Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Re: What do you provide for your patients

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted

Hi Dr. Snell,

Thank you for your informative post as to what current texts are available for patients' exercises. However when you cite the comments of a Kaiser physiatrist about our profession as being of significance we part company. D.C.s' are not MD's lapdogs waiting for a few words of approbation from them. I have practiced in the city of Keizer for about 45 years I've cared for thousands of patients and believe it or not nary a one of them was an MD referral. Philosophically chiropractic and all of the various methods under the medical umbrella are miles apart so why should I care at all as to this guys opinion.

Herb Freeman D.C.

What do you provide for your patients

The recent thread with someone asking what exercises to prescribe for LBP and the responses, or lack thereof was interesting. The field of exercise science in treatment of a variety of disorders is burgeoning with the new ACSM's Exercise is Medicine campaign as well as with the release of books such as Spark: The Revolutionary New Science of Exercise and the Brain by J. Ratey. Within our own field, chiropractors sadly continue to be slow to adopt this trend and to educate themselves in what the science supports. I work with a lot of personal trainers in town, and with several PTs. They regularly are surprised that I, a chiropractor, seem to be abreast of the literature in exercise science. I am regularly disappointed that so many of my colleagues, and even the recent grads, seem to barely have an understanding of what works and what doesn't when it comes to exercise. It's maddening to continue to get disc patients who have been prescribed "yoga" that includes forward bends, knees to chest and twisting poses and can't seem to get that pain down their leg get any better. It's frustrating to see abdominal hollowing exercises a la' Hodges work on transversus and the subsequent misinterpretation of the findings of those studies, continue to be spread as misinformation and thus creating more dysfunction in that patient. I wonder what is to become of our profession when we don't demonstrate to the public that we know more about how to treat their back pain than their trainer at the gym who has attended a McGill conference, a Gray conference, a Gray Cook conference and regularly tunes in to SportsRehabExpert.com. What do we have to offer in response? The latest practice income generating tips gleaned at the latest conference? This lack of understanding does not seem to be lost on our patients in my experience.What prompted me to write tonight was a communique I received today that was intended for Kaiser physicians. The following was written by a physiatrist and was intended to be a quick guide to appropriate referral for PCPs in the local Kaiser system. After giving a good (I feel) description of the pros and cons of manipulation therapy he states:"How does manipulation fit into the general musculoskeletal care continuum and how does it relate to our PT services? Manipulation as a form of treatment is legitimate, whether you consider the field of chiropractic so or not. If we had PTs that did manipulation we would not need to refer out to have this form of treatment. The down side of Chiropractic from our perspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passive modalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an under emphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourish throughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general. This then may leave the patient after a few visits feeling better but not fortifying them with education, strength and flexibility which are the foundation of prevention for recurrent spinal pain."I haven't participated in this forum for a while. It's interesting to spend a few days here again. If I'm too out of place here, I'll go away again. But I would be interested in finding out if DCs in this progressive state are tuning in to the changing times and positioning themselves to have cultural authority for ALL things concerning conservative management of the spine. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center 3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956 drpsnell.chiroweb.comwww.fixyourownback.comMember American College of Sports Medicine

Posted

Hi Dr. Snell,

Thank you for your informative post as to what current texts are available for patients' exercises. However when you cite the comments of a Kaiser physiatrist about our profession as being of significance we part company. D.C.s' are not MD's lapdogs waiting for a few words of approbation from them. I have practiced in the city of Keizer for about 45 years I've cared for thousands of patients and believe it or not nary a one of them was an MD referral. Philosophically chiropractic and all of the various methods under the medical umbrella are miles apart so why should I care at all as to this guys opinion.

Herb Freeman D.C.

What do you provide for your patients

The recent thread with someone asking what exercises to prescribe for LBP and the responses, or lack thereof was interesting. The field of exercise science in treatment of a variety of disorders is burgeoning with the new ACSM's Exercise is Medicine campaign as well as with the release of books such as Spark: The Revolutionary New Science of Exercise and the Brain by J. Ratey. Within our own field, chiropractors sadly continue to be slow to adopt this trend and to educate themselves in what the science supports. I work with a lot of personal trainers in town, and with several PTs. They regularly are surprised that I, a chiropractor, seem to be abreast of the literature in exercise science. I am regularly disappointed that so many of my colleagues, and even the recent grads, seem to barely have an understanding of what works and what doesn't when it comes to exercise. It's maddening to continue to get disc patients who have been prescribed "yoga" that includes forward bends, knees to chest and twisting poses and can't seem to get that pain down their leg get any better. It's frustrating to see abdominal hollowing exercises a la' Hodges work on transversus and the subsequent misinterpretation of the findings of those studies, continue to be spread as misinformation and thus creating more dysfunction in that patient. I wonder what is to become of our profession when we don't demonstrate to the public that we know more about how to treat their back pain than their trainer at the gym who has attended a McGill conference, a Gray conference, a Gray Cook conference and regularly tunes in to SportsRehabExpert.com. What do we have to offer in response? The latest practice income generating tips gleaned at the latest conference? This lack of understanding does not seem to be lost on our patients in my experience.What prompted me to write tonight was a communique I received today that was intended for Kaiser physicians. The following was written by a physiatrist and was intended to be a quick guide to appropriate referral for PCPs in the local Kaiser system. After giving a good (I feel) description of the pros and cons of manipulation therapy he states:"How does manipulation fit into the general musculoskeletal care continuum and how does it relate to our PT services? Manipulation as a form of treatment is legitimate, whether you consider the field of chiropractic so or not. If we had PTs that did manipulation we would not need to refer out to have this form of treatment. The down side of Chiropractic from our perspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passive modalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an under emphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourish throughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general. This then may leave the patient after a few visits feeling better but not fortifying them with education, strength and flexibility which are the foundation of prevention for recurrent spinal pain."I haven't participated in this forum for a while. It's interesting to spend a few days here again. If I'm too out of place here, I'll go away again. But I would be interested in finding out if DCs in this progressive state are tuning in to the changing times and positioning themselves to have cultural authority for ALL things concerning conservative management of the spine. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center 3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956 drpsnell.chiroweb.comwww.fixyourownback.comMember American College of Sports Medicine

Posted

Hey , thanks for the request. My 2 cents...Since your practice focus seems to be MVA, Don (not Dan!!!) 's book if you don't already have it.Here's several more general must-haves, not all inclusive, just off the top of my head:Rehabilitation of the Spine: A Practitioner's Manual, Craig LiebensonLow Back Disorders and Ultimate Back Fitness and Performance, Stuart McGill--The best available science on lumbar stabilization exercise. To my mind FWIW, if you treat spine disorders and aren't conversant with the material in these books then you're WAY behind the curve. This material is being discussed on EVERY major sports med, training and fitness blog, not to mention the NY Times and many other major media outlets.Diagnosis and Treatment of Movement Impairment Syndromes, Shirley Sahrmann-- She's a PT who has for 25 years been at the forefront of positioning PTs as movement analysis experts and portal of care providers.Gray Cook's Functional Movement Assessment work is good too, but you'll find it mostly on DVD. Diane Lee's work is interesting, but a bit too steeped in Hodge's work.Try some of those, but commit McGill's work to memory. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center

3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956

drpsnell.chiroweb.comwww.fixyourownback.comMember American College of Sports MedicineDate: Wed, 3 Feb 2010 20:58:29 -0800From: gcluen2002@...Subject: Re: What do you provide for your patientsdrpsnell@...

Dr. Snell,I'd appreciate it if you could recommend some exercise rehab books & /or seminars. I've always been interested in teaching my patients exercises to help strengthen and maintain their spinal integrity & I'm always looking to improve my care for the patients. I also believe we as a profession need to utilize the accepted norms in exercise rehab rather than keeping our focus on passive therapies. Thanks for the great post. Cluen, DCAuto & Work Injury Center3311 NE MLK Blvd. Suite 202Portland, OR 97212503-282-4878From: Snell <drpsnell@...>oregon dc listserve < >Sent: Wed, February 3, 2010 7:44:03 PMSubject: What do you provide for your patients

The recent thread with someone asking what exercises to prescribe for LBP and the responses, or lack thereof was interesting. The field of exercise science in treatment of a variety of disorders is burgeoning with the new ACSM's Exercise is Medicine campaign as well as with the release of books such as Spark: The Revolutionary New Science of Exercise and the Brain by J. Ratey. Within our own field, chiropractors sadly continue to be slow to adopt this trend and to educate themselves in what the science supports. I work with a lot of personal trainers in town, and

with several PTs. They regularly are surprised that I, a chiropractor, seem to be abreast of the literature in exercise science. I am regularly disappointed that so many of my colleagues, and even the recent grads, seem to barely have an understanding of what works and what doesn't when it comes to exercise. It's maddening to continue to get disc patients who have been prescribed "yoga" that includes forward bends, knees to chest and twisting poses and can't seem to get that pain down their leg get any better. It's frustrating to see abdominal hollowing exercises a la' Hodges work on transversus and the subsequent misinterpretation of the findings of those studies, continue to be spread as misinformation and thus creating more dysfunction in that patient. I wonder what is to become of our profession when we don't demonstrate to the public that we know more about how to treat their back pain than their trainer at the gym who has

attended a McGill conference, a Gray conference, a Gray Cook conference and regularly tunes in to SportsRehabExpert. com. What do we have to offer in response? The latest practice income generating tips gleaned at the latest conference? This lack of understanding does not seem to be lost on our patients in my experience.What prompted me to write tonight was a communique I received today that was intended for Kaiser physicians. The following was written by a physiatrist and was intended to be a quick guide to appropriate referral for PCPs in the local Kaiser system. After giving a good (I feel) description of the pros and cons of manipulation therapy he states:"How does manipulation fit into the general musculoskeletal care continuum and how does it relate to our PT services? Manipulation as a form of treatment is legitimate, whether you consider the field of chiropractic so or not. If we

had PTs that did manipulation we would not need to refer out to have this form of treatment. The down side of Chiropractic from our perspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passive modalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an under emphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourish throughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general. This then may leave the patient after a few visits feeling better but not fortifying them with education, strength and flexibility which are the foundation of prevention for recurrent spinal pain."I haven't participated in this forum for a while. It's interesting to spend a few days here again. If I'm too out of place here, I'll go away again. But I would be interested in finding out if DCs in this progressive state are tuning in to the changing times and positioning themselves to have cultural authority for ALL

things concerning conservative management of the spine. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center

3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956

drpsnell.chiroweb. comwww.fixyourownback. comMember American College of Sports Medicine

Posted

Hey , thanks for the request. My 2 cents...Since your practice focus seems to be MVA, Don (not Dan!!!) 's book if you don't already have it.Here's several more general must-haves, not all inclusive, just off the top of my head:Rehabilitation of the Spine: A Practitioner's Manual, Craig LiebensonLow Back Disorders and Ultimate Back Fitness and Performance, Stuart McGill--The best available science on lumbar stabilization exercise. To my mind FWIW, if you treat spine disorders and aren't conversant with the material in these books then you're WAY behind the curve. This material is being discussed on EVERY major sports med, training and fitness blog, not to mention the NY Times and many other major media outlets.Diagnosis and Treatment of Movement Impairment Syndromes, Shirley Sahrmann-- She's a PT who has for 25 years been at the forefront of positioning PTs as movement analysis experts and portal of care providers.Gray Cook's Functional Movement Assessment work is good too, but you'll find it mostly on DVD. Diane Lee's work is interesting, but a bit too steeped in Hodge's work.Try some of those, but commit McGill's work to memory. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center

3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956

drpsnell.chiroweb.comwww.fixyourownback.comMember American College of Sports MedicineDate: Wed, 3 Feb 2010 20:58:29 -0800From: gcluen2002@...Subject: Re: What do you provide for your patientsdrpsnell@...

Dr. Snell,I'd appreciate it if you could recommend some exercise rehab books & /or seminars. I've always been interested in teaching my patients exercises to help strengthen and maintain their spinal integrity & I'm always looking to improve my care for the patients. I also believe we as a profession need to utilize the accepted norms in exercise rehab rather than keeping our focus on passive therapies. Thanks for the great post. Cluen, DCAuto & Work Injury Center3311 NE MLK Blvd. Suite 202Portland, OR 97212503-282-4878From: Snell <drpsnell@...>oregon dc listserve < >Sent: Wed, February 3, 2010 7:44:03 PMSubject: What do you provide for your patients

The recent thread with someone asking what exercises to prescribe for LBP and the responses, or lack thereof was interesting. The field of exercise science in treatment of a variety of disorders is burgeoning with the new ACSM's Exercise is Medicine campaign as well as with the release of books such as Spark: The Revolutionary New Science of Exercise and the Brain by J. Ratey. Within our own field, chiropractors sadly continue to be slow to adopt this trend and to educate themselves in what the science supports. I work with a lot of personal trainers in town, and

with several PTs. They regularly are surprised that I, a chiropractor, seem to be abreast of the literature in exercise science. I am regularly disappointed that so many of my colleagues, and even the recent grads, seem to barely have an understanding of what works and what doesn't when it comes to exercise. It's maddening to continue to get disc patients who have been prescribed "yoga" that includes forward bends, knees to chest and twisting poses and can't seem to get that pain down their leg get any better. It's frustrating to see abdominal hollowing exercises a la' Hodges work on transversus and the subsequent misinterpretation of the findings of those studies, continue to be spread as misinformation and thus creating more dysfunction in that patient. I wonder what is to become of our profession when we don't demonstrate to the public that we know more about how to treat their back pain than their trainer at the gym who has

attended a McGill conference, a Gray conference, a Gray Cook conference and regularly tunes in to SportsRehabExpert. com. What do we have to offer in response? The latest practice income generating tips gleaned at the latest conference? This lack of understanding does not seem to be lost on our patients in my experience.What prompted me to write tonight was a communique I received today that was intended for Kaiser physicians. The following was written by a physiatrist and was intended to be a quick guide to appropriate referral for PCPs in the local Kaiser system. After giving a good (I feel) description of the pros and cons of manipulation therapy he states:"How does manipulation fit into the general musculoskeletal care continuum and how does it relate to our PT services? Manipulation as a form of treatment is legitimate, whether you consider the field of chiropractic so or not. If we

had PTs that did manipulation we would not need to refer out to have this form of treatment. The down side of Chiropractic from our perspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passive modalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an under emphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourish throughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general. This then may leave the patient after a few visits feeling better but not fortifying them with education, strength and flexibility which are the foundation of prevention for recurrent spinal pain."I haven't participated in this forum for a while. It's interesting to spend a few days here again. If I'm too out of place here, I'll go away again. But I would be interested in finding out if DCs in this progressive state are tuning in to the changing times and positioning themselves to have cultural authority for ALL

things concerning conservative management of the spine. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center

3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956

drpsnell.chiroweb. comwww.fixyourownback. comMember American College of Sports Medicine

Posted

Herb I have the greatest respect for you. However, to answer your

question "why should you care..." directly, perhaps you shouldn't, but

the other DCs on this forum navigating the current environment of

practice and planning for their future should. Why? The currency of

the kingdom is research. The research says that manual therapy,

manipulation and exercise combined work better than any of them alone.

The Kaiser physiatrist in question is teaching the gatekeepers in your

community how to view you and your colleagues. Kaiser is one of the

only HMOs in the US that consistently runs in the black. Their model

is frequently used as an example of some of the things that are right

with managed care, whether you or I think so or not.Herb,

this topic is of no interest to many of us on this forum who have

panels into the 1000s. With decent care, most docs can maintain those

practices with internal referrals. But for those that are building and

have whole future ahead, the playing field is different than it was 45

years ago. Evidence based practice has changed things, for both MDs

and for DCs. If MDs and DCs can't come together on this then as this

physiatrist points out, they will refer, eventually to PTs who

manipulate. In short Herb, this MD's opinion is the canary in the coal

mine...and that's why we should listen. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center

3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956

drpsnell.chiroweb.comwww.fixyourownback.comMember American College of Sports MedicineOregondcs From: hbf4747@...Date: Wed, 3 Feb 2010 20:31:56 -0800Subject: Re: What do you provide for your patients

Hi Dr. Snell,

Thank you for your informative post as to what current texts are available for patients' exercises. However when you cite the comments of a Kaiser physiatrist about our profession as being of significance we part company. D.C.s' are not MD's lapdogs waiting for a few words of approbation from them. I have practiced in the city of Keizer for about 45 years I've cared for thousands of patients and believe it or not nary a one of them was an MD referral. Philosophically chiropractic and all of the various methods under the medical umbrella are miles apart so why should I care at all as to this guys opinion.

Herb Freeman D.C.

What do you provide for your patients

The recent thread with someone asking what exercises to prescribe for LBP and the responses, or lack thereof was interesting. The field of exercise science in treatment of a variety of disorders is burgeoning with the new ACSM's Exercise is Medicine campaign as well as with the release of books such as Spark: The Revolutionary New Science of Exercise and the Brain by J. Ratey. Within our own field, chiropractors sadly continue to be slow to adopt this trend and to educate themselves in what the science supports. I work with a lot of personal trainers in town, and with several PTs. They regularly are surprised that I, a chiropractor, seem to be abreast of the literature in exercise science. I am regularly disappointed that so many of my colleagues, and even the recent grads, seem to barely have an understanding of what works and what doesn't when it comes to exercise. It's maddening to continue to get disc patients who have been prescribed "yoga" that includes forward bends, knees to chest and twisting poses and can't seem to get that pain down their leg get any better. It's frustrating to see abdominal hollowing exercises a la' Hodges work on transversus and the subsequent misinterpretation of the findings of those studies, continue to be spread as misinformation and thus creating more dysfunction in that patient. I wonder what is to become of our profession when we don't demonstrate to the public that we know more about how to treat their back pain than their trainer at the gym who has attended a McGill conference, a Gray conference, a Gray Cook conference and regularly tunes in to SportsRehabExpert.com. What do we have to offer in response? The latest practice income generating tips gleaned at the latest conference? This lack of understanding does not seem to be lost on our patients in my experience.What prompted me to write tonight was a communique I received today that was intended for Kaiser physicians. The following was written by a physiatrist and was intended to be a quick guide to appropriate referral for PCPs in the local Kaiser system. After giving a good (I feel) description of the pros and cons of manipulation therapy he states:"How does manipulation fit into the general musculoskeletal care continuum and how does it relate to our PT services? Manipulation as a form of treatment is legitimate, whether you consider the field of chiropractic so or not. If we had PTs that did manipulation we would not need to refer out to have this form of treatment. The down side of Chiropractic from our perspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passive modalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an under emphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourish throughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general. This then may leave the patient after a few visits feeling better but not fortifying them with education, strength and flexibility which are the foundation of prevention for recurrent spinal pain."I haven't participated in this forum for a while. It's interesting to spend a few days here again. If I'm too out of place here, I'll go away again. But I would be interested in finding out if DCs in this progressive state are tuning in to the changing times and positioning themselves to have cultural authority for ALL things concerning conservative management of the spine. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center 3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956 drpsnell.chiroweb.comwww.fixyourownback.comMember American College of Sports Medicine

Posted

Herb I have the greatest respect for you. However, to answer your

question "why should you care..." directly, perhaps you shouldn't, but

the other DCs on this forum navigating the current environment of

practice and planning for their future should. Why? The currency of

the kingdom is research. The research says that manual therapy,

manipulation and exercise combined work better than any of them alone.

The Kaiser physiatrist in question is teaching the gatekeepers in your

community how to view you and your colleagues. Kaiser is one of the

only HMOs in the US that consistently runs in the black. Their model

is frequently used as an example of some of the things that are right

with managed care, whether you or I think so or not.Herb,

this topic is of no interest to many of us on this forum who have

panels into the 1000s. With decent care, most docs can maintain those

practices with internal referrals. But for those that are building and

have whole future ahead, the playing field is different than it was 45

years ago. Evidence based practice has changed things, for both MDs

and for DCs. If MDs and DCs can't come together on this then as this

physiatrist points out, they will refer, eventually to PTs who

manipulate. In short Herb, this MD's opinion is the canary in the coal

mine...and that's why we should listen. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center

3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956

drpsnell.chiroweb.comwww.fixyourownback.comMember American College of Sports MedicineOregondcs From: hbf4747@...Date: Wed, 3 Feb 2010 20:31:56 -0800Subject: Re: What do you provide for your patients

Hi Dr. Snell,

Thank you for your informative post as to what current texts are available for patients' exercises. However when you cite the comments of a Kaiser physiatrist about our profession as being of significance we part company. D.C.s' are not MD's lapdogs waiting for a few words of approbation from them. I have practiced in the city of Keizer for about 45 years I've cared for thousands of patients and believe it or not nary a one of them was an MD referral. Philosophically chiropractic and all of the various methods under the medical umbrella are miles apart so why should I care at all as to this guys opinion.

Herb Freeman D.C.

What do you provide for your patients

The recent thread with someone asking what exercises to prescribe for LBP and the responses, or lack thereof was interesting. The field of exercise science in treatment of a variety of disorders is burgeoning with the new ACSM's Exercise is Medicine campaign as well as with the release of books such as Spark: The Revolutionary New Science of Exercise and the Brain by J. Ratey. Within our own field, chiropractors sadly continue to be slow to adopt this trend and to educate themselves in what the science supports. I work with a lot of personal trainers in town, and with several PTs. They regularly are surprised that I, a chiropractor, seem to be abreast of the literature in exercise science. I am regularly disappointed that so many of my colleagues, and even the recent grads, seem to barely have an understanding of what works and what doesn't when it comes to exercise. It's maddening to continue to get disc patients who have been prescribed "yoga" that includes forward bends, knees to chest and twisting poses and can't seem to get that pain down their leg get any better. It's frustrating to see abdominal hollowing exercises a la' Hodges work on transversus and the subsequent misinterpretation of the findings of those studies, continue to be spread as misinformation and thus creating more dysfunction in that patient. I wonder what is to become of our profession when we don't demonstrate to the public that we know more about how to treat their back pain than their trainer at the gym who has attended a McGill conference, a Gray conference, a Gray Cook conference and regularly tunes in to SportsRehabExpert.com. What do we have to offer in response? The latest practice income generating tips gleaned at the latest conference? This lack of understanding does not seem to be lost on our patients in my experience.What prompted me to write tonight was a communique I received today that was intended for Kaiser physicians. The following was written by a physiatrist and was intended to be a quick guide to appropriate referral for PCPs in the local Kaiser system. After giving a good (I feel) description of the pros and cons of manipulation therapy he states:"How does manipulation fit into the general musculoskeletal care continuum and how does it relate to our PT services? Manipulation as a form of treatment is legitimate, whether you consider the field of chiropractic so or not. If we had PTs that did manipulation we would not need to refer out to have this form of treatment. The down side of Chiropractic from our perspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passive modalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an under emphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourish throughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general. This then may leave the patient after a few visits feeling better but not fortifying them with education, strength and flexibility which are the foundation of prevention for recurrent spinal pain."I haven't participated in this forum for a while. It's interesting to spend a few days here again. If I'm too out of place here, I'll go away again. But I would be interested in finding out if DCs in this progressive state are tuning in to the changing times and positioning themselves to have cultural authority for ALL things concerning conservative management of the spine. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center 3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956 drpsnell.chiroweb.comwww.fixyourownback.comMember American College of Sports Medicine

Posted

Well put, Herb.

A little like Bocelli worring about what Tiny Tim thinks he should be singing.

Not that I'm against exercise.

Ann DC

Re: What do you provide for your patients

Hi Dr. Snell,

Thank you for your informative post as to what current texts are available for patients' exercises. However when you cite the comments of a Kaiser physiatrist about our profession as being of significance we part company. D.C.s' are not MD's lapdogs waiting for a few words of approbation from them. I have practiced in the city of Keizer for about 45 years I've cared for thousands of patients and believe it or not nary a one of them was an MD referral. Philosophically chiropractic and all of the various methods under the medical umbrella are miles apart so why should I care at all as to this guys opinion.

Herb Freeman D.C.

What do you provide for your patients

The recent thread with someone asking what exercises to prescribe for LBP and the responses, or lack thereof was interesting. The field of exercise science in treatment of a variety of disorders is burgeoning with the new ACSM's Exercise is Medicine campaign as well as with the release of books such as Spark: The Revolutionary New Science of Exercise and the Brain by J. Ratey. Within our own field, chiropractors sadly continue to be slow to adopt this trend and to educate themselves in what the science supports. I work with a lot of personal trainers in town, and with several PTs. They regularly are surprised that I, a chiropractor, seem to be abreast of the literature in exercise science. I am regularly disappointed that so many of my colleagues, and even the recent grads, seem to barely have an understanding of what works and what doesn't when it comes to exercise. It's maddening to continue to get disc patients who have been prescribed "yoga" that includes forward bends, knees to chest and twisting poses and can't seem to get that pain down their leg get any better. It's frustrating to see abdominal hollowing exercises a la' Hodges work on transversus and the subsequent misinterpretation of the findings of those studies, continue to be spread as misinformation and thus creating more dysfunction in that patient. I wonder what is to become of our profession when we don't demonstrate to the public that we know more about how to treat their back pain than their trainer at the gym who has attended a McGill conference, a Gray conference, a Gray Cook conference and regularly tunes in to SportsRehabExpert.com. What do we have to offer in response? The latest practice income generating tips gleaned at the latest conference? This lack of understanding does not seem to be lost on our patients in my experience.

What prompted me to write tonight was a communique I received today that was intended for Kaiser physicians. The following was written by a physiatrist and was intended to be a quick guide to appropriate referral for PCPs in the local Kaiser system. After giving a good (I feel) description of the pros and cons of manipulation therapy he states:

"How does manipulation fit into the general musculoskeletal care continuum and how does it relate to our PT services? Manipulation as a form of treatment is legitimate, whether you consider the field of chiropractic so or not. If we had PTs that did manipulation we would not need to refer out to have this form of treatment. The down side of Chiropractic from our perspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passive modalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an under emphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourish throughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general. This then may leave the patient after a few visits feeling better but not fortifying them with education, strength and flexibility which are the foundation of prevention for recurrent spinal pain."

I haven't participated in this forum for a while. It's interesting to spend a few days here again. If I'm too out of place here, I'll go away again. But I would be interested in finding out if DCs in this progressive state are tuning in to the changing times and positioning themselves to have cultural authority for ALL things concerning conservative management of the spine.

W. Snell, D.C.

Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc

at Hawthorne Wellness Center

3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd.

Portland, OR 97214

Ph. 503-235-5484

Fax 503-235-3956

drpsnell.chiroweb.com

www.fixyourownback.com

Member American College of Sports Medicine

Posted

Phil thanks for your response it clarifies and justifies not only your concerns and position but why there will always be a schism in our profession.

Herb

What do you provide for your patients

The recent thread with someone asking what exercises to prescribe for LBP and the responses, or lack thereof was interesting. The field of exercise science in treatment of a variety of disorders is burgeoning with the new ACSM's Exercise is Medicine campaign as well as with the release of books such as Spark: The Revolutionary New Science of Exercise and the Brain by J. Ratey. Within our own field, chiropractors sadly continue to be slow to adopt this trend and to educate themselves in what the science supports. I work with a lot of personal trainers in town, and with several PTs. They regularly are surprised that I, a chiropractor, seem to be abreast of the literature in exercise science. I am regularly disappointed that so many of my colleagues, and even the recent grads, seem to barely have an understanding of what works and what doesn't when it comes to exercise. It's maddening to continue to get disc patients who have been prescribed "yoga" that includes forward bends, knees to chest and twisting poses and can't seem to get that pain down their leg get any better. It's frustrating to see abdominal hollowing exercises a la' Hodges work on transversus and the subsequent misinterpretation of the findings of those studies, continue to be spread as misinformation and thus creating more dysfunction in that patient. I wonder what is to become of our profession when we don't demonstrate to the public that we know more about how to treat their back pain than their trainer at the gym who has attended a McGill conference, a Gray conference, a Gray Cook conference and regularly tunes in to SportsRehabExpert.com. What do we have to offer in response? The latest practice income generating tips gleaned at the latest conference? This lack of understanding does not seem to be lost on our patients in my experience.What prompted me to write tonight was a communique I received today that was intended for Kaiser physicians. The following was written by a physiatrist and was intended to be a quick guide to appropriate referral for PCPs in the local Kaiser system. After giving a good (I feel) description of the pros and cons of manipulation therapy he states:"How does manipulation fit into the general musculoskeletal care continuum and how does it relate to our PT services? Manipulation as a form of treatment is legitimate, whether you consider the field of chiropractic so or not. If we had PTs that did manipulation we would not need to refer out to have this form of treatment. The down side of Chiropractic from our perspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passive modalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an under emphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourish throughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general. This then may leave the patient after a few visits feeling better but not fortifying them with education, strength and flexibility which are the foundation of prevention for recurrent spinal pain."I haven't participated in this forum for a while. It's interesting to spend a few days here again. If I'm too out of place here, I'll go away again. But I would be interested in finding out if DCs in this progressive state are tuning in to the changing times and positioning themselves to have cultural authority for ALL things concerning conservative management of the spine. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center 3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956 drpsnell.chiroweb.comwww.fixyourownback.comMember American College of Sports Medicine

Posted

Dr. Snell,I appreciate your input to this problem, as it is a BIG problem that PT's are now doing what we always thought was ours. We did X-ray for 20 years before MD's and then they took it as theirs, yes we continued and even teach it in the schools, but now Or doc feel it is just easier to send their patient to the hospital, plus the insurance will pay there. Asleep again, no one sees what they are doing or not doing. Well, if we don't do it we will lose it and that is exactly what I see happening across the board from x-ray to exercise (Chiropractic Sports Medicine) If we do not get on the ball we will loose our place to those that are not asleep and are looking for the business. WE have to be the best, not second best. Wiese D..C From: Snell <drpsnell@...>Subject: RE: What do you provide for your patients"oregon dc listserve" < >Date: Wednesday, February 3, 2010, 9:50 PM

Herb I have the greatest respect for you. However, to answer your

question "why should you care..." directly, perhaps you shouldn't, but

the other DCs on this forum navigating the current environment of

practice and planning for their future should. Why? The currency of

the kingdom is research. The research says that manual therapy,

manipulation and exercise combined work better than any of them alone.

The Kaiser physiatrist in question is teaching the gatekeepers in your

community how to view you and your colleagues. Kaiser is one of the

only HMOs in the US that consistently runs in the black. Their model

is frequently used as an example of some of the things that are right

with managed care, whether you or I think so or not.Herb,

this topic is of no interest to many of us on this forum who have

panels into the 1000s. With decent care, most docs can maintain those

practices with internal referrals. But for those that are building and

have whole future ahead, the playing field is different than it was 45

years ago. Evidence based practice has changed things, for both MDs

and for DCs. If MDs and DCs can't come together on this then as this

physiatrist points out, they will refer, eventually to PTs who

manipulate. In short Herb, this MD's opinion is the canary in the coal

mine...and that's why we should listen. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center

3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956

drpsnell.chiroweb.comwww.fixyourownback.comMember American College of Sports MedicineOregondcs From: hbf4747@...Date: Wed, 3 Feb 2010 20:31:56 -0800Subject: Re: What do you provide for your patients

Hi Dr. Snell,

Thank you for your informative post as to what current texts are available for patients' exercises. However when you cite the comments of a Kaiser physiatrist about our profession as being of significance we part company. D.C.s' are not MD's lapdogs waiting for a few words of approbation from them. I have practiced in the city of Keizer for about 45 years I've cared for thousands of patients and believe it or not nary a one of them was an MD referral. Philosophically chiropractic and all of the various methods under the medical umbrella are miles apart so why should I care at all as to this guys opinion.

Herb Freeman D.C.

What do you provide for your patients

The recent thread with someone asking what exercises to prescribe for LBP and the responses, or lack thereof was interesting. The field of exercise science in treatment of a variety of disorders is burgeoning with the new ACSM's Exercise is Medicine campaign as well as with the release of books such as Spark: The Revolutionary New Science of Exercise and the Brain by J. Ratey. Within our own field, chiropractors sadly continue to be slow to adopt this trend and to educate themselves in what the science supports. I work with a lot of personal trainers in town, and with several PTs. They regularly are surprised that I, a chiropractor, seem to be abreast of the literature in exercise science. I am regularly disappointed that so many of my colleagues, and even the recent grads, seem to barely have an understanding of what works and what doesn't when it comes to exercise. It's maddening to continue to get disc patients who have been prescribed "yoga" that includes forward bends, knees to chest and twisting poses and can't seem to get that pain down their leg get any better. It's frustrating to see abdominal hollowing exercises a la' Hodges work on transversus and the subsequent misinterpretation of the findings of those studies, continue to be spread as misinformation and thus creating more dysfunction in that patient. I wonder what is to become of our profession when we don't demonstrate to the public that we know more about how to treat their back pain than their trainer at the gym who has attended a McGill conference, a Gray conference, a Gray Cook conference and regularly tunes in to SportsRehabExpert. com. What do we have to offer in response? The latest practice income generating tips gleaned at the latest conference? This lack of understanding does not seem to be lost on our patients in my experience.What prompted me to write tonight was a communique I received today that was intended for Kaiser physicians. The following was written by a physiatrist and was intended to be a quick guide to appropriate referral for PCPs in the local Kaiser system. After giving a good (I feel) description of the pros and cons of manipulation therapy he states:"How does manipulation fit into the general musculoskeletal care continuum and how does it relate to our PT services? Manipulation as a form of treatment is legitimate, whether you consider the field of chiropractic so or not. If we had PTs that did manipulation we would not need to refer out to have this form of treatment. The down side of Chiropractic from our perspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passive modalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an under emphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourish throughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general. This then may leave the patient after a few visits feeling better but not fortifying them with education, strength and flexibility which are the foundation of prevention for recurrent spinal pain."I haven't participated in this forum for a while. It's interesting to spend a few days here again. If I'm too out of place here, I'll go away again. But I would be interested in finding out if DCs in this progressive state are tuning in to the changing times and positioning themselves to have cultural authority for ALL things concerning conservative management of the spine. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center 3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956 drpsnell.chiroweb. comwww.fixyourownback. comMember American College of Sports Medicine

Posted

Dr. Snell,I appreciate your input to this problem, as it is a BIG problem that PT's are now doing what we always thought was ours. We did X-ray for 20 years before MD's and then they took it as theirs, yes we continued and even teach it in the schools, but now Or doc feel it is just easier to send their patient to the hospital, plus the insurance will pay there. Asleep again, no one sees what they are doing or not doing. Well, if we don't do it we will lose it and that is exactly what I see happening across the board from x-ray to exercise (Chiropractic Sports Medicine) If we do not get on the ball we will loose our place to those that are not asleep and are looking for the business. WE have to be the best, not second best. Wiese D..C From: Snell <drpsnell@...>Subject: RE: What do you provide for your patients"oregon dc listserve" < >Date: Wednesday, February 3, 2010, 9:50 PM

Herb I have the greatest respect for you. However, to answer your

question "why should you care..." directly, perhaps you shouldn't, but

the other DCs on this forum navigating the current environment of

practice and planning for their future should. Why? The currency of

the kingdom is research. The research says that manual therapy,

manipulation and exercise combined work better than any of them alone.

The Kaiser physiatrist in question is teaching the gatekeepers in your

community how to view you and your colleagues. Kaiser is one of the

only HMOs in the US that consistently runs in the black. Their model

is frequently used as an example of some of the things that are right

with managed care, whether you or I think so or not.Herb,

this topic is of no interest to many of us on this forum who have

panels into the 1000s. With decent care, most docs can maintain those

practices with internal referrals. But for those that are building and

have whole future ahead, the playing field is different than it was 45

years ago. Evidence based practice has changed things, for both MDs

and for DCs. If MDs and DCs can't come together on this then as this

physiatrist points out, they will refer, eventually to PTs who

manipulate. In short Herb, this MD's opinion is the canary in the coal

mine...and that's why we should listen. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center

3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956

drpsnell.chiroweb.comwww.fixyourownback.comMember American College of Sports MedicineOregondcs From: hbf4747@...Date: Wed, 3 Feb 2010 20:31:56 -0800Subject: Re: What do you provide for your patients

Hi Dr. Snell,

Thank you for your informative post as to what current texts are available for patients' exercises. However when you cite the comments of a Kaiser physiatrist about our profession as being of significance we part company. D.C.s' are not MD's lapdogs waiting for a few words of approbation from them. I have practiced in the city of Keizer for about 45 years I've cared for thousands of patients and believe it or not nary a one of them was an MD referral. Philosophically chiropractic and all of the various methods under the medical umbrella are miles apart so why should I care at all as to this guys opinion.

Herb Freeman D.C.

What do you provide for your patients

The recent thread with someone asking what exercises to prescribe for LBP and the responses, or lack thereof was interesting. The field of exercise science in treatment of a variety of disorders is burgeoning with the new ACSM's Exercise is Medicine campaign as well as with the release of books such as Spark: The Revolutionary New Science of Exercise and the Brain by J. Ratey. Within our own field, chiropractors sadly continue to be slow to adopt this trend and to educate themselves in what the science supports. I work with a lot of personal trainers in town, and with several PTs. They regularly are surprised that I, a chiropractor, seem to be abreast of the literature in exercise science. I am regularly disappointed that so many of my colleagues, and even the recent grads, seem to barely have an understanding of what works and what doesn't when it comes to exercise. It's maddening to continue to get disc patients who have been prescribed "yoga" that includes forward bends, knees to chest and twisting poses and can't seem to get that pain down their leg get any better. It's frustrating to see abdominal hollowing exercises a la' Hodges work on transversus and the subsequent misinterpretation of the findings of those studies, continue to be spread as misinformation and thus creating more dysfunction in that patient. I wonder what is to become of our profession when we don't demonstrate to the public that we know more about how to treat their back pain than their trainer at the gym who has attended a McGill conference, a Gray conference, a Gray Cook conference and regularly tunes in to SportsRehabExpert. com. What do we have to offer in response? The latest practice income generating tips gleaned at the latest conference? This lack of understanding does not seem to be lost on our patients in my experience.What prompted me to write tonight was a communique I received today that was intended for Kaiser physicians. The following was written by a physiatrist and was intended to be a quick guide to appropriate referral for PCPs in the local Kaiser system. After giving a good (I feel) description of the pros and cons of manipulation therapy he states:"How does manipulation fit into the general musculoskeletal care continuum and how does it relate to our PT services? Manipulation as a form of treatment is legitimate, whether you consider the field of chiropractic so or not. If we had PTs that did manipulation we would not need to refer out to have this form of treatment. The down side of Chiropractic from our perspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passive modalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an under emphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourish throughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general. This then may leave the patient after a few visits feeling better but not fortifying them with education, strength and flexibility which are the foundation of prevention for recurrent spinal pain."I haven't participated in this forum for a while. It's interesting to spend a few days here again. If I'm too out of place here, I'll go away again. But I would be interested in finding out if DCs in this progressive state are tuning in to the changing times and positioning themselves to have cultural authority for ALL things concerning conservative management of the spine. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center 3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956 drpsnell.chiroweb. comwww.fixyourownback. comMember American College of Sports Medicine

Posted

"The down side of Chiropractic from our perspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passive modalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an under emphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourish throughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general."

I'd have to absolutely agree with this. We've gone away from being skilled adjusters and manual based physicians who heal with our hands, to a heavily gadget dependent group.

ph Medlin D.C.Spine Tree Chiropractic1607 NE Alberta StPDX, OR 97211503-788-6800

What do you provide for your patients

The recent thread with someone asking what exercises to prescribe for LBP and the responses, or lack thereof was interesting. The field of exercise science in treatment of a variety of disorders is burgeoning with the new ACSM's Exercise is Medicine campaign as well as with the release of books such as Spark: The Revolutionary New Science of Exercise and the Brain by J. Ratey. Within our own field, chiropractors sadly continue to be slow to adopt this trend and to educate themselves in what the science supports. I work with a lot of personal trainers in town, and with several PTs. They regularly are surprised that I, a chiropractor, seem to be abreast of the literature in exercise science. I am regularly disappointed that so many of my colleagues, and even the recent grads, seem to barely have an understanding of what works and what doesn't when it comes to exercise. It's maddening to continue to get disc patients who have been prescribed "yoga" that includes forward bends, knees to chest and twisting poses and can't seem to get that pain down their leg get any better. It's frustrating to see abdominal hollowing exercises a la' Hodges work on transversus and the subsequent misinterpretation of the findings of those studies, continue to be spread as misinformation and thus creating more dysfunction in that patient. I wonder what is to become of our profession when we don't demonstrate to the public that we know more about how to treat their back pain than their trainer at the gym who has attended a McGill conference, a Gray conference, a Gray Cook conference and regularly tunes in to SportsRehabExpert.com. What do we have to offer in response? & n bsp; The latest practice income generating tips gleaned at the latest conference? This lack of understanding does not seem to be lost on our patients in my experience.What prompted me to write tonight was a communique I received today that was intended for Kaiser physicians. The following was written by a physiatrist and was intended to be a quick guide to appropriate referral for PCPs in the local Kaiser system. After giving a good (I feel) description of the pros and cons of manipulation therapy he states:"How does manipulation fit into the general musculoskeletal care continuum and how does it relate to our PT services? Manipulation as a form of treatment is legitimate, whether you consider the field of chiropractic so or not. If we had PTs that did manipulation we would not need to refer out to have this form of treatment. The down side of Chiropractic from our perspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passive modalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an under emphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourish throughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general. This then may leave the patient after a few visits feeling better but not fortifying them with education, strength and flexibility which are the foundation of prevention for recurrent spinal pain."I haven't participated in this forum for a while. It's interesting to spend a few days here again. If I'm too out of place here, I'll go away again. But I would be interested in finding out if DCs in this progressive state are tuning in to the changing times and positioning themselves to have cultural authority for ALL things concerning conservative management of the spine. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center 3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956 drpsnell.chiroweb.comwww.fixyourownback.comMember American College of Sports Medicine

Posted

A couple of studies along this theme: The first supports the combined use of manual methods (manipulation/mobilization) and exercise; Google for a open access PDF file: SPINE Volume 29, Number 14, pp 1541–1548 The second suggests superiority of FD over exercise for chronic LBP:Eur Spine J (2006) 15: 1070–1082 (another open-access PDF) Seitz, DC Tuality Physicians 730-D SE Oak St Hillsboro, OR 97123 (503)640-3724 From: drpsnell@...Date: Wed, 3 Feb 2010 19:44:03 -0800Subject: What do you provide for your patients

The recent thread with someone asking what exercises to prescribe for LBP and the responses, or lack thereof was interesting. The field of exercise science in treatment of a variety of disorders is burgeoning with the new ACSM's Exercise is Medicine campaign as well as with the release of books such as Spark: The Revolutionary New Science of Exercise and the Brain by J. Ratey. Within our own field, chiropractors sadly continue to be slow to adopt this trend and to educate themselves in what the science supports. I work with a lot of personal trainers in town, and with several PTs. They regularly are surprised that I, a chiropractor, seem to be abreast of the literature in exercise science. I am regularly disappointed that so many of my colleagues, and even the recent grads, seem to barely have an understanding of what works and what doesn't when it comes to exercise. It's maddening to continue to get disc patients who have been prescribed "yoga" that includes forward bends, knees to chest and twisting poses and can't seem to get that pain down their leg get any better. It's frustrating to see abdominal hollowing exercises a la' Hodges work on transversus and the subsequent misinterpretation of the findings of those studies, continue to be spread as misinformation and thus creating more dysfunction in that patient. I wonder what is to become of our profession when we don't demonstrate to the public that we know more about how to treat their back pain than their trainer at the gym who has attended a McGill conference, a Gray conference, a Gray Cook conference and regularly tunes in to SportsRehabExpert.com. What do we have to offer in response? The latest practice income generating tips gleaned at the latest conference? This lack of understanding does not seem to be lost on our patients in my experience.What prompted me to write tonight was a communique I received today that was intended for Kaiser physicians. The following was written by a physiatrist and was intended to be a quick guide to appropriate referral for PCPs in the local Kaiser system. After giving a good (I feel) description of the pros and cons of manipulation therapy he states:"How does manipulation fit into the general musculoskeletal care continuum and how does it relate to our PT services? Manipulation as a form of treatment is legitimate, whether you consider the field of chiropractic so or not. If we had PTs that did manipulation we would not need to refer out to have this form of treatment. The down side of Chiropractic from our perspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passive modalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an under emphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourish throughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general. This then may leave the patient after a few visits feeling better but not fortifying them with education, strength and flexibility which are the foundation of prevention for recurrent spinal pain."I haven't participated in this forum for a while. It's interesting to spend a few days here again. If I'm too out of place here, I'll go away again. But I would be interested in finding out if DCs in this progressive state are tuning in to the changing times and positioning themselves to have cultural authority for ALL things concerning conservative management of the spine. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center

3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956

drpsnell.chiroweb.comwww.fixyourownback.comMember American College of Sports Medicine

Posted

A couple of studies along this theme: The first supports the combined use of manual methods (manipulation/mobilization) and exercise; Google for a open access PDF file: SPINE Volume 29, Number 14, pp 1541–1548 The second suggests superiority of FD over exercise for chronic LBP:Eur Spine J (2006) 15: 1070–1082 (another open-access PDF) Seitz, DC Tuality Physicians 730-D SE Oak St Hillsboro, OR 97123 (503)640-3724 From: drpsnell@...Date: Wed, 3 Feb 2010 19:44:03 -0800Subject: What do you provide for your patients

The recent thread with someone asking what exercises to prescribe for LBP and the responses, or lack thereof was interesting. The field of exercise science in treatment of a variety of disorders is burgeoning with the new ACSM's Exercise is Medicine campaign as well as with the release of books such as Spark: The Revolutionary New Science of Exercise and the Brain by J. Ratey. Within our own field, chiropractors sadly continue to be slow to adopt this trend and to educate themselves in what the science supports. I work with a lot of personal trainers in town, and with several PTs. They regularly are surprised that I, a chiropractor, seem to be abreast of the literature in exercise science. I am regularly disappointed that so many of my colleagues, and even the recent grads, seem to barely have an understanding of what works and what doesn't when it comes to exercise. It's maddening to continue to get disc patients who have been prescribed "yoga" that includes forward bends, knees to chest and twisting poses and can't seem to get that pain down their leg get any better. It's frustrating to see abdominal hollowing exercises a la' Hodges work on transversus and the subsequent misinterpretation of the findings of those studies, continue to be spread as misinformation and thus creating more dysfunction in that patient. I wonder what is to become of our profession when we don't demonstrate to the public that we know more about how to treat their back pain than their trainer at the gym who has attended a McGill conference, a Gray conference, a Gray Cook conference and regularly tunes in to SportsRehabExpert.com. What do we have to offer in response? The latest practice income generating tips gleaned at the latest conference? This lack of understanding does not seem to be lost on our patients in my experience.What prompted me to write tonight was a communique I received today that was intended for Kaiser physicians. The following was written by a physiatrist and was intended to be a quick guide to appropriate referral for PCPs in the local Kaiser system. After giving a good (I feel) description of the pros and cons of manipulation therapy he states:"How does manipulation fit into the general musculoskeletal care continuum and how does it relate to our PT services? Manipulation as a form of treatment is legitimate, whether you consider the field of chiropractic so or not. If we had PTs that did manipulation we would not need to refer out to have this form of treatment. The down side of Chiropractic from our perspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passive modalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an under emphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourish throughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general. This then may leave the patient after a few visits feeling better but not fortifying them with education, strength and flexibility which are the foundation of prevention for recurrent spinal pain."I haven't participated in this forum for a while. It's interesting to spend a few days here again. If I'm too out of place here, I'll go away again. But I would be interested in finding out if DCs in this progressive state are tuning in to the changing times and positioning themselves to have cultural authority for ALL things concerning conservative management of the spine. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center

3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956

drpsnell.chiroweb.comwww.fixyourownback.comMember American College of Sports Medicine

Posted

Speak for yourself, my friend. Them fighting words to me ... my hands are what I have! Yes, I work with microcurrent when needed but my hands come first!

Years ago I attempted to get them insured .... the agent looked at me like I was crazy and escorted me out the door!.

Sunny ;'-))

Sunny Kierstyn, RN DC Fibromyalgia Care Center of Oregon 2677 Willakenzie Road, 7CEugene, Oregon, 97401541- 654-0850; Fx; 541- 654-0834www.drsunnykierstyn.com

; drpsnell@...From: spinetree@...Date: Thu, 4 Feb 2010 08:44:24 -0800Subject: Re: What do you provide for your patients

"The down side of Chiropractic from our perspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passive modalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an under emphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourish throughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general."

I'd have to absolutely agree with this. We've gone away from being skilled adjusters and manual based physicians who heal with our hands, to a heavily gadget dependent group.

ph Medlin D.C.Spine Tree Chiropractic1607 NE Alberta StPDX, OR 97211503-788-6800

What do you provide for your patients

The recent thread with someone asking what exercises to prescribe for LBP and the responses, or lack thereof was interesting. The field of exercise science in treatment of a variety of disorders is burgeoning with the new ACSM's Exercise is Medicine campaign as well as with the release of books such as Spark: The Revolutionary New Science of Exercise and the Brain by J. Ratey. Within our own field, chiropractors sadly continue to be slow to adopt this trend and to educate themselves in what the science supports. I work with a lot of personal trainers in town, and with several PTs. They regularly are surprised that I, a chiropractor, seem to be abreast of the literature in exercise science. I am regularly disappointed that so many of my colleagues, and even the recent grads, seem to barely have an understanding of what works and what doesn't when it comes to exercise. It's maddening to continue to get disc patients who have been prescribed "yoga" that includes forward bends, knees to chest and twisting poses and can't seem to get that pain down their leg get any better. It's frustrating to see abdominal hollowing exercises a la' Hodges work on transversus and the subsequent misinterpretation of the findings of those studies, continue to be spread as misinformation and thus creating more dysfunction in that patient. I wonder what is to become of our profession when we don't demonstrate to the public that we know more about how to treat their back pain than their trainer at the gym who has attended a McGill conference, a Gray conference, a Gray Cook conference and regularly tunes in to SportsRehabExpert.com. What do we have to offer in response? & n bsp; The latest practice income generating tips gleaned at the latest conference? This lack of understanding does not seem to be lost on our patients in my experience.What prompted me to write tonight was a communique I received today that was intended for Kaiser physicians. The following was written by a physiatrist and was intended to be a quick guide to appropriate referral for PCPs in the local Kaiser system. After giving a good (I feel) description of the pros and cons of manipulation therapy he states:"How does manipulation fit into the general musculoskeletal care continuum and how does it relate to our PT services? Manipulation as a form of treatment is legitimate, whether you consider the field of chiropractic so or not. If we had PTs that did manipulation we would not need to refer out to have this form of treatment. The down side of Chiropractic from our perspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passive modalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an under emphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourish throughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general. This then may leave the patient after a few visits feeling better but not fortifying them with education, strength and flexibility which are the foundation of prevention for recurrent spinal pain."I haven't participated in this forum for a while. It's interesting to spend a few days here again. If I'm too out of place here, I'll go away again. But I would be interested in finding out if DCs in this progressive state are tuning in to the changing times and positioning themselves to have cultural authority for ALL things concerning conservative management of the spine. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center 3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956 drpsnell.chiroweb.comwww.fixyourownback.comMember American College of Sports Medicine

Your E-mail and More On-the-Go. Get Windows Live Hotmail Free. Sign up now.

Posted

Speak for yourself, my friend. Them fighting words to me ... my hands are what I have! Yes, I work with microcurrent when needed but my hands come first!

Years ago I attempted to get them insured .... the agent looked at me like I was crazy and escorted me out the door!.

Sunny ;'-))

Sunny Kierstyn, RN DC Fibromyalgia Care Center of Oregon 2677 Willakenzie Road, 7CEugene, Oregon, 97401541- 654-0850; Fx; 541- 654-0834www.drsunnykierstyn.com

; drpsnell@...From: spinetree@...Date: Thu, 4 Feb 2010 08:44:24 -0800Subject: Re: What do you provide for your patients

"The down side of Chiropractic from our perspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passive modalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an under emphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourish throughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general."

I'd have to absolutely agree with this. We've gone away from being skilled adjusters and manual based physicians who heal with our hands, to a heavily gadget dependent group.

ph Medlin D.C.Spine Tree Chiropractic1607 NE Alberta StPDX, OR 97211503-788-6800

What do you provide for your patients

The recent thread with someone asking what exercises to prescribe for LBP and the responses, or lack thereof was interesting. The field of exercise science in treatment of a variety of disorders is burgeoning with the new ACSM's Exercise is Medicine campaign as well as with the release of books such as Spark: The Revolutionary New Science of Exercise and the Brain by J. Ratey. Within our own field, chiropractors sadly continue to be slow to adopt this trend and to educate themselves in what the science supports. I work with a lot of personal trainers in town, and with several PTs. They regularly are surprised that I, a chiropractor, seem to be abreast of the literature in exercise science. I am regularly disappointed that so many of my colleagues, and even the recent grads, seem to barely have an understanding of what works and what doesn't when it comes to exercise. It's maddening to continue to get disc patients who have been prescribed "yoga" that includes forward bends, knees to chest and twisting poses and can't seem to get that pain down their leg get any better. It's frustrating to see abdominal hollowing exercises a la' Hodges work on transversus and the subsequent misinterpretation of the findings of those studies, continue to be spread as misinformation and thus creating more dysfunction in that patient. I wonder what is to become of our profession when we don't demonstrate to the public that we know more about how to treat their back pain than their trainer at the gym who has attended a McGill conference, a Gray conference, a Gray Cook conference and regularly tunes in to SportsRehabExpert.com. What do we have to offer in response? & n bsp; The latest practice income generating tips gleaned at the latest conference? This lack of understanding does not seem to be lost on our patients in my experience.What prompted me to write tonight was a communique I received today that was intended for Kaiser physicians. The following was written by a physiatrist and was intended to be a quick guide to appropriate referral for PCPs in the local Kaiser system. After giving a good (I feel) description of the pros and cons of manipulation therapy he states:"How does manipulation fit into the general musculoskeletal care continuum and how does it relate to our PT services? Manipulation as a form of treatment is legitimate, whether you consider the field of chiropractic so or not. If we had PTs that did manipulation we would not need to refer out to have this form of treatment. The down side of Chiropractic from our perspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passive modalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an under emphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourish throughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general. This then may leave the patient after a few visits feeling better but not fortifying them with education, strength and flexibility which are the foundation of prevention for recurrent spinal pain."I haven't participated in this forum for a while. It's interesting to spend a few days here again. If I'm too out of place here, I'll go away again. But I would be interested in finding out if DCs in this progressive state are tuning in to the changing times and positioning themselves to have cultural authority for ALL things concerning conservative management of the spine. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center 3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956 drpsnell.chiroweb.comwww.fixyourownback.comMember American College of Sports Medicine

Your E-mail and More On-the-Go. Get Windows Live Hotmail Free. Sign up now.

Posted

I'm purely manual. Im speaking for MOST DCs in our state though.

ph Medlin D.C.Spine Tree Chiropractic1607 NE Alberta StPDX, OR 97211503-788-6800

What do you provide for your patients

The recent thread with someone asking what exercises to prescribe for LBP and the responses, or lack thereof was interesting. The field of exercise science in treatment of a variety of disorders is burgeoning with the new ACSM's Exercise is Medicine campaign as well as with the release of books such as Spark: The Revolutionary New Science of Exercise and the Brain by J. Ratey. Within our own field, chiropractors sadly continue to be slow to adopt this trend and to educate themselves in what the science supports. I work with a lot of personal trainers in town, and with several PTs. They regularly are surprised that I, a chiropractor, seem to be abreast of the literature in exercise science. I am regularly disappointed that so many of my colleagues, and even the recent grads, seem to barely have an understanding of what works and what doesn't when it comes to exercise. It's maddening to continue to get disc patients who have been prescribed "yoga" that includes forward bends, knees to chest and twisting poses and can't seem to get that pain down their leg get any better. It's frustrating to see abdominal hollowing exercises a la' Hodges work on transversus and the subsequent misinterpretation of the findings of those studies, continue to be spread as misinformation and thus creating more dysfunction in that patient. I wonder what is to become of our profession when we don't demonstrate to the public that we know more about how to treat their back pain than their trainer at the gym who has attended a McGill conference, a Gray conference, a Gray Cook conference and regularly tunes in to SportsRehabExpert.com. What do we have to offer in response? & n bsp; The latest practice income generating tips gleaned at the latest conference? This lack of understanding does not seem to be lost on our patients in my experience.What prompted me to write tonight was a communique I received today that was intended for Kaiser physicians. The following was written by a physiatrist and was intended to be a quick guide to appropriate referral for PCPs in the local Kaiser system. After giving a good (I feel) description of the pros and cons of manipulation therapy he states:"How does manipulation fit into the general musculoskeletal care continuum and how does it relate to our PT services? Manipulation as a form of treatment is legitimate, whether you consider the field of chiropractic so or not. If we had PTs that did manipulation we would not need to refer out to have this form of treatment. The down side of Chiropractic from our perspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passive modalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an under emphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourish throughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general. This then may leave the patient after a few visits feeling better but not fortifying them with education, strength and flexibility which are the foundation of prevention for recurrent spinal pain."I haven't participated in this forum for a while. It's interesting to spend a few days here again. If I'm too out of place here, I'll go away again. But I would be interested in finding out if DCs in this progressive state are tuning in to the changing times and positioning themselves to have cultural authority for ALL things concerning conservative management of the spine. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center 3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956 drpsnell.chiroweb.comwww.fixyourownback.comMember American College of Sports Medicine

Your E-mail and More On-the-Go. Get Windows Live Hotmail Free. Sign up now.

Posted

I'm purely manual. Im speaking for MOST DCs in our state though.

ph Medlin D.C.Spine Tree Chiropractic1607 NE Alberta StPDX, OR 97211503-788-6800

What do you provide for your patients

The recent thread with someone asking what exercises to prescribe for LBP and the responses, or lack thereof was interesting. The field of exercise science in treatment of a variety of disorders is burgeoning with the new ACSM's Exercise is Medicine campaign as well as with the release of books such as Spark: The Revolutionary New Science of Exercise and the Brain by J. Ratey. Within our own field, chiropractors sadly continue to be slow to adopt this trend and to educate themselves in what the science supports. I work with a lot of personal trainers in town, and with several PTs. They regularly are surprised that I, a chiropractor, seem to be abreast of the literature in exercise science. I am regularly disappointed that so many of my colleagues, and even the recent grads, seem to barely have an understanding of what works and what doesn't when it comes to exercise. It's maddening to continue to get disc patients who have been prescribed "yoga" that includes forward bends, knees to chest and twisting poses and can't seem to get that pain down their leg get any better. It's frustrating to see abdominal hollowing exercises a la' Hodges work on transversus and the subsequent misinterpretation of the findings of those studies, continue to be spread as misinformation and thus creating more dysfunction in that patient. I wonder what is to become of our profession when we don't demonstrate to the public that we know more about how to treat their back pain than their trainer at the gym who has attended a McGill conference, a Gray conference, a Gray Cook conference and regularly tunes in to SportsRehabExpert.com. What do we have to offer in response? & n bsp; The latest practice income generating tips gleaned at the latest conference? This lack of understanding does not seem to be lost on our patients in my experience.What prompted me to write tonight was a communique I received today that was intended for Kaiser physicians. The following was written by a physiatrist and was intended to be a quick guide to appropriate referral for PCPs in the local Kaiser system. After giving a good (I feel) description of the pros and cons of manipulation therapy he states:"How does manipulation fit into the general musculoskeletal care continuum and how does it relate to our PT services? Manipulation as a form of treatment is legitimate, whether you consider the field of chiropractic so or not. If we had PTs that did manipulation we would not need to refer out to have this form of treatment. The down side of Chiropractic from our perspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passive modalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an under emphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourish throughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general. This then may leave the patient after a few visits feeling better but not fortifying them with education, strength and flexibility which are the foundation of prevention for recurrent spinal pain."I haven't participated in this forum for a while. It's interesting to spend a few days here again. If I'm too out of place here, I'll go away again. But I would be interested in finding out if DCs in this progressive state are tuning in to the changing times and positioning themselves to have cultural authority for ALL things concerning conservative management of the spine. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center 3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956 drpsnell.chiroweb.comwww.fixyourownback.comMember American College of Sports Medicine

Your E-mail and More On-the-Go. Get Windows Live Hotmail Free. Sign up now.

Posted

Hey Joe, thanks for the warm welcome! There's a bit of contention out there on how far to take the no flexion thing in general. I had a chance to chat Stu McGill up on this a few weeks ago at a conference in FL. He feels that some flexion is OK, he only discourages flexion and twisting in a loaded spine. What I need to follow up on with him is what constitutes "loaded". Is body weight "loaded"? My sense is that he will respond in the way that he typically does...treatments are patient specific, test the vector and see how the patient responds. But consistent with MacKenzie procedures, current thinking is that under no circumstances should a hot disc be loaded into flexion. I have found that focusing only on the disc mechanics, prescribing MacKenzie extensions and avoiding all lumbar flexion for a few weeks allows the area to heal enough to test those facet gapping vectors down the road. Interestingly, McGill brought up an interesting study in progress that may gives us MacKenzie folks something to think about in the headlong, longterm push into greater and greater extension vectors. They have early findings of facet inflammation and hypertrophic changes when that process is too long. Something of a duh to some of us.Candidly, I've always suspected that 's flexion-distraction was more beneficial due to the distraction, and that if I eased too far into flexion, the radicular sx invariably worsened. As a result, I've found that performing "F & D" with lots of distraction and minimal flexion gives better results, unless the posterior lesion, disc or ligament or facet is very inflamed. I usually find side posture positions to accentuate extension, with care to avoid peripheralizing radicular sx gives me better results.Good to hear from you Joe! W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center

3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956

drpsnell.chiroweb.comwww.fixyourownback.comMember American College of Sports MedicineFrom: spinetree@...To: drpsnell@...Subject: Re: What do you provide for your patientsDate: Thu, 4 Feb 2010 08:40:33 -0800

Hey !!

One question for you. I many times prescribe a knee to chest type of stretch for disc patients. Twisting, no, extension should be avoided in the beginning as well, but knees to chest? Don't we want to open up the facets IVF and gently stretch the musculatre much like a flexion/distraction position? Albeit, it isn't the only thing i suggest for folks, but i'm curious as to your take on the subject.

Welcome back.

Joe.

ph Medlin D.C.Spine Tree Chiropractic1607 NE Alberta StPDX, OR 97211503-788-6800

What do you provide for your patients

The recent thread with someone asking what exercises to prescribe for LBP and the responses, or lack thereof was interesting. The field of exercise science in treatment of a variety of disorders is burgeoning with the new ACSM's Exercise is Medicine campaign as well as with the release of books such as Spark: The Revolutionary New Science of Exercise and the Brain by J. Ratey. Within our own field, chiropractors sadly continue to be slow to adopt this trend and to educate themselves in what the science supports. I work with a lot of personal trainers in town, and with several PTs. They regularly are surprised that I, a chiropractor, seem to be abreast of the literature in exercise science. I am regularly disappointed that so many of my colleagues, and even the recent grads, seem to barely have an understanding of what works and what doesn't when it comes to exercise. It's maddening to continue to get disc patients who have been prescribed "yoga" that includes forward bends, knees to chest and twisting poses and can't seem to get that pain down their leg get any better. It's frustrating to see abdominal hollowing exercises a la' Hodges work on transversus and the subsequent misinterpretation of the findings of those studies, continue to be spread as misinformation and thus creating more dysfunction in that patient. I wonder what is to become of our profession when we don't demonstrate to the public that we know more about how to treat their back pain than their trainer at the gym who has attended a McGill conference, a Gray conference, a Gray Cook conference and regularly tunes in to SportsRehabExpert.com. What do we have to offer in response? & n bsp; The latest practice income generating tips gleaned at the latest conference? This lack of understanding does not seem to be lost on our patients in my experience.What prompted me to write tonight was a communique I received today that was intended for Kaiser physicians. The following was written by a physiatrist and was intended to be a quick guide to appropriate referral for PCPs in the local Kaiser system. After giving a good (I feel) description of the pros and cons of manipulation therapy he states:"How does manipulation fit into the general musculoskeletal care continuum and how does it relate to our PT services? Manipulation as a form of treatment is legitimate, whether you consider the field of chiropractic so or not. If we had PTs that did manipulation we would not need to refer out to have this form of treatment. The down side of Chiropractic from our perspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passive modalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an under emphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourish throughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general. This then may leave the patient after a few visits feeling better but not fortifying them with education, strength and flexibility which are the foundation of prevention for recurrent spinal pain."I haven't participated in this forum for a while. It's interesting to spend a few days here again. If I'm too out of place here, I'll go away again. But I would be interested in finding out if DCs in this progressive state are tuning in to the changing times and positioning themselves to have cultural authority for ALL things concerning conservative management of the spine. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center 3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956 drpsnell.chiroweb.comwww.fixyourownback.comMember American College of Sports Medicine

Posted

Hey Joe, thanks for the warm welcome! There's a bit of contention out there on how far to take the no flexion thing in general. I had a chance to chat Stu McGill up on this a few weeks ago at a conference in FL. He feels that some flexion is OK, he only discourages flexion and twisting in a loaded spine. What I need to follow up on with him is what constitutes "loaded". Is body weight "loaded"? My sense is that he will respond in the way that he typically does...treatments are patient specific, test the vector and see how the patient responds. But consistent with MacKenzie procedures, current thinking is that under no circumstances should a hot disc be loaded into flexion. I have found that focusing only on the disc mechanics, prescribing MacKenzie extensions and avoiding all lumbar flexion for a few weeks allows the area to heal enough to test those facet gapping vectors down the road. Interestingly, McGill brought up an interesting study in progress that may gives us MacKenzie folks something to think about in the headlong, longterm push into greater and greater extension vectors. They have early findings of facet inflammation and hypertrophic changes when that process is too long. Something of a duh to some of us.Candidly, I've always suspected that 's flexion-distraction was more beneficial due to the distraction, and that if I eased too far into flexion, the radicular sx invariably worsened. As a result, I've found that performing "F & D" with lots of distraction and minimal flexion gives better results, unless the posterior lesion, disc or ligament or facet is very inflamed. I usually find side posture positions to accentuate extension, with care to avoid peripheralizing radicular sx gives me better results.Good to hear from you Joe! W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center

3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956

drpsnell.chiroweb.comwww.fixyourownback.comMember American College of Sports MedicineFrom: spinetree@...To: drpsnell@...Subject: Re: What do you provide for your patientsDate: Thu, 4 Feb 2010 08:40:33 -0800

Hey !!

One question for you. I many times prescribe a knee to chest type of stretch for disc patients. Twisting, no, extension should be avoided in the beginning as well, but knees to chest? Don't we want to open up the facets IVF and gently stretch the musculatre much like a flexion/distraction position? Albeit, it isn't the only thing i suggest for folks, but i'm curious as to your take on the subject.

Welcome back.

Joe.

ph Medlin D.C.Spine Tree Chiropractic1607 NE Alberta StPDX, OR 97211503-788-6800

What do you provide for your patients

The recent thread with someone asking what exercises to prescribe for LBP and the responses, or lack thereof was interesting. The field of exercise science in treatment of a variety of disorders is burgeoning with the new ACSM's Exercise is Medicine campaign as well as with the release of books such as Spark: The Revolutionary New Science of Exercise and the Brain by J. Ratey. Within our own field, chiropractors sadly continue to be slow to adopt this trend and to educate themselves in what the science supports. I work with a lot of personal trainers in town, and with several PTs. They regularly are surprised that I, a chiropractor, seem to be abreast of the literature in exercise science. I am regularly disappointed that so many of my colleagues, and even the recent grads, seem to barely have an understanding of what works and what doesn't when it comes to exercise. It's maddening to continue to get disc patients who have been prescribed "yoga" that includes forward bends, knees to chest and twisting poses and can't seem to get that pain down their leg get any better. It's frustrating to see abdominal hollowing exercises a la' Hodges work on transversus and the subsequent misinterpretation of the findings of those studies, continue to be spread as misinformation and thus creating more dysfunction in that patient. I wonder what is to become of our profession when we don't demonstrate to the public that we know more about how to treat their back pain than their trainer at the gym who has attended a McGill conference, a Gray conference, a Gray Cook conference and regularly tunes in to SportsRehabExpert.com. What do we have to offer in response? & n bsp; The latest practice income generating tips gleaned at the latest conference? This lack of understanding does not seem to be lost on our patients in my experience.What prompted me to write tonight was a communique I received today that was intended for Kaiser physicians. The following was written by a physiatrist and was intended to be a quick guide to appropriate referral for PCPs in the local Kaiser system. After giving a good (I feel) description of the pros and cons of manipulation therapy he states:"How does manipulation fit into the general musculoskeletal care continuum and how does it relate to our PT services? Manipulation as a form of treatment is legitimate, whether you consider the field of chiropractic so or not. If we had PTs that did manipulation we would not need to refer out to have this form of treatment. The down side of Chiropractic from our perspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passive modalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an under emphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourish throughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general. This then may leave the patient after a few visits feeling better but not fortifying them with education, strength and flexibility which are the foundation of prevention for recurrent spinal pain."I haven't participated in this forum for a while. It's interesting to spend a few days here again. If I'm too out of place here, I'll go away again. But I would be interested in finding out if DCs in this progressive state are tuning in to the changing times and positioning themselves to have cultural authority for ALL things concerning conservative management of the spine. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center 3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956 drpsnell.chiroweb.comwww.fixyourownback.comMember American College of Sports Medicine

Posted

Hi Joe and Phil,I would agree, Phil. Joe, you are thinking about the problem in one way that may be helpful for some patients. Another way is to imagine the forces that caused the disc bulge to begin with and create the opposite with daily exercise demand on the body along with chiro, work/life modifications. When seen from this perspective, patients that have lost the ability to create lordosis in the lumbar spine during sitting (which they do every waking minute for decades) and this has created forces that squish the "jelly-in-the-doughnut" back. So we use extension exercises like cobra and lateral glides along with lots of talking about posture and need for daily motion to "suck the

jelly back in". From this perspective, you can see why flexion-biased exercises might be less desirable, though they may be used for a small period to decrease muscle spasm.I must admit that this theory does not work for everyone. When it doesn't, we re-evaluate and try to get a new story that makes sense. We can't mistake the "map for the actual road". Also, Micheal Sears has a great DVD that uses restorative yoga postures and is a wonderful way to go for neutralizing pelvis/lumbar spine while beginning to address the other surrounding dysfunctions. I don't have a hot disc, but I just tried the DVD 2 days in a row and will be ordering more for my patients. His bias tends to be more for flattening of the lumbar lordosis than my bias likes, but he is releasing muscular tension in an unloaded/supine position which is a great way to break up destructive muscle patterns. Just my 2 cents.Jay

Lindekugel, DCConcordia Chiropractic Center5425 NE 33rd ave.Portland OR 97211503-287-2273From: Snell <drpsnell@...>oregon dc listserve < >Sent: Thu, February 4, 2010 12:00:47 PMSubject: RE: What do you provide for your patients

Hey Joe, thanks for the warm welcome! There's a bit of contention out there on how far to take the no flexion thing in general. I had a chance to chat Stu McGill up on this a few weeks ago at a conference in FL. He feels that some flexion is OK, he only discourages flexion and twisting in a loaded spine. What I need to follow up on with him is what constitutes "loaded". Is body weight "loaded"? My sense is that he will respond in the way that he typically does...treatments are patient specific, test the vector and see how the patient responds. But consistent with MacKenzie procedures, current thinking is that under no circumstances should a hot disc be loaded into flexion. I have found that focusing only on the disc mechanics, prescribing MacKenzie extensions and avoiding all lumbar flexion for a few weeks allows the area to heal enough to test those facet gapping vectors down the road. Interestingly, McGill

brought up an interesting study in progress that may gives us MacKenzie folks something to think about in the headlong, longterm push into greater and greater extension vectors. They have early findings of facet inflammation and hypertrophic changes when that process is too long. Something of a duh to some of us.Candidly, I've always suspected that 's flexion-distraction was more beneficial due to the distraction, and that if I eased too far into flexion, the radicular sx invariably worsened. As a result, I've found that performing "F & D" with lots of distraction and minimal flexion gives better results, unless the posterior lesion, disc or ligament or facet is very inflamed. I usually find side posture positions to accentuate extension, with care to avoid peripheralizing radicular sx gives me better results.Good to hear from you Joe! W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center

3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956

drpsnell.chiroweb. comwww.fixyourownback. comMember American College of Sports MedicineFrom: spinetree@qwestoffi ce.netdrpsnellhotmail (DOT) comSubject: Re: What do you provide for your patientsDate: Thu, 4 Feb 2010 08:40:33 -0800

Hey !!

One question for you. I many times prescribe a knee to chest type of stretch for disc patients. Twisting, no, extension should be avoided in the beginning as well, but knees to chest? Don't we want to open up the facets IVF and gently stretch the musculatre much like a flexion/distraction position? Albeit, it isn't the only thing i suggest for folks, but i'm curious as to your take on the subject.

Welcome back.

Joe.

ph Medlin D.C.Spine Tree Chiropractic1607 NE Alberta StPDX, OR 97211503-788-6800

What do you provide for your patients

The recent thread with someone asking what exercises to prescribe for LBP and the responses, or lack thereof was interesting. The field of exercise science in treatment of a variety of disorders is burgeoning with the new ACSM's Exercise is Medicine campaign as well as with the release of books such as Spark: The Revolutionary New Science of Exercise and the Brain by J. Ratey. Within our own field, chiropractors sadly continue to be slow to adopt this trend and to educate themselves in what the science supports. I work with a lot of personal trainers in town, and with several PTs. They regularly are surprised that I, a chiropractor, seem to be abreast of the literature in exercise science. I am regularly disappointed that so many of my colleagues, and even the recent grads, seem to barely have an understanding of what works and what doesn't when it comes to exercise. It's maddening to continue to get disc patients who have been prescribed "yoga" that includes forward bends, knees to chest and twisting poses and can't seem to get that pain down their leg get any better. It's frustrating to see abdominal hollowing exercises a la' Hodges work on transversus and the subsequent misinterpretation of the findings of those studies, continue to be spread as misinformation and thus creating more dysfunction in that patient. I wonder what is to become of our profession when we don't demonstrate to the public that we know more about how to treat their back pain than their trainer at the gym who has attended a McGill conference, a Gray conference, a Gray Cook conference and regularly tunes in to SportsRehabExpert. com. What do we have to offer in response? & n bsp; The latest practice income generating tips gleaned at the latest conference? This lack of understanding does not seem to be lost on our patients in my experience.What prompted me to write tonight was a communique I received today that was intended for Kaiser physicians. The following was written by a physiatrist and was intended to be a quick guide to appropriate referral for PCPs in the local Kaiser system. After giving a good (I feel) description of the pros and cons of manipulation therapy he states:"How does manipulation fit into the general musculoskeletal care continuum and how does it relate to our PT services? Manipulation as a form of treatment is legitimate, whether you consider the field of chiropractic so or not. If we had PTs that did manipulation we would not need to refer out to have this form of treatment. The down side of Chiropractic from our perspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passive modalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an under emphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourish throughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general. This then may leave the patient after a few visits feeling better but not fortifying them with education, strength and flexibility which are the foundation of prevention for recurrent spinal pain."I haven't participated in this forum for a while. It's interesting to spend a few days here again. If I'm too out of place here, I'll go away again. But I would be interested in finding out if DCs in this progressive state are tuning in to the changing times and positioning themselves to have cultural authority for ALL things concerning conservative management of the spine. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center 3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956 drpsnell.chiroweb. comwww.fixyourownback. comMember American College of Sports Medicine

Posted

Hi Joe and Phil,I would agree, Phil. Joe, you are thinking about the problem in one way that may be helpful for some patients. Another way is to imagine the forces that caused the disc bulge to begin with and create the opposite with daily exercise demand on the body along with chiro, work/life modifications. When seen from this perspective, patients that have lost the ability to create lordosis in the lumbar spine during sitting (which they do every waking minute for decades) and this has created forces that squish the "jelly-in-the-doughnut" back. So we use extension exercises like cobra and lateral glides along with lots of talking about posture and need for daily motion to "suck the

jelly back in". From this perspective, you can see why flexion-biased exercises might be less desirable, though they may be used for a small period to decrease muscle spasm.I must admit that this theory does not work for everyone. When it doesn't, we re-evaluate and try to get a new story that makes sense. We can't mistake the "map for the actual road". Also, Micheal Sears has a great DVD that uses restorative yoga postures and is a wonderful way to go for neutralizing pelvis/lumbar spine while beginning to address the other surrounding dysfunctions. I don't have a hot disc, but I just tried the DVD 2 days in a row and will be ordering more for my patients. His bias tends to be more for flattening of the lumbar lordosis than my bias likes, but he is releasing muscular tension in an unloaded/supine position which is a great way to break up destructive muscle patterns. Just my 2 cents.Jay

Lindekugel, DCConcordia Chiropractic Center5425 NE 33rd ave.Portland OR 97211503-287-2273From: Snell <drpsnell@...>oregon dc listserve < >Sent: Thu, February 4, 2010 12:00:47 PMSubject: RE: What do you provide for your patients

Hey Joe, thanks for the warm welcome! There's a bit of contention out there on how far to take the no flexion thing in general. I had a chance to chat Stu McGill up on this a few weeks ago at a conference in FL. He feels that some flexion is OK, he only discourages flexion and twisting in a loaded spine. What I need to follow up on with him is what constitutes "loaded". Is body weight "loaded"? My sense is that he will respond in the way that he typically does...treatments are patient specific, test the vector and see how the patient responds. But consistent with MacKenzie procedures, current thinking is that under no circumstances should a hot disc be loaded into flexion. I have found that focusing only on the disc mechanics, prescribing MacKenzie extensions and avoiding all lumbar flexion for a few weeks allows the area to heal enough to test those facet gapping vectors down the road. Interestingly, McGill

brought up an interesting study in progress that may gives us MacKenzie folks something to think about in the headlong, longterm push into greater and greater extension vectors. They have early findings of facet inflammation and hypertrophic changes when that process is too long. Something of a duh to some of us.Candidly, I've always suspected that 's flexion-distraction was more beneficial due to the distraction, and that if I eased too far into flexion, the radicular sx invariably worsened. As a result, I've found that performing "F & D" with lots of distraction and minimal flexion gives better results, unless the posterior lesion, disc or ligament or facet is very inflamed. I usually find side posture positions to accentuate extension, with care to avoid peripheralizing radicular sx gives me better results.Good to hear from you Joe! W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center

3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956

drpsnell.chiroweb. comwww.fixyourownback. comMember American College of Sports MedicineFrom: spinetree@qwestoffi ce.netdrpsnellhotmail (DOT) comSubject: Re: What do you provide for your patientsDate: Thu, 4 Feb 2010 08:40:33 -0800

Hey !!

One question for you. I many times prescribe a knee to chest type of stretch for disc patients. Twisting, no, extension should be avoided in the beginning as well, but knees to chest? Don't we want to open up the facets IVF and gently stretch the musculatre much like a flexion/distraction position? Albeit, it isn't the only thing i suggest for folks, but i'm curious as to your take on the subject.

Welcome back.

Joe.

ph Medlin D.C.Spine Tree Chiropractic1607 NE Alberta StPDX, OR 97211503-788-6800

What do you provide for your patients

The recent thread with someone asking what exercises to prescribe for LBP and the responses, or lack thereof was interesting. The field of exercise science in treatment of a variety of disorders is burgeoning with the new ACSM's Exercise is Medicine campaign as well as with the release of books such as Spark: The Revolutionary New Science of Exercise and the Brain by J. Ratey. Within our own field, chiropractors sadly continue to be slow to adopt this trend and to educate themselves in what the science supports. I work with a lot of personal trainers in town, and with several PTs. They regularly are surprised that I, a chiropractor, seem to be abreast of the literature in exercise science. I am regularly disappointed that so many of my colleagues, and even the recent grads, seem to barely have an understanding of what works and what doesn't when it comes to exercise. It's maddening to continue to get disc patients who have been prescribed "yoga" that includes forward bends, knees to chest and twisting poses and can't seem to get that pain down their leg get any better. It's frustrating to see abdominal hollowing exercises a la' Hodges work on transversus and the subsequent misinterpretation of the findings of those studies, continue to be spread as misinformation and thus creating more dysfunction in that patient. I wonder what is to become of our profession when we don't demonstrate to the public that we know more about how to treat their back pain than their trainer at the gym who has attended a McGill conference, a Gray conference, a Gray Cook conference and regularly tunes in to SportsRehabExpert. com. What do we have to offer in response? & n bsp; The latest practice income generating tips gleaned at the latest conference? This lack of understanding does not seem to be lost on our patients in my experience.What prompted me to write tonight was a communique I received today that was intended for Kaiser physicians. The following was written by a physiatrist and was intended to be a quick guide to appropriate referral for PCPs in the local Kaiser system. After giving a good (I feel) description of the pros and cons of manipulation therapy he states:"How does manipulation fit into the general musculoskeletal care continuum and how does it relate to our PT services? Manipulation as a form of treatment is legitimate, whether you consider the field of chiropractic so or not. If we had PTs that did manipulation we would not need to refer out to have this form of treatment. The down side of Chiropractic from our perspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passive modalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an under emphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourish throughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general. This then may leave the patient after a few visits feeling better but not fortifying them with education, strength and flexibility which are the foundation of prevention for recurrent spinal pain."I haven't participated in this forum for a while. It's interesting to spend a few days here again. If I'm too out of place here, I'll go away again. But I would be interested in finding out if DCs in this progressive state are tuning in to the changing times and positioning themselves to have cultural authority for ALL things concerning conservative management of the spine. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center 3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956 drpsnell.chiroweb. comwww.fixyourownback. comMember American College of Sports Medicine

Posted

No offense here Phil because I am sure we are on the same page much more than we are not, but here is the scenario.One could argue that chiropractic is the most effective form of treatment for back pain. To have PT's, MD's DO's saying 'why don't you do more of our stuff that we do but has been found to be inferior to chiropractic' could come off a little odd to some chiropractors who feel they are doing a great job with their patients. Now I say this as a chiropractor that spends more time than most, in our YOGA STUDIO treating patient with exercise prescription. I think exercise therapy is important for my clinic, but chiropractic is chiropractic, and does just fine on its own as well.It also ruffles my feathers a bit that a Physio would point the finger

at chiropractic. Ever seen a physio continually "adjust" (couldn't help myself) medications without lifestyle modification? Can you say "rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic"!? I just don't always have patience for MD's who don't care for chiropractic. But I am glad you do, because you put a better face on the profession than I might on a grumpy Thursday. Another 2 cents. I'm broke!Jay Lindekugel, DCConcordia Chiropractic Center5425 NE 33rd avePortland Or. 97211From: Snell <drpsnell@...>oregon dc listserve < >Sent: Wed, February 3, 2010 7:44:03 PMSubject: What do you provide for your patients

The recent thread with someone asking what exercises to prescribe for LBP and the responses, or lack thereof was interesting. The field of exercise science in treatment of a variety of disorders is burgeoning with the new ACSM's Exercise is Medicine campaign as well as with the release of books such as Spark: The Revolutionary New Science of Exercise and the Brain by J. Ratey. Within our own field, chiropractors sadly continue to be slow to adopt this trend and to educate themselves in what the science supports. I work with a lot of personal trainers in town, and

with several PTs. They regularly are surprised that I, a chiropractor, seem to be abreast of the literature in exercise science. I am regularly disappointed that so many of my colleagues, and even the recent grads, seem to barely have an understanding of what works and what doesn't when it comes to exercise. It's maddening to continue to get disc patients who have been prescribed "yoga" that includes forward bends, knees to chest and twisting poses and can't seem to get that pain down their leg get any better. It's frustrating to see abdominal hollowing exercises a la' Hodges work on transversus and the subsequent misinterpretation of the findings of those studies, continue to be spread as misinformation and thus creating more dysfunction in that patient. I wonder what is to become of our profession when we don't demonstrate to the public that we know more about how to treat their back pain than their trainer at the gym who has

attended a McGill conference, a Gray conference, a Gray Cook conference and regularly tunes in to SportsRehabExpert. com. What do we have to offer in response? The latest practice income generating tips gleaned at the latest conference? This lack of understanding does not seem to be lost on our patients in my experience.What prompted me to write tonight was a communique I received today that was intended for Kaiser physicians. The following was written by a physiatrist and was intended to be a quick guide to appropriate referral for PCPs in the local Kaiser system. After giving a good (I feel) description of the pros and cons of manipulation therapy he states:"How does manipulation fit into the general musculoskeletal care continuum and how does it relate to our PT services? Manipulation as a form of treatment is legitimate, whether you consider the field of chiropractic so or not. If we

had PTs that did manipulation we would not need to refer out to have this form of treatment. The down side of Chiropractic from our perspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passive modalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an under emphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourish throughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general. This then may leave the patient after a few visits feeling better but not fortifying them with education, strength and flexibility which are the foundation of prevention for recurrent spinal pain."I haven't participated in this forum for a while. It's interesting to spend a few days here again. If I'm too out of place here, I'll go away again. But I would be interested in finding out if DCs in this progressive state are tuning in to the changing times and positioning themselves to have cultural authority for ALL

things concerning conservative management of the spine. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center

3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956

drpsnell.chiroweb. comwww.fixyourownback. comMember American College of Sports Medicine

Posted

No offense here Phil because I am sure we are on the same page much more than we are not, but here is the scenario.One could argue that chiropractic is the most effective form of treatment for back pain. To have PT's, MD's DO's saying 'why don't you do more of our stuff that we do but has been found to be inferior to chiropractic' could come off a little odd to some chiropractors who feel they are doing a great job with their patients. Now I say this as a chiropractor that spends more time than most, in our YOGA STUDIO treating patient with exercise prescription. I think exercise therapy is important for my clinic, but chiropractic is chiropractic, and does just fine on its own as well.It also ruffles my feathers a bit that a Physio would point the finger

at chiropractic. Ever seen a physio continually "adjust" (couldn't help myself) medications without lifestyle modification? Can you say "rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic"!? I just don't always have patience for MD's who don't care for chiropractic. But I am glad you do, because you put a better face on the profession than I might on a grumpy Thursday. Another 2 cents. I'm broke!Jay Lindekugel, DCConcordia Chiropractic Center5425 NE 33rd avePortland Or. 97211From: Snell <drpsnell@...>oregon dc listserve < >Sent: Wed, February 3, 2010 7:44:03 PMSubject: What do you provide for your patients

The recent thread with someone asking what exercises to prescribe for LBP and the responses, or lack thereof was interesting. The field of exercise science in treatment of a variety of disorders is burgeoning with the new ACSM's Exercise is Medicine campaign as well as with the release of books such as Spark: The Revolutionary New Science of Exercise and the Brain by J. Ratey. Within our own field, chiropractors sadly continue to be slow to adopt this trend and to educate themselves in what the science supports. I work with a lot of personal trainers in town, and

with several PTs. They regularly are surprised that I, a chiropractor, seem to be abreast of the literature in exercise science. I am regularly disappointed that so many of my colleagues, and even the recent grads, seem to barely have an understanding of what works and what doesn't when it comes to exercise. It's maddening to continue to get disc patients who have been prescribed "yoga" that includes forward bends, knees to chest and twisting poses and can't seem to get that pain down their leg get any better. It's frustrating to see abdominal hollowing exercises a la' Hodges work on transversus and the subsequent misinterpretation of the findings of those studies, continue to be spread as misinformation and thus creating more dysfunction in that patient. I wonder what is to become of our profession when we don't demonstrate to the public that we know more about how to treat their back pain than their trainer at the gym who has

attended a McGill conference, a Gray conference, a Gray Cook conference and regularly tunes in to SportsRehabExpert. com. What do we have to offer in response? The latest practice income generating tips gleaned at the latest conference? This lack of understanding does not seem to be lost on our patients in my experience.What prompted me to write tonight was a communique I received today that was intended for Kaiser physicians. The following was written by a physiatrist and was intended to be a quick guide to appropriate referral for PCPs in the local Kaiser system. After giving a good (I feel) description of the pros and cons of manipulation therapy he states:"How does manipulation fit into the general musculoskeletal care continuum and how does it relate to our PT services? Manipulation as a form of treatment is legitimate, whether you consider the field of chiropractic so or not. If we

had PTs that did manipulation we would not need to refer out to have this form of treatment. The down side of Chiropractic from our perspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passive modalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an under emphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourish throughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general. This then may leave the patient after a few visits feeling better but not fortifying them with education, strength and flexibility which are the foundation of prevention for recurrent spinal pain."I haven't participated in this forum for a while. It's interesting to spend a few days here again. If I'm too out of place here, I'll go away again. But I would be interested in finding out if DCs in this progressive state are tuning in to the changing times and positioning themselves to have cultural authority for ALL

things concerning conservative management of the spine. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center

3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956

drpsnell.chiroweb. comwww.fixyourownback. comMember American College of Sports Medicine

Posted

I must say that after treating multiple failed cases from Keiser's esteemed medical team I have little interest in what these folks think; of us Chiropractors.  As far as I have seen Keiser's treatment of soft tissue injuries is horrendous.  I must say I am with Herb on this one.  I have been practicing for many years and and if I depended on the opinion and good will of MD's/ PT's for my survival I would have been bankrupt many years ago.

Schneider DCPDXOn Thu, Feb 4, 2010 at 8:32 AM, Walter Wiese <docwiese7@...> wrote:

 

Dr. Snell,II appreciate your input to this problem, as it is a BIG problem that PT's are now doing what we always thought was ours.  We did X-ray for 20 years before MD's and then they took it as theirs, yes we continued and even teach it in the schools, but now Or doc feel it is just easier to send their patient to the hospital, plus the insurance will pay there.  Asleep again, no one sees what they are doing or not doing.  Well, if we don't do it we will lose it and that is exactly what I see happening across the board from x-ray to exercise (Chiropractic Sports Medicine) If we do not get on the ball we will loose our place to those that are not asleep and are looking for the business.  WE have to be the best, not second best.

Wiese D..C From: Snell <drpsnell@...>

Subject: RE: What do you provide for your patients " oregon dc listserve " < >

Date: Wednesday, February 3, 2010, 9:50 PM

Herb I have the greatest respect for you. However, to answer your

question " why should you care... " directly, perhaps you shouldn't, but

the other DCs on this forum navigating the current environment of

practice and planning for their future should. Why?  The currency of

the kingdom is research.  The research says that manual therapy,

manipulation and exercise combined work better than any of them alone. 

The Kaiser physiatrist in question is teaching the gatekeepers in your

community how to view you and your colleagues.  Kaiser is one of the

only HMOs in the US that consistently runs in the black.  Their model

is frequently used as an example of some of the things that are right

with managed care, whether you or I think so or not.Herb,

this topic is of no interest to many of us on this forum who have

panels into the 1000s.  With decent care, most docs can maintain those

practices with internal referrals. But for those that are building and

have whole future ahead, the playing field is different than it was 45

years ago.  Evidence based practice has changed things, for both MDs

and for DCs.  If MDs and DCs can't come together on this then as this

physiatrist points out, they will refer, eventually to PTs who

manipulate. In short Herb, this MD's opinion is the canary in the coal

mine...and that's why we should listen. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center

3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956

drpsnell.chiroweb.comwww.fixyourownback.comMember American College of Sports Medicine

Oregondcs From: hbf4747@...Date: Wed, 3 Feb 2010 20:31:56 -0800

Subject: Re: What do you provide for your patients

 

Hi Dr. Snell,

           Thank you for your informative post as to what current texts are available for patients' exercises. However when you cite the comments of a Kaiser physiatrist about our profession as being of significance we part company. D.C.s' are not MD's lapdogs waiting for a few words of approbation from them. I have practiced in the city of Keizer for about 45 years I've cared for thousands of patients and believe it or not nary a one of them was an MD referral. Philosophically chiropractic and all of the various methods under the medical umbrella are miles apart so why should I care at all as to this guys opinion.

       Herb Freeman D.C.

What do you provide for your patients

 

The recent thread with someone asking what exercises to prescribe for LBP and the responses, or lack thereof was interesting.  The field of exercise science in treatment of a variety of disorders is burgeoning with the new ACSM's Exercise is Medicine campaign as well as with the release of books such as Spark: The Revolutionary New Science of Exercise and the Brain by J. Ratey.  Within our own field, chiropractors sadly continue to be slow to adopt this trend and to educate themselves in what the science supports.  I work with a lot of personal trainers in town, and with several PTs. They regularly are surprised that I, a chiropractor, seem to be abreast of the literature in exercise science.  I am regularly disappointed that so many of my colleagues, and even the recent grads, seem to barely have an understanding of what works and what doesn't when it comes to exercise.  It's maddening to continue to get disc patients who have been prescribed " yoga " that includes forward bends, knees to chest and twisting poses and can't seem to get that pain down their leg get any better.  It's frustrating to see abdominal hollowing exercises a la' Hodges work on transversus and the subsequent misinterpretation of the findings of those studies, continue to be spread as misinformation and thus creating more dysfunction in that patient.  I wonder what is to become of our profession when we don't demonstrate to the public that we know more about how to treat their back pain than their trainer at the gym who has attended a McGill conference, a Gray conference, a Gray Cook conference and regularly tunes in to SportsRehabExpert. com.  What do we have to offer in response?  The latest practice income generating tips gleaned at the latest conference? This lack of understanding does not seem to be lost on our patients in my experience.What prompted me to write tonight was a communique I received today that was intended for Kaiser physicians.  The following was written by a physiatrist and was intended to be a quick guide to appropriate referral for PCPs in the local Kaiser system.  After giving a good (I feel) description of the pros and cons of manipulation therapy he states: " How does manipulation fit into the general musculoskeletal care continuum and how does it relate to our PT services?  Manipulation as a form of treatment is legitimate, whether you consider the field of chiropractic so or not.  If we had PTs that did manipulation we would not need to refer out to have this form of treatment.  The down side of Chiropractic from our perspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passive modalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an under emphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourish throughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general.  This then may leave the patient after a few visits feeling better but not fortifying them with education, strength and flexibility which are the foundation of prevention for recurrent spinal pain. " I haven't participated in this forum for a while. It's interesting to spend a few days here again. If I'm too out of place here, I'll go away again.  But I would be interested in finding out if DCs in this progressive state are tuning in to the changing times and positioning themselves to have cultural authority for ALL things concerning conservative management of the spine. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center 3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956 drpsnell.chiroweb. comwww.fixyourownback. com

Member American College of Sports Medicine

-- Schneider DC PDX

Posted

I must say that after treating multiple failed cases from Keiser's esteemed medical team I have little interest in what these folks think; of us Chiropractors.  As far as I have seen Keiser's treatment of soft tissue injuries is horrendous.  I must say I am with Herb on this one.  I have been practicing for many years and and if I depended on the opinion and good will of MD's/ PT's for my survival I would have been bankrupt many years ago.

Schneider DCPDXOn Thu, Feb 4, 2010 at 8:32 AM, Walter Wiese <docwiese7@...> wrote:

 

Dr. Snell,II appreciate your input to this problem, as it is a BIG problem that PT's are now doing what we always thought was ours.  We did X-ray for 20 years before MD's and then they took it as theirs, yes we continued and even teach it in the schools, but now Or doc feel it is just easier to send their patient to the hospital, plus the insurance will pay there.  Asleep again, no one sees what they are doing or not doing.  Well, if we don't do it we will lose it and that is exactly what I see happening across the board from x-ray to exercise (Chiropractic Sports Medicine) If we do not get on the ball we will loose our place to those that are not asleep and are looking for the business.  WE have to be the best, not second best.

Wiese D..C From: Snell <drpsnell@...>

Subject: RE: What do you provide for your patients " oregon dc listserve " < >

Date: Wednesday, February 3, 2010, 9:50 PM

Herb I have the greatest respect for you. However, to answer your

question " why should you care... " directly, perhaps you shouldn't, but

the other DCs on this forum navigating the current environment of

practice and planning for their future should. Why?  The currency of

the kingdom is research.  The research says that manual therapy,

manipulation and exercise combined work better than any of them alone. 

The Kaiser physiatrist in question is teaching the gatekeepers in your

community how to view you and your colleagues.  Kaiser is one of the

only HMOs in the US that consistently runs in the black.  Their model

is frequently used as an example of some of the things that are right

with managed care, whether you or I think so or not.Herb,

this topic is of no interest to many of us on this forum who have

panels into the 1000s.  With decent care, most docs can maintain those

practices with internal referrals. But for those that are building and

have whole future ahead, the playing field is different than it was 45

years ago.  Evidence based practice has changed things, for both MDs

and for DCs.  If MDs and DCs can't come together on this then as this

physiatrist points out, they will refer, eventually to PTs who

manipulate. In short Herb, this MD's opinion is the canary in the coal

mine...and that's why we should listen. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center

3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956

drpsnell.chiroweb.comwww.fixyourownback.comMember American College of Sports Medicine

Oregondcs From: hbf4747@...Date: Wed, 3 Feb 2010 20:31:56 -0800

Subject: Re: What do you provide for your patients

 

Hi Dr. Snell,

           Thank you for your informative post as to what current texts are available for patients' exercises. However when you cite the comments of a Kaiser physiatrist about our profession as being of significance we part company. D.C.s' are not MD's lapdogs waiting for a few words of approbation from them. I have practiced in the city of Keizer for about 45 years I've cared for thousands of patients and believe it or not nary a one of them was an MD referral. Philosophically chiropractic and all of the various methods under the medical umbrella are miles apart so why should I care at all as to this guys opinion.

       Herb Freeman D.C.

What do you provide for your patients

 

The recent thread with someone asking what exercises to prescribe for LBP and the responses, or lack thereof was interesting.  The field of exercise science in treatment of a variety of disorders is burgeoning with the new ACSM's Exercise is Medicine campaign as well as with the release of books such as Spark: The Revolutionary New Science of Exercise and the Brain by J. Ratey.  Within our own field, chiropractors sadly continue to be slow to adopt this trend and to educate themselves in what the science supports.  I work with a lot of personal trainers in town, and with several PTs. They regularly are surprised that I, a chiropractor, seem to be abreast of the literature in exercise science.  I am regularly disappointed that so many of my colleagues, and even the recent grads, seem to barely have an understanding of what works and what doesn't when it comes to exercise.  It's maddening to continue to get disc patients who have been prescribed " yoga " that includes forward bends, knees to chest and twisting poses and can't seem to get that pain down their leg get any better.  It's frustrating to see abdominal hollowing exercises a la' Hodges work on transversus and the subsequent misinterpretation of the findings of those studies, continue to be spread as misinformation and thus creating more dysfunction in that patient.  I wonder what is to become of our profession when we don't demonstrate to the public that we know more about how to treat their back pain than their trainer at the gym who has attended a McGill conference, a Gray conference, a Gray Cook conference and regularly tunes in to SportsRehabExpert. com.  What do we have to offer in response?  The latest practice income generating tips gleaned at the latest conference? This lack of understanding does not seem to be lost on our patients in my experience.What prompted me to write tonight was a communique I received today that was intended for Kaiser physicians.  The following was written by a physiatrist and was intended to be a quick guide to appropriate referral for PCPs in the local Kaiser system.  After giving a good (I feel) description of the pros and cons of manipulation therapy he states: " How does manipulation fit into the general musculoskeletal care continuum and how does it relate to our PT services?  Manipulation as a form of treatment is legitimate, whether you consider the field of chiropractic so or not.  If we had PTs that did manipulation we would not need to refer out to have this form of treatment.  The down side of Chiropractic from our perspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passive modalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an under emphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourish throughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general.  This then may leave the patient after a few visits feeling better but not fortifying them with education, strength and flexibility which are the foundation of prevention for recurrent spinal pain. " I haven't participated in this forum for a while. It's interesting to spend a few days here again. If I'm too out of place here, I'll go away again.  But I would be interested in finding out if DCs in this progressive state are tuning in to the changing times and positioning themselves to have cultural authority for ALL things concerning conservative management of the spine. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center 3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956 drpsnell.chiroweb. comwww.fixyourownback. com

Member American College of Sports Medicine

-- Schneider DC PDX

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...