Guest guest Posted March 2, 2011 Report Posted March 2, 2011 This is a decent informed consent. I don’t like the, ‘as in the practice of medicine’, statement as it seems like a poke in the eye comment. I would just stick to us. Vern, can you scan and post your informed consent for us to look at? Also, there are a number of legal or insurance type reviewers on this list serve perhaps they have some insight? Also, Mike and other lawyers, ideas? s. fuchs dc From: Janet L Rueger, DC [mailto:bodytalk@...] Sent: Tuesday, March 01, 2011 8:17 PM Sharron Fuchs Cc: Subject: Re: Informed Consent Sharron, I've attached my consent form. I'd appreciate your opinion of it. Anyone who wishes is welcome to use it, if it covers us. Janet L Rueger, DC Certified in Craniopathy Certified BodyTalk Practitioner 149 Clear Creek Dr., # 105 Ashland, OR, 97520 541-690-6799 bodytalk@... On Mar 1, 2011, at 5:13 PM, Sharron Fuchs wrote: Vern had a good response to this a few posts back. Regarding CVA or any injury for that matter. if a patient understands that there is some risk involved and still signs the document there is more of an uphill battle to prove the case because the patient KNEW the risks and still said yes. In a CVA where the patient signed a consent we would have to prove negligence in the manner in which the treatment was rendered ie excessive force not just that the patient got the treatment which was not needed etc. I’d say that an informative and singed informed consent can prevent a case from ever being filed. If you can prevent malpractice upfront it keeps insurance rates down for all. For those who have no insurance, first and foremost let me say you are ‘crazy’…why risk your life’s savings for lack of insurance? And secondly, getting sued is a major stress for a doctor. So prevent it as best as you can. I hope this makes sense. It is hard to explain all the things that go in to assessing a case. s. fuchs dc From: Schneider [mailto:portlandchiro1@...] Sent: Tuesday, March 01, 2011 4:32 PM Sharron Fuchs Cc: Subject: Re: Informed Consent So Sharron, what exactly does this informed consent do with regard to litigation? Does it preclude being sued for malpractice if a CVA occurs on a patient in relation to a chiropractic TX? Or does it just reduce the settlement or increase chances of case being dismissed? If you have malpractice Ins. and practice carefully why get folks all hot and bothered .. Schneider DC PDX On Tue, Mar 1, 2011 at 1:28 PM, Sharron Fuchs <sharronf@...> wrote: My impression is that lots of DCs do use them. Having a signed informed consent is a cheap way to avoid litigation. s. fuchs dc From: ph Medlin [mailto:spinetree@...] Sent: Tuesday, March 01, 2011 12:32 PM ; Sharron Fuchs Subject: Re: Informed Consent I'm curious to know how many docs actually use these forms. I do not, and it appears that regardless we could be sued. ph Medlin D.C. From: sharron Sent: Tuesday, March 01, 2011 12:17 PM Subject: Re: [From OregonDCs] Informed Consent Based on the following from Freeman re: Cassidy's 'research' I do not think the language in the informed consent posted by Dr. Dyson would hold water: s.fuchs dc From: Freeman [mailto:forensictrauma@...] Sent: Thursday, February 17, 2011 7:16 PM Sharron Fuchs Subject: Re: Risk of Vertebrobasilar Stroke and Chiropractic Care Hi Sharron, Below are my comments about a report Cassidy did in a malpractice case in which the patient died after the manipulation. The first problem with the study was that the total number of subjects who had a stroke and who had seen a chiropractor in the 7 days prior to the stroke was only 14, and there were only 6 who saw a chiropractor on the same day as the stroke. As it is certainly true that chiropractic practices attract patients with neck pain, and patients who are already having a VBA dissection will have neck pain, then there is certainly a risk of a reverse causation conclusion (the manipulation caused the dissection) when the opposite is the case. This is NOT the case with the patient who presents with minimal or no neck symptoms and then has a stroke within 5 minutes of a cervical manipulation, as the probability of coincidental occurrence of stroke decreases dramatically as the time between the manipulation and the stroke lessens. If all 6 of the chiropractic patients had dissections or strokes within minutes of manipulation this would be extremely important information to have as the relationship would almost certainly not be coincidental, yet this information does not exist in the study described by Dr. Cassidy. Such study is complicated by the fact that there is no way to know from the study methods in how many of the 14 patients who saw chiropractors within a week of their stroke there would have been a causal relationship expected; if the answer is only 1 or 2 then the study would not have had sufficient power (numbers of subjects in each category) to identify a real difference between the groups. It is easiest to describe the flaw in this approach with analogy; consider drug A that is suspected to have fatal reaction in one in every 10,000 doses. If we wanted to study whether the drug A kills people versus drug B, which we know doesn't kill people, we could get 10,000 people who had died, and then find that 200 had taken drug A and 200 had taken drug B. We would incorrectly conclude that the rate of death due to drug A is no greater than with drug B, yet we only assembled 1/50th of the number of people who had taken the drug to find 1 person who had died from the drug! The errone ous conclusion would be that drug A doesn't kill people. It is important to note that whether chiropractic procedures are related to stroke is unrelated to the relationship of stroke and PCP visits. What the study does demonstrate is that patients who are having a VAD with neck pain will present to both a PCP and a chiropractor - an unsurprising finding. However, the paper doesn't demonstrate that a chiropractic treatment to the neck will not or cannot precipitate a stroke. The conclusion is fallacious because the methods of the study cannot disprove a causal relationship. In addition to the above comments about the faulty conclusions that Dr. Cassidy drew with regard to his study, I am in possession of a report of Dr. Silver, dated March 4, 2009. Dr. Silver is a neurologist and a co-author of Dr. Cassidy's, and he clearly does not share Dr. Cassidy's opinion that chiropractic manipulation is not causally associated with VBA stroke. In fact, Dr. Silver pointedly notes in his report that the paper he co-authored included a specific disclaimer that the research did NOT rule out chiropractic treatment as a cause of stroke. When one looks at the study itself, the reason for the need for the disclaimer which Dr. Silver brings forward, is simple. The types of epidemiologic studies that Dr. Cassidy referred to in his report cannot be used as a basis for drawing exclusive causal inferences, as such a study can, at best, be said to have failed to demonstrate a causal association. This is a well accepted fact in epidemiologic science and it is highly inappropriate and frankly wrong for Dr. Cassidy to draw the conclusions he has from his research, which was in fact designed to arrive at a no-relationship conclusion. As I have stated above, there are a number of methodologic problems with Dr. Cassidy's research, and I have only discussed some of them above, but would be happy to go into more detail if asked. For various reasons, some of which are a result of faulty study design, Dr. Cassidy's research failed to find an association between manipulation and VBA stroke. As I mentioned above, Dr. Cassidy be gan with this hypothesis, and chose to attempt to find proof to support this hypothesis. No unbiased scientist would interpret this study's findings to mean that chiropractic treatment doesn't or can't cause VBA stroke, and this can be seen by Dr. Silver's disagreement with the manner in which Dr. Cassidy is trying to use this study. D Freeman PhD MPH DC Forensic Epidemiologist Affiliate Professor Department of Public Health and Preventive Medicine Oregon Health and Science University School of Medicine http://www.ohsu.edu/xd/education/schools/school-of-medicine/departments/clinical-departments/public-health/people/michael-d-freeman-phd-mph-d.cfm Adjunct Associate Professor of Forensic Medicine and Epidemiology Institute of Forensic Medicine, Faculty of Health Sciences Aarhus University Aarhus, Denmark Mailing address: 1234 SW 18th Ave, Suite 102 Portland, OR 97205 T 971-255-1008, F 971-255-1046 C 503-871-0715 forensictrauma@... > > Thanks for that! > > ph Medlin D.C. > > > From: Jamey Dyson > Sent: Monday, February 28, 2011 5:38 PM > Oregon > Subject: Informed Consent [1 Attachment] > > > I really like this informed consent. It explains the risks very well in my opinion. > Jamey > > > > > ---------------------------------------------------------- > > > > > > > ---------------------------------------------------------- > > > I really like this informed consent. It explains the risks very well > in my opinion. > Jamey > -- Schneider DC PDX Quote
Guest guest Posted March 2, 2011 Report Posted March 2, 2011 I would if I owned a scanner……Vern From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Sharron FuchsSent: Wednesday, March 02, 2011 4:01 PMCc: Subject: RE: Informed Consent This is a decent informed consent. I don’t like the, ‘as in the practice of medicine’, statement as it seems like a poke in the eye comment. I would just stick to us. Vern, can you scan and post your informed consent for us to look at? Also, there are a number of legal or insurance type reviewers on this list serve perhaps they have some insight? Also, Mike and other lawyers, ideas? s. fuchs dc From: Janet L Rueger, DC [mailto:bodytalk@...] Sent: Tuesday, March 01, 2011 8:17 PMSharron FuchsCc: Subject: Re: Informed Consent Sharron, I've attached my consent form. I'd appreciate your opinion of it. Anyone who wishes is welcome to use it, if it covers us. Janet L Rueger, DCCertified in CraniopathyCertified BodyTalk Practitioner149 Clear Creek Dr., # 105Ashland, OR, 97520541-690-6799bodytalk@... On Mar 1, 2011, at 5:13 PM, Sharron Fuchs wrote: Vern had a good response to this a few posts back. Regarding CVA or any injury for that matter. if a patient understands that there is some risk involved and still signs the document there is more of an uphill battle to prove the case because the patient KNEW the risks and still said yes. In a CVA where the patient signed a consent we would have to prove negligence in the manner in which the treatment was rendered ie excessive force not just that the patient got the treatment which was not needed etc. I’d say that an informative and singed informed consent can prevent a case from ever being filed. If you can prevent malpractice upfront it keeps insurance rates down for all. For those who have no insurance, first and foremost let me say you are ‘crazy’…why risk your life’s savings for lack of insurance? And secondly, getting sued is a major stress for a doctor. So prevent it as best as you can. I hope this makes sense. It is hard to explain all the things that go in to assessing a case. s. fuchs dc From: Schneider [mailto:portlandchiro1@...] Sent: Tuesday, March 01, 2011 4:32 PMSharron FuchsCc: Subject: Re: Informed Consent So Sharron, what exactly does this informed consent do with regard to litigation? Does it preclude being sued for malpractice if a CVA occurs on a patient in relation to a chiropractic TX? Or does it just reduce the settlement or increase chances of case being dismissed? If you have malpractice Ins. and practice carefully why get folks all hot and bothered . Schneider DCPDXOn Tue, Mar 1, 2011 at 1:28 PM, Sharron Fuchs <sharronf@...> wrote: My impression is that lots of DCs do use them. Having a signed informed consent is a cheap way to avoid litigation. s. fuchs dc From: ph Medlin [mailto:spinetree@...] Sent: Tuesday, March 01, 2011 12:32 PM ; Sharron FuchsSubject: Re: Informed Consent I'm curious to know how many docs actually use these forms. I do not, and it appears that regardless we could be sued. ph Medlin D.C. From: sharron Sent: Tuesday, March 01, 2011 12:17 PM Subject: Re: Informed Consent Based on the following from Freeman re: Cassidy's 'research' I do not think the language in the informed consent posted by Dr. Dyson would hold water:s.fuchs dcFrom: Freeman [mailto:forensictrauma@...] Sent: Thursday, February 17, 2011 7:16 PMSharron FuchsSubject: Re: Risk of Vertebrobasilar Stroke and Chiropractic CareHi Sharron,Below are my comments about a report Cassidy did in a malpractice case in which the patient died after the manipulation.The first problem with the study was that the total number of subjects who had a stroke and who had seen a chiropractor in the 7 days prior to the stroke was only 14, and there were only 6 who saw a chiropractor on the same day as the stroke. As it is certainly true that chiropractic practices attract patients with neck pain, and patients who are already having a VBA dissection will have neck pain, then there is certainly a risk of a reverse causation conclusion (the manipulation caused the dissection) when the opposite is the case.This is NOT the case with the patient who presents with minimal or no neck symptoms and then has a stroke within 5 minutes of a cervical manipulation, as the probability of coincidental occurrence of stroke decreases dramatically as the time between the manipulation and the stroke lessens. If all 6 of the chiropractic patients had dissections or strokes within minutes of manipulation this would be extremely important information to have as the relationship would almost certainly not be coincidental, yet this information does not exist in the study described by Dr. Cassidy. Such study is complicated by the fact that there is no way to know from the study methods in how many of the 14 patients who saw chiropractors within a week of their stroke there would have been a causal relationship expected; if the answer is only 1 or 2 then the study would not have had sufficient power (numbers of subjects in each category) to identify a real difference between the groups. It is easiest to describe the flaw in this approach with analogy; consider drug A that is suspected to have fatal reaction in one in every 10,000 doses. If we wanted to study whether the drug A kills people versus drug B, which we know doesn't kill people, we could get 10,000 people who had died, and then find that 200 had taken drug A and 200 had taken drug B. We would incorrectly conclude that the rate of death due to drug A is no greater than with drug B, yet we only assembled 1/50th of the number of people who had taken the drug to find 1 person who had died from the drug! The errone ous conclusion would be that drug A doesn't kill people.It is important to note that whether chiropractic procedures are related to stroke is unrelated to the relationship of stroke and PCP visits. What the study does demonstrate is that patients who are having a VAD with neck pain will present to both a PCP and a chiropractor - an unsurprising finding. However, the paper doesn't demonstrate that a chiropractic treatment to the neck will not or cannot precipitate a stroke. The conclusion is fallacious because the methods of the study cannot disprove a causal relationship.In addition to the above comments about the faulty conclusions that Dr. Cassidy drew with regard to his study, I am in possession of a report of Dr. Silver, dated March 4, 2009. Dr. Silver is a neurologist and a co-author of Dr. Cassidy's, and he clearly does not share Dr. Cassidy's opinion that chiropractic manipulation is not causally associated with VBA stroke. In fact, Dr. Silver pointedly notes in his report that the paper he co-authored included a specific disclaimer that the research did NOT rule out chiropractic treatment as a cause of stroke. When one looks at the study itself, the reason for the need for the disclaimer which Dr. Silver brings forward, is simple. The types of epidemiologic studies that Dr. Cassidy referred to in his report cannot be used as a basis for drawing exclusive causal inferences, as such a study can, at best, be said to have failed to demonstrate a causal association. This is a well accepted fact in epidemiologic science and it is highly inappropriate and frankly wrong for Dr. Cassidy to draw the conclusions he has from his research, which was in fact designed to arrive at a no-relationship conclusion. As I have stated above, there are a number of methodologic problems with Dr. Cassidy's research, and I have only discussed some of them above, but would be happy to go into more detail if asked. For various reasons, some of which are a result of faulty study design, Dr. Cassidy's research failed to find an association between manipulation and VBA stroke. As I mentioned above, Dr. Cassidy be gan with this hypothesis, and chose to attempt to find proof to support this hypothesis. No unbiased scientist would interpret this study's findings to mean that chiropractic treatment doesn't or can't cause VBA stroke, and this can be seen by Dr. Silver's disagreement with the manner in which Dr. Cassidy is trying to use this study. D Freeman PhD MPH DCForensic EpidemiologistAffiliate ProfessorDepartment of Public Health and Preventive MedicineOregon Health and Science University School of Medicinehttp://www.ohsu.edu/xd/education/schools/school-of-medicine/departments/clinical-departments/public-health/people/michael-d-freeman-phd-mph-d.cfmAdjunct Associate Professor of Forensic Medicine and EpidemiologyInstitute of Forensic Medicine, Faculty of Health SciencesAarhus University Aarhus, DenmarkMailing address: 1234 SW 18th Ave, Suite 102Portland, OR 97205T 971-255-1008, F 971-255-1046C 503-871-0715forensictrauma@...>> Thanks for that!> > ph Medlin D.C.> > > From: Jamey Dyson > Sent: Monday, February 28, 2011 5:38 PM> Oregon > Subject: Informed Consent [1 Attachment]> > > I really like this informed consent. It explains the risks very well in my opinion.> Jamey> > > > > ----------------------------------------------------------> > > > > > > ----------------------------------------------------------> > > I really like this informed consent. It explains the risks very well > in my opinion.> Jamey>-- Schneider DC PDX No virus found in this message.Checked by AVG - www.avg.comVersion: 10.0.1204 / Virus Database: 1435/3477 - Release Date: 03/02/11 Quote
Guest guest Posted March 3, 2011 Report Posted March 3, 2011 In response to Dr. Medlin, it’s important to remember that a signed informed consent protects you not only from those rare occasions when a patient is actually injured but also from instances when patients PERCEIVE they have been injured. Furthermore, just as we cannot guarantee a cure, so too we cannot guarantee there will be no adverse outcome. There are always risks. Life is a risk. If you don’t inform your patients of those risks, however unlikely they may be, you may be held negligent. With informed consent, even when you’ve done everything correctly, there is still the risk of an adverse response, and in those situations it will most likely be seen that you’ve done your due diligence and you will be held harmless. J. Burke, DC, DABCO Associate Professor University of Western States Gresham Integrated Care 1304 NW Civic Drive Gresham, Oregon 97030 503-512-1040 Email: mburke@... Quote
Guest guest Posted March 3, 2011 Report Posted March 3, 2011 Makes perfect sense and I've just included the consent form in all new patient files. ph Medlin D.C. From: Burke Sent: Thursday, March 03, 2011 9:14 AM ' ' Subject: Re: Informed Consent In response to Dr. Medlin, it’s important to remember that a signed informed consent protects you not only from those rare occasions when a patient is actually injured but also from instances when patients PERCEIVE they have been injured. Furthermore, just as we cannot guarantee a cure, so too we cannot guarantee there will be no adverse outcome. There are always risks. Life is a risk. If you don’t inform your patients of those risks, however unlikely they may be, you may be held negligent. With informed consent, even when you’ve done everything correctly, there is still the risk of an adverse response, and in those situations it will most likely be seen that you’ve done your due diligence and you will be held harmless. J. Burke, DC, DABCO Associate Professor University of Western States Gresham Integrated Care 1304 NW Civic Drive Gresham, Oregon 97030 503-512-1040 Email: mburke@... Quote
Guest guest Posted March 3, 2011 Report Posted March 3, 2011 Follow this link for a blog entry on informed consent from , a chiropractic office specialist. http://c-aide.blogspot.com/2011/03/informed-consent.html Hacmac, DC Portland, OR503-656-8098_________________________________________________________________________________Electronic Privacy Notice. This e-mail, and any attachments, contains information that is, or may be, covered by the Electronic Communications Privacy Act, 18 U.S.C. 2510-2521, and is also confidential and proprietary in nature. If you are not the intended recipient, please be advised that you are legally prohibited from retaining, using, copying, distributing, or otherwise disclosing this information in any manner. Instead, please reply to the sender that you have received this communication in error, and then immediately delete it. Thank you in advance for your cooperation. ; mburke@...From: spinetree@...Date: Thu, 3 Mar 2011 09:49:38 -0800Subject: Re: Re: Informed Consent Makes perfect sense and I've just included the consent form in all new patient files. ph Medlin D.C. From: Burke Sent: Thursday, March 03, 2011 9:14 AM ' ' Subject: Re: Informed Consent In response to Dr. Medlin, it’s important to remember that a signed informed consent protects you not only from those rare occasions when a patient is actually injured but also from instances when patients PERCEIVE they have been injured. Furthermore, just as we cannot guarantee a cure, so too we cannot guarantee there will be no adverse outcome. There are always risks. Life is a risk. If you don’t inform your patients of those risks, however unlikely they may be, you may be held negligent. With informed consent, even when you’ve done everything correctly, there is still the risk of an adverse response, and in those situations it will most likely be seen that you’ve done your due diligence and you will be held harmless. J. Burke, DC, DABCO Associate Professor University of Western States Gresham Integrated Care 1304 NW Civic Drive Gresham, Oregon 97030 503-512-1040 Email: mburke@... Quote
Guest guest Posted March 4, 2011 Report Posted March 4, 2011 I like and use Vern'sDr. A Caughlin DC CAC155 NW 1st Ave Day, Or. 97845 office 541-575-1063 fax 541-575-5554spinetree@...; ; mburke@...From: ehacmac@...Date: Thu, 3 Mar 2011 18:23:10 -0800Subject: RE: Re: Informed Consent Follow this link for a blog entry on informed consent from , a chiropractic office specialist. http://c-aide.blogspot.com/2011/03/informed-consent.html Hacmac, DC Portland, OR503-656-8098_________________________________________________________________________________Electronic Privacy Notice. This e-mail, and any attachments, contains information that is, or may be, covered by the Electronic Communications Privacy Act, 18 U.S.C. 2510-2521, and is also confidential and proprietary in nature. If you are not the intended recipient, please be advised that you are legally prohibited from retaining, using, copying, distributing, or otherwise disclosing this information in any manner. Instead, please reply to the sender that you have received this communication in error, and then immediately delete it. Thank you in advance for your cooperation. ; mburke@...From: spinetree@...Date: Thu, 3 Mar 2011 09:49:38 -0800Subject: Re: Re: Informed Consent Makes perfect sense and I've just included the consent form in all new patient files. ph Medlin D.C. From: Burke Sent: Thursday, March 03, 2011 9:14 AM ' ' Subject: Re: Informed Consent In response to Dr. Medlin, it’s important to remember that a signed informed consent protects you not only from those rare occasions when a patient is actually injured but also from instances when patients PERCEIVE they have been injured. Furthermore, just as we cannot guarantee a cure, so too we cannot guarantee there will be no adverse outcome. There are always risks. Life is a risk. If you don’t inform your patients of those risks, however unlikely they may be, you may be held negligent. With informed consent, even when you’ve done everything correctly, there is still the risk of an adverse response, and in those situations it will most likely be seen that you’ve done your due diligence and you will be held harmless. J. Burke, DC, DABCO Associate Professor University of Western States Gresham Integrated Care 1304 NW Civic Drive Gresham, Oregon 97030 503-512-1040 Email: mburke@... Quote
Guest guest Posted March 4, 2011 Report Posted March 4, 2011 Well that’s because you are an extremely intelligent individual, lol! Vern From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Charlie CaughlinSent: Friday, March 04, 2011 7:57 AMehacmac@...; spinetree@...; ; mburke@...Subject: RE: Re: Informed Consent I like and use Vern's Dr. A Caughlin DC CAC155 NW 1st Ave Day, Or. 97845 office 541-575-1063 fax 541-575-5554spinetree@...; ; mburke@...From: ehacmac@...Date: Thu, 3 Mar 2011 18:23:10 -0800Subject: RE: Re: Informed Consent Follow this link for a blog entry on informed consent from , a chiropractic office specialist.http://c-aide.blogspot.com/2011/03/informed-consent.html Hacmac, DC Portland, OR503-656-8098_________________________________________________________________________________Electronic Privacy Notice. This e-mail, and any attachments, contains information that is, or may be, covered by the Electronic Communications Privacy Act, 18 U.S.C. 2510-2521, and is also confidential and proprietary in nature. If you are not the intended recipient, please be advised that you are legally prohibited from retaining, using, copying, distributing, or otherwise disclosing this information in any manner. Instead, please reply to the sender that you have received this communication in error, and then immediately delete it. Thank you in advance for your cooperation. ; mburke@...From: spinetree@...Date: Thu, 3 Mar 2011 09:49:38 -0800Subject: Re: Re: Informed Consent Makes perfect sense and I've just included the consent form in all new patient files. ph Medlin D.C. From: Burke Sent: Thursday, March 03, 2011 9:14 AM' ' Subject: Re: Informed Consent In response to Dr. Medlin, it’s important to remember that a signed informed consent protects you not only from those rare occasions when a patient is actually injured but also from instances when patients PERCEIVE they have been injured. Furthermore, just as we cannot guarantee a cure, so too we cannot guarantee there will be no adverse outcome. There are always risks. Life is a risk. If you don’t inform your patients of those risks, however unlikely they may be, you may be held negligent. With informed consent, even when you’ve done everything correctly, there is still the risk of an adverse response, and in those situations it will most likely be seen that you’ve done your due diligence and you will be held harmless.J. Burke, DC, DABCOAssociate ProfessorUniversity of Western StatesGresham Integrated Care1304 NW Civic DriveGresham, Oregon 97030503-512-1040Email: mburke@... No virus found in this message.Checked by AVG - www.avg.comVersion: 10.0.1204 / Virus Database: 1435/3481 - Release Date: 03/04/11 Quote
Guest guest Posted March 4, 2011 Report Posted March 4, 2011 Interesting blog. Do you know this person? It is funny that they are posting on issues that we are discussing on the list serve....gosh, some look my own words. I think he is right. Would people object to a uniform informed consent form posted on the OBCE website? s.fuchs dc > > > Follow this link for a blog entry on informed consent from , a chiropractic office specialist. > > http://c-aide.blogspot.com/2011/03/informed-consent.html > > > > Hacmac, DC > Portland, OR > 503-656-8098 > > ________________________________________________________________________________\ _ > Electronic Privacy Notice. This e-mail, and any attachments, contains information that is, or may be, covered by the Electronic Communications Privacy Act, 18 U.S.C. 2510-2521, and is also confidential and proprietary in nature. If you are not the intended recipient, please be advised that you are legally prohibited from retaining, using, copying, distributing, or otherwise disclosing this information in any manner. Instead, please reply to the sender that you have received this communication in error, and then immediately delete it. Thank you in advance for your cooperation. > > > > > ; mburke@... > From: spinetree@... > Date: Thu, 3 Mar 2011 09:49:38 -0800 > Subject: Re: Re: Informed Consent > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Makes perfect sense and I've just included the consent > form in all new patient files. > > ph Medlin D.C. > > > > > From: Burke > Sent: Thursday, March 03, 2011 9:14 AM > ' ' > Subject: Re: Informed Consent > > > > > > In response to Dr. Medlin, it's important to remember > that a signed informed consent protects you not only from those rare occasions > when a patient is actually injured but also from instances when patients > PERCEIVE they have been injured. Furthermore, just as we cannot guarantee a > cure, so too we cannot guarantee there will be no adverse outcome. There are > always risks. Life is a risk. If you don't inform your patients of those risks, > however unlikely they may be, you may be held negligent. With informed consent, > even when you've done everything correctly, there is still the risk of an > adverse response, and in those situations it will most likely be seen that > you've done your due diligence and you will be held harmless. > > J. Burke, > DC, DABCO > Associate > Professor > University of Western > States > Gresham Integrated > Care > 1304 NW Civic > Drive > Gresham, Oregon > 97030 > 503-512-1040 > Email: mburke@... > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 5, 2011 Report Posted March 5, 2011 Glen, I think you are on to something here. If we can just get all this info in a concise format we will have a great form indeed!! I love the lightning infl-along with the protective value of adjusting relative to strokes. Schneider DCPDXOn Sat, Mar 5, 2011 at 11:35 AM, Dr. Glenn Sykes <drsykes@...> wrote: I’ve been giving “Informed Consent” some thought. And after listening to a fascinating debate I have come up with an informed consent form that I think brings together both sides of the debate. You are not truly informed simply because you know stroke is a possible adverse reaction to an adjustment. You’re only fully informed if you know the relative risk of that outcome. And since humans are incredibly poor judges of relative risk… I figured why not list the relative risk data. The facts and figures are mostly totally made up by me. So please don’t rip them apart. However my intent is quite clear. I’m sure somebody out there has easy access to the correct stats and could clean this up. I apologize if the layout does not come thru clearly… Chiropractic Clinic PARQ FORM Congratulations on choosing chiropractic care. I feel it is important to for all patients to be educated consumers of their health care. To that end I will be sitting down with you to discuss the Procedures I recommend, the common Alterative to those procedures and the relative Risk associated with the procedures and the alternatives. At the end, should you have any Questions I will be happy to give you all the time you need. The recommendations I will make are based on my 2,500 hours of undergraduate training, 4,700 hours of chiropractic education, 3 years as an anatomy & physiology professor, 15 years of clinical experience, over 1000 hours of post-graduate continuing education. Not to mention, well as over a hundred years of scientific research into chiropractic. Procedures Risks Rate Chiropractic adjustments -Sprain 1/200 -Dislocations 1/10,000 -Stroke 1/7,000,000 Ultrasound - bone burns 1/1,500 E-stim -reaction to gel 1/100 Hot packs -burns 1/5,000 Massage -bruising 1/100 Exercise - sprains/strains 1/20 Slipping in my parking lot on the way in -broken hip 1/7 (lifetime risk if hip fracture) Driving to my office -car accident one death every 13 minutes (I looked that one up) Choking on the chocolate covered Espresso Bean that came with the coffee you bought on the way to the office -death by choking 1/1,000 Getting struck by lightning in my parking lot –death by electrocution 1/6,000,000 (more likely than a stroke) Alternative Risks Rate NASIDS -death 1/50,000 Surgery -failed surgery ½ of all back surgeries patients are no better or worse Anesthesia related death - death 1/10,000 Rest -no improvement ¼ don’t get better with rest Narcotics -addiction 1/1,000 Steroids -destruction of bone Kidneys, adrenals, 100% guaranteed damage to one or all of those systems and immune system Do nothing - risk of a spontaneous stroke 4.67/10,000* (Which means if you came in for chiropractic you have a 1/7,000,000 chance of dying from a stroke. If you don’t come in you have approximately a 1 in 2,100 chance of dying from a stroke. Or said another way: Medical research, in an attempt to destroy chiropractic, has proven that chiropractic offers a 3000 fold protection from stroke!) (* from the Stroke Center: 143,579 stroke deaths/307,000,000 people in USA; if my math is correct = 4.67/10,000 death rate) I have read this PARQ and Dr. Glenn has answered all my questions. Patients name:___________________________ Date______________________ Glenn Sykes, DC Gresham Town Fair Chiropractic Clinic Phone: (503) 667-6744 Fax: (503) 661-7896 WWW.GRESHAMCHIROPRACTOR.NET __________ Information from ESET NOD32 Antivirus, version of virus signature database 5912 (20110227) __________ The message was checked by ESET NOD32 Antivirus. http://www.eset.com -- Schneider DC PDX Quote
Guest guest Posted March 5, 2011 Report Posted March 5, 2011 I love it. I'm not saying that as a board member, but as a doctor. I hope someone looks up and posts all the other risk rates. I think it is fun- not much in a doctor's office is fun and gets the point across. Ann Goldeen informed consent I’ve been giving “Informed Consent” some thought. And after listening to a fascinating debate I have come up with an informed consent form that I think brings together both sides of the debate. You are not truly informed simply because you know stroke is a possible adverse reaction to an adjustment. You’re only fully informed if you know the relative risk of that outcome. And since humans are incredibly poor judges of relative risk… I figured why not list the relative risk data. The facts and figures are mostly totally made up by me. So please don’t rip them apart. However my intent is quite clear. I’m sure somebody out there has easy access to the correct stats and could clean this up. I apologize if the layout does not come thru clearly… Chiropractic Clinic PARQ FORM Congratulations on choosing chiropractic care. I feel it is important to for all patients to be educated consumers of their health care. To that end I will be sitting down with you to discuss the Procedures I recommend, the common Alterative to those procedures and the relative Risk associated with the procedures and the alternatives. At the end, should you have any Questions I will be happy to give you all the time you need. The recommendations I will make are based on my 2,500 hours of undergraduate training, 4,700 hours of chiropractic education, 3 years as an anatomy & physiology professor, 15 years of clinical experience, over 1000 hours of post-graduate continuing education. Not to mention, well as over a hundred years of scientific research into chiropractic. Procedures Risks Rate Chiropractic adjustments -Sprain 1/200 -Dislocations 1/10,000 -Stroke 1/7,000,000 Ultrasound - bone burns 1/1,500 E-stim -reaction to gel 1/100 Hot packs -burns 1/5,000 Massage -bruising 1/100 Exercise - sprains/strains 1/20 Slipping in my parking lot on the way in -broken hip 1/7 (lifetime risk if hip fracture) Driving to my office -car accident one death every 13 minutes (I looked that one up) Choking on the chocolate covered Espresso Bean that came with the coffee you bought on the way to the office -death by choking 1/1,000 Getting struck by lightning in my parking lot –death by electrocution 1/6,000,000 (more likely than a stroke) Alternative Risks Rate NASIDS -death 1/50,000 Surgery -failed surgery ½ of all back surgeries patients are no better or worse Anesthesia related death - death 1/10,000 Rest -no improvement ¼ don’t get better with rest Narcotics -addiction 1/1,000 Steroids -destruction of bone Kidneys, adrenals, 100% guaranteed damage to one or all of those systems and immune system Do nothing - risk of a spontaneous stroke 4.67/10,000* (Which means if you came in for chiropractic you have a 1/7,000,000 chance of dying from a stroke. If you don’t come in you have approximately a 1 in 2,100 chance of dying from a stroke. Or said another way: Medical research, in an attempt to destroy chiropractic, has proven that chiropractic offers a 3000 fold protection from stroke!) (* from the Stroke Center: 143,579 stroke deaths/307,000,000 people in USA; if my math is correct = 4.67/10,000 death rate) I have read this PARQ and Dr. Glenn has answered all my questions. Patients name:___________________________ Date______________________ Glenn Sykes, DC Gresham Town Fair Chiropractic Clinic Phone: (503) 667-6744 Fax: (503) 661-7896 WWW.GRESHAMCHIROPRACTOR.NET __________ Information from ESET NOD32 Antivirus, version of virus signature database 5912 (20110227) __________The message was checked by ESET NOD32 Antivirus.http://www.eset.com Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.