Guest guest Posted October 30, 2002 Report Posted October 30, 2002 Hi Olga, Sometimes I wonder who is really behind all the pad press that health substances and foods (i.e. soy) get. Is it in the best interest of drug and food companies who feel that they have to compete with holistic foods and medicines to find bad results for consummers of the health products? Who else would benefit from such findings? And how well can we trust these studies? As soon as a claim is made, be it good or bad, along comes another study to contradict it. Tracey lahra2000@... wrote: > In a message dated 10/29/02 1:03:42 PM Eastern Standard Time, > writes: > > << that Echinacea is not good for M.E. patients to use. They did not > give > citations. >> > > I don't know why it would not be good. I have had excellent results > with > echinacea. > I used to get sick as soon as the weather got colder and would remain > mostly > ill for the winter with flu-like symptoms, but the echinacea totally > turned > it around for me, like a miracle! I take the liquid from Gaia herbs. > I also > noticed a significant increase in energy and stamina. > Olga > > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 30, 2002 Report Posted October 30, 2002 I too was wondering why they made that statement about echinacea and meant to email them about it and haven't yet. For I have used it when I feel a cold coming on or have been exposed to an infection, and though I can't show a cause and effect relationship, I never went on to get sick. The immune system is too diverse and complex to speak about it's being overactivated. I've heard and read lots to suggest strongly that it can be over- in some respects and under- in others, and that often in ME/CFS that's the very case. I don't know what E does to what aspect of the immune system; but I do know that docs have told me not to use it constantly; just for short periods when I need it to fend off a cold or flu or sore throat, etc. If I write NCF I'll ask. Fortunately, I get no reactions to E when I take it. But we should know what they know that led them to issue that statement. Judith Wisdom On Tue, 29 Oct 2002 17:53:09 +0200 " Yildiz " <ng2113@...> writes: I think it was because Echinacea stimulates the immune system.If immune system is over active at some stage of illness than Echinacea would not be good for that person.It depends if your immune system is over activated or underactivated.I remember trying it years ago.I had some allergic problems like running nose etc. It got worse after taking. E. so I stopped using it. Thanks Nil Echinacea | Hello, | I noticed in the latest newsletter of the National CFIDS/ME Foundation that | they said | that Echinacea is not good for M.E. patients to use. They did not give | citations. | Could someone give me some insight on this? | Thanks, | Steve Du Pre | Webpage: http://www.angelfire.com/jazz/isaiah40soaringeagle/index.html | " By words the mind is winged. " Aristophanes | | | This list is intended for patients to share personal experiences with each other, not to give medical advice. If you are interested in any treatment discussed here, please consult your doctor. | | Quote
Guest guest Posted December 19, 2002 Report Posted December 19, 2002 , can I forward this to another list? Echinacea I just emailed a friend of mine, who is an herbalist, about the recent Wisconsin study saying echinacea is ineffective in shortening the duration of colds. Here's what he had to say (I got permission to forward it)--I know it's been a topic of many of my lists and conversations lately. I especially like the distinctions about how important it is to take the correct form of echinacea for it to be effective. Sorry for those of you who might get this on multiple lists. L. Proud mom to Autumn 1-13-97 & Zoe 8-8-00 Talk with other hip mom's about attachment parenting at milwaukeeAPmoms-subscribe ----- Hi Troy and Jen Yes, I am aware of this study. Its yet another bit of herbal news that makes the news because it hits at something potentially fallible regarding herbs in general and echinacea specifically. The article released in the MJS at least stated that other forms of echinacea (teas/liquid extracts) might be more effective than the form used (capsules) in the study. This was an excellent and valid point. Most encapsulated herbs are basically worthless. This is so for a couple of reasons. Herbs are plants and in order for someone to get nutritional or medicinal value from an raw herb the herb MUST BE DIGESTED first. All digestion starts in the mouth with chewing/mixing-with-saliva. When an encapsulated herb is simply swallowed, it by-passes one of the first phases of digestion. If you take herb capsules on an empty stomach, the herbs may by-pass the stomach as well, another phase of digestion. Tableted froms of herbs may be a bit better because they at least get touched by saliva and will usually break down in the stomach (if a person's digestion is strong and healthy). Another downside of capsules is that herbs tend to lose their potency rapidly once they are ground and put in capsules. Even inside a capsule, the herb is exposed to oxygen and is in the process of breaking down. Dried herbs were once living plants and when that plant is picked it begins to decay immediately and continues that process over time until it is inert relative to its nutritional and medicinal attributes. This is ESPECIALLY true of echinacea. It degrades in capsule form faster than most other herbs; e.g., it loses ~60% potency the first year when in capsule form and is inert somewhere between 2-3 years. I NEVER use or recommend anyone else use echinacea in capsule form. Even in Traditional Ayurvedic Medicine and Traditional Chinese Medicine, most of the " pill " formulations found in those systems of medicine are made into a tablet form using a carrier (honey, ghee, raw milk, water, slippery elm powder, etc.) that is edible and plays a part in the therapeutic effect of the herb(s) being delivered. These " pills " are made to be chewed or sucked on, or at least come in contact with saliva and be tasted before swallowed. NOTE: " Tasting " an herb, or any food, is an essential part of therapy in that it tells your body what's coming and your body begins to respond to those signals because there is no herb that the body is not programmed to respond to...plants and humans are evolutionarily compatible and interdependent. If you want results with echinacea, use one of the following: 1. Chew fresh echinacea root 2. Chew dried echinacea root (root less than one year old is best) 3. Make a decoction from freshly dried echinacea root (dried root should be less than 1 year old) 4. Make an infusion from freshly dried echinacea flower tops and upper portion of plants from E. purpurea. 5. Use a tincture form of any species (a blend is best) of Echinacea (alcohol tinctures last 3-5 years) 6. Mix freshly ground echinacea powder with a carrier befitting of you personal constitution and form into small pills. Take as needed and chew them thoroughly. From a clinical research and clinical application standpoint, there is absolutely no doubt that properly prepared echinacea has a beneficial influence on the immune system. As the MJS article mentioned, there have been numerous studies in Europe showing echinacea to effective and safe when used for treating cold symptoms. Even more importantly, from a historical standpoint, the great Eclectic Physicians (they were based in Cincinnati, but had 10,000+ physicians nationally) of the 1800s used echinacea, very effectively, as one of their main remedies. Its even more impressive when you realize what they were using echinacea for. Today its marketed as a cold/flu remedy, but the great Eclectics Physicians were using it for sepsis (blood poisonings), non-healing sores, serious bacterial infections, etc. They only used it in two forms: as a tincture (primary use) and as a decoction (externally as a wash and internally). Hope that helps to clear the air relative to this immensely beneficial medicinal plant that we have available to us. Peace Quote
Guest guest Posted December 19, 2002 Report Posted December 19, 2002 I don't see why not! Jen ----- , can I forward this to another list? Quote
Guest guest Posted December 22, 2003 Report Posted December 22, 2003 The one I take is like 1100mg and the one I give the kids is only like 25. I thought it was such a difference. I wondered if there were any set amounts that were more beneficial. Bambi Re: Flu and pumping up the immune system I give what the bottle says to give, it all depends on the weight or age and the concentration of the Echinacea. The one I have has other ingredients with it, so its not Echinacea alone. If you get any echinacea for kids, I'm sure they tell you the dosage. If you only have the one for adults, then maybe you can find one for kids and look at how much they recommend for kids and do the calculation. Hope that helps. fourlittleblessings2love@... wrote: > How much echinacea do you give to kids? > Bambi > ----- Original Message ----- a.. Quote
Guest guest Posted October 6, 2004 Report Posted October 6, 2004 from Dale, Mom to Katy, CVID, age 20 I know that it's popular lately to just share opinions, and I can't provide you with the exact research paper that shows this information but I will state as clearly as I know how: Echinacea is NOT to be used with PID patients because it has been shown to boost the immune system. Now that sounds like a wonderful thing -- but for a patient with a minimally functioning immune system that could be the trigger to start autoimmune processes. In other words, give echinacea to an immune deficient person, and their immune system could be encouraged to start functioning -- but in the wrong way -- attacking self. Autoimmune complications are real and dangerous for our population. Please don't take that chance. I don't know how many times I've been told by well-meaning family and friends that all Katy needs is just a good cup of Echinacea tea and she wouldn't be sick all the time. Please, please avoid echinacea and any other alternative solution that is not approved by your clinical immunologist. In His service, Dale Quote
Guest guest Posted October 18, 2004 Report Posted October 18, 2004 Hi Tim, The best schedule for echinacea for me is none at all. It either increases my ME symptoms with no benefits at all or I notice no difference depending on the brand. Hope that you have better luck! With warmest regards, Annette ___________________________________________________________ALL-NEW Messenger - all new features - even more fun! http://uk.messenger. Quote
Guest guest Posted February 4, 2010 Report Posted February 4, 2010 Ok as many of you all know I'm taking the Hydrogen Peroxide to treate my HIV, aside from that I take Essiac, Cat's Claw, and Pau D'Arco. All serve a different purpose. However, I have always questioned echinacea. I have never taken it but when I google it, this has got to be the most Controversial natural product out there. Many big pharamaceutical companies are urging people not to take it. As they were saying about MMS and the Hydrogen Peroxide therapy. They are claiming it does more damage than good to HIV patients. Back when I was naive and on meds I wanted nothing to do with echinacea. I remember I was given an herbal throat spray for my singing and it contained echinacea and I freaked out. I just find it odd that many things that have help people like the Hydrogen Peroxide Therapy and MMS the FDA is quick to interfere, same thing with this natural product. I smell a cover up! We all know they like to cover up all the good natural things out there. As anyone here taken Echinacea before? Quote
Guest guest Posted February 4, 2010 Report Posted February 4, 2010 Hi Don, I took echinacea quite a bit in the early years after I became HIV+. At some point I stopped it, probably because of the articles you mention that claim it helps hiv reproduce. I personally wouldn't hesitate to use it at all, although it isn't part of my regimen right now. Actually, I haven't been taking any of my supplements the last couple months--giving my liver a break, I guess. On 2/4/10, Don <donjuan69uni@...> wrote: > > > Ok as many of you all know I'm taking the Hydrogen Peroxide to treate my > HIV, aside from that I take Essiac, Cat's Claw, and Pau D'Arco. All serve a > different purpose. However, I have always questioned echinacea. I have > never taken it but when I google it, this has got to be the most > Controversial natural product out there. Many big pharamaceutical companies > are urging people not to take it. As they were saying about MMS and the > Hydrogen Peroxide therapy. They are claiming it does more damage than good > to HIV patients. Back when I was naive and on meds I wanted nothing to do > with echinacea. I remember I was given an herbal throat spray for my > singing and it contained echinacea and I freaked out. I just find it odd > that many things that have help people like the Hydrogen Peroxide Therapy > and MMS the FDA is quick to interfere, same thing with this natural > product. I smell a cover up! We all know they like to cover up all the > good natural things out there. As anyone here taken Echinacea before? Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.