Guest guest Posted September 19, 1998 Report Posted September 19, 1998 INFORMED CONSENT Dawn <prove@...> wrote: > > Dear PROVE Members, > It is being brought to our attention with alarming frequency that many Texas > families are not being provided with the federally required Vaccine > Informtation Statements prior to vaccination. Additionally, there are many > doctors who are refusing to report vaccine side effects. Please inform us of > these instances so that we may help these families file reports of > professional misconduct against their provider. It is difficult enough for > parents to receive adequate information to give true informed consent, and > this blatant disregard for the few legal protections families have must be > stopped. > > Here are the federal requirements posted on the Centers for Disease Control > Website: > > The National Childhood Vaccine Injury Act (NCVIA), passed by congress in > 1986, requires that all health care providers must (1) provide vaccine > recipients with a Vaccine Information Statement (VIS) prior to each dose and > (2) report certain adverse events following vaccination to the Vaccine > Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS). > > Instructions for Use of Vaccine Information Statements (VIS) > > The NCVIA requires that all health care providers who administer vaccines > containing diphtheria, tetanus, pertussis, polio, measles, mumps, rubella, > hepatitis B, haemophilus influenzae type b and varicella must provide a copy > of the appropriate Vaccine Information Statement (VIS) to the vaccine > recipient, their parent or legal guardian prior to each dose. A VIS must be > given with every vaccination, including each dose in a multi-dose series. > The educational materials should be supplimented with visual presentations > or oral explanations, as necessary. Health care providers should consider > giving parents copies of the VIS in advance. This will allow parents time > to absorb the information and ask questions if necessary. > > Vaccine Information Statements have been developed to comply with the > requirements of the NCVIA. Each document contains a brief description of the > disease as well as the risks and benefits of the vaccine. > > Health care providers are not required to obtain the signature of the > vaccine recipient, parent or legal guardian acknowledging receipt of the > VIS. However, to document that the VIS was given, health care providers > must note in the patient's permanent medical record (1) the date printed on > the VIS and (2) the date the VIS is given to the patient or legal guardian. > > In addition, the NCVIA requires that health care providers document in the > patient's permanent medical record the following: (1) date the vaccine was > given, (2) the vaccine manufacturer and lot number and (3) the name and > address of the health care provider administering the vaccine (This should > be the address where the medical record is located. If immunizations are > given in a shopping mall, for example, the address would be the clinic where > the permanent record is kept). > > Vaccine Information Statements (VISs) are developed by the Centers for > Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). The content and form of these > documents cannot be altered without permission of the CDC (except to add > identifying information of state and local health departments). A master > copy (from which other copies can be made) of each VIS is available by > calling the National Immunization Hotline at (800)232-2522. Please allow > 4-6 weeks for delivery. At present, the VISs are only offered in English. > Several states have done translations, and sharing of this information > between states is encouraged. Call your state health department to see what > translations are available. Health care providers may translate the VISs > into other languages without permission from CDC. > > Sincerely, > ***************************************************************** > Dawn > PROVE(Parents Requesting Open Vaccine Education) > prove@... (email) > http://home.swbell.net/prove (web site) > ***************************************************************** > PROVE provides information on vaccines, and > immunization policies and practices that affect the > children and adults of Texas. Our mission is to prevent > vaccine injury and death and to promote and protect > the right of every person to make informed independent > vaccination decisions for themselves and their families. > ***************************************************************** > Any information obtained here is not to be construed as > medical OR legal advice. The decision to vaccinate and how > you implement that decision is yours and yours alone. > ***************************************************************** -- .. Quote
Guest guest Posted April 26, 2004 Report Posted April 26, 2004 > It is true that most babies seem to come through the barrage of >shots they received by age 2 fine I don't really believe this is true. The overall health of today's children is very poor. Chronic ear infections and other recurring infections are very common, and allergies, asthma and other chronic illnesses once rare are now so common that they are almost seen as normal. While there are surely other contributing factors vaccinations are the common thread in that they are given to almost 100% of children and directly affect the overall vitality and immune system specifically. All the best, Lilian " Humankind has not woven the web of life. We are but one thread within it. Whatever we do to the web we do to ourselves. All things are bound together. All things connect. " -Chief Seattle _______________________________________ Baby Back-Tie the soft, safe and comfortable way to carry your baby on your front or back! http://www.babyback-tie.com Quote
Guest guest Posted April 26, 2004 Report Posted April 26, 2004 At 02:00 PM 04/26/2004 -0400, you wrote: >With all of my educating those in my circle of friends about vaccinations it seems to have come to naught. Of the only young mom that was willing to look at the information showing vaccines to be injurious she still chose to allow her newborn to be vaccinated before he was 12 hours old. It baffles me how this can be the case. He was born at 9:30 a.m Sunday April 25 and by noon they had the papers in the mother's face and she signed the consent form. It is true that most babies seem to come through the barrage of shots they received by age 2 fine, there are those few that don't. > > > Well, I guess 99 out of 100 do............maybe...........but autism is now 1 in 100 basically (varies) But there isn't just autism There's asthma, diabetes, ear infections, ADD/ADHD, SIDS, and so much more. The odds are diminishing every day -------------------------------------------------------- Sheri Nakken, R.N., MA, Classical Homeopath Vaccination Information & Choice Network, Nevada City CA & Wales UK $$ Donations to help in the work - accepted by Paypal account vaccineinfo@... voicemail US 530-740-0561 (go to http://www.paypal.com) or by mail Vaccines - http://www.nccn.net/~wwithin/vaccine.htm Vaccine Dangers On-Line course - http://www.nccn.net/~wwithin/vaccineclass.htm Homeopathy On-Line course - http://www.nccn.net/~wwithin/homeo.htm ANY INFO OBTAINED HERE NOT TO BE CONSTRUED AS MEDICAL OR LEGAL ADVICE. THE DECISION TO VACCINATE IS YOURS AND YOURS ALONE. ****** " Just look at us. Everything is backwards; everything is upside down. Doctors destroy health, lawyers destroy justice, universities destroy knowledge, governments destroy freedom, the major media destroy information and religions destroy spirituality " .... Ellner Quote
Guest guest Posted April 26, 2004 Report Posted April 26, 2004 It's unfortunate that people today just " trust " those that are in the medical profession and fail to question those practices that " we " feel are unnecessary. People just put this blind faith into their doctors and it is something I will never do again (I never knew that there was a chance my child could die from a vaccine!). We have been brainwashed into believing that vaccines are the miracle of the 20th century and of course want what is best for our children so we go with what " the experts " recommend. It also doesn't help that the papers and information that is given out on vaccines is no where close to informed consent! It's sad but the big pharma has done an awesome sell job. Suzanne Ohio Quote
Guest guest Posted April 26, 2004 Report Posted April 26, 2004 At 05:11 PM 04/26/2004 -0400, you wrote: >It's unfortunate that people today just " trust " those that are in the medical profession and fail to question those practices that " we " feel are unnecessary. People just put this blind faith into their doctors and it is something I will never do again (I never knew that there was a chance my child could die from a vaccine!). We have been brainwashed into believing that vaccines are the miracle of the 20th century and of course want what is best for our children so we go with what " the experts " recommend. It also doesn't help that the papers and information that is given out on vaccines is no where close to informed consent! It's sad but the big pharma has done an awesome sell job. >Suzanne >Ohio > You have to be vigilant about everything anymore and it is exhausting. My mom who 'gets' it about vaccines and most medical things and talks to me first, usually, allowed her doctor to increase her BP meds and then started having dizziness and told Nurse Practitioner that she thought it was increase in BP meds and NP begrudgingly said, OK stop it but I'll have to give you a diuretic. Mom didn't know why but thought it must be to help the reaction. NOT. She didn't want to worry me so didn't talk to me first. Hopefully we have reached another level of understanding. (moms an RN too) Weeks later she is still paying the price and everyday its something else and she WAS basically really healthy before they messed with this. She's 79 and her BP was in normal range - absolute fools - just in office it was high. EVERYONE should know you don't treat a one time high BP the way they did. It took me days to get her OK to fly here to UK and everyday now working with something new related to the mess (of course also dealing with other issues, but this is what pushed her over the edge). ABSOLUTELY infuriating. My mom is so mad she says she'll never go back to that doctor even though she really liked him ( & she is as meek and mild as they come - not like me ;-) ). But now I find out how he blackmails her - tells her if she doesn't want to do what he says, she need not come back. Wants them to come in every 6 months for physicals. She also went off her cholesterol statin (which I didn't know she was on) without telling him. And says if she stays she'll have to lie or he'll throw her out. And she doesn't want to stay, but afraid to be without a doctor. It isn't just peds who throw you out and intimidate and blackmail. Disgusting................. -------------------------------------------------------- Sheri Nakken, R.N., MA, Classical Homeopath Vaccination Information & Choice Network, Nevada City CA & Wales UK $$ Donations to help in the work - accepted by Paypal account vaccineinfo@... voicemail US 530-740-0561 (go to http://www.paypal.com) or by mail Vaccines - http://www.nccn.net/~wwithin/vaccine.htm Vaccine Dangers On-Line course - http://www.nccn.net/~wwithin/vaccineclass.htm Homeopathy On-Line course - http://www.nccn.net/~wwithin/homeo.htm ANY INFO OBTAINED HERE NOT TO BE CONSTRUED AS MEDICAL OR LEGAL ADVICE. THE DECISION TO VACCINATE IS YOURS AND YOURS ALONE. ****** " Just look at us. Everything is backwards; everything is upside down. Doctors destroy health, lawyers destroy justice, universities destroy knowledge, governments destroy freedom, the major media destroy information and religions destroy spirituality " .... Ellner Quote
Guest guest Posted July 28, 2005 Report Posted July 28, 2005 we have patients take a pre surgery test and sign that we reviewed the questions and answers with them and allowed them to ask other questions. This is kept in their file. Janelle D. McLeod, RDGastric Bypass CoordinatorPenn State Hershey Medical Center717-531-6321 This message (including any attachments) contains information intended for a specific individual(s) and purpose that may be privileged, confidential or otherwise protected from disclosure pursuant to applicable law. Any inappropriate use, distribution or copying of the message is strictly prohibited and may subject you to criminal or civil penalty. If you have received this transmission in error, please reply to the sender indicating this error and delete the transmission from your system immediately. >>> jenniferjsams@... 7/27/2005 2:28 PM >>> Does anyone have the patient sign any kind of informed consent or acknowledgement of education for their pre-op evaluation? I have them do a quiz on their pre-admission eduaction day, but do not for their evaluation. It was suggested that I do something for them to sign there as well. Any ideas/examples would be greatly appreciated! J. Sams MS RD/LD Quote
Guest guest Posted July 28, 2005 Report Posted July 28, 2005 Check the Files section of the website for lots of good ideas previously submitted by others. I modified this one for our institution; it has a place for the patient to sign and date at the end: Patient Pre-Op Post-Test.doc Assess comprehension Hilleary, MPH, RD San Diego VA Healthcare System Date: Wed, 27 Jul 2005 14:28:28 -0400 From: " Sams " <jenniferjsams@...> Subject: informed consent Does anyone have the patient sign any kind of informed consent or acknowledgement of education for their pre-op evaluation? I have them do a quiz on their pre-admission eduaction day, but do not for their evaluation. It was suggested that I do something for them to sign there as well. Any ideas/examples would be greatly appreciated! Quote
Guest guest Posted June 3, 2008 Report Posted June 3, 2008    My son was also given the HepB in the hospital without my consent (1994) even though it was VERY CLEAR in my birthing plan (he was born in a birthing center within a hospital in Texas), that NO vaccines were to be given. I didn't know of this until I arrived home & went through the paperwork about a week later. I called the hospital, & they insisted I signed something (um, drug-free birth, no excuses) but, & get this, they were UNABLE TO FIND THE DOCUMENT I SUPPOSEDLY SIGNED!!!!! If I had half a brain, I should've sued someone at the time, but oh well......    KIMBERLY Quote
Guest guest Posted June 3, 2008 Report Posted June 3, 2008 I am just curious, wouldn't there be a bandaid where the shot was given? > >    My son was also given the HepB in the hospital without my consent (1994) even though it was VERY CLEAR in my birthing plan (he was born in a birthing center within a hospital in Texas), that NO vaccines were to be given. I didn't know of this until I arrived home & went through the paperwork about a week later. I called the hospital, & they insisted I signed something (um, drug-free birth, no excuses) but, & get this, they were UNABLE TO FIND THE DOCUMENT I SUPPOSEDLY SIGNED!!!!! If I had half a brain, I should've sued someone at the time, but oh well......   >  > KIMBERLY > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 3, 2008 Report Posted June 3, 2008 My little man was bathed & dressed when we left the hospital. I had plenty of help when we got home, I was basically nursing & sleeping, so if there was a bandaid I never saw it..... > > > > My son was also given the HepB in the hospital without my > consent (1994) even though it was VERY CLEAR in my birthing plan (he > was born in a birthing center within a hospital in Texas), that NO > vaccines were to be given. I didn't know of this until I arrived > home & went through the paperwork about a week later. I called the > hospital, & they insisted I signed something (um, drug-free birth, no > excuses) but, & get this, they were UNABLE TO FIND THE DOCUMENT I > SUPPOSEDLY SIGNED!!!!! If I had half a brain, I should've sued > someone at the time, but oh well...... > > > > KIMBERLY > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 3, 2008 Report Posted June 3, 2008 What paperwork? The bill? Maybe they charged you even if he didn't get it. I think you would have noticed a bandaid. Winnie Re: Informed Consent Vaccinations > > My little man was bathed & dressed when we left the hospital. I had > plenty of help when we got home, I was basically nursing & > sleeping, so > if there was a bandaid I never saw it..... > > > > > > > > > My son was also given the HepB in the hospital without my > > consent (1994) even though it was VERY CLEAR in my birthing > plan (he > > was born in a birthing center within a hospital in Texas), > that NO > > vaccines were to be given. I didn't know of this until I arrived > > home & went through the paperwork about a week later. I > called the > > hospital, & they insisted I signed something (um, drug-free > birth, no > > excuses) but, & get this, they were UNABLE TO FIND THE > DOCUMENT I > > SUPPOSEDLY SIGNED!!!!! If I had half a brain, I should've sued > > someone at the time, but oh well...... > > > > > > KIMBERLY > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 3, 2008 Report Posted June 3, 2008 I'm not exactly certain why I'm suddenly feeling the need to defend myself, but the paperwork I'm referring to is my son's immunization record which was in along with all the other stuff they sent me home with: diaperbag full of bottles, shampoos/lotions, etc., discharge papers/bill, " new mommy " pamplets, a donut for me to sit on (DID use that!!), & tons of coupons for formula & disposable diapers I also never used. I suppose I could go back & try to find the people who helped me those 1st few weeks & ask them if they removed a bandaid?? Bottom line: I never gave permission for the shot, nor did his father, & it was given " routinely " anyway. 1st & last baby of mine born in a hospital.... > > > > > > > > My son was also given the HepB in the hospital without my > > > consent (1994) even though it was VERY CLEAR in my birthing > > plan (he > > > was born in a birthing center within a hospital in Texas), > > that NO > > > vaccines were to be given. I didn't know of this until I arrived > > > home & went through the paperwork about a week later. I > > called the > > > hospital, & they insisted I signed something (um, drug-free > > birth, no > > > excuses) but, & get this, they were UNABLE TO FIND THE > > DOCUMENT I > > > SUPPOSEDLY SIGNED!!!!! If I had half a brain, I should've sued > > > someone at the time, but oh well...... > > > > > > > > KIMBERLY > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 3, 2008 Report Posted June 3, 2008 Ooops, I just realized I meant to post my original comment with regard to Re: informed consent (without capitals), my bad. My post didn't really make too much sense here, sorry.... > > > > > > > > > > > > > > My son was also given the HepB in the hospital without my > > > > consent (1994) even though it was VERY CLEAR in my birthing > > > plan (he > > > > was born in a birthing center within a hospital in Texas), > > > that NO > > > > vaccines were to be given. I didn't know of this until I arrived > > > > home & went through the paperwork about a week later. I > > > called the > > > > hospital, & they insisted I signed something (um, drug-free > > > birth, no > > > > excuses) but, & get this, they were UNABLE TO FIND THE > > > DOCUMENT I > > > > SUPPOSEDLY SIGNED!!!!! If I had half a brain, I should've sued > > > > someone at the time, but oh well...... > > > > > > > > > > KIMBERLY Quote
Guest guest Posted June 4, 2008 Report Posted June 4, 2008 , When I worked in OB nursing, I didn't use a bandaid on the babies I gave the Hep B to unless they were bleeding a lot from the injection site. So, it's quite possible there was never a bandaid there for you to notice. Oh, how I wish I could go back and undo all of those vaccines I gave! Kay Re: Informed Consent I'm not exactly certain why I'm suddenly feeling the need to defend myself, but the paperwork I'm referring to is my son's immunization record which was in along with all the other stuff they sent me home with: diaperbag full of bottles, shampoos/lotions, etc., discharge papers/bill, " new mommy " pamplets, a donut for me to sit on (DID use that!!), & tons of coupons for formula & disposable diapers I also never used. I suppose I could go back & try to find the people who helped me those 1st few weeks & ask them if they removed a bandaid?? Bottom line: I never gave permission for the shot, nor did his father, & it was given " routinely " anyway. 1st & last baby of mine born in a hospital.... > > What paperwork? The bill? Maybe they charged you even if he didn't get it. > > I think you would have noticed a bandaid. > > Winnie Quote
Guest guest Posted June 4, 2008 Report Posted June 4, 2008 Not asking you to defend yourself, just confused about what paperwork they would give. I've seen things billed to the insurance co. that we didn't get sometimes, just because they're a matter of routine. I thought maybe there was a chance they did that and didn't actuallly give the vaccine. Either way, it's outrageous they would give vaccines without permission. Considering most people get them, you'd think it would stick out that you told them not to. Winnie Re: Informed Consent Vaccinations > I'm not exactly certain why I'm suddenly feeling the need to defend > myself, but the paperwork I'm referring to is my son's immunization > record which was in along with all the other stuff they sent me home > with: diaperbag full of bottles, shampoos/lotions, etc., discharge > papers/bill, " new mommy " pamplets, a donut for me to sit on (DID use > that!!), & tons of coupons for formula & disposable diapers I > also never > used. I suppose I could go back & try to find the people who > helped me > those 1st few weeks & ask them if they removed a bandaid?? > Bottom line: > I never gave permission for the shot, nor did his father, & it > was given > " routinely " anyway. 1st & last baby of mine born in a hospital.... > > > > > > > > > > My son was also given the HepB in the hospital without my > > > > consent (1994) even though it was VERY CLEAR in my birthing > > > plan (he > > > > was born in a birthing center within a hospital in Texas), > > > that NO > > > > vaccines were to be given. I didn't know of this until I arrived > > > > home & went through the paperwork about a week later. I > > > called the > > > > hospital, & they insisted I signed something (um, drug-free > > > birth, no > > > > excuses) but, & get this, they were UNABLE TO FIND THE > > > DOCUMENT I > > > > SUPPOSEDLY SIGNED!!!!! If I had half a brain, I should've sued > > > > someone at the time, but oh well...... > > > > > > > > > > KIMBERLY > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 4, 2008 Report Posted June 4, 2008 no time have i been in room when my neices and nephews were born ad got shot did they get a bandaid **************Get trade secrets for amazing burgers. Watch " Cooking with Tyler Florence " on AOL Food. (http://food.aol.com/tyler-florence?video=4? & NCID=aolfod00030000000002) Quote
Guest guest Posted June 4, 2008 Report Posted June 4, 2008 > > What paperwork? The bill? Maybe they charged you even if he didn't get it. > > I think you would have noticed a bandaid. > > Winnie > > Where is the shot usually given, arm or leg? I refused Hep.B & Vit.K for my son and just signed some blue form that i am declining the shot at this time. I had doubts lately that maybe they injected him anyway but then i don't remember seeing any bandaids on him. Do they apply a bandaid after vit.K as well? Good point about the bandiad, if there wasn't any that means no shots where given. This just relieved my fears, now i am pretty sure he did not receive any shots just like i requested. Katarina Quote
Guest guest Posted July 1, 2010 Report Posted July 1, 2010 http://www.tpa-uk.org.uk/customary_vs_prudent2.pdf Luv - Sheila Hi All, Do we have any information on Informed Consent in the files section as I can't seem to find it. B No virus found in this incoming message. Checked by AVG - www.avg.com Version: 8.5.439 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/2971 - Release Date: 06/30/10 18:38:00 Quote
Guest guest Posted August 4, 2010 Report Posted August 4, 2010 Here are some practical tips on IC: - Do not blindly copy and paste the IC proforma which has been used by others. The language and formating of copy-paste work shows it all. - Work on the IC proforma to make it more participant friendly. - Always put yourself in the shoes of participants and then think if the IC proforma protects and guarantees the participant rights. What EC/ IRB usually looks for in " Informed Consent " - That the IC proforma is neatly typed / printed, is in understandable plain language which is followed by the local participants. - If it is in English then a translated copy is also attached. - Contains all necessary important information but briefly. - Participants are able to understand and comprehend the contents - IC form is witnessed by a neutral person who is not an investigator - No effort is done to use legal jargon and snatch away participant rights. - Copy of the document is also given to the participant who has signed. Dr Vijay Thawani Quote
Guest guest Posted August 4, 2010 Report Posted August 4, 2010 Thank You sir for providing these really useful practical tips. Dr Smita From: Vijay <drvijaythawani@...>Subject: Informed consentnetrum Date: Thursday, 5 August, 2010, 12:08 AM Here are some practical tips on IC:- Do not blindly copy and paste the IC proforma which has been used by others. The language and formating of copy-paste work shows it all. - Work on the IC proforma to make it more participant friendly.- Always put yourself in the shoes of participants and then think if the IC proforma protects and guarantees the participant rights.What EC/ IRB usually looks for in "Informed Consent"- That the IC proforma is neatly typed / printed, is in understandable plain language which is followed by the local participants.- If it is in English then a translated copy is also attached.- Contains all necessary important information but briefly.- Participants are able to understand and comprehend the contents - IC form is witnessed by a neutral person who is not an investigator- No effort is done to use legal jargon and snatch away participant rights.- Copy of the document is also given to the participant who has signed.Dr Vijay Thawani Quote
Guest guest Posted March 1, 2011 Report Posted March 1, 2011 I'm curious to know how many docs actually use these forms. I do not, and it appears that regardless we could be sued. ph Medlin D.C. From: sharron Sent: Tuesday, March 01, 2011 12:17 PM Subject: Re: Informed Consent Based on the following from Freeman re: Cassidy's 'research' I do not think the language in the informed consent posted by Dr. Dyson would hold water:s.fuchs dcFrom: Freeman [mailto:forensictrauma@...] Sent: Thursday, February 17, 2011 7:16 PMSharron FuchsSubject: Re: Risk of Vertebrobasilar Stroke and Chiropractic CareHi Sharron,Below are my comments about a report Cassidy did in a malpractice case in which the patient died after the manipulation.The first problem with the study was that the total number of subjects who had a stroke and who had seen a chiropractor in the 7 days prior to the stroke was only 14, and there were only 6 who saw a chiropractor on the same day as the stroke. As it is certainly true that chiropractic practices attract patients with neck pain, and patients who are already having a VBA dissection will have neck pain, then there is certainly a risk of a reverse causation conclusion (the manipulation caused the dissection) when the opposite is the case.This is NOT the case with the patient who presents with minimal or no neck symptoms and then has a stroke within 5 minutes of a cervical manipulation, as the probability of coincidental occurrence of stroke decreases dramatically as the time between the manipulation and the stroke lessens. If all 6 of the chiropractic patients had dissections or strokes within minutes of manipulation this would be extremely important information to have as the relationship would almost certainly not be coincidental, yet this information does not exist in the study described by Dr. Cassidy. Such study is complicated by the fact that there is no way to know from the study methods in how many of the 14 patients who saw chiropractors within a week of their stroke there would have been a causal relationship expected; if the answer is only 1 or 2 then the study would not have had sufficient power (numbers of subjects in each category) to identify a real difference between the groups. It is easiest to describe the flaw in this approach with analogy; consider drug A that is suspected to have fatal reaction in one in every 10,000 doses. If we wanted to study whether the drug A kills people versus drug B, which we know doesn't kill people, we could get 10,000 people who had died, and then find that 200 had taken drug A and 200 had taken drug B. We would incorrectly conclude that the rate of death due to drug A is no greater than with drug B, yet we only assembled 1/50th of the number of people who had taken the drug to find 1 person who had died from the drug! The errone ous conclusion would be that drug A doesn't kill people.It is important to note that whether chiropractic procedures are related to stroke is unrelated to the relationship of stroke and PCP visits. What the study does demonstrate is that patients who are having a VAD with neck pain will present to both a PCP and a chiropractor - an unsurprising finding. However, the paper doesn't demonstrate that a chiropractic treatment to the neck will not or cannot precipitate a stroke. The conclusion is fallacious because the methods of the study cannot disprove a causal relationship.In addition to the above comments about the faulty conclusions that Dr. Cassidy drew with regard to his study, I am in possession of a report of Dr. Silver, dated March 4, 2009. Dr. Silver is a neurologist and a co-author of Dr. Cassidy's, and he clearly does not share Dr. Cassidy's opinion that chiropractic manipulation is not causally associated with VBA stroke. In fact, Dr. Silver pointedly notes in his report that the paper he co-authored included a specific disclaimer that the research did NOT rule out chiropractic treatment as a cause of stroke. When one looks at the study itself, the reason for the need for the disclaimer which Dr. Silver brings forward, is simple. The types of epidemiologic studies that Dr. Cassidy referred to in his report cannot be used as a basis for drawing exclusive causal inferences, as such a study can, at best, be said to have failed to demonstrate a causal association. This is a well accepted fact in epidemiologic science and it is highly inappropriate and frankly wrong for Dr. Cassidy to draw the conclusions he has from his research, which was in fact designed to arrive at a no-relationship conclusion. As I have stated above, there are a number of methodologic problems with Dr. Cassidy's research, and I have only discussed some of them above, but would be happy to go into more detail if asked. For various reasons, some of which are a result of faulty study design, Dr. Cassidy's research failed to find an association between manipulation and VBA stroke. As I mentioned above, Dr. Cassidy be gan with this hypothesis, and chose to attempt to find proof to support this hypothesis. No unbiased scientist would interpret this study's findings to mean that chiropractic treatment doesn't or can't cause VBA stroke, and this can be seen by Dr. Silver's disagreement with the manner in which Dr. Cassidy is trying to use this study. D Freeman PhD MPH DCForensic EpidemiologistAffiliate ProfessorDepartment of Public Health and Preventive MedicineOregon Health and Science University School of Medicinehttp://www.ohsu.edu/xd/education/schools/school-of-medicine/departments/clinical-departments/public-health/people/michael-d-freeman-phd-mph-d.cfmAdjunct Associate Professor of Forensic Medicine and EpidemiologyInstitute of Forensic Medicine, Faculty of Health SciencesAarhus University Aarhus, DenmarkMailing address: 1234 SW 18th Ave, Suite 102Portland, OR 97205T 971-255-1008, F 971-255-1046C 503-871-0715forensictrauma@...>> Thanks for that!> > ph Medlin D.C.> > > From: Jamey Dyson > Sent: Monday, February 28, 2011 5:38 PM> Oregon > Subject: Informed Consent [1 Attachment]> > > I really like this informed consent. It explains the risks very well in my opinion.> Jamey> > > > > ----------------------------------------------------------> > > > > > > ----------------------------------------------------------> > > I really like this informed consent. It explains the risks very well > in my opinion.> Jamey> Quote
Guest guest Posted March 1, 2011 Report Posted March 1, 2011 My impression is that lots of DCs do use them. Having a signed informed consent is a cheap way to avoid litigation. s. fuchs dc From: ph Medlin [mailto:spinetree@...] Sent: Tuesday, March 01, 2011 12:32 PM ; Sharron Fuchs Subject: Re: Informed Consent I'm curious to know how many docs actually use these forms. I do not, and it appears that regardless we could be sued. ph Medlin D.C. From: sharron Sent: Tuesday, March 01, 2011 12:17 PM Subject: Re: [From OregonDCs] Informed Consent Based on the following from Freeman re: Cassidy's 'research' I do not think the language in the informed consent posted by Dr. Dyson would hold water: s.fuchs dc From: Freeman [mailto:forensictrauma@...] Sent: Thursday, February 17, 2011 7:16 PM Sharron Fuchs Subject: Re: Risk of Vertebrobasilar Stroke and Chiropractic Care Hi Sharron, Below are my comments about a report Cassidy did in a malpractice case in which the patient died after the manipulation. The first problem with the study was that the total number of subjects who had a stroke and who had seen a chiropractor in the 7 days prior to the stroke was only 14, and there were only 6 who saw a chiropractor on the same day as the stroke. As it is certainly true that chiropractic practices attract patients with neck pain, and patients who are already having a VBA dissection will have neck pain, then there is certainly a risk of a reverse causation conclusion (the manipulation caused the dissection) when the opposite is the case. This is NOT the case with the patient who presents with minimal or no neck symptoms and then has a stroke within 5 minutes of a cervical manipulation, as the probability of coincidental occurrence of stroke decreases dramatically as the time between the manipulation and the stroke lessens. If all 6 of the chiropractic patients had dissections or strokes within minutes of manipulation this would be extremely important information to have as the relationship would almost certainly not be coincidental, yet this information does not exist in the study described by Dr. Cassidy. Such study is complicated by the fact that there is no way to know from the study methods in how many of the 14 patients who saw chiropractors within a week of their stroke there would have been a causal relationship expected; if the answer is only 1 or 2 then the study would not have had sufficient power (numbers of subjects in each category) to identify a real difference between the groups. It is easiest to describe the flaw in this approach with analogy; consider drug A that is suspected to have fatal reaction in one in every 10,000 doses. If we wanted to study whether the drug A kills people versus drug B, which we know doesn't kill people, we could get 10,000 people who had died, and then find that 200 had taken drug A and 200 had taken drug B. We would incorrectly conclude that the rate of death due to drug A is no greater than with drug B, yet we only assembled 1/50th of the number of people who had taken the drug to find 1 person who had died from the drug! The errone ous conclusion would be that drug A doesn't kill people. It is important to note that whether chiropractic procedures are related to stroke is unrelated to the relationship of stroke and PCP visits. What the study does demonstrate is that patients who are having a VAD with neck pain will present to both a PCP and a chiropractor - an unsurprising finding. However, the paper doesn't demonstrate that a chiropractic treatment to the neck will not or cannot precipitate a stroke. The conclusion is fallacious because the methods of the study cannot disprove a causal relationship. In addition to the above comments about the faulty conclusions that Dr. Cassidy drew with regard to his study, I am in possession of a report of Dr. Silver, dated March 4, 2009. Dr. Silver is a neurologist and a co-author of Dr. Cassidy's, and he clearly does not share Dr. Cassidy's opinion that chiropractic manipulation is not causally associated with VBA stroke. In fact, Dr. Silver pointedly notes in his report that the paper he co-authored included a specific disclaimer that the research did NOT rule out chiropractic treatment as a cause of stroke. When one looks at the study itself, the reason for the need for the disclaimer which Dr. Silver brings forward, is simple. The types of epidemiologic studies that Dr. Cassidy referred to in his report cannot be used as a basis for drawing exclusive causal inferences, as such a study can, at best, be said to have failed to demonstrate a causal association. This is a well accepted fact in epidemiologic science and it is highly inappropriate and frankly wrong for Dr. Cassidy to draw the conclusions he has from his research, which was in fact designed to arrive at a no-relationship conclusion. As I have stated above, there are a number of methodologic problems with Dr. Cassidy's research, and I have only discussed some of them above, but would be happy to go into more detail if asked. For various reasons, some of which are a result of faulty study design, Dr. Cassidy's research failed to find an association between manipulation and VBA stroke. As I mentioned above, Dr. Cassidy be gan with this hypothesis, and chose to attempt to find proof to support this hypothesis. No unbiased scientist would interpret this study's findings to mean that chiropractic treatment doesn't or can't cause VBA stroke, and this can be seen by Dr. Silver's disagreement with the manner in which Dr. Cassidy is trying to use this study. D Freeman PhD MPH DC Forensic Epidemiologist Affiliate Professor Department of Public Health and Preventive Medicine Oregon Health and Science University School of Medicine http://www.ohsu.edu/xd/education/schools/school-of-medicine/departments/clinical-departments/public-health/people/michael-d-freeman-phd-mph-d.cfm Adjunct Associate Professor of Forensic Medicine and Epidemiology Institute of Forensic Medicine, Faculty of Health Sciences Aarhus University Aarhus, Denmark Mailing address: 1234 SW 18th Ave, Suite 102 Portland, OR 97205 T 971-255-1008, F 971-255-1046 C 503-871-0715 forensictrauma@... > > Thanks for that! > > ph Medlin D.C. > > > From: Jamey Dyson > Sent: Monday, February 28, 2011 5:38 PM > Oregon > Subject: Informed Consent [1 Attachment] > > > I really like this informed consent. It explains the risks very well in my opinion. > Jamey > > > > > ---------------------------------------------------------- > > > > > > > ---------------------------------------------------------- > > > I really like this informed consent. It explains the risks very well > in my opinion. > Jamey > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 1, 2011 Report Posted March 1, 2011 I will look at this but realize I AM NOT a lawyer. I need help for this task. SharronSent from my iPhoneOn Mar 1, 2011, at 8:19 PM, "Janet L Rueger, DC" <bodytalk@...> wrote:Sharron,I've attached my consent form. I'd appreciate your opinion of it. Anyone who wishes is welcome to use it, if it covers us.Janet L Rueger, DCCertified in CraniopathyCertified BodyTalk Practitioner149 Clear Creek Dr., # 105Ashland, OR, 97520541-690-6799bodytalk@...On Mar 1, 2011, at 5:13 PM, Sharron Fuchs wrote: Vern had a good response to this a fewposts back. Regarding CVA or any injury for that matter. if a patientunderstands that there is some risk involved and still signs the document thereis more of an uphill battle to prove the case because the patient KNEW therisks and still said yes. In a CVA where the patient signed a consent we wouldhave to prove negligence in the manner in which the treatment was rendered ieexcessive force not just that the patient got the treatment which was notneeded etc. I’d say that an informative and singed informed consent canprevent a case from ever being filed. If you can prevent malpracticeupfront it keeps insurance rates down for all. For those who have no insurance,first and foremost let me say you are ‘crazy’…why risk your life’ssavings for lack of insurance? And secondly, getting sued is a major stress fora doctor. So prevent it as best as you can. I hope this makes sense. It is hard toexplain all the things that go in to assessing a case. s. fuchs dc From: Schneider [mailto:portlandchiro1@...] Sent: Tuesday, March 01, 2011 4:32PMSharron FuchsCc: Subject: Re: Informed Consent So Sharron, what exactlydoes this informed consent do with regard to litigation? Does itpreclude being sued for malpractice if a CVA occurs on a patient in relation toa chiropractic TX? Or does it just reduce the settlement or increase chances ofcase being dismissed? If you have malpractice Ins. and practice carefullywhy get folks all hot and bothered . Schneider DCPDXOn Tue, Mar 1, 2011 at 1:28 PM, Sharron Fuchs <sharronf@...> wrote: My impression is that lots of DCs do use them.Having a signed informed consent is a cheap way to avoid litigation. s. fuchs dc From: ph Medlin[mailto:spinetree@...]Sent: Tuesday, March 01, 201112:32 PM ;Sharron FuchsSubject: Re: Informed Consent I'm curious to know how many docs actually use theseforms. I do not, and it appears that regardless we could be sued. ph Medlin D.C. From: sharron Sent: Tuesday,March 01, 2011 12:17 PM Subject: Re: [FromOregonDCs] Informed Consent Based on the following from Freeman re: Cassidy's 'research' I do notthink the language in the informed consent posted by Dr. Dyson would hold water:s.fuchs dcFrom: Freeman [mailto:forensictrauma@...] Sent: Thursday, February 17, 2011 7:16 PMSharron FuchsSubject: Re: Risk of Vertebrobasilar Stroke and Chiropractic CareHi Sharron,Below are my comments about a report Cassidy did in a malpractice case in whichthe patient died after the manipulation.The first problem with the study was that the total number of subjects who hada stroke and who had seen a chiropractor in the 7 days prior to the stroke wasonly 14, and there were only 6 who saw a chiropractor on the same day as thestroke. As it is certainly true that chiropractic practices attract patientswith neck pain, and patients who are already having a VBA dissection will haveneck pain, then there is certainly a risk of a reverse causation conclusion(the manipulation caused the dissection) when the opposite is the case.This is NOT the case with the patient who presents with minimal or no necksymptoms and then has a stroke within 5 minutes of a cervical manipulation, asthe probability of coincidental occurrence of stroke decreases dramatically asthe time between the manipulation and the stroke lessens. If all 6 of thechiropractic patients had dissections or strokes within minutes of manipulationthis would be extremely important information to have as the relationship wouldalmost certainly not be coincidental, yet this information does not exist inthe study described by Dr. Cassidy. Such study is complicated by the fact that there is no way to know from thestudy methods in how many of the 14 patients who saw chiropractors within aweek of their stroke there would have been a causal relationship expected; ifthe answer is only 1 or 2 then the study would not have had sufficient power(numbers of subjects in each category) to identify a real difference betweenthe groups. It is easiest to describe the flaw in this approach with analogy;consider drug A that is suspected to have fatal reaction in one in every 10,000doses. If we wanted to study whether the drug A kills people versus drug B,which we know doesn't kill people, we could get 10,000 people who had died, andthen find that 200 had taken drug A and 200 had taken drug B. We wouldincorrectly conclude that the rate of death due to drug A is no greater thanwith drug B, yet we only assembled 1/50th of the number of people who had takenthe drug to find 1 person who had died from the drug! The errone ous conclusionwould be that drug A doesn't kill people.It is important to note that whether chiropractic procedures are related tostroke is unrelated to the relationship of stroke and PCP visits. What thestudy does demonstrate is that patients who are having a VAD with neck painwill present to both a PCP and a chiropractor - an unsurprising finding.However, the paper doesn't demonstrate that a chiropractic treatment to theneck will not or cannot precipitate a stroke. The conclusion is fallaciousbecause the methods of the study cannot disprove a causal relationship.In addition to the above comments about the faulty conclusions that Dr. Cassidydrew with regard to his study, I am in possession of a report of Dr. Silver, dated March 4, 2009. Dr. Silver is a neurologist and a co-author of Dr.Cassidy's, and he clearly does not share Dr. Cassidy's opinion thatchiropractic manipulation is not causally associated with VBA stroke. In fact,Dr. Silver pointedly notes in his report that the paper he co-authored includeda specific disclaimer that the research did NOT rule out chiropractic treatmentas a cause of stroke. When one looks at the study itself, the reason for the need for the disclaimerwhich Dr. Silver brings forward, is simple. The types of epidemiologic studiesthat Dr. Cassidy referred to in his report cannot be used as a basis fordrawing exclusive causal inferences, as such a study can, at best, be said tohave failed to demonstrate a causal association. This is a well accepted factin epidemiologic science and it is highly inappropriate and frankly wrong forDr. Cassidy to draw the conclusions he has from his research, which was in factdesigned to arrive at a no-relationship conclusion. As I have stated above,there are a number of methodologic problems with Dr. Cassidy's research, and Ihave only discussed some of them above, but would be happy to go into moredetail if asked. For various reasons, some of which are a result of faultystudy design, Dr. Cassidy's research failed to find an association betweenmanipulation and VBA stroke. As I mentioned above, Dr. Cassidy be gan with thishypothesis, and chose to attempt to find proof to support this hypothesis. Nounbiased scientist would interpret this study's findings to mean thatchiropractic treatment doesn't or can't cause VBA stroke, and this can be seenby Dr. Silver's disagreement with the manner in which Dr. Cassidy is trying touse this study. D Freeman PhD MPH DCForensic EpidemiologistAffiliate ProfessorDepartment of Public Health and Preventive MedicineOregon Health and Science UniversitySchool of Medicinehttp://www.ohsu.edu/xd/education/schools/school-of-medicine/departments/clinical-departments/public-health/people/michael-d-freeman-phd-mph-d.cfmAdjunct Associate Professor of Forensic Medicine and EpidemiologyInstitute of Forensic Medicine, Faculty of HealthSciencesAarhus UniversityAarhus, DenmarkMailing address: 1234 SW 18th Ave,Suite 102Portland, OR97205T 971-255-1008, F 971-255-1046C 503-871-0715forensictrauma@...>> Thanks for that!> > ph Medlin D.C.> > > From: Jamey Dyson > Sent: Monday, February 28, 2011 5:38 PM> Oregon > Subject: Informed Consent [1 Attachment]> > > I really like this informed consent. It explains the risks very well in myopinion.> Jamey> > > > > ----------------------------------------------------------> > > > > > > ----------------------------------------------------------> > > I really like this informed consent. It explains the risks very well > in my opinion.> Jamey>-- Schneider DC PDX<Consent single Dr.doc> Quote
Guest guest Posted March 2, 2011 Report Posted March 2, 2011 Understood. However, Sharron mentioned that Dr. Dyson's form wouldn't "hold water". My point was: are we to be expected to not only provide and informed consent, have a discussion about it (all the while speaking about the potential of the sky falling) AND make sure that an attorney can't nit pick the form apart to force us to still be liable? Personally, I've never proffered an informed consent due to the absolute ridiculous low rates of risk. Due to the CYA aspect of things I'm adding one as of today. However, we can have patients sign these forms all we want and it will not do anything about public perception, lies and exaggeration regarding CVA and chiropractic adjustments. In fact, a good attorney may even find you at fault regardless, albeit with more difficulty......sigh. ph Medlin D.C. From: Vern Saboe Sent: Tuesday, March 01, 2011 6:34 PM Sharron Fuchs Cc: Subject: Re: Informed Consent Yes, I can tell you as someone who has worked for OUM and NCMIC defending my colleagues and reviewing these cases even the few CVA cases I've been involved with not being able to document that the doctors being sued gained informed consent from the patient was everything. The plaintiff simply cannot prove negligence if there is both a written informed consent in the file and a PARQ conference discussing the written form etc., within the chart. In my experience there never would have been a suit if the doctors involved had informed consent documented....Vern Saboe Informed Consent [1 Attachment]> > > I really like this informed consent. It explains the risks very well in my opinion.> Jamey> > > > > ----------------------------------------------------------> > > > > > > ----------------------------------------------------------> > > I really like this informed consent. It explains the risks very well > in my opinion.> Jamey> -- Schneider DC PDX Quote
Guest guest Posted March 2, 2011 Report Posted March 2, 2011 Folks, I’d like to offer two things to this discussion which I hope will quell the concerns expressed about this topic. First, attached is an informed consent form I have used and found quite helpful. Please feel free to copy it onto your own letterheads (or retype it, since the attachment probably won’t copy too well). The OBCE has used this informed consent as an example in the material given out at the programs they hold for new licensees. I can’t say that it constitutes an endorsement by the Board, but they apparently think it’s viable. The way I used it when I was in private practice was that I gave a verbal PARQ to a patient after the history and exam (which was also documented in the chart), then handed them the form to read and, if they agreed, sign. Occasionally a patient would ask a question, but I never had anyone refuse to sign it. Be aware that it is sometimes necessary to modify the informed consent, as in cases where the patient may be at higher than usual risk for an adverse event, e.g., osteoporosis. I recommend having the patient additionally sign any addendum that spells out the unusual circumstance. Second, I’ve found in my work training interns that they are often reluctant to give an appropriate PARQ. I think it is understandable to want to avoid discussing potential adverse side effects, but I advocate a more confrontational approach. I prefer to tell a patient that there are risks to chiropractic adjustments including fractures, disc injuries, dislocations, sprains, and stroke (OMG!), but the likelihood of anything more than post-treatment muscle soreness is rare. I think it’s better to use a take-the-bull-by-the-horns approach and get it over with. This is what I teach my interns. As with the informed consent form, I’ve never had a patient refuse treatment after this kind of PARQ. I hope this is helpful. J. Burke, DC, DABCO Associate Professor University of Western States Gresham Integrated Care 1304 NW Civic Drive Gresham, Oregon 97030 503-512-1040 Email: mburke@... 1 of 1 File(s) InformedConsent.pdf Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.