Guest guest Posted March 15, 2010 Report Posted March 15, 2010 " Without at least a full length photo of the person in question from at least two angles, I couldn't decide the biomechanics of an individual even statically for such a guess as was made by a previous poster. " Really? Why not? The pt must be examined in standing including posture and gait, sitting (including reflexes), supine, long sitting and prone. Included in each position Palpation of the bony landmarks of the pelvis, sacrum and LE's can give quite an accurate picture. Pelvic asymmetries, sacral rotations, true and apparent LLD are common causes to low back pain and need to be addressed. Again, this is where a clinician's skill at differential diagnosis differs from guessing it's a herniated disc. " Guessing " as was stated in a previous post that the answer to back pain is full squats and back extension exercises is the real problem and why so many rather suffer intermittent back pain than have another person guess at a treatment. As I said before, a good hx and exam by a trained professional before dx is always encouraged. Phil Caraher, DPT, MS, CSCS Chapel Hill, NC _____ From: Supertraining [mailto:Supertraining ] On Behalf Of deadliftdiva@... Sent: Sunday, March 14, 2010 4:13 PM Supertraining Subject: Re: What does core strength training achieve? Sigh. I was thinking along a similar path to Todd (again). <This is clearly a habit or a sign of the apocalypse, depending on your personal view of the world...>. Without at least a full length photo of the person in question from at least two angles, I couldn't decide the biomechanics of an individual even statically for such a guess as was made by a previous poster. I would also say that if Ed says it's not temporary, he's the best and most reliable source of information, for the individual will generally report being in pain or not (grin). As Todd suggests below, a pelvis most definitely would have to move substantially or it could not reach the grass in most standardly constructed individuals. (I have to say " standard " here as there are most definitely squatting dwarves in powerlifting for example, who are far closer to the grass in that region than the rest of us prior to movement!). With some mirth and measure of response, The Phantom aka Schaefer, RMT/CMT, competing powerlifter Denver, Colorado, USA ============================== Re: What does core strength training achieve? Ed is not alone. I developed a nagging lumbar problem L4/L5 which impacted my Femoral intermediate cutaneous nerve. I was sent to physical therapy, (which could be a whole seperate discussion), in order to strengthen and stretch the area. The manipulation, planks and ridiculous exercises that I executed as part of the protocol infuriated the area of my back making matters worse. I decided to take matters into my own hands. Squats (ATG) on every rep, reverse hypers and Knees to Elbows have help tremendously. ============================== Quote
Guest guest Posted March 16, 2010 Report Posted March 16, 2010 I'm glad that competition squats don't go ATG. I'm glad they go only to parallel or just below parallel. Edwin Freeman, Jr. San Francisco, USA In a message dated 3/15/2010 1:32:44 P.M. Pacific Daylight Time, deadliftdiva@... writes: As Todd suggests below, a pelvis most definitely would have to move substantially or it could not reach the grass in most standardly constructed individuals. (I have to say " standard " here as there are most definitely squatting dwarves in powerlifting for example, who are far closer to the grass in that region than the rest of us prior to movement!). Quote
Guest guest Posted March 17, 2010 Report Posted March 17, 2010 After rereading the start of this thread, I remembered why I had pointed out the need for at least a LOOK at the human we're talking about. (side note: I also had to curb my wish to " Rapunzel " somebody...) That was my point....and no, I wouldn't be so foolish as to decide it all from a photo, yet the poster who criticizes my point of needing a look at the person is the very person who has been going on about a suggestion toward treatment - sight unseen? The poster in question also is the same one upon rereading who discounted the point i had made too - about Ed knowing whether he is in pain or not! Personally when I work with somebody, yes, I look at them and talk to them. If they report NOT being in pain, I tend to believe them. Few people will outright lie to you about that without other motivation! If the posters in this thread who say their pain improved and they found relief in squatting are honest and I see NO reason to suggest they are not ....then why does Phil persist in suggesting they are incorrect? I believe treatment needs to be tailored to the individual, just like training and other variables which vary from person to person. What works for one may not work for another, but dissuading someone from trying squatting to relieve their pain is not a good idea IMHO because it may be this works for that particular person. Back to the point of the thread, I'm curious as to the build style and squat style (there are a good many styles) the people who are using the squat for pain relief successfully have - do they share a build similarity? A photo would tell me that easily. Anyway that's an attempt to respond to the rather extreme criticisms of my other post and I hope it helps get the thread back on track. I'm just glad the posters who were in pain have found a way to relieve it and it gives us yet another possible way to address what may be a lingering and highly frustrating condition. The Phantom aka Schaefer, RMT/CMt, competing powerlifter Denver, Colorado, USA RE: What does core strength training achieve? " Without at least a full length photo of the person in question from at least two angles, I couldn't decide the biomechanics of an individual even statically for such a guess as was made by a previous poster. " Really? Why not? The pt must be examined in standing including posture and gait, sitting (including reflexes), supine, long sitting and prone. Included in each position Palpation of the bony landmarks of the pelvis, sacrum and LE's can give quite an accurate picture. Pelvic asymmetries, sacral rotations, true and apparent LLD are common causes to low back pain and need to be addressed. Again, this is where a clinician's skill at differential diagnosis differs from guessing it's a herniated disc. " Guessing " as was stated in a previous post that the answer to back pain is full squats and back extension exercises is the real problem and why so many rather suffer intermittent back pain than have another person guess at a treatment. As I said before, a good hx and exam by a trained professional before dx is always encouraged. ======================= Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.