Guest guest Posted January 2, 2010 Report Posted January 2, 2010 I've been taking Lugols for over a year, (have hashis/on Armour), stopped for few months, but have been back now for several months...... But the bottom line is---is there any real evidence that Lugols is harmful to thyroids.....???? I know there has been one poster who said a child developed thyroid problem after taking Iodine, but HAS ANYONE ELSE experienced negative thyroid effects, either on this forum or anywhere else.....??? Blessings, Margaret"We are not held back by the love we didn't receive in the past, but by the love we're not extending in the present." nne on Quote
Guest guest Posted January 2, 2010 Report Posted January 2, 2010 In addition to our negative experiences, there was another blogger yesterday that said her 11 year old developed a goiter, too. So that's 5 people in total. Not sure if some people are just sensitive to iodine, because so many people have positive experiences. i would say, have your thyroid scanned every couple of months and track your tsh, t3 t4, etc. while on Iodoral. In a message dated 1/2/2010 5:34:27 P.M. Central Standard Time, margretdzn@... writes: I've been taking Lugols for over a year, (have hashis/on Armour), stopped for few months, but have been back now for several months...... But the bottom line is---is there any real evidence that Lugols is harmful to thyroids.....???? I know there has been one poster who said a child developed thyroid problem after taking Iodine, but HAS ANYONE ELSE experienced negative thyroid effects, either on this forum or anywhere else.....??? Blessings, Margaret"We are not held back by the love we didn't receive in the past, but by the love we're not extending in the present." nne on Quote
Guest guest Posted January 2, 2010 Report Posted January 2, 2010 I don't believe everything Mercola says. Less and less, actually. At some point, a few years ago, he really seemed to have his own agenda, which includes his sales. I prefer to trust Dr. Brownstein and Dr. Jarvis (Folk Medicine)Nonie See what I mean. Now she is against iodine and some are for it. I have hear a lot of testimonials on has it helped most that take it but then there are the e-mails like this one that scares me.More confused now than ever. from Illinois Quote
Guest guest Posted January 2, 2010 Report Posted January 2, 2010 Since Dr's Brownstein, Abraham, and Flechas have a history of having treated more than 4,000 patients to date with iodine (Lugol's or Iodoral) without such problems materializing sans for in perhaps only a few instances (if that), I tend to think that Mercola is wrong here. I have not stopped taking my Iodoral just because of reading the Mercola article that I highlighted everyone's awareness to. > > > > I've been taking Lugols for over a year, (have hashis/on Armour), stopped > for few months, but have been back now for several months...... > But the bottom line is---is there any real evidence that Lugols is harmful > to thyroids.....???? > I know there has been one poster who said a child developed thyroid > problem after taking Iodine, but HAS ANYONE ELSE experienced negative thyroid > effects, either on this forum or anywhere else.....??? > > Blessings, Margaret > " We are not held back by the love we didn't receive in the past, but by > the love we're not extending in the present. " > nne on > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 2, 2010 Report Posted January 2, 2010 Yeah, anyone can say anything. And he should know better, really. He spouts that, makes Lugol's the boogy man and does not explain why. Gives no reasonable explanation. To tell you the truth I'm very leery of people that sell products that naysay other products. Bethann If we could sell our experiences for what they cost us, we'd all be millionaires. Abigail Van Buren jerry diamond wrote: > > > > > " However, if you are going to use a supplement I would strongly advise > using supersaturated iodine (SSKI) which is available as an inexpensive > prescription. Typically 1-3 drops a day are all that are required. > Please avoid using Lugol’s solution or iodine... " > -MERCOLA > > SSKI IS PARTIALLY WHAT LUGOL'S IS? RIGHT? POTASSIUM IODIDE > jerry > > > > > From: ladybugsandbees <ladybugsandbees@ sbcglobal. net> > Subject: Re: Mercola bashes Lugol's on October 6, 2009 > iodinegroups (DOT) com > Date: Saturday, January 2, 2010, 2:42 PM > > > > You will always find opposing views for anything. You have to > decide for yourself. Go to www.optimox. com > <http://www.optimox.com> and you will read the opposite with more > research to back it up. > > Steph > > > * Mercola bashes Lugol's on October 6, 2009 > > > > I quote: " Please avoid using Lugol's solution or iodine, as that > will actually worsen your thyroid condition. " > > Here is the Mercola link: > > http://tinyurl. com/y9a9paq <http://tinyurl.com/y9a9paq> > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 2, 2010 Report Posted January 2, 2010 Don't forget Dr. Abraham. Steph RE: Mercola bashes Lugol's on October 6, 2009 I don't believe everything Mercola says. Less and less, actually. At some point, a few years ago, he really seemed to have his own agenda, which includes his sales. I prefer to trust Dr. Brownstein and Dr. Jarvis (Folk Medicine)Nonie See what I mean. Now she is against iodine and some are for it. I have hear a lot of testimonials on has it helped most that take it but then there are the e-mails like this one that scares me.More confused now than ever. from Illinois Quote
Guest guest Posted January 2, 2010 Report Posted January 2, 2010 And don’t forget Max Gerson, MD =-) RE: Mercola bashes Lugol's on October 6, 2009 I don't believe everything Mercola says. Less and less, actually. At some point, a few years ago, he really seemed to have his own agenda, which includes his sales. I prefer to trust Dr. Brownstein and Dr. Jarvis (Folk Medicine)Nonie See what I mean. Now she is against iodine and some are for it. I have hear a lot of testimonials on has it helped most that take it but then there are the e-mails like this one that scares me.More confused now than ever. from Illinois Quote
Guest guest Posted January 2, 2010 Report Posted January 2, 2010 Ahh yes.... there are so many. Hoxsey is another one. I am studying so many in ND school. It is quite remarkable how we got to be such a pharmaceutically oriented country. The main reason is through money and power. Big pharma had it and the nature cure docs didn't so they were hauled into court, jailed and run out of the country. It's a shame because we have lost a wonderful art of healing. Steph RE: Mercola bashes Lugol's on October 6, 2009 I don't believe everything Mercola says. Less and less, actually. At some point, a few years ago, he really seemed to have his own agenda, which includes his sales. I prefer to trust Dr. Brownstein and Dr. Jarvis (Folk Medicine)Nonie See what I mean. Now she is against iodine and some are for it. I have hear a lot of testimonials on has it helped most that take it but then there are the e-mails like this one that scares me.More confused now than ever. from Illinois Quote
Guest guest Posted January 2, 2010 Report Posted January 2, 2010 I totally agree. Very sad. RE: Mercola bashes Lugol's on October 6, 2009 I don't believe everything Mercola says. Less and less, actually. At some point, a few years ago, he really seemed to have his own agenda, which includes his sales. I prefer to trust Dr. Brownstein and Dr. Jarvis (Folk Medicine)Nonie See what I mean. Now she is against iodine and some are for it. I have hear a lot of testimonials on has it helped most that take it but then there are the e-mails like this one that scares me.More confused now than ever. from Illinois Quote
Guest guest Posted January 2, 2010 Report Posted January 2, 2010 Yes, yes! There ARE many good doctors! Too bad so many think Mercola knows all.Nonie And don’t forget Max Gerson, MD =-) Don't forget Dr. Abraham. Steph I don't believe everything Mercola says. Less and less, actually. At some point, a few years ago, he really seemed to have his own agenda, which includes his sales. I prefer to trust Dr. Brownstein and Dr. Jarvis (Folk Medicine)Nonie Quote
Guest guest Posted January 2, 2010 Report Posted January 2, 2010 Yes, I have I experienced a severe rash and dry skin and periods every 2 weeks. I stopped it and don't think that I will start it again but that does not mean that it doesn't work for other people. > > > > I've been taking Lugols for over a year, (have hashis/on Armour), stopped > for few months, but have been back now for several months...... > But the bottom line is---is there any real evidence that Lugols is harmful > to thyroids.....???? > I know there has been one poster who said a child developed thyroid > problem after taking Iodine, but HAS ANYONE ELSE experienced negative thyroid > effects, either on this forum or anywhere else.....??? > > Blessings, Margaret > " We are not held back by the love we didn't receive in the past, but by > the love we're not extending in the present. " > nne on > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 2, 2010 Report Posted January 2, 2010 The Bible says in 1 Thess 3 to " challenge everything, put it to the test to see what is Holy and True. " Paraphrasing of course, but everything, here and everywhere. As you research, you'll see people's truth, non-truth, motives, agendas and such, especially when they are questioned on it, and won't come clean. I'm fairly new here, and have read through Dr. Mercola's article probably 10 times, and read through all 115 comments there. Many of the comments question him on Lugols/Iodoral, and he never replies! There are several commenters that do supplement with iodine, and several with Lugols/Iodoral. He does reply to one person, that the adrenals are almost always having a problem right along with the thryroid. In my case with my heart skipping beats, I've also researched many pages and many hours, and I believe my main problem is my adrenals, however mine and my wife's tsh's have been high, so we did the iodine patch test, and it was bad.....gone in less than an hour! Iodine is also used by the adrenals, so we are starting with only a little bit, because we don't have anything real serious as some of you have discussed. After just a few days using iodine/seaweed we felt great, but then about a week later, some side effects/headaches, even though we are using the suggested supplements. After much reading, I agree with Steph's comments on seaweed that there is too much of a chance/risk of arsenic, bromine, flourine, and such in seaweed, so we stopped. We have tried World Organic Liquid Kelp with potassium iodide, with no problems, and now we have added our dosage by using Standard Process Iodomere, and next we'll try Standard Process Prolamine Iodine, which a lot of chiropractors use, and recommended to me. So for us this works. Remember supplements are just supplements, and food is always best. In Dr. Mercola's article he does state that the 3 common deficiencies are Vitamin D, Magnesium, and Iodine, which almost no one will argue. We take these with along with a good whole food multivitamin/antioxidants, fish oil, and probiotic. These are the necessities that most including Dr. Mercola agree with. After this supplements should be used sparingly to help with certain symptoms/diagnoses, to restore the body to optimal health, then stop taking them, and back to the basics. Dr. Mercola and many will tell you this. I don't know why Dr. Mercola won't just state why he doesn't like Lugols/Iodoral, I emailed them with just that question, and they only stated the same thing that was in the article, I emailed back and drilled them, on my health issues, and relied on Dr. M's suggestions, but was baffled, and confused on this. I still got the same reply, but a little more vague. I replied, with does Dr. Mercola's team need to research this more before making a sound statement on Iodine suggestions and dosages, and they said yes that he does want to be sure before giving his opinions, but they didn't say for Lugols specifically. As you can see I am a detailed person, and diligent as are most of you, especially to be using Iodine, which might be the most touchiest supplement to use out there. I was using an adrenal supplement for almost 6 years for extra energy, which worked great for a wile, then it was a roller coaster ride, then I believe a crash this past year with my heart skipping. My chiropractor who sells Standard Process and follows Dr. Stuart White's practice in Houston, told me what I stated above about supplementation, but he also says if you don't get good somewhat timely results from your supplements above, then stop taking it and try some other brand, but only the above stuff unless guided by a practitioner, or very experienced. Crashing my adrenals got me experienced!!! Stay diligent as you are, and keep reading asking and challenging for truth and knowledge, and you'll always at least be heading in the right direction, and hopefully faster than slower. I would've rather gone through what I've gone through over the last 6 years as opposed to people I know mainly my family members that have terrible health, and a father that died of esophageal cancer, and would not change his ways. When you find truth, change your ways, fix it and keep it fixed, as I tell my 6 and 4 year old. There is a wealth of info on this site, including Dr. Lam which I read a ton on his site. Thanks to Steph and others that have contributed and developed one of my top sites for gathering info now! Happy New Year, and as our pastor said tonight, it's going to be your best year ever! Chris > > > > > > > > I've been taking Lugols for over a year, (have hashis/on Armour), stopped > > for few months, but have been back now for several months...... > > But the bottom line is---is there any real evidence that Lugols is harmful > > to thyroids.....???? > > I know there has been one poster who said a child developed thyroid > > problem after taking Iodine, but HAS ANYONE ELSE experienced negative thyroid > > effects, either on this forum or anywhere else.....??? > > > > Blessings, Margaret > > " We are not held back by the love we didn't receive in the past, but by > > the love we're not extending in the present. " > > nne on > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 2, 2010 Report Posted January 2, 2010 I read the article too and it looks like he is advocating iodine supplementation. He listed iodine deficiency as one of the three most common deficiencies along with Vit. D and Magnesium. He is quoted “patient advocate” Shomon as one who does not advocate the high-dose iodine. He also references another doctor, Power, who advocates the iodine protocol. He referenced Dr. Brownstein too. I thought it was a very good and informative article. Quote
Guest guest Posted January 3, 2010 Report Posted January 3, 2010 Yet Pharma are fraudsters,criminals and murdereres.Who can believe a word they say? The . From: ladybugsandbees <ladybugsandbees@...>Subject: Re: Mercola bashes Lugol's on October 6, 2009iodine Date: Sunday, 3 January, 2010, 1:48 Ahh yes.... there are so many. Hoxsey is another one. I am studying so many in ND school. It is quite remarkable how we got to be such a pharmaceutically oriented country. The main reason is through money and power. Big pharma had it and the nature cure docs didn't so they were hauled into court, jailed and run out of the country. It's a shame because we have lost a wonderful art of healing. Steph RE: Mercola bashes Lugol's on October 6, 2009 I don't believe everything Mercola says. Less and less, actually. At some point, a few years ago, he really seemed to have his own agenda, which includes his sales. I prefer to trust Dr. Brownstein and Dr. Jarvis (Folk Medicine)Nonie See what I mean. Now she is against iodine and some are for it. I have hear a lot of testimonials on has it helped most that take it but then there are the e-mails like this one that scares me.More confused now than ever. from Illinois Quote
Guest guest Posted January 3, 2010 Report Posted January 3, 2010 "put everything to the test". Certainly that is good practice. However the test to establish say mineral values needs to be done in the lab. A subjective feeling state may be very misleading. Then the question is . are the recommended daily values reliable? At best they are generalisations and by definition will not fit everyone... A solution would be a portable testing kit which is reliable and inexpensive. where you could match the subjective feeling to the values represented by the tests. There are kits out there. But I haven't read any feedback from users only claims by docotrs trying to sell the kit. As I see it the further one goes into biochemistry the more complex it becomes with no definitive answers. Unless that is the deficiency is fairly straighforward. I found taking magnesium got rid of my heart flutters and terrible sciatica pain in just two days. I found vitamin C cleared up a tooth infection in 24 hours. My wife found supplementing with Floradix improved her iron status and she felt much more energetic. The right food too can have a dramatic effect. Or the elimination of a bad food. From: crouth2 <crouth1@...>Subject: Re: Mercola bashes Lugol's on October 6, 2009iodine Date: Sunday, 3 January, 2010, 4:15 The Bible says in 1 Thess 3 to "challenge everything, put it to the test to see what is Holy and True." Paraphrasing of course, but everything, here and everywhere. As you research, you'll see people's truth, non-truth, motives, agendas and such, especially when they are questioned on it, and won't come clean. I'm fairly new here, and have read through Dr. Mercola's article probably 10 times, and read through all 115 comments there. Many of the comments question him on Lugols/Iodoral, and he never replies! There are several commenters that do supplement with iodine, and several with Lugols/Iodoral. He does reply to one person, that the adrenals are almost always having a problem right along with the thryroid. In my case with my heart skipping beats, I've also researched many pages and many hours, and I believe my main problem is my adrenals, however mine and my wife's tsh's have been high, so we did the iodine patch test, and it was bad.....gone in less than an hour! Iodine is also used by the adrenals, so we are starting with only a little bit, because we don't have anything real serious as some of you have discussed. After just a few days using iodine/seaweed we felt great, but then about a week later, some side effects/headaches, even though we are using the suggested supplements. After much reading, I agree with Steph's comments on seaweed that there is too much of a chance/risk of arsenic, bromine, flourine, and such in seaweed, so we stopped. We have tried World Organic Liquid Kelp with potassium iodide, with no problems, and now we have added our dosage by using Standard Process Iodomere, and next we'll try Standard Process Prolamine Iodine, which a lot of chiropractors use, and recommended to me. So for us this works. Remember supplements are just supplements, and food is always best. In Dr. Mercola's article he does state that the 3 common deficiencies are Vitamin D, Magnesium, and Iodine, which almost no one will argue. We take these with along with a good whole food multivitamin/ antioxidants, fish oil, and probiotic. These are the necessities that most including Dr. Mercola agree with. After this supplements should be used sparingly to help with certain symptoms/diagnoses, to restore the body to optimal health, then stop taking them, and back to the basics. Dr. Mercola and many will tell you this. I don't know why Dr. Mercola won't just state why he doesn't like Lugols/Iodoral, I emailed them with just that question, and they only stated the same thing that was in the article, I emailed back and drilled them, on my health issues, and relied on Dr. M's suggestions, but was baffled, and confused on this. I still got the same reply, but a little more vague. I replied, with does Dr. Mercola's team need to research this more before making a sound statement on Iodine suggestions and dosages, and they said yes that he does want to be sure before giving his opinions, but they didn't say for Lugols specifically. As you can see I am a detailed person, and diligent as are most of you, especially to be using Iodine, which might be the most touchiest supplement to use out there. I was using an adrenal supplement for almost 6 years for extra energy, which worked great for a wile, then it was a roller coaster ride, then I believe a crash this past year with my heart skipping. My chiropractor who sells Standard Process and follows Dr. Stuart White's practice in Houston, told me what I stated above about supplementation, but he also says if you don't get good somewhat timely results from your supplements above, then stop taking it and try some other brand, but only the above stuff unless guided by a practitioner, or very experienced. Crashing my adrenals got me experienced! !! Stay diligent as you are, and keep reading asking and challenging for truth and knowledge, and you'll always at least be heading in the right direction, and hopefully faster than slower. I would've rather gone through what I've gone through over the last 6 years as opposed to people I know mainly my family members that have terrible health, and a father that died of esophageal cancer, and would not change his ways. When you find truth, change your ways, fix it and keep it fixed, as I tell my 6 and 4 year old. There is a wealth of info on this site, including Dr. Lam which I read a ton on his site. Thanks to Steph and others that have contributed and developed one of my top sites for gathering info now! Happy New Year, and as our pastor said tonight, it's going to be your best year ever! Chris> >> > > > > > I've been taking Lugols for over a year, (have hashis/on Armour), stopped > > for few months, but have been back now for several months......> > But the bottom line is---is there any real evidence that Lugols is harmful > > to thyroids.... .???? > > I know there has been one poster who said a child developed thyroid > > problem after taking Iodine, but HAS ANYONE ELSE experienced negative thyroid > > effects, either on this forum or anywhere else.....???> > > > Blessings, Margaret> > "We are not held back by the love we didn't receive in the past, but by > > the love we're not extending in the present." > > nne on> >> Quote
Guest guest Posted January 3, 2010 Report Posted January 3, 2010 Ironic isn't it that the nature cure docs were hauled into court. when that model of healthcare has so much to offer and for so little cost. Especially in the light of the recent $2.3 billion dollar fine handed out to Pfizers, the largest drug company in the world, and the comment by the judge that the company were serial fraudsters as this was their 4th time in court for similar offences, in the last ten years.. They were caught out when a whistleblower revealed their scams and the whistleblower received $56 million dollars! And in all this there was no mention of the deaths and adverse effects on patients.What did the patients get nothing!!! Not nothing death and serious adverse effects... The story was all about the money. Peoples lives apparently are of little account. And at every stage the doctors were accomplices to the Pharma marketing plan.!!! Such people, sincere people are scorned and vilified as quacks? Is there anyone in conventional healthcare who is sincere and has the patients interest at heart? They are as rare as hens teeth. From: ladybugsandbees <ladybugsandbees@...>Subject: Re: Mercola bashes Lugol's on October 6, 2009iodine Date: Sunday, 3 January, 2010, 1:48 Ahh yes.... there are so many. Hoxsey is another one. I am studying so many in ND school. It is quite remarkable how we got to be such a pharmaceutically oriented country. The main reason is through money and power. Big pharma had it and the nature cure docs didn't so they were hauled into court, jailed and run out of the country. It's a shame because we have lost a wonderful art of healing. Steph RE: Mercola bashes Lugol's on October 6, 2009 I don't believe everything Mercola says. Less and less, actually. At some point, a few years ago, he really seemed to have his own agenda, which includes his sales. I prefer to trust Dr. Brownstein and Dr. Jarvis (Folk Medicine)Nonie See what I mean. Now she is against iodine and some are for it. I have hear a lot of testimonials on has it helped most that take it but then there are the e-mails like this one that scares me.More confused now than ever. from Illinois Quote
Guest guest Posted January 3, 2010 Report Posted January 3, 2010 Dang tootin' magnesium works. I've had to increase my magnesium to prevent extreme charlie horses in my calves and feet, I didn't want to take more than I was taking but, which was 400 mg a day, but I still was having problems with extreme cramps in my calves and feet. My feet would be bent double and twisted the cramps were so severe. They hurt so bad they'd have me in tears. So I increased my dose to 600 mg per day, took that dosage a week or so, and that worked a little better, but still cramps. So I added another half tablet to make it 700 mg per day,in split doses, and that seems to be the magic number. And somehow or other it also has lowered my pulse rate. And the anxiety attacks when I lie down to sleep have completely disappeared. My son tried to get a snuffly nose last week, and I fed him 4 1,000mg garlic gels every 3-6 hours, and Vit C to tolerance, I also gave him 20,000 IU of Vit D3, and a shot of Lugol's. The the threatening snuffles disappeared. My granddaughter started having problems after being on antibiotics, I know, I know, but my daughter was in a tizzy about the whooping cough, there was an epidemic of it here during the beginning of the school year. And this was before I found out about Lugol's:) The school required a note from a doctor before she could go back to school. So she took her to the doctor. And naturally he prescribed an antibiotic. Sigh. So granddaughter developed Candida symptoms. I was waiting for it to appear. I was in a hurry, my daughter was upset, and I didn't want to waste time waiting for an order to be shipped. So I sent my daughter down to the local health food store with my bank debit card and had her buy some children's probiotics. Those were really really expensive at the health food store! But it was worth it. Two weeks taking the probiotics, and the problems have completely disappeared. We're going to give her the probiotics for a full six weeks though to make sure they stick. I'll be watching to make sure they don't reappear. So all this stuff absolutely does work, you just have to know what to use, and when, and how. And different stuff works for some folks. But the magnesium seems to work across the board for everybody. Bethann If we could sell our experiences for what they cost us, we'd all be millionaires. Abigail Van Buren david kenna wrote: > > > > " put everything to the test " . > Certainly that is good practice. > However the test to establish say mineral values needs to be done in the > lab. > A subjective feeling state may be very misleading. > Then the question is . are the recommended daily values reliable? > At best they are generalisations and by definition will not fit everyone... > A solution would be a portable testing kit which is reliable and > inexpensive. > where you could match the subjective feeling to the values represented > by the > tests. > There are kits out there. But I haven't read any feedback from users only > claims by docotrs trying to sell the kit. > As I see it the further one goes into biochemistry the more complex it > becomes > with no definitive answers. > Unless that is the deficiency is fairly straighforward. > I found taking magnesium got rid of my heart flutters and terrible > sciatica pain > in just two days. > I found vitamin C cleared up a tooth infection in 24 hours. > My wife found supplementing with Floradix improved her iron status and > she felt > much more energetic. > The right food too can have a dramatic effect. Or the elimination of a > bad food. > > > > > > > > > > > > > From: crouth2 <crouth1email (DOT) com> > Subject: Re: Mercola bashes Lugol's on October 6, 2009 > iodinegroups (DOT) com > Date: Sunday, 3 January, 2010, 4:15 > > > The Bible says in 1 Thess 3 to " challenge everything, put it to the > test to see what is Holy and True. " Paraphrasing of course, but > everything, here and everywhere. As you research, you'll see > people's truth, non-truth, motives, agendas and such, especially > when they are questioned on it, and won't come clean. I'm fairly new > here, and have read through Dr. Mercola's article probably 10 times, > and read through all 115 comments there. Many of the comments > question him on Lugols/Iodoral, and he never replies! There are > several commenters that do supplement with iodine, and several with > Lugols/Iodoral. He does reply to one person, that the adrenals are > almost always having a problem right along with the thryroid. In my > case with my heart skipping beats, I've also researched many pages > and many hours, and I believe my main problem is my adrenals, > however mine and my wife's tsh's have been high, so we did the > iodine patch test, and it was bad.....gone in less than an hour! > Iodine is also used by the adrenals, so we are starting with only a > little bit, because we don't have anything real serious as some of > you have discussed. After just a few days using iodine/seaweed we > felt great, but then about a week later, some side > effects/headaches, even though we are using the suggested > supplements. After much reading, I agree with Steph's comments on > seaweed that there is too much of a chance/risk of arsenic, bromine, > flourine, and such in seaweed, so we stopped. We have tried World > Organic Liquid Kelp with potassium iodide, with no problems, and now > we have added our dosage by using Standard Process Iodomere, and > next we'll try Standard Process Prolamine Iodine, which a lot of > chiropractors use, and recommended to me. So for us this works. > Remember supplements are just supplements, and food is always best. > In Dr. Mercola's article he does state that the 3 common > deficiencies are Vitamin D, Magnesium, and Iodine, which almost no > one will argue. We take these with along with a good whole food > multivitamin/ antioxidants, fish oil, and probiotic. These are the > necessities that most including Dr. Mercola agree with. After this > supplements should be used sparingly to help with certain > symptoms/diagnoses, to restore the body to optimal health, then stop > taking them, and back to the basics. Dr. Mercola and many will tell > you this. I don't know why Dr. Mercola won't just state why he > doesn't like Lugols/Iodoral, I emailed them with just that question, > and they only stated the same thing that was in the article, I > emailed back and drilled them, on my health issues, and relied on > Dr. M's suggestions, but was baffled, and confused on this. I still > got the same reply, but a little more vague. I replied, with does > Dr. Mercola's team need to research this more before making a sound > statement on Iodine suggestions and dosages, and they said yes that > he does want to be sure before giving his opinions, but they didn't > say for Lugols specifically. As you can see I am a detailed person, > and diligent as are most of you, especially to be using Iodine, > which might be the most touchiest supplement to use out there. I was > using an adrenal supplement for almost 6 years for extra energy, > which worked great for a wile, then it was a roller coaster ride, > then I believe a crash this past year with my heart skipping. My > chiropractor who sells Standard Process and follows Dr. Stuart > White's practice in Houston, told me what I stated above about > supplementation, but he also says if you don't get good somewhat > timely results from your supplements above, then stop taking it and > try some other brand, but only the above stuff unless guided by a > practitioner, or very experienced. Crashing my adrenals got me > experienced! !! Stay diligent as you are, and keep reading asking > and challenging for truth and knowledge, and you'll always at least > be heading in the right direction, and hopefully faster than slower. > I would've rather gone through what I've gone through over the last > 6 years as opposed to people I know mainly my family members that > have terrible health, and a father that died of esophageal cancer, > and would not change his ways. When you find truth, change your > ways, fix it and keep it fixed, as I tell my 6 and 4 year old. There > is a wealth of info on this site, including Dr. Lam which I read a > ton on his site. Thanks to Steph and others that have contributed > and developed one of my top sites for gathering info now! Happy New > Year, and as our pastor said tonight, it's going to be your best > year ever! Chris > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I've been taking Lugols for over a year, (have hashis/on > Armour), stopped > > > for few months, but have been back now for several months...... > > > But the bottom line is---is there any real evidence that Lugols > is harmful > > > to thyroids.... .???? > > > I know there has been one poster who said a child developed > thyroid > > > problem after taking Iodine, but HAS ANYONE ELSE experienced > negative thyroid > > > effects, either on this forum or anywhere else.....??? > > > > > > Blessings, Margaret > > > " We are not held back by the love we didn't receive in the > past, but by > > > the love we're not extending in the present. " > > > nne on > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 3, 2010 Report Posted January 3, 2010 But the field of holistic medicine is also becoming substantially a for profit business oriented field of endeavor, and assuredly the same frail (sinful if you prefer) human nature that is evident for those connected to big pharma must certainly be present for those associated with the marketing of holistic supplements and approaches to healing to at least some extent, no? > > > From: ladybugsandbees <ladybugsandbees@...> > Subject: Re: Mercola bashes Lugol's on October 6, 2009 > iodine > Date: Sunday, 3 January, 2010, 1:48 > > >  > > > > > Ahh yes.... there are so many. Hoxsey is another one. I am studying so many in ND school. It is quite remarkable how we got to be such a pharmaceutically oriented country. The main reason is through money and power. Big pharma had it and the nature cure docs didn't so they were hauled into court, jailed and run out of the country. It's a shame because we have lost a wonderful art of healing. >  > Steph >  >  > > RE: Mercola bashes Lugol's on October 6, 2009 > >  > > I don't believe everything Mercola says. Less and less, actually. At some point, a few years ago, he really seemed to have his own agenda, which includes his sales. > I prefer to trust Dr. Brownstein and Dr. Jarvis (Folk Medicine) > > Nonie > > >  > > > > > > > See what I mean. Now she is against iodine and some are for it. I have hear a lot of testimonials on has it helped most that take it but then there are the e-mails like this one that scares me. > More confused now than ever. > >  from Illinois > > > > >  > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 3, 2010 Report Posted January 3, 2010 Magnesium RDA values are not reliable even by NIH standards. A researcher who had written a piece on magnesium for NIH was suprised to find that even though the patient was taking the RDA values they were still showing signs of deficiency. It ddin't occur to him that the RDA values may be wrong.. at that time for that patient. Brave of you to increase the amount. Whether that amount 700mgs is a good maintenance amount is a different matter. Anyhow it worked and by trial and error, or in this case trial and success you found out. for you ..at that time.. well done... I find it inspirational when someone shares something that works..as well as what doesn't work > > > From: crouth2 <crouth1email (DOT) com>> Subject: Re: Mercola bashes Lugol's on October 6, 2009> iodinegroups (DOT) com> Date: Sunday, 3 January, 2010, 4:15> > > The Bible says in 1 Thess 3 to "challenge everything, put it to the> test to see what is Holy and True." Paraphrasing of course, but> everything, here and everywhere. As you research, you'll see> people's truth, non-truth, motives, agendas and such, especially> when they are questioned on it, and won't come clean. I'm fairly new> here, and have read through Dr. Mercola's article probably 10 times,> and read through all 115 comments there. Many of the comments> question him on Lugols/Iodoral, and he never replies! There are> several commenters that do supplement with iodine, and several with> Lugols/Iodoral. He does reply to one person, that the adrenals are> almost always having a problem right along with the thryroid. In my> case with my heart skipping beats, I've also researched many pages> and many hours, and I believe my main problem is my adrenals,> however mine and my wife's tsh's have been high, so we did the> iodine patch test, and it was bad.....gone in less than an hour!> Iodine is also used by the adrenals, so we are starting with only a> little bit, because we don't have anything real serious as some of> you have discussed. After just a few days using iodine/seaweed we> felt great, but then about a week later, some side> effects/headaches, even though we are using the suggested> supplements. After much reading, I agree with Steph's comments on> seaweed that there is too much of a chance/risk of arsenic, bromine,> flourine, and such in seaweed, so we stopped. We have tried World> Organic Liquid Kelp with potassium iodide, with no problems, and now> we have added our dosage by using Standard Process Iodomere, and> next we'll try Standard Process Prolamine Iodine, which a lot of> chiropractors use, and recommended to me. So for us this works.> Remember supplements are just supplements, and food is always best.> In Dr. Mercola's article he does state that the 3 common> deficiencies are Vitamin D, Magnesium, and Iodine, which almost no> one will argue. We take these with along with a good whole food> multivitamin/ antioxidants, fish oil, and probiotic. These are the> necessities that most including Dr. Mercola agree with. After this> supplements should be used sparingly to help with certain> symptoms/diagnoses, to restore the body to optimal health, then stop> taking them, and back to the basics. Dr. Mercola and many will tell> you this. I don't know why Dr. Mercola won't just state why he> doesn't like Lugols/Iodoral, I emailed them with just that question,> and they only stated the same thing that was in the article, I> emailed back and drilled them, on my health issues, and relied on> Dr. M's suggestions, but was baffled, and confused on this. I still> got the same reply, but a little more vague. I replied, with does> Dr. Mercola's team need to research this more before making a sound> statement on Iodine suggestions and dosages, and they said yes that> he does want to be sure before giving his opinions, but they didn't> say for Lugols specifically. As you can see I am a detailed person,> and diligent as are most of you, especially to be using Iodine,> which might be the most touchiest supplement to use out there. I was> using an adrenal supplement for almost 6 years for extra energy,> which worked great for a wile, then it was a roller coaster ride,> then I believe a crash this past year with my heart skipping. My> chiropractor who sells Standard Process and follows Dr. Stuart> White's practice in Houston, told me what I stated above about> supplementation, but he also says if you don't get good somewhat> timely results from your supplements above, then stop taking it and> try some other brand, but only the above stuff unless guided by a> practitioner, or very experienced. Crashing my adrenals got me> experienced! !! Stay diligent as you are, and keep reading asking> and challenging for truth and knowledge, and you'll always at least> be heading in the right direction, and hopefully faster than slower.> I would've rather gone through what I've gone through over the last> 6 years as opposed to people I know mainly my family members that> have terrible health, and a father that died of esophageal cancer,> and would not change his ways. When you find truth, change your> ways, fix it and keep it fixed, as I tell my 6 and 4 year old. There> is a wealth of info on this site, including Dr. Lam which I read a> ton on his site. Thanks to Steph and others that have contributed> and developed one of my top sites for gathering info now! Happy New> Year, and as our pastor said tonight, it's going to be your best> year ever! Chris> > > > >> > >> > >> > > I've been taking Lugols for over a year, (have hashis/on> Armour), stopped> > > for few months, but have been back now for several months......> > > But the bottom line is---is there any real evidence that Lugols> is harmful> > > to thyroids.... .????> > > I know there has been one poster who said a child developed> thyroid> > > problem after taking Iodine, but HAS ANYONE ELSE experienced> negative thyroid> > > effects, either on this forum or anywhere else.....???> > >> > > Blessings, Margaret> > > "We are not held back by the love we didn't receive in the> past, but by> > > the love we're not extending in the present."> > > nne on> > >> >> > > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 3, 2010 Report Posted January 3, 2010 certainly. it will always come back to "caveat emptor". let the buyer beware. give too much credence to the doctor or other healthcare professional may mean not paying attention to one's own wisdom. or not taking responsibility.. But there is a difference. the alternative practitioners, don't knowingly go out with a marketing plan which they know will kill people. Research from court documents showed that Merck knew 4 years before Vioxx was withdrawn that it was killing and seriously harming people. Not to mention them creating false paperwork to get the drug approved. These actions kill people. Yet all that happens is they get fined or pay compensation. Shouldn't they at least be jailed? They don't have that sort of cash. From: lsayre@... <lsayre@...>Subject: Re: Mercola bashes Lugol's on October 6, 2009iodine Date: Sunday, 3 January, 2010, 13:19 But the field of holistic medicine is also becoming substantially a for profit business oriented field of endeavor, and assuredly the same frail (sinful if you prefer) human nature that is evident for those connected to big pharma must certainly be present for those associated with the marketing of holistic supplements and approaches to healing to at least some extent, no? > > > From: ladybugsandbees <ladybugsandbees@ ...>> Subject: Re: Mercola bashes Lugol's on October 6, 2009> iodinegroups (DOT) com> Date: Sunday, 3 January, 2010, 1:48> > >  > > > > > Ahh yes.... there are so many. Hoxsey is another one. I am studying so many in ND school. It is quite remarkable how we got to be such a pharmaceutically oriented country. The main reason is through money and power. Big pharma had it and the nature cure docs didn't so they were hauled into court, jailed and run out of the country. It's a shame because we have lost a wonderful art of healing.>  > Steph>  >  > > RE: Mercola bashes Lugol's on October 6, 2009> >  > > I don't believe everything Mercola says. Less and less, actually. At some point, a few years ago, he really seemed to have his own agenda, which includes his sales. > I prefer to trust Dr. Brownstein and Dr. Jarvis (Folk Medicine)> > Nonie> > >  > > > > > > > See what I mean. Now she is against iodine and some are for it. I have hear a lot of testimonials on has it helped most that take it but then there are the e-mails like this one that scares me.> More confused now than ever.> >  from Illinois> > > > >  > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 3, 2010 Report Posted January 3, 2010 Welllll, I may need that amount because I supplement with D3 and that increases the free calcium levels in the blood a lot! And when you get higher calcium levels with not enough magnesium, uh oh, watch out. The problems begin. I'm looking into K2 to see if that will reduce the amount of free calcium and get it into the bones where it will do the most good:) I'll probably reduce the magnesium doses at that point. Bethann If we could sell our experiences for what they cost us, we'd all be millionaires. Abigail Van Buren david kenna wrote: > > > Magnesium RDA values are not reliable even by NIH standards. > A researcher who had written a piece on magnesium for NIH > was suprised to find that even though the patient was taking > the RDA values they were still showing signs of deficiency. > It ddin't occur to him that the RDA values may be wrong.. > at that time for that patient. > Brave of you to increase the amount. > Whether that amount 700mgs is a good maintenance amount > is a different matter. > Anyhow it worked and by trial and error, or in this case trial > and success you found out. for you ..at that time.. well done... > I find it inspirational when someone shares something that > works..as well as what doesn't work > > > > > > > > > > > > > > From: crouth2 <crouth1email (DOT) com> > > Subject: Re: Mercola bashes Lugol's on October 6, 2009 > > iodinegroups (DOT) com > > Date: Sunday, 3 January, 2010, 4:15 > > > > > > The Bible says in 1 Thess 3 to " challenge everything, put it to the > > test to see what is Holy and True. " Paraphrasing of course, but > > everything, here and everywhere. As you research, you'll see > > people's truth, non-truth, motives, agendas and such, especially > > when they are questioned on it, and won't come clean. I'm fairly new > > here, and have read through Dr. Mercola's article probably 10 times, > > and read through all 115 comments there. Many of the comments > > question him on Lugols/Iodoral, and he never replies! There are > > several commenters that do supplement with iodine, and several with > > Lugols/Iodoral. He does reply to one person, that the adrenals are > > almost always having a problem right along with the thryroid. In my > > case with my heart skipping beats, I've also researched many pages > > and many hours, and I believe my main problem is my adrenals, > > however mine and my wife's tsh's have been high, so we did the > > iodine patch test, and it was bad.....gone in less than an hour! > > Iodine is also used by the adrenals, so we are starting with only a > > little bit, because we don't have anything real serious as some of > > you have discussed. After just a few days using iodine/seaweed we > > felt great, but then about a week later, some side > > effects/headaches, even though we are using the suggested > > supplements. After much reading, I agree with Steph's comments on > > seaweed that there is too much of a chance/risk of arsenic, bromine, > > flourine, and such in seaweed, so we stopped. We have tried World > > Organic Liquid Kelp with potassium iodide, with no problems, and now > > we have added our dosage by using Standard Process Iodomere, and > > next we'll try Standard Process Prolamine Iodine, which a lot of > > chiropractors use, and recommended to me. So for us this works. > > Remember supplements are just supplements, and food is always best. > > In Dr. Mercola's article he does state that the 3 common > > deficiencies are Vitamin D, Magnesium, and Iodine, which almost no > > one will argue. We take these with along with a good whole food > > multivitamin/ antioxidants, fish oil, and probiotic. These are the > > necessities that most including Dr. Mercola agree with. After this > > supplements should be used sparingly to help with certain > > symptoms/diagnoses, to restore the body to optimal health, then stop > > taking them, and back to the basics. Dr. Mercola and many will tell > > you this. I don't know why Dr. Mercola won't just state why he > > doesn't like Lugols/Iodoral, I emailed them with just that question, > > and they only stated the same thing that was in the article, I > > emailed back and drilled them, on my health issues, and relied on > > Dr. M's suggestions, but was baffled, and confused on this. I still > > got the same reply, but a little more vague. I replied, with does > > Dr. Mercola's team need to research this more before making a sound > > statement on Iodine suggestions and dosages, and they said yes that > > he does want to be sure before giving his opinions, but they didn't > > say for Lugols specifically. As you can see I am a detailed person, > > and diligent as are most of you, especially to be using Iodine, > > which might be the most touchiest supplement to use out there. I was > > using an adrenal supplement for almost 6 years for extra energy, > > which worked great for a wile, then it was a roller coaster ride, > > then I believe a crash this past year with my heart skipping. My > > chiropractor who sells Standard Process and follows Dr. Stuart > > White's practice in Houston, told me what I stated above about > > supplementation, but he also says if you don't get good somewhat > > timely results from your supplements above, then stop taking it and > > try some other brand, but only the above stuff unless guided by a > > practitioner, or very experienced. Crashing my adrenals got me > > experienced! !! Stay diligent as you are, and keep reading asking > > and challenging for truth and knowledge, and you'll always at least > > be heading in the right direction, and hopefully faster than slower. > > I would've rather gone through what I've gone through over the last > > 6 years as opposed to people I know mainly my family members that > > have terrible health, and a father that died of esophageal cancer, > > and would not change his ways. When you find truth, change your > > ways, fix it and keep it fixed, as I tell my 6 and 4 year old. There > > is a wealth of info on this site, including Dr. Lam which I read a > > ton on his site. Thanks to Steph and others that have contributed > > and developed one of my top sites for gathering info now! Happy New > > Year, and as our pastor said tonight, it's going to be your best > > year ever! Chris > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I've been taking Lugols for over a year, (have hashis/on > > Armour), stopped > > > > for few months, but have been back now for several months...... > > > > But the bottom line is---is there any real evidence that Lugols > > is harmful > > > > to thyroids.... .???? > > > > I know there has been one poster who said a child developed > > thyroid > > > > problem after taking Iodine, but HAS ANYONE ELSE experienced > > negative thyroid > > > > effects, either on this forum or anywhere else.....??? > > > > > > > > Blessings, Margaret > > > > " We are not held back by the love we didn't receive in the > > past, but by > > > > the love we're not extending in the present. " > > > > nne on > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 3, 2010 Report Posted January 3, 2010 , thanks for the article, but I'm not a "scholar", could you give me the cliff notes.....???? Gosh darned if I could understand any of that.....(smile).... Blessings, Margaret"We are not held back by the love we didn't receive in the past, but by the love we're not extending in the present." nne on Quote
Guest guest Posted January 3, 2010 Report Posted January 3, 2010 This article may illustrate the reason for Mercola's anti-Lugol's stance. http://jn.nutrition.org/cgi/content/full/127/6/1214 Also, FWIW, he was in preparations for marketing his new kelp supplement at the time. The article highlights the requirement for selenium supplementation. > > I quote: " Please avoid using Lugol's solution or iodine, as that will actually worsen your thyroid condition. " > > Here is the Mercola link: > > http://tinyurl.com/y9a9paq > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 3, 2010 Report Posted January 3, 2010 good point From: owlsplace <owlsplace@...>Subject: Re: Mercola bashes Lugol's on October 6, 2009iodine Date: Sunday, 3 January, 2010, 22:55 This article may illustrate the reason for Mercola's anti-Lugol's stance.http://jn.nutrition .org/cgi/ content/full/ 127/6/1214Also, FWIW, he was in preparations for marketing his new kelp supplement at the time.The article highlights the requirement for selenium supplementation.>> I quote: "Please avoid using Lugol's solution or iodine, as that will actually worsen your thyroid condition."> > Here is the Mercola link:> > http://tinyurl. com/y9a9paq> Quote
Guest guest Posted January 3, 2010 Report Posted January 3, 2010 Interesting, but the Iodine protocol includes Iodine, vot C and magnesium:) So maybe Mercola didn't do his homework. Shame on him. He should know better. Orrrr he has someone besides him writing articles and sticking his name on them. He's been questioned on quite a few things that's he's written. I read his articles but I always keep that in mind when I read them/ He needs to site research for his articles. Another conservative type is Dr Sahelian. He has has some very good information for which he gives references to back up what he says in his articles. But he is very conservative, and I don't always agree with his views either. Everyone must remember that these are opinions only, not laws. If something works for the individual and does no harm, then their opinion doesn't count for much. The problem with any protocols including making sure to take selenium with the Iodine protocol gets changed by people following them. They decide selenium or magnesium is not really doing anything they can see or tell and they skip it. Then the Lugol's or Iodoral doesn't work right and they blame the substance instead of the themselves for not following the protocol. I assumed from the beginning there was a good reason for the salt, selenium, magnesium and Vit C:) But I believe it has been explained. Bethann If we could sell our experiences for what they cost us, we'd all be millionaires. Abigail Van Buren owlsplace wrote: > > > > > This article may illustrate the reason for Mercola's anti-Lugol's stance. > http://jn.nutrition .org/cgi/ content/full/ 127/6/1214 > <http://jn.nutrition.org/cgi/content/full/127/6/1214> > Also, FWIW, he was in preparations for marketing his new kelp supplement > at the time. > The article highlights the requirement for selenium supplementation. > > > > > > > I quote: " Please avoid using Lugol's solution or iodine, as that will > actually worsen your thyroid condition. " > > > > Here is the Mercola link: > > > > http://tinyurl. com/y9a9paq <http://tinyurl.com/y9a9paq> > > > > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.