Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Single vs Multiple Sets

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Guest guest
Posted

Greetings Giovanni,

The " the size principle, which states that motor units are recruited

in order of increasing size " was not mentioned as it didn't seem

really germaine to the conversation.

The size principle discussion inevitably leads to interesting but not

entirely agreed to concepts. The most interesting being the

possibility/probability? of reversing the order of recruitment

during highly intense efforts.

I haven't kept up with this research but may again as the order of

recruitment maybe very important. As I remember, from somewhere, fast

twitch fibers cannot be recruited at a high tension when the slower

twitch fibers have been exhausted/fatigued from the " bottom up " --

size wise?! This promotes the concept of doing high intensity reps

from the first rep on. The muscle then would be fatigued from the " top

down " .

Jerry Telle

Lakewood CO USA

On Mar 30, 2010, at 12:24 PM, Giovanni Ciriani wrote:

> I don't see in this discussion any mention of " Henneman's size

> principle "

> which affects and determines both strength, fiber recruitment

> percentage,

> and type of fibers recruited. Any reason for that?

> Giovanni Ciriani - West Hartford, CT - USA

>

> On Tue, Mar 30, 2010 at 2:20 AM, Jerry Telle <JRTELLE@...> wrote:

>

> >

> >

> >

> > Greetings ,

> >

> >

> > Casler writes:

> >

> > If you perform " warm-up " and approach sets you have already moved

> to a

> > multi-set model.

> >

> > Telle -- Right, I don't think it is possible, save absolute strength

> > circumstances, to recruit Fast twitch fibers maximally with out a

> > warmup(s).

> >

> >

> > Casler writes:

> >

> > For one to believe that a Single Set to Failure can produce equal or

> > better

> > results than a multiple set schema you need to buy into the OPTIMAL

> > Stimulus

> > argument, that you can provide the maximal and optimal stimulus to a

> > muscle

> > via a Single Set taken to Exhaustive Failure.

> >

> > Telle -- Not sure we have total semantic overlap but does not an

> > optimal stimulus also require an optimal load?

> >

> >

> > Casler writes:

> >

> > To accept this you need then agree that no matter what your

> condition

> > that

> > you can somehow produce an overload within that set, or believe

> that the

> > body will produce SuperCompensation indefinitely.

> >

> > In the arena of stimuli you have TENSIONS, and you have Fatigues.

> The

> > Fatigues are Metabolic, Neural, Muscular, and Mental. In Strength

> > Training

> > the Primary Stimulus is Tension, with all the Fatigues providing the

> > supporting roles to stimulus. All models of training combine these

> > stimulus

> > elements to an OVERLOAD within the framework of the current

> condition or

> > last, most recent stimulus. That is, for an adaptive response to

> > occur, the

> > most recent stimulus " package " (not the government version) must in

> > some way

> > exceed what the organism has been previously exposed to.

> >

> > Telle -- I think I see what your " stimulus, " in a general sense,

> > means(?). And I assume that " the

> > most recent stimulus " package " must in some way

> > exceed what the organism has been previously exposed to " by

> [Telle] or

> > because the supercompensation has resulted in greater strength

> > (hypertrophic here) and can thus produce greater tensions to an

> > overload (more weight at original speed or greater speed at the

> > previous weight.? And greater fatigue can/is accomplished (though I

> > need a good quantifying definition of fatigue.) Maybe a difference

> in

> > max weight/speed over fatigued state failure?????? I admit to

> > " fatigue " ignorance -- how to define it.

> >

> >

> > Casler writes:

> >

> > In the beginning trainees make a type of progress I call

> " leapfrog " or

> > SUPER

> > Compensation. This progress is usually rapid and driven by the

> fact that

> > the Motor System can learn rather quickly how to produce and apply

> more

> > force than the muscle have been accustomed to (overload), this then

> > causes

> > the muscles to adapt to the HIGHER TENSIONS and WORK via protein

> > synthesis

> > (growth).

> >

> > Telle -- as long as I'm this far out on the limb, does muscle fiber

> > summation increase with training or is greater tension mainly a

> > synchronization function? Obviously synchronization leads to greater

> > connective tissue tension -- but not to specific fibers?

> >

> >

> > Casler writes:

> >

> > This process occurs for a short period driven by the cycle of

> neural and

> > tissue adaptations (leapfrogging) to appear as " overcompensatory "

> > adaptations. However the SuperCompensation observation reaches

> > diminishing

> > returns when applied via a Single Set program.

> >

> > Telle -- Are there studies directly demonstrating this? Is the

> > relationship linear or generally curvilinear?

> > Were any of the studies HIIT (Yates) style? do researchers even know

> > the difference and of course how was intensity measured.

> >

> >

> > Casler writes:

> >

> > Now you are faced with a dilemma of accepting that " further "

> stimulus

> > via a

> > second set will cause a greater stimulus, or that it will cause an

> > " overtraining or over-reaching " result. Well of course we already

> know

> > that

> > it DOES NOT cause overtraining unless carried to the extreme under

> > long term

> > circumstances.

> >

> > Telle -- I had lunch, the other day, with a person who used my

> version

> > of a max intensity set, at least 10 years ago.

> > The particulars,

> > 1. He trained by himself which meant no mental " goading " from me,

> > 2. The 1 set included 10 reps, each a drop rep/set of 1 from the

> > original 95% positive 1RM, starting weight. Each following rep

> being a

> > projected 90-100% momentary 1RM.

> > 3. The negatives were my negative enhancement techniques -- that is

> > manipulating lever arm/moment physics to increase relative

> resistance

> > during the negative action.

> > 4. His " intensity " by my estimation (no EMG or other monitoring

> > devices) was about 90% of competition max. I don't think he ever

> > trained solely for max strength.

> > 5. We have trained together off and on for 50 years. So I have a lot

> > of anecdotal information.

> > 6. My research training machine could provide the same resistance --

> > that is using a linear actuator to adjust positive and negative

> > inertial load. Training in this manner produced the same resistance

> > efect os the free weight loads.

> >

> > We stopped his max training after the 2nd session. As he put it.

> " The

> > first training session was fine, the second a real mental effort "

> And

> > " the third would have been an impossibility. "

> > He remembers? not sleeping well for 2 nights after each session at

> > once a week training. That's one set of a 10 rep set of 1RM with

> > eccentric overload each rep..

> >

> > We switched him back to a 5-7 rep drop set protocol for 3 total sets

> > and did he fine! So in my estimation 1 set of 10 reps can produce

> > (probably mental) over training

> >

> >

> > Casler writes:

> >

> > We also know that increased workload (adequately applied)

> > DOES cause overload conditions and further progress.

> >

> > The fallacy of the single set model as optimal also is based on the

> > limited

> > assumption that " full metabolic, mental and neural " exhaustion is

> the

> > Optimal Stimulus, when it is not. The optimal stimulus for Strength

> > training is Progressively Overloading the Tensions and the Work

> that a

> > muscle(s) is exposed to. It is IMPOSSIBLE to create a continuously

> > available overload indefinitely via a SINGLE SET. No one has ever

> done

> > it,

> > and no one is currently doing it.

> >

> > Telle-- Nor is it likely anyone will. I remember reading that

> Mentzer

> > (reliability?) trained Yates for 1 set of 6 reps with a similar

> > protocol for Nautilus pullovers.

> > I assume this was a single? training session in this manner? I

> > remember lots of " Mentzer talk " in the article.

> >

> > Casler writes;

> >

> >

> > What IS possible is that you can reach a fairly high level (%

> result)

> > via

> > the Single Set model with the highest intensity (highest effort to

> each

> > moment of the exercise). But just like there is no real perpetual

> motion

> > machine, there is no single example of any elite strength athlete or

> > World

> > Champion employing anything close to this model.

> >

> > Telle -- STILL I would still like to know the results of a really

> > intense 1 drop set protocol.

> >

> > Isn't this fun?

> >

> >

> > As always,

> >

> > Jerry Telle

> > Lakewood CO USA

> >_,_._,___

>

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...