Guest guest Posted September 27, 2010 Report Posted September 27, 2010 , cataracts often respond to eye hydration but there's nothing by way of data to support the claim that coconut water penetrates, and if it was true, it would certainly kill cells by lysing them due to the non-isotonic nature of such a treatment. Same reason as needing saline water for an IV. Making water wetter by microclustering it, and using MegaHydrate, which hydrates cells, may be a useful approach. all good, Duncan > > I remember reading somewhere about flushing the eyes with fresh young coconut water and then laying a warm-hot compress over the closed eyes to disolve away cataracts. I have been unable to locate the protocal. The question I have is: What is the maximum/optimum temperature that could be used. > Also is it better to use a hot/warm wet compress or a dry wrapped hot water bottle. > Thanks in advance for any relevant infrmation > Cheers,Doug > > Quote
Guest guest Posted September 29, 2010 Report Posted September 29, 2010 Duncan, I have read many tales of American GIs using coconut water in IVs during WW-II when supplies ran ut of plasma. I assume it must be isotonic like saline. Is my assumption wrong? Alobar On Mon, Sep 27, 2010 at 12:34 PM, Duncan Crow <duncancrow@...> wrote: > , cataracts often respond to eye hydration but there's nothing by way of data to support the claim that coconut water penetrates, and if it was true, it would certainly kill cells by lysing them due to the non-isotonic nature of such a treatment. Same reason as needing saline water for an IV. > > Making water wetter by microclustering it, and using MegaHydrate, which hydrates cells, may be a useful approach. > > all good, > > Duncan > Quote
Guest guest Posted September 30, 2010 Report Posted September 30, 2010 Alobar, coconut doesn't seem isotonic to me as there is no salty taste. I have no doubt the life-saving procedure of giving coconut water IV to injured during WWII killed some blood cells unless salt was added. Here's a Google on isotonic saline intravenous: <http://www.google.com/search?client=aff-cs-worldbrowser & forid=1 & ie=utf-8 & oe=UTF\ -8 & q=isotonic+saline+intravenous> all good, Duncan > > , cataracts often respond to eye hydration but there's nothing by way of data to support the claim that coconut water penetrates, and if it was true, it would certainly kill cells by lysing them due to the non-isotonic nature of such a treatment. Same reason as needing saline water for an IV. > > > > Making water wetter by microclustering it, and using MegaHydrate, which hydrates cells, may be a useful approach. > > > > all good, > > > > Duncan > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted September 30, 2010 Report Posted September 30, 2010 Duncan, It may not taste salty but a number of sources on the internet say that it is indeed isotonic. Just do a google for " is coconut water isotonic " . Here is just one of many who say that it is: http://www.body-health.org/2009/09/coconut-water-as-natural-isotonic.html Dee > > > , cataracts often respond to eye hydration but there's nothing by way of data to support the claim that coconut water penetrates, and if it was true, it would certainly kill cells by lysing them due to the non-isotonic nature of such a treatment. Same reason as needing saline water for an IV. > > > > > > Making water wetter by microclustering it, and using MegaHydrate, which hydrates cells, may be a useful approach. > > > > > > all good, > > > > > > Duncan > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 1, 2010 Report Posted October 1, 2010 Duncan, Alobar is right. There is sodium in coconut water. > > > , cataracts often respond to eye hydration but there's nothing by way of data to support the claim that coconut water penetrates, and if it was true, it would certainly kill cells by lysing them due to the non-isotonic nature of such a treatment. Same reason as needing saline water for an IV. > > > > > > Making water wetter by microclustering it, and using MegaHydrate, which hydrates cells, may be a useful approach. > > > > > > all good, > > > > > > Duncan > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 1, 2010 Report Posted October 1, 2010 Hi Dee, I understand that people say that in their opinion coconut water is isotonic, but according to this food analysis: http://nutritiondata.self.com/facts/nut-and-seed-products/3115/2 coconut water contains 600 mg potassium and 252 mg sodium per 250 ml, or 2.4 mg/ml potassium and 1.008 mg/ml sodium. ....while this human blood analysis shows 339 mg sodium per 100 ml, which translates to 3.39 mg/ml sodium http://www.jbc.org/content/78/2/337.full.pdf So, blood contains three times the sodium that coconut water does. all good, Duncan > > > > , cataracts often respond to eye hydration but there's nothing by way of data to support the claim that coconut water penetrates, and if it was true, it would certainly kill cells by lysing them due to the non-isotonic nature of such a treatment. Same reason as needing saline water for an IV. > > > > > > > > Making water wetter by microclustering it, and using MegaHydrate, which hydrates cells, may be a useful approach. > > > > > > > > all good, > > > > > > > > Duncan > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 1, 2010 Report Posted October 1, 2010 Duncan, Apparently the fact that it may have somewhat less sodium than blood hasn't prevented it's use as intravenous hydration - so perhaps your view comes closer to " opinion " . You can view the Pub Med article here: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10674546 Abstract Medical resources routinely used for intravenous hydration and resuscitation of critically ill patients may be limited in remote regions of the world. When faced with these shortages, physicians have had to improvise with the available resources, or simply do without. We report the successful use of coconut water as a short-term intravenous hydration fluid for a Island patient, a laboratory analysis of the local coconuts, and a review of previously documented intravenous coconut use. Dee > > Hi Dee, I understand that people say that in their opinion coconut water is isotonic, but according to this food analysis: > http://nutritiondata.self.com/facts/nut-and-seed-products/3115/2 > coconut water contains 600 mg potassium and 252 mg sodium per 250 ml, or 2.4 mg/ml potassium and 1.008 mg/ml sodium. > > ...while this human blood analysis shows 339 mg sodium per 100 ml, which translates to 3.39 mg/ml sodium http://www.jbc.org/content/78/2/337.full.pdf > > So, blood contains three times the sodium that coconut water does. > > > all good, > > Duncan Quote
Guest guest Posted October 1, 2010 Report Posted October 1, 2010 Duncan, And here is more Pub Med data to support eye hydration as well as IV: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11447514 Am J Emerg Med. 2001 Jul;19(4):287-9. Influence of coconut water on hemostasis. Pummer S, Heil P, Maleck W, Petroianu G. Department of Pharmacology & Toxicology, University of Heidelberg at Mannheim, Mannheim, Germany. Abstract Coconut water (CNW) can be used as short-term intravenous hydration and resuscitation fluid. We investigated the influence of coconut water on plasma coagulation in vitro. Either CNW or physiological saline (PS) was added to citrated plasma of 8 healthy volunteers. Coagulation capability of diluted plasma was evaluated by thrombelastography (TEG). Replacement of up to 50 % of citrated plasma by CNW or PS did not influence initiation of coagulation as indicated by split point and reaction time, respectively. Strength of fibrin clot as expressed by maximum amplitude (MA) of TEG recording dose dependently declined in both groups. Replacing 50 % of citrated plasma by CNW (coconut water) or PS (physiological saline) reduced MA by 39% and 32%, respectively. The influence of coconut water on hemostasis as assessed by TEG (thrombelastography) does not differ from the effect caused by an identical volume of PS (physiological saline) " So your opinion that " it would certainly kill cells by lysing them due to the non-isotonic nature of such treatment " - well it just doesn't hold water. Dee On Mon, Sep 27, 2010 at 12:34 PM, Duncan Crow <duncancrow@> wrote: > > > > > , cataracts often respond to eye hydration but there's nothing by way of data to support the claim that coconut water penetrates, and if it was true, it would certainly kill cells by lysing them due to the non-isotonic nature of such a treatment. Same reason as needing saline water for an IV. snip>> > > > > > > > > > all good, > > > > > > > > > > Duncan > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 1, 2010 Report Posted October 1, 2010 Dee, your example is a report of a single patient who I assume survived the treatment. A last-ditch heroic. Yup, heroic life-saving attempts on the " critically ill " have included intravenous injection of coconut water, and in making the decision to do it, necessity outweighs prudence. Let's err on the side of advocating prudence when we have that luxury. With but 1/3 the salt that a prudently prepared isotonic intravenous solution contains, I'm sure coconut water lyses fewer blood cells than distilled water will, and coconut water IV may not kill the patient outright; however, it IS enough to markedly increase ischemic stroke risk that results from the lysing of blood cells. Unless I was in danger of immediately losing my life, like the patients in the war story, I prudently would not accept that risk, and I urge people to appreciate the risk. One's opinion of whether the the isotonicity of the IV is " enough " to call it a prudent choice is trumped by data. I've just shown coconut water is not isotonic as claimed; in fact, two times more salt should be added to get isotonicity near the low end of blood range and avoid disturbing or killing blood cells and inducing a clot. There's actually a science to it and a reason for using the term in medcine. isotonic /iso·ton·ic/ (-ton´ik) 1. denoting a solution in which body cells can be bathed without net flow of water across the semipermeable cell membrane. 2. denoting a solution having the same tonicity as another solution with which it is compared. 3. maintaining uniform tonus. all good, Duncan > > Duncan, > > Apparently the fact that it may have somewhat less sodium than blood hasn't prevented it's use as intravenous hydration - so perhaps your view comes closer to " opinion " . You can view the Pub Med article here: > http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10674546 > > Abstract > Medical resources routinely used for intravenous hydration and resuscitation of critically ill patients may be limited in remote regions of the world. When faced with these shortages, physicians have had to improvise with the available resources, or simply do without. We report the successful use of coconut water as a short-term intravenous hydration fluid for a Island patient, a laboratory analysis of the local coconuts, and a review of previously documented intravenous coconut use. > > Dee > > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 1, 2010 Report Posted October 1, 2010 Dee, the abstract you posted below used 50% coconut water and 50% citrated plasma to improve tonicity of the coconut water from 1/3 enough salt to 2/3 enough salt BEFORE exposing the solution to blood cells that may otherwise be damaged. The war story has it that coconut water was IV'd directly to the patient; the new approach is a lot different and much safer. Why do you suppose they want to bother adding plasma to the coconut water rather than simply adding coconut water to the patient's IV, Dee? Safety, maybe? all good, Duncan > > > > > > , cataracts often respond to eye hydration but there's nothing by way of data to support the claim that coconut water penetrates, and if it was true, it would certainly kill cells by lysing them due to the non-isotonic nature of such a treatment. Same reason as needing saline water for an IV. > snip>> > > > > > > > > > > all good, > > > > > > > > > > > > Duncan > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 1, 2010 Report Posted October 1, 2010 Duncan, I guess you misunderstood the Pub Med article. The decision to use an injection of coconut water was based on " a review of previously documented intravenous coconut use " . That, in their view, made it prudent. And as for your dictionary definition as your " proof " that coconut water is not sufficiently isotonic, I refer you to the second pub med article which found that " The influence of coconut water on hemostasis as assessed by TEG (thrombelastography) does not differ from the effect caused by an IDENTICAL VOLUME of PS (physiological saline) " . That would certainly allow it to conform to your dictionary definition isotonic. Dee > > > > Duncan, > > > > Apparently the fact that it may have somewhat less sodium than blood hasn't prevented it's use as intravenous hydration - so perhaps your view comes closer to " opinion " . You can view the Pub Med article here: > > http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10674546 > > > > Abstract > > Medical resources routinely used for intravenous hydration and resuscitation of critically ill patients may be limited in remote regions of the world. When faced with these shortages, physicians have had to improvise with the available resources, or simply do without. We report the successful use of coconut water as a short-term intravenous hydration fluid for a Island patient, a laboratory analysis of the local coconuts, and a review of previously documented intravenous coconut use. > > > > Dee > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 1, 2010 Report Posted October 1, 2010 Dee: " documented " means that somebody recorded the old war story in this regard, not that the emergency procedure produced no harm. This has nothing to do with prudence, and further research was deemed to be required in order to establish a safe and prudent dose. The research found that when coconut water is amended by adding an equal part of blood serum, making it twice as isotonic as it was but still about 33% low in salt compared to plasma, it performs similarly to an equal volume of saline. Not that it's yet isotonic, but close enough to not rupture cell walls. The devil is in the details, and I'd expect that nobody who has these details will attempt this at home without similarly amending the coconut water. all good, Duncan > > Duncan, > > I guess you misunderstood the Pub Med article. The decision to use an injection of coconut water was based on " a review of previously documented intravenous coconut use " . That, in their view, made it prudent. And as for your dictionary definition as your " proof " that coconut water is not sufficiently isotonic, I refer you to the second pub med article which found that " The influence of coconut water on hemostasis as assessed by TEG (thrombelastography) does not differ from the effect caused by an IDENTICAL VOLUME of PS (physiological saline) " . That would certainly allow it to conform to your dictionary definition isotonic. > > Dee > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 1, 2010 Report Posted October 1, 2010 Duncan, quote from the abstract: " Either CNW or physiological saline (PS) was added to citrated plasma of 8 healthy volunteers. " Note the words " either " and " or " . In either case they used the same amount in each, so the coconut water+citrated plasma combination would have less salt in it than the physiological saline+citrated plasma - and yet both produced identical results. That must mean that the AMOUNT of salt is inconsequential and would surely indicate it's safe use in the eye. So let's return to the main issue, shall we? Your contention was that coconut water is NOT isotonic and yet these studies and the fact it was safely used in IV's is proof enough that it is. Dee > > > > > > > , cataracts often respond to eye hydration but there's nothing by way of data to support the claim that coconut water penetrates, and if it was true, it would certainly kill cells by lysing them due to the non-isotonic nature of such a treatment. Same reason as needing saline water for an IV. > > snip>> > > > > > > > > > > > all good, > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Duncan > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 1, 2010 Report Posted October 1, 2010 Oh, I doubt anyone here will set up their own IV Duncan, but those who have access to fresh coconut water might still want to try it for their cataracts. Dee > > > > Duncan, > > > > I guess you misunderstood the Pub Med article. The decision to use an injection of coconut water was based on " a review of previously documented intravenous coconut use " . That, in their view, made it prudent. And as for your dictionary definition as your " proof " that coconut water is not sufficiently isotonic, I refer you to the second pub med article which found that " The influence of coconut water on hemostasis as assessed by TEG (thrombelastography) does not differ from the effect caused by an IDENTICAL VOLUME of PS (physiological saline) " . That would certainly allow it to conform to your dictionary definition isotonic. > > > > Dee > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 1, 2010 Report Posted October 1, 2010 Dee, I agree that either one or the other was used in equal amounts for the test. The saline is the placebo and the half coconut water is the test. I concur that 50:50 coconut-water:plasma failed to produce actual damage, depite influx or efflux of water throuigh the cell membranes. Yup, some influx/efflux is not considered to be damaging although it disables the cell for a period until the cell restores itself. None of that used straight coconut water in the blood as that would not be something a doctor would do except in dire emergencies. At this point the doctors know it is relatively safe to dilute blood plasma 50:50 with coconut water rather than giving straight coconut water intravenously. So, we have to agree to disagree with your contention that coconut water is isotonic; the researchers had to make it closer to isotonic by doubling its salt content so as to prevent damage. This is what happened when they mixed it 50:50 with plasma, which has normal saltiness. Again, the research you pointed out referred to old war stories and did some detail work to flesh out the lack of concrete knowledge around such a practice. They did NOT follow the stories and simply use coconut water intravenously; it was made to contain more salt, to be isotonic first, which is what I suggested in the first place. all good, Duncan > > > > > > > > , cataracts often respond to eye hydration but there's nothing by way of data to support the claim that coconut water penetrates, and if it was true, it would certainly kill cells by lysing them due to the non-isotonic nature of such a treatment. Same reason as needing saline water for an IV. > > > snip>> > > > > > > > > > > > > all good, > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Duncan > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 1, 2010 Report Posted October 1, 2010 Duncan, I think you need to read the abstract more carefully: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11447514 l. First of all, the test was done in vitro - meaning that the solutions were not injected into the subjects intravenously but added to the blood taken from the subjects. 2. The blood (plasma) taken from the subjects was then citrated (purified). Make sense? 3. Then 1/2 the citrated plasma was mixed with coconut water and the other half mixed with physiological saline by up to 50% - hence BOTH mixtures contained citrated plasma that was then evaluated by thrombelastography. 4. The investigation was to study the influence of coconut water on blood clotting and " Replacement of up to 50 % of citrated plasma by CNW or PS did not influence initiation of coagulation as indicated by split point and reaction time, respectively. " Your insistance that the coconut water was mixed 50:50 with the citrated plasma but not with the saline is just wrong. They were both mixed with the citrated plasma because the study was done ON the plasma that was citrated in vitro. And THAT is the reason it was mixed 50:50. Making the coconut water more salty had nothing to do with mixing it with the plasma. I'm rather surprised that you don't get this. Dee > > Dee, I agree that either one or the other was used in equal amounts for the test. The saline is the placebo and the half coconut water is the test. > > I concur that 50:50 coconut-water:plasma failed to produce actual damage, depite influx or efflux of water throuigh the cell membranes. Yup, some influx/efflux is not considered to be damaging although it disables the cell for a period until the cell restores itself. > > None of that used straight coconut water in the blood as that would not be something a doctor would do except in dire emergencies. At this point the doctors know it is relatively safe to dilute blood plasma 50:50 with coconut water rather than giving straight coconut water intravenously. > > So, we have to agree to disagree with your contention that coconut water is isotonic; the researchers had to make it closer to isotonic by doubling its salt content so as to prevent damage. This is what happened when they mixed it 50:50 with plasma, which has normal saltiness. > > Again, the research you pointed out referred to old war stories and did some detail work to flesh out the lack of concrete knowledge around such a practice. They did NOT follow the stories and simply use coconut water intravenously; it was made to contain more salt, to be isotonic first, which is what I suggested in the first place. > > all good, > > Duncan > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 1, 2010 Report Posted October 1, 2010 Just in case you misunderstand my last paragraph I will rephrase it as follows: Your insistance that the coconut water was mixed 50:50 with the citrated plasma but the saline was not is just wrong. They were both mixed with the citrated plasma because the study was done ON the plasma that was citrated in vitro. And THAT is the reason it was mixed 50:50. Making the coconut water more salty had nothing to do with mixing it with the plasma. I'm rather surprised that you don't get this. Dee -- In Coconut Oil , " Dolores " <dgk@...> wrote: > > Duncan, > > I think you need to read the abstract more carefully: > http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11447514 > > l. First of all, the test was done in vitro - meaning that the solutions were not injected into the subjects intravenously but added to the blood taken from the subjects. > > 2. The blood (plasma) taken from the subjects was then citrated (purified). Make sense? > > 3. Then 1/2 the citrated plasma was mixed with coconut water and the other half mixed with physiological saline by up to 50% - hence BOTH mixtures contained citrated plasma that was then evaluated by thrombelastography. > > 4. The investigation was to study the influence of coconut water on blood clotting and " Replacement of up to 50 % of citrated plasma by CNW or PS did not influence initiation of coagulation as indicated by split point and reaction time, respectively. " > > Your insistance that the coconut water was mixed 50:50 with the citrated plasma but not with the saline is just wrong. They were both mixed with the citrated plasma because the study was done ON the plasma that was citrated in vitro. And THAT is the reason it was mixed 50:50. Making the coconut water more salty had nothing to do with mixing it with the plasma. I'm rather surprised that you don't get this. > > Dee > > > > > > Dee, I agree that either one or the other was used in equal amounts for the test. The saline is the placebo and the half coconut water is the test. > > > > I concur that 50:50 coconut-water:plasma failed to produce actual damage, depite influx or efflux of water throuigh the cell membranes. Yup, some influx/efflux is not considered to be damaging although it disables the cell for a period until the cell restores itself. > > > > None of that used straight coconut water in the blood as that would not be something a doctor would do except in dire emergencies. At this point the doctors know it is relatively safe to dilute blood plasma 50:50 with coconut water rather than giving straight coconut water intravenously. > > > > So, we have to agree to disagree with your contention that coconut water is isotonic; the researchers had to make it closer to isotonic by doubling its salt content so as to prevent damage. This is what happened when they mixed it 50:50 with plasma, which has normal saltiness. > > > > Again, the research you pointed out referred to old war stories and did some detail work to flesh out the lack of concrete knowledge around such a practice. They did NOT follow the stories and simply use coconut water intravenously; it was made to contain more salt, to be isotonic first, which is what I suggested in the first place. > > > > all good, > > > > Duncan > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 2, 2010 Report Posted October 2, 2010 Dee: Yup, the amount of plasma was the same in each case and the 50:50 with saline is the control and the 50:50 with coconut water is the test to see if 50:50 plasma:coconut water would trigger blood coagulation. I think the bottom line is that the researchers were looking for a way to safely dilute blood plasma with coconut water so coagulation of the recipient's blood does not occur if coconut water is used intravenously. Mixing coconut water with plasma has everything to do with making it twice as salty, and that's what occurred. I think tonicity has a lot to do with the way the experiment was set up; I note that there is no fibrin to start coagulation in coconut water so it is must be another factor in coconut water that causes blood coagulation unless it's suitably diluted with plasma first. all good, Duncan Quote
Guest guest Posted October 2, 2010 Report Posted October 2, 2010 Duncan, You keep insisting that the coconut water was added to the plasma in order to increase it's salinity but there is no indication that this was the case and you have provided no proof that this is now routinely done. As a matter of fact, when it was used in the cases that have been recorded there is no indication that it was added to plasma (outside of the patient) before inserting it into the I.V. And why would it need to be? Wouldn't the coconut water combine with the patient's own blood - just as it combined with the blood used in the in vitro (test tube) test? If you are going to test the action of a substance on blood in a test tube you OBVIOUSLY need to mix it with blood in order to determine the effect it would have on blood - and THAT is the reason, it would seem to me, that it was added to the blood. The bottom line, here, however, is that from all indications the use of coconut water in I.V.'s, when the normal saline solution was not available, proved to be successful. That alone proves that coconut water is indeed isotonic. So far you have failed to show that it is not, and you have also provided no proof that the recorded use of coconut water in I.V.'s was anything but successful. Dee -- In Coconut Oil , " Duncan Crow " <duncancrow@...> wrote: > >snip> > I think the bottom line is that the researchers were looking for a way to safely dilute blood plasma with coconut water so coagulation of the recipient's blood does not occur if coconut water is used intravenously. > > Mixing coconut water with plasma has everything to do with making it twice as salty, and that's what occurred. I think tonicity has a lot to do with the way the experiment was set up; I note that there is no fibrin to start coagulation in coconut water so it is must be another factor in coconut water that causes blood coagulation unless it's suitably diluted with plasma first. > > all good, > > Duncan > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 2, 2010 Report Posted October 2, 2010 Now, to get back to the subject of using young coconut water for cataracts, I found the procedure online - including a very interesting true story by Dr. Fife that inspired him to include it in his book. All who are plagued with cataracts - enjoy!: http://www.mb.com.ph/articles/211348/coconut-water-health-and-healing Dee Quote
Guest guest Posted October 2, 2010 Report Posted October 2, 2010 It was used as IV during WWII. If it didn't have benefit, maybe those people would have died, no? > > > > Hi Dee, I understand that people say that in their opinion coconut water is isotonic, but according to this food analysis: > > http://nutritiondata.self.com/facts/nut-and-seed-products/3115/2 > > coconut water contains 600 mg potassium and 252 mg sodium per 250 ml, or 2.4 mg/ml potassium and 1.008 mg/ml sodium. > > > > ...while this human blood analysis shows 339 mg sodium per 100 ml, which translates to 3.39 mg/ml sodium http://www.jbc.org/content/78/2/337.full.pdf > > > > So, blood contains three times the sodium that coconut water does. > > > > > > all good, > > > > Duncan > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 2, 2010 Report Posted October 2, 2010 You are absolutely right . Too bad it's taken almost 20 posts to make that point stick - but if Duncan has his way it could take even more. Hope this helps :-) Best, Dee > > > > > > Hi Dee, I understand that people say that in their opinion coconut water is isotonic, but according to this food analysis: > > > http://nutritiondata.self.com/facts/nut-and-seed-products/3115/2 > > > coconut water contains 600 mg potassium and 252 mg sodium per 250 ml, or 2.4 mg/ml potassium and 1.008 mg/ml sodium. > > > > > > ...while this human blood analysis shows 339 mg sodium per 100 ml, which translates to 3.39 mg/ml sodium http://www.jbc.org/content/78/2/337.full.pdf > > > > > > So, blood contains three times the sodium that coconut water does. > > > > > > > > > all good, > > > > > > Duncan > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 5, 2010 Report Posted October 5, 2010 Um, Dee, the researchers wanted to determine whether blood plasma watered down with coconut water will trigger coagulation in the recipient patient. The experiment with plasma did not check for lysing of blood cell walls. In fact I haven't seen any research that combined coconut water with blood; just those anecdotes of old war stories and your comment below that some research perhaps added coconut water to blood. Got a link to data from that research? all good, Duncan > > > >snip> > > I think the bottom line is that the researchers were looking for a way to safely dilute blood plasma with coconut water so coagulation of the recipient's blood does not occur if coconut water is used intravenously. > > > > Mixing coconut water with plasma has everything to do with making it twice as salty, and that's what occurred. I think tonicity has a lot to do with the way the experiment was set up; I note that there is no fibrin to start coagulation in coconut water so it is must be another factor in coconut water that causes blood coagulation unless it's suitably diluted with plasma first. > > > > all good, > > > > Duncan > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 5, 2010 Report Posted October 5, 2010 Hi , when coconut water IV killed a patient during the war it would have resulted from a calculated risk under trying circumstances. The doctors would record the death as due to blood loss with no harm, no foul for their last-ditch heroics. The reason for researching coconut water added to plasma is to quantify the coagulation danger. I'd want similar research to quantify the danger of adding coconut water to whole blood. What's missing is the exact figures for the known risk of lysing cells and causing blood coagulation. Not knowing something does not imply risk acceptance outside of heroic war tales. Dee's contention that research had been done with whole blood seems to be optimistic; I couldn't find it. all good, Duncan > > > > > > > > Hi Dee, I understand that people say that in their opinion coconut water is isotonic, but according to this food analysis: > > > > http://nutritiondata.self.com/facts/nut-and-seed-products/3115/2 > > > > coconut water contains 600 mg potassium and 252 mg sodium per 250 ml, or 2.4 mg/ml potassium and 1.008 mg/ml sodium. > > > > > > > > ...while this human blood analysis shows 339 mg sodium per 100 ml, which translates to 3.39 mg/ml sodium http://www.jbc.org/content/78/2/337.full.pdf > > > > > > > > So, blood contains three times the sodium that coconut water does. > > > > > > > > > > > > all good, > > > > > > > > Duncan > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 5, 2010 Report Posted October 5, 2010 Duncan, I already mentioned the pub med article that references the use of coconut water in I.V. (combing coconut water with venous blood) - but I'll repeat it once more: The intravenous use of coconut water. -Falck D, T, Falck TM, Tutuo N, Clem K. Department of Emergency Medicine, Loma University Medical Center, CA 92354, USA. Abstract Medical resources routinely used for intravenous hydration and resuscitation of critically ill patients may be limited in remote regions of the world. When faced with these shortages, physicians have had to improvise with the available resources, or simply do without. We report the successful use of coconut water as a short-term intravenous hydration fluid for a Island patient, a laboratory analysis of the local coconuts, and a review of previously documented intravenous coconut use.(end quote) Now you can say, as you have already, that isn't a LOT of incidences but you have yet to provide even ONE that demonstrates the lysing (disintegration) of blood cell walls by coconut water. So until you do . . . Enough Said, Dee > > snip>The experiment with plasma did not check for lysing of blood cell walls. > > In fact I haven't seen any research that combined coconut water with blood; just those anecdotes of old war stories and your comment below that some research perhaps added coconut water to blood. Got a link to data from that research? > > all good, > > Duncan > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.