Guest guest Posted October 5, 2010 Report Posted October 5, 2010 > > , cataracts often respond to eye hydration but there's nothing by way of data to support the claim that coconut water penetrates, and if it was true, it would certainly kill cells by lysing them due to the non-isotonic nature of such a treatment. Same reason as needing saline water for an IV. (end Duncan quote) Not all good, Dee Quote
Guest guest Posted October 5, 2010 Report Posted October 5, 2010 Someone on another list was asking about cataracts. I posted a quote from the link you gave to her. She is going to try coconut water several times a week. I will report back when she posts back to that list. I sure would give it a try if I had cataracts. Not only do I not have $$ for surgery, I do not want my lenses removed and be forced to wear contact lenses 24/7. I tried contacts once, back 30 years ago and I hated them! Alobar On Sat, Oct 2, 2010 at 4:58 PM, Dolores <dgk@...> wrote: > > Now, to get back to the subject of using young coconut water for cataracts, I found the procedure online - including a very interesting true story by Dr. Fife that inspired him to include it in his book. > All who are plagued with cataracts - enjoy!: > http://www.mb.com.ph/articles/211348/coconut-water-health-and-healing > > Dee > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 6, 2010 Report Posted October 6, 2010 > > , cataracts often respond to eye hydration but there's nothing by way of data to support the claim that coconut water penetrates, and if it was true, it would certainly kill cells by lysing them due to the non-isotonic nature of such a treatment. Same reason as needing saline water for an IV. (end Duncan quote) Not all good, Dee Quote
Guest guest Posted October 6, 2010 Report Posted October 6, 2010 WOW! Smile - It makes you feel better... Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile Re: Young Coconut Water for Cataracts. > > , cataracts often respond to eye hydration but there's nothing by way of data to support the claim that coconut water penetrates, and if it was true, it would certainly kill cells by lysing them due to the non-isotonic nature of such a treatment. Same reason as needing saline water for an IV. (end Duncan quote) Not all good, Dee ------------------------------------ Quote
Guest guest Posted October 6, 2010 Report Posted October 6, 2010 Duncan, You said: The doctors would record the death as due to blood loss with no harm, no foul for their last-ditch heroics. " Isn't this a wild guess on your part, assuming that this is what the doctors did? Your reply is based on YOUR assumptions, any proof too? Quote
Guest guest Posted October 6, 2010 Report Posted October 6, 2010 Alobar, Your being diabetic poses a good risk that you can go blind after eye surgery. I know of someone who lost his eyes trying to fix cataracts, he was diabetic... > > Someone on another list was asking about cataracts. I posted a quote > from the link you gave to her. She is going to try coconut water > several times a week. I will report back when she posts back to that > list. > > I sure would give it a try if I had cataracts. Not only do I not > have $$ for surgery, I do not want my lenses removed and be forced to > wear contact lenses 24/7. I tried contacts once, back 30 years ago > and I hated them! > > Alobar > > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 6, 2010 Report Posted October 6, 2010 I do not plan to ever have cataract surgery. Even if I ever did get cataracts. Alobar On Wed, Oct 6, 2010 at 12:11 PM, <@...> wrote: > > Alobar, > > Your being diabetic poses a good risk that you can go blind after eye surgery. Â I know of someone who lost his eyes trying to fix cataracts, he was diabetic... > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 7, 2010 Report Posted October 7, 2010 Dee, this study points out coconut water is hypotonic, and one report that used coconut water as a dextrose substitute sure enough mixed it with saline. Coconut water has only half the sodium blood has but very high potassium. Of course high potassium can cause heart attacks so it carries risks. http://ipac.kacst.edu.sa/eDoc/2007/164453_1.pdf Coconut water was apparently pressed into service in WWII by a doctor who worked with the Japanese. One doctor's report of emergency procedures with no measurements of red blood cell lysis. The research points out that this overseas work was a very uncommon practice in which the MDs occasionally had to press into use whatever fluid he could to save lives in a third world country, or just do without. The document says the practice would not fly in developed countries and I agree. Anyway coconut water is still considered to be hypotonic today, and saline should probably be added for safety. I support safety controls in this regard. <snip>DISCUSSION Osmolality/Osmolarity The total inorganic cationic content averaged 90 mEq/L. This result is congruent with the description of GCW by Eiseman as having ``the characteristics of a hypotonic intracellular fluid. The total cation or anion content averaged 81 mEq/L (a little over one-half of that of human plasma)'' [7]. Olurin et al. measured the tonicity of 20 green coconut samples. Although they do not provide further details, they describe GCW as hypo-osmolar [4]. GCW is hypotonic/ hypo-osmolar in comparison with plasma only with respect to its inorganic ionic composition. If one takes into consideration organic compounds, as clinicians do, then it becomes hypertonic/hyperosmolar. Major Elements (mM/L) Our results confirm previously published data. As compared with normal plasma values GCW has a very high K content, a high Ca, Mg, and P content and a low Na content. The clinical implications of high K, Ca, and Mg have been discussed previously [4,68]</snip> all good, Duncan > > > , cataracts often respond to eye hydration but there's nothing by way > of data to support the claim that coconut water penetrates, and if it was true, > it would certainly kill cells by lysing them due to the non-isotonic nature of > such a treatment. Same reason as needing saline water for an IV. (end Duncan quote) > > Not all good, > Dee > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 7, 2010 Report Posted October 7, 2010 No , it's knowledge of common medical practice that got me to that reply. Let me explain: When the doctor has only coconut water he can use it as an IV fluid or do without as the research stated. If he does without, there's no harm if the patient dies, as not using coconut water IV is not considered to be a withheld medical practice. If he takes responsibility for giving the coconut water IV and the patient dies, the death is officially due to the reality of measurable blood loss rather than the optimistic but failed last minute heroic attempt. In either case there's no blame and the death is simply recorded. all good, Duncan > > Duncan, > > You said: The doctors would record the death as due to blood loss with no harm, no foul for their last-ditch heroics. " > > Isn't this a wild guess on your part, assuming that this is what the doctors did? Your reply is based on YOUR assumptions, any proof too? > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 7, 2010 Report Posted October 7, 2010 : diabetes normally carries a risk of or actual very high oxidative stress and inflammation, which will impair microcirculation and healing, but Alobar on the one hand has been fighting oxidative stress for years now so he would be a good candidate for an operation. On the other hand diabetics who don't know they can control their diabetes and their oxidative stress would be in a higher risk category as your friend was. Dunno that he wasn't taking supplements but it seems not as the impairment of the healing process would have been considerably reduced if he had been. all good, Duncan > > > Alobar, > > Your being diabetic poses a good risk that you can go blind after eye surgery. I know of someone who lost his eyes trying to fix cataracts, he was diabetic... > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 7, 2010 Report Posted October 7, 2010 Duncan, Thanks for finding that pdf source but I'm afraid you completely missed the point in the paragraph you quoted below so I will highlight that point in capital letters while repeating it here: quote: " GCW (green coconut water) is hypotonic/hypo-osmolar in comparison with plasma only with respect to its inorganic ionic composition. If one takes into consideration organic compounds, as clinicians do, THEN IT BECOMES HYPERTONIC/HYPEROSMOLAR. " According to www.medterms.com a Hypertonic solution is: " A solution with a higher salt concentration than in normal cells of the body and the blood. " And here are the conclusions in the article which you neglected to state: quote: " CONCLUSION One may conclude that although GCW is not completely equivalent to hightech (and high cost) TPN solutions with trace element supplements, it may provide sufficient support of at least some of the trace elements if used as a substitute. Even more importantly, trace metal intoxications seem unlikely with GCW from our source, although trace metal content may vary with country or region of origin, timing of harvest and other factors " Now, have you found any research to substantiate your claim that using coconut water for cataracts would " kill cells by lysing them " ? Dee -- In Coconut Oil , " Duncan Crow " <duncancrow@...> wrote: > > Dee, this study points out coconut water is hypotonic, <snip> > http://ipac.kacst.edu.sa/eDoc/2007/164453_1.pdf > > <snip>DISCUSSION Osmolality/Osmolarity The total inorganic cationic content averaged 90 mEq/L. This result is congruent with the description of GCW by Eiseman as having ``the characteristics of a hypotonic intracellular fluid. The total cation or anion content averaged 81 mEq/L (a little over one-half of that of human plasma)'' [7]. Olurin et al. measured the tonicity of 20 green coconut samples. Although they do not provide further details, they describe GCW as hypo-osmolar [4]. GCW is hypotonic/ hypo-osmolar in comparison with plasma only with respect to its inorganic ionic composition. If one takes into consideration organic compounds, as clinicians do, then it becomes hypertonic/hyperosmolar. Major Elements (mM/L) Our results confirm previously published data. As compared with normal plasma values GCW has a very high K content, a high Ca, Mg, and P content and a low Na content. The clinical implications of high K, Ca, and Mg have been discussed previously [4,68]</snip> > > > all good, > > Duncan > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 7, 2010 Report Posted October 7, 2010 Dee we have an issue with not finding enough people who want to be in the control group; i.e. getting IV coconut water without the saline. The research I saw cited made it 50:50 with saline. Don't you wonder why? Don't dick with me, Dee, the term isotonic and tonicity was coined for this exact kind of avoidable and disastrous reaction in medicine. I think that's enough said on the matter; we know conclusively that coconut water is chemically hypotonic unless you include organic impurity, which fails to confer protection that salt does. I don't include such impurities in my calculation. > > > > Dee, this study points out coconut water is hypotonic, > <snip> > > http://ipac.kacst.edu.sa/eDoc/2007/164453_1.pdf > > > > > <snip>DISCUSSION Osmolality/Osmolarity The total inorganic cationic content averaged 90 mEq/L. This result is congruent with the description of GCW by Eiseman as having ``the characteristics of a hypotonic intracellular fluid. The total cation or anion content averaged 81 mEq/L (a little over one-half of that of human plasma)'' [7]. Olurin et al. measured the tonicity of 20 green coconut samples. Although they do not provide further details, they describe GCW as hypo-osmolar [4]. GCW is hypotonic/ hypo-osmolar in comparison with plasma only with respect to its inorganic ionic composition. If one takes into consideration organic compounds, as clinicians do, then it becomes hypertonic/hyperosmolar. Major Elements (mM/L) Our results confirm previously published data. As compared with normal plasma values GCW has a very high K content, a high Ca, Mg, and P content and a low Na content. The clinical implications of high K, Ca, and Mg have been discussed previously [4,68]</snip> > > > > > > all good, > > > > Duncan > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 7, 2010 Report Posted October 7, 2010 Duncan, Who exactly is the " we " who have an issue with not finding people in the control group " ? Have you been trying to set up research on the use of coconut water for cataracts? And where is the research you saw that " made it 50:50 with saline " ? You have never presented that research here so I guess you want us to take your word for it? Duncan I am not trying to " dick " with you and have no idea what you mean by your subsequent sentence (s). Perhaps someone else can but I can make no sense of it whatsoever. However if you feel that enough has been said on the matter I agree with you entirely. But please don't try to blame me if you have been unable to support your contentions with anything but personal opinion. So enough said, Dee > > > > Duncan, > > > > Thanks for finding that pdf source but I'm afraid you completely missed the point in the paragraph you quoted below so I will highlight that point in capital letters while repeating it here: > > quote: " GCW (green coconut water) is hypotonic/hypo-osmolar in comparison with plasma only with respect to its inorganic ionic composition. If one takes into consideration organic compounds, as clinicians do, THEN IT BECOMES HYPERTONIC/HYPEROSMOLAR. " > > > > According to www.medterms.com a Hypertonic solution is: " A solution with a higher salt concentration than in normal cells of the body and the blood. " > > > > And here are the conclusions in the article which you neglected to state: > > > > quote: " CONCLUSION > > One may conclude that although GCW is not completely equivalent to hightech > > (and high cost) TPN solutions with trace element supplements, it may > > provide sufficient support of at least some of the trace elements if used as a substitute. Even more importantly, trace metal intoxications seem unlikely with > > GCW from our source, although trace metal content may vary with country or > > region of origin, timing of harvest and other factors " > > > > Now, have you found any research to substantiate your claim that using coconut water for cataracts would " kill cells by lysing them " ? > > > > Dee > > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 24, 2010 Report Posted October 24, 2010 Duncan, I have been having a terrible time with my dogs. We have had parvo and are trying to get over ecoli. I am able to give subq fluids and while reading this I wondered if CW would be of any help? I am not talking about a sick dog, I am talking about a seriously ill dog that the vet has given up on. Do you think using CW subq will help at all? What if I added water that has melted salt in it? Thanks, Sylvia On Fri, Oct 1, 2010 at 11:13 AM, Duncan Crow <duncancrow@...> wrote: > > Dee, your example is a report of a single patient who I assume survived the > treatment. A last-ditch heroic. Yup, heroic life-saving attempts on the > " critically ill " have included intravenous injection of coconut water, and > in making the decision to do it, necessity outweighs prudence. > > Let's err on the side of advocating prudence when we have that luxury. With > but 1/3 the salt that a prudently prepared isotonic intravenous solution > contains, I'm sure coconut water lyses fewer blood cells than distilled > water will, and coconut water IV may not kill the patient outright; however, > it IS enough to markedly increase ischemic stroke risk that results from the > lysing of blood cells. > > Unless I was in danger of immediately losing my life, like the patients in > the war story, I prudently would not accept that risk, and I urge people to > appreciate the risk. > > One's opinion of whether the the isotonicity of the IV is " enough " to call > it a prudent choice is trumped by data. I've just shown coconut water is not > isotonic as claimed; in fact, two times more salt should be added to get > isotonicity near the low end of blood range and avoid disturbing or killing > blood cells and inducing a clot. There's actually a science to it and a > reason for using the term in medcine. > > isotonic /iso·ton·ic/ (-ton´ik) > 1. denoting a solution in which body cells can be bathed without net flow > of water across the semipermeable cell membrane. > 2. denoting a solution having the same tonicity as another solution with > which it is compared. > 3. maintaining uniform tonus. > > > all good, > > Duncan > > > > > > Duncan, > > > > Apparently the fact that it may have somewhat less sodium than blood > hasn't prevented it's use as intravenous hydration - so perhaps your view > comes closer to " opinion " . You can view the Pub Med article here: > > http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10674546 > > > > Abstract > > Medical resources routinely used for intravenous hydration and > resuscitation of critically ill patients may be limited in remote regions of > the world. When faced with these shortages, physicians have had to improvise > with the available resources, or simply do without. We report the successful > use of coconut water as a short-term intravenous hydration fluid for a > Island patient, a laboratory analysis of the local coconuts, and a > review of previously documented intravenous coconut use. > > > > Dee > > > > > > > > ------------------------------------ > > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 25, 2010 Report Posted October 25, 2010 Hi Sylvia; the success stories I've read around Parvo resulted from rectal enema treatment of the dogs with colloidal silver. In one story only the two puppies that were most likely to die were selected for treatement; they survived and the untreated ones did not. Coconut water intravenous may be useful IV if ordinary saline is needed but not available. In my area saline is available. You can also make your own, and then there's the option of using coconut water on a dehydrated patient. Yes I'd add saline sol or salt to the coconut water to at least double the salt content and also cope with its very high potassium content. Unblanaced electrolytes are dangerous. all good, Duncan > > Duncan, I have been having a terrible time with my dogs. We have had parvo > and are trying to get over ecoli. I am able to give subq fluids and while > reading this I wondered if CW would be of any help? I am not talking about a > sick dog, I am talking about a seriously ill dog that the vet has given up > on. Do you think using CW subq will help at all? What if I added water that > has melted salt in it? Thanks, Sylvia > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.