Guest guest Posted August 3, 2010 Report Posted August 3, 2010 well nothing has really been " proven " yet.....but CFS patients have a higher frequency of leukemia / lymphoma. ________________________________ From: Dan B <kdrbrill@...> Sent: Tue, August 3, 2010 5:19:49 PM Subject: Re: XMRV...and cancers... Â Hi Sue, I know you mean well, but perhaps you didn't understand my question. With all due sincere respect, the only cancer that XMRV has been shown in studies to be related to is one form of aggressive prostate cancer. I did several google searches after you claimed that XMRV can lead to leukemia, and nothing turned up. Maybe you were mixing it up with HTLV-1 or 2? Here's a quote from the WPI website: " HTLV-1 and 2 causes T-cell leukemia and T-cell lymphoma. " d. > > > > hi yannick. XMRV can, in some cases, lead to leukemia. I have not had a >biopsy. > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 4, 2010 Report Posted August 4, 2010 Well, yes, but that is often because of a heavily SCEBV infection. Epstein Barr is known to lead to Lymphoma. I just participated and exchanged emails with a researcher in Taiwan who was interested in cross-contanimation of Epstein Barr of canines and humans. Because I have a very high amount of Epstein Barr I did send her my data and the data of my 2 dogs, my 2 dogs both had a chronic illness and both developed suddenly Lyphoma and died very soon after another. She is still working on her current research project but has already published one paper on the subject. She asked me to come to Taiwan to get treatment but unfortunately that is impossible for me. You write that it isn't 'proven' yet. If that is the case than you shouldn't state it as a fact that XMRV causes Lymphoma. -- Portland, OR On Aug 3, 2010, at 8:19 PM, Sue wrote: > well nothing has really been " proven " yet.....but CFS patients have a higher > frequency of leukemia / lymphoma. > > > > > ________________________________ > From: Dan B <kdrbrill@...> > > Sent: Tue, August 3, 2010 5:19:49 PM > Subject: Re: XMRV...and cancers... > > > Hi Sue, > > I know you mean well, but perhaps you didn't understand my question. > > With all due sincere respect, the only cancer that XMRV has been shown in > studies to be related to is one form of aggressive prostate cancer. > > > I did several google searches after you claimed that XMRV can lead to leukemia, > and nothing turned up. Maybe you were mixing it up with HTLV-1 or 2? > > Here's a quote from the WPI website: > > " HTLV-1 and 2 causes T-cell leukemia and T-cell lymphoma. " > > d. > > >>> >>> hi yannick. XMRV can, in some cases, lead to leukemia. I have not had a >> biopsy. >> >> Quote
Guest guest Posted August 4, 2010 Report Posted August 4, 2010 christine..why would you have to go to taiwan for EBV treatment? dr. a. martin lerner and many other doctors in the US treat it, using valtrex or famvir. sue ________________________________ From: Tink <tink.belle@...> Sent: Wed, August 4, 2010 4:53:04 AM Subject: Re: Re: XMRV...and cancers... Â Well, yes, but that is often because of a heavily SCEBV infection. Epstein Barr is known to lead to Lymphoma. I just participated and exchanged emails with a researcher in Taiwan who was interested in cross-contanimation of Epstein Barr of canines and humans. Because I have a very high amount of Epstein Barr I did send her my data and the data of my 2 dogs, my 2 dogs both had a chronic illness and both developed suddenly Lyphoma and died very soon after another. She is still working on her current research project but has already published one paper on the subject. She asked me to come to Taiwan to get treatment but unfortunately that is impossible for me. You write that it isn't 'proven' yet. If that is the case than you shouldn't state it as a fact that XMRV causes Lymphoma. -- Portland, OR On Aug 3, 2010, at 8:19 PM, Sue wrote: > well nothing has really been " proven " yet.....but CFS patients have a higher > frequency of leukemia / lymphoma. > > > > > ________________________________ > From: Dan B <kdrbrill@...> > > Sent: Tue, August 3, 2010 5:19:49 PM > Subject: Re: XMRV...and cancers... > > > Hi Sue, > > I know you mean well, but perhaps you didn't understand my question. > > With all due sincere respect, the only cancer that XMRV has been shown in > studies to be related to is one form of aggressive prostate cancer. > > > I did several google searches after you claimed that XMRV can lead to leukemia, > > and nothing turned up. Maybe you were mixing it up with HTLV-1 or 2? > > Here's a quote from the WPI website: > > " HTLV-1 and 2 causes T-cell leukemia and T-cell lymphoma. " > > d. > > >>> >>> hi yannick. XMRV can, in some cases, lead to leukemia. I have not had a >> biopsy. >> >> Quote
Guest guest Posted August 4, 2010 Report Posted August 4, 2010 XMRV is closely related to a group of retroviruses that are known to cause leukemias and lymphomas in animals. Its closest relative is a mouse leukemia virus, hence the name Xenotropic murine leukemia virus-related virus, although most mice are immune to it. It is not yet proven to cause leukemia or lymphoma in humans, but I get the impression that scientists would not be surprised if it does. Beverly Quote
Guest guest Posted August 5, 2010 Report Posted August 5, 2010 , thanks for the update......are you saying XMRV does not lead to non-hodkins lymphoma?..... [Moderator: " lead to " is not the right term, the better term is " have a higher risk " . I.e. smoking cigars do not leave to cancer (i.e. Burns did not get cancer and lived to almost 100). The odds increases.... I personally have spoken with Judy Mikovitz and she contends that XMRV for CFS patients leads no non-hodkins lymphoma. I also understand that the NIH studies which have yet to be published show that there are at least 3 strains of this virus, one of which appears to be related to CFIDS. Quote
Guest guest Posted August 5, 2010 Report Posted August 5, 2010 Good question, I've never heard of a published study on this but I don't keep a close watch on that stuff. I've heard it mentioned in interviews and articles. My understanding is that the first people tested for XMRV were samples that were frozen from people in Dr. 's pratice that had come down with leukemia or lymphoma. Beverly >I have heard that CFS patients have an increased rate of cancer, >but I can't find the source of that info...does anybody have references? Quote
Guest guest Posted August 5, 2010 Report Posted August 5, 2010 Sue, I have an excellent physician here that treats my viral and bacterial infections. I was invited to Taiwan to further participate in the study that I was already participating in from a distance. The study was of course mainly based Eastern medicine. Which I use now as well as part of my integrative treatment plan. Personally I don't think Valtrex or Famvir is the answer, at least not for me. -- Portland, OR On Aug 4, 2010, at 7:53 AM, Sue wrote: > christine..why would you have to go to taiwan for EBV treatment? dr. a. martin > lerner and many other doctors in the US treat it, using valtrex or famvir. > > sue > > > > > ________________________________ > From: Tink <tink.belle@...> > > Sent: Wed, August 4, 2010 4:53:04 AM > Subject: Re: Re: XMRV...and cancers... > > > Well, yes, but that is often because of a heavily SCEBV infection. > Epstein Barr is known to lead to Lymphoma. > > I just participated and exchanged emails with a researcher in Taiwan who was > interested in cross-contanimation of Epstein Barr of canines and humans. > Because I have a very high amount of Epstein Barr I did send her my data and the > data of my 2 dogs, my 2 dogs both had a chronic illness and both developed > suddenly Lyphoma and died very soon after another. She is still working on her > current research project but has already published one paper on the subject. > She asked me to come to Taiwan to get treatment but unfortunately that is > impossible for me. > > You write that it isn't 'proven' yet. If that is the case than you shouldn't > state it as a fact that XMRV causes Lymphoma. > -- > > Portland, OR Quote
Guest guest Posted August 5, 2010 Report Posted August 5, 2010 Hi Yannick The Taiwanese study is of course based on Eastern Medicine and not on Western. So the answer is not as easy as take a Famvir pill and your viral infection will be gone. It's a mix of herbal medicine, acupuncture, drainage massages and new Eastern medicine. IMO Western medicine treats symptom but not the cause. Eastern medicine treats the cause so the body can deal with the symptoms i.e the viral infection, detox etc. In my case a non-functioning immune system makes is possible for all viral and bacterial infections to use me as a host. As long as we don't fix or can't fix the immune system I stay ill. -- Portland, OR On Aug 4, 2010, at 9:25 AM, cancfs wrote: > Hi , > > Out of curiosity, what kind of treatment did the Taiwanese doctor want to give you for your EBV? > > I have heard that CFS patients have an increased rate of cancer, but I can't find the source of that info...does anybody have references? > > Yannick > > >> >> Well, yes, but that is often because of a heavily SCEBV infection. >> Epstein Barr is known to lead to Lymphoma. >> >> I just participated and exchanged emails with a researcher in Taiwan who was interested in cross-contanimation of Epstein Barr of canines and humans. >> Because I have a very high amount of Epstein Barr I did send her my data and the data of my 2 dogs, my 2 dogs both had a chronic illness and both developed suddenly Lyphoma and died very soon after another. She is still working on her current research project but has already published one paper on the subject. >> She asked me to come to Taiwan to get treatment but unfortunately that is impossible for me. >> >> You write that it isn't 'proven' yet. If that is the case than you shouldn't state it as a fact that XMRV causes Lymphoma. >> -- >> >> Portland, OR >> > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 5, 2010 Report Posted August 5, 2010 They came down with Leukemia or Lymphoma due to their high EBV titers? IMO CFS itself does not lead to a higher risk of Leukemia or Lymphoma but the opportunistic infections we have to deal with do. Do you know if it was documented what the suspected cause of their Leukemia or Lymphoma was? -- Portland, OR On Aug 5, 2010, at 11:00 AM, Beverly wrote: > Good question, I've never heard of a published study on this but I don't > keep a close watch on that stuff. I've heard it mentioned in interviews and > articles. My understanding is that the first people tested for XMRV were > samples that were frozen from people in Dr. 's pratice that had come > down with leukemia or lymphoma. > Beverly > >> I have heard that CFS patients have an increased rate of cancer, >> but I can't find the source of that info...does anybody have references? > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 5, 2010 Report Posted August 5, 2010 They dont actually know yet if XMRV can directly cause cancer by itself. They are studying it. But indirectly, it messes up the immune system  ________________________________ From: Tink <tink.belle@...> Sent: Thu, August 5, 2010 4:49:32 PM Subject: Re: Re: XMRV...and cancers...  They came down with Leukemia or Lymphoma due to their high EBV titers? IMO CFS itself does not lead to a higher risk of Leukemia or Lymphoma but the opportunistic infections we have to deal with do. Do you know if it was documented what the suspected cause of their Leukemia or Lymphoma was? -- Portland, OR On Aug 5, 2010, at 11:00 AM, Beverly wrote: > Good question, I've never heard of a published study on this but I don't > keep a close watch on that stuff. I've heard it mentioned in interviews and > articles. My understanding is that the first people tested for XMRV were > samples that were frozen from people in Dr. 's pratice that had come > down with leukemia or lymphoma. > Beverly > >> I have heard that CFS patients have an increased rate of cancer, >> but I can't find the source of that info...does anybody have references? > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 5, 2010 Report Posted August 5, 2010 I don't know It doesn't make sense to me that one thing causes cancer or for that matter one thing causes CFS It seems like it's a combination of factors Thanks Steve On Aug 5, 2010, at 2:28 PM, Sue wrote: > They dont actually know yet if XMRV can directly cause cancer by > itself. They > are studying it. But indirectly, it messes up the immune system > > > > ________________________________ > From: Tink <tink.belle@...> > > Sent: Thu, August 5, 2010 4:49:32 PM > Subject: Re: Re: XMRV...and cancers... > > > They came down with Leukemia or Lymphoma due to their high EBV titers? > > IMO CFS itself does not lead to a higher risk of Leukemia or > Lymphoma but the > opportunistic infections we have to deal with do. > > Do you know if it was documented what the suspected cause of their > Leukemia or > Lymphoma was? > > -- > > Portland, OR > > On Aug 5, 2010, at 11:00 AM, Beverly wrote: > > > Good question, I've never heard of a published study on this but I > don't > > keep a close watch on that stuff. I've heard it mentioned in > interviews and > > articles. My understanding is that the first people tested for > XMRV were > > samples that were frozen from people in Dr. 's pratice > that had come > > down with leukemia or lymphoma. > > Beverly > > > >> I have heard that CFS patients have an increased rate of cancer, > >> but I can't find the source of that info...does anybody have > references? > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 5, 2010 Report Posted August 5, 2010 it doesnt necessarily cause the cancer..it depends where in the genome the virus inerts itself to transform the cell and then that cell has to multiply and be selected for over other cells for cancer to eventually develop sue ________________________________ From: S B <stangah@...> Sent: Thu, August 5, 2010 10:57:07 PM Subject: Re: Re: XMRV...and cancers... I don't know It doesn't make sense to me that one thing causes cancer or for that matter one thing causes CFS It seems like it's a combination of factors Thanks Steve On Aug 5, 2010, at 2:28 PM, Sue wrote: > They dont actually know yet if XMRV can directly cause cancer by > itself. They > are studying it. But indirectly, it messes up the immune system > > > > ________________________________ > From: Tink <tink.belle@...> > > Sent: Thu, August 5, 2010 4:49:32 PM > Subject: Re: Re: XMRV...and cancers... > > > They came down with Leukemia or Lymphoma due to their high EBV titers? > > IMO CFS itself does not lead to a higher risk of Leukemia or > Lymphoma but the > opportunistic infections we have to deal with do. > > Do you know if it was documented what the suspected cause of their > Leukemia or > Lymphoma was? > > -- > > Portland, OR > > On Aug 5, 2010, at 11:00 AM, Beverly wrote: > > > Good question, I've never heard of a published study on this but I > don't > > keep a close watch on that stuff. I've heard it mentioned in > interviews and > > articles. My understanding is that the first people tested for > XMRV were > > samples that were frozen from people in Dr. 's pratice > that had come > > down with leukemia or lymphoma. > > Beverly > > > >> I have heard that CFS patients have an increased rate of cancer, > >> but I can't find the source of that info...does anybody have > references? > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 6, 2010 Report Posted August 6, 2010 Sorry but I don't agree with you. Everything I have read about viral infections and XMRV is just that, another virus, states that in order for a virus to survive it needs a 'not functioning like it should' immune system. If the immune system would do it's job, like it should, the virus wouldn't stand a chance and would be killed off. It isn't the XMRV virus that 'messes up' the immune system. The immune system is already messed up, that's how the virus got in in the first place. -- Portland, OR On Aug 5, 2010, at 2:28 PM, Sue wrote: > They dont actually know yet if XMRV can directly cause cancer by itself. They > are studying it. But indirectly, it messes up the immune system > > > > > > ________________________________ > From: Tink <tink.belle@...> > > Sent: Thu, August 5, 2010 4:49:32 PM > Subject: Re: Re: XMRV...and cancers... > > > They came down with Leukemia or Lymphoma due to their high EBV titers? > > IMO CFS itself does not lead to a higher risk of Leukemia or Lymphoma but the > opportunistic infections we have to deal with do. > > Do you know if it was documented what the suspected cause of their Leukemia or > Lymphoma was? > > -- > > Portland, OR > > On Aug 5, 2010, at 11:00 AM, Beverly wrote: > >> Good question, I've never heard of a published study on this but I don't >> keep a close watch on that stuff. I've heard it mentioned in interviews and >> articles. My understanding is that the first people tested for XMRV were >> samples that were frozen from people in Dr. 's pratice that had come >> down with leukemia or lymphoma. >> Beverly >> >>> I have heard that CFS patients have an increased rate of cancer, >>> but I can't find the source of that info...does anybody have references? > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 6, 2010 Report Posted August 6, 2010 You don't seem to know the details about XMRV. XMRV isn't like regular DNA viruses. It's an RNA virus, a retrovirus, which basically means it inserts itself into your DNA. So, once it's in your DNA in your cells, every time your infected cell replicates the virus replicates. And it infects cells of the immune system. XMRV has already been shown to be infectious in humans and transmittable in humans. Very little about XMRV is proven yet, but this is a good summary about how it may " mess up the immune system " from the WPI's website is this: " The current working hypothesis is that XMRV infection of B, T, NK and other cells of the innate immune response causes chronic inflammation and immune deficiency resulting in an inability to mount an effective immune response to opportunistic infections. " This is from: http://www.wpinstitute.org/xmrv/index.html So, the idea is that XMRV infects the immune system cells and the body's attempts to address this infection leads to chronic inflammation and immune deficiency, which then allows other opportunistic infections to take hold and make you sick. This is similar to how HIV works. And yes, some people with HIV aren't sick. The same seems to be true with XMRV, as about 4-7% of the healthy population has XMRV but are currently asymptomatic. Amy On Fri, Aug 6, 2010 at 1:56 AM, Tink <tink.belle@...> wrote: > > > Sorry but I don't agree with you. > > Everything I have read about viral infections and XMRV is just that, > another virus, states that in order for a virus to survive it needs a 'not > functioning like it should' immune system. > If the immune system would do it's job, like it should, the virus wouldn't > stand a chance and would be killed off. > > It isn't the XMRV virus that 'messes up' the immune system. The immune > system is already messed up, that's how the virus got in in the first place. > > > -- > > Portland, OR > > On Aug 5, 2010, at 2:28 PM, Sue wrote: > > > They dont actually know yet if XMRV can directly cause cancer by itself. > They > > are studying it. But indirectly, it messes up the immune system > > > > > > > > > > > > ________________________________ > > From: Tink <tink.belle@... <tink.belle%40gmail.com>> > > <%40> > > Sent: Thu, August 5, 2010 4:49:32 PM > > Subject: Re: Re: XMRV...and cancers... > > > > > > They came down with Leukemia or Lymphoma due to their high EBV titers? > > > > IMO CFS itself does not lead to a higher risk of Leukemia or Lymphoma but > the > > opportunistic infections we have to deal with do. > > > > Do you know if it was documented what the suspected cause of their > Leukemia or > > Lymphoma was? > > > > -- > > > > Portland, OR > > > > On Aug 5, 2010, at 11:00 AM, Beverly wrote: > > > >> Good question, I've never heard of a published study on this but I don't > > >> keep a close watch on that stuff. I've heard it mentioned in interviews > and > >> articles. My understanding is that the first people tested for XMRV were > > >> samples that were frozen from people in Dr. 's pratice that had > come > >> down with leukemia or lymphoma. > >> Beverly > >> > >>> I have heard that CFS patients have an increased rate of cancer, > >>> but I can't find the source of that info...does anybody have > references? > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 6, 2010 Report Posted August 6, 2010 are you saying that millions of people have died of HIV ( " just another virus " ) because they all had weak immune systems??? come on lol ________________________________ From: Tink <tink.belle@...> Sent: Fri, August 6, 2010 4:56:53 AM Subject: Re: Re: XMRV...and cancers... Â Sorry but I don't agree with you. Everything I have read about viral infections and XMRV is just that, another virus, states that in order for a virus to survive it needs a 'not functioning like it should' immune system. If the immune system would do it's job, like it should, the virus wouldn't stand a chance and would be killed off. It isn't the XMRV virus that 'messes up' the immune system. The immune system is already messed up, that's how the virus got in in the first place. -- Portland, OR On Aug 5, 2010, at 2:28 PM, Sue wrote: > They dont actually know yet if XMRV can directly cause cancer by itself. They > are studying it. But indirectly, it messes up the immune system > > > > > > ________________________________ > From: Tink <tink.belle@...> > > Sent: Thu, August 5, 2010 4:49:32 PM > Subject: Re: Re: XMRV...and cancers... > > > They came down with Leukemia or Lymphoma due to their high EBV titers? > > IMO CFS itself does not lead to a higher risk of Leukemia or Lymphoma but the > opportunistic infections we have to deal with do. > > Do you know if it was documented what the suspected cause of their Leukemia or > Lymphoma was? > > -- > > Portland, OR > > On Aug 5, 2010, at 11:00 AM, Beverly wrote: > >> Good question, I've never heard of a published study on this but I don't >> keep a close watch on that stuff. I've heard it mentioned in interviews and >> articles. My understanding is that the first people tested for XMRV were >> samples that were frozen from people in Dr. 's pratice that had come >> down with leukemia or lymphoma. >> Beverly >> >>> I have heard that CFS patients have an increased rate of cancer, >>> but I can't find the source of that info...does anybody have references? > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 6, 2010 Report Posted August 6, 2010 Thank you for the summary Amy. I am familiar with the various explanations of how XMRV works. I know it inserts itself into your DNA, I have spend many hours educating myself on XMRV. I objected to the simple explanation that 'it messes up your immune system' it is so much more than just that. I stand by my opinion that an immune system is already dysfunctional before it is infected with XMRV. -- Portland, OR On Aug 6, 2010, at 11:03, Pwr2Heal <pwr2heal@...> wrote: > You don't seem to know the details about XMRV. XMRV isn't like regular DNA > viruses. It's an RNA virus, a retrovirus, which basically means it inserts > itself into your DNA. So, once it's in your DNA in your cells, every time > your infected cell replicates the virus replicates. And it infects cells of > the immune system. XMRV has already been shown to be infectious in humans > and transmittable in humans. > > Very little about XMRV is proven yet, but this is a good summary about how > it may " mess up the immune system " from the WPI's website is this: > > " The current working hypothesis is that XMRV infection of B, T, NK and other > cells of the innate immune response causes chronic inflammation and immune > deficiency resulting in an inability to mount an effective immune response > to opportunistic infections. " > > This is from: http://www.wpinstitute.org/xmrv/index.html > > So, the idea is that XMRV infects the immune system cells and the body's > attempts to address this infection leads to chronic inflammation and immune > deficiency, which then allows other opportunistic infections to take hold > and make you sick. This is similar to how HIV works. And yes, some people > with HIV aren't sick. The same seems to be true with XMRV, as about 4-7% of > the healthy population has XMRV but are currently asymptomatic. > > Amy > > On Fri, Aug 6, 2010 at 1:56 AM, Tink <tink.belle@...> wrote: > >> >> >> Sorry but I don't agree with you. >> >> Everything I have read about viral infections and XMRV is just that, >> another virus, states that in order for a virus to survive it needs a 'not >> functioning like it should' immune system. >> If the immune system would do it's job, like it should, the virus wouldn't >> stand a chance and would be killed off. >> >> It isn't the XMRV virus that 'messes up' the immune system. The immune >> system is already messed up, that's how the virus got in in the first place. >> >> >> -- >> >> Portland, OR >> >> On Aug 5, 2010, at 2:28 PM, Sue wrote: >> >>> They dont actually know yet if XMRV can directly cause cancer by itself. >> They >>> are studying it. But indirectly, it messes up the immune system >>> >>> >>> >>> > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 6, 2010 Report Posted August 6, 2010 Nonsense, you are twisting my words. I have never stated anything like that. Physicians are telling me the same, in the end it's just another virus that we need to eliminate. At least if you are as I'll as I am and are the proud owner of many viral and bacterial infections and yes also XMRV. The way my chances are now I will probably die from SCEBV complications(leukemia or lymphoma?) from one of the other HHV complications or XMRV or maybe my bacterial infections such as CMV or Lyme, MAC(mycobacterium avium complex). Take your pick, to me it doesn't matter the end result will be the same. There is no way for me yet to fight the SCEBV just as there is no way to fight the XMRV, with the medications we have tried we have had no luck. Just like in HIV these infections were able to strike because of a weakened immune system. And like one of the other posters wrote, I think it was Steve, it's not a one single thing but a combinations of factors. -- On Aug 6, 2010, at 11:48, Sue <suebackagain123@...> wrote: > are you saying that millions of people have died of HIV ( " just another virus " ) > because they all had weak immune systems??? come on lol > > > > > ________________________________ > From: Tink <tink.belle@...> > > Sent: Fri, August 6, 2010 4:56:53 AM > Subject: Re: Re: XMRV...and cancers... > > > Sorry but I don't agree with you. > > Everything I have read about viral infections and XMRV is just that, another > virus, states that in order for a virus to survive it needs a 'not functioning > like it should' immune system. > If the immune system would do it's job, like it should, the virus wouldn't stand > a chance and would be killed off. > > It isn't the XMRV virus that 'messes up' the immune system. The immune system is > already messed up, that's how the virus got in in the first place. > > -- > > Portland, OR > > On Aug 5, 2010, at 2:28 PM, Sue wrote: > >> > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 6, 2010 Report Posted August 6, 2010 Well, we're all allowed to have our own opinions, aren't we. :-) I admit, though, that I find it curious you don't think that a retrovirus which infects immune system cells might cause the immune system to become dysfunctional. It seems like such a direct explanation of cause and effect I can't grasp not thinking it might be the cause of the dysfunction. Hopefully research will eventually fill in some of the details about how XMRV works in our illness, though. Amy On Fri, Aug 6, 2010 at 5:37 PM, Tink <tink.belle@...> wrote: > > > Thank you for the summary Amy. I am familiar with the various explanations > of how XMRV works. I know it inserts itself into your DNA, I have spend many > hours educating myself on XMRV. > > I objected to the simple explanation that 'it messes up your immune system' > it is so much more than just that. I stand by my opinion that an immune > system is already dysfunctional before it is infected with XMRV. > > -- > > Portland, OR > > On Aug 6, 2010, at 11:03, Pwr2Heal <pwr2heal@...<pwr2heal%40gmail.com>> > wrote: > > > You don't seem to know the details about XMRV. XMRV isn't like regular > DNA > > viruses. It's an RNA virus, a retrovirus, which basically means it > inserts > > itself into your DNA. So, once it's in your DNA in your cells, every time > > your infected cell replicates the virus replicates. And it infects cells > of > > the immune system. XMRV has already been shown to be infectious in humans > > and transmittable in humans. > > > > Very little about XMRV is proven yet, but this is a good summary about > how > > it may " mess up the immune system " from the WPI's website is this: > > > > " The current working hypothesis is that XMRV infection of B, T, NK and > other > > cells of the innate immune response causes chronic inflammation and > immune > > deficiency resulting in an inability to mount an effective immune > response > > to opportunistic infections. " > > > > This is from: http://www.wpinstitute.org/xmrv/index.html > > > > So, the idea is that XMRV infects the immune system cells and the body's > > attempts to address this infection leads to chronic inflammation and > immune > > deficiency, which then allows other opportunistic infections to take hold > > and make you sick. This is similar to how HIV works. And yes, some people > > with HIV aren't sick. The same seems to be true with XMRV, as about 4-7% > of > > the healthy population has XMRV but are currently asymptomatic. > > > > Amy > > > > On Fri, Aug 6, 2010 at 1:56 AM, Tink <tink.belle@...<tink.belle%40gmail.com>> > wrote: > > > >> > >> > >> Sorry but I don't agree with you. > >> > >> Everything I have read about viral infections and XMRV is just that, > >> another virus, states that in order for a virus to survive it needs a > 'not > >> functioning like it should' immune system. > >> If the immune system would do it's job, like it should, the virus > wouldn't > >> stand a chance and would be killed off. > >> > >> It isn't the XMRV virus that 'messes up' the immune system. The immune > >> system is already messed up, that's how the virus got in in the first > place. > >> > >> > >> -- > >> > >> Portland, OR > >> > >> On Aug 5, 2010, at 2:28 PM, Sue wrote: > >> > >>> They dont actually know yet if XMRV can directly cause cancer by > itself. > >> They > >>> are studying it. But indirectly, it messes up the immune system > >>> > >>> > >>> > >>> > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 6, 2010 Report Posted August 6, 2010 > Just like in HIV these infections were able to strike because of a weakened immune system. Are you saying that HIV doesn't cause a weakened immune system itself, but that people get HIV infections because they have a weakened immune system already? Any idea on what causes this already weakened immune system? Just trying to understand where you're coming from, since it seems quite different from my point of view. Thanks, Amy On Fri, Aug 6, 2010 at 6:12 PM, Tink <tink.belle@...> wrote: > > > Nonsense, you are twisting my words. I have never stated anything like > that. Physicians are telling me the same, in the end it's just another virus > that we need to eliminate. At least if you are as I'll as I am and are the > proud owner of many viral and bacterial infections and yes also XMRV. > The way my chances are now I will probably die from SCEBV > complications(leukemia or lymphoma?) from one of the other HHV complications > or XMRV or maybe my bacterial infections such as CMV or Lyme, > MAC(mycobacterium avium complex). Take your pick, to me it doesn't matter > the end result will be the same. There is no way for me yet to fight the > SCEBV just as there is no way to fight the XMRV, with the medications we > have tried we have had no luck. > > Just like in HIV these infections were able to strike because of a weakened > immune system. And like one of the other posters wrote, I think it was > Steve, it's not a one single thing but a combinations of factors. > > -- > > > On Aug 6, 2010, at 11:48, Sue <suebackagain123@...<suebackagain123%40.ca>> > wrote: > > > are you saying that millions of people have died of HIV ( " just another > virus " ) > > because they all had weak immune systems??? come on lol > > > > > > > > > > ________________________________ > > From: Tink <tink.belle@... <tink.belle%40gmail.com>> > > <%40> > > Sent: Fri, August 6, 2010 4:56:53 AM > > Subject: Re: Re: XMRV...and cancers... > > > > > > > Sorry but I don't agree with you. > > > > Everything I have read about viral infections and XMRV is just that, > another > > virus, states that in order for a virus to survive it needs a 'not > functioning > > like it should' immune system. > > If the immune system would do it's job, like it should, the virus > wouldn't stand > > a chance and would be killed off. > > > > It isn't the XMRV virus that 'messes up' the immune system. The immune > system is > > already messed up, that's how the virus got in in the first place. > > > > -- > > > > Portland, OR > > > > On Aug 5, 2010, at 2:28 PM, Sue wrote: > > > >> > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 6, 2010 Report Posted August 6, 2010 See http://www.islandnet.com/~legends/fostertheory.htm , as a medical geographer was struck by the relative lack of AIDS cases in Africa where soil selenium levels were high compared with areas which were low. Western diet derived from intensively farmed, irrigated soils which are largely deficient in selenium, predisposes to low selenium intake and thus a susceptibility to a weakened immune system R Re: Re: XMRV...and cancers... >> >> > >> > >> > Sorry but I don't agree with you. >> > >> > Everything I have read about viral infections and XMRV is just that, >> another >> > virus, states that in order for a virus to survive it needs a 'not >> functioning >> > like it should' immune system. >> > If the immune system would do it's job, like it should, the virus >> wouldn't stand >> > a chance and would be killed off. >> > >> > It isn't the XMRV virus that 'messes up' the immune system. The immune >> system is >> > already messed up, that's how the virus got in in the first place. >> > >> > -- >> > >> > Portland, OR >> > >> > On Aug 5, 2010, at 2:28 PM, Sue wrote: >> > >> >> >> > >> >> Quote
Guest guest Posted August 6, 2010 Report Posted August 6, 2010 its the retrovirus that weakens the immune system. having intermittent, active herpes viruses is not an uncommon finding in humans but retroviral activity is not normal. and there is treatment for CEBV - acyclovir. in fact, some studies have shown that eleimination of EBV may be possible with prolonged antiherpetic treatment. and there is also treatment for XMRV - yes, it is experimental still - but it is out there: raltegravir, isentress, and AZT. it isnt perfect, but it helps. damage begins a few weeks after a retrovirus infects a host and many of us have been sick for decades. i cannot believe more people are not badgering their doctors for treatment. -s ________________________________ From: Tink <tink.belle@...> " " < > Sent: Fri, August 6, 2010 9:12:38 PM Subject: Re: Re: XMRV...and cancers... Â Nonsense, you are twisting my words. I have never stated anything like that. Physicians are telling me the same, in the end it's just another virus that we need to eliminate. At least if you are as I'll as I am and are the proud owner of many viral and bacterial infections and yes also XMRV. The way my chances are now I will probably die from SCEBV complications(leukemia or lymphoma?) from one of the other HHV complications or XMRV or maybe my bacterial infections such as CMV or Lyme, MAC(mycobacterium avium complex). Take your pick, to me it doesn't matter the end result will be the same. There is no way for me yet to fight the SCEBV just as there is no way to fight the XMRV, with the medications we have tried we have had no luck. Just like in HIV these infections were able to strike because of a weakened immune system. And like one of the other posters wrote, I think it was Steve, it's not a one single thing but a combinations of factors. -- On Aug 6, 2010, at 11:48, Sue <suebackagain123@...> wrote: > are you saying that millions of people have died of HIV ( " just another virus " ) > because they all had weak immune systems??? come on lol > > > > > ________________________________ > From: Tink <tink.belle@...> > > Sent: Fri, August 6, 2010 4:56:53 AM > Subject: Re: Re: XMRV...and cancers... > > > Sorry but I don't agree with you. > > Everything I have read about viral infections and XMRV is just that, another > virus, states that in order for a virus to survive it needs a 'not functioning > like it should' immune system. > If the immune system would do it's job, like it should, the virus wouldn't >stand > > a chance and would be killed off. > > It isn't the XMRV virus that 'messes up' the immune system. The immune system >is > > already messed up, that's how the virus got in in the first place. > > -- > > Portland, OR > > On Aug 5, 2010, at 2:28 PM, Sue wrote: > >> > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 7, 2010 Report Posted August 7, 2010 Amy, I never said or wrote that I didn't think that a retrovirus could cause the immune system to be dysfunctional. I agree with you on that. One explanation of how XMRV enters our body is that XMRV is a piggy-back virus, which means we have already been infected with another virus, EBV? To me it seems logical that an immune system was dysfunctional to begin with, if it wasn't a viral infection wouldn't have a chance to survive. And we wouldn't be ill for over 30 years. We would shake it off and go on with our lives, instead we never recovered. I think it also can explain why so many 'healthy' people can test positive for XMRV and have no symptoms. Their immune systems are probably in good shape to start with. -- Portland, OR On Aug 6, 2010, at 7:09 PM, Pwr2Heal wrote: > Well, we're all allowed to have our own opinions, aren't we. :-) I admit, > though, that I find it curious you don't think that a retrovirus which > infects immune system cells might cause the immune system to become > dysfunctional. It seems like such a direct explanation of cause and effect > I can't grasp not thinking it might be the cause of the dysfunction. > Hopefully research will eventually fill in some of the details about how > XMRV works in our illness, though. > > Amy > > On Fri, Aug 6, 2010 at 5:37 PM, Tink <tink.belle@...> wrote: > >> >> >> Thank you for the summary Amy. I am familiar with the various explanations >> of how XMRV works. I know it inserts itself into your DNA, I have spend many >> hours educating myself on XMRV. >> >> I objected to the simple explanation that 'it messes up your immune system' >> it is so much more than just that. I stand by my opinion that an immune >> system is already dysfunctional before it is infected with XMRV. >> >> -- >> >> Portland, OR > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 7, 2010 Report Posted August 7, 2010 We have tried all that and more Sue. I am not just sticking my head around the corner, as a Dutch expression is, but I have been around for a while. I'm fully aware of all treatments, mainstream and experimental, Eastern and than some. Having active herpes viruses might not be an uncommon finding but it contributes a lot to further weakening of the immune system. There are gradations of course, some people do not have a problem with active viral infections, I do though. We are all individuals, not one trick ponies. What works for you might not work for me. It is as simple as that. Maybe people do not push their physicians for anti-viral treatment for their retro virus because they probably have discussed the course of action to take when they got their positive 'XMRV detected' test results back. At least that is how we work. We know very well through trial and error that a treatment with any of the anti-virals will kill me and I know quite certain I'm not the only one. There are other ways than to aggressively treat an already weakened body and do a lot of damage. -- Portland, OR On Aug 6, 2010, at 9:04 PM, Sue wrote: > its the retrovirus that weakens the immune system. having intermittent, active > herpes viruses is not an uncommon finding in humans but retroviral activity is > not normal. and there is treatment for CEBV - acyclovir. in fact, some studies > have shown that eleimination of EBV may be possible with prolonged antiherpetic > treatment. and there is also treatment for XMRV - yes, it is experimental still > - but it is out there: raltegravir, isentress, and AZT. it isnt perfect, but it > helps. damage begins a few weeks after a retrovirus infects a host and many of > us have been sick for decades. i cannot believe more people are not badgering > their doctors for treatment. > -s > > > > > ________________________________ > From: Tink <tink.belle@...> > " " < > > Sent: Fri, August 6, 2010 9:12:38 PM > Subject: Re: Re: XMRV...and cancers... > > > Nonsense, you are twisting my words. I have never stated anything like that. > Physicians are telling me the same, in the end it's just another virus that we > need to eliminate. At least if you are as I'll as I am and are the proud owner > of many viral and bacterial infections and yes also XMRV. > > The way my chances are now I will probably die from SCEBV complications(leukemia > or lymphoma?) from one of the other HHV complications or XMRV or maybe my > bacterial infections such as CMV or Lyme, MAC(mycobacterium avium complex). Take > your pick, to me it doesn't matter the end result will be the same. There is no > way for me yet to fight the SCEBV just as there is no way to fight the XMRV, > with the medications we have tried we have had no luck. > > Just like in HIV these infections were able to strike because of a weakened > immune system. And like one of the other posters wrote, I think it was Steve, > it's not a one single thing but a combinations of factors. > > -- > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 7, 2010 Report Posted August 7, 2010 Amy, I don't think it is as black and white as you state it is. There are shades of grey and as Marti already wrote, both theories can be right. In real life I have seen over the years a couple of gay friends who came into contact with an HIV positive person, got emergency treatment right away and came away with a clean bill of health. Others who had already some kind of chronic illness were not so lucky. Of course this proofs nothing but research says that these are not isolated cases. Anything can cause an weakened immune system, a person can have an auto-immune disease, thyroid/hormonal dysfunction, bacterial and viral infections, Diabetes etc. I think Marti wrote it so very well, there might be more than one possibility. Personally I don't think I belong in the category where the XMRV is the cause of everything. I already had a weakened immune system when I was a child of 5 y.o this stemmed from drinking water that was contaminated and I got Hepatitis. Twice. I started my M.E in 1970 when I was hospitalized with EBV for 4 months, 2 on ICU. It was one of the worsted cases they had ever seen. After that I have never recovered. -- Portland, OR On Aug 6, 2010, at 7:12 PM, Pwr2Heal wrote: >> Just like in HIV these infections were able to strike because of a >> weakened immune system. > > Are you saying that HIV doesn't cause a weakened immune system itself, but > that people get HIV infections because they have a weakened immune system > already? Any idea on what causes this already weakened immune system? > > Just trying to understand where you're coming from, since it seems quite > different from my point of view. > > Thanks, Amy Quote
Guest guest Posted August 7, 2010 Report Posted August 7, 2010 hi marti. i am not taking supplements anymore. they never helped me and i wasted thousands over the years. as to how i find my doctor, the only explanation i can give is that it was a miracle. i went to this doctor (as well as many others) many years ago, desperate for help. he is one of the top infectious disease docs in the city. he couldnt help me then, but made an off-handed remark that maybe CFS is a " new virus " . since then, i kept him in mind, knowing he might be open-minded. in the following years, i saw several american doctors and spent everything i had. nothing helped. as soon as the Science article came out, i raced to that local doctor's office. he refused the drugs for months but he saw i was seriously suicidal and needed something. i couldnt take anymore. i spent days crying, rocking, clutching my head. it was unbearable. i had already paid to be considered for euthanasia in switzerland. finally, the doctor agreed to a 1-montn trial of AZT. it helped. eventually, he let me add the other drugs. i am a little better now. i am still very sick and to an onlooker, i would seem about the same as before....but it has made the disease at least bearable for now. also, one of my inflammatory markers, elastase, has normalized. it has never been normal before, always through the roof. my drug plan, which i will likely lose next year, pays for the drugs. however, generic AZT is about $170/month, Isentress and Tenofovir can be had with patient assistance programs through the drug company if you quality. i think they also may be available in generic form from overseas (india, etc.). i realize not everyone can obtain the drugs right now.....but thats my story. -s ________________________________ From: marti_zavala <marti_zavala@...> Sent: Sat, August 7, 2010 11:31:27 AM Subject: Re: XMRV...and cancers...  Unlike several people on the list, I don't have a good doctor to go to. I have two good ones that help me a little but they are not good ME/CFIDS docs - they aren't even poor ones - they don't make the grade at all. All I have is mainstream medicine with Medicare. I don't even have the money for my meds and supplements. I could not afford most CFIDS docs. I was shocked to read that Dr. Klimas is covered by Medicare and would be so cheap (excluding the travel) which I am willing to do but not always able, physically and financially. But to see her would require an out of network referral and that just doesn't happen in my world. If I go straight Medicare, I would not need a referral, but I would have to pay for all of my prescriptions, which I cannot do. Catch-22. I also think it is premature to be asking for treatment. I think it is too early. Some studies are needed before we start experimenting with some serious drugs. But, in regards to a test, I can badger my docs for a TEST and that would be futile. And even if they agreed to request the test, I would have to pay out of pocket for it - which I cannot do. So, I am curious, for those that are leading the way here, How do you do it? What am I missing? How are you finding these great docs? How are you paying for their services? How are you paying for the meds and supplements? Humbly, Marti > > i cannot believe more people are not badgering > their doctors for treatment. > -s Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.