Guest guest Posted August 7, 2010 Report Posted August 7, 2010 See below. On Sat, Aug 7, 2010 at 3:46 AM, Tink <tink.belle@...> wrote: > > > Amy, > > I don't think it is as black and white as you state it is. There are shades > of grey and as Marti already wrote, both theories can be right. > Although you seem to be assuming that I think it's as simple as XMRV causes all cases of CFS, I don't and I never stated that I did. It has been my opinion from the start (long before Marti wrote it here) that there are many different ways that someone ends up with CFS. XMRV may not be involved at all in some cases for all we know at this point. I was simply asking if you could explain your own thinking more because some of the things you wrote seemed to exclude these multiple possibilities. > > In real life I have seen over the years a couple of gay friends who came > into contact with an HIV positive person, got emergency treatment right away > and came away with a clean bill of health. Others who had already some kind > of chronic illness were not so lucky. Of course this proofs nothing but > research says that these are not isolated cases. > > >> Just like in HIV these infections were able to strike because of a >> weakened immune system. > > Are you saying that HIV doesn't cause a weakened immune system itself, but > that people get HIV infections because they have a weakened immune system > already? Any idea on what causes this already weakened immune system? > > Anything can cause an weakened immune system, a person can have an > auto-immune disease, thyroid/hormonal dysfunction, bacterial and viral > infections, Diabetes etc. > I was questioning your statement " Just like in HIV these infections were able to strike because of a weakened immune system " because that sounded like you thought people *only *got HIV from having a weakened immune. I can see that from a certain point of view this is true (more on that in a second), but I don't think that it's logical to say that some other virus has to come along to weaken the immune system first and *only then *HIV can infect you. If another virus can weaken the immune system first why couldn't HIV and XMRV be the first virus to weaken the immune system? That was the point of my question to you. But, clearly, you can have an already susceptible immune system from non-viral sources, such as toxins and/or genetic issues, which can allow any virus to come in and weaken the immune system. Also, there may be specific genetic variations that certain viruses are able to take advantage of in order to cause infection. In such a case, XMRV could definitely be the first virus to weaken someone's immune system. My personal opinion is that it probably takes a perfect storm of issues (eg, genetics, toxins, pathogens) to cause someone to come down with CFS. In which case you really have to address ALL of these issues in order to get truly well again. Then the question would be whether XMRV has to be one of the straws on the camels back that causes CFS, or if you can get true CFS without XMRV. Just as you can't get AIDS without HIV, can you get CFS without XMRV? So much is still unknown at this point. I just don't like to see people making blanket statements based only on their opinion at this point because it can be misleading to others who haven't done as much research on the topic. This is how incorrect information begins to circulate on the internet. > > I think Marti wrote it so very well, there might be more than one > possibility. Personally I don't think I belong in the category where the > XMRV is the cause of everything. I already had a weakened immune system when > I was a child of 5 y.o this stemmed from drinking water that was > contaminated and I got Hepatitis. Twice. I started my M.E in 1970 when I was > hospitalized with EBV for 4 months, 2 on ICU. It was one of the worsted > cases they had ever seen. After that I have never recovered. > Have you considered the possibility that you were more susceptible to getting Hepatitis and then EBV because you already had XMRV in the background weakening your immune system? Seems like an obvious possibility to me. Quote
Guest guest Posted August 7, 2010 Report Posted August 7, 2010 Dr. Mikovits has already stated that there is no mechanism such as this piggy-backing idea that has been circulating on the internet. I don't see why people don't think they could have already had an XMRV infection when they were exposed to something like EBV. The EBV infection then triggers significant inflammation which is known to trigger/activate XMRV, and wa-la, you have CFS that you can't recover from. On Sat, Aug 7, 2010 at 2:41 AM, Tink <tink.belle@...> wrote: > > > Amy, > > I never said or wrote that I didn't think that a retrovirus could cause the > immune system to be dysfunctional. I agree with you on that. > > One explanation of how XMRV enters our body is that XMRV is a piggy-back > virus, which means we have already been infected with another virus, EBV? To > me it seems logical that an immune system was dysfunctional to begin with, > if it wasn't a viral infection wouldn't have a chance to survive. And we > wouldn't be ill for over 30 years. We would shake it off and go on with our > lives, instead we never recovered. I think it also can explain why so many > 'healthy' people can test positive for XMRV and have no symptoms. Their > immune systems are probably in good shape to start with. > > -- > > Portland, OR > > > On Aug 6, 2010, at 7:09 PM, Pwr2Heal wrote: > > > Well, we're all allowed to have our own opinions, aren't we. :-) I admit, > > though, that I find it curious you don't think that a retrovirus which > > infects immune system cells might cause the immune system to become > > dysfunctional. It seems like such a direct explanation of cause and > effect > > I can't grasp not thinking it might be the cause of the dysfunction. > > Hopefully research will eventually fill in some of the details about how > > XMRV works in our illness, though. > > > > Amy > > > > On Fri, Aug 6, 2010 at 5:37 PM, Tink <tink.belle@...<tink.belle%40gmail.com>> > wrote: > > > >> > >> > >> Thank you for the summary Amy. I am familiar with the various > explanations > >> of how XMRV works. I know it inserts itself into your DNA, I have spend > many > >> hours educating myself on XMRV. > >> > >> I objected to the simple explanation that 'it messes up your immune > system' > >> it is so much more than just that. I stand by my opinion that an immune > >> system is already dysfunctional before it is infected with XMRV. > >> > >> -- > >> > >> Portland, OR > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 7, 2010 Report Posted August 7, 2010 i just dont see how i could have already had XMRV. no one in my family has illnesses related to XMRV....i wasnt breast fed....had never had sex....had never had a blood transfusion...... i suppose it could be contaminated vaccines......but i think it is using some other proteins to infect the cells somehow. i did read something about that in a journal article.... ________________________________ From: Pwr2Heal <pwr2heal@...> Sent: Sat, August 7, 2010 1:02:30 PM Subject: Re: Re: XMRV...and cancers... Â Dr. Mikovits has already stated that there is no mechanism such as this piggy-backing idea that has been circulating on the internet. I don't see why people don't think they could have already had an XMRV infection when they were exposed to something like EBV. The EBV infection then triggers significant inflammation which is known to trigger/activate XMRV, and wa-la, you have CFS that you can't recover from. On Sat, Aug 7, 2010 at 2:41 AM, Tink <tink.belle@...> wrote: > > > Amy, > > I never said or wrote that I didn't think that a retrovirus could cause the > immune system to be dysfunctional. I agree with you on that. > > One explanation of how XMRV enters our body is that XMRV is a piggy-back > virus, which means we have already been infected with another virus, EBV? To > me it seems logical that an immune system was dysfunctional to begin with, > if it wasn't a viral infection wouldn't have a chance to survive. And we > wouldn't be ill for over 30 years. We would shake it off and go on with our > lives, instead we never recovered. I think it also can explain why so many > 'healthy' people can test positive for XMRV and have no symptoms. Their > immune systems are probably in good shape to start with. > > -- > > Portland, OR > > > On Aug 6, 2010, at 7:09 PM, Pwr2Heal wrote: > > > Well, we're all allowed to have our own opinions, aren't we. :-) I admit, > > though, that I find it curious you don't think that a retrovirus which > > infects immune system cells might cause the immune system to become > > dysfunctional. It seems like such a direct explanation of cause and > effect > > I can't grasp not thinking it might be the cause of the dysfunction. > > Hopefully research will eventually fill in some of the details about how > > XMRV works in our illness, though. > > > > Amy > > > > On Fri, Aug 6, 2010 at 5:37 PM, Tink ><tink.belle@...<tink.belle%40gmail.com>> > wrote: > > > >> > >> > >> Thank you for the summary Amy. I am familiar with the various > explanations > >> of how XMRV works. I know it inserts itself into your DNA, I have spend > many > >> hours educating myself on XMRV. > >> > >> I objected to the simple explanation that 'it messes up your immune > system' > >> it is so much more than just that. I stand by my opinion that an immune > >> system is already dysfunctional before it is infected with XMRV. > >> > >> -- > >> > >> Portland, OR > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 7, 2010 Report Posted August 7, 2010 Vaccine contamination is my current best guess as to how I could have gotten XMRV. 3 of my doctors all guarantee me that I have it based on history and symptoms. I'm like you, though, Sue. No one in my family has illnesses related to XMRV, I wasn't breast fed, never had sex before having symptoms, didn't have a blood transfusion, etc. I was not an acute onset case (so this piggy-backing virus theory wouldn't explain my case). Other than vaccine contamination I don't know how someone like me could have gotten it. There is the idea of transmission by saliva, but that seems less likely to me than vaccine contamination. On Sat, Aug 7, 2010 at 4:54 PM, Sue <suebackagain123@...>wrote: > > > i just dont see how i could have already had XMRV. no one in my family has > illnesses related to XMRV....i wasnt breast fed....had never had sex....had > > never had a blood transfusion...... i suppose it could be contaminated > vaccines......but i think it is using some other proteins to infect the > cells > somehow. i did read something about that in a journal article.... > > ________________________________ > From: Pwr2Heal <pwr2heal@... <pwr2heal%40gmail.com>> > <%40> > Sent: Sat, August 7, 2010 1:02:30 PM > > Subject: Re: Re: XMRV...and cancers... > > > Dr. Mikovits has already stated that there is no mechanism such as this > piggy-backing idea that has been circulating on the internet. I don't see > why people don't think they could have already had an XMRV infection when > they were exposed to something like EBV. The EBV infection then triggers > significant inflammation which is known to trigger/activate XMRV, and > wa-la, > you have CFS that you can't recover from. > > On Sat, Aug 7, 2010 at 2:41 AM, Tink <tink.belle@...<tink.belle%40gmail.com>> > wrote: > > > > > > > Amy, > > > > I never said or wrote that I didn't think that a retrovirus could cause > the > > immune system to be dysfunctional. I agree with you on that. > > > > One explanation of how XMRV enters our body is that XMRV is a piggy-back > > virus, which means we have already been infected with another virus, EBV? > To > > me it seems logical that an immune system was dysfunctional to begin > with, > > if it wasn't a viral infection wouldn't have a chance to survive. And we > > wouldn't be ill for over 30 years. We would shake it off and go on with > our > > lives, instead we never recovered. I think it also can explain why so > many > > 'healthy' people can test positive for XMRV and have no symptoms. Their > > immune systems are probably in good shape to start with. > > > > -- > > > > Portland, OR > > > > > > On Aug 6, 2010, at 7:09 PM, Pwr2Heal wrote: > > > > > Well, we're all allowed to have our own opinions, aren't we. :-) I > admit, > > > though, that I find it curious you don't think that a retrovirus which > > > infects immune system cells might cause the immune system to become > > > dysfunctional. It seems like such a direct explanation of cause and > > effect > > > I can't grasp not thinking it might be the cause of the dysfunction. > > > Hopefully research will eventually fill in some of the details about > how > > > XMRV works in our illness, though. > > > > > > Amy > > > > > > On Fri, Aug 6, 2010 at 5:37 PM, Tink > ><tink.belle@... <tink.belle%40gmail.com><tink.belle%40gmail.com>> > > > wrote: > > > > > >> > > >> > > >> Thank you for the summary Amy. I am familiar with the various > > explanations > > >> of how XMRV works. I know it inserts itself into your DNA, I have > spend > > many > > >> hours educating myself on XMRV. > > >> > > >> I objected to the simple explanation that 'it messes up your immune > > system' > > >> it is so much more than just that. I stand by my opinion that an > immune > > >> system is already dysfunctional before it is infected with XMRV. > > >> > > >> -- > > >> > > >> Portland, OR > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 7, 2010 Report Posted August 7, 2010 no cancer at all in my family. i do have some mental illness in my family and i did consider that perhaps XMRV might play a part....but i somehow doubt it. i really have a strong feeling i got it the same time i got mono. but i guess we'll see. ________________________________ From: louella m <lmonrovia@...> Sent: Sat, August 7, 2010 8:32:45 PM Subject: Re: XMRV...and cancers... Â I thought I read that it is vertically transmitted in the DNA. So you could inherit it.. but maybe like amy said, there has to be something epigenetically that switches it on, like oxidative stress. Is there any cancer in your family? I believe the WPI folks think it may turn out to be connected to more than just prostate cancer. > > > > > >> > > >> > > >> Thank you for the summary Amy. I am familiar with the various > > explanations > > >> of how XMRV works. I know it inserts itself into your DNA, I have spend > > many > > >> hours educating myself on XMRV. > > >> > > >> I objected to the simple explanation that 'it messes up your immune > > system' > > >> it is so much more than just that. I stand by my opinion that an immune > > >> system is already dysfunctional before it is infected with XMRV. > > >> > > >> -- > > >> > > >> Portland, OR > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 7, 2010 Report Posted August 7, 2010 hi marti. my doctor is in canada...but if you are in the states, a few have told me that dr. joseph brewer in kansas is dabbling in antiretrovirals. dr. holtorf is considering it too. dr. brewer, i believe, takes medicare. there are a few others too..i could ask around. dr. mikovits must have some names, if you want to email her. sue ________________________________ From: marti_zavala <marti_zavala@...> Sent: Sun, August 8, 2010 12:24:44 AM Subject: Re: XMRV...and cancers...  Hi Suw, I take supplements and some meds. I am finding that the amino acids are the most helpful. I am curious where your doctor is and if you could back channel his information. Maybe I'll have some money some day! Marti > > > > i cannot believe more people are not badgering > > their doctors for treatment. > > -s > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 7, 2010 Report Posted August 7, 2010 How do you know you have XMRV? On Aug 7, 2010, at 5:41 PM, Pwr2Heal wrote: > Vaccine contamination is my current best guess as to how I could > have gotten > XMRV. 3 of my doctors all guarantee me that I have it based on > history and > symptoms. I'm like you, though, Sue. No one in my family has illnesses > related to XMRV, I wasn't breast fed, never had sex before having > symptoms, > didn't have a blood transfusion, etc. I was not an acute onset case > (so > this piggy-backing virus theory wouldn't explain my case). Other than > vaccine contamination I don't know how someone like me could have > gotten > it. There is the idea of transmission by saliva, but that seems less > likely > to me than vaccine contamination. > > On Sat, Aug 7, 2010 at 4:54 PM, Sue <suebackagain123@... > >wrote: > > > > > > > i just dont see how i could have already had XMRV. no one in my > family has > > illnesses related to XMRV....i wasnt breast fed....had never had > sex....had > > > > never had a blood transfusion...... i suppose it could be > contaminated > > vaccines......but i think it is using some other proteins to > infect the > > cells > > somehow. i did read something about that in a journal article.... > > > > ________________________________ > > From: Pwr2Heal <pwr2heal@... <pwr2heal%40gmail.com>> > > < > %40> > > Sent: Sat, August 7, 2010 1:02:30 PM > > > > Subject: Re: Re: XMRV...and cancers... > > > > > > Dr. Mikovits has already stated that there is no mechanism such as > this > > piggy-backing idea that has been circulating on the internet. I > don't see > > why people don't think they could have already had an XMRV > infection when > > they were exposed to something like EBV. The EBV infection then > triggers > > significant inflammation which is known to trigger/activate XMRV, > and > > wa-la, > > you have CFS that you can't recover from. > > > > On Sat, Aug 7, 2010 at 2:41 AM, Tink > <tink.belle@...<tink.belle%40gmail.com>> > > wrote: > > > > > > > > > > > Amy, > > > > > > I never said or wrote that I didn't think that a retrovirus > could cause > > the > > > immune system to be dysfunctional. I agree with you on that. > > > > > > One explanation of how XMRV enters our body is that XMRV is a > piggy-back > > > virus, which means we have already been infected with another > virus, EBV? > > To > > > me it seems logical that an immune system was dysfunctional to > begin > > with, > > > if it wasn't a viral infection wouldn't have a chance to > survive. And we > > > wouldn't be ill for over 30 years. We would shake it off and go > on with > > our > > > lives, instead we never recovered. I think it also can explain > why so > > many > > > 'healthy' people can test positive for XMRV and have no > symptoms. Their > > > immune systems are probably in good shape to start with. > > > > > > -- > > > > > > Portland, OR > > > > > > > > > On Aug 6, 2010, at 7:09 PM, Pwr2Heal wrote: > > > > > > > Well, we're all allowed to have our own opinions, aren't > we. :-) I > > admit, > > > > though, that I find it curious you don't think that a > retrovirus which > > > > infects immune system cells might cause the immune system to > become > > > > dysfunctional. It seems like such a direct explanation of > cause and > > > effect > > > > I can't grasp not thinking it might be the cause of the > dysfunction. > > > > Hopefully research will eventually fill in some of the details > about > > how > > > > XMRV works in our illness, though. > > > > > > > > Amy > > > > > > > > On Fri, Aug 6, 2010 at 5:37 PM, Tink > > ><tink.belle@... <tink.belle%40gmail.com><tink.belle > %40gmail.com>> > > > > > wrote: > > > > > > > >> > > > >> > > > >> Thank you for the summary Amy. I am familiar with the various > > > explanations > > > >> of how XMRV works. I know it inserts itself into your DNA, I > have > > spend > > > many > > > >> hours educating myself on XMRV. > > > >> > > > >> I objected to the simple explanation that 'it messes up your > immune > > > system' > > > >> it is so much more than just that. I stand by my opinion that > an > > immune > > > >> system is already dysfunctional before it is infected with > XMRV. > > > >> > > > >> -- > > > >> > > > >> Portland, OR > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 8, 2010 Report Posted August 8, 2010 On Aug 7, 2010, at 9:58 AM, Pwr2Heal wrote: > > Have you considered the possibility that you were more susceptible to > getting Hepatitis and then EBV because you already had XMRV in the > background weakening your immune system? Seems like an obvious possibility > to me. I have considered that possibility yes, but I take many things in consideration. Even the the consideration that this retro virus could be a man made virus(*gasp*) and not in existence when I was 5 y.o. Who knows? Until definite proof is available anything is possible. > just don't like to see people > making blanket statements based only on their opinion at this point because > it can be misleading to others who haven't done as much research on the > topic. This is how incorrect information begins to circulate on the > internet. In a mailing list situation people discuss topics based on their own opinions and experiences. After all we are not writing a research paper. I expect that anyone who participates in mailing list discussions will take that in consideration. To prevent further confusion and unproductive discussions in the future I will use a disclaimer in my messages. -- Portland, OR ••• Disclamer ••• Comments and statements made in this email are my own personal opinions only and do not necessarily reflect the positions or opinions of researchers and physicians. All comments and statements are based upon my current knowledge and my own personal experiences. Quote
Guest guest Posted August 8, 2010 Report Posted August 8, 2010 Sue, It was mono for me too, when I was a teenager. Marcia on in Salem, Massachusetts On Aug 8, 2010, at 12:35 AM, Sue wrote: > no cancer at all in my family. i do have some mental illness in my > family and i > did consider that perhaps XMRV might play a part....but i somehow > doubt it. i > really have a strong feeling i got it the same time i got mono. but > i guess > we'll see. > > _ Quote
Guest guest Posted August 8, 2010 Report Posted August 8, 2010 keep in mind that there have been outbreaks of CFS in schools and in a convent. ________________________________ From: Tink <tink.belle@...> Sent: Sun, August 8, 2010 4:01:15 AM Subject: Re: Re: XMRV...and cancers... On Aug 7, 2010, at 9:58 AM, Pwr2Heal wrote: > > Have you considered the possibility that you were more susceptible to > getting Hepatitis and then EBV because you already had XMRV in the > background weakening your immune system? Seems like an obvious possibility > to me. I have considered that possibility yes, but I take many things in consideration. Even the the consideration that this retro virus could be a man made virus(*gasp*) and not in existence when I was 5 y.o. Who knows? Until definite proof is available anything is possible. > just don't like to see people > making blanket statements based only on their opinion at this point because > it can be misleading to others who haven't done as much research on the > topic. This is how incorrect information begins to circulate on the > internet. In a mailing list situation people discuss topics based on their own opinions and experiences. After all we are not writing a research paper. I expect that anyone who participates in mailing list discussions will take that in consideration. To prevent further confusion and unproductive discussions in the future I will use a disclaimer in my messages. -- Portland, OR ••• Disclamer ••• Comments and statements made in this email are my own personal opinions only and do not necessarily reflect the positions or opinions of researchers and physicians. All comments and statements are based upon my current knowledge and my own personal experiences. ------------------------------------ This list is intended for patients to share personal experiences with each other, not to give medical advice. If you are interested in any treatment discussed here, please consult your doctor. Quote
Guest guest Posted August 8, 2010 Report Posted August 8, 2010 For me, originating from Europe and having arrived in the US only 4 years ago, the history is different. When I was in the hospital ill with EBV in 1971 I wasn't the only one. There was a large outbreak in the town where I lived. I was diagnosed in 1980 with M.E Outbreaks were not documented across Europe. Before the EU came into place countries did not exchange information freely. It is started to come along now but it is still difficult. There are language barriers that do not exist in Northern America, Eastern Europe connection to the rest of Europe is still in it's early stages. Norther and Western Europe like Scandinavia, Netherlands, Danmark, Germany, UK etc have a now a pretty good working and exchange relationship. However in the 50/60/70's when I was growing up every country was an island. So there is not much known or documented about isolated outbreaks. The UK has some documents on outbreaks in 1955, in the end 70's and early 80's. Iceland has a documented outbreak. But little is known about other countries. -- Portland, OR ••• Disclamer ••• Comments and statements made in this email are my own personal opinions only and do not necessarily reflect the positions or opinions of researchers and physicians. All comments and statements are based upon my current knowledge and my own personal experiences. On Aug 8, 2010, at 10:53 AM, Sue wrote: > keep in mind that there have been outbreaks of CFS in schools and in a convent. > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 8, 2010 Report Posted August 8, 2010 Hi , What part of Europe were you in during 1971? Marcia on in Salem, Massachusetts On Aug 8, 2010, at 3:57 PM, Tink wrote: > For me, originating from Europe and having arrived in the US only 4 > years ago, the history is different. > > When I was in the hospital ill with EBV in 1971 I wasn't the only > one. There was a large outbreak in the town where I lived. I was > diagnosed in 1980 with M.E > > Outbreaks were not documented across Europe. Before the EU came into > place countries did not exchange information freely. It is started > to come along now but it is still difficult. There are language > barriers that do not exist in Northern America, Eastern Europe > connection to the rest of Europe is still in it's early stages. > Norther and Western Europe like Scandinavia, Netherlands, Danmark, > Germany, UK etc have a now a pretty good working and exchange > relationship. > > However in the 50/60/70's when I was growing up every country was an > island. So there is not much known or documented about isolated > outbreaks. The UK has some documents on outbreaks in 1955, in the > end 70's and early 80's. Iceland has a documented outbreak. But > little is known about other countries. > > > -- > > Portland, OR > > ••• Disclamer ••• > Comments and statements made in this email are my own personal > opinions only and do not necessarily reflect the positions or > opinions of researchers and physicians. All comments and statements > are based upon my current knowledge and my own personal experiences. > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.