Guest guest Posted December 22, 2010 Report Posted December 22, 2010 , The Adrenal Antibodies may or may not be present in Primary AD. By the time of dx - most of the adrenals are gone/ atrophied and therefore not able to produce a high # of antibodies anymore. A basic GP should understand this principle. Have you contacted the s Disease Self Help Group? http://www.addisons.org.uk/topics/mt_index.html Jane > > Hi Sheila, > > I did show him the ASI test and the emails and presention from Genova, (as I have read that people on here have done that), but he shook his head and said it was not recognised by the NHS and that he couldnt take it into account thats why he had me do the first SST test. > > My GP referred me to him when Dr A B from Birmingham hospital(off your list) said he wouldnt tret me and didnt recoginize T3 as a treatment or the ASI test! Im not sure where that leaves me now or whom to go to from here? I live in East Staffordshire - does anyone have any ideas please? > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 22, 2010 Report Posted December 22, 2010 , Other Tests * Adrenocorticotropic hormone (ACTH) stimulation test o Note: In emergent situations, do not delay treatment of presumed adrenal insufficiency during diagnostic testing. Treatment with dexamethasone allows ACTH stimulation testing without affecting or interfering with the measurement of serum cortisol levels. http://emedicine.medscape.com/article/765753-diagnosis > > > > What your endo. should be doing is to prescribe between 25 and 50mcg of > > Dexamethasone which is roughly equivalent to 20mg of cortisol - Quote
Guest guest Posted December 22, 2010 Report Posted December 22, 2010 Hi there Can I ask - does the short senacten test have to show the cortisol doubling then each time the bloods are taken? Not sure if I have read what you are saying correctly so forgive me if I have gone off at a tangent. best wishes Mandy Quote
Guest guest Posted December 22, 2010 Report Posted December 22, 2010 In healthy individuals, the cortisol level should double from a baseline of 20-30 ug/dl within 60 minutes. For example, if the serum cortisol level was 25 ug/dl before the stimulation, it should reach at least 50 ug/dl. (me: please note ! some labs use nmol/dl rather than ug/dl ..... conversion nmol/L to ug/dL : divide by 27.59) Hi and all – and calling on Lethal Lee, if you were around.... I just re-read my last post to you, , and noticed that a typo has crept in – please see above ... this should read nmol/L and not nmol/dl... – sorry. But when reading about the conversion rate, I got puzzled. Personally I have no knowledge or understanding about conversion rates, and the figure of 27.59 for cortisol originates from a link that Lethal Lee had kindly provided in an earlier thread http://www.addisons-network.co.uk/ad_tests.html I checked the figure against the table and it is as L.L. said ...so I assume that this conversion rate is correct. However, when I read that the Wiki link regards a healthy cortisol level as (for example) 25 ug/dl, I am now very confused.... 25 ug/dl = 689.75 nmol/L, which according to the NHS ref range for cortisol that I have been given seems to be a high figure. The ref range on my own lab copy states a norm range of 140 – 690 nmol/L ... my own am cortisol level at last count had been 353 nmol/L, which I always thought was an ok-figure. I recall reading in some article that the critical level for am cortisol would be below 150 nmol/L ..... have I dreamt this?? I would be grateful if someone could please tell me what a *normal* and healthy level of a morning cortisol figure should be in nmol/L ? A thoroughly confused Quote
Guest guest Posted December 23, 2010 Report Posted December 23, 2010 Who would we write to find out why the NHS medical practitioners are REFUSING to take test results from private laboratories into account when treating their patients, especially when the NHS doesn't even do a 24 hour salivary adrenal profile to see where our cortisol and DHEA levels lie at four specific times during the day. It is appalling that such practitioners are leaving their patients suffering and not treating them. WHO SAID that they cannot take such results from a highly respected firm such as Genova into account. I would ask your endocrinologist that question - I bet he won't be able to give you an answer. I think the last 'guidance' from the RCP and BTA on the diagnosing and management of primary hypothyroidism has scared quite a few doctors off prescribing T3, but I think we have to do battle with them and demand they show us the evidence to show that nobody needs any form of T3 thyroid hormone replacement - or needs their adrenals boosting. Luv - Sheila Hi Sheila, I did show him the ASI test and the emails and presention from Genova, (as I have read that people on here have done that), but he shook his head and said it was not recognised by the NHS and that he couldnt take it into account thats why he had me do the first SST test. My GP referred me to him when Dr A B from Birmingham hospital(off your list) said he wouldnt tret me and didnt recoginize T3 as a treatment or the ASI test! Im not sure where that leaves me now or whom to go to from here? I live in East Staffordshire - does anyone have any ideas please? kind regards > > Ask your endo. to tell you exactly why he doesn't recognise the ASI test and > give him a copy of the attached to show that Genova Diagnostics are a very > highly recommended laboratory around the world. If he doesn't know how to > properly carry out a short synacthen test and disregards your adrenal 24 > hour profile, I think it is time you moved on to somebody who has done their > research and put your health into their hands. This man simply isn't > interested in knowing the true facts. > > Luv - Sheila > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 23, 2010 Report Posted December 23, 2010 Does this help - there is a full paper on this Abstract Objective: Assessment of the hypothalamic–pituitary–adrenal (HPA) axis relies on the interpretation of serum (total) cortisol in response to dynamic tests of the HPA axis. Most cortisol is bound to cortisolbinding globulin (CBG) and serum total cortisol levels are significantly affected by variation in CBG. We hypothesised that CBG variation significantly affects interpretation of dynamic tests of the HPA axis. Design: We investigated the effect of CBG variation on the outcome of the 250 mg short Synacthen test (SST) in 30 healthy adults. Methods: Blood was sampled at time 230, 0 (at which point Synacthen was given) and +30 min. CBG and total cortisol were measured at each time-point. Integrity of the HPA axis was confirmed by measurement of urine cortisol. Results: We found that CBG varied significantly within individuals, falling from 51^3:4 to 43^ 3:2mg=ml .P , 0:0001. on changing from standing to lying. Total cortisol levels strongly correlated with CBG .r . 0:88; P , 0:0001.: Thirteen subjects had a +30 min total cortisol ,550 nmol/l. In these subjects, the CBG levels at each time-point were significantly lower compared with subjects who had a +30 min total cortisol of .550 nmol/l .P , 0:05.: To correct for variation in CBG we calculated the total cortisol:CBG ratio and found no significant difference in the +30 min ratio between these two groups. Conclusion: CBG varies significantly within and between individuals. This is accompanied by changes in serum total cortisol large enough to affect the outcome of an SST and, by implication, other tests of the HPA axis. European Journal of Endocrinology 146 231–235 http://www.eje-online.org/cgi/reprint/146/2/231.pdf However, when I read that the Wiki link regards a healthy cortisol level as (for example) 25 ug/dl, I am now very confused.... 25 ug/dl = 689.75 nmol/L, which according to the NHS ref range for cortisol that I have been given seems to be a high figure. The ref range on my own lab copy states a norm range of 140 – 690 nmol/L ... my own am cortisol level at last count had been 353 nmol/L, which I always thought was an ok-figure. I recall reading in some article that the critical level for am cortisol would be below 150 nmol/L ..... have I dreamt this?? I would be grateful if someone could please tell me what a *normal* and healthy level of a morning cortisol figure should be in nmol/L ? A thoroughly confused Quote
Guest guest Posted December 23, 2010 Report Posted December 23, 2010 In summary, we have shown that serum total cortisol correlates with CBG, and that CBG varies significantly between individuals and within individuals between standing and lying. This normal variation in CBG is accompanied by changes in serum total cortisol, which can be large enough to affect the outcome of the SST and, by implication, other tests dependent on measured serum total cortisol. We have only examined the effect of CBG variation on the SST. The effect of CBG variation on the outcome of an ITT is clearly an important area that warrants further investigation. More importantly, our work needs to be extended to patients with pituitary disease and patients on steroid therapy. Nonetheless, our data suggest that serum cortisol levels should be interpreted with reference to the CBG. Oh Lordy..... and I thought proof-reading Pete's thesis was a challenge for the old grey matter - LOL - thanks for that, Sheila, now I am just that little bit more confused <g> Let me see if I've got this right....so there are no "normal" serum cortisol levels, because the interpretation of what is "normal" depends on our cortisol binding globulin (CBG) and those levels in turn vary significantly between the patient standing or lying down and those variations are big enough to affect the outcome of a short Synacthen test... great! And just to complicate matters, reports from members telling us about their test experience varies from them lying down for the duration of the test to wandering about the place after the ACTH hormone got injected and to come back 30 mins later for the final blood draw .... now that makes it all as clear as mud! No wonder endos don't know how to interpret a Synacthen test ..... However, for the sake of some clarification I gather from this article and the NHS handbook guidelines that for a (more or less) meaningful interpretation of an SST a patient who fulfils 3 given criteria, namely – a) the test is performed at 9 am the stimulated cortisol level rises above 550 nmol/L c) the incremental rise from the cortisol baseline level after 30 minutes is greater than 170 nmol/L - he or she can be given the `all clear' for having passed the test. For anyone not having made that hurdle, the result is inconclusive and needs further investigation. Given the NHS guideline figure of > 500 nmol/L and the necessity for an incremental rise of more than 170 nmol/L for a 9 o'clock morning short Synacthen Test to me indicates that a *normal* baseline cortisol level has to be a level above 380 nmol/L - give or take the CBG implication, of course..... – am I on the right track, Sheila ??? But even if I were, I am still puzzled why Wiki would state 20-30 ug/dl as the "norm" for a `healthy' cortisol level ? With love from a not much wiser, but very grateful for the article, xx Quote
Guest guest Posted December 23, 2010 Report Posted December 23, 2010 Can I ask - does the short senacten test have to show the cortisol doubling then each time the bloods are taken? Not sure if I have read what you are saying correctly so forgive me if I have gone off at a tangent. Hi Mandy, Not a doubling each time blood is taken (which is after 30 mins and sometimes – but not always - again after 60 mins) – but according to Wiki the baseline cortisol level should at least double after 1 hour in order to get a `normal' result. But doubling alone is not the only criteria apparently, the baseline cortisol level should also be within a given ref range for a `normal' result .... according to Wiki that would be 20-30 ug/dl, which (at the given conversion rate of 27.59) constitutes a much higher nmol/L figure than the NHS handbook guidelines state. I would imagine that the NHS guidelines carry a higher degree of relevancy, but as far as I can make out from the article Sheila has posted, even their figures are subject to certain conditions..... To my mind, I think that the theory of doubling cortisol levels 1 hour after injection of ACTH as a measure of a `normal' result is probably correct, only I find the actual stated figures in either value – nmol/L or ug/dl - extremely confusing. Love, Quote
Guest guest Posted December 24, 2010 Report Posted December 24, 2010 Yes, you are on the right track - but it is all very complicated. It does seem that the people carrying out these SSI's have not been taught the correct protocol or not following the correct protocol and somebody, somewhere needs to get this rectified, otherwise, there are going to be many cases of adrenal insufficiency missed and they are being left to suffer without a correct diagnosis. We need a simplified version of the correct procedure put into our Files and even on to our web site so anybody going for a short synacthen test knows exactly what must be done and if it is not being done, are able to question those doing the test as to why not. , in the New Year, is this something you would be willing to take on and create a concise, easily understood and correct protocol citing references, which cannot be disputed. Our Aims and Objects are, after all, to help in the further education of medical practitioners and it is vitally important that our members understand how this works. Luv - Sheila Let me see if I've got this right....so there are no " normal " serum cortisol levels, because the interpretation of what is " normal " depends on our cortisol binding globulin (CBG) and those levels in turn vary significantly between the patient standing or lying down and those variations are big enough to affect the outcome of a short Synacthen test... great! And just to complicate matters, reports from members telling us about their test experience varies from them lying down for the duration of the test to wandering about the place after the ACTH hormone got injected and to come back 30 mins later for the final blood draw .... now that makes it all as clear as mud! No wonder endos don't know how to interpret a Synacthen test ..... However, for the sake of some clarification I gather from this article and the NHS handbook guidelines that for a (more or less) meaningful interpretation of an SST a patient who fulfils 3 given criteria, namely – a) the test is performed at 9 am the stimulated cortisol level rises above 550 nmol/L c) the incremental rise from the cortisol baseline level after 30 minutes is greater than 170 nmol/L - he or she can be given the `all clear' for having passed the test. For anyone not having made that hurdle, the result is inconclusive and needs further investigation. Given the NHS guideline figure of > 500 nmol/L and the necessity for an incremental rise of more than 170 nmol/L for a 9 o'clock morning short Synacthen Test to me indicates that a *normal* baseline cortisol level has to be a level above 380 nmol/L - give or take the CBG implication, of course..... – am I on the right track, Sheila ??? But even if I were, I am still puzzled why Wiki would state 20-30 ug/dl as the " norm " for a `healthy' cortisol level ? With love from a not much wiser, but very grateful for the article, xx Quote
Guest guest Posted December 24, 2010 Report Posted December 24, 2010 Does the Wiki article cite references to the science ? Luv - Sheila Can I ask - does the short senacten test have to show the cortisol doubling then each time the bloods are taken? Not sure if I have read what you are saying correctly so forgive me if I have gone off at a tangent. Hi Mandy, Not a doubling each time blood is taken (which is after 30 mins and sometimes – but not always - again after 60 mins) – but according to Wiki the baseline cortisol level should at least double after 1 hour in order to get a `normal' result. But doubling alone is not the only criteria apparently, the baseline cortisol level should also be within a given ref range for a `normal' result .... according to Wiki that would be 20-30 ug/dl, which (at the given conversion rate of 27.59) constitutes a much higher nmol/L figure than the NHS handbook guidelines state. I would imagine that the NHS guidelines carry a higher degree of relevancy, but as far as I can make out from the article Sheila has posted, even their figures are subject to certain conditions..... To my mind, I think that the theory of doubling cortisol levels 1 hour after injection of ACTH as a measure of a `normal' result is probably correct, only I find the actual stated figures in either value – nmol/L or ug/dl - extremely confusing. Quote
Guest guest Posted December 24, 2010 Report Posted December 24, 2010 And to make mention that the Short Synacthen Test is a test for mainly Primary s Disease. The gold standard test for Secondary Addions ( ie pituitary) is the Insulin Stress Test or similar. CONCLUSIONS: Cortisol response to cosyntropin varies considerably among healthy persons. The cosyntropin test performs well in patients with primary adrenal insufficiency, but the lower sensitivity in patients with secondary adrenal insufficiency necessitates use of tests involving stimulation of the hypothalamus if the pretest probability is sufficiently high. The operating characteristics of the 250-microg and 1-microg cosyntropin tests are similar. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12899587?dopt=Abstract > > Does the Wiki article cite references to the science ? > > Luv - Sheila > > > > Can I ask - does the short senacten test have to show the cortisol doubling > then each time the bloods are taken? > > Not sure if I have read what you are saying correctly so forgive me if I > have gone off at a tangent. > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 24, 2010 Report Posted December 24, 2010 > Does the Wiki article cite references to the science ? > Luv - Sheila Yes, Sheila, the Wiki link does give references - .... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ACTH_stimulation_test and yes, I could try and put something together for our files about the Synacthen test, but it would have to be with the usual disclaimer, particularly bearing in mind that all I can say about this test and its interpretation is my own understanding of what I have read; it's all come from different sources and since the experts apparently are at odds with how this test should be done and how to interpret the results, I could not possible make any categorical statements - but like with all things, common sense should prevail and at least we can tell members what to look out for before having this test done ... - I will contact you privately beforehand, Sheila, I would not put anything in the files without your approval. Have a lovely, peaceful and healthy Christmas, everyone, with love, xx Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.