Guest guest Posted June 15, 2010 Report Posted June 15, 2010 From what I know - No it is not possible to get thyroid cancer and I am almost positive you cannot get hyperT either. Low iodine and toxins are the cause of both. What do her labs look like? Does she have Free T3 and Free T4 levels? If her doctor is using TSH only to dx hyperT then this is wrong. It's a pituitary hormone. Did he get any antibody levels? Tg Ab or TPO Ab? She may have an autoimmune thyroid condition which is common with those that have had breast cancer. Does she have other issue? Has she taken the iodine loading test with bromide levels. She needs to if she hasn't. Detox, Detox, Detox. Clean diet of whole foods. Steph URGENT - for Hello ,My sister is taking for some months 100mg of Iodoral. Now, her oncologist tells her that her thyroid is completely out of balance and she's now hyper. She has neck pain and throat pain and had for a couple of days swollen lymph nodes in the neck. The lymph nodes came back to normal but the pain persist. I,m afraid she can have thyroid cancer. She already has breast cancer. Is it possible that 100mg of Iodoral to cause hyperthyroidism or thyroid cancer?Thank you.Brindusa Quote
Guest guest Posted June 15, 2010 Report Posted June 15, 2010 Her doctor just called her and reffered her to an endocrinologist. We just learned the news. Probably the endocrinolog will do the others tests. Do you think that the pain in her neck could be a symptom of thyroid cancer? I'm devastated because it is me who insisted her to take Iodoral. Thanks. > > From what I know - No it is not possible to get thyroid cancer and I am almost positive you cannot get hyperT either. Low iodine and toxins are the cause of both. What do her labs look like? Does she have Free T3 and Free T4 levels? If her doctor is using TSH only to dx hyperT then this is wrong. It's a pituitary hormone. Did he get any antibody levels? Tg Ab or TPO Ab? She may have an autoimmune thyroid condition which is common with those that have had breast cancer. > > Does she have other issue? Has she taken the iodine loading test with bromide levels. She needs to if she hasn't. > > Detox, Detox, Detox. Clean diet of whole foods. > > Steph > > > URGENT - for > > > > Hello , > > My sister is taking for some months 100mg of Iodoral. Now, her oncologist tells her that her thyroid is completely out of balance and she's now hyper. She has neck pain and throat pain and had for a couple of days swollen lymph nodes in the neck. The lymph nodes came back to normal but the pain persist. I,m afraid she can have thyroid cancer. She already has breast cancer. > > Is it possible that 100mg of Iodoral to cause hyperthyroidism or thyroid cancer? > > Thank you. > > Brindusa > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 15, 2010 Report Posted June 15, 2010 I had no pain in my neck. Just nodules. The endo will run a TSH & T4 - maybe antibodies but I doubt it. Personally I wouldn't go. I would find an alternative med doc that will help. Steph URGENT - for > > > > Hello ,> > My sister is taking for some months 100mg of Iodoral. Now, her oncologist tells her that her thyroid is completely out of balance and she's now hyper. She has neck pain and throat pain and had for a couple of days swollen lymph nodes in the neck. The lymph nodes came back to normal but the pain persist. I,m afraid she can have thyroid cancer. She already has breast cancer. > > Is it possible that 100mg of Iodoral to cause hyperthyroidism or thyroid cancer?> > Thank you.> > Brindusa> Quote
Guest guest Posted June 15, 2010 Report Posted June 15, 2010 Thanks again , . > > > > From what I know - No it is not possible to get thyroid cancer and I am almost positive you cannot get hyperT either. Low iodine and toxins are the cause of both. What do her labs look like? Does she have Free T3 and Free T4 levels? If her doctor is using TSH only to dx hyperT then this is wrong. It's a pituitary hormone. Did he get any antibody levels? Tg Ab or TPO Ab? She may have an autoimmune thyroid condition which is common with those that have had breast cancer. > > > > Does she have other issue? Has she taken the iodine loading test with bromide levels. She needs to if she hasn't. > > > > Detox, Detox, Detox. Clean diet of whole foods. > > > > Steph > > > > > > URGENT - for > > > > > > > > Hello , > > > > My sister is taking for some months 100mg of Iodoral. Now, her oncologist tells her that her thyroid is completely out of balance and she's now hyper. She has neck pain and throat pain and had for a couple of days swollen lymph nodes in the neck. The lymph nodes came back to normal but the pain persist. I,m afraid she can have thyroid cancer. She already has breast cancer. > > > > Is it possible that 100mg of Iodoral to cause hyperthyroidism or thyroid cancer? > > > > Thank you. > > > > Brindusa > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 15, 2010 Report Posted June 15, 2010 Try not to panic! Docs use your panic to push you into things that may not be in your best interest. If you argue with an obstetrician, he talks about dead babies -- which is designed to make you so frightened for your unborn child that you fall into line. With oncologists, you get the line about how there is not a minute to waste, if they are to save your life. (They know that cancer takes YEARS to develop, but those few extra hours you want to spend doing your uppety research will be the ones that kill you!) I bet others can tell you the panic stories that go with other specialties. BREATHE! Cancer develops over YEARS before you ever know it is there; you have time to ask a few questions!First of all, my own experience & everything on the list suggests that when you start the iodine protocol, everything in your body will try to rebalance itself. Some test values may go a little out of whack. Hormones can shift. It's like tapping one element on a mobile -- all the other elements can bob & dance for a bit until they stabilize again. Any abnormal test value is thrilling to a doctor, if it puts him in a position to say, "Oh, you silly woman! You did this silly thing & threw your body out of balance, & now I will have to rescue you. (And by the way, now you should do EVERYTHING I say, because I have shown you with this test score that you don't know what you're doing.)" If your sister hadn't been taking iodine, those test values might mean something different than they do. But all they probably mean right now is that her body hasn't reached saturation yet, & is going through changes. The doc doesn't know anything about iodine, & he doesn't want your sister treating herself, so his opinion is not all that helpful. He is trying to make her afraid & compliant; he is trying to rush her into treatments that will trash her immune system, & make her subject to other cancers down the line, if she gets past this one. He has an agenda, & it's about maintaining his control, & pursuing the allopathic concept of health (which is nothing like MY concept of health.)Secondly, changes or pain in the thyroid do not necessarily (or even very likely!) mean cancer. A lot of us experience a little swelling when we start iodine -- & swelling can be uncomfortable. Myself, I am finding that every time I reduce my iodine, the nodule in my thyroid flares back up & twinges. Any time this sucker grows or shrinks, I am likely to have a bit of discomfort. But the point there is that it shrinks back again when I restore the iodine.Thirdly, not everything in the neck is a thyroid. There are lymph nodes in the neck, & the lymphatic system tries to pump out toxins. Any time you have something as serious as cancer going on, the lymph system is probably struggling to clear away toxins. (A rebounder is supposed to be really good for helping the lymphatic system do its thing. You don't even have to JUMP -- just bounce lightly up & down without your feet even leaving the surface.)Fourthly, there is a psychological component -- when you are told you have poisoned your thyroid, any twinge in your neck can be magnified.In the final analysis, your sister is going to have to decide what makes her feel safest. Some people opt for chemo & radiation & all that other stuff, & get declared cured -- & then die of cancer shortly anyway. (My husband's first wife was declared totally cancer-free, after years of torture, only to have the cancer come back stronger than ever after a very short time.) A lot of the "cures" are a mirage. But some people feel so much safer trusting doctors that that is what they need to do, even if you or I might think it is not the best choice.A lot of us weirdos have gotten to the point where we feel safer doing cleanses & eating organic & taking supplements, & if we DO find ourselves dealing with cancer, would be more afraid of chemo & radiation than of cancer. But once you are the girl in the hot seat, you have to figure that out for yourself.YOU DID NOT HARM YOUR SISTER! You did not make her sick. Your advice was to try a harmless supplement, with potential benefits. Even if it doesn't cure her, it did not cause her illness. Cancer takes years to grow. In the unlikely event she has thyroid cancer, she didn't get it in the last few months. And she certainly didn't get the original cancer from iodine. It is hard to maintain your perspective when you are so worried -- & when the docs are trying to make you & your sister feel foolish for trying iodine. BREATHE!AnneOn Jun 15, 2010, at 5:52 PM, brindusa wrote: Her doctor just called her and reffered her to an endocrinologist. We just learned the news. Probably the endocrinolog will do the others tests. Do you think that the pain in her neck could be a symptom of thyroid cancer? I'm devastated because it is me who insisted her to take Iodoral. Thanks. > > From what I know - No it is not possible to get thyroid cancer and I am almost positive you cannot get hyperT either. Low iodine and toxins are the cause of both. What do her labs look like? Does she have Free T3 and Free T4 levels? If her doctor is using TSH only to dx hyperT then this is wrong. It's a pituitary hormone. Did he get any antibody levels? Tg Ab or TPO Ab? She may have an autoimmune thyroid condition which is common with those that have had breast cancer. > > Does she have other issue? Has she taken the iodine loading test with bromide levels. She needs to if she hasn't. > > Detox, Detox, Detox. Clean diet of whole foods. > > Steph > > > URGENT - for > > > > Hello , > > My sister is taking for some months 100mg of Iodoral. Now, her oncologist tells her that her thyroid is completely out of balance and she's now hyper. She has neck pain and throat pain and had for a couple of days swollen lymph nodes in the neck. The lymph nodes came back to normal but the pain persist. I,m afraid she can have thyroid cancer. She already has breast cancer. > > Is it possible that 100mg of Iodoral to cause hyperthyroidism or thyroid cancer? > > Thank you. > > Brindusa > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 16, 2010 Report Posted June 16, 2010 Thank you so much Anne, for your time and effort to encourage me. I'm so afraid of doctors, and the problem is that my sister belevies them and not me. Brindusa > > > > > > From what I know - No it is not possible to get thyroid cancer > > and I am almost positive you cannot get hyperT either. Low iodine > > and toxins are the cause of both. What do her labs look like? Does > > she have Free T3 and Free T4 levels? If her doctor is using TSH > > only to dx hyperT then this is wrong. It's a pituitary hormone. Did > > he get any antibody levels? Tg Ab or TPO Ab? She may have an > > autoimmune thyroid condition which is common with those that have > > had breast cancer. > > > > > > Does she have other issue? Has she taken the iodine loading test > > with bromide levels. She needs to if she hasn't. > > > > > > Detox, Detox, Detox. Clean diet of whole foods. > > > > > > Steph > > > > > > > > > URGENT - for > > > > > > > > > > > > Hello , > > > > > > My sister is taking for some months 100mg of Iodoral. Now, her > > oncologist tells her that her thyroid is completely out of balance > > and she's now hyper. She has neck pain and throat pain and had for > > a couple of days swollen lymph nodes in the neck. The lymph nodes > > came back to normal but the pain persist. I,m afraid she can have > > thyroid cancer. She already has breast cancer. > > > > > > Is it possible that 100mg of Iodoral to cause hyperthyroidism or > > thyroid cancer? > > > > > > Thank you. > > > > > > Brindusa > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 16, 2010 Report Posted June 16, 2010 I would go to google scholar and look up " iodine induced hyperthyroidism " Here is a link to the search. http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=iodine+induced+hyperthyroidism & hl=en & as_sdt=\ 400000000001 & as_sdtp=on Hope that helps. -Zed Quote
Guest guest Posted June 16, 2010 Report Posted June 16, 2010 Oh, and did she begin at 100mg or did she work her way up to it? Someone who is iodine defficient and put on a 100mg dose is an ideal canidate for developing hyperthyroidism. It is common in iodine deficient countries after a sudden increase of Iodine in their diet. Hope this helps. -Zed Quote
Guest guest Posted June 16, 2010 Report Posted June 16, 2010 Yes, be careful not to let the doctors persuade her into sugery. They tried to use fear with me. I found a nodule, they ordered a sonogram, then a biopsie,....the day of the biopsie I was told there was no use in doing the biopsie because of the percentage of false negatives....I had 3 doctors in my area telling me that I needed to have my thyroid removed in case it was cancer....I even was told by one doctor " You know, you are a single mom, this is nothing to be messing around with! " and was told by another " don't let your fear guide your decision! " ...if fear was guiding my decision then I would have hurried up and got the operation.... I was in grad school at the time so I had access to all sorts of medical journals and books..and I watched medical seminars..I read and researched and the 3 doctors (A GP, an ENT, and the X-ray guy?) were not ready to deal with someone who was knowledgable and had questions...if they could answer my questions I would consider the operation....they did not have the answers and it became apparent that I knew more than them....So I insisted on a secong and third opinion.... The second opinion was an endocrinolgist...and The third opinion was a Doctor at Columbia University in the Thyroid center....he is considered an expert in the field..... THey performed an ultra sound guided biopsie and both doctors said that it was " unequivocally benign! " So now I just need a sonagram once a year to moniter its size... I just graduated from Grad school....and decided to now focus more of my time to healing...because this large nodule is obviously a sign from my body that all is not well....along with the weight gain and exhustion....ect... So I started to research and learned about iodine and about all the other necessary nutrients....which brought me to this page.... Point of my story.....You are scared....and for a good reason....do not blindly follow what is being told to you... In grad school they try to teach us not to question the status quo....to just except what is taught to us...although i also learned about things that were once excepted in my feild that are no longer excepted because luckly someone did question rather than follow blindly.... By nature I ask questions and never just except what is told to me as truth (drove some of my professors crazy!) My classmates, who I love, rarely questioned and mainly memorized.....I believe that most doctors are much like my class mates. Most believe they are doing what is best because that is what they were taught....and they never questioned otherwise... Good Luck! > > > > > > From what I know - No it is not possible to get thyroid cancer > > and I am almost positive you cannot get hyperT either. Low iodine > > and toxins are the cause of both. What do her labs look like? Does > > she have Free T3 and Free T4 levels? If her doctor is using TSH > > only to dx hyperT then this is wrong. It's a pituitary hormone. Did > > he get any antibody levels? Tg Ab or TPO Ab? She may have an > > autoimmune thyroid condition which is common with those that have > > had breast cancer. > > > > > > Does she have other issue? Has she taken the iodine loading test > > with bromide levels. She needs to if she hasn't. > > > > > > Detox, Detox, Detox. Clean diet of whole foods. > > > > > > Steph > > > > > > > > > URGENT - for > > > > > > > > > > > > Hello , > > > > > > My sister is taking for some months 100mg of Iodoral. Now, her > > oncologist tells her that her thyroid is completely out of balance > > and she's now hyper. She has neck pain and throat pain and had for > > a couple of days swollen lymph nodes in the neck. The lymph nodes > > came back to normal but the pain persist. I,m afraid she can have > > thyroid cancer. She already has breast cancer. > > > > > > Is it possible that 100mg of Iodoral to cause hyperthyroidism or > > thyroid cancer? > > > > > > Thank you. > > > > > > Brindusa > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 16, 2010 Report Posted June 16, 2010 this is why this group exists--to dispell the myths aobut iodine. have you read the research on http://www.optimox.com? Gracia taking 100mg Iodoral--formerly " hyper " zedtava wrote: > > I would go to google scholar and look up " iodine induced hyperthyroidism " > > Here is a link to the search. > > http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=iodine+induced+hyperthyroidism & hl=en & as_sdt=\ 400000000001 & as_sdtp=on > <http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=iodine+induced+hyperthyroidism & hl=en & as_sdt\ =400000000001 & as_sdtp=on> > > Hope that helps. > > -Zed > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 16, 2010 Report Posted June 16, 2010 I don't agree with this. Many people start at high doses with no issues of the thyroid. Please show research to back this up. Steph Re: URGENT - for Oh, and did she begin at 100mg or did she work her way up to it? Someone who is iodine defficient and put on a 100mg dose is an ideal canidate for developing hyperthyroidism. It is common in iodine deficient countries after a sudden increase of Iodine in their diet. Hope this helps. -Zed Quote
Guest guest Posted June 16, 2010 Report Posted June 16, 2010 Yes, I have read all the information on Optimox and more. Trust me, there is a lot more information out there. I am not saying that high doses of iodine are not beneficial. I do belive that continuously upping your dose to achieve desired results is not always the best solution. In some cases it may be, but you are not the same as the next person. All you have to do is read the many stories on this forum to realize that iodine affects people in different ways. Hyper becomes hypo, normal becomes non-existant and so on. A part of dispelling myths is to look past the research done by one group and to look at the big picture. Don't mean to step on toes -Zed Quote
Guest guest Posted June 16, 2010 Report Posted June 16, 2010 That is why you have to be very careful on blanket statements that high doses of iodine can lead to hyperthyroid. It isn't true and it is a VERY rare case if it occurs. I spend weeks dispelling and calming fears of newcomers when things like this get started. They will just shut down and not take anything out of fear. Re: URGENT - for Yes, I have read all the information on Optimox and more. Trust me, there is a lot more information out there. I am not saying that high doses of iodine are not beneficial. I do belive that continuously upping your dose to achieve desired results is not always the best solution. In some cases it may be, but you are not the same as the next person. All you have to do is read the many stories on this forum to realize that iodine affects people in different ways. Hyper becomes hypo, normal becomes non-existant and so on. A part of dispelling myths is to look past the research done by one group and to look at the big picture. Don't mean to step on toes-Zed Quote
Guest guest Posted June 16, 2010 Report Posted June 16, 2010 zedtava wrote: > > Yes, I have read all the information on Optimox and more. Trust me, > there is a lot more information out there. > You did not give any references. You are making claims with nothing to back it up. Who are you and what are your credentials that you can make statements like this, and why should we believe you? Quote
Guest guest Posted June 16, 2010 Report Posted June 16, 2010 There is a difference between many people and one person. Someone taking 100mg could become hypo or hyper. It depends on many factors. The problem with high dose therapy in the range of 1mg or more is that there is very little research available. As far as what is available, there are many cases in which someone who is iodine deficient or even iodine sufficent based off WHO guidelines receives iodine and becomes hyperthyroid. Google scholar is a good place to start as far as fishing through years of research. Here is an article. Unfortunately it costs money to read all of it, but the abstract should be enough. http://www.liebertonline.com/doi/abs/10.1089%2F105072501300176453 Once again, don't mean to step on toes. Just trying to provide insight. -Zed <ladybugsandbees@...> wrote: > > I don't agree with this. Many people start at high doses with no issues of the thyroid. > > Please show research to back this up. > > Steph > > > Re: URGENT - for > > > > Oh, and did she begin at 100mg or did she work her way up to it? Someone who is iodine defficient and put on a 100mg dose is an ideal canidate for developing hyperthyroidism. It is common in iodine deficient countries after a sudden increase of Iodine in their diet. > > Hope this helps. > > -Zed > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 16, 2010 Report Posted June 16, 2010 You are wrong. There is lots of research. Dr. Brownstein and I have it. That is what I do .... research Iodine. I have so much right now that it is so unorganized that I can't make heads or tails of what is what. 1 mg is NOT HIGH DOSE. Traditional medicine used way higher milligram dosing. Stupid WHO guidelines are not scientific. I learned that very early on and if you do the research on those RDA, RDI and all the other recommended amounts they are the minimum amount that keeps you from catastrophic disease. They are not the amounts that keep you in health. There is a big difference there. I have that article. I am going to print it right now and re-read it. Have you read it? Re: URGENT - for > > > > Oh, and did she begin at 100mg or did she work her way up to it? Someone who is iodine defficient and put on a 100mg dose is an ideal canidate for developing hyperthyroidism. It is common in iodine deficient countries after a sudden increase of Iodine in their diet. > > Hope this helps. > > -Zed> Quote
Guest guest Posted June 16, 2010 Report Posted June 16, 2010 You don't have to believe me, or your doctor, or anyone else. I am just offering my knowlege from researching Iodine almost every day for the last year. I thought this group was about sharing information, not pointing fingers. As far as references, what would you like? Read my previous posts and maybe you will find some there. Never hurts to learn a little by doing a basic search on google scholar. There is so much to discover outside of what people provide for you. -Zed > > > > Yes, I have read all the information on Optimox and more. Trust me, > > there is a lot more information out there. > > > You did not give any references. You are making claims with nothing to > back it up. > > Who are you and what are your credentials that you can make statements > like this, and why should we believe you? > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 16, 2010 Report Posted June 16, 2010 That's rough, because you might have to watch her go through a lot of stuff you think is crazy. But it is her body. If you talked her into going alternative all the way, & she was scared, you wouldn't be doing her any favors.I have had the brutal experience of having family members more or less tell me I'm nuts. (Your family is supposed to SUPPORT you, isn't it?) Through various natural approaches, I have gone from having allergies, constant colds, arthritis, etc. ad nauseum, to a much improved (though not yet perfect) state of health. My son's "genetic & incurable" ASD symptoms have improved significantly (though he is still a long way from recovered.) We are living advertisements for rethinking the way a person lives... But the iodine protocol is on their crazy list, & none of them will even read up on it -- even though I would be willing to bet they are all seriously iodine deficient.When people don't want to be bothered by the facts, they are incredibly able to ignore them. One of the hardest things I have to do every day is watch people make bad choices that are undermining their health. I know a woman with MS who guzzles diet soda by the case; many authorities claim that artificial sweeteners are a major factor in MS, & that some people go into remission as soon as they give them up.You can't make decisions for your sister -- now matter how scared you are. (And who would want the responsibility?) It is hard to support what you feel is a bad decision, but that might be your job now. Good luck.AnneOn Jun 16, 2010, at 6:51 AM, brindusa wrote: Thank you so much Anne, for your time and effort to encourage me. I'm so afraid of doctors, and the problem is that my sister belevies them and not me. Brindusa > > > > > > From what I know - No it is not possible to get thyroid cancer > > and I am almost positive you cannot get hyperT either. Low iodine > > and toxins are the cause of both. What do her labs look like? Does > > she have Free T3 and Free T4 levels? If her doctor is using TSH > > only to dx hyperT then this is wrong. It's a pituitary hormone. Did > > he get any antibody levels? Tg Ab or TPO Ab? She may have an > > autoimmune thyroid condition which is common with those that have > > had breast cancer. > > > > > > Does she have other issue? Has she taken the iodine loading test > > with bromide levels. She needs to if she hasn't. > > > > > > Detox, Detox, Detox. Clean diet of whole foods. > > > > > > Steph > > > > > > > > > URGENT - for > > > > > > > > > > > > Hello , > > > > > > My sister is taking for some months 100mg of Iodoral. Now, her > > oncologist tells her that her thyroid is completely out of balance > > and she's now hyper. She has neck pain and throat pain and had for > > a couple of days swollen lymph nodes in the neck. The lymph nodes > > came back to normal but the pain persist. I,m afraid she can have > > thyroid cancer. She already has breast cancer. > > > > > > Is it possible that 100mg of Iodoral to cause hyperthyroidism or > > thyroid cancer? > > > > > > Thank you. > > > > > > Brindusa > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 16, 2010 Report Posted June 16, 2010 Did you read that article or just the abstract? I just read it. There are some issues with the study. Steph Re: URGENT - for You don't have to believe me, or your doctor, or anyone else. I am just offering my knowlege from researching Iodine almost every day for the last year. I thought this group was about sharing information, not pointing fingers.As far as references, what would you like? Read my previous posts and maybe you will find some there. Never hurts to learn a little by doing a basic search on google scholar. There is so much to discover outside of what people provide for you. -Zed> >> > Yes, I have read all the information on Optimox and more. Trust me, > > there is a lot more information out there.> >> You did not give any references. You are making claims with nothing to > back it up.> > Who are you and what are your credentials that you can make statements > like this, and why should we believe you?> > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 16, 2010 Report Posted June 16, 2010 Maybe a little research on the group's archives could provide more info for you, there are many research articles. There are sources on this list that have been studying iodine for much longer periods than one year. What people are trying to tell you is that you are not providing references to back up what you are saying. Death, hyperthyroidism, etc. where are the stats? The link you provided is the basic mainstream thinking. Where are the studies with percentages of patients with these symptoms? If you're going to make these kind of statements, you need to back them up. Folks here have done a lot more than "basic searches on google scholar". Linn On Jun 16, 2010, at 1:19 PM, zedtava wrote: You don't have to believe me, or your doctor, or anyone else. I am just offering my knowlege from researching Iodine almost every day for the last year. I thought this group was about sharing information, not pointing fingers. As far as references, what would you like? Read my previous posts and maybe you will find some there. Never hurts to learn a little by doing a basic search on google scholar. There is so much to discover outside of what people provide for you. -Zed > > > > Yes, I have read all the information on Optimox and more. Trust me, > > there is a lot more information out there. > > > You did not give any references. You are making claims with nothing to > back it up. > > Who are you and what are your credentials that you can make statements > like this, and why should we believe you? > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 16, 2010 Report Posted June 16, 2010 What makes you think that you are right and I am wrong? People thought they were right when they claimed the world was square. Just curious. You can say that 1000000mg is not a high dose. And no, I do not think that the RDA is the right amount, it is way too low. As far as the comment on traditional medicine. Traditional medicine is full of good and bad, just like current practices. I too have piles of iodine research. It is all sitting on my desk. I'm sure, like you, that once you feel like you are on to something, a paper will pop up that show the exact opposite results. How much of the research on high iodine dosing is from Brownstein himself? Or Abraham or Flechas? Practically the same group of minds working together. No, I have not read that article. I should request it. I just did a search on google scholar and it popped up. I honestly don't have time to go through all my articles and pick out specific ones that show exactly what you want to see. If people are interested they can do it themselves. Try and respect others opinions. I work hard to discover new things, just like you . -Zed Quote
Guest guest Posted June 16, 2010 Report Posted June 16, 2010 All I am saying is that there are many sources out there. Some are right, some are wrong. Some that are right will be proven wrong in the future. Before you decided to do anything, it is best to educate yourself on the matter. I have made an effort to provide sources whenever necessary. Sometimes it is best for you to do the research yourself. Sorry for hijacking this thread. -Zed Quote
Guest guest Posted June 16, 2010 Report Posted June 16, 2010 The research Dr. Brownstein has is from outside sources. He is careful to make sure that he is scientific. I am here to tell you that yes - Dr. Abraham and Dr. Brownstein think similarly but Dr. Flechas does stray from the pack. He does not mimic their logic on many things. When I heard him speak at the Iodine conference in 2007 I was surprised to hear a few comments he had because like you - I believed they were three peas in a pod. That is not the case. Dr. Brownstein writes a lot about personal experience but that does not mean that its foundation is not rooted in research other than clinical observation. Of course traditional medicine had its issues - blood letting, etc for example. But Big Pharma has taken over and when you start digging into the politics of the truth that has been suppressed because of it and even the people who have lost their lives because they stood up for what they believed then you will see how wrong our medical system today. Follow the money trail. Iodine cannot be patented so therefore it isn't going to be promoted. They tried to patent it by creating Iogen (2 or 3 mgs tablet don't remember exactly) that failed clinical trials and now is marketed OTC as a way to stave off breast cancer. *cough* It's also $30 / bottle for these small tablets. What a rip off. But I digress. You never answered my question and I asked it twice. The article you referenced - did you read it or just think the title would support your stance? Reading it gives a much different picture. Where's the beef? (so to speak) Re: URGENT - for What makes you think that you are right and I am wrong? People thought they were right when they claimed the world was square. Just curious. You can say that 1000000mg is not a high dose. And no, I do not think that the RDA is the right amount, it is way too low.As far as the comment on traditional medicine. Traditional medicine is full of good and bad, just like current practices. I too have piles of iodine research. It is all sitting on my desk. I'm sure, like you, that once you feel like you are on to something, a paper will pop up that show the exact opposite results. How much of the research on high iodine dosing is from Brownstein himself? Or Abraham or Flechas? Practically the same group of minds working together. No, I have not read that article. I should request it. I just did a search on google scholar and it popped up. I honestly don't have time to go through all my articles and pick out specific ones that show exactly what you want to see. If people are interested they can do it themselves. Try and respect others opinions. I work hard to discover new things, just like you . -Zed Quote
Guest guest Posted June 16, 2010 Report Posted June 16, 2010 This group IS about sharing information. In your post, you stated " Trust me, there is a lot more information out there. " yet you have yet to answer my question about WHO you are and why you can speak with such authority. What are your credentials, why should I trust you? So far you're only given an abstract to a flawed study. zedtava wrote: > > You don't have to believe me, or your doctor, or anyone else. I am > just offering my knowlege from researching Iodine almost every day for > the last year. > > I thought this group was about sharing information, not pointing fingers. > > As far as references, what would you like? Read my previous posts and > maybe you will find some there. Never hurts to learn a little by doing > a basic search on google scholar. > > There is so much to discover outside of what people provide for you. > > -Zed > > > > > > > > Yes, I have read all the information on Optimox and more. Trust me, > > > there is a lot more information out there. > > > > > You did not give any references. You are making claims with nothing to > > back it up. > > > > Who are you and what are your credentials that you can make statements > > like this, and why should we believe you? > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 16, 2010 Report Posted June 16, 2010 Here is the same reply I just sent to Iodine Induced Hyperthyroidism is called the Jod-Basedow Phenomenon. Here are some links, including definitions, case studies and journal articles. Sorry if some are not full links. http://medical-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/Jod-Basedow+phenomenon http://jnm.snmjournals.org/cgi/reprint/38/11/1816 http://www.annalsoflongtermcare.com/attachments/5483.pdf http://grande.nal.usda.gov/ibids/index.php?mode2=detail & origin=ibids_references & \ therow=606803 http://www.liebertonline.com/doi/abs/10.1089/thy.1998.8.83 http://whqlibdoc.who.int/monograph/WHO_MONO_44_(p385).pdf http://www.bmj.com/cgi/pdf_extract/3/5984/630 http://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/S0140673677900617 It supposedly is the opposite of the Wolff Chaikoff effect. -Zed Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.