping my core strong. I'm not a nut about it but I'm definitely wondering why I'm struggling much. I'm taking Pilates to reduce/eliminate my low back pain so that I can keep lifting weights and increasing the weight. Pilates has effectively reduced or eliminated it in the past though it takes about 3 months to achieve. My plan going forward it to supplement it at least once a week to keep the weights going on. At 33 my flexibility in my hams and psoas has always been a project so that's part of it. I stretch out after every workout. Maybe there is something lacking in my programming that the Pilates is addressing but for me I think there is undeniable value to putting that in the rotation. Maybe it's just my personal body's need and not something a study would actually back up. Matt Kahl Kenosha, WI Quote
Guest guest Posted March 5, 2010 Report Posted March 5, 2010 Thank you Carl for posting Rippetoe's article. I would love to hear some thoughts on this: In the article Rippetoe takes a quote from the therapists that stated " i-t band syndrome is mostly caused in runners due to a weakness in the glute medius " . Is it just me or is anyone else sick of hearing how improtant the glute medius is and how weak it must be in anyone who has any back, knee, i-t band problems. From my experience and knowledge of the role of the glute medius, in a runner would it not be highly strong because it is used in the support phase as a primary function. I have found it to be week but not because it needs more strengthening but because it is burnt out from being overused and that the glute max is what needs to strengthen to release i-t band syndrome. I had a week glute medius tested by physios in relation to some knee isues I was having, all I got from them was to strengthen it. I was aggressive and did all kinds of strengthening they gave me, knee pain continued for a year or more. I ended up getting some treatments from a world renowned chiropractor and applied kineisiologist and in about one minute after assesing my weak glute medius he explained the limited role it has and how it is getting over emphysised and that what I needed to do was cross friction massage and some adductor strengthening. My knee pain was gone in 2 weeks. I also work with some coaches who blindly follow glute medius warm up or as they say activation, wake up routines. They believe it to be good because quote un-quote elite trainers are using it with pros in there training centers. I guess I just feel that from all the lateral work and linear sprinting athletes do that the glute medius gets enough work. Any thought would be great as I am starting to really ramble on. Thanks everyone Doug Fairbanks Boston, MA ================================== Supertraining From: carl@... Date: Thu, 4 Mar 2010 08:02:04 +1100 Subject: Re: What does core strength training achieve? ambyb wrote: > I've noticed a number of articles recently that seem to case doubts > on the utility of many core strength exercises. I'm curious if anyone > has thoughts or other experiences with this subject. To be an > effective use of anyone's time, I would expect an exercise to either: > (A) improve performance; or ( improve health, ie, reduce injuries. > Does core strength training do either of these better than other > exercises might? For example, one of the cited articles implies that > traditional, high resistance strength training might be better for > core development than most popular core exercises. Sounds reasonable > to me. Your thoughts? Rippetoe writes on this point : http://startingstrength.com/articles/core_stability_rippetoe.pdf It is a matter of pride to me that I can go through an entire weekend seminar without once using the “C”-word. Out of a concern for my participants and my reputation I fastidiously avoid using the term “core” when referring to the trunk musculature or the stability thereof. I am so utterly goddamn tired of hearing about the “core” from members of the lay public, infomercialers, doctors, PTs, ATCs, personal trainers, and strength coaches that as a form of protest I refuse to use the term at all. That is why it will appear in this article only in scare quotes. “Core.” “Core,” dammit. The “core” is the collection of muscles that stabilize the spine. It is composed of all of the abs, the three layers of the side abdominal wall, the posterior spinal muscles, the pelvic floor muscles, the hip flexors, and actually the diaphragm and the intercostals, although that may be working a little too far north. These muscles work together to control spinal position, which normally means keeping the spine rigid during work that involves force generated by the hips and legs and transferred through the trunk to a resistance at the hands, or in the specific training situation created by the squat, on the back or shoulders. The “core” muscles maintain the intervertebral relationships that allow the spine to both transfer force and remain uninjured in the process. They are extremely important in all sports, especially the barbell sports, and that is why I have an interest in this topic. The problem with the concept of training specifically for “core” stabilization is that it doesn’t make any sense. Leaving aside the arguments for using it to prevent back pain in sedentary populations (everybody that doesn’t have a “stable core” has back pain?), it proceeds from several ridiculous assumptions, and it is completely inapplicable to an athlete who is training properly on a basic barbell program. While it is absolutely true that all movements in sports that involve a ground reaction – a movement involving the feet generating power against the ground while the body, usually through the hands, applies it to a resistance – utilize the pelvic and trunk musculature to stabilize the spine during the movement, there is nothing magical about this part of the muscular anatomy that causes it to function as anything but a normal link in the kinetic chain. The “motor” is the hips and legs and the “transmission” is the spine. Without a big motor, the transmission has nothing hard to do. The spine is important, and therefore its stability is important; when the whole system is loaded, the motor and the transmission adapt together at the same time. The entire kinetic chain is developed by barbell training because squats, deadlifts, presses, and the Olympic lifts utilize the entire kinetic chain – and therefore strengthen the entire kinetic chain in the same way you’re going to use it........ I am puzzled that anyone who has actually gone through the process of getting strong themselves actually thinks that this approach to training really causes an improvement in athletic performance. Unless a person is an unadapted rank novice (for whom anything acts as an adaptive stimulus) or a genetic freak (for whom ineffective silly shit like 5 lb. Alternate Dumbbell Presses while standing on a Bosu® thingee) will not adversely affect an already elite performance (as said athlete will confirm when asked by somebody other than his coach), “core stability” training is an absolute waste of time that could be much better spent getting stronger – and therefore more stable – in much more effective ways. Any person who has first-hand experience with both heavy barbell training and fooling around at the physical therapist’s office knows this to be true. And most importantly of all, this is actually the way the vast majority of the drivel that composes modern exercise “science” gets promulgated: people with no personal experience with the process of getting much stronger begin to hold forth on a method they like, one that seems like it ought to work. They try it on untrained populations, who – not terribly surprisingly – get better than they were before. They write about it in a peer-reviewed journal (whose reviewers are all publishing in the same journal) or on the internet. Time goes by, and a brand-new training system is born. Sound familiar? I hope so. Learn to evaluate before you end up wasting precious time..... =========================== Quote
Guest guest Posted March 5, 2010 Report Posted March 5, 2010 Hi Matt, This is my first post on this forum,and I think its great I too am a big fan of Rippetoe,but soley in the realm of weight training.He is excellent within his universe,but refuses to take a step outside of it.Thats neither good nor bad,but it certainly does not leave open the possibilities for other modalities being very valuable in our training.. I was introduced to Pilates after hernating my L-4/5 after years of karate and a shorter stint at BJJ.I had always lifted and trained with intensity,but was actually clueless as to " moving from my center " and and understanding the structural integration of the human body. To make a long story short,I have devoted full time to training and teaching Pilates,and I am 100% convinced that weight training is not enough to build a strong functional core.In no way does that discredit olympic style/powerlifting lifting,but strength has many different applications and no single approach can encompass all. Mark and I have " debated " this topic at length.In my world I look at " core strength " in a gymnastic type framework,while Mark feels the ability to support and move massive weights as the ultimate indicator. Who is right?I think it is really a matter of perspective.. What I do know,is what you have experienced.Pilates type movements is something my body needs,and I train several world class/pro athletes who come to me for the very reason.FYI,I do not drink the Pilates kool-aid,and I have spoken to Stuart McGill regarding Pilates type training,hoping to back it up with some emperical evidence.. Anyway,keep up the lifting and stick with the Pilates!!!!! Allan Sag Harbor,NY > > I'm a big fan of Rippetoe and rank his book as my #1 for getting the > foundation of form and programming. I'm unconvinced though that weight > training is enough to completely strengthen the core, but perhaps it's > adequate to keep getting strong and participating in the sports your > training for at least through your 20's. Now I'm not a big fan of the > " core " agenda and have no interest in balance boards or bosu ball > jumping jacks. What I do question is since I do all my OH presses > standing, do bb squats to parallel, and deadlifts with perfect form than > as others have stated my core should be good to go. Now just 2 weeks > ago I started back with Pilates and signed up for beginners level since > I've been away. It is incredibly hard for me to pull of an hours worth > of mostly beginners moves when in the past I've been able to do advanced > classes when I was a regular with it. So with weight lifting and > minimal ab work(knee raises, planks, etc) shouldn't I have been able to > at least handle the basics with weightlifting keeping my core strong. > I'm not a nut about it but I'm definitely wondering why I'm struggling > much. I'm taking Pilates to reduce/eliminate my low back pain so that I > can keep lifting weights and increasing the weight. Pilates has > effectively reduced or eliminated it in the past though it takes about 3 > months to achieve. My plan going forward it to supplement it at least > once a week to keep the weights going on. At 33 my flexibility in my > hams and psoas has always been a project so that's part of it. I > stretch out after every workout. Maybe there is something lacking in my > programming that the Pilates is addressing but for me I think there is > undeniable value to putting that in the rotation. Maybe it's just my > personal body's need and not something a study would actually back up. > > Matt Kahl > Kenosha, WI > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 5, 2010 Report Posted March 5, 2010 My thoughts on the gluteus medius is that it is a pelvic stabilizer. After toe off and during the swing phase the opposite side gluteus medius (and TFL) contracts to keep the ASIS parallel to the ground. Most therapists and such use open kinetic chain movements to strengthen the gluteus medius. However the glute med. is contracted while the non-swinging leg is on the ground. Closed kinetic chain movements might do a better job strengthening the glute med. in a more " functional " manor. These would be in-line lunges with , step ups, single leg deadlifts and so on bi-lateral or ipsilateral resistance where one focuses on keeping the knee in line with the toe and the pelvis " square " to the floor. Casey Gallagher CSCS Snohomish WA, USA Re: What does core strength training achieve? ambyb wrote: > I've noticed a number of articles recently that seem to case doubts > on the utility of many core strength exercises. I'm curious if anyone > has thoughts or other experiences with this subject. To be an > effective use of anyone's time, I would expect an exercise to either: > (A) improve performance; or ( improve health, ie, reduce injuries. > Does core strength training do either of these better than other > exercises might? For example, one of the cited articles implies that > traditional, high resistance strength training might be better for > core development than most popular core exercises. Sounds reasonable > to me. Your thoughts? Rippetoe writes on this point : http://startingstrength.com/articles/core_stability_rippetoe.pdf<http://starting\ strength.com/articles/core_stability_rippetoe.pdf> It is a matter of pride to me that I can go through an entire weekend seminar without once using the " C " -word. Out of a concern for my participants and my reputation I fastidiously avoid using the term " core " when referring to the trunk musculature or the stability thereof. I am so utterly goddamn tired of hearing about the " core " from members of the lay public, infomercialers, doctors, PTs, ATCs, personal trainers, and strength coaches that as a form of protest I refuse to use the term at all. That is why it will appear in this article only in scare quotes. " Core. " " Core, " dammit. The " core " is the collection of muscles that stabilize the spine. It is composed of all of the abs, the three layers of the side abdominal wall, the posterior spinal muscles, the pelvic floor muscles, the hip flexors, and actually the diaphragm and the intercostals, although that may be working a little too far north. These muscles work together to control spinal position, which normally means keeping the spine rigid during work that involves force generated by the hips and legs and transferred through the trunk to a resistance at the hands, or in the specific training situation created by the squat, on the back or shoulders. The " core " muscles maintain the intervertebral relationships that allow the spine to both transfer force and remain uninjured in the process. They are extremely important in all sports, especially the barbell sports, and that is why I have an interest in this topic. The problem with the concept of training specifically for " core " stabilization is that it doesn't make any sense. Leaving aside the arguments for using it to prevent back pain in sedentary populations (everybody that doesn't have a " stable core " has back pain?), it proceeds from several ridiculous assumptions, and it is completely inapplicable to an athlete who is training properly on a basic barbell program. While it is absolutely true that all movements in sports that involve a ground reaction - a movement involving the feet generating power against the ground while the body, usually through the hands, applies it to a resistance - utilize the pelvic and trunk musculature to stabilize the spine during the movement, there is nothing magical about this part of the muscular anatomy that causes it to function as anything but a normal link in the kinetic chain. The " motor " is the hips and legs and the " transmission " is the spine. Without a big motor, the transmission has nothing hard to do. The spine is important, and therefore its stability is important; when the whole system is loaded, the motor and the transmission adapt together at the same time. The entire kinetic chain is developed by barbell training because squats, deadlifts, presses, and the Olympic lifts utilize the entire kinetic chain - and therefore strengthen the entire kinetic chain in the same way you're going to use it........ I am puzzled that anyone who has actually gone through the process of getting strong themselves actually thinks that this approach to training really causes an improvement in athletic performance. Unless a person is an unadapted rank novice (for whom anything acts as an adaptive stimulus) or a genetic freak (for whom ineffective silly shit like 5 lb. Alternate Dumbbell Presses while standing on a Bosu® thingee) will not adversely affect an already elite performance (as said athlete will confirm when asked by somebody other than his coach), " core stability " training is an absolute waste of time that could be much better spent getting stronger - and therefore more stable - in much more effective ways. Any person who has first-hand experience with both heavy barbell training and fooling around at the physical therapist's office knows this to be true. And most importantly of all, this is actually the way the vast majority of the drivel that composes modern exercise " science " gets promulgated: people with no personal experience with the process of getting much stronger begin to hold forth on a method they like, one that seems like it ought to work. They try it on untrained populations, who - not terribly surprisingly - get better than they were before. They write about it in a peer-reviewed journal (whose reviewers are all publishing in the same journal) or on the internet. Time goes by, and a brand-new training system is born. Sound familiar? I hope so. Learn to evaluate before you end up wasting precious time..... =========================== ------------------------------------ Modify/cancel your subscription at: mygroups<mygroups> Sign all letters with full name & city of residence if you wish them to be published! Quote
Guest guest Posted March 5, 2010 Report Posted March 5, 2010 Sigh. I was 1 of the rare lifters who got IT band syndrome. I never had a weak glute....and I had more than a little patellar tendinosis to go with the IT band issue. What eventually cured mine is a combo of ice, massage therapy, and deadlift. Avoiding the PL squat for the initial stretch, sigh. i.e. nothing below parallel there....and when I did resume squatting, limiting my weights and my sets. Working for form, not training squat as aggressively. I did get good results on the platform, no personal bests on squat but respectable. The irony of all this focus on glutes is that it's far from a weak point on me. From my experience, IT band syndrome is not something from a weak glute. I got mine from using a leg press, loaded pretty heavy, and having my foot position too close together for sets of 8. One mistake in positioning and I could barely walk for 10 days...and worried I'd done more than a bit of something there. I'm not surprised yours improved from the leg flapper machines. I've been suggesting people use them for fixing IT band syndrome for years now - along with squatting high - until the item is better - and full deadlifts to help rebalance the whole posterior chain. Few lifters get this syndrome, but the ones that do can sort themselves with patience. The Phantom aka Schaefer, RMT/CMT, competing powerlifter Denver, Colorado, USA Re: What does core strength training achieve? ambyb wrote: > I've noticed a number of articles recently that seem to case doubts > on the utility of many core strength exercises. I'm curious if anyone > has thoughts or other experiences with this subject. To be an > effective use of anyone's time, I would expect an exercise to either: > (A) improve performance; or ( improve health, ie, reduce injuries. > Does core strength training do either of these better than other > exercises might? For example, one of the cited articles implies that > traditional, high resistance strength training might be better for > core development than most popular core exercises. Sounds reasonable > to me. Your thoughts? Rippetoe writes on this point : http://startingstrength.com/articles/core_stability_rippetoe.pdf It is a matter of pride to me that I can go through an entire weekend seminar without once using the �C�-word. Out of a concern for my participants and my reputation I fastidiously avoid using the term �core� when referring to the trunk musculature or the stability thereof. I am so utterly goddamn tired of hearing about the �core� from members of the lay public, infomercialers, doctors, PTs, ATCs, personal trainers, and strength coaches that as a form of protest I refuse to use the term at all. That is why it will appear in this article only in scare quotes. �Core.� �Core,� dammit. The �core� is the collection of muscles that stabilize the spine. It is composed of all of the abs, the three layers of the side abdominal wall, the posterior spinal muscles, the pelvic floor muscles, the hip flexors, and actually the diaphragm and the intercostals, although that may be working a little too far north. These muscles work together to control spinal position, which normally means keeping the spine rigid during work that involves force generated by the hips and legs and transferred through the trunk to a resistance at the hands, or in the specific training situation created by the squat, on the back or shoulders. The �core� muscles maintain the intervertebral relationships that allow the spine to both transfer force and remain uninjured in the process. They are extremely important in all sports, especially the barbell sports, and that is why I have an interest in this topic. The problem with the concept of training specifically for �core� stabilization is that it doesn�t make any sense. Leaving aside the arguments for using it to prevent back pain in sedentary populations (everybody that doesn�t have a �stable core� has back pain?), it proceeds from several ridiculous assumptions, and it is completely inapplicable to an athlete who is training properly on a basic barbell program. While it is absolutely true that all movements in sports that involve a ground reaction � a movement involving the feet generating power against the ground while the body, usually through the hands, applies it to a resistance � utilize the pelvic and trunk musculature to stabilize the spine during the movement, there is nothing magical about this part of the muscular anatomy that causes it to function as anything but a normal link in the kinetic chain. The �motor� is the hips and legs and the �transmission� is the spine. Without a big motor, the transmission has nothing hard to do. The spine is important, and therefore its stability is important; when the whole system is loaded, the motor and the transmission adapt together at the same time. The entire kinetic chain is developed by barbell training because squats, deadlifts, presses, and the Olympic lifts utilize the entire kinetic chain � and therefore strengthen the entire kinetic chain in the same way you�re going to use it........ I am puzzled that anyone who has actually gone through the process of getting strong themselves actually thinks that this approach to training really causes an improvement in athletic performance. Unless a person is an unadapted rank novice (for whom anything acts as an adaptive stimulus) or a genetic freak (for whom ineffective silly shit like 5 lb. Alternate Dumbbell Presses while standing on a Bosu� thingee) will not adversely affect an already elite performance (as said athlete will confirm when asked by somebody other than his coach), �core stability� training is an absolute waste of time that could be much better spent getting stronger � and therefore more stable � in much more effective ways. Any person who has first-hand experience with both heavy barbell training and fooling around at the physical therapist�s office knows this to be true. And most importantly of all, this is actually the way the vast majority of the drivel that composes modern exercise �science� gets promulgated: people with no personal experience with the process of getting much stronger begin to hold forth on a method they like, one that seems like it ought to work. They try it on untrained populations, who � not terribly surprisingly � get better than they were before. They write about it in a peer-reviewed journal (whose reviewers are all publishing in the same journal) or on the internet. Time goes by, and a brand-new training system is born. Sound familiar? I hope so. Learn to evaluate before you end up wasting precious time..... =========================== ------------------------------------ Modify/cancel your subscription at: mygroups Sign all letters with full name & city of residence if you wish them to be published! Quote
Guest guest Posted March 6, 2010 Report Posted March 6, 2010 As with many training concepts, each side of the argument has some validity and some flaws. There are instances, particularly but not exclusively in the rehabilitation setting, where isolation lumbar stability exercises (e.g., bird dogs, side planks) are useful. There are instances, again particularly but not exclusively in the rehabilitation setting, where weak links in the chain are needed to be trained in isolation. However, I am in agreement with some others that integrated, high-resistance training with squats, deadlifts, cleans, and the like will train the lumbar stability musculature to a more effective extent than the low-resistance, isolation exercises alone. The mistake (made by some others) is to then conclude that the latter exercises are never needed. The general concept of this debate is not new. In the old Soviet weightlifting literature, one school of thought can be seen to propose that " only the classic exercises " are needed, while another proposes that " a variety of special exercises " are needed. Isolated lumbar stability exercises do have a place. This does not mean they should be applied universally. The classic barbell exercises have an obvious place in strength development and also in development of lumbar stability. However, not everyone can do them safely or effectively at all times and after all injuries. When you have " pure " rehabilitation professionals debating a concept with " pure " strength training or high performance individuals, they are frequently not going to see things the same. Those rare individuals familiar with both populations tend to take a more nuanced view. The wise approach is to be able to understand not only the " what " of exercise selection, but the how, the why, the when, and the who. More narrow-minded approaches often result from working with a narrower population, which may limit one's perspective. Evan Peck Rochester, MN > > I've noticed a number of articles recently that seem to case doubts > > on the utility of many core strength exercises. I'm curious if anyone > > has thoughts or other experiences with this subject. To be an > > effective use of anyone's time, I would expect an exercise to either: > > (A) improve performance; or ( improve health, ie, reduce injuries. > > Does core strength training do either of these better than other > > exercises might? For example, one of the cited articles implies that > > traditional, high resistance strength training might be better for > > core development than most popular core exercises. Sounds reasonable > > to me. Your thoughts? > > Rippetoe writes on this point : > > http://startingstrength.com/articles/core_stability_rippetoe.pdf<http://starting\ strength.com/articles/core_stability_rippetoe.pdf> > > It is a matter of pride to me that I can go through an entire weekend seminar without once using > the " C " -word. Out of a concern for my participants and my reputation I fastidiously avoid using the > term " core " when referring to the trunk musculature or the stability thereof. I am so utterly goddamn > tired of hearing about the " core " from members of the lay public, infomercialers, doctors, PTs, ATCs, > personal trainers, and strength coaches that as a form of protest I refuse to use the term at all. That is > why it will appear in this article only in scare quotes. " Core. " " Core, " dammit. > The " core " is the collection of muscles that stabilize the spine. It is composed of all of the abs, the > three layers of the side abdominal wall, the posterior spinal muscles, the pelvic floor muscles, the hip > flexors, and actually the diaphragm and the intercostals, although that may be working a little too far > north. These muscles work together to control spinal position, which normally means keeping the > spine rigid during work that involves force generated by the hips and legs and transferred through > the trunk to a resistance at the hands, or in the specific training situation created by the squat, on the > back or shoulders. The " core " muscles maintain the intervertebral relationships that allow the spine to > both transfer force and remain uninjured in the process. They are extremely important in all sports, > especially the barbell sports, and that is why I have an interest in this topic. > The problem with the concept of training specifically for " core " stabilization is that it doesn't make > any sense. Leaving aside the arguments for using it to prevent back pain in sedentary populations > (everybody that doesn't have a " stable core " has back pain?), it proceeds from several ridiculous > assumptions, and it is completely inapplicable to an athlete who is training properly on a basic barbell > program. While it is absolutely true that all movements in sports that involve a ground reaction - a > movement involving the feet generating power against the ground while the body, usually through the > hands, applies it to a resistance - utilize the pelvic and trunk musculature to stabilize the spine during > the movement, there is nothing magical about this part of the muscular anatomy that causes it to > function as anything but a normal link in the kinetic chain. The " motor " is the hips and legs and the > " transmission " is the spine. Without a big motor, the transmission has nothing hard to do. The spine is > important, and therefore its stability is important; when the whole system is loaded, the motor and the > transmission adapt together at the same time. The entire kinetic chain is developed by barbell training > because squats, deadlifts, presses, and the Olympic lifts utilize the entire kinetic chain - and therefore > strengthen the entire kinetic chain in the same way you're going to use it........ > > I am puzzled that anyone who has actually gone through the process of getting strong themselves > actually thinks that this approach to training really causes an improvement in athletic performance. > Unless a person is an unadapted rank novice (for whom anything acts as an adaptive stimulus) or a > genetic freak (for whom ineffective silly shit like 5 lb. Alternate Dumbbell Presses while standing on > a Bosu® thingee) will not adversely affect an already elite performance (as said athlete will confirm > when asked by somebody other than his coach), " core stability " training is an absolute waste of time > that could be much better spent getting stronger - and therefore more stable - in much more effective > ways. Any person who has first-hand experience with both heavy barbell training and fooling around > at the physical therapist's office knows this to be true. > And most importantly of all, this is actually the way the vast majority of the drivel that composes > modern exercise " science " gets promulgated: people with no personal experience with the process > of getting much stronger begin to hold forth on a method they like, one that seems like it ought to > work. They try it on untrained populations, who - not terribly surprisingly - get better than they were > before. They write about it in a peer-reviewed journal (whose reviewers are all publishing in the same > journal) or on the internet. Time goes by, and a brand-new training system is born. Sound familiar? I > hope so. Learn to evaluate before you end up wasting precious time..... > > =========================== > > > ------------------------------------ > > Modify/cancel your subscription at: > > mygroups<mygroups> > > Sign all letters with full name & city of residence if you > wish them to be published! > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 7, 2010 Report Posted March 7, 2010 Thanks to all for many great responses. I'm actually tempted for the first time in my life to try some " real " strength training instead of the core work I've been doing the last decade. (But scared I'll do something wrong and get hurt.)Here's the latest study I came across. J Strength Cond Res. 2009 Dec;23(9):2443-50. Seven weeks of instability and traditional resistance training effects on strength, balance and functional performance. Kibele A, Behm DG.: Institute for Sports and Sport Science, University Kassel, Kassel, Germany. The objective of the study was to compare the effect of a 7-week unstable and stable resistance training program on measures of strength, balance, and functional performance. Forty participants were divided into unstable or stable resistance training groups. Training was conducted twice a week for 7 weeks. Pre- and post-testing measures included leg extension strength, static and dynamic balance, sit-ups, long jump, hopping test for time, shuttle run, and sprint. Results showed that there was no overall difference between unstable and stable resistance training and the training effects were independent of gender. All measures except sprint time improved with training. Interaction effects demonstrated that unstable resistance training did provide an advantage for number of sit-ups performed (p = 0.03; 8.9%) and the right leg hopping test (6.2%; p = 0.0001). This study has demonstrated that instability resistance training may be considered as effective as traditional stable resistance training for inexperienced resistance trainers. Based on the present study and the literature, instability resistance training should be incorporated in conjunction with traditional stable training to provide a greater variety of training experiences without sacrificing training benefits. Amby Burfoot Runner's World Emmaus PA Quote
Guest guest Posted March 7, 2010 Report Posted March 7, 2010 The below may be of interest. Dr Mcbride wrote (rehabilitation): " Comparison of general exercise, motor control exercise and spinal manipulative therapy for chronic low back pain: A randomized trial. Ferreira ML, Ferreira PH, Latimer J, Herbert RD, Hodges PW, Jennings MD, Maher CG, Refshauge KM. Pain. 2007 Sep;131(1-2):31-7. Epub 2007 Jan 23. I think this is a very nice study, 80 subjects in each group. Group 1 - General Exercise - Group (8) exercise class involving general strengthing exercises and cardio. Group 2 - Specific Exercise - Exercise utilized to control inter-segmental movement of spine - ultrasonagraphy feedback. Patient Specific Function Scores - No significant difference between groups at 6 or 12 months. Global Percieved Effect Scores - No significant difference between groups at 6 or 12 months. Exercise and nonspecific low back pain: a literature review. Henchoz Y, Kai-Lik So A. Joint Bone Spine. 2008 Oct;75(5):533-9. Epub 2008 Sep 17. This is a review paper. They examined general versus specific exercise studies, and also other issues. Chose five studies that they felt were well designed. Conlude no clear pattern of concensus in data on advantages of general or specific exercises. Suggest further research. In 3 of the 5 studies the data indicates no difference between treatment conditions (general vs specific). Supplementation of general endurance exercise with stabilisation training versus general exercise only. Physiological and functional outcomes of a randomised controlled trial of patients with recurrent low back pain. Supplementation of general endurance exercise with stabilisation training versus general exercise only. Physiological and functional outcomes of a randomised controlled trial of patients with recurrent low back pain. Koumantakis GA, PJ, Oldham JA. Clin Biomech (Bristol, Avon). 2005 Jun;20(5):474-82. Group 1 - General Exercise + Stabilization Exercise Group 2 - General Exercise Only Paraspinal Muscle Fatigue, Paraspinal Muscle Strength, Functional Speed Tests - No significant difference between groups From my perspective I believe the data from these studies indicates that general exercise is as effective in treating low back pain incomparison to specific exercise. My earlier statements above are based on these findings...instead of doing functional movement screenings, let's do something really outragous and just have them perform general exercises and see if they get better. For someone to actually think they can perform an individual functional movement screening and determine what is wrong and what treatments to then perform seems odd to me considering how little we know about how the body works. I have been intemately involved with every facet of exercise for 20 years and have trained and rehabed 100's upon 100's of people and can tell you right now I could never do a functional movement screening and tell you whats wrong with someone. Let's get rid of all the functional movement screenings, core strengthening, muscle imbalance theories, strengthen this muscle, stretch that muscle, hip controls the knee stuff and just have someone use general exercise and work on poor body composition (reason for most back and knee problems). If you don't believe research has all the answers and we should make it more simple it sure seems like a lot of individuals want to make it more complicated. No one has ever disproven by research that by simply taking a group of knee and back problems and getting them in better shape (stronger) and leaner that would not have the same success rate as functional movement screenings, etc. No one can prove that by making things more complicated by saying " well everyone is an individual case " improves the outcome of the process. Yet you go into any clinic and they go through all these evaluation processes, ice, then stim, then one legged abduction, one legged adduction, hip flexor, hip extensor, etc. Why this philosophy? Why not just keep it simple with general exercise. You can't discard the concept of general exercise because no one has ever shown it not to be just as effective, so in the mean time while we are not sure why not just try it? I mentioned this to a PT the other day and he said " well until squats are proven to improve ACL injuries I am going to stick to what I already use. " Well, what you already use hasn't been proven to work either. People say that research doesn't tell them everything and I agree, but why then do they only use things that everyone else says works. Why not do something no one else is doing? Using barbell squats to treat low back pain, now that is innovative and new. Saying you are going to use functional movement screenings is just more of the same old tired mentality. I am not disagreeing with anyone I am just trying to open the discussion to the idea that anything is possible. Including the fact that most currently used rehab techniques might be all useless or they might be the best, how do we know until we compare them to all kinds of alternatives. I would love to see some rehab personel say they have used some division I strength coach workout to rehab a low back pain patient and you know what, it worked. Amazing. ================== Carruthers Wakefield, UK > > > > Thanks to all for many great responses. I'm actually tempted for the first time in my life to try some " real " strength training instead of the core work I've been doing the last decade. (But scared I'll do something wrong and get hurt.)Here's the latest study I came across. > > J Strength Cond Res. 2009 Dec;23(9):2443-50. > Seven weeks of instability and traditional resistance training effects on strength, balance and functional performance. > > Kibele A, Behm DG.: Institute for Sports and Sport Science, University Kassel, Kassel, Germany. > > The objective of the study was to compare the effect of a 7-week unstable and stable resistance training program on measures of strength, balance, and functional performance. Forty participants were divided into unstable or stable resistance training groups. Training was conducted twice a week for 7 weeks. Pre- and post-testing measures included leg extension strength, static and dynamic balance, sit-ups, long jump, hopping test for time, shuttle run, and sprint. Results showed that there was no overall difference between unstable and stable resistance training and the training effects were independent of gender. All measures except sprint time improved with training. Interaction effects demonstrated that unstable resistance training did provide an advantage for number of sit-ups performed (p = 0.03; 8.9%) and the right leg hopping test (6.2%; p = 0.0001). This study has demonstrated that instability resistance training may be considered as effective as traditional stable resistance training for inexperienced resistance trainers. Based on the present study and the literature, instability resistance training should be incorporated in conjunction with traditional stable training to provide a greater variety of training experiences without sacrificing training benefits. > Amby Burfoot > Runner's World > Emmaus PA > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 7, 2010 Report Posted March 7, 2010 Here is an old post from Dr Mel C Siff: Today, in the fitness and therapeutic world, one of the latest buzz terms is " core stability " and courses are cropping up everywhere to teach this amazing new discovery in the world of motor control. The implications are that an athlete or normal human is somehow seriously deficient if core stability exercises are not being done in some or other discrete, isolated fashion. The belief here, of course, is that isolated core stabilising exercises necessarily improve balance and postural control. They do not, since most stabilisation and movement in sports where the hands and feet are in contact with a surface also depends very strongly on PERIPHERAL contact with the given surface (some exceptions are diving, airborne gymnastic and skating manoeuvres, and trampolining.) If this contact is inefficient or unstable, then no amount of core stabilisation is going to overcome any deficiency in peripheral stability. Some simple examples - imagine what would happen to a gymnast or trapeze artist with poor ankle strength and stability or a huge weightlifter with great core stability but deficiencies in grip or ankle strength and stability? One could list a thousand similar examples. This concept of a separate motor quality called " core stability " leads to the very faulty belief that core stability is more important and more central to overall stability than peripheral stability. The fact is that the body is a linked system of many interacting components, and current " core stabilisation " dogma happens to be yet another example of isolationist training. To borrow a somewhat clichéd term from the vocabulary of the late South African Prime Minister, General Jan Smuts (who coined the word " holism " ), it would be far better to talk about " holistic " stability training. An emphasis on " core stability " is a step towards general instability, unless it is matched by peripheral stabilisation. Once upon a time we had kinaesthetic or proprioceptive training or even motor skill training - now we have " core stability " training, which is by no means an suitable modern substitute for what used to be offered. Possibly it is time for the whole " core stabilisation " industry needs to carefully re-examine itself and take a step back to its more solid older roots. " Core stabilisation " may be a new term, but it offers little or nothing new to fitness, therapy or sports training that was not covered perfectly well a long time ago. ================= Carruthers Wakefield, UK Quote
Guest guest Posted March 8, 2010 Report Posted March 8, 2010 I am on Dr McBride's side. Reading the post reminds me of a book that I just finished reading " Sway: the iressistable pull of irrational behavior " . There are plenty of topics in this book, intended towards sales and marketing strategist, that have a direct connection to clinical and practical application of exercise as a physiological modality. One example used in this book - which I don't have in front of me so I am paraphrasing - relates to treatments of bipolar disorder, PTSD, and other psyhciatric diagnosis. It was reported, at some time (again, book not right in front of me) that DIAGNOSIS didn't matter relative to treatment. What did matter was the sense that the patient was involved and the therapist was engaged in the process. The same I am sure has to be true when it comes to exercise modalities. I also think of the " Novice Effect " reported on the Starting Strength website. I work in college athletics. It appears to me that we, as a profession, increase the complexity of an exercise looking for an adaptive " core " response when certain individuals are relatively " unfit " for ANY demands, let alone the demands of " elite " athletics and we wonder why chronic/overuse injuries aren't eliminated through corrective/rehabilitative exercise. There has to be more for discussion on this topic alone, but I digress. I am working with a high jumper right now, for example, that is 18 years old and has a history of hamstring injury NOT while competing BUT INSTEAD when doing sprints and plyometric training. I am not saying sprints and plyo's are not effective. I am saying that this method of strength development CAN work for developmental athletes and for athletes growing into their bodies. However the " progressive overload " of an increase in body mass (natural growth)eventually ends and thus the concurrent stimulus for overload does as well. What has worked for this young man has been the development of BASIC large muscle group strength - squats initially for the legs which led to split squats and deadlifts for his back and butt. He has gotten stronger which has led to an increase in jumping power. Up to now our goal has been painfree sprinting and jumping. He has yet to compete at the college level, so a success in my book will be his ability to train for and compete in an actual meet. From there we can worry about PR's and national titles. I have used my own " functional movement assessment " and I appreciate what CAN be learned in a short amount of time about and athlete/client. I also know that most of those tests are biased on the side of the tester and are more likely to find a problem where one doesn't necessarily exist. I also have personally rehabilitated my self from chronic back pain from a degenerative pathology using progressive strengthening starting with kettlebells and adding in barbbell exercises. I have been pain free for 3 years. I deadlift, I front squat, I push press, for strength, I jump and I do pull ups. None of that causes problems ever. Strength is what helped me reduce my back spasms. AS I got stronger the tension released. The pain associated with spasm is non-existent. Am I going to be a professional athlete? No. Should we ignore the value of core/basic/large muscle group strength for athletic performance in an effort to focus on deep stabilizer strength? No. I don't believe that a glute medius weakness would present IF/WHEN glute maximum strength were appropriately developed. I belive it was Boyle who made the comment once that the hip stabilizers respond better to impact than any other type of training. So, learning to land is an important part of his " core " program. I am all over the place here, sorry. What I try to instill in those I work with is: First - BE STRONG (legs, back, and shoulder complex...ala Mark Rippetoe) Second - Be in shape (eat right, rest, recover, and keep body composistion under control) Third - Be athletic (plyo's). Sam Brethauer ATC CSCS Overland Park KS, Lee's Summit MO, USA > > > > > > > > Thanks to all for many great responses. I'm actually tempted for the first time in my life to try some " real " strength training instead of the core work I've been doing the last decade. (But scared I'll do something wrong and get hurt.)Here's the latest study I came across. > > > > J Strength Cond Res. 2009 Dec;23(9):2443-50. > > Seven weeks of instability and traditional resistance training effects on strength, balance and functional performance. > > > > Kibele A, Behm DG.: Institute for Sports and Sport Science, University Kassel, Kassel, Germany. > > > > The objective of the study was to compare the effect of a 7-week unstable and stable resistance training program on measures of strength, balance, and functional performance. Forty participants were divided into unstable or stable resistance training groups. Training was conducted twice a week for 7 weeks. Pre- and post-testing measures included leg extension strength, static and dynamic balance, sit-ups, long jump, hopping test for time, shuttle run, and sprint. Results showed that there was no overall difference between unstable and stable resistance training and the training effects were independent of gender. All measures except sprint time improved with training. Interaction effects demonstrated that unstable resistance training did provide an advantage for number of sit-ups performed (p = 0.03; 8.9%) and the right leg hopping test (6.2%; p = 0.0001). This study has demonstrated that instability resistance training may be considered as effective as traditional stable resistance training for inexperienced resistance trainers. Based on the present study and the literature, instability resistance training should be incorporated in conjunction with traditional stable training to provide a greater variety of training experiences without sacrificing training benefits. > > Amby Burfoot > > Runner's World > > Emmaus PA > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 10, 2010 Report Posted March 10, 2010 Matt (or anybody who questions use of the abs during powerlifts or OWL), Have you ever performed several sets of deadlifts, clean and jerks, front or back squats at 90-95% of 1RM and notice the use of core musculature? Look in the Supertraining archives. The late Dr. Siff expanded on this topic a lot, and much better than anybody I know. This is one of the most talked about topics on this forum. Kolasinski , CA > > I'm a big fan of Rippetoe and rank his book as my #1 for getting the > foundation of form and programming. I'm unconvinced though that weight > training is enough to completely strengthen the core, but perhaps it's > adequate to keep getting strong and participating in the sports your > training for at least through your 20's. Now I'm not a big fan of the > " core " agenda and have no interest in balance boards or bosu ball > jumping jacks. What I do question is since I do all my OH presses > standing, do bb squats to parallel, and deadlifts with perfect form than > as others have stated my core should be good to go. Now just 2 weeks > ago I started back with Pilates and signed up for beginners level since > I've been away. It is incredibly hard for me to pull of an hours worth > of mostly beginners moves when in the past I've been able to do advanced > classes when I was a regular with it. So with weight lifting and > minimal ab work(knee raises, planks, etc) shouldn't I have been able to > at least handle the basics with weightlifting keeping my core strong. > I'm not a nut about it but I'm definitely wondering why I'm struggling > much. I'm taking Pilates to reduce/eliminate my low back pain so that I > can keep lifting weights and increasing the weight. Pilates has > effectively reduced or eliminated it in the past though it takes about 3 > months to achieve. My plan going forward it to supplement it at least > once a week to keep the weights going on. At 33 my flexibility in my > hams and psoas has always been a project so that's part of it. I > stretch out after every workout. Maybe there is something lacking in my > programming that the Pilates is addressing but for me I think there is > undeniable value to putting that in the rotation. Maybe it's just my > personal body's need and not something a study would actually back up. > > Matt Kahl > Kenosha, WI > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 10, 2010 Report Posted March 10, 2010 Wonderful article, I think overall general compound exercises, will correct multiple aches and pains, because if one muscle is imbalanced or whatever reason, its going to impose on every surrounding muscle group. Squats are tremendous for core strenght, and well everything. I wish more people took approach to a single issue this way. It is kinda of like taking asparin, if you have a headache, the drug is carried through out the body, along with treating many of the variables that cause this problem. Just like a back problem could come from poor structural imbalance, so why not take a systemic approach to fix a local symptom? Flees City? Country? ________________________________ From: Casler <bioforce.inc@...> Supertraining Sent: Wed, March 10, 2010 2:03:09 PM Subject: What does core strength training achieve? Â The below may be of interest. Dr Mcbride wrote (rehabilitation) : <SNIP> From my perspective I believe the data from these studies indicates that general exercise is as effective in treating low back pain incomparison to specific exercise. My earlier statements above are based on these findings...instead of doing functional movement screenings, let's do something really outragous and just have them perform general exercises and see if they get better. For someone to actually think they can perform an individual functional movement screening and determine what is wrong and what treatments to then perform seems odd to me considering how little we know about how the body works. I have been intemately involved with every facet of exercise for 20 years and have trained and rehabed 100's upon 100's of people and can tell you right now I could never do a functional movement screening and tell you whats wrong with someone. Let's get rid of all the functional movement screenings, core strengthening, muscle imbalance theories, strengthen this muscle, stretch that muscle, hip controls the knee stuff and just have someone use general exercise and work on poor body composition (reason for most back and knee problems). If you don't believe research has all the answers and we should make it more simple it sure seems like a lot of individuals want to make it more complicated. No one has ever disproven by research that by simply taking a group of knee and back problems and getting them in better shape (stronger) and leaner that would not have the same success rate as functional movement screenings, etc. <snip> Why not do something no one else is doing? Using barbell squats to treat low back pain, now that is innovative and new. Saying you are going to use functional movement screenings is just more of the same old tired mentality. I am not disagreeing with anyone I am just trying to open the discussion to the idea that anything is possible. Including the fact that most currently used rehab techniques might be all useless or they might be the best, how do we know until we compare them to all kinds of alternatives. I would love to see some rehab personel say they have used some division I strength coach workout to rehab a low back pain patient and you know what, it worked. Amazing. Casler writes: Exactly. I have developed a protocol for reconditioning the TSM (Torso Stabilization Mechanism) that centers around the use of BARBELL SQUATS and several other KEY actions that is highly effective at conditioning the mechanisms and active and passive anatomy that participate in " force management " when doing everything from " tying your shoes " to " lifting hundreds of pounds " . It seems to increase ability, and reduce either reoccurrence or severity of reoccurrence. In virtually ALL LBP problems, it generally summarizes in a lack of adequate force management and protection from those forces to weak or injured tissues that either do not repair or repair very slowly. It DOES require one disregard some long held beliefs that actually tend to lead to decreased conditioning, decreased ability, and even setting one's self up for injury. ========================== Quote
Guest guest Posted March 10, 2010 Report Posted March 10, 2010 I have had chronic back problems for years, but have found that full range squats done with good form seem to make a dramatic difference in how my back feels. My back feels great for about 4-5 days and then gradually the benefit wears off and its time to do squats again. I would like to better understand how it works, but agree that it somehow " rebalances " some postural problems.  For me squats work much better than back extensions, inversion, stretching, yoga, planks, or anything else that I have found. For it to work well I have to go quite low (butt to the floor).  Ed White Sandwich, MA USA  From: david flees <david.flees@...> Subject: Re: What does core strength training achieve? Supertraining Date: Wednesday, March 10, 2010, 2:39 PM  Wonderful article, I think overall general compound exercises, will correct multiple aches and pains, because if one muscle is imbalanced or whatever reason, its going to impose on every surrounding muscle group. Squats are tremendous for core strenght, and well everything. I wish more people took approach to a single issue this way. It is kinda of like taking asparin, if you have a headache, the drug is carried through out the body, along with treating many of the variables that cause this problem. Just like a back problem could come from poor structural imbalance, so why not take a systemic approach to fix a local symptom? Flees City? Country? ____________ _________ _________ __ From: Casler <bioforce.inc@ gte.net> Supertraining Sent: Wed, March 10, 2010 2:03:09 PM Subject: What does core strength training achieve?  The below may be of interest. Dr Mcbride wrote (rehabilitation) : <SNIP> From my perspective I believe the data from these studies indicates that general exercise is as effective in treating low back pain incomparison to specific exercise. My earlier statements above are based on these findings...instead of doing functional movement screenings, let's do something really outragous and just have them perform general exercises and see if they get better. For someone to actually think they can perform an individual functional movement screening and determine what is wrong and what treatments to then perform seems odd to me considering how little we know about how the body works. I have been intemately involved with every facet of exercise for 20 years and have trained and rehabed 100's upon 100's of people and can tell you right now I could never do a functional movement screening and tell you whats wrong with someone. Let's get rid of all the functional movement screenings, core strengthening, muscle imbalance theories, strengthen this muscle, stretch that muscle, hip controls the knee stuff and just have someone use general exercise and work on poor body composition (reason for most back and knee problems). If you don't believe research has all the answers and we should make it more simple it sure seems like a lot of individuals want to make it more complicated. No one has ever disproven by research that by simply taking a group of knee and back problems and getting them in better shape (stronger) and leaner that would not have the same success rate as functional movement screenings, etc. <snip> Why not do something no one else is doing? Using barbell squats to treat low back pain, now that is innovative and new. Saying you are going to use functional movement screenings is just more of the same old tired mentality. I am not disagreeing with anyone I am just trying to open the discussion to the idea that anything is possible. Including the fact that most currently used rehab techniques might be all useless or they might be the best, how do we know until we compare them to all kinds of alternatives. I would love to see some rehab personel say they have used some division I strength coach workout to rehab a low back pain patient and you know what, it worked. Amazing. Casler writes: Exactly. I have developed a protocol for reconditioning the TSM (Torso Stabilization Mechanism) that centers around the use of BARBELL SQUATS and several other KEY actions that is highly effective at conditioning the mechanisms and active and passive anatomy that participate in " force management " when doing everything from " tying your shoes " to " lifting hundreds of pounds " . It seems to increase ability, and reduce either reoccurrence or severity of reoccurrence. In virtually ALL LBP problems, it generally summarizes in a lack of adequate force management and protection from those forces to weak or injured tissues that either do not repair or repair very slowly. It DOES require one disregard some long held beliefs that actually tend to lead to decreased conditioning, decreased ability, and even setting one's self up for injury. ============ ========= ===== Quote
Guest guest Posted March 12, 2010 Report Posted March 12, 2010 I agree with squats working well for core building. My overall strength level increased significantly after incorporating heavy squats into my program. I also recently started rotating in Zercher squats to maintain good form. You may want to have your vitamin D level checked if you have chronic lower back pain. My business deals with malabsorption due to celiac disease, but anyone can have a low D level depending on the latitude at which they live, diet, etc. Libonati City? Country? Quote
Guest guest Posted March 12, 2010 Report Posted March 12, 2010 Ed is not alone. I developed a nagging lumbar problem L4/L5 which impacted my Femoral intermediate cutaneous nerve. I was sent to physical therapy, (which could be a whole seperate discussion), in order to strengthen and stretch the area.  The manipulation, planks and ridiculous exercises that I executed as part of the protocol infuriated the area of my back making matters worse. I decided to take matters into my own hands. Squats (ATG) on every rep, reverse hypers and Knees to Elbows have help tremendously.  Mark Cotton New Jersey, USA Extreme Conditioning Personal Training Mark Cotton, B.A., PICP & ISSA Certified (732) 979-7201 www.extremeconditioning.com From: Ed White <kitesurfer257@...> Subject: Re: What does core strength training achieve? Supertraining Date: Wednesday, March 10, 2010, 9:26 PM  I have had chronic back problems for years, but have found that full range squats done with good form seem to make a dramatic difference in how my back feels. My back feels great for about 4-5 days and then gradually the benefit wears off and its time to do squats again. I would like to better understand how it works, but agree that it somehow " rebalances " some postural problems.  For me squats work much better than back extensions, inversion, stretching, yoga, planks, or anything else that I have found. For it to work well I have to go quite low (butt to the floor). ----------------------------- Quote
Guest guest Posted March 13, 2010 Report Posted March 13, 2010 That is not a bad start. But, when there is a problem with the LE the whole kinetic chain needs to be examined to properly dx and developed an effective treatment plan. Phil Caraher, DPT, MS, CSCS Chapel Hill, NC _____ From: Supertraining [mailto:Supertraining ] On Behalf Of casey gallagher Sent: Friday, March 05, 2010 2:48 PM Supertraining Subject: Re: What does core strength training achieve? My thoughts on the gluteus medius is that it is a pelvic stabilizer. After toe off and during the swing phase the opposite side gluteus medius (and TFL) contracts to keep the ASIS parallel to the ground. Most therapists and such use open kinetic chain movements to strengthen the gluteus medius. However the glute med. is contracted while the non-swinging leg is on the ground. Closed kinetic chain movements might do a better job strengthening the glute med. in a more " functional " manor. These would be in-line lunges with , step ups, single leg deadlifts and so on bi-lateral or ipsilateral resistance where one focuses on keeping the knee in line with the toe and the pelvis " square " to the floor. Casey Gallagher CSCS Snohomish WA, USA Re: What does core strength training achieve? ambyb wrote: > I've noticed a number of articles recently that seem to case doubts > on the utility of many core strength exercises. I'm curious if anyone > has thoughts or other experiences with this subject. To be an > effective use of anyone's time, I would expect an exercise to either: > (A) improve performance; or ( improve health, ie, reduce injuries. > Does core strength training do either of these better than other > exercises might? For example, one of the cited articles implies that > traditional, high resistance strength training might be better for > core development than most popular core exercises. Sounds reasonable > to me. Your thoughts? Rippetoe writes on this point : http://startingstre <http://startingstrength.com/articles/core_stability_rippetoe.pdf> ngth.com/articles/core_stability_rippetoe.pdf<http://startingstre <http://startingstrength.com/articles/core_stability_rippetoe.pdf> ngth.com/articles/core_stability_rippetoe.pdf> It is a matter of pride to me that I can go through an entire weekend seminar without once using the " C " -word. Out of a concern for my participants and my reputation I fastidiously avoid using the term " core " when referring to the trunk musculature or the stability thereof. I am so utterly goddamn tired of hearing about the " core " from members of the lay public, infomercialers, doctors, PTs, ATCs, personal trainers, and strength coaches that as a form of protest I refuse to use the term at all. That is why it will appear in this article only in scare quotes. " Core. " " Core, " dammit. The " core " is the collection of muscles that stabilize the spine. It is composed of all of the abs, the three layers of the side abdominal wall, the posterior spinal muscles, the pelvic floor muscles, the hip flexors, and actually the diaphragm and the intercostals, although that may be working a little too far north. These muscles work together to control spinal position, which normally means keeping the spine rigid during work that involves force generated by the hips and legs and transferred through the trunk to a resistance at the hands, or in the specific training situation created by the squat, on the back or shoulders. The " core " muscles maintain the intervertebral relationships that allow the spine to both transfer force and remain uninjured in the process. They are extremely important in all sports, especially the barbell sports, and that is why I have an interest in this topic. The problem with the concept of training specifically for " core " stabilization is that it doesn't make any sense. Leaving aside the arguments for using it to prevent back pain in sedentary populations (everybody that doesn't have a " stable core " has back pain?), it proceeds from several ridiculous assumptions, and it is completely inapplicable to an athlete who is training properly on a basic barbell program. While it is absolutely true that all movements in sports that involve a ground reaction - a movement involving the feet generating power against the ground while the body, usually through the hands, applies it to a resistance - utilize the pelvic and trunk musculature to stabilize the spine during the movement, there is nothing magical about this part of the muscular anatomy that causes it to function as anything but a normal link in the kinetic chain. The " motor " is the hips and legs and the " transmission " is the spine. Without a big motor, the transmission has nothing hard to do. The spine is important, and therefore its stability is important; when the whole system is loaded, the motor and the transmission adapt together at the same time. The entire kinetic chain is developed by barbell training because squats, deadlifts, presses, and the Olympic lifts utilize the entire kinetic chain - and therefore strengthen the entire kinetic chain in the same way you're going to use it........ I am puzzled that anyone who has actually gone through the process of getting strong themselves actually thinks that this approach to training really causes an improvement in athletic performance. Unless a person is an unadapted rank novice (for whom anything acts as an adaptive stimulus) or a genetic freak (for whom ineffective silly shit like 5 lb. Alternate Dumbbell Presses while standing on a BosuR thingee) will not adversely affect an already elite performance (as said athlete will confirm when asked by somebody other than his coach), " core stability " training is an absolute waste of time that could be much better spent getting stronger - and therefore more stable - in much more effective ways. Any person who has first-hand experience with both heavy barbell training and fooling around at the physical therapist's office knows this to be true. And most importantly of all, this is actually the way the vast majority of the drivel that composes modern exercise " science " gets promulgated: people with no personal experience with the process of getting much stronger begin to hold forth on a method they like, one that seems like it ought to work. They try it on untrained populations, who - not terribly surprisingly - get better than they were before. They write about it in a peer-reviewed journal (whose reviewers are all publishing in the same journal) or on the internet. Time goes by, and a brand-new training system is born. Sound familiar? I hope so. Learn to evaluate before you end up wasting precious time..... =========================== ------------------------------------ Modify/cancel your subscription at: http://groups. <mygroups> /mygroups<http://groups. <mygroups> /mygroups> Sign all letters with full name & city of residence if you wish them to be published! Quote
Guest guest Posted March 13, 2010 Report Posted March 13, 2010 Ed, Its possible that you could be mobilizing your pelvis with the squats which would provide you temporary relief. Over time it will return to its asymmetrical position(.?). its impossible to say for sure of course without a proper examination. As a DPT, I take the time to examine the lower extremities, etc. for my pts who have LBP. Of course a good hx and examination before diagnosis is always encouraged. Phil Caraher, DPT, MS, CSCS Chapel Hill, NC _____ From: Supertraining [mailto:Supertraining ] On Behalf Of Mark Cotton Sent: Friday, March 12, 2010 1:14 PM Supertraining Subject: Re: What does core strength training achieve? Ed is not alone. I developed a nagging lumbar problem L4/L5 which impacted my Femoral intermediate cutaneous nerve. I was sent to physical therapy, (which could be a whole seperate discussion), in order to strengthen and stretch the area. The manipulation, planks and ridiculous exercises that I executed as part of the protocol infuriated the area of my back making matters worse. I decided to take matters into my own hands. Squats (ATG) on every rep, reverse hypers and Knees to Elbows have help tremendously. Mark Cotton New Jersey, USA Extreme Conditioning Personal Training Mark Cotton, B.A., PICP & ISSA Certified (732) 979-7201 www.extremeconditioning.com From: Ed White <kitesurfer257@ <mailto:kitesurfer257%40> > Subject: Re: What does core strength training achieve? Supertraining@ <mailto:Supertraining%40> Date: Wednesday, March 10, 2010, 9:26 PM I have had chronic back problems for years, but have found that full range squats done with good form seem to make a dramatic difference in how my back feels. My back feels great for about 4-5 days and then gradually the benefit wears off and its time to do squats again. I would like to better understand how it works, but agree that it somehow " rebalances " some postural problems. For me squats work much better than back extensions, inversion, stretching, yoga, planks, or anything else that I have found. For it to work well I have to go quite low (butt to the floor). ----------------------------- Quote
Guest guest Posted March 14, 2010 Report Posted March 14, 2010 Sigh. I was thinking along a similar path to Todd (again). <This is clearly a habit or a sign of the apocalypse, depending on your personal view of the world...>. Without at least a full length photo of the person in question from at least two angles, I couldn't decide the biomechanics of an individual even statically for such a guess as was made by a previous poster. I would also say that if Ed says it's not temporary, he's the best and most reliable source of information, for the individual will generally report being in pain or not (grin). As Todd suggests below, a pelvis most definitely would have to move substantially or it could not reach the grass in most standardly constructed individuals. (I have to say " standard " here as there are most definitely squatting dwarves in powerlifting for example, who are far closer to the grass in that region than the rest of us prior to movement!). With some mirth and measure of response, The Phantom aka Schaefer, RMT/CMT, competing powerlifter Denver, Colorado, USA ============================== Re: What does core strength training achieve? Ed is not alone. I developed a nagging lumbar problem L4/L5 which impacted my Femoral intermediate cutaneous nerve. I was sent to physical therapy, (which could be a whole seperate discussion), in order to strengthen and stretch the area. The manipulation, planks and ridiculous exercises that I executed as part of the protocol infuriated the area of my back making matters worse. I decided to take matters into my own hands. Squats (ATG) on every rep, reverse hypers and Knees to Elbows have help tremendously. ============================== Quote
Guest guest Posted March 14, 2010 Report Posted March 14, 2010 Todd, 1. As apposed to a more abnormal path of motion.? 2. I did take it upon myself to assume his relief was temporary. Because that's what he said. 3. As I said, I would examine the LE's and any other any other segment, quadrant or asymmetry I felt I needed to in order to properly diagnose the problem. Phil Caraher, DPT, MS, CSCS Chapel Hill, NC ========================= _____ From: Supertraining [mailto:Supertraining ] On Behalf Of todd langer Sent: Sunday, March 14, 2010 1:09 PM Supertraining Subject: RE: What does core strength training achieve? Phil, A couple of quick thoughts. 1. It's not only " possible " that an ATG squat mobilizes a pelvis, but mandatory or else he wouldn't be moving at all. Did you mean towards a more " normalized " path of motion? 2. You took it upon yourself to automatically assume Ed's relief to be temporary. Why? 3. How would you know he has an asymmetric pelvis in the first place without a differential diagnosis of sorts? 4. Why would you only examine the lower extremities for patients with LBP? It's very common for the shoulders, thorax and cervical spine to be in play as well. Sure, GRF are a big deal, but so is gravity and spatial orientation. Take care! Todd Langer, MSc Boulder, CO ============================== _____ From: Supertraining@ <mailto:Supertraining%40> [mailto:Supertraining@ <mailto:Supertraining%40> ] On Behalf Of Phil Caraher Sent: Saturday, March 13, 2010 7:37 PM Supertraining@ <mailto:Supertraining%40> Subject: RE: What does core strength training achieve? Ed, Its possible that you could be mobilizing your pelvis with the squats which would provide you temporary relief. Over time it will return to its asymmetrical position(.?). its impossible to say for sure of course without a proper examination. As a DPT, I take the time to examine the lower extremities, etc. for my pts who have LBP. Of course a good hx and examination before diagnosis is always encouraged. Phil Caraher, DPT, MS, CSCS Chapel Hill, NC _____ From: Supertraining@ <mailto:Supertraining%40> [mailto:Supertraining@ <mailto:Supertraining%40> ] On Behalf Of Mark Cotton Sent: Friday, March 12, 2010 1:14 PM Supertraining@ <mailto:Supertraining%40> Subject: Re: What does core strength training achieve? Ed is not alone. I developed a nagging lumbar problem L4/L5 which impacted my Femoral intermediate cutaneous nerve. I was sent to physical therapy, (which could be a whole seperate discussion), in order to strengthen and stretch the area. The manipulation, planks and ridiculous exercises that I executed as part of the protocol infuriated the area of my back making matters worse. I decided to take matters into my own hands. Squats (ATG) on every rep, reverse hypers and Knees to Elbows have help tremendously. ============================== Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.