Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Re: What do you provide for your patients

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted



Hey ,

Ya know, i look at it both ways actually, but i'll tell ya, i've treated a lot of hot discs and you just try getting those folks into extension right away. OUCH. Cobra and any extension is Contraindicated in a patient where the motion creates radicular pain consistant with a n. root compression pain referral. Think about the acute nature before we think about changing what got em there. Opening up those facets, decreasing inflammation and taking pressure off the n. root should be first. When patient is tolerant, begin extension exercises to help "squeeze" disc material away from n. root and begin postural reformation etc. But, why on earth close down those facets and put MORE pressure on an already impinged n. root in the acute stage? I don't see the benefit, and all rehab books i've read do not suggest this. Don't forget that for most of these patients, the leg pain is ,more severe than the back pain.

For instance, a herniated L5/S1 creates most times a very tonic hamstring. Stretching this hamstring (especially agressively) in the acute stages can stretch the N. root and keep your patient in a heck of a lot of pain. Tight hamstrings very well could have played a roll in causation, but to address them too early and too aggressively can be very counterproductive.

I agree that in todays society, the hypolordotic spine is abundant and i teach pelvic tilting (pouring the water out) as well as some SOT, mckenzie and yoga style exercises in order to help them attain more postural balance in the future and thereby reducing another incident.

ph Medlin D.C.Spine Tree Chiropractic1607 NE Alberta StPDX, OR 97211503-788-6800

What do you provide for your patients

The recent thread with someone asking what exercises to prescribe for LBP and the responses, or lack thereof was interesting. The field of exercise science in treatment of a variety of disorders is burgeoning with the new ACSM's Exercise is Medicine campaign as well as with the release of books such as Spark: The Revolutionary New Science of Exercise and the Brain by J. Ratey. Within our own field, chiropractors sadly continue to be slow to adopt this trend and to educate themselves in what the science supports. I work with a lot of personal trainers in town, and with several PTs. They regularly are surprised that I, a chiropractor, seem to be abreast of the literature in exercise science. I am regularly disappointed that so many of my colleagues, and even the recent grads, seem to barely have an understanding of what works and what doesn't when it comes to exercise. It's maddening to continue to get disc patients who have been prescribed "yoga" that includes forward bends, knees to chest and twisting poses and can't seem to get that pain down their leg get any better. It's frustrating to see abdominal hollowing exercises a la' Hodges work on transversus and the subsequent misinterpretation of the findings of those studies, continue to be spread as misinformation and thus creating more dysfunction in that patient. I wonder what is to become of our profession when we don't demonstrate to the public that we know more about how to treat their back pain than their trainer at the gym who has attended a McGill conference, a Gray conference, a Gray Cook conference and regularly tunes in to SportsRehabExpert. com. What do we have to offer in response? & n bsp; The latest practice income generating tips gleaned at the latest conference? This lack of understanding does not seem to be lost on our patients in my experience.What prompted me to write tonight was a communique I received today that was intended for Kaiser physicians. The following was written by a physiatrist and was intended to be a quick guide to appropriate referral for PCPs in the local Kaiser system. After giving a good (I feel) description of the pros and cons of manipulation therapy he states:"How does manipulation fit into the general musculoskeletal care continuum and how does it relate to our PT services? Manipulation as a form of treatment is legitimate, whether you consider the field of chiropractic so or not. If we had PTs that did manipulation we would not need to refer out to have this form of treatment. The down side of Chiropractic from our perspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passive modalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an under emphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourish throughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general. This then may leave the patient after a few visits feeling better but not fortifying them with education, strength and flexibility which are the foundation of prevention for recurrent spinal pain."I haven't participated in this forum for a while. It's interesting to spend a few days here again. If I'm too out of place here, I'll go away again. But I would be interested in finding out if DCs in this progressive state are tuning in to the changing times and positioning themselves to have cultural authority for ALL things concerning conservative management of the spine. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center 3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956 drpsnell.chiroweb. comwww.fixyourownback. comMember American College of Sports Medicine

Posted



Hey ,

Ya know, i look at it both ways actually, but i'll tell ya, i've treated a lot of hot discs and you just try getting those folks into extension right away. OUCH. Cobra and any extension is Contraindicated in a patient where the motion creates radicular pain consistant with a n. root compression pain referral. Think about the acute nature before we think about changing what got em there. Opening up those facets, decreasing inflammation and taking pressure off the n. root should be first. When patient is tolerant, begin extension exercises to help "squeeze" disc material away from n. root and begin postural reformation etc. But, why on earth close down those facets and put MORE pressure on an already impinged n. root in the acute stage? I don't see the benefit, and all rehab books i've read do not suggest this. Don't forget that for most of these patients, the leg pain is ,more severe than the back pain.

For instance, a herniated L5/S1 creates most times a very tonic hamstring. Stretching this hamstring (especially agressively) in the acute stages can stretch the N. root and keep your patient in a heck of a lot of pain. Tight hamstrings very well could have played a roll in causation, but to address them too early and too aggressively can be very counterproductive.

I agree that in todays society, the hypolordotic spine is abundant and i teach pelvic tilting (pouring the water out) as well as some SOT, mckenzie and yoga style exercises in order to help them attain more postural balance in the future and thereby reducing another incident.

ph Medlin D.C.Spine Tree Chiropractic1607 NE Alberta StPDX, OR 97211503-788-6800

What do you provide for your patients

The recent thread with someone asking what exercises to prescribe for LBP and the responses, or lack thereof was interesting. The field of exercise science in treatment of a variety of disorders is burgeoning with the new ACSM's Exercise is Medicine campaign as well as with the release of books such as Spark: The Revolutionary New Science of Exercise and the Brain by J. Ratey. Within our own field, chiropractors sadly continue to be slow to adopt this trend and to educate themselves in what the science supports. I work with a lot of personal trainers in town, and with several PTs. They regularly are surprised that I, a chiropractor, seem to be abreast of the literature in exercise science. I am regularly disappointed that so many of my colleagues, and even the recent grads, seem to barely have an understanding of what works and what doesn't when it comes to exercise. It's maddening to continue to get disc patients who have been prescribed "yoga" that includes forward bends, knees to chest and twisting poses and can't seem to get that pain down their leg get any better. It's frustrating to see abdominal hollowing exercises a la' Hodges work on transversus and the subsequent misinterpretation of the findings of those studies, continue to be spread as misinformation and thus creating more dysfunction in that patient. I wonder what is to become of our profession when we don't demonstrate to the public that we know more about how to treat their back pain than their trainer at the gym who has attended a McGill conference, a Gray conference, a Gray Cook conference and regularly tunes in to SportsRehabExpert. com. What do we have to offer in response? & n bsp; The latest practice income generating tips gleaned at the latest conference? This lack of understanding does not seem to be lost on our patients in my experience.What prompted me to write tonight was a communique I received today that was intended for Kaiser physicians. The following was written by a physiatrist and was intended to be a quick guide to appropriate referral for PCPs in the local Kaiser system. After giving a good (I feel) description of the pros and cons of manipulation therapy he states:"How does manipulation fit into the general musculoskeletal care continuum and how does it relate to our PT services? Manipulation as a form of treatment is legitimate, whether you consider the field of chiropractic so or not. If we had PTs that did manipulation we would not need to refer out to have this form of treatment. The down side of Chiropractic from our perspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passive modalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an under emphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourish throughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general. This then may leave the patient after a few visits feeling better but not fortifying them with education, strength and flexibility which are the foundation of prevention for recurrent spinal pain."I haven't participated in this forum for a while. It's interesting to spend a few days here again. If I'm too out of place here, I'll go away again. But I would be interested in finding out if DCs in this progressive state are tuning in to the changing times and positioning themselves to have cultural authority for ALL things concerning conservative management of the spine. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center 3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956 drpsnell.chiroweb. comwww.fixyourownback. comMember American College of Sports Medicine

Posted

I remember Dr. Wei saying that he hadpositional upright MRIs showing that extention can make some discs bulge. Lookat this pdf #80 on the cervical disc. I don’t think this is an upright film butextention showed a higher detection of missed discs: http://www.fonar.com/pdf/Spine_Journal_UCLA_study.pdf s. fuchs dc From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of joe medlinSent: Monday, February 08, 20109:48 AM Snell; oregon dclistserve; LindekugelSubject: Re: Whatdo you provide for your patients  Hey , Ya know, i look at it both ways actually, but i'll tell ya, i'vetreated a lot of hot discs and you just try getting those folks into extensionright away. OUCH. Cobra and any extension is Contraindicated in a patient wherethe motion creates radicular pain consistant with a n. root compression painreferral. Think about the acute nature before we think about changing what gotem there. Opening up those facets, decreasing inflammation and takingpressure off the n. root should be first. When patient is tolerant, beginextension exercises to help " squeeze " disc material away from n. rootand begin postural reformation etc. But, why on earth close down those facetsand put MORE pressure on an already impinged n. root in the acute stage? Idon't see the benefit, and all rehab books i've read do not suggest this. Don'tforget that for most of these patients, the leg pain is ,more severe than theback pain. For instance, a herniated L5/S1 creates most times a very tonichamstring. Stretching this hamstring (especially agressively) in the acutestages can stretch the N. root and keep your patient in a heck of a lot ofpain. Tight hamstrings very well could have played a roll in causation, but toaddress them too early and too aggressively can be very counterproductive. I agree that in todays society, the hypolordotic spine is abundant andi teach pelvic tilting (pouring the water out) as well as someSOT, mckenzie and yoga style exercises in order to help them attain morepostural balance in the future and thereby reducing another incident. ph Medlin D.C.Spine Tree Chiropractic1607 NE Alberta StPDX, OR 97211503-788-6800 What do you provide for your patients The recent thread withsomeone asking what exercises to prescribe for LBP and the responses, or lackthereof was interesting. The field of exercise science in treatment of avariety of disorders is burgeoning with the new ACSM's Exercise is Medicinecampaign as well as with the release of books such as Spark: The Revolutionary New Science of Exercise and the Brainby J. Ratey. Within our own field, chiropractorssadly continue to be slow to adopt this trend and to educate themselves in whatthe science supports. I work with a lot of personal trainers intown, and with several PTs. They regularly are surprised that I, achiropractor, seem to be abreast of the literature in exercise science. Iam regularly disappointed that so many of my colleagues, and even the recentgrads, seem to barely have an understanding of what works and what doesn't whenit comes to exercise. It's maddening to continue to get disc patients whohave been prescribed " yoga " that includes forward bends, knees tochest and twisting poses and can't seem to get that pain down their leg get anybetter. It's frustrating to see abdominal hollowing exercises a la'Hodges work on transversus and the subsequent misinterpretation of the findingsof those studies, continue to be spread as misinformation and thus creatingmore dysfunction in that patient. I wonder what is to become of ourprofession when we don't demonstrate to the public that we know more about howto treat their back pain than their trainer at the gym who has attended aMcGill conference, a Gray conference, a Gray Cook conference and regularlytunes in to SportsRehabExpert. com. What do we have to offer inresponse? & n bsp; The latest practice income generating tips gleaned at thelatest conference? This lack of understanding does not seem to be loston our patients in my experience.What prompted me to write tonight was a communique I received today that wasintended for Kaiser physicians. The following was written by aphysiatrist and was intended to be a quick guide to appropriate referral forPCPs in the local Kaiser system. After giving a good (I feel) descriptionof the pros and cons of manipulation therapy he states: " How does manipulation fit into the general musculoskeletal care continuumand how does it relate to our PT services? Manipulation as a form oftreatment is legitimate, whether you consider the field of chiropractic so ornot. If we had PTs that did manipulation we would not need to refer outto have this form of treatment. The down side of Chiropractic from ourperspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passivemodalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an underemphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourishthroughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general. This then mayleave the patient after a few visits feeling better but not fortifying themwith education, strength and flexibility which are the foundation of preventionfor recurrent spinal pain. " I haven't participated in this forum for a while. It's interesting to spend afew days here again. If I'm too out of place here, I'll go away again. But I would be interested in finding out if DCs in this progressive state aretuning in to the changing times and positioning themselves to have culturalauthority for ALL things concerning conservative management of the spine.W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at HawthorneWellness Center 3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd.Portland, OR97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956 drpsnell.chiroweb. comwww.fixyourownback. comMember American Collegeof Sports Medicine

Posted

I remember Dr. Wei saying that he hadpositional upright MRIs showing that extention can make some discs bulge. Lookat this pdf #80 on the cervical disc. I don’t think this is an upright film butextention showed a higher detection of missed discs: http://www.fonar.com/pdf/Spine_Journal_UCLA_study.pdf s. fuchs dc From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of joe medlinSent: Monday, February 08, 20109:48 AM Snell; oregon dclistserve; LindekugelSubject: Re: Whatdo you provide for your patients  Hey , Ya know, i look at it both ways actually, but i'll tell ya, i'vetreated a lot of hot discs and you just try getting those folks into extensionright away. OUCH. Cobra and any extension is Contraindicated in a patient wherethe motion creates radicular pain consistant with a n. root compression painreferral. Think about the acute nature before we think about changing what gotem there. Opening up those facets, decreasing inflammation and takingpressure off the n. root should be first. When patient is tolerant, beginextension exercises to help " squeeze " disc material away from n. rootand begin postural reformation etc. But, why on earth close down those facetsand put MORE pressure on an already impinged n. root in the acute stage? Idon't see the benefit, and all rehab books i've read do not suggest this. Don'tforget that for most of these patients, the leg pain is ,more severe than theback pain. For instance, a herniated L5/S1 creates most times a very tonichamstring. Stretching this hamstring (especially agressively) in the acutestages can stretch the N. root and keep your patient in a heck of a lot ofpain. Tight hamstrings very well could have played a roll in causation, but toaddress them too early and too aggressively can be very counterproductive. I agree that in todays society, the hypolordotic spine is abundant andi teach pelvic tilting (pouring the water out) as well as someSOT, mckenzie and yoga style exercises in order to help them attain morepostural balance in the future and thereby reducing another incident. ph Medlin D.C.Spine Tree Chiropractic1607 NE Alberta StPDX, OR 97211503-788-6800 What do you provide for your patients The recent thread withsomeone asking what exercises to prescribe for LBP and the responses, or lackthereof was interesting. The field of exercise science in treatment of avariety of disorders is burgeoning with the new ACSM's Exercise is Medicinecampaign as well as with the release of books such as Spark: The Revolutionary New Science of Exercise and the Brainby J. Ratey. Within our own field, chiropractorssadly continue to be slow to adopt this trend and to educate themselves in whatthe science supports. I work with a lot of personal trainers intown, and with several PTs. They regularly are surprised that I, achiropractor, seem to be abreast of the literature in exercise science. Iam regularly disappointed that so many of my colleagues, and even the recentgrads, seem to barely have an understanding of what works and what doesn't whenit comes to exercise. It's maddening to continue to get disc patients whohave been prescribed " yoga " that includes forward bends, knees tochest and twisting poses and can't seem to get that pain down their leg get anybetter. It's frustrating to see abdominal hollowing exercises a la'Hodges work on transversus and the subsequent misinterpretation of the findingsof those studies, continue to be spread as misinformation and thus creatingmore dysfunction in that patient. I wonder what is to become of ourprofession when we don't demonstrate to the public that we know more about howto treat their back pain than their trainer at the gym who has attended aMcGill conference, a Gray conference, a Gray Cook conference and regularlytunes in to SportsRehabExpert. com. What do we have to offer inresponse? & n bsp; The latest practice income generating tips gleaned at thelatest conference? This lack of understanding does not seem to be loston our patients in my experience.What prompted me to write tonight was a communique I received today that wasintended for Kaiser physicians. The following was written by aphysiatrist and was intended to be a quick guide to appropriate referral forPCPs in the local Kaiser system. After giving a good (I feel) descriptionof the pros and cons of manipulation therapy he states: " How does manipulation fit into the general musculoskeletal care continuumand how does it relate to our PT services? Manipulation as a form oftreatment is legitimate, whether you consider the field of chiropractic so ornot. If we had PTs that did manipulation we would not need to refer outto have this form of treatment. The down side of Chiropractic from ourperspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passivemodalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an underemphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourishthroughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general. This then mayleave the patient after a few visits feeling better but not fortifying themwith education, strength and flexibility which are the foundation of preventionfor recurrent spinal pain. " I haven't participated in this forum for a while. It's interesting to spend afew days here again. If I'm too out of place here, I'll go away again. But I would be interested in finding out if DCs in this progressive state aretuning in to the changing times and positioning themselves to have culturalauthority for ALL things concerning conservative management of the spine.W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at HawthorneWellness Center 3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd.Portland, OR97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956 drpsnell.chiroweb. comwww.fixyourownback. comMember American Collegeof Sports Medicine

Posted

Hi Joe,It is contraindicated to produce extension in a patient that extension creates more leg/foot pain. If you get more peripheralization (more pain in leg) with lumbar extension, extension would be contraindicated. If you get more centralization of symptoms (less pain in leg/foot) with extension, try to get the patient to do the extension exercises even if there is more pain in the back. Lots of communication here. If they are not tolerant of these exercises, unload the spine and use Static Back/modified shavasana poses also. Or sometimes standing or sitting postures are all the body will tolerate. We treat the body where it is and only give what the body will take.But remember, these provocative tests are like dating. You learn nothing on

the first date. Similarly, you learn nothing from the tests by just testing once or twice in each direction. The provocative (extension, flexion, lateral shear, etc) tests must be done 7-10 times in each direction and then wait to see if the direction makes the symptoms peripheral or central. Best,JayFrom: joe medlin <spinetree@...> Snell <drpsnell@...>; oregon dc listserve < >; Lindekugel <pdxchiroguy@...>Sent: Mon, February 8, 2010 9:48:18 AMSubject: Re: What do you provide for your patients



Hey ,

Ya know, i look at it both ways actually, but i'll tell ya, i've treated a lot of hot discs and you just try getting those folks into extension right away. OUCH. Cobra and any extension is Contraindicated in a patient where the motion creates radicular pain consistant with a n. root compression pain referral. Think about the acute nature before we think about changing what got em there. Opening up those facets, decreasing inflammation and taking pressure off the n. root should be first. When patient is tolerant, begin extension exercises to help "squeeze" disc material away from n. root and begin postural reformation etc. But, why on earth close down those facets and put MORE pressure on an already impinged n. root in the acute stage? I don't see the benefit, and all rehab books i've read do not suggest this. Don't forget that for most of these patients, the leg pain is ,more severe than the back pain.

For instance, a herniated L5/S1 creates most times a very tonic hamstring. Stretching this hamstring (especially agressively) in the acute stages can stretch the N. root and keep your patient in a heck of a lot of pain. Tight hamstrings very well could have played a roll in causation, but to address them too early and too aggressively can be very counterproductive.

I agree that in todays society, the hypolordotic spine is abundant and i teach pelvic tilting (pouring the water out) as well as some SOT, mckenzie and yoga style exercises in order to help them attain more postural balance in the future and thereby reducing another incident.

ph Medlin D.C.Spine Tree Chiropractic1607 NE Alberta StPDX, OR 97211503-788-6800

What do you provide for your patients

The recent thread with someone asking what exercises to prescribe for LBP and the responses, or lack thereof was interesting. The field of exercise science in treatment of a variety of disorders is burgeoning with the new ACSM's Exercise is Medicine campaign as well as with the release of books such as Spark: The Revolutionary New Science of Exercise and the Brain by J. Ratey. Within our own field, chiropractors sadly continue to be slow to adopt this trend and to educate themselves in what the science supports. I work with a lot of personal trainers in town, and with several PTs. They regularly are surprised that I, a chiropractor, seem to be abreast of the literature in exercise science. I am regularly disappointed that so many of my colleagues, and even the recent grads, seem to barely have an understanding of what works and what doesn't when it comes to exercise. It's maddening to continue to get disc patients who have been prescribed "yoga" that includes forward bends, knees to chest and twisting poses and can't seem to get that pain down their leg get any better. It's frustrating to see abdominal hollowing exercises a la' Hodges work on transversus and the subsequent misinterpretation of the findings of those studies, continue to be spread as misinformation and thus creating more dysfunction in that patient. I wonder what is to become of our profession when we don't demonstrate to the public that we know more about how to treat their back pain than their trainer at the gym who has attended a McGill conference, a Gray conference, a Gray Cook conference and regularly tunes in to SportsRehabExpert. com. What do we have to offer in response? & n bsp; The latest practice income generating tips gleaned at the latest conference? This lack of understanding does not seem to be lost on our patients in my experience.What prompted me to write tonight was a communique I received today that was intended for Kaiser physicians. The following was written by a physiatrist and was intended to be a quick guide to appropriate referral for PCPs in the local Kaiser system. After giving a good (I feel) description of the pros and cons of manipulation therapy he states:"How does manipulation fit into the general musculoskeletal care continuum and how does it relate to our PT services? Manipulation as a form of treatment is legitimate, whether you consider the field of chiropractic so or not. If we had PTs that did manipulation we would not need to refer out to have this form of treatment. The down side of Chiropractic from our perspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passive modalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an under emphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourish throughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general. This then may leave the patient after a few visits feeling better but not fortifying them with education, strength and flexibility which are the foundation of prevention for recurrent spinal pain."I haven't participated in this forum for a while. It's interesting to spend a few days here again. If I'm too out of place here, I'll go away again. But I would be interested in finding out if DCs in this progressive state are tuning in to the changing times and positioning themselves to have cultural authority for ALL things concerning conservative management of the spine. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center 3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956 drpsnell.chiroweb. comwww.fixyourownback. comMember American College of Sports Medicine

Posted



Thanks Jay,

Thats all i'm saying, is that treating the patient with exercises that are opposite the forces that caused the herniation isn't always possible at first. I do agree however that Ultimately thats where we want to go. However, One test of Kemps where the patient exhibits high pain level going down leg into foot is enough for me to keep them off extension for a bit. Not sure i need to do it 7-10 times.

ph Medlin D.C.Spine Tree Chiropractic1607 NE Alberta StPDX, OR 97211503-788-6800

What do you provide for your patients

The recent thread with someone asking what exercises to prescribe for LBP and the responses, or lack thereof was interesting. The field of exercise science in treatment of a variety of disorders is burgeoning with the new ACSM's Exercise is Medicine campaign as well as with the release of books such as Spark: The Revolutionary New Science of Exercise and the Brain by J. Ratey. Within our own field, chiropractors sadly continue to be slow to adopt this trend and to educate themselves in what the science supports. I work with a lot of personal trainers in town, and with several PTs. They regularly are surprised that I, a chiropractor, seem to be abreast of the literature in exercise science. I am regularly disappointed that so many of my colleagues, and even the recent grads, seem to barely have an understanding of what works and what doesn't when it comes to exercise. It's maddening to continue to get disc patients who have been prescribed "yoga" that includes forward bends, knees to chest and twisting poses and can't seem to get that pain down their leg get any better. It's frustrating to see abdominal hollowing exercises a la' Hodges work on transversus and the subsequent misinterpretation of the findings of those studies, continue to be spread as misinformation and thus creating more dysfunction in that patient. I wonder what is to become of our profession when we don't demonstrate to the public that we know more about how to treat their back pain than their trainer at the gym who has attended a McGill conference, a Gray conference, a Gray Cook conference and regularly tunes in to SportsRehabExpert. com. What do we have to offer in response? & n bsp; The latest practice income generating tips gleaned at the latest conference? This lack of understanding does not seem to be lost on our patients in my experience.What prompted me to write tonight was a communique I received today that was intended for Kaiser physicians. The following was written by a physiatrist and was intended to be a quick guide to appropriate referral for PCPs in the local Kaiser system. After giving a good (I feel) description of the pros and cons of manipulation therapy he states:"How does manipulation fit into the general musculoskeletal care continuum and how does it relate to our PT services? Manipulation as a form of treatment is legitimate, whether you consider the field of chiropractic so or not. If we had PTs that did manipulation we would not need to refer out to have this form of treatment. The down side of Chiropractic from our perspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passive modalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an under emphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourish throughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general. This then may leave the patient after a few visits feeling better but not fortifying them with education, strength and flexibility which are the foundation of prevention for recurrent spinal pain."I haven't participated in this forum for a while. It's interesting to spend a few days here again. If I'm too out of place here, I'll go away again. But I would be interested in finding out if DCs in this progressive state are tuning in to the changing times and positioning themselves to have cultural authority for ALL things concerning conservative management of the spine. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center 3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956 drpsnell.chiroweb. comwww.fixyourownback. comMember American College of Sports Medicine

Posted



Thanks Jay,

Thats all i'm saying, is that treating the patient with exercises that are opposite the forces that caused the herniation isn't always possible at first. I do agree however that Ultimately thats where we want to go. However, One test of Kemps where the patient exhibits high pain level going down leg into foot is enough for me to keep them off extension for a bit. Not sure i need to do it 7-10 times.

ph Medlin D.C.Spine Tree Chiropractic1607 NE Alberta StPDX, OR 97211503-788-6800

What do you provide for your patients

The recent thread with someone asking what exercises to prescribe for LBP and the responses, or lack thereof was interesting. The field of exercise science in treatment of a variety of disorders is burgeoning with the new ACSM's Exercise is Medicine campaign as well as with the release of books such as Spark: The Revolutionary New Science of Exercise and the Brain by J. Ratey. Within our own field, chiropractors sadly continue to be slow to adopt this trend and to educate themselves in what the science supports. I work with a lot of personal trainers in town, and with several PTs. They regularly are surprised that I, a chiropractor, seem to be abreast of the literature in exercise science. I am regularly disappointed that so many of my colleagues, and even the recent grads, seem to barely have an understanding of what works and what doesn't when it comes to exercise. It's maddening to continue to get disc patients who have been prescribed "yoga" that includes forward bends, knees to chest and twisting poses and can't seem to get that pain down their leg get any better. It's frustrating to see abdominal hollowing exercises a la' Hodges work on transversus and the subsequent misinterpretation of the findings of those studies, continue to be spread as misinformation and thus creating more dysfunction in that patient. I wonder what is to become of our profession when we don't demonstrate to the public that we know more about how to treat their back pain than their trainer at the gym who has attended a McGill conference, a Gray conference, a Gray Cook conference and regularly tunes in to SportsRehabExpert. com. What do we have to offer in response? & n bsp; The latest practice income generating tips gleaned at the latest conference? This lack of understanding does not seem to be lost on our patients in my experience.What prompted me to write tonight was a communique I received today that was intended for Kaiser physicians. The following was written by a physiatrist and was intended to be a quick guide to appropriate referral for PCPs in the local Kaiser system. After giving a good (I feel) description of the pros and cons of manipulation therapy he states:"How does manipulation fit into the general musculoskeletal care continuum and how does it relate to our PT services? Manipulation as a form of treatment is legitimate, whether you consider the field of chiropractic so or not. If we had PTs that did manipulation we would not need to refer out to have this form of treatment. The down side of Chiropractic from our perspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passive modalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an under emphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourish throughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general. This then may leave the patient after a few visits feeling better but not fortifying them with education, strength and flexibility which are the foundation of prevention for recurrent spinal pain."I haven't participated in this forum for a while. It's interesting to spend a few days here again. If I'm too out of place here, I'll go away again. But I would be interested in finding out if DCs in this progressive state are tuning in to the changing times and positioning themselves to have cultural authority for ALL things concerning conservative management of the spine. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center 3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956 drpsnell.chiroweb. comwww.fixyourownback. comMember American College of Sports Medicine

Posted

Yeah Joe,I think we are really close on this one. Finer point - I would just add that I might still put the patient through the McKenzie provocative maneuvers even with the positive Kemps, or I might save it for a future date. Just to get some more information on what happens when we cause a little creep in the tissues in all directions and confirm that I want to stay away from extension for a while. I don't speak for the McKenzie folks, but my understanding is that they say it does take several repetitive provocations to get good information. This may seem like overkill, but I think it is helpful in determining exercise prescription.Cheers,JayFrom: joe medlin <spinetree@...> Lindekugel <pdxchiroguy@...>; Snell <drpsnell@...>; oregon dc listserve < >Sent: Tue, February 9, 2010 8:35:51 AMSubject: Re: What do you provide for your patients



Thanks Jay,

Thats all i'm saying, is that treating the patient with exercises that are opposite the forces that caused the herniation isn't always possible at first. I do agree however that Ultimately thats where we want to go. However, One test of Kemps where the patient exhibits high pain level going down leg into foot is enough for me to keep them off extension for a bit. Not sure i need to do it 7-10 times.

ph Medlin D.C.Spine Tree Chiropractic1607 NE Alberta StPDX, OR 97211503-788-6800

What do you provide for your patients

The recent thread with someone asking what exercises to prescribe for LBP and the responses, or lack thereof was interesting. The field of exercise science in treatment of a variety of disorders is burgeoning with the new ACSM's Exercise is Medicine campaign as well as with the release of books such as Spark: The Revolutionary New Science of Exercise and the Brain by J. Ratey. Within our own field, chiropractors sadly continue to be slow to adopt this trend and to educate themselves in what the science supports. I work with a lot of personal trainers in town, and with several PTs. They regularly are surprised that I, a chiropractor, seem to be abreast of the literature in exercise science. I am regularly disappointed that so many of my colleagues, and even the recent grads, seem to barely have an understanding of what works and what doesn't when it comes to exercise. It's maddening to continue to get disc patients who have been prescribed "yoga" that includes forward bends, knees to chest and twisting poses and can't seem to get that pain down their leg get any better. It's frustrating to see abdominal hollowing exercises a la' Hodges work on transversus and the subsequent misinterpretation of the findings of those studies, continue to be spread as misinformation and thus creating more dysfunction in that patient. I wonder what is to become of our profession when we don't demonstrate to the public that we know more about how to treat their back pain than their trainer at the gym who has attended a McGill conference, a Gray conference, a Gray Cook conference and regularly tunes in to SportsRehabExpert. com. What do we have to offer in response? & n bsp; The latest practice income generating tips gleaned at the latest conference? This lack of understanding does not seem to be lost on our patients in my experience.What prompted me to write tonight was a communique I received today that was intended for Kaiser physicians. The following was written by a physiatrist and was intended to be a quick guide to appropriate referral for PCPs in the local Kaiser system. After giving a good (I feel) description of the pros and cons of manipulation therapy he states:"How does manipulation fit into the general musculoskeletal care continuum and how does it relate to our PT services? Manipulation as a form of treatment is legitimate, whether you consider the field of chiropractic so or not. If we had PTs that did manipulation we would not need to refer out to have this form of treatment. The down side of Chiropractic from our perspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passive modalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an under emphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourish throughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general. This then may leave the patient after a few visits feeling better but not fortifying them with education, strength and flexibility which are the foundation of prevention for recurrent spinal pain."I haven't participated in this forum for a while. It's interesting to spend a few days here again. If I'm too out of place here, I'll go away again. But I would be interested in finding out if DCs in this progressive state are tuning in to the changing times and positioning themselves to have cultural authority for ALL things concerning conservative management of the spine. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center 3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956 drpsnell.chiroweb. comwww.fixyourownback. comMember American College of Sports Medicine

Posted

Yeah Joe,I think we are really close on this one. Finer point - I would just add that I might still put the patient through the McKenzie provocative maneuvers even with the positive Kemps, or I might save it for a future date. Just to get some more information on what happens when we cause a little creep in the tissues in all directions and confirm that I want to stay away from extension for a while. I don't speak for the McKenzie folks, but my understanding is that they say it does take several repetitive provocations to get good information. This may seem like overkill, but I think it is helpful in determining exercise prescription.Cheers,JayFrom: joe medlin <spinetree@...> Lindekugel <pdxchiroguy@...>; Snell <drpsnell@...>; oregon dc listserve < >Sent: Tue, February 9, 2010 8:35:51 AMSubject: Re: What do you provide for your patients



Thanks Jay,

Thats all i'm saying, is that treating the patient with exercises that are opposite the forces that caused the herniation isn't always possible at first. I do agree however that Ultimately thats where we want to go. However, One test of Kemps where the patient exhibits high pain level going down leg into foot is enough for me to keep them off extension for a bit. Not sure i need to do it 7-10 times.

ph Medlin D.C.Spine Tree Chiropractic1607 NE Alberta StPDX, OR 97211503-788-6800

What do you provide for your patients

The recent thread with someone asking what exercises to prescribe for LBP and the responses, or lack thereof was interesting. The field of exercise science in treatment of a variety of disorders is burgeoning with the new ACSM's Exercise is Medicine campaign as well as with the release of books such as Spark: The Revolutionary New Science of Exercise and the Brain by J. Ratey. Within our own field, chiropractors sadly continue to be slow to adopt this trend and to educate themselves in what the science supports. I work with a lot of personal trainers in town, and with several PTs. They regularly are surprised that I, a chiropractor, seem to be abreast of the literature in exercise science. I am regularly disappointed that so many of my colleagues, and even the recent grads, seem to barely have an understanding of what works and what doesn't when it comes to exercise. It's maddening to continue to get disc patients who have been prescribed "yoga" that includes forward bends, knees to chest and twisting poses and can't seem to get that pain down their leg get any better. It's frustrating to see abdominal hollowing exercises a la' Hodges work on transversus and the subsequent misinterpretation of the findings of those studies, continue to be spread as misinformation and thus creating more dysfunction in that patient. I wonder what is to become of our profession when we don't demonstrate to the public that we know more about how to treat their back pain than their trainer at the gym who has attended a McGill conference, a Gray conference, a Gray Cook conference and regularly tunes in to SportsRehabExpert. com. What do we have to offer in response? & n bsp; The latest practice income generating tips gleaned at the latest conference? This lack of understanding does not seem to be lost on our patients in my experience.What prompted me to write tonight was a communique I received today that was intended for Kaiser physicians. The following was written by a physiatrist and was intended to be a quick guide to appropriate referral for PCPs in the local Kaiser system. After giving a good (I feel) description of the pros and cons of manipulation therapy he states:"How does manipulation fit into the general musculoskeletal care continuum and how does it relate to our PT services? Manipulation as a form of treatment is legitimate, whether you consider the field of chiropractic so or not. If we had PTs that did manipulation we would not need to refer out to have this form of treatment. The down side of Chiropractic from our perspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passive modalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an under emphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourish throughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general. This then may leave the patient after a few visits feeling better but not fortifying them with education, strength and flexibility which are the foundation of prevention for recurrent spinal pain."I haven't participated in this forum for a while. It's interesting to spend a few days here again. If I'm too out of place here, I'll go away again. But I would be interested in finding out if DCs in this progressive state are tuning in to the changing times and positioning themselves to have cultural authority for ALL things concerning conservative management of the spine. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center 3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956 drpsnell.chiroweb. comwww.fixyourownback. comMember American College of Sports Medicine

Posted

Yeah Joe,I think we are really close on this one. Finer point - I would just add that I might still put the patient through the McKenzie provocative maneuvers even with the positive Kemps, or I might save it for a future date. Just to get some more information on what happens when we cause a little creep in the tissues in all directions and confirm that I want to stay away from extension for a while. I don't speak for the McKenzie folks, but my understanding is that they say it does take several repetitive provocations to get good information. This may seem like overkill, but I think it is helpful in determining exercise prescription.Cheers,JayFrom: joe medlin <spinetree@...> Lindekugel <pdxchiroguy@...>; Snell <drpsnell@...>; oregon dc listserve < >Sent: Tue, February 9, 2010 8:35:51 AMSubject: Re: What do you provide for your patients



Thanks Jay,

Thats all i'm saying, is that treating the patient with exercises that are opposite the forces that caused the herniation isn't always possible at first. I do agree however that Ultimately thats where we want to go. However, One test of Kemps where the patient exhibits high pain level going down leg into foot is enough for me to keep them off extension for a bit. Not sure i need to do it 7-10 times.

ph Medlin D.C.Spine Tree Chiropractic1607 NE Alberta StPDX, OR 97211503-788-6800

What do you provide for your patients

The recent thread with someone asking what exercises to prescribe for LBP and the responses, or lack thereof was interesting. The field of exercise science in treatment of a variety of disorders is burgeoning with the new ACSM's Exercise is Medicine campaign as well as with the release of books such as Spark: The Revolutionary New Science of Exercise and the Brain by J. Ratey. Within our own field, chiropractors sadly continue to be slow to adopt this trend and to educate themselves in what the science supports. I work with a lot of personal trainers in town, and with several PTs. They regularly are surprised that I, a chiropractor, seem to be abreast of the literature in exercise science. I am regularly disappointed that so many of my colleagues, and even the recent grads, seem to barely have an understanding of what works and what doesn't when it comes to exercise. It's maddening to continue to get disc patients who have been prescribed "yoga" that includes forward bends, knees to chest and twisting poses and can't seem to get that pain down their leg get any better. It's frustrating to see abdominal hollowing exercises a la' Hodges work on transversus and the subsequent misinterpretation of the findings of those studies, continue to be spread as misinformation and thus creating more dysfunction in that patient. I wonder what is to become of our profession when we don't demonstrate to the public that we know more about how to treat their back pain than their trainer at the gym who has attended a McGill conference, a Gray conference, a Gray Cook conference and regularly tunes in to SportsRehabExpert. com. What do we have to offer in response? & n bsp; The latest practice income generating tips gleaned at the latest conference? This lack of understanding does not seem to be lost on our patients in my experience.What prompted me to write tonight was a communique I received today that was intended for Kaiser physicians. The following was written by a physiatrist and was intended to be a quick guide to appropriate referral for PCPs in the local Kaiser system. After giving a good (I feel) description of the pros and cons of manipulation therapy he states:"How does manipulation fit into the general musculoskeletal care continuum and how does it relate to our PT services? Manipulation as a form of treatment is legitimate, whether you consider the field of chiropractic so or not. If we had PTs that did manipulation we would not need to refer out to have this form of treatment. The down side of Chiropractic from our perspective in Physical Medicine, is that there is an over-reliance upon passive modalities of treatment like manipulation, heat, ultrasound and an under emphasis on currently accepted concepts of exercise therapy which flourish throughout sports medicine and rehabilitation in general. This then may leave the patient after a few visits feeling better but not fortifying them with education, strength and flexibility which are the foundation of prevention for recurrent spinal pain."I haven't participated in this forum for a while. It's interesting to spend a few days here again. If I'm too out of place here, I'll go away again. But I would be interested in finding out if DCs in this progressive state are tuning in to the changing times and positioning themselves to have cultural authority for ALL things concerning conservative management of the spine. W. Snell, D.C. Director, Solutions Sports & Spine, Inc at Hawthorne Wellness Center 3942 SE Hawthorne Blvd. Portland, OR 97214 Ph. 503-235-5484 Fax 503-235-3956 drpsnell.chiroweb. comwww.fixyourownback. comMember American College of Sports Medicine

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...