Guest guest Posted March 21, 2010 Report Posted March 21, 2010 Casler writes: It is because the additional sets allow an OVERLOAD to be produced, that eventually will not be available in a Single Set. Flees Writes: Another big issue with this is that progressive overload is great, what is the percentage of your 1 rep max, are youi doing multiple sets with. I know i work up to 365 for a deadlift, and 5 or 6 of those sets are 1-3 reps, then 1 all out set of 365 for 5-6. How is it possible for me to comeback and do 365 again if i gave it my all on this one set? Trust me im 150 at 5'2, and trying to hit that weight twice, is a no go. Casler writes: Extending the duration of the eccentric with a load imposed limit of the single set will not generally be superior. The more important issue is that 10 10sec eccentric actions will reduce the load you can use in the set. This imposition will by itself reduce the stimulus. And again the longer TUL (where the load will be lower) will likely only add to the endurance of the set. If the trainee has the strength for 1sec positive actions, then you would be better off raining the load and performing a natural speed eccentric. That would yield higher tension forces throughout the reps and set. Flees writes: The 10 sec is a hypothetical i usually stick with a 4-6 sec eccentric, and an explosive positive. Again half the sets people do up to their last set, should be counted as warmups. And last time i checked your not going to do 405 for 10 reps for 4 sets, usually people do 135 x 10, then 225 x 10, then 315 x 10, then they are to exhausted to hti the weight of 405 but get to it any ways, and do 405 for 8, when i impose all those sets should be warm ups of 3-5 reps, and 405 should be your working set. So where is the overload in your theory? If your really just building up lactate in the muscle and pre exhaustingit, or you could absolutely be freshed and warmed up.  Casler writes: There is a large difference between a 2 second eccentric action and a 10 second. Flees writes: No way i just thought those were numbers. Casler writes: That is a Strawman argument and the article DID NOT suggest that multiple sets to the extreme be performed. Why not reverse your strawman and REDUCE the amount of training to a Single Rep of a Single Set. That has as much credence. We all know that for each goal there is a range of TTI (time tension index) where we need a particular range or Time (duration) and Tension to stimulate the response. Deviations above or below this will change the adaptations. Casler writes: None of those points were subjects of the article. And if you read it closely it was a " meta-analysis " of research, not research itself. Flees writes: You are correct sir, this is not the study of this article, and that strawman idea, well, it is used just not for hypertrophy. Any who, my thing is in real life training, putting out 100% for 4 sets, is well impossible. If you get the same reps weight along with time of eccentric and coeccentric contraction, then, you were not putting your all into it. Theoretically, i feel you can only go all out once, and for example the squat 405 for ten reps with a longer negative will conclude better then 405 for 8 reps with a shorter negative. this will always be a conflicting arguement when specific to hypertrophy, just like carbs vs keto in dieting, i might not have every scientific analysis to back up my points, but i gauruntee you, that if you give it your all on that one set, compared to burning yourself out for those 4 sets just to be to taxed to actually lift that heavy weight to the best of your ability. Sorry for the disagreement, and how i did not notice the " meta-analysis " Flees Sterling, Virginia ________________________________ From: Casler <bioforce.inc@...> Supertraining Sent: Sun, March 21, 2010 2:16:05 PM Subject: Single vs Multiple Sets  Flees wrote: I can see how this theory is concluded, but do you think that the reason their is more hypertrophy followed by multiple sets then one set is because the total time under tension. Casler writes: It is because the additional sets allow an OVERLOAD to be produced, that eventually will not be available in a Single Set. Flees wrote: Lets say you did 4 sets of 10 reps with 135 for bench press at a 1 second positive and negative, now compare this to 135 for 1 set, of 10 reps, with 10 second negatives, and a 1 second explosive positive, whats the difference? for you 1 set you have a total of 110 seconds of time undertension, with your 4 sets you have a total of 80 seconds time undertension. So which would yeild better results? Casler writes: Extending the duration of the eccentric with a load imposed limit of the single set will not generally be superior. The more important issue is that 10 10sec eccentric actions will reduce the load you can use in the set. This imposition will by itself reduce the stimulus. And again the longer TUL (where the load will be lower) will likely only add to the endurance of the set. If the trainee has the strength for 1sec positive actions, then you would be better off raining the load and performing a natural speed eccentric. That would yield higher tension forces throughout the reps and set. Flees wrote: I believe their is a proper balance between sets and the actual rep. I do more of a HIT style of training being faithful to Dog crap, compared to the old volume approach i used to use for the first 4 years of lifting. My problem is that if you bench 135 just up and down for 4 sets of 10, well your hitting the muscle but i think a 2-3 second negative, is not only proper, but its been proven time and time and time again, the negative is the muscle building and strength portion of the lift. Casler writes: There is a large difference between a 2 second eccentric action and a 10 second. Flees wrote: If you go by the current theory that multiple sets is better then 1 set, why not go the extreme if more is better and do 50 sets of bench, just destroying everything bodypart each day? Casler writes: That is a Strawman argument and the article DID NOT suggest that multiple sets to the extreme be performed. Why not reverse your strawman and REDUCE the amount of training to a Single Rep of a Single Set. That has as much credence. We all know that for each goal there is a range of TTI (time tension index) where we need a particular range or Time (duration) and Tension to stimulate the response. Deviations above or below this will change the adaptations. Flees wrote: What about the massive caloric intake. Or the steroid abuse with the theory more is better. There is more to a workout then sets and reps. It takes a collaborative effort of nutrition, recovery, ROM, proper sets, training style and theory, supplements taken, body and muscle fiber types, its endless. Good research though. Casler writes: None of those points were subjects of the article. And if you read it closely it was a " meta-analysis " of research, not research itself. Regards, Casler TRI-VECTOR 3-D Force Systems Century City, CA Quote
Guest guest Posted March 22, 2010 Report Posted March 22, 2010 , You posted: " Another big issue with this is that progressive overload is great, what is the percentage of your 1 rep max, are you doing multiple sets with. I know i work up to 365 for a deadlift, and 5 or 6 of those sets are 1-3 reps, then 1 all out set of 365 for 5-6. How is it possible for me to comeback and do 365 again if i gave it my all on this one set? Trust me im (sic) 150 at 5'2, and trying to hit that weight twice, is a no go. " Multiple sets with 80%-100% of a 1RM are highly possible. Studies (I don't have the references but can supply them if needed) have shown time and time again that multiple sets can be performed at or very near 1RM weight. Power lifting and weight lifting competitions show this quite well. Most lifters will start their first attempt with 90%-95% 1RM. The second attempt is 100%-102% and if that is a successful attempt the third attempt is 105%-110% 1RM. Many lifters have hit Personal records on their second - which is what I did at the 1999 WABDL worlds - or third attempts. By your theory this would be impossible. You also stated: " i think a 2-3 second negative, is not only proper, but its been proven time and time and time again, the negative is the muscle building and strength portion of the lift " Actually it hasn't been proven that a 2-3 second " negative " is " proper " . A lifter who trains using a slow eccentric contraction cannot use the same amount of weight as a person who uses a natural movement time therefore the force placed on the motor units involved decreases. In order to improve strength one must generate force. This is done by increasing the weight or the movement speed. A slow eccentric focus is a construct of body building philosophies and it has its place among people who want to focus on muscular hypertrophy but not for those who wish to develop strength, power, speed or athletic performance. Casey Gallagher CSCS Snohomish, WA USA Single vs Multiple Sets Flees wrote: I can see how this theory is concluded, but do you think that the reason their is more hypertrophy followed by multiple sets then one set is because the total time under tension. Casler writes: It is because the additional sets allow an OVERLOAD to be produced, that eventually will not be available in a Single Set. Flees wrote: Lets say you did 4 sets of 10 reps with 135 for bench press at a 1 second positive and negative, now compare this to 135 for 1 set, of 10 reps, with 10 second negatives, and a 1 second explosive positive, whats the difference? for you 1 set you have a total of 110 seconds of time undertension, with your 4 sets you have a total of 80 seconds time undertension. So which would yeild better results? Casler writes: Extending the duration of the eccentric with a load imposed limit of the single set will not generally be superior. The more important issue is that 10 10sec eccentric actions will reduce the load you can use in the set. This imposition will by itself reduce the stimulus. And again the longer TUL (where the load will be lower) will likely only add to the endurance of the set. If the trainee has the strength for 1sec positive actions, then you would be better off raining the load and performing a natural speed eccentric. That would yield higher tension forces throughout the reps and set. Flees wrote: I believe their is a proper balance between sets and the actual rep. I do more of a HIT style of training being faithful to Dog crap, compared to the old volume approach i used to use for the first 4 years of lifting. My problem is that if you bench 135 just up and down for 4 sets of 10, well your hitting the muscle but i think a 2-3 second negative, is not only proper, but its been proven time and time and time again, the negative is the muscle building and strength portion of the lift. Casler writes: There is a large difference between a 2 second eccentric action and a 10 second. Flees wrote: If you go by the current theory that multiple sets is better then 1 set, why not go the extreme if more is better and do 50 sets of bench, just destroying everything bodypart each day? Casler writes: That is a Strawman argument and the article DID NOT suggest that multiple sets to the extreme be performed. Why not reverse your strawman and REDUCE the amount of training to a Single Rep of a Single Set. That has as much credence. We all know that for each goal there is a range of TTI (time tension index) where we need a particular range or Time (duration) and Tension to stimulate the response. Deviations above or below this will change the adaptations. Flees wrote: What about the massive caloric intake. Or the steroid abuse with the theory more is better. There is more to a workout then sets and reps. It takes a collaborative effort of nutrition, recovery, ROM, proper sets, training style and theory, supplements taken, body and muscle fiber types, its endless. Good research though. Casler writes: None of those points were subjects of the article. And if you read it closely it was a " meta-analysis " of research, not research itself. Regards, Casler TRI-VECTOR 3-D Force Systems Century City, CA Quote
Guest guest Posted March 22, 2010 Report Posted March 22, 2010 Any thoughts on the statement from the study " There was no significant difference between 2-3 sets per exercise and 4-6 sets per exercise (difference = 0.10 +/- 0.10; CI: -0.09, 0.30; p = 0.29) " Â Presumably that applied to both trained and untrained subjects. Â 2-3 sets is well below what one finds in the typical body building regime. Â Jon Haddan Irvine, CAÂ From: casey gallagher <gallagher2201@...> Subject: Re: Single vs Multiple Sets Supertraining Date: Monday, March 22, 2010, 11:38 AM , You posted: " Another big issue with this is that progressive overload is great, what is the percentage of your 1 rep max, are you doing multiple sets with. I know i work up to 365 for a deadlift, and 5 or 6 of those sets are 1-3 reps, then 1 all out set of 365 for 5-6. How is it possible for me to comeback and do 365 again if i gave it my all on this one set? Trust me im (sic) 150 at 5'2, and trying to hit that weight twice, is a no go. " Multiple sets with 80%-100% of a 1RM are highly possible. Studies (I don't have the references but can supply them if needed) have shown time and time again that multiple sets can be performed at or very near 1RM weight. Power lifting and weight lifting competitions show this quite well. Most lifters will start their first attempt with 90%-95% 1RM. The second attempt is 100%-102% and if that is a successful attempt the third attempt is 105%-110% 1RM. Many lifters have hit Personal records on their second - which is what I did at the 1999 WABDL worlds - or third attempts. By your theory this would be impossible. You also stated: " i think a 2-3 second negative, is not only proper, but its been proven time and time and time again, the negative is the muscle building and strength portion of the lift " Actually it hasn't been proven that a 2-3 second " negative " is " proper " . A lifter who trains using a slow eccentric contraction cannot use the same amount of weight as a person who uses a natural movement time therefore the force placed on the motor units involved decreases. In order to improve strength one must generate force. This is done by increasing the weight or the movement speed. A slow eccentric focus is a construct of body building philosophies and it has its place among people who want to focus on muscular hypertrophy but not for those who wish to develop strength, power, speed or athletic performance. Casey Gallagher CSCS Snohomish, WA USA ========================= Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 Casler wrote: It is because the additional sets allow an OVERLOAD to be produced, that eventually will not be available in a Single Set.  Hi , One need not produce an additional set at 365#. Overload can be established by dropping to 345# and performing 2-3 reps in a second or third set. Then next session same 345# for 3-4 reps, and so on. Point being that you add workload which produces overload as long as it is greater than the previous session(s). The " OVERLOAD " is in performing work beyond your previous session.  Writes: You are completely correct i have strayed from the article, i am sorry. My problem with overload, is mainly recovery abilities, and I am dead after additional sets, IF i give that one set my all, using forced reps and negatives. My problem with your overload statement is that you can increase workload in 1 set each workout. You either add more wieght, increase or decrease rep speed, and increase reps. The whole point of training is progression, dependent upon goals of size or strength, you will need different protocols for different training goals. Casler writes: Sounds like you are confusing " performance " with " intensity " . You are correct that you cannot likely produce 100% of the same performance immediately. But " intensity " is EFFORT to MOMENTARY ABILITY. So no matter how fatigued you are, you can still attempt 100% intensity to the effort if you wish. No where is it stated nor did I suggest that you need to duplicate the same " performance " . Hi INTENSITY to Ability is usually sufficient. Writes : I feel intensity and performance go hand and hand, the higher the intensity usually the better performance, but with again the overload principle is it really necessary to annhilate, or stimulate. Casler writes: Again, no matter how intensely you perform a single set, linear (single factor) progress has a limit. Once that limit is established, you will need to produce additional overload within the session to continue to stimulate gains. Writes : Additional overload does not mean extra sets.... I feel that you can keep progressing of single set training, as long as your overload on that set, and always improve from the last workout. Flees Sterling, Virginia ________________________________ From: Casler <bioforce.inc@...> Supertraining Sent: Mon, March 22, 2010 3:48:33 PM Subject: Single vs Multiple Sets  Casler wrote: It is because the additional sets allow an OVERLOAD to be produced, that eventually will not be available in a Single Set. Flees responds: Another big issue with this is that progressive overload is great, what is the percentage of your 1 rep max, are youi doing multiple sets with. I know i work up to 365 for a deadlift, and 5 or 6 of those sets are 1-3 reps, then 1 all out set of 365 for 5-6. How is it possible for me to comeback and do 365 again if i gave it my all on this one set? Trust me im 150 at 5'2, and trying to hit that weight twice, is a no go. Casler writes: Hi , One need not produce an additional set at 365#. Overload can be established by dropping to 345# and performing 2-3 reps in a second or third set. Then next session same 345# for 3-4 reps, and so on. Point being that you add workload which produces overload as long as it is greater than the previous session(s). Flees responds: The 10 sec is a hypothetical i usually stick with a 4-6 sec eccentric, and an explosive positive. Again half the sets people do up to their last set, should be counted as warmups. And last time i checked your not going to do 405 for 10 reps for 4 sets, usually people do 135 x 10, then 225 x 10, then 315 x 10, then they are to exhausted to hti the weight of 405 but get to it any ways, and do 405 for 8, when i impose all those sets should be warm ups of 3-5 reps, and 405 should be your working set. So where is the overload in your theory? If your really just building up lactate in the muscle and pre exhaustingit, or you could absolutely be freshed and warmed up. Casler writes: The " OVERLOAD " is in performing work beyond your previous session. Casler wrote: None of those points were subjects of the article. And if you read it closely it was a " meta-analysis " of research, not research itself. Flees responds: You are correct sir, this is not the study of this article, and that strawman idea, well, it is used just not for hypertrophy. Any who, my thing is in real life training, putting out 100% for 4 sets, is well impossible. If you get the same reps weight along with time of eccentric and coeccentric contraction, then, you were not putting your all into it. Theoretically, i feel you can only go all out once, and for example the squat 405 for ten reps with a longer negative will conclude better then 405 for 8 reps with a shorter negative. Casler writes: Sounds like you are confusing " performance " with " intensity " . You are correct that you cannot likely produce 100% of the same performance immediately. But " intensity " is EFFORT to MOMENTARY ABILITY. So no matter how fatigued you are, you can still attempt 100% intensity to the effort if you wish. No where is it stated nor did I suggest that you need to duplicate the same " performance " . Hi INTENSITY to Ability is usually sufficient. Flees responds: this will always be a conflicting arguement when specific to hypertrophy, just like carbs vs keto in dieting, i might not have every scientific analysis to back up my points, but i gauruntee you, that if you give it your all on that one set, compared to burning yourself out for those 4 sets just to be to taxed to actually lift that heavy weight to the best of your ability. Casler writes: Again, no matter how intensely you perform a single set, linear (single factor) progress has a limit. Once that limit is established, you will need to produce additional overload within the session to continue to stimulate gains. ========================== Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 " My problem with your overload statement is that you can increase workload in 1 set each workout. You either add more wieght (sic), increase or decrease rep speed, and increase reps. The whole point of training is progression, dependent upon goals of size or strength, you will need different protocols for different training goals. " Studies have shown time and time again - there have been at least two meta-analyses of studies posted on this forum alone - that multiple sets help one to improve strength, athletic performance and hypertrophy short term and long term versus single set training. " I feel intensity and performance go hand and hand, the higher the intensity usually the better performance, but with again the overload principle is it really necessary to annihilate, or stimulate. " Intensity and performance do not go hand in hand. In order to develop power, one must train at a low intensity using loads as light as body weight - plyometrics - and upwards of 60%-70% 1RM in a fatigue free environment in order to maintain or improve movement velocity from one set to the next. Casey Gallagher CSCS Snohomish, WA USA Single vs Multiple Sets Casler wrote: It is because the additional sets allow an OVERLOAD to be produced, that eventually will not be available in a Single Set. Flees responds: Another big issue with this is that progressive overload is great, what is the percentage of your 1 rep max, are youi doing multiple sets with. I know i work up to 365 for a deadlift, and 5 or 6 of those sets are 1-3 reps, then 1 all out set of 365 for 5-6. How is it possible for me to comeback and do 365 again if i gave it my all on this one set? Trust me im 150 at 5'2, and trying to hit that weight twice, is a no go. Casler writes: Hi , One need not produce an additional set at 365#. Overload can be established by dropping to 345# and performing 2-3 reps in a second or third set. Then next session same 345# for 3-4 reps, and so on. Point being that you add workload which produces overload as long as it is greater than the previous session(s). Flees responds: The 10 sec is a hypothetical i usually stick with a 4-6 sec eccentric, and an explosive positive. Again half the sets people do up to their last set, should be counted as warmups. And last time i checked your not going to do 405 for 10 reps for 4 sets, usually people do 135 x 10, then 225 x 10, then 315 x 10, then they are to exhausted to hti the weight of 405 but get to it any ways, and do 405 for 8, when i impose all those sets should be warm ups of 3-5 reps, and 405 should be your working set. So where is the overload in your theory? If your really just building up lactate in the muscle and pre exhaustingit, or you could absolutely be freshed and warmed up. Casler writes: The " OVERLOAD " is in performing work beyond your previous session. Casler wrote: None of those points were subjects of the article. And if you read it closely it was a " meta-analysis " of research, not research itself. Flees responds: You are correct sir, this is not the study of this article, and that strawman idea, well, it is used just not for hypertrophy. Any who, my thing is in real life training, putting out 100% for 4 sets, is well impossible. If you get the same reps weight along with time of eccentric and coeccentric contraction, then, you were not putting your all into it. Theoretically, i feel you can only go all out once, and for example the squat 405 for ten reps with a longer negative will conclude better then 405 for 8 reps with a shorter negative. Casler writes: Sounds like you are confusing " performance " with " intensity " . You are correct that you cannot likely produce 100% of the same performance immediately. But " intensity " is EFFORT to MOMENTARY ABILITY. So no matter how fatigued you are, you can still attempt 100% intensity to the effort if you wish. No where is it stated nor did I suggest that you need to duplicate the same " performance " . Hi INTENSITY to Ability is usually sufficient. Flees responds: this will always be a conflicting arguement when specific to hypertrophy, just like carbs vs keto in dieting, i might not have every scientific analysis to back up my points, but i gauruntee you, that if you give it your all on that one set, compared to burning yourself out for those 4 sets just to be to taxed to actually lift that heavy weight to the best of your ability. Casler writes: Again, no matter how intensely you perform a single set, linear (single factor) progress has a limit. Once that limit is established, you will need to produce additional overload within the session to continue to stimulate gains. ========================== Quote
Guest guest Posted March 24, 2010 Report Posted March 24, 2010 I find that if I don't do near maximal sets of 2s,3s,4s, and 5s in training with regards to bench pressing, squatting, deadlifting, and shoulder pressing my lifts go down. Any thoughts on this? Edwin Freeman, Jr. San Francisco, USA In a message dated 3/24/2010 1:02:52 P.M. Pacific Daylight Time, drew@... writes: , Assuming an the effort of the single set and final set of a multi set protocol are equal, I highly doubt what you're claiming. I have no doubts multiple sets are beneficial for the sake of neural adaptations/skill training for power lifters and weight lifters, however for the majority I doubt it makes as much of a difference as you claim. -- Drew Baye High Intensity Training www.baye.com Quote
Guest guest Posted March 25, 2010 Report Posted March 25, 2010 " Oh C'Mon " .... " Mentzer--Viator etal are the only Pros that ever trained " correctly " ! Jay The Muscle Couple Las Vegas, Nevada Single vs Multiple Sets , Assuming an the effort of the single set and final set of a multi set protocol are equal, I highly doubt what you're claiming. I have no doubts multiple sets are beneficial for the sake of neural adaptations/skill training for power lifters and weight lifters, however for the majority I doubt it makes as much of a difference as you claim. -- Drew Baye Casler writes: Firstly the " effort " in the session (sets) would not be " equal " as the body would be loaded beyond the previous session to cause overload. That is the idea behind Multiset Models. They build a greater controlled of overload distributed over more sets and reps. Thus the contention that a Single Set Model cannot ultimately produce an " equal " stimulus result of a Multiple Set Model. Your assertion was that to create " overload " within a Single Set, all you had to do is " work harder " . I gave you a Rep Max example where you could NOT work harder within the Single Set model. Do you then doubt that additional loadings in a second set will cause overload? Do you also doubt that additional overload stimulus will cause further adaptation? You also forgot to post your method for creating " overload " within a Single Rep Maximum Set that has plateaued. And why would such overload of multiple set means be more specific or appropriate to a particular type of strength athlete? If the Single Set Model displayed the OPTIMAL stimulus possible, we would only need train a SINGLE REP MAXIMUM set (such as the 10RM I listed earlier) each workout and have perfectly linear progress to full genetic realization. Do you have a single example of any such occurrence? Would you not agree that the worlds elite strength athletes and bodybuilders ALL train on a multiset model? Regards, Casler TRI-VECTOR 3-D Force Systems Century City, CA Quote
Guest guest Posted March 25, 2010 Report Posted March 25, 2010 Mark, I worked out at Gold's during the latter half of the 70s.  This was after Joe Gold had sold the gym and it had been relocated to Santa . The Menzters were there.  I agree with your assessment. I don't remember anything about their workouts that stood out from the other bodybuilders. Jon HaddanIrvine, CA From: Mark Cotton <mark@...> Subject: Re: Single vs Multiple Sets Supertraining Date: Tuesday, March 23, 2010, 6:40 PM Hi all-  This is an interesting topic.  If we look back at bodybuilders in the 60's and 70's and view their training logs (or what are reported to be their logs) we find that a high number of multiple sets are used per body part. Arnold, Draper, Zane, Beckles...they all did huge multiple sets numbering as much as 15-20 per body part. Bear in mind that they generally kept the rep range in the 10-12 range for hypertrophy. I understand that they were aided athletes. Still, that is enormous volume.  Now here comes Mike and Ray Mentzer with this idea of " pre-fatigue " and sets to failure. They along with Arthur believed that this was the most efficient way to train. Years later, Dorian Yates did something similar with HIT Training.  This is all well and good, but if you study the Mentzers and Yates you find two things. First, they built award winning physiques the more traditional way. This tells us that volume based upon multiple sets respecting a rep range works. Secondly, even after they " converted " to new ways of training something interesting is noticed. They used " warm up sets " using progressively heavier weights until they felt sufficiently " warmed up " to start their working sets of 2-4 sets. That being said you could make the argument that 5 sets of incline bench press using heavier weights each set and then starting heavy incline flyes immediately followed by incline bench to failure for two cycles is now 9 sets for pecs. Yates in that respect, is no different.  The single set theory is something that Mike Mentzer experimented with later in his life. He even felt that if a set was done properly that you could work a bodypart once or twice a month. Really?  If you were going to perform the perfect set what or how would it be performed? Start with maybe 4 reps, forced reps, then negatives, then drops all within one set? (did I forget anything)? This would ensure total failure. But, would it really? After a rest period of five minutes you could repeat it again. How many more times until you could not continue? Is this failure? If so, what is the recovery time? Two days, two weeks? What hog wash!  Multiple sets serve a purpose. You just can't accomplish all you need to in a low number of sets as your training age increases. I agree with Casey, " Studies have shown time and time again - there have been at least two meta-analyses of studies posted on this forum alone - that multiple sets help one to improve strength, athletic performance and hypertrophy short term and long term versus single set training. "  I was long winded and I apologize.  Thanks, Extreme Conditioning Personal Training Mark Cotton, B.A., PICP & ISSA Certified East Brunswick, NJ (732) 979-7201 =================== Quote
Guest guest Posted March 25, 2010 Report Posted March 25, 2010 , Thanks for the clarification. Do you have any thoughts on Rhea's meta-analysis conclusion that up to 8 sets per muscle group part were optimal for strength gains for highly conditioned athletes, whereas I believe he concluded 4 sets was sufficient for recreational athletes.  Jon Haddan Irvine, CA From: shredaholic <Yngvai@...> Subject: Re: Single vs Multiple Sets Supertraining Date: Tuesday, March 23, 2010, 1:42 PM > > Any thoughts on the statement from the study " There was no significant difference between 2-3 sets per exercise and 4-6 sets per exercise (difference = 0.10 +/- 0.10; CI: -0.09, 0.30; p = 0.29) "  > Presumably that applied to both trained and untrained subjects.  2-3 sets is well below what one finds in the typical body building regime.  > Hi, Jon, I am the author of this paper. There were only 2 studies in my analysis that involved 4-6 sets per exercise. Because of this, the statistical power to detect a difference between the 2-3 set category and the 4-6 set category is very low. More studies in the 4-6 set category would be needed to know if there is a true difference. Also, I incorporated studies that used " sets per exercise " as the criteria. However, in bodybuilding routines, you can have multiple exercises. Thus, you could do 2-3 sets per exercise, but 2-3 exercises per muscle group. My paper was not able to address this because of the limited number of studies incorporated. However, when looking at the magnitude of the effect size estimates, gains started to taper off at the 4-6 set per exercise category. Thus, even when looking at it in a per muscle group sense, there is probably little benefit to doing more than 4-6 sets per muscle group. This is supported further when you look at my previous meta-analysis on strength. In that paper, there was no significant interaction between multiple exercises per body part and set volume. This means that if you did, say, 3 sets per exercise, there was no benefit to doing multiple exercises for the same muscle groups. Strength gains in this study also plateaued at 4-6 sets per exercise (with, again, the caveat of limited studies in the 4-6 set range). ==================== Quote
Guest guest Posted March 25, 2010 Report Posted March 25, 2010 I have a few. Strength is not just a function of hypertrophy. As, many here appear to think. But, it is also a functional of neurological adaptations. Not just the adaptations that occur when learning a novel task but at all levels of athlete during the training process. So, if you are not training in the 2-5 rep zone you are probably missing that. Phil Caraher, Chapel Hill, NC _____ From: Supertraining [mailto:Supertraining ] On Behalf Of efreem3407@... Sent: Wednesday, March 24, 2010 4:55 PM Supertraining Subject: Re: Single vs Multiple Sets I find that if I don't do near maximal sets of 2s,3s,4s, and 5s in training with regards to bench pressing, squatting, deadlifting, and shoulder pressing my lifts go down. Any thoughts on this? Edwin Freeman, Jr. San Francisco, USA In a message dated 3/24/2010 1:02:52 P.M. Pacific Daylight Time, drew@... <mailto:drew%40baye.com> writes: , Assuming an the effort of the single set and final set of a multi set protocol are equal, I highly doubt what you're claiming. I have no doubts multiple sets are beneficial for the sake of neural adaptations/skill training for power lifters and weight lifters, however for the majority I doubt it makes as much of a difference as you claim. =================== Quote
Guest guest Posted March 25, 2010 Report Posted March 25, 2010 Power has two components. It is not just the speed of the movement as you seem to suggest. VZ makes clear the adaptations that occur with various percentages of 1RM. The adaptations are very specific and you should take a look has his research. Training with low percaentages improves power with low percentages of 1RM, etc. Plyometrics or more correctly the stretch-shortening cycle is a motor control issue. Specifically because its training the proprioceptors including the muscle spindles and GTO's. It is quite different that strength and power training/development. Phil Caraher DPT, MS, CSCS Chapel Hill, NC _____ From: Supertraining [mailto:Supertraining ] On Behalf Of casey gallagher Sent: Wednesday, March 24, 2010 10:52 AM Supertraining Subject: Re: Single vs Multiple Sets Giovanni, Most of what I've read - Don Chu, Zatsiorsky and so on - shows that weights between 40%-60% 1RM are sufficient to develop power. Since there is essentially a maximum or ideal movement speed, when using loads that drop below 40% force diminishes and power output decreases. My comment about plyometrics was to illustrate that there is (most often) no external load used other than gravity and the person's body weight. Casey Gallagher CSCS Snohomish, WA USA Single vs Multiple Sets > > Casler wrote: > > It is because the additional sets allow an OVERLOAD to be produced, that > eventually will not be available in a Single Set. > > Flees responds: > Another big issue with this is that progressive overload is great, what is > the percentage of your 1 rep max, are youi doing multiple sets with. I know > > i work up to 365 for a deadlift, and 5 or 6 of those sets are 1-3 reps, > then > 1 all out set of 365 for 5-6. How is it possible for me to comeback and do > 365 again if i gave it my all on this one set? Trust me im 150 at 5'2, and > trying to hit that weight twice, is a no go. > > Casler writes: > > Hi , One need not produce an additional set at 365#. Overload can be > established by dropping to 345# and performing 2-3 reps in a second or > third > set. > > Then next session same 345# for 3-4 reps, and so on. Point being that you > add workload which produces overload as long as it is greater than the > previous session(s). > > Flees responds: > > The 10 sec is a hypothetical i usually stick with a 4-6 sec eccentric, and > an explosive positive. Again half the sets people do up to their last set, > should be counted as warmups. And last time i checked your not going to do > 405 for 10 reps for 4 sets, usually people do 135 x 10, then 225 x 10, then > > 315 x 10, then they are to exhausted to hti the weight of 405 but get to it > > any ways, and do 405 for 8, when i impose all those sets should be warm ups > > of 3-5 reps, and 405 should be your working set. So where is the overload > in > your theory? If your really just building up lactate in the muscle and pre > exhaustingit, or you could absolutely be freshed and warmed up. > > Casler writes: > > The " OVERLOAD " is in performing work beyond your previous session. > > Casler wrote: > > None of those points were subjects of the article. And if you read it > closely it was a " meta-analysis " of research, not research itself. > > Flees responds: > You are correct sir, this is not the study of this article, and that > strawman idea, well, it is used just not for hypertrophy. Any who, my thing > > is in real life training, putting out 100% for 4 sets, is well impossible. > If you get the same reps weight along with time of eccentric and > coeccentric > contraction, then, you were not putting your all into it. Theoretically, i > feel you can only go all out once, and for example the squat 405 for ten > reps with a longer negative will conclude better then 405 for 8 reps with a > > shorter negative. > > Casler writes: > > Sounds like you are confusing " performance " with " intensity " . You are > correct that you cannot likely produce 100% of the same performance > immediately. But " intensity " is EFFORT to MOMENTARY ABILITY. So no matter > how fatigued you are, you can still attempt 100% intensity to the effort if > > you wish. > > No where is it stated nor did I suggest that you need to duplicate the same > > " performance " . Hi INTENSITY to Ability is usually sufficient. > > Flees responds: > this will always be a conflicting arguement when specific to hypertrophy, > just like carbs vs keto in dieting, i might not have every scientific > analysis to back up my points, but i gauruntee you, that if you give it > your > all on that one set, compared to burning yourself out for those 4 sets just > > to be to taxed to actually lift that heavy weight to the best of your > ability. > > Casler writes: > > Again, no matter how intensely you perform a single set, linear (single > factor) progress has a limit. > > Once that limit is established, you will need to produce additional > overload > within the session to continue to stimulate gains. > > ========================== > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 25, 2010 Report Posted March 25, 2010 Powerlifters train for maximum intensity all the time? If maximum is giving all you have for one rep and not being able to perform a second; then powerlifters are doing that in the squat, bench press, and deadlift. Weightlifters would be doing that in the snatch and clean and jerk. Edwin Freeman, Jr. San Francisco, USA In a message dated 3/25/2010 11:07:25 A.M. Pacific Daylight Time, JRTELLE@... writes: Hi and all, I assume you, , mean that one cannot reach potential on 1 working set -- assuming 2 -3 warmup sets. This may not be the case. When one considers all the con and eccentric variations that no one has even tried, it MAY be possible to reach max strength and hypertrophy on one working set. Since no one, that I know of, has even approached a 100% intensity set, wisely, nor have studies addressed the many variations of concentric or concentric-eccentric sets -- I believe 1 working set is enough for the vast number of non elite trainers? I assume is attempting to and performing near or max intensity concentric sets. That being the case more than 1 working set may be enough with anything more being overtraining. Most of us remember that Dorian Yates believed in these 1-2 max sets and he didn't (?) even use max over load eccentrics? We also may remember that he was often hurt with a permanently torn/ deformed biceps. Speaking of high/max intensity reps/sets, has anyone even attempted to define, measure and control for various intensity reps? ????? Jerry Telle Lakewood CO USA Quote
Guest guest Posted March 25, 2010 Report Posted March 25, 2010 In terms of muscle strength and hypertrophy stimulus, would you consider 10 rest-pause repetitions (of a basic compound exercise) with a resistance that is approx 2 RM and a 10 sec rest between each rep to be:  a) 1 set of 10  10 sets of 1 rep c) or something else  Ed White CapeCod, MA USA Speaking of high/max intensity reps/sets, has anyone even attempted to define, measure and control for various intensity reps? Casler writes: I have a provisional patent on such a device. I defined INTENSITY as Effort to Ability. The measure was an electronic means that measured and recorded the current reps and set forces every degree of the ROM. It then held those measurements in memory and provided real-time comparisons on the next training session. Since numbers would be too quickly generated for the trainee to react to, I employed a colored system of backlighting on the screen. Blue = effort below last session and lower intensity Green = Exactly the same effort and EQUAL intensity Yellow = Slightly greater effort and greater intensity Orange and Red = Higher levels of intensity over the last performance So the interaction was one of attempting to stay at least in the Yellow for each degree of motion for each rep. Keep in mind this comparison was measuring the " real time " effort (each millisecond) and comparing it to the last best performance from you on the machine. So the colors were adjusting the screen glow continuously, and your efforts were to attempt to escalate your performance in a way that displayed an equaling or increase in your performance and this intensity. (this is making the assumption that your last and present performances were sufficiently high intensity efforts) This however is NOT actually a measure of intensity as much as a measure of relative intensity of performance based on a previous intensity measurement, but it was the best I could come up with for progressive use of an " relative " intensity measure. I felt the device could be incredibly useful in advising patients and trainees on the " level " of effort (INTENSITY) they should train. For example a rehab patient or senior citizen might want to only see green and yellow glow for most of the exercise. A competitive athlete might want to NOT see any green and only Yellow Orange. You could even assign a level to specific reps like RED in the first reps, or last reps, depending on the program. Regards, Casler TRI-VECTOR 3-D Force Systems Century City, CA Quote
Guest guest Posted March 26, 2010 Report Posted March 26, 2010 I'm well aware that power has two components. I am making brief synopses statements. Training with low percentages while in the same week training with high percentages improves strength and power. Plyometrics can and do improve power. I didn't go into the reasons why because I felt it wasn't necessary for this thread. But more to the point, plyometrics stimulate the afferent and efferent responses through the MSF and flower spray organs. They desensitize the GTO in order to improve the stretch reflex. Casey Gallagher CSCS Snohomish WA USA Single vs Multiple Sets > > Casler wrote: > > It is because the additional sets allow an OVERLOAD to be produced, that > eventually will not be available in a Single Set. > > Flees responds: > Another big issue with this is that progressive overload is great, what is > the percentage of your 1 rep max, are youi doing multiple sets with. I know > > i work up to 365 for a deadlift, and 5 or 6 of those sets are 1-3 reps, > then > 1 all out set of 365 for 5-6. How is it possible for me to comeback and do > 365 again if i gave it my all on this one set? Trust me im 150 at 5'2, and > trying to hit that weight twice, is a no go. > > Casler writes: > > Hi , One need not produce an additional set at 365#. Overload can be > established by dropping to 345# and performing 2-3 reps in a second or > third > set. > > Then next session same 345# for 3-4 reps, and so on. Point being that you > add workload which produces overload as long as it is greater than the > previous session(s). > > Flees responds: > > The 10 sec is a hypothetical i usually stick with a 4-6 sec eccentric, and > an explosive positive. Again half the sets people do up to their last set, > should be counted as warmups. And last time i checked your not going to do > 405 for 10 reps for 4 sets, usually people do 135 x 10, then 225 x 10, then > > 315 x 10, then they are to exhausted to hti the weight of 405 but get to it > > any ways, and do 405 for 8, when i impose all those sets should be warm ups > > of 3-5 reps, and 405 should be your working set. So where is the overload > in > your theory? If your really just building up lactate in the muscle and pre > exhaustingit, or you could absolutely be freshed and warmed up. > > Casler writes: > > The " OVERLOAD " is in performing work beyond your previous session. > > Casler wrote: > > None of those points were subjects of the article. And if you read it > closely it was a " meta-analysis " of research, not research itself. > > Flees responds: > You are correct sir, this is not the study of this article, and that > strawman idea, well, it is used just not for hypertrophy. Any who, my thing > > is in real life training, putting out 100% for 4 sets, is well impossible. > If you get the same reps weight along with time of eccentric and > coeccentric > contraction, then, you were not putting your all into it. Theoretically, i > feel you can only go all out once, and for example the squat 405 for ten > reps with a longer negative will conclude better then 405 for 8 reps with a > > shorter negative. > > Casler writes: > > Sounds like you are confusing " performance " with " intensity " . You are > correct that you cannot likely produce 100% of the same performance > immediately. But " intensity " is EFFORT to MOMENTARY ABILITY. So no matter > how fatigued you are, you can still attempt 100% intensity to the effort if > > you wish. > > No where is it stated nor did I suggest that you need to duplicate the same > > " performance " . Hi INTENSITY to Ability is usually sufficient. > > Flees responds: > this will always be a conflicting arguement when specific to hypertrophy, > just like carbs vs keto in dieting, i might not have every scientific > analysis to back up my points, but i gauruntee you, that if you give it > your > all on that one set, compared to burning yourself out for those 4 sets just > > to be to taxed to actually lift that heavy weight to the best of your > ability. > > Casler writes: > > Again, no matter how intensely you perform a single set, linear (single > factor) progress has a limit. > > Once that limit is established, you will need to produce additional > overload > within the session to continue to stimulate gains. > > ========================== > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 26, 2010 Report Posted March 26, 2010 > , > Thanks for the clarification. Do you have any thoughts on Rhea's meta-analysis conclusion that up to 8 sets per muscle group part were optimal for strength gains for highly conditioned athletes, whereas I believe he concluded 4 sets was sufficient for recreational athletes. Â > Jon Haddan > Irvine, CA Hi, Jon, I don't trust the conclusions of Rhea's meta-analyses. There are a lot of problems with the methodology of their papers. In fact I'm kind of surprised they were published. Krieger Editor, Journal of Pure Power Analyst, Vivacity Redmond, WA Quote
Guest guest Posted March 26, 2010 Report Posted March 26, 2010 Hi Ed, Your question exemplifies my concerns with various different training paradigms, the operations to define them and the studies needed for comparisons. Science is a good distance in the future. Isaac Berger did a drop set study in the mid 60's that suggested the utility of 10 sets of 1 rep drop sets -- considered by Berger to be 1 set of descending reps. Despite the positive results, I have seen no other studies comparing drop sets with more traditional training. There were a few questionable drop set studies by ?????? a Nautilus proponent indicating possible drop set benefits. Jerry Telle Lakewood CO USA On Mar 25, 2010, at 7:49 PM, Ed White wrote: > In terms of muscle strength and hypertrophy stimulus, would you > consider 10 rest-pause repetitions (of a basic compound exercise) > with a resistance that is approx 2 RM and a 10 sec rest between each > rep to be: > > a) 1 set of 10 > 10 sets of 1 rep > c) or something else > > Ed White > CapeCod, MA USA Quote
Guest guest Posted March 26, 2010 Report Posted March 26, 2010 H i , I essentially agree with everything you have expressed. Still I would like research to demonstrate your projections. It may be that you, and the likes of you, with the tremendous physical endowments you have would need 3-4 working sets (at what level of intensity?) while others would get 98% benefits from , after 2 warmup sets, 1 set training? Thanks for the Yates revelations. I always wondered about this. > Casler writes: > > I would contend that it is virtually impossible for a healthy > trainee to > Over Train or even Over Reach via a Single Set Model no matter what > the > intensity. I have simply witnessed and personally performed too many > higher > volume (more than a SINGLE SET) High Intensity sets to think that > possible. > ---------- AND It is at this point where the multi-set model will continue to > > produce progress due to the ability to create an overload NOT > available in > but a Single Set Rep Maximum that has plateaued. This is due to a > DIRECT > (not SUPER) COMPENSATION, where the adaptation is directly > proportional to > the overload created over multiple sets > Telle -- This belief I might contest. When each positive rep (8-10) is done with a 1RM descending weight and every eccentric rep is a max (nearly) eccentric overload as operationally defined by rep speed -- about 1-1.5 second that cannot be stopped. I've never seen anyone (of the few I have asked to perform) that were not completely???!! trained. As a matter of fact this just about put them into shock and this paradigm was dropped! in favor of of 6-8 rep same load drop sets with eccentrics about 80% of momentary eccentric strength (again estimated by apparent? momentary effort and speed). The machine I invented seemed to well for some variations. As always, Jerry Telle Lakewood CO USA On Mar 25, 2010, at 1:14 PM, Casler wrote: > Jerry Telle wrote: > Hi and all, > > I assume you, , mean that one cannot reach potential on 1 > working set -- assuming 2 -3 warm-up sets. > > Casler wrote: > > My argument is based " specifically " on the assertion that a SINGLE > SET per > bodypart or specific exercise can produce the same stimulus as a > Multiple > Set Model. > > The proponents of this Model often claim it has the ability to > produce the > ultimate/optimal stimulus and that further stimulation is not only not > beneficial, but it is counterproductive. > > They also generally are against ANY warm up or approach/prep sets, > which > would then move us to the Multi-Set Model. > > Jerry Telle wrote: > This may not be the case. When one considers all the con and eccentric > variations that no one has even tried, > it MAY be possible to reach max strength and hypertrophy on one > working set. > > Casler writes: > > In theory at some point in performing a Single Set only, you would > attain a > Rep Maximum ability. You may even increase that slightly (if a > beginner or > intermediate trainee) via " leapfrog " SuperCompensation. If followed > progressively you will plateau as SuperCompensatory gains diminish. > > It is at this point that it becomes impossible to produce an > overload to the > body. It is at this point where the multi-set model will continue to > produce progress due to the ability to create an overload NOT > available in > but a Single Set Rep Maximum that has plateaued. This is due to a > DIRECT > (not SUPER) COMPENSATION, where the adaptation is directly > proportional to > the overload created over multiple sets. > > Jerry Telle wrote: > Since no one, that I know of, has even approached a 100% intensity > set, wisely, nor have studies addressed the many variations of > concentric or concentric-eccentric sets -- I believe 1 working set is > enough for the vast number of non elite trainers? > > Casler writes: > > To be sure, for lower level needs, there is an economy/efficiency to > the > Single Set Model and that is not the issue for me. > > Jerry Telle wrote: > I assume is attempting to and performing near or max intensity > concentric sets. That being the case more than 1 working > set may be enough with anything more being overtraining. > > Casler writes: > > I would contend that it is virtually impossible for a healthy > trainee to > Over Train or even Over Reach via a Single Set Model no matter what > the > intensity. I have simply witnessed and personally performed too many > higher > volume (more than a SINGLE SET) High Intensity sets to think that > possible. > > I would grant however if you employed a great number of exercises in a > routine, one might possibly need to increase recovery periods. > > Jerry Telle wrote: > Most of us remember that Dorian Yates believed in these 1-2 max sets > and he > didn't (?) even use max over load > eccentrics? > > Casler writes: > > I was training at Golds a couple times when Dorian was there and > observed > him a bit as we were using the same pulldown machine. He performed a > warm > up set with around 200# and then 3 sets with 300-400#. I might add > that > this was after some VERY HEAVY Barbell Rowing. > > So my observation did not support the claims that he trains with a > Single > Set Model. > > Jerry Telle wrote: > Speaking of high/max intensity reps/sets, has anyone even attempted to > define, measure and control for various intensity reps? > > Casler writes: > > I have a provisional patent on such a device. > > I defined INTENSITY as Effort to Ability. The measure was an > electronic > means that measured and recorded the current reps and set forces every > degree of the ROM. It then held those measurements in memory and > provided > real-time comparisons on the next training session. Since numbers > would be > too quickly generated for the trainee to react to, I employed a > colored > system of backlighting on the screen. > > Blue = effort below last session and lower intensity > Green = Exactly the same effort and EQUAL intensity > Yellow = Slightly greater effort and greater intensity > Orange and Red = Higher levels of intensity over the last performance > > So the interaction was one of attempting to stay at least in the > Yellow for > each degree of motion for each rep. > > Keep in mind this comparison was measuring the " real time " effort > (each > millisecond) and comparing it to the last best performance from you > on the > machine. So the colors were adjusting the screen glow continuously, > and > your efforts were to attempt to escalate your performance in a way > that > displayed an equaling or increase in your performance and this > intensity. > (this is making the assumption that your last and present > performances were > sufficiently high intensity efforts) > > This however is NOT actually a measure of intensity as much as a > measure of > relative intensity of performance based on a previous intensity > measurement, > but it was the best I could come up with for progressive use of an > " relative " intensity measure. > > I felt the device could be incredibly useful in advising patients and > trainees on the " level " of effort (INTENSITY) they should train. For > example a rehab patient or senior citizen might want to only see > green and > yellow glow for most of the exercise. A competitive athlete might > want to > NOT see any green and only Yellow Orange. You could even assign a > level to > specific reps like RED in the first reps, or last reps, depending on > the > program. > > Regards, > > Casler > TRI-VECTOR 3-D Force Systems > Century City, CA > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 27, 2010 Report Posted March 27, 2010 Hi Jerry! You refer to Dr. Berger's study done in the 1960's. Issac Berger was weightlifting silver medalist in the 1964 Olympics in the 60 kg. class. He also held the world record in the C & J in the same class. To my knowldege the study has not been replicated. Best wishes! Dan Wathen, Youngstown (OH) State University, USA > > > In terms of muscle strength and hypertrophy stimulus, would you > > consider 10 rest-pause repetitions (of a basic compound exercise) > > with a resistance that is approx 2 RM and a 10 sec rest between each > > rep to be: > > > > a) 1 set of 10 > > 10 sets of 1 rep > > c) or something else > > > > Ed White > > CapeCod, MA USA > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 27, 2010 Report Posted March 27, 2010 Casey, Yes. I agree and I think we are saying the same thing. Phil Caraher CH, NC _____ From: Supertraining [mailto:Supertraining ] On Behalf Of casey gallagher Sent: Friday, March 26, 2010 11:26 AM Supertraining Subject: Re: Single vs Multiple Sets I'm well aware that power has two components. I am making brief synopses statements. Training with low percentages while in the same week training with high percentages improves strength and power. Plyometrics can and do improve power. I didn't go into the reasons why because I felt it wasn't necessary for this thread. But more to the point, plyometrics stimulate the afferent and efferent responses through the MSF and flower spray organs. They desensitize the GTO in order to improve the stretch reflex. =========================== Quote
Guest guest Posted March 29, 2010 Report Posted March 29, 2010 > Casler writes: > > Strangely enough the Single Set proponents always trot out Dorian [Yates] ... > > And while it might be claimed that [Yates] DID on occasion train a Single Set > OF AN EXERCISE to FAILURE, they performed MULTIPLE Sets for each BodyPart > which is MULTI-SET training, NOT Single. The classification of Dorian Yates as a proponent of " single set training " has always boggled my mind as well. In a way, I supposed he was a " single set trainer " since he was using only a single set per exercise, but, as you say above, , everything that I have been able to find about Yates also indicates that he performed multiple exercises per body part. IE chest day would consist of multiple pressing movements with barbells, dumbells, and machines, followed by flys. If these workouts are correct, Yates was not performing only one set per muscle group. Clearly, he was using a smaller volume than many of his bodybuilding forebears, but he was also clearly not an advocate of something like HIT training (or even one set per muscle group). Crain Los Angeles, CA Quote
Guest guest Posted March 30, 2010 Report Posted March 30, 2010 Greetings , Casler writes: If you perform " warm-up " and approach sets you have already moved to a multi-set model. Telle -- Right, I don't think it is possible, save absolute strength circumstances, to recruit Fast twitch fibers maximally with out a warmup(s). Casler writes: For one to believe that a Single Set to Failure can produce equal or better results than a multiple set schema you need to buy into the OPTIMAL Stimulus argument, that you can provide the maximal and optimal stimulus to a muscle via a Single Set taken to Exhaustive Failure. Telle -- Not sure we have total semantic overlap but does not an optimal stimulus also require an optimal load? Casler writes: To accept this you need then agree that no matter what your condition that you can somehow produce an overload within that set, or believe that the body will produce SuperCompensation indefinitely. In the arena of stimuli you have TENSIONS, and you have Fatigues. The Fatigues are Metabolic, Neural, Muscular, and Mental. In Strength Training the Primary Stimulus is Tension, with all the Fatigues providing the supporting roles to stimulus. All models of training combine these stimulus elements to an OVERLOAD within the framework of the current condition or last, most recent stimulus. That is, for an adaptive response to occur, the most recent stimulus " package " (not the government version) must in some way exceed what the organism has been previously exposed to. Telle -- I think I see what your " stimulus, " in a general sense, means(?). And I assume that " the most recent stimulus " package " must in some way exceed what the organism has been previously exposed to " by [Telle] or because the supercompensation has resulted in greater strength (hypertrophic here) and can thus produce greater tensions to an overload (more weight at original speed or greater speed at the previous weight.? And greater fatigue can/is accomplished (though I need a good quantifying definition of fatigue.) Maybe a difference in max weight/speed over fatigued state failure?????? I admit to " fatigue " ignorance -- how to define it. Casler writes: In the beginning trainees make a type of progress I call " leapfrog " or SUPER Compensation. This progress is usually rapid and driven by the fact that the Motor System can learn rather quickly how to produce and apply more force than the muscle have been accustomed to (overload), this then causes the muscles to adapt to the HIGHER TENSIONS and WORK via protein synthesis (growth). Telle -- as long as I'm this far out on the limb, does muscle fiber summation increase with training or is greater tension mainly a synchronization function? Obviously synchronization leads to greater connective tissue tension -- but not to specific fibers? Casler writes: This process occurs for a short period driven by the cycle of neural and tissue adaptations (leapfrogging) to appear as " overcompensatory " adaptations. However the SuperCompensation observation reaches diminishing returns when applied via a Single Set program. Telle -- Are there studies directly demonstrating this? Is the relationship linear or generally curvilinear? Were any of the studies HIIT (Yates) style? do researchers even know the difference and of course how was intensity measured. Casler writes: Now you are faced with a dilemma of accepting that " further " stimulus via a second set will cause a greater stimulus, or that it will cause an " overtraining or over-reaching " result. Well of course we already know that it DOES NOT cause overtraining unless carried to the extreme under long term circumstances. Telle -- I had lunch, the other day, with a person who used my version of a max intensity set, at least 10 years ago. The particulars, 1. He trained by himself which meant no mental " goading " from me, 2. The 1 set included 10 reps, each a drop rep/set of 1 from the original 95% positive 1RM, starting weight. Each following rep being a projected 90-100% momentary 1RM. 3. The negatives were my negative enhancement techniques -- that is manipulating lever arm/moment physics to increase relative resistance during the negative action. 4. His " intensity " by my estimation (no EMG or other monitoring devices) was about 90% of competition max. I don't think he ever trained solely for max strength. 5. We have trained together off and on for 50 years. So I have a lot of anecdotal information. 6. My research training machine could provide the same resistance -- that is using a linear actuator to adjust positive and negative inertial load. Training in this manner produced the same resistance efect os the free weight loads. We stopped his max training after the 2nd session. As he put it. " The first training session was fine, the second a real mental effort " And " the third would have been an impossibility. " He remembers? not sleeping well for 2 nights after each session at once a week training. That's one set of a 10 rep set of 1RM with eccentric overload each rep.. We switched him back to a 5-7 rep drop set protocol for 3 total sets and did he fine! So in my estimation 1 set of 10 reps can produce (probably mental) over training Casler writes: We also know that increased workload (adequately applied) DOES cause overload conditions and further progress. The fallacy of the single set model as optimal also is based on the limited assumption that " full metabolic, mental and neural " exhaustion is the Optimal Stimulus, when it is not. The optimal stimulus for Strength training is Progressively Overloading the Tensions and the Work that a muscle(s) is exposed to. It is IMPOSSIBLE to create a continuously available overload indefinitely via a SINGLE SET. No one has ever done it, and no one is currently doing it. Telle-- Nor is it likely anyone will. I remember reading that Mentzer (reliability?) trained Yates for 1 set of 6 reps with a similar protocol for Nautilus pullovers. I assume this was a single? training session in this manner? I remember lots of " Mentzer talk " in the article. Casler writes; What IS possible is that you can reach a fairly high level (% result) via the Single Set model with the highest intensity (highest effort to each moment of the exercise). But just like there is no real perpetual motion machine, there is no single example of any elite strength athlete or World Champion employing anything close to this model. Telle -- STILL I would still like to know the results of a really intense 1 drop set protocol. Isn't this fun? As always, Jerry Telle Lakewood CO USA Jerry Telle wrote: Thanks for the Yates revelations. I always wondered about this. Casler writes: Strangely enough the Single Set proponents always trot out Dorian or Mike (who was an old friend of mine for many years) as examples of such training when neither actually succeeded in using that model for their ultimate genetic expression during their peaks. And while it might be claimed that they DID on occasion train a Single Set OF AN EXERCISE to FAILURE, they performed MULTIPLE Sets for each BodyPart which is MULTI-SET training, NOT Single On Mar 27, 2010, at 10:07 AM, Casler wrote: > Jerry Telle wrote: > > H i , > > I essentially agree with everything you have expressed. Still I would > like research to demonstrate > your projections. It may be that you, and the likes of you, with the > tremendous physical endowments > you have would need 3-4 working sets (at what level of intensity?) > while > others would get 98% benefits > from , after 2 warmup sets, 1 set training? > > Casler writes: > > Hi Jerry, > > If you perform " warm-up " and approach sets you have already moved to a > multi-set model. > > For one to believe that a Single Set to Failure can produce equal or > better > results than a multiple set schema you need to buy into the OPTIMAL > Stimulus > argument, that you can provide the maximal and optimal stimulus to a > muscle > via a Single Set taken to Exhaustive Failure. > > To accept this you need then agree that no matter what your > condition that > you can somehow produce an overload within that set, or believe that > the > body will produce SuperCompensation indefinitely. > > In the arena of stimuli you have TENSIONS, and you have Fatigues. The > Fatigues are Metabolic, Neural, Muscular, and Mental. In Strength > Training > the Primary Stimulus is Tension, with all the Fatigues providing the > supporting roles to stimulus. All models of training combine these > stimulus > elements to an OVERLOAD within the framework of the current > condition or > last, most recent stimulus. That is, for an adaptive response to > occur, the > most recent stimulus " package " (not the government version) must in > some way > exceed what the organism has been previously exposed to. > > In the beginning trainees make a type of progress I call " leapfrog " > or SUPER > Compensation. This progress is usually rapid and driven by the fact > that > the Motor System can learn rather quickly how to produce and apply > more > force than the muscle have been accustomed to (overload), this then > causes > the muscles to adapt to the HIGHER TENSIONS and WORK via protein > synthesis > (growth). > > This process occurs for a short period driven by the cycle of neural > and > tissue adaptations (leapfrogging) to appear as " overcompensatory " > adaptations. However the SuperCompensation observation reaches > diminishing > returns when applied via a Single Set program. > > Now you are faced with a dilemma of accepting that " further " > stimulus via a > second set will cause a greater stimulus, or that it will cause an > " overtraining or over-reaching " result. Well of course we already > know that > it DOES NOT cause overtraining unless carried to the extreme under > long term > circumstances. We also know that increased workload (adequately > applied) > DOES cause overload conditions and further progress. > > The fallacy of the single set model as optimal also is based on the > limited > assumption that " full metabolic, mental and neural " exhaustion is the > Optimal Stimulus, when it is not. The optimal stimulus for Strength > training is Progressively Overloading the Tensions and the Work that a > muscle(s) is exposed to. It is IMPOSSIBLE to create a continuously > available overload indefinitely via a SINGLE SET. No one has ever > done it, > and no one is currently doing it. > > What IS possible is that you can reach a fairly high level (% > result) via > the Single Set model with the highest intensity (highest effort to > each > moment of the exercise). But just like there is no real perpetual > motion > machine, there is no single example of any elite strength athlete or > World > Champion employing anything close to this model. > > Jerry Telle wrote: > Thanks for the Yates revelations. I always wondered about this. > > Casler writes: > > Strangely enough the Single Set proponents always trot out Dorian or > Mike > (who was an old friend of mine for many years) as examples of such > training > when neither actually succeeded in using that model for their ultimate > genetic expression during their peaks. > > And while it might be claimed that they DID on occasion train a > Single Set > OF AN EXERCISE to FAILURE, they performed MULTIPLE Sets for each > BodyPart > which is MULTI-SET training, NOT Single. > > Regards, > > Casler > TRI-VECTOR 3-D Force Systems > Century City, CA > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 30, 2010 Report Posted March 30, 2010 I don't see in this discussion any mention of " Henneman's size principle " which affects and determines both strength, fiber recruitment percentage, and type of fibers recruited. Any reason for that? Giovanni Ciriani - West Hartford, CT - USA On Tue, Mar 30, 2010 at 2:20 AM, Jerry Telle <JRTELLE@...> wrote: > > > > Greetings , > > > Casler writes: > > If you perform " warm-up " and approach sets you have already moved to a > multi-set model. > > Telle -- Right, I don't think it is possible, save absolute strength > circumstances, to recruit Fast twitch fibers maximally with out a > warmup(s). > > > Casler writes: > > For one to believe that a Single Set to Failure can produce equal or > better > results than a multiple set schema you need to buy into the OPTIMAL > Stimulus > argument, that you can provide the maximal and optimal stimulus to a > muscle > via a Single Set taken to Exhaustive Failure. > > Telle -- Not sure we have total semantic overlap but does not an > optimal stimulus also require an optimal load? > > > Casler writes: > > To accept this you need then agree that no matter what your condition > that > you can somehow produce an overload within that set, or believe that the > body will produce SuperCompensation indefinitely. > > In the arena of stimuli you have TENSIONS, and you have Fatigues. The > Fatigues are Metabolic, Neural, Muscular, and Mental. In Strength > Training > the Primary Stimulus is Tension, with all the Fatigues providing the > supporting roles to stimulus. All models of training combine these > stimulus > elements to an OVERLOAD within the framework of the current condition or > last, most recent stimulus. That is, for an adaptive response to > occur, the > most recent stimulus " package " (not the government version) must in > some way > exceed what the organism has been previously exposed to. > > Telle -- I think I see what your " stimulus, " in a general sense, > means(?). And I assume that " the > most recent stimulus " package " must in some way > exceed what the organism has been previously exposed to " by [Telle] or > because the supercompensation has resulted in greater strength > (hypertrophic here) and can thus produce greater tensions to an > overload (more weight at original speed or greater speed at the > previous weight.? And greater fatigue can/is accomplished (though I > need a good quantifying definition of fatigue.) Maybe a difference in > max weight/speed over fatigued state failure?????? I admit to > " fatigue " ignorance -- how to define it. > > > Casler writes: > > In the beginning trainees make a type of progress I call " leapfrog " or > SUPER > Compensation. This progress is usually rapid and driven by the fact that > the Motor System can learn rather quickly how to produce and apply more > force than the muscle have been accustomed to (overload), this then > causes > the muscles to adapt to the HIGHER TENSIONS and WORK via protein > synthesis > (growth). > > Telle -- as long as I'm this far out on the limb, does muscle fiber > summation increase with training or is greater tension mainly a > synchronization function? Obviously synchronization leads to greater > connective tissue tension -- but not to specific fibers? > > > Casler writes: > > This process occurs for a short period driven by the cycle of neural and > tissue adaptations (leapfrogging) to appear as " overcompensatory " > adaptations. However the SuperCompensation observation reaches > diminishing > returns when applied via a Single Set program. > > Telle -- Are there studies directly demonstrating this? Is the > relationship linear or generally curvilinear? > Were any of the studies HIIT (Yates) style? do researchers even know > the difference and of course how was intensity measured. > > > Casler writes: > > Now you are faced with a dilemma of accepting that " further " stimulus > via a > second set will cause a greater stimulus, or that it will cause an > " overtraining or over-reaching " result. Well of course we already know > that > it DOES NOT cause overtraining unless carried to the extreme under > long term > circumstances. > > Telle -- I had lunch, the other day, with a person who used my version > of a max intensity set, at least 10 years ago. > The particulars, > 1. He trained by himself which meant no mental " goading " from me, > 2. The 1 set included 10 reps, each a drop rep/set of 1 from the > original 95% positive 1RM, starting weight. Each following rep being a > projected 90-100% momentary 1RM. > 3. The negatives were my negative enhancement techniques -- that is > manipulating lever arm/moment physics to increase relative resistance > during the negative action. > 4. His " intensity " by my estimation (no EMG or other monitoring > devices) was about 90% of competition max. I don't think he ever > trained solely for max strength. > 5. We have trained together off and on for 50 years. So I have a lot > of anecdotal information. > 6. My research training machine could provide the same resistance -- > that is using a linear actuator to adjust positive and negative > inertial load. Training in this manner produced the same resistance > efect os the free weight loads. > > We stopped his max training after the 2nd session. As he put it. " The > first training session was fine, the second a real mental effort " And > " the third would have been an impossibility. " > He remembers? not sleeping well for 2 nights after each session at > once a week training. That's one set of a 10 rep set of 1RM with > eccentric overload each rep.. > > We switched him back to a 5-7 rep drop set protocol for 3 total sets > and did he fine! So in my estimation 1 set of 10 reps can produce > (probably mental) over training > > > Casler writes: > > We also know that increased workload (adequately applied) > DOES cause overload conditions and further progress. > > The fallacy of the single set model as optimal also is based on the > limited > assumption that " full metabolic, mental and neural " exhaustion is the > Optimal Stimulus, when it is not. The optimal stimulus for Strength > training is Progressively Overloading the Tensions and the Work that a > muscle(s) is exposed to. It is IMPOSSIBLE to create a continuously > available overload indefinitely via a SINGLE SET. No one has ever done > it, > and no one is currently doing it. > > Telle-- Nor is it likely anyone will. I remember reading that Mentzer > (reliability?) trained Yates for 1 set of 6 reps with a similar > protocol for Nautilus pullovers. > I assume this was a single? training session in this manner? I > remember lots of " Mentzer talk " in the article. > > Casler writes; > > > What IS possible is that you can reach a fairly high level (% result) > via > the Single Set model with the highest intensity (highest effort to each > moment of the exercise). But just like there is no real perpetual motion > machine, there is no single example of any elite strength athlete or > World > Champion employing anything close to this model. > > Telle -- STILL I would still like to know the results of a really > intense 1 drop set protocol. > > Isn't this fun? > > > As always, > > Jerry Telle > Lakewood CO USA > > Jerry Telle wrote: > Thanks for the Yates revelations. I always wondered about this. > > Casler writes: > > Strangely enough the Single Set proponents always trot out Dorian or > Mike > (who was an old friend of mine for many years) as examples of such > training > when neither actually succeeded in using that model for their ultimate > genetic expression during their peaks. > > And while it might be claimed that they DID on occasion train a Single > Set > OF AN EXERCISE to FAILURE, they performed MULTIPLE Sets for each > BodyPart > which is MULTI-SET training, NOT Single > On Mar 27, 2010, at 10:07 AM, Casler wrote: > > > Jerry Telle wrote: > > > > H i , > > > > I essentially agree with everything you have expressed. Still I would > > like research to demonstrate > > your projections. It may be that you, and the likes of you, with the > > tremendous physical endowments > > you have would need 3-4 working sets (at what level of intensity?) > > while > > others would get 98% benefits > > from , after 2 warmup sets, 1 set training? > > > > Casler writes: > > > > Hi Jerry, > > > > If you perform " warm-up " and approach sets you have already moved to a > > multi-set model. > > > > For one to believe that a Single Set to Failure can produce equal or > > better > > results than a multiple set schema you need to buy into the OPTIMAL > > Stimulus > > argument, that you can provide the maximal and optimal stimulus to a > > muscle > > via a Single Set taken to Exhaustive Failure. > > > > To accept this you need then agree that no matter what your > > condition that > > you can somehow produce an overload within that set, or believe that > > the > > body will produce SuperCompensation indefinitely. > > > > In the arena of stimuli you have TENSIONS, and you have Fatigues. The > > Fatigues are Metabolic, Neural, Muscular, and Mental. In Strength > > Training > > the Primary Stimulus is Tension, with all the Fatigues providing the > > supporting roles to stimulus. All models of training combine these > > stimulus > > elements to an OVERLOAD within the framework of the current > > condition or > > last, most recent stimulus. That is, for an adaptive response to > > occur, the > > most recent stimulus " package " (not the government version) must in > > some way > > exceed what the organism has been previously exposed to. > > > > In the beginning trainees make a type of progress I call " leapfrog " > > or SUPER > > Compensation. This progress is usually rapid and driven by the fact > > that > > the Motor System can learn rather quickly how to produce and apply > > more > > force than the muscle have been accustomed to (overload), this then > > causes > > the muscles to adapt to the HIGHER TENSIONS and WORK via protein > > synthesis > > (growth). > > > > This process occurs for a short period driven by the cycle of neural > > and > > tissue adaptations (leapfrogging) to appear as " overcompensatory " > > adaptations. However the SuperCompensation observation reaches > > diminishing > > returns when applied via a Single Set program. > > > > Now you are faced with a dilemma of accepting that " further " > > stimulus via a > > second set will cause a greater stimulus, or that it will cause an > > " overtraining or over-reaching " result. Well of course we already > > know that > > it DOES NOT cause overtraining unless carried to the extreme under > > long term > > circumstances. We also know that increased workload (adequately > > applied) > > DOES cause overload conditions and further progress. > > > > The fallacy of the single set model as optimal also is based on the > > limited > > assumption that " full metabolic, mental and neural " exhaustion is the > > Optimal Stimulus, when it is not. The optimal stimulus for Strength > > training is Progressively Overloading the Tensions and the Work that a > > muscle(s) is exposed to. It is IMPOSSIBLE to create a continuously > > available overload indefinitely via a SINGLE SET. No one has ever > > done it, > > and no one is currently doing it. > > > > What IS possible is that you can reach a fairly high level (% > > result) via > > the Single Set model with the highest intensity (highest effort to > > each > > moment of the exercise). But just like there is no real perpetual > > motion > > machine, there is no single example of any elite strength athlete or > > World > > Champion employing anything close to this model. > > > > Jerry Telle wrote: > > Thanks for the Yates revelations. I always wondered about this. > > > > Casler writes: > > > > Strangely enough the Single Set proponents always trot out Dorian or > > Mike > > (who was an old friend of mine for many years) as examples of such > > training > > when neither actually succeeded in using that model for their ultimate > > genetic expression during their peaks. > > > > And while it might be claimed that they DID on occasion train a > > Single Set > > OF AN EXERCISE to FAILURE, they performed MULTIPLE Sets for each > > BodyPart > > which is MULTI-SET training, NOT Single. > > > > Regards, > > > > Casler > > TRI-VECTOR 3-D Force Systems > > Century City, CA > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 30, 2010 Report Posted March 30, 2010 I don't see in this discussion any mention of " Henneman's size principle " which affects and determines both strength, fiber recruitment percentage, and type of fibers recruited. Any reason for that? Giovanni Ciriani - West Hartford, CT - USA On Tue, Mar 30, 2010 at 2:20 AM, Jerry Telle <JRTELLE@...> wrote: > > > > Greetings , > > > Casler writes: > > If you perform " warm-up " and approach sets you have already moved to a > multi-set model. > > Telle -- Right, I don't think it is possible, save absolute strength > circumstances, to recruit Fast twitch fibers maximally with out a > warmup(s). > > > Casler writes: > > For one to believe that a Single Set to Failure can produce equal or > better > results than a multiple set schema you need to buy into the OPTIMAL > Stimulus > argument, that you can provide the maximal and optimal stimulus to a > muscle > via a Single Set taken to Exhaustive Failure. > > Telle -- Not sure we have total semantic overlap but does not an > optimal stimulus also require an optimal load? > > > Casler writes: > > To accept this you need then agree that no matter what your condition > that > you can somehow produce an overload within that set, or believe that the > body will produce SuperCompensation indefinitely. > > In the arena of stimuli you have TENSIONS, and you have Fatigues. The > Fatigues are Metabolic, Neural, Muscular, and Mental. In Strength > Training > the Primary Stimulus is Tension, with all the Fatigues providing the > supporting roles to stimulus. All models of training combine these > stimulus > elements to an OVERLOAD within the framework of the current condition or > last, most recent stimulus. That is, for an adaptive response to > occur, the > most recent stimulus " package " (not the government version) must in > some way > exceed what the organism has been previously exposed to. > > Telle -- I think I see what your " stimulus, " in a general sense, > means(?). And I assume that " the > most recent stimulus " package " must in some way > exceed what the organism has been previously exposed to " by [Telle] or > because the supercompensation has resulted in greater strength > (hypertrophic here) and can thus produce greater tensions to an > overload (more weight at original speed or greater speed at the > previous weight.? And greater fatigue can/is accomplished (though I > need a good quantifying definition of fatigue.) Maybe a difference in > max weight/speed over fatigued state failure?????? I admit to > " fatigue " ignorance -- how to define it. > > > Casler writes: > > In the beginning trainees make a type of progress I call " leapfrog " or > SUPER > Compensation. This progress is usually rapid and driven by the fact that > the Motor System can learn rather quickly how to produce and apply more > force than the muscle have been accustomed to (overload), this then > causes > the muscles to adapt to the HIGHER TENSIONS and WORK via protein > synthesis > (growth). > > Telle -- as long as I'm this far out on the limb, does muscle fiber > summation increase with training or is greater tension mainly a > synchronization function? Obviously synchronization leads to greater > connective tissue tension -- but not to specific fibers? > > > Casler writes: > > This process occurs for a short period driven by the cycle of neural and > tissue adaptations (leapfrogging) to appear as " overcompensatory " > adaptations. However the SuperCompensation observation reaches > diminishing > returns when applied via a Single Set program. > > Telle -- Are there studies directly demonstrating this? Is the > relationship linear or generally curvilinear? > Were any of the studies HIIT (Yates) style? do researchers even know > the difference and of course how was intensity measured. > > > Casler writes: > > Now you are faced with a dilemma of accepting that " further " stimulus > via a > second set will cause a greater stimulus, or that it will cause an > " overtraining or over-reaching " result. Well of course we already know > that > it DOES NOT cause overtraining unless carried to the extreme under > long term > circumstances. > > Telle -- I had lunch, the other day, with a person who used my version > of a max intensity set, at least 10 years ago. > The particulars, > 1. He trained by himself which meant no mental " goading " from me, > 2. The 1 set included 10 reps, each a drop rep/set of 1 from the > original 95% positive 1RM, starting weight. Each following rep being a > projected 90-100% momentary 1RM. > 3. The negatives were my negative enhancement techniques -- that is > manipulating lever arm/moment physics to increase relative resistance > during the negative action. > 4. His " intensity " by my estimation (no EMG or other monitoring > devices) was about 90% of competition max. I don't think he ever > trained solely for max strength. > 5. We have trained together off and on for 50 years. So I have a lot > of anecdotal information. > 6. My research training machine could provide the same resistance -- > that is using a linear actuator to adjust positive and negative > inertial load. Training in this manner produced the same resistance > efect os the free weight loads. > > We stopped his max training after the 2nd session. As he put it. " The > first training session was fine, the second a real mental effort " And > " the third would have been an impossibility. " > He remembers? not sleeping well for 2 nights after each session at > once a week training. That's one set of a 10 rep set of 1RM with > eccentric overload each rep.. > > We switched him back to a 5-7 rep drop set protocol for 3 total sets > and did he fine! So in my estimation 1 set of 10 reps can produce > (probably mental) over training > > > Casler writes: > > We also know that increased workload (adequately applied) > DOES cause overload conditions and further progress. > > The fallacy of the single set model as optimal also is based on the > limited > assumption that " full metabolic, mental and neural " exhaustion is the > Optimal Stimulus, when it is not. The optimal stimulus for Strength > training is Progressively Overloading the Tensions and the Work that a > muscle(s) is exposed to. It is IMPOSSIBLE to create a continuously > available overload indefinitely via a SINGLE SET. No one has ever done > it, > and no one is currently doing it. > > Telle-- Nor is it likely anyone will. I remember reading that Mentzer > (reliability?) trained Yates for 1 set of 6 reps with a similar > protocol for Nautilus pullovers. > I assume this was a single? training session in this manner? I > remember lots of " Mentzer talk " in the article. > > Casler writes; > > > What IS possible is that you can reach a fairly high level (% result) > via > the Single Set model with the highest intensity (highest effort to each > moment of the exercise). But just like there is no real perpetual motion > machine, there is no single example of any elite strength athlete or > World > Champion employing anything close to this model. > > Telle -- STILL I would still like to know the results of a really > intense 1 drop set protocol. > > Isn't this fun? > > > As always, > > Jerry Telle > Lakewood CO USA > > Jerry Telle wrote: > Thanks for the Yates revelations. I always wondered about this. > > Casler writes: > > Strangely enough the Single Set proponents always trot out Dorian or > Mike > (who was an old friend of mine for many years) as examples of such > training > when neither actually succeeded in using that model for their ultimate > genetic expression during their peaks. > > And while it might be claimed that they DID on occasion train a Single > Set > OF AN EXERCISE to FAILURE, they performed MULTIPLE Sets for each > BodyPart > which is MULTI-SET training, NOT Single > On Mar 27, 2010, at 10:07 AM, Casler wrote: > > > Jerry Telle wrote: > > > > H i , > > > > I essentially agree with everything you have expressed. Still I would > > like research to demonstrate > > your projections. It may be that you, and the likes of you, with the > > tremendous physical endowments > > you have would need 3-4 working sets (at what level of intensity?) > > while > > others would get 98% benefits > > from , after 2 warmup sets, 1 set training? > > > > Casler writes: > > > > Hi Jerry, > > > > If you perform " warm-up " and approach sets you have already moved to a > > multi-set model. > > > > For one to believe that a Single Set to Failure can produce equal or > > better > > results than a multiple set schema you need to buy into the OPTIMAL > > Stimulus > > argument, that you can provide the maximal and optimal stimulus to a > > muscle > > via a Single Set taken to Exhaustive Failure. > > > > To accept this you need then agree that no matter what your > > condition that > > you can somehow produce an overload within that set, or believe that > > the > > body will produce SuperCompensation indefinitely. > > > > In the arena of stimuli you have TENSIONS, and you have Fatigues. The > > Fatigues are Metabolic, Neural, Muscular, and Mental. In Strength > > Training > > the Primary Stimulus is Tension, with all the Fatigues providing the > > supporting roles to stimulus. All models of training combine these > > stimulus > > elements to an OVERLOAD within the framework of the current > > condition or > > last, most recent stimulus. That is, for an adaptive response to > > occur, the > > most recent stimulus " package " (not the government version) must in > > some way > > exceed what the organism has been previously exposed to. > > > > In the beginning trainees make a type of progress I call " leapfrog " > > or SUPER > > Compensation. This progress is usually rapid and driven by the fact > > that > > the Motor System can learn rather quickly how to produce and apply > > more > > force than the muscle have been accustomed to (overload), this then > > causes > > the muscles to adapt to the HIGHER TENSIONS and WORK via protein > > synthesis > > (growth). > > > > This process occurs for a short period driven by the cycle of neural > > and > > tissue adaptations (leapfrogging) to appear as " overcompensatory " > > adaptations. However the SuperCompensation observation reaches > > diminishing > > returns when applied via a Single Set program. > > > > Now you are faced with a dilemma of accepting that " further " > > stimulus via a > > second set will cause a greater stimulus, or that it will cause an > > " overtraining or over-reaching " result. Well of course we already > > know that > > it DOES NOT cause overtraining unless carried to the extreme under > > long term > > circumstances. We also know that increased workload (adequately > > applied) > > DOES cause overload conditions and further progress. > > > > The fallacy of the single set model as optimal also is based on the > > limited > > assumption that " full metabolic, mental and neural " exhaustion is the > > Optimal Stimulus, when it is not. The optimal stimulus for Strength > > training is Progressively Overloading the Tensions and the Work that a > > muscle(s) is exposed to. It is IMPOSSIBLE to create a continuously > > available overload indefinitely via a SINGLE SET. No one has ever > > done it, > > and no one is currently doing it. > > > > What IS possible is that you can reach a fairly high level (% > > result) via > > the Single Set model with the highest intensity (highest effort to > > each > > moment of the exercise). But just like there is no real perpetual > > motion > > machine, there is no single example of any elite strength athlete or > > World > > Champion employing anything close to this model. > > > > Jerry Telle wrote: > > Thanks for the Yates revelations. I always wondered about this. > > > > Casler writes: > > > > Strangely enough the Single Set proponents always trot out Dorian or > > Mike > > (who was an old friend of mine for many years) as examples of such > > training > > when neither actually succeeded in using that model for their ultimate > > genetic expression during their peaks. > > > > And while it might be claimed that they DID on occasion train a > > Single Set > > OF AN EXERCISE to FAILURE, they performed MULTIPLE Sets for each > > BodyPart > > which is MULTI-SET training, NOT Single. > > > > Regards, > > > > Casler > > TRI-VECTOR 3-D Force Systems > > Century City, CA > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 30, 2010 Report Posted March 30, 2010 I don't see in this discussion any mention of " Henneman's size principle " which affects and determines both strength, fiber recruitment percentage, and type of fibers recruited. Any reason for that? Giovanni Ciriani - West Hartford, CT - USA On Tue, Mar 30, 2010 at 2:20 AM, Jerry Telle <JRTELLE@...> wrote: > > > > Greetings , > > > Casler writes: > > If you perform " warm-up " and approach sets you have already moved to a > multi-set model. > > Telle -- Right, I don't think it is possible, save absolute strength > circumstances, to recruit Fast twitch fibers maximally with out a > warmup(s). > > > Casler writes: > > For one to believe that a Single Set to Failure can produce equal or > better > results than a multiple set schema you need to buy into the OPTIMAL > Stimulus > argument, that you can provide the maximal and optimal stimulus to a > muscle > via a Single Set taken to Exhaustive Failure. > > Telle -- Not sure we have total semantic overlap but does not an > optimal stimulus also require an optimal load? > > > Casler writes: > > To accept this you need then agree that no matter what your condition > that > you can somehow produce an overload within that set, or believe that the > body will produce SuperCompensation indefinitely. > > In the arena of stimuli you have TENSIONS, and you have Fatigues. The > Fatigues are Metabolic, Neural, Muscular, and Mental. In Strength > Training > the Primary Stimulus is Tension, with all the Fatigues providing the > supporting roles to stimulus. All models of training combine these > stimulus > elements to an OVERLOAD within the framework of the current condition or > last, most recent stimulus. That is, for an adaptive response to > occur, the > most recent stimulus " package " (not the government version) must in > some way > exceed what the organism has been previously exposed to. > > Telle -- I think I see what your " stimulus, " in a general sense, > means(?). And I assume that " the > most recent stimulus " package " must in some way > exceed what the organism has been previously exposed to " by [Telle] or > because the supercompensation has resulted in greater strength > (hypertrophic here) and can thus produce greater tensions to an > overload (more weight at original speed or greater speed at the > previous weight.? And greater fatigue can/is accomplished (though I > need a good quantifying definition of fatigue.) Maybe a difference in > max weight/speed over fatigued state failure?????? I admit to > " fatigue " ignorance -- how to define it. > > > Casler writes: > > In the beginning trainees make a type of progress I call " leapfrog " or > SUPER > Compensation. This progress is usually rapid and driven by the fact that > the Motor System can learn rather quickly how to produce and apply more > force than the muscle have been accustomed to (overload), this then > causes > the muscles to adapt to the HIGHER TENSIONS and WORK via protein > synthesis > (growth). > > Telle -- as long as I'm this far out on the limb, does muscle fiber > summation increase with training or is greater tension mainly a > synchronization function? Obviously synchronization leads to greater > connective tissue tension -- but not to specific fibers? > > > Casler writes: > > This process occurs for a short period driven by the cycle of neural and > tissue adaptations (leapfrogging) to appear as " overcompensatory " > adaptations. However the SuperCompensation observation reaches > diminishing > returns when applied via a Single Set program. > > Telle -- Are there studies directly demonstrating this? Is the > relationship linear or generally curvilinear? > Were any of the studies HIIT (Yates) style? do researchers even know > the difference and of course how was intensity measured. > > > Casler writes: > > Now you are faced with a dilemma of accepting that " further " stimulus > via a > second set will cause a greater stimulus, or that it will cause an > " overtraining or over-reaching " result. Well of course we already know > that > it DOES NOT cause overtraining unless carried to the extreme under > long term > circumstances. > > Telle -- I had lunch, the other day, with a person who used my version > of a max intensity set, at least 10 years ago. > The particulars, > 1. He trained by himself which meant no mental " goading " from me, > 2. The 1 set included 10 reps, each a drop rep/set of 1 from the > original 95% positive 1RM, starting weight. Each following rep being a > projected 90-100% momentary 1RM. > 3. The negatives were my negative enhancement techniques -- that is > manipulating lever arm/moment physics to increase relative resistance > during the negative action. > 4. His " intensity " by my estimation (no EMG or other monitoring > devices) was about 90% of competition max. I don't think he ever > trained solely for max strength. > 5. We have trained together off and on for 50 years. So I have a lot > of anecdotal information. > 6. My research training machine could provide the same resistance -- > that is using a linear actuator to adjust positive and negative > inertial load. Training in this manner produced the same resistance > efect os the free weight loads. > > We stopped his max training after the 2nd session. As he put it. " The > first training session was fine, the second a real mental effort " And > " the third would have been an impossibility. " > He remembers? not sleeping well for 2 nights after each session at > once a week training. That's one set of a 10 rep set of 1RM with > eccentric overload each rep.. > > We switched him back to a 5-7 rep drop set protocol for 3 total sets > and did he fine! So in my estimation 1 set of 10 reps can produce > (probably mental) over training > > > Casler writes: > > We also know that increased workload (adequately applied) > DOES cause overload conditions and further progress. > > The fallacy of the single set model as optimal also is based on the > limited > assumption that " full metabolic, mental and neural " exhaustion is the > Optimal Stimulus, when it is not. The optimal stimulus for Strength > training is Progressively Overloading the Tensions and the Work that a > muscle(s) is exposed to. It is IMPOSSIBLE to create a continuously > available overload indefinitely via a SINGLE SET. No one has ever done > it, > and no one is currently doing it. > > Telle-- Nor is it likely anyone will. I remember reading that Mentzer > (reliability?) trained Yates for 1 set of 6 reps with a similar > protocol for Nautilus pullovers. > I assume this was a single? training session in this manner? I > remember lots of " Mentzer talk " in the article. > > Casler writes; > > > What IS possible is that you can reach a fairly high level (% result) > via > the Single Set model with the highest intensity (highest effort to each > moment of the exercise). But just like there is no real perpetual motion > machine, there is no single example of any elite strength athlete or > World > Champion employing anything close to this model. > > Telle -- STILL I would still like to know the results of a really > intense 1 drop set protocol. > > Isn't this fun? > > > As always, > > Jerry Telle > Lakewood CO USA > > Jerry Telle wrote: > Thanks for the Yates revelations. I always wondered about this. > > Casler writes: > > Strangely enough the Single Set proponents always trot out Dorian or > Mike > (who was an old friend of mine for many years) as examples of such > training > when neither actually succeeded in using that model for their ultimate > genetic expression during their peaks. > > And while it might be claimed that they DID on occasion train a Single > Set > OF AN EXERCISE to FAILURE, they performed MULTIPLE Sets for each > BodyPart > which is MULTI-SET training, NOT Single > On Mar 27, 2010, at 10:07 AM, Casler wrote: > > > Jerry Telle wrote: > > > > H i , > > > > I essentially agree with everything you have expressed. Still I would > > like research to demonstrate > > your projections. It may be that you, and the likes of you, with the > > tremendous physical endowments > > you have would need 3-4 working sets (at what level of intensity?) > > while > > others would get 98% benefits > > from , after 2 warmup sets, 1 set training? > > > > Casler writes: > > > > Hi Jerry, > > > > If you perform " warm-up " and approach sets you have already moved to a > > multi-set model. > > > > For one to believe that a Single Set to Failure can produce equal or > > better > > results than a multiple set schema you need to buy into the OPTIMAL > > Stimulus > > argument, that you can provide the maximal and optimal stimulus to a > > muscle > > via a Single Set taken to Exhaustive Failure. > > > > To accept this you need then agree that no matter what your > > condition that > > you can somehow produce an overload within that set, or believe that > > the > > body will produce SuperCompensation indefinitely. > > > > In the arena of stimuli you have TENSIONS, and you have Fatigues. The > > Fatigues are Metabolic, Neural, Muscular, and Mental. In Strength > > Training > > the Primary Stimulus is Tension, with all the Fatigues providing the > > supporting roles to stimulus. All models of training combine these > > stimulus > > elements to an OVERLOAD within the framework of the current > > condition or > > last, most recent stimulus. That is, for an adaptive response to > > occur, the > > most recent stimulus " package " (not the government version) must in > > some way > > exceed what the organism has been previously exposed to. > > > > In the beginning trainees make a type of progress I call " leapfrog " > > or SUPER > > Compensation. This progress is usually rapid and driven by the fact > > that > > the Motor System can learn rather quickly how to produce and apply > > more > > force than the muscle have been accustomed to (overload), this then > > causes > > the muscles to adapt to the HIGHER TENSIONS and WORK via protein > > synthesis > > (growth). > > > > This process occurs for a short period driven by the cycle of neural > > and > > tissue adaptations (leapfrogging) to appear as " overcompensatory " > > adaptations. However the SuperCompensation observation reaches > > diminishing > > returns when applied via a Single Set program. > > > > Now you are faced with a dilemma of accepting that " further " > > stimulus via a > > second set will cause a greater stimulus, or that it will cause an > > " overtraining or over-reaching " result. Well of course we already > > know that > > it DOES NOT cause overtraining unless carried to the extreme under > > long term > > circumstances. We also know that increased workload (adequately > > applied) > > DOES cause overload conditions and further progress. > > > > The fallacy of the single set model as optimal also is based on the > > limited > > assumption that " full metabolic, mental and neural " exhaustion is the > > Optimal Stimulus, when it is not. The optimal stimulus for Strength > > training is Progressively Overloading the Tensions and the Work that a > > muscle(s) is exposed to. It is IMPOSSIBLE to create a continuously > > available overload indefinitely via a SINGLE SET. No one has ever > > done it, > > and no one is currently doing it. > > > > What IS possible is that you can reach a fairly high level (% > > result) via > > the Single Set model with the highest intensity (highest effort to > > each > > moment of the exercise). But just like there is no real perpetual > > motion > > machine, there is no single example of any elite strength athlete or > > World > > Champion employing anything close to this model. > > > > Jerry Telle wrote: > > Thanks for the Yates revelations. I always wondered about this. > > > > Casler writes: > > > > Strangely enough the Single Set proponents always trot out Dorian or > > Mike > > (who was an old friend of mine for many years) as examples of such > > training > > when neither actually succeeded in using that model for their ultimate > > genetic expression during their peaks. > > > > And while it might be claimed that they DID on occasion train a > > Single Set > > OF AN EXERCISE to FAILURE, they performed MULTIPLE Sets for each > > BodyPart > > which is MULTI-SET training, NOT Single. > > > > Regards, > > > > Casler > > TRI-VECTOR 3-D Force Systems > > Century City, CA > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 30, 2010 Report Posted March 30, 2010 Casler wrote: For one to believe that a Single Set to Failure can produce equal or better results than a multiple set schema you need to buy into the OPTIMAL Stimulus argument, that you can provide the maximal and optimal stimulus to a muscle via a Single Set taken to Exhaustive Failure. Telle -- Not sure we have total semantic overlap but does not an optimal stimulus also require an optimal load? Casler writes: Optimal Stimulus is not my term, but generally used by Single Setters to signify their belief that the " optimal stimulus " it available and present when performing SSTF (single sets to failure) I would doubt with all the elements to contend with in creating a stimulus, that we could ever establish what is OPTIMAL. However, we certainly DO KNOW that those who train at more advanced and higher levels use Multi-Set Models. Therefore it is amusing that such claims are made. Casler wrote: To accept this you need then agree that no matter what your condition that you can somehow produce an overload within that set, or believe that the body will produce SuperCompensation indefinitely. In the arena of stimuli you have TENSIONS, and you have Fatigues. The Fatigues are Metabolic, Neural, Muscular, and Mental. In Strength Training the Primary Stimulus is Tension, with all the Fatigues providing the supporting roles to stimulus. All models of training combine these stimulus elements to an OVERLOAD within the framework of the current condition or last, most recent stimulus. That is, for an adaptive response to occur, the most recent stimulus " package " (not the government version) must in some way exceed what the organism has been previously exposed to. Telle -- I think I see what your " stimulus, " in a general sense, means(?). And I assume that " the most recent stimulus " package " must in some way exceed what the organism has been previously exposed to " by [Telle] or because the supercompensation has resulted in greater strength (hypertrophic here) and can thus produce greater tensions to an overload (more weight at original speed or greater speed at the previous weight.? And greater fatigue can/is accomplished (though I need a good quantifying definition of fatigue.) Maybe a difference in max weight/speed over fatigued state failure?????? I admit to " fatigue " ignorance -- how to define it. Casler writes: Fatigues are Biological and Mental processes resulting from the action(s) that deplete or degrade performance. I have generally classified them as: 1) Metabolic 2) Neural 3) Muscular 4) Mental Each of the above have fatigue elements begin from the very first stride, or rep and accumulate against performance. They are " inter-related " physically and these classifications are very loose, but allow us to more clearly observe what stimuli tend to cause the different fatigues. Casler wrote: In the beginning trainees make a type of progress I call " leapfrog " or SUPER Compensation. This progress is usually rapid and driven by the fact that the Motor System can learn rather quickly how to produce and apply more force than the muscle have been accustomed to (overload), this then causes the muscles to adapt to the HIGHER TENSIONS and WORK via protein synthesis (growth). Telle -- as long as I'm this far out on the limb, does muscle fiber summation increase with training or is greater tension mainly a synchronization function? Obviously synchronization leads to greater connective tissue tension -- but not to specific fibers? Casler writes: Good question and I presume so, but someone involved more deeply in the recent findings might have a better answer. Casler wrote: This process occurs for a short period driven by the cycle of neural and tissue adaptations (leapfrogging) to appear as " overcompensatory " adaptations. However the SuperCompensation observation reaches diminishing returns earlier when applied via a Single Set program. Telle -- Are there studies directly demonstrating this? Is the relationship linear or generally curvilinear? Were any of the studies HIIT (Yates) style? do researchers even know the difference and of course how was intensity measured. Casler writes: The relationship is to the level of stimulus and the " potential " available. That is, the initial adaptations are the largest and taper depending on the stimulus and the remaining potential. Casler wrote: Now you are faced with a dilemma of accepting that " further " stimulus via a second set will cause a greater stimulus, or that it will cause an " overtraining or over-reaching " result. Well of course we already know that it DOES NOT cause overtraining unless carried to the extreme under long term circumstances. Telle -- I had lunch, the other day, with a person who used my version of a max intensity set, at least 10 years ago. The particulars, 1. He trained by himself which meant no mental " goading " from me, 2. The 1 set included 10 reps, each a drop rep/set of 1 from the original 95% positive 1RM, starting weight. Each following rep being a projected 90-100% momentary 1RM. 3. The negatives were my negative enhancement techniques -- that is manipulating lever arm/moment physics to increase relative resistance during the negative action. 4. His " intensity " by my estimation (no EMG or other monitoring devices) was about 90% of competition max. I don't think he ever trained solely for max strength. 5. We have trained together off and on for 50 years. So I have a lot of anecdotal information. 6. My research training machine could provide the same resistance -- that is using a linear actuator to adjust positive and negative inertial load. Training in this manner produced the same resistance efect os the free weight loads. We stopped his max training after the 2nd session. As he put it. " The first training session was fine, the second a real mental effort " And " the third would have been an impossibility. " He remembers? not sleeping well for 2 nights after each session at once a week training. That's one set of a 10 rep set of 1RM with eccentric overload each rep.. We switched him back to a 5-7 rep drop set protocol for 3 total sets and did he fine! So in my estimation 1 set of 10 reps can produce (probably mental) over training Casler writes: It is important to note that ALL serious training is but an attempt to find effective loading patterns to most effectively provide stimulus for the adaptations we are seeking. My point is that the Single Setters ignore the limitations contained with that model. It is TOTALLY sufficient (IMO) as a general fitness level application, but to tout it as the OPTIMAL Stimulus for all training goals is inaccurate and failed in premise. Your above " Higher Density Intensity " set is an effort to take that restriction to a higher level. You recognized that the early reps of a set are generally " underloaded " and that providing a more accurate load for EACH rep might have efficiency and economy to the goal. Point being it likely was more effective for some types of goals. That said, once you had adapted to THAT level of stimulus, performing a second bout of the same after a recovery period (rest between sets) would provide and additional load and overload to the body. Regards, Casler TRI-VECTOR 3-D Force Systems Century City, CA Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.