Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Re: T3 question - chest pain

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted

It could well be the T3 that was causing your problems . It

is possible that your body is now absorbing all the thyroid hormone with the HC

now properly in place and suddenly the dose you have been taking for so long

was found to be just too much so by cutting it back, you are able to cope with

less. I am guessing here, of course, there is no way of knowing at this

distance, but I have seen this happen so often.

However, you have not said how you really feel right now - do

you feel better on the dose you are taking at present?

Luv - Sheila

I wonder if I could trouble you to give me some advice please?

I've been taking T3 since 2006 after taking Armour and discovering that I am T4

intolerant (diagnosed by Dr P). I also take HC at 20mg per day. Last week I

started to have chest pain (with flushing lasting about 60 seconds, then nausea

and left hand tingling), and had about 10 episodes of it over the course of the

week. I reduced my T3 from 40mcg pd and upped my HC to 25mg pd. I did go to the

GP and he said he didnt know what the pain was took my temp (36.8), BP 140/70

(high for me normally 110/60) and listened to my chest and said my pulse was

normal. I had reduced my T3 by then. My symptoms seem to have settled now and I

am currently taking 15mcg T3 pd and 25mg HC pd. My question is - do you think

its related to the T3 and if so why has my body said I dont want as much now?

My iron levels are high and ferritin normal ( I dont have haemachromatosis - I

have had the gene test).

Any advice/comments would be very useful.

many thanks

P.s. Merry Christmas!

Posted

Hi Sheila,

Thanks for replying.

I do feel a bit better, temps 36.37 and pulse aroung mid 60's on waking but

still have joint pain, weakness and tiredness. Its odd how I have been taking

it for years and now its out of sync! This pain started on 6th December but

also odd that it was after I had the SST test on the 15th Nov and my B12

injection on the 19th Nov - coincidence?

Can it really happen that quickly and after so long?

Im seeing the NHS endo this afternoon - do you think it is worth mentioning it

to him or best to leave it alone - I dont want him to stop the T3 as I get this

on the NHS?

many thanks

>

> It could well be the T3 that was causing your problems . It is possible

> that your body is now absorbing all the thyroid hormone with the HC now

> properly in place and suddenly the dose you have been taking for so long was

> found to be just too much so by cutting it back, you are able to cope with

> less. I am guessing here, of course, there is no way of knowing at this

> distance, but I have seen this happen so often.

>

> However, you have not said how you really feel right now - do you feel

> better on the dose you are taking at present?

>

> Luv - Sheila

>

>

>

Posted

It could well be the short synacthen test that has kicked your

adrenals into action. I think at this stage, I would not tell the

endocrinologist - he might cut your T3 back, and this is something you can do

on your own if you feel the need. Are you sure you are not suffering with any

of the associated conditions that needs sorting out. See attached. Any one of

these could be causing you a problem. Alternatively the pain might not be

thyroid related.

Luv - Sheila

Thanks for replying.

I do feel a bit better, temps 36.37 and pulse aroung mid 60's on waking but

still have joint pain, weakness and tiredness. Its odd how I have been taking

it for years and now its out of sync! This pain started on 6th December but

also odd that it was after I had the SST test on the 15th Nov and my B12

injection on the 19th Nov - coincidence?

Can it really happen that quickly and after so long?

Im seeing the NHS endo this afternoon - do you think it is worth mentioning it

to him or best to leave it alone - I dont want him to stop the T3 as I get this

on the NHS?

many thanks

--- In

1 of 1 File(s)

WHY ISN'T LEVOTHYROXINE WORKING.doc

Posted

Hi Sheila, thanks for that link. Im sure that I have addressed these already

under Dr P as I have been a patient since 2006. But still not quite well. I

did have something similar when I tried to take Armour a couple of years ago,

which is why Dr P says I have conversion problems.

Interesting about what you say about the SST kicking my adrenals into action

when my result was so " odd " . Baseline 386, 30 mins 226. 60 mins 326. I did

feel dreadful afterwards and had to take it easy for the rest of the day after

the test as I felt very tired and dizzy.

Dont know what to think?!?

>

> It could well be the short synacthen test that has kicked your adrenals into

> action. I think at this stage, I would not tell the endocrinologist - he

> might cut your T3 back, and this is something you can do on your own if you

> feel the need. Are you sure you are not suffering with any of the associated

> conditions that needs sorting out. See attached. Any one of these could be

> causing you a problem. Alternatively the pain might not be thyroid related.

>

> Luv - Sheila

>

>

>

Posted

Remind us what action they said is needed at the hospital after

receiving such results for your short synacthen test ? I simply cannot

remember everybody's messages unfortunately

Luv - Sheila

Hi Sheila, thanks for that link. Im sure that I have addressed these already

under Dr P as I have been a patient since 2006. But still not quite well. I did

have something similar when I tried to take Armour a couple of years ago, which

is why Dr P says I have conversion problems.

Interesting about what you say about the SST kicking my adrenals into action

when my result was so " odd " . Baseline 386, 30 mins 226. 60 mins 326.

I did feel dreadful afterwards and had to take it easy for the rest of the day

after the test as I felt very tired and dizzy.

Dont know what to think?!?

Posted

Interesting about what you say about the SST kicking my adrenals into action when my result was so "odd". Baseline 386, 30 mins 226. 60 mins 326. I did feel dreadful afterwards and had to take it easy for the rest of the day after the test as I felt very tired and dizzy.

Hello ,

"Odd" is putting it mildly ....... Are you sure that those figures are the correct ones they gave you for your short Synacthen test, ? They seem extremely unlikely (impossible) to me, unless you had been taking steroids (other than Dexamethasone) or been on HRT or other sex hormone supplementation before or during the test, and that would render the test results invalid anyway.

After the blood draw for the baseline cortisol the injection of ACTH hormone is supposed to stimulate the adrenals into producing lots of cortisol – hence the cortisol figure would go UP and not down, as your figures apparently suggest. This does not make any sense whatsoever – at least not to me. If someone knows differently I would be grateful if you could enlighten me, as I have never heard of cortisol levels dropping during a SST. If you were given those figures, I can only assume that you were taking some kind of steroid or sex hormone which has messed with the figures..... and in that case the SST result would be invalid and tell you nothing at all.

Best wishes,

Posted

Hi Sheila,

The endo wrote to me to say the results were odd and suggested I " tail down " the

HC and retest. Anyway I wrote to him to quote the CKS pages suggesting that I

may have s and he immediately wrote to me to offer another appt.

I have been this afternoon and he has admitted that my results are not normal

(but I did take it into my our hands to take HC so he says- the ASI test very

low on cortisol and DHEA - endo says he doesnt accept those results)-but I have

said that I want his support. He says he will support me as long as I try and

reduce down the HC and retest at 15mg. I normally take 20mg pd. I mentioned

again about my hysterectomy 7 years ago and that the remaining ovary may have

failed and he has now suggested an adrenal antibody test.

Any way the bottom line is he has prescribed HC as he admits I need it and the

self injection kit!! :-) Im in the system now and at least he is giving me

some support although I have had to drag it out of him by writing to him and

copying PALS in like I have read about on this forum. Thats good news for me -

If I cant get down to 15mg I have to ring his secretary and we will take it from

there. Hes accepted me as his patient now and has prescribed and is going to

write to my GP so he can continue with the prescription.

What do you think?

>

> Remind us what action they said is needed at the hospital after receiving

> such results for your short synacthen test ? I simply cannot remember

> everybody's messages unfortunately

>

> Luv - Sheila

>

>

>

Posted

Hi ,

I was instructed by the endo to take my HC as normal the day before and last

dose to be taken at 3.30pm. He knows I was taking progesterone cream too.

He thinks that are odd and is testing my adrenal antibodies and wants me to

retake the test when on 15mg HC pd - currently 20mg per day.

What do you make of that? Ive read on hospital websites that you can still take

HC the day before the test.

>

>

> Interesting about what you say about the SST kicking my adrenals into

> action when my result was so " odd " . Baseline 386, 30 mins 226. 60 mins

> 326. I did feel dreadful afterwards and had to take it easy for the rest

> of the day after the test as I felt very tired and dizzy.

>

>

>

>

>

> Hello ,

>

> " Odd " is putting it mildly [#-o] [:-/] ....... Are you sure

> that those figures are the correct ones they gave you for your short

> Synacthen test, ? They seem extremely unlikely (impossible) to me,

> unless you had been taking steroids (other than Dexamethasone) or been

> on HRT or other sex hormone supplementation before or during the test,

> and that would render the test results invalid anyway.

>

> After the blood draw for the baseline cortisol the injection of ACTH

> hormone is supposed to stimulate the adrenals into producing lots of

> cortisol – hence the cortisol figure would go UP and not down, as

> your figures apparently suggest. This does not make any sense whatsoever

> – at least not to me. If someone knows differently I would be

> grateful if you could enlighten me, as I have never heard of cortisol

> levels dropping during a SST. If you were given those figures, I can

> only assume that you were taking some kind of steroid or sex hormone

> which has messed with the figures..... and in that case the SST result

> would be invalid and tell you nothing at all.

>

> Best wishes,

>

>

>

Posted

I was instructed by the endo to take my HC as normal the day before and lastdose to be taken at 3.30pm. He knows I was taking progesterone cream too.He thinks that are odd and is testing my adrenal antibodies and wants me toretake the test when on 15mg HC pd - currently 20mg per day.What do you make of that? Ive read on hospital websites that you can still takeHC the day before the test.

Hi ,

What do I make of that? ..... frankly - I think it will be a complete and utter waste of your time and their NHS money.

I would print out pages 48 and 49 of the below Endocrinology Handbook, hand it to your endo and question him what exactly he is trying to establish with this Synacthen test and ask how he will attempt an interpretation from the resulting figures. My guess is – he won't have a clue!

The handbook does state that a SST may be used to ascertain if the adrenals are still functioning normally after a prolonged course of corticosteroids at the end of such a course, but that is not the aim of the game for you (as I understand it). Presumably you are undergoing the SST to establish your adrenal function – full stop..... - and not your adrenal function after having taken a course of HC for an x-amount of time to deal with some disease or to check your adrenal function after the removal of a tumour. You are not taking HC as a treatment for some disease, you are taking HC because your adrenals are (presumably) not producing sufficient cortisol and are not strong enough to cope without exogenous intervention. You already know that they can't cope – you just want to know the extent of their failure. This is not something a SST will tell you as long as you are still taking (any amount of) HC or any other steroid (with the exception of Dexamathasone). You, if I understand the intention correctly, need to know if your adrenals are capable of working without any HC and not if your adrenals are back to working full capacity after a course of corticosteroids. I hope I am getting the difference over – I don't know how else to explain it more clearly.

http://dialspace.dial.pipex.com/town/estate/aquc35/book/Bible2010v1b.pdf

page 48:

ADRENAL INVESTIGATIONS

SHORT SYNACTHEN TEST

INDICATION

Used in the diagnosis of hypoadrenalism as a screening test.

It is an increasingly used alternative to the insulin tolerance test to diagnose secondary

hypoadrenalism due to pituitary hypofunction. However, it should not be used in the early postoperative

assessment of the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis (an insulin tolerance/glucagon stress

test should be used instead).

May also be used to ascertain that the adrenals are functioning normally after a prolonged course of

corticosteroids, or after suppression by Cushing's syndrome (e.g. after removal of a unilateral

Cushing's adrenal adenoma).

Diagnosis and characterisation of 21-hydroxylase deficiency and other causes of adrenal hyperplasia.

Diagnosis of non-classical congenital adrenal hyperplasia in the context of a hyperandrogenic woman,

if the morning follicular-phase baseline 17-hydroxyprogesterone is >6.0 nmol/l.

CONTRAINDICATIONS

Definitely not required for assessment of hypoadrenalism if random cortisol > 550nmol/l.

If a random cortisol >450, patients are very likely to pass the test, and some feel that in this

circumstance, the test is not usually warranted.

SIDE EFFECTS

None

PREPARATION

If on steroids ensure that none is taken the night prior to the test or on the morning of the test. The

final (me: final, to my mind, means last dose of a course of HC, not last dose for the day) dose of hydrocortisone should be at midday, on the day prior to the test.

HRT or any oestrogen should be discontinued for 6 weeks before the test.

What your endo wants you to do – reduce HC and repeat the test whilst still taking HC – to my mind does not make sense. In order to establish what is left of your adrenal function, you need to have that test having been off all HC and any other steroid (except for Dexamethasone) for a minimum of 6 weeks. With the best will in the world, I cannot see how anyone can draw a meaningful conclusion from a test result when the patient is still taking steroids.... at least that is how I understand this whole business.

Love,

Posted

Hi ,

Before my daughter had Synacthen test we had this discussion with her consultant

who wasn't an endo but had had some experience in testing adrenals. We had

information from a doctor friend of ours that HC would interfere with the

results of the test.

So the consultant rang the biochemist while we were in the room. The biochemist

put the consultant right and told him my daughter would have to take

dexamethasone for 5 days before the test. And this test did show low adrenal

function.

However now my daughter has finally seen an endo at another hospital he wants

her to slowly come off the HC and have another Synacthen test after she has been

off the steroids for 6 weeks. His view is any amount of steroids can effect the

test even inhalers for asthma.

Although I have had my disagreement with the biochemists (mainly because they

put a diagnosis on the test results when they haven't seen the patient) I do

think they are up to date with the tests they do.

Judy

>

>

> Hi ,

>

> I was instructed by the endo to take my HC as normal the day before and last

dose to be taken at 3.30pm. He knows I was taking progesterone cream too.

>

> He thinks that are odd and is testing my adrenal antibodies and wants me to

retake the test when on 15mg HC pd - currently 20mg per day.

>

> What do you make of that? Ive read on hospital websites that you can still

take HC the day before the test.

>

>

>

Posted

The correct procedure is to put a HC dependent person onto Dexamethasone for a

time ( weeks?) before the test. Dex will not show up in the blood sample the

same way and will not affect the results.

...................................................................

Adrenocorticotropic hormone (ACTH) stimulation test

* Note: In emergent situations, do not delay treatment of presumed adrenal

insufficiency during diagnostic testing. Treatment with dexamethasone allows

ACTH stimulation testing without affecting or interfering with the measurement

of serum cortisol levels.

* Obtain baseline serum cortisol and ACTH levels.

* Administer 0.25 mg (250 mcg) of cosyntropin (synthetic ACTH) intravenously

(IV) or intramuscularly (IM).

* Repeat cortisol levels every 30 minutes (some authors recommend 60 min)

and 6 hours after ACTH administration.

* Normal response is indicated when the cortisol level doubles in response

to ACTH stimulation.

* In adrenal insufficiency, serum cortisol levels fail to rise after ACTH

administration.

http://emedicine.medscape.com/article/765753-diagnosis

> >

> >

> > Hi ,

> >

> > I was instructed by the endo to take my HC as normal the day before and last

dose to be taken at 3.30pm. He knows I was taking progesterone cream too.

> >

> > What do you make of that? Ive read on hospital websites that you can still

take HC the day before the test.

> >

> >

>

> >

>

Posted

, This looks like a postive result for s Disease. Your adrenals

failed to double or reach 550. Have you been dxed officially? You will need

the dx and treatment plan, injection kits, medic alert bracelets etc.

Adrenal antibodies may or may not show up - even in Primary s. Did you

have aldosterone/renin tested ? How is your sodium/ potassium levels? DHEA?

What was the baseline ACTH result?

Jane

> >

> > It could well be the short synacthen test that has kicked your adrenals into

> > action. I think at this stage, I would not tell the endocrinologist - he

> > might cut your T3 back, and this is something you can do on your own if you

> > feel the need. Are you sure you are not suffering with any of the associated

> > conditions that needs sorting out. See attached. Any one of these could be

> > causing you a problem. Alternatively the pain might not be thyroid related.

> >

> > Luv - Sheila

> >

> >

> >

>

Posted

> After the blood draw for the baseline cortisol the injection of ACTH

> hormone is supposed to stimulate the adrenals into producing lots of

> cortisol – hence the cortisol figure would go UP and not down, as

> your figures apparently suggest. This does not make any sense whatsoever

> – at least not to me. If someone knows differently I would be

> grateful if you could enlighten me, as I have never heard of cortisol

> levels dropping during a SST.

I have heard of this happening, but i don't know what the reason is. when i had

my tests, they queried my results because they did not go up or down - they said

either they'd go up, or down, but not stay the same.

I have been reading more about the adrenals lately, and came across this article

which talks about CBG - cortisol binding

globulin.http://www.addisons-network.co.uk/high_cbg_ad.html

I have wondered whether the 'adrenal fatigue' has to do with whether there are

excess levels of CBG over time. Apparently high estrogen increases CBG in

women? High CBG might explain why some people have to take very high amounts of

cortiol and it wears off soon?

This article is interesting:

http://www.addisons-network.co.uk/high_cbg_ad.html

New Discovery?: High Cortisol Binding Globulin as cause of 's?

Mike Welch, Devon,UK.

First published: 14 February 2006

Since late 2004 it has become increasingly obvious that a proportion of patients

who present to their General Practitioner (GP), Primary Care Physician (PCP), or

Endocrinologist, with a multitude of signs and symptoms which closely resemble

or are identical to those often seen with adrenal insufficiency, or 's

Disease per se, when tested do NOT exhibit the classical results which may have

been expected with the condition.

It is well known that the body may be expected to respond to stress with an

increase in the level of cortisol. When a random sample of blood plasma is

analysed for cortisol, patients with adrenal insufficiency may be seen to

exhibit a low, low normal, or normal level of this hormone. However, for years

it has been the norm to confirm the diagnosis of 's Disease by means of

the SynActhen (Synthetic ACTH enhancement) test, known in the USA and some other

countries as the Stim (ACTH stimulation) test.

This test is traditionally performed on patients who are not on any

supplementary corticosteroid therapy (i.e. hydrocortisone or prednisolone).

However in an emergency patients who have been prescribed the alternative

corticosteroid, dexamethasone, may have the SynActhen test performed without

results being adversely affected or skewed. A baseline cortisol assay sample of

blood is taken. The patient is then given the appropriate dose of ACTH,

following which repeat samples of blood are taken after 30 minutes & often

another at 60 minutes for further cortisol assays to determine what response has

been generated by the adrenal glands.

It has been noted that a few patients who, clinically, have been judged by their

physician to exhibit classic signs of 's disease, have reported to me

personally or via the '' 's disease discussion group that they have

been told by their physician that their SynActhen test results have not

supported a diagnosis of 's disease. Where these particular patients have

had access to copies of the results of these tests or the results have been

explained to the patient by the physician, it has often been related that the

cortisol response has either been sub-optimal from a normal or low normal

baseline level, or that the result appears to be 'normal'. Several of this group

of patients have subsequently had repeat SynActhen tests performed and found

that the results have varied from the previous tests. Not all the patients who

have initially had sub-optimal or normal results have had repeat tests carried

out.

In the United States, an alternative diagnosis if 'adrenal fatigue' is often

offered for example, where the ACTH stimulation test fails to provide the

expected results in the face of clinical signs & symptoms highly suggestive of

's disease.

I am a retired Chief Biomedical Scientist with over 36 years experience in

pathology and I believe these results from patients who were clinically

suffering from symptoms of adrenal insufficiency suggest that something else was

interfering, in those patients' blood stream, with their cortisol levels. I had

already noticed that most of this group of patients were female and that many

had reported they also suffered from an established diagnosis of hypothyroidism

or Hashimoto's disease. One female patient in the group who also had Hashimoto's

disease reported that her replacement dose of thyroxine had at one time required

increasing over a period of several months from 200µg/day (often recognised as

full replacement dose) to 400µg/day at the time of an apparently unrelated

medical condition. This required increase had been investigated by her

endocrinologist and discovered to be the result of an elevated level of thyroid

binding globulin (TBG).

From research on the Internet, I discovered a paper by Wyeth Lederle, a well

known drug company, in which they related the fact that patients with increased

TBG levels also were often found to also have elevated levels of both sex

hormone binding globulins (SHBG) and cortisol binding globulins (CBG). I also

uncovered another report by the Department of Chemical Pathology at Hong Kong

University Hospital in which they mentioned in a ward manual that high CBG could

affect cortisol response to ACTH, 'often from a normal baseline'.

Following discussion with an endocrinologist in the United States, with patients

who have encountered similar problems in establishing an adequate diagnosis by

their physicians, and after further extensive research on the Internet, I submit

the following theory which I confidently believe explains the previously unknown

or 'atypical' form of 's disease, its cause, and the tests required to

assist the clinician to establish the diagnosis:-

The Theory of High CBG 's Disease.

The cause of primary 's disease in the 21st century is autoimmune in

approximately 70% of cases, with antibodies (where found) directed against

adrenal tissue.

The SynActhen test as described currently remains the method of choice to

establish if adrenal insufficency exists.

In a small proportion of patients (see below) who clinically manifest the signs

and symptoms of adrenal insufficiency, the SynActhen test as currently performed

fails to support the diagnosis of 's disease. Instead it may show either

an unexpected normal result, or a sub-optimal response to ACTH from, often, a

normal baseline. Furthermore, results may vary on subsequent repeated SynActhen

tests from previous investigations.

It is suggested that an elevated level of Cortisol Binding Globulin, which are

known to have been reported in patients with pre-existing raised Thyroid Binding

Globulin levels, binds to the free cortisol in the blood plasma, thus giving

false negative or variable non-responsive results when a SynActhen test is

performed under current conditions.

Tests Required to Confirm or Exclude High CBG 's Disease.

Current methodology for SynActhen tests measures total plasma cortisol levels,

i.e. free plus protein bound plasma cortisol.

Bound cortisol cannot be easily metabolised by the human body, thus the measured

levels of cortisol in the SynActhen test may not truly reflect the amount of

free cortisol available for use within the body.

A modification to the SynActhen test whereby free cortisol in plasma is the

required measurement, together with an assay of CBG, may be required to enable

the clinician

to establish a diagnosis of atypical, or high CBG, 's disease.

Current methodology for the assay of free cortisol in plasma is not yet

established as an accredited technique. This requires urgent attention. In

discussion with my own endocrinologist (who accepted that the CBG AD theory is

correct) I understand that work is in progress to establish an accredited method

for this test within the UK.

Criteria for Patients With Suspected High CBG 's Disease.

The patients who should be considered as suffering from High CBG 's

disease and who should be tested as above fit into a fairly tight group of

criteria.

They appear to satisfy most or all of the following criteria:

Female.

Suffer from an upset of oestrogen/progesterone balance. (Mostly related to

gynaecological problems, may also include patients with or who have suffered

from oestrogen dependent breast carcinoma, amongst other conditions)

With hypothyroidism or established Hashimoto's thyroiditis, on replacement

thyroxine.

With elevated thyroid binding globulin.

Have been shown to demonstrate non-responsive or variable SynActhen test results

often from normal or low normal baseline cortisol.

Exhibit classic symptoms of adrenal deficiency or 's disease (including

those patients elsewhere in the world considered to suffer from 'adrenal

fatigue').

Expected Results:

Patients suffering from 'High CBG 's Disease' may expect to show the

following ranges of test results:-

Cortisol binding globulin assay: ELEVATED *

Standard SynActhen (ACTH stimulation) test with TOTAL plasma cortisol assays *:

Baseline total cortisol: Typically LOW NORMAL or NORMAL result

Post ACTH injection total cortisol levels (usually 30 & 60 minutes): Typically

NORMAL or SUB-OPTIMAL ** response

Modified SynActhen (ACTH stimulation) test with FREE plasma cortisol assays *:

Baseline free cortisol: Typically LOW result

Post ACTH injection free cortisol levels (usually 30 & 60 minutes):

Typically LOW or SUB-OPTIMAL response

* Laboratories should establish their own results reference ranges for normal

populations.

** Response may be seen to be dropping at 60 minutes from already sub-optimal

response at 30 minutes.

Posted

What

your endo. should be doing is to prescribe between 25 and 50mcg of Dexamethasone

which is roughly equivalent to 20mg of cortisol - and that way, you won't have

to wean off the HC to have the test done again. Telephone his secretary this morning

and ask about this. This needs sorting quickly . Once you have had the

test results you can then go back onto your HC. Dexamethasone is a long acting

drug so you only take it once a day but often it lasts much longer than 24

hours so when you take your next dose, you probably still have some in your

body. Not sure how people cope with this, unless you take your dose when your

body tells you that it needs it. Let us know what they say .

Luv

- Sheila

Hi Sheila,

The endo wrote to me to say the results were odd and suggested I " tail

down " the HC and retest. Anyway I wrote to him to quote the CKS pages

suggesting that I may have s and he immediately wrote to me to offer

another appt.

I have been this afternoon and he has admitted that my results are not normal

(but I did take it into my our hands to take HC so he says- the ASI test very

low on cortisol and DHEA - endo says he doesnt accept those results)-but I have

said that I want his support. He says he will support me as long as I try and

reduce down the HC and retest at 15mg. I normally take 20mg pd. I mentioned

again about my hysterectomy 7 years ago and that the remaining ovary may have

failed and he has now suggested an adrenal antibody test.

Any way the bottom line is he has prescribed HC as he admits I need it and the

self injection kit!! :-) Im in the system now and at least he is giving me some

support although I have had to drag it out of him by writing to him and copying

PALS in like I have read about on this forum. Thats good news for me - If I

cant get down to 15mg I have to ring his secretary and we will take it from

there. Hes accepted me as his patient now and has prescribed and is going to

write to my GP so he can continue with the prescription.

What do you think?

>

> Remind us what action they said is needed at the hospital after receiving

> such results for your short synacthen test ? I simply cannot remember

> everybody's messages unfortunately

>

> Luv - Sheila

>

>

>

Posted

Hi Sheila,

Why didnt the Endo tell me all this? Its so confusing! He says he wants me to

go down to 15mg per day and then redo the SST - but what would be the point if

what you say is correct. Ive tried ringing the secretary but shes not in. I'll

keep trying - but I am thinking of writing to him again so at least its official

again. Is there somewhere where there is a protocol that I can print off and

send with the letter thats official.

I can see that there are some other replies to me and shall look at them to see

if anyone else mentions this or a reference. Im seeing Dr P on the 23rd Jan

(snow permitting).

>

> What your endo. should be doing is to prescribe between 25 and 50mcg of

> Dexamethasone which is roughly equivalent to 20mg of cortisol - and that

> way, you won't have to wean off the HC to have the test done again.

> Telephone his secretary this morning and ask about this. This needs sorting

> quickly .

Posted

Hi ,

I was taking HC prior to the test - I took my last dose at 3.30pm the day before

the test - thats what the Endo told me to do - \I haveit in writing from him.

He knows that I am using progesterone cream too.

I have a copy of the results from the SST and what I said previously is correct.

Unless the nurse that did it mixed them up??

So if I " tail off " to 15mg per day from 20mg per day that I take now - would

there be any point in doing the test again as the drop is still quite small. On

Monday when I saw him I did say that I agreed to do this and didnt think that

this is such a small drop in meds. Would it make any difference to the result?

Is there any published information that I can point out to him about this test?

I look foward to hearing from you.

regards

>

>

> Interesting about what you say about the SST kicking my adrenals into

> action when my result was so " odd " . Baseline 386, 30 mins 226. 60 mins

> 326. I did feel dreadful afterwards and had to take it easy for the rest

> of the day after the test as I felt very tired and dizzy.

>

>

>

>

>

Posted

MODERATED TO REMOVE PREVIOUS MESSAGES ALREADY READ. PLEASE ENSURE THAT YOU HAVE

DONE THIS BEFORE CLICKING 'SEND' AND LEAVE JUST A SMALL PORTION OF WHAT YOU ARE

RESPONDING TO. MANY THANKS - SHEILA

_________________________________________________

Thank you for that information. Very, very interesting!!!! I have

followed the link and will be printing it out and thinking of a letter over the

Christmas period. I think that this works best with this Endo. He wants to

test my Adrenal Antibodies - not sure what that means?

>

>

>

>

>

> I was instructed by the endo to take my HC as normal the day before and

> last

> dose to be taken at 3.30pm. He knows I was taking progesterone cream

> too.

>

> He thinks that are odd and is testing my adrenal antibodies and wants me

> to

> retake the test when on 15mg HC pd - currently 20mg per day.

>

> What do you make of that? Ive read on hospital websites that you can

> still take

> HC the day before the test.

>

>

>

>

Posted

PREVIOUS MESSAGES DELETED - MODERATOR

_____________________________________

Hi Judy,

I think what you say mirrors what others have said about not being on the HC

when doing the SST.

How is your daughter doing on this other medication? Is she managing to come

off the HC and how far is she into the new meds? Is she quite well?

Which hospital is she under and who is she seeing?

Look forward to hearing from you and hope you have a good Christmas!

>

> Hi ,

>

> Before my daughter had Synacthen test we had this discussion with her

consultant who wasn't an endo but had had some experience in testing adrenals.

We had information from a doctor friend of ours that HC would interfere with the

results of the test.

>

Posted

HI Judy,

No I have not been officially dx but Endo has given me an emergency injection as

he says I am steriod dependant! Yes I am as I need them!! He says that I took

them off my own back after the ASI test results which he doesnt recognise. All

true but the NHS were not helping me - same old story as we know here on this

forum.

He said that he cant rule out s but he didnt understand the results, and

I didnt have anything other than my FSH LH and DHEAS measured. DHEAS is low,

but he doesnt think I need any of that.

I already wear a SOS braclet and have done since I started the HC ( just in

case). He did say he would write to my GP to advise what is happening. My GP

(quite rightly) says hes not an expert on this area and is looking to the Endo

for advice on management etc.

Endo says that if the Adrenal Antibodies is strongly positive then that points

to s.

Regards

>

> , This looks like a postive result for s Disease. Your adrenals

failed to double or reach 550. Have you been dxed officially? You will need

the dx and treatment plan, injection kits, medic alert bracelets etc.

>

> Adrenal antibodies may or may not show up - even in Primary s. Did you

have aldosterone/renin tested ? How is your sodium/ potassium levels? DHEA?

What was the baseline ACTH result?

Posted

EDITED TO REMOVE PREVIOUS MESSAGE - MODERATOR

___________________________________

Hi

Thanks for your reply - this article looks very interesting!!

Were you still taking HC the day before or were you off them altogether? This

article says you need to be off HC altogether.

regards

>

> I have heard of this happening, but i don't know what the reason is. when i

had my tests, they queried my results because they did not go up or down - they

said either they'd go up, or down, but not stay the same.

>

> I have been reading more about the adrenals lately, and came across this

article which talks about CBG - cortisol binding

globulin.http://www.addisons-network.co.uk/high_cbg_ad.html

>

Posted

Ask your endo. to tell you exactly why he doesn't recognise the

ASI test and give him a copy of the attached to show that Genova Diagnostics

are a very highly recommended laboratory around the world. If he doesn't know

how to properly carry out a short synacthen test and disregards your adrenal 24

hour profile, I think it is time you moved on to somebody who has done their

research and put your health into their hands. This man simply isn't interested

in knowing the true facts.

Luv - Sheila

No I have not been officially dx but Endo has given me an emergency injection

as he says I am steriod dependant! Yes I am as I need them!! He says that I

took them off my own back after the ASI test results which he doesnt recognise.

All true but the NHS were not helping me - same old story as we know here on

this forum.

He said that he cant rule out s but he didnt understand the results, and

I didnt have anything other than my FSH LH and DHEAS measured. DHEAS is low,

but he doesnt think I need any of that.

I already wear a SOS braclet and have done since I started the HC ( just in

case). He did say he would write to my GP to advise what is happening. My GP

(quite rightly) says hes not an expert on this area and is looking to the Endo

for advice on management etc.

Endo says that if the Adrenal Antibodies is strongly positive then that points

to s.

Regards

_,___

1 of 1 File(s)

Genova Quality Assurance.pdf

Posted

Hello ,I was taking HC prior to the test - I took my last dose at 3.30pm the day beforethe test - thats what the Endo told me to do - \I haveit in writing from him. He knows that I am using progesterone cream too.

I hope I did not come over as `telling you off'- I certainly did not mean to do that .... you just followed your endo's instructions as anybody would have done in your position. What I am struggling with is your endo's intentions – what is he actually testing? If he wants to check if you may be suffering from 's disease or adrenal insufficiency, then to my mind this is not the way to go about it, because whilst you are on HC and other steroids this test will not give him any meaningful answers. I have a copy of the results from the SST and what I said previously is correct.Unless the nurse that did it mixed them up??

The figures are very likely "correct" in that those were the figures which were measured – only they won't tell him anything as far as I can make out. Perhaps there is some kind of interpretation when after ACTH injection the cortisol levels of a patient on HC medication dip rather than elevate, but if there were then I am not aware of it, nor can I find any such reference in the NHS guidelines for an SST.So if I "tail off" to 15mg per day from 20mg per day that I take now - wouldthere be any point in doing the test again as the drop is still quite small. OnMonday when I saw him I did say that I agreed to do this and didnt think thatthis is such a small drop in meds. Would it make any difference to the result? I am no expert, but I honestly cannot see any point in repeating this test whilst you are on any amount of steroids. Even the Progesterone cream you are using would influence the test result and render it invalid..... and this puts you in a difficult situation, because as you say, you are steroid dependent and therefore weaning you off HC for the sake of this test would probably do more harm than good. If you were truly addisonian – meaning that autoantibodies are destroying parts of your adrenal glands, then you would need HC and/or Florinef (depending on which kind of 's) for life. Just like thyroid autoantibodies will destroy our thyroid gland, adrenal autoantibodies will destroy most of the adrenals glands – so in either case we need to replace the specific respective hormones that the glands cannot produce any more.... in case of primary 's that would be the mineral- and glucocorticoids (Florinef & HC).

If your adrenal antibodies came back positive, it would tell you if an autoimmune process/attack were going on with your adrenals glands – and yes, I would imagine that a positive adrenal autoantibodies result would point the finger at a possible 's diagnosis in the same way that positive thyroid autoantibodies are diagnostic of Hashimoto's.

Is there any published information that I can point out to him about this test?I think if you print out the section from the NHS handbook (pages 48 and 49) and put certain questions to him in writing, that would be a good idea.

Questions to ask him would be –

What is the purpose for a repeat test? (i.e. is it to diagnose or rule out primary adrenal insufficiency or 's disease?)

Since any steroid other than Dexamethasone will influence the outcome and interpretation of an SST, would it be advisable to switch you from HC to Dexamethasone for the purpose of the test? – and if so, for how long (days, weeks?) – and would you have to stop the Progesterone cream - and for how long - before a re-test?

Would it be prudent to order an ACTH Plasma test in addition to the ACTH Stimulation test (SST) ? (pls. see below Wiki link)

If your endo insists/confirms that it would be ok to perform a SST whilst you are taking a reduced amount of HC, would he please explain how a test under those circumstances would be interpreted – please also study the following link and perhaps print it out for your endo -

http://www.dundee.ac.uk/medther/tayendoweb/images/short%20synacthen%20test.pdf

The following Wiki link is also very informative, it explains well how SST results and ACTH Plasma test results should to be interpreted....

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ACTH_stimulation_test

Interpretation of results

Cortisol stimulation

In healthy individuals, the cortisol level should double from a baseline of 20-30 ug/dl within 60 minutes. For example, if the serum cortisol level was 25 ug/dl before the stimulation, it should reach at least 50 ug/dl.

(me: please note ! some labs use nmol/dl rather than ug/dl ..... conversion nmol/L to ug/dL : divide by 27.59)

Interpretation for primary adrenal insufficiency and 's disease

The baseline cortisol level in people with adrenal insufficiency is usually near 15 ug/dl. An ACTH stimulation test that raises the cortisol concentration to 20 ug/dl would support the diagnosis of primary adrenal insufficiency. In 's disease, baseline cortisol is well below 10 ug/dl and rises no more than 25 percent.

Interpretation for secondary adrenal insufficiency

ACTH may dramatically stimulate cortisol from the low baseline value encountered in patients suffering from secondary adrenal insufficiency. Stimulation resulting in a greater than 14-fold increase in serum concentration over 30 minutes has been reported, although more typically serum cortisol levels will double or triple from baseline. The lower the baseline cortisol, the more likely it is that the patient's cortisol will increase by a large amount.[13]

In some instances, a second test can suggest primary adrenal insufficiency (cortisol value less than doubled). The diagnosis may be changed from secondary to primary adrenal insufficiency or to include primary adrenal insufficiency. In secondary adrenal insufficiency, if the adrenal glands lack ACTH for enough time, cortisol production can atrophy[14] and fail to rise to a value at least double the base cortisol value. It is proper to continue with the diagnosis of secondary adrenal insufficiency.

If secondary adrenal insufficiency is diagnosed, the insulin tolerance test (ITT) or the CRH (Corticotropin-releasing hormone) stimulation test can be used to distinguish between a hypothalamic (tertiary) and pituitary (secondary) cause, but is rarely used in clinical practice.[14]

ACTH plasma test plus cortisol stimulation

An ACTH plasma test should always be given at the same time as the ACTH stimulation, although many doctors consider the test inaccurate. This test measures how much ACTH the pituitary gland is producing. A healthy ACTH value should be just into the upper third of the range (assuming a range of 10–60 ng/L). The ACTH plasma and ACTH stimulation test together can give a clearer picture, especially for secondary adrenal insufficiency.[11]

Interpretation for primary adrenal insufficiency and 's disease

ACTH will be high[11] - either at the top or above range. In 's disease, ACTH may be way above range and may reach the hundreds. In very rare cases can reach the 1000s and 2000s.

Interpretation for secondary adrenal insufficiency

ACTH will be low[11] - Usually below 35, but most people with secondary fall within the range limit. Although uncommon, values for ACTH can reach into the low 40s.

In some cases, actual cause of low ACTH is from low CRH in the hypothalamus. It is possible to have separate ACTH and CRH impairment such as can happen in a head injury.[15]

I hope all of the above helps,

Best wishes,

Posted

Hi Sheila,

I did show him the ASI test and the emails and presention from Genova, (as I

have read that people on here have done that), but he shook his head and said it

was not recognised by the NHS and that he couldnt take it into account thats why

he had me do the first SST test.

My GP referred me to him when Dr A B from Birmingham hospital(off your list)

said he wouldnt tret me and didnt recoginize T3 as a treatment or the ASI test!

Im not sure where that leaves me now or whom to go to from here? I live in East

Staffordshire - does anyone have any ideas please?

kind regards

>

> Ask your endo. to tell you exactly why he doesn't recognise the ASI test and

> give him a copy of the attached to show that Genova Diagnostics are a very

> highly recommended laboratory around the world. If he doesn't know how to

> properly carry out a short synacthen test and disregards your adrenal 24

> hour profile, I think it is time you moved on to somebody who has done their

> research and put your health into their hands. This man simply isn't

> interested in knowing the true facts.

>

> Luv - Sheila

>

>

>

>

Posted

No I didnt think that. But I am really grateful that you have taken

the time to give me a very lengthy reply! :-)

Its very useful and I shall write to him with all that you have said - it all

makes sense what you say and I totally agree. Im going to print what you have

written and over christmas formulate a sutiable reply!!

Once again many thanks and I will keep you posted!

There is one more thing though - I live in the East Staffordshire district - do

you know anyone else I could see that would be more sympathetic to my situation?

many thanks

>

>

>

>

> Hello ,

>

> I was taking HC prior to the test - I took my last dose at 3.30pm the

> day before

> the test - thats what the Endo told me to do - \I haveit in writing from

> him.

> He knows that I am using progesterone cream too.

>

> I hope I did not come over as `telling you off'- I certainly did

> not mean to do that .... you just followed your endo's instructions

> as anybody would have done in your position. What I am struggling with

> is your endo's intentions – what is he actually testing? If he

> wants to check if you may be suffering from 's disease or

> adrenal insufficiency, then to my mind this is not the way to go about

> it, because whilst you are on HC and other steroids this test will not

> give him any meaningful answers.

>

> I have a copy of the results from the SST and what I said previously is

> correct.

> Unless the nurse that did it mixed them up??

>

> The figures are very likely " correct " in that those were the

> figures which were measured – only they won't tell him anything

> as far as I can make out. Perhaps there is some kind of interpretation

> when after ACTH injection the cortisol levels of a patient on HC

> medication dip rather than elevate, but if there were then I am not

> aware of it, nor can I find any such reference in the NHS guidelines for

> an SST.

>

>

Posted

Hi ,

It's complicated by the fact that my daughter is having so many allergies to any

medication. She is coping with the reduction, reducing every month. So she

should be off all steroids by the end of February and then has an appointment

with her endo in March. We have a named endo nurse specialist at the hospital we

can ring if she has any problems.

What I am really pointing out is even if you have been switched to dexamethasone

you are not guarantee the endo will accept test results. My daughters results

showed adrenal insufficiency but this test now been dismissed by the endo.

I'll email you privately as to the endo and hospital.

Judy

>

> PREVIOUS MESSAGES DELETED - MODERATOR

> _____________________________________

>

> Hi Judy,

>

> I think what you say mirrors what others have said about not being on the HC

when doing the SST.

>

> How is your daughter doing on this other medication? Is she managing to come

off the HC and how far is she into the new meds? Is she quite well?

>

> Which hospital is she under and who is she seeing?

>

> Look forward to hearing from you and hope you have a good Christmas!

>

>

>

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...