Guest guest Posted November 27, 2000 Report Posted November 27, 2000 Is anyone taking echinacea? Is it contraindicated in any way? a Quote
Guest guest Posted November 28, 2000 Report Posted November 28, 2000 I don't know what the medical thinking is about echinacea, but I do know that when I take echinacea, my FM symptoms flare up worse, every time. But then I usually am taking echinacea when I'm fighting an illness, and it might just be the illness that makes me feel worse. I know that echinacea isn't recommended for people with autoimmune disorders, and some people consider FM to be an autoimmune disorder. I am more CFS than FM, so I'm not sure if CFS would be considered an autoimmune disorder or not. lindaj@... Re: echinacea > Is anyone taking echinacea? Is it contraindicated in any way? a > Quote
Guest guest Posted November 28, 2000 Report Posted November 28, 2000 I believe Echinacea is contraindicated in those with autoimmune disorders. Steve B. Re: echinacea > Is anyone taking echinacea? Is it contraindicated in any way? a > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted November 28, 2000 Report Posted November 28, 2000 Dear LInda, Dr. Weil, writes of using of echinacea at the *begining* of a respiratory infection to reduce symtoms and length of illness. You are right that some people - specifically those with lupus, should not take this herb because it will produce autoantibodies. The rheumatologists have claimed FMS as their territory and *might* see this as an autoimmune process. My Rheum lumps both CFS/FMS together for most part, and, to me, the there still are too many unknowns to classify either in hard catagories - MHO only. I haven't yet found a resolution to chronic respiratory infections although I'm doing major house cleaning, allergy shots, and am taking the post about fungal sinusitus to all doctors I deal with. I did have remission from these this past year when I started tx for lyme, in which in addition to antibotics, I took difulcan everyday. Don't know which worked though, but I am checking in with LLMD next week. Wish me luck and I wish the same to you! take care >I don't know what the medical thinking is about echinacea, but I do know >that when I take echinacea, my FM symptoms flare up worse, every time. But >then I usually am taking echinacea when I'm fighting an illness, and it >might just be the illness that makes me feel worse. I know that echinacea >isn't recommended for people with autoimmune disorders, and some people >consider FM to be an autoimmune disorder. I am more CFS than FM, so I'm not >sure if CFS would be considered an autoimmune disorder or not. > > >lindaj@... Quote
Guest guest Posted November 28, 2000 Report Posted November 28, 2000 > Is anyone taking echinacea? Is it contraindicated in any way? a > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted November 28, 2000 Report Posted November 28, 2000 Hi a! My ND adds echinacea (along with ginseng and thyroid) to my vitamin drips (Meyer's Cocktails). These drips were helping me. (...not getting any more due to cost.) Kind regards, Trudy Message: 2 Date: Tue, 28 Nov 2000 07:02:36 EST From: StarDantzer@... Subject: Re: echinacea Is anyone taking echinacea? Is it contraindicated in any way? a Quote
Guest guest Posted November 29, 2000 Report Posted November 29, 2000 I took echinacea for 6 months or so with no discrnable effect. If you have poor digestion like me, it may just gunk up your intestines without boosting your immune system. I would try 5-10 other things before ech. Mike > I don't know what the medical thinking is about echinacea, but I do know > that when I take echinacea, my FM symptoms flare up worse, every time. But > then I usually am taking echinacea when I'm fighting an illness, and it > might just be the illness that makes me feel worse. I know that echinacea > isn't recommended for people with autoimmune disorders, and some people > consider FM to be an autoimmune disorder. I am more CFS than FM, so I'm not > sure if CFS would be considered an autoimmune disorder or not. > > > lindaj@h... > > Re: echinacea > > > > Is anyone taking echinacea? Is it contraindicated in any way? a > > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 8, 2000 Report Posted December 8, 2000 I read that echinacea stimultes TH2 ;it's somehwre on Konlee's website. Phil lindaj@... wrote: > I don't know what the medical thinking is about echinacea, but I do know > that when I take echinacea, my FM symptoms flare up worse, every time. But > then I usually am taking echinacea when I'm fighting an illness, and it > might just be the illness that makes me feel worse. I know that echinacea > isn't recommended for people with autoimmune disorders, and some people > consider FM to be an autoimmune disorder. I am more CFS than FM, so I'm not > sure if CFS would be considered an autoimmune disorder or not. Quote
Guest guest Posted October 12, 2001 Report Posted October 12, 2001 Echinacea > Does anyone know how I go about getting Echinacea Medi-Herb by Standard > Process? I was just at there website and it seems you have to be a > " qualified health care practitioner " to order from them. Someone posted > recently that this was the best Enchinacea and I just ran out of what I've > been using. Rose Rose, Unfortunately for people who aren't in the health field, one must have a Standard Process account in order to purchase both Standard Process supplements and Medi-Herb herbal tinctures, which Standard Process distributes. I suggest finding a chiropractor in your area. Sometimes, health food stores have a nutritional consultant or similar person on staff, so they order the supplements and sell them off the shelf. Here's a tip for people who don't have access to Medi-Herb Echinacea: All potent Echinacea will tingle in the mouth so much that the tongue will almost become numb. If your brand of Echinacea doesn't do this, it doesn't contain the desired phytochemicals and therefore won't work. Nina Quote
Guest guest Posted October 12, 2001 Report Posted October 12, 2001 Echinacea > Does anyone know how I go about getting Echinacea Medi-Herb by Standard > Process? I was just at there website and it seems you have to be a > " qualified health care practitioner " to order from them. Someone posted > recently that this was the best Enchinacea and I just ran out of what I've > been using. Rose Rose, Unfortunately for people who aren't in the health field, one must have a Standard Process account in order to purchase both Standard Process supplements and Medi-Herb herbal tinctures, which Standard Process distributes. I suggest finding a chiropractor in your area. Sometimes, health food stores have a nutritional consultant or similar person on staff, so they order the supplements and sell them off the shelf. Here's a tip for people who don't have access to Medi-Herb Echinacea: All potent Echinacea will tingle in the mouth so much that the tongue will almost become numb. If your brand of Echinacea doesn't do this, it doesn't contain the desired phytochemicals and therefore won't work. Nina Quote
Guest guest Posted October 12, 2001 Report Posted October 12, 2001 Has anyone tried DR Schulz's Echinacia? 1-800 HERBDOC He claims that his added habanero peppers increase the blood and lymph circulation which makes his formula 10x more effective than Echinachia by itself.( His words, not mine) Christel Quote
Guest guest Posted October 12, 2001 Report Posted October 12, 2001 Has anyone tried DR Schulz's Echinacia? 1-800 HERBDOC He claims that his added habanero peppers increase the blood and lymph circulation which makes his formula 10x more effective than Echinachia by itself.( His words, not mine) Christel Quote
Guest guest Posted October 12, 2001 Report Posted October 12, 2001 Has anyone tried DR Schulz's Echinacia? 1-800 HERBDOC He claims that his added habanero peppers increase the blood and lymph circulation which makes his formula 10x more effective than Echinachia by itself.( His words, not mine) Christel Quote
Guest guest Posted October 12, 2001 Report Posted October 12, 2001 > Here's a tip for people who don't have access to Medi-Herb Echinacea: All > potent Echinacea will tingle in the mouth so much that the tongue will > almost become numb. If your brand of Echinacea doesn't do this, it doesn't > contain the desired phytochemicals and therefore won't work. > > Nina Dr. Shulze's echinacea tincture makes my mouth tingle like crazy. No other echinacea I've tried (have only tried maybe 8 or 10) even comes close. Dave Quote
Guest guest Posted October 12, 2001 Report Posted October 12, 2001 > Here's a tip for people who don't have access to Medi-Herb Echinacea: All > potent Echinacea will tingle in the mouth so much that the tongue will > almost become numb. If your brand of Echinacea doesn't do this, it doesn't > contain the desired phytochemicals and therefore won't work. > > Nina Dr. Shulze's echinacea tincture makes my mouth tingle like crazy. No other echinacea I've tried (have only tried maybe 8 or 10) even comes close. Dave Quote
Guest guest Posted October 12, 2001 Report Posted October 12, 2001 > Here's a tip for people who don't have access to Medi-Herb Echinacea: All > potent Echinacea will tingle in the mouth so much that the tongue will > almost become numb. If your brand of Echinacea doesn't do this, it doesn't > contain the desired phytochemicals and therefore won't work. > > Nina Dr. Shulze's echinacea tincture makes my mouth tingle like crazy. No other echinacea I've tried (have only tried maybe 8 or 10) even comes close. Dave Quote
Guest guest Posted October 13, 2001 Report Posted October 13, 2001 Gaia is on the shelf at Wild Oats. I won't buy it so haven't even priced it. SaraLou echinacea In a message dated 10/12/01 8:14:36 PM Eastern Daylight Time, oxyplus writes: << Dr. Shulze's echinacea tincture makes my mouth tingle like crazy. No other echinacea I've tried (have only tried maybe 8 or 10) even comes close. >> I use the tincture from Gaia herbs. I'm not sure where to buy it, because I get it from my holistic doctor. It costs 100.00 for EIGHT ounces, and that lasts a long time. I think you can get it cheaper through N.E.E.D.S. but they don't always have it. It certainly burns and tingles, tastes hideous, so I know it must be good stuff! Quote
Guest guest Posted October 13, 2001 Report Posted October 13, 2001 Gaia is on the shelf at Wild Oats. I won't buy it so haven't even priced it. SaraLou echinacea In a message dated 10/12/01 8:14:36 PM Eastern Daylight Time, oxyplus writes: << Dr. Shulze's echinacea tincture makes my mouth tingle like crazy. No other echinacea I've tried (have only tried maybe 8 or 10) even comes close. >> I use the tincture from Gaia herbs. I'm not sure where to buy it, because I get it from my holistic doctor. It costs 100.00 for EIGHT ounces, and that lasts a long time. I think you can get it cheaper through N.E.E.D.S. but they don't always have it. It certainly burns and tingles, tastes hideous, so I know it must be good stuff! Quote
Guest guest Posted October 13, 2001 Report Posted October 13, 2001 Gaia is on the shelf at Wild Oats. I won't buy it so haven't even priced it. SaraLou echinacea In a message dated 10/12/01 8:14:36 PM Eastern Daylight Time, oxyplus writes: << Dr. Shulze's echinacea tincture makes my mouth tingle like crazy. No other echinacea I've tried (have only tried maybe 8 or 10) even comes close. >> I use the tincture from Gaia herbs. I'm not sure where to buy it, because I get it from my holistic doctor. It costs 100.00 for EIGHT ounces, and that lasts a long time. I think you can get it cheaper through N.E.E.D.S. but they don't always have it. It certainly burns and tingles, tastes hideous, so I know it must be good stuff! Quote
Guest guest Posted October 29, 2002 Report Posted October 29, 2002 I think it was because Echinacea stimulates the immune system.If immune system is over active at some stage of illness than Echinacea would not be good for that person.It depends if your immune system is over activated or underactivated.I remember trying it years ago.I had some allergic problems like running nose etc. It got worse after taking. E. so I stopped using it. Thanks Nil Echinacea | Hello, | I noticed in the latest newsletter of the National CFIDS/ME Foundation that | they said | that Echinacea is not good for M.E. patients to use. They did not give | citations. | Could someone give me some insight on this? | Thanks, | Steve Du Pre | Webpage: http://www.angelfire.com/jazz/isaiah40soaringeagle/index.html | " By words the mind is winged. " Aristophanes | | | This list is intended for patients to share personal experiences with each other, not to give medical advice. If you are interested in any treatment discussed here, please consult your doctor. | | Quote
Guest guest Posted October 29, 2002 Report Posted October 29, 2002 Hi All, I also had overly stimulating experiences from Echinacea to the degree that I can't really take it. Mike Quote
Guest guest Posted October 29, 2002 Report Posted October 29, 2002 Hi Steve, I've used echinacea for years whenever I get a cold. It works for me and never made me more sick. I also stopped getting strept throat (which was occuring up to 5 times a year) once I started using echinacea. I was exposed alot becauseI taught in primary school. I don't know if that was a coincidence or not but it works for me! Tracey Du Pre wrote: > Hello, > I noticed in the latest newsletter of the National CFIDS/ME Foundation > that > they said > that Echinacea is not good for M.E. patients to use. They did not > give > citations. > Could someone give me some insight on this? > Thanks, > Steve Du Pre > Webpage: http://www.angelfire.com/jazz/isaiah40soaringeagle/index.html > > " By words the mind is winged. " Aristophanes > > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 29, 2002 Report Posted October 29, 2002 Tracey Kristal wrote: > > > > > Hi Steve, > > I've used echinacea for years whenever I get a cold. It works for me > and never made me more sick. I also stopped getting strept throat > (which was occuring up to 5 times a year) once I started using > echinacea. I was exposed alot becauseI taught in primary school. I > don't know if that was a coincidence or not but it works for me! Btw, I don't use it for the every day sore throat that we have with ME, I use a throat spray with calendula and arnica montana for that. > Tracey > > > > > > > > > Du Pre wrote: > > > Hello, > > I noticed in the latest newsletter of the National CFIDS/ME > Foundation > > that > > they said > > that Echinacea is not good for M.E. patients to use. They did not > > give > > citations. > > Could someone give me some insight on this? > > Thanks, > > Steve Du Pre > > Webpage: > http://www.angelfire.com/jazz/isaiah40soaringeagle/index.html > > > > " By words the mind is winged. " Aristophanes > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 29, 2002 Report Posted October 29, 2002 Hi Kathy, You know, there was this brand for echinacea tincture I used to be able to get for years and then suddenly I couldn't find it anymore and I couldn't remember the brand name. I liked it because it was sweet and mild, now all I can find is really harsh tasting stuff. I use the Eclectic Institute (pink label) mostly now, although I just buy whatever I can find and I've tried different products but can't find anything that resembles that sweet stuff I used to get. I know super echinacea is super harsh and I don't think it's necessarily better. I like echinacea tea by Traditional Medicinals (all their teas are great) too. The throat spray I use is called " Sore Throat Spray " by Similasan. I use it all the time at night and in the morning and only half the bottle is gone and it's been a year! It expires in 2004. A very good deal. It works straight away or has a delayed response but does the trick and three sprays is all that's needed at a time. Tracey polkadot@... wrote: > - > > Regarding the Echinacea...what form do you take and how often? > > The sore throat spray...what product is working for you? > > Thanks > > Kathy > > > Re: Echinacea > > > > > > > > Tracey Kristal wrote: > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Hi Steve, > > > > > > I've used echinacea for years whenever I get a cold. It works for > me > > > and never made me more sick. I also stopped getting strept throat > > > > (which was occuring up to 5 times a year) once I started using > > > echinacea. I was exposed alot becauseI taught in primary school. > I > > > don't know if that was a coincidence or not but it works for me! > > > > Btw, I don't use it for the every day sore throat that we have with > ME, > > I use a throat spray with calendula and arnica montana for that. > > > > > Tracey > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Du Pre wrote: > > > > > > > Hello, > > > > I noticed in the latest newsletter of the National CFIDS/ME > > > Foundation > > > > that > > > > they said > > > > that Echinacea is not good for M.E. patients to use. They did > not > > > > give > > > > citations. > > > > Could someone give me some insight on this? > > > > Thanks, > > > > Steve Du Pre > > > > Webpage: > > > http://www.angelfire.com/jazz/isaiah40soaringeagle/index.html > > > > > > > > " By words the mind is winged. " Aristophanes > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 29, 2002 Report Posted October 29, 2002 Thanks for the info Tracey. Boy, I never thought to consider Similasan...I use their eyedrops 1 & 2 and really like them. In looking at their website, they make a bunch of products including this spray. I am going to order some tomorrow. Thanks again. Kathy Re: Echinacea > > > > > > > > > > > > > Tracey Kristal wrote: > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Hi Steve, > > > > > > > > I've used echinacea for years whenever I get a cold. It works for > > me > > > > and never made me more sick. I also stopped getting strept throat > > > > > > (which was occuring up to 5 times a year) once I started using > > > > echinacea. I was exposed alot becauseI taught in primary school. > > I > > > > don't know if that was a coincidence or not but it works for me! > > > > > > Btw, I don't use it for the every day sore throat that we have with > > ME, > > > I use a throat spray with calendula and arnica montana for that. > > > > > > > Tracey > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Du Pre wrote: > > > > > > > > > Hello, > > > > > I noticed in the latest newsletter of the National CFIDS/ME > > > > Foundation > > > > > that > > > > > they said > > > > > that Echinacea is not good for M.E. patients to use. They did > > not > > > > > give > > > > > citations. > > > > > Could someone give me some insight on this? > > > > > Thanks, > > > > > Steve Du Pre > > > > > Webpage: > > > > http://www.angelfire.com/jazz/isaiah40soaringeagle/index.html > > > > > > > > > > " By words the mind is winged. " Aristophanes > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.