Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Re: Mercola bashes Lugol's on October 6, 2009

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted

Margaret,

If there were cliff notes they would say something like stay within recognized

protocols unless you have a reason to deviate and are willing to assume the

responsibility.

There are lots of knowledgeable experienced people here on this group willing to

help out if you need some direction but the responsibility part remains in your

hands. The iodine protocol is pretty simple although when I started using

Lugol's I wasn't aware of it. I had a need and I found out what I needed to know

here.

Speaking of those people I would like to say thanks for being part of this

group. I know would prefer discussions stay on topic but I usually

find this group an interesting read and never a waste of time.

Happy New Year to all and God bless,

> , thanks for the article, but I'm not a " scholar " , could you give me the

cliff notes...>

Posted

Iodine isn’t going to kill you.  I don’t know Dr. Mercola’s

reason for not endorsing iodine but he does recommend kelp, which includes

iodine.  You will ALWAYS find conflicting opinions about EVERYTHING!  Don’t let

that freeze you into inaction.  You will not know how iodine affects YOU unless

you  try it.  We are all unique individuals with unique needs and reactions to

things.  How you react to something may not be the same as somebody else’s

reaction.  What one person needs is not the same as another person.  Dr.

Mercola is highly respected in the world of alternative medicine but he, like

everybody else, has his own opinions which may or may not be correct.  Have you

actually read the article?  He didn’t offer any reason behind his suggestion –

none at all.  He refers to Dr. Brownstein, who we all know is an advocate of

iodine.    I actually cannot locate the entire quote that is mentioned in Jerry’s

post.  I can find a partial quote, but not the entire thing, so it appears to

me that he has edited it.  That paragraph now reads, “If you are iodine

deficient, I recommend adding

sea vegetables to your diet.  The best source of organically bound iodine

that I know of is non-commercially harvested seaweeds. The dose is about 5

grams a day or about one ounce per week, so a pound would last about two

months. It is typically better to obtain a nutrient from a natural food

whenever possible than from a supplement, so use supplements only as a last

resort. Some patients also report that they respond better to food-based forms

of iodine -- like seaweeds -- than the supplement forms. However, if

you are going to use a supplement I would strongly advise using supersaturated

iodine (SSKI) which is available as an inexpensive prescription.

Typically 1-3 drops a day are all that are required.â€

Elsewhere he says the following:

“Q.

Are there any particular supplements you think most people with hypothyroidism

should probably be taking?

A. I am not a huge fan of supplements and encourage most people to optimize

their diet. I have an outline

that I have all my patients follow and it is a good starting point. The

nutritional changes help to optimize their insulin levels, which have an

important element to normalizing the biochemistry that generally goes along

with chronic illness.

But for specific recommendations for hypothyroidism, I feel the best supplement

that one could possibly take for proactive thyroid health on a regular basis

would be some form of organic iodine. A simple way to determine if one requires

this is to paint a patch of tincture of iodine on your skin the size of a half

dollar. The iodine brown coloration should last at least 24 hours. The faster

it is absorbed the greater the body's iodine deficiency.

The best source of organically bound iodine that I know of is non-commercially

harvested seaweeds. The dose is about 5 grams a day or about one ounce per

week. So a pound would last about two months. Radioactive iodine is another

factor that can damage the thyroid so one needs to flood the gland with healthy

iodine from organic sources like seaweed. As you know this is particularly

important for pregnant women as if they have untreated hypothyroidism their, a

New England Journal of Medicine study showed that their children may have lower

IQ scores.

The better seaweeds are hand picked and dried and not typically available in

health food stores. They are the absolute best forms of minerals that I am

aware of. Unfortunately the people who produce this usually run small

operations, and do not make their products widely known. Kelp from the health

food store may work, but it really depends on how it was harvested and there is

no way to know that reliably, so I rely on seaweed harvesters who hand pick the

seaweed and reliably dry them free from contaminants.â€

It

appears to me that his “bashing†of Lugol’s is not really bashing but a

recommendation to optimize one’s diet and provide the iodine needed in that

way.  That is typically the best way to address health issues when possible. 

I

found this elsewhere:  “Iodide-only products, such as SSKI (saturated

solution of potassium iodide), are inferior to iodide/iodine preparations in

the repletion of iodine deficiency due to varying rates of absorption.â€Â  He is

recommending that one avoid those products.  Lugol’s is not SSKI, but a mixture

of iodine/iodine, as is Iodoral.

It is important to do your own research and then do

what you feel is best for yourself.  Read the experts, but then make up your

own mind.

Pamela

From:

iodine [mailto:iodine ] On Behalf Of ND

Sent: Saturday, January 02, 2010 4:32 PM

iodine

Subject: Re: Mercola bashes Lugol's on October 6, 2009

See what I mean. Now

she is against iodine and some are for it. I have hear a lot of testimonials on

has it helped most that take it but then there are the e-mails like this one

that scares me.

More confused now than ever.

from

Illinois

From: jerry diamond

<dmnds2001@...>

iodine

Sent: Sat, January 2, 2010 2:58:37 PM

Subject: Re: Mercola bashes Lugol's on October 6, 2009

Posted

Merck's Gardasil will be next. Only it may take a few more deaths. What an

absolute atrocity.

I'll take my chances on holistic/alternative for now. I agree that some are

supplement pushers and usually it's what they carry in their offices.

>

> certainly. 

> it will always come back to " caveat emptor " . let the buyer beware.

> give too much credence to the doctor or other healthcare professional

> may mean not paying attention to one's own wisdom. or not taking

> responsibility..

> But there is a difference. the alternative practitioners, don't knowingly

> go out with a marketing plan which they know will kill people.

> Research from court documents showed that Merck knew 4 years

> before Vioxx was withdrawn that it was killing and seriously harming

> people. Not to mention them creating false paperwork to get the drug

> approved.

> These actions kill people. Yet all that happens is they get fined or

> pay compensation. 

> Shouldn't they at least be jailed?

>  

>  

>  

> They don't have that sort of cash.

>  

>  

>

>

>

Posted

Big Pharma have their hands in the pockets of our Congressmen. No where in the

world does Big Pharma have more control over government than they do here. Then

when we " fanatics " start talking holistic medicine in lieu of pharmaceuticals,

they and Big Pharma are quick to try to silence us.

Big Pharma controls our governement to a large degree. When that stops, true

justice can then be served.

>

> If you or I did what they did we would be under

> the jail. I consider that murder, manslaughter at

> the least. Because they knew what they were doing

> would harm people.That to me says intention, and

> forethought.

>

> And I'm with you on that, I do not understand why

> companies are allowed to murder people and get

> away with it. Dupont is a case in point with the

> cancer clusters in a town close to one of their

> now abandoned facilities. People died and are

> still dying. The company admits there was a

> problem with some kind of effluent filtration they

> had. Dupont has offered air ventilation. Excuse me?

>

> The CEOs and board of directors of these companies

> need to be made to consume their own toxic garbage

> until they expire! The company's business frozen,

> properties, assets, and profits seized and offered

> to the victims and their survivors and families in

> compensation. That would put a brake on a lot of

> stuff that other companies are doing. I don't

> understand why they're not held accountable. And

> the fines? They're not helping the victims.

>

> What has me puzzled is the fact that this kind of

> thing should have people rioting in the streets.

> And there's not a hint of reaction to these

> outrageous situations.

>

> Bethann

>

> If we could sell our experiences for what they

> cost us, we'd all be millionaires.

> Abigail Van Buren

>

>

Posted

Yes, ...there's a lot of corruption in this world.and in this country--the country that I love.

It's sad and outrageous. I think it will take a "higher power" to really straighten things out.

We can only do the best we can...we win some, we loose some.

Debbie Ann

Re: Mercola bashes Lugol's on October 6, 2009

Big Pharma have their hands in the pockets of our Congressmen. No where in the world does Big Pharma have more control over government than they do here. Then when we "fanatics" start talking holistic medicine in lieu of pharmaceuticals, they and Big Pharma are quick to try to silence us. Big Pharma controls our governement to a large degree. When that stops, true justice can then be served.>> If you or I did what they did we would be under > the jail. I consider that murder, manslaughter at > the least. Because they knew what they were doing > would harm people.That to me says intention, and > forethought.> > And I'm with you on that, I do not understand why > companies are allowed to murder people and get > away with it. Dupont is a case in point with the > cancer clusters in a town close to one of their > now abandoned facilities. People died and are > still dying. The company admits there was a > problem with some kind of effluent filtration they > had. Dupont has offered air ventilation. Excuse me?> > The CEOs and board of directors of these companies > need to be made to consume their own toxic garbage > until they expire! The company's business frozen, > properties, assets, and profits seized and offered > to the victims and their survivors and families in > compensation. That would put a brake on a lot of > stuff that other companies are doing. I don't > understand why they're not held accountable. And > the fines? They're not helping the victims.> > What has me puzzled is the fact that this kind of > thing should have people rioting in the streets. > And there's not a hint of reaction to these > outrageous situations.> > Bethann> > If we could sell our experiences for what they > cost us, we'd all be millionaires.> Abigail Van Buren> >

  • 3 weeks later...
Posted

They finally posted a link to a rat study as to why Lugol's was not recommended.

Here it is:

http://media.mercola.com/ImageServer/images/Thyroid/EvidenceOfThyroixine.pdf

I did a quick search on Lugol and drew a blank. If someone has the time and

wants to rat it out (pun intended) it might be interesting.

>

> I quote: " Please avoid using Lugol's solution or iodine, as that will actually

worsen your thyroid condition. "

>

> Here is the Mercola link:

>

> http://tinyurl.com/y9a9paq

>

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...